Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapy Firearm Ethics
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, enough about Little House in the Prairie and the Bionic Woman.
- 0:04Let's do a podcast in which I have a really fun time reviewing an
- 0:10ethics case from my insurance company, detailing a case that involves firearms. What
- 0:17do you say, let's get into it. It definitely wasn't me involved.
- 0:21So the client is a thirty five year old married female with two minor children
- 0:29meaning kids right, longstanding history of depression and substance used disorder. For the
- 0:35thirty five year old woman, she had participated in an impatient treatment program for
- 0:41substance abuse in the past. However, she continued to struggle with substance abuse.
- 0:47The clients psychiatric medication regimen consisted of a bunch of meds basically for moods
- 0:54and anxiety. She was previously employed as a financial analyst, but during treatment,
- 1:00the client was on disability leave due to depression and wasn't employed, but
- 1:06her husband did work. So I'm going to lay it out by month because
- 1:10it kind of situates it in time, which matters to the case. So
- 1:12in April of this particular year that they don't list because they're leaving out identifying
- 1:18information. In April of this year, the client began treatment with a new
- 1:22psychiatrist for depression, lack of motivation, and hopelessness. So depression. I
- 1:27don't know why the client switched to new psychiatrists, but she did. On
- 1:32the new client questionnaire that the psychiatrists administered, the client indicated she indicated that
- 1:37she had thoughts of hurting herself in the past. Shortly after the initial psychiatric
- 1:42evaluation, the client's husband contacted the treating psychiatrist. And the husband so the
- 1:49husband calls or emails or something. I'm guessing it's a phone call. The
- 1:53husband calls a psychiatrist to report new symptoms, brand new symptoms of paranoia and
- 1:59bizarre behavior and an increase in alcohol consumption, and a concern that the client
- 2:04had guns in the home, so that the family had guns in the home.
- 2:07So this is kind of interesting because why out of nowhere, because the
- 2:13husband would know right about the wife's presentation and to have right after starting treatment
- 2:20suddenly paranoia, bizarre behavior, increase in alcoholic consumption. Hard to know what
- 2:24would be your suspicion given that profile, suspicion about why did the client suddenly
- 2:30have new symptoms? Maybe she underreported when she showed up. I don't know,
- 2:35okay, but why would the husband suddenly see new symptoms? Oh well,
- 2:39maybe she started using drugs or something. I don't know, Yeah,
- 2:42you know. Another possibility is that she was starting to increase in some sort
- 2:49of symptom and that's what prompted her to seek the psychiatrist to begin with,
- 2:53because maybe she had a previous prescriber or psychiatrist or something that she had drifted
- 2:58away from and had just the meds that were continuing to be refilled in terms
- 3:04of the prescription, and maybe she noticed something and so she contacts the psychiatrist.
- 3:08Another possibility is that, which is left out of the case file or
- 3:12the case of this brief, that the psychiatrist changed the meds somehow, you
- 3:17know, so hard to know. Shortly after, okay, so that the
- 3:22husband calls and says this, And so if you had a client that had
- 3:29this sort of report, you have a brand new client and you don't you're
- 3:35treating a client for depression. But there's no disclosure from the clients saying that
- 3:39they are suicidal currently. And there's something on a questionnaire that said they had
- 3:45thoughts of hurting themselves in the past. I mean it's hard to know from
- 3:49this case briefing, but there's no mention that the psychiatrist did any kind of
- 3:53suicidal assessment, which of course should be done in a situation like this regardless.
- 4:00Really all clients when you first see them, there should be some question,
- 4:03like you know, sometimes it's just a good idea just to ask are
- 4:06you or have you ever thought about suicide? Just even if there's no indication
- 4:12that that question is necessarily warranted, just to make sure there wouldn't be any
- 4:17reason not to ask that questions good practice. Yeah, And also for me,
- 4:21whenever I have the impulse not to ask a question like that during assessments,
- 4:28it's usually because of countertransference. Right, I'm afraid that I'm going to
- 4:32alienate the client, And I have to tell myself, Look, if you're
- 4:38going to treat a client, you can't be afraid of that. And what
- 4:42does that say about the dynamic right now or my own insecurity or something that's
- 4:46going on right Plus, by asking it, it sets a precedent that those
- 4:50topics are on the table, and I think that's a good message to give
- 4:56a client right from the beginning. Look, we're not here to dance around
- 4:59things. We're here to talk openly, and I'm okay with whatever is going
- 5:05to be told to me. You know, I'm prepared for it. And
- 5:09don't just automatically assume that clients will know that you know. So uh,
- 5:14but yeah, what would you what would you do if you heard that?
- 5:17So? So, I think what you're asking is what would I do if
- 5:21I heard a client say that they had a history of thoughts or you know,
- 5:26behaviors that are self harmful or risky or you know, wanting to die
- 5:30or something. And are you asking what would I do after I hear back
- 5:32from the husband? Yeah, well, I'd want to talk to my client
- 5:34and I'd want to ask the husband is there any reason to think that there's
- 5:38an immediate danger? Like right this second? And I probably ask specifically are
- 5:42the guns locked up? Does the client have access to them? Because if
- 5:45they do, that's a whole of the thing. When I'm just you know,
- 5:48like, why don't we just either put them away somewhere else, get
- 5:51them to a friend or how would you do that? Though? Like would
- 5:55you just say it with the husband? Yeah? Like, how about we
- 5:58get rid of the guns. I've said that to a client about a year
- 6:00that's not the clients the husband of the client. Yeah, well, um,
- 6:04I think at that point, I don't care who it is. Let's
- 6:08just get the guns out of the possibility of the you know, client done
- 6:12doing something impulsive or whatever risky. Yeah. I don't have any problem with
- 6:15that. That's that's just seems like reasonable. Yeah. Yeah, I'm on
- 6:19a subject. Some people are hesitant to get rid of their guns or to
- 6:26store them. Yeah, that happened to me about a year ago. What
- 6:28happened. I have a client who's partner was admired in depression and they have
- 6:33a lot of guns, and I just said, how about we lock them
- 6:35up? So you're talking to the partner, you know, I'm talking to
- 6:39my client about her partner who's depressed, and um, um has a lot
- 6:44of guns, right, And I'm like, why wouldn't we lock them up?
- 6:46Like what do you need them out for? You don't need them out
- 6:48for anything. Lock them up where I can, I say, for something,
- 6:53Just something where her partner has access to, cannot have access to,
- 6:57you cannot have access and you know, not sneaky, just like, let's
- 7:00all get on page here. You don't need these guns, you're depressed it's
- 7:02a risk factor. One thing that it's important to understand is that thirty percent
- 7:06is suicides are completed within five minutes of the thought of the thing occurring.
- 7:10Thirty percent are completed. So it doesn't matter whether or not somebody is like,
- 7:15well, it's not that it doesn't matter. It's not a guarantee if
- 7:18somebody's not suicidal right now, that they won't be in an hour or a
- 7:21day or a week. And it's not like anybody can predict that stuff,
- 7:26So why monkey with it? Life is precious and short. We're all going
- 7:30to die soon enough. We don't need to rush it. So I'm all
- 7:33for caution and you know, give them what I'm hearing here, like lock
- 7:38them up? Did they do it? No? They refused why I didn't
- 7:43want to offend their partner. Didn't want to offend their partner? Yeah?
- 7:46Yeah, And I you know what am I gonna do? I you know,
- 7:49they're free to not do it. The person wasn't describing imminent risk,
- 7:56so it's not like there's any there's no, there's no there's nothing more that
- 8:01can be done. The person is not an imminent risk, so there's you
- 8:05know, you just the present moment is all they'll go off of when it
- 8:09comes to assessment. Yeah. Yeah, so offending the client was worried that
- 8:16she would offend her husband because he would get upset that she's trying to manage
- 8:24his life or that he's like, I'm not at risk. What are you
- 8:28talking about? Something like that? Okay, Yeah. Another factor that will
- 8:33happen sometimes is that people with guns are more likely to be conservative, and
- 8:39within conservative echo chambers, there are certain propaganda points that discussed and brainwashed into
- 8:48people that we as therapists are. These liberal anti gun people might even literally
- 8:56believe we're trying to take away their guns so we can invade their homes and
- 9:00take over their lives and make them into non binary gay people or so whatever
- 9:05they're were Literally, I mean, you say what, I used to make
- 9:07jokes like this five years ago as a way of exaggerating these kind of Stephen
- 9:13Colbert kind of jokes. You read the serious surveys and the polls that they
- 9:20will take on Americans, there's a sizable chunk that literally believe this ship,
- 9:26Like a fourth of Americans are have been indoctrinated into this cult of propaganda that
- 9:33is absurd. More absurd than that, like lizard people in Hollywood that are
- 9:37drinking the blood of babies so they can stay young. Tom Hanks and Barack
- 9:41Obama. And it's always liberals, by the way, are true though yeah
- 9:46so um so. But even if they're not indoctrinated into that silliness, they
- 9:54will resist because they think that we are these wimpy liberals that are don't understand
- 10:01guns, or we don't understand that they are safe with their guns or something
- 10:05like that, and so they'll have a problem with it just on that level.
- 10:11And so if that's the case, then some level of massaging has to
- 10:16be administered to say, like, look, I'm not trying to take away
- 10:18your against this is just a temporary thing. You're in control of the guns.
- 10:22I'm just saying here are the facts, and the facts are blah blah
- 10:26blah. Yeah, like I could give a shit about somebody owning guns.
- 10:31Yeah, you know, you want to talk politics, that's another matter.
- 10:33But I don't want anybody's guns. I don't care about that stuff. Like,
- 10:35let's just not die over it, right right anyways, So he see,
- 10:43so the husband reported these symptoms. He also advised that his wife had
- 10:48stated that she was contemplating filing for divorce. The psychiatrist at the time,
- 10:54Oh, it was so, it was on the phone. Psychiatrist on the
- 10:56phone overheard the client yelling at her husband during this phone call, including a
- 11:01threat to divorce him. So the husband calls. Then the psychiatrist notes this,
- 11:07Yeah, the psychiatrist recommended that the client be seen in an emergency department,
- 11:11so that the psychiatrist tells the husband, you should take your wife to
- 11:16the emergency department. And also the psychiatrists explained the process for involuntary commitment.
- 11:22So what do you think about that? It seems a bit premature, like
- 11:26he hasn't even talked he the psychiatrist to he or she here. I don't
- 11:28know if we have the gender of this doesn't matter. They have not talked
- 11:31to their own client about what's going on. I think that's a mistake.
- 11:35Like, first off, you're destroying your treatment alliance, and second off,
- 11:39you actually don't know, you don't have any you have just a little bit
- 11:43of data about what's going on, and you know they're in the middle of
- 11:46a fight clearly, or some kind of conflict or whatever. Stuff's going to
- 11:50be exaggerated or amplified. You don't, you're not going to know. So
- 11:52if it were me, I would say, can I talk to my person?
- 11:58Please? Can you just hand them the phone? Yeah? Are you
- 12:01willing to talk? Should we? Can we meet? Right? I don't
- 12:05know why anybody wouldn't do that, you know, er, yeah, fine,
- 12:09if but not, That's not the only thing I would do, right,
- 12:11especially if the wife is right there. I don't think i'd even talk
- 12:13about the process for based on what's been spoken about here, I wouldn't even
- 12:18talk about the process for involuntary commitment. I don't see any that's like,
- 12:22well, it's like seven steps away if we even get there. Yeah.
- 12:26So, according to the brief the husband, according to I think the documentation
- 12:31of the psychiatrist, the husband didn't actually do what the psychiatrist told him to
- 12:37do. And you know, I think, when in doubt, make the
- 12:41recommendation. So there's a couple pieces. There's a couple reasons to do what
- 12:46the psychiatrist did. But I agree with what you're saying. But if there
- 12:52were a reason to do it, one is you just don't have the time
- 12:56or the capacity to provide treatment in a situation something like that, right,
- 13:00especially if you're not used to it. I don't even answer my phone unless
- 13:05I know who's calling me, you know what I mean, Because I don't
- 13:07want to be caught in a situation like that which has happened before. I'll
- 13:11pick up the phone while I'm at a family get together or something and thinking
- 13:16at someone else, and that's a client and they're in crisis, and I'm
- 13:20like, oh crap, like I answered, I can't just it'd be weird
- 13:22if I was like, sorry, I didn't mean to answer the phone.
- 13:26You know, I tell my clients I'm not a crisis line, and you
- 13:31know, so want to give the impression to my clients that which is true.
- 13:35That I don't really want to set up that expectation, because yeah,
- 13:39if I not that, I want to deny my client's help. But if
- 13:43I set up an expectation, then that could harm the client in the future
- 13:46because they would call me in another crisis thinking that I'm going to be able
- 13:50to help them, and I won't be able to do that. That's the
- 13:54risk. It's sort of like feeding ducks at the pond. If you keep
- 13:58feeding them, eventually they depend on you and they can't feed themselves. And
- 14:03what if you take a vacation, all the ducks will die. So it
- 14:07does them no good. Even though you want to help and the ducks are
- 14:11looking cute, you're actually harming them by making them dependent on that because you're
- 14:16not a consistent service provider. Now, if you are, and some people
- 14:22are like we talked before about the DBT folks, who will set that up,
- 14:24then okay, yeah, great, yeah, So one thing to do
- 14:31is to just keep the conversations as short as as possible and just recommend the
- 14:39most safe option, and it's you know, it's a safe option to have
- 14:45her go to an emergency department to get evaluated, because that you know that
- 14:52in person professional will be able to figure out what's going on and to see
- 14:56if there's any kind of issue there and if the husband and what does the
- 15:00husband want the psychiatrists to do in the moment? Do you know what I
- 15:03mean? So you're like, look, I'm not an on call emergency service
- 15:07provider. There are emergency service providers and here's that location for that another reason
- 15:15to do this sort of thing. And I wouldn't do this with adults,
- 15:18but I would sometimes with kids if they were to do this sort of stuff.
- 15:22With me is I would not given to the crisis mode because one thing
- 15:30that I might be thinking about is I have a new client right now,
- 15:35I don't really know the landscape, and I'm getting this call and I mean,
- 15:39so, have you ever received this kind of call or text or something
- 15:43from a new client where suddenly they are involving you a lot in their day
- 15:48to day conflicts? You know, they're having an if it's an individual client
- 15:52or even a couple, and they will in the moment as they're having the
- 15:58fight, one or both of them will reach out to you. That hasn't
- 16:02nothing like that comes to mind right now, though I can't imagine at least
- 16:06in the individual work that that hasn't happened. I think that probably has been.
- 16:10I'm not thinking of anything off the top of my head. It certainly
- 16:11doesn't end very often. Yeah, I know. And the stereotypist that happens
- 16:15all the time, because the Hollywood stereotypists, all clients are, you know,
- 16:21weird and pennant and ready and you know what about Bob that kind of
- 16:23stuff, right, But but it has happened in my career earlier. And
- 16:30one of the things that I eventually learned because so I'll tell you my progress
- 16:34with this when I first would get those calls from clients and my early career
- 16:40because I didn't know the landscape. I hadn't received any guidance on this,
- 16:42I don't think, and I was pretty desperate to please clients because I felt
- 16:48like an imposter and I wanted to make a career and I would really deliver.
- 16:55I would do what I could. Oh, okay, you know,
- 16:57let's do some crisis management. Over time, I found was that these very
- 17:00rare clients, like one out of every three hundred clients or something will do
- 17:04this, that no amount of me doing triage will actually stop the problem.
- 17:11I'm just becoming triangulated. It's just ruining my free time. If anything,
- 17:18it might be making it worse because I'm not really able to help them in
- 17:21the moment the way that I can in session. It's not necessarily going to
- 17:26benefit them for me not to respond if they call in a crisis, but
- 17:30I determined it doesn't help them. If I do, I'm just sort of
- 17:36making my life worse and possibly making the treatment worse because I'm there would be
- 17:41time so when I would have only a certain amount of time, and I
- 17:44would try to provide a triage treatment, and I would wonder afterwards if I
- 17:48had ruptured the relationship because I was kind of brief because I had to be
- 17:52you know, so in terms of keeping the frame of therapy, I was
- 17:55like, Okay, I don't want to do that anymore. So what I
- 17:56started to do later on if that happened, and you know, eventually I
- 18:03figured out there's just ways of not being able to be contacted in between sessions,
- 18:07you know, because that's not the service that I provide. I mean,
- 18:11certainly there are always of contact to me, but not in an emergency.
- 18:14But what I eventually figured out was that when they would contact me like
- 18:18that, I would immediately have a very over the top recommendation because the idea
- 18:29was, look, you know, because I by then would have already talked
- 18:32with them about you know, I'm not an emergency service. There are crisis
- 18:34lines, there are hospitals, there are these other services, and they would
- 18:38still be contacting me, and so I would just say, well, you
- 18:41need to go to the hospital, and they they would want to engage in
- 18:45the conversation, but you know, but he said or something, you know,
- 18:48I'd be like, you need to go to the emergency service, because
- 18:51you know we've already talked about that, and you know I'd be calm and
- 18:52I wouldn't be punishing. I just but you need to go or you need
- 18:56to call the crisis line, because they are set up to actually help you
- 19:00with that. Absolutely, I understand you're going through something, and I totally
- 19:03get it. We'll talk about it in our session. You know, if
- 19:07it's still an issue by then, I'm guessing it will be. But there
- 19:10are professionals that are trained and set up to actually provide you a service in
- 19:15this woman. You need to do that, but they wouldn't want to do
- 19:17that because that's going too far. And what I would what would eventually happen
- 19:22is these clients would just stop calling me. Because it's sort of a modification
- 19:27of Bowen's technique of detriangulating, right, because it's not exactly like this,
- 19:33But the way that Bowen did with his family of origin is his sister would
- 19:37come to him complaining about their dad, and he would go right to their
- 19:41dad and say, by the way, sister is saying this about you,
- 19:47and so you should probably talk with her about it. And then sister just
- 19:49stopped telling Mary Bowen about anything, because she's like, why he's just gonna
- 19:55he's just gonna blab about it. He Bowen wasn't lying, you know,
- 20:00he was just saying, look, you're telling me, I'm going to tell
- 20:03the other I don't. I'm not going to be stuck in a position of
- 20:07having to sit with this, and so would it would work kind of in
- 20:12that way. So I don't know if that's what the psychiatrist was thinking,
- 20:15but anyway, that's what the psychiatrist did. So the psychiatrist followed up with
- 20:22the client by phone the following day, as I think as an impulse that
- 20:27you would have, and she denied the behaviors and reported no suicidal ideation.
- 20:33So she's basically saying, I wasn't paranoid, my husband is crazy, I
- 20:40didn't have an alcohol, I don't have an alcohol. I'm not drinking alcohol
- 20:45very much or something like that. And no, I don't have suicidal thoughts.
- 20:49And there wasn't any report of suicidal thoughts from the husband according to the
- 20:53brief, just the fact that there were guns in the home. So during
- 20:57this timeframe were ongoing medication adjustments which might have predated this symptom change. Despite
- 21:07compliance with the medication regimen that she continued, the client continued to experience exacerbations
- 21:14of moderate to severe depression. Okay, so in May. So that was
- 21:18April in May, so I think this is just a month into treatment with
- 21:23the psychiatrist. The psychiatrist documented that the client was not reacting well to the
- 21:29medications, that meaning that the severe to moderate depression was still present, and
- 21:37there were several meds that the client was on. So now the first thing
- 21:41I think is, well, you have a brand new client and I don't
- 21:47know the history of course because it's not given, but you probably need more
- 21:49time to see if the medications are going to work or tweaking this and tweaking
- 21:56that. But anyway, he or oh it is does say he, and
- 22:00the brief so the psychiatrist identifies he. So he the psychiatrist initiated trans magnetic
- 22:06stimulation or TMS treatment, because that is something that some treatment providers will recommend
- 22:14when medications aren't working for treatment resistant depression. You know, it's like,
- 22:18well it doesn't work with a lot of people, but worth a shot,
- 22:21that kind of thing. And all the psychiatry notes from this time from a
- 22:25parl and May reflected an absence of suicidality, so the psychiatrist was apparently assessing
- 22:32for it and noting that there was no suicidal thoughts. So in June,
- 22:37so this is two months into treatment, the transcranial magnetic stimulation treatment began.
- 22:42However, the client reported minimal improvement the client, so that the psychiatrist is
- 22:48still kind of figuring out like, Okay, what else can we try?
- 22:52And what else would you would you see a psychiatrist recommending in that moment.
- 22:59Well, as I understand it, though, a good trial of antidepressant is
- 23:03four to six weeks, this is two months and we're already into TMS.
- 23:08Yeah, I mean maybe they have a whole sheaf of notes from previous treatment
- 23:12and they're relying on, you know, previous experience with that stuff, and
- 23:18you know, you know, and so they have that data to go on.
- 23:21Right, It's not a typical story that you'll hear. The typical story
- 23:25will be trying out different concoctions and cocktails of meds for two to three years
- 23:33before you give up on meds and start going to transcaranal you know, stimulation.
- 23:37But if meds were considered maybe not an option or not working and this
- 23:45TMS doesn't seem to be working, which I think also needs time to see
- 23:48if it's going to work. But what would you do next? Well,
- 23:52there's always you know, the ect that that's a possibility for treatment resistant depression.
- 23:56There's some crappy side effects, you know, memory lossing, confusion and
- 24:00all that, but so data behind it. Electro convulsive therapy. Yeah,
- 24:03what else? Well, I don't know what else is there. Well,
- 24:07there's therapy. Oh yeah, there's therapy. Listen to me. I become
- 24:11a psychiatrist and I'm just thinking biologic. How about some therapy. You obviously
- 24:15have a distressed relationship. Maybe we should be talking to you know, like
- 24:19yeah, yeah, yeah, hey, guess what I know something about therapy.
- 24:22Yeah, I've been doing that for a little more than two weeks now.
- 24:27So the client was referred to counseling and initiated treatment with the insured counselor
- 24:33who was in private practice. And I did look for any gender identication for
- 24:37the insured counselor and it wasn't given. So the counselor did an initial evaluation
- 24:45and in which the client reported symptoms of anxiety, depression and history of addiction
- 24:49to pain medication. The counselor documented the client's statement I will never get better
- 24:56quote unquote, but indicated that the client denied suicidal thoughts. Okay, so
- 25:00the counselor is thinking, there seems to be some things hovering around suicide.
- 25:07But after an assessment, maybe a quick one, the client denied any kind
- 25:12of suicidal thoughts. The question on the counseling assessment form referencing quote unquote danger
- 25:19to self or others was left blank. So hard to know what was going
- 25:25on there. But maybe the client just didn't see it, or didn't understand
- 25:30it, or didn't care to. But at least this is, you know,
- 25:34not answered. Plans were made for return visits at two week intervals with
- 25:41the counselor. What do you think about that? Maybe that has to do
- 25:45with the counselor's availability, or the clients how much they could afford to spend
- 25:49on therapy or who knows, you know, weekly therapies arbitrary. Nobody knows
- 25:56that that's the right amount. And though given where they say is going,
- 26:00it's making me think that the counselor was missing something important. So two weeks
- 26:07is a long time. Yeah, if I had a colleague or a supervisy,
- 26:12and they told me this. I would really ask them what was the
- 26:18thinking there, because the standard is every week and then if you find you
- 26:23don't need that much, then you scale it back. But you're talking about
- 26:27someone that is moderate to severely depressed. There's no talk about suicide, but
- 26:33we understand that there's a risk there. There's reports, and who knows if
- 26:37the councilor knew about this, which might be another problem that the psychiatrist didn't
- 26:41alert the counselor. But you know, maybe maybe the psychiatrist did about the
- 26:47phone call and the talk about guns and stuff. That would certainly warrant more
- 26:52frequent therapy, but like you said, it's sort of an arbitrary number at
- 26:56two week sessions. Every two weeks doesn't mean that you can't do good treatment,
- 27:03So hard to know what's going on there. One week after the initial
- 27:07counseling visit, the client presented a psychiatry follow up appointment for The client went
- 27:15to a psychiatry follow up appointment complaining of continued symptoms of depression, hopelessness,
- 27:21and anxiety. The psychiatrist, so it's one thing when clients are depressed and
- 27:26anxious, right and hopeless It's another thing when they are pleading, right,
- 27:33there's a there's clearly some kind of alert that the client is alerting. And
- 27:38again you just would think you'd do more than every two weeks spending me.
- 27:42Yeah, the psychiatrist advised the client to continue the current meds and the TMS
- 27:48treatments and prescribed a new medication for lithium. So pard to know of the
- 27:55wisdom on that one. Maybe it is the standard of care, within the
- 28:00standard of character to do that under those circumstances. But from the earlier in
- 28:03the brief, there were formads that the client was on. I don't know
- 28:07if that was changed, but there's a lot of things being thrown at the
- 28:12wall. Yeah, in a relatively short amount of time. Like again,
- 28:18I'm not a prescriber, so I can't comment on it professionally, but I'll
- 28:22say as an observational professional from observation, like we said, usually they give
- 28:27it more time because I think another thing that's psychiatrists or even just medical professionals
- 28:33in general will experience over time is people come into their office complaining about a
- 28:38lot of things acutely, and even if the medical professional does nothing to change
- 28:45the treatment regimen, a lot of clients and patients will just get better because
- 28:51of circumstance or their body will change or something, and it's sometimes better to
- 28:57do nothing than to do something. Yeah, right, And so often that's
- 29:03what you'll see, especially with a very new client and they just started therapy
- 29:08last week, and that's the very first session. You know, it's like,
- 29:11let's let's just kind of give it a little bit more breathing space.
- 29:15There's no suicidal thoughts, there's no emergency here, so you know, let's
- 29:18let's take it easy. But anyway, new medication. At the next counseling
- 29:22session with the counselors is the second session, the client reported that the TMS
- 29:27treatments and medication adjustments were not effective. During this session, the counselor utilized
- 29:33cognitive behavioral therapy techniques and documented that the client posed no danger to self or
- 29:41others. So when you hear that in the brief, the councilor use CBT
- 29:45and documented that the client, quote unquote, was no danger to self or
- 29:48others. What do you think happened there? It's hard to know. That
- 29:52feels like I cover my butt kind of note like did I ask? Because
- 29:56if I asked I document that I asked as a to whether or not a
- 30:00danger, and that sounds like an assessment based on who knows what right.
- 30:04There's no data about well, what did I do? Yeah? Did I
- 30:07ask right? And this is a pet peeve of mine and also something that
- 30:11I really try to hammer into my trainees, which is that there are reasons
- 30:17to leave a lot of things out of your notes. You don't want to
- 30:18put things in the notes that are going to harm the client or bother the
- 30:22client down the road if the client gets pulled. There's no reason to include
- 30:25certain details in the client file that are unnecessary. However, there are some
- 30:30topics where you really have to explain the bigger picture because if it becomes an
- 30:37issue later on, you really want to have that in your notes. So
- 30:41what I think is based on what the brief the way it's written, it
- 30:45says, you know, the client in the documentation, the client quote unquote
- 30:48posed no danger to self. Rather, so what I think is the ensured
- 30:53counselor they're using one of those forms or a program or something, or those
- 30:59online services where you check boxes. Yeah, which I actually enjoy because it
- 31:06saves a lot of time, But did not indicate anything in the notes as
- 31:11to what that meant. As you're saying, like, all you have to
- 31:14say is I conducted a mini assessment of suicidal thoughts and intent and there was
- 31:22no danger to self. The client indicated no danger, no thoughts about suicide
- 31:27or something like. That's much more specific than what I think as a checkbox
- 31:30that says no danger to self for others. You know it's not doesn't If
- 31:34the client attempts or complete suicide in the future, then you would want that
- 31:40that more definitive statement in your notes, you know what I mean. Second
- 31:42session with someone that's got some history, I'd be thinking crisis plan, like,
- 31:48Okay, great, you're not suicide, don't know, fantastic, What
- 31:49are we going to do if it happens? Why? Why with every client
- 31:55or with the client that had this kind of presentation? What about what about
- 31:59this presentation? Well, there's talk about suicide. There's a refer from a
- 32:01psychiatrist because they have depression and hopelessness. And I don't know where it was,
- 32:07I can't remember all the details, but there's some mention of suicide somewhere
- 32:10along the way here, and the client, while on the psychiatrist intake form
- 32:15indicated thoughts of harming herself in the past at some point at some point,
- 32:22and that was just a checkbox kind of thing. And who knows that the
- 32:24councilor even knew about that. So yeah, that's true. So this is
- 32:29the kind of a person with present with depression. I'd be asking about this
- 32:32stuff and I'd be talking about I'd be getting dad. I hope I'd be
- 32:36getting Dad. I mean, I don't think people generally they don't withhold information.
- 32:39If you ask, generally speaking, they'll tell us. Well. So
- 32:44I don't know if this is changing, but I read online sometimes on Reddit,
- 32:50people will talk about this about how they will withhold There's this notion out
- 32:57there, which I think is just misinformation online but also maybe cherry picking some
- 33:04bad apples in our profession, where there's this notion in a certain subgroup of
- 33:08people on the internet that you should never tell your mental health professional, regardless
- 33:13of this circumstance, that you are thinking about suicide, because they will lock
- 33:16you up. Yeah. Yeah, I've had clients say this to me and
- 33:20I just describe to them here's how it works. Yeah. But if they
- 33:23have that thought and they are certain of it, then they won't even bring
- 33:28up the topic for you to dispel, okay, you know what I mean,
- 33:30or they won't believe us when we do spell it. So there's that.
- 33:36Also, we can't guarantee that they won't be erroneously locked up because I
- 33:40you know, I'm if a client tells me that they are of a certain
- 33:45risk that doesn't justify me seeking involuntary hospitalization, then there's that level of nuanced
- 33:53understanding and expertise, but not every mental health professional has that expertise. Yeah.
- 33:59Also, I can't guarantee that if they weren't to tell someone else,
- 34:02like the crisis line or their doctor or a friend, that that wouldn't happen,
- 34:07because anyone can call the mhps, and the mhps they're much better at
- 34:13it than you and I are, by the way, because that that's their
- 34:15job. That's what they do all day. But you know, every once
- 34:20in a while, might you get a bad MHP that jumps on that action
- 34:25too fast. And then but then there's another layer where the mhps actually bring
- 34:30the person, maybe with a police escort or something, to the hospital.
- 34:32Well, the hospital also has to admit to the person after an assessment so
- 34:37there's a lot of layers too. Incompetence that would have to occur. Doesn't
- 34:39happen at times. Reportedly, apparently there are stories. It's hard to believe
- 34:45that it happens very often, but you know, you could see some people
- 34:47making that mistake. Also, some clients have a hard time communicating what they're
- 34:52going through, and they might, you know, like I had a client,
- 34:57one of my very first clients, maybe literally my second client. The
- 35:00second session of my second client. Wow, he the first session, everything
- 35:07was fine, and you know, actually, let's take a break and when
- 35:09we get back, let's talk about it. Yeah. Sure, okay,
- 35:16we're back from the break. So my second client or third client or something,
- 35:21first session, everything would find the second session, he sits down and
- 35:25I say something like and I'm nervous and I'm twenty five, have no idea
- 35:30what I'm doing. Oh, and I had to videotape this session because it
- 35:36was an assignment for school. They said you have to videotape five of your
- 35:40sessions because you know, this is back before they had any kind of video
- 35:45feed that you could just record, right, and you had to rent this
- 35:51giant VHS video camera from the university and a giant tripod and somehow situated in
- 35:59the tiny little intern therapy office. And so it's this monstrosity just interfering like
- 36:07this third cyborg is like with us in the therapy session, and I'm doubly
- 36:14triply terrified because of that that this is going to be watched, and I
- 36:19have you know. So he sits down and and I says it because we
- 36:24must have talked about it previously, and he said it was okay and signed
- 36:29the paper, dada da, and then he proceeds to not talk for the
- 36:31entire session. I'm asking him questions. I think I chose him because he
- 36:37was so easy in our first session, but this session completely different. Maybe
- 36:40it was the camera. I don't know, but I was doing everything I
- 36:44could to try to get him to say something, and he did. He
- 36:46didn't complain, he didn't say turned the camera off. I think I even
- 36:52suggested turning the camera. He didn't say. He didn't want to be like
- 36:54he just it was. To this day, I still don't understand what was
- 36:59going on in his mind. I suspect that he was interesting. I don't
- 37:05think I've ever really thought about with my current understanding of humans and clients.
- 37:08I've never really it's kind of issuing when you do that, right, You
- 37:12sort of make these assumptions earlier on, and then over time you don't reevaluate
- 37:15it. Right. It's sort of like childhood trauma, right, It's like
- 37:17you get treated in a certain way and like you're a piece of crap.
- 37:22You conclude your piece of crap, and then later on you still basically see
- 37:25yourself. It's like, yeah, yeah, I was a piece of crap,
- 37:28but with your current knowledge, well no, I was four. I
- 37:30couldn't have been a piece of crap. So I'm sort of doing that right
- 37:34now? Is what was going on? I mean, I certainly had no
- 37:38idea what's doing, so I'm sure that played a role. I think he
- 37:42was just wanting to be snarky. The camera couldn't have helped, you know.
- 37:46I must have been something about the camera. Who knows? Anyway,
- 37:51he the session is almost over, and I'm thinking, how is my professor
- 37:55going to evaluate me based on this session? You know, but like this
- 38:00is all you're going to be able to get because this is the only I
- 38:01don't have that many clients right now anyway, So at the I look at
- 38:06the clock and it's the end of the session, and so I say it,
- 38:08well, it's the end of the session, so it's time to adjourn,
- 38:13and he looks up. The client looks up and he says, I
- 38:15want to kill myself, and I'm like, huh. Also completely at this
- 38:22out of my element. I had received some training on this, but hadn't
- 38:25done much role playing if at all, didn't know what to do. Well,
- 38:30I knew enough to say, Okay, can you hold on for a
- 38:34second, And I actually left my office and got my supervisor. Oh good.
- 38:37I don't know if they told me to do that. Maybe they did,
- 38:39I don't know. It could be an instinct. Yeah, I don't
- 38:43know. I mean, my instinct would have been to just freeze and be
- 38:46ashamed of myself. So they must have told me to do this, because
- 38:51that's quite a bold move to just because I'll often be telling trainees, look,
- 38:54if you're completely in a bind, you don't know what to know what
- 38:58to do, just pause this session and leave the office, or stay in
- 39:02the office and just give yourself some time to think. You don't have to
- 39:07think on your feet, you know what I mean. You're not on stage
- 39:09at the opera House. The show doesn't have to go on. You can
- 39:13take a break. I do that regularly. Now what do you mean,
- 39:17I'll freeze or I'll whatever, and I'll just say I just need a minute.
- 39:21Oh really Yeah, and gives you a time to collect yourself. That's
- 39:24great because so many mistakes can happen if we don't do that, if we
- 39:29just be like, oh, I can't take a break. I have it.
- 39:30Yes, very rarely, I think will clients or will therapist do that?
- 39:36Oh, it's a good idea. Yeah, And if you really have
- 39:38to or go to the bathroom, just say, even if you don't know
- 39:43what to say, just being you know what, I'm kind of in a
- 39:45bathroom mercy. Can you have less I'm gonna go the bathroom in my back,
- 39:47or if you do have a bathroom mercy. I've heard therapists say,
- 39:52oh, we got to at a bathroom emercy. I didn't know what to
- 39:53do. It's like, just go to the bathroom. It's not you know.
- 39:57So I got my supervisor, and my supervisor came in and took over.
- 40:02I don't remember what happened exactly. I think an assessment was done in
- 40:07all this his own videotape by the way we could just go check the film.
- 40:12And I remember my teacher, I think I told him the circumstance and
- 40:15he watched like thirty seconds and he was like, well, yeah, what
- 40:19are you gonna do? It sounds like you did the best you could.
- 40:21And it was totally fine that My professor was just yeah, you know,
- 40:25what are you going to do? The client just didn't want to talk.
- 40:28That happened sometimes, and I thought I'm going to be kicked out of the
- 40:30program. So all that's to say is that that's an example of a client
- 40:36who doesn't feel super comfortable telling me what they're going through and apparently waited until
- 40:43the very last minute of the session. And maybe that is why he didn't
- 40:46want to talk, because he was ashamed to disclose that or something hard to
- 40:51know. Yeah, But the point is is that we can't necessarily know what
- 40:54a client is going through based on whether or not we asked. Getting back
- 41:00to the brief, So canceling sessions continued at two week intervals with no significant
- 41:05changes or improvements. So again, we know where this is headed, or
- 41:09we suspect where this is headed at this point, but they don't know.
- 41:13And what if what if I told you that I had a client that was
- 41:17experiencing treatment resistant depression, but I had conducted, you know, a thorough
- 41:23enough assessment of suicidal risk and told you there's no history of suicidal thoughts,
- 41:30there's no current suicidal thoughts, there is hopelessness. But the client has said
- 41:36that they don't think about suicide. And and I said, and I'm you
- 41:39know, I'm doing everything I can. The client is in psychiatric treatment and
- 41:46pretty frequent, and they're really trying a lot of different options or trying you
- 41:51know, the TMS or trying different meds. And I've seen the client twice
- 41:55so far, and I'm doing CBT. So what do you think about this
- 42:00CBT part? That's fine, it's part of the standard of care, is
- 42:02CBT, you know, Yeah, especially in the beginning. If I were
- 42:07to have a client that was experiencing this, I don't know if I would
- 42:12call it CBT in my mind, but it would look a lot like CBT.
- 42:15It would be a lot of cognitive techniques and also you know, behavioral
- 42:20techniques triggers and what to do with yourself to get yourself out of bed and
- 42:25to keep moving and one step at a time, and da da, da,
- 42:29so a lot of CBT would be recommended. You certainly wouldn't recommend let's
- 42:34talk about your traumas or let's talk about your childhood. That's not the direction
- 42:38that most clinicians would go in in a situation like this. But what would
- 42:42you think about the fact that I was still seeing the client every two weeks?
- 42:46Well, based on what said here is there, nothing's getting better,
- 42:50but nothing's getting worse. So I don't know. If I had time in
- 42:52my schedule, I might say, do you think we should change our frequency
- 42:55here? And if they had to, you know, if that was something
- 42:59they were interested and able to do, then you know, maybe we should
- 43:01pump it up, or maybe we should add something else like well, you
- 43:07know me, I think DBT, So maybe a DBT skills class would be
- 43:09a good adjunct after the second session. No, no, no, I
- 43:15mean I might, I might say that. I mean, but but I
- 43:17don't know that I would be thinking that now, Yeah for me, because
- 43:22I think it's easy to look at these cases and go, oh, that's
- 43:25bad. Yeah, yeah, right, But depression, especially if it's been
- 43:30going on for years and years and years, which we don't know the history,
- 43:34but it's possible that she's been depressed and she was a teenage yeah,
- 43:38and hasn't attempted or completed or thought about suicide the entire time is suffering quite
- 43:45a bit and that sucks, but there's no emergency here, right. Another
- 43:49part of it is that I'm guessing there isn't documentation about a conversation about the
- 43:52frequency of therapy, which is another thing we should say for clinicians out there,
- 43:58is when ever there's the possibility of something bad happening in the future,
- 44:04like suicide, and certainly there's a lot of things revolving around that possibility.
- 44:07With this case, right man, you need to document more about and assess
- 44:13more. And so with another client, say they come in for self actualization
- 44:16and it's every two weeks, and you had a conversation about how often,
- 44:21and the client was like, yeah, you know, I'm thinking every two
- 44:23weeks. Do you need to put that in the session notes? Probably not.
- 44:27You could, but you don't have to. It's not if I were
- 44:30the supervisor, I wouldn't say that would be something you absolutely have to indicate
- 44:35in your notes because it's not likely that anything is going to happen where the
- 44:38file is going to be scrutinized in that way, and even if it was,
- 44:42there was no indication of any kind of issue there. Now in the
- 44:45initial assessment there should be some mention of an assessment of suicide and other kind
- 44:52of risky behaviors. But if that's done the then okay. But if there
- 44:55is a risk of something bad, then any anything that could that's the way
- 45:00you. I always want to This is what I do with my trainees,
- 45:01and what I do myself is okay, there's no indicase of suiciety, but
- 45:05there's a lot of things revolving around that. Let's say this client dies of
- 45:07suicide next week or in a month or something. What would the if lawyers
- 45:14were trying to get me based on the file, what could they get me
- 45:20with. Well, they could get me with the two week thing. Well,
- 45:22that means I better. Even though I have a justification for it,
- 45:25I need to make sure I vet that with the client and document it right,
- 45:30because if you do that then it likely will be okay. But if
- 45:35you have nothing in your notes regarding your thinking process or the conversation with the
- 45:39client, because like you said, the client could have literally said I don't
- 45:42want to see you law I don't. It's not possible for me to see
- 45:45you if more than every two weeks, I can't afford it. If that's
- 45:49in the notes, then you know that helps. That helps doesn't necessarily protect
- 45:52you completely because you know other things you could do. But anyway, so
- 45:57at this point, it's possible that everyone's doing what they should be doing.
- 46:00Yeah, but there's not documentation of It's less than a month into psychotherapy,
- 46:06right, yeah, Okay, So skipping ahead to the end of August,
- 46:08so this all began in aprils, you know, five months later or something,
- 46:13the sixth counseling session is happening, So it sounds like maybe every two
- 46:19weeks, maybe a little bit longer than that. The six counseling session,
- 46:22the client reported to the counselor worsening depression, overwhelming sadness, and suicidal thoughts
- 46:30for the first time, but no plan or intent. So that's in the
- 46:35documentation, worsening depression, overwhelming sadness, and suicidal thoughts, but without plan
- 46:42or intent. So what would you think clinically if you heard that, Well,
- 46:45I'd be thinking our risk is going up. I'd be thinking crisis,
- 46:49and I'd also be curious about what's going on in life? Did something change?
- 46:52Is the more conflict at home? What have you? What's going on
- 46:57and can we learn about it? Yeah, also be thinking about med changes
- 47:01because there's possibility that could be a factor, and that also is a major
- 47:07concern. We know from research that when you have certain meds or mead changes
- 47:12again, even with people that are seemingly getting better with the depression, that
- 47:15can have a sudden, overwhelming, strange impulse to kill themselves. So greater
- 47:21monitoring and crisis planning is important. But anyway, yeah, I would be
- 47:27very concerned because there are so many risk factors at play right now. So
- 47:34I even though there's you know, if a client came to me with a
- 47:37different presentation and said, you know, for the first time in my life,
- 47:40you know, I kind of I've been having these thoughts that I don't
- 47:44want to exist anymore because I'm you know, I'm kind of sad about my
- 47:47life. I would get my attention. That would and then I do an
- 47:50assessment. There's no plann or intent. They're like, no, no,
- 47:53I'm not going to kill myself. I just I don't know. Sometimes I
- 47:58just have this flash thought and I instantly say no, I don't. I
- 48:02don't want to die. I don't want to do that to my family,
- 48:05and I'm pretty sure things will get better in the future. Something like that,
- 48:07you know, they'd be very low grade suicidal thoughts. Ish And if
- 48:15there was at a different situation without depression, without the med thing, without
- 48:17the guns, without the reports from the husband, which we don't know,
- 48:21if the councilor even knew about it, you don't know, if it was
- 48:24just that, then I wouldn't be terribly alarmed. It would be something to
- 48:29monitor over time. You know. I've had clients where the entire course of
- 48:31therapy for ten years, they're in that state where they just have this intrusive
- 48:35thought that that happens sometimes when they're demoralized, and it never rises above even
- 48:42just I just don't want to exist. I wish I didn't have to live,
- 48:45you know, it doesn't even rise to the level of therefore I want
- 48:50to kill myself, you know. So you know, I'm quite accustomed to
- 48:53that. But given all the other things that we've heard in this goal,
- 48:58there's a lot of major you know, ongoing treatment resistant depression. So not
- 49:02only is she hopeless, but she's becoming hopeless about her hopelessness. Yeah,
- 49:07overwhelming sadness, she reports right now, overwhelming sad. She was already pretty
- 49:12sad before new suicidal thoughts. Gun a history of substance use as another major
- 49:20risk factor. Something like half of all completed suicides are pleaded while the person
- 49:28is intoxicated, usually on alcohol. So it's you know, there's a lot
- 49:32of risk factors there, and that's where the art form of suicidal assessment kind
- 49:38of comes in because a lot of times it'll be reduced to well, do
- 49:43they have a plan, do they have intent? No, then everything's fine,
- 49:45But if you look at all the other things, and as you said,
- 49:47it only takes five minutes for something to happen. Yeah, Okay.
- 49:53Then the counselor documented that the client was a danger to self for others.
- 49:59So I think that it's that checkbox because it's in that quotation, you know,
- 50:05meaning that there wasn't much more documentation than that. The counselor documented that
- 50:10the client was a danger to self and others and advised the client to remove
- 50:15the guns from the home. Okay, so there's a documentation of that,
- 50:19I advise you to remove the guns from the home. So based on the
- 50:22brief. I think this documentation was very short, you know, the checkbox
- 50:29and then maybe a sentence of I recommended the clients the client get with the
- 50:32guns based on the way that this plays out. Not enough documentation. So
- 50:38it's another thing that I tell my trainees is that when you enter in this
- 50:42situation, this is a full, long ass paragraph that you write in your
- 50:46notes. This progress note will look very different from your other progress notes.
- 50:51Your other progress notes might have five sentences, maybe less, but this one
- 50:55will be a full page of very specific information. I talked with the client
- 51:02about this. The client said this. I administered this measure of suicidality that
- 51:09client tested for this. We talked about a safety plan. Here is the
- 51:15safety you know. We talked about triggers. You know, you do all
- 51:19the things, and sometimes you do it once and then you refer back to
- 51:22it in previous progress on so you're not doing it all the time. But
- 51:24first one time, there's like a really solid, very descriptive paragraph that uses
- 51:32all the subjects and verbs and objects. I talked with the client. Not
- 51:38client said or client indicates suicidality, okay to whom? Yeah? Right?
- 51:45And in one way, yeah, the client said this to me, you
- 51:51know, and then I said, da, da da, you know,
- 51:54not every word, not verbatim, but you know, very descriptive. And
- 51:59doing that at not only for me, I think more importantly it helps the
- 52:04clinician to galvanize their thoughts, because if you miss something, you got to
- 52:08revisit it in the second you know it's you're reviewing it afterwards, making sure
- 52:13you got all your stuff. A lot of times with me, I'll write
- 52:15that note in the middle of session with the client. I'll even show the
- 52:19client the note because I want them to know what I'm seeing. I like
- 52:24that, and also the crisis plan they need to see obviously as well,
- 52:28you know, so everyone's on the same page, you know, because I
- 52:31don't want them to die. Okay, So the client insisted that removing the
- 52:39guns was not necessary. So I'm guessing the client saying, well, you
- 52:45know, I just have a couple of suicidal thoughts, but I don't have
- 52:50a plan. I don't want to kill myself. It's not necessary to get
- 52:52rid of the guns. I'm guessing it was something like that. What would
- 52:53you do if a client did that? Well, they're free to keep their
- 52:57guns. I mean, who am I the cops. Right, it's there.
- 53:00We have a we have a clause in the constitution, So it's not
- 53:04up to me to get the guns out. It's up to me to document
- 53:06that I recommended that they get the guns out, that I really encourage them
- 53:09to get the guns out, that I encourage them to at least lock them
- 53:13up then or have their partner hide them or whatever. Right right, Yeah,
- 53:19that's a great thing that you mentioned, is that it's not just get
- 53:22rid of your guns. It's giving them options and saying like, well,
- 53:25look, you don't have to sell your guns necessarily, but maybe just have
- 53:29your husband take them to some other place like a storage locker that only he
- 53:35has a locker or two. Are you you're not getting rid of them?
- 53:37Or how about he just locked them up in a because you know, some
- 53:43people might say, well we have the guns for home safety. Okay,
- 53:45so they don't want to get rid of the guns. Well, how about
- 53:47your husband just get a lock that only he has the lock too, so
- 53:51that you know, in a pinch, he can actually get in there.
- 53:52But but you can't for the foreseeable future. Um, you know, throwing
- 53:58out options, documenting that the client still says no, We only have one
- 54:04recourse really at that point, where it is to seek involuntary treatment. Right.
- 54:09Well, if they're presenting as an imminent threat, it's not an imminent
- 54:13threat to own a gun. It's an imminent threat. You have reason to
- 54:15think that the person is going to use the gun, not could use the
- 54:19gun that's not an imminent threat, is going to use the gun as an
- 54:22imminent threat. So you have to document. You have to assess for it.
- 54:25Yeah, you might get it wrong, they might lie. I mean,
- 54:29anything could happen, but you still have to assess for it. The
- 54:30thing to keep in mind here is you cannot prevent somebody from killing themselves,
- 54:34but you don't want to lose your license over it. So be thorough,
- 54:37be careful, write it down, and keep in mind you don't want them
- 54:40to die, right, So do your best. Yeah, and this is
- 54:45the confusion that I went through actually at first when in Washington State. There
- 54:50are different court precedents and different laws and different states in the United States.
- 54:54And basically, long story short is, we have a lower threshold to being
- 55:00sued when it comes to a client taking action that is harmful to themselves or
- 55:05others. In the past, if you had a client that presented some indications
- 55:09of harm to self and others, but there was no identified target of you
- 55:14know, they didn't say I'm going to go kill Joe blow down the street
- 55:17if there's no identified individual. If they're just saying, you know, I'm
- 55:21going to get super drunk tonight and I might drive I don't know. Like
- 55:27in the past, that wasn't a situation which we had to do anything about
- 55:30it. We couldn't be sued if the client did get drunk and drove into
- 55:35someone and killed them, you know, but given court precedent, now we
- 55:38might get successfully sued or lose our license or something like that under that circumstance,
- 55:44and it's supposed to do about it. Well, so that you're in
- 55:46the exact same place I used to be before I heard from all the legal
- 55:51and the lawyers and stuff. Yeah, because from my standpoint, I'm like,
- 55:54that's bullshit. I don't have control over the clients. What am I
- 55:58supposed to do fallow them around and hit the drink out of their hand and
- 56:01take their keys this I'm only talking to the client an hour a week.
- 56:06I don't have the power. So I'm I'm screwed. I have to control
- 56:10all my clients or I have to terminate. Well, what what's my Okay?
- 56:15So we're not responsible to control or to prevent harm. We're responsible to
- 56:21do everything in our power reasonably within reasonable limits. We're expected to do everything
- 56:28we can to prevent the harm. So if the client here you're seeing,
- 56:32well, suicidal thoughts but no plan, no intent, but guns and alcohol,
- 56:37and I say, hey, let's get rid of the guns, and
- 56:39then the client refuses, Well, I'm not responsible to therefore go to the
- 56:45house and get rid of the guns or somehow call the cops on the house,
- 56:47because what are they going to do? But I am responsible to do
- 56:51everything in my power. Okay, So what's in my power to do?
- 56:54As you said to not only be very elaborate in your convincing and you're throwing
- 57:01out options and like, hey, how about you try this or how about
- 57:05this? Is there a worry that you're having if you did lock up your
- 57:08guns? Like what's the concern there? You know, you don't just say
- 57:12get rid of your guns and the client says no, and you just move
- 57:14on like you do everything in your power and then you document it. Okay.
- 57:19So that's one angle Another is that obviously you have a crisis plan and
- 57:22you involve the husband in that because he's at ground zero with all this.
- 57:27And if he's willing and the client is willing to involve the husband, they
- 57:30usually are, then you do that. And you also tell the husband,
- 57:35I'm recommending that we is there an option here where only you can have access
- 57:38to the guns in the house, or you know, is there something we
- 57:40can do here, or or the ammunition or something I don't know, and
- 57:44you talk about it with him. If he refuses, again, you document
- 57:46all that because you're thinking, if the client does kill themselves or kill him
- 57:52because we've heard about some conflict, then I will at least have it documented
- 57:58that I did everything within my power. And I also document that the risk
- 58:01level is not high enough to justify me seeking in volunteer hospitalization, because not
- 58:08only does it not wreck, does it not indicate that, but no hospital
- 58:12will admit a client under those circumstances. If they admitted clients under those circumstances,
- 58:17a third of the population of Seattle would be locked up in a hospital.
- 58:21Immedialized kidnapping. Right, Well, we can under certain circumstances. You
- 58:25know, someone has to be of imminent harm to themselves. So yeah,
- 58:30that's what you do. There's no indication that any of that happened, man
- 58:32of any conversation of anything. Okay. However, six days after the visit,
- 58:39the client died by suicide due to a self affected gunshot wound. That
- 58:44sucks. So this is after the six counseling session. This is about five
- 58:46months into psychiatric treatment, maybe four months into counseling, or maybe three or
- 58:52four months into counseling. And remember that the client comes into session the sex
- 59:00the sixth session and says, for the very first time to anyone, I
- 59:04have suicidal thoughts, but I don't have a plan. I don't have intent.
- 59:07The therapist says, well, let's maybe there's a longer conversation, let's
- 59:12get rid of your guns. The client refuses, and the therapists, according
- 59:15to the documentation, doesn't really go beyond that. The client goes home six
- 59:19days later kills herself with a gun. So this is another alert because there's
- 59:27a myth out there that people will have will indicate that they have a plan.
- 59:31People who have suicidal thoughts but no plan or intent are not really at
- 59:36risk of suicide. But as you were pointing out earlier, when you have
- 59:39a gun, because if she didn't have a gun, she'd probably still be
- 59:43alive today. Because it's this notion of somehow like if they really want to
- 59:47die by suicide, they'll do it it simply, it's not true. It's
- 59:51not in the data. Yeah, there are other ways you can kill yourself,
- 59:54and if someone's really determined, they know, they'll figure out other ways
- 59:58to do it. But guns make it so easy. Yeah, you just
- 1:00:01grab it and do it. It's impulsive. Yeah. Other methods require you
- 1:00:07know, I won't go into it, but require a lot more planning,
- 1:00:10a lot more thinking about it, the possibility of a not working, possibility
- 1:00:15of a lot of a lot of pain, of a lot of suffering up
- 1:00:19until the death. You know, like jumping from a tall height. That
- 1:00:24can be scary to people. It sounds strange, but you know, when
- 1:00:28people are in that position, they will think about that sort of thing that
- 1:00:30sounds kind of awful. I wish I had a gun, that kind of
- 1:00:35thing, you know. Okay, so let's take a break, deep breath,
- 1:00:38Yeah, we get back. Let's let's conclude this ethics case. All
- 1:00:47right, back from the break. So a toxicology report was administered on the
- 1:00:53deceased and it revealed high levels of alcohol, dazepam, and hydrocodone, which
- 1:00:59is valuum in vicd in brand names of those so alcohol, a benzo valium,
- 1:01:04and a pain killer vicodin. Yeah, which is a common scenario,
- 1:01:09as I was saying earlier, for people that will complete suicide. Sometimes it's
- 1:01:15an influence, like because of the drug use, their mood plummets, or
- 1:01:22they get into a big fight with someone and it escalates and that sort of
- 1:01:25thing. So sometimes one of the suicidal factors is this. But another possibility
- 1:01:31is that the person was already determined to attempt and they just took a bunch
- 1:01:36of substances to make it easier for them, or to make it be less
- 1:01:40pain or to assure that it will happen. That kind of thing, right,
- 1:01:45So start to know what the situation was. But okay, So shortly
- 1:01:49after the client's death, the family filed a lawsuit on behalf of the husband
- 1:01:52and the children against the insured counselor and the psychiatrist the family. The plaintiff
- 1:01:59asserted that a counselor knew the client was at risk of suicide and didn't do
- 1:02:01enough to address the risk. So just chiming in there, it's possible that
- 1:02:06they did, but they didn't document it because there's no there's no documentation of
- 1:02:10it right now. It's also possible that the councilor didn't do enough, didn't
- 1:02:15do it. Yeah, it's possible. The plain if further assertive. The
- 1:02:17family further asserted that the councilor and the psychiatrists failed to request an ROI,
- 1:02:22which could have helped them coordinate lowering risk of suicide. So the psychiatrist and
- 1:02:28the councilor never talked, didn't talk to each other because there was no you
- 1:02:32know, no release of information was sought from from the client. What do
- 1:02:36you think about that? That's a good practice to just get the ROI and
- 1:02:39consult and involve the client like we are a treatment team. Be a treatment
- 1:02:45team, the three of us without going into specifics. You know a lot
- 1:02:49of clients right now. Well, just sort of think about the clients over
- 1:02:52the past five years or something. What percentage of them do you have an
- 1:02:57ROI with another treatment professional? Maybe five percent? Really? Yeah, I'm
- 1:03:01actually after our meeting today, I'm talking to a therapist colleague of mine who's
- 1:03:07seeing one person who and I'm seeing that person's spouse, and we're gonna coordinate
- 1:03:12our efforts. Okay, Yeah. The reason why I'm a little surprised is
- 1:03:15given our type of clientele, which are not the super depressed individuals or people
- 1:03:22who suffer from other kinds of things like sizophrenia or something, there's not usually
- 1:03:27a big pelling or requirement to do that sort of thing. If you had
- 1:03:34a client there was suicidal. If you have a client that's suffering from eating
- 1:03:37disorder, for example, coordination of care is is the standard. But for
- 1:03:40you and I, that's not always the case. And so what I found
- 1:03:45for myself was, you know, if I had a client that, say,
- 1:03:49was suffering from anxiety and was being prescribed a benzo diazepine from their psychiatrist,
- 1:03:54I wouldn't have an impulse necessarily to talk with the psychiatrist as long as
- 1:03:58I felt like I had a good idea of what was happening with the client.
- 1:04:01I just would feel like it'd be kind of a waste of time because
- 1:04:05when I talk to physicians is you know, I can get a lot of
- 1:04:10information from the client about what it's like to talk to the physician the kind
- 1:04:13of thing and as long as everything seems to be going okay, I don't
- 1:04:17I just don't bother. So I think that there's that. Having said that,
- 1:04:23in this case, you have a client that is having a lot of
- 1:04:26ups and downs and treatment resistant depression and some risk of suicide, you just
- 1:04:32think that there would be some discussion, even if it was pretty brief,
- 1:04:36because I think that people will think, well, why wouldn't you talk.
- 1:04:41Well, one of the reasons is it's not it's not necessarily very productive.
- 1:04:45What are you going to say? You know, there's a possibility that the
- 1:04:49counselor, if they called the psychiatrist, the conversation would be like, yeah,
- 1:04:54so she has treatment resistant depression, and so I'm the counselor and I'm
- 1:04:59saying, you know, I'm basically doing CBT with her. Doesn't seem to
- 1:05:02be working initially, but you know, I'm going to stick it out,
- 1:05:05and she's complying with treatments and things to be going okay, how are you
- 1:05:11doing? And the psychiatrist as well. You know, I've been trying a
- 1:05:13lot of different meds. I'm trying to course of this and we'll see if
- 1:05:16that works. I've already tried this sort of thing. Okay, anything else,
- 1:05:19Nope, Like, you know, because the psychiatrist doesn't not necessarily know
- 1:05:26about talk therapy preserbably doesn't know and probably doesn't care necessarily just like just do
- 1:05:31your thing. I don't really care. And the counselor doesn't know anything about
- 1:05:36the meds ye specifically and can't really have a conversation about that. So,
- 1:05:42you know, but should there be But could there have been talk cross information
- 1:05:47around? Well, there was that moment when the husband called me and there
- 1:05:51was that thing, and on my assessment sheet she did talk about wanting to
- 1:05:56harm herself in the past, and so I just to give you that because
- 1:05:59the counser might benefit of you know, But what's the message that a client
- 1:06:03gets when the therapist and the psychiatrists want to talk to one another about the
- 1:06:08client's welfare and well being. It's one of it's protective and it's caring.
- 1:06:13Yeah, which is a really powerful thing, especially if someone who's suffering like
- 1:06:15this. Yeah, again twenty twenty, they should talk. But if a
- 1:06:21colleague or you came to me with this case prior to the death and said,
- 1:06:27and I asked a question, you know, have you talked to the
- 1:06:29psychiatrist and you said, no, I don't. I wouldn't really think anything
- 1:06:31about it. Yeah, because there's not a there's not you know, with
- 1:06:35an eating disorder, for example, I'll go into specifics, but there's a
- 1:06:39lot of there's things that necessitate coordination of care. Yeah. Yeah, And
- 1:06:45if I heard that the client was conflicting with the psychiatrist, or if I
- 1:06:50felt like the psychiatrist wasn't doing a good job, then I would want to
- 1:06:56talk to them, you know. Not that I'm a physician, but sometimes
- 1:06:59I'll hear wonky things, you know, like if the psychia like I guess
- 1:07:02if I were this counselor, I might want to talk to psychiatrist and say,
- 1:07:05like get a sense of why he's switching the medications so quickly, Because
- 1:07:14if I detected fear in the psychiatrist, I would actually say, well,
- 1:07:16you know, let's let me give me some time. I would just try
- 1:07:19to give a message of like give me a little bit of time to see
- 1:07:23if this will work. So then you imagine the ego you'd run into.
- 1:07:26No, No, I've had that. I've had psychiatrists that certainly have a
- 1:07:30lot of ego, but I've had some psychiatrists that appreciate it, because,
- 1:07:33yeah, because for a lot of prescribers, you know, some are great
- 1:07:39and have a very well rounded understanding and experience, but in my experience,
- 1:07:44under stress, they can be stressed out and they don't have necessarily a system
- 1:07:49in place that can help them with their emotions internally, or support or a
- 1:07:56way of framing it. And I've had to soothe psychiatrist before. I remember
- 1:08:01this one psychiatrist had. We had this client that was frustrating from a clinical
- 1:08:06point, and the client was frustrated to We weren't frustrated with her, but
- 1:08:11we were all frustrated together about her symptoms and ongoing issues. And I detected
- 1:08:15something and the psychiatrist because I heard something from the client, so and I
- 1:08:20probably already was coordinating care at that point, but anyway, I talked to
- 1:08:24the psychiatrist and I remember she was talking a lot about how she was She's
- 1:08:28like, yeah, you know, and the client came into session and she
- 1:08:30was talking about this and that, and I think my client just really liked
- 1:08:33to talk about her problems. She was open about that kind of stuff,
- 1:08:38and the psychiatrist wasn't necessarily use of that, and she's like, yeah,
- 1:08:42so what do you think. Do you think there's like a some sort of
- 1:08:45personality just order going on there? And I just detected a lack of nuance
- 1:08:48of understanding even what a personality sort of was. And I also I remember
- 1:08:54wondering if the psychiatrist was looking to that, because there are no meds for
- 1:08:58psych for personalities orders, so you can imagine a psychiatrist being tempted to go
- 1:09:03in that direction because it releases them from having to do anything something. Yeah.
- 1:09:09Yeah, it's like, well they're there, I can't help them because
- 1:09:13they have a personal disorder and it's their fault, that kind of thing.
- 1:09:15I mean, yeah, I don't know exactly right, And I had to
- 1:09:19talk with the Psychiatrist's like, well, you know, it's not really my
- 1:09:23clinical observation. Um, I think this is what happening. She she's just
- 1:09:26really going through a time, and I think she thinks of you as a
- 1:09:29good listener, so she's she's telling you things and and and you're right though,
- 1:09:34you know, I validated the psychiatrist, so you're right. She does
- 1:09:38present in a kind of interesting way. She's kind of mildly histrionic about the
- 1:09:45way she presents, but you know, it's not severe. And I've been
- 1:09:48with her longer and for years, and you know, and she's like okay,
- 1:09:53okay, well all right, and and it's like, you know,
- 1:09:56so so they helped them settle, Yeah, helped them to kind of re
- 1:10:00orient. And I think for some psychiatrists they want to pass the responsibility,
- 1:10:05which it really should be on me because I have way more contact and expertise
- 1:10:11in this area, and the psychiatrist wants to worry about the symptoms and the
- 1:10:15mats and stuff. And it's like, yeah, yeah, I got it,
- 1:10:17I got the ball. You know, I'm assessing, I'm treating,
- 1:10:20I feel optimistic about the future. Um, we just have to stay the
- 1:10:25course, you know. And you know, and so for some psychiatrists,
- 1:10:29they they really want that. I want that, yeah, and deserve it
- 1:10:32really because it's it's it's a lot for them to handle when they're seeing a
- 1:10:36client or a patient for fifteen minutes every month, you know, It's it's
- 1:10:41scary for them. Oh yeah. Whereas for us, we you know,
- 1:10:44we can kind of luxuriate. And I would not want that job. Yeah,
- 1:10:46yeah, yeah, I have literally like five hundred patients in a month
- 1:10:50and goodness. Yeah, okay, so so they got sued. Part of
- 1:10:55the suit was the ROI wasn't in place, got it? Yeah? Yeah.
- 1:10:58The release of information experts came in. Those experts for the defense.
- 1:11:04There's experts for the plaintiff that evaluate the case before it goes to trial.
- 1:11:09And the experts reviewed the case and they found that during the last counseling session,
- 1:11:14the sixth one, the client reported worsening depression and expressed contemplation of suicide,
- 1:11:18but denied having a specific planner intent. So they confirmed that. The
- 1:11:24defense experts asserted that the counselor probably should have done more, though they also
- 1:11:30asserted that the documentation was insufficient, and the plaintiffs expert also looked at the
- 1:11:35counselor and testified that the documentation of danger to sell for others. Remember that
- 1:11:42in quotations inferred there was a serious concern for the clients safety that was not
- 1:11:45addressed. So that is another If you're a clinician and you have one of
- 1:11:50those checkboxes thing, if you check one of those boxes, that does not
- 1:11:55mean you have done your job, you know, it means you need to
- 1:11:59aberate a lot in your notes and I think that's one of the pitfalls of
- 1:12:03having one of those checkboxes things is too it doesn't say if you check it,
- 1:12:09please explain in a paragraph, you know, or it doesn't prompt you
- 1:12:13to add to answer ten more questions. You know. They think, well,
- 1:12:15I check that box, so my assessment is done, my documentation is
- 1:12:19done. So I don't know if that's what happened, but I think it's
- 1:12:21possible. I'm old school man. I still write him out by hand with
- 1:12:26a pen, with a pen, yeah, yeah, I don't type of
- 1:12:28man write him Yeah, paper charts in a lock filing cabinet. Yeah,
- 1:12:31it's easier that way, it is, I mean for us, old people,
- 1:12:36for people. Yeah yeah. Defense experts also express criticism that the councilor
- 1:12:43did not use a standardized suicide risk assessment. What do you think about that?
- 1:12:47That's a good idea. Do you use one? No? Yeah,
- 1:12:50I don't think I don't, but I don't work with suicidal people anymore.
- 1:12:53In fact, if in the rare event that somebody would call me with that
- 1:12:57concern, m I screened for it. So I wouldn't flag someone for not
- 1:13:02using a standardized suicide risk assessment. It certainly can help and certainly will cover
- 1:13:06your butt later on. You don't need a standard You need to just document
- 1:13:11that you checked thoroughly. So you need to know what to ask about or
- 1:13:14look for. Yeah, because standardized means that it's been researched and it's been
- 1:13:20decided the consensus is that it's a good tool. I have never found a
- 1:13:24very good tool, honestly, So I developed my own that I used for
- 1:13:28that use for myself, and I also gave it to my supervise so my
- 1:13:31students. So it's not a standardized test because or assessment because it has them
- 1:13:36in research. Yet it is formalized and it's based on a lot of research.
- 1:13:42Yeah, it's developed by me, an expert, so I'm guessing that
- 1:13:46that would have also helped sufficient even though it's not quote unquote a stanardized suicide
- 1:13:50risks. But the point is is that you need some kind of a system,
- 1:13:56and if you don't have a system, if you just go off the
- 1:13:58top of your head, it won't work because there's too many details. There's
- 1:14:01too many things that you have to make sure that you do. There's checklists,
- 1:14:06and there's a lot of risk factors and protective factors and it's hard to
- 1:14:11know them off the top of your head, right, and it's hard in
- 1:14:15the moment to remember the thresholds of the different levels of risk. There's different
- 1:14:18systems of levels of risk. You know, there's no risk. Usually there's
- 1:14:21like minimal risk, medium or moderate risk, higher risk, and then imminent
- 1:14:27risk. So sometimes it's hard to remember those those thresholds, you know.
- 1:14:31So defense experts said, you know, would have been nice if you would
- 1:14:35have documented more and or also had a standardized suicide risk system. Also no
- 1:14:42safety plan, of course, because you would need to document a lot even
- 1:14:45to get to that point. But no safety plan at all. So that's
- 1:14:49a huge problem, really big mist that the client comes in says, I'm
- 1:14:57thinking about suicide and you barely have any documentation and there's no safety plan.
- 1:15:04Yeah, it's such an easy thing to do. Did they even talk about
- 1:15:08it then? I mean, not in this documentation, and I'm guessing not,
- 1:15:13probably not that because if you did, you'd think you would have mentioned
- 1:15:15it. Now Would that have prevented the client from killing yourself? Hard to
- 1:15:20say. It's not necessarily going to be preventative. It could be preventative,
- 1:15:25though, which is the reason to have it right. So I would guess,
- 1:15:29based on my protocol that that I could have prevented her or at least
- 1:15:33my system, which is the first thing that I go to, the strongest
- 1:15:39thing that I can go to. What do you think the strongest element of
- 1:15:42a safety plan that I could use. I think it's going to be involved
- 1:15:45people that care about that person, exactly, the husband. I don't know
- 1:15:47if it would work, but that would be the first thing that I would
- 1:15:51think about to try to make it work. And it always works for me,
- 1:15:57and seemingly because there's so much that the husband can do. Husband can
- 1:16:03alert the hospital or alert the police if something happens. You know, if
- 1:16:09she's highly intoxicated and she's clamoring to get to a gun and you can put
- 1:16:15the guns away, right. He can also just be there. One of
- 1:16:18the major factors of suicide completion is isolationally. And it's weird how And I'll
- 1:16:26tell this as I'm talking with clients and situations like this, I'll be like,
- 1:16:30I know it sounds kind of weird, but people when they have really
- 1:16:33high intent to kill themselves, if they're in a room with anyone, they
- 1:16:39often won't do it. It's weird. That that would be a barrier doesn't
- 1:16:42necessarily a barrier, but but often really what happens is if you're just watching
- 1:16:46TV or just crying in the bathroom and your husband is sitting there, the
- 1:16:53impulse that really rises to that action level of suicide doesn't usually happen from people.
- 1:17:00So if we can work together over the next week until I see you
- 1:17:02again next next week, so that you're just dev alone the guns that you
- 1:17:10know, so I will call the husband on the phone or get them to
- 1:17:15come in or something. But in the pinch, I'd probably just call them
- 1:17:17on the phone. As you know, I'd get permission ROI, Dad,
- 1:17:21tell the client, Look, this is what we're going to talk about.
- 1:17:24It's for your sake, dadada, and a lot. If I say it
- 1:17:28right, the client will really want me to talk to this because sometimes family
- 1:17:33members aren't supporting in the best way, you know what I mean. They're
- 1:17:38distancing or criticizing. Oh, you're just doing it for attention, when it's
- 1:17:42you know right, They just need some support and maybe a little bit of
- 1:17:45learning to help care properly for somebody who's in awful pain. Right. A
- 1:17:49big factor known to research regarding suicide completion is what they call thwarted belongingness.
- 1:17:56So if you can feel like you belong, yeah, then you're less likely
- 1:18:01in a lot of cases to complete or even think about suicide, So no
- 1:18:05safety plan. Defence experts also asserted that the counselor should have seen the client
- 1:18:12more frequently than every two weeks. It's pretty obvious, and should have obtained
- 1:18:15the client's consent to collaborate with the trading psychiatrist given the presentation, The insurance
- 1:18:21concluded that if this goes to court, they will likely lose, and they
- 1:18:27will lose big because the jury will likely have a lot of sympathy for the
- 1:18:30famili's loss. You know, imagine the kids get on the stand and talk
- 1:18:33about how the evil counselor and psychiatrists drop the ball. Yeah. I do
- 1:18:39have a problem with that because, you know, there's a lot that led
- 1:18:43up to the thing, and it doesn't all rest in the council's lap.
- 1:18:45They do have an ethical and moral responsibility and a legal one, but there's
- 1:18:49a lot of things that contributed to that poor person's downfall. True, but
- 1:18:55I think the way the tort law works is did the counselor fail to administer
- 1:19:00the standard of care. The answer is yes, Yeah, for sure.
- 1:19:03You're going to find a lot of very level headed experts that would agree.
- 1:19:09Oh, I'm not arguing that at all. I'm arguing the emotional thing where
- 1:19:13it's like, oh, it's the big bad therapist, you know, fault
- 1:19:15like right, like like I get that, that's the way the legal system
- 1:19:18works, you know, But when you think about a person's well being in
- 1:19:23welfare, and I'm not saying that this therapist doesn't have a huge responsibility.
- 1:19:26They do. Yeah, I'm saying that there's a lot that contributed to that
- 1:19:29poor person's suicide. Right, could have been trauma, could have been her
- 1:19:33parents, parents, could have been stuff in them. Maybe he was cheating
- 1:19:39or something. I don't know. Yeah, and we certainly wouldn't say one
- 1:19:43hundred percent of the blame is on the clinicians. No, No, they
- 1:19:45didn't do their job, is right, And it's not asking much that counselors
- 1:19:51do their job. Isn't that hard? It can be done, It can
- 1:19:56be done well. Now does it surprise you that the counselor didn't do their
- 1:20:00job? Sadly? Now? Yeah, yeah, yeah, I would say
- 1:20:03this is the average, This is the norm. This is not the excit.
- 1:20:08There's sometimes when we read these cases like a client having sex with their
- 1:20:12client with their therapist, those are the exceptions to the rule. But this,
- 1:20:17on the other hand, is in my adectual experience the norm, and
- 1:20:23the fact that we don't get sued more often is because clients simply just don't
- 1:20:28complete suicide very often. So I'm guessing if you did a random audit of
- 1:20:34random counselors across the United States, more than fifty percent would have all the
- 1:20:40problems that this case has. But the client just never attempts or doesn't complete,
- 1:20:45or the client doesn't complete, and the family just doesn't think to sue
- 1:20:48the therapist or whatever. So pretty sad situation. And if we have more
- 1:20:56than fifty percent that have this problem, then it's a problem with our profession
- 1:21:00and a problem with our culture and our training. Things are changing, for
- 1:21:02sure, especially in the last five to ten years. It like in Washington
- 1:21:09State, a bereaved wife of a husband who died by suicide. I believe
- 1:21:15she was a professor at University of Washington of like policy making or something,
- 1:21:18and so she went on a campaign to lobby and to raise awareness around counselors
- 1:21:26and mental health professionals that don't do their job regarding suicide assessment, and got
- 1:21:31a law passed ten fifteen years ago that requires all Washington mental health professionals to
- 1:21:36get six hours I think of suicide assessment and treatment every five years or something
- 1:21:42like that. And I remember when that started. I didn't like it because
- 1:21:46I hate all the rules that we have to follow, Just like, yes,
- 1:21:49we should all be good at suicide, but don't make me jump through
- 1:21:54a hoop on something that I already kind of know about, you know what
- 1:21:58I mean. But it's sort of like the seat belt law. When that
- 1:22:00first happened, I was sort of annoyed with it in the late eighties,
- 1:22:05but now I'm like, yeah, you know, it's it's it's probably a
- 1:22:10good thing that because before that, no one wore their seat belts. Can
- 1:22:13you imagine, Yeah, mid eighties seventies, I literally never wore a seatbelt
- 1:22:17unless I was in my friend's car and his mom was a stickler for seat
- 1:22:21belts and we and I remember we would all laugh at her. Yeah,
- 1:22:26and you know, yeah, freedom is good and rules aren't always the best,
- 1:22:30but sometimes we're so stupid we need those kinds are rules. Yeah,
- 1:22:33it's true, but anyway, Yeah, so I blame our treat our training
- 1:22:40programs. I blame supervisors for not because you could take a class on suicide
- 1:22:45assessment treat but it's a whole other thing in the real world, and supervisors
- 1:22:47are ground zero with their trainees and need to And that's I felt it was.
- 1:22:53That's why I did the whole deep dive on suicide a number of years
- 1:22:57back, because I was actually the first thing I was doing was developing my
- 1:23:00own training protocol and my own system because I had a research and ideas and
- 1:23:06different assessments, but none of them really encapsulated the whole thing, and so
- 1:23:12I developed it for myself and then as a as a byproduct of that came
- 1:23:15the deep dives that I did. And I thought, I just it's my
- 1:23:19responsibility. People hire me for supervision, and whether they ask for it or
- 1:23:25not, it's my responsibility to make sure that they're competent in this area and
- 1:23:28and that I serve it to them on a silver platter so that they don't
- 1:23:30have to spend all this time researching and developing tools. And da da dada,
- 1:23:35here's the training booklet here's the assessment thing, here the thresholds, here's
- 1:23:40what you do. Obviously call me as well, but here's here's the protocol
- 1:23:44and da dada, and there's a lot of other things that have to come
- 1:23:46into play, like with crisis plan. Some counselors will say, call me
- 1:23:51when you're suicidal, and I'll I have a whole module on that, Like,
- 1:23:55no, don't do that unless you are really prepared to be that kind
- 1:23:59of profession. But don't never. I'd have this in bold letters, never
- 1:24:02put yourself in the crisis plan. You are. It's tempting as a therapist
- 1:24:08to put yourself in the crisis plan. Have you seen that? Well,
- 1:24:11I've done it because I was that therapist that was available twenty four seven,
- 1:24:15and when that changed, I let my people know I work with that population
- 1:24:19anymore. But I don't. I'm not in anybody's crisis plan, right yeah,
- 1:24:24yeah, And it's um a huge burden for the therapist to be that.
- 1:24:30And I've and I've seen you know, therapists will call me and be
- 1:24:33like, um, because because I have throughout these these things. Because if
- 1:24:39everything works fine, then everything's fine. But oftentimes it doesn't. What if
- 1:24:43a client texts you and calls you and says, um, I'm in a
- 1:24:47pinch or I'm suffering, and then hangs up the phone, and then you're
- 1:24:51it's Friday night. But unlet's say, even if you have the free time
- 1:24:56and you're like, okay, so you call them back, they don't answer
- 1:24:59the phone. What you do, it's the only crisis plane. Often it's
- 1:25:01not you can you can't control for every circumstance, but if you're going to
- 1:25:05be part of the crisis team, then you've really got to be part of
- 1:25:09the crisis team, right, So then you put in there. If you
- 1:25:12call me and leave a message indicating risk and I call you back and I
- 1:25:15don't get a phone call, I'm calling the cops because that's the only thing.
- 1:25:19That's the best thing I can do, because I'm not going to drive
- 1:25:23out to your house. Dad. So the insurance concluded that if they go
- 1:25:28to court then they will likely lose big, but it was unclear if the
- 1:25:31plaintiff could convince the jury that the counselor committed a breach in the standard of
- 1:25:36care. So they didn't really know. Because although you and I are like,
- 1:25:41that's pretty bad, it's possible I think what the plaintiffs experts were thinking
- 1:25:45was that, well, according to the documentation, it doesn't look good for
- 1:25:47the counselor, but it's possible the counselor could get understand and saying, well,
- 1:25:51no, we talked about a lot of things that it didn't include a
- 1:25:55documentation I remember, And if the jury believes that, because you know,
- 1:25:58maybe the counselor did. So, it's not clear if there wasn't a safety
- 1:26:02plan, because there might have been kind of one. Also, the counselor
- 1:26:05could make it up because it's their word against a dead person's words. So,
- 1:26:10um, so, the plaintiff and the defense decided to try to reach
- 1:26:15settlement and mediation and the total own cur how much do you think the insurance
- 1:26:20company had to pay out, both in the legal fees but also the liat
- 1:26:28you know, the pain and suffering to the family because they also got sued
- 1:26:30for wages. You know, right right, that's part of half a million
- 1:26:34dollars. That's exactly it. Wow, you're on the money. Yes,
- 1:26:39yeah, well, actually it says greater than half a million, which I
- 1:26:42think means just a little bit more than half a million. But that's a
- 1:26:45good job. But that's that's a lot. That is a lot for our
- 1:26:49kind of cases. Yeah. Usually it's you know, if there's a payout
- 1:26:54at all, it's thirty five thousand dollars. It's something like that. Yeah.
- 1:26:57So, uh, I guess suicide, there's a there's a lot,
- 1:27:00there's a lot more. Yeah, possibility there. Yeah. Um, this
- 1:27:04is so scary. I mean, it doesn't have to be scary if you're
- 1:27:06just thorough, but just you know, these ethics cases always scare me.
- 1:27:11I always leave here like I think I got two more gray hairs? What's
- 1:27:15what's the fear of the fears that I'm actually that therapist? I mean literally
- 1:27:19like I'm like in their shoes and like like i just feel scared, you
- 1:27:23know, like as if it were me, what would what would they get
- 1:27:26you on? No, no, no, I'm saying literally, I'm like
- 1:27:29it's like I'm in their shoes and I'm going, you're watching a horror movie.
- 1:27:31Yeah, I'm watching a horror movie and you're like, get out of
- 1:27:33the house. Yeah right, they get the chainsaw, they get the chains
- 1:27:36yeah. Um. So in conclusion, to go over the risk factors that
- 1:27:42we heard in the case that were present, what were they for a suicide.
- 1:27:49Suicide. They had a history of thinking about it. Yeah, okay,
- 1:27:53they had um at the time of death, reported current thinking about it
- 1:27:58current. They didn't say they were an imminent threat, but they said they
- 1:28:00were thinking about suicide. They had a history depression, they had Well,
- 1:28:04we know it, but we don't know if the therapist knew it that there
- 1:28:08was tumult at home, if there was an ROI, there would have been
- 1:28:12that known. There was the statement about increased sadness and increased hopelessness, shited
- 1:28:20their others and guns. They had guns, yeah, the big Yeah they
- 1:28:25had guns. Yeah, a history of substance abuse and no safety plan,
- 1:28:30at least no documented safety plan. Yeah. Change in meds, right,
- 1:28:33not responding well to treatments, compliant, But but it's not helping, right,
- 1:28:40because if you're hopeless and you become hopeless about the hopelessness, as I
- 1:28:43was saying earlier, then you're really hopeless. Yeah, right, because it's
- 1:28:46like it's only going to get worse. It's a change of symptoms is another
- 1:28:53thing that the husband reported. Hard to know if what the accuracy of that
- 1:28:57is, and also evident possible evidence of the client not necessarily complying with treatment,
- 1:29:05because there seemed to be, at least in the way the brief was
- 1:29:09discussed, a possibility that she wasn't fully disclosing to her treatment professionals because the
- 1:29:15husband said something, then she comes in and says no. So there's some
- 1:29:18red flags that the client, for whatever reason, might be withholding some things.
- 1:29:24And when you have that, then you really as a mental health professional,
- 1:29:29just have to have to say, well, sky's a limit in terms
- 1:29:31of what's possible, So I have to be more careful under the circumstances because
- 1:29:35I can't even trust what the client is telling me is the full story.
- 1:29:40So better safe than sorry. So the problems, we've already been over them.
- 1:29:45But just to conclude, no safety plan, minimal documentation, no coordination
- 1:29:48of care, and if the counselor had an adequate conversation with the client making
- 1:29:55sure the client had no intent doing everything possible, you know, there's a
- 1:29:59possibility that if the therapist did indeed do all those things and the clients still
- 1:30:05died that one, they would not have been successfully sued, or even initially,
- 1:30:11they might not have been sued at all because the family would have known
- 1:30:15or something, and that the therapist was doing everything that they can right there.
- 1:30:21If there was an alliance like we so psychiatrist, therapist, anybody else,
- 1:30:29we are a treat and client themselves. We are a treatment team.
- 1:30:34Yeah yeah, yeah, So like you know that Top Gun in that movie
- 1:30:39Top Gun, they they they portray the Russia, a well known pinnacle of
- 1:30:45mental health depiction. Yeah, yeah, a metaphor. No, the um,
- 1:30:51the big pilots, the Russian pilots, they're they're in um. Like
- 1:30:58you can't see their faces when they show inside their cockpit. You know,
- 1:31:00they're not real. So it's easy to just vilify, you know, like
- 1:31:04this therapist is like a magpilot. You know, they're not a real person.
- 1:31:09They haven't established an alliance with you know, the husband in particular,
- 1:31:13I think, or whoever else is a protector. Yeah, interesting metaphor,
- 1:31:18but apt yea, And yeah, I mean as a family and a couple
- 1:31:24of therapists myself, right, the impulse is there for me, and the
- 1:31:30barriers of entry are minimal for me to do that. Just let's get the
- 1:31:34husband in here, let's get them all. I'm not treating the husband,
- 1:31:38but let's let's bring everybody in, you know, and I think Some counselors,
- 1:31:43some treatment professionals, they just oh, yeah, my training, they
- 1:31:46don't do that. They don't they don't think about that. Yeah, so
- 1:31:49you'll find in some circles they'll say that would muddy the waters, it would
- 1:31:55create chaos, it would be counterproductive, depends you know, like or even
- 1:31:59unethical. Some people will say it's unethical for you to have the husband in
- 1:32:02this session. Yeah, well it's just crazy talk. Yeah, literally,
- 1:32:08people will say that. So yeah, well, so it's the final word
- 1:32:13on this ethics case other than you're scared you need a beer. Final word.
- 1:32:20Um, well it is noon, so it's officially not the morning anymore.
- 1:32:24Oh yeah, bob, not having a beer. Um, learn your
- 1:32:28learn your trade. Learn your trade. It's not hard to learn. You'll
- 1:32:31you'll be glad you learned it. You won't. If you're listening to this
- 1:32:33case and you're a therapist, you will not regret learning. If you already
- 1:32:39learned it, great, good for you. But this is this is straightforward.
- 1:32:44And have a checklist. Have a checklist. Don't invent a wheel.
- 1:32:47You're right. Have a thing that you establish at a time when you're calm,
- 1:32:54that you pull out in the moment and maybe the little sessions of the
- 1:32:59client. Yeah, like here's what I do, here's what we're doing.
- 1:33:00Yeah, and if you want one model, you can listen to buy Deep
- 1:33:04Dies, which is available to patrons, and it walks all through that I
- 1:33:09provide the whole thing, right, It was just a lecture presentation of the
- 1:33:15system that I would use with my trainees. You know, did you do
- 1:33:17you provide folks with you know, like a paper. No, that would
- 1:33:21require publication and citation. Yeah, yeah, right, So I just you
- 1:33:28know, it's kind of weird how like people will ask me that, like
- 1:33:30could we see your notes or something? And as an academic, there's a
- 1:33:33huge chasm between yammering into a microphone podcast and publishing an official document from you
- 1:33:44as an academic. I mean, even those, um, the merch we
- 1:33:47have about apologies, I have to look to see I'm literally wearing the same
- 1:33:51Oh my god, that's you as my mug. You're drinking out of your
- 1:33:55shirt. But it's, uh, you know, if being healthy means being
- 1:33:58corny. But for the merch that I had for my apology components, I
- 1:34:03was really nervous about doing that, but I published it because it's a publication.
- 1:34:08You know, even though it's a shirt and a mug, it's still
- 1:34:11an academic publication. And I made sure that I formatted it in a somewhat
- 1:34:18of an APA sort of way. I think, I think I about to
- 1:34:26even used a typical APA font that you will see. But yeah, I
- 1:34:31mean, you know, like when I wrote my book on supervision, that
- 1:34:34you great book that you helped me write. Yeah, it's a good book.
- 1:34:38You're looking to learn how to be a supervisor? That is a great
- 1:34:40book. What's it called? Multi Role Clinical Supervision? Not a great title,
- 1:34:44but descriptive. And I didn't need to use all of the citations or
- 1:34:48the APA formatting or the standard of academic publication because I wasn't submitting to a
- 1:34:55journal. But I used all of it. You know, I did all
- 1:34:58of those things because not that I'm trying to fit in, but it's there's
- 1:35:02a reason why APA has all those rules of standardized publication and citation and arguments
- 1:35:11and you know, giving credit rek credits due and making sure you support your
- 1:35:14argue. You know, it's a reason why APA has all those rules.
- 1:35:16And so so that's why I don't just publish my notes or things like that
- 1:35:21that's fine. Yeah, I get it, because I'd have to do all
- 1:35:24that and I want to do other things with my time, because you know,
- 1:35:29when I do publish things, publish you printed a T shirt with footnotes.
- 1:35:33When I do publish things, half of the time spent is on the
- 1:35:40manuscript and the other half is on all that APA stuff. Making sure that
- 1:35:43I'm following all the rules and giving credit REK credits due and being acurate with
- 1:35:47my claims. That's a big one. It takes a long time, and
- 1:35:50I just have I'm going to die in thirty years ish and i have limited
- 1:35:56time on this planet. And along those lines, let's adjourn every one.
- 1:36:00Please take care of yourself and make sure you're an ethical therapist who consults and
- 1:36:04gets well training because you deserve it