Latest / Deconstructing Horror / Heretic (2024): The Big Lie of Religious Certainty (Part 2) | Deconstructing Horror
Transcript
- Ryan: The example you guys are using of like the fundamentalist going from but basically the the belief the belief system shifts, but the but the way I go about it doesn't shift. It reminds me of a of a roommate I had when I was at a very conservative, outrightly fundamentalist Baptist college. And his whole thing was he would always say, like, I used to believe in evolution, and I was like, I was like a real believer, but now that's all garbage, and I only believe the exact opposite. I'm like, okay, it took me a long time to realize, you're still the same person. Like you Jesus didn't, like his words, not mine, Jesus didn't fundamentally change everything about you. He just shifted the thing you were trying to convince other people of. So With like with you guys doing work and, you know, with tribute teaching in the philosophy of religion space, where does like in your opinion, where does that come from? Like that that mindset, is it just like hardwired into us at some point? This is how I'm gonna communicate beliefs the rest of my life? Or is it a thing that's taught as opposed to caught? tripp: Okay, I mean there's two bits of it, right? Like that that framework didn't really exist for most of human history because we're in a rather unique situation, where there's a host of variables, right? So we're post reformation, so the individual subject is the believer. post reformation in and then like beliefs are what leads in defining your faith, right? And just, you know, you could just pause and think to yourself, how many times did Jesus clarify to the disciples the specific things they needed to believe? And go ahead. It's not long to think of it. Now, go ahead and think through all the ways in which you act, relate, and engage the world, Jesus taught his disciples to do, and expected that you would do them so much, he goes, he sometimes began things and he says, Well, when you do these things. He doesn't say like When you believe in the triune God or when you believe in blah blah blah like all the in the one times the big time you get like a specific theological confession in the New Testament, I mean the gospels, Peter's confession, Jesus, you are the Christ, Son of the Living God. Jesus doesn't go thinks you read Isaiah correctly, I am the suffering servant, the evidence demanded the verdict. He says, My heavenly Father revealed that to you, right? So it's not even like the correct belief is the result of right reflection using your reason and scripture or whatever. It is an experiential encounter or revelation from God, right? And so, like we're at a time where we think, beliefs first, the individuals has some kind of oblig ethical obligation to understand, articulate and defend it. The belief precedes and justifies the religion. And so that is our situation then which develops, then throw in, right? the sheer diversity of religious options that people encounter day to day, not at the end of a colonialist battle or in another nation state, but in neighbors that your kids enjoy playing with. we live at a time where if you take that belief centered thing, and and or especially the anti intellectual defended defensive ones that both atheists and And theist of the types we're talking about tend to do, right? Where it's either literally true or literally not true as if the word literally is like helpful Ryan: Yeah. tripp: or related to what a biblical text is, right? And so if that's the case, all the things we've learned about history and science and things, there's a kind of fragilization of belief that takes place if our form of faith is belief first. And has to be verified, defended, and articulated on these terms. And so like as you get a situation where the the expectations of an early Reformation Christendom for faith encounters a post-Enlightenment religiously plural world with now the a at a kind of exclusive humanist option, right? The ability to live a good life without ultimate reference to ultimacy, Ryan: Yeah. tripp: then they're the you're going to be anxious. But what if what you're being anxious for isn't really religion and it's not even the majority of any of the living religions history. It's the kind of, you know, late modern Frankenstein gone wild version. It's like where where the monster that you created in r the Reformation becomes a threat to undermine your beliefs in a post Enlightenment context. And so the the I and so w but see if you're in that situation and then you think, like you really think the the the ability to make sense of the world necessitates a f the true version. As if it's accessible and understandable and transferable, then you're going to be anxious. Right. And so that's why emo check has this other kind of not she's way less anxious because the that's that's not her expectation. And Ryan: Yeah. tripp: does it actually keep her from being on mission or from even inviting people into their religious community successfully? No. Right. Because their answers are not ultimately a threat to her encounter with the divine in the LDS church. Ryan: Yeah, mean she straight up says it when Hugh Grant gives like you said, when he gives that, you know, ten minute Wikipedia search breakdown of everything that preceded the historical Jesus. She's like, Are you kidding me? That guy has a has a bird head. Like there's several Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah, that line is funny. Ryan: like that I I found her her response her response to that moment so therapeutic of like, you know, I'm gonna she risks herself in the direction of of having actual faith as opposed to his very scientific and we've we've said controlled environment. He does not operate outside of an environment that he cannot control. And that like that is weakness to it. That's like the dic dictionary definition of weakness. It like to only put myself in situations that I have a distinct advantage in. That it like it is absolutely infuriating when you realize what he's doing. Like even okay, so earlier, trip trip referenced the the the five minutes they had to close his eyes. Here was one of the parts that I closed my eyes in, but then I realized afterwards, my god, it's a it's a psychological trick, and it works on me as the viewer. When they open that hallway. And it's it's wide open, there's nothing in there, and they turn the corner and they see the statue. That freaked me the hell out. And then I was like, wait, it's just a statue. But he puts it there on purpose. He puts it there so if you turn the corner, there is that that fear, that doubt, that don't come any closer. And I was like, You crafty son of a bitch. Like That's a real good trick because it worked on me. And I'm like, I'm looking behind me, I'm looking down my hallway. And I'm like, my God, that worked. You're controlling the environment. So that to me gave away the fact that he was just he's he's setting this up because he's weak. He doesn't actually like have an upper hand on them. And I I feel like sometimes the like the tactics people use when they talk about belief. It's really it's just that. It's a tactic to make you feel like you should be on your heels. Like you should be on the defensive. Josh, is there anything to to to add to that like that idea that belief systems are are kind of weaponized against people and how they're weaponized against people? I do have another follow-up I wanna get to, but I don't wanna leave this if you have have a thought on your mind for the for this train of thought. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Well, I'm just thinking like something that both of you have mentioned, ra either implicitly or explicitly, is the kind of existential aspect of faith, which that that tends to get left out in like more fundamentalist spaces, whether rather whether that be atheist or or theist. and like it's you know, in reality, it's it's painted as like this, you know, say the Reddit atheist is like this. open-minded person, blah blah blah. But what you realize is actually no, their like epistemological framework is extraordinarily narrow and controlled. And you have to play within that framework in order for it to go anywhere. and so like even in those kind of conversations, you know, the the existential bit is important, but also like logic can't Tell us everything. Like you can't capture reality in logical syllogisms. Like it just doesn't happen. Like, give me a logical syllogism to explain you know, the connection between like you and your spouse when you're having sex. You can't. Or like when you hold, I don't have I've never had this experience, but like when you hold your child for the first time, you can't capture that logically. And so there's some things in life that you can't. know that way, you can only know by doing. And that is the egg that is an existential kind of truth. You know, William, this is like William James makes this argument in a famous lecture he gave, I think, at Harvard. Is that was Will to Believe delivered at Harvard trip? Yeah. Where he basically is trying to give justification for having like religious faith without having like a hundred percent logical proof. and what he does is, I mean, I don't have to walk through the whole argument. I don't know if that'd be helpful. Ryan: You want to, don't you? Josh Patterson (He/Him): I do kind of want to, but ultimately he comes to the conclusion that yes, it is justifiable to have you know, religious faith even when we don't have sufficient, you know, logical evidence because of this kind of existential bit. Like there are some truths that just require doing. Like with for example with Trip, for example, if I was like, I met Trip on the internet. I wonder if we're gonna be friends. If him and I just sit in our respective offices pondering if Josh and Tripp are gonna be friends, nothing fucking happens. I have to meet Trip halfway. We both have to do something to get at that truth. So like we have to risk being wrong. We have to risk, you know, whatever. to come to a a place where now we know the truth is that Trip doesn't like Josh or Trip does like Josh. or whatever it is. So that's the I don't know. Ryan: It it it so i if I'm hearing this correctly, it would r it would require you to go outside of an environment that you have absolute assurance in. Like you would have to like you would have Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yes. Ryan: to put yourself out there and be like, Will Tripp and I be friends? I have to kinda I have to risk something, at least at the very least being uncomfortable or, you know, at the very worst, you know, being rejected. but Hugh Grant's character doesn't do that at all. He he he only sets himself up for his version of success, I guess. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah, and and James makes this point where he's like, There are these two things that often get put together that we must know truth and we must avoid error. And he critiques and says, they sound like they're saying the same thing, but they're not. tripp: Uh-huh. Josh Patterson (He/Him): and that's one of his critiques. And I think that's Hugh Grant's character cares more about avoiding error than actually knowing truth. Because in order to know truth, you will be wrong sometimes. It's like necessitated in the discovery of truth. So like yeah. Ryan: it it's only when the perceived error shows up and Sister Paxton's like, Hey, you made an error here. That's that what you said there makes perfect sense because that's the moment that he actually gets uncomfortable. Is when the error is pointed out. I okay, I Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah, and things start to unravel. Yeah. Ryan: Josh, I I know I know this I don't know if it's gonna seem like a a a left turn, but you have through the last few years been casually teaching me about theopoetics. And I feel like the a that end scene where she's praying for Hugh Grant as he is coming closer and closer and she says prayer doesn't work. Is her prayer in that moment what would you classify that as an act of theopoetics of not having that absolute sh assurance, but I am still engaging with the with the I guess the the nature of faith without having it rock solid. Is that completely off base? Josh Patterson (He/Him): no, I think you're right. Actually I'd be I'd be here curious to hear Trip riff on this as well. But like, yeah, so theopoetics, theopoasis, or like God making basically theopoasis. within the you know, there's different ways it's been talked about in the tradition. Sometimes it's just like tied to Christian mysticism and it's still like this neoplatonic mysticism thing. The way that I use that, and I'm pulling from Caputo. Is he's not saying he's not saying like hold up, we are using poetic language to describe this being God. God is like, we're not writing a poem about God. Ours talk about God is the poem, God is a part of the poem, and so humans constitute or actualize the divine. So in in that moment, when she prays. she is actualizing the divine. She is like Caputo calls that a theology of the event. Like in that moment, the insistence of God was actualized in her prayer. And so like I would say yes. I think it's a moment of theo poetics. but I yeah, I'd be curious if Tripp has any thoughts on that because he likes he likes radical theology, but then he likes to be like, Josh, process is better. tripp: Well, it is, but that's beside the point. And Josh Patterson (He/Him): Ha ha ha tripp: also I'll just say it was a the revival of theopoetics was because of Catherine Keller, who Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yes. tripp: is a processed theologian. But I'm sure Josh Patterson (He/Him): Shout out. tripp: horror films people love deep nerd cuts in the current academy among philosophers of religion. So the okay, so that li th one, you note why she says prayer doesn't work. It's here's a study this or Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yes. tripp: that right and actually there are plenty of studies that would say the other way right and also the the the purchase of what work means there is miraculous intervention of some type right all that like the the number of things that are entailed in the assessing of whether prayer works or not are connected to her rather naive view of faith. Right. And so part of what is being made again there is a a way of thinking about the God world relationship in a dynamic synergy that isn't a miraculous intervention or sitting on the sidelines, right? And so the in and what you tell me what if you you know, it's a play with the word miraculous, but like that you were praying for the one who you think just killed your friend. And are giving him a dignity he hasn't given any of the women in his torture thing. is that anything less than a powerful demonstration of the grace of God. That's why it moved Josh, right? And so i so many times I I think it's our expectations that we it's like we hand the divine Two doors to walk through and then go, you didn't go down the one I want. Screw you. This isn't it doesn't work. And the whole time you're it you know, what if the problem is they you w I mean, I know at least in the monotheistic traditions, we have this origin story that we thought it would be really cool if we could possess the knowledge of good and evil so we could sit in God's seat and create the conditions of judgment and assessment. And that was a problem. Right, but the you're occupying that space of having seized that which is not yours and then you create the conditions for God to be God. Like the kind of hubris that's entailed in it is just like befuddling. Right. It's in and there's so many narratives in religious traditions where people take that those kind of assumptions. And the story is the divine's like, Whoa, whoa, can we go back to the who made who thing? Right? Or take, you know, Job. Ryan: Yes, that's exactly where my mind. tripp: Or Abraham on multiple occasions. like yeah like Abraham's sitting there like complaining to God, like, you promised this, blah blah blah and and God's like, son, you need to chill out. Ryan: Bitch! Well, I in tripp: The Ryan: trip, like the the second you started down that train of thought, I immediately thought of when when God comes to Job and says, excuse me, where the hell were you? When I did all of this and it kind of just like puts Job in his place. Jo Josh and I had a conversation where Job came up as well, you know, in the dis in a discussion about judgment and Job being a good example, a critique of what did you say, Josh? It w Job acts as a critique of Josh Patterson (He/Him): I I would say one way to read it is a critique of retributive justice or theology of retribution. The like if you do Ryan: Yeah. Don't spend Josh Patterson (He/Him): good, good things happen, bad, bad things happen. Yeah. Ryan: Job's been coming up a lot and I feel like maybe he's he's good fodder for horror interpretations. I I I usually do this Josh Patterson (He/Him): My favorite part of Job is how God just uses people as pawns in his stupid games with Satan. That's my favorite part of the whole book. Ryan: You that that is that is so you. that's like like Hugh Grant's character, just moving pieces on his little no his little chessboard, his little in his little incel modeling project. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Call it. Ryan: so tripp: Yeah, could you imagine going on a date with that guy? Josh Patterson (He/Him): my gosh. Ryan: Absolutely not. tripp: He would be like, my wife has a pie. Ryan: I'm married to a candle. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. Ryan: I so d you tripp: It's edible wax. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Let me pour it on you. Yeah. Ryan: it's body wax. Yeah. I tripp: Ryan, I I can I ask you a question? Ryan: sure tripp: Okay. I've been going back and forth on what it was, but you get you know the piece of wood that breaks off when they're trying to climb out, and then she hides it. Ryan: Yes. Yep. tripp: It's literally a piece of wood with three nails on it. And then Ryan: Yeah, super subtle. tripp: that's that's that's what she uses to kill the dude later. like w what did you make of that? Ryan: I honestly there were several points in this in this movie, that being one of them, where it's like, huh, okay. Like it was just like a like an Easter egg. I was like, piece of wood, three nails. Well that was I mean, bravo to the screenwriter, you know, who overlooked, you know, one of the gospels and and picked up that one. I I did like it kind of as like a subtle nod to that's the thing that, you know that's the thing that quote unquote saves. them at the end, but then Sophie Thatcher's character, Sister Barnes, the one who kills Hugh Grant with the board of three nails, she still dies. And I know there's a lot of theories about, you know, I I'm sure you can find a a YouTuber that looks a lot like me who would be like, the ending of the heretic, you know, can you know, explained or whatever. but There's a lot of different interpretations of like if that is that is that the death spiral that Sister Paxson's on and she's seeing herself as being saved. but that moment where Sister Barnes gets up, does the salvific act of saving her friend, but then dying, I'm like, okay, I can I can get behind this. Like, at least as imagery, I I I liked it. tripp: Yeah, and and I would say like one one possible reading is right the the crucifixion is like the death of God meaning this kind of thing, right? And the whole premise of the kind of finality of like the one true religion, right? That kind of thing. it's like the cross itself is auto deconstructive. of that kind of certainty and it's ultimately what kills like what kills the threat of the one true explainer of God is God's death, not you know, and th I would say sh you you say she just dies, but the last scene is the butterfly scene. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yes. tripp: And you get earlier in it where they're talking about the afterlife and like, well if I came back, I want to be a butterfly Ryan: back as we're fine. tripp: and I want to let the people I know I love them there and I want to land on their hand. And so the like not only does that scene right in some way the butterfly in the hand kind of signals the limits of both the inherited LDS stories finality, thinking about life, but it also problematizes the reductive atheist thing, right? And it suggests the viability of Of her faith, even though she just lost it going in there and is the only one that survives, it can persist in the presence of the unknown and the unexplained. Right. So like her friend in in a way, like resurrects her faith, where now she has a faith that can contain promise without promising all the answers. Right. And the butterfly, like, is that signal, right? That her own intuitions when she dreamed of you know what you would do. are are are so shared between you know, between the two of them in their friendship, that's the actual narrative that's used to like signal promise, hope, faith on the other side of certainty. Ryan: Good one. Like the the promise that doesn't have to pro I I'm I'm butchering it, but like the promise that doesn't have to promise everything is that was really that that struck a chord. now the the the the man in the front row that got really excited when Tripp said death of God. Josh, you about to say something there? I cut you off. Josh Patterson (He/Him): No, but I did I did get excited, about that. But I was thinking too, like another this is gonna like kind of deter us off the death of God thing, is that okay? Like another Ryan: No, that's fine because my next my next question was, Josh, you you've heard this one before, but my next question is my closing question of you know, is there anything that we need to like come back to and cap this conversation Josh Patterson (He/Him): yeah. Ryan: off with that you you don't want to leave unsaid before we get done? Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah, so I think I'm curious what you guys think about this because there's you know, there's also the and trip, you and I talked about this last night. There's the like LDS brother that comes to the house, right? And like Yeah. tripp: Seventy show dude. Ryan: Eric Foreman. Yeah. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. And like it's rather obvious that something sketchy is going on, right? And then he leaves tripp: Yeah. Josh Patterson (He/Him): and then he comes back and like, you know, I'd be remiss, blah, blah, blah. And they make it set up so like he's gonna like challenge him or something. And he gives him a fucking pamphlet. Like, I one way, one possible way of reading that could be, you know, and maybe it's because whatever I haven't watched it yet, but whatever that thing on Netflix that everyone's watching, Death of a Pastor's Wife, it could be seen as a critique of institutional religions when they know something bad is going on and then they fiend an investig an investigation. So they like on the surface look like they're doing the right thing. While they know something sketchy's going on and then they just pass it over. Like I think it could be seen as a critique of institutional religions that way. Abuse. tripp: Yeah, 'cause he like he his fear, much like the other dude, Hugh Grant's character, it it's his fear that drives him, right? So he sh his fear is like he's the obedient sheep being you know, f bound by duty. So he's doing his job to go find them. He he's like anyone that is ultimately a servant of an institution that doesn't protect the most vulnerable in it. He does his due diligence so the lawyer can't complain, but like it does not take much like I mean, a moderate version of like just a a little bit of observance skills. You're like the the answers that guy's giving are not adequate. And then like you Ryan: Yeah, shady as hell. tripp: obviously are thinking about the experience as you're leaving, and then you're like, you know what? I really missed an opportunity to share the gospel of the Lord. And you go back and you know, the obviously the best way to share it is with a pamphlet. That's so Josh Patterson (He/Him): Check tracks. tripp: so so powerful, right? And so we return to the door of the clearly disturbed dude that's that's got big sus vibes, and there's no other explanation you have left of where two teenage girls that you're supervising are, and what does he do? Another kindler, gentler version of what Hugh Grant does, right? Like the all the missionaries and all the women being tortured in the middle of this house are subject to both of their systems. And they're they won't they're they're completely he's committed in the house to having the one true religion and he's committed to his duty running interference and and you know s running the missionary group. But he doesn't like It doesn't like animate what animates him is the checklist of fidelity. Not like did I check on him? Did I give the track? Not like basic observational skills. This dude is super sus. Right. And at a time where ever the you know, from clergy abuse on, all the stuff where people's fidelity to an institution leads to the neglect of the weak and vulnerable, namely children and women o overall, th they both neglected the kind of attentive awareness to a system of death. And yeah. Ryan: Just to add real quick, I can't believe I'm adding to something trips thing, but whatever. it's Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. Ryan: you see him literally before he realizes that Barnes and Paxton aren't back at the mission. He is literally doing chores. And this is just another chore he's doing is making sure, like, well, they they're usually back by 5:30, you're usually back by 5.30. Before I can call it a day. I gotta make sure these two human beings are okay. And God forbid, like I I might have to go and check in on a few places. Also, like Hugh Grant is is Hugh Grant's playing a game, but Tophor Grace's character is also playing a game. It's I think it's a less overtly violent and malicious game, but it's still like, he's still trying to, like Tripp said, like, I'm just trying to clear my name here so that if someone says like By the way, where did Paxson and Barnes go? And you're like, I I d I did my due diligence. I did all the things I was supposed to do. It's like, yeah, but they're still not back. Like, we don't have those two human beings we sent to strangers' houses. so like we're kinda worried. And he's like, it's just another chore I do, man. Like what do you I just work here. tripp: Yeah, and it's Hugh Grant's character's like, Well have you called the cops? Ryan: Why why? I know I could see that, like him being the villain in the movie, him being like, you know, like, have you called the cops? No, I didn't call the cops, and he's internally thinking like, yes. you know, but but also it's like you had to have the creepy, anti social, like incel dude remind you that you might need to call the cops with two missing people? Come on, dude. tripp: Yeah. Does anyone think he did? I don't think he Ryan: Yeah. tripp: called till the next morning. I bet he went home, went to sleep, and he's like, They didn't get there today, but I totally brought that guy a track. Ryan: Can't pin it on me. tripp: I have the heart I have a servant's heart. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. Ryan: Trip, is there a is there a like a a final thought, like a thing that you wanna return to or something that we just can't stop the conversation without you getting that getting getting that burning question or burning thought off off your mind? tripp: I would just say like one of the one of the things like when you step away from the film, that I think is a is a helpful gift wherever you are, is the it performs for you the like utter defeat of attempting to possess and know everything Which is ultimately a desire for you to be able to control and manage the divine. Right? Whether it's by you know, pushing God all the way outside of the world onto a cross, or putting God right at the center of everything, structured in your nice order. and what is often culturally the often culturally we signal belief with intelligence and justifications, the most faithful one in it and the one you you know, is close enough to God to be a butterfly, right? Is the the the one who had a very different relationship to their own faith coming in and coming out. And so the and and yet, you know, you could imagine if you go back to that first scene which, you know, really sounded like the female version of Jay and Silent Bob talking, right? The about the the Yeah, that Ryan: Think magnum condoms are actually bigger. tripp: kind of stuff. the the like if you think back to that scene, an institution prefers the doe eyed naive commitment and yet The one whose faith finds purchase and possibilities in real challenges is the other one. And and so h one of the gifts the film gives is for those that have no idea how they can perform doughy eyed naive belief anymore. The film's like evidence that good. Like like you don't have to stay a baby forever. It's not Ryan: Right. tripp: like that is a normal part of life. Like every you don't even know how to speak when you're born. You learn the language, rhythms, rituals, stories, and beliefs of a tradition. But the whole point of it is the trans your own transformation so that you can be an active agent participating with the the divine in life and in relationship. And so the it like to me that that's a pot that is an invitation to a different way of holding one's faith. that is compelling and beautiful e even if you know there's about five minutes that are completely unnecessary for me to see that Ryan: And I'm curious, Tripp, what five minutes were that? Or what was that in the film? tripp: nasty vomiting profitus thing. I don't like up close stabby Ryan: I knew it. tripp: pokies. I'm like I can just see it from behind or aside. Like use shadow better. Like why right when convulsing vomit poison stuff and guts are coming out of someone do I need a up close picture? Like you have it's all in the dark and then you're just like, just so you know. Ryan: Never eat Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. Ryan: never eating fruit pie again. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. Ryan: I I just tripp: I thought for a second that he was gonna like have that creepy lady cut them pieces of pie and serve it to them and I was like, Nah, I don't even wanna watch anyone eat this. Who knows what's in that thing? I wasn't even thinking about poison. I'm just like Ryan: Just two normal people eating pie and you're like, no no no I've seen enough. man, that's great. tripp: I mean I don't I d I don't wanna know what the sanitation grade of that kitchen is. Ryan: it's hor I be I guarantee it's horrible. I I just one thing you said there, kinda coalesced into my the thought that I took out of this movie was how Sister Paxton is is set up as this like, look at this. Look at this person. She's just another one of the sheeple who, you know, is just, you know she's so th thinly, you know Tied to this belief system, but then she she goes on like a journey of faith throughout the entire film. Like in a in an hour and fifty minutes, she she becomes and evolves into something that he didn't expect. And I love the, you know, yes, she prays for him, and that's like her ultimate act of faith at the end, is to do something in the face of like complete, you know guess annihilation that he's not he's not approaching her to be like you know what you were right I was wrong this whole time he's like no no no no no you're gonna die you're gonna die like and and I do love that when she's up in the hallway, she asserts herself, challenge him, debate him. And that's her like, she's gone through her like Dark Knight of the Soul part of part of the movie, and she comes Josh Patterson (He/Him): Uh-huh. Ryan: out and she's like, Okay, like I I I need to do something. I can't just keep being a bystander here. I need to confront it. Even if even if I'm completely up against it and I'm probably not gonna make it out of here. I need to I need to know that I am capable of challenging him. And she does. And she composes herself very well and it's it's it leads to the final, you know, act of the movie. I just I I really loved that. Josh, do you have a final thought? that just wanna end with or we are we good? Josh Patterson (He/Him): I mean I I think we're good, dude. I I've really enjoyed this conversation. I I think Yeah, I don't know. It it for me it it really is just I always get hung up on this whole like the existential side of faith 'cause that's very much like that's the world that I live in these days. and so this movie I think demonstrates that that beautifully. you know, and even like the I'm reminded too of like it Was it Sister Paxton you said was the one who makes it out at the end? Ryan: Yeah, yep. Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah. So there's also something about like kind of it reminds me of like, you know, those like little old ladies at church that have been faithfully attending this community for 60 years and like every Sunday makes food in the kitchen and whatever. And their maybe their belief system is seems kind of like shallow or basic on the front end. Ryan: Wait. Josh Patterson (He/Him): But the way that they existentially risk themselves, the way that they live in the world demonstrates the depth of their faith. And I think there's you know, her character also kind of makes me think of that kind of, you know, person in real life as well, that we kind of want to dismiss quickly is like, the little old lady who, you know, her faith is so shallow, the Jesus loves me, this I know kind of person. But when in reality the way she lives her life, etc., demonstrates the depths of her. Her faith and commitment, which I think is cool. So that's just another Ryan: so guys, before we we wrap up here, I just wanted have Trip and and then Josh like tell you a little bit about Beer Camp and how you can still engage with Beer Camp. with it just coming up, we're releasing this before all three of us are gonna be at the event. so Trip, tell people a little about Beer Camp and how they can engage with it. tripp: Yeah, so Theology Beer Camp, this is the ninth year. It's October eighth to tenth. This year we're in Kansas City. it's sold out. There's gonna be seven hundred people there. and for the in person, but there's also an online version and you you know, there's gonna be like thirty plus scholars like Cornell West and Gary Dorian and Ilya Dilio, Diana Butler Bass, Kristen Dumay. Like it's it's Lots of nerdy fun and then like thirty different podcasts, including Ryan, Josh and I's and a bunch of others. And there's a whole series of sessions that are like nerding out about like geek stuff, including there'll be a live version of your podcast. I know there's gonna be a host of other like nerd sessions, including the Tolkien session and things like that. So, there's you can sign up. come online. Theologybeer dot camp is a website. And then you'll be able to pick two different stages you can watch live throughout the day. And then you'll also get the recordings of all the other stages and such. So it's it's a it's a lot of fun. And you know if we still had in person tickets I'd tell you about lots of other cool stuff that happened there. But next year. Next year you can all come and it's it's always exciting. and This year I'm confident will be more enjoyable for Ryan because he's not participating in hot ones. Last year, Ryan, a friend of ours was not feeling very well. And Will Rose was not feeling well. It's his Ryan: you can you can name names here, trip. Yeah. Coward. tripp: birthday, you know, so I didn't want to, you know, throw him under the bus on his birthday. And Ryan: recording this on his birthday. tripp: and and he wasn't feeling well. So Ryan, you know, just because he's a a good friend. steps up is like, don't worry, I'll do it. And we were we were in the same Airbnb that night and now Ryan's commitment to hot ones was significant. but only a small portion of it was demonstrated publicly unless you were in an Airbnb with him and needed to use the restroom in the night because the cold floor near exit station was the very popular place for the does. Ryan: Peace. So I will say this to not give you too much detail on this trip was right across the hallway from the bathroom. So anything that happened to me, he heard. and Hot Ones was definitely not what I had envisioned for my beer camp last year, but two friends that have done episodes of this podcast with me, good friends Leah Robinson and Christy Whaley were the ones hosting Hot Ones. And when Will bowed out, I was concerned about Will because he was all jet lagged and he wasn't feeling well. and stuff, I said, well, I'm willing to help out a friend, but also I don't want Leah and Christy to call me a coward or worse. So I tripp: Well Ryan: was like, you know what? Let's just get this over with. I ate so much ice cream and and and and hot wings and gosh, it I I don't want to relive it, but I'm glad I did it. tripp: Yeah. Yeah. I feel like the outro music for this episode is ring of fire. Ryan: Get Johnny Catch's people on that. but yeah, you can check out Theology Beer Camp information below. Josh, could you just real quick tell people what the what like the theme of camp is this year and like w what what the vibe is going to be like if they tune in online? Josh Patterson (He/Him): Yeah, yeah. So this year's theme is the God Podcase, which is super fun. So we're pulling from a bunch of like apocalyptic, post-apocalyptic IP. so we're doing like Stranger Things and Dune and Battlestar Galactica and like all this kind of stuff. So it's gonna be it's gonna be super cool. The different stages are themed after these different IPs. the I think my favorite stage that I'm most excited about is the upside down. I love Stranger Things. And so the upside down is literally in the basement of the church appropriate. Ryan: Yeah. Josh Patterson (He/Him): We're gonna have well, I guess for online people this doesn't matter, but we're having a post-apocalyptic prom in the upside Ryan: Yeah. Josh Patterson (He/Him): down with a DJ, and an MC, and it's gonna be it's gonna be a lot of fun. So that's kind of the vibe. I mean, you Ryan: Yeah. Josh Patterson (He/Him): know, if you look around, the world sometimes feels like it's on fire, and we tripp: Huh? Josh Patterson (He/Him): we get to Ryan: I have no unearthly Josh Patterson (He/Him): Come together Ryan: idea what you mean. Josh Patterson (He/Him): in solidarity with one another as a community, you know, to explore ways through. So Ryan: I appreciate you guys. I love you both. can't wait to see you in Kansas City. super excited to give you guys hugs and hang out and get to see some fantastic other friends that we I only get to see once a year. really excited about beer camp this year. But if you enjoyed this ed edition of the podcast and you enjoyed our discussion on heretic, just feel free to subscribe, leave a comment, tell us what you enjoyed about it, give it a thumbs up, all those things. And just remember that no matter what is going on in the world, that the horrors may persist, but so can we. Boom.