Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How the Best Marketplaces Use Dynamic Pricing to Balance Supply and Demand
Transcript
- Lucas: So last week I booked a surf lesson through a marketplace called Surfy, and the price changed three times in the hour before I confirmed. And I thought — this is exactly the kind of friction most marketplaces try to avoid. But Surfy's founder told me that dynamic pricing actually increased their conversion rate by 22 percent. Luna: Wait — you surf? Lucas: Badly. But the point is, Surfy uses real-time price adjustments to balance supply and demand. And it's not just them. Uber's surge pricing, Airbnb's smart pricing — these are marketplaces that treat pricing as a liquidity lever, not just a revenue tool. Luna: I feel like most listeners have a love-hate relationship with surge pricing. Like, you get hit with a 2x multiplier on a rainy night and you're convinced the algorithm is personally robbing you. Lucas: Right. But Uber's argument is that without surge pricing, there'd be no available rides at all. The price signal pulls more drivers onto the road. In 2019, Uber published a paper showing that surge pricing increased driver supply by 35 percent in high-demand zones within 10 minutes. Luna: So the price spike isn't just about extracting more money — it's about getting more supply into the market. That's the liquidity argument. Lucas: Exactly. And Airbnb's smart pricing feature, which they launched in 2015, uses a similar logic. Hosts can opt in, and Airbnb's algorithm recommends a nightly price based on local demand, seasonality, and similar listings. They claim it increased booking rates by 15 percent on average. Luna: But here's the tension: consumers often perceive dynamic pricing as unfair. A 2022 study from the Journal of Marketing found that 60 percent of respondents felt surge pricing was exploitative, even when they understood the rationale. Lucas: That's the trust problem. And it's why some marketplaces avoid dynamic pricing altogether. Ebay, for example, uses auctions, which are a form of dynamic pricing, but the price is set by bidders, not an opaque algorithm. There's more perceived fairness because people see the bidding process. Luna: Right. But auctions create their own friction — you have to wait days for an auction to end. For a surf lesson, or a ride, you need to transact now. Lucas: And that's where Surfy's approach was interesting. They didn't use surge pricing per se. Instead, they used scarcity-based pricing: as slots filled up, the price ticked up. But the key is they showed the reason — 'only 2 spots left at this price' — so users felt it was a fair signal of demand, not a money grab. Luna: Transparency around the algorithm. That's a big lesson. Airbnb also shows hosts why the recommendation is what it is — comparable listings, local events — so it feels less like a black box. Lucas: Let's dig into the numbers a bit. Surfy's founder told me that before dynamic pricing, their no-show rate was around 25 percent. Instructors would hold slots, people wouldn't show, and the marketplace lost trust on the supply side. After implementing dynamic pricing — with cancellation penalties tied to the price — no-shows dropped to 15 percent. Luna: So dynamic pricing also reduces the cost of empty slots. That's a second-order effect. It's not just about maximizing revenue in the moment — it's about protecting supply side economics. Lucas: Right. And that's why I think the best marketplaces think about pricing as a liquidity tool first. They ask: what price will bring enough supply and enough demand together to make a transaction happen? The revenue is almost secondary. Luna: But there's a flip side. If you're a marketplace that relies on predictable pricing, like a subscription box or a B2B service, dynamic pricing can undermine the value proposition. You're selling certainty, not flexibility. Lucas: Good point. So the decision hinges on the type of marketplace. For time-sensitive, perishable inventory — rides, hotel rooms, surf lessons — dynamic pricing is almost essential. For curated goods or long-term contracts, fixed pricing might build more trust. Luna: And the implementation matters. Uber learned the hard way that extreme surge pricing during emergencies — like during the 2017 London Bridge attacks — can backfire spectacularly. They later capped surge pricing during emergencies. Lucas: That's a critical nuance. You can't treat pricing as purely algorithmic — you need guardrails. Uber now has a 'price ceiling' during disasters, and they donate a portion of surge revenue to the affected area. That's a brand decision as much as a pricing one. Luna: So for founders building a marketplace today, what's the one thing they should take away? Lucas: I'd say: start with fixed pricing, measure your liquidity metrics — fill rates, time to first transaction, no-show rates — then experiment with dynamic pricing on a small segment. Surfy tested it for two months on just one beach before rolling out. Luna: And be transparent about what you're doing. Show the user why the price changed. That alone can convert a negative reaction into a positive one. Lucas: Exactly. Dynamic pricing is a scalpel, not a sledgehammer. Used well, it can unlock liquidity that no static price can achieve. Used poorly, it erodes the trust that marketplaces depend on. Luna: Alright, speaking of trust — we keep this podcast ad-free and that's something we're proud of. But it only works because listeners like you support it. If today's episode gave you something useful, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest thing, but it adds up. Lucas: Yeah, truly. It's the reason we can keep diving into these operator-level details without any sponsorships or agenda. So if you got value, that link is all we'd ask. Luna: And back to pricing — one more example I wanted to mention. A marketplace called Turo, the peer to peer car rental platform, uses dynamic pricing for a slightly different reason: to manage fleet utilization during holidays. They found that raising prices 20 percent during peak times actually increased total revenue by 30 percent without reducing bookings — because demand was that inelastic. Lucas: That's a great case. It shows that dynamic pricing isn't just about balancing supply and demand — it's also about capturing value that would otherwise be left on the table. But you have to know your demand elasticity first. Turo had years of data before they could calibrate that. Luna: So the common thread: data, transparency, and experimentation. No one gets it right on day one. Lucas: Right. And that's why the best marketplaces treat pricing as an ongoing conversation with their users, not a one-time decision. It's a tool that evolves as the marketplace matures. Luna: Alright, next episode we'll look at how marketplaces handle fraud — specifically, the synthetic identity problem that's been plaguing fintech-enabled platforms. Lucas: Looking forward to that one. For now, thanks for listening.