Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 38 - AI Checkout Hype Check: Shopify's Numbers, Aviator Nation's Early Wins, and the Small Business Digital Divide
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to The Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's e-commerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Okay, so picture this.
- 0:29[Rachel] You're checking out online, and it's not you clicking buttons anymore.
- 0:32[Rachel] It's a bot doing the shopping for you.
- 0:35[Speaker 3] Sounds relaxing.
- 0:37[Rachel] Right?
- 0:37[Rachel] Shopify's throwing money at it.
- 0:39[Rachel] OpenAI's got a whole checkout thing cooking.
- 0:41[Rachel] Google's in there too.
- 0:43[Rachel] Everybody's building the robot cashier.
- 0:45[Speaker 3] Big flex from all three.
- 0:46[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 0:47[Rachel] This is The Checkout Point.
- 0:48[Rachel] I'm Max.
- 0:49[Rachel] That's Rachel.
- 0:50[Rachel] And we've got a lot to get through this week.
- 0:52[Speaker 3] We do.
- 0:53[Rachel] But here's my question before we even touch the fancy tech.
- 0:56[Rachel] Is any of this actually working yet?
- 0:59[Rachel] Like, are people buying stuff through AI, or is it just a
- 1:01[Rachel] really expensive demo?
- 1:03[Speaker 3] That's...
- 1:04[Speaker 3] Yeah, that's the question I want answered too, because I've sat in
- 1:07[Speaker 3] enough meetings where the slide looks amazing and the ROI slide is
- 1:11[Speaker 3] blank.
- 1:12[Rachel] Oh, no.
- 1:13[Speaker 3] I'm serious.
- 1:14[Speaker 3] Adoption numbers versus announcement numbers are two different documents.
- 1:18[Rachel] We'll get into whether the hype matches the actual behavior.
- 1:21[Speaker 3] And stick around because later we're talking about who's actually growing right
- 1:25[Speaker 3] now, and it is not who you'd guess.
- 1:28[Rachel] Small guy versus big guy, it gets uncomfortable.
- 1:31[Speaker 3] A little.
- 1:32[Rachel] Seriously, though, if you've got a small shop, stick with us to
- 1:35[Rachel] the end because that part's for you.
- 1:37[Speaker 3] It's not just filler.
- 1:39[Speaker 3] It's kind of the whole point of today's rundown.
- 1:41[Rachel] Alright.
- 1:42[Rachel] Platforms racing to build this AI shopping future before anybody's proven shoppers
- 1:46[Rachel] even want it.
- 1:48[Rachel] That's where we start.
- 1:49[Speaker 3] Let's see if the emperor's got clothes.
- 1:56[Rachel] Okay, so here's the part that actually stopped me scrolling.
- 1:59[Rachel] Shopify's own explainer breaks down this whole thing called the Universal Commerce
- 2:04[Rachel] Protocol.
- 2:05[Speaker 3] The one with Google?
- 2:06[Rachel] Co-built with Google, yeah.
- 2:07[Rachel] But check the backers list: Amazon, Mastercard, Meta, Target, Walmart, and Visa.
- 2:14[Speaker 3] Wait, all of them on the same protocol?
- 2:17[Rachel] All of them.
- 2:18[Rachel] Like, companies that fight each other for every dollar of ad spend
- 2:21[Rachel] are suddenly holding hands on Checkout infrastructure.
- 2:25[Speaker 3] That's actually kind of wild when you put it that way.
- 2:28[Rachel] Think about what that actually means for a merchant, though.
- 2:31[Rachel] If Visa, Mastercard, and Meta are all speaking the same Checkout language,
- 2:35[Rachel] That's supposed to mean way less integration headache down the road.
- 2:39[Speaker 3] In theory.
- 2:40[Speaker 3] Instead of building six different custom connectors for every AI shopping surface,
- 2:45[Speaker 3] you build once and it plugs into all of them.
- 2:48[Speaker 3] That's the promise anyway.
- 2:49[Speaker 3] One spec instead of a pile of one-off partnerships that break every
- 2:54[Speaker 3] time somebody updates their API.
- 2:56[Rachel] So what's actually in it for the merchant beyond fewer headaches?
- 2:59[Rachel] Like, does this get them in front of shoppers who weren't finding
- 3:02[Rachel] them before?
- 3:03[Speaker 3] Maybe, eventually.
- 3:05[Speaker 3] Right now, it's still mostly plumbing.
- 3:07[Speaker 3] The traffic gains are a separate question from whether the pipes exist.
- 3:11[Rachel] Right.
- 3:12[Rachel] And it's not just Shopify's corner of the Internet.
- 3:14[Speaker 3] Because OpenAI is doing their own version.
- 3:17[Rachel] OpenAI's own announcement lays it out.
- 3:19[Rachel] It's called Instant Checkout built with Stripe running on something they call
- 3:24[Rachel] the Agentic Commerce Protocol.
- 3:26[Speaker 3] Okay, walk me through what that actually does because protocol names mean
- 3:30[Speaker 3] nothing to me.
- 3:32[Rachel] Fair.
- 3:33[Rachel] Basically, US ChatGPT users can already buy stuff from Etsy sellers straight
- 3:38[Rachel] inside the chat window.
- 3:39[Rachel] No tabs, no cart, just buy it there.
- 3:43[Speaker 3] Right now.
- 3:44[Speaker 3] Not a pilot, not a wait list.
- 3:46[Speaker 3] Live now for Etsy.
- 3:48[Speaker 3] And OpenAI says over a million Shopify merchants are coming soon on
- 3:53[Speaker 3] top of that.
- 3:54[Rachel] A million.
- 3:55[Speaker 3] A million.
- 3:56[Rachel] And here's the part I like.
- 3:58[Rachel] OpenAI specifically says the product results in there stay unsponsored.
- 4:03[Speaker 3] So it's not like paid placement dressed up as a recommendation.
- 4:07[Rachel] That's what they're claiming, yeah.
- 4:09[Rachel] Merchants just pay a small fee when a purchase actually completes.
- 4:12[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 4:13[Speaker 3] That's a meaningfully different business model than search ads, if it's true.
- 4:18[Rachel] I mean, think about what pay only when it completes changes for
- 4:21[Rachel] a small shop.
- 4:22[Rachel] You're not paying for clicks that go nowhere.
- 4:24[Rachel] You're only paying when someone actually buys.
- 4:27[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 4:27[Speaker 3] And that's the argument for it.
- 4:29[Speaker 3] It shifts risk off the merchant and onto the platform, which is
- 4:33[Speaker 3] usually the merchant's favorite kind of deal.
- 4:35[Speaker 3] Though I'd want to see the actual fee percentage before I called
- 4:38[Speaker 3] it a good deal.
- 4:39[Speaker 3] Small fee is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
- 4:43[Rachel] There's always an, "if it's true," with you.
- 4:46[Speaker 3] That's my whole job here, Max.
- 4:48[Rachel] Fair enough.
- 4:49[Speaker 3] But step back for a second.
- 4:50[Speaker 3] Amazon, Walmart, Target, Visa, Mastercard, Meta on one side.
- 4:56[Speaker 3] OpenAI and Stripe over here doing their own thing with a million
- 4:59[Speaker 3] merchants incoming.
- 5:01[Rachel] Two totally separate rails both claiming they're the future of how people
- 5:04[Rachel] are gonna shop.
- 5:05[Speaker 3] And here's the thing, they're not even compatible with each other.
- 5:09[Speaker 3] A merchant plugged into one doesn't automatically show up in the other.
- 5:13[Rachel] Which means everybody building a storefront right now has to make a
- 5:16[Rachel] bet on which rail is gonna matter more without any real data
- 5:20[Rachel] to base that bet on.
- 5:21[Rachel] That's a rough spot to be in if you're a smaller brand
- 5:24[Rachel] trying to decide where to spend your dev hours.
- 5:26[Speaker 3] And nobody's asked the boring question yet.
- 5:29[Rachel] Which is?
- 5:30[Speaker 3] Is anybody actually using either of them?
- 5:34[Rachel] Exactly, because a backer list is not a user count.
- 5:37[Rachel] Visa signing a press release doesn't mean my mom's buying a candle
- 5:41[Rachel] through a chatbot.
- 5:42[Speaker 3] No way is my mom buying anything through a chatbot, Max.
- 5:46[Speaker 3] I promise you.
- 5:47[Speaker 3] So that's what I actually wanna know before we crown anybody.
- 5:50[Speaker 3] Forget who signed on.
- 5:51[Speaker 3] What does the traffic look like?
- 5:53[Speaker 3] What are people actually doing at checkout right now?
- 5:56[Rachel] It's kind of like everybody announcing they built a highway before anyone's
- 5:59[Rachel] checked if cars are actually driving on it.
- 6:01[Speaker 3] Right.
- 6:02[Speaker 3] And press releases are cheap to publish.
- 6:04[Speaker 3] Building an actual road people use, that's the hard part, and that's
- 6:08[Speaker 3] exactly what nobody's shown us yet.
- 6:11[Rachel] Which is exactly why the backer list doesn't settle anything for me
- 6:14[Rachel] either.
- 6:14[Rachel] Six giant companies signing onto a protocol tells you about ambition, not
- 6:18[Rachel] about whether a single shopper has clicked buy through it.
- 6:22[Speaker 3] Ambition versus usage.
- 6:23[Speaker 3] That's the whole gap we're chasing this episode.
- 6:26[Rachel] That's the pivot, isn't it?
- 6:27[Speaker 3] That's the pivot.
- 6:28[Speaker 3] Pitch decks are cheap.
- 6:29[Speaker 3] I want the adoption numbers.
- 6:31[Rachel] Then let's get into what's really happening on the ground because it's
- 6:34[Rachel] not quite the story either side is telling.
- 6:36[Speaker 3] I've got a feeling I know where this is going.
- 6:43[Rachel] Shop.
- 6:44[Speaker 3] Okay, actual numbers.
- 6:46[Speaker 3] Shopify's own explainer says AI-driven traffic to their stores jumped eightfold year
- 6:51[Speaker 3] over year in Q1 2026.
- 6:53[Rachel] Eightfold?
- 6:54[Rachel] That's a big jump.
- 6:55[Speaker 3] It is.
- 6:56[Speaker 3] And AI search orders, so people actually buying after an AI sent
- 7:00[Speaker 3] them there, that's up almost thirteenfold.
- 7:03[Rachel] Wait, 13 times?
- 7:05[Rachel] Okay, now we're talking real growth.
- 7:07[Speaker 3] I mean, thirteenfold on orders is the number that actually matters to
- 7:10[Speaker 3] me.
- 7:11[Speaker 3] Traffic is easy to inflate.
- 7:13[Speaker 3] People click all sorts of links.
- 7:14[Speaker 3] Somebody actually finishing a purchase after an AI sent them there, that's
- 7:18[Speaker 3] a real signal.
- 7:19[Rachel] Sure.
- 7:20[Rachel] But real signal and real revenue aren't the same thing either, right?
- 7:24[Rachel] A store could see orders jump thirteenfold off a base of basically
- 7:28[Rachel] nothing and still be talking about a tiny slice of total sales.
- 7:31[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 7:32[Speaker 3] We don't know the base number.
- 7:33[Rachel] Exactly.
- 7:34[Rachel] And multipliers without a denominator make for a great headline and a
- 7:38[Rachel] much murkier picture underneath.
- 7:40[Speaker 3] Right.
- 7:40[Speaker 3] And until Shopify actually publishes a base number, I'm treating both of
- 7:44[Speaker 3] those multipliers as Directionals, not definitive.
- 7:47[Speaker 3] It's a great headline stat, but headline stats are exactly the kind
- 7:51[Speaker 3] of thing marketing teams pick because they flatter the story.
- 7:54[Rachel] Directionals fine.
- 7:55[Rachel] Just don't let anyone put eightfold on a slide and call it
- 7:58[Rachel] proof of anything.
- 8:00[Rachel] I wanna see it against last quarter's actual order volume before I
- 8:03[Rachel] get excited.
- 8:04[Speaker 3] Traffic and orders, yeah.
- 8:05[Speaker 3] But traffic isn't revenue, and I wanna know who's actually flipping the
- 8:09[Speaker 3] switch on this stuff.
- 8:10[Rachel] So who said the eightfold number anyway?
- 8:13[Speaker 3] Which matters because these traffic numbers didn't leak.
- 8:16[Speaker 3] They got handed to us directly by the guy running the company.
- 8:19[Speaker 3] That's a flex, but it's also just marketing until we see who's
- 8:22[Speaker 3] actually converting.
- 8:24[Rachel] Sure.
- 8:24[Rachel] Though, to be fair, companies usually don't lead with numbers that make
- 8:27[Rachel] them look bad.
- 8:28[Rachel] If Finkelstein's sharing it, it's probably one of the better stats they've
- 8:32[Rachel] got.
- 8:32[Speaker 3] Shopify's own president, Harley Finkelstein, shared that one.
- 8:35[Speaker 3] Marketing Brew picked it up.
- 8:37[Rachel] Okay, so it's not some random blog post.
- 8:39[Rachel] It's coming from the top.
- 8:40[Speaker 3] Right.
- 8:41[Speaker 3] Straight from Finkelstein.
- 8:42[Speaker 3] But here's the number that stopped me.
- 8:44[Speaker 3] Marketing Brew also reported that as of March, only about a dozen
- 8:48[Speaker 3] Shopify merchants were actually using Agentic Checkout.
- 8:52[Rachel] A dozen?
- 8:54[Rachel] Out of how many stores are on Shopify?
- 8:56[Speaker 3] Millions.
- 8:57[Speaker 3] A dozen merchants live because of limited platform access.
- 9:01[Speaker 3] So all that traffic Shopify's bragging about is mostly just browsing.
- 9:04[Speaker 3] People looking, not buying, at least not through the agent.
- 9:08[Rachel] That's like everyone lining up outside a store that's only got one
- 9:11[Rachel] register open.
- 9:12[Speaker 3] And that one register thing isn't just a metaphor.
- 9:15[Speaker 3] If only a dozen merchants can actually run this, then all that
- 9:19[Speaker 3] traffic Shopify's bragging about is mostly just browsing.
- 9:22[Speaker 3] People looking, not buying, at least not through the agent.
- 9:26[Rachel] So the eightfold and thirteenfold numbers are basically bumping into a wall
- 9:29[Rachel] that Shopify itself put there by limiting access.
- 9:33[Rachel] That's kind of a self-inflicted bottleneck.
- 9:35[Speaker 3] Self-inflicted, but also kind of understandable.
- 9:38[Speaker 3] You don't wanna open the floodgates on a brand-new checkout flow before
- 9:41[Speaker 3] you've stress tested it.
- 9:43[Rachel] Sure.
- 9:43[Rachel] Caution makes sense.
- 9:45[Rachel] It just means the eightfold headline is doing a lot more work
- 9:48[Rachel] than the reality behind it.
- 9:49[Speaker 3] Kind of, yeah.
- 9:51[Speaker 3] And it's not just Shopify being slow.
- 9:53[Speaker 3] Fast Company talked to a Forrester analyst, Emily Pfeiffer, and she said
- 9:57[Speaker 3] brands are rushing into this because of FOMO.
- 10:00[Rachel] FOMO?
- 10:00[Rachel] Like fear of missing out FOMO?
- 10:02[Speaker 3] Exactly that.
- 10:03[Speaker 3] Her quote was that nobody's actually figured it out yet.
- 10:07[Rachel] Wait, an actual analyst said nobody's figured it out.
- 10:10[Rachel] That's kind of a gut punch for anyone who dropped money on
- 10:13[Rachel] this.
- 10:14[Speaker 3] It is.
- 10:15[Speaker 3] And Fast Company also said the OpenAI and Shopify Instant Checkout rollout
- 10:20[Speaker 3] fell short of what was originally promised.
- 10:22[Rachel] Fell short how?
- 10:24[Rachel] Like fewer merchants, fewer categories?
- 10:26[Rachel] What?
- 10:27[Rachel] That's frustrating not knowing what fell short even covers.
- 10:30[Rachel] Categories, geography, merchant count.
- 10:33[Rachel] We're just supposed to take smaller than promised on faith?
- 10:36[Speaker 3] They didn't spell out every detail, just that the scope came in
- 10:40[Speaker 3] smaller than what got announced.
- 10:41[Speaker 3] Which fine, that happens with early rollouts.
- 10:44[Speaker 3] But it does make you wonder how much of this whole space
- 10:46[Speaker 3] is still just plans on a whiteboard versus something a shopper can
- 10:50[Speaker 3] actually touch today.
- 10:52[Rachel] So you've got a company saying traffic's up eightfold, and in the
- 10:55[Rachel] same breath, a dozen merchants can actually ring anything up.
- 10:59[Speaker 3] That's the gap.
- 11:00[Speaker 3] Big number on one side, tiny number on the other.
- 11:03[Rachel] I mean, come on.
- 11:04[Rachel] That's a pretty wide split.
- 11:06[Speaker 3] It is.
- 11:07[Speaker 3] And an outside analyst is out here saying the whole space hasn't
- 11:10[Speaker 3] cracked the problem.
- 11:11[Rachel] It's wild that an analyst paid to watch this space is the
- 11:14[Rachel] one saying nobody's cracked it, not some outside critic.
- 11:17[Rachel] That's coming from inside the room.
- 11:19[Speaker 3] Right.
- 11:19[Speaker 3] And it lines up with everything else we just laid out.
- 11:22[Speaker 3] Big traffic numbers, a handful of merchants actually live, a rollout that
- 11:27[Speaker 3] came in smaller than advertised.
- 11:29[Rachel] Three different data points all pointing the same direction, and none of
- 11:32[Rachel] them came from a skeptic looking to make platforms look bad.
- 11:35[Speaker 3] Which honestly makes it more convincing, not less.
- 11:39[Speaker 3] This isn't outside criticism.
- 11:41[Speaker 3] It's the industry's own numbers telling on itself.
- 11:44[Rachel] So where does that leave us?
- 11:45[Rachel] Is anybody making actual money off this yet?
- 11:48[Speaker 3] That's the thing.
- 11:49[Speaker 3] Some people are, just maybe not the way you'd expect from all
- 11:52[Speaker 3] the announcements.
- 11:53[Rachel] Now that I wanna hear.
- 11:59[Rachel] Okay, so real names, real brands.
- 12:02[Rachel] Glossy's got a piece on Aviator Nation.
- 12:04[Rachel] That's the retro California streetwear, the tie-dye hoodies.
- 12:08[Speaker 3] Oh, I know those hoodies.
- 12:09[Rachel] Right?
- 12:10[Rachel] So Glossy says they're seeing early orders coming in from ChatGPT, plus
- 12:14[Rachel] growing sales through Shopify's Shop app.
- 12:16[Speaker 3] Wait, actual orders, not just traffic?
- 12:20[Rachel] Orders.
- 12:21[Rachel] Early ones, sure, but orders.
- 12:23[Rachel] Glossy frames it as them rethinking discovery altogether.
- 12:26[Rachel] Like, where do people even find you now?
- 12:28[Speaker 3] That's the first name brand win we heard all episode that isn't
- 12:31[Speaker 3] a backer logo.
- 12:33[Rachel] Exactly.
- 12:34[Rachel] One brand, one channel, actual dollars.
- 12:37[Speaker 3] What I like about the Aviator Nation example is it's not a
- 12:40[Speaker 3] platform announcement.
- 12:42[Speaker 3] It's an actual brand deciding where to spend its energy.
- 12:45[Speaker 3] That's a different kind of signal than a backer list.
- 12:48[Rachel] Right.
- 12:48[Rachel] Somebody in their marketing team looked at where orders were coming from
- 12:51[Rachel] and said, "Okay, this channel's worth leaning into."
- 12:54[Speaker 3] Okay, but I wanna zoom out because most of the money moving
- 12:57[Speaker 3] right now isn't coming from any of this AI stuff.
- 13:00[Rachel] Yeah.
- 13:00[Rachel] So speaking of actual dollars, PYMNTS had this thing about the summer
- 13:05[Rachel] sales events.
- 13:06[Speaker 3] The Prime Day Walmart deals overlap?
- 13:08[Rachel] Yeah.
- 13:09[Rachel] PYMNTS says the overlap changed who showed up and how much they
- 13:13[Rachel] spent, and the crowd fueling Amazon and Walmart summer sales was mostly
- 13:17[Rachel] Boomers.
- 13:18[Speaker 3] Boomers, not Gen Z doom scrolling into a chatbot cart.
- 13:23[Speaker 3] Boomers clicking add to cart on a laptop.
- 13:26[Rachel] Pretty much.
- 13:28[Speaker 3] That's the actual story of who's spending money in e-commerce right now,
- 13:31[Speaker 3] and it's the least sexy possible answer.
- 13:34[Rachel] I mean, it makes sense, though.
- 13:35[Rachel] Boomers have the disposable income and the loyalty to those two retailers
- 13:39[Rachel] built up over decades.
- 13:41[Rachel] They're not experimenting with some new chatbot.
- 13:43[Rachel] They're doing what's worked for them for twenty years.
- 13:45[Speaker 3] Right.
- 13:46[Speaker 3] And that's a way bigger chunk of actual dollars changing hands than
- 13:49[Speaker 3] anything we've talked about with Agentic checkout so far.
- 13:52[Speaker 3] Old habits, but real spending.
- 13:55[Rachel] It's kind of the opposite of the story we spent the whole
- 13:57[Rachel] first half of the show on.
- 13:59[Rachel] No protocol, no press release, just people showing up and buying what
- 14:02[Rachel] they always buy.
- 14:03[Speaker 3] Which is maybe the most honest data point in this whole episode.
- 14:07[Rachel] It's not glamorous, but it's real.
- 14:09[Rachel] And here's another one that's not glamorous: Land's End.
- 14:12[Speaker 3] Oh, the catalog people.
- 14:14[Rachel] Still around.
- 14:15[Rachel] FashionNetwork reported Land's End posted a two point seven percent bump
- 14:19[Rachel] in revenue, up three hundred two million dollars for the quarter.
- 14:23[Speaker 3] Three hundred million from a company people forget exists.
- 14:27[Rachel] And it put them back in the black.
- 14:29[Rachel] The driver was strong growth in their US e-commerce channel specifically.
- 14:32[Speaker 3] That's honestly a pretty good comeback story for a brand people mostly
- 14:36[Speaker 3] associate with catalogs from twenty years ago.
- 14:39[Rachel] And it's not one lucky quarter either.
- 14:41[Rachel] It's the whole channel actually performing, which for a brand that age
- 14:44[Rachel] is basically a second life.
- 14:46[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 14:47[Speaker 3] And it says something that the fix wasn't flashy.
- 14:50[Speaker 3] Just make the online experience not annoying, and people show up.
- 14:54[Speaker 3] No chatbot required, no protocol war, just decent execution.
- 14:58[Rachel] Yeah, and it shows the boring stuff still works.
- 15:01[Rachel] Better site, better checkout experience, no fancy AI required, and the revenue
- 15:05[Rachel] follows.
- 15:06[Speaker 3] So no ChatGPT checkout, no agentic anything.
- 15:10[Speaker 3] Just their website worked better, and people bought stuff on it.
- 15:14[Rachel] That's the whole thing.
- 15:15[Rachel] Old school online retail doing fine.
- 15:18[Speaker 3] This is basically my point from the top of the show.
- 15:20[Speaker 3] Everybody wants to talk about the protocol wars, but Land's End just
- 15:24[Speaker 3] quietly fixed their site and made money.
- 15:27[Rachel] Boring but profitable.
- 15:28[Speaker 3] I'll take boring and profitable over an expensive pilot every time.
- 15:32[Rachel] It's funny, none of these three stories needed a new protocol or
- 15:35[Rachel] a checkout bot.
- 15:37[Rachel] Aviator Nation just showed up where customers were already looking.
- 15:40[Rachel] Boomers just kept doing what works.
- 15:42[Rachel] Land's End just fixed their site.
- 15:44[Speaker 3] Which honestly makes me a little suspicious of how much of the
- 15:47[Speaker 3] AI checkout conversation is actually about shopper behavior versus just platforms wanting
- 15:53[Speaker 3] a bigger piece of every transaction.
- 15:55[Rachel] That's a little cynical.
- 15:56[Speaker 3] I'm a little cynical, Max.
- 15:58[Speaker 3] It's kinda my whole thing on this show.
- 16:00[Rachel] So you've got Aviator Nation catching a wave off AI discovery, Boomers
- 16:04[Rachel] driving the big summer numbers the old-fashioned way, and Land's End turning
- 16:08[Rachel] a profit off e-commerce that has nothing to do with any of
- 16:10[Rachel] this hype.
- 16:11[Speaker 3] Three completely different playbooks all making money this week.
- 16:15[Rachel] Right.
- 16:15[Rachel] But none of those three are small operations without a Shopify develop
- 16:19[Rachel] team or a marketing budget.
- 16:21[Speaker 3] Yeah, and that's the uncomfortable part because for every brand actually cashing
- 16:25[Speaker 3] in on this shift, there's a small merchant who isn't anywhere near
- 16:28[Speaker 3] it.
- 16:29[Rachel] And nobody really wants to sit with that part.
- 16:37[Rachel] So we keep saying the smallest merchants are getting left behind.
- 16:40[Rachel] I want a number, not a vibe.
- 16:42[Speaker 3] Okay, so PYMNTS just put out a piece time to Labor Day,
- 16:47[Speaker 3] right as everybody's staring down Q4.
- 16:49[Speaker 3] Mm.
- 16:50[Rachel] And basically, their framing is Main Street has way more ways to
- 16:54[Rachel] sell, get paid, and source goods than it did four years ago.
- 16:58[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 16:59[Speaker 3] That tracks.
- 17:00[Speaker 3] More platforms, more payment rails, more suppliers online.
- 17:04[Rachel] Right.
- 17:04[Rachel] But the same piece says that access isn't spreading evenly.
- 17:08[Rachel] The tools exist, but the smallest shops aren't the ones picking them
- 17:11[Rachel] up.
- 17:12[Speaker 3] Which is the part that actually matters.
- 17:14[Speaker 3] Having a tool available and having the time, cash, and staff to
- 17:18[Speaker 3] implement it are two very different things.
- 17:21[Rachel] Exactly.
- 17:21[Rachel] Like, you're a two-person shop, you're not sitting down to integrate a
- 17:25[Rachel] new checkout protocol on a Tuesday.
- 17:28[Speaker 3] You're just trying to keep the lights on through the holidays.
- 17:31[Rachel] Right.
- 17:31[Speaker 3] And it's not like these tools are even that expensive individually.
- 17:35[Speaker 3] It's the time cost that kills small operators.
- 17:38[Speaker 3] Learning a new platform, migrating data, testing that nothing breaks, that's hours
- 17:43[Speaker 3] Nobody on a two-person team has spare.
- 17:46[Rachel] Right.
- 17:46[Rachel] And hours are the one resource you genuinely can't buy more of
- 17:50[Rachel] during Q4 crunch.
- 17:51[Rachel] You can maybe scrape together the cash for a new tool, but
- 17:54[Rachel] not the bandwidth to learn it properly.
- 17:57[Speaker 3] Which is exactly why the tools exist doesn't mean much on its
- 18:01[Speaker 3] own.
- 18:01[Speaker 3] Existing and being usable by someone stretched that thin are two different
- 18:06[Speaker 3] things.
- 18:07[Rachel] Yeah.
- 18:07[Rachel] That gap is basically the whole story in one sentence.
- 18:10[Speaker 3] It also means whatever we recommend to a Small shop owner has
- 18:14[Speaker 3] to respect that time crunch, not just pile another to-do onto their
- 18:17[Speaker 3] list.
- 18:19[Rachel] Fair.
- 18:19[Rachel] So if there's a takeaway here, it's pick one thing, not Adopt
- 18:23[Rachel] everything at once.
- 18:25[Speaker 3] So who is scaling then?
- 18:27[Speaker 3] Because clearly Somebody's grabbing this.
- 18:30[Rachel] So here's an interesting one that's kind of adjacent.
- 18:32[Rachel] Vatai, which does cross-border e-commerce compliance, just filed to list in Hong
- 18:37[Rachel] Kong.
- 18:38[Speaker 3] Compliance?
- 18:39[Speaker 3] Like tariffs and customs paperwork?
- 18:42[Rachel] Yeah, exactly that world.
- 18:43[Rachel] And the filing cites sixty-six percent revenue growth.
- 18:48[Speaker 3] Wait, sixty-six percent?
- 18:50[Speaker 3] That's not small growth.
- 18:52[Speaker 3] That's a company that found a real problem and getting paid to
- 18:55[Speaker 3] solve it.
- 18:56[Rachel] Right?
- 18:57[Rachel] And think about what that says.
- 18:59[Rachel] Cross-border selling has gotten complicated enough that a whole company can grow
- 19:03[Rachel] two-thirds in a year just handling the compliance headache.
- 19:07[Speaker 3] So the winners this week aren't just the flashy AI checkout names,
- 19:11[Speaker 3] it's also the boring infrastructure layer behind global selling.
- 19:15[Rachel] Totally.
- 19:16[Rachel] Nobody wants to talk about customs paperwork on a podcast, but somebody's
- 19:20[Rachel] making real money off it.
- 19:22[Speaker 3] I'd listen to that episode, honestly.
- 19:24[Rachel] Maybe next season.
- 19:25[Speaker 3] In all seriousness, though, that's a pattern worth noticing.
- 19:28[Speaker 3] When something gets complicated enough, a specialist business shows up to sell
- 19:32[Speaker 3] you the complexity back to you as a service.
- 19:35[Rachel] Right.
- 19:35[Rachel] And that's basically the whole infrastructure layer of e-commerce in a nutshell.
- 19:39[Rachel] Shipping got complicated, so you got logistics platforms.
- 19:42[Rachel] Payments got complicated, so you got payment processors.
- 19:45[Rachel] Now, cross-border compliance is complicated, so you get Vatai.
- 19:49[Speaker 3] But zoom out for a second.
- 19:51[Speaker 3] You've got Vatai scaling on cross-border complexity.
- 19:54[Speaker 3] You've got the platforms from earlier scaling on AI traffic.
- 19:58[Speaker 3] And then Main Street's smallest guys are stuck trying to just keep
- 20:01[Speaker 3] their storefront running.
- 20:03[Rachel] Right.
- 20:03[Rachel] And that's not really one story anymore.
- 20:06[Rachel] It's two.
- 20:07[Rachel] There's the story of who's building the infrastructure and cashing in on
- 20:10[Rachel] complexity.
- 20:11[Speaker 3] And the story of who doesn't have the time or budget to
- 20:13[Speaker 3] even use it.
- 20:15[Rachel] Yeah.
- 20:15[Speaker 3] And the smallest businesses fall into the second bucket almost by definition.
- 20:19[Speaker 3] They don't have a compliance team.
- 20:21[Speaker 3] They don't have a dev team testing new checkout flows.
- 20:24[Rachel] They've got a Shopify store and maybe one employee doing three jobs.
- 20:29[Speaker 3] Right.
- 20:29[Speaker 3] So when the big guys scale, they scale from an already huge
- 20:33[Speaker 3] base.
- 20:34[Speaker 3] When Vatai grows sixty-six percent, that's off a business built specifically to
- 20:38[Speaker 3] solve one expensive problem.
- 20:40[Rachel] Meanwhile, the corner shop is just trying to figure out shipping rates.
- 20:44[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 20:45[Speaker 3] It's not a level playing field.
- 20:47[Speaker 3] It's a totally different field.
- 20:49[Rachel] Yeah, that's the contrast frame right there.
- 20:51[Speaker 3] So heading into the holiday run-up, you've got platforms racing ahead on
- 20:55[Speaker 3] AI-commerce traffic, compliance specialists cashing in on cross-border complexity, and the smallest
- 21:00[Speaker 3] sellers just trying to hang on to what they've got.
- 21:03[Rachel] Which honestly is the real headline under everything we talked about today.
- 21:07[Rachel] Big platforms and specialists are scaling fast, and the smallest storefronts risk
- 21:11[Rachel] getting left out of the whole AI-commerce wave entirely.
- 21:15[Speaker 3] That's the state of play heading into the holiday run-up.
- 21:17[Rachel] Yeah.
- 21:18[Rachel] Let's wrap it up.
- 21:24[Rachel] Hmm.
- 21:26[Speaker 3] So here's where I land on all of it.
- 21:28[Speaker 3] The big platforms get the AI wiring.
- 21:31[Speaker 3] The small sellers get left figuring out spreadsheets on their own, and
- 21:34[Speaker 3] that gap isn't closing anytime soon.
- 21:36[Rachel] Yeah.
- 21:37[Speaker 3] The agentic checkout stuff, the protocols, all that, it's built for merchants
- 21:42[Speaker 3] who already have a dev team on staff.
- 21:44[Speaker 3] Main Street doesn't have that.
- 21:46[Rachel] Right.
- 21:46[Rachel] And that Hong Kong filing we just talked about, that's a company
- 21:49[Rachel] solving problems for sellers who can already afford a compliance vendor.
- 21:53[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 21:54[Speaker 3] Somebody's got to build the version of this for the guy running
- 21:57[Speaker 3] one Shopify store out of his garage.
- 22:00[Rachel] Or that's just next year's episode.
- 22:02[Speaker 3] Probably.
- 22:03[Rachel] But seriously, if you're running a small shop and you're listening to
- 22:06[Rachel] this feeling a little attacked, that's not the point.
- 22:09[Rachel] The point is the tools built for you specifically probably aren't here
- 22:13[Rachel] yet, and that's worth knowing before you sink a weekend into chasing
- 22:16[Rachel] the wrong upgrade.
- 22:17[Speaker 3] Which means the smart move right now is probably not chasing every
- 22:21[Speaker 3] agentic checkout headline.
- 22:23[Speaker 3] It's just making sure your actual site and your actual checkout work
- 22:26[Speaker 3] well for the customers you already have.
- 22:29[Rachel] Simple as that, honestly.
- 22:30[Rachel] Fix what's already broken before you bet on what's brand new, and
- 22:33[Rachel] you'll be in better shape than half the platforms racing to build
- 22:36[Rachel] this stuff.
- 22:37[Speaker 3] That's the whole newsletter right there, really.
- 22:39[Rachel] All right.
- 22:40[Rachel] Well, that's a wrap for this week's Checkout Point.
- 22:42[Speaker 3] Thanks for hanging with us.
- 22:44[Rachel] Seriously, thank you guys for listening.
- 22:45[Rachel] If you want more on any of this, the checkout stuff, the
- 22:48[Rachel] small business numbers, whatever, head over to PYMNTS.co.
- 22:51[Rachel] We've got more written up there.
- 22:53[Speaker 3] No pressure, just good stuff if you wanna dig deeper.
- 22:55[Rachel] Totally.
- 22:56[Rachel] We'll catch you next week.
- 22:57[Speaker 3] See you then.
- 22:59[Rachel] Go check your dashboards, folks.