Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The New Weather, The New Economy
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to another episode of the Market Edge, a podcast produced
- 0:10by the American Council of Engineering Companies, where we explore the trends,
- 0:15challenges, and opportunities shaping the business of engineering.
- 0:19This series is presented in partnership with ACC Nationals Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 0:24I am Diana O'Lear, and today we're discussing an issue that increasingly affects
- 0:29every sector of the economy, what veteran journalist and broadcaster Llewellyn
- 0:34King calls the new weather.
- 0:36Llewellyn, thank you so much for being here today and welcome to the Market Edge.
- 0:41Thank you. It's a great pleasure to be with you, Diana.
- 0:45Likewise. So I've been watching and I haven't even had a chance to tell Llewellyn
- 0:49this, but I've been watching him host press briefings for the United States
- 0:52Energy Association for years.
- 0:54And he does a phenomenal job. And I'm also subscribed to his column,
- 0:58which usually includes some witty
- 1:00humor about bow ties and also very thought-provoking concepts as well.
- 1:05So in his latest issue, The New Weather Reality Will Change the Nation,
- 1:10Defy Politics, he really reminds us that prolonged drought, extreme heat,
- 1:16flooding can impact not only business decisions,
- 1:20but policy and infrastructure investment, which is why I welcomed him here today.
- 1:25So I've been hearing a lot lately about the Super El Nino, which has led to
- 1:30increased discussion about what extreme weather can really do to an economy.
- 1:36And for engineering firms, that matters because weather can expose vulnerabilities
- 1:42in transportation networks, water systems, energy infrastructure,
- 1:45which I'm sure you're very familiar with,
- 1:48community resilience, and even accelerate investment opportunities that engineers
- 1:53help plan, design, and build.
- 1:55So Llewellyn, I'm going to get right to it. Based on your column,
- 1:59What is the new weather and why do you believe it could be one of the defining
- 2:03issues of the next decade?
- 2:05Well, because we see it everywhere. It's not just the Super El Nino. That's part of it.
- 2:12But we've seen a radical change in the weather. And this is not totally disputable.
- 2:18We know the glaciers are melting because the ocean is warmer.
- 2:24The land is certainly warmer. We're seeing really aberrant weather across the
- 2:29globe. And we have for quite a few years now.
- 2:32I deal a lot with electric utilities and talk to a lot of CEOs and top executives.
- 2:39And one of the questions you sort of routinely ask is, what keeps you awake at night?
- 2:46And 10 years ago, they would say, oh, cybersecurity or the supply chain or something
- 2:53like that or government regulation.
- 2:56But in the last three years, the answer has always been the same.
- 3:00The weather, because electric utilities, of course, are very directly affected by it.
- 3:06And it is a huge concern, and they have to engineer against unknown weather.
- 3:13I asked weather experts, and I have my own tame meteorologist, and.
- 3:19He says, well, it's a combination of global warming and of other factors,
- 3:25human density in some parts of the globe.
- 3:28He doesn't put it down to one thing, but he certainly is sure that we do have
- 3:34what I have called the new weather.
- 3:38It's hard to argue with that. It has to be becoming a bipartisan solution or
- 3:43a viewpoint sooner or later.
- 3:46I have to say I can't help but notice my own vacation getting disrupted by increased
- 3:52winds and getting sandburned or kids not being able to do activities because of the heat.
- 3:58And so I definitely see it becoming more of a prevalent issue.
- 4:02Now, I want to go on to my next question, which is a little bit more about migration impacts.
- 4:08So, you wrote that the heat, not economics, could curtail the north to southwest
- 4:15flow of people, which we call the flight to those sunbelt states.
- 4:19What are you seeing that suggests weather may start influencing migration patterns
- 4:24more than it has in the past?
- 4:26Well, we've seen over a period of more than a decade, a steady flow of people
- 4:32from north to south and particularly to the southwest.
- 4:37And as people realize that they may have to endure two or three months of 100
- 4:43degrees plus temperatures, they are going to start thinking twice about that.
- 4:48If you can't let your children go outside in the summer, that's not a very good
- 4:53situation. I was down in Texas, and my Uber driver, she said that it had been awful for her children.
- 5:02Last summer, they hadn't been able to get out of the house, often for long periods.
- 5:08And when they were out of the house, she had to warn them about things like,
- 5:12don't put your hands on the car. It may be too hot. It could burn you.
- 5:16These are new realities, and that's going to affect. The other thing is the
- 5:21cost of air conditioning.
- 5:23Air conditioning has ceased to be a luxury. If you've got temperatures north
- 5:29of 100 degrees and sometimes north of 110, air conditioning is part of your way of life.
- 5:37And people who don't have enough of it or don't get adequate air conditioning can't afford it.
- 5:43It's joined, I mean, electricity is up there with the rent, your medicines,
- 5:48the other necessities, and food.
- 5:51People will opt for air conditioning and let something else go,
- 5:56particularly healthcare, it seems.
- 5:59The National Public Radio has just done a very interesting study,
- 6:04in which they calculate, and they've done it pretty scientifically,
- 6:09they calculate that heat deaths, people who die because it's too hot,
- 6:15are probably underreported five-fold.
- 6:19They've run out about 2,000 a year, 1,500, 2,000 a year.
- 6:24But their analysis, and it's very hard to say that somebody died of the heat,
- 6:29their analysis suggests that really it's five times that number.
- 6:36And that's a lot of people dying, and a lot of people who will die if they don't
- 6:41have protection against the heat.
- 6:43So, it's reasonable to conclude that people will suddenly factor the cost of
- 6:49being in heat in their lifestyle choices and their places of work and residence.
- 6:57Great answer. So before I go on to my next question, I just wanted to add a comment.
- 7:00When I was preparing for this interview, I had saw,
- 7:05a comment that I had made in our trend research about how Zillow and Redfin
- 7:10in 2024 actually were providing climate risk data on house listings.
- 7:17And in both platforms, 80% of potential buyers factor this data into real estate purchases.
- 7:24However, I learned recently that Zillow actually moved from displaying the scores directly
- 7:30to linking it for users because real estate agents and homeowners were actually
- 7:35arguing that climate risk scores could hurt home sales, which I thought was
- 7:40extremely interesting.
- 7:42It's definitely something people don't maybe don't want to talk about,
- 7:45but it's absolutely, you're absolutely right. It's out there.
- 7:48So I want to pivot now to a little more of the infrastructure challenge.
- 7:52So you wrote that adapting to the weather could point toward infrastructure
- 7:57repair enhancement. And I think I heard you hinting about that with water and
- 8:02energy. So where do you think the biggest infrastructure gaps exist today?
- 8:07And where could investment be needed most urgently?
- 8:11Well, an ongoing challenge is the electric grid, but also our bridges and roads,
- 8:18roads buckle quickly in the heat,
- 8:21the deterioration in bridges where you have water affecting the rebar, etc.
- 8:29All happens a little quicker when it's very hot or very cold.
- 8:34Weather extremes have a huge impact on the infrastructure.
- 8:39The engineering challenges are to keep the grid going, to expand the grid,
- 8:44to meet all the demands on it, but also to meet all the other demands.
- 8:49We're also going to have to engineer our way out of sea level rise.
- 8:56We can't abandon the whole East
- 9:00Coast to the United States, but Boston to Norfolk are all in danger of,
- 9:07water rising so high, and even New York City, that some sort of barriers will have to be built,
- 9:13pumps, that kind of thing.
- 9:15There will have to be some kind of response to sea level rise,
- 9:20and that's a consequence of the new weather.
- 9:24So that brings us to a really good point is, you know, like who's going to pay for it?
- 9:29So it brings me to another line in your column that struck me,
- 9:33your observation that huge infrastructure projects may be proposed at a time
- 9:39when concerns about deficits are growing.
- 9:41So what tension do you see developing between the growing need for infrastructure
- 9:47investment and concerns about government spending?
- 9:51Well, I think that the government, any government that we have going forward,
- 9:57will have to deal with infrastructure, and will have to find the money.
- 10:01And finding the money is going to be very difficult. We have a $40 trillion national debt.
- 10:07Basically, we'd have to, I think, repeal all the tax cuts since 1993 in order
- 10:16to get the budget under control and realign some of the expenses that we have.
- 10:22Remember, the way the budget is structured, the amount of disposable income is very small.
- 10:29A lot of it is just consumed with statutory obligations that all of the democracies
- 10:37are going, or all of the countries of the world, that matter,
- 10:40democracies and otherwise.
- 10:42But the democracies, all of which are in some difficulty, most of which are running huge deficits.
- 10:49The United Kingdom is particularly bad at the moment, are going to have to deal
- 10:53not only with the new weather but with a new economic reality.
- 10:59Old trajectories are not going to be sustainable, and this means,
- 11:04to use a rather simplistic term, bell tightening.
- 11:10There will not be as much money as there was. There may not be as much money in defense.
- 11:15There may not be as much money going into things that I desperately hope are
- 11:20not cut, but like research, maybe higher education.
- 11:25I'm not a budget expert, and I wouldn't like to tell the political class what
- 11:31they're going to do, but I know what they have to do.
- 11:35They have to deal with the new realities.
- 11:39So if federal funding does become more constrained or,
- 11:43belt tightened, do you see states, local governments, utilities,
- 11:48or private investors even taking on a larger role in financing the infrastructure
- 11:53needed to adapt to this new weather?
- 11:56Well, I think yes. And if it can be done profitably, there will be money.
- 12:01There's a lot of money around.
- 12:03It's just the government doesn't have it.
- 12:06You can see by the huge amount of money that has been invested in artificial
- 12:10intelligence or ephemeral just how much money is floating around and how,
- 12:17easily money can be raised for projects that people can get a return on.
- 12:23I think that the AI itself may be of great help.
- 12:28It's going to certainly help in planning a much more efficient use of resources,
- 12:34a much more predictable future because it is a great tool for prediction,
- 12:40like the life of a bridge or the life of,
- 12:43a power line or the life of a power plant or.
- 12:48Even the rate and impact of sea level rise will be much more accurately predicted
- 12:56with AI than it would have been heretofore.
- 13:00Even the weather itself is now much more accurately predicted than it was previously
- 13:07because all weather forecasters are using AI.
- 13:12Very interesting. So you said
- 13:13AI could help. So I kind of want to pivot to how AI could harm, because,
- 13:19as we approach a new weather with extreme temperatures, high heat and drought,
- 13:26how do things like data centers impact?
- 13:30And they're already taking a huge drain on those resources.
- 13:35What happens now with this new weather? Are we able to sustain at the path we're
- 13:40on? Do you think there'll be additional infrastructure investment because of
- 13:43it or more moratoriums and stopping data centers?
- 13:47No, there will be more infrastructure because of it. And data centers are both
- 13:53the solution and the problem.
- 13:55But the one thing to remember about data centers is they won't grow exponentially forever.
- 14:03We will get better chips, we'll get better cooling, there will be less use of
- 14:09water in cooling, and at some point we may even get a photon chip,
- 14:14a light chip, which would create no heat whatsoever.
- 14:18And suddenly, data centers, rather than eating up the world,
- 14:23will become stranded assets, very large buildings with no particular purpose.
- 14:30The future is never,
- 14:32a line that just goes up and up and up. Things change.
- 14:36The example I like to use is synthetic rubber.
- 14:41When the automobile came along and rubber was natural rubber coming from rubber
- 14:46trees, it would be reasonable, take,
- 14:50rubber as your data center, to say, oh, the whole world is going to be consumed
- 14:55with rubber plantations.
- 14:57And there were rubber plantations in Africa. There were rubber plantations up
- 15:02the Amazon, then of course it wasn't sustainable.
- 15:06And what happened is we developed synthetic rubber, and that was the end of
- 15:11the boom in natural rubber.
- 15:14And there are many other things you can think of where it appeared a particular
- 15:18resource was overstretched, and suddenly it was in abundance,
- 15:23or an alternative resource was deployed.
- 15:28So, looking forward, if we're having this conversation in 2030,
- 15:33what would tell you that the country has successfully adapted to the new weather
- 15:38rather than simply us reacting to it?
- 15:41Well, I think, and again, you know, these projections are subject to many changes. Right.
- 15:51And so the inputs are never perfect, but it would be reasonable to assume that we'll be taking,
- 15:59the amount of carbon we put into the atmosphere more seriously.
- 16:04There's been some hiatus in that concern due to the current administration.
- 16:10We will already see more efficient data centers, we will see improvements in
- 16:17our chips, and we will see other ways of doing things.
- 16:22That's something that I find hugely interesting and has not gotten a lot of
- 16:27attention, and that is the Danube, the great river in Europe,
- 16:31is short of water because of the new weather, if you will,
- 16:35certainly because of the drought and heat that has played Europe this year,
- 16:40leading to, among other things, wildfires.
- 16:43But there's a nuclear power plant on the Danube that had to stop operating,
- 16:48or looked as though it would have to stop operating, because there wasn't enough cooling water.
- 16:55And they are switching to air cooling.
- 16:58A company called Poltec, a big engineering nuclear company, has built a system
- 17:05of expelling the heat directly to the air.
- 17:09If you think of air-cooled engines on motorcycles, for example, that on a large scale.
- 17:15Now, that's very interesting. I mean, I'm sure there are downsides to it.
- 17:19The only one I can tell you at the moment is the power plant loses a little power, about 3%.
- 17:26Perhaps all that heat going into the air might have some other consequences,
- 17:32but it does show there are other ways.
- 17:35This exponential growth and the need for water for cooling may be it,
- 17:40and then we will get better ways of cooling things.
- 17:44And that's sort of a continued part of the marvel of engineering.
- 17:49We have problems and we engineer out of them.
- 17:53We don't actually get out of problems with political slogans.
- 17:58We get out of them with solid, often engineering solutions.
- 18:04You know, you're a great salesman for engineering. Do you happen to have any background in that?
- 18:10No, I'm very much on the words side, or was. But I fell in love with engineering.
- 18:16Part of my father was a mechanic.
- 18:18But I've always seen engineering as something that can produce solutions.
- 18:24I've said often that the real poets of our time are engineers,
- 18:30not poets, because engineers can make dreams come true.
- 18:36Poets dream dreams. I read a lot of poetry. But engineering makes the difference.
- 18:43And we live in a cocoon that is engineered.
- 18:48You know, from the moment we wake up in the morning, we've probably been cooled
- 18:52or heated overnight because of the time the engineers have developed.
- 18:57And the rest of our day is totally dependent on engineering.
- 19:01If you go down in an elevator, that's an engineering achievement.
- 19:05If you get into an automobile, that's an engineering achievement.
- 19:10And if you have a coffee maker, that too is an engineering achievement,
- 19:14as is the electricity that operates it. So there's no escaping engineering.
- 19:20We are its children these days, and it has been the most extraordinary servant of humanity.
- 19:29Well, thank you for that, Llewellyn. I think no one else could say it better.
- 19:34That's about all the time we have for today. Llewellyn, thank you so much for joining me.
- 19:40It's been a great pleasure, Diana. Absolutely. And thank you to our listeners
- 19:44for tuning in to another episode of The Market Edge. I'm Diana Olaire. See you next time.