Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️107 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 6th Oct Mostly Peat Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. There was a lovely little moment at lunchtime today that deserves a mention, for reasons known only to whoever allocates the rooms in the Strouhal Art Centre, we found ourselves having lunch in the dance studio, not in our usual spot. But this meant that Dalradian had to vacate the
- 1:14premises to make way for the art protectors. Fedelma was quick to point out that hopefully this was a sign of things to come, and one day they might find themselves being asked to vacate Coronalt as well, and we'll file that under good omens. And it was probably the easiest relocation project discussed all
- 1:38day, but more about this later. Before we get to that, though, I think we need another word of the day. And today's word was confident. The Doobies must have been all schooled to start their evidence by saying how confident they were with their bespoke plans and methodology, and finishing in a similar vein,
- 2:04there was a great deal of confidence about the place today. We heard that the consultants were confident in the peat restoration proposals and confident in the mitigation measures. They were very confident that the blanket bog restoration and compensation would be effective, and
- 2:22confident that we can offset the loss. There was no doubt we were told that the measures were appropriate and proven to be effective. Then Conor Fagan began probing what that confidence meant in scientific terms, and once they were asked to put a level of certainty on it, some of that confidence
- 2:44began to acquire qualifications, even ebbing away, not unlike water down a peat drain. Doctor Isherwood for F O D C followed up talking about the sensitivity of peatland restoration and translocation. It is difficult to be absolutely confident that it will be completely effective. Some of it may take, some may
- 3:10not, and the scientific research does not allow anyone to say with certainty that it will all work. So confident may have been the word of the day, although it turned out later that the evidence attached to it came with a few qualifications, it was around this time that we had another memorable contribution
- 3:31from Dr. Emmermann speaking about the drainage pipes beneath the peat. These pipes are part of the proposed peat enhancement cells. The idea, as was explained, is that the peat needs to remain saturated without becoming flooded, with drainage pipes helping to fine-tune the amount of water.
- 3:53The diameter of the pipes can apparently be selected so that just the right amount of water passes through. The peat cannot be too wet, it cannot be too dry, and somewhere in the middle sits the perfect drainage pipe, keeping everything just right. Doctor Emmerman was not convinced. He said he had never
- 4:16heard of what he called Goldilocks drainage pipes, and pointed out that drainage pipes lowered the water table. His concern was that this did not explain how they would control the water content of the peat sitting above them. He also raised the fairly practical problem of the pipes eventually
- 4:38clogging, once buried beneath the peat, getting back in to repair them could become quite an operation, if not impossible. Whilst Goldilocks may have found the porridge that was just right, keeping a mountain of translocated peat at precisely the correct moisture levels for years appears to involve a bit.
- 5:00Or engineering. There was another interesting exchange before lunch when Conor Fagan picked up on the description of discussions between the applicant and NIEA as a negotiation. He was very clear about this. In his view, the appropriate environmental standard is not something for an
- 5:21applicant and the environmental agency to negotiate between themselves and then present as an agreed position. NIEA still has to exercise its own independent judgement about whether what has been proposed is acceptable.
- 5:40After lunch, there was some clarification from the applicant's side. Negotiation, we were told, had meant that the approach to compensation should be agreed on on a site by site basis, and was not intended to mean negotiation in the legal sense. The important point in all of this is the position of
- 6:01the regulator. There has to be confidence that the environmental standards are being applied from a neutral position, and that agreement between the applicant and the NIEA does not become the end of the discussion. Of course, when the major client interface group has been sitting down with the
- 6:21regulators for years in advance of the inquiry. It is difficult not to view the relationship with some degree of caution. Then discussions turned to the subject of moving Pete. Here in Ireland, we are well used to stories of moving statues and the occasional miracle. Today was peat that was moving, and
- 6:44judging by the evidence, a miracle may be required twice over. One to follow the ever-evolving plan for where the peat is going, and another miracle to actually get it there, whilst keeping it intact, wet, and capable of being restored, there is a huge amount of peat involved in this
- 7:06development. Some of it is blanket bog, some valley mire, some is to be translocated, some stored, and some used in restoration. There are construction areas, cells, berms, roads, drains, ponds, machinery, and buffers, all occupying the same site, as well as the buildings. The discussion
- 7:33turned to peat being placed on top of existing peat, and the implications for peat stability. There were references to slope stability calculations, geo studio analysis, temporary storage areas, and engineered berms, but the commissioner kept trying to pin down a very specific issue concerning the
- 7:56weight of peat being placed on top of peat, and where had that been assessed, within the landslide hazard work? The exchange became fairly tense, with the commissioner warning mr. Dorman that he was on the verge of making her very cross, because she was trying to get an answer to the point she had
- 8:15raised. From the third-party side, the earth protectors. The problem became increasingly practical. Once peat is stripped, it has to go somewhere. The site still has to function while all this is happening. Machinery has to move around it. Buffers have to be maintained. Roads are being
- 8:36built. Drainage is being installed. The West Pond Stroke Reservoir has been constructed early in the development and takes up a huge area. There's also changes in ground levels across the site. Niall McAleer made the point that the deeper you go in peat, the wetter and softer it becomes, which makes
- 8:56the handling operation very difficult. Pat Hartie then took us into the sequence of the works and space available to carry them out on the site. This is where the whole exercise reminded me of one of those sliding puzzles where you have 15 squares and one empty space, and everything has to be moved
- 9:16in exactly the right order. Except this particular puzzle involves 1000s of tonnes of wet peat, heavy machinery, drainage infrastructure, and protected habitats, and a noticeable lack of any detailed planning. But sure, what's new? The difficulty is every time peat is moved, its structure can be damaged, and it
- 9:40can begin to dry if intact upper layers of peat are being lifted and preserved. Space is needed to put them down. Stacking peat brings its own problems because of compression, and temporary storage still has to be accommodated somewhere within an already busy construction site. There was more discussion about
- 10:02where the peat would sit during the different stages of construction, how machinery would reach it, how buffers would operate, and how the various areas would remain available as the development progressed. Fedelma drew attention to the West Pond Stroke Reservoir, which is
- 10:19planned early in the construction programme and occupies a sizeable piece of ground. Once that is in place, the available working area changes again. It was a long discussion, but the point at the heart of it was quite straightforward. A peat management proposal has to work
- 10:38physically on the ground. The peat cannot simply disappear from one drawing and reappear later on another. We heard evidence that using peat in its natural state is recognised good practice. There was particular discussion about the proposal to blend peat with topsoil to create a growing medium.
- 10:59The Klinger made the distinction that this is not really reuse of peat in its natural state, as recovery or recycling, and this is important because around 92% of the excavated blanket bog and valley mire peat is proposed to be dealt with in this way. And then late in the afternoon, we were treated to a short
- 11:22excursion into European environmental law. The applicant side decided that the precautionary principle needed some explanation. mr. Goodwin took us through the guidance from the European Commission and spoke about proportionality, non-discrimination, consistency, costs and benefits, scientific
- 11:43evidence, and the need to review decisions as new information becomes available. Conor Fagan came back to this and pointed out that the document being relied upon was a broad European Commission communication covering several areas, including health, and that in this case its general principles
- 12:04had to be understood in the particular context of habitats law. He then brought it back to the planning policy that actually applies here, where there is a risk of significant environmental damage. The precautionary approach means erring on the side of environmental protection. After
- 12:25quite an extensive legal tour, mr. Fagan managed to bring the precautionary principle back to something most people in the room could understand: where there is genuine scientific uncertainty, you exercise caution. And that seemed a fitting place to arrive after today's evidence. There was
- 12:48confidence everywhere today, but confidence does not equal competence. As the discussion moved into the physical business of stripping peat, moving it round the site, keeping it wet, and eventually trying to restore the habitat, all that confidence began to meet the science. We know it is very difficult to be
- 13:09absolutely confident that peat restoration or translocation can be completely effective, that some of it might take and some might not, and that claiming 100% success was simply not scientifically possible. Confidence, it seems, has acquired its own terms and conditions. And on that note, I
- 13:30leave it for today. See you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Front Line. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the
- 13:49conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these
- 14:07voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.