Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 218. Teaching Truths & Tactics: Live Lessons From Stanford in Cape Town
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: You can catalyze community through compelling communication.
- 0:07My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:11Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:13Welcome to this live episode of Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:18The power of community to enhance learning, entrepreneurship, and
- 0:22connection is truly amazing.
- 0:24I witnessed this firsthand at the recent Stanford SEED summit
- 0:28in Cape Town, South Africa.
- 0:30I invite you to listen in as Stanford professors Jesper Sørensen, Christian
- 0:34Wheeler and incoming GSB Dean Sarah Soule share their thoughts with and
- 0:39answer questions from the close to five hundred SEED members in our audience.
- 0:45So let's get started.
- 0:46Jesper, thank you for joining us.
- 0:47Excited to have you.
- 0:48When you and I spoke earlier on the podcast, we talked about strategy and
- 0:53telling stories around strategy, and I know that you've done some recent work
- 0:58that continues that line where you've done research with your colleague, Glenn
- 1:02Carroll, on the use of analogies in being effective in the work that you do?
- 1:08Can you share a little bit more about that?
- 1:10Jesper Sørensen: Sure.
- 1:10As many of you know, Glenn and I published a book a few years ago, and the paper
- 1:14that we recently wrote on analogies, we think of this as the missing chapter.
- 1:18The chapter that didn't get done in the book, and we use analogies all the time.
- 1:22So we say this is kind of like that when we're trying to explain something, right?
- 1:26So we think sound is like a wave, right?
- 1:29There's a classic way of thinking about explaining principles
- 1:32in physics, for example.
- 1:33And we use this all the time in business as well.
- 1:36So I think what most familiar to people would be, we use
- 1:39it in startup pitches, right?
- 1:40All the time.
- 1:41So we'll say, my company is the Uber of, or something like that.
- 1:45And then what we're doing is we're trying to persuade people that our
- 1:51organization and that analogy has the same potential and maybe even the same
- 1:56business model as the source organization.
- 2:00So that's a much more common way of reasoning, I think that people do.
- 2:03It's a particularly powerful for idea generation and it's also
- 2:08particularly powerful for persuasion.
- 2:10As a form of communication it's really quite compelling.
- 2:13Uh, at the same time, it's super dangerous as a basis for strategic thinking.
- 2:18So what our article is about is basically about how can you think
- 2:21about what makes for a good analogy from a strategic perspective.
- 2:25And I think one element of this is we tend to think about analogies as being
- 2:29about what we call horizontal comparisons.
- 2:32So we're capturing features and comparing them to each other, but we actually
- 2:36think that the more important thing to do is what we think about as the
- 2:39vertical relationships, which is really about what's the logic underlying each.
- 2:44When you say that your business is the Uber of something else, what is it
- 2:48about Uber's business model that you are saying applies in your business?
- 2:53And so the article really tries to flesh those ideas out.
- 2:56Matt Abrahams: I like that idea of, it's not horizontal but the vertical
- 2:59logic that's really important.
- 3:00That answer was as good as your previous answers, so thank you.
- 3:05Sarah, I recently had the pleasure of hearing you give a lecture where
- 3:08you talked about some recent research you were doing on how corporations
- 3:12respond to societal issues.
- 3:14Would you share for all of us a little bit about that research
- 3:16and what we can take away from it?
- 3:18Sarah Soule: Sure.
- 3:18Absolutely, Matt.
- 3:20One of my PhD students and I got very interested in corporate political
- 3:24statements, and some of you maybe have made these statements before.
- 3:29Many of you have read these statements before, but we were
- 3:32interested in these as a growing phenomenon, at least in the US case.
- 3:36And we collected a number of these around a lot of different social and political
- 3:42issues, and we started to notice some very interesting patterns in some of these.
- 3:47And in particular, one of the things that we noticed is that usually
- 3:52organizations and companies, they usually put forward and put out very
- 3:56positive information about themselves.
- 3:58In extreme cases, we may call this greenwashing or some other kind of
- 4:03pinkwashing and so on, but typically we think about companies putting forth
- 4:07something positive about themselves.
- 4:10But in these political statements, we noticed that companies were
- 4:14doing something very different, and that we came to call confession.
- 4:18They were releasing negative information about themselves with respect to whatever
- 4:22the political or social issue is.
- 4:24So for example, in the environmental space, rather than putting out something
- 4:29that might resemble something on the spectrum of greenwashing, companies would
- 4:33put something out talking about how dirty their supply chains are, things like this.
- 4:38And so we came, as I said, to refer to this as confession, company
- 4:42confessions, but we were also interested in understanding how
- 4:46people, the general public, consumers, might react to those statements.
- 4:51And so we conducted a number of online experiments and asked
- 4:55people to rate these companies with respect to different dimensions of
- 5:00corporate social responsibility.
- 5:02And the way this worked is that we created some vignettes, some sort of
- 5:05fake statements that a company might put out based on some of the company
- 5:10statements that we had collected.
- 5:12And we asked people a series of questions.
- 5:15And what we were manipulating in the experiment was the extent to which
- 5:19they confess something negative about themselves versus neutral versus positive.
- 5:24And what we found was that companies that confess something were rated
- 5:29more highly with respect to corporate social responsibility than those
- 5:33that just put a neutral statement out or a positive statement out.
- 5:37But there's a little wrinkle in this finding, and that's that if the
- 5:41company was confessing something that was particularly surprising or might
- 5:47seem counter to what an individual's priors might be, they were discounted
- 5:52very heavily and believed to be not at all responsible with respect to
- 5:56corporate social responsibility.
- 5:58So for example, if we have a lumber company that confesses to something
- 6:03with respect to deforestation, they get a bump in how people perceive
- 6:08them in terms of their level of corporate social responsibility.
- 6:11But if the lumber company confesses to using sweatshop labor in
- 6:16an emerging market, that they are discounted very heavily.
- 6:19So in a sense, I think what we are picking up on is hypocrisy, and that's
- 6:24that consumers and general public is very astute at picking up something
- 6:28that feels like it could be hypocritical or feels like it could be an empty
- 6:33statement that doesn't connect to their general business and so on.
- 6:37So that's the gist of what we've been doing.
- 6:39Matt Abrahams: Which I find really interesting.
- 6:41I'm curious, do you think that this notion of corporate confession is
- 6:45something that companies should be thinking about in terms of how they
- 6:49present themselves in the world?
- 6:51Sarah Soule: I think I would say that, and this is maybe obvious, but it's
- 6:54astounding to me how many of these corporate statements we saw, which
- 6:57really did seem a bit performative and seem quite hypocritical, I think
- 7:01the takeaway for me is that we can tease out something that feels like
- 7:06individuals sensing that there's something awry in what the company is saying.
- 7:11And so I think what I would say is that when one, if a company is going to use
- 7:14this strategy of releasing corporate statements, they really need to be
- 7:18very careful about what they're doing.
- 7:20That whatever they're confessing to is directly related to their line of
- 7:24business, their values, their mission, their strategy, and not weighed into
- 7:29political issues that are far afield from where they play and what they do.
- 7:34Matt Abrahams: So stay close to what you know and what you do.
- 7:36Sarah Soule: Yes.
- 7:36Matt Abrahams: Thank you.
- 7:37So Christian, you co-teach a class on spontaneous management, I love
- 7:41that idea, where you blend ideas from your area of study and improvisation.
- 7:46What are one or two of the ideas you can share that you teach in your class that
- 7:50can help all of us in the ever-changing environment we live in today?
- 7:53Christian Wheeler: Sure.
- 7:54I'll say a couple of things.
- 7:55We get used to postponing judgment.
- 7:57We have a tendency to rush to categorization, to assume that we
- 8:00understand things before we really do, because it saves us cognitive energy.
- 8:05It makes us feel that we have an understanding and a confidence
- 8:08about the way things are.
- 8:09But what it takes away from us is a curiosity about things around us,
- 8:14the ability to notice things that might peak our interest, and it
- 8:17also leads to inaccurate judgments.
- 8:20We also have a tendency to judge ourselves often in a moment.
- 8:24Right now, I may be having some self-talk thinking about whether this is a good
- 8:27answer or people liking this answer.
- 8:29I don't know.
- 8:30This is not the time for me to be judging this answer because the more
- 8:34I'm in my head, judging this answer I'm giving, the less I'm thinking
- 8:37about what I'm gonna say next.
- 8:39So I can listen to the podcast when it's out, reflect on my
- 8:42performance, think about how I could do better, but now is not the time
- 8:45for me to be judging my answer.
- 8:47Then I would also say another thing is being present.
- 8:50A lot of the class talks about capitalizing on serendipity,
- 8:54about being attentive to nonverbal signals from other people.
- 8:57This requires that we are in the moment.
- 9:00If we're honest about how we spend much of our time, it's like this, right?
- 9:04Staring at our telephones.
- 9:06You can't be present if you're staring at your telephone.
- 9:08And what it does is it has all of these effects on being able to
- 9:12capitalize on chance circumstances, being able to notice things that
- 9:16might capture our interest, but it also takes us out of this interaction
- 9:19that you're having with other people.
- 9:20And research shows that not only does it diminish the quality of
- 9:23your interactions, but it actually lowers your cognitive capabilities.
- 9:27If you have a telephone in front of you, switched off, then if it's out of
- 9:31the room, so it doesn't even need to be turned on, just merely having it present
- 9:35distracts us from the moment, and it lowers our ability to think carefully.
- 9:39Matt Abrahams: So our phones are making us dumber.
- 9:41Christian Wheeler: Absolutely.
- 9:42Matt Abrahams: Interesting.
- 9:43So I want to dive a little deeper.
- 9:45I, 'cause I see being present and non-judgmental sort of together.
- 9:48I mean, what are some things we can do to be more present oriented?
- 9:52It's one thing to want to be, it's another thing to actually do it.
- 9:55Christian Wheeler: Well, a simple thing is put your phone in your bag, turn it off.
- 9:58But I think more, we often use our cell phones as a sort
- 10:01of security blanket, right?
- 10:02The moment we have an unoccupied second of time we have this sense of existential,
- 10:09oh, here I am alone with my thoughts.
- 10:11What will I do now?
- 10:12You can overcome this feeling.
- 10:15And in fact, I was alive at a time when we didn't have such devices and
- 10:19we just had to wait for the train with nothing to do, and we were okay.
- 10:23Matt Abrahams: And you can actually have a conversation with somebody instead of,
- 10:26Christian Wheeler: You actually can.
- 10:27And for example, that even though many of us have the hypothesis, the lay belief,
- 10:32that it would be unpleasant to have a conversation with a stranger at the
- 10:35train, research shows quite the opposite.
- 10:37That if you strike up a conversation with someone on the train, I think
- 10:40they did this on buses in Chicago, you like that conversation not only more
- 10:44than you thought that you would, but that it improves your quality of life.
- 10:46So having this ability to interact with your environment in an uninhibited way
- 10:51from your devices is something that it takes a while to get used to, but
- 10:55it can improve your quality of life.
- 10:56Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 10:57And I wanna pick up on a thread that Christian mentioned about not in the
- 11:00moment ruminating on what's happening.
- 11:04There's a difference, to my mind, between rumination and reflection.
- 11:07A lot of us get in our head in the moment when something doesn't go
- 11:10right and that prevents us from being in that moment or what comes next.
- 11:14But it does make sense after the fact to reflect.
- 11:16That's how we learn.
- 11:17So that separation between rumination and reflection, I think is important.
- 11:21But I want us to spend a few moments talking about AI, artificial
- 11:24intelligence, and I'm curious to learn from each of you, how is it
- 11:28impacting the work that you do with your students, in the research you do?
- 11:32Sarah, do you mind talking about AI first for us?
- 11:35Sarah Soule: Sure.
- 11:35Happy to.
- 11:36I think probably everybody in the room understands that this is impacting all
- 11:40of us in ways that we probably even a year ago, didn't think possible.
- 11:44But a few things that come to my mind in terms of research, one of the things
- 11:48that I've been using it for is to run some of these corporate statements
- 11:52that I mentioned through an AI to pick up on the sentiment of the speaker,
- 11:57the writer, and to see, and we haven't done much with this yet, but we plan
- 12:01to look at the emotionality of these statements and see if we can pick up
- 12:05in any way that might impact how people rate these companies in terms of their
- 12:09level of corporate social responsibility.
- 12:12So that's one way that we're using this in research.
- 12:14In teaching, I was thinking about this just the other day, I was preparing
- 12:19an exercise for use in a classroom for people to map their social network.
- 12:25And so I prepared the exercise and I said, well, I wonder what ChatGPT
- 12:29would say about this exercise.
- 12:31It gave me some amazing suggestions for reflection questions, things I
- 12:35hadn't even thought about, and I've been doing this for many years now.
- 12:39So that was humbling, but also very helpful as well.
- 12:42I've asked ChatGPT recently to create menus for me of higher protein, vegetarian
- 12:50or plant-based diets that meet a certain number of grams of protein per day.
- 12:56And I was, again, astounded at how quickly it would spit out these very, I haven't
- 13:00tried them yet, but very reasonable sounding kinds of ideas and diets.
- 13:05And so I think that this is, while at times terrifying, I think it's also
- 13:10been very helpful, in at least those aspects of my life and work these days.
- 13:14Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 13:15So you're using it in research, in your teaching, and even in your personal life.
- 13:19Christian, how are you leveraging AI for what you do?
- 13:21Christian Wheeler: Yeah.
- 13:21I don't use it so much for my teaching for reasons related to what
- 13:24we were just discussing, but I do use it quite a bit for my research.
- 13:28A new thing that I'm excited about is having participants
- 13:32engage in conversations with AI.
- 13:35So some of the things that we do, we are interested in having people think about
- 13:38their attitudes or their thoughts or their beliefs in a different way than they might
- 13:42spontaneously do so, or ordinarily do so.
- 13:45And back in the day, what we would do is we would give them instructions to,
- 13:49to think about it in a certain way.
- 13:50But what you can do now is have people have a conversation with the chatbot.
- 13:55They will encourage them over a series of rounds to think about
- 13:58something in a particular way.
- 13:59We'll ask them follow up questions designed to have them
- 14:02have this sort of realization about their thoughts or beliefs.
- 14:05And so I think that's an exciting new direction for manipulation
- 14:08of psychological constructs.
- 14:10Matt Abrahams: So you're using it a lot in research and actually having people
- 14:13using the tool to help people reflect on their communication and their thoughts.
- 14:17Excellent.
- 14:17Very good.
- 14:18Jesper, how are you using AI?
- 14:20Jesper Sørensen: I would say the extent that I use it, I use it in, in teaching.
- 14:23So one of the things that I have always struggled with in teaching is
- 14:26examples and ways of illustrating ideas.
- 14:29And so I was recently working with some colleagues on a, developing a new
- 14:33course where we needed to come up with some kind of hypothetical examples
- 14:38to be able to explain certain basic principles in economics and strategy.
- 14:44And I'm just terrible at doing that myself, right?
- 14:47I just, I cannot do it.
- 14:48I can give you all the theory in the world, but being connected
- 14:51to the real world is really hard.
- 14:53So, that's because I like my phone.
- 14:56So stay away, Christian.
- 14:57Leave me alone.
- 14:58But I did use ChatGPT for this, where I basically wrote a prompt
- 15:02saying, okay, you're an expert in this particular topic, and I think in
- 15:05economics for example, and then I had like a broad outline of what I wanted.
- 15:09I wanted to be a luxury hotel that had an HR management problem and was thinking
- 15:14about incentives and all that other stuff.
- 15:17The amount of creativity that just popped up like immediately was amazing.
- 15:22And I feel more comfortable using it in that way 'cause I do worry
- 15:26about these models hallucinating, but these are fictitious examples.
- 15:30So hallucination is fine, right?
- 15:32But what we want is to make sure that they can be used to illustrate
- 15:35the concepts that we're doing.
- 15:37And I thought that was actually a really a powerful use case for me.
- 15:41Matt Abrahams: I like how you're leveraging its ability to be
- 15:43creative, to be creative for you.
- 15:45In the work I do around spontaneous speaking, I'll often have my students
- 15:50go to an LLM if they're preparing to give a presentation, or some other
- 15:54interaction, and have the LLM serve up spontaneous things for them to respond to.
- 16:00For example, my students might be giving a presentation and they
- 16:03can say, imagine I'm giving a presentation to fellow MBA students.
- 16:07What are three questions they might ask?
- 16:09And then the students practice answering those questions that are served up.
- 16:12So it serves as a way of generating questions so they can practice.
- 16:16And talking to someone else on the podcast who is an expert on AI, we had a similar
- 16:20conversation, and the recommendation he gave me is, if you don't know how
- 16:24to use it, ask it and it can tell you.
- 16:26I told ChatGPT that I was interested in doing this particular assignment.
- 16:30How could it help me?
- 16:31And it gave me lots of interesting ideas about how it could help me.
- 16:34And we actually executed on a few of those.
- 16:36So sometimes if you don't know how to use AI, maybe AI can help you
- 16:40figure out how you could use it.
- 16:42So this will be our final question for the panel.
- 16:44Christian, let me start with you.
- 16:45I'd like for you to share something you're working on that you're currently
- 16:48really excited about, and I'll give you some extra credit, imaginary
- 16:51extra credit, if you can apply what you're working on to everybody in the
- 16:56audience and how they could leverage it.
- 16:58Christian Wheeler: A lot of my research projects are a bit in the weeds, so I'm
- 17:01gonna give you something very simple, that most of you should be able to apply.
- 17:05For a lot of the things that we do, we need to generate a title
- 17:08or a heading to what we're doing, and we have a choice to make.
- 17:11We could frame that title as a statement, or we could frame
- 17:15that title as a question.
- 17:17So for example, if I have a newspaper article about green tea, I could say green
- 17:22tea has health benefits, question mark.
- 17:25Or I could say green tea has health benefits, period.
- 17:29Which one is better?
- 17:31Question mark.
- 17:31I thought so too.
- 17:32You're wrong.
- 17:34Yeah.
- 17:35Isn't that interesting?
- 17:36As it turns out, statements work better.
- 17:38We've tested this over multiple domains.
- 17:40We've tested it with actual newspaper headlines, millions and
- 17:44millions of newspaper headlines.
- 17:45We've tested it with things like Reddit posts and seeing
- 17:48how many up votes they get.
- 17:50We've tested it with academic articles and seeing how many
- 17:53citations those academic articles get.
- 17:55In all of those cases, question marks perform worse than statements.
- 17:59The effect isn't huge.
- 18:00If it were too big, we would be a little suspicious of it.
- 18:02It's a little effect, but it's a reliable effect.
- 18:05Matt Abrahams: That was a great answer, exclamation point.
- 18:08I don't know how that plays, but good.
- 18:10Jesper, what's something you're working on that we can all benefit from?
- 18:13Jesper Sørensen: We recently at the GSB, we've been, I've been working
- 18:15with some colleagues on developing a new asynchronous course called
- 18:20Stanford Business Essentials, and this is a product that's targeted
- 18:24at early career professionals.
- 18:26So these are basically people who have graduated from university or
- 18:30something like that, and they're starting out in their careers.
- 18:33And one of the inspirations for this product is I look at my own children
- 18:36who have been in this situation and they are just befuddled right by
- 18:40what's going on in their organizations.
- 18:42Like, why do things happen this way, et cetera, et cetera.
- 18:45I think this is a great tool for really getting people up to speed.
- 18:50Matt Abrahams: I was recently being interviewed for a Korean outlet because
- 18:54my book was just translated into Korean, and the interviewer told me that at the
- 18:58university level, they are teaching a class on how to make phone calls because
- 19:04students at that age don't know how to actually speak on the phone to somebody.
- 19:09And so this notion of providing foundational skills, I don't know
- 19:13that we have to get that foundational, but really rings the cord for sure.
- 19:17Sarah, how about something you're working on?
- 19:18I know you've got a lot going on.
- 19:20Sarah Soule: Coming back to the project that I mentioned before about these
- 19:23corporate statements, one of the other things that we've been looking at
- 19:26is whether or not elements of those statements will induce people to donate
- 19:33money to the particular issue at hand.
- 19:35Also to write voluntary letters on behalf of the issue at hand.
- 19:39And so we wanna try to see if these things can mobilize people to do something.
- 19:43So if we have a statement, a fictitious statement about a lumber
- 19:47company, and it's just confessed to deforestation, will people who see a
- 19:52confession actually be more willing to give money to an environmental
- 19:57cause, or write a letter, volunteer to write a letter, a longer letter.
- 20:01But one of the things that we've been playing with comes back to something
- 20:04that you have taught me, Matt, and that is the what, so what, now what,
- 20:09framework that you all now also know.
- 20:12And it turns out that framework has been used in studies of getting
- 20:16people to mobilize, and it's usually referred to as a kind of collective
- 20:21active action frame where you name the problem, you say why it's important,
- 20:26and then you mobilize people.
- 20:27You ask people to do something.
- 20:29So we are looking at that exact same structure and wondering, and looking,
- 20:34and we will test, to see whether or not that particular structure is
- 20:38more or less likely to induce people to mobilize on behalf of the cause.
- 20:43So that's something new, another piece of that project.
- 20:45Matt Abrahams: That's really fascinating.
- 20:47Persuasion is so interesting, but I like that you're playing with, does the
- 20:50structure of the message actually impact?
- 20:53One of the things I'm researching and interested in is the role
- 20:55of in strategic communication.
- 20:59So if you think about it, everything I've talked about while I've been with you
- 21:02is about fidelity, accuracy and clarity.
- 21:05But often we use ambiguity to achieve our goals.
- 21:08Think about this.
- 21:09If I cooked a meal for you, I've already told you I'm a lousy cook, and I give
- 21:14it to you, and I say, what do you think?
- 21:16You could tell me the truth.
- 21:17It's awful, but that might hurt my feelings.
- 21:19So you might say something wonderfully ambiguous, like, I've never quite
- 21:22tried anything like this before, right?
- 21:26And so you fulfilled the strategic obligation of responding, but doing so
- 21:30in a way that doesn't hurt my feelings.
- 21:31So I'm really interested in times where fidelity isn't the goal, where
- 21:35we're purposely ambiguous and what that means for our communication.
- 21:38So thank you for all of you sharing, not just your insights into your
- 21:41research, but also for sharing ideas that we can all deploy.
- 21:45So this is the fun part.
- 21:46So I'd love to invite those of you who have questions to wait
- 21:50for the microphone to show up.
- 21:52I see a hand over here.
- 21:54Audience Member 1: Hi there.
- 21:54Thank you to all the panelists.
- 21:55Wonderful to hear all the different insights.
- 21:57My name is Gary Struble.
- 21:59I run a media company in Namibia.
- 22:00And just perhaps linking back into the AI question, you are all quite specific
- 22:05about answering it in a way about how AI makes your life easier, but I imagine
- 22:10AI is also going to make your lives much more difficult if it isn't already.
- 22:15And I perhaps just address the question to anyone on the panel, is from an
- 22:18academic perspective, from perhaps even strategizing as to how academia remains
- 22:23relevant in how it's currently structured, how are you grappling with the problems
- 22:28of AI in grading students and creating the funnels that academia relies upon?
- 22:35Christian Wheeler: Well, my challenges are perhaps a little
- 22:36different from some of the others.
- 22:38Most of the assignments in my class are self-reflections, and I want them to
- 22:43think about what that experience was like.
- 22:46What did they learn from that?
- 22:47How are they going to apply that?
- 22:48And perhaps not surprisingly, there's a non-trivial subset of participants or
- 22:53students who have AI self-reflect about an experience that the AI did not have.
- 22:59So that's a challenge and it's a little discouraging.
- 23:02So the, the solution to that is to have them do it in person
- 23:06and have them talk about it.
- 23:07But I think it is a subset of a more general problem that I think you're
- 23:10hinting at, is that people offloading the intellectual work that they might do,
- 23:15whether it's introspective intellectual work or creating a new product off the AI.
- 23:20And in my case, it's just, um, preventing introspection.
- 23:24Sarah Soule: I think another space that we worry a lot about this is in using some
- 23:28sort of AI tool to write academic papers, even if the research findings are in
- 23:33fact valid and true, and actual research findings, asking an AI to actually
- 23:39write the results up is worrisome.
- 23:41And so I think those of us who serve as journal editors, who serve
- 23:45as reviewers, have to be ever more vigilant to try to figure out ways to
- 23:50try to detect this kind of use of AI.
- 23:53I don't think anybody would worry too much if anybody used an AI to
- 23:57give them feedback on the writing, but to have an AI generate the
- 24:01writing is more problematic, I think.
- 24:04Jesper Sørensen: Yeah, I would just say that I think it's definitely
- 24:06a problem in the context of giving exams and so on and so forth, as
- 24:11Christian was referring to as well.
- 24:13I think professors and then teachers are still, I think, struggling with the nature
- 24:17of the problem, which I think actually has less to do with the technology per se
- 24:21than with the equilibrium we reach with respect to what an exam serves to do.
- 24:26And I actually think it's gonna require faculty and instructors everywhere to
- 24:31think more deeply about what they're trying to accomplish and make those
- 24:34kinds of assessments more meaningful.
- 24:36Because I think a lot of students, they end up using these kinds of tools to
- 24:40answer questions because they are not actually interested in the introspection
- 24:45or the learning or the development.
- 24:46They know that would be something they would get out of it if they wrote the
- 24:50work themselves, but they think that the whole exercise is just pointless.
- 24:55But that's a flaw on our part, and that's what we have to address, right?
- 24:59So there are some fixes that are around.
- 25:02Having people take exams by hand and in person and so on and so forth.
- 25:06And I think that's also part of it.
- 25:08But at the end of the day, I also think we need to really think about
- 25:11what assessment is and what we're trying to accomplish with assessment.
- 25:14Matt Abrahams: One of the things my co-teacher and I are thinking about
- 25:17doing is using the communication we have with AI as a way of reinforcing some
- 25:21of the communication skills we have.
- 25:23When you're typing in a prompt, you're writing a message.
- 25:25Now the audience happens to be an LLM instead of a person.
- 25:29But we can actually reinforce some of the ideas that we're trying to
- 25:31talk about when we actually have human to human communication.
- 25:34So actually using the way we interact with AI as another avenue to teach some of the
- 25:39skills is something we're toying with.
- 25:41Audience Member 2: Um, my name is Tana Tutu from Ethiopia.
- 25:44I'm in manufacturing, but by training I'm a psychologist, but I don't practice.
- 25:50But instead of saying I don't practice, I practice because I live with people.
- 25:54So I deal with people.
- 25:56So my question is regarding AI.
- 25:58I know it's going to take over some of the jobs and positions.
- 26:03And regarding having a chat with a chatbot, when you give it a prompt,
- 26:09you have to give it, you are a psychologist, a socialist like that.
- 26:13So for somebody who's lost their parents, can you just give them a prompt by, you
- 26:19are my mom, so you'll be speaking to me like this, speaking to me like that.
- 26:24So in a positive way, I see that in overcoming grief.
- 26:30That's one of the questions.
- 26:31I want you to give us a view.
- 26:34The other one is, in having a discussion with AI, like with the chatbot,
- 26:39how safe is our secrets with AI?
- 26:42You know, with humans, you're scared.
- 26:44Oh, I can trust that.
- 26:46And then there will be another version of it, which is gossip.
- 26:49So just give us few dimensions in that respect.
- 26:52Thank you.
- 26:53Matt Abrahams: So I don't know how to answer either of those questions except
- 26:56to say that my sense is as somebody who is always very concerned about privacy,
- 27:02that I would be very concerned sharing very personal information with it.
- 27:06That said, I certainly know that we are far deficient in the number of
- 27:11therapists that we have in the world.
- 27:14And people have lots of serious mental illness and challenges, and
- 27:18there might be an opportunity for AI to help some people in some ways.
- 27:22So we have to think about what that means.
- 27:24I can tell you from my perspective, I think there's great opportunity to share
- 27:29information through LLMs and chatbots.
- 27:33So for example, we're in the process of creating a chatbot for the podcast where
- 27:37you can go and you can ask a question just like you did, and it will scour all
- 27:41of the wonderful guests that we have.
- 27:44And it will say that question is very similar to something Jesper said in this
- 27:48episode, you might wanna listen to it.
- 27:50So I see it as an a mechanism to help people learn as well,.
- 27:54But I think it's really early days.
- 27:55I don't know if others of you have opinions on this, but I
- 27:58don't know how to answer those questions except to say they're good
- 28:00questions and we should look at it.
- 28:02Christian Wheeler: Yeah, I don't have a ton to add.
- 28:03I mean, there's research on, you know, there are a number of AI companions now
- 28:08that can take on various characteristics.
- 28:10The research shows that people get very emotionally attached
- 28:14to these AI companions.
- 28:15Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, I don't know.
- 28:19I don't have research on that particular aspect, but for me personally, I will
- 28:23take a person over a screen any day.
- 28:25Audience Member 3: Uh, my name is Leslie Meringue from Glytime
- 28:27Time Foods, Zimbabwe, and we run the Kelloggs of Africa.
- 28:31But now my question is, if we are competing neck to neck with that
- 28:35particular business in a particular region, and you compare yourself with
- 28:39that particular business, does it not come with legal connotations to it?
- 28:43Jesper Sørensen: To legal connotations?
- 28:45Is that what you said?
- 28:46Yes.
- 28:47Yes.
- 28:47I would not encourage the use of analogies like that in a marketing context.
- 28:52Um, and that's not really what we were focused on, right?
- 28:55So we were focused on how do you concisely and effectively communicate what your
- 29:00company is about to somebody else.
- 29:02Now you need to be careful.
- 29:03So for example, I was once teaching some of these ideas to executives and, and they
- 29:08were a group of Australian executives.
- 29:10And so I told 'em, I asked them about a company that's based in Silicon
- 29:14Valley called Rover, Rover.com.
- 29:16And Rover is the Uber of dog walking.
- 29:20It's a very Silicon Valley idea.
- 29:22And so I asked them what, like when you hear the phrase the Uber of dog walk,
- 29:26none of them were familiar with this company, what does that mean to you?
- 29:30And one of the first answers was, oh, that means that I can get
- 29:34a dog walker on demand, okay?
- 29:36Because when you think about an Uber, one of the characteristics
- 29:39of an Uber is you pull out your app and you say, I want a car right now.
- 29:43And it shows up.
- 29:44That's not at all what Rover does, right?
- 29:45The analogy is about it's gig working, right?
- 29:48So they have a bunch of people who have too much time on their hand and not enough
- 29:52money, and a bunch of people who have too much money and too many dogs, right?
- 29:56And they're, they're trying to get them aligned with each other.
- 29:59And that's also what Uber is like.
- 30:01But again, so the reason you need to be careful with analogies is
- 30:04there can be that kind of miss because people have their own
- 30:07mental models of what's going on.
- 30:10So when you compare yourself to another company you need to be careful about what
- 30:14it is your audience is actually hearing when you're making that comparison.
- 30:18'Cause otherwise it can really lead to misunderstandings.
- 30:21Matt Abrahams: Thank you for being part of our live audience.
- 30:23And with that I end, I'll ask you to thank our amazing guests and I appreciate
- 30:27the questions that you all ask.
- 30:28Thank you very much.
- 30:32Thank you for joining us for this special Think Fast Talk Smart podcast
- 30:37episode, recorded live as part of the biannual Stanford SEED Conference.
- 30:42To hear another live episode like this, please listen to episode 194.
- 30:48This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me Matt Abrahams.
- 30:54Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 30:56With thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 30:58Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 31:02Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 31:04Also follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 31:07And check out FasterSmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 31:11learning content and our newsletter.
- 31:14Please consider our premium offering with extended Deep Thinks episodes
- 31:18AMAs, Ask Matt Anything, and much more at FasterSmarter.io/premium.