Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Deconstructing Trauma
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everyone. My name is Gabriel eyeless.
- 0:03I'm a psychotherapist and a Buddhist scholar, and this is
- 0:06the Curious mind podcast. And on this podcast, I try to
- 0:12dissect with my guests complex, psychological topics, and
- 0:17sometimes I reflect on self-development and meditation
- 0:21as well. My guest today is what we call.
- 0:28Always cough as assistant professor of clinical research
- 0:31and Leadership at the George Washington University, School of
- 0:35Medicine, and Health Sciences, and Washington d.c.
- 0:38He's a psychologist as well as a historian and philosopher of the
- 0:42medical sciences and has several Publications among others on
- 0:47trauma. And for example, his book
- 0:50published in 2014 titled in German shock effect on his to
- 0:54OSHA, epistemology is Thomas. Which would translate in English
- 0:59as shock effects, a historical, epidemiology of trauma.
- 1:04Welcome Ali. Well, thank you for having me.
- 1:08So we briefly discussed that you have spent some years with the
- 1:14trauma topic and you're quite fortunate to have this double
- 1:18perspective as a historian and psychologists on this.
- 1:23So I'm quite glad to discuss such a complex Topic as trauma
- 1:30with you naturally, will will not get to discuss it fully,
- 1:34which would take hours, I guess with your experience.
- 1:37But at least you touch upon some important topics and it is a
- 1:41highly relevant topic today to start with, why don't you give
- 1:45us a short historical overview about the concept and
- 1:49understanding of trauma starting with the 19th century, where it
- 1:54became quite relevant. Sure.
- 1:57I'm happy to do that. I think a thumbnail sketch of
- 2:02the of the history of psychological trauma.
- 2:07Like you said starts in the 19th century alone in the 1860s,
- 2:10particularly most historians, it's traced it back to the 1860s
- 2:15with a ailment that was called at the time Railway spine.
- 2:18So it was, it was Railway accidents.
- 2:22That led some people, some passengers to show symptoms the
- 2:26Dubai diverse range of Simpsons one should add mostly of them
- 2:30somatic symptoms of bodily symptoms and after Railway
- 2:33accidents, without there, being an obvious lesion or damage of
- 2:38the body. And I mean, this is significant
- 2:42right? For an already, this episode,
- 2:44this first episode worse of something emerges that were
- 2:48later morph into the medical discourse.
- 2:51In the psychological discourse of post-traumatic suffering is
- 2:55in the context. Of changes in law and that
- 3:02brought that the let individuals who suffer from such accidents
- 3:06make claims for compensations because they suffered suffer
- 3:10from these accidents. That was already at that early
- 3:12time. Yes, that is what prompted the
- 3:15first writings on Railway spine in which later became Railway
- 3:19brain, and then soon became the accident, Neurosis or traumatic,
- 3:24neurosis, and it sort of morphed into something Evermore.
- 3:26Psychological both in terms of its causes.
- 3:29But also in terms of the consequences it had.
- 3:32So this is the first sort of staged, the First Act of trauma,
- 3:36appearing on the historical stage or something like.
- 3:39I mean, what I mean by that, is course, is not trauma.
- 3:42As such or the experience of violence is such.
- 3:44A course, yet is something that has been stats, studied, or that
- 3:48raises the concern of the medical and the broader sense to
- 3:53Health Professions and Is there's three one could say,
- 4:00three episodes were trauma becomes really to give you just
- 4:05a quick overview. Historically.
- 4:06So, this one is the accidents of the second Second Industrial
- 4:10Revolution. And then we have the Great War
- 4:13or the first world first world war or shellshock becomes a very
- 4:18prominent topic. Of course also in England, but
- 4:21also traumatic and Neurosis. Or his theory, I ski area in
- 4:24Germany to not issue. the clicks note also warned you roses but
- 4:30it all war waging Nations at the time and then this continues
- 4:34into the second world war and then of course the last sort of
- 4:38the more recent episode is again is war the Vietnam War and where
- 4:43this becomes a stallion topic and to sort of in again a
- 4:48continuation of the legal context that was always
- 4:51important is maybe the 1980s and 90s discussions about False
- 4:57memory and the traumatic effects of sexual abuse and which again
- 5:07already channeled. Again, a lot of interest from
- 5:09from the profession but also from the public.
- 5:11So the I think I think this sort of the war context and the legal
- 5:15context there, they've been forces and hence a lot of
- 5:19historians have stated. There's a waxing and waning of
- 5:25interest in trauma over time. I'm so it is, it brings
- 5:28contingency into history in a way because once in the postwar
- 5:32Years, there's or historians have long, I've argued this this
- 5:37diminished interest in. It shoots up again the 1970s.
- 5:40So that's sort of the, you know, the long, like a very rough
- 5:46sketch of those of how trauma became, at least a topic in the
- 5:51medical and psychological Sciences.
- 5:53Yes, and we will come to talk about this more, but Again we
- 5:57have maybe for the last decade or so I think we live in a time
- 6:02where this again a lot of public interest in the topic of drama
- 6:06and a an expansion of what psychological trauma means to
- 6:13people and how they understand it.
- 6:16Now, one important aspect that also read in one of your
- 6:21Publications on trauma that was connected with the concept of
- 6:26Psychological trauma was disruption and discontinuation.
- 6:32Can you expand a little bit about that?
- 6:34How did they come about? And what is the place of these
- 6:40kinds of ideas of the disruption of experience the disruption of
- 6:44Life? What does it have to do with the
- 6:47understanding of trauma? Right.
- 6:50I think when I thought about how trauma, and this is a more, I
- 6:55think this is really gets into A sort of one of the more I would
- 6:58guess I would say philosophical questions around this.
- 7:04I don't I don't I wouldn't say necessarily that experts on
- 7:09trauma or trauma therapist explicitly thought of trauma in
- 7:14terms of disruption, but very much The way it was seen or the
- 7:22way I think, the implicit assumption that accompanies, a
- 7:26lot of the, this, the treatment of trauma was that it was a
- 7:31discontinuation of experience that something that stands
- 7:34outside normal everyday experience.
- 7:37I think one of in the DSM and the diagnostic and statistical
- 7:41Manual of mental disorders, right?
- 7:43In the first edition of the DSM, that mentioned Peter.
- 7:48PTSD, that was in 1980. The definition and this is,
- 7:53there is a so-called trauma Criterion, right?
- 7:56And it was sort of stands, outside normal experience.
- 8:02So there was it's an abnormal experience that trauma
- 8:05constitutes, that was one of the basic tenants.
- 8:09Yeah, so just to talk a little bit.
- 8:10So the DSM is one of the major classifications for diagnosis.
- 8:14So in 1980 professionals could for the first I'm give the
- 8:19officially the diagnosis of PTSD.
- 8:22Even though it was discussed, traumatic responses were
- 8:26discussed already for a long, a time, but this is the time when
- 8:29it arrived at the mainstream of the psychological and medical
- 8:33community and it was officially recognized as such.
- 8:38So people with these kinds of symptoms than could get the
- 8:41diagnosis of PTSD. And as you mentioned at that
- 8:44time, there was one of the criteria is that At the events
- 8:49that took place and correct me if I'm wrong.
- 8:52Yeah. Should have been something
- 8:53excessive out of the normal where the experience was
- 9:00discontinuation, for the lack of a better word, where the normal
- 9:03life ended for whatever reason, be it an accident mute a war
- 9:08situation. Be it, a violent, sort of abuse
- 9:12sexual or otherwise, and that constituted one part of the idea
- 9:18at that. I'm of how the traumatic
- 9:21response came about. Is that more or less?
- 9:23Correct? Yeah, you know, that's great,
- 9:24that's a great paraphrase. The great way to put it, but I
- 9:30think it's this, this idea that trauma is not something that
- 9:33belongs to Everyday Life, patterns, its out, its it can't
- 9:38be expected. He can't be anticipated.
- 9:41It gets you when your defenses are down, right?
- 9:45It's not something. And that leaves these scars.
- 9:48Yes. And but the idea and so that's
- 9:52the idea that it's accompanied by great fear that is always
- 9:56been around for a long time. The question was always, what
- 10:01does trauma act as a trigger? What is it or is it just or is
- 10:05it the actual cause of an ailment of the complaint of a
- 10:10psychological disorder in prior to the PTSD diagnosis in the
- 10:15DSM, was more often seen as a trigger There's something in the
- 10:19person in the personality that lets the trauma act, as a
- 10:24trigger to bring a pathology to the for like make make make
- 10:30something make this let this person fall psychologically ill,
- 10:34but it's not. The trauma itself is not that
- 10:37relevant when it comes to having a causal explanation of that
- 10:41ailment or that. So, does that mean that this the
- 10:44understanding was that not events or traumatic, but Only
- 10:48the combination of an event and a susceptible individual caused.
- 10:53The trauma response. Is that right?
- 10:56And even, even though I mean you can find even though, At the
- 11:03time, I mean you I've and I think in the chapter you've
- 11:06mentioned before there's also there's some influential books,
- 11:09went about not the stress of War already in the 1940s.
- 11:14So in the wake of the second world war, the idea that normal
- 11:18people quote, unquote and could suffer trauma was also taken for
- 11:23granted, but the question was okay, when does it become a
- 11:26chronic problem? And they are clinician would say
- 11:28no, it's it's, it's something. That only that only with a
- 11:33certain predisposition will become a chronic problem but
- 11:36their acute stress reactions or attraction reactions to trauma
- 11:42that are pathological, but it's not, these are just you know,
- 11:46transient, right? So maybe it's good at this point
- 11:50to for the people who are not quite aware of this and don't
- 11:54have access to the DSM to recount.
- 11:57What medically is perceived or you know, for the Therapeutic,
- 12:04medical establishment, what is necessary.
- 12:07In order to diagnose today, a post-traumatic stress disorder
- 12:12PTSD diagnosis. So, this is not historical.
- 12:15This is from today, it's the DSM-5 addition and the what
- 12:21needs to be there needs in combination is quite strong.
- 12:27We need to see quite strong limitations or Four rings in the
- 12:32individual. In order to be able to give this
- 12:35diagnosis. This is not, you know, an easy
- 12:38thing to do that because I feel somehow distressed or because I
- 12:42have a burnout for example, that this could be misdiagnosed as a
- 12:47PTSD. So, the most important element
- 12:51in the beginning is that the needs to be an exposure to an
- 12:56actual or threatened death situation or a serious injury or
- 13:01a sexual. Violence.
- 13:02This can be a situation that was threatening to me or I can also
- 13:07be traumatized by witnessing or someone else was in a dangerous
- 13:12situation or died and so on. So which explains how ambulance
- 13:16drivers for example or survivors of War, who just witnessed how
- 13:21their comrades have fallen. And so on, they can equally be
- 13:25traumatized. So the exposure to such an event
- 13:29in some way. As necessary as a criterium and
- 13:34then we need other criterias as well.
- 13:37Something like distressing intrusions.
- 13:39Intrusion is an experience that jumps into my mind out of the
- 13:46blue basically and has little to do with my inclinations, or with
- 13:51what I want to think about. And it's persistent and that I
- 13:55cannot just make it go away, this can be a memory that comes
- 13:59up, can be Memory in daytime. Can be marrying dreams, can be
- 14:03flashbacks where we experience entire episodes of the traumatic
- 14:09event that I encountered. So those kinds of intrusions are
- 14:14quite characteristic. Don't always have to be there,
- 14:16but they're quite quite quite should characteristic and
- 14:20because they usually create such a distressing emotional.
- 14:23Reaction a normal response of people is that they try to avoid
- 14:28situations which trigger such memories.
- 14:31Such intrusions in the mind. So there's the characteristic of
- 14:36the avoidance. And then, in general, the need
- 14:40to be distressing experiences, feelings, thoughts, negative
- 14:46beliefs about oneself, General heightened, experience of fear
- 14:53and distress. So a whole range of negative
- 14:58experience experiences. For an extended period of time,
- 15:03right? So all in all, we can see that
- 15:08it is a severe severe syndrome and people who kind of carefully
- 15:16diagnose this would not mistake someone who has depressive
- 15:23episodes and you know questioning if they if their
- 15:28life has purpose and so on would usually not mistake that.
- 15:31Act with a piteous D and this becomes relevant.
- 15:34When I think when we talk more about the current situation
- 15:37today and how the idea of what trauma psychological trauma is
- 15:42has significantly proliferated among part of the lay community
- 15:48and how they understand it. How do you perceive kind of the
- 15:54development from those 1980s? Let's say, two more this
- 16:00millennia. So in the past 20 years, what
- 16:03have you observed as changes in the understanding and awareness
- 16:08of psychological trauma? Yeah, I think what you're
- 16:13getting at is is really is really important in the sense
- 16:19that trauma became this very expansive category, right?
- 16:23I think there's some, some authors who have suggested that
- 16:26there is a conceptual bracket creep, that's what they have
- 16:29called with with with regard to DSM.
- 16:31Also, that more and more events could be classified as traumatic
- 16:36and I think more recent additions.
- 16:38So I'd have tried to remedy that in response so but I I think
- 16:44it's it's it for I can see how that question is is really
- 16:51relevant for psychologists, psychotherapists and
- 16:54psychologists and and but also for yeah, the general public
- 17:01because we have a We connect moral claims, right?
- 17:06And exactly to the trauma and we say you're, you have access to a
- 17:13privileged position that is epistemic logically privilege
- 17:17because you're a victim but that's also morally privilege
- 17:20because you're a victim. Can you explain the
- 17:22epistemological Pod? I think there is a, I mean, this
- 17:25has very concrete applications in literary Theory, right?
- 17:30Where the trauma the traumatized at like in some some of these
- 17:33Readings of how Tramp trauma manifests and literature is that
- 17:37there's some kind of privileged access to them.
- 17:40Yeah, to the to reality, I mean I don't want to go go into that
- 17:44but there's and I think there's also common notion Among Us that
- 17:49a true history. One that is not distorted by
- 17:52interests is written by those who have who are victims who
- 17:56have right. And this is, of course.
- 17:58Also connected to a topic that also looms large of course in.
- 18:03All my studies in the humanities which is the remembrance of the
- 18:07Holocaust and the schwa. So it is it is this these
- 18:13attempts to make history disappear which happened after
- 18:17that second world war, right in instead of in the postwar Europe
- 18:21and that trauma was a vehicle to rehabilitate or 22.
- 18:28To address this, right to your to, to redress this and let
- 18:33voices come to the fore that haven't been heard and have a
- 18:37more more direct confrontation with the violent past.
- 18:40And I think that trauma played a role in that.
- 18:42And I think for all these different reasons that overlap
- 18:44or strands that overlap trauma has become also this epistemic
- 18:48logically privileged position or like the traumatized as this.
- 18:52This, this privileged position is something from the Viewpoint
- 18:55of us verse Survivor from the viewpoint.
- 18:58Of somebody who's a victim, things appear different and
- 19:02arguably more clear, right? I'm to put, it sort of took to
- 19:06put it in simple terms, but I think that's sort of the idea
- 19:08behind it. So, what I get from that is that
- 19:12it shows that different levels to the topic.
- 19:17On the one level we have the individual who has experienced
- 19:20something traumatic and suffers from that, and seeks the
- 19:27recognition. Because help goes to therapy
- 19:30once to overcome that for their own personal sake, in order to
- 19:33get along well with their life, which is the job of
- 19:36psychotherapy. And then, there is a level where
- 19:40I understand that Society had to come to term with a structural
- 19:45aspect of trauma, for example, when War happens, where it has
- 19:52to come to terms with itself. What are we as a society doing
- 19:56with people sending soldiers? Goes out to war zones.
- 20:00How do we understand ourselves in this position for possible?
- 20:06Implications of? How does that feedback into the
- 20:09peace movement? So not just as a general kind of
- 20:12idea that peace is nice and nobody should kill each other
- 20:14but also we don't want to send our children anymore.
- 20:18We as a society into war to see them again coming back.
- 20:22Traumatized. I mean you're in the u.s. you
- 20:25have seen this with the Iraq War As a topic, I have relatives who
- 20:33have been in the u.s. soldiers and in Iraq.
- 20:37So and then it becomes a whole societal thing where it's the
- 20:41topic is discussed. What is Justified as a traumatic
- 20:47event? How do we take people, seriously
- 20:51who make a claim to be victims? These are quite difficult
- 20:55discussions. Of having had on the societal
- 20:59level and especially I think in the few past years there have
- 21:04been shifts in kind of the recognition of what is
- 21:09legitimately can be perceived as trauma.
- 21:13And yes I would like to hear your thoughts on that and I
- 21:17don't know, I think this is really it's really, I think you
- 21:19put your, putting your finger on it and that there's a collective
- 21:24Dimension to this that there were During sort of the realm of
- 21:29values and sort of also assessing what we can, what
- 21:35sacrifices are Justified or not, and what you want, who gets to
- 21:42have this status and whom should we believe?
- 21:45So, I think there's there's yeah, there's all these these
- 21:48questions there. But I think these questions are
- 21:53somehow are not answerable within trauma discourse, right?
- 21:56They're not, they need go beyond them.
- 21:59And I think that's one of the one of the points of criticisms
- 22:02that that are frequently raised, is that, if trauma stays within
- 22:09this sort of psychological realm and they cannot get to, they
- 22:13sort of obscure some of these larger questions that you just
- 22:16sort of raised the erase and you pointed tool.
- 22:20Because yeah, there it's not it's not a moral discussion in
- 22:22principle especially with the turn to traumatic skeet, trauma
- 22:27being perceived in terms of traumatic stress as something
- 22:31that has a predictable pattern in an individual that is
- 22:34affected by it and where you don't need to look to the cause
- 22:39necessarily, if you identify that the pattern in principle,
- 22:44you know, the idea is at least sort of an evidence based
- 22:47practice in Psychotherapy that it's that it's shared in some
- 22:51scientific communities would say, Well, it, you know, the
- 22:53question of whether this is a trauma or not becomes in a way,
- 22:57Very light, because they can say, well, let's just bracket
- 23:00that moral question and treat the PTSD.
- 23:03But there's yeah, you need to pass that threshold, right?
- 23:07And then you, once you can see past the threshold, you are
- 23:10your, the view your certified victim, so to speak.
- 23:14But this is this, I mean this I don't mean in any way pejorative
- 23:18or in a disparaging way. I think it's it's more.
- 23:24The acknowledgement is important to put it positively right.
- 23:26The acknowledgement is Absolutely, and psychotherapist
- 23:30have been thrust into that role of millions of they are the ones
- 23:34who acknowledge this wrongdoing that has that has happened.
- 23:39And that is, that is a, that is a, that is a can be an isolating
- 23:43this course, right? But it couldn't in but the it
- 23:46should involve like the goal is, of course, and psychotherapist
- 23:50have some often tried that in the past to connect it, to
- 23:52broader societal topics and actually feed it back into
- 23:56society and not just stay. Within the Consulting room.
- 23:59All right. So I think it is, it is a, it's
- 24:03something. It's just a moral aspect.
- 24:05I think. You can't ignore with trauma.
- 24:07And then just to add of course, in the DSM, the ways mental
- 24:11disorders are classified. It is PTSD, is an oddity that in
- 24:15the sent, to the extent that it Introduces a direct call makes a
- 24:21cause of Claim about where the disorder comes from.
- 24:24No other. I mean, they're all no other
- 24:27disorder in the DSM does that except for the of course that
- 24:30are set of organic. But but otherwise there's no,
- 24:33there's no claim being made about what the etiology is
- 24:38Young, is, what PTSD is different.
- 24:40And I think if you took that away, it wouldn't be any more,
- 24:44right? So it's not, I think the this
- 24:46idea that you can just diagnose a syndrome or For this
- 24:49collection of syndromes and then once and that will lead you to a
- 24:52path of trauma. That is that is, that is Yeah,
- 24:56that is mistaken, likely. Yes.
- 24:59So here, but just can, I just be other point, I think to the
- 25:03expansion of trauma, what hasn't changed?
- 25:07And I think I tried, I tried to make that in various try to make
- 25:12that claim in various things that I've wrote is trauma has
- 25:15always been an attractive concept?
- 25:19I don't, I don't believe repairs.
- 25:20That PTSD is something that catapulted it too.
- 25:26You know, I mean it's sort of certainly give it more exposure
- 25:30but I think that that clinicians have been interested in trauma
- 25:34and that this was a an interesting model to think with
- 25:38also, in various fields in is the case and that there's always
- 25:42been a struggle to define the blinds.
- 25:45I mean even if you look at the sort of at the earliest at the
- 25:48earliest discussion about railway spine, you always had
- 25:50struggles of okay what is a quote unquote real disorder and
- 25:53what is the you know? Fictitious.
- 25:57And what is, what is sort of the, and I think that sort of
- 25:59baked into it from the beginning.
- 26:01Yes, I would like to continue on that line of thought, because,
- 26:07as you put it in, in one of your articles, the way of thinking
- 26:13that it doesn't have to be necessarily one major event that
- 26:19is traumatic, but that basically, everyone is traumatic
- 26:22traumatized, by our way, of life.
- 26:26Is, in fact, quite old and that takes away exactly the element
- 26:30that you mentioned. The one causal links to external
- 26:34Factor. When one of the kind of
- 26:37philosophers are Dawn on, probably also other people in
- 26:42that line were commenting as far as I remember that the way of
- 26:47life that we have is traumatic, nobody can be without traumatic
- 26:52scars because we all have to overcome The difficult life
- 26:57condition that capitalism has imposed itself on us, and I find
- 27:02it interesting that this very proliferating, very vague kind
- 27:07of thinking about that vague. But encompassing way of thinking
- 27:11about trauma has a Resurgence today.
- 27:19And again, in a very broad sense of thinking that.
- 27:24Yes, all of my hurts. All my pains must go back to
- 27:28some trauma. Do my parenting to me being are
- 27:32ended by my parents to make grown-up.
- 27:35Neglected needs my past relationships, have traumatized
- 27:39me that somehow resembles to me, the way of thinking that just
- 27:45dramatic word. This label of trauma that you
- 27:48mentioned is so attractive. To us, has become a little bit
- 27:54too attractive for our own sake. And is apply to so many everyday
- 27:59situations. How do you perceive from the
- 28:01historical perspective? But also from your observations,
- 28:04such a broad application to the normal scarring, let's put it
- 28:10this way and we all have yeah, I think, I think you're right to
- 28:15point out that this has a long history, and I do think that
- 28:21That PTSD the way it emerged and the sort of the risk that you're
- 28:26right about the Resurgence, that took place when it became this
- 28:30diagnostic category. But I also think in part what I
- 28:37mean, doesn't explain it, but I think we also have to ask.
- 28:39Okay, how come we tend to? I mean I'm using the we now.
- 28:45I hope I don't know how inclusive that we is right but
- 28:48but I think when we when I Ink about trauma at the time when I
- 28:54studied psychology and in this is more personal, anecdote, I
- 28:56guess than it is age. So sound historical argument but
- 29:01I hope you enjoy. Let me indulge this, I think.
- 29:07We especially we've lost a bit of the language to discuss how
- 29:13our environment shapes us and our social environment shapes Us
- 29:17in the social sciences. So, there has been, I mean, I
- 29:20studied I began studying psychology in the 2000s and when
- 29:26at the time everybody spoke of the brain and Neuroscience and
- 29:31neuropsychology were was, was the hype.
- 29:34And that was, I mean, that's not so much the case anymore and
- 29:37there's A lot of long faces and, and disappointments.
- 29:42But I think trauma was always compatible with the biological
- 29:47sciences. So there was also a push towards
- 29:51integrating trauma. The study of trauma with these
- 29:56other disciplines and insights in Psychology.
- 29:59Also, lost last a bit, its footing in in, in the social
- 30:03sciences at the same time. So I think there's also like
- 30:06there's a displacement In some extent, in the way, we think
- 30:09about how the social shapes our thinking.
- 30:12Our experience is like, yeah. And Trauma is sort of a leftover
- 30:17of that. That's we, I think the it is, it
- 30:22is a it, it displaced and replace some of the more richer
- 30:27discussions. I think that happened in the
- 30:30post-war period and about how social conditions shake and the
- 30:36experience of Of everyday people or maybe also how they influence
- 30:41certain neuroses, and how like the the Getty of a Neurosis
- 30:46could become this point where anthropologists and sociologists
- 30:51and psychologists could sit together and think about what
- 30:54that, what that meant. I think this is, this is not not
- 30:57the case anymore. So, trauma also feels like feels
- 31:01like, it is filling a gap or that's what it felt like to me
- 31:04because Because of the way psychology also became more of a
- 31:09science rooted in the biological sciences rather than in the
- 31:12interpretive conditions that make up other branches of the
- 31:15social sciences. So that's I think it's one part
- 31:18of it, I think. Yes.
- 31:19And then became attractive for those reasons, I think we've
- 31:21discussed, what, if I'd quite fascinating about it, that?
- 31:26So, again, when we look at today, we have a very fragmented
- 31:30discourse. We have obviously individuals
- 31:34who clearly Belong to the core category of diagnose,
- 31:40diagnoseable, kind of PTSD, we have more kind of, historically,
- 31:47based understanding of the trauma discourse.
- 31:50And we have a generalized Vibe of what people understand as
- 31:55trauma, what I find fascinating, whenever we encounter such a
- 31:59fragmented discourse, about topics that it leaves, the
- 32:04individual in a place of insecurity.
- 32:06Purity. And because this is what we do,
- 32:12right? I mean it's it's a very complex
- 32:14topic but we as individuals are always on fraction with a public
- 32:18discourse that we depend on in order to make sense of our own
- 32:23life. We need to use words, we need to
- 32:26use the of The Vibes that are prevalent in society today.
- 32:30In order to reflect about ourselves, apply to the
- 32:34fragmented trauma discourse on. On one hand, I have people who
- 32:39in a very nonchalant, by the way, way say that they were
- 32:44traumatized by the previous relationship or that just kind
- 32:50of. As a matter of fact, assume that
- 32:53it's correct. When they say that, they were
- 32:56traumatized by childhood in a non pdsd way, but in a more
- 33:01General way and we have for example parents, who are In a
- 33:07very serious way of frayed that if they do something wrong, they
- 33:11will traumatize the children. Coming from a very general,
- 33:16understanding that scarring is traumatizing that making
- 33:21mistakes that, you know, withholding things from your
- 33:27children, not giving them certain experiences, not giving
- 33:31them enough support, maybe not loving them enough, and so on
- 33:34will have dramatic effect because this is the how the word
- 33:39reverberates, right? It's it has the, the, the the
- 33:43The freaking like the the idea of serious hurt of injury is
- 33:50embedded in the word. So the tension between kind of a
- 33:54generalized idea of trauma and this connotation that it still
- 33:58holds which is a serious injury in.
- 34:03Infected certain people I think where they see themselves as
- 34:07traumatized with afraid to traumatize other people and
- 34:12where they don't know how to respond to this because it
- 34:14brings you on the Dilemma in a relationship with your children.
- 34:18You cannot just always be nice. You expressions for our needs to
- 34:24show the limitations of what is possible, not possible.
- 34:27Will inflict some sort of pain in the other person and it can
- 34:32Intimidating to feel that this and I might be responsible for
- 34:36trauma in that. How do you perceive this
- 34:40conflict of the individual who has to deal with the
- 34:44consequences of a proliferated trauma understanding and their
- 34:48own life situations and decisions that they have to
- 34:50make? all right, I think I think one
- 34:55can. These are lots of different
- 34:56questions I feel right? I think it's in one hand.
- 34:59But I think what your way of framing it is really nice to
- 35:01say. This is sort of a I don't want
- 35:04to, I don't want to make this pun but you could say they're
- 35:07traumatized by the ubiquity of trauma and this would like it if
- 35:11you Comet eyes, of course, in scare quotes in this sense
- 35:14because I wouldn't use it in this sort of very flexible
- 35:17sense. And but I think what's important
- 35:20to I think To ask for anybody who feels this being overwhelmed
- 35:29by these by that moral plea, that comes with a claim to be of
- 35:32being traumatized and is to take a pragmatic perspective.
- 35:39But now in this, not in the sense in the everyday sense of
- 35:41like, let's find some middle ground and not put all the
- 35:45difficult questions aside but innocence in the philosophical
- 35:48sense which is what are people doing when they speak of trauma.
- 35:53In that sense and I think there's some of the census you
- 35:56mentioned or some of the usages you mentioned the point of very
- 36:00different things. I think that was one of the
- 36:02points. I tried to make us in the essay
- 36:05that you mentioned earlier is critical theorists like a Da
- 36:08Nang and Liotta or some shisha core.
- 36:12All those authors they use it for a specific purpose and they
- 36:15have a specific. It's embedded within a
- 36:18philosophical or theoretical project the user in one way and
- 36:22the Ian's, who want to treat trauma?
- 36:24Victims is another way, and I think I use it for other
- 36:27entities and those who are using it in research to clinical
- 36:32research and want to, you know, use it for epidemiological
- 36:35studies. And they might have a different
- 36:36understanding because they found a different notion of trauma,
- 36:39useful, for what would have whatever it is that they're
- 36:41doing? And I think it's the same.
- 36:43You can break this down to 22 the interpersonal level when
- 36:50people speak about being traumatized.
- 36:53Relationships. I mean you would have to look at
- 36:55the specifics, right? Of that.
- 36:56Always come back. Okay?
- 36:57What, what this is person trying to do here by labeling it as
- 37:02such is a, that's do they want to talk about it further?
- 37:06Do they not want to talk about it further?
- 37:08I had this experience once with the patient who I felt and she
- 37:12was not my but I wasn't this case discussion was involved and
- 37:16she was living. We were, I was talking to a
- 37:18Therapeutic Community and it was clear.
- 37:20When this person mentioned, their trauma was Clear that she
- 37:23just didn't want to talk about whatever the therapist wanted to
- 37:25talk about it. So she she this is not to say
- 37:30that was not a trauma but it was also clear and I think one has
- 37:32to take that seriously. Yeah.
- 37:34And not just say this is an expansive view.
- 37:36So I think instead of getting bogged down in discussions over
- 37:39semantics it's like getting back.
- 37:41Okay, what sense is trauma? Used here?
- 37:43Because it's clearly something else.
- 37:45Then if a researcher uses it or a therapist.
- 37:48So we have to come to grips with how we use it in everyday life.
- 37:52And I think that's Just yeah, I think, looking at how it's used
- 37:55in other discourses, is actually can be helpful for that.
- 37:59Yes, but making creating the contrast and realizing all that,
- 38:02but that's very different. The way I don't know uses this
- 38:05as this sort of a metaphor, then how this researcher uses this
- 38:08and then you might go think about yourself.
- 38:09Well, how did, how am I using this?
- 38:11And and what am I trying to do? When I when I say, I don't want
- 38:16to traumatize my kids and some of the questions you get out
- 38:19right there are questions that are fundamental questions about.
- 38:23About raising a child or their fundamental questions about how
- 38:26to cope with conflict in relationships, and maybe trauma
- 38:31is not the best vocabulary for solving some of these conflict.
- 38:35I would like to hear. Do you think I'm off here?
- 38:37Oh no, I wanted to say that. It's actually, it's an excellent
- 38:40point, not just for the clinical practice, but it really
- 38:45reflects. I think, on on us consciously
- 38:48navigating, the Modern Life and media life that we have.
- 38:53Today including social media where one key skill today and
- 39:00for the future is that we have to be quite careful with or
- 39:05attentive to the terms that are used.
- 39:08And to be attentive to what is the possible purpose of someone
- 39:15using certain vocabulary loaded words, especially mind when
- 39:22because it implies wise agency, victimhood, a morally Superior
- 39:27position. And so on the things that you
- 39:28mentioned and that we unfortunately live in a social
- 39:34media environment where instrumentalizing such terms is
- 39:39relatively common and we are exposed to that and because of
- 39:45because of being exposed to so many sources and interests who
- 39:49use those words and various ways.
- 39:53It's very important to have the skill to understand that I
- 39:59cannot just, I cannot just take it without digesting it.
- 40:03I kind of just have to chew what I'm what I'm consuming and it's
- 40:14not a secret that psychological talk self-development talk.
- 40:19And so on is, as Broadly used as Ella.
- 40:24I think today and those terms have kind of psychological
- 40:30implications and connected with social media consumption and
- 40:38terms like drama. I think it's good for people to
- 40:42ask themselves. What am I doing to myself when I
- 40:47am applying a certain label to myself or someone that I am
- 40:52directly in? Contact with, does it strengthen
- 40:55me? Or does it weaken me?
- 40:58Am I looking for attention? I'm a looking for support.
- 41:02Is this an expression of fear of doing something wrong?
- 41:06Or is it an honest search for, you know, circumstances that
- 41:12would seriously hurt people? And this is extremely complex
- 41:18and surely, we cannot decide those questions or say that it's
- 41:24exaggerated all the time, it points more and more.
- 41:27I think to the responsible individual who cannot rely
- 41:31anymore that, the source is where it's coming from, are
- 41:33doing it responsibly and where we have to kind of be careful of
- 41:38the diet of vocabulary that we apply to our lives. you know, I
- 41:46think you're, I mean, I'm all for being conscious the way you
- 41:51use word and words and being aware of their implications and
- 41:55connotations, but I think it's also it would be so but it would
- 42:03be wrong to say that there's a There's a true.
- 42:06At least this is against the historian speaking, right?
- 42:08What is what is the essence of it of what's the core of it of
- 42:11being traumatized? I think that that's problematic
- 42:15for I wouldn't go go there that some some people or some authors
- 42:20have a better grasp of what what it was actually meant to do and
- 42:23what's the, what's the, what's the problem?
- 42:26What, you know, too that they represent the traumatic more
- 42:31accurately than other uses of the term trauma, or I would be
- 42:34would be reluctant to say that. But I think Your ride to look at
- 42:36it how we use the term and when it's applicable and we're not
- 42:40and is, is hard to is hard to also, assess, I think, without
- 42:46taking the whole situation into account often, right?
- 42:48I think I like the example, I mentioned earlier.
- 42:51I think there's other ways it can be, it can be a good good
- 42:56way for, for bringing up for, especially in today's media,
- 43:00ecology, right? To bringing up certain topics,
- 43:03that maybe we should know about or care about.
- 43:05Trauma can be an important tool or framing it is in terms of
- 43:09post, post traumatic suffering or the effects of trauma.
- 43:15But it has always, there's always a flip side to this,
- 43:18right? There's always a that it, you
- 43:21gain something and you lose something.
- 43:23And then I think it's important to think about, okay?
- 43:24What do you lose when you have it in this way?
- 43:26And I think it has shown for social movements, for instance,
- 43:30you can have it, you know, Rd contextualizing effect to frame
- 43:34things as trauma. Because other things that you
- 43:37cannot Point your finger at like this is the effect of trauma
- 43:40that don't enter public awareness light.
- 43:43So you need, you need to trauma but what if you don't have it,
- 43:46but you still see that there's clearly something wrong that
- 43:48needs to be addressed. And maybe also that is damaging
- 43:52to people's. And so I think it's it is a,
- 43:58these are very thorny questions. So I wouldn't I would just trust
- 44:02that, I think it's very hard to know, maybe to sum up my point.
- 44:05I think it's hard to police the usage of a word.
- 44:09Yeah, this is, this is applicable.
- 44:10This is not, and because it's evolving and I think, maybe, you
- 44:13know, who knows? It's one could think about the
- 44:15future of this, the way we use trauma and could think, well,
- 44:18maybe in a couple of decades, that moral, the moral
- 44:23connotation and the moral superiority, let's say let's
- 44:28let's look let's add maybe superiority is the wrong word.
- 44:31But the moral status that you gain by being a trauma victim,
- 44:35that could decide that could go away when it's so often used in
- 44:39these sort of diluted ways. It could, it could very well
- 44:43disappear and would have to think about something else.
- 44:47But but I but yeah, I think it's just it's It's not in anyone's
- 44:53hands. No, it's not, it's Society
- 44:56figuring it out for itself, right?
- 44:59We witness that basically life as, as we kind of tap into those
- 45:06different discourses. My last question to you, is more
- 45:09General because you Delta Phi, see, it correctly for a couple
- 45:13of years with the trauma topic and the past when you were done
- 45:21with, The most parts and you started to move on to different
- 45:26topics. How do you look back on the
- 45:30topic? What has been major shifts in
- 45:33your understanding? What is your takeaway from an
- 45:37exposure to the complexity of the topic that most of us don't
- 45:40have? From the psychological historian
- 45:45perspective. I think, I think from a when I
- 45:51look sort of inside the academy, what historians are doing, what
- 45:57literary Scholars are doing. So, in the humanities, there is,
- 46:02I think there's a shift away from trauma as a singular
- 46:08singular event. The thinking about that, in
- 46:11these terms, this was a much more critical.
- 46:16Readings of trauma. I think the fields the field of
- 46:20trauma studies has moved moved in New Directions.
- 46:24It's engaging much more closely with sort of the with the, I
- 46:28would call it the maybe the Perry traumatic that what
- 46:31happens around trauma and what happens in these events.
- 46:35But what, how is it? What's the social context here
- 46:40of those experiences of those who might be perpetrating?
- 46:44It of the social conditions that Make it possible that these
- 46:49things happens happen. I think there's there's a
- 46:52opening I think I'm towards these kinds of questions and so
- 46:59I think that's in principle. Good development.
- 47:02Yes. I think also being found less
- 47:04useful. I think.
- 47:04So the the whole notion of trauma is an analytic category
- 47:08that it maybe was in the 1990s and early 2000s.
- 47:12That's not, that's not not so important anymore in the At
- 47:16ease. And I see now from the at least
- 47:21from a u.s. perspective, what there's a general shift again to
- 47:25social determinants of Health, also mental health in medicine,
- 47:29but also in Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology to social
- 47:33condition. Structural conditions in a much
- 47:35broader sense were trauma. Still has a plays a role, but
- 47:38it's clear that it's will, it's tending to become less less of
- 47:43big wood as I think and less important for these other types
- 47:45of analyses. So there's More shift towards
- 47:47structural questions, like, stress stress causing events,
- 47:52for example, and just not just events, but sort of housing
- 47:56conditions, structural working position.
- 47:59Yes. And racism.
- 48:01And and, you know, all the isms and sexism and racism in
- 48:06particular, and how they affect mental health, or family
- 48:09structures or food insecurity or there's so many.
- 48:14Yeah, you know, so many lines of Research that are going on,
- 48:18going that? Look at the social conditions
- 48:20much more again. So I think the trauma hype, that
- 48:24that was I think again to get back to the point I made earlier
- 48:27that is somehow it seems to be connected to the decade of the
- 48:29brain and and biology Sation of parts of psychology and the
- 48:36scientific ation of parts of psychology.
- 48:38I think that is a little on the when we're afraid it's the
- 48:41pendulum swinging back more towards looking at broader
- 48:43social conditions. So my so I feel I see sort of
- 48:47the how that might look different from from every day
- 48:53for everyday people and their traumas become such a ubiquitous
- 48:56term in everyday parlance. But I think for for luck swaths
- 49:01of of the medical Sciences, the psychological Sciences but also
- 49:04need of manatees. I think we're bit on the
- 49:06downturn. Yes.
- 49:08Oh yeah, I find that very interesting.
- 49:11This observation and I have not made this connection yet, but
- 49:14yes. Indeed like you mentioned I
- 49:16studied psychology a little bit earlier.
- 49:18I started 1994 and already back then there was a big height and
- 49:22neuropsychology, and that was this whole period of time the
- 49:28mid-90s, basically going on today, where a good part of I
- 49:34think the scientific psychological Community has
- 49:37retreated to The heart signs so to speak of Neurology and
- 49:44neuropsychology and this is how I understand your argument.
- 49:49It kind of left a vacuum left, the fields over to more General
- 49:56authors conceptualizes to a more General discourse and has
- 50:02retreated from those more vague elements of the public discourse
- 50:06around psychological terms. Us.
- 50:08And that this has contributed to a quite different idea.
- 50:15An unscientific idea, a nun, hardcore, diagnostic idea of
- 50:20trauma and that this would be one of the forces that enable us
- 50:24to, to fluctuate fluctuate. So much with different
- 50:30connotations of the term. Is that correct?
- 50:34I understood your point. I think if I understood you
- 50:36correctly, I think. Yeah, I think you you got your
- 50:41getting at it night but maybe another way of putting it for me
- 50:44or something. Sometimes they also think about
- 50:46it is it is a trauma was a good for the immediate post
- 50:51psychoanalytic era around Ben was a good term because it had
- 50:55this connection to psychoanalysis freudianism to
- 50:58some ideas of how the environment shapes us at how our
- 51:01desired shape us in our hearts and our, you know, - experience
- 51:06shape us. But at the same, Time it was it
- 51:10didn't really get into the whole, you know, human, as a
- 51:15conflicted being yes. It was more like something
- 51:19outside that, that impacts us. And that was also easily in,
- 51:21that can be easily integrated into a scientific models, that
- 51:25neatly divided up the world until.
- 51:27Okay, that's what happens. That's what happens inside, and
- 51:30that's sort of the external factors that impacted.
- 51:32I think it, it was, it was, it could align with that and was
- 51:36consistent with that, and that's why Could sort of it filled this
- 51:39void in science, but at the same time, I'll maybe also in public
- 51:42discourse where the whole model of conflict was no longer didn't
- 51:48strike people, or people is particularly useful in many.
- 51:51Many Western, you know, industrialized nations, because
- 51:55we have to deal less with conflicts of authority.
- 51:57I would assume. And, and but we sort of we were
- 52:01thinking more about our limits and how about our, you know,
- 52:05I'll struggle with them and and Are ya or our limits are also
- 52:10set to are narcissistic fantasies may be, right?
- 52:13So I think that's that's trauma, really fits the bill.
- 52:16They're like to address some of these questions are interesting.
- 52:20I did not promise that we would solve all the problems or what
- 52:25I'm to the concept of trauma and history of trauma.
- 52:27But it was certainly for me a very interesting detailed
- 52:30conversation and I hope that the audience sees the many different
- 52:34aspects and facets of kind of deconstructing and looking at
- 52:40such a complex phenomenon and might be inspired to delve a
- 52:45little bit more into it. I will leave some links and to
- 52:49your Publications blow and I thank you very much for the
- 52:54conversation. Thank you, D.
- 52:56Thank you.