Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / Ep 65 | Andrew Wiechert | Unpacking Underappreciated Overseas Opportunities with WCM | ROI Podcast
Transcript
- 0:09Ryan: In 2025, developed and emerging market equities I think outperformed most investors' expectations.
- 0:16Ryan: And as we look forward to this year in 2026, many investors are wondering where to go from here.
- 0:22Ryan: Where are the opportunities, where are the risks to manage?
- 0:25Ryan: Today I'm joined by Andrew Weikert, Portfolio Manager at WCM, where he's been since 2007.
- 0:31Ryan: I'm going to ask those questions and more.
- 0:33Ryan: Thanks for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 0:37Ryan: So, Andrew, as we think about the different opportunities and risks around in the developed markets, the emerging markets, what's top of mind for you?
- 0:48Ryan: I I want to start off with risks, because that's uh kind of, you know, there's there's a lot of geopolitical instability around the world, a lot of uh unprecedented uh things that have uh kind of materialized.
- 1:00Ryan: So as you're thinking about managing risk uh in an actively managed equity fund, is there anything that just kind of jumps off the page to you?
- 1:09Andrew: We're all trying to assess risk at any time.
- 1:11Andrew: I mean, uh valuation is a function of risk premium, right?
- 1:15Andrew: So for us um one of the things we're excited about in international in particular, and there's been this debate about you know valuations of US versus international or emerging markets being at maybe historic gaps.
- 1:32Andrew: What I think that's reflective of is you know, historically the certainty in the US was much higher than it is today, and the valuations reflected that risk premium.
- 1:44Andrew: For us, what we're seeing is actually, you know, whether it's Europe, Japan, China, ingredients for positive change.
- 1:56Andrew: And those are maybe different across different geographies, but but where you know coming off a lower base and having positive change agents, and we can get into you know each geography in the ones that are maybe more interesting here, but where we've seen this shift in the delta between opportunities for US companies and international feels skewed for international here, more so than it has, you know, in the better part of two decades, where just US dominance was was the main story.
- 2:32Andrew: We're pretty excited on our side for for what the next five, ten years holds in non-U.S.
- 2:38Ryan: What I'm hearing you say, and correct me if I'm wrong, is that you know there there were maybe some risks that were greater risks for those international markets that are maybe starting to lessen.
- 2:48Andrew: Is that yeah, and I I it's always gonna be comparative, right?
- 2:51Andrew: So the the tariff uncertainty in the U.S.
- 2:55Andrew: Like what does the long-term tariff structure look like?
- 2:59Andrew: What does that well how does that impact US consumers three years out from now?
- 3:04Andrew: There's just less certainty, arguably, from a U what is U.S.
- 3:08Andrew: defense policy gonna look like?
- 3:10Andrew: What does, you know, we clearly have changing mentality in the US in terms of what our priorities are now compared to a couple years ago, and probably three or five years from now, those will be different too.
- 3:24Andrew: But that maybe volatility and tariff rate or policy or you know, what's our role gonna be in on the global stage in defense?
- 3:34Andrew: And the US is taking a more isolationist type policy which has long-term impacts.
- 3:42Andrew: But there for us, the uncertainty created in the environment in the US should actually, in some cases, create a void outside of the US where we think the best companies can step into that void.
- 3:55Andrew: A great example is like European defense.
- 3:57Andrew: So the US was the epicenter of like Western defense spending, but also our role was make sure everyone's behaving accordingly and in an alignment with you know US policy.
- 4:15Andrew: And we have indicated we're going to take a less active role.
- 4:21Andrew: And actually, sometimes we'll have divergent policy from maybe Canada.
- 4:25Andrew: Maybe we'll have divergent policy from Europe.
- 4:27Andrew: And what we're seeing is the response in Canada, the response in Europe is I guess we have to build it ourselves.
- 4:36Andrew: And a lot of people in the US are excited about that.
- 4:38Andrew: Great, let's not subsidize that.
- 4:40Andrew: But in that change, you're seeing defense budgets go up in Europe.
- 4:45Andrew: You're seeing if if historically you would use Lockheed or Raytheon, you're not going to use them anymore.
- 4:52Andrew: You're going to use a local European company.
- 4:55Andrew: So for us, when we think about the competitive advantage and who's winning those bids, and a lot of times defense cycles are many decades long, there's an advantage for European defense contractors.
- 5:08Andrew: That's not to say that the budget for European defense will be higher than the US five years from now.
- 5:14Andrew: It's just to say that the rate of change is more positive there than it is here as we are stepping away and they are stepping in to fill that void.
- 5:23Andrew: And we think those types of structural shifts create opportunities.
- 5:27Andrew: So arguably, like European defense companies should treat at a premium to U.S.
- 5:32Andrew: defense companies.
- 5:33Andrew: But that's not the dynamic we see right now because of this historical premium of U.S.
- 5:40Andrew: equities versus rest of the world.
- 5:42Ryan: So that rebalancing of defense spending you think is going to favor some of those local companies.
- 5:47Ryan: That makes sense.
- 5:48Ryan: Do they have the same sort of technology that, you know, Raytheon or Lockheed or some of the U.S.
- 5:55Ryan: uh companies?
- 5:56Andrew: Is there a Yeah, no, I mean there's all the so you you always think about like U.S.
- 6:01Andrew: technological advantage.
- 6:02Andrew: Like that is another reason for the premium in U.S.
- 6:06Andrew: markets.
- 6:07Andrew: Um I would argue on the defense side, that's less pronounced, but I'm I would never suggest to bet against U.S.
- 6:15Andrew: technological advantage or innovation, just when you think about how the maybe the uh the opportunities that are coming in added uncertainty and changes of policy for us skew toward excitement in in XUS markets.
- 6:30Ryan: Yeah.
- 6:31Ryan: Um that's uh that is very interesting.
- 6:33Ryan: And I think the goal is for at least for um NATO countries, aren't they supposed to increase military spending to something like five percent of GDP by 2013?
- 6:45Andrew: And they're nowhere close, yeah.
- 6:46Andrew: Right?
- 6:46Andrew: But that should be a long-term tailwind for a lot of those, and it's one of the pocket of the market we're excited about.
- 6:52Andrew: Yeah.
- 6:52Andrew: And that's you don't get that representation by owning the SP.
- 6:55Ryan: Sure.
- 6:56Ryan: And and those are, to your point, uh probably valuations are much more attractive than what you pay comparably.
- 7:02Andrew: Yeah, and I mean, like, I mean, you can say what you want about it, but even in Canada, where Canada has historically been like a brother, we have shown that our policy toward how we kind of treat or approach or a strategy around Canada may be different now.
- 7:22Andrew: And so the Canadian defense company, they no longer have to compete with the US one, which is, I mean, it's a favor to them, and Canada is saying we have to kind of build it ourselves.
- 7:33Andrew: So, well, actually, you could say it's the right policy, but also what does that shift create?
- 7:37Andrew: And just always for us looking at those opportunities and those structural changes that as you know, shareholders you can align an active portfolio that's concentrated in the best ideas with some of these developments that are happening in your favor.
- 7:52Ryan: So at WCM, you are a bottoms-up stock picking firm, generally speaking.
- 7:57Ryan: Absolutely, right?
- 7:58Ryan: Yes.
- 7:59Ryan: So um that that um those these sorts of themes, how do they impact that?
- 8:03Ryan: I mean, you you're you're not necessarily looking at top down.
- 8:06Ryan: I I started the conversation with macro, but you're not necessarily making decisions based on macroeconomics.
- 8:12Ryan: Um talk a little bit about what you're looking for as you're kind of doing that bottom-up analysis.
- 8:17Andrew: Yeah, so it's always gonna be bottom-up, but I mean, you could say it's a macro view, you can say it's recognition of tailwinds.
- 8:24Andrew: For us, it does have an impact on you know how we either model or think about the total shareholder return expectation.
- 8:32Andrew: That's always gonna start at the company level, but not looking at it in a vacuum, not ignoring the world around us, is that changing in its favor?
- 8:41Andrew: And really uh what we're focused on is high-quality companies, and we're defining that across two vectors.
- 8:48Andrew: One is moat trajectory, which I know Paul and Mike talked a lot about when they did their podcast, and then cultures that support that.
- 8:56Andrew: And the cultural angle is a unique one for WCM.
- 8:59Andrew: Um, but it is really thinking about that moat trajectory, and and really back to that European defense argument, when you think about oh, that you know, BAE for a contract in in Europe, they used to have to compete with the US primes.
- 9:15Andrew: If you think about the direction of their competitive advantage, they're actually in an advantage now where historically maybe because of the technological disadvantage, they would have lost that.
- 9:25Andrew: Now, because of this emerging home country bias or need or requirement, they have a better chance to win.
- 9:32Andrew: So thinking about really how the landscape, the competitive landscape is evolving and which companies are most likely to capture an outsized share of that.
- 9:43Andrew: So both recognition of the tailwind, but also understanding the that's what we call moat trajectory is who's taking share.
- 9:51Andrew: Where's the competitive advantage coming from, not just the absolute size of the current moat, but where that's headed and incrementally how is that changing, and really a focus on that positive change.
- 10:02Ryan: Yeah.
- 10:02Ryan: So for those that didn't see the podcast that we did with uh with Mike and Paul, uh, we did talk a bit about a bit about moat trajectory as opposed to just moat and kind of a staple of competitive advantage.
- 10:13Ryan: Um, could could you maybe ex expand on that a little bit?
- 10:16Ryan: What do you mean by um moat trajectory?
- 10:18Ryan: So obviously that means you know you're expanding um your competitive advantage, but how do you measure that?
- 10:23Andrew: Yeah, I mean there's not a great necessarily the we've we've backhanded like a ROIC as a good proxy for it.
- 10:34Andrew: Okay, it's not perfect.
- 10:35Andrew: Uh but if you just think if you say, hey, I want to focus on companies where the delta in the ROIC is positive.
- 10:44Andrew: So that could be companies going from three or five percent to 10 or 15 rather than the absolute ROIC, where a lot of times you think about a quality company, when you think about MOATs, it's uh ROIC in the 20s or 30s, above your weighted average cost of capital.
- 11:03Andrew: That means you're probably doing something right.
- 11:05Andrew: But for us, it's more about the focus of the derivative of that and the direction of change, because we'd much rather own a business with you know five or six percent on its way to 15 than 40 on its way to 35 or 30.
- 11:19Ryan: Right.
- 11:20Ryan: Yeah, and that probably flows through to valuations.
- 11:23Ryan: That company in your second example that has a uh you know a declining return on invested capital, probably their valuation is going to take a little bit of a hit from that as well.
- 11:32Andrew: Yeah, absolutely.
- 11:33Andrew: And for us, those can be either like value or quality traps, is how we think of them, is where the maybe the historical quality of that business is higher than the future quality, we'd rather be on the opposite side of that.
- 11:46Andrew: And even for us, valuation often protects us against overpaying.
- 11:52Andrew: And if you do have quality improvements, you really just get paid for that positive change.
- 11:58Andrew: And the risk, if you're wrong, if you don't pay that much for it, is pretty minimal.
- 12:04Ryan: Yeah.
- 12:05Ryan: Um, okay, so you mentioned uh some defense, uh European defense companies or international defense companies.
- 12:12Ryan: Uh, are there any other sort of sectors or themes that uh you look at and you say, man, this is uh kind of represents an attractive opportunity?
- 12:20Andrew: Yeah, so I mean we talked about maybe other other markets.
- 12:23Andrew: Um the you know, we we're seeing this corporate governance reform in Japan, which has been you know something we've talked we've heard talked about for the better part of 30 years.
- 12:36Andrew: Um they are it's you know slow moving, they could take a lot of lessons from the US, but they are clearly indicating that they want to be more focused on good and more thoughtful shareholder-friendly governance.
- 12:58Andrew: Uh part of this is they have this historical cross-holding structure.
- 13:03Andrew: So you want to do business with a company in Japan, let's say you're an insurance company that sells auto insurance.
- 13:10Andrew: Well, you are gonna need to own shares in auto manufacturers.
- 13:15Andrew: If you want Toyota's policy, you're gonna have to be a shareholder of Toyota.
- 13:20Andrew: So, what's happened is all of these companies, because the way that they historically did business was, I want to be your business partner, let me show you in that in you know, honoring that partnership, I'll buy shares of your company.
- 13:34Andrew: So oftentimes these companies at this point, the value of them has more to do with their crossholdings than the actual company in which they're operating.
- 13:45Andrew: And they have gotten pressure both from you know regulators and the exchange to say, hey, this is not a very shareholder-friendly structure.
- 13:55Andrew: Uh let's try to get people out of this business norm.
- 14:00Andrew: And that's hard, it takes time.
- 14:03Andrew: Um, but one of the things we're seeing is the receptiveness is actually more positive than you would think.
- 14:11Andrew: Because historically you'd go to Toyota and say, I'm if they just saw me sell your their shares, they'd say, What's wrong with this?
- 14:17Andrew: Does this have an impact to our partnership?
- 14:19Andrew: But now Toyota is going to all their partners and saying, we have to sell your shares too, and you're selling, and we get it.
- 14:25Andrew: Like we you kind of have a pass here from all these partnerships to say, we get why you might be selling our shares.
- 14:33Andrew: It doesn't mean anything about our relationship.
- 14:36Andrew: So they they there's this more you know global reset button where we think coming out of this development, which the unwind is gonna be slower than most investors have patience for, but eventually you'll see you know healthier companies at the at the finish line.
- 14:56Andrew: And for us, being on the side of positive change toward that is is gonna be positive for shareholders even today.
- 15:03Ryan: So um if I understand you correctly, but what the goal of that would ultimately be that the share price performance is more in line with the actual corporate performance of those companies as opposed to you know as a sort of byproduct of how their cross-asset relationships are.
- 15:20Ryan: Correct.
- 15:20Ryan: Is that right?
- 15:21Ryan: Yes, yeah.
- 15:21Ryan: Okay.
- 15:22Ryan: Um are there with the unwind, is are there risks to the downside with that because people are selling shares, or does it does it kind of wash out on both sides?
- 15:33Andrew: It tends to wash out.
- 15:34Andrew: I mean, there's some that are pretty widely held, like the mm larger the cap, maybe the more widely held, but those actually should have more liquid, they should be able to digest it better.
- 15:45Andrew: The impact of that should be fairly immaterial, especially at the rate that they're doing.
- 15:49Andrew: Okay.
- 15:50Andrew: Now, what what the risk is that they sell all these and then they have cash, and then that cash has nowhere to go.
- 15:58Andrew: For us, the hope is either it comes back to shareholders or they have good ways to reinvest it in their own business.
- 16:04Ryan: Okay.
- 16:04Ryan: Um, you know, another theme that's obviously driven equity markets across the world has been uh AI and the investment in data centers.
- 16:13Ryan: Um, how do you think about that from the perspective of investing in Europe or other other international markets?
- 16:20Andrew: Yeah, that I mean that absolutely AI data center is like topic du jour.
- 16:25Andrew: Um for us, we are very much focused on what's taking share within that complex.
- 16:31Andrew: Now we understand that there's a clear tailwind there.
- 16:38Andrew: We're early innings on developing these tools, what those look like.
- 16:44Andrew: And the clearest winner out of the gate has been the hardware-related companies.
- 16:49Andrew: For us, if we do own hardware, we want to own parts of that that are taking share within the data center.
- 16:55Andrew: So not just exposed to the tailwind behind it, but also an argument whether it's a cheaper alternative, whether their technology advantage where they are even within the existing data centers, continue to take share.
- 17:10Andrew: And that can happen across, you know, the power complex, HVAC, Ethernet versus other ways to connect devices.
- 17:19Andrew: But for us, it's the focus on moat trajectory along with the tailwind that is the more important part.
- 17:26Andrew: We're also excited about some of the neo-cloud companies.
- 17:29Andrew: So where we're seeing GPU as a service, which is if I'm an AI startup, I don't necessarily need the traditional cloud model to run my business.
- 17:39Andrew: I want a more dedicated GPU cloud.
- 17:43Andrew: And we think over time, when you think about the overall share of cloud, GPU as a service coming off of a zero base will probably be higher five years from now than it is today, and being a part of that growth within that subset of the overall complex.
- 18:02Andrew: The other thing we're excited about is what is the next phase of this?
- 18:07Andrew: Who are the winners outside of hardware, which are the ones you know in the first and second and maybe most capital investments?
- 18:14Andrew: That's right.
- 18:14Andrew: They're buying hardware, but you know, what's next?
- 18:19Andrew: Who does it benefit the most going forward?
- 18:22Andrew: And there are a few places uh data-related company, like data will be the center of how you feed these large language models, uh, the quality of that data, the ownership of that data.
- 18:34Andrew: We're only going to unlock more insight as these tools become more powerful and arguably curated data that's proprietary, whether that's from an exchange or somebody who you know captures all the driving data or whatever that is, proprietary data sets will be arguably worth more as we are able to make more decisions based on that data.
- 18:59Andrew: Um, the other thing we're seeing is we expect productivity gains in the future.
- 19:04Andrew: So those That's the whole point of AI, right?
- 19:07Andrew: That's the whole point, right?
- 19:08Andrew: So actually, companies that have a bigger where labor represents a bigger percent of their cost structure stand to benefit more than the software company that has 60% margins that can you know lay off a couple people and now they have 63% margins.
- 19:24Andrew: The company that if they go from five to fifteen percent, that rate of change is much higher.
- 19:30Andrew: So we're excited about you know what is that long-term productivity gain looks like.
- 19:35Andrew: And sometimes that's you know, the the banks or the telcos or the more sleepy industrial companies.
- 19:41Andrew: So we're thinking about that next leg of AI.
- 19:44Andrew: Um, not that that's super clear who's gonna be that winner or not.
- 19:48Andrew: That's a the that's always a debate within our firm.
- 19:51Andrew: Um, but we are we're starting to move past the the obvious hardware winner and into what is phase two and three and four look like.
- 19:59Ryan: So one of the issues in the US, and most of our viewership is uh you know from the US, although I just looked, we have uh viewers in 118 countries.
- 20:09Ryan: Wow, believe it or not.
- 20:10Ryan: Um some of them are probably you know one, two viewers and some uh some far off.
- 20:14Ryan: Some VPNs.
- 20:15Ryan: I would say most of our uh viewers are are US focused.
- 20:19Ryan: And so one of the things that we're all familiar with with this build out of AI and data centers is the growing need for supplying power for those and and that's right, and all the regulatory issues of uh putting power grids in and how you create that power.
- 20:34Ryan: Uh what is that like in other parts of the world?
- 20:37Ryan: I'm thinking specifically of Europe, but if you've got other examples, I'd be curious of that as well.
- 20:41Ryan: Are they having the same sort of regulatory issues and uh or or hurdles?
- 20:46Ryan: Are they lowering barriers?
- 20:47Ryan: What's the uh what's the outlook there?
- 20:49Andrew: I think around the world we've gotten nuclear wrong.
- 20:52Andrew: Um and there's plenty of reasons.
- 20:55Andrew: It's a not in my backyard, you know, sure case all the whether whether it's here or around the world.
- 21:02Andrew: Um, but it's clear that our current power generation is inadequate for what we're building.
- 21:09Andrew: Now, what how to what extent that is, what that looks like, whether wind plays a bigger role, gas turbines play a bigger role, nuclear plays a big all of these are probably true.
- 21:21Andrew: Um in Europe specifically, what's interesting, and one of the dynamics we're excited about, and we've seen this in cement actually, um, is regulators in Europe, and I mean it was almost comical how restrictive they were.
- 21:39Andrew: Um they uh as part of both the Ukraine Russia conflict, but also where they had a scare related to energy prices, they realized oh, maybe we went too far in some places.
- 21:59Andrew: You've seen them scale back a little bit.
- 22:02Andrew: And I think part of this is because they are kind of trying to take some of the wind up out of the right wing movements in Europe.
- 22:10Andrew: Um, but by over-regulating and now moving the other direction, that's another place where we actually see opportunity.
- 22:19Andrew: And some I talked about cement for a second, but a lot of these cement companies used to have, you know, cement's very expensive to it's expensive to burn rocks to create cement, but it's also expensive to transport.
- 22:33Andrew: Um, so you always you had a lot of these smaller local players, but because regulations around the environmental footprint got so restrictive, a lot of the smaller players got washed out or got they went away.
- 22:48Andrew: And so what happened is you had this major consolidation of this industry, and now you've the regulators have essentially said, oh, this was too restrictive.
- 22:59Andrew: We're gonna need this to rebuild, especially if you have to rebuild after the conflict, or you know, we're increasing defense spending.
- 23:07Andrew: This is a part of our broad either stimulus or infrastructure or defense programs.
- 23:12Andrew: We're gonna need this, we can't suffocate all these companies.
- 23:15Andrew: So the policy has shifted to be a little bit more favorable.
- 23:19Andrew: But because you've had this consolidation, the ones that are gonna benefit from this shift are the remaining ones left.
- 23:25Andrew: So when I when we're thinking about, oh, how has this backdrop shifted?
- 23:29Andrew: How did we get here?
- 23:31Andrew: It was tough.
- 23:32Andrew: And the ones, the best companies were the ones that survived that difficult period, and now we're going away where it's a little more positive, and that incremental change can be massive improving economics for these companies.
- 23:44Ryan: Yeah.
- 23:44Ryan: Cement companies are not necessarily the banter in a cocktail party as much as AI investment.
- 23:52Andrew: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 23:53Andrew: But it's I mean, it's funny because like cat caterpillars become an AI company now because not only their role in you know power generation, but also the construction.
- 24:03Andrew: So it's it's fun.
- 24:18Ryan: Yeah.
- 24:18Ryan: Uh we've talked mainly about developed markets, but I'm curious on your take for emerging markets.
- 24:24Ryan: Um, you know, there was uh both emerging and developed it relatively well in 2025.
- 24:31Ryan: Yeah.
- 24:31Ryan: Um thinking about 2026 and really beyond, you know, what what's your, I guess from a high level, your take on uh emerging, and then we can kind of drill in a little bit.
- 24:41Andrew: Yeah, I'm the that argument of valuations as trough versus US premium was actually more pronounced in EM than it was in other developed.
- 24:51Andrew: So there's a little bit of a you know, maybe valuation tailwind, but one of the things we're very excited about is China specifically.
- 25:00Andrew: And one of the China's been a very difficult market for investors for just about 20 years now.
- 25:08Andrew: Um and part of that was unpredictable policy.
- 25:12Andrew: Uh you could be on the wrong side of the CCP, you could be on the wrong side of the US.
- 25:18Andrew: So you could get caught in this um in a trap from either side at any point.
- 25:24Andrew: And what happened, some of its technology leaders, they would, you know, get taken out back every once in a while.
- 25:31Andrew: Um and say, hey, no, you what you need to do needs to be more aligned with Chinese policy and the interests of Chinese people.
- 25:39Andrew: And that was a very difficult backdrop.
- 25:42Andrew: Not to mention, they had the worst response to COVID on the planet.
- 25:46Andrew: So they were very restrictive, they strangled their own economy, um, and even when the rest of the world had moved on, they they were slow.
- 26:00Andrew: So we saw not only this, you know, this like economic policy headwind, but also all the good technology companies were at risk of being disrupted or forced to you know divest good assets or whatever it was as some punishment to you know pay back the CCP, that was a very difficult backdrop for investors.
- 26:27Andrew: What's actually shifted, you've seen that policy reaction where they understand you maybe some of these were a mistake.
- 26:36Andrew: We've we want more GDP growth essentially.
- 26:39Andrew: We want to stimulate our economy more.
- 26:41Andrew: Um we also know that if we're gonna win in AI and the future of technology, we can't take the technology companies out back every six months.
- 26:52Andrew: So you've seen both a policy shift, but also the structure that caused the derating in China for the better part of 20 years, even if that just stabilizes.
- 27:04Andrew: So you've had great earnings growth in a lot of these companies, like the major either e-com or internet or AI data center names in China, they've had very healthy growth in a vacuum.
- 27:18Andrew: It's just been lower risk premium from investors.
- 27:24Andrew: And if we would argue if as long as that stabilizes, the shareholder return expectations should be pretty positive from here.
- 27:31Andrew: And if in fact it starts to go the other way and you see some valuation support or even you know, maybe more historic valuation revisit, revisiting those or closing that gap, you have enormous shareholder return potential.
- 27:49Andrew: So we, you know, about just about 18 months ago now started to become more constructive, and we've only seen further evidence that that's that's it's an exciting market for us.
- 28:02Andrew: And I think EM investors who have been dismissive and hiding in India, that those are the ones that are likely going to be chasing some of this positive change in China.
- 28:14Ryan: I think one of the concerns that I hear from investors is that they're they're worried about the decoupling of the Chinese economy and the US economy because of some of the geopolitical issues, because of some of the you know more protectionist trade policies.
- 28:28Ryan: Um do you think that maybe the rate of change in that is has is going to improve because it was so extreme in 2025 that maybe 2026 looks better?
- 28:38Ryan: Or is that just something that we're gonna, in a new uh new sort of world, we're gonna just live with this decoupled economy?
- 28:45Andrew: The maybe the primary value had for China for a long time, their economy was centered around cheap labor.
- 28:52Andrew: Like let's be the world's, we got a lot of people, um, wages are low, we can we can do what you don't want to do.
- 29:04Andrew: So they were in effect a labor, an outsourced labor partner for US manufacturing for a long time.
- 29:13Andrew: And we realized in this decoupling that hey, this can't be our only you gotta move factories back here to the US or find other places outside of China to make these.
- 29:25Andrew: A lot of that has happened, but that's also been a drag on the Chinese economy because they've had this identity shift.
- 29:36Andrew: And one of the things that's accelerated, so on the US side, it's moving away from them as a labor source.
- 29:43Andrew: But on the China side is what is our identity in the future?
- 29:48Andrew: What is the value we bring outside of this labor pool that we have?
- 29:54Andrew: And for us, where we've seen that evolution is really in manufacturing.
- 29:58Andrew: So where the US is maybe the technological center of the world, where China used to be known for making cheap, low-quality product, where they're moving is to higher quality, higher value.
- 30:15Andrew: So it's actually the highest value consumer prop often.
- 30:18Andrew: So rather than the thing that costs a tenth of the price but lasts a fifth of the time, let's build something that's you know 60% the price but just as good.
- 30:30Andrew: And what we're seeing is there's sometimes like a golden screw that only China can do.
- 30:35Andrew: And they they have a manufacturing advantage in many parts of or a lot of these companies, whether it's in healthcare, technology, or consumer goods, or we would say the like humanoid robots, there's a good chance that China, a China robot, wins that, or in EVs.
- 30:55Andrew: Like the in Brazil, if you're buying an EV, it's very hard for the US company to compete with the Chinese EV because they're just as reliable and they're much cheaper.
- 31:06Andrew: So where we're seeing this quality of manufacturing renaissance in China, and certain companies should benefit in an outsized way from that shift over time.
- 31:18Andrew: But that's been hard for China.
- 31:20Ryan: The example that you just gave of uh you know Brazil and and I'm sure that's just an example of pick a country, right?
- 31:26Ryan: Um, why are they able to sell a product so much cheaper?
- 31:29Ryan: Is it because it's being subsidized?
- 31:31Ryan: Is it just because you know labor costs are cheaper, or is um is it they've got some other efficiency?
- 31:37Ryan: So they how are they able to sell into Brazil for a much lower price than Tesla?
- 31:44Andrew: So it's both uh r oftentimes like a resource advantage and still a labor advantage.
- 31:50Andrew: So where now it's not just the labor manufacturing outsourcing, and that's gone up a little bit, that there's labor inflation there, that maybe the US company it's cheaper now to use Malaysia to manufacture something than it is China, but it's still much cheaper in Beijing than it is in Michigan.
- 32:11Andrew: Um so that's a cost advantage that they have, but also a lot of the technology, like in power semiconductors, where the Chinese competitor has historically been low behind on the technology curve to like the European or US counterpart, as they've closed that technology gap, they're still priced at a much cheaper price point.
- 32:38Andrew: And we're seeing them take share absolutely in China, but then even outside of that.
- 32:43Andrew: So again, it's back to this moat trajectory case where it's like if I can get 90% of the value for 40% of the price, that's a pretty good prop.
- 32:53Andrew: So we you're seeing that type of market share growth, and it's really because they've closed the gap in manufacturing technology more than I think they've got been appreciated for.
- 33:05Ryan: Okay.
- 33:06Ryan: Um, so outside of China, are there any other areas where in the emerging markets you kind of say, well, you know, this is a good example of where there may be an opportunity that uh maybe most of us are overlooking?
- 33:18Andrew: Aaron Powell Yeah, I mean, there's always gonna be exciting opportunities for us in I mean, we're global, we have a global orientation, whether that's you know some Brazilian e-com or fintech.
- 33:32Andrew: For us, the big in EM specifically, the biggest markets are the most impactful, where it used to be, you know, the conversation used to be the BRICS, right?
- 33:41Andrew: Where it was all about Brazil, Russia, India, and China.
- 33:45Andrew: Russia's zero now.
- 33:47Andrew: Brazil has, because of its struggles, not really kept up.
- 33:52Andrew: And the primary like country call you're making is India, China, and EM specifically.
- 33:59Andrew: And for a long time, because of this dynamic with China being difficult, India benefited from that.
- 34:05Andrew: And you saw valuations go up, it was the safest, maybe least risky, or least risky, uh, and it became the place to go in EM, and you saw companies of maybe comparable quality outside of India, like if it's a Brazilian fintech versus an Indian fintech, the Indian one would trade at three times the multiple.
- 34:29Andrew: So oftentimes we think about um not just going to geographies, but from a bottom-up standpoint, what does the return profile look for like?
- 34:39Andrew: And for us, there's a lot of excitement really across the board in EM.
- 34:44Ryan: So as you're constructing a portfolio as uh a bottom-up manager, especially in, you know, there's many different sectors, there's many different uh countries and currencies, and there's a lot that goes into that.
- 34:57Ryan: Um, to what degree are you just picking companies and how much in the back of your mind or in the front of your mind are you actually making allocations sort of between economies and sectors and currencies?
- 35:09Andrew: Uh how does how does that work in your we try not to have like a currency view.
- 35:13Andrew: Um you could we've heard all these the case for a weakening dollar that could potentially be positive for non-US companies.
- 35:23Andrew: Um but really the core of our thesis on any given name is going to be bottom-up.
- 35:30Andrew: Now, our team in particular focuses a lot on companies that are transitioning from maybe more value orientation or value-centric history to a more growth-oriented or a higher quality future.
- 35:46Andrew: And this in the context of these positive changes, sometimes those happen in slow motion, but but in these transitions, these are often focused on companies that that live in a proverbial no-man's land or a gray area between growth and value investors.
- 36:02Andrew: And industrials actually for us has been a pretty exciting subcategory for that, and partially because industrials is like the catch-all of too hard to classify, or I don't know exactly what the like HVAC companies are in there, credit bureaus, aerospace and defense, like the the variety of companies in industrials is much higher than it is like in financials, where it's it's mostly like insurance and banks.
- 36:32Ryan: Yeah, that's interesting.
- 36:33Ryan: I hadn't thought about that, but that's very true.
- 36:34Ryan: Very true.
- 36:35Ryan: There's a lot of industries that are within that one sector, right?
- 36:38Andrew: Yeah, so industrials is like the grab bag gigs categorization, and for us where we're trying to exploit oftentimes companies that are lacking a clear investor identity, that is a fertile hunting ground for us.
- 36:51Andrew: But that's not necessarily because we think those are more GDP linked than other things.
- 36:55Andrew: That's not taking a GDP view, right?
- 36:57Andrew: It's that this part of the market, because of this odd categorization, is an interesting uh subset or opportunity set.
- 37:06Ryan: So part of your process also involves um the culture assessment of a company.
- 37:13Ryan: Uh can you talk a little bit about what that what that means and you know what is what are you trying to achieve by evaluating a company's culture?
- 37:22Andrew: So I we think culture is everything.
- 37:24Andrew: The people who do show up every day, make the decisions, uh, push a company forward, what that that is ultimately when you're buying a company with any sort of time horizon more than another six months or so, you're making a bet on culture.
- 37:42Andrew: Now, culture is difficult to quantify.
- 37:45Andrew: Uh there's no metric that you can point to that says, you know, this means good culture and this means bad.
- 37:55Andrew: For us, it's always in the context of the opportunity we're looking at, but it's really centered on three you know sub-platforms or sub um characteristics of culture.
- 38:09Andrew: And one is the strength of that culture, how pervasive is it throughout the organization?
- 38:15Andrew: Is that strength coming from bottom up?
- 38:17Andrew: Is it from the people?
- 38:18Andrew: Is it from the top?
- 38:19Andrew: What is the flow of that look like?
- 38:22Andrew: Uh and how strong is that?
- 38:25Andrew: Uh the second one is an adaptability.
- 38:28Andrew: Uh that's can they is there external awareness?
- 38:32Andrew: Is there internal awareness?
- 38:33Andrew: Do they know what they're good at?
- 38:34Andrew: Are they able to pivot and change uh and make decisions that aren't in their maybe five-year plan that they drew up?
- 38:43Andrew: And then the last and the most important is the culture strategy alignment.
- 38:48Andrew: And that's are in terms of growing their moat trajectory is the strategy and the incentive structure for the people set up in a way that's aligned with them actually achieving that.
- 39:00Andrew: And I mean, we talked about some of these value to growth names or these transitional names.
- 39:06Andrew: One of the things we focus on is culture as a catalyst for positive change.
- 39:11Andrew: So, you know, when you think about it, it's hard to quantify.
- 39:15Andrew: If you're thinking about a cultural turnaround, like let's say, you know, any company that has underperformed for a long time, and if you ask them about that, they never say, Oh, yeah, this we feel good about this.
- 39:26Andrew: They all they'll all say this is why we're gonna be better, this is what we want to do better.
- 39:32Andrew: They're all, you know, that every company will have a story about why it will be better in the future, if it was difficult in the past.
- 39:39Andrew: So getting taking their word for it isn't enough.
- 39:42Andrew: But if you are gonna be betting on positive cultural change, for us, sometimes you need new people.
- 39:48Andrew: So if you think about like if I said, hey, is employee turnover good or bad for culture?
- 39:55Andrew: Uh and you could say, well, if it's a high performing culture, a lot of employee turnover would be a bad thing, right?
- 40:02Andrew: Because you have talented people, you probably lost a good portion of them.
- 40:06Andrew: Um, but if you're an underperforming culture, if I say if they say, Hey, we're gonna figure it out now, but we're gonna have all the same people here, that's not necessarily a great recipe.
- 40:17Andrew: So we want to see turnover.
- 40:19Andrew: And it is it turnover at the you know, the bottom level or the top at the board level, at the executive level.
- 40:24Andrew: So for us, when we're thinking about how is the organization evolving, do they have the right people?
- 40:31Andrew: Saying, hey, turnover of employees, that's bad, no turnover is good, that's not that's not how we think about it.
- 40:38Andrew: It's gonna be contextualized.
- 40:40Andrew: What do we need, what actually needs to change?
- 40:42Andrew: Where where are the problems in that?
- 40:44Andrew: How do you root those out?
- 40:45Andrew: Is it just certain people need to go or you need a certain set of people to join?
- 40:49Andrew: Uh, how do you recruit those people?
- 40:51Andrew: So for us, it's a living, breathing.
- 40:53Andrew: Um breathing part of a company, uh, but it's also very slow moving and hard to change.
- 41:02Andrew: So we understand the inertia of cultures and and changing cultures, it can be very difficult.
- 41:07Ryan: Yeah, and that's uh it seems to me that that's part of the secret sauce, if you will, for what WCM is trying to achieve.
- 41:14Ryan: It's not something that can be easily just looking at a balance sheet or an income statement.
- 41:18Ryan: You don't necessarily see culture there.
- 41:20Ryan: Maybe there's evidence, there's there's some little things that you can pull out of it.
- 41:24Andrew: I haven't seen it, but uh maybe maybe AI can develop.
- 41:27Ryan: AI, maybe someone Claude will figure it out.
- 41:29Ryan: Um we we tend to end these uh web these these podcasts um asking for a book recommendation.
- 41:36Ryan: Okay.
- 41:36Ryan: Um I'm always looking for new things to read, and so I'm curious, is there anything that you know in the last few years uh you've read that had an impact on you or something that you haven't read yet, but you're thinking about?
- 41:49Andrew: So I'm uh this is not super recent read for me.
- 41:52Andrew: Um it's called Pitbull.
- 41:54Andrew: Okay.
- 41:55Andrew: Um recording artist?
- 41:58Andrew: No, not the recording artist.
- 41:59Andrew: It was a trade his Mart Marty or Buzzy was his nickname.
- 42:04Andrew: Schwartz is the last name.
- 42:07Andrew: Um it was like a he's a trader in the 80s, okay, and he kind of figures out a way to win um in terms of there is for him, he kind of discovers there's this positive signal in the bond market that translates to the SP futures, and he figures out this disconnect and that there's predictive characteristics of the bond market that could that 30 minutes later you'd see show up in the equity market.
- 42:41Andrew: So because this gap existed, he could arbitrage it, he makes a ton of money doing this.
- 42:48Andrew: So with futures, you can have as much leverage as you want.
- 42:51Andrew: Um now the risk of that was it didn't it wasn't a great fit for other people's money, but you get to see him in kind of discovering this way to win, which he kind of stumbled on and tried different things.
- 43:08Andrew: Um and then he's kind of he tries to do it with other people's money.
- 43:12Andrew: He's like, Oh, this isn't for me, that's too much pressure.
- 43:15Andrew: Then he, you know, makes a bunch of money for himself, and he's like, I guess I should buy art now.
- 43:20Andrew: Um, like he and then he kind of goes through some of the it's it's an interesting journey in you know, both his discovery, but also just sometimes the way to win is that you discover something that you're good at that you can apply, and there's not a there's not one recipe for a way to win.
- 43:41Andrew: And that was it was like kind of this unique, idiosyncratic way he won that helps inform but it always it helped me and s realize like there's never a single size fits all or one way to win.
- 43:56Andrew: And if you can carve out an advantage, whatever that is.
- 43:59Andrew: And understand it, you can exploit that for as long as you can, add value, and that's what you should lean into.
- 44:08Ryan: Is that like an autobiography by that uh uh the I I think so.
- 44:13Andrew: Yeah.
- 44:13Andrew: Interesting.
- 44:13Andrew: I mean, yes, it's I mean it's autobiographical.
- 44:16Andrew: I just I there's probably I'm sure he exaggerates plenty, but I it stretched some of the things.
- 44:21Andrew: Yeah, I'm sure he stretched some of it.
- 44:22Andrew: Okay.
- 44:23Andrew: Um the other one, and you know, this is also in this like systems of ways to win.
- 44:29Andrew: Um I I think everyone should read Super System by Doyle Brunson.
- 44:34Andrew: It's a poker book.
- 44:35Andrew: Okay.
- 44:35Andrew: Um and some of that hasn't dated incredibly well.
- 44:41Andrew: But I mean, the so there are a few things I don't know if you play poker at all, but um, poker got really big when there was like sports strikes in the early 2000s, and then poker was like all over ESPN, and we was like watch a world series of poker.
- 44:59Ryan: I always end up being a little bit uh too impatient.
- 45:01Ryan: Like I'm like, and then I just start betting too aggressively, and someone just takes me down.
- 45:06Andrew: So so Doyle Brunson won two World Series of Pokers in like in the 60s, and he then wrote the like the Bible for a poker strategy in the 70s.
- 45:20Andrew: Okay.
- 45:20Andrew: Um and there was you know, his primary observation was that with suited connectors, so it's it's like lower cards, like eight if you have eight nine of diamonds, that has a better chance of beating aces than if you're playing King Queen.
- 45:40Andrew: And it's because they're they're not as correlated.
- 45:43Andrew: You can make a straight or a flush, and that can beat those big pairs.
- 45:48Andrew: So he recognized this kind of EV discrepancy in poker as it related to suited connectors.
- 45:56Andrew: Okay, and then he built a career on that.
- 45:57Andrew: So it really was his understanding.
- 45:59Andrew: And sure, there's all sorts of things in poker, reading your opponent, you know, managing position and chip size.
- 46:06Andrew: Like, there's a lot uh in terms of in that strategy, yeah, but it is for me reflective of like when you are playing a game, understanding what you can bring to the table, what your advantages compared to everyone else at the table, and is there a way to institutionalize that?
- 46:23Andrew: And I I mean he had some of those things wrong.
- 46:25Andrew: So you also have to understand, like, be adaptable in that.
- 46:29Andrew: And I think if you just took his super system as gospel and never changed, you that's not effective 50 years later necessarily.
- 46:40Andrew: Now, some of those lessons are still valuable, but I think a lot of people will take when they're in the investing world, they'll take those classics as gospel rather than these were guides for the game they were playing at the time.
- 46:54Andrew: And there's important lessons in that, but you have to have adaptability and continue to learn and watch the game as it evolves.
- 47:02Ryan: Yeah.
- 47:02Ryan: All right.
- 47:03Ryan: Well, those are two great uh book recommendations.
- 47:05Ryan: We'll definitely have to check them out.
- 47:07Ryan: Um, I appreciate you making the uh the trip over here to uh participate in the podcast, and we look forward to maybe doing this again sometime.
- 47:14Ryan: Sure.
- 47:15Ryan: Thanks.
- 47:15Ryan: Thanks for having me.
- 47:16Ryan: All right, and thanks to all of you as well for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 47:22Ryan: We'll see you next time.