Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Law of Diminishing Returns in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: There's this moment in a product manager's career — let's call her Priya — where she was doing everything right by the playbook. She joined every cross-functional committee, volunteered for the CEO's pet project, grabbed coffee with three different VPs every week. And for the first six months, it worked. Her proposals sailed through approvals. She got fast-tracked to a senior role. Then around month seven, the returns started flattening, and by month nine, she was working harder for less. Luna: Wait, so she was over-networking? I thought consistency was the whole game in office politics. Lucas: Consistency matters, but only up to a point. What Priya ran into is the law of diminishing returns applied to political capital. Economists talk about this all the time — each additional unit of input yields less and less output after a certain threshold. In her case, the first five relationships unlocked real influence. The sixth through tenth? They gave her redundant information and marginal goodwill. The eleventh? It started to look like desperation. Luna: That's a brutal inflection point. So how do you know where yours is? Lucas: Great question, and there's a framework for it. I like to call it the zone of maximum impact. Before that zone, each additional hour you spend building relationships yields outsized returns. After it, the curve bends the wrong way. The key is finding the peak. For most knowledge workers, that peak is somewhere between four and seven strong alliances. Beyond that, you're trading depth for breadth. Luna: But what if your role demands a wide network? Like a sales leader who has to know everyone? Lucas: That's the nuance. The law doesn't say stop building relationships. It says optimize the mix. For a sales leader, the returns per contact might stay positive longer because each deal requires a fresh introduction. But even there, you'll hit a point where chasing ten new contacts means you can't nurture the five that could close next quarter. The 80-20 rule applies: about eighty percent of your political wins come from twenty percent of your relationships. Luna: So Priya should have done an 80-20 audit. Who are the twenty percent that actually matter? Lucas: Exactly. And here's the uncomfortable part — the twenty percent might not be the highest-ranked people. Priya had a VP of Engineering who never returned her emails but cleared blockers for her team every single time. That's a high-return relationship she took for granted. Meanwhile, she was spending two hours a month preparing for a steering committee where she had exactly one ally. The effort to impact ratio was terrible. Luna: So you're saying she should have dropped the committee entirely? Lucas: Or reduced her investment. She could send a delegate, or attend every other meeting, or prepare a one-pager instead of a full slide deck. The point is to treat your political energy like a budget. You've got one hundred units a week — or whatever it is — and every meeting, every follow-up email, every hallway conversation consumes some of it. Priya was spending eighty units to get ten units of return, when she could have spent forty units to get eight units and saved the other forty for something with higher leverage. Luna: I think there's a psychological trap here too. The more time you've invested in a relationship, the harder it is to pull back, even if the returns are diminishing. That's the sunk cost fallacy we talked about in episode 86. Lucas: Hundred percent. And diminishing returns accelerates that trap, because you start adding more effort to compensate for the falling returns — exactly when you should be doing the opposite. There's a study I came across from the University of Chicago, from around 2021, that looked at how executives allocate their networking time. They found that the top performers spent about sixty percent of their relationship-building time on a core group of four to six people, and the rest on a broad, low-effort net. The average performers split their time almost evenly across fifteen-plus contacts. Luna: So the structure matters more than the total count. That's a concrete takeaway. Lucas: Let me give you another concrete tool. I call it the 'stop list.' Every quarter, write down three political activities you are going to stop doing. Not reduce — stop. For Priya, those might be: no more monthly one-on-ones with the Chief of Staff who never acts on her input, no more preparing for the Friday all-hands Q&A because she never gets called on, no more attending the innovation workshop that's essentially a brainstorming session with no follow-through. That frees up maybe three hours a week. Luna: And then you reinvest those hours into the high-return twenty percent. Lucas: Right. And the beauty of the stop list is that it forces a decision. Most people just add more to their plate because they're afraid of losing optionality. But in office politics, optionality is an illusion if you're spread too thin. You don't lose influence by dropping a low-return activity. You lose influence by failing to deepen the relationships that actually move your agenda. Luna: I want to push back on one thing though. The law of diminishing returns assumes a static environment. But what if the context shifts — a reorganization, a new boss, a project pivot? Then the relationships that were low-return might suddenly become critical. Lucas: That's a fair challenge, and it's the reason you don't zero out anything. You prune, you don't burn. The stop list is about stopping behaviors, not necessarily severing relationships. For example, Priya can still grab coffee with the Chief of Staff once a quarter to stay on her radar. She just stops the monthly structured meeting. That way, she preserves the relationship at a maintenance level without over-investing. Luna: Maintenance level — I like that. So the framework becomes: invest heavily in the core, maintain the periphery, and cut the activities that don't serve either. Lucas: Exactly. And the way you audit that is with a simple test. Ask yourself: if I stopped doing this tomorrow, would anyone notice? If the answer is no, or the people who would notice are not in your twenty percent, it's a candidate for the stop list. Priya ran that test on her weekly status update email to the VP of Marketing. She'd been sending it for two years. The VP had opened it maybe four times. She stopped sending it. Nothing happened. That's a pure win. Luna: That's almost a relief to hear. There's this hidden fear that if you pull back, you'll lose ground. But if the returns are already diminishing, you're not losing ground — you're just wasting it. Lucas: Right. And there's another angle here that might be counterintuitive. Sometimes overexposure doesn't just produce diminishing returns — it can produce negative returns. There's a concept from social psychology called the 'overexposure effect.' If you're too visible, too available, people start to take you for granted, or worse, they perceive you as less influential because you seem to have too much time on your hands. Luna: That's the opposite of what most career advice says. Usually it's 'get in front of people, be visible.' Lucas: It works until it doesn't. Think about the senior leader who chairs every committee. At first, people think they're indispensable. Then after a while, the perception shifts — they start to seem like a bottleneck, or like they don't trust their team. The same applies to individual contributors. If you're always the one asking questions in the town hall, people stop listening. Your signal to noise ratio drops. Luna: So the goal is to be strategic about when and where you show up. Not just consistent, but selectively consistent. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me back to the law of diminishing returns as a lens. It's not about working less. It's about working smarter on the political dimension. Priya eventually restructured her week. She blocked two hours on Tuesday for deep prep with her two biggest allies before a key presentation. She cut her committee attendance by half. She started routing requests through her core network instead of handling them herself. Within two months, her project approval rate went back up — not because she was doing more, but because she was doing the right things. Luna: Honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that stop list technique alone is worth trying. If you found this useful, you know the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. We keep this show ad-free, and listener support is what makes that possible. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to say this kind of specific, no-fluff career advice matters to you. And we appreciate it. So back to where we were — the stop list is one tool, but the deeper principle is about watching the curve. Priya's story shows that office politics isn't a straight line. You don't just build influence and it compounds forever. It compounds, then it plateaus, then it can decline if you keep adding inputs without checking the output. Luna: That's a sobering thought for people who are ambitious. It means you can't just say 'I need to network more' or 'I need to be more visible.' You have to ask 'more of what, with whom, and at what cost?' Lucas: Right. And the cost isn't just time. It's also the dilution of your brand. If you're known as the person who's everywhere, you're not known for anything specific. Diminishing returns applies to reputation too. Each additional interaction that doesn't reinforce your core narrative weakens it slightly. Luna: So the takeaway is: pick a few relationships, a few forums, a few activities, and go deep. And have the discipline to stop the rest. Lucas: Exactly. And that discipline is what separates people who build lasting political capital from people who burn out or plateau. So here's a question for the listener — and for us to think about next time: if you had to write your stop list today, what would be the first item on it? Luna: That's a good challenge to leave on. I know mine already. Lucas: Me too. We'll pick it up from there next episode.