Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #219 - Brad West / Chris Gardner
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Is your government willing to make cuts to any stream of immigration
- 0:22to soften demand for housing. I think one of the most important things that
- 0:26we need to understand is that immigration is a source of opportunity, of growth,
- 0:31of economic advantage for Canada. But it's also important to make sure that,
- 0:36as we always have, we're doing it responsibly and at a pace that
- 0:40our cities, our municipalities, even our rural regions can absorb. Hey,
- 0:46folks, my name is Mohamir and this is Van Color, British Columbia's bona
- 0:49fide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, we're dedicating the entire show
- 0:54to immigration, and of course, in signature Van Color fashion, we're going
- 0:58to explore the issue from a few unique angles. First, let's look at
- 1:02immigration from a municipal lens. Of course, the federal government sets immigration targets,
- 1:07but ultimately it's provinces and municipalities that are responsible for ensuring adequate housing,
- 1:12healthcare, schools, public transportation and other infrastructure that is required to accommodate a
- 1:19growing population. One BC mayor made waves over Christmas after he called Canada's national
- 1:25immigration plan irresponsible. He's here to explain the most popular mayor in Metro Vancouver
- 1:32not named Linda Buchanan. He is the mayor of Port Coquitlam. Brad West
- 1:37Mayor West. Nice to see you. Nice to see you, Mo,
- 1:40And I would be remiss if I didn't start off. I know this is
- 1:42important to you by wishing you a happy New Year. Happy New Year,
- 1:47Brad. You know it's not February yet, so we're still able to wish
- 1:49each other. So I appreciate it. I may go, oh, good
- 1:53for you, Good for you. I appreciate that. Let's just get to
- 1:56the let's cut to the chase. Here in the city of pork Quita,
- 2:00are immigrants no longer welcome. No, they are welcome. They're a hugely
- 2:05important part of our community. Okay, because you made it sound like pork
- 2:08equilum is full. No, pork equiplum is not full. But this is
- 2:14really about what is an appropriate level of immigration. I think immigration is important
- 2:20to a country for a number of reasons, which we can explore. But
- 2:23what is also important is that there is some control in place on the number
- 2:28of immigration, number of immigrants that come to a country, and it has
- 2:32been the case in our country for decades generations that we've had a certain volume
- 2:40of immigration. What we have seen in recent years is that number has become
- 2:46supercharged, and it would be interesting to explore some of the reasons why that's
- 2:50happened, because some of the biggest cheerleaders for that come from corporate Canada and
- 2:54they obviously have an interest in a very high level of immigration, particularly in
- 3:01one of the streams that often is not discussed but needs to be at the
- 3:07forefront, which is the temporary foreign workers. Absolutely, that's a garbage program.
- 3:13We're actually going to be talking about that later in the show. But
- 3:16if you, for instance, take the last twelve months, Candae population has
- 3:22grown largely from immigration. In the last twelve months by one point two five
- 3:27million people. That is a record largest number on record, and not only
- 3:34the largest number, it surpasses the normal rate of population growth by a significant
- 3:39amount. Now, people have needs. You can't just say okay, here's
- 3:46one point twenty five million people and walk away from sure. People need a
- 3:52place to live, people need ways to get around, people need healthcare,
- 3:57people need education, families need child heldcare. There are so many different needs
- 4:01that come with a growing population. And what we haven't seen is the corresponding
- 4:08increase in investment in those services. In fact, I would argue that most
- 4:13of them are at the breaking point you have. I mean they're probably broken
- 4:17or past it. Yeah, you know, we have schools where you can't
- 4:21get kids in a classroom. They're in portable. Look at what is happening
- 4:25in Surrey in terms of the number of kids they're in portables. You have
- 4:29how many British Columbians who don't have a family physician, can't get a family
- 4:32doctor. You have childcare weight lists that are just insane. You're told,
- 4:39you know, oh, you should have been on our wait list. You
- 4:43know when you even had the thought that you may have a child at some
- 4:46point. Sure, you have all of those pressures. At the same time,
- 4:51you are looking at a supercharged rate of immigration one point two five million
- 4:57people in the last twelve months. I can understand that you're seeing this in
- 5:01your community of Port Equilam. I fully understand that. I guess where I
- 5:04get a little troubled is you're framing this really based around the immigration issue.
- 5:10I mean, why aren't you I know that you know the Solicitor General Mike
- 5:13Farnworth was a mentor to you But why aren't you criticizing the BCNDP for not
- 5:16increasing health care capacity. We have people, as you just noticed, as
- 5:19you just sort of alluded to, we have people dying on cancer care wait
- 5:24lists. Why aren't you criticizing them about the over two thousand portables that we
- 5:28have in our school systems throughout the province. Why aren't you criticizing the federal
- 5:31government for the amount of corporate welfare it doles out to seemingly all these big
- 5:35companies that they're in bed with. Why aren't you criticizing the federal government for
- 5:39billions of dollars that is shipping overseas to no benefit to the average Canadian.
- 5:44Like those things I feel like are more important than this idea of like,
- 5:46oh, it's all these immigrants that have caused the healthcare to break or schooling
- 5:51to break. That's not what I've said at all, And in fact,
- 5:55what I just did was criticize the government on all of those things that you
- 5:59articulate. I've said the portable issue, the healthcare issue, and of course
- 6:02they bear responsibility for that, But I'm also saying that not as a result
- 6:09of an individual person, individual immigrants responsibility, but the system that has been
- 6:16designed by the government is putting so much pressure on all of those social service
- 6:26infrastructure pieces and physical infrastructure as well. The whole way Canada's immigration system is
- 6:32set up, in my opinion, does a huge disservice to the immigrant themselves.
- 6:39It does a great deal of this service as well to the people that
- 6:43are living here. It is really, I think, largely a form of
- 6:46corporate welfare. And that's why, as I said at the beginning, the
- 6:50biggest cheerleaders for increasing the rate and and more comes from the biggest corporation and
- 7:00the top CEOs in this country. They view it often, I think,
- 7:03as a source of cheap labor. You look as well at our post secondary
- 7:10institutions. They have become addicted to international students well, and we have schools
- 7:15that are basically just degree mills, right, Like, they're not even providing
- 7:18a good education or at least what they advertise to these students that are coming
- 7:21from abroad exactly right. So I don't think, I don't believe for a
- 7:26minute that being critical of those systems and saying that there should be a reasonable
- 7:33limit on the number of people who we are bringing into our country through the
- 7:39various stream speed it temporary foreign workers, international students, or immigration, is
- 7:45in any way trying to lay blame at the feet of those individuals. They're
- 7:49victims, sure, they themselves are being victimized by the system that has been
- 7:55set up. Yeah, and I appreciate that. Again, I just feel
- 7:58like it needs to be counterbalanced the issues around capacity, and I think it
- 8:03isn't just one government. I think for decades we've been failed by successive provincial
- 8:07governments and federal governments in terms of creating these capacities, and under the full
- 8:13knowledge that the population is growing through immigration and that we need immigrants. I
- 8:18mean, you talked about family doctors. My family doctor is from South Africa.
- 8:22He's an immigrant. He recently brought in another family doctor from the UK.
- 8:26I just don't want to see a system where we stop bringing in these
- 8:28people that we need to contribute to the fabric and the building of our country.
- 8:33No, and that's certainly not my argument. There might be others for
- 8:37me, now, I mean, I think they'd be wrong, but I
- 8:41also think there needs to be a reasonable limit. I think it is entirely
- 8:46within reason that a country would say that there is going to be a certain
- 8:52cap because again, everyone has needs. You can't bring people in and just
- 9:00walk away and think that things will materialize by themselves. Yeah, like the
- 9:05idea that, well, we need to build more homes. I agree,
- 9:11it's very easy to say we need to build more homes. You don't wave
- 9:13a magic wand and have the materialize all overnight. But the way our immigration
- 9:20system and the various streams that we've talked about there are set up are completely
- 9:24ignorant. I would agree there's absolutely no flistic plan they I mean when you
- 9:28have the BMO saying and the column is from the BMO saying that this immigration
- 9:35plan it has no viability in reality whatsoever? I mean when Corporate Canada is
- 9:43saying that you know that the pendulum has probably swung Absolutely, Brad, I
- 9:48got to cut you off there. Thank you for this chat. You and
- 9:50I are friends, were pals, so I appreciate that we could discuss this
- 9:54somewhat sensitive issue. But again always appreciate your time. Thanks you so thanks
- 9:56for having me. Absolutely, folks, that's the mayor of Coquitlam, never
- 10:01shy to speak his mind. He is Mayor Brad West. Now, after
- 10:03some business, we're going to continue the conversation, but with a focus on
- 10:07Canada's labor shortage. Is our current immigration strategy filling the gaps of our labor
- 10:13market? Let's talk about it up next. Welcome back to this as Van
- 10:24Color. We're told that Canada needs high immigration due to our current labor shortage.
- 10:30Of course, I don't have to tell you that throughout the province,
- 10:33the country, even our communities need more healthcare workers, more educators, and
- 10:37more people to build all the housing that we're desperate for. But is our
- 10:41current immigration strategy filling in the gaps of our labor market? Here to discuss
- 10:46is the former Principal Secretary to Premier Christy Clark and the current President of the
- 10:50Independent Contractors and Business Association of British Columbia. He is Chris Gardner, and
- 10:56this conversation is supported by shelter point, single multi whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island
- 11:03uniquely shelter point. So Chris, as someone who represents several different industries,
- 11:11just how bad is the labor shortage in British Columbia or in Canada as a
- 11:15whole. Well, you know this issue has been one that is felt across
- 11:20our economy and we've been doing. There's been a lot of conversation about this
- 11:22for the last five close to a decade, five years close to a decade,
- 11:26and in construction we're feeling that acutely, and it is it's been the
- 11:28number one issue for our members and construction contractors across the country for many,
- 11:35many years. And just to put that in perspective, how bad it's been.
- 11:39If you look at the start of last year, we had about eighty
- 11:41thousand construction job vacancies across the country, eighty thousand vacancies across Canada. Across
- 11:48Canada, so in British Columbia we probably have about fifteen percent of those,
- 11:50just given our proportions of the population and the economy, and so that is
- 11:56a significant gap in skills that contractor require to perform all the work to build
- 12:01the roads, the bridges, the houses and the infrastructure we need to support
- 12:05our economy in our communities. And then if you look at what's happening in
- 12:09terms of the structure of the workforce, about twenty percent of construction workers are
- 12:15fifty five or older. Really okay, construction workers retire earlier than the general
- 12:18publation, usually around sixty so we're going over a demographic cliff and there's a
- 12:22short and there's this huge gap of job vacancies. Now, as we went
- 12:26through twenty twenty three, there was a little bit of an easing up in
- 12:30terms of the job openings, but there's still a gap. There are still
- 12:35contractors. We just released a survey today and it's still eighty seven percent of
- 12:39our members and we have forty five hundred members and clients across Western Canada are
- 12:45saying that they are going to be busier or as busy in the last year.
- 12:48So very robust, very obsilient part of our economy, and the number
- 12:52one issue remains the shortage of workers. So then if you think about what's
- 12:56happening in terms of let's just look at British Columbia. Yea, in twenty
- 13:00twenty two, for the first time in the history of this province, more
- 13:03people died than were born and that trend continued last year. So absent immigration,
- 13:09we have a declining population in British Climb sure, low fertility rate,
- 13:13yes, right, absolutely, So there's two ways through this. One is
- 13:16technology innovation, being more productive, doing things in a more innovative way.
- 13:20That's that's not a short we catch a three D print roads yet, But
- 13:26that is part of the solution. Sure. The other part is immigration,
- 13:30and so you must be thrilled, right because we have record immigration in Canada,
- 13:33so clearly we must be meeting these vacancies. Well, no, and
- 13:37here's here's the problem we have with what's happening in immigration right now. And
- 13:41they're probably in the last you know, six months, there's been more written
- 13:46on immigration and what's happening in Canada than probably any other issue. Like every
- 13:50time you open up a paper, a publication or go online, there's there's
- 13:56an article about immigration. So here's what's happening roughly right now. We are
- 14:00on pace to increase our population and we did this in the last twelve months
- 14:03by about one point to one point three million people. That is a historic
- 14:07rate of population increase. We haven't seen that since just after World War Two.
- 14:13And in fact, the third quarter of last year was the greatest population
- 14:16increase in Canada since eighteen sixtiese wow. So the floodgates are open. And
- 14:20so that increase includes temporary foreign workers and international students as well. Right,
- 14:26it's not just permanent residents. It's probably one third permanent immigrants about four hundred
- 14:31and fifty thousand, and then the rest of the one point two to three
- 14:35million will be temporary foreign workers, international students, and refugees. Okay,
- 14:39And so when you look at that population increase in Canada on an annual base,
- 14:43who at one point two one, it's about ninety eight percent because of
- 14:46immigration. So let's just look at the four hundred and fifty thousand permanent immigrants
- 14:52who came to Canada last year. Only two percent, or nine thousand are
- 14:56going to pursue a career in the construction trates. So you know, at
- 15:01the b of the year, we had a demand for eighty thousand jobs and
- 15:05new immigrants are taking up about nine thousand of them. So the challenge is
- 15:09we are failing miserably on identifying the skills gaps in our economy and then going
- 15:15out and recruiting the people with the skills to fill those gaps. We have
- 15:20failed at that. We're failing at that, and so and then when you
- 15:24combine that failure with and adding basically what we're doing right now, we're on
- 15:30pace to add a city the size of Calgary every year to canon. Wow.
- 15:35So think of that in terms of the pressure on healthcare, on education,
- 15:41on infrastructure, roads, bridges, and on a whole bunch of other
- 15:46social service systems that make our communities stop. So what can we do,
- 15:50like, what can the federal government do to ensure that folks that are coming
- 15:54are indeed filling in the job vacancies that we need, whether it's in healthcare
- 15:56or in construction, or education or wherever else. Well, just on the
- 16:00trades, I would say, it's like, let's just look at it from
- 16:03a very simple math perspective. Construction makes up about ten percent of Canada NBC's
- 16:07economy. Sure, so why don't we say that we're going to take ten
- 16:12percent of the four hundred and fifty thousand premium, right, so that ten
- 16:15percent of them should have a background or willingness to pursue a career in the
- 16:18trades. So if we did that, that's forty five thousand workers, not
- 16:22nine thousand workers. Right. So we do something as simple as that,
- 16:26and we don't. And the reason why we don't is, I think a
- 16:27couple of things. One is, I think there's a there's a there's a
- 16:32little bit of a bias toward the four year university degree versus someone who's got
- 16:40construction or trades experience. And we see that in our own education systems,
- 16:44in high schools here in Canada and British Columbia. If you know, if
- 16:48a young if a young person says to a high school counselor I want to
- 16:52start my own business, that councilor nine times out of ten is going to
- 16:55say good to UBC go to ask if you and study business, right,
- 16:56you're not going to say, go to a trades or technical school, learn
- 17:00a skill, learn a trade, get some experience and become a contractor start
- 17:03your own business. Because when you drive by a construction site and you see
- 17:07all those signs hanging there, there are names more often that there are names
- 17:10of people, families, partners who've taken risks, started a business and come
- 17:15from working on the tools. We don't tell that story. If you're interested
- 17:18in technology, there's more technology now being deployed in how we design and build
- 17:23buildings than ever before. Construction is a technology story. We don't tell that
- 17:27to youather people. We just have about a minute remaining, so I want
- 17:30to ask you this fair enough. We can try to attract people that have
- 17:34backgrounds in certain trades or certain professions. How do we ensure that they actually
- 17:37work in those professions, because once they're here, maybe they go into another
- 17:41field. Right, So how do we ensure that they do work in the
- 17:44trades or construction Well, you know, well, I think there's ways to
- 17:48say that for a certain period of time. Maybe you can't shackle someone to
- 17:53a vocation for the rest of their lives, but you can say, for
- 17:56you know, a two year period, you've got to work for in the
- 18:00construction trades. In this field broadly, probably broadly to find there's nineteen construction
- 18:04trades is a lot of opportunity, and if you're not interested in working on
- 18:07the tools, there's jobs in head offices, in marketing and project management and
- 18:11things like that. So I think there's ways we can do that. Right
- 18:15now, we're doing nothing, and that's why we have only two percent of
- 18:18new permanent immigrants pursuing a career in the trades. Yeah, like the system
- 18:22is failing yah, clearly, So we've got to do a better job.
- 18:26We just we have to do about it. Sounds like we just have to
- 18:27do something or at least try. That would be good to start. Chris,
- 18:30I appreciate your time tonight. Thank you so much, Thank you very
- 18:33much, folks. He is the president of the Independent Contractors in Business Association
- 18:37of British Columbia. He is Chris Gardner. Thank you to Shelter Point Single
- 18:41Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations, especially when they involve complaining about our federal
- 18:47government. Now, after some business, you might be wondering how we've gone
- 18:51an entire episode about immigration without talking to, you know, an immigrant.
- 18:55Well, I'm an immigrant and I'm going to take a moment up next.
- 19:04Welcome back to this as van color. Earlier in the show, I mentioned
- 19:07how Canada's temporary foreign worker program is garbage. Well, let me explain and
- 19:14let's take a moment. Canada's temporary foreign worker program is a disgrace that's rightfully
- 19:29been denounced as a modern form of slavery. Created in nineteen seventy three,
- 19:33the temporary foreign worker program allows Canadian employers to hire foreign workers to fill temporary
- 19:40jobs when qualified Canadians are not available. The word qualified is interesting since temporary
- 19:47foreign workers are increasingly employed in low paying jobs like those in agriculture, retail,
- 19:52and food services, work that, while demanding, doesn't require the type
- 19:56of technical training, education, or experience that most HR managers would associate with
- 20:02qualifications. Even the word temporary is a misnomer, since there is no maximum
- 20:07amount of time that someone can be employed as a temporary foreign worker. Now,
- 20:12the government of Canada assures these migrant workers that they have the same rights
- 20:17and protections as Canadians and permanent residents, except they don't. Setting aside,
- 20:22how temporary foreign workers do not have a pathway to citizenship. They can also
- 20:27be deported if they're fired, if they quit, or even if they get
- 20:32injured on the job. And since the status of each temporary foreign worker is
- 20:36tied exclusively to a single employer, the workers can't just find another job because
- 20:41they'd be deported before that would happen. This is why temporary foreign workers fall
- 20:47victim to excessive working hours, a lack of access to healthcare, violence,
- 20:52and wage theft, including a lack of overtime pay, not to mention,
- 20:56how particularly in agricultural settings, workers are off ten and housed in overcrowded,
- 21:02unsanitary, and inhumane conditions. This is the reality for many temporary foreign workers,
- 21:07as discovered by a recent United Nations fact finding mission which concluded that the
- 21:11temporary foreign worker program constitutes a breeding ground for contemporary forms of slavery. Now,
- 21:18Canadian employers who rely on this program insists that Canadians don't want to work
- 21:23these jobs, which fine, but if your entire business model hinges on exploiting
- 21:29powerless migrants, then maybe you should be forced to change that business model.
- 21:42Folks. That's our show. Thank you to Port Coquitlam Mayor Brad West and
- 21:47ICBA President Chris Gardner for their time tonight. We will be back next week.
- 21:51In the meantime, find me on TikTok or Twitter or ex whatever Elon
- 21:55Musk is calling it these days. At Van color. Of course, this
- 21:57is Van color, and I'm amir telling you that in a province where you
- 22:02can be anything, be colorful. Peace