Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E240 Political Machinima, PTSD and America’s Army | Welcome to the Desert of the Real (Aug 2026)
Transcript
- Tracy Harwood 01:00 Hello and welcome to this month's episodes of the Completely Machinima podcast. I'm here today with Ricky Grove and Damian Valentine, and Phil is off on his holly bob somewhere, somewhere nice and colorful. I hope. Damien Valentine 01:20 I can see you staring up that mountain behind Tracy Harwood 01:22 you. Yeah, that's George Hammer in the background. That's Bryce Canyon. I could have sworn I saw him when I was there too. So yeah. Anyway, Ricky Grove 01:31 Bryce Canyon is a wonderful place, Tracy Harwood 01:33 isn't it? Amazing, spectacular. I would suggest absolutely incredible. Anyway, we've got some amazing films for you this month. We're going to start the the month off though with Ricky's pick. Ricky, why don't you tell us about it? Ricky Grove 01:49 I sure will. This is a 2009 machinima that I came across on the archive.org. Now archive.org again, as I've been picking from it is a great source for finding machinima. However, you have to go through a lot of average and below average films, at least from our perspective here at Completely Machinima. But you do find these gems, and this was a film that I hadn't. I didn't see when it came out in 2009, and when I came across it, I was just staggered by how smart and and and really satirical and political the film is. Machinima is not known for producing political films, partially because the interests of gamers who make the films aren't geared towards politics; they're geared towards fun and and risque and and silly, absurdist humor. I mean, Red vs. Blue is a very interesting series, but inevitably, when you come down to it, it really doesn't have much content. It's like a a funny TV show that keeps playing the same joke over and over. So when I came across "Welcome to the Desert of the Real, I was struck first by the title because it reminded me of I think it was Baudryard's book. about Tracy Harwood 03:25 some old desert, Ricky Grove 03:26 yeah, the desert of the real. I I thought that was pretty interesting. Simulacra and simulation, which is also quoted in The Matrix, by the way. And so I thought, well, that's interesting. The it was created by a game designer and artist, Paolo Pettersini, who was a founder of the radical game development collective Mole Industria. And what he did was he took a game that was created by the U.S. Department of Defense, called America's Army, and he completely inverted the purpose of the game. The game was a state-funded tact. It was a free state-funded tactical shooter that was used as a kind of recruitment tool in public relations, saying, you know, this is the army. You could be a hero and all of that. And instead, what he did was, is he inverted the content to talk about post-traumatic stress disorder, and he uses the the the checklist that the army uses from their post-traumatic stress disorder checklist, and and he uses questions in that in tandem with his his filming of America's Army to to to characterize. A army recruit who has post traumatic stress disorder. It's very simple. There's no dialog. There's some very interesting, odd, and interesting music in it by a Finnish group called Pan Sonic, and using the desert, Essentially, this the story is is a sniper shoots a person, and apparently that triggers. One assumes that triggers their breakdown, and they he starts wandering in the desert, and you go through the deserted army bases and and and desolate places until you finally end up into the wide open desert, which is a wonderful metaphor for the the lack of feeling that the the soldier has. It's just very very smart. It's poetic. It's striking. It's perfectly paced. It's only about five and a half minutes long, and it makes its point without hitting you over the head, which has always, I think, been a problem with people trying to do political media, is they become polemics, and you end up going, "Wow, you've you've stacked the deck here. He doesn't do that at all. He uses a very simple plot, very simple character. The only criticism I would have of it is that because it's in a game that is pretty primitive in 2009, you're unable to see the the character's face in any extended way, and so you can't show that vacant look on the character's face at times. the The film really asks for close-ups of the guy, but he doesn't give it to you because of the limits of the of the game. But that's a minor quibble to this really really sharp and affecting and moving political machinima, which I love to put those two words together because you just don't see them very often. I really, really liked this film. I was impressed with it and was eager to share it with you to hear what you thought of it, fire away. Damien Valentine 07:25 I I remember when the the U.S. Army game was released. It was very controversial because there was lots of debate where about should video games be used as a recruitment tool, and obviously eventually it did get released. I can't say ever played it, but Ricky, I'm glad you mentioned that's the game that was made with it because I was watching the film. I think I don't recognize the game that this was made with, so that you know it does help them to know. And I feel like add something because that controversy is obviously long forgotten now. But when this film was made, that would have been something very much in the filmmaker's mind, which may have been one of the reasons that he decided to take the game and indulge it round. Yeah, yeah. I, you mentioned that the game is very primitive by today's standards, and you can't really get a look on the character's face. And I agree that it's a shame that you don't get that vacant look. On the other hand, they're not. It's not really animated that well either, so it kind of works and is also covered. So that could be anyone, and I feel like it's not any specific character. This is something that affects a lot of people, and so not having a distinct look at his face means it's a lot easier to imagine that this could be anyone rather than, well, that guy looks exactly like however they've designed him. You know, we talk about red versus blue and the helmets making the characters anonymous, and that's done for comedy reasons. But this, again, you don't see his face, so it's kind of he's kind of anonymous, but it works to tell that you know this is a very traumatized individual who's been put in this situation, and you know he's not anyone, he's not a specific character. This could be any soldier that gets recruited. So this could be you if you decide to sign up, and yeah, you're put in a situation that is very difficult. And of course, being a soldier, there's no way to predict what you're going to face. So I kind of like that, and yeah, just there's a bit where you got the mask covering it there, and then the helmet covers his face. He just his eyes. Having more animation around his eyes would have been good, but at the same time, yeah, it it still worked for me. Ricky Grove 09:49 Yeah, yeah. Like I said, it was minor. It was a minor issue, and I take your point. Damien Valentine 09:54 Yeah, I I thought it was a very powerful film. It's not one that. I would want to ask any soldiers: Is this accurate? Because I wouldn't want to traumatize anyone. But from what I, my understanding of soldiers who have seen combat and come come home with a lot of PTSD and other issues, this is a fairly accurate portrayal of some of the things that they go through. There are some very interesting shots, like the shot where it's the sniper scope. I think the filmmaker spent a lot of time making that feel very natural, because oftentimes when you're doing those kind of shots in games just to play it, you've got the mouse or the controller, and it's it doesn't necessarily feel like we'd expect because he's very carefully closing, and he kind of goes a little too far, and he moves back, and he's taking his time to line up the shot perfectly. Whereas if you if you're just playing the game, you would move it, and then you take the shot, and maybe you hit, maybe you miss, but there's just something about the way the camera moves that makes it feel more like more natural. As in, camera is actually looking down a real scope at the target, and so a lot of I think a lot of time is spent by the filmmaker to make that feel real, and it also adds to the trauma because this character is very carefully lining up the shot. He knows that that's a real person out there, so he's taking his time to to aim at, and then he he takes the shot, and the screen goes blank, and that's when the the trauma hits him, and it kind of sets off the message behind the film. So I feel like taking that that slow movement, that slow moment of it adds more to it. So I was very impressed by that too. So yeah, this is an excellent pick, Ricky. I think I saw it. I do remember seeing it a long time ago. I couldn't tell you where or how, but I know I do remember watching it before. So it's nice to see it again, and it's a very thought-provoking film. Ricky Grove 12:03 Yeah, you're right. You're right. Tracy Harwood 12:05 Well, yeah, I I I got a bunch of thoughts as you would expect. Actually, though, I started off looking a little bit at the artist that that's created it. But before I get to that, let me just say there's two different versions of this I found. So obviously, Ricky, you've given us the Internet Archive version, and that's the one I originally viewed. But there is also on Paolo's YouTube channel a version of this without the credits. My advice is watch the credits of it too, because I think that's important in the context of what this is is actually about. All he's done is taken those credits in order to shorten it a little bit and put the credits in the description, but it loses a little something in in having done that. So Damien Valentine 13:00 I just add the reason before we did that is at the time YouTube had very tight time restrictions on the videos you could upload. Tracy Harwood 13:07 2013, I think, or it's it's been uploaded a lot more recently than than when it was released in 2000. Damien Valentine 13:17 But even in 2013, it was they were still very picky about how long you could. Tracy Harwood 13:22 Were they? Well, I mean, yeah, I thought 15 minutes there was. Damien Valentine 13:25 I can't remember specifically. I just know where they were. Anyway, carry on. Tracy Harwood 13:29 Well, I think it's quite interesting that he's done that. But like I said, I think he's lost a little bit, or there's a little bit of context missing in just having done that. And I'll come back to that because I think it's kind of relevant. So this is, you know, I'd have said Pedicini. He's he's an Italian-born artist, and he's a game designer, and he's an educator. And as I understand it, he's now based in Pittsburgh, where he's an associate professor of art at Carnegie Mellon. Super. ironically, I was reading some background material on on his work, and and he studied media under Michael Nietzsche of the yeah of the machinima read it read it infamy, and there's some comments on some of the things that he talks talks to various journalists and what have you about some of his work, where he's basically explaining he didn't have a clue what Michael was talking about when he was discussing performative machinima, which I think is really really quite funny. Yes, and somewhat ironic in the in in the context of us looking at this now. So he's actually been creating this kind of work since 2003, and he's basically, you know, he's produced politically engaged games and digital artworks under that name. You identify Ricky Moller Molle Industria, Moller Industria, or however one pronounces that. I'm sorry, I butchered that. I think what his work does is explores the relationship between kind of electronic entertainment and ideology, and his games really address things like labor and and alienation and kind of corporate exploitation and militarism, religion I think is another theme. Consumer technology is another one. Environmental crises and what have you, and the the difficulties associated with all those of political change. I think what distinguishes his practice is that these arguments are built into the rules of the games that he builds, which is an interesting approach. So he's adapting, I believe. I think the game that this was filmed in was actually built using Unreal Engine originally was it released in 2003, and I think as I also read about the game a little bit, it was a game designed to recruit soldiers post 911. So it was pitching at people who wanted to respond to that, either in Iraq or Afghanistan or or wherever. So that's you know that's what he kind of used as his palette, so to speak. Now he also often appropriates familiar game forms, so things like management simulations and shooters and city builders and these kind of political games, but he alters them so that the underlying ideologies become visible. And and and basically, what he's trying to do is trap the player of a of a game inside some kind of compromised system. Now, you know, this is a this is a machinima. This is not a game adaptation necessarily. However, I think he's obviously modded it somehow in order to remove some of the the mechanics. This particular film, "Welcome to the Desert of the Real, belongs to sort of an avant-garde tradition of what's referred to, or what what seems to have become referred to as counter gaming, including things like tactical media and culture jamming, in which artists kind of appropriate military games to challenge the ideologies are those games actually promote. So rather than inventing a kind of a fictional representation of warfare, what he's done is use this game, America's Army, you know, to basically empty it of missions and enemies and kind of heroic achievement, and then kind of reconnects its more sort of sanitized military image to the psychological consequences of of combat. That's his the way he's kind of gone about it, and I think it's it's actually constructed, as you sort of said, Ricky, by bringing these two institutional products of the U.S. military system together. The images obviously come from that game, but the words, as you said, come from the military version of the PTSD checklist, which, as I understand it, is produced by the Department of Veteran Affairs. So I think what the work's doing is is is really quite clever. Is is asking us to look beyond what the military game makes playable, and he's confronting us with confronting us with what its its rules and representations leave out. In other words, the consequences of having participated in some kind of action. Tracy Harwood 18:57 I think what's interesting is the relationship between the materials used and how he's presented them, and that's why I think it's worth looking at the version on the archive, because the credits have a very specific order, which I think demonstrates the significance of how this thing has been put together. And if you're looking at it, what he credits first is the PTSD checklist as the source of the text that he's used in the in the film before identifying the gain as the source of the images, and and then the sound follow follows that. So that order I believe is significant, and I think when you think about that, that kind of reflects the the structure of of kind of what you're seeing because it's the checklist that's really the driving force for what you're looking at. The game kind of provides the visual material, but it's these kind of clinical. Questions that determine how that material is interpreted. You know, I mean, it's it's clearly how we selected it, but it's also how we interpret it as we're kind of going through it. And essentially, you're looking at the same blank kind of desert scenes, but each time you get another little page of text, it makes you feel a little bit different about what it is you're looking at, just as a desert scene, which is and the Ricky Grove 20:26 film also progresses towards a just blank desert. Yeah, initially you have buildings and things like that, but then when you finally get to the blank desert with this huge sun, so it's actually stripping away everything. Tracy Harwood 20:41 Yeah, that's that's right. But the words themselves are what drive you to feel colder and colder about it. I think it's quite it's quite it's quite a surreal experience, sort of you know getting right into it. And I recommend you put the you know a binaural headset on just to sort of really get into the white noise that you hear as Ricky Grove 21:00 well. Tracy Harwood 21:00 Yes. So you know, as you sort of said, Damien, the opening, and I think initially, I think it initially appears to kind of reproduce the, you know, maybe the visual language of a military shooter. We kind of see a bit of a close up of him, and then we look through this sight, as you said, and the crosshairs, and you kind of, you know, you you you you become him in that kind of moment because you're you go from sort of third person to first person in that kind of view. You don't you don't see him shoot, but you you're almost certain that that's what's happened because at the moment that takes place, you're him. But then it goes black just as the as the shot is fired, it's black. So he's you know what what he then does I think which is which is interesting. He kind of quite quickly withdraws from this kind of conventional then military viewpoint, and and basically the film kind of leaves behind the excitement and the speed and the tactical purpose that you would kind of normally associate with the game. And instead, what you're left then with is this sort of solitary individual soldier, kind of moving through this just largely empty, deserted desert escape. You see the soldier walking away from a gun that he appears to have left on the ground, and he's walking into the distance. And nothing in the scene really explains exactly what has happened. You kind of think you do, but you don't see any of it really. There's no mission briefing. There's no kind of heroic action, and there's no confirmation that the objective of whatever it is he's there to do has actually been completed. He just simply recedes against you know against this kind of landscape, just kind of gets smaller and smaller and smaller, and I think that's quite, you know, important in the context of what we're talking about. And that's at the point where I think the game becomes no longer this kind of tactical arena, but more of a psychological space. Yeah, I thought Ricky Grove 23:20 that too. In a way, the blackout might be, to your point, the blackout might be a switch from external reality to his internal reality. Yeah, Tracy Harwood 23:31 exactly. That's exactly as I saw it as well. You know, sort of, you you then start to sort of feel the closing in of it, don't you? The kind of Ricky Grove 23:39 yeah, yeah. Tracy Harwood 23:39 There's sort of an isolation, a kind of a disorientation, and in the end, you're not really sure whether what you're looking at is him experiencing that world or him remembering Ricky Grove 23:52 it. Yes, I Tracy Harwood 23:52 think is Ricky Grove 23:53 good point. Tracy Harwood 23:54 Kind of intriguing. I think that if we just talk about these comments, these you know, these text moments. I think they're interesting. Really, the first kind of checklist statement that you see talks about repeated disturbing memories, thoughts, images, or dreams of a stressful military experience. Now, what he does, really quite cleverly, is not illustrate what that bit of text sort of talks about. Not in a literal, not in a literal kind of flashback way. Instead, what he's doing is, you know, he's he's letting the story behave like a traumatic memory, and these kind of similar images recur: the walking, the emptiness of the dunes, the abandoned buildings, the watchtowers, the doorways, the sun, the relenting sun, if you like, that kind of repeatedly overwhelms the image. And these are not kind of presented as parts of a clear narrative. They're kind of. They're disconnected fragments, rather like visual impressions that can't be organized into a kind of a stable account of what might have happened, and that's where the sound design kind of reinforces it. There's no kind of dialog. There's no explanatory voiceover in in place of that speech. We kind of just hear wind and a sort of sustained wash of sound, almost, and I, I think that's important too. Almost resembling white noise in places, it becomes more obvious that that's what it is, but it's not necessarily discernible as it starts. Really, I think I think that ambiguity actually is is really quite effective because I think the sound belongs kind of well. You're not really quite sure it kind of belongs simultaneously. I think to the desert and maybe to the soldiers in a mind state as well, and I think as you listen to it, I I listened to it without kind of looking at it, and I kind of thought, well, I'm not really sure that's weather. I'm not really sure whether that's interference or tinnitus, maybe, or you know, would that be kind of psychic pressure, or is that kind of a residual noise of something that that this soldier has experienced that just can't kind of be silenced. It's it's really clever, cleverly done. I mean, white noise normally masks other sounds, and and and in a sense, that growing sound of it does drown out other sounds eventually. It kind of fills it fills the space along with that kind of relenting sun. That's what what you're left with that over over kind of whelming image of those two things, and I think that's how how he creates that kind of distance. I think distance between us as a viewer and what's happening with this kind of soldier. I think that's the clever bit, really, because you're never quite, you know, once you've once you've left that first person view, you're never quite back in that soldier's domain again. He's always moving away from you, Ricky Grove 27:22 yeah. Tracy Harwood 27:22 Which you know that kind of that reflects how other people perceive people that have PTSD, isn't it? They kind of there's always that kind of distance, yeah. And and it shifts the relationship we kind of have to the character. I think it's also worth saying that the the you know that checklist every time there's a a quote in there, it moves our thoughts about what it is we're seeing every time, and the the more you the watch it, the more you kind of feel that emotional shift. So every time another quote comes comes up, you feel more and more dread as to what it is you're going to read, and then what will follow it. You know. So, for example, the comment troubling, trouble falling or staying. Do you have trouble falling or sailing asleep. Well, the thing that follows that is a dawn-like landscape where the sun is kind of low on the horizon, suggesting that he's up early because he just can't sleep and he's gone for a little stroll. And then you've got these kind of long, quiet passages that also create this kind of uncertainty between waking and dreaming. And the desert, you might argue, kind of seems real, but it but also it's very empty and just so repetitive. You're not really sure whether that's part of part of the dreamscape, really. Yeah, and then finally, I think the the the question about feeling that that one's future is somehow to be cut short is basically accompanied by the soldier moving largely, you know, he's he's going towards a sort of blank blank horizon. He's he's kind of walking, but there's no visible destination beyond that desert and the glare of the sun, and progress therefore becomes kind of indistinguishable, I suppose, from from from him disappearing into it, and and that is another kind of one of the the the you know the challenges, is it not? Of you know how do you escape this kind of environment? Ricky Grove 29:54 If it was a Hollywood film that have his buddies pull up in a truck and go, hey. Are you okay, man? Hey, I think he's out of it. We got to get him some treatment. They put him in the back, and then they take him away, and that'd be a you know Tracy Harwood 30:09 a party. He he Ricky Grove 30:10 struggled for years, but then finally had a family and kids, and is doing well today. Damien Valentine 30:16 And a rock music soundtrack. Ricky Grove 30:18 Yes, yeah, yeah. So I was very grateful that zero sentimentality was part of this. Tracy Harwood 30:29 Yeah. Well, yes. I mean, there, there, there isn't. There's no, there's no optimism in it. I don't think at all. I think what he's done, you know, Perdicini. I think he's he's turned the army's own representational machinery against itself. Frankly, I mean, it's a game designed to present military service as kind of controlled and purposeful and and attractive. You know, to to you know for for recruitment purposes, really. Ricky Grove 31:01 Yeah. Tracy Harwood 31:01 But what this guy's done is is presented the things that the game leaves out, which is you know the possibility, the Ricky Grove 31:13 effect of all of this, Tracy Harwood 31:14 indeed. But the possibility that that military experience continues long after the mission is finished, in in the form of these kind of intrusive memories, the avoidance of issues, sleeplessness, emotional numbness. Ricky Grove 31:30 Yeah, that's why I think the movie is the film is so smart. Tracy Harwood 31:34 It is smart. Ricky Grove 31:35 It's because the great mass of machinima, as we've experienced it through history is just entertainment, and that's fine. I'm not. I'm not saying that's bad or anything like that. But it's always good to have somebody who's thoughtful and who thinks about well, what is this game trying to do? Well, they're leaving out, as you point out, the effects of all of this so-called heroism on long after they finish the war, and that's a very smart thing to do with something like machinima. I think that's great. Tracy Harwood 32:13 I think he's done it really very well. I mean, I think the other thing, the only other thing really, I would say is the fact that you know you both talked about emotion and that you couldn't see it in the character's face-I don't think he ever intended to show it, even if if the the character was able to give over the sense of emotion. I think the point isn't about the emotion of the soldier. I think it's about the distance and the. I think you're misunderstanding Ricky Grove 32:43 me. What what I said. I didn't say we needed a close up to show emotion. We needed a close up to show no emotion. Tracy Harwood 32:51 Right. Okay. Yeah. Well, I think he's achieved it without a close up. Ricky Grove 32:56 I understand that. I just wanted to clarify my point. Tracy Harwood 32:58 Thank you. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, perfectly. Well, it's not a lone piece of work in doing what it's doing. I mean, I think you can compare it to folks like Joe Delaps "Dead in Iraq, which was also performed in America's Army over a kind of an extended period of time. I think we've talked about that before, and in in that particular artwork, Joe basically went into the game, but wouldn't fight. Instead, he basically typed the names and the details of all the soldiers that were killed in Iraq into its kind of communication system, and you know these kinds of and and and we've also talked about other machinima that looks at the the consequences of war in different different ways. I mean, you know, these these function as kind of counter propaganda, really, And they're not easy watches. I would suggest if if they're played in, you know, I'd say you've got to be in a reasonable state of mind to sort of watch this and not be affected by it, really. But yeah, it's a it's a really interesting pick. I'm really glad you you brought it to us. I think it's it's a it's a timely discussion of yet another example of some very well done machinima, irrespective of the irrespective of the game's been long since superseded by greater cinematic qualities. Ricky Grove 34:38 I actually think that it might be a good film to remake. Tracy Harwood 34:44 You could be right. Yeah, Ricky Grove 34:47 I know you guys argue for the anonymity of it, but I think it would be interesting to remake it in a more visual style, so that for for one thing, the sniper. Sniping experience is, while it's effective, it's not the best thing to initiate a traumatic breakdown, because part of the reason is the sniper is far away from the victim, and so the impact of the victim dying is not as significant as, say, blowing, you know, a group of people up or cutting down a bunch of people with a massive gun, you know, that sort of thing might be more might be more a better way to show a breakdown such a scenario, and you could do that with a modern game. Tracy Harwood 35:44 Which game would you choose? Ricky Grove 35:48 I would do it in Unreal Engine, or and recreate everything from scratch. For one thing, the desert could be much more varied and realistic. Sinking into the sand would be a wonderful metaphor for him sinking into some emotional state. The he might come across dead body with no reaction to it, or groups of dead bodies. The atmosphere and sky could be more Dynamic, you know, and and it might even have a a time change from daylight to sunset or night or something like that. Anyway, would you give you an opportunity to revisit not so much the concept but the the craft of making the story, Tracy Harwood 36:44 yeah. Damien Valentine 36:47 But when you tracy when you asked what game, I was going to say something like Call of Duty, but then when Ricky explained why he would go with Unreal, I think yeah, actually that's the better choice. So I thought Call of Duty because it's got all the soldier stuff in. I'm pretty sure that those games are put out as a recruitment tool to try and show Wars Call. You could be a big hero and all of that, but I think having the control that something like Unreal would offer to change the you know the time of day and things like that, so you can show him just standing there, and time passes. You can't do that in Call of Duty because it's all fixed and look as cinematic as possible. But yeah, something where you get maximum control. So I'd agree with you for that. Ricky Grove 37:31 Yeah, you'd you'd lose that irony of creating a counter machinima inside of us of of a game that was whose motive was entirely different, but I think that would be okay because the message is more important than that irony, and the irony is long lost. Tracy Harwood 37:53 Fair enough. Call of Duty. I mean, John McInnes worked on that with military people, did he not on on the latest version? I don't know, Ricky Grove 38:04 probably. Tracy Harwood 38:07 Yeah. Well, okay. Great discussion. Thank you very much for bringing to this table. Ricky Grove 38:13 Yes, indeed. Tracy Harwood 38:14 It's a it's a really fascinating thing to talk through and reflect upon. Audience, what would you put this one to? What would you remake this particular filming? To Ricky's point, Damien's point. Comments would be very welcome. That's it for this week. I hope you enjoyed our discussion. Thank you to Damien and Ricky, and we'll see you next week. Ricky Grove 38:41 Okay. Thanks, everyone. Bye.