Latest / Wheel Takes / KOD (Ch31-33 Part 1): Girlbossing Too Close to the Sun
Transcript
- 0:17Hello, Hi, and welcome back once again to Wheel Takes, a podcast
- 0:22about the Wheel of Time. I choked on my own Saliva, a series
- 0:29of fantasy novels written by Robert Jordan that were then finished by Brandon Sanderson.
- 0:34I'm Gus, I've read all of them, and I'm Ali, and I
- 0:37have read ten of them up to Knife of Dreams chapter thirty two. You
- 0:47might hear are cat Minnie. She's also many has decided to make her presence
- 0:50known thirty three. I think yeah, thirty three, thirty three. This
- 0:56podcast only contains spoilers for what Ally's already read again, and that's everything up
- 1:00to and including Knife of Dreams chapter thirty three. Ali has it gone.
- 1:07It's going all right, you know. I am being slightly distracted by the
- 1:15cat. She is wanting very much to be involved in our recording today.
- 1:21Yes, and that's very sweet of her. We love Mini, I'm min
- 1:25We definitely have a few people to think. I need to figure out where
- 1:29we left off last time, So give me one second, all right,
- 1:33Thanks for jumping up to a pine. Alexander G. Alexander G. Just
- 1:38like an illustrious cardigan, you are warm. People flock to you. Because
- 1:42you just have that wonderful, inviting way about you. You are comfortable to
- 1:49be around, somebody that just puts the solid ease. And you are someone
- 1:55who, in the words of Taylor Swift, when you feel like a old
- 2:00cardigan under someone's bed, I put you on and said you are my favorite.
- 2:06You're my favorite, Alexander ge And for that we thank you, and
- 2:09thanks for being a part of this community. Thanks for jumping up to a
- 2:13pint. Danielle see Danielle see just like a devoted screen protector. Oh I
- 2:22got a phone. Nice. You never crack under pressure. You're somebody who
- 2:25can just stay calm even in the fiercest storms. You are clear in what
- 2:32you want and you are willing to go for it and do what it takes
- 2:38to get there. And you are someone who sticks to their guns when everything
- 2:44can be difficult to navigate, sometimes difficult to figure out the way forward.
- 2:51You know how to stick to your guns and listen to your gut. And
- 2:53for that we thank you, and thanks for being a part of this community.
- 2:55Thanks for jumping up to a pint. Lays I think is how I
- 2:59prounce or Alisa one. We've said your name before and I'm sure we got
- 3:05it wrong then and we're gonna get it wrong now and I'm sorry, and
- 3:07for that we thank you. Thanks for being part of this community. But
- 3:10in addition to that, just like a glowing lazy Susan, all right,
- 3:16I love a lazy Susan. Yeah. You know. It's those like little
- 3:20wheels that are on yeah tables that just kind of like go around and you
- 3:24can put stuff on it, so it's like, pass me the salt and
- 3:28it's on the lazy Susan. I love lazy Susan's. And just like a
- 3:32lazy Susan, you are not lazy. You are innovative. You know how
- 3:38to work smarter, not harder. You are good at navigating life's twists and
- 3:44turns. You will prevail no matter what, and you're really awesome and for
- 3:51that we thank you, and thanks for being a part of this community.
- 3:53Thank you for jumping to a pint. Andrea s Andrea s just like a
- 4:00show stopping Yeah, I don't think I've used that one. Uh, why
- 4:05am I thinking? Move foy? Like because we watched, because we watched
- 4:11Bridgerton, Where did the recording go? Hello, it's back? Everything went
- 4:17away for a second Yeah, everything went dark. It was very scary.
- 4:19You're watching Bridgist and they talked about midy is why movefoy French? I think
- 4:27is it for you? I think so the y l l A like sheets.
- 4:30I've also heard it pronounced on British baking, British British f e U
- 4:38I l e. I think it'd be okay. I have no idea.
- 4:44French French is fun with all the invisible less The French are going to love
- 4:53this, all right, But just like that, you have many layer right,
- 5:00doesn't have a lot of layers and that part of the thing, it's
- 5:04a difficult. Yeah. I think they counted them on. They like you
- 5:11had to have a certain amount. You have a lot of layers. There's
- 5:14a lot to you mean fun means one thousand sheets. Yeah, I don't
- 5:19know if they counted to a thousand. I'm sure they did not. But
- 5:23uh, just like that, you have a lot of layers. There's a
- 5:27lot to you. You're a complicated person. There's a lot to get to
- 5:30know, and that makes you so interesting. You're also fancy. You know,
- 5:36you're someone who knows how to make a statement. You are well dressed,
- 5:40you are well quaffed. You know, you know that sometimes the best
- 5:46things in life aren't free, and that's okay. You treat yourself. Uh
- 5:51and you also, yeah, you do know how to treat yourself and for
- 5:55that we thank you, and thanks for being a part of this community.
- 5:57And last but not least, for today, thanks for the cup of coffee.
- 6:00Brian v Brian Vee. Just like a chimerical slide, Woh you are
- 6:11fun. You're just fun to be around, a crowd favorite truly always.
- 6:18You know how to embrace the simplicity of life well also being unafraid to climb
- 6:25the ladder to success, and for that we thank you, and thanks for
- 6:29being a part of this community. Thanks everyone, you're all lovely. And
- 6:32if you're listening and skipping thirty seconds every time the patron thank you start,
- 6:38I do put a time stamp down below for you to know when they end,
- 6:42which is right about now. We have a couple of things. Oh
- 6:45somebody said that they think of it as like my horoscopes. Oh I love
- 6:47that so cute. We have two things to address briefly from last week.
- 6:53One is we did a generalization last week and that was bad of us.
- 6:57Yes, I think here's the thing. In the flow of conversation, Yes,
- 7:01sometimes I fail to get at the nuance that I mean to get at
- 7:05right right, because we're bouncing around. And obviously I hope. I'm thankful
- 7:14to the people who reached out and gave us the benefit of the doubt about
- 7:17this and recognized that that is unusual for us to not go into the nuance
- 7:20of something, So thank you for that. But so basically I started talking
- 7:27about fitness influencers, and you know the influencers that are online that give advice
- 7:34about health and fitness, like one size fits all, generalized advice about health
- 7:40and fitness. Yes, And accidentally, when I was talking about the dangers
- 7:43of those generalizations, I did a generalization in talking about them. So so
- 7:47we ourselves are in fact part of the problem. We are. So here's
- 7:53the thing. Never take health and fitness advice from us. No ever.
- 8:00We are not in any way like registered anything experts in anything that has to
- 8:05do with health and fitness. And I always am encouraging people when it comes
- 8:09to health and fitness. Obviously, if it works for you, yes,
- 8:13and it is something that is helpful to you. If there's a diet or
- 8:16exercise plan or time that you wake up that is a good lifestyle choice for
- 8:22you. That's awesome, and we celebrate that always. We're never meaning to
- 8:26put down anything ever that is working for somebody. Yes, because obviously health
- 8:33and fitness is a very holistic thing, right, there is no one size
- 8:35fits all. We're all out. You were doing all this different. However,
- 8:41what I was meaning to go for in that conversation, and the thing
- 8:46that frustrates me as someone with a chronic illness, right, and this is
- 8:48where that's coming from, and who has a brain that is not one size
- 8:52fits all. I get very frustrated by some unqualified people out here giving advice
- 9:01as if this is the answer to everyone's problems, because I think there are
- 9:03people in this world that are making money off of praying on people's insecurities and
- 9:09desperations. And that is the difference to me. If there is something out
- 9:15there that is helpful to you, and I've certainly found, you know,
- 9:18certain diets and exercises and lifestyle plans to be helpful to me, and so
- 9:24sometimes I will share those things as like a this was helpful to me and
- 9:30maybe will be helpful to you, right, But never ever, ever,
- 9:35would I presume to tell anyone what to do with their bodies or lives.
- 9:41Yes, in that way. So just to make that clear. The only
- 9:46thing that I was coming forever, And I did appreciate other people telling me
- 9:50like I got where you were coming from, because I too have a chronic
- 9:52illness and have people go, have you tried yoga and you just want to
- 9:58explode? Do you just want to explode into a million pieces when somebody does
- 10:05that? But yoga is very helpful to a lot of people, or you
- 10:09know, eliminating carbs. When I said no carbs equals no brain, I
- 10:16got cut off in that conversation, not on purpose. We were just going
- 10:20with the flow, and I know Gus knows what I mean, and sometimes
- 10:24I forget that there's a microphone there. What I meant by that is that
- 10:28a no carb diet is not recommended for many people. Right. I had
- 10:35that idea of carbs being bad for me pushed at me from a young age
- 10:39and had to repair my relationship with carbs. And what I learned is that
- 10:43my body personally, when I do not eat carbs, it impairs my brain
- 10:48function and my body's function. That's not true for everybody, right, But
- 10:52what I meant by that was not people who do not eat carbs are stupid,
- 10:56right, What I meant by that is it could, if your body
- 11:01is like mine, impair your body's function. Right, That's what I meant.
- 11:05Thank you to the people who reached out and we're concerned about that.
- 11:09I hope that that clears things up. Obviously, it is my bad that
- 11:13I phrased it so poorly, and I take full responsibility for that. Well,
- 11:20and I was rushing through the conversation too, right, So that's that's
- 11:22all true and are bad. And the second thing I wanted to touch on
- 11:28that we completely skipped over in the rush to not talk about Galina is the
- 11:33the shadow going back to Yes, yeah, and that is now the remnant,
- 11:41excuse me of a remnant. That's my read of what's going on.
- 11:45So Therav is taking a handful of the surviving shidow, probably several thousand,
- 11:50back to the waste, and her whole thing is like, and we're never
- 11:54leaving again. We're gonna go, We're gonna stay, we're gonna rebuild,
- 11:56We're gonna be the people we used to be. I kind of thought that
- 12:00at the time but then I was thinking, well, that operates under the
- 12:03assumption that that's not going to be going to be true for the rest of
- 12:07the ay Eel, do you know what I mean? Sure? So,
- 12:09I mean, which I guess makes sense, right, because now, why
- 12:13do they need to be in the waste? Right? It was a proving
- 12:16ground and all that. Yeah, it was a place they went because it
- 12:20provided them some level of safety and then also punishment for what they you know,
- 12:26did, yeah, or think they did or think they did. And
- 12:30you know that's also assuming that you know, the remainder of the Aeel survived
- 12:37the last battle, which I hope they do, but you know, I
- 12:41feel like after that, maybe they've proven what they need to prove and don't
- 12:46need to go back to the waste and punish themselves for generations. Yeah,
- 12:48that is that is my reading of what this is is when we had the
- 12:54whole prophecy of a remnant of a remnant shall remain it is of the original
- 13:00society that was the ay Eel and the way they functioned, A sliver of
- 13:05a sliver will their lifestyle you will, yeah, will retain that lifestyle choice,
- 13:09and that remnant first would be the shadow and then the remnant of the
- 13:13Remnant or the Shadow who survived this particular battle. So yeah, I mean
- 13:18I guess for me that does make a lot of sense because Rand kind of
- 13:24went in and blew up their whole way of life, their whole thinking,
- 13:28and some of them are going, let's go back to the simplicity of what
- 13:33we knew, And I guess there is a comfort and safety in that.
- 13:37I mean, we talk about deconstruction on this podcast all eggy on in right
- 13:41or the AEEL. It's a really hard thing to do. It's really fucking
- 13:46hard. It's a really hard thing to do, and I really applaud anyone
- 13:48who's in that process because especially if you come from an extreme environment. Oh
- 13:56yeah, it's really really I mean the IEL is objectively a pretty streamist they
- 14:01have yeah, well, I mean, you know, they're very fundamental in
- 14:05a lot of ways. Yes, not to say that they're necessarily bad or
- 14:09toxic, Oh no, it just means that they have very strong and strict
- 14:13beliefs. I mean, the Shadow are a little yeah for a lot,
- 14:16but I mean I could understand why the Rava in particular, and this group
- 14:22in particular, saw how the Shadow behaved when the rules were kind of out
- 14:28the window, or they were making the rules kind of work for them in
- 14:33a bad way. And when you know what, it was better before.
- 14:37It was better before. We have manyat your tail. If you many,
- 14:43sweet sweet thing, you can't be here. You can't be right there brushing
- 14:46your tail against I'm sorry, you can't. You can't do it. Okay,
- 14:50it's going to be over here. Well hurt you, Okay, all
- 14:52right. So I feel like, yeah, their whole thing became objectively very
- 15:01bad because they they kind of lost the plot. They kind of were like,
- 15:07well, I guess there are no rules now, and we're going to
- 15:09follow the way we were, but we're going to make it so much worse
- 15:16for no reason. So while I don't like the RAVA because I feel like
- 15:20her relationship with Galina is really awful. Yes, I feel like they that
- 15:28her ability to see the fact that they have become the baddies and that she
- 15:35needs to reverse course with this with who she can save, is you know,
- 15:43understandable and not that's the that's the not bad thing that she's done.
- 15:50I think that's the main one. That's the relationship with Galina bad, toxic,
- 15:54and I gloo balloom it. But if we're looking at it without Galina,
- 16:00I understand why she's doing it. Yeah, because this I suppose there
- 16:03is such thing as deconstruction in a bad way, yes, right, Like
- 16:07you can deconstruct too close to the sell. That's a little bit aerum too,
- 16:12right, I mean, and deconstruction yeah, I guess that is The
- 16:17complicated, nuanced thing about deconstruction that we've never really talked about on this podcast
- 16:21is that, like, there is deconstruction for your benefit and there's deconstruction to
- 16:27your detriment, And unfortunately there's not really always a way to tell which is
- 16:32which. I think partially it's like when you're at those vulnerable periods in your
- 16:37life and you're searching for those mentors for who to be, Like you've realized
- 16:44that the life that you thought you had to quote Wrain in season one of
- 16:49the show, your life isn't going to be what you thought. When you
- 16:52realize that the fundamental principles that your life is founded on are built on on
- 17:00sand instead of rock. To quote the Bible, I didn't go to Catholic
- 17:04school, but I do love that parable right about the wise man and the
- 17:10foolish man and you realize that everything is built on sand. I think kind
- 17:15of the the make or break it point is who you encounter after that,
- 17:21what mentors you seek out and whether they're able to yeah, what you feel
- 17:26that, what you fill that void with, because I think everybody needs a
- 17:29guiding principle of some kind, like congrats. If you are a person that
- 17:34is like I'm just out here freeballing it. I think that's a tough principle.
- 17:45Can be as simple as be chill, try to do good, do
- 17:48good things. Yeah, in this life. Try to leave the world a
- 17:52little better than you found. It is kind of where I've landed. And
- 17:59that can be in small and large ways, but often very small. I
- 18:04think, yeah, I think you have to find a way to find a
- 18:11new path, and I think it can. That's the time you are the
- 18:14most vulnerable for other toxic mindsets because it's like, oh, that void makes
- 18:21you vulnerable to other people who claim to have the answers. And I think
- 18:26some of the most dangerous people are the people who are like I have it
- 18:29all figured out. Yes, well, I don't remember this impossible. Socrates
- 18:34is like the wisest man is a man who knows he knows nothing. That's
- 18:37also been I think scientifically even that was more psychologically proven also, right,
- 18:44But like there's the expert fallacy or whatever it's called, where it's like,
- 18:48oh god, beater Minehoff. No, that's different. That's when you when
- 18:52you recognize something that you haven't, you learn a new thing, and then
- 18:56you see it everywhere as batter Minehoff. Yeah. But it's like the people
- 18:59who actually, some people who think they know the most about something usually don't.
- 19:03Well, they're usually actually people who have a middling grasp on it.
- 19:04Yeah. People who actually do know a lot about things usually whatever, Yeah,
- 19:10usually feel insecure and like they don't know a lot about it. So
- 19:14actually, if you are feeling like I'm not I'm out here in this field,
- 19:19feeling imposter syndrome and all this stuff, it might be that you actually
- 19:23know more. Could be because you know what you don't know. Yeah,
- 19:30anyway, that's the shadow. Now we're gonnake a real quick break and we're
- 19:33gonna talk about your friend and mine. Carry ona. We'll be right back,
- 19:38eat it right back, We're back. How you doing. All right?
- 20:00Here's the thing. I am okay with being wrong about things. Yes
- 20:03i am. I am and I'm not mad at how this turned out.
- 20:11I just really liked my theory, I think because I felt like it.
- 20:17Here's the thing, I think Robert Jordan and I disagreed on how important Van
- 20:19Deine was going to ultimately be to the overall plot. I think when there
- 20:25is a mystery for me, that is something that I latch onto really hard
- 20:30in any media, well, especially when the POV character is consistently pondering the
- 20:34mystery. Like I think that's part of the reason I love Bridgerton so much,
- 20:37is like who was Lady Whistled Out? Was a great in for me
- 20:42because I like that kind of it's I'm like a dog with a bone on
- 20:48that. When Robert Jordan also frequently does engage hard with the mystery of things,
- 20:53yeah, I think he does. And so it's interesting because I think
- 21:00that Robert Jordan and I disagreed on how much of a mystery this was going
- 21:03to be and how important to the plot this is going to be. And
- 21:07that's fine, well, how important thematically it was going to be, right,
- 21:11And I think I was thinking of it from a perspective of like,
- 21:14what would be the most compelling to me if we were going to give this
- 21:18a ton of weight, which for me an old lady death, a cool
- 21:23dramatic old lady death I either wanted, which I did ultimately get cool old
- 21:29lady revenge, yes, which I did. Alternate. Yea from Adelius or
- 21:33Adalias is a great line. It was great line, and so I'm cool
- 21:38with that as a sibling where I'm like, if if something ever happened to
- 21:45one of my siblings, the person would rue the day, I am sad
- 21:49that she died immediately after, instantaneously afterwards. Yes, I yeah, I
- 21:55think I was picturing it to be more of an explosive thing one way or
- 21:57the other, Whereas I think that the focus for Robert Jordan was Elaine in
- 22:03this situation, which I suppose is the correct instinct since Elaine is a main
- 22:07character. Yeah, I think I just got really excited about the possibility of
- 22:11like an old lady either being the person that had to kill her sister because
- 22:18she was a baddie in which case, like now we're really getting into the
- 22:23complexity of what we saw with like Leandron in the show. Yeah, an
- 22:27ink Tar in the book, an ink Tar in the book, which I
- 22:30just I think I also wanted that ink tar feeling again. Yeah, well,
- 22:33because that's such a great moment. It's such a great moment, and
- 22:37it really supports Robert Jordan's thesis and the complexity of sometimes life just hands us
- 22:42a bad hand, and there are two bad choices, and sometimes we accidentally,
- 22:48because it's hard in certain lights to see which one's the worst choice,
- 22:52we make the worst choice because we can't see the full path. Yeah,
- 22:56you know, And so I like that because I think that Robert Jordan does
- 23:02have this whole thing of like you're never too far gone and sometimes what looks
- 23:08like a bad person can can have more complexity. And I guess at this
- 23:14time period that we're in, the complexity of situations is speaking to me.
- 23:21Yeah, of course, right, Like just our ability to maybe see that
- 23:26a lot of people are just trying their best in the world. Well,
- 23:30it's almost like we engage with hot nuance on this podcast. Oh yeah.
- 23:33And there's certainly things where it's like this is a thing that's objectively bad,
- 23:37and this is a person that's done. It's enough objectively bad things that we
- 23:41can you know, or big enough objectively bad things that we can be like
- 23:44that's an objectively bad person, right, right, But I think a lot
- 23:48of people fall within a spectrum of you know, being taken advantage of or
- 23:53making a bad call. That's what you wanted to see interplay with Vantine.
- 23:59Yeah, I thought maybe that's where we were going. And I think I
- 24:03fell in love with that theory in a way because to me, it encapsulated
- 24:08that. And so I was a little like, oh when it turned out
- 24:12to be Cariana. It doesn't mean that it wasn't good writing or anything like
- 24:18that. I just I think I just fell in love with my theory.
- 24:21Yeah. And I mean even even in the lead up, like listening to
- 24:23the chapter again, you've got the whole thing where Elaine is in a circle
- 24:27with Saitha and Vanden is in a circle with Caryana, and there's all this
- 24:32stuff in her head of like, well, I know van Deen's good,
- 24:34so therefore two good sisters have a hold on two bad sisters. I do
- 24:38think there were there were a lot of opportunities for Robert Jordan to pull it
- 24:41in that direction. And actually, you know, I was looking at the
- 24:45old forums, van Deen was the leading suspect. Really, vande was the
- 24:49leading suspect. Because everybody was like, Carryana. I guess she's weaker,
- 24:53so she would have to use the t Saitha acted kind of weird. Uh
- 25:00uh Yeah, I guess For me, I wasn't particularly attached to either character,
- 25:06so the reveal of it being Carryana did not matter to me. No,
- 25:11but Vanden getting her revenge then was the thing that mattered more. Yeah,
- 25:17it's a good moment. It's a good moment. Yeah, Well,
- 25:21because I guess. I guess. I was like, you can go down
- 25:22one of two paths. Either way, Vandin kind of has to be centered
- 25:26in this. You can either go down the path of Vanden did it,
- 25:30which now I kind of wonder if maybe he swerved possible because I think the
- 25:36justification now for why did she poison her is she wasn't as strong in the
- 25:38power, therefore she had to use the tea. Yeah, which makes sense.
- 25:42And I guess the other the other rationale or evidence for it being carry
- 25:47on is Carriana has served tea to people before. Oh okay, yeah,
- 25:52yeah, I guess I guess that'll make sense. I mean, it makes
- 25:56sense, make sense. It's it's just it's mad at it. Yeah,
- 25:59I'm just like, I guess, I guess who did it was not as
- 26:03important as I as it was to me. I mean, I'll be real,
- 26:07I'm I look, I like your version more. I think it's a
- 26:10lot more interesting. I think it has a lot more a lot more.
- 26:12Wait of you, I don't want to wait. And I'm not saying Robert
- 26:15Jordan didn't do a good job. I'm just saying this wasn't what he was
- 26:17concerned with as much. Yeah, so I think if if if he were
- 26:22concerned with this being a more central plot point than it ended up being,
- 26:27right, then either he does what I thought he was going to do,
- 26:34or I guess amp up the personalities of Sorri Sonia a bit more. But
- 26:44then we're arguing and that asshold lady moment. Then we're arguing for more time
- 26:48with minor characters in the middle books. Yeah, but I would have been
- 26:52okay with more time on this, Yeah, I get. I guess my
- 26:55thing is I was like, I would have been okay with more time spent
- 27:00on this mystery because I liked it so much. Well, and it's interesting,
- 27:03and we've known Adelius and van Deen for a very very long time.
- 27:07We've known this it's book two, right, and we've been working on this
- 27:11mystery since book eight, I think is one. And the drag car being
- 27:18there, I mean, I felt like the seeds were planted. I don't
- 27:22necessarily care that they didn't come to fruition. I just yeah, I'm glad
- 27:27we got a bad ass old lady. I was kind of expecting more of
- 27:30a bigger fight between the if the reveal happened. I was kind of expecting
- 27:36more of a back and forth, you know, more of an old lady
- 27:40magic battle versus taking her out with a dagger. But I guess Robert Jordan
- 27:42also really likes doing the like this is the thing you wouldn't expect the you
- 27:48know, utilization of swords or a plate or a knife at that point.
- 27:56Yeah, so I guess you know. I do love the energy of I'm
- 28:00taking you out with me. Yea, if I'm going out, you're going
- 28:03out. I love that. And I do love that we've given an old
- 28:07lady because I feel like old women get so ignored. Yeah, in or
- 28:14even just older women, women over thirty five honestly gets so ignored in narratives
- 28:21that it's pretty thrilling to me to have an older woman have such a big
- 28:29moment. I guess I just wanted more of her. I would have also
- 28:33liked more of it. Yeah, I guess I just wanted more, Which
- 28:37is fine. Listen, if we're going to be levying a criticism, I
- 28:41wanted to read more of it is usually a pretty good one. That's a
- 28:44good Yeah, leave us wanting more, I guess, Robert. So we're
- 28:47going to pick it up here with chapter thirty one. The house on full
- 28:49Moon Street. That's the logo. What is it? It's a black adulo
- 28:52black odds your logo. We were in the car and you were very motion
- 28:56sick, so you didn't take notes. I did not know. And we've
- 29:00discussed a lot of the significant elements of this chapter. But don't worry.
- 29:04We'll talk about the rest and we're probably going to do all three chapters today.
- 29:08We might have to cut it midway through for time. I know we
- 29:11did three hours last week. We cannot do that every week anymore, unfortunately.
- 29:15But there you go. So it's a lane chapter. How she she
- 29:21is fine, she has a plan. Yeah, and you know what,
- 29:26we can talk about the whole arc of these three chapters a little bit,
- 29:30which is nice. Getting into which real fun Yeah, yeah, very I
- 29:33think it's funny. I think it's funny that we had a woman. We
- 29:37have a lot of women captive plot lines the past three books, yes,
- 29:42or the past few books. Yes. Right, So I thought it was
- 29:45funny that fail just became uncaptured life. Oh oh, because I guess well,
- 29:52okay, So my thought process was either this gets resolved this book,
- 29:56yeah right, because I was like, all right, well, this could
- 30:00be just a climactic moment for Elaine's plotline in this book, in which case
- 30:06this gets resolved pretty quickly because we're running out of time. Or I was
- 30:11like, it's like the duration of Elaine's pregnancy. That was the other thought
- 30:15I had, because I was like, we have this whole thing about Okay,
- 30:21she's not going to be harmed during the pregnancy because the babies and she
- 30:26will be fine. And I was like, but there's like a lot of
- 30:29she goes we're all going to survive this pregnancy. That's the viewing that Manhattan.
- 30:33Yeah, we three specific word you will you will give birth to two?
- 30:40Yeah. I think it's like you will, you will they will be
- 30:42born healthy, You'll have two healthy babies. So She's like, so by
- 30:47that logic, they're gonna I'm gonna be okay until they come to term.
- 30:51And I but we've yeah, we've talked about like much nuances birth, missing
- 30:59your legs, you can give, you can have an involuntary sea section,
- 31:03any numbers. That's the thing. That's one of the things I'm worried about,
- 31:07is like, are we setting her up? Because I just don't believe
- 31:10that Rand and all of his wives survive. Now you've said that, yeah,
- 31:14Yeah, I just I think and I don't think all the two Rivers
- 31:17kids survive. You've said that too. Yeah. So I'm concerned about this,
- 31:22I think. And I'm worried about Land because he's the doomed warrior artist.
- 31:26That is kind of his whole bag. Yeah, and the doomed warrior
- 31:30archetype doesn't always die, but often they do. So I was kind of
- 31:34like, Okay, is this going to be a whole pregnancy issue. And
- 31:37now we've got you know, her being held with her babies. I mean,
- 31:42what a great pond for them to have. Very so I was stressed
- 31:48out. I was really stressed out because I was kind of like, are
- 31:53they going to have her captive? This whole time I was stressed And the
- 32:00answer is no. The answer the answer is she got she gets saved next
- 32:02chapter. She does get saved next chapter. But I was stressed out for
- 32:07these three chapters. Uh so I was really sad that Vandyne died. She
- 32:12has me too. She has a number of meetings. The kN kind of
- 32:15quibble about who's in charge, and then uh, duhara, what is it?
- 32:20Basaheen comes in? Remember her No du horror Basaheen? Yes, red
- 32:27Aja. She's like, what up? Oh yeah, I'm here to be
- 32:29your advisor. Suck my dick. And Elaine is like leaves. Oh,
- 32:35and she's like, maybe you should go fuck yourself. Also, once you,
- 32:38once you finally get on the throne, guess what's gonna happen. We're
- 32:42gonna take your ass back to the tower and then and then paddle your ass
- 32:45for well okay, so she's like, alightah, will forgive you for leaving?
- 32:50Yeah, because Swan, because Swan told you to. But everything else
- 32:52we're gonna smack the shit out. But you pretending to be I sauld die,
- 32:58We're going to make you over that. Yeah. Lene is like I
- 33:00was just like, first of all, she's the fricking queen of and or
- 33:06Well, but it's the whole thing, right, The Umberland seat makes thrones
- 33:08tremble and all that. Yeah, but I just don't feel like the opening
- 33:15to work with me goes over well when you're also like, but we're also
- 33:21going to beat the shit to smack your ass like a drum. Yes,
- 33:23I just feel like this could have been handled. I'm like, where is
- 33:28the grayaja here? Where is where are they? So then she leaves and
- 33:31then uh then made Denny Denny shows up and it's like, hey, hallwn
- 33:37Norri wants to talk. Uugh, she cannot get a moment to herself.
- 33:42No, this is my nightmare. She's of course she's up late pregnancy issues
- 33:46and all that. Hallwd Norri busts in. How's he dressed out? He
- 33:53says something went wrong? No, he's excited. He's brought Hark back.
- 33:57Remember that creepy guy from like eight chapters ago, was like, I didn't
- 34:00the rab the people. I'm fine, and Elne is like, you're a
- 34:04fucking cut person. We could either hang you or we could or you go
- 34:07after David Hamlin drive you directly into the wall. That is David Hanlin.
- 34:12Oh, and Hark survived. Hark made it out, although I don't know,
- 34:15man, it kind of seems like they let him make it out right,
- 34:21that could be. Yes, So Hark comes in, Nori comes in.
- 34:25This is all very suspicious that he survived. Actually, yeah, he
- 34:29goes. I followed him, like you said, my lady, And he's
- 34:31done to the same house three nights counting this one. It's on full Moon
- 34:35Street in the New Shitty. It is only place she ever goes except to
- 34:38havering the common rooms. Yeah, this is total Sorry, I was like
- 34:42very emotionsick during this part. Yeah, yeah, this is totally a trap.
- 34:45He drinks some, he does Dyson's a lot to the man, hesitated
- 34:49dry washing his hands. I can go now, all right, my lady,
- 34:52you'll take off whatever it was you put on me. And they learned
- 34:55that lady Chayanne owns the house, and well, I don't know where they
- 35:00lives there, my lady, but there's there's two eyes to die there tonight.
- 35:04I saw one of them letting Mellar out while the other was coming in,
- 35:07and the one who was coming in said, uh, a pity,
- 35:09there are only two of us, Faalian, No, that's so obvious.
- 35:15No, the way lady Chayne works us only she said lady like she didn't
- 35:19mean it. She did funny. She was carrying a stray cat thing scrowning.
- 35:22She was begging your party. My lady didn't mean no offense speaking of
- 35:25a niceid die that way. But it took me a minute to realize she
- 35:28was. I said, ie, it did. There was There was a
- 35:30good lad from the entry hall. There was, but she was so plain
- 35:32and thin with a wide nose, and nobody could take her for And I
- 35:36said, I we have some study and Elene is like, fuck yeah,
- 35:38man, hell yeah, we got him right where we want him. And
- 35:42yet when in hindsight, yeah, that this was about Marilyn Gamalfin announcing Falian's
- 35:49name to they'd be like, it's good to see you again, Ali,
- 35:52who I live with? Oh yeah, I know the thing about dialogue is
- 35:55that when you write dialogue is that people don't say other's names very almost ever,
- 36:00almost ever, unless they're really trying to emphasize a point. Yeah.
- 36:06So yeah, we say each other's names on the podcast to differentiate from addressing
- 36:10y'all oftentimes, but yeah, most people don't say each other's names very often
- 36:16in a conversation between the two of them. That's very suspicious, yes,
- 36:21and her going Robert Jordan would know that, so yeah, that is very
- 36:23purpose Yeah. A pity there are only two of us. Yeah, I
- 36:28mean, it couldn't be more more obvious that there were more of them.
- 36:31I don't feel. Yeah, I was pretty stressed out during this entire chapter.
- 36:37Yeah, because I was like, I think this is a trap.
- 36:40Oh, and also Failian, in the course of the same conversation, apparently
- 36:45called her Marilyn, so they announced both of their names. Yeah, Elaine,
- 36:52here's what's realistic about this. Elaine is very young, oh god.
- 36:54Yeah, and saw an opportunity dangling in front of her and was so excited
- 37:00about the opportunity that she didn't think it through as much as I think she
- 37:05should have. Yeah. I also think that this thing about like you will
- 37:08be fine until babies come, like, even though she doesn't really talk about
- 37:12that in this chapter, doesn't that's I think that is messing with her brain
- 37:16a little bit, Like I think it is making her make more reckless decisions
- 37:22than she might normally. Now, let me real quick tell you I completely
- 37:25misremembered this part because in my memory, she thinks about the baby's thing and
- 37:31the prophecy and we'll all be okay. The entire time she mentioned is it
- 37:36once in the third chapter after she is captured. Yeah, and I but
- 37:40I think that just because she doesn't mention it right doesn't mean it's not factoring
- 37:45into the equation. I also, I I I feel like she is also
- 37:52desperate for a win in her mind. Oh yeah, I have made some
- 37:59silly decisions before because I am excited about something. Right, you get someone
- 38:05excited enough, especially someone this young, they might not see the forest for
- 38:09the trees, And I think that was their calculus in the past. I
- 38:13have been very hard on a lane for this. But re listening to it
- 38:16this time, I'm like, it's a little dumb, But it's not nearly
- 38:21as dumb as I remembered. I was very unfair previously. I think that,
- 38:25yeah, does she walk into a trap A little bit? Sure,
- 38:29But I think that she it's no worse than any of the traps that Rand
- 38:32has walked into, which there are about seven hundred. No, I don't.
- 38:37Yeah, I think they have. Well, I mean, the girls
- 38:43all walked into a trap of the stone of tear too Yeah, everybody else
- 38:45walked into many Yeah, I feel like they've all walked into trapped. Part
- 38:49of it is. Part of it is I feel this attempt on Robert Jordan's
- 38:53part, which I appreciate. I think some of the things that have happened
- 38:58to them in the past few uh chapters is Robert Jordan's attempt to also make
- 39:04us feel Morrain's absence. Yeah, right, Like some of their silly decision
- 39:08making is because they are young and they're lacking the person that was kind of
- 39:14most guiding them. I mean they have van Deen and uh and carry on
- 39:20it and all of whom are kind of like, we don't want to think
- 39:22it's a good idea and we don't want to go. But because of the
- 39:27Adelius incident, Elaine is not really willing to trust any of them. Right,
- 39:32Well, it's just that decision. Yeah, what just Fandein. She'll
- 39:36trust Fandein. She'll trust Fandein. But we haven't seen a lot of Elaine
- 39:40leaning on van deen in any way. Her mentor right now is Clivier,
- 39:45not Cliverer. What's her name, uh, Dialon Dialon. Dilon's been Elaine's
- 39:51mentor. Yeah, and Serdita tells her not to go. Brigita tells her
- 39:55bring me with you, and Elaine is like, that is dumb as fuck.
- 39:59What are you going to That is fair and say, probably saved Priggych's
- 40:02life. And now it's tough, you know, because on the one hand,
- 40:07we often chastise these characters for not bringing guards, right Rand and the
- 40:14Maidens. On the other hand, in this instance, what the fuck is
- 40:17she gonna do? That's my thing is It's complicated, right because on the
- 40:22one hand, why does Gandalf need a bodyguard? Like we also talk about
- 40:28in magic battles, leave the maidens out of it. Yes, yeah,
- 40:30but in battle battles where there are other people who are not magic trying to
- 40:37get at you also and trying to get at all your people, leaving the
- 40:40maidens behind feels like a dumb decision considering they are badass warrior women who want
- 40:49to fight. Yes, but yeah, if Rand we're going to go face
- 40:52down Samael and Damon Dread, why would you bring the maidens? That's kind
- 40:58of the difference for me. But Damon Dread and Samo also showed up within
- 41:01army. Why would you leave the maidens behind? Because that just makes it
- 41:06possible for when you're not paying attention, someone to launch an arrow at your
- 41:09ass, because you can still, as van Den shows, die by the
- 41:14blade, die by a stray arrow. That can still happen, and so
- 41:17you do need the Maidens watching your back. And that's when I do understand
- 41:22why I get okay the Nuance right, because I know Gandalf has like Aragorn
- 41:25and stuff, but they're not like his official bodyguards, right. They're also
- 41:30the the Fellowship, and Gandalf is quite famously the Astari generally are quite famously
- 41:38lone wandering. Well, I guess the blue ones not really the blue ones
- 41:43hang out in pairs. I didn't know there were blue ones. Yeah,
- 41:45there are blue wizards, brown wizards, gray wizards. Oh wow. This
- 41:49really is Lord of the Rings, isn't it in some ways? But they're
- 41:52also only I think, oh god, there's only like fifteen Astari or something
- 41:55like that. There's not many does radagas, the brown Sarimon Gandolf. I
- 42:00think there's like four blue wizards, but they're off doing other stuff. Sure,
- 42:06it's been a long time since I've read The Silmarillion, But I guess
- 42:08my thing right is that I don't necessarily mind the bodyguard thing, except for
- 42:16I'm like, it just seems to be the women. Yeah, yeah,
- 42:21yeah, I mean we've touched, we talked about that. But then I'm
- 42:24like, I do understand though, the necessity of having a bodyguard because of
- 42:30the stray bullet thing that can still happen. And yeah, right, I
- 42:34get that part where it's like you're busy dealing with the magic fight. I'll
- 42:37deal with the fight fight, and we'll kind of come back in like I
- 42:40see the advantages when you see Lannim or Rain fight together in like the Two
- 42:46Rivers, Right, you see it, You're like, oh, okay,
- 42:49that makes a lot of sense why that is a thing. But in this
- 42:52particular instance, yeah, where it's just magic on magic, it does not
- 42:55make sense to bring Brigita. She's just there to get killed. Then think
- 43:00so hard, Yeah, what is she gonna do? Stab them? Hark
- 43:02tells Elaine about this, and Elaine starts like twerking. She's very excited.
- 43:07She's dancing, and they're like She's like, all right, you're gonna lead
- 43:12us there. The dancing part is very relatable and we're gonna check it out.
- 43:16Yeah, I okay, this is another thing. I'm not sure.
- 43:22I think pregnant women are amazing and can do whatever they want. At the
- 43:28same time, I'm like, girl, you are pregnant with twins. Perhaps
- 43:31punt this to someone else to take care of. We could use a little
- 43:36bit of, you know, star trek the next generation logic. Here the
- 43:42captain doesn't lead the away party. I think, particularly when you are pregnant
- 43:50with twits and the weaves are buttered noodles, you are and you are specifically
- 43:53having a hard time and listen, the infantilization of pregnant women is real,
- 44:00and I get it. At the same time, it is a pretty intense
- 44:05medical condition, you know, we like it's simultaneously one of those things where
- 44:08you're like, you don't want to infantilize the like brains and the minds of
- 44:14and the capabilities of coregnant women. But at the same time you're like,
- 44:17but should you be lifting heavy boxes? It is a medical condition, yeah,
- 44:22but careful, a potentially disabling medical condition well, and also, notably,
- 44:28magically, both things can be true. Magically, she is somewhat disabled
- 44:34by this effective Yes, let's be honest, she is disabled because it's kind
- 44:37of like a coin toss. Now, now here's the fun thing. What
- 44:38I kind of like Rand is also going through this a little bit with the
- 44:43projectile vomiting whenever he grabs the source, right, And I have questioned in
- 44:47the past his willingness to throw himself into things, considering he's the most important
- 44:52person in the world, Like does it always have to be you? So
- 44:58we're going to keep talking about this right after these ads welcome back, and
- 45:16then to talk about the complexities of this once again. I do also,
- 45:20though, believe that if you are asking people to go do dangerous things for
- 45:23you, you should also be willing to do said dangerous things. It's complex
- 45:29stuff. Well, like Brigita shows up and she's like, what the fuck
- 45:30are we doing? And then Van Deen walks in goes, what hair brained,
- 45:35cracked painted scheme are you talking about, Brigita? See? And I
- 45:39think I think the fact that so many people think this is a bad plan
- 45:45makes me go, maybe we reconsider that this may be a really bad plan.
- 45:51I mean, these black as sisters and this is what's complicated for me.
- 45:54On the one hand, very obvious plan, trap trap, right,
- 45:59very obvious. You're pregnant. Everyone's telling you this is a very obvious trap.
- 46:04But I do also understand and get the reluctance during all of this other
- 46:08crap that's happening going, why don't we not just leave them there, have
- 46:14them acquire a you know, bail fire stick or whatever and come for us.
- 46:19Well, I think part of it is they haven't yet. I get
- 46:22that. Yeah, but that doesn't mean they won't. Yeah, but it's
- 46:25also sort of now we know where they are and where they have been for
- 46:30at least three days running, it stands to reason they're probably not going to
- 46:34leave. Why do we reason that because the estate is owned by lady Chayanne.
- 46:40I don't know. I just it's like they've been going there consistently for
- 46:43several days running. There are multiple eyes to die there, and Melar is
- 46:46going there. I don't know. I think it stands to reason they're not
- 46:49going to relocate if they don't think they've been found, I guess, or
- 46:53at least not this very evening. But there's also no guarantee that they won't
- 46:58rally their numbers and come attack. That's true, they know where they are
- 47:01too, the palace, it's the most obvious place in Camelin. Yeah,
- 47:06but I guess my thoughts on that are they could have attacked any time in
- 47:09the last three months or however long it's been. Yeah, I get,
- 47:15I mean yeah, but that doesn't mean they won't. I mean, that
- 47:20could just mean they've been preparing to do that for three months. I agree.
- 47:22I'm just saying I don't think there would be any harm in waiting until
- 47:25tomorrow. Probably not a lot wait till tomorrow. Well, because it's like
- 47:30four in the morning. What advantage will tomorrow bring a little more time to
- 47:34plan? But conversely, it also potentially gives, uh gives time for the
- 47:43fact that she knows that they're there to somehow get at it. That's true,
- 47:45especially if Kryana found out ahead of time. Right. That's the thing
- 47:50is like her acting immediately makes it so that there's no possibility of this information
- 47:59getting back to those people. So I get why she jumps on this.
- 48:04I do. Was it kind of dumb? I mean, hindsight's twenty twenty.
- 48:10Foresight is also twenty twenty in this instance, But I think her assumption
- 48:15was like, well, I know I'm gonna be fine, So if I
- 48:19come for them at this moment in time, and I'm the one who surprises
- 48:23them. Then I get to take out something that has been a loom mating
- 48:29threat that has probably been stressful, that could be a weak point within the
- 48:34city as I am being attacked from without. Yeah, so Vanden is actually
- 48:38into this. She thinks it's a good idea. Brigita hates it, Serifa
- 48:44and Caryana hate it. Ultimately, they bring and she was kind of hoping
- 48:49their reactions to this would reveal something that they both Yeah, they both were
- 48:52posed. They bring fifty guards women along with them, plus all the warders.
- 48:58They don't go in the house obviously, but yeah, again, what
- 49:00are they gonna do? Though? Yeah, I know, I adn't.
- 49:04I feel like they needed to bring all the ice to die they could Jam
- 49:07Sneaks doesn't even sneak. He just like walks into the street to take a
- 49:10look. And Elaine's like, what the fuck? And then Deeen is like,
- 49:13it'd be way more suspicious if he were sneaking. He's doing the put
- 49:16on a hard hat, carry a clipboard and get a reflector vest thing.
- 49:21Act like you belong yeah, act like you're just there checking out the real
- 49:24estate. Elaine links with Saritha Van Deen links with Carryana. Burgita's like,
- 49:31I don't like dars and Elaine is like, I don't care, but yeah
- 49:36they go in. I feel like Brigita and Elaine's relationship is so hard for
- 49:40Burgita. Yeah, of course it is. Brigita like she's been at She's
- 49:46been made a head of the Guard, right, which is something she didn't
- 49:51even want in the first place. She was kind of woke up one day
- 49:55and found out that she was somebody's order, which is kind of rough.
- 50:00Her whole life, you know, has been kind of taken from her at
- 50:04this point. She was punted out of being a hero of the Horn.
- 50:07Now might never reunite with Guide Okaine, and now she's linked forever with or
- 50:13for as long as she's alive to this gal who is like twenty years old
- 50:21making at times interesting decisions, will not listen to her no matter what.
- 50:27Now she's also getting a side dose of pregnancy hormone she never asked for.
- 50:31Brigita has the rawest deal in the books so far. It's interesting because you
- 50:36would think that this would call up memories for Elaine of like Gallat Because Brigita
- 50:42and Elaine to me, feels like a much older sister, much younger sister
- 50:45dynamic. Oh definitely, yeah, definitely, the amount of stress that she
- 50:52feels over the decisions her younger sister is making when she's like, I have
- 50:55so much experience in this stuff, yeah, and you'll are just going to
- 51:00go disregarding Yep, I'm gonna do my own shit. Yeah, it is
- 51:04an older sister young of your sister dynamic. So they go in. Uh
- 51:09uh. Millie Skane is in there chatting with Falian and Marilyn, and they
- 51:14just they just jump them. They just they just fucking pop in and shield
- 51:17them and grab them. And Millie skin goes, what is the meaning of
- 51:21this? I recognize you. You're Elaine Trakande, the daughter heir, but
- 51:24that gives you no right to invade my home. Okay, so Millie Skan
- 51:28recognizes a Laine, yes, but no one ever fucking recognizes more gaze and
- 51:32assault me, and Elaine is like, what up? Now you fucked up?
- 51:37Now you fucked up. Now you fucked up, Now you fucked up.
- 51:40You have fucked up? Now, I just it's the I think the
- 51:49most painful thing for me always is when the plan is going so well and
- 51:52then they get just the cock swept out for all that. Yeah, that's
- 51:57hard. Yeah. They get like excited and they're cocky and you're like,
- 52:00yay, a victory for you, and then it's like a staggering loss of
- 52:05conjol. Actually, so then they get electrocuted by something and they're like,
- 52:07oh fuck, and they get shielded. She would have shouted if she could
- 52:12have, if she thought that Brigita and the others could do more than die
- 52:15for women, Elaine recognized, I mean, I guess they can. As
- 52:19Niza Remine and Tamila Kinda Road Cheesmul fucking Emory and Eldrith john Dar four black
- 52:24sisters. She could have wept. Serretha groan softly and they're like, what
- 52:29the I just yeah, I love I love this switch. I feel like
- 52:38it's a good turn about. I think what I'm just really hoping is that
- 52:45Elaine writes like the nicest apology letter to Brigita after this. I don't think
- 52:51it's gonna happen, but I would like for her to just realize that she
- 52:57needs to start listening to people when they tell her that she just she's Elaine
- 53:02is the queen of bad ideas. I'm just gonna be honest. Let's like,
- 53:06let's let's go, let's go there. You know what, Elaine,
- 53:09Elaine was a fucking idiot this chapter. I get where she's coming from at
- 53:14the same time, but I just feel like, well, I don't know,
- 53:19this was complicated for me. She's like simultaneously was a fucking idiot because
- 53:22you Here's what I wish she had done. Here's the thing. I wish
- 53:25she had recognized that this was an obvious trap. Yeah right, because I
- 53:31don't think she really did. I wish she had gone in her mind.
- 53:35And this is not me saying this about Robert. This is me saying this
- 53:38about Elaine is a character. I'm like, girl, you need to get
- 53:42wiser really fast. You can't be drinking strange people's tea anymore. We're not
- 53:46at that point anymore where we can be like, let's walk willy nilly into
- 53:51these traps. Oh, Wilson Nilsen. It's funny because actually that the red
- 53:58Ada woman from earlier specifically does bring up Randa Mkira, I know, and
- 54:02she keeps making these decisions where I go, we need to understand that there
- 54:09are people trying to get you, even more now that the pregnancy news is
- 54:14out, and I mean, I'm sorry. The first person we're going to
- 54:16assume is that it's rans you two are a scene making out in every corner
- 54:22of the Stone of Tears hasn't gotten back to people. That's why they say
- 54:25that she's such a valuable target, Right, that's part of it. Otherwise,
- 54:30I mean, yeah, I guess daughter heir, but I mean rand
- 54:36is a huge part of it. And everybody thinks they have to know,
- 54:38right, like a David Hanlan thing. Well, first of all, I'm
- 54:43sure that they have talked to David Hanlon. They're like, did you knock
- 54:45up the daughter air Vandor? And he's like no, he's being coy about
- 54:49it because he liked to the Dark Friends. Probably he's an asshole. What
- 54:53purpose would that, sir? All I'm saying is Charles Guybond is right here.
- 54:57You'd be directly fucking them over, like if I look, I know,
- 55:00I know, I agree with you. I'm just saying Charles Gaybon is
- 55:04right there being completely unproblematic, which was Charles Gaybon. He's the guy who's
- 55:07named after a real dude who is just he shows up and he's like,
- 55:10what up? I brought like nine hundred thousand men. How you doing?
- 55:15Do you guys need any help? I feel like that's so funny because when
- 55:20I read that, I was like, this isn't a real person. I
- 55:23looked at the last name, Guybon, and I was like, did he
- 55:27just really go like, eh, guy, it's Charles Gabon is a real
- 55:30person. So funny I was a fantasy name. I just decided that was
- 55:35such a fake. Now Charles Gaybon is explicitly based on and whose wife bid
- 55:42to have a character named out. That's hilarious. I love that. Yeah,
- 55:45because I looked at it and was like, that's the fakest name I've
- 55:49seen. That feels like pant Patson I love. I'm so glad pant Potson
- 55:52gets brought up so often. That is a desert in Malazan. Yeah,
- 55:57but you go, oh, so he was sitting in his kitchen and pot
- 56:00Son, Yeah, yeah, what was I talking about? You were calling
- 56:07Elaine an idiot? Well okay, but I'm like, it's funny. We
- 56:09had opposite react because I read some like, oh, she's way smarter than
- 56:13I thought. She was, like fucking dumb. I think the dumb ass
- 56:20part of this was not realizing that this wasn't I don't think it was dumb
- 56:24to immediately go there, because I'm like, then it doesn't give them any
- 56:29chance to prepare her, which is good. I thought that part was smart,
- 56:32like don't give them any chance because now they know that he's come back
- 56:37and told her this stuff, so like, well, she's gonna come eventually,
- 56:39right, But the immediacy I thought was smart. I wish that she
- 56:44had gone, But this is an obvious trap, so let's make some contingency
- 56:46plans. Yes, that would have been good for that, I think.
- 56:52I think that I acknowledging that this was a clear trap would have been a
- 56:57good thing to do. I think if she had taken two more seconds to
- 57:00think about it. Yeah, and I think you probably, to be fair,
- 57:04could have mobilized more of the guard to like cordon off a perimeter.
- 57:09Well, like, why do we have to go in the house. Why
- 57:13why do we have to go in the house. Why not just blow up
- 57:16the house? There might be other people in the house, perple, good
- 57:20house. Can you just start up muttering people? Blow up the house,
- 57:23murder people? No, i'd but I go. She doesn't want to kill
- 57:29them, she wants to arrest them. Do you have to see people to
- 57:30shield them? Yes, you need to see anything two channel. That's that's
- 57:35part of why we should have doorways and corners. Did it, yes,
- 57:39No, Look, there should have been any significant degree of scouting and reconnoitering
- 57:44done ahead of time. But they're also like, oh, this dude apparently
- 57:47has eyes in the back of his ass, and if we get a scout
- 57:51within three hundred feet of him, they die immediately, which I get.
- 57:52I get that part. I get that part. I many I My only
- 57:58thing is I wish could we have done like the tiniest peep hole gateway to
- 58:02spy on the house. I think that there are a lot of the way
- 58:05peephole gateway that we could have done this more cleverly. I agree with you
- 58:12there. I think that the lack of backup and contingency plan was quite badly
- 58:15done. I just wish. Okay, I liked that they shielded them immediately.
- 58:21Great, we have them, let's explore the rest to the house.
- 58:24Let's anticipate that they might have there might be more than just two. Considering
- 58:29they made a point to say that there were only two of them in front
- 58:31of the spy, why would they talk so loudly about that. I don't
- 58:37know. I think the immediacy was correct. I think we should have taken
- 58:42two more seconds to go, what if this is something they want us to
- 58:47do and we're being walking into a trap. I agree it's hard because the
- 58:58more people you mobilize, Yeah, the more morbility there, the more visibility
- 59:00there is, the more that this could leak out. I don't know.
- 59:05I don't think she was an idiot. I should refrain. Could have been
- 59:08better, could have we could have benessed this a smidge more. I think
- 59:14this reminds me most of that time when Rand was like, you know what
- 59:16I'm gonna do. I'm gonna go clear up this whole fucking Kyrie Ane and
- 59:21Rebellion in the Woods thing because I'm having a real good day. Taveran's on
- 59:24my side. I'm gonna bust in and be like, hello, Caroline,
- 59:29Damadred. This is what that reminds me of. Accept I do actually think
- 59:31Elaine is being smarter about it than Rand was. Which part was that one?
- 59:35Was this? When Fane stabbed him the second time and oh yeah,
- 59:37Bob showed up, that was a very obvious trap as well. That was
- 59:40even a trap. That was a trap. Rand just like walked into the
- 59:45enemy camp like, hello, my name is band Al Gore. That was
- 59:49that was a choice that he did make. Yeah, yeah, No,
- 59:52you're right. I think I think Elaine was much smarter in this moment than
- 59:57Rand was in that one. I think that so her inability to anticipate the
- 1:00:02trappiness of this. It's that thing of like when you hear something that's too
- 1:00:07good to be true, it kind of is yes, And I think in
- 1:00:12that way she failed to make any kind of congestion like could they have not
- 1:00:15I mean, Van Dene's been spending all this time with these what of a
- 1:00:21knitting circle goal the kin gals. Ye, maybe we could have brought some
- 1:00:24of them along, that'd be good and had them wait outside. That'd be
- 1:00:29good because we brought all these other these guards and shit who are going to
- 1:00:32be fundamentally useless in this situation. I mean, I guess they do come
- 1:00:37through more. Yeah, at the cost of hundreds of lives, which could
- 1:00:43we not have just brought the can in drop the kin on Brigita also does
- 1:00:46specifically set it up so that these soldiers walk directly into a meat grinder,
- 1:00:52so that the c folk will feel bad and help, which I have thoughts
- 1:00:58a little bit. I understand why she did it. I don't totally disagree
- 1:01:01with it. Don't we have evidence to suggest that the Kin are completely non
- 1:01:06not bad, like they're not. As far as we know, the Black
- 1:01:10Aja had no knowledge of the Kin. However, the Kin also don't really
- 1:01:16know combat weaves? Do they not a shield? Yes? And that is
- 1:01:22very true that all the c folks really do. They drop one lightning bolt
- 1:01:24on asny and then they shield and gag everyone else. Yeah. I think
- 1:01:30I think we could have anticipated the trappiness. We know Van Deine has been
- 1:01:35spending a lot of time with the can right and I know, I mean
- 1:01:38she was suspicious to me. But their leader just got murdered by probably Black
- 1:01:45Aja, So they're going to be inclined to help. They already have been
- 1:01:47inclined to help if if your isid die, they want to help. So
- 1:01:52I think that's part of the concern is that they won't be able to attack
- 1:01:54the black Adja isid die because like, oh, but their isid I because
- 1:01:58in the past, when did the five six story house thing, they were
- 1:02:01like, oh, what do we do? What do we do what do
- 1:02:04we Admittedly, that was four books ago. That was four books ago,
- 1:02:07and their leader was still alive. Their leader had not been killed by Black
- 1:02:09Auja. Yes, I feel like the the and ninety didn't have a come
- 1:02:14to Jesus with them about the fact that they don't need to listen to Isidie
- 1:02:17all the time. Yeah, I think I think they And I don't know
- 1:02:21if that was this group, Yeah it was, it was, Okay,
- 1:02:23so their attitude has to shifted a little. All you need to do is
- 1:02:28do a little rallying cry of like all we're looking to do is shield them,
- 1:02:30yeah, and take them captive. Yeah. I And then I think
- 1:02:36you go in with like you're you basically do exactly the same this is it'd
- 1:02:40be the Spider Man meme, Right, you do the exact same thing they
- 1:02:44wanted to do, which was because I think the the context of what their
- 1:02:50plan was is there, like say really loudly to because we know that David
- 1:02:55Hanlin knows that Elaine is having him followed. Yes, it stands to reason
- 1:03:00then that anything that this spy is able to pick up might have been on
- 1:03:07purpose. So and even if it weren't, right, I feel like it
- 1:03:10would take like ten seconds, like ten extra minutes to mobilize all the kid
- 1:03:15Right, we take ten extra minutes to go grab them as quickly as possible.
- 1:03:19Right, We give them a four to one one. We say our
- 1:03:22plan is this group of like three or four. However many four go in.
- 1:03:29They see that the daughter air is there. They're excited because they think
- 1:03:31their trap has been sprung. Worst case scenario, we've mobilized you for no
- 1:03:36reason. Right, best case scenario, they have more come in and do
- 1:03:40this little oopsie daisy trap. You all come in and do the exact same
- 1:03:45oopsy daisy trap. Don't The kN also have a woman who is specifically really
- 1:03:52really good at shields. Yes, the one that can stretch the shields.
- 1:03:55Yeah, I forgot about that. I'm like, why aren't we using her?
- 1:03:59The toys are there, the chess pieces are there. I think that
- 1:04:02she needed to take this. And this is true of a lot of people.
- 1:04:06Right, they go on their first impulse and yes, we did need
- 1:04:10to go tonight. Here's another thing, by the way, carry Ona.
- 1:04:13When she's like we shouldn't do this, she goes, I've never been called
- 1:04:15a coward, but I don't fancy trying to sneak up on someone who might
- 1:04:18have a rob that can make bail fire. That's valid, and Elaine goes,
- 1:04:24he could hardly have misheard something as simple as there are only two of
- 1:04:27us, and they spoke be ause if they didn't expect any others in this
- 1:04:31case, you don't even need the wind Finders. And if you do need
- 1:04:34the wind Finders, then you go to them and you go, I'll make
- 1:04:36an additional deal whatever it is they don't really even talk about. I think
- 1:04:42part of well, because I'm trying to figure out, so you do.
- 1:04:45You say to the wind Finders, we'll give you these people as as teachers
- 1:04:49like, and you can do unto them, the no, the the black
- 1:04:54Aja. Yeah, you do unto them what we did to mcghettion. Ugh,
- 1:04:59that'd be rough, doable, but rough well, I mean, paren
- 1:05:00just did that with a freaking Shidoh. I guess we're not above war crimes.
- 1:05:05I saw this true. It's great TikTok about How's the Dragon? Where
- 1:05:10it was like, it's not about who's right or who's wrong, or Team
- 1:05:14this or team that, It's about who's your favorite war criminal. And I
- 1:05:17think that's true. The wheel of time as well. This applies because at
- 1:05:20this point we're all war criminals, right, It's about who's your favorite war
- 1:05:25criminal, and Elaine is one of my favorite war criminals. And so therefore,
- 1:05:30yeah, because I think the meat grinder thing was was not the solution
- 1:05:34to this problem. Well, it's rough, it's terrible, it's needless and
- 1:05:40unnecessary. And if I were in that army, I leave. Hundreds of
- 1:05:44people are getting incinerated and disintegrated. I believe a horsehead flew daintily, which
- 1:05:50I was like, Wow, what a sentence. Now I love reading this
- 1:05:55part. It is really interesting. But I yeah, you're right, they
- 1:05:59very much could have used the KIN in the initial plan. Yeah, and
- 1:06:02I think that they don't know combat waves as well. But also, what
- 1:06:06have we been doing with the kin if not teaching them combat waves? Why
- 1:06:10have we not been teaching them combat waves? I think Elaine kind of forgot
- 1:06:15about the can is the answer. We cannot be forgetting about the kid.
- 1:06:18Elaine also is like they don't have the oaths, they're extra useful. Elaine
- 1:06:24or Brigita is also like, oh I don't want to you know, I
- 1:06:27want to keep them clear of all the violence and bloodshed. Impossible, it's
- 1:06:30the apothegy. Yeah, that's true, impossible and silly. Yeah, it's
- 1:06:32as silly as what RAN's doing with the Maidens, to be honest, If
- 1:06:35that's true, impossible and silly. Also their leader was just brutally murdered.
- 1:06:43Yeah. Yeah, so I think they would be game to be involved because
- 1:06:46you can go, here's your ability to get retribution. In chapter thirty three,
- 1:06:51when the wind Finders are they drop one lightning bolt. She goes a
- 1:06:56lightning strike. It appeared she hoped Brigita had managed to involve the Finders.
- 1:07:00Unlikely, as that seemed the time would come when the kin would have to
- 1:07:03use the power. As the time is now, no one could stand aside
- 1:07:06from Tarm and Guiden, but correct let them preserve their innocence a little longer.
- 1:07:11No, First of all, these are grown ass women. These are
- 1:07:15not children. Yeah, Like it'd be one thing if they were like thirteen
- 1:07:18year old girls, but these are grown ass women. I also, I
- 1:07:21have to think, as essentially vigilante channelers in Abu Dhar and other places,
- 1:07:29I have to think some of the can have used the power defensively before.
- 1:07:33It's they're from Abu Dhar. Yeah, what innocence, I know, ma'am.
- 1:07:40Yeah, they're not tinkers, no, ma'am, ma'am. Okay,
- 1:07:44we needed this is the thing. We needed ten extra breaths. And I
- 1:07:46think this is true of most plans. That's yeah, right, Like I
- 1:07:49think, especially when you're young, you jump into like your first impulse and
- 1:07:55your first instinct, and her first instinct wasn't wrong. She just needed to
- 1:08:00take five minutes to really breathe in what's happening and really examine it from all
- 1:08:05angles. Yeah. I think that's where like Moraine would have been useful here
- 1:08:11because she's so good at that why Van Dee? And I think Van Deen
- 1:08:15didn't do it because Van Deen is so grief stricken and eager for revenge that
- 1:08:21again, that carrot gets dangled in front of her and she completely loses the
- 1:08:28big picture. And the big picture is that why would this hospital, Why
- 1:08:31would this spy survive over everybody else? Yeah? Right, why would the
- 1:08:38spy survive over everybody else? People who might have been trained to be spies.
- 1:08:43But this guy's like a random person from the street. Well, it's
- 1:08:45kind of the it's the Vannin thing, right, And Yeah, that might
- 1:08:49be true, that he might be the best one because he's from the streets,
- 1:08:53right, But we also have to consider the possibility that, like,
- 1:08:59what are the awe that he'd get such a perfect conversation right in front of
- 1:09:02him. It's a little when they know they're being followed, and that they
- 1:09:06would have this conversation on the front porch, on the front porch and identify
- 1:09:12one another by name on the front porch when they are known black odjects and
- 1:09:15say how many are in this house? That is a little sucks. Regardless
- 1:09:18of whether or not that is true, I think that the preparation needed to
- 1:09:23be that this could have been planted on purpose. I think the preparation should
- 1:09:28always be this could also be a trap, So how can we Because yes,
- 1:09:32the instinct to go immediately I think was the correct one, that was
- 1:09:36the correct decision. But I think we needed fifteen minutes to summon everybody,
- 1:09:41because if we had the amount of time it took to summon an army of
- 1:09:45people to go, we had time to get the kid. Yeah, we
- 1:09:47had time. Yeah, and the army is much more useless. I know
- 1:09:53Robert Jordan loves his armies and loves these moments of like let's introduce like Vietnam
- 1:10:00trauma, to to to England. Like, I get that that is the
- 1:10:03the thing that he that's his, that's his the thing that's burning in him,
- 1:10:11and I don't want to take that away. And I do think you
- 1:10:13know, at the end of the day, if we pull away from the
- 1:10:15text, the reason he did it this way is probably because he wanted to
- 1:10:18do another one of these battle scenes. He wanted to moment. Yeah,
- 1:10:23that's fine, it's a great moment. Yeah. And I'm not I'm just
- 1:10:27like thinking about it in terms of Elaine is a character, and I'm like,
- 1:10:31how could she have had a little more acumen in this situation, shown
- 1:10:36a little more? Yeah, thought because I think that the loss of life
- 1:10:42here, from a narrative standpoint, was what Robert Jordan wanted and that's completely
- 1:10:46fair. But if I'm like living in this world, yeah, and I'm
- 1:10:50thinking about it as if these people were real, right, I think Elaine
- 1:10:56needs to work smarter, yes, not hard, yes, And I think
- 1:11:00she needs to start anticipating that she and the rest of these kids needs to
- 1:11:05start anticipating that there are traps in this world that like sometimes something that feels
- 1:11:12certain. We have to have a contingency plan for if that plan goes awry.
- 1:11:17I mean, we saw it with Rant, We've seen it with Rant,
- 1:11:20We've seen it with Elaine, We've seen it with Agwain. With the
- 1:11:26we have to be anticipating that people are willing to betray us, yeah,
- 1:11:30and that things can be traps. We have to stop accepting strange tea.
- 1:11:33We have to just get a little smarter here, even though we are in
- 1:11:36our teens or early twenties. We have to start being like, if it
- 1:11:42is too good to be true, it might be. Let's anticipate that this
- 1:11:45could be too good to be true, that our ability to exact revenge may
- 1:11:49be dangled in front of us for a reason. Notably, Millie's skin didn't
- 1:11:55expect all these other Isidie to show up, so that oh these oh really?
- 1:12:00Yeah, Millie Skane says, you have my thanks for your timely rescue,
- 1:12:03but do you have a reason for coming here tonight? Did Mara didn't
- 1:12:06send you m so? I think said I were in on it, Billie
- 1:12:13Skane was not. This is interesting because again, when we think about survivor,
- 1:12:19the person not in on the plan is in the bottom of the alliance.
- 1:12:23So it's interesting because we it seemed as though Millie Skane had a bit
- 1:12:27of the power position because she drowned that one Carrett Jacob Carrottan, and she
- 1:12:32has you know, enacted some brutalities to put it mildly, onto Failian right
- 1:12:41with Failian that she kind of gave to David Hamlin, which I so you
- 1:12:48would think that she is in the power position over these other people, but
- 1:12:55the fact that she has been left out of this plan suggests otherwise. Her
- 1:13:00position in this group is very shaky. Yeah, because of that a little
- 1:13:03bit. Uh, I'm interested in that. Well, now they're all captive
- 1:13:08anyway, m hm. So to Mila goes Elaine's the only one we need.
- 1:13:14I'd enjoy playing with the others, but they're active for now, because
- 1:13:16I mean, if we know anything about captive Black Asia, they get out,
- 1:13:20they either get saying they will I'm saying that does happen a lot.
- 1:13:25Well, they either get out or they get brutally murdered by somebody. I'd
- 1:13:29enjoy playing with the others, but they'd be a burden we don't need if
- 1:13:31you're going to kill them. Marilyn said, as they're discussing the price of
- 1:13:34bread, spare Carryana. She is one of us annient for Carryana, that
- 1:13:40they knew that a gift from Adelius. Vanden murmured, and carry Ona's eyes
- 1:13:44went very wide. Her mouth opened, but no sound came out. Mandein
- 1:13:47was like, I don't need any more confirmation than that. The two women
- 1:13:50sagged and fell to the carpet. Vandeen began trying to push herself up,
- 1:13:54but Carriana lay staring at the ceiling, the hiddle to van Deen's belt knife
- 1:13:58protruding from beneath her breastbone. The glows surrounded Cheesmol, and she touched Vanden
- 1:14:01with a complex weave of fire, earth and water. The white haired woman
- 1:14:05collapsed as if her bones had melted. The same weave, fitting that Chesmul
- 1:14:10killed them, considering she is the yellow Ajia. The same weave touched Saitha,
- 1:14:14and she pulled a lane down atop her as she fell. Siretha's eyes
- 1:14:17were already glazing. Their waters will be coming now, chees Mal said,
- 1:14:23a little more killing to do. It does say more positive things about Varren
- 1:14:26at this point. For me, that the show combined Vandein and Varren and
- 1:14:32no one seemed to throw a big fit over it. Yeah, sure,
- 1:14:36which again seems to suggest to me that Varin is whatever alignment Vanden is,
- 1:14:44because otherwise, you know, Twitter, we would have seen some level of
- 1:14:48outrage over it if that could not have been a smooth combination. The dog
- 1:14:53is wagging his tail in a sleep, is what that is. You are
- 1:14:56also assuming that people care about Vandin, people care about true people are outraged
- 1:15:01over his changed from his characters. We don't need to get into all that.
- 1:15:06I'm just saying, No, that's a good point, that small details,
- 1:15:10and I'm not I'm not harshing anybody's vibe on that. You know,
- 1:15:14if that detail matters to you. Yeah, details are good, like whatever,
- 1:15:17like what bike and don't like whatever you want. But I feel like
- 1:15:21if that had been such a huge diversion, I'm just looking for clues wherever.
- 1:15:29I sure, you know what, keep it up, because I'm really
- 1:15:31unsure about Varon at space. It's fun, isn't it. Well? If
- 1:15:34Van Deden is good, then that says good things about Varren. Pot We're
- 1:15:41actually gonna we're gonna cut it here. We're we're we're we're a little tight
- 1:15:45for time this week, and we're gonna do the other two chapters either next
- 1:15:47week or the week after, depending on if episode eight coverage is done.
- 1:15:51Uh, we're working on it. This whole episode was just how I would
- 1:15:56have done it differently. Well, no, not like, not me as
- 1:16:00a writer, but me, if I were Elaine, if I did it
- 1:16:03how I if Yeah? Yeah, if it were me. Uh, how
- 1:16:10would I have girl bossed this? Why? I'm smarter than a lad.
- 1:16:15But I get it. I get where she's coming from. She's young,
- 1:16:17and you know, pity, sweet sweet thing. It's so loud, such
- 1:16:24a big tale, darling. It's like a weapon. Yeah, they're going
- 1:16:28to be like we didn't really talk about the books. We just talked about
- 1:16:30Ali's feelings. Listen, just flodding, Elaine, Pete, Mike, God,
- 1:16:36maybe he's dreaming about us. I hope he is dreaming about all of
- 1:16:41you. Was girl bossing too close to the sun. That is the conclusion.
- 1:16:45That is the conclusion. And now she is captive for for the next
- 1:16:49chapter, and then she'll be fine. She's so lucky she has Bergita.
- 1:16:53I'm very excited for the next chapters soon because you know who else we get
- 1:16:58to talk about next time. Sylvas remember Silva, no Pete. Okay,
- 1:17:04okay, you remember you don't remember Sylvas. No, you remember a creepy
- 1:17:10old man who who thought Aera Milla was his daughter and his granddaughter, not
- 1:17:15Sylvia. No, no, no, no, no. Sylvas is his
- 1:17:17granddaughter who always like acts really stupid. Yes, I love her. She
- 1:17:23shows up. You read this chapter? Oh right, she shows up.
- 1:17:25He's like, what up? He's dead? Uh? Fuck you guys,
- 1:17:28I'm tim Olane. Yay, I love her. No, I completely missed
- 1:17:32that. I forgot who she was. Well, you'll have to review that
- 1:17:35because I love that part. Because I love that. I think that is
- 1:17:39the one problem about, like, you know, yes, reading a chapters
- 1:17:43at a time, is that you do sometimes forget people. Yay, I
- 1:17:45like Sylvas. Yeah. Unfortunately, she then volunteers to have her torturer,
- 1:17:48uh be the supervisor for Ara, Mila, n And and Elenia. But
- 1:17:53you know whatever, we'll get to that one anyway. Cross everge. Thanks
- 1:17:57for listening. Everyone. We have social media if you want to know what
- 1:17:59we've got going on. We've also got a up podcast. We've also got
- 1:18:00a Patreon it's linked down below. It's patreon dot com, slash wheel takes
- 1:18:03and we have merch stories and you can also leave us a rating in a
- 1:18:05review if you want, which helps a lot. Other than that anything else,
- 1:18:08Elly, If I were in charge, this would have been free books.
- 1:18:14Thanks for listening everyone, Bye bye