Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Citadel (1938)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Today we are covering yet
- 0:23another film of the 11th Oscar year? That's right.
- 0:29And I was gonna ask you, when you saw The White
- 0:33Parade, did you think that that was one of the
- 0:36only hospital -related films that you would be
- 0:40seeing for this? No, no. Because you knew, like,
- 0:44One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest is to come. Sure,
- 0:46yeah, yeah. Not a very long list. I think there's
- 0:51a lot of movies about doctors, and I think that
- 0:53that's remained true even in the short period
- 0:56of time that we've covered on the show. Louis
- 0:57Pasteur, sure. Yeah. Aerosmith as well, I would
- 1:01say, as a doctor. Oh, yeah. I would also say
- 1:03that. You know who else would? Him. Yes, that's
- 1:06right. Yeah, he would. His wife wouldn't. Spoiler
- 1:11alert. Yeah. But I think that this is kind of
- 1:13a very common topic and especially one you could
- 1:17almost argue that a story about. I'm sorry. Would
- 1:20you say his wife wouldn't say that because she's
- 1:21dead or. That was the joke. OK. Yeah. Just making
- 1:25sure. That's the one. Because, again, what she
- 1:28was exposed to. Wasn't it the plague? The plague
- 1:32that fell on her toast. What was it? It was.
- 1:35I don't think it was. It was a cigarette. The
- 1:37cigarette. Yes, yes, yes, yes. So... Plague toast
- 1:41is rough. Don't you... I would argue that a plague
- 1:44cigarette is not much better. Don't you hate
- 1:46that? Cinnamon toast plague. Don't you hate that?
- 1:49More bubonic in every bite. Some plague on your
- 1:52cigarette? Yeah. It's the worst. It's like, as
- 1:54if they're not bad enough already, now we got
- 1:57the plague on the end of our cigarette? Jeez.
- 2:01There's two Surgeon General warnings. There's
- 2:03like, oh, nicotine's really bad for you, also
- 2:05the plague. Hey, good news. You don't have cancer.
- 2:10Bad news. You got the plague. Oh, man. What was
- 2:15I saying? Oh, doctors. Yeah, I think that you
- 2:18can almost argue that a story about a doctor
- 2:21at this point is kind of the way like a biopic
- 2:24is kind of like your quote unquote Oscar bait
- 2:27movie. Yeah. You make a movie about a real life
- 2:30doctor or at least one that exists like in the
- 2:33real world and isn't super fictionalized. you're
- 2:37probably going to have an appearance at the Oscars,
- 2:39especially if you have a solid performance like
- 2:42the one Robert Donut. Not Donut. Robert Donut
- 2:46is giving here. It's morning time, and I really
- 2:50want something sweet. That's all that was. It
- 2:52was a little fruity and slip. Yeah, so Robert
- 2:56Duncan Donut is doing something in this movie.
- 3:00Yeah, I'm... I mean this truly. I think I say
- 3:03this at the beginning of most episodes, but I
- 3:05am really excited to talk about this one with
- 3:07you. I didn't have much interest or interest,
- 3:10much knowledge on the Citadel before this. And
- 3:14sometimes when we're going through the list of
- 3:16movies that we're going to cover, I look at the
- 3:19title and I have a little bit of woo boy. Right.
- 3:23Where I'm like, OK, so what are we covering?
- 3:25We're covering Jezebel. Cool. I own that one.
- 3:26What's this one? The Citadel. It's like, oh,
- 3:29no. Yeah. I want to cover some, like, you know,
- 3:331700s, like, you know, some movie that I don't
- 3:37understand anything about this. I'm going to
- 3:40be completely lost. That wasn't this. No. I was
- 3:44very interested and just knew nothing about it.
- 3:48So let's dive right into it. We're talking about
- 3:50The Citadel today. The Citadel has four nominations.
- 3:54They are Adapted Screenplay. This is for Ian
- 3:56Dalrymple, Elizabeth Hill, and Frank Weed. Actor
- 4:00in a leading role. This was Robert Duncan Donut
- 4:03as Dr. Andrew Manson. God. Director King Vador
- 4:08makes his return. Yeah, he does. In outstanding
- 4:11production, this was for Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer
- 4:14MGM. MGM. Here we are talking once again about
- 4:18an MGM film nominated for Best Picture. Who would
- 4:20have thought? I need to make that tally and see
- 4:24who holds the record. It's obviously MGM, but
- 4:26I want to know by how much. You know what we
- 4:28should honestly do? Uh, at the beginning of this
- 4:30recording, you should message Bryce and just
- 4:32tell him, give me a tally. Yeah. Don't look it
- 4:34up. Just give me a tally. And I'm sure he's going
- 4:36to have free before the end of this recording.
- 4:38He probably already has it. He's like, let me
- 4:40just grab my file. Yeah. Let me, let me open
- 4:43up like my physical filing cabinet. He doesn't
- 4:46even make it digital. He's like physical media.
- 4:49It's worth noting that there is an episode for
- 4:51this year that we have not been able to watch
- 4:55just yet. Yeah. And we are going to be able to
- 4:58watch it because we just told Bryce, hey, we
- 5:00can't find it. And he's like, I got you, dog.
- 5:02Yeah. And he just sent us a copy. So thank you,
- 5:06Bryce, friend and fan of the podcast, friend
- 5:09first and foremost, for helping us watch all
- 5:12these movies. Yeah, we legitimately wouldn't
- 5:15be able to do it without you. Yeah, legitimately.
- 5:17Thank you, dude. But yes, directed by King Vidor.
- 5:21We have spoken about him before with The Champ.
- 5:25Which I think we both were pretty sweet on for
- 5:28the most part. Yeah, I think that was, you know,
- 5:30the honeymoon period of Wallace Beery. Yeah.
- 5:32And we really liked his performance in it. And
- 5:35also we were still a little high on Little Jackie
- 5:38Cooper from Skippy. I still like Little Jackie
- 5:41Cooper. Yeah. I've never lost. We haven't given
- 5:43much of a chance to, you know. No. And he's getting
- 5:46so big now, you know. He's, he's. Can you imagine
- 5:49saying that about someone who's been nominated
- 5:51for an Oscar? You're getting so big now. Yeah.
- 5:54Well. When you're a kid, you grow. You grow up.
- 5:57You just wouldn't say that to him like that.
- 5:59Well, I wouldn't say it to Jackie Cooper. I wouldn't
- 6:02call him little Jackie Cooper. That doesn't change
- 6:04the fact that he's not growing out of the little
- 6:06phase. Do you think you should do that with all
- 6:09little Bow Wow, little John? Now he's Bow Wow.
- 6:13Little Romeo? Is he just Romeo? Oh, I don't know
- 6:16about them. But little Bow Wow is definitely
- 6:18Bow Wow now. I think he was after Roll Bounce.
- 6:21So with LL Cool J. Yeah. Do you know what that
- 6:24stands for? Lil Cool J. Nope. Ladies Love Cool
- 6:28James. Oh, really? Yeah. Ladies Love LL Cool
- 6:32J James. So do you think now we should call him,
- 6:36what is it, Ladies Are Lukewarm on Cool J? I
- 6:42thought you were going to say. L -A -L -O. Lalo.
- 6:48Lalo Cool J. I thought you were going to say,
- 6:51Ladies Love Jackie Cooper. And I was like, that
- 6:53might be true. I don't know. Okay, hold on. Lalo
- 6:58is lukewarm. Wait, is lukewarm one word or two?
- 7:01It's one word. It's one word. So it's Lalo. So
- 7:04Lalo Cool J, that's a great idea. We have to
- 7:07talk about the movie. Ladies are lukewarm on
- 7:11Cool J. Jeez. Cool James. Tay's going to love
- 7:14that. Tay's going to love the hell out of that.
- 7:16Robert Donat. Plays Dr. Andrew Mason. And I'm
- 7:19going to struggle with his name, I think, throughout
- 7:21the entirety of this episode. You just say Robert.
- 7:23Yeah, Robert. Robert. Never mind. Rosalind Russell
- 7:29makes her first appearance on the podcast as
- 7:31Christine Barlow. Also starring in this film
- 7:34is Ralph Richardson as Dr. Philip Denny. And
- 7:37Rex Harrison as Dr. Frederick Walford. Walford,
- 7:40yeah. Walford, okay. Are you doing that giant
- 7:43worm thing on TikTok? Robert. Robert. Help me,
- 7:47Robert. I don't like that thing. Yeah. Okay,
- 7:51I do know what you're doing then. I just wasn't
- 7:53sure. Robert. Yeah, so this is based on a novel
- 7:56by A .J. Cronin. Came out in 1937. Sure did.
- 8:00So the Citadel went a very long way in changing
- 8:02some things for the hospital, or the medical
- 8:06field, I'll say. Not a ton of knowledge on this
- 8:11prior to seeing this movie. Again, with a name
- 8:14like The Citadel, I did not anticipate what it
- 8:16ended up being. I had no idea. It's such a misleading
- 8:18title. It is. So here is the general synopsis
- 8:23of at least the film, The Citadel. Andrew Manson
- 8:28has decided to be a doctor and has started practicing
- 8:31where he can, and he is being frustrated time
- 8:35and time again with learning that he can't just
- 8:38practice medicine the way that he wants to and
- 8:39take care of people because he is finding that
- 8:42the medical field is more nuanced and that there
- 8:45have been shortcuts taken to instead make the
- 8:47profession easier on the practicing doctors than
- 8:51it is on the Hippocratic Oath that they have
- 8:53taken. And he is navigating that while also navigating
- 8:56romance with his wife, played by Rosalind Russell
- 9:01as Christine, or Chris, as he calls her. Yeah.
- 9:05So, I want to go ahead and say this. I had no
- 9:10idea what this movie was going to do. I think
- 9:13we talked about movies like The Story of Louis
- 9:16Pasteur. We've talked about Aerosmith, and Aerosmith
- 9:20we both liked a lot. Story of Louis Pasteur,
- 9:22not so much. We thought the performances were
- 9:24good, specifically that of Paul Muni, but not
- 9:27really much else beyond that. So as soon as it
- 9:30became clear that this was more a movie about
- 9:32a doctor, I was a little concerned. I was like,
- 9:34oh no, we just got Louis Pasteur. Here's their
- 9:37response to it. This movie, and this is complimentary,
- 9:40almost has no business being nominated for a
- 9:43Best Picture, because it isn't as interested.
- 9:46in things like the story of Louis Pasteur, where
- 9:48it's like, look at the importance of this. And
- 9:50it is more, we made a movie about this time period,
- 9:53about this subject matter, and we just happened
- 9:55to make, for the first half at least, a romantic
- 9:58comedy about this. And I will say that I don't
- 10:03know who Robert Donat is. How did I butcher his
- 10:08name, but you had trouble with Donat and I had
- 10:10trouble with Robert? Robert. They can't pronounce
- 10:15my name, Robert. They think my last name is a
- 10:18donut, Robert. I can't have sugar, Robert. Anyone
- 10:23not knowing what that is is just going to be
- 10:25like it's a fever dream. I don't know much about
- 10:29Robert Donut. Uh, but what I can tell you is
- 10:31that I was infatuated with his performance in
- 10:33this movie. He's so good. He is. And it's not
- 10:36even like, you know, oh, you're one of the best
- 10:38actors I've ever seen. It's just, you have made
- 10:40a character that I just want to spend as much
- 10:41time with as possible. Yeah. And there is humor
- 10:44in this movie. There is such a, is he Scottish?
- 10:47I think. I think so. He is Scottish. And there's
- 10:51such a levity in his performance, a levity in
- 10:54the way that he talks with people. It's almost
- 10:56like he has found a way to blend a Cary Grant.
- 10:59I'm not saying he's that debonair. But he's found
- 11:01a way to blend a Cary Grant with an Edward Everett
- 11:05Horton in terms of the facial expressions that
- 11:08he makes, the way that he kind of interrupts
- 11:10himself with a stammer when he feels like he's
- 11:12kind of blindsided by something that someone
- 11:14said. He is kind of all over the place in a good
- 11:19way. Right, right. Sorry. Right, right. Sorry.
- 11:22I thought you were like, hold on, dog fight.
- 11:24There are dogs fighting outside, but we're fine.
- 11:27They heard us talking about Jackie Cooper again.
- 11:29We're like, please don't shoot my neighbor's
- 11:32dog. It is, it's wild how much I like this. I
- 11:38like this a lot. Yes. And it is just the fact
- 11:42in, you know, I talked about one of my favorite
- 11:43movies of last year being. Oh, should I have
- 11:46done this as my double feature instead? It's
- 11:48already done. The Ballad of Wallace Island. Oh,
- 11:51yeah, yeah. I remember you talking about that.
- 11:52I loved that movie. And it was just because it
- 11:54is charming. And this movie is charming as well.
- 11:58It isn't always charming throughout, but at least
- 12:00for that first hour, you see a lot of Dr. Manson
- 12:05being very... not self -aware. And then he kind
- 12:10of catches it immediately. You see him kind of
- 12:12like baffled at certain things, but also the
- 12:14cast of characters that he meets. He really starts
- 12:17blending in with like Denny, one of the other
- 12:19doctors that he meets. And this movie is just
- 12:22so at times whimsical and so funny and so interesting.
- 12:27And then it also goes to really dark places.
- 12:29And it is a movie that is a cautionary tale of
- 12:32where we were at. Some would argue where we currently
- 12:36still are with medical practices. So I really
- 12:40enjoyed The Citadel. How did you feel? Yeah,
- 12:43no, I was the same way where I said, oh, this
- 12:46is a movie about a doctor. We've done this so
- 12:48many times now in some ways and in ways we've
- 12:52enjoyed a lot and in other ways where we're like,
- 12:54I can do without this. And this really surprised
- 12:58me. Robert Donat is so good in this. He really
- 13:02is charming. He reminds me. Even in the way he
- 13:05looks of that Christmas movie where it's a bunch
- 13:10of different people. Love Actually? Love Actually.
- 13:13The guy that is writing the story or whatever.
- 13:17Colin Firth. He reminds me of Colin Firth. Oh,
- 13:19that's a great comp. Yes. Oh, yeah. He looks
- 13:23so much like him. Ziggy also said that he looked
- 13:26like Gary Sinise a little bit. Yeah. Which I
- 13:28thought was interesting. I see that too. And
- 13:30I love Gary Sinise. He's a little tall for Colin
- 13:32Firth, but I see Gary Sinise in his facial expressions.
- 13:36But man, he was just so endearing and entertaining
- 13:41and real in this. So it does kind of feel whimsical
- 13:45at times because it's very lighthearted when
- 13:47the movie first starts. And there's a naivety
- 13:51to his character that is a little infectious.
- 13:55You're like, oh, this is cool. Like, I like that
- 13:56he is a new doctor that wants to do good. He
- 14:01wants to be that doctor who is there for the
- 14:04people and who helps people. And I think that
- 14:07in a story where he becomes more jaded when he
- 14:12learns more about the medical field and how corrupt
- 14:16it is at times, following that journey would
- 14:19normally bring me down and I would just be like,
- 14:21I don't want this. I want the hopefulness of
- 14:24the young practitioner. But I'm along for the
- 14:27ride because of Robert Donat, you know? And that
- 14:30was fantastic for me. And Rosalind Russell, as
- 14:32the strong woman behind the successful man in
- 14:37this movie, is so perfect. She's so good in this
- 14:40movie, and I love her. Yeah, and there's a lot
- 14:43of other movies that I think, lesser movies,
- 14:47that would have treated Chris as like, well,
- 14:51there's a fate that she has to pay. Like, you
- 14:53know, Denny in this, we're getting way ahead
- 14:55of ourselves, but Denny, I think, ends up playing
- 14:58the character that most other movies would say,
- 15:00well, that has to be Chris. And I think in the
- 15:02book that is the case. Interesting. Yeah, I think
- 15:05that is something major that was shifted here.
- 15:09Again, we'll talk about this later, but the fate
- 15:11of Andrew Manson's best friend, Denny, has been
- 15:17swapped out for his wife, Chris, from book to
- 15:20movie. Got it. I, you know, I haven't read the
- 15:24book, so I don't know how impactful that is one
- 15:26way or the other. But I have seen the movie and
- 15:28I will say that I'm glad that Chris is not the
- 15:32one that meets with that fate. Right. Because
- 15:34there really isn't a sacrifice that she faces
- 15:36because of like. her hitching her wagon to like
- 15:39manson right yeah otherwise i think in the book
- 15:41it sounds like that is kind of the route they
- 15:44took but it's a happier ending obviously when
- 15:46it isn't that but i will also say this i think
- 15:49that we've talked a lot about like norma sheer
- 15:50and um many other uh talented actresses that
- 15:54we were just completely enamored by um so Who
- 15:58is Rosalind Russell? Because in this movie, the
- 16:01whole time, any time that Dr. Andrew Manson did
- 16:04something that was not in favor of his wife,
- 16:07I was like, you idiot. Right. You fool. Do you
- 16:11not see the goddess in front of you in this exact
- 16:13moment? Yeah. Why would you do this to yourself?
- 16:17I love Rosalind Russell in this. I think she
- 16:20plays the part perfectly. Like you said, she
- 16:22is the strong woman behind him that is the guiding
- 16:27light to kind of remind him of who he is. And
- 16:30she also kind of falls a little bit to the facade
- 16:32of what life can be under living with a doctor.
- 16:37Right. We'll get to that later, too. But she
- 16:40is, even the way they're introduced, this is
- 16:43so interesting because Dr. Andrew Manson from
- 16:45the beginning, Manson is so by the book and Manson
- 16:49is someone who is like, if you're giving this
- 16:51kid milk, this is not the way this is going to
- 16:54work out. You have to be doing this. You have
- 16:56to do this by the book. I'm going to report you.
- 16:57And he's so frustrated with her not giving in
- 17:00because he's a doctor and just believing his
- 17:01like, you know, word that he gets so frustrated.
- 17:04But then over time he realizes, oh, well. I was
- 17:07foolish for this. And I was so by the book that
- 17:10I didn't stop and think about the human element
- 17:12of this. And you were actually helping the kid.
- 17:14And I'm sorry about that. And that vulnerability
- 17:16is what I think she admires most and wants to
- 17:19like be surrounded by him a bit more because
- 17:22she's seeing him admit when he's wrong very early
- 17:25on. And again, like there's times in this movie
- 17:29where it almost is filmed like a Hallmark movie.
- 17:31Where they're outside and I think she's on a
- 17:33bike and he's just walking next to her. And they're
- 17:36just like talking. And it's like a three or four
- 17:38minute scene of just them talking while they're
- 17:39just walking outside. And there is no like camera
- 17:43trickery. There's no like, wow, look at the way
- 17:44they filmed this. It's just we are going to film
- 17:46these two talking. And their chemistry is fantastic.
- 17:49But it's one of those things where it's not,
- 17:51hey, together you guys are dynamite. Separate,
- 17:53they're great. I think Rosalind Russell has a
- 17:55little less to do, obviously, than Donat does
- 17:59as... Manson which is you know fully understandable
- 18:03with the context of the movie but together they
- 18:06are just so good and they're just such a so much
- 18:09fun to watch they are the their meeting is strange
- 18:12because it feels like they skip the meet cute
- 18:15like they almost start off as enemies yes and
- 18:19then the reason they get together is to like
- 18:22further his career he reaches a point where there's
- 18:25an opportunity for him to go be a doctor for
- 18:28a specific town But they need somebody who's
- 18:31married for whatever reason. The townsfolk there
- 18:34are like, we want our doctor to be married. I
- 18:37don't know why, but that's the case. So he's
- 18:40kind of wandering around looking for her because
- 18:42she's kind of the only woman he knows in town.
- 18:45And his plan is to ask her to marry him so that
- 18:50he can get this job. So I don't know. I don't
- 18:54like their their. intro together it because it
- 18:57doesn't it feels very forced and very unnatural
- 19:00and it's strange to me how he's like would you
- 19:04want to get married so that i can get this job
- 19:06and like you know we'll be good together and
- 19:08she's like yeah sure i'll do that and then they're
- 19:10great together but everything leading up to that
- 19:12i was like well this is weird feels weird that's
- 19:15interesting i i didn't have i didn't bump on
- 19:17that as much because I took a little bit more
- 19:20as he had that opportunity to apologize to her
- 19:22and tell her how he felt. And then they talk
- 19:25a little bit more, just like slightly a bit more
- 19:27about like, oh, well, I know Denny. I know Denny,
- 19:29too. And that's kind of like the way that they
- 19:30can kind of vouch for each other. And then as
- 19:33they're talking, he kind of mentions like, yeah,
- 19:35they're interested in me, but I would need to
- 19:37be married. And I don't remember exactly how
- 19:39this conversation went. But from her, she said
- 19:42something like, would that be so terrible if
- 19:44you were married? Right. There's definitely flirting
- 19:46there. And there's a conversation of like, well,
- 19:48is that something we could do? To where I think
- 19:50he's like, oh, you would want that? An interesting
- 19:52thing about this movie is, you know, we've talked
- 19:53a lot about some other movies where it feels
- 19:56like the man is kind of coercing. The woman are
- 19:59like chasing him a lot or chasing her a lot.
- 20:01In Old Chicago. In Old Chicago. We talked a little
- 20:04bit about, oh, there's a movie that you felt
- 20:07like it was like one of those libeled lady type
- 20:09movies where you felt like it was just him chasing
- 20:11her the whole time. I think it was Top Hat. Top
- 20:14hat, yes. Top hat where it just felt like he
- 20:16was bothering her the whole time and wouldn't
- 20:17leave her alone. In this movie, you don't feel
- 20:21that. And you feel more like this is an actual
- 20:23courting of a relationship where you feel both
- 20:25parties are interested and invested. And there's
- 20:28not that sinister nature on either of their sides.
- 20:30If anything, it's the corrupt nature of the medical
- 20:34field and what that has done to other people
- 20:37in that same practice. And how it can corrupt,
- 20:40you know, even the innocent in this. And at first
- 20:45I was worried it was a cautionary tale. It was
- 20:47the kind of movie that was going to end with,
- 20:49you know, well, this is what Manson went on to
- 20:51be. And isn't that, you know, just the way that
- 20:55the cookie crumbles. So sorry about it. Yeah.
- 20:57And I'm happy with how it ended. And we'll talk
- 20:59about that when we get to it. But it's a movie
- 21:01that is so interested in its characters as well
- 21:05as the message. It is not one that is focusing
- 21:08just on the message or just on the relationship.
- 21:10It is a nice blend of that. And from the get
- 21:12-go, we see there's a small practice in, oh God,
- 21:17I don't even remember where it is, London or
- 21:19something, that he goes to work under a doctor.
- 21:21But then he realizes that doctor is bedridden
- 21:23and he doesn't go anywhere. And he is pretty
- 21:26much the only practicing doctor, even though
- 21:28he is an assistant to the doctor. He's not getting
- 21:32the cut that he needs. And he realizes he's being
- 21:35worked. You know, there's a great scene with
- 21:37the doctor's wife when Dr. Andrew Mason sits
- 21:42down with her. And she has this huge plate of
- 21:45food. Yeah. A lot of food. She even has a stout.
- 21:48And she's like, you know, with my low blood and
- 21:50everything, like I need to eat a lot. She's anemic.
- 21:52Anemic. So I need to eat all this food. I need
- 21:54to have a stout. I hope you understand. And then
- 21:56the camera cuts to his plate. And I think it's
- 21:58like three smaller pieces of bacon. Yep. And
- 22:01like a little dinner roll or something. And that's
- 22:03all. And he even kind of sits that out to like
- 22:06go and do more work. He's so eager to get into
- 22:08the field. And he enjoys helping everyone, but
- 22:10then slowly he realizes that there are people
- 22:12who have taken advantage of this. Whether it
- 22:15be this woman who is trying to cut all the wages
- 22:17that he could receive from this, from the work
- 22:19he's doing, and instead give to someone at the
- 22:21top who's not doing anything. Right. And, you
- 22:24know, it's great because at first he doesn't
- 22:26see this as, well, this is how all doctors are.
- 22:29It's just, well, this is that one person. And
- 22:31then he goes somewhere else and sees a little
- 22:32bit more of that too. I almost wish I didn't
- 22:36like this movie so much because sometimes these
- 22:37episodes are just like, yeah, it's great. Yeah,
- 22:40yeah. And I want to be a little more descriptive
- 22:41about it. But this is just, I was so pleasantly
- 22:46surprised by this because this is a movie that
- 22:49I won't get ahead of myself when it comes to
- 22:51the scoring and everything. This is a movie where
- 22:53I'm like, I just want to watch this again at
- 22:54some point. Like I just, I want to live in this
- 22:57little world. I'm kind of existing in the first
- 22:59hour right now. I want to live in this world
- 23:01as much as I can because the world is so charming.
- 23:04And sure, there are people who take advantage
- 23:07of the situation, but it's almost played like
- 23:09a sitcom where like, yeah, these people are doing
- 23:12that. But does that make them the worst person
- 23:14in the world? No, it's just they're very colorful
- 23:17and they have their own like, you know, personalities
- 23:19and their own motivations. And how does that
- 23:22blend with this person? And the movie is so interested
- 23:25in showing how those characterizations play against
- 23:27each other than it is like bad, good. Right?
- 23:30There's a little nuance in that. And for the
- 23:34first hour, I feel like the movie expertly balances
- 23:37that. Expertly looks at like, here's this person
- 23:40that may be a little more jaded about how this
- 23:42works. And then here's this person who's a little
- 23:44more seasoned and tries to guide that hand. And
- 23:46a lot of that, the latter experiment in that
- 23:49is Denny. Denny is the doctor who has been a
- 23:52little more involved in this and has seen this
- 23:54through. What did you think about Denny as a
- 23:56character? Denny is... Interesting because I
- 24:00don't think he plays that huge of a role until
- 24:02the end of the movie. Obviously, he's in it and
- 24:05he is kind of like the focal point for Chris
- 24:10and Manson. But he kind of exists just as like
- 24:14a little side character. And really, when he
- 24:18shows up at the end after Manson has kind of
- 24:20become a little. tired in the medical world,
- 24:25a little lazy and definitely a lot jaded, where
- 24:29he's doing his practice more for money than he
- 24:33is for like the good and the humanity of it all.
- 24:37I think when Danny shows up, trying to reel him
- 24:40back into that, that's when he really is not
- 24:43only an important character, but like a phenomenal
- 24:46character. He's so well acted. And he has one
- 24:50of the best lines in the movie. I was going to
- 24:52say not to get ahead of ourselves, but I think
- 24:53we're moving towards that way anyway. He shows
- 24:56up outside of Manson and Chris's apartment, and
- 25:02he's completely wasted. And he's sitting on the
- 25:06floor and they come out and they're like, what's
- 25:08going on? What's wrong? And this is his moment
- 25:10where he had previously come to Manson to be
- 25:13like, look, I want to try this thing where it's
- 25:14basically like kind of insurance. It's more like
- 25:17a subscription service of, you know, everybody
- 25:20pays two dollars a month and it provides medical.
- 25:25Coverage? Medical coverage. Thank you. Jeez.
- 25:27Medical coverage for like everybody, you know.
- 25:29It's socialism. Hey. Yeah. It's very funny to
- 25:33see these people like, hey, I have this idea
- 25:34of what if we did this and did that? I'm like,
- 25:36so socialism. Yeah, yeah. Like we have a term
- 25:39for that now. Right. But of course, yeah, 1938.
- 25:42But he shows up and like he's trying to sell
- 25:44this idea to Manson. And it's a very hopeful,
- 25:49ideal. And it's very much him being like, this
- 25:53will help everybody. And Manson is so against
- 25:56it at this point because he has resorted to kind
- 25:59of swindling hypochondriacs is how he's making
- 26:02his money. He's giving placebos and he's diagnosing
- 26:06people with illnesses that either don't really
- 26:10mean anything. Or don't need the type of help
- 26:13or constant help that he's providing. It's just
- 26:15a way to suck money from them. So he denies Denny's
- 26:19idea. And Denny shows up after this and he's
- 26:22like, you've changed. And he has my favorite
- 26:25line in the movie. Where he says, the world's
- 26:28full of mean people. Millions of them. When your
- 26:31pal goes and joins them, it hurts. And it's such
- 26:34like a biting line. That really like begins to
- 26:39shift Manson. and his his morals back towards
- 26:43the side of good and everything that happens
- 26:46after this is is obviously the the turning point
- 26:49for him but i think his performance there is
- 26:52so solid and he's such a great side character
- 26:55that it's hard not to love him i think that's
- 26:59almost why i relate this to sitcom in that like
- 27:02denny for the first half of the movie does play
- 27:04kind of the you know almost like wisecracking
- 27:08sidekick neighbor of the sitcom where it's kind
- 27:11of like yeah sure what are the uh winslow's up
- 27:13to oh that urkel's coming through isn't he and
- 27:16he just kind of pops in and says something you're
- 27:18like oh that's so funny i love that urkel i love
- 27:20that denny yeah and then at the end he pops back
- 27:23up and he is the same old same old uh but then
- 27:26he you know kind of is changed a little bit by
- 27:29Andrew and what he said previously. He's like,
- 27:32hey, I've been really inspired by what we've
- 27:34talked about before, and I think I've actually
- 27:35found this thing that is really going to be revolutionary,
- 27:37and we should do this to help people. What you
- 27:40haven't mentioned yet is that I did bring up
- 27:43where he sees how the medical field, at least
- 27:46the doctors or the people who have practices,
- 27:49can be a little corrupt and can skim off the
- 27:53top. But then we also see where he goes to a
- 27:55town, he starts helping all these, you know,
- 27:58miners, any individual who are working in the
- 28:01mining field. And in the mines, is what I'm trying
- 28:04to say. And this is where he had to move to be,
- 28:07he had to be married to move here and be a practicing
- 28:10doctor. And he's kind of shaking that off. And
- 28:13he's like, yeah, that's a horrible experience
- 28:15that we had with her, but I'm moving on. And
- 28:17then he starts seeing that, like, there are doctors
- 28:20here who want to give, you know. pink uh pills
- 28:23and pink medicine that are placebos essentially
- 28:25and make them feel like they don't need uh they
- 28:29are getting medication but it really just prolongs
- 28:32everything yeah he wants to solve it he wants
- 28:34to look specifically into how i just mentioned
- 28:38this to chase yesterday when we were at the wedding
- 28:40um i was like it's kind of funny watching movies
- 28:43from like the 1930s because there will always
- 28:45be a character who's like i think i've made a
- 28:47breakthrough discovery working in mines Not good.
- 28:51Yeah. It affects your lungs. Do you know that?
- 28:53And everyone's like, what? I'm like, yeah, man,
- 28:56of course. But it's always very funny to kind
- 29:00of like be reminded of like, oh yeah, the 1930s.
- 29:02Yeah. Well, even the socialism thing. Exactly.
- 29:04Yeah. Well, so in socialism was one thing, but
- 29:07when they're like, when everyone's like, oh,
- 29:09inhaling dust isn't good for you. I was like,
- 29:12okay, thanks. The crazy thing about the socialism
- 29:14is when Denny's like. And Manson says, nah, I
- 29:18don't think it'll work. And he goes, it is working
- 29:20in America. And you're like, and he looks at
- 29:23the camera and goes, yeah, he's like, how's it
- 29:26going in America? So he he sees how like doctors
- 29:33are also taking advantage of their patients and
- 29:36all that. But then at the same time, he sees
- 29:38how patients are also kind of wanting to cut
- 29:41corners as well. Like, hey, can you give me my
- 29:44medicine? Well, hey, that medicine actually is
- 29:45going to help you. In order for me to diagnose
- 29:47the real problem, we need to have you have symptoms
- 29:49a little bit longer. And now all of the minors
- 29:52are saying, well, then just give me my card back.
- 29:54And now I won't follow under your practice. I'll
- 29:57go to someone else's practice. And on top of
- 29:59that, the medical field themselves are kind of
- 30:01rejecting the work that he originally put out
- 30:03about the dust in the mines and how it's affecting
- 30:07everyone's lungs. And he more or less gets pushed
- 30:10away. And the medical field doesn't want to work
- 30:12with him as much. The patients don't want to
- 30:15work with him as much. So he starts traveling
- 30:16instead, and he finds his way in London. And
- 30:19at this point, he's been rejected by the medical
- 30:22board, one way or another. He's been blacklisted.
- 30:25But he's found frustrations with people who own
- 30:27their own practices, the medical board, doctors,
- 30:30patients. So when he sees a familiar face, and
- 30:33he finds a co -worker in London that he's worked
- 30:37with in the past, he kind of gets taken under
- 30:39his wing. He's like, hey, let me show you how
- 30:40things are done here. And he starts seeing like
- 30:42a little bit of the same, but it's more romanticized,
- 30:45right? Well, here's how you can benefit from
- 30:47that. Here's how you can benefit from the clients
- 30:49who don't really have anything wrong. Here's
- 30:51how you can benefit from like these doctors.
- 30:53And are you really doing anything wrong? Or are
- 30:55you just more benefiting from the system that
- 30:57exists? Right. And that's where we see him really
- 30:59turn. And it's not like he becomes this evil
- 31:02character. He's just kind of swayed by, oh yeah.
- 31:05We don't have to worry about that. But at the
- 31:07same time, he's losing his humanity. He's losing
- 31:10that humanity that he had in this little girl
- 31:12who Anna, I think was her name, at the restaurant.
- 31:16Miss Orlando's daughter? That's right. Anna Orlando.
- 31:20That's a great name, by the way. Damn. She knew
- 31:23what she was doing. Also, I love that scene where
- 31:27they go to Mrs. Orlando's restaurant, and they're
- 31:31just getting praised. And at one point... She's
- 31:35saying how much she loves the doctor and how
- 31:37much she loves Chris. And they're saying how
- 31:39much they love the food. And at one point, Robert,
- 31:41and I don't know if I'm just putting this impression
- 31:43on him or if this is actually how I heard him,
- 31:45but it was him saying, like, well, maybe I'll
- 31:47reference some of my patients here and prescribe
- 31:50them with a little bit of bolognese. And it's
- 31:53just, again, so funny, so charming. Like, it
- 31:56doesn't come across as like he's being, like,
- 31:57belittling. It's that's who he is. And I will
- 32:00go ahead and say, I am a sucker for a Scottish
- 32:02accent. So there's a chance that like him just
- 32:04like being like, hi, in a Scottish accent. I'm
- 32:06like, oh my God, he's so true. Yeah, yeah. So
- 32:08that might be me. But all of that to say that
- 32:11he's been swayed by this. So when Denny meets
- 32:14with him again, he kind of finds this like de
- 32:18-evolved version of Manson, who has turned into
- 32:22one of these other socialite doctors who... Who
- 32:27prescribes medication to people that don't really
- 32:29need it. And he has kind of attached himself
- 32:31to this socialite in... I forget her name. Toppy.
- 32:37Topsy? Toppy. Yeah. It's Toppy. Something like
- 32:40that. I remember Toppy LaRue, I think. Toppy
- 32:42LaRue. Because I saw that name and I was... Toppy
- 32:45Leroy. Leroy. Thank you. I saw the name because
- 32:49at one point... chris opens up a newspaper and
- 32:52it says that uh socialite toppy la roy was seen
- 32:56with a couple people and one of the names mentioned
- 32:58was uh andrews and at the time at the top when
- 33:01it showed her picture it says toppy la roy i
- 33:04just laughed it's like that's just such a funny
- 33:06like if you asked me in 2026 to name that character
- 33:09you're like hey we have this character here's
- 33:11who she is what do you want to name her i'm like
- 33:12i don't know toppy la roy they're done yeah thank
- 33:15you um But he's attached himself to this. So
- 33:18this is the version of Manson that Denny meets
- 33:21with at the Italian restaurant. And that's when
- 33:24he kind of has his heart broken. Because Chris
- 33:26is open, not even open, but infatuated with the
- 33:30idea. Yeah. She's such a cool character because
- 33:33not only is she supportive of Andrew the entire
- 33:38time, but she's constantly pushing and... being
- 33:43part of like what he wants to achieve. So while
- 33:47they're there studying and researching tuberculosis
- 33:50and all of these other diseases, like she's there
- 33:52with a microscope, also looking at slides and
- 33:55trying to discover things as well. And I love
- 33:57that. Like she's almost a, not a business partner
- 34:01because that's not what it is, but you know,
- 34:03that type of partnership in this career and life
- 34:06and marriage and everything else, she's very
- 34:08involved. So yeah, she's very supportive of Benny's
- 34:11idea, Denny's idea. Yeah. And I forgot, too,
- 34:15that Denny, as good of a friend as he is for
- 34:18Manson, is proven even more so when, at one point,
- 34:22he gifts Manson with his only... Microscope.
- 34:27Microscope. Thank you. And then that kind of
- 34:30like... creates the slogan that Manson has, even
- 34:34with Chris, where he's like, you know, if I have
- 34:36a notebook, an empty room and a microscope, I
- 34:40can figure that I could save the world. Yeah.
- 34:42And he had now has all those things and he can
- 34:45do this. And Chris even reminds him, you know,
- 34:47when he feels really down and out and everything,
- 34:49she reminds him that you have a room. Don't you
- 34:51have a microscope in there? And he goes, check
- 34:53it out. And she gives him a notepad. Yeah. So
- 34:55like, she's helping him like realize that he
- 34:57can do whatever he wants in this. So. This is
- 35:00why I did get really kind of skeptical and I
- 35:03started guarding myself a little bit when Manson
- 35:06did kind of de -evolve to this version, this
- 35:10negative version of a doctor and everything he
- 35:13stands for. Because even Miss Orlando, was it
- 35:17Mama Orlando? Is that just me trying to make
- 35:19her more Italian? I think that's what it is.
- 35:20Okay. Orlando. When she's telling him about Anna
- 35:24and how sick she is and wish we could trust a
- 35:27real doctor. I don't really trust the doctor
- 35:29that we have now. He's like, I love olives. He's
- 35:32just getting top of nod and everything. It's
- 35:37kind of funny in the moment how she's like, yeah,
- 35:39I don't think she's going to make it. He's like,
- 35:40ah, cheese. Little Spanish fish. He's like, you
- 35:45know, I love my cheese. I'm sure she'll be all
- 35:47right. And just walks away. And I guard myself
- 35:50because I'm like, I really don't. want this to
- 35:52be the rest of the movie yep and we'll fast forward
- 35:55a little bit uh because of how drunk he is and
- 35:57when they send him off denny does find himself
- 35:59in an accident and immediately this kind of is
- 36:02what flips manson and manson now is like well
- 36:05i gotta save my best friend what can i do and
- 36:07he calls in charles avery who he's been introduced
- 36:10as like you know this world -renowned surgeon
- 36:11that he's been working with gotten a lot of recommendations
- 36:14referrals he's made a lot of his money on like
- 36:16you know working with avery and his patients
- 36:18and this is my understanding at least i hope
- 36:20it is yours He comes to the realization that
- 36:23once Avery loses Denny on the operating table,
- 36:27that Avery actually isn't a practicing surgeon.
- 36:30I don't know if it's that severe, but it is that
- 36:34he's self -proclaimed as far as like his skill
- 36:39as a surgeon. Like all of these very complex
- 36:43and difficult surgeries, maybe he has not performed.
- 36:46I don't know if he's not. a licensed surgeon.
- 36:49What did you just say? I think licensed. Yeah.
- 36:51Licensed. I don't know if it's that severe, but
- 36:54it is like, wow, you are not who you say you
- 36:57are. Well, cause he even starts, uh, trying to
- 37:00calm down Manson where he's like, Hey, someone's
- 37:02going to hear you like calm down. Yeah. Which
- 37:03means that it's true. Right. Like sure. And that
- 37:06there's something that can come out to where
- 37:07like he loses all of that. So you might be right.
- 37:11Maybe it is like, Hey, I am a surgeon, but also
- 37:12just not a good one. So like, I just try to keep
- 37:14it calm, which is interesting. Cause when you
- 37:16see him operating, He's just very like stoic.
- 37:19Yeah. And part of you is like, oh, he's keeping
- 37:21his calm. But in reality, he just doesn't care.
- 37:23And he doesn't know what he's doing. Yeah. And
- 37:25despite what Manson's telling him in real time,
- 37:29he's dying. Like you're losing him. You got to
- 37:31like work a little bit faster. Give him adrenaline.
- 37:33Like there's things you can do. And it's not
- 37:35just like, hey, my friend died on your table.
- 37:37So now I have a vendetta against you. It's him
- 37:39saying, I watched you actively not try to save
- 37:41him. Yes. And you didn't know what to do. And
- 37:44this is your fault. His death is on your hands.
- 37:47And that is what wakes him up fully. That idea
- 37:50of not only did I lose my best friend, but I
- 37:53lost it because I surrounded myself with these
- 37:55kinds of people. It's Robert Donat's best scene
- 37:59in this movie, I think, when Denny is lost on
- 38:03the operating table. And he has that attack on
- 38:07this doctor, this surgeon. And he's like, you're
- 38:10a murderer. You have committed murder here. You
- 38:13are not a real doctor. Killed him. Like, I watched
- 38:17you kill him. All of that is so intense and so
- 38:20well done. And I love the moments where he's
- 38:23like, hey, keep your voice down. Someone's going
- 38:24to hear you. And he's like, I don't care. Like,
- 38:26I love that he's not yelling at him during this
- 38:30whole scene. He's just like straight to the point,
- 38:33like looking him dead in the eye and just being
- 38:34like, no, like this is the truth is going to
- 38:37come out. And like, you're done. This is it.
- 38:40It's such a. such a good performance from donat
- 38:44it's great and honestly this is it's kind of
- 38:48like bittersweet because he was nominated for
- 38:51uh leading role in this he didn't win um which
- 38:55you know we'll talk about who did win and like
- 38:57the deserved nature of that but this is the kind
- 39:00of performance that you almost want to see a
- 39:02win for so you can see more of this yeah you
- 39:04know um but thrilled that he got a nomination
- 39:07for actor in a leading role here because god
- 39:10does he deserve it But to me, it's a combination,
- 39:13I think, for the revelatory nature of his performance
- 39:17here, that it's between the one that you just
- 39:19mentioned of him accusing Avery being a murderer,
- 39:22and then it's also him kind of snapping himself
- 39:25out of what he's feeling and going to find Anna,
- 39:28find her in the hospital. And it's not just him
- 39:32going to find her, but it's more the conversation
- 39:33he has with the doctor outside, where he's like,
- 39:36hey, if you take her out of here, I'm going to
- 39:39report you to the police. And without missing
- 39:41a beat, he just goes right into like, Orlando,
- 39:44are you sufficiently happy with the procedure
- 39:48and care that you've gotten from your doctor?
- 39:50Oh, yeah. No. Are you wanting to release him
- 39:53in favor of giving me coverage? Yes. He's like,
- 39:55good morning, and just leaves. Yes. It's so good.
- 39:58And it's just like, instead of even arguing with
- 40:00him, it's just, I know how this has to go. We're
- 40:02going to have that conversation. Conversation's
- 40:04done. I'm out. And it's just so quick. And that
- 40:08is the quick nature of his brain. That's him
- 40:10knowing not just what's right, but also the right
- 40:13way to do it within the field. And this is the
- 40:17balance of the movie that I love so much. It's
- 40:19not just the righteous, well, this is what's
- 40:22right. I don't care if it's by the law or whatever.
- 40:24I'm doing that. He's doing both. He's doing like
- 40:27morally, this is what's right. We're going to
- 40:29save lives. And also here's what needs to happen
- 40:31in order for this to be legal. And that doesn't
- 40:33even help him because he finds himself in court
- 40:35having to defend his actions. And this is where
- 40:38he has his like, you know, stand in the court,
- 40:40big courtroom speech. He's kind of had this a
- 40:43little bit earlier too, but it was more like
- 40:45among peers and some of the minors in town. But
- 40:48in this, it's more he's in front of a judge and
- 40:50lawyers and a lot of other jury members. And
- 40:53this is where he really gets to have his final
- 40:55speech. Not just literally in the movie, but
- 40:57to speak truth to how he wants this field to
- 41:01succeed. But at the same time, we are allowing
- 41:04ourselves to even go further back. And we are
- 41:07halting progress in some of these things. And
- 41:10it's the final line of the movie before he walks
- 41:12out with Chris and Chris gets to see like how
- 41:14fired up he is about this and how wrong it is.
- 41:17And she realizes she has her husband back. Yeah.
- 41:19So it's this perfect idea of like, you know,
- 41:22this movie doesn't have to end in tragedy. I
- 41:23mean, it does with Denny, but it doesn't have
- 41:25to end in tragedy for the two characters that
- 41:27we fell in love with throughout this movie. It
- 41:29can be a hopeful ending. It feels like Aerosmith,
- 41:31but with like a brighter ending than that did.
- 41:35Robert Donat is a huge part of that in his performance.
- 41:38But also the way King Vador shoots this, the
- 41:41screenplay of it. I'm excited to go read the
- 41:43book now and see how much of the similarity is
- 41:45there. But I almost am concerned that I'm not
- 41:48going to like it as much because I just love
- 41:50Robert Donat's performance in this so much. So
- 41:52we'll see how that goes. But I loved this. It's
- 41:55such a good story. And I feel like it's a very
- 41:58common story. Sure. Setting it in the medical
- 42:02field. is is unique i don't think it's one that
- 42:06i've necessarily seen before but there are plenty
- 42:08of movies and stories in general that talk about
- 42:11you know somebody that is involved in either
- 42:13a career or a passion or just something in their
- 42:15life and as they get closer to their goals they
- 42:19become a little corrupt and then it takes something
- 42:22to snap them back into reality there was a good
- 42:25portion of this movie where i was like this is
- 42:27kind of like the lion king where you know Simba
- 42:30is destined to be this great king and then he
- 42:34is forced to kind of shy away from his responsibilities.
- 42:39And then he has a moment where he's looking into
- 42:42the water while the clouds are moving behind
- 42:43him. And there's like a disembodied voice talking,
- 42:46saying, remember who you are. Like that exact
- 42:50thing happens in this movie. And I think it's
- 42:52one of the maybe cheesiest parts of the movie
- 42:55for me. It is, yeah. And this is directly after...
- 42:59manson leaves the hospital where denny has passed
- 43:02away and he has the moment with chris and then
- 43:05he's like he doesn't say anything he just walks
- 43:07away and there's some really spotty uh rear projection
- 43:12like quote -unquote green screen behind him of
- 43:16him just walking through the city and seeing
- 43:18like the dark parts of of the city because he
- 43:21spent all of this time uh You know, feeding placebos
- 43:25to the wealthy and the higher class. And now
- 43:29he's down on the ground level and he's seeing,
- 43:31you know, like young mothers struggling to find
- 43:34food for their children. And he's seeing homeless
- 43:37people begging for change on the side of the
- 43:39road. And this is more of the city now telling
- 43:43him, like, look, these are the people that you
- 43:45should be helping. I have a theory that the voice
- 43:48he hears in the end is the city. You think so?
- 43:51Well, I mean, look, none of it makes sense. Yeah.
- 43:53None of it's going to make sense regardless.
- 43:55And you could probably say the most realistic
- 43:57thing is it's his conscience kind of like speaking
- 43:59to him. But in reality, you're right. The city
- 44:02has shown him all those things. So I think it's
- 44:03kind of that a little bit. Yeah. I did like the
- 44:07idea that it was like if the camera panned back
- 44:09just a little bit when he walks off screen, if
- 44:11you just see like Orlando with like a shoehorn
- 44:14or like a bullhorn. Yeah. She's like, remember
- 44:17who you are. and save anna and make sure you
- 44:20order bolognese you are the one true surgeon
- 44:23and you like my food don't forget i have your
- 44:27favorite cheeses yes remember the spanish fish
- 44:31and the uh pickled walnuts i think they mentioned
- 44:35at one time which i was like what what is that
- 44:37that was a great uh double or uh that was a great
- 44:42like uh double take for me yeah where she was
- 44:45like oh my My daughter's in the hospital and
- 44:47I don't know how much she has longer to live.
- 44:49Oh, I love pickled walnuts. Well, my daughter's
- 44:51pickled walnuts. We don't have those here. I
- 44:57was like, she's a pickled one. Yeah, that gets
- 44:59weird. Unfortunately, he got me with that where
- 45:01I was like, oh, yes. Oh, right. She's she's dying.
- 45:03Yes. OK. Yeah. Let's go back to that. He distracted
- 45:05you long enough. I did take it as that. I also
- 45:08did really think at one point maybe like I was
- 45:10kind of waiting for that doctor who came from
- 45:12America to tell him how much he loved his reporting
- 45:15on the his essay. on the dust that's found in
- 45:18like the mines and everything. Yeah. I thought
- 45:20there's maybe a chance that like he was there
- 45:22and he was kind of like, you've done great work
- 45:23and you'll continue to great work. But then like
- 45:25the scene ended and like three scenes later,
- 45:28I was like, Oh, was that just like a random voice?
- 45:30Like I kind of forgot about that completely.
- 45:32Yeah. It, it, it is weird. It's like, I'm sure
- 45:35it is a specific person's voice, but in the moment
- 45:38I couldn't tell who it was. So I was like, Oh,
- 45:40this is an interesting choice. I do like that.
- 45:42He's like flipping coins into the water though.
- 45:45Just like, All the money I've made doing what
- 45:47I'm doing, I don't care. Like, take it all. So
- 45:49it is a little heavy -handed, I think, that particular
- 45:53scene. It's not perfect. But I do think it's
- 45:55necessary. I wish it looked better. The backdrops
- 45:58behind them look kind of rough throughout the
- 46:00entire sequence. I wonder if it's because it
- 46:03was at night. Because the scenes of him walking
- 46:06through the town that I mentioned with Chris,
- 46:08those look so great. And maybe it's because the
- 46:10lighting was better. So this, they just had to
- 46:12do it like, you know, with the green screen.
- 46:14Yeah. I'm not sure. But otherwise, it's a movie
- 46:16that I think looks fantastic. It does. It does.
- 46:18I think that is the sequence that kept it from
- 46:21getting like an art direction nomination. Sure.
- 46:23So, but yeah, I think this is fantastic. And
- 46:27I love this particular story of like a man who
- 46:31becomes jaded and then finds his way back kind
- 46:35of through hope, you know, through. through the
- 46:39idea of making a difference, of doing better.
- 46:42And I think it's very interesting that this particular
- 46:44story had such an impact on the real world and
- 46:48the hospital system. The book did, certainly.
- 46:51I think the movie may have helped on that. I'm
- 46:53not entirely sure, but it did go a long way in
- 46:56making that happen. One thing I wanted to point
- 46:58out here was there isn't a ton of behind -the
- 47:01-scenes here, and I kind of like that because
- 47:03it allowed me to get really into the movie, and
- 47:04I enjoyed that. However, I did see that... There
- 47:09was one person who screen tested for the role
- 47:11of Christine. Obviously, that went to Rosalind
- 47:14Russell. Thank God. But there's one person who
- 47:17was screen tested for Christine and didn't get
- 47:19it. Vivian Lee, who went on to do Gone with the
- 47:23Wind. And I'm excited to get to Gone with the
- 47:26Wind. It's still always slipped my radar. Not
- 47:29right. I've been aware of it, but I've never
- 47:30prioritized seeing it. So I'm excited to do that
- 47:33next month with you. But I have a feeling that,
- 47:35like, Vivian Leigh wouldn't have brought as much
- 47:36as Rosalind Russell did to this. Because Vivian
- 47:38Leigh, to me, especially Gone with the Wind and
- 47:40the stature of that movie, it feels like it's
- 47:42such an elevated, like, you know, performance.
- 47:44And, like, the movie has to be elevated. And
- 47:46in this, Rosalind Russell knows where to go.
- 47:48And she just, like, fits in that pocket. Perfect.
- 47:51Perfectly. So, I can't imagine it with Vivian
- 47:54Leigh. I didn't know your thoughts. I think Rosalind
- 47:57Russell is, like, so perfect for this. The way
- 48:00that, like, Talia Shire is Adrian. in the Rocky
- 48:02franchise. She's, she's just so perfectly supportive.
- 48:06And like, there's that scene where the, the miners
- 48:09show up at their house when Andrew isn't home
- 48:12and destroys all of their lab equipment. And
- 48:15then she shows up to tell Andrew what happened.
- 48:17And, and even that, like the emotional moment
- 48:19she's having where she's crying and she's like,
- 48:21this is, this is what happened. They came and
- 48:23they destroyed everything. Like there's, there's
- 48:25a good bit of range there in her performance.
- 48:27And one thing that I will say about Chris, And
- 48:32her story is that moment where she reads the
- 48:35paper and she sees that Andrew was out with Toppy
- 48:38Leroy. That doesn't really go anywhere. If anything,
- 48:42I think it may strike a little bit of a division
- 48:45in their relationship to where she's thinking,
- 48:47okay, something might be happening there. Thankfully,
- 48:49the movie doesn't go very far in showing that
- 48:51that's a possibility. Yeah. Because even when
- 48:54he agrees to go to dinner with her and she's
- 48:56being very pushy about it. It's almost kind of
- 48:59funny who among us really, as a married man,
- 49:02if I ever get kind of like swayed in a conversation
- 49:04like that and I end up going, my conversation
- 49:06is the same thing as Manson's here, where that
- 49:11woman walks away, Toppy, and she's like, all
- 49:13right, he's coming to dinner with me. I'm so
- 49:15excited. He's probably going to cheat on his
- 49:16wife with me. And he's like, this renowned scientist
- 49:18is going to be there. I can't wait. And when
- 49:21his wife calls, he's like, yeah, I'm getting
- 49:23dinner with an event tonight with this gentleman.
- 49:25And what's so funny is I think he sees it that
- 49:27way. right it's not about toppy yeah he's like
- 49:30yeah i mean toppy invited me but i'm gonna hang
- 49:31out with this scientist that i look forward to
- 49:33talking to you that's me right like if some girl
- 49:36was like yeah okay i invited ryan to dinner this
- 49:38is great i'm like what do you mean didn't even
- 49:41know it was gonna be there right i would love
- 49:43to talk with and they're gonna have pickled walnuts
- 49:45my god i'm there so And she sees that in the
- 49:49paper and there's a little division between them
- 49:51for that. And that's kind of like, did I truly
- 49:53lose my husband? Yeah. But you're right. That
- 49:55didn't go anywhere. There's no like, did he have
- 49:57a relationship with Toppy or anything like that?
- 49:59Nothing like that. It's teased. Yeah. And I like
- 50:01that a lot. It feels like that's kind of below
- 50:03the movie. I like that it doesn't become a plot
- 50:06point because I didn't want that in their story.
- 50:08Correct. But I do think it might be an example
- 50:10of the adaptation of the book. Kind of being
- 50:14like, okay, here's this scene, this scene, this
- 50:16scene. Because the movie kind of speed runs through
- 50:19all of these different scenarios. And I was reading
- 50:22Bryce's review. And he said that he read the
- 50:24book before he saw the movie. And that was one
- 50:27of the negatives he found. Interesting. Was that
- 50:29it didn't spend enough time and give you enough.
- 50:32Of the impact that was hitting the characters
- 50:35because it was moving so quickly. I didn't necessarily
- 50:38feel that way. Neither did I. But I think if
- 50:40there is an example of that, it's probably the
- 50:42like hint of a possible affair that is just completely
- 50:45swept under the rug. I mean, the whole Toppy
- 50:48scene or sequence feels like that should be maybe
- 50:51a quarter of the movie. Yeah. And there's only
- 50:53a couple scenes. So I do understand that. But
- 50:55at no point did that affect the movie for me.
- 50:57No. Yeah. Yeah. I didn't feel it either. Do you
- 51:00want to get into ratings? I'd love to. We're
- 51:02matched. We are. And we weren't before this started.
- 51:05I was about to say, I thought you were a little
- 51:06lower. Yeah. Not in a bad way, but. I'm just,
- 51:09today we're recording the second episode of the
- 51:12day and I'm like, hey, I kind of like this movie.
- 51:15And then we talk about it. I'm like, oh, I really
- 51:17like this movie. That's so cool, man. I feel
- 51:19the same way. Sometimes we're talking. I mean,
- 51:21I did it with Jezebel, right? Like I was a three
- 51:23and I moved up to three and a half and it was
- 51:25in that conversation. So that's why sometimes
- 51:27I'm like, hey, here's my tentative score. Yeah,
- 51:30yeah. It kind of depends on when I talk with
- 51:31Kyle. And that's one thing I love about how we
- 51:33do this is that we don't text each other like,
- 51:35hey, I love this movie. Hey, I didn't care about
- 51:37this movie. I think sometimes I'll tell you,
- 51:39Godspeed. Right. All I'll get is a, hey, say
- 51:43a prayer before this movie because you're going
- 51:44to need to repent. Right. And then you'll love
- 51:47it. I'll be like, ah, I gotcha. And I love that.
- 51:51So we can talk about this and kind of like rehash,
- 51:53or not rehash, but like find out how we feel
- 51:55about it in real time. Yeah. So we both landed
- 51:58on four stars. This is excellent. That's really
- 52:03good. It's not perfect. You mentioned there's
- 52:05some scenes that just don't really stand out
- 52:07that well. And honestly, time may remember this
- 52:10very well for me, and I may put this at a four
- 52:12and a half. I'm very excited to go out and buy
- 52:15this. I want to own this. This was a movie that
- 52:18sometimes I think we can find things when we're
- 52:20doing this coverage that are like, hey, this
- 52:22is a really great movie. It's not my favorite,
- 52:24but it is great. And then you can find movies
- 52:27that are great. That just also mean a lot to
- 52:30you. And that's where the Citadel landed for
- 52:32me. This is probably going to be like a big statement
- 52:34that we don't have time to really get into. And
- 52:38I wish I would have said it earlier. But to me,
- 52:40this is like post -war Capra where there is a
- 52:44lot of like, hey, here are the like American
- 52:48values and morals, which, you know, this doesn't
- 52:51take place in America. So I understand that.
- 52:53But like you have such a positive, optimistic
- 52:55guy who at one point does. get jaded and shift
- 52:59to corruption a little bit but he comes back
- 53:01and it's that hope and like moral compass that
- 53:05brings him back but it's post -war cabra because
- 53:08he's not afraid to show like the darkness that
- 53:11is existing in this man's story the the scene
- 53:15where he uh delivers a baby and it's like a stillborn
- 53:19baby and they show the baby and he brings the
- 53:22baby back you know he baby eventually starts
- 53:25crying and breathing but in that moment i was
- 53:27like that's heavy that is a heavy thing that
- 53:30i don't think i've seen depicted on screen until
- 53:34like the post 2010 era you know like just that
- 53:39imagery i was like this is crazy um and then
- 53:43denny's death like is very dark so i think that
- 53:46that's stuff that capra eventually with like
- 53:48it's a wonderful life isn't afraid to put in
- 53:50his movies and i was very excited to see king
- 53:53the door like he's he's not afraid to do it here
- 53:55yeah you're you're so onto something with the
- 54:00uh post -war capra and it's better than uh the
- 54:04capra sense in that because in the capra version
- 54:07of this you would have that last speech that
- 54:09he has in front of that whole jury and you have
- 54:11the jury stand up and be like he's right and
- 54:14like everyone rallies behind him and this one
- 54:16it's much more of a quiet victory of hey i feel
- 54:19redeemed in what i did and his wife has validated
- 54:23i've seen that in you now like i've i see the
- 54:26rejuvenated version of who you are and you can
- 54:27go on to be who you need to be it's a subtle
- 54:30like more uh celebrated uh ending it's funny
- 54:34i use the word celebrated because i think in
- 54:35capra it would be a full celebration of everyone
- 54:38on screen like he did it what a great man he
- 54:40is and in this it's less of a great man and just
- 54:43more like his journey through this like flawed
- 54:45system yes um That's such a great call. The Citadel
- 54:48to me is the grounded version of the fantasy
- 54:51that Capra normally tells. That's awesome. That's
- 54:54a great way to put it. What a metaphor to make.
- 54:58And you know how I love Capra, and I'm happy
- 55:00to dog on him in that moment. For my double feature,
- 55:03I went with a movie that also talked a little
- 55:06bit about the idea of balancing your career and
- 55:09your life, and specifically, you know, what you're
- 55:12giving up. by putting yourself fully into that
- 55:14career. And I went with something I can't believe
- 55:17actually was not nominated for Best Picture.
- 55:192018, Damien Chazelle's First Man. Oh, yeah.
- 55:23The relationship between Ryan Gosling and Claire
- 55:25Foy. It's not a one -to -one. To be honest with
- 55:30you, I want to put Devil Wears Prada. I think
- 55:31Devil Wears Prada is a much better comp for this
- 55:34because you see Andy actually getting into the
- 55:37world of this career and how that affects her,
- 55:40but then ultimately standing up for her own beliefs.
- 55:42And then ultimately she can be successful in
- 55:44that career or adjacent to that career because
- 55:47she stood up to that. And that is the trajectory
- 55:49of what Andrew Manson sees in this film. And
- 55:54Andy Sachs and Andrew Manson. Cut from the same
- 55:57cloth. Yeah. Just, you know, I didn't mean that
- 55:59pun. One for the fashion world and one for the
- 56:01medical field. But because I've already used
- 56:04that for, funny enough, another hospital film,
- 56:07The White Parade, I'm going with First Man. Yeah.
- 56:11I like First Man. I think that it is pretty heavily
- 56:16overlooked. Weirdly enough, not Chazelle's most,
- 56:19like, overlooked and underrated movie. It's...
- 56:23Whiplash is so good. Well, Brad Pitt made sure
- 56:25of that. Not Whiplash. Babylon. Yeah. Geez. Whiplash,
- 56:28obviously, is very well -renowned. Very celebrated.
- 56:30But, yeah. Babylon is so good. But First Man,
- 56:32it's a solid movie. Definitely not his best,
- 56:35but, like, I really, really enjoyed that movie.
- 56:37And the sequence of the lunar lander coming down
- 56:41with Justin Horowitz's music. Like, I'll run
- 56:44to that sometimes, and it blows my mind. It's
- 56:48so good. We love scores. Also, that movie is
- 56:51a certified dude's rock cast. Yeah. Where it's
- 56:54like, what do you mean you have Patrick Fugit,
- 56:57I can't think of his name now, Kyle Chandler,
- 57:00Christopher Abbott, Brian Gosling, obviously.
- 57:04So many men that you're just like, yeah, dude's
- 57:06rock. Yeah, yeah. With a better score than F1.
- 57:09True. I love that score. Concept I was talking
- 57:14about where somebody shies away from the greatness
- 57:17that they are pursuing and then is brought back
- 57:20in to be even greater, I think, at the end. I
- 57:24went with that theming. And this might seem a
- 57:26little silly, but this might be my favorite example
- 57:29of that exact thing happening. And I went with
- 57:32the Amazing Spider -Man 2. How dare you laugh?
- 57:36No, no, I just didn't expect it. It's not how
- 57:39dare you pick that. It's more like, wow, I didn't
- 57:41see that coming. It's a superhero movie. It's
- 57:45a Spider -Man movie. Like he's swinging around.
- 57:48He's saving the city and all of that. The villain
- 57:50in that movie is kind of laughable and it's bloated
- 57:54with villains and things. It's not like objectively
- 57:58the best Spider -Man movie or superhero movie.
- 58:00And I understand that. But Spider -Man goes through
- 58:03a tragedy at the end of that movie and kind of
- 58:06hangs up the suit. And he says, I'm done. I'm
- 58:09giving up. And there is a disembodied voice that
- 58:14plays over a montage of him kind of coming back
- 58:17to that idea of, like, I have a responsibility.
- 58:20I promise to do good. I made an oath that I need
- 58:24to keep. And that voice is playing. It's Emma
- 58:28Stone's voice. And it's all about, like, hope
- 58:31and how you have to be the hope for the people
- 58:33that have lost hope. And the final scene where
- 58:36he shows up. to defend the little kid dressed
- 58:38as Spider -Man. And I know that whole scene by
- 58:41heart, like all of the lines and him just saying,
- 58:44okay, I'm here and I'm going to save the city.
- 58:47The best Spider -Man moment in all of history
- 58:51to me is in that moment. And that's the prime
- 58:54example of like, I'm back because I owe it not
- 58:58only to myself, but to everybody. Well, and it's
- 59:00also a direct one -to -one of, like, him losing
- 59:02someone, hanging it up, being told about the
- 59:05disembodied voice to get back to it, and then
- 59:06literally saving a child. Yeah, yeah. Like, that
- 59:09is—you could say that, and you could be describing
- 59:11either the Citadel or Tazen, too. Yeah. Dr. Andrew
- 59:15Garfield. Dr. Peter Parker. Well, I mean, that's—
- 59:17Yeah, that kind of happens, but— Yeah, true.
- 59:19Robert. That's my Uncle Denny! Uncle Den! Yeah,
- 59:26Uncle Den. There we go. Yeah, so— Solid double
- 59:31feature from you. I love First Man. And, you
- 59:34know, some people like Andrew Garfield. Also,
- 59:37kudos to you for seeing him kind of like being
- 59:40tempted by the dark side in the medical field
- 59:42and not immediately thinking if a Spider -Man
- 59:44movie is being compared here, that it's Venom.
- 59:47Venom the movie or Spider -Man 3? Well, I mean,
- 59:50Spider -Man 3 with like, you know, the symbiote
- 59:51and everything. Well, if this would have had
- 59:54even a single dance sequence, I would have done
- 59:56that, probably. Oh, that is missing that. Get
- 59:59up. it would have been him talk he almost got
- 1:00:03up and danced when he tasted that bolognese though
- 1:00:05he didn't he did he was like pickled walnuts
- 1:00:08you say trumpets play in the background saxophones
- 1:00:11um hey that is the citadel the citadel i completely
- 1:00:16forgot what it's called um if you have thoughts
- 1:00:18on this movie go ahead and shoot us an email
- 1:00:21at outaopodcast at gmail .com Leave a review
- 1:00:25for the show or comments in the show notes on
- 1:00:28Spotify and all of the other players. We're going
- 1:00:30to start utilizing that to read your opinions
- 1:00:33on the ceremony episodes. That's another option
- 1:00:37for you guys while we work through even more
- 1:00:40ways for that to happen. And if you would like
- 1:00:42to support the show financially. You can check
- 1:00:45out patreon .com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast.
- 1:00:48We have tons of benefits like the community discord,
- 1:00:51bonus early access episodes, and then the horror
- 1:00:55of the overlooked bonus podcast, where we talk
- 1:00:58about all of the horror movies that the Academy
- 1:01:00turned their noses up at, but are still worth
- 1:01:03checking out today. So beyond that, what do we
- 1:01:06have coming next episode, Ryan? Next episode,
- 1:01:09we will be talking about test pilot. Oh, okay.
- 1:01:12I didn't know nothing about this. Neither do
- 1:01:14I. And again, as much as I can walk into these
- 1:01:17movies blind, like I did with Citadel, and like,
- 1:01:19it doesn't always work out that way. Yeah. But
- 1:01:22the most I can do that, the better. I am looking
- 1:01:25forward to hearing us talk about that in the
- 1:01:27future. Well, you're editing it, so you will.
- 1:01:30Yeah, I'll hear it like three times. It'll be
- 1:01:32great. So, guys, thanks for listening. As always,
- 1:01:35I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the
- 1:01:37movies.