Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Succession Planning: From Policy to Practice with David Reed
Transcript
- 0:00mark: Hey everyone, this is Mark T Trike with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited today to be here with David Reed of Reed and Jolly David.
- 0:06How are you today?
- 0:08I'm doing great Mark.
- 0:09And it's a pleasure to be on.
- 0:10I appreciate it.
- 0:11Yeah.
- 0:12Yeah.
- 0:12I think a while back, maybe at the beginning, beginning of the year,
- 0:16end of last year, we chatted about collections and all the things that were
- 0:19going on related to n NCAA's, priority ladder, and on asset quality and had
- 0:25a really fun conversation around that.
- 0:27And of course, I've known you since my days at NCA when you helped us on
- 0:31some strategic planning facilitation with our senior executives.
- 0:36Had a lot of fun back in the
- 0:37david: days,
- 0:37mark: back in the day, right?
- 0:38Yeah.
- 0:39Boy, time flies, man.
- 0:41And and you shot me a note about N NCAA's succession planning rule coming up here.
- 0:45And I know you're out and about.
- 0:47You're out right now getting ready to chat with That's
- 0:49david: exactly right.
- 0:49I'm in beautiful Maine for their volunteer conference.
- 0:52And and it's a hot topic.
- 0:54mark: It is a hot topic, and one of the reasons it's hot is because
- 0:58January one NCAA's rule becomes, yeah.
- 1:00So all federally insured credit unions get on board all federally.
- 1:04That's that's feds and states all across the country.
- 1:07And you're out there helping them understand what it means
- 1:10and what it doesn't mean.
- 1:12So let's tee that up.
- 1:13The, there's the a as, as we were chatting earlier there's the paper
- 1:17of, how do you build a policy, right?
- 1:19And all that.
- 1:20And then there's the.
- 1:21There's the reality of, okay, what does that mean and how do we implement it?
- 1:24So where do you wanna go first on that?
- 1:26You wanna go with let's,
- 1:27david: let's just start let's just start there.
- 1:29It's policy versus practice.
- 1:31And as you mentioned, so I roam the countryside working with credit
- 1:35unions all across the country.
- 1:37I'm a credit union kind of guy, and whether it's speaking at a conference or.
- 1:42If it's my role for a number of credit unions I'm the board's council,
- 1:46so not the corporate council, but I'm the council for the board.
- 1:48So attending board meetings, helping them with things.
- 1:51And so this topic comes up over and over again, and where I have seen a little bit,
- 1:59I would call a disconnect, would be that.
- 2:04Lots of people on, okay, how to dress, how to, draft your policy, here are the
- 2:08key components of it, and ev and, God bless 'em all, they're cutting out of
- 2:12the executive summary of the sure of the rule and just, giving it to you.
- 2:16And then I will see people when they begin to talk about the nuts and bolts.
- 2:21It is typically focused on one of two areas, and they're both related.
- 2:25One is going to be executive retention.
- 2:30That is the CEO and going beyond.
- 2:32And I know you'll, get a kick outta this little gallows humor.
- 2:34But, going beyond the hit by a bus scenario, right?
- 2:38For, okay, who's your number two and what happens in an emergency situation going
- 2:42beyond that career pathing identifying the sets of skills and all that.
- 2:46And then the other bucket is you have a lot of people out there now, they
- 2:50talk about golden handcuffs, right?
- 2:51They talk about split dollars.
- 2:53They talk about, the various plans that you can utilize in order
- 2:57to attract and retain people.
- 3:00And if you have lightning in a bottle with the CEO, first of all, God bless
- 3:03you, you wanna make sure that this, 50 something CEO stays with you for a while.
- 3:08So you implement those items and people will talk about that and talk about it's
- 3:12an investment and all these other things.
- 3:13And one of the things that I see that's lacking over and over again
- 3:16is, okay, let's talk about volunteers.
- 3:19And we'll get to this a little bit, but you've been in a number of boardrooms.
- 3:22I've been in a number of boardrooms.
- 3:24Typically, when you look around, shall we say most boards are stable.
- 3:30mark: Stable.
- 3:31That's a, yeah.
- 3:31Stable.
- 3:32That's a last half that's here
- 3:34david: a euphemism.
- 3:35And so what I say is that everybody's talking about the policy or the
- 3:39paper, and very few people are talking about the practice, about, it's the
- 3:42dark side of succession planning.
- 3:44So I think that's a good place to tee it up.
- 3:47mark: Very good.
- 3:47Yeah.
- 3:47So the, yeah, so the paper you gotta have the policy, the
- 3:50regulation goes who it covers.
- 3:52There was some changes in who it covered.
- 3:55And so on.
- 3:55And on the executive side, it's interesting because a, as I look at it,
- 4:01as a former examiner, former executive at NCUA I was always about this could
- 4:07be done via a letter to credit unions versus a regulation, but I didn't
- 4:12view it as, okay, what are the tools.
- 4:16That are going to allow me to keep my executives around.
- 4:19'cause there's, there, there's pay and compensation and benefits.
- 4:23Which to me is it, I guess I hadn't thought of it that way, but of course if
- 4:26you're trying to retain them and you're gonna have succession planning, yeah.
- 4:30You wanna have a good number two in line, you gotta pay the number two.
- 4:33And I get all, I get that side of it.
- 4:35And I guess I, I looked at it from the side of.
- 4:38On that side of it was the smaller credit union.
- 4:40Sometimes they have the CEO slash manager and then that's the highest paid person
- 4:46and they can't really afford a good number to, and that, that creates some issues,
- 4:50which I think is maybe the lens of a Todd Harper foreman into a board member is
- 4:55you need to, there's too many mergers.
- 4:57When the CEO retires, there's nobody in line.
- 5:01You're gonna do that.
- 5:01That's exactly
- 5:01david: right.
- 5:02As a matter of fact I believe that Todd had said that at the meeting
- 5:06that this was launched, he said that, of course, the NCUA a as part of
- 5:11their mission, they wanna look at the stability of leadership and all of that.
- 5:15And so they, they did the root cause analysis of a lot of different
- 5:18mergers, and they found especially at smaller shops that the reason
- 5:23for a good number of these mergers.
- 5:26Was the fact that there was no there was no number two, there
- 5:30was no good succession plan.
- 5:31And they, he also went went so far as the mission.
- 5:34While it is a bit rarer, but I've certainly seen it, you have a five person
- 5:38board and suddenly three of 'em kinda look around and said, you know what?
- 5:41I'm.
- 5:42I am done.
- 5:43We are all of a certain age our CEO our manager's 10 years younger,
- 5:47we're not even gonna give an option.
- 5:49We always get invite.
- 5:50And you know how this works too.
- 5:51We always get invited to lunch at the annual meeting and that other
- 5:54credit union says, you know what?
- 5:57How would you guys like to have a three year, reign as a
- 6:00as an advisory board for us?
- 6:02And we'll just merge into you guys.
- 6:03We'll keep all your employees and next thing we have another
- 6:06business unit that, that's gone.
- 6:08So it is, I sometimes compare it to 7 0 1 0.4
- 6:13which came about, I think in 2007 or 2008, talks about board duties and authorities.
- 6:17It, that the reason that came about.
- 6:20Let's face it, n NCAA a's been around since whatever, 70, 71, and
- 6:24it took until 2008 to get this rule.
- 6:26Why?
- 6:26Because when we first met, I call it, I still call it the recent unpleasantness.
- 6:31There's the corporate credit union issues, mortgage backed securities
- 6:34and things like that, but.
- 6:36You had all those credit unions that failed.
- 6:38And in the after action report, of course, it's done as a regular part
- 6:42a as the manager of the National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund.
- 6:44The NCA found overwhelmingly that a lot of boards weren't being active enough.
- 6:49They were not asking the proper questions.
- 6:51They did not understand risk appetite.
- 6:53And a good part of that was ta-da, not a good enough reading of the
- 6:56financials, especially trend analysis.
- 6:59And so what happens, 7 0 1 specifically puts that out and that's where
- 7:02we are in succession planning.
- 7:03I think it was hit dead on that it's an issue.
- 7:06Smaller credit union.
- 7:08It goes without saying, which of course, anytime somebody says that,
- 7:10especially a lawyer, we have to say it.
- 7:12But so a smaller shop the manager's been there for 25 years, maybe longer.
- 7:18Maybe been there since she was a teller.
- 7:20mark: Right.
- 7:20david: And she's been running it, it's her life.
- 7:22It's her, it is her her youngest child.
- 7:26And and the number two, who's been there for, let's say 10 years.
- 7:30Loves the credit union, committed to it, loves number one, but has
- 7:34no desire for her life path to be what the manager's path is.
- 7:40So if somebody ask her what to do, if that, is that something you wanna do?
- 7:43No, I'll be number two.
- 7:45mark: Right?
- 7:45david: Or, the next thing you know, maybe this is going into too much detail is
- 7:50that, number two gets it automatically and either they're not well suited for it.
- 7:54It or the board comes in and says we'll give you a 10% bump from where you are.
- 7:59That should be really good.
- 8:00They say wait a second.
- 8:01What I was before was operations and now I'm everything.
- 8:05mark: And
- 8:05david: suddenly, it just, it doesn't end well.
- 8:07mark: And now when the alarms go off, it's me that has to go in on Saturday morning.
- 8:11There
- 8:11david: you go.
- 8:12I made a joke about that today.
- 8:13I made a joke about about being called in with the credit union
- 8:18with less than 24 hours notice.
- 8:19And the opening line was we, and I won't even mention his name, I'll just say.
- 8:23Rhode Island's own.
- 8:25Who did the Wicked Kennedy impression?
- 8:28The he was the, I think the associate regional director
- 8:31in charge of supervision.
- 8:32And the board chair said they've asked for a meeting.
- 8:35They don't want our CEO there.
- 8:37What does that sound like?
- 8:38And I said, bad news say, I see that look on your face.
- 8:42And only people that have been through that.
- 8:44And i, I go out and and just meet with the board and talk to 'em about a
- 8:48bunch of things, including succession, because surprise, they had two empty
- 8:51chairs on their board and other issues
- 8:53mark: yeah.
- 8:53And and you'd also mentioned we're all of a certain age, right?
- 8:56I I don't go on Facebook a lot, but I have a group from high school that's my class.
- 9:01And and they're
- 9:02david: all older than you, right?
- 9:03You're looking right.
- 9:04They're all,
- 9:04mark: man, they all look old, right?
- 9:06But occasionally, guys, the only news you have there is, hey, it's the x number
- 9:11of party, and I don't go back for it.
- 9:13But anyway, we're having the party this time, or.
- 9:15So I sad news to report so and joke oh, there you go.
- 9:19So and so passed away, right?
- 9:20So the circle of, so you have boards that are falling.
- 9:24You may, maybe you got a five member board.
- 9:27You got two 70 year olds, two 60 year olds and the young guy who's 59, right?
- 9:31And Right.
- 9:32Brand new The baby.
- 9:33The baby, yeah.
- 9:33They've been grooming him since he was on the supervisory committee 15 years ago.
- 9:37Correct.
- 9:38And you sit down as a group like that and say you need to have the
- 9:42succession planning for your board.
- 9:43How do you tackle that?
- 9:45What kind of nuances and challenges do they have?
- 9:47How do you get them to understand.
- 9:49They need some new, obviously they go, yeah, we probably could get
- 9:52somebody, but this is how, we're the only ones who wanna do it.
- 9:54They think sometimes,
- 9:55david: Oh my gosh, let's lead off, let's lead off with that.
- 9:58So that's what I hear.
- 9:59I hear this over and over again.
- 10:00And I've done a number of different workshops, a number of different
- 10:04projects because, I speak on I call the topic building a deeper bench.
- 10:08So succession planning just ran right into my my arms, so to speak.
- 10:13And now I, I get a lot of calls to help people out with this.
- 10:16And and again, like I said, a number of credit unions, in addition to,
- 10:20being outside general counsel are different from being outside general
- 10:23counsel, where they're asking me about, compliance issues or things like that.
- 10:27Now the board has me as their counsel now, they're asking me about stuff like this.
- 10:30And it's universally starts out with we can't find volunteers.
- 10:35mark: And I,
- 10:35david: and I say, and I typically try to say, and you know me, Emma.
- 10:38I'm a relatively plainspoken person.
- 10:40I try to guard back my my observation of what I consider to be the
- 10:45obvious, but I, what I say to them is you need to look harder.
- 10:49You need to look harder.
- 10:49That, that's the, they're out there.
- 10:51We're a nation of 335 million people.
- 10:53You yourselves have a hundred thousand population, right?
- 10:57You have new members coming in every month, so you need to look
- 11:00harder, but you, you hit it, and I saw recently and you'll love this
- 11:04it's not a bubble graph, right?
- 11:06But it's a graph and it showed, it had two, two data points, right?
- 11:10One line was was my age right?
- 11:13And it showed it going up.
- 11:14Above that is a line that says my definition of old, and it's
- 11:20above it and also going up,
- 11:21mark: right?
- 11:22david: But in, in any group, right?
- 11:24And the types of people that would become members of the board and I'm a recovery
- 11:27and credit union volunteer myself.
- 11:29I spent 10 years on a supervisory committee.
- 11:31But these are people that are likely to volunteer for other things in their
- 11:33community, things at their church, things in, in, in the business world.
- 11:38And as you get older and I found this with myself.
- 11:42And I, I've just, not that long ago, crossed over the Magic 60 but as you
- 11:46get older, the group of people that you regularly interact with shrinks
- 11:50mark: Sure.
- 11:51david: And and now, instead of going into work every day, and I
- 11:54experienced this when I left from being a credit unit executive to
- 11:58having my own firm that consisted of all two people that work remotely.
- 12:01All these people that are your friends and compatriots, suddenly that's gone.
- 12:06And now, so now who are you around every day.
- 12:08So when you think about who would be really good about this?
- 12:10You're not working anymore.
- 12:11You may not be involved in any of the community associations anymore.
- 12:15So maybe you're active at church and things like that and, but the
- 12:17people that you hang out with, are now tending to be your age and have
- 12:22the same reduced scope, if you will.
- 12:24And I often point out, you're right, that's not a great formula.
- 12:31For finding new people.
- 12:32And then, we will add in and we can add this as maybe a separate
- 12:35conversation topic, but then you start adding in the concept of diversity.
- 12:40And by diversity, first of all, I, I don't want to, I don't wanna trigger
- 12:43anyone, but what I mean by simply diversity is different viewpoints.
- 12:47So it, it's gonna be, it could be age, it could be sex, it could be
- 12:51race, it could be national origin.
- 12:53It could be do you have a disability?
- 12:55Are you former military?
- 12:57Do you live in the community?
- 12:58Do you have you gotten a loan in the last five years?
- 13:01Do you know how to use an iPhone?
- 13:03It could be any.
- 13:04Any do your own business, and then we can start getting into all the nitty gritty.
- 13:08Ooh.
- 13:08We want an independent business owner.
- 13:10We want somebody that has it experience.
- 13:12We want somebody to have accounting.
- 13:13So as you get all that, you're not gonna develop that from a five person
- 13:18board that's been together and the newest person came on, five years ago.
- 13:21You, you need a process.
- 13:23And that's what, it's not an event.
- 13:24You need a process that can inventory the community.
- 13:29And what contacts do you have?
- 13:32Are you community based?
- 13:33In which case, where's your community services board?
- 13:35Where is your your Salvation Army?
- 13:38Your do you have local colleges, high schools in the area?
- 13:41Where are, the people that are really active?
- 13:43And from that, you're now you're gonna look at your succession plan,
- 13:47you're gonna do an assessment.
- 13:48What are we looking for?
- 13:50And it's not about numbers.
- 13:51It's not about, oh my gosh, we are 45% Caucasian and 35% Hispanic and
- 13:56and the remaining is African American.
- 13:58So that's what we want the proportion to be.
- 13:59No, it's not gonna require, it's gonna inform.
- 14:02So how do you build a process that recognizes that in, because from there
- 14:07you've gotta plug it into nominations.
- 14:09And I'm surprised, I'm like, oh for succession planning, I'm like, all
- 14:12right, let's talk about nomination.
- 14:13What does that have to do with it?
- 14:14I'm like.
- 14:17Because here's what the nominations, and we're gonna, we're gonna do a we're
- 14:21gonna do a physical exercise here.
- 14:23So when these appear, just remind me, mark are we on camera?
- 14:26mark: We are.
- 14:27david: Perfect.
- 14:28Fold your arms, fold them.
- 14:30Just fold your arms in front of you.
- 14:31They're looking at you already got the parent look.
- 14:33mark: Yep.
- 14:33Now
- 14:34david: heck that you got the regulator.
- 14:35Look okay.
- 14:36That's right.
- 14:36Yeah.
- 14:36mark: Now
- 14:37david: unfold them.
- 14:39Listen carefully, act deliberately fold them the opposite way.
- 14:46mark: That's like the thumb exercise.
- 14:48I don't even know.
- 14:49I don't think I can.
- 14:50david: And that's just muscle memory, right?
- 14:52Yeah.
- 14:53So the bottom line is if we've been doing the same thing over and
- 14:55over again, we tend to do that.
- 14:59And if we're gonna change it, we have to be deliberate.
- 15:02And that's where it goes from paper.
- 15:05To practice.
- 15:06mark: Makes sense.
- 15:07Yeah.
- 15:07We've always done it this way, right?
- 15:08Yeah.
- 15:09Yeah.
- 15:09Oh my
- 15:09david: gosh.
- 15:09The most hated words in even more hated, by the way, than we're from the federal
- 15:13government and we're here to help us.
- 15:15Very help.
- 15:16It's just always the way we've done it.
- 15:17mark: That's right.
- 15:18david: Let me also just say that 'cause you mentioned strategic planning
- 15:21with the NCA and working with my wife Diane Reed, the the CU doctor.
- 15:25We do some strategic planning and it is just.
- 15:29Fascinating to tell a group and have them have the aha moment and say,
- 15:35listen, if you had a new voice at the table, and I'm sure we'll get to this,
- 15:40but they could be an advisory committee member, they could be a supervisor,
- 15:43just another voice in the room.
- 15:44Somebody that says, why do we do it that way?
- 15:47And suddenly everybody at the table looks around and they're like.
- 15:53Do you know what?
- 15:53That's a great point.
- 15:54I have no idea why we do it that way.
- 15:55We
- 15:56mark: think NCA told us that 15 exams ago and we that's exactly right.
- 15:59Yeah.
- 15:59david: Good luck finding it in writing.
- 16:01Yeah.
- 16:01mark: Yeah.
- 16:01And we'll change it.
- 16:02We'll change it when they tell us they have to.
- 16:04And oh, by the way.
- 16:05On succession planning, now you have to, 'cause there's that's exactly
- 16:09david: right.
- 16:09There you go.
- 16:09There you go.
- 16:10There we go.
- 16:10mark: And on the diversity thing, there's a book I make the title of which I love.
- 16:14Wisdom of crowds.
- 16:15And
- 16:16Oh
- 16:16yeah.
- 16:16It's about the diversity of thought and.
- 16:19And you need to bring different people to the table to get to the best answer.
- 16:22And, and the preface of that book that it's at it's in
- 16:25England and it's a a town fair.
- 16:28And the cow.
- 16:29The cow, right?
- 16:30Guess the weight of the cow.
- 16:32You guess the, it's go ahead.
- 16:33Go ahead.
- 16:33Say it because you, what you guess the way to the cow.
- 16:36And you win.
- 16:37If you get it right you win, you, you win.
- 16:39I think you want the cow or you win some, you win, have part of
- 16:42the cow or something like that.
- 16:43But afterwards they took all the slips of what people guessed and
- 16:46they added it off, hundreds of them.
- 16:48And guess what?
- 16:49That was?
- 16:50They nailed it on average because collectively, the people knew.
- 16:53It's like going to the horse track and betting, they figure out who
- 16:56the favorite is, who the second is.
- 16:57And who the third is.
- 16:59And over time it plays out you're not, you're gonna win if you pick the long
- 17:02shot occasionally, but if you pick the favorite, you're gonna win more often.
- 17:05But that's exactly that whole concept of bringing more.
- 17:08To the table then, it's been these six people, five people for forever, right?
- 17:14And then we go out and find our friends and who happened, who
- 17:17happened to think like us so
- 17:19david: Because let's face it, the, that goes back into what I was saying
- 17:21before, what you were intimating, our filters are this, Hey, guess what, mark?
- 17:25I'm probably the only person that thinks this way, but I find
- 17:28myself more comfortable around people that are like me, right?
- 17:31Because everybody else agitates the heck outta me, right?
- 17:34So that's just, that is just that's the way that works.
- 17:37And let me also throw this in because, one of the barriers to change in this, not
- 17:42just, this is always the way we've done it, but it's this, it's wait a second.
- 17:45Now you seem to be indicting me.
- 17:48I'm a great board member.
- 17:49Hey, young man, I've been doing this for 35 years.
- 17:52I've given everything.
- 17:53I've missed weddings.
- 17:54I came in here when I was sick as a dog.
- 17:57I, I I used to do the books and all of that, and it, and now
- 18:00you're saying I'm not good enough.
- 18:01I'm like, so whoa.
- 18:03No.
- 18:03It's, if there's no indictment of you, thank you for your service.
- 18:06God bless you.
- 18:06That's how things work.
- 18:07What I'm saying is.
- 18:10That there is a time and a season for everything, so you are great.
- 18:15What I'm saying is these new voices, that diversity of thought,
- 18:19people that can say you know what?
- 18:20I just logged onto my Chase app and they came up with three
- 18:25balloon notes and said, oh, by the way, we see your cars coming up.
- 18:28We see that you have a certificate of deposit, we'd like to offer you something
- 18:32else, and we've done a quick soft pull of your credit report and we've determined
- 18:37that you have at least one credit card with an interest rate over 11%.
- 18:41We can offer you one at seven.
- 18:44And, what are we doing like that?
- 18:45And everybody else is I don't even have a credit card.
- 18:48And, yeah.
- 18:48It's just, it's getting that new thought in there.
- 18:52Probably one of the things we should discuss is the different channels of doing
- 18:55this, and is there a way of doing it that doesn't go under the board and say, Mark,
- 18:59thank you for your 35 years of service.
- 19:01Get outta here.
- 19:02mark: Yeah.
- 19:02So let's pivot to that.
- 19:03What are the channels, you mentioned advisory boards.
- 19:06Do you suggest people have advisory boards or advisory floaters that
- 19:10learned the supervisory camp?
- 19:12Absolutely.
- 19:12What's the path?
- 19:13What's the path to, to building a, one of
- 19:15david: the things just a couple years ago.
- 19:19And it, first of all, the path is not the same for everybody.
- 19:22And it's not necessarily, about size and complexity.
- 19:26It's about where you are from a governance's perspective, where you
- 19:29are from a community perspective.
- 19:32But I obviously I'm a bylaws fan, right?
- 19:35I'm a governance freak.
- 19:36And I tell people the bylaws is that's their number one roadmap for governance.
- 19:40And I really liked the last.
- 19:43A couple of changes from the NCUA.
- 19:45I love the fact that they added additional information about the advisory, and
- 19:49I love how they added additional information about Director Emeritus.
- 19:52Just as a reminder the advisory board member I, is they have to
- 19:56pass all the background checks.
- 19:58They have to be bondable, right?
- 20:00Because they're gonna have personal, private information presented to 'em.
- 20:03But now it's basic.
- 20:04It is, it's an internship program.
- 20:08It's an unpaid internship for mostly an unpaid position, but
- 20:12now you can bring on these people and they have a chance to learn.
- 20:16Is this for me?
- 20:18And again, I have a bias for supervisory committee, but I will just say this.
- 20:23If you look at the bucket of skills for a supervisory committee it
- 20:27is dramatically different from the bucket of skills, right?
- 20:31For the board.
- 20:31And you could be the, the boy talk about old time books.
- 20:34It's the Peter principle, right?
- 20:36In any given hierarchy, a person tends to rise up to their level of,
- 20:40shall we say, not producing well.
- 20:41mark: Right.
- 20:42david: But the more channels that you have the better.
- 20:45And then let's work in a few other things.
- 20:48So I'm a big fan of that.
- 20:49Provided they're onboarded.
- 20:51mark: And I'm thinking of the director of Meredith, so you, let's
- 20:53say you got a board of five, right?
- 20:54Each one's 20%.
- 20:56And I'm gonna make a correlation to N-C-A-N-C-A is losing 22% of their staff.
- 21:01It's the 22% of their staff that have 30 years, 35 years.
- 21:0525 years, and are eligible to either retire early under the,
- 21:09that's a lot of knowledge, isn't it?
- 21:10That's, it's a lot of knowledge, but it, but if you have a board of five
- 21:13and a guy's guy, or a lady who's been on that board for 25 years, and you
- 21:17just say, okay, we're gonna put you out the pasture, that's 20% of your.
- 21:22Corporate knowledge at least, because they probably have more than 20% of
- 21:26the years oh, that's exactly right.
- 21:27Let's
- 21:28david: just, let's just hit that one.
- 21:29It's a great point.
- 21:29So first of all, here's an easy one.
- 21:31I'm all about low hanging fruit, right?
- 21:33So how about we increase the board size?
- 21:36Right.
- 21:36And upsizing the board.
- 21:38Now, obviously if you're a state chartered credit union, you're gonna have different
- 21:41interactions with your state regulator.
- 21:43But for the most part I will say almost universally which is like almost exactly.
- 21:48So not all the time, but the vast majority of times increasing your
- 21:52board size is never gonna be a problem.
- 21:54Now, once you start downsizing, there could be some other issues.
- 21:58So let's say you're at five popping up to seven.
- 22:02Don't have the drain, don't have the brain drain immediately.
- 22:05Put a few more people, put a few more people on there.
- 22:08And so that's another way to address it.
- 22:11And we want to be respectful of our volunteers.
- 22:15We wanna honor them.
- 22:16And I've heard people make the jokes, oh we'll name our training room
- 22:19after them, and that'll be that.
- 22:20Now we can do director emeritus, because let's go ahead and talk about some things.
- 22:24Let's just, let's bring this out.
- 22:26Okay.
- 22:28You have a more mature board member.
- 22:31Now, this is one of the now few things that they're actively
- 22:35involved in, and they're not only actively, they're in charge, they're
- 22:38at the top of that pyramid, right?
- 22:40They are in charge of the one employee who's running a, a federally chartered
- 22:45or insured for the most part.
- 22:46Not always, obviously credit union.
- 22:49And they get travel from that.
- 22:51They get camaraderie from that they get a sense of purpose for that.
- 22:55And that's tough.
- 22:56So if you move them into a director emeritus, then you can offer and I'll just
- 23:04say maybe I go a little bit over, but I typically offer them one term of travel.
- 23:10Provided they, they come to the meetings and participate.
- 23:13I, I want to, and it's not, people say, oh, you're paying them off.
- 23:16No.
- 23:16I want to keep them in the camp because of what you mentioned, their
- 23:20knowledge and their experience and I think that's the way to do it.
- 23:24Now let's go back to that crossing of the hands.
- 23:26If your nominations policy consists of, we go to every incumbent.
- 23:33If they want to run, we nominate 'em.
- 23:36If that's your nominations policy, first of all, you're absolutely wrong, right?
- 23:41You need a job description.
- 23:42It would be great if you had an assessment and I'm a pretty,
- 23:45again, I'm a pretty simple guy.
- 23:47To be on the board, you need four things.
- 23:49Here's the four things you need to do, right?
- 23:50So you may wanna put this on the credit union examination
- 23:54solutions pay site, right?
- 23:56Yeah.
- 23:56Just cut me in for 80% more.
- 23:58Cool.
- 23:58You
- 23:58mark: got it.
- 23:58You got it.
- 23:59david: Here's all I need.
- 24:00Ready?
- 24:01Show up.
- 24:04That's a big one.
- 24:05That's a big one.
- 24:06Be prepared.
- 24:08Read that board package.
- 24:09Ask questions as necessary.
- 24:11And by the way, when you ask questions, copy the whole rest of the board, right?
- 24:15So that everybody sees that communication channel show up.
- 24:18Be prepared, participate.
- 24:22We remember the old, the old joke of, examiners would say
- 24:25how active was the board?
- 24:26Lemme tell you how active they are.
- 24:27They're this active, right?
- 24:31Show up, be prepared, participate.
- 24:33And the final one, are you ready?
- 24:35Play well with others.
- 24:36mark: Right?
- 24:38david: And that's it, and so you need a succession plan.
- 24:44That's going to hopefully play well into that.
- 24:48And like advisory committee members.
- 24:50That's great.
- 24:50So now you can see, are they showing up, are they prepared?
- 24:53Are they participating?
- 24:54They can't vote, but they could participate.
- 24:57And the biggest thing, could they play well with others?
- 24:59Every board, any and I may even ask people on my next session here at
- 25:03this volunteer conference, but if I were to look at a room of 200 people.
- 25:07That's what it was this morning.
- 25:08200 people.
- 25:09If I were to ask how many of you have been on other boards or other leadership
- 25:14post in a volunteer, I'm gonna guesstimate easily close to two thirds of the
- 25:18people are gonna raise their hand.
- 25:20Because that's just it.
- 25:21It's the model that's like to help.
- 25:22We like to be involved.
- 25:23And eventually, if you're gonna be involved, of course I want to be on the
- 25:25board 'cause I want my voice to count.
- 25:28And if you ask that same group of people, how many of you
- 25:30guys have either been driven.
- 25:33To exit that opportunity or almost driven to exit that opportunity
- 25:37because there was somebody else there that was just such a jerk.
- 25:40And I'm gonna guesstimate, most of those hands are gonna go up.
- 25:43And I think there are ways that we can design a process to help
- 25:47with succession that will help do that as long as they move, right?
- 25:52As long as they go to step one, they'll have a map.
- 25:56They gotta have a map.
- 25:58Because whenever the NCUA comes around again, or their state
- 26:01supervisory authorities come around, they'll have that map.
- 26:03The question is, are they gonna take the first step on it?
- 26:06mark: Great point.
- 26:07You do well, play well with others.
- 26:09I mo I moved once with NCUA because I didn't, my boss
- 26:14didn't play well for others.
- 26:15With Oh.
- 26:16Oh wow.
- 26:16And, I went halfway across the country for that reason.
- 26:19So worked out.
- 26:21But
- 26:21david: yeah, everything happens for a reason.
- 26:23But it wasn't see what had happened, wasn.
- 26:24mark: It was, no, it wasn't easy when it happened and did a lot
- 26:27of soul searching relative to it.
- 26:29And I found a better boss on the West coast and and then that, positioned me for
- 26:34other situations and those board members who left one board and they're now on this
- 26:38board you learn, I learned from my good bosses, and I learned from my bad bosses.
- 26:43Absolutely.
- 26:44Absolutely.
- 26:44david: Hey, as the Good book says, the, the dude upstairs, he
- 26:48can be helped with good things that happen or bad things, right?
- 26:51My wife has taught me a phrase and we've only been together for 40
- 26:54plus years, so I'm still trying to learn it, but the phrase is this, I
- 26:57used to always say it is what it is.
- 26:59And I can still hear Diane's voice actually from where I'm talking.
- 27:01I can see Diane and she is lovely.
- 27:04It is what it is, but it becomes what we make of it.
- 27:08Right,
- 27:08mark: yep.
- 27:08It's wonderful.
- 27:09And so
- 27:09david: there are ways that you can look you wanna avoid the one hit wonder.
- 27:12And this is the same way by, if you were career pathing a teller to show
- 27:18them how to become a teller supervisor.
- 27:21Then an assistant branch manager, and then a loan officer and a branch
- 27:24manager to VP of lending, right?
- 27:26You're gonna do some of these same things, but you also have the
- 27:28person that comes in that says, oh, I've been a teller for a month.
- 27:31I'm ready to be the CEO now.
- 27:33So you gotta say whoa.
- 27:34Here's the plan.
- 27:35Here's what it looks like.
- 27:36mark: The career, here's the career ladder.
- 27:37And you can have that career ladder for the absolutely volunteers.
- 27:41As well as the staff in the credit union.
- 27:43I
- 27:43david: seem to recall many discussions in the NCUA, always
- 27:46trying to make sure that was clear.
- 27:48If you want to go here's what you need to pack,
- 27:50mark: right?
- 27:51Yeah.
- 27:51Yeah.
- 27:51What are my opportunities?
- 27:52How do I get there?
- 27:53Et cetera, et cetera.
- 27:54So what have we missed, David?
- 27:56What when you're do you've got your, you've got your syllabus for your.
- 28:00Your your presentation what topics have we not touched as it relates to session?
- 28:05So I
- 28:05david: guess let's talk about this.
- 28:06So when I talk about that first step, what is that first step?
- 28:09Because we have to counter, Hey, we've tried to get new volunteers before.
- 28:12Remember that time we got that one volunteer?
- 28:14How long ago was that?
- 28:15I don't know.
- 28:16Let's face it, the older you get.
- 28:17Everything is, you're thinking it was three years and somebody
- 28:20says no, that was 12 years ago.
- 28:22So one of the, one of the things is give them and I try to do this
- 28:26if I work with an individual credit union or even in, in my trainings.
- 28:29And again, I just onboarded a new credit union as a board council and
- 28:32where they want me to talk about this.
- 28:33But I'm like, all right, let's just look at what you could do.
- 28:36Where are the available volunteers?
- 28:39Okay, doesn't that question, isn't that question informed
- 28:41by what are you looking for?
- 28:43You don't want to just put on a bunch of 23-year-old people, right?
- 28:46So what you, so now you're gonna have all that and you're gonna
- 28:48help, that's gonna be in the plan.
- 28:49So now how do we get to 'em?
- 28:52And another risk is.
- 28:54And we're not saying everything's wrong about it, but you wanna
- 28:56get 'em through multiple doors.
- 28:57You wanna get 'em to the tap on the shoulder from the board.
- 29:00Maybe the CEO mentioned somebody maybe another employee mentioned somebody.
- 29:05Any number of things.
- 29:06I'll tell this story.
- 29:08One of my favorite stories on acquisition of new identification and acquisition,
- 29:12new volunteers was I was I was MCing.
- 29:17The, a very large supervisory committee, an internal audit
- 29:20conference by America's credit units.
- 29:22And somebody said I'll tell you how we get new members of the supervisory committee.
- 29:26I said, do tell.
- 29:27Because this applies to them as well.
- 29:29Absolutely.
- 29:29And they said almost every year at the annual meeting, somebody will get up and
- 29:32say, all yeah, I was looking at page two.
- 29:35Footnote three.
- 29:36And here's what I wanna know.
- 29:37What are these other losses that you've considered and
- 29:40what are you trying to hide?
- 29:42And what we do is that, that stick in the mud right there.
- 29:45We say, Hey, you know what, we're gonna get you that information
- 29:48and why don't we do it over lunch?
- 29:50'cause I wanna tell you about opportunities on
- 29:52the supervisory committee.
- 29:53So that's one.
- 29:54Let's start with some simple things, we know that according to according
- 29:57to everybody's bylaws, they have to advertise for positions X number of
- 30:01days prior to the annual meeting, right?
- 30:03Let's call it 120 days.
- 30:05And they have to get a nominations committee.
- 30:07They have to do this, they have to have the slate in then they have to
- 30:10give an opportunity for people to petition if that's what they want to.
- 30:12So all of that is there, right?
- 30:14Most everybody, I dunno how many of these, I prepared an Excel spreadsheet
- 30:17that you just put the number in.
- 30:19I don't know if you've ever used Excel, mark.
- 30:21It's a really good program.
- 30:22You should you should look into that.
- 30:23One of my,
- 30:23mark: one of my favorites
- 30:25david: and and pivot table.
- 30:27And so beyond that, how about we just, you know what?
- 30:30Keep the ad out there.
- 30:32Keep it out there.
- 30:3312 months outta the year.
- 30:36Whoa.
- 30:36What's that gonna do?
- 30:37What it's gonna do is it's gonna open a door.
- 30:39Maybe you get nobody, maybe you get 10 people.
- 30:42Maybe you put maybe you put advertisements in the newsletters
- 30:46of your big community organizations.
- 30:48Maybe you ping people you're already working with.
- 30:50Maybe you have a great relationship with the HR person of the employer
- 30:54that used to be your primary sick.
- 30:56All of these people you're gonna identify and then you're gonna reach
- 30:58out and what are you gonna give 'em?
- 31:00You're gonna give 'em a job description.
- 31:01This is what we're looking for, and then ready.
- 31:06You need to have a process to accept that.
- 31:10So now you're gonna have, so let's say you have just a quick application or
- 31:14whatever, it's, somebody's gonna look at that, you're gonna confirm receipt of
- 31:18it and then interview where appropriate.
- 31:22And let's face it, we've had situations before where you have
- 31:26had in, you've had seemingly very qualified people that, that go very
- 31:30public, that says, Hey, wait a second.
- 31:32We, we, applied.
- 31:35For volunteer position and nobody even called us back.
- 31:37mark: Right.
- 31:38david: And then you go back and look at they've been nominating
- 31:40the same people that were up for years and years, and maybe there's
- 31:43a reason for that, they should have at least, contacted those people.
- 31:46Yeah.
- 31:46So you're going to create that process.
- 31:50You're gonna know what you want.
- 31:51You're gonna put it out there.
- 31:52Any number of places, put it in the branch, for the people that come in
- 31:55there, have it come up as a popup, once somebody hits just pick weird
- 32:00number 25 transactions in a month.
- 32:02Boom, it pops up.
- 32:03Have you considered this?
- 32:05Hit this link.
- 32:06Send out a text to people.
- 32:07E-sign, e-sign is great.
- 32:09And then we go back into the process.
- 32:11Oh, we only have five seats.
- 32:12All right, push it up to.
- 32:13I don't push it up to 12, of course would be 12, be 13 go to extra seats, create
- 32:19the advisory committees, and with each one of those, here's what we expect of you.
- 32:23And that's and then you may be able to bring on some people.
- 32:26Oh, but a lot of those people whoa, what was it Jefferson said?
- 32:29How much time do we waste reacting to affronts?
- 32:34That are only in our mind
- 32:35mark: Have never actually occurred.
- 32:37Mark Twain I've had some horrific experiences in my life, some
- 32:41of which actually happened.
- 32:42Right.
- 32:42david: Oh, I love that.
- 32:43I, oh my God.
- 32:44Yeah.
- 32:44Mark Twain.
- 32:45Don't get me started.
- 32:47So those are just some ideas.
- 32:49Of how to do it.
- 32:50And and I have mentioned some things that probably, I have some very valent ideas.
- 32:55I like some things I don't like other things.
- 32:57Yep.
- 32:57And I don't mean to say that there's any single wrong thing, but let's go back to
- 33:01the CEO and helping to identify they're active in the community, they're part
- 33:05of other organizations that can help.
- 33:07The issue is that if you have the CEO naming everybody.
- 33:13I've literally had people say, oh yeah, I've met the super, I've
- 33:16met the nominations committee.
- 33:17It's the CEO, or the CEO EO says I could do this, or it
- 33:20says, I, says I can do that.
- 33:22Or hey I've known, some supervisory committees where there'll be maybe an
- 33:26independent mind and a couple neighbors of the CEO and that's just not how
- 33:31sure the system was designed to work
- 33:33mark: A and it, they could be perfectly qualified.
- 33:36They, it could be a situation where they'll question the CEO,
- 33:39but it gives the perception.
- 33:41That you're not looking for a diverse pool, that you're not looking for
- 33:45maybe you're looking for this question.
- 33:46Thought.
- 33:47Yeah.
- 33:47Looking, and that's a great point, right?
- 33:48Where when do I vote Yes.
- 33:49So I, yeah exactly right.
- 33:50david: Could be very well qualified people, but, hey, if they're, if they're
- 33:54drinking, eggnog in the garage, they may have a tendency to talk about things.
- 33:57mark: Very good.
- 33:58Yeah.
- 33:59W if there's one other thing I should have asked you that I didn't David,
- 34:02what would that be on this topic?
- 34:05Did we hit it all?
- 34:07david: We certainly hit it, so I would, so maybe this question.
- 34:10So what's the biggest thing that a credit unit needs to overcome to ensure success?
- 34:18And I would go back to, i'm not sure who the quotation is.
- 34:21I'm sure you'll know.
- 34:22We've met the enemy and they are us.
- 34:24And the biggest thing I is that this is always the way we've done it and to
- 34:29take ownership of it, to recognize that change may be a little bit painful, right?
- 34:34I'm not a big change person.
- 34:35I'm we recently moved the coffee maker in our kitchen, and I'm
- 34:39still a little emotionally.
- 34:41Fragile from that decision.
- 34:42But
- 34:43That's part of the process of growing that there are lots of options.
- 34:48A and overcome yourself, map it out.
- 34:50The succession plan, the requirement January 20, 26, as you stated, gives
- 34:56a great opportunity to focus on this.
- 34:59So the question for them is, what's that first step?
- 35:02What happens next?
- 35:05mark: And if someone wants to reach out to you and is ready to take that first
- 35:08step they've forgotten that this rule is in place in January, or they just want
- 35:14to talk to you about how they, we've got our plan, we think we've got it.
- 35:17They want to get in touch with you and how they might be able to make it better.
- 35:19What's the best way for them to get in touch with you?
- 35:22david: Email by far.
- 35:23I look at that all the time.
- 35:24Too much as as my wife would say, it's david@reedandjolly.com,
- 35:31and I think you'll give 'em that in other formats as well.
- 35:33But that, that, that's the best way and I am happy to help.
- 35:36In any way that I can, I've probably made most mistakes possible in this area.
- 35:41So I, I'm ready to have other people avoid those landmines.
- 35:44mark: There you go.
- 35:45There you go.
- 35:45That's the scar tissue that, that went, that that doing things and making
- 35:49decisions creates, that's fantastic.
- 35:51Absolutely.
- 35:52Thank you.
- 35:52Thank you so much for your time.
- 35:53As always.
- 35:54Pleasure chatting with you.
- 35:55Absolutely my friend.
- 35:56Thank you so much, mark.
- 35:57Take care.
- 35:58And God bless you.
- 35:58You got it.
- 35:59God bless you.
- 36:00And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 36:02This is Mark Reel, signing off with flying colors.