Latest / The Morning Rundown / Trump's Iran Remark, Tennessee's Failed Execution, and Mortgage Rates at 7.28%
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I am on my second cup of coffee, a vanilla oat
- 0:18[Maya] thing I regret, and it's still not enough for this news cycle.
- 0:21[David] Second?
- 0:22[David] Maya, it's barely past the opening music.
- 0:25[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 0:26[Maya] Some mornings demand it.
- 0:28[David] Fair.
- 0:28[Maya] Anyway, welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:31[Maya] I'm Maya, and that's David, who is drinking plain black coffee like
- 0:35[Maya] a person with no joy.
- 0:36[David] Joy is overrated.
- 0:38[David] Efficiency, that's my thing.
- 0:40[Maya] Sure it is.
- 0:41[Maya] So what have we got?
- 0:42[David] Three stories.
- 0:43[David] First, a remark from President Trump about Iran that has people fighting
- 0:47[David] over what he actually meant.
- 0:49[Maya] Then Tennessee, where a failed execution has people asking who answers for
- 0:53[Maya] it.
- 0:54[David] And mortgage rates.
- 0:55[David] One number, seven point two eight percent, and it lands right on
- 0:59[David] the household budget.
- 1:00[Maya] Ooh, the wallet one.
- 1:01[Maya] Everybody's favorite.
- 1:03[David] Nobody's favorite.
- 1:04[Maya] And we'll keep it fair today.
- 1:05[Maya] We'll say what the sources say, and where they don't say, we'll
- 1:08[Maya] tell you that too.
- 1:09[David] Which, fair warning, comes up more than once this morning.
- 1:12[Maya] Honestly, that's the most useful thing we can promise on a morning
- 1:16[Maya] like this.
- 1:17[David] Low bar, high value.
- 1:19[Maya] Okay, okay.
- 1:20[Maya] Let's start with a speech that got a lot of people arguing
- 1:23[Maya] about what it meant.
- 1:24[David] Right.
- 1:25[David] Because with this one, the words matter, and so does the context.
- 1:29[Maya] Okay, so the reaction part.
- 1:32[Maya] Al Jazeera reported that Democrats and Republicans both got loud about Trump's
- 1:36[Maya] remarks on Iran, San Diego, and Los Angeles.
- 1:40[David] Both parties?
- 1:41[David] That's rare.
- 1:42[Maya] Right?
- 1:43[Maya] And the White House disputed how everybody read it.
- 1:46[David] Of course it did.
- 1:47[David] So what's the dispute exactly?
- 1:49[Maya] The Hill reported that Communications Director Steven Cheung called the reaction a
- 1:53[Maya] media freak-out.
- 1:55[David] Chuckle-able.
- 1:56[Maya] Subtle.
- 1:57[Maya] Then The Hill says the rapid response account put it this way:
- 2:01[Maya] Trump meant the US is fighting to stop Iran from getting a
- 2:04[Maya] nuclear weapon that could hit LA and San Diego.
- 2:08[David] Hmm.
- 2:08[David] And that reading actually makes sense to me.
- 2:10[David] A president talking about why you block a nuclear weapon is a
- 2:13[David] pretty normal thing to say.
- 2:15[Maya] Sure, but I mean, come on, the wording is what started the
- 2:18[Maya] fire.
- 2:19[David] Fair.
- 2:19[David] What did he actually say?
- 2:21[Maya] Axios published the fuller passage from the rally in Grand Island, Nebraska,
- 2:25[Maya] and Axios described the speech as ambiguous.
- 2:28[David] Ambiguous.
- 2:29[David] Not damning, not clean.
- 2:32[Maya] Right.
- 2:32[Maya] And Axios also quoted Newsom, San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria, and LA
- 2:38[Maya] Mayor Bass reacting to it.
- 2:40[David] Wait, so the mayors of the two cities named are weighing in?
- 2:42[David] Of course they are.
- 2:44[Maya] Totally.
- 2:45[Maya] Here's a funny wrinkle, though.
- 2:46[Maya] The coverage doesn't even match on the verb.
- 2:49[David] Oh?
- 2:50[Maya] Either Iran could take the cities or Iran could take out.
- 2:55[David] That's a different sentence.
- 2:56[David] One sounds like seizing, the other sounds like destroying.
- 2:59[Maya] Exactly.
- 3:01[Maya] And I'm not going to pretend I can settle that from here.
- 3:03[David] Good, because the sources only give us so much.
- 3:06[David] We know it got reported, we know what the White House says
- 3:09[David] he meant, and we know the wording was loose.
- 3:11[Maya] Let me push on the cross-party part, though.
- 3:14[Maya] Al Jazeera says both sides were outraged, but a lot of that
- 3:17[Maya] outrage turns on which sentence you think he meant.
- 3:21[David] Right.
- 3:21[David] If you hear a threat of destruction aimed at American cities, that's
- 3:24[David] alarming coming from a President.
- 3:26[David] If you hear an argument for stopping a nuclear weapon, it's a
- 3:29[David] case for the policy.
- 3:30[David] Same speech, two different readings.
- 3:32[Maya] And the White House is saying the second reading is the right
- 3:35[Maya] one, and that the first is overheated.
- 3:37[David] Which it's right to argue.
- 3:39[David] The media freak-out line is a spin line, sure, but the Rapid
- 3:42[David] Response explanation is at least a specific claim you can hold up
- 3:45[David] against the passage.
- 3:47[Maya] Though critics would say a President owns his wording.
- 3:51[Maya] If people across the aisle heard something troubling, maybe the phrasing was
- 3:55[Maya] the problem.
- 3:56[David] That's a Fair knock.
- 3:57[David] Clear words are part of the job.
- 3:59[David] But it's also Fair to say that outrage on day one isn't
- 4:02[David] proof of what he meant.
- 4:03[David] Both things can be true.
- 4:04[Maya] And that's the honest position.
- 4:06[Maya] People who hate him will hear the worst version, his defenders will
- 4:09[Maya] hear the nuclear threat version, and the Transcript sits in the middle
- 4:13[Maya] being vague.
- 4:15[David] Transcripts Never take sides.
- 4:17[Maya] Never.
- 4:18[Maya] Okay, Speaking of which, a very different kind of story where Nobodys
- 4:22[Maya] arguing about what was meant because something plainly went wrong.
- 4:26[David] Tennessee.
- 4:27[Maya] From a fight over words to a Failed in the real world.
- 4:30[Maya] Yeah, Tennessee.
- 4:32[Maya] Okay, serious one.
- 4:34[Maya] Christa Pike, Tennessee, and an Execution that did not work.
- 4:40[David] Right, and the update matters.
- 4:41[David] Uh, PBS NewsHour, in an update dated October sixth, says Pike is
- 4:46[David] fifty and survived two doses of pentobarbital last Wednesday.
- 4:49[Maya] Two doses?
- 4:51[David] Two.
- 4:52[David] Her lawyers say she is now awake and speaking in a hospital.
- 4:56[Maya] And that part comes from her lawyers, right?
- 4:58[Maya] Not the state?
- 4:59[David] Yes.
- 5:00[David] Her lawyers also say her arms were burned and blistered.
- 5:03[David] That's their account, and I'd keep it labeled that way.
- 5:05[Maya] Fair.
- 5:06[Maya] Is there anything on how she's doing?
- 5:08[David] The BBC piece describes a medical expert advising her legal team, who
- 5:12[David] says she's communicating in a basic way.
- 5:15[David] So again, her side's expert, not an independent finding.
- 5:18[Maya] Hmm, okay.
- 5:20[David] Now the accountability piece.
- 5:21[David] CBS News reports that Governor Bill Lee announced Corrections Commissioner Frank Strada
- 5:26[David] will step down this month.
- 5:28[Maya] Step down, not fired.
- 5:30[David] The report says step down while an independent review goes forward.
- 5:34[David] I wouldn't read more into the wording than that.
- 5:36[Maya] And Strada's position?
- 5:38[David] He says the department followed protocol.
- 5:40[Maya] Huh.
- 5:41[Maya] So a failed execution and the guy running the department says everything
- 5:46[Maya] went by the book.
- 5:47[David] Which is a hard sentence to sit next to a hospital bed.
- 5:50[David] Pike's lawyers say something different.
- 5:52[David] They say the IV team missed that her veins had blown.
- 5:55[Maya] Wait, so the state says protocol was followed, and the lawyers say
- 6:00[Maya] the team missed a basic warning sign.
- 6:03[David] Those are the two accounts.
- 6:04[David] Maya, I can't tell you which is right, and neither can anyone
- 6:07[David] reading these reports.
- 6:08[Maya] Yeah, it's the review's job then.
- 6:11[David] Exactly.
- 6:11[David] That's why an independent one matters.
- 6:14[David] If the department grades its own homework, nobody believes the grade, whichever
- 6:17[David] way it comes out.
- 6:19[Maya] Let me press on that, because independent review can sound like a
- 6:22[Maya] magic phrase.
- 6:23[Maya] What are we actually waiting on?
- 6:25[David] Honestly, the sources give us the outline and not the details.
- 6:29[David] The governor announced it, the commissioner is stepping down this month while
- 6:32[David] it goes forward, and that's what's on the record.
- 6:34[David] I'm not going to guess at its scope or its timeline.
- 6:37[Maya] Okay, but we can say what the two accounts put in front
- 6:40[Maya] of it.
- 6:41[David] Sure.
- 6:41[David] One account is that the department followed protocol.
- 6:44[David] The other is that the IV team missed that her veins had
- 6:47[David] blown.
- 6:47[David] Those aren't just different spin, they're different claims about what happened in
- 6:51[David] that room, and sorting that out is the sort of thing a
- 6:53[David] review exists for.
- 6:55[Maya] I'd add the uncomfortable part.
- 6:57[Maya] Following protocol and a failed execution can both be true.
- 7:01[Maya] If the protocol was followed and it still went wrong, then maybe
- 7:05[Maya] the question is the protocol.
- 7:07[David] That's a real possibility, and it's a different kind of accountability.
- 7:10[David] It's not who messed up, it's whether the process itself was sound.
- 7:15[David] But that's us thinking out loud, not something the reports say.
- 7:18[Maya] Right.
- 7:18[Maya] And for the commissioner, stepping down while saying he did it by
- 7:21[Maya] the book is a strange spot.
- 7:24[David] It is, though I'd stay careful there too.
- 7:26[David] The summary we have gives us the resignation and his position, and
- 7:30[David] I won't fill in a reason.
- 7:32[Maya] Totally.
- 7:33[Maya] Okay, the question everybody asks next: Can Tennessee just try again?
- 7:38[David] PBS quotes a law professor on that.
- 7:40[David] The professor doubts the Supreme Court would block a retry on double
- 7:44[David] jeopardy grounds.
- 7:45[Maya] Hold on.
- 7:46[Maya] Double jeopardy sounds like the obvious argument.
- 7:48[Maya] You can't be punished twice for the same thing.
- 7:51[David] It does sound obvious, but that's one expert's view, not a ruling.
- 7:55[David] No court has decided it here, as far as these sources say.
- 7:59[Maya] So it's an opinion about a case that hasn't happened yet.
- 8:02[David] Right.
- 8:03[David] An informed opinion, but still a forecast.
- 8:06[Maya] Got it.
- 8:07[Maya] And nothing beyond that.
- 8:09[David] Nothing beyond that.
- 8:10[David] We have a survivor, a resignation, two competing stories, and a review
- 8:14[David] that hasn't reported.
- 8:15[Maya] Which is where we leave it until it does.
- 8:18[David] Speaking of things with real consequences, let's go to something that touches
- 8:22[David] almost every household budget.
- 8:24[Maya] Yes.
- 8:24[Maya] Check your wallet first.
- 8:27[Maya] Okay, David, this one I actually feel in my bones.
- 8:30[Maya] Freddie Mac put out its survey dated October first, and the thirty-year
- 8:34[Maya] fixed is sitting at seven point two eight percent.
- 8:38[David] Yeah, and I wanna be careful with that number because it's not
- 8:41[David] a mood.
- 8:42[David] It's a weekly survey, and it's the primary source for this whole
- 8:45[David] story.
- 8:46[Maya] Wait, so what was it before?
- 8:48[David] The week before, it was seven point zero three, so that's a
- 8:51[David] jump in a single week.
- 8:53[Maya] Ouch.
- 8:54[David] A year earlier, it was six point three percent, so the same
- 8:57[David] loan costs noticeably more to carry than it did last fall.
- 9:01[Maya] That's the kind of gap people feel at the kitchen table, you
- 9:04[Maya] know what I mean?
- 9:05[David] Totally.
- 9:06[David] And the fifteen-year rate is six point six zero percent.
- 9:09[David] Lower rate, but a much bigger monthly bite because you're paying it
- 9:12[David] off faster.
- 9:13[David] Families weigh that trade constantly.
- 9:16[Maya] Okay, but let's make it human.
- 9:18[Maya] Say a couple is house hunting.
- 9:20[Maya] They had a number in their head last year.
- 9:21[Maya] What happens now?
- 9:23[David] So I won't invent a payment figure because I don't have their
- 9:25[David] loan size.
- 9:26[David] But think of it as a dial.
- 9:28[David] Same house, same down payment, and the monthly bill creeps up every
- 9:32[David] time that rate ticks up.
- 9:34[Maya] So the house didn't change price, but it got more expensive.
- 9:38[David] Right.
- 9:38[David] The sticker on the lawn is the same.
- 9:40[David] The real price is the monthly payment, and a lot of folks
- 9:43[David] shop by the monthly payment, not the list price.
- 9:46[Maya] Which means some houses just quietly slide out of reach.
- 9:50[David] Exactly.
- 9:51[David] And for people who stretch to fit a budget already, a week-to-week
- 9:55[David] jump like that can tip it.
- 9:57[Maya] Hmm.
- 9:57[Maya] Is it just mortgages, though?
- 9:59[David] No.
- 10:00[David] NPR reported on October seventh that mortgage rates are at their highest
- 10:04[David] level in almost three years.
- 10:06[Maya] Almost three years?
- 10:07[Maya] That's wild, right?
- 10:09[David] And NPR said it's not stopping at housing.
- 10:12[David] The cost of car loans and higher education loans is hit too.
- 10:16[Maya] So the family shopping for a house might also be the family
- 10:19[Maya] with a teenager heading to college.
- 10:21[David] Or one that needs a second car.
- 10:23[David] Same squeeze, three different lenders.
- 10:25[Maya] And the thing is, the sources don't hand us a car loan
- 10:28[Maya] rate or a student loan rate today, so I can't tell you
- 10:31[Maya] how much.
- 10:32[David] Right, and I won't make one up.
- 10:34[David] NPR's point is the direction.
- 10:36[David] Borrowing is getting costlier across the board, not only for houses.
- 10:40[Maya] Which changes how a family plans.
- 10:42[Maya] If you're stretching for a house and a car and tuition, you
- 10:46[Maya] can't treat those as separate decisions.
- 10:48[David] Exactly.
- 10:49[David] It all comes out of the same monthly budget.
- 10:51[David] A bit more on the mortgage can mean less room for everything
- 10:53[David] else, and that's the real pressure.
- 10:56[Maya] And the year-over-year gap matters there too, doesn't it?
- 10:59[Maya] Six point three four to seven point two eight.
- 11:02[David] It does.
- 11:03[David] Anyone who started planning a year ago was working from a very
- 11:06[David] different number, and the one-week move from seven point zero three is
- 11:10[David] the part that stings for people about to commit.
- 11:13[Maya] Borrowing season is rough.
- 11:15[David] It is.
- 11:16[David] And here's a practical point: If you're shopping, don't anchor on last
- 11:20[David] year's rate.
- 11:21[David] Ask for a payment quote at today's rate, then see what you
- 11:23[David] can live with.
- 11:24[Maya] And if you're not ready to buy?
- 11:26[David] Then you've got time to watch.
- 11:28[David] Freddie Mac's next weekly release is due Thursday, October eighth, and that
- 11:31[David] tells us whether this was a blip or a trend.
- 11:34[Maya] Tomorrow, basically.
- 11:35[David] Basically.
- 11:36[David] One number and a lot of people will be refreshing the page.
- 11:39[Maya] Hmm.
- 11:40[Maya] I'd be one of them, honestly.
- 11:42[David] Same.
- 11:43[David] Mortgages are the quiet bill that decides where your life happens.
- 11:47[Maya] Okay, let's pull the three together.
- 11:50[Maya] Okay, coffee's gone, so I'm officially out of excuses.
- 11:54[Maya] Before we go, let's do the quick lap, one line each.
- 11:57[David] Go for it.
- 11:59[Maya] The Iran remark.
- 12:00[Maya] The White House says people misread it.
- 12:02[Maya] Axios called the speech ambiguous, and the outrage came from both parties.
- 12:07[David] Tennessee, a failed execution, a corrections commissioner stepping down, and two competing
- 12:12[David] accounts of what went wrong that an independent review has to sort
- 12:15[David] out.
- 12:16[Maya] And mortgage rates.
- 12:17[Maya] The thirty-year is at seven point two eight percent, and NPR says
- 12:22[Maya] that's the highest in almost three years.
- 12:25[David] So a speech, a failure, and a bill.
- 12:30[Maya] Okay, David, you get one line to tie this whole pile together.
- 12:34[David] Fine.
- 12:35[David] A president's words, a state's botched procedure, a mortgage rate.
- 12:39[David] Every one of them comes down to who answers for what and
- 12:41[David] who ends up paying for it.
- 12:43[Maya] Hmm.
- 12:44[Maya] That's tidy.
- 12:46[David] I try.
- 12:47[Maya] And it holds up.
- 12:48[Maya] With the speech, the answer is a plain statement of what was
- 12:52[Maya] meant.
- 12:52[Maya] With Tennessee, it's the review.
- 12:54[Maya] Different kinds of answers, same question.
- 12:57[David] Right.
- 12:58[David] And I'd say the first two at least have somebody you can
- 13:00[David] point at and ask, a spokesperson, a governor, a commissioner.
- 13:05[Maya] Whereas the mortgage one is the grimmest because nobody on the other
- 13:09[Maya] end explains anything.
- 13:11[Maya] You just get the bill.
- 13:13[David] Grim, but at least the number doesn't spin itself.
- 13:17[Maya] Okay, that's fair.
- 13:18[Maya] It's the one story today with no two sides arguing about what
- 13:22[Maya] it means.
- 13:23[David] Well, until somebody argues about what it means for your budget, then
- 13:26[David] we're right back at the start.
- 13:28[Maya] Of course we are.
- 13:30[Maya] Okay, I'm going to refill the cup and pretend I didn't hear
- 13:33[Maya] that.
- 13:34[David] Go.
- 13:34[David] Thanks for hanging out with us, everybody.
- 13:36[Maya] And that's the Rundown.