Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Cimarron (1931)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:43nominee from 1927 to today. I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 0:46We're talking old movies again. We're back. We're
- 0:48back. We've wrapped up everything with the 2026
- 0:52Oscar Academy Award nominations. Yeah. Congrats
- 0:56to all the winners. Wow. Remember that one? Yeah.
- 0:58That was crazy. Do you remember when so -and
- 1:02-so... I'm so scared to even throw out a fake
- 1:06scenario. This would be great if you just left
- 1:08a blank so you can come back in and be like Jesse
- 1:11Buckley. Yeah, and just add a robot. Which, who
- 1:15knows, maybe the podcast app will do it for me
- 1:17since we're just at that point now. Remember
- 1:19when Joel Egerton came on stage and just accepted
- 1:24the award he wasn't nominated for? Yeah. Wow.
- 1:26Best original song. Well, that kind of... Train
- 1:28dreams! There it is. No, but we're recording
- 1:32this before. The Oscars from last year. So it's
- 1:35such a weird thing for us. Yeah. Well, and to
- 1:39keep things fully transparent, last night we
- 1:41just did our showing, our Discord movie night
- 1:44of Sinners. Yeah. So a month later, if you guys
- 1:48were there, thanks again. Thank you. Appreciate
- 1:49it. It was a blast. and looking forward to doing
- 1:52more of that. Notice we didn't see you in there,
- 1:55Bryce. Yeah, what's up with that? You can expect
- 1:57a letter. Well, I guess at this point, you have
- 1:59expected a letter from us for a month. At this
- 2:01point, we've probably brought this up to him
- 2:03like 17 times. I saw he just got a tattoo that
- 2:06took five hours long to trace. But my thought
- 2:09process is, even if that was happening while
- 2:10the screening was happening, I don't think his
- 2:13hand is busy because it's his leg. So just literally
- 2:15pull your phone out and watch Sinners with us.
- 2:19While you're getting a tattoo. Unacceptable.
- 2:21Unacceptable. Guys, if you want to disappoint
- 2:23us in real time, feel free to check out patreon
- 2:27.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. I actually
- 2:31have two shout outs available. Thank you so much,
- 2:34Emily and Soy Bread Word for your contributions
- 2:37to the podcast and becoming backers of the show.
- 2:41Welcome in. Yeah. Thank you so much. We really
- 2:44appreciate you. Your funds will definitely go
- 2:47towards a commercial -free presentation at the
- 2:50next Discord watch party. Sorry about all the
- 2:54dominoes and Wendy's commercials. I feel really
- 2:56influenced to get that wig and the NYX cosmetics.
- 3:00The first commercial that played, I felt so bad.
- 3:02But anyway, it was fun. It was actually kind
- 3:04of a nice break from some of the... And I will
- 3:07give HBO Max this. Most of them were timed very
- 3:11well. Most of them. It felt like, hey, cool,
- 3:13here's a little breather before the next one.
- 3:15Others were like middle of a scene. Yeah. So
- 3:17not so good. But yeah. Hey, how are you feeling
- 3:22about leaving modern films behind and going back
- 3:25to 1931? what's the word for it, a bit emotional
- 3:32about it because obviously a lot of my interests
- 3:36lie in the movies that are currently out right
- 3:39now, which doesn't mean I don't enjoy going through
- 3:41those movies, but there's a little less research
- 3:43that goes into what I'm ingesting in real time
- 3:46versus what I'm going back and doing research
- 3:49for for the pod. So I think my comfort level
- 3:54is a little lower, but that's exciting. Right.
- 3:57Like you want to make yourself a little more
- 3:59uncomfortable so you can like kind of rise to
- 4:00the occasion and like prepare a little bit more,
- 4:02which I think I've done for these movies and
- 4:04I'm excited to do. But I think there's just more
- 4:06of like a natural sense of, well, hey, I've looked
- 4:10up this movie on my own, like just interest because
- 4:12it's happening in real time. Right. But no, I'm
- 4:14very excited because I think like, you know,
- 4:16it's made me nostalgic now for who we did this,
- 4:19but it doesn't feel like why we started the pod.
- 4:21Right. We wanted to talk about the older stuff.
- 4:23So yeah, I'm excited. What about you? Because
- 4:25not your first rodeo doing this, obviously. Right,
- 4:27right. And that's kind of what I was going to
- 4:29say. I don't want to be like negative to the
- 4:32next five movies we're going to cover. But this
- 4:35is a batch of movies that we did cover on the
- 4:37original iteration of the show. And I, spoiler
- 4:40alert, I don't really love any of these five
- 4:43movies. Sure. Some more than others, but none
- 4:45of these are like five star just masterpieces.
- 4:49So I'm kind of. Ready for next year, 1932. But
- 4:54beyond that, I am excited just to be talking
- 4:56about old movies again. I've kind of developed
- 4:59a, like a really, like a sweet spot, I guess,
- 5:03for just more classical film. I don't know why
- 5:07that is. Well, I've noticed that. Like you've
- 5:08been watching, you're kind of like death racing,
- 5:10not really a little bit like the older Academy
- 5:13Awards. Because I noticed you're knocking out
- 5:15like Little Caesar and stuff that isn't like,
- 5:17you know, showing up on the pod. Yeah. But was
- 5:19present at the Academy Awards. Yeah. And I think
- 5:22right now there's like four or five movies from
- 5:25this, the fourth Academy Awards that I've yet
- 5:27to see. And that's it. So I'm close to completing
- 5:30the death race for this year of the Oscars as
- 5:33well. It's got to be a lot less daunting then.
- 5:362026. Well, it depends on how you feel about,
- 5:40like... Well, in sheer numbers. Sure. And stuff
- 5:43like that. But just from a numbers game. Yes.
- 5:46Numbers game, totally. Yeah. But, you know, there's
- 5:48no F1s in 1931, so it's a little more enjoyable.
- 5:53I was about to say, when you talked about how
- 5:55you didn't really love any of these movies, I
- 5:57was like, well, they can't all be F1s. Yeah.
- 5:59No. They're all F -minuses. Speaking of... Yeah.
- 6:04Let's talk about Cimarron. Let's do it. Cimarron,
- 6:07released in 1931 by RKO Pictures, directed by
- 6:12Wesley Ruggles, and nominated for seven Academy
- 6:16Awards. That's right. And those nominations are
- 6:18as follows. Outstanding Production, RKO Radio
- 6:21Pictures. Best Writing, this was under adaptation,
- 6:24and that was from Howard Estabrook. Best Art
- 6:27Direction, by Max Rhee. Best Director, as you
- 6:30mentioned, Wesley Ruggles. Best Actor, Richard
- 6:32Dix. Just leaving a pause there for me. Best
- 6:35actress, Irene Dunn. And best cinematography,
- 6:39Edward Kronjager. To add on to that adapted screenplay,
- 6:42this was based on the novel written by Edna Ferber.
- 6:45There you go. Who, this is kind of cool. I own
- 6:49this book. I started reading it, immediately
- 6:51stopped. I wonder what could have made you stop.
- 6:54Yeah, the story in this is tough, and we'll talk
- 6:56more about that in just a moment. But I did want
- 6:58to look up and see what else she had written.
- 7:00Okay. She certainly led to the creation of more
- 7:04notable films throughout history. Showboat. Oh,
- 7:08yeah. The big musical spectacle a few years prior.
- 7:11Stage Door is a very popular play, also made
- 7:13into a film. And then the James Dean classic,
- 7:17Giant. Oh, really? Yeah, she wrote the book,
- 7:19which was later adapted in 1954, I believe. Oh,
- 7:22that's interesting. I didn't know that. Yeah,
- 7:24I had no idea. Kind of cool. I don't know if
- 7:27I'll ever read any of those, which is sad because
- 7:29I feel like that's based off of my like five
- 7:32pages of Cimarron. But this this is kind of a
- 7:35rough story. Well, you know, honestly, it's it's
- 7:37of its time, which is an excuse for it. But maybe
- 7:41you'll enjoy the writing more for something like
- 7:43Giant, which came at a later time than something
- 7:45from like 1930, where things were still very
- 7:48unresolved and problematic. Yeah. Who's to say?
- 7:52But one thing I do want to point out here is
- 7:54that we mentioned seven nominations, and you
- 7:57might be asking yourself, well, how many awards
- 7:58were there actually? And the good news is that
- 8:00there were actually any eligible category here
- 8:04for Cimarron, it was nominated for. So something
- 8:06pretty interesting to see it kind of, you know,
- 8:08we talk about sinners having the 16 nominations
- 8:11for 2026, that being an all -time record. Very
- 8:14cool to see a movie like this, well, a time.
- 8:17Or rather a record like this being set where
- 8:20it's nominated for every eligible category. And
- 8:22it's so interesting to think about that because
- 8:24you have this doing arguably something sinners
- 8:28didn't, which is receive a nomination in every
- 8:31category. Right. But obviously it's very different.
- 8:33Very different. In no way am I saying. And extremely
- 8:36content. Way better than sinners. I would say
- 8:39one is incredible at representation and one is
- 8:41absolutely god awful at representation. Accurate.
- 8:44Yeah. Nailed it. So. Tell us a little bit about
- 8:47the story. Sure. So Cimarron follows Richard
- 8:50Dix as Yancey Cravat. Terrible. Cravit? Terrible
- 8:53person. Cravat. Cravat. Yeah. Okay. Terrible.
- 8:57Terrible. Awful. Nobody's likable in this movie.
- 8:59Sorry. No, you're right. I mean, that's a good
- 9:01way to do it. So Yancey and Sabra, his wife,
- 9:05they live in, it's not really clarified at the
- 9:09beginning. It's not Oklahoma. But they moved
- 9:12to Oklahoma. Is that right? Yeah. I don't think
- 9:14it ever says where they're coming from. They
- 9:16were from the south. I know that because he does
- 9:18mention like southern fried chicken and leaving
- 9:20that behind at one point. Yeah, sure. Yeah. Maybe
- 9:23Kentucky. Sure. They're living in like some kind
- 9:25of mansion. Like they've come from a place of
- 9:28privilege. And specifically, Yancey is interested
- 9:31in moving to Oklahoma where they're settling
- 9:33for the first time. Land has just opened up.
- 9:36And it really is a... free -for -all of who can
- 9:40obtain land for the next. There is a, you know,
- 9:44I think our feelings on the movie are going to
- 9:46be pretty clear, but I do want to say I was pretty
- 9:48interested in a scene early on in this where
- 9:50they announce that that land is available, but
- 9:53at a specific time. So you actually see people
- 9:55lining up. Oh, yeah. Almost like a war. It's
- 9:59like an event. It's like they put it in the paper
- 10:02and they're like, hey, there's going to be a
- 10:03big land grab and a flea market. And, you know,
- 10:07maybe you can grab a hot dog or something. Yeah.
- 10:09It's this whole big deal. It is. And it reminded
- 10:11me a little bit of Lord of the Rings, The Two
- 10:13Towers. It looked like they were getting ready
- 10:16for battle. Yeah. Because they just almost make
- 10:18a wall. of, like, there's a line we can't cross,
- 10:21and then we have, you know, horses, we have carriages,
- 10:23like, we have everything we need to get here
- 10:26and settle first. And they all have flags. Yep.
- 10:28And this is to indicate that they have this land
- 10:31first. And I thought this process was not just
- 10:34well shot, but was well set up to where, like,
- 10:37people aren't saying this, but you're watching
- 10:39and kind of piecing together. It's good filmmaking.
- 10:40Yeah. To, like, that scene specifically. Yancey
- 10:44is... poised to find this great spot right beyond
- 10:47this canyon. He's being followed by this woman.
- 10:49And when he gets there, she actually injures
- 10:52herself. And he feels bad. And he wants to go
- 10:55check on her and check on her horse. And she's
- 10:57like, oh, hey, can you get my horse? You have
- 10:58to put him out of his misery. Can you get my
- 11:00horse? You have to put him out of his misery.
- 11:03He broke his leg. He's like, yeah, sure. So while
- 11:05he does that, she steals his horse and goes and
- 11:07plants the land for himself. And he misses out
- 11:09on this opportunity. The scene we're talking
- 11:13about in the mansion with his family, you see
- 11:15that his family really doesn't, or rather, Sabra's
- 11:18family really doesn't approve of him. They don't
- 11:21approve of their relationship. And this is a
- 11:22man who is yearning for the next big thing. Manifest
- 11:25destiny. Manifest destiny. And he convinces Sabra
- 11:29quite easily, honestly, to leave everything behind
- 11:32and go to Oklahoma to find land, even though
- 11:35it's not guaranteed to them. Right. And build
- 11:38their own. Life there. Yeah. And the movie really
- 11:41does follow just these two individuals as they
- 11:44build this life in Oklahoma and what that looks
- 11:46like settling for the first time in that land.
- 11:48So, Kyle, what did you think of Cimarron? This
- 11:53is probably the movie that has aged the worst
- 11:58that we've covered. So far, easily. Right. Yes.
- 12:01Totally. There are so many just, like, moments
- 12:06played for a laugh. that are incredibly racist.
- 12:12Sabra is so cruel to the Native Americans in
- 12:17this film. The cringe that my jaw got stuck in
- 12:23halfway through the movie where you're just like,
- 12:25I'm sorry, what? What did you say? It's bad.
- 12:28And just kind of the way that these characters
- 12:31are played as heroes, that alone is wild because
- 12:36you... You know, you have all of these white
- 12:39men heading out into Osage and just taking whatever
- 12:44lands out there, all while bashing the Native
- 12:47American tribes. Yeah, it's, you know, it's interesting
- 12:51because you would almost expect Savra to kind
- 12:53of be the humanity behind Yancey to keep him
- 12:56grounded. Like he's a man of like ambition and
- 12:59he just wants the next big thing and he's fighting
- 13:01for that at all times. You would almost expect
- 13:03that character to have less regard. for individuals
- 13:07and then sabra try to keep him grounded but in
- 13:10reality he kind of subverts that a little bit
- 13:13we'll talk about him in a second but sabra you're
- 13:16right is just inhumane like just very cruel towards
- 13:19the the native americans and it just comes across
- 13:22as like who am i supposed to be rooting for here
- 13:23and there's one character that i think you are
- 13:25rooting for a little bit but not very much because
- 13:28they're not in the movie too long for me that
- 13:30was isaiah Isaiah is the child that works at,
- 13:34well, rather lives, but probably works too, at
- 13:36Sabra's family's mansion in the beginning. And
- 13:40he actually sneaks his way into the carriage
- 13:43with Yancey and Sabra on their way to Oklahoma
- 13:47and just begs them, hey, look, I'm already out
- 13:49here. Let me just live with you. And they're
- 13:51like, all right, you little scamp, get out of
- 13:53here. Why don't you help out a little bit? And
- 13:55they aren't cruel to him, but they're also not
- 13:59loving. It's more kind of like looking, okay,
- 14:02kid, whatever. You're already here. Go ahead
- 14:04and do this. Put him to work. Like, make him
- 14:06drive one of the carriages when they're going
- 14:08through town. Right. Again, they're not, like,
- 14:10kind to him, but they're also not hateful. But
- 14:13it comes across as just, like, a disregard for
- 14:16him. Like, if he dies, he dies, basically, is
- 14:19the way he kind of feels. So the whole time,
- 14:21you're like, God, kid, I want you to get out
- 14:23of here. I want you to live and get out of here.
- 14:25He's involved in a shootout? Like... absolutely
- 14:28insane what's happening in this movie well and
- 14:31and here's how the lead up just to that scene
- 14:34alone and you know there's there's tons that
- 14:36happen in this movie but he gave the synopsis
- 14:38and so we're just picking little moments of this
- 14:41yeah yeah this family establishing themselves
- 14:44in oklahoma but the lead up to that scene with
- 14:46isaiah is he gets all dressed up to go to church
- 14:49with the cravats and everybody in town is laughing
- 14:53at him wearing his his decked out duds yep That
- 14:57Yancey has so kindly paid for. Right. So Yancey's
- 15:01solution is, hey, listen, why don't you just
- 15:05not go to church with us? And Isaiah's like,
- 15:07oh, well, I really want to go to church. I want
- 15:11that really bad. And he's like, you're going
- 15:13to do something more important. You are going
- 15:15to go home and you are going to guard the house.
- 15:17That's super important. Don't let anybody mess
- 15:19with it. Here, here's this gun. If anybody tries
- 15:23anything, shoot them. And Isaiah's like, absolutely.
- 15:26I will give my life for this house. Then there's
- 15:30a shootout, and what happens? Isaiah's life is
- 15:33lost. And there's kind of no big fanfare in his
- 15:38send -off. There's no emotional turn point. No.
- 15:42It's not like Yancey realizes, oh, man, I did
- 15:44this, and I played a part in this, and that's
- 15:46going to weigh on me. He's like, well, you win
- 15:48some, you lose some. Yeah, which is very accurate,
- 15:52I think, to Yancey and the Cravats. personalities
- 15:55in this movie as a whole to him it's it's like
- 15:58oh i i lost another thing that i owned which
- 16:02is awful to say but that is the relationship
- 16:04he had with isaiah and it's it's just like okay
- 16:08time to move on and the movie lingers not you
- 16:12mentioned something there that really resonated
- 16:14with me and it was specifically the idea that
- 16:16yancey i think thinks of himself as the hero
- 16:19and i'll go one step further i think the movie
- 16:21tries to think of yancey as the hero in this
- 16:23and I want to compare him to something like a
- 16:27Frank Capra picture or like a Jimmy Stewart.
- 16:29Like, I think that they are trying to position
- 16:32Yancey as like a, they're trying to position
- 16:35him as a George Bailey in It's a Wonderful Life,
- 16:37where he is a man of conviction and trying to
- 16:42get there, but he's always been put down and
- 16:43he's just trying to be the best person he can
- 16:45be. That's not who Yancey Kravat is in this movie.
- 16:49There's a scene specifically just before what
- 16:52we're talking about here with, you know, the
- 16:53church scene. And it's the actual literal church
- 16:56scene of what's happening inside the church.
- 16:58And somehow, maybe I lost context on this. Everyone's
- 17:01just like, hey, Yancey, why don't you run up
- 17:03church? Why don't you just like be the pastor
- 17:05for today? He's like, I'd love to. And he leads
- 17:08this service. And there's a scene that's supposed
- 17:11to be like very, you know, look at how we're
- 17:13letting everyone in. We're letting like the Native
- 17:15Americans like join us in this. We're letting
- 17:18like, you know, the gangsters, the people who
- 17:19want trouble, like sit in the back of the room.
- 17:21We're letting people of different religions,
- 17:23atheists, agnostics, like come here and be with
- 17:26us. While they do do that, there's also a character
- 17:29who sits up front and he's like, hey, is it okay
- 17:31if I sit here? And Yancey's like, yes, of course,
- 17:34not a problem. And I think he's... I can't remember
- 17:37exactly what it was physically or like that he
- 17:39says that indicates, okay, well, he's Jewish,
- 17:41right? But then while Yancey is speaking and
- 17:45giving the service, he's kind of calling out
- 17:47everyone who's different. And he's like, look
- 17:50at all these people who are here. Look who's
- 17:52different. Look at the Hebrew up front. And I
- 17:54was like, what are you doing? Right. This is
- 17:56exactly the opposite of what you say you're doing
- 17:58or the movie says you're doing where you're accepting
- 18:01and bringing people in because you're only highlighting
- 18:03your differences. Yeah. And it just feels like
- 18:05a victory lap of like, look how progressive we
- 18:08are when you're still being so hateful and like.
- 18:13Like you're still dividing each other and saying
- 18:15we have our own place and we can't come together
- 18:17except for this one place. And even then we're
- 18:19still going to call it out. Yeah. It just felt
- 18:20very disingenuous. He's like white knighting
- 18:23himself. Exactly. Almost literally. You're right.
- 18:25White knighting himself. It feels so gross and
- 18:30just very yuck of a movie. Yeah. It's very bizarre.
- 18:35Everything that all of these characters do. is
- 18:39is so jarring and just mind -boggling that same
- 18:43room i guess it's like the town hall there's
- 18:45a shootout at one point and yancey takes out
- 18:47a big outlaw but he's like standing on the stage
- 18:51of this place and it's filled with like a hundred
- 18:53people yeah and he shoots a guy in the back of
- 18:56the room everybody starts screaming and he's
- 18:58like all right everybody chill out it's fine
- 19:00now look the bullet just went right past your
- 19:03ear didn't hit you chill yeah it's it's worth
- 19:07mentioning just for the visual cue and i hope
- 19:09we can include a scene in this maybe on the socials
- 19:11but the scene you're talking about it is a town
- 19:14hall but it looks almost like a circus tent yes
- 19:16like it's huge it's massive and i'm just gonna
- 19:19guess no no shorter than like maybe 60 70 yards
- 19:23between where yancey is standing and this person
- 19:26he's shooting and somehow Yancey just takes a
- 19:30gun out and just like one shot, bam. It's like,
- 19:32hey, no, it's fine, guys. Don't worry. There
- 19:34are maybe 150 people between you and this man.
- 19:37Right. And you just took out a gun in church
- 19:39and shot this man. Again, it's a different time.
- 19:42I'm just going to go ahead and say it. I don't
- 19:44think that was happening. I don't think that
- 19:45was happening in 1930. But, you know, where was
- 19:48I? Who can say? Yeah. Let us know out there if
- 19:51you were there. Well, this would have been earlier.
- 19:53Oh, that's true. Whatever. 1889. Yeah, yeah.
- 19:56Yeah. So this was Osage. So 1889, it wasn't happening.
- 20:02I'm just going to go ahead and state. Well, everybody's
- 20:05a dead eye in this too. You remember when they
- 20:07shoot Yancey's hat off? Yes. Shooting somebody's
- 20:12hat off happens a lot in Westerns. I don't think
- 20:15that's easy at all. I think, arguably, that's
- 20:19probably one of the hardest things to do. I would
- 20:22like to see a movie that does a shootout where
- 20:24someone shoots another person's hat. And it just
- 20:26kind of like moves back a little bit, but there's
- 20:28a hole in it. Yeah. And they're like, were you
- 20:30trying to shoot that off? Like just to show how
- 20:32impossible that really is. And they're just like,
- 20:34yeah. Can't you tell? Or if it's like a tomato
- 20:38soup can where like the lid just kind of like.
- 20:41Which goes off but stays on their head. Yeah.
- 20:43Something like that. Anyways, point is, you've
- 20:46nailed something here. The tone of this movie
- 20:48is all over the place. Because it wants to be
- 20:51funny in that mansion scene. There's a scene
- 20:54where Isaiah is hanging on a chandelier, cleaning,
- 20:58and it's just a visual gag. And you're like,
- 21:00okay, what are we doing? It wants to be endearing
- 21:03to show, well, look how kind of a man Yancey
- 21:06is to be hosting this. this church service and
- 21:09be welcoming of these individuals and trying
- 21:11to start like a print press of like his own newspaper
- 21:13that also has a very problematic name. Like.
- 21:17Yeah. It tries to show him as like this sincere
- 21:20man, but it also wants to be the shootout. But
- 21:23it also wants to be this drama of like a marital
- 21:25strain in their relationship between Sabra and
- 21:27Yancey. It's worth mentioning that this movie,
- 21:30while set in 1889, does span a lot of time. Yeah,
- 21:3340 years. 40 years specifically. Goes all the
- 21:35way up to 1929. And to me, I saw what it was
- 21:40going for, and I really wasn't interested throughout
- 21:43any of the movie. Maybe that's unfair to say,
- 21:46but I feel like nothing was as captivating to
- 21:49me as that opening scene of everyone trying to
- 21:52stake land on Osage. Yeah, that land grab scene
- 21:54is the best part like filmmaking wise in this
- 21:59movie for sure. It's also great because there's
- 22:01hardly any story. There's hardly any personality
- 22:03in the characters. So you don't get any of that.
- 22:06Honestly, I almost picked it as my double feature
- 22:09and I didn't. So I'll say it here. Sorry if I'm
- 22:11going to spoil it for you. It's very Mad Max
- 22:13Fury Road. Yeah. It really is just like a lot
- 22:17of great footage. This is where I think cinematography
- 22:19does play its part for the most part in this
- 22:21movie. Is everyone racing to that part or to
- 22:24their point in land? And I thought there was
- 22:26some great footage of like, you know, the carts
- 22:28breaking apart or horses falling over. Like there
- 22:31is good cinematography there specifically, but
- 22:34nothing, nothing in that movie was as interesting
- 22:37beyond that one scene. No, I agree. That's in
- 22:39the first three minutes. Yeah, absolutely. You
- 22:42bring up Mad Max. To me, it reminds me of Ben
- 22:45-Hur and the chariot scenes. Oh, absolutely.
- 22:47Because all of the camera work is like right
- 22:50in there in the action. It really is impressive.
- 22:53You can kind of see the progression from All
- 22:56Quiet on the Western Front the previous year
- 22:58and like the charging armies going through the
- 23:01trenches and things. translated here with this
- 23:04charge forward across the quote unquote battlefield.
- 23:08I will say there's some other camera work in
- 23:10this that I did enjoy quite a bit. There's a
- 23:13moment, I forget who she's arguing with. Sabra
- 23:16is arguing with somebody and she kind of runs
- 23:19up on them from the street and the camera is
- 23:22just set on Dolly and it does like a nice little
- 23:24gliding pan following her. But I think that camera
- 23:27movement alone. kind of supports her anger and
- 23:31her rage in that moment and shows that she is
- 23:33a woman not afraid to move forward and take what
- 23:36is hers. Super cool, but are we really going
- 23:38to get that excited over a panning camera? No.
- 23:41That's not even a pan, a tracking shot. I'll
- 23:44meet you there, and I do think any of the scenes
- 23:46that are filmed in the town, like outside of
- 23:49buildings, are really interesting. There's a
- 23:53shot of Yancey confronting the criminal that
- 23:56he ends up shooting in church. And I think that
- 23:58scene of it's not it's kind of a tracking shot,
- 24:01but I don't think it's on a dolly. It kind of
- 24:03follows him from one side of the town to another
- 24:05side of the town. I thought that camera work
- 24:07was interesting and I really did enjoy it. But
- 24:09otherwise, it did feel kind of just like a framing,
- 24:12you know, just place it here and we'll have this
- 24:14shot. Not too much of an interest for me. One
- 24:17thing I want to point out is that this movie,
- 24:19again, we talked about does go through a lot
- 24:21of time, 40 years specifically. And the majority
- 24:24of the movie. really does touch on the idea.
- 24:27It kind of becomes a familial drama. And it really
- 24:31is between Sabra and Yancey. Yancey, again, has
- 24:35this yearning to continue to move. I think in
- 24:37the beginning, Sabra says something about like,
- 24:39well, hey, we've only been here like five years.
- 24:41You're already ready to move. That's just kind
- 24:43of who you are. You're an explorer in that sense.
- 24:45That's a reoccurring theme with her. As my mother
- 24:47always said, I never stay anywhere longer than
- 24:49five years. Yes. So Yancey... Keeps that tradition
- 24:53and says, well, hey, look, I really want to follow
- 24:56like, you know, the Native Americans and like
- 24:58go with them for a bit. So I think I am going
- 25:00to leave you and our son behind. And to me, this
- 25:03just I never got this from Yancey. Like this
- 25:06wasn't like, oh, that's such a Yancey move. It
- 25:08just felt like something the story needed him
- 25:10to do. So I really didn't like I'm more so saying
- 25:14this to ask you, did that feel right for his
- 25:17character or did that just feel like a plot point
- 25:19to you? So I think that that really is supposed
- 25:21to be the overall theme of this story is that
- 25:25some men can't be stationary. Like they've got
- 25:30to keep moving. They've got to keep exploring.
- 25:31I just looked it up because I had to remember
- 25:34it meant something. But Cimarron literally means
- 25:37in Spanish, wild, untamed, or feral. So that's
- 25:42kind of the whole thing. This like manifest destiny,
- 25:44like I mentioned earlier, Yancey is just constantly
- 25:47like. I must go. The mountains are calling me
- 25:50and I must go. And that's kind of the whole thing
- 25:53between Yancey and Sabra is she's like, I must
- 25:57stay. Well, I must go. What do we do? Right.
- 26:01But like the beginning, it shows her and maybe
- 26:04I would pick that up a bit more if the beginning
- 26:06wasn't like her saying, well, hey, I'll come
- 26:08with you. Like, why not? But she goes with the
- 26:12the idea that, OK, we're going to go and we're
- 26:15going to settle. And that will be our life. So
- 26:17after that, when he was like, you know what?
- 26:20I think I'm going to go for a walk for like five,
- 26:23six years. That's when she's like, wait a minute.
- 26:26Yeah. This is what I signed up for. Yeah. Okay.
- 26:28That's fair. That makes a bit more sense. But
- 26:31for me, it just, it felt like that plot point
- 26:34when it starts and you're right, it is five years,
- 26:36but then that carries on the next 15 or so years
- 26:39that it covers of, well, daddy wasn't there.
- 26:43Yancey wasn't there for me. And it goes all the
- 26:46way up to 1920. 1929, rather. Yeah. And we see
- 26:49that the publication that Yancey and Sabra started
- 26:52has blown up. And it is this large publication.
- 26:56And it's headed solely by Sabra. Yeah. But Yancey
- 26:59has not reappeared. Yancey has been this almost
- 27:02nomad. Like living off the land and living like
- 27:05with the land, so to speak. And he went and fought
- 27:08in the Spanish -American War. He did. And then
- 27:10that leads to the end. And I don't want to hop
- 27:12there if there's anything you want to talk about
- 27:13before then. But to me, yeah, exactly. Beautiful
- 27:17scene by him at the end there. We'll get to that.
- 27:19Yeah, just this movie really did not like intrigue
- 27:21me. And it's interesting because, I mean, I don't
- 27:24know if you want to start at the end here, kind
- 27:26of talk about this big spoiler with this movie,
- 27:28but it won Best Picture. Yeah. Why? I think it'll
- 27:33be more evident after we watch all five of these
- 27:35films. I have one more left to see, and I won't
- 27:41say it because we'll get there. There's a movie
- 27:42that to me isn't perfect, but I was like, oh,
- 27:45that's it. Probably from a story point, right?
- 27:48Correct. I think that at this time, the Academy
- 27:51was praising big swings. Size. Yes. Scale, scope.
- 27:56Absolutely. When you look at the three past winners,
- 28:00Wings. The Broadway Melody, All Quiet on the
- 28:03Western Front. Those are huge. Certainly All
- 28:04Quiet. Yeah. Yeah. Certainly Wings as well. True.
- 28:08They're huge films. Broadway Melody, you can
- 28:11argue the sound and the musical element of it
- 28:13is what's big about it. Well, and the new take
- 28:17of, you know, being able to film musicals. Yeah,
- 28:19exactly. So I think that the Academy loves to
- 28:22praise just big, giant spectacles. And thanks
- 28:25to the production design in this film, this is
- 28:28what. We're looking at a huge spectacle. You
- 28:32can kind of see like early glimpses of gone with
- 28:36the wind in this at times. Yes. Like poor man's
- 28:39gone with the wind. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I wouldn't
- 28:41even say poor man's. I think that like, I really
- 28:44do like the production design in this. The town
- 28:46looks lived in. It looks real. All of the interior
- 28:50sets and everything, especially with the well
- 28:53-off cravats, they're beautiful sets. Everything
- 28:57feels. Very practical, very lived in. I like
- 29:01that. Yeah, you're right. When I say poor man's
- 29:04gone with the wind, I don't mean that the quality
- 29:06or production is poor. You just mean they didn't
- 29:08have a crane? That's exactly what I meant. No,
- 29:12I just meant the connection between Gansey and
- 29:15Sabra is certainly not what we saw in Gone with
- 29:17the Wind. And in no way am I bringing up the
- 29:21plot for this movie at any time. You're talking
- 29:23about just the scale. Just the scale, yeah. I'm
- 29:24with you. So I think that... is is what led to
- 29:27this winning best picture and again this is kind
- 29:31of where i got to in the first iteration of the
- 29:34podcast so i'm curious what the rest of the 30s
- 29:36will look like if the academy will continue to
- 29:39to recognize and reward just scale true well
- 29:45i think it will and you know when i say especially
- 29:47all quiet in the western front the reason i say
- 29:49that is it is a year removed Right. Like, hey,
- 29:52we just did this last year and we saw what we're
- 29:54capable of. So why wouldn't we continue that
- 29:56trend? Like a movie that tries to capture that
- 29:58size and scale. Because you're right. The rest
- 30:01of the films here are not necessarily matching
- 30:06this in terms of like the scope of the story.
- 30:09And the scope of the story is interesting. I
- 30:11just don't think it's handled very well. And
- 30:13also very, very. very difficult to be watching
- 30:16this from a 2026 perspective because there's
- 30:19just so much in it there's you know they talk
- 30:22about the desires and the wants and like you
- 30:24know well hey honey i'm very much wanting this
- 30:27land and start a publication you there's like
- 30:30the church and like the school for the kids and
- 30:32things you'd be interested in isaiah look what
- 30:33you're interested in and it's just the oldest,
- 30:36stupidest, racist joke of what they'd be interested
- 30:38in. So there's just so much in it that just kind
- 30:41of reminds you of, oh, that was the time and
- 30:43this was funny back then. And this is played
- 30:45for laughs. And it's disheartening a little bit,
- 30:48but also it's hard because, and this is just
- 30:52me kind of lifting the veil a little bit, it's
- 30:54hard to watch movies like that because on one
- 30:56hand, I think it's asking you, or history rather,
- 30:58is asking you to look back and kind of just forgive
- 31:00it because it was a different time. It's hard
- 31:03to feel that way. It's hard to kind of like forgive
- 31:05the movie for that and not kind of put a notch
- 31:06on it, you know? Yeah. I think the most difficult
- 31:09thing for me watching this, this time, this is
- 31:12my second watch of this movie now, pray for me.
- 31:15I hear the third time is when it really pops
- 31:18off. Yeah. There was a point where I was watching
- 31:21this and I was like, I feel like I know people
- 31:24that would really enjoy this movie today. Would
- 31:27it be like a yearning for like the old days?
- 31:30Yeah. Yeah. It's a, it's, it's very much a, they
- 31:34don't make them like gone with the wind anymore.
- 31:36You know what I mean? Yeah. Should they? Right.
- 31:40Exactly. And, and that's kind of, that's kind
- 31:43of the hard thing about watching this as well,
- 31:45because you have your own moral standpoints where
- 31:47you're like, wow, this stuff is rough. Yeah.
- 31:49But then there's also that bit where you're like,
- 31:51it's 2026. So this, this is very difficult to
- 31:54what, wait, you like this movie? And it's just
- 31:57maybe because of the times we're living in now,
- 32:00there was just a lot of, wow, I don't think people
- 32:03will hate this as much as I think they will.
- 32:05Sure. And, you know, it's funny because, well,
- 32:08I didn't think I was going to do this, but here
- 32:09we are. When we talk about how we look at films
- 32:12in the past, there's ways that you can kind of
- 32:14look back and say, okay, well, this is a time
- 32:17capsule. Of like, well, look where we were and
- 32:20we're trying to capture that. And yeah, it's
- 32:22not pretty and no one's proud of this, but this
- 32:24is what was happening back then. And there's
- 32:26ways you can do that. And the way that you can
- 32:28do that recently happened in a movie called Nirvana,
- 32:31The Band, The Show, The Movie, where they talk
- 32:32about 2008 and they talk about a movie. And there's
- 32:35a joke in the movie that is like, how was this
- 32:38acceptable back then? Because it's not acceptable
- 32:40now. and that to me is a time capsule where you're
- 32:43saying like well look this did happen and this
- 32:45was a thing that we did in 2008 but is that acceptable
- 32:48by today's standards and that to me is the way
- 32:50you do a time capsule Cimarron it doesn't feel
- 32:53like a time capsule of like hey like I mean obviously
- 32:55it's of the time but it's not like well hey this
- 32:58was happening and they don't play it like well
- 32:59this is what was happening back then and sorry
- 33:01if you don't approve of it it was played for
- 33:03laughs yes so it really is like embracing it
- 33:07rather than like showcasing it to show like yeah
- 33:10maybe this isn't great but this is what was happening
- 33:12at that time that feels wrong right and and i
- 33:15would go beyond saying it's played for laughs
- 33:16to me that's like a blazing saddles kind of of
- 33:19thing where it's like this is really played for
- 33:22laughs and you can you can get behind a movie
- 33:24like that it's not laughing with the character
- 33:27it's laughing at the character right correct
- 33:29i would say that cimarron is played for like
- 33:32pride and patriotism and you're supposed to go
- 33:36to the movie and you're supposed to be excited
- 33:38about what the people are doing and what the
- 33:41country is doing and the the the way we have
- 33:44grown and wow remember when it was just territory
- 33:48and now it belongs to you yeah and yeah it's
- 33:52just it's just rough it's rough it's rough to
- 33:54watch and that makes it you know Not enjoyable.
- 33:58I'd like to point out that I think this is the
- 33:59episode where you and I have had the most pauses.
- 34:02Yeah. Where we're just like, what do we do about
- 34:04this? Yeah. And, you know, it's funny because
- 34:07when I edit, I remove all of those pauses. So
- 34:10you're not going to hear that at home. But know
- 34:12that just before every every time we start speaking,
- 34:16there is like a 20 second pause where we're just
- 34:19looking at each other, sweating a little bit.
- 34:22And mildly panicking. Well, a little bit. But
- 34:25also, like, you know, I didn't make Cimarron,
- 34:27so I'm not too concerned about it. And that's
- 34:29not what it is. It's not like, what do we do?
- 34:32We're talking about this movie. It's more of
- 34:33just like, almost like Rodney Dangerfield. Like,
- 34:36I'm dying up here. What else are we going to
- 34:40talk about for 10 minutes? Yeah, you know, maybe,
- 34:42honestly, that's... To go back to your first
- 34:45question you had for me was like, how do I feel
- 34:47about talking about, you know, these older movies
- 34:49from 1931 when we've been talking about 19 or
- 34:5119? Wow. 2025 movies. And I think this is a good
- 34:55example where it's easier to kind of speak to
- 34:58like the intention of some things. It's harder
- 35:00because there aren't as many interviews, you
- 35:02know, for movies like this. I talk a lot about
- 35:05physical media and I actually bought a DVD of
- 35:07Cimarron in preparation for this. So that would
- 35:10make front page. Thank you, Criterion, for making
- 35:12your His Girl Friday. with the front page disc
- 35:15in there, and Cimarron, the two movies that I
- 35:18own physically for this. We'll talk about why
- 35:20I can't do that for Eastland on the next episode.
- 35:22And I was really looking forward to watching
- 35:25it. And I texted you, and I was like, my DVD
- 35:28doesn't work. Like, my DVD can't play. Is it
- 35:32DVD or Blu -ray? It was DVD. I don't know if
- 35:35their Blu -ray exists for Cimarron. I've double
- 35:38-checked for this, but it was a pretty older
- 35:39DVD, too. But it wouldn't work. So I ended up
- 35:42just watching it on YouTube instead. But we talk
- 35:45about the intention of stuff like that. We don't
- 35:48know. There aren't recorded sessions of, well,
- 35:51hey, here's the interview. But we have that available
- 35:54with these newer movies. So to me, I feel like
- 35:57I can go an hour, 30 minutes, two hours talking
- 36:00about those movies because there's so much documentation
- 36:02of the intention. You don't have that luxury
- 36:05here. So instead, it really is like what the
- 36:08movie is telling you. And what the movie is telling
- 36:10you, at least telling me, and it sounds like
- 36:11it's the same for you, is like, this doesn't
- 36:14feel good. Right. Yeah. Yes, it's a huge story.
- 36:18And yes, it's the founding of Oklahoma. And yes,
- 36:20it's like talking about Osage in 1889. Correct?
- 36:25Yeah. 1889. But does the story wrap up in a successful
- 36:31way? And I guess that leads to the ending. The
- 36:33idea of Yancey being this nomad that has gone
- 36:36off and fought in the war and has left his family
- 36:38behind, I don't feel a lot of vindication. For
- 36:41his character. It doesn't feel like, you know,
- 36:43hey, I'm looking back and I realize all the mistakes
- 36:45I've made because he really just has the ability
- 36:47to say goodbye to Sabra and that's it. Like,
- 36:50he's just been shot. Is that right? Like, I'm
- 36:53forgetting. No, there was an accident at the
- 36:55oil fields. That's right. And I think the idea
- 36:58is he died saving a bunch of people because Yancey's
- 37:01the hero. Of course. Right. And of course you
- 37:04don't see that happen. Someone's just like, hey,
- 37:05did you hear that this happened? Yeah. He's dying
- 37:07right now. And Sabra's like, whoa, no way. Like
- 37:10right when I show up? Okay, cool. And she runs
- 37:12over and they have like the most nothing of a
- 37:15moment together. It is almost, it's not quite
- 37:19as emotional because that's done better, but
- 37:20it almost does play like Tobey Maguire, Peter
- 37:24Parker, and Uncle Ben in Sam Raimi's Spider -Man,
- 37:26where he's just like, see ya, kid. Like, oh no!
- 37:31Uncle, but that's her husband. Yeah, exactly.
- 37:34So Tobey Maguire plays that much better than
- 37:37it's played in Cimarron. Oh, yeah. So does Uncle
- 37:39Ben. Correct. And it just feels kind of like,
- 37:42all right, we're done. It doesn't feel like a
- 37:44huge emotional point. At no point did this movie
- 37:48have, well, that's not true, past 30 minutes
- 37:51with Isaiah. At no point did this movie have
- 37:53me emotionally invested. No, not at all. Because
- 37:55you're just kind of watching these characters
- 37:57and not invested in their stories, their stakes,
- 37:59and what they're doing. I kind of liked Sabra
- 38:01a little bit for her seeing through, committing,
- 38:04like you said, settling, and saying, well, if
- 38:06you're going to start this publication, I'm going
- 38:08to see it through, and I'm going to work with
- 38:10the team that we have, and we're going to build
- 38:12this out together. But you're right. She's cruel
- 38:14towards people that don't look like her. Not
- 38:17all, because she was, again, not loving towards
- 38:20Isaiah, but accepting. At least. Well, and that's
- 38:23kind of the thing. She has that moment towards
- 38:25the latter half of the film where Cimarron, their
- 38:29son, starts to fall for a Native American girl.
- 38:32Correct. So at first she's totally against it,
- 38:35but she eventually becomes kind of like a spokesperson
- 38:38for the Native American tribes. And there's even
- 38:42that moment where she gets thanked by the chief.
- 38:46She's like, you're very kind. And it's just more
- 38:49of that, like, hey, stop patting yourself on
- 38:51the back. Like, we remember what you said about
- 38:54him 45 minutes ago. Yeah. So she's kind of an
- 38:58interesting character because it is like, look
- 39:01at this very strong female lead. She would definitely
- 39:05complain to the manager at the grocery store.
- 39:07Certainly. Yeah. And also, if a woman walked
- 39:12up to me at a restaurant and was like, This is
- 39:14my husband, or sorry, my husband. This is my
- 39:17child, Cimarron. That's all I need to know. Yeah.
- 39:20They call him Sim or Simmy. Do you mean your
- 39:22horse? Yeah. You mean your horse, Cimarron. Certainly
- 39:26not your child. Yeah, but also her name is Sabra.
- 39:30Love the hot dogs. It's not even spelled the
- 39:32same way. That actually might be a terrible joke.
- 39:34I don't know. Love your hummus? Hot dogs? Sabra?
- 39:36Oh, they do make hummus. Do they make hot dogs?
- 39:40Sabrat. It was a terrible joke, but not for the
- 39:44reason I thought. Well, hey, you know what? Here's
- 39:46to having a subwrought summer. 360 party dog.
- 39:50Hey, what do you think of Irene Dunn? Like, we
- 39:53didn't really talk about the performances. So
- 39:54you don't want to embrace my Charlie XCX joke?
- 39:56Okay, I'll just skip right past it. I think there's
- 39:58a reason I skip past the performances, right?
- 40:00I mean, if I can't connect with you emotionally
- 40:02as a character, it's hard for me to say that
- 40:05your performance was really fantastic. Now, that's
- 40:08not to say it's bad acting jobs. I think it's
- 40:10a lot of the writing. That does, you know, again,
- 40:13not sure why that's nominated for those characters,
- 40:15but certainly the scope helps. You're right.
- 40:17But I'll say that I enjoyed Irene Dunn a bit
- 40:21more than Richard Dix. Richard Dix to me just
- 40:24kind of felt like, see, this feels unfair because
- 40:27I feel like a lot of it is the writing of those
- 40:29characters. I don't know. I think that Irene
- 40:32Dunn is a pretty believable character in this.
- 40:36Richard Dix does have kind of like a cartoony
- 40:40vibe to him at times. I agree with you. It feels
- 40:43like the night. Like it's just, well, this is
- 40:46just who I am. Like I'm the best. Like I'm the
- 40:48most sympathetic person in this room. And he's
- 40:51not. Like he thinks he's the best of us. Right.
- 40:53And Irene plays Sabra a bit more humble, but
- 40:59not heroic. And not like, you're right that she
- 41:03makes a change. And she does actually change.
- 41:05To me, Yancey is like burdened, and this kind
- 41:09of plays into my double feature that I chose.
- 41:11He's burdened by like this desire to just always
- 41:15be exploring and always building something. And
- 41:17maybe that's his downfall, but because we don't
- 41:20see his death, because the movie doesn't decide
- 41:22to follow him, the movie stays with Sabra. But
- 41:25we just hear about Yancey from like, or hear
- 41:28that Yancey has been traveling and going off
- 41:30to war and working at the oil rig. It doesn't
- 41:34follow him, so it doesn't feel like it's his
- 41:36story. Yeah. It feels like it's more Sabra's
- 41:38story towards the last half. But it doesn't do
- 41:41anything much of interest with that. No, no,
- 41:44no. Outside of just the slight growth. But you're
- 41:46right. Even with her character, if she is going
- 41:49to grow and she is becoming more accepting of
- 41:51people and realizing her wrongdoing, then it
- 41:53should be her taking a back seat to those people.
- 41:56Yeah. Rather than, well, now you should praise
- 41:59me because now I... I understand that you're
- 42:02human too, right? That makes me a great person.
- 42:05Sure, yeah. It's like the blind side. It's just
- 42:09rough. Wow, Cimarron's the blind side. I didn't
- 42:11realize that. You're totally right. Yeah. Now,
- 42:14you know, I think we're really asking this movie
- 42:17to do something that it just was not going to
- 42:19do in 1931. Of course. As far as the performances
- 42:22go, though, I do think that Richard Dix is very
- 42:25one note. Like, he's like... Again, the mountains
- 42:29are calling for me and I must go and that's it.
- 42:31Irene Dunn does get a lot of opportunity to display
- 42:35sadness, anger in that moment where she's running
- 42:38up on the guy, anger at Yancey for a good portion
- 42:41of the movie, anger at literally any race. There's
- 42:44that too. Yippee for Hollywood, I guess. She's
- 42:48got more to work with. So I understand her nomination.
- 42:51Beyond that, though, I think that the praise
- 42:54for this movie really comes from its production
- 42:56design. That's probably the best this movie has
- 42:59to offer. Sure. And really the only reason beyond
- 43:03saying, hey, are you a completionist? Watch this
- 43:05movie. The only other reason I would recommend
- 43:07it is to check out the production design because
- 43:10it is impressive, I would say. Yeah, absolutely.
- 43:12I mean, they, you know, they show this empty
- 43:15land and everyone traveling in that scene I talked
- 43:17about, but then they also build out Osage. They
- 43:20build out what becomes Oklahoma and that town
- 43:22itself does feel lived in. And, you know, I roasted
- 43:26the church scene a little bit of how it looks
- 43:28like a circus tent, but it is big in scale. So
- 43:31I agree, production design, especially in this
- 43:33year with the other four nominees, it is the
- 43:36best of them, for sure. So production design,
- 43:38it did take the win from the designer Max Rhee.
- 43:41Also, we talked about how it was the outstanding
- 43:43production and did win Best Picture from RKO
- 43:45Radio Pictures. But it also won Best Writing
- 43:48for Adaptation. And that was Howard Estabrook
- 43:51based on the novel that you had mentioned. How
- 43:53do you feel about screenplay, this taking the
- 43:56win from the other four nominees? I mean, this
- 44:00is one that's always hard because we're 95 years
- 44:06removed from. I was like, I'm 37. I'm not 90.
- 44:1095 years removed from these movies and probably
- 44:14even further removed from their source material.
- 44:16Sure. So it's like, I don't know. This might
- 44:19be the perfect translation of Edna Ferber's novel.
- 44:23Maybe that's exactly what the novel wants. Based
- 44:27off the first five pages, they nailed it. This
- 44:30movie is racist and cruel and very much, hey,
- 44:35look at all the good we did while we hurt all
- 44:38these people. Yeah, no, you're right. And I see
- 44:41the vision on that. I think for me, there's a
- 44:43movie that's coming up a little bit later that
- 44:46I think, in terms of picture and writing, To
- 44:49me, it feels more Oscars. It feels more true
- 44:51Oscars. And you're right, this is still very
- 44:53much Oscars in the sense of Look at America patting
- 44:56itself on the back. But it feels like the writing,
- 44:59especially, I think this would be more original
- 45:01than adapted, but the writing of a movie that's
- 45:04coming later, it feels like the characters, the
- 45:07way they speak to each other, the way that kind
- 45:09of elaborates their character. it feels much
- 45:11more earnest than something like this. What movie
- 45:14are you referring to? Front page. Okay. So the
- 45:17writing in that specifically, that to me is like,
- 45:19well, that's great writing. And I understand
- 45:21like adapted versus original, but this felt lack
- 45:24of inspiration, just uninspired is what I felt.
- 45:28Yeah. So for me, I understand the situations
- 45:30are a big part of it, but the character interactions
- 45:32is also what I'm looking for in writing. I just
- 45:35didn't really feel that moved by Cimarron. Yeah,
- 45:39I don't know that it would take so much research
- 45:43from both of us to have a better understanding
- 45:46of the writing nomination and the win, I think.
- 45:49I guess I can get it like, again, 95 years removed.
- 45:53I understand why it won what it did, why it was
- 45:56nominated for what it did. Do I agree? No, but
- 45:59that might also be a 2026 lens looking back at
- 46:02it. I'm excited to talk about the ceremony year
- 46:04this year because, again, I've watched most of,
- 46:07if not all, all by the time you're listening
- 46:09to this of the movies nominated. So I'll have
- 46:11a better, like, listen, this shouldn't have won.
- 46:13This other thing was fantastic. Knowing you,
- 46:16I think you will. We'll see. Some of that stuff's
- 46:18hard to find, which is weird. Well, some of the
- 46:20stuff we've seen is hard to find, too. We'll
- 46:21talk about that next week. That's true. Howard
- 46:23Estabrook also wrote Hell's Angels. Oh, and that
- 46:26came out the year prior, right? Yeah, yeah. That's
- 46:28a good movie. I like that story. Really like
- 46:31the underline of that. That's a good movie. Yeah,
- 46:34that was a good one. This also won the Art Direction.
- 46:37award for max re we talked about that the the
- 46:40interesting thing here is he did the art and
- 46:42set decoration on this movie but also the costume
- 46:45design interesting this man was busy you know
- 46:48what's kind of funny about that i mean obviously
- 46:50you should be proud of any award that you get
- 46:52nominated for let alone win but i do think it's
- 46:54kind of funny that he did both and they're like
- 46:55hey man you did uh the costume design in the
- 46:58art direction right they're like yeah good art
- 46:59direction you'd be like costumes were pretty
- 47:02good too though right like sure well As we said,
- 47:06there's no costume category. But I totally hear
- 47:10you. Thank you. Thank you for not ruining my
- 47:12joke. I appreciate that. So, Wesley Ruggles.
- 47:15Yeah. Directed this film. Sure did. You want
- 47:18to talk about ratings? Sure. I'm just kidding.
- 47:21So, the most fascinating thing I saw about Wesley
- 47:24Ruggles, right? For the film London Town in 1946,
- 47:29he was hired. This was set to be the first British
- 47:34Technicolor musical. And the people of Britain
- 47:38said, we don't know how to do that. We should
- 47:41get a professional. We should get an American.
- 47:44So they got Wesley Ruggles, who had never directed
- 47:46a musical in his life. But he was American. This
- 47:50movie failed so bad that he retired. Oh, no.
- 47:57I haven't seen any of his other films, but in
- 48:00the time span between Cimarron and London Town,
- 48:03he does have some... better known movies that
- 48:07did pretty well. But that little bit of trivia
- 48:10just killed me. I was like, poor dude. Well,
- 48:13well delivered too. I understand what they're
- 48:15going for. And I see the vision because specifically
- 48:18with a movie to your point, with the scale and
- 48:20scope of something like Cimarron, you would think
- 48:22that a musical isn't far out of reach. And maybe
- 48:26also now with the 2026 lens, you're looking back
- 48:28and you're like, Hey, you already made a movie
- 48:29about Oklahoma. You're gonna make a musical.
- 48:31Just make Oklahoma. But of course, you know,
- 48:34that's not a thing in 1946. Yeah, I think we
- 48:37still had a couple years. If only there's a movie
- 48:40you had just seen that talked about how Oklahoma
- 48:42was made and celebrating it. By the time this
- 48:45episode comes out, I'll be so far removed from
- 48:47this movie that I don't know that I'll even understand
- 48:50that reference. I'll be like, when did I watch
- 48:51a movie? Oh yeah, Rat. Yeah, Rat Boy. Speaking
- 48:55of Rat, George E. Stone was in this movie. Was
- 48:57he really? Wait, was it George E. Stone or was
- 48:59it George Stone? Because they're two different
- 49:01people and I always get that confused. Hence
- 49:03the E. George E. Stone. I forget if that's the
- 49:05rat or not, or if that's the warden in the big
- 49:08house. I was about to flip my book and I realized
- 49:11that I don't have that note in there. Great.
- 49:13Wonderful. Welcome to our podcast where we kind
- 49:16of know things. I hope that you can kind of come
- 49:18back later on and be like, I was right. Yeah.
- 49:21In like 10 years. And there's note wrong. We
- 49:24should do that. Your next iteration should be
- 49:27once we go through all of the years here up until
- 49:30like, you know, 2024, I guess when we're caught
- 49:32up on everything we've covered. Yeah. You should
- 49:35now go back to the same episodes, but add an
- 49:38incorrect buzzer noise. And whenever we say something
- 49:41that's incorrect, just... Someone's like, oh,
- 49:43okay, cool. They were wrong. I like that. That
- 49:45way I don't have to record anything new. I'm
- 49:47just re -editing the old episodes. Because by
- 49:49then you'll just be sitting in your rocking chair
- 49:50and just like mash a button whenever you hear
- 49:52something and be like, that's wrong. That's wrong.
- 49:54God, the whole thing is just going to be... Man,
- 49:57they must have been cursing up a storm in these
- 49:59episodes. Except for that bit about Wesley Ruggles
- 50:01having to retire. That is 100 % true. Oh man,
- 50:06that's so good. But yeah, I mean, that's Cimarron.
- 50:09It's a rough start to 1931. It is. Right? Because
- 50:12it's the best picture winner, but it's hard to
- 50:15feel as celebratory when last year we had All
- 50:19Quiet on the Western Front. Yeah. And that won,
- 50:21and it feels like a reason to celebrate. It's
- 50:23something that's remembered to this day. And
- 50:25Cimarron is forgotten to time, and rightfully
- 50:27so. Right. I think it was always destined to
- 50:30be forgotten to time because the sensibilities
- 50:32of it are never going to match, maybe even beyond
- 50:351930, well. done 1930 but maybe 1931 32 well
- 50:40certainly not 31 32 and on maybe it was more
- 50:43and it feels good maybe we don't talk about that
- 50:46but uh certainly feels like it's less celebratory
- 50:49than something like all quiet on the western
- 50:51front or even outside of barring an f1 win anything
- 50:55that happened in the 2026 oscars man you know
- 50:58this is public domain even though it came out
- 51:01in 1931 Was it really? Oh, yeah, it was. You
- 51:03just told me this. What was the reason that it
- 51:06hasn't hit the 100 -year mark, but why is that?
- 51:08They missed a deadline for their trademark or
- 51:12something. It's like a paperwork thing where
- 51:14they were like, oops, okay, well, this is public
- 51:17domain now. We'll just treat it as a 1930 movie,
- 51:19which I think is just like this perfect summary
- 51:23and example of, yeah, it's fine. We dropped the
- 51:27ball. It does feel like a little bit of like
- 51:29the... The unwanted child. Yeah. Of the whole
- 51:33like, well, hey, we actually can't take that
- 51:35because it's not 100 years. Well, you can have
- 51:37it right now. Like, yeah. We don't have to wait
- 51:39100 years. You can have it right now if you want.
- 51:41We don't want it. Congratulations, public. Yeah.
- 51:43This belongs to you. Public is like, we're good.
- 51:45We're fine. You can just leave that where it
- 51:47is. But I'm excited to talk about the other movies.
- 51:49We'll get there next week. But it was always
- 51:52going to be a rough start to it. But I'm excited
- 51:54for where this is going to go. And I think it's
- 51:56going to lead to some great conversations when
- 51:58we talk about our double features. But before
- 52:00we get there, anything you'd like to say about
- 52:02Cimarron? Would you like to publicly apologize
- 52:04to Cimarron for any of the ways that you feel
- 52:06about it? No. Great. Neither do I. Do you want
- 52:09to get into your ratings? Yeah, I do. I gave
- 52:10it two stars. Which seems high. I just want to
- 52:14say. That's the trouble with rating systems is
- 52:17that, I don't mean to do that. That's the trouble
- 52:19with rating systems. But yeah, I mean, oh, here's
- 52:24your rating right here. Yeah. It's right on my
- 52:25letterbox. Yeah, two stars. Also worth noting.
- 52:29You gave it two stars? I gave it two stars. And
- 52:31you know who else gave it two stars? Bryce. Oh,
- 52:34did he? Bryce gave two stars. So across the board,
- 52:36all three official hosts of Once Upon a Time
- 52:38in the Oscars gave this movie two stars. And
- 52:41I agree with you. And I know what you're saying.
- 52:43Like two stars is low. And it feels a little
- 52:46high for the way we've talked about it. Right.
- 52:48And that's because so much of it is like, you
- 52:50know, with my buddy Evan has this joke that he
- 52:53definitely didn't make, but he says it all the
- 52:54time of like, when you watch a movie that's like
- 52:56very problematic, but you look over at your neighbor
- 52:58while you're watching and shake your head the
- 53:00whole time so they know you don't approve. Right.
- 53:02That's what this movie feels like, where it's
- 53:04just like, hey, we're talking about this movie,
- 53:06but I need you to know I don't approve of it.
- 53:08But I see the scope, and I see the vision, and
- 53:10I see what they're going for. So it's not a half
- 53:13star. It's not a zero star movie. It really is
- 53:16just disappointing that after the high of highs
- 53:20with All Quiet on the Western Front, we're talking
- 53:22about something like Cimarron. So that's the
- 53:24difficulty for me. Yeah, the two stars definitely
- 53:27comes from me sitting in a theater in 1931 watching
- 53:31it. Yes. If I'm strictly looking back at it from
- 53:34this lens and judging it as a viewer of today,
- 53:37I mean, I wouldn't watch this. It does feel a
- 53:40little bit like in 1930, you're like, wow, look
- 53:42what we can do. And in 2026, you're like, look
- 53:44what we did. But a little more. Shame. Yeah,
- 53:47exactly. We're ringing the shame bell. Yeah.
- 53:49Two stars feels appropriate for this. Totally.
- 53:52But also, I need Letterboxd. Again, bring more
- 53:56fractions. But also, let me have a smiley face
- 54:00and frowny face. Because I think a smiley face
- 54:02two stars is a much different rating than a frowny
- 54:05face two stars. Two stars. Hmm. Yeah. Two stars.
- 54:08Huh. Yeah. Big difference. Big difference. Big
- 54:11difference. You know what? Auditory. There should
- 54:14be an auditory rating system where it's two stars,
- 54:16but there's a little sound. button next to it
- 54:19like a speaker yeah and you click and it's me
- 54:21being like oh like oh he's impressed cool yeah
- 54:23the other one's like oh he doesn't agree with
- 54:25this man i like that idea i do too letterboxd
- 54:28how frustrating to click on a movie on letterboxd
- 54:31and just hear And you're like, what was that?
- 54:36Yeah, I think that would be how we would have
- 54:37more Ruggles situations. I think specifically
- 54:41if I was Wesley Ruggles and I was on Letterboxd,
- 54:44I was like, oh, what's everyone thinking of my
- 54:45big epic movie I made? And it's just like a hundred,
- 54:47like a sea of just a bunch of people going, uh.
- 54:50Yeah. You want to get into. I'd love to. What
- 54:55is it? Double features. Yeah. That is what it
- 54:57is. You just agreed. I could have said anything
- 54:58there. I would love to not talk about Cimarron
- 55:00anymore. Yeah. Do you want to go first? Yeah,
- 55:03I'll go first. I went with a movie that follows
- 55:07a man and his family who kind of have this, hey,
- 55:12we're going to go to this place, this town, and
- 55:15we're going to start anew, and we're going to
- 55:18make something for ourselves. It doesn't have
- 55:21the same family dynamics, and it kind of turns
- 55:23into a more traditional Western. Okay. Okay,
- 55:26we're safe. Way better movie, though. This is
- 55:29Tombstone. Wonderful. Yeah. Great pick. You've
- 55:33got Wyatt Earp heading out to Tombstone with
- 55:36his brothers, their wives, his wife, and they're
- 55:39going to make a name. He does all kinds of things.
- 55:42He's leaving the law life behind and buying a
- 55:46casino, basically, like a poker house. And then,
- 55:49you know, shenanigans ensue, and we know how
- 55:52that goes down. That's actually the tagline on
- 55:54the poster, right? Yeah, 100%. Another cool little,
- 55:58hey, this is why this best... This is why this
- 56:00double feature is going to be better than yours,
- 56:02Ryan, is Richard Dix went on to play Wyatt Earp
- 56:06in Tombstone, the town too tough to die. Oh,
- 56:09so you have a little bit of a layered thing in
- 56:11there. Wow. A little layer cake for you. I didn't
- 56:13know that we had to be better than each other
- 56:14on these double features. It's good to know now.
- 56:16No, we don't. But, you know, I am. No, I'm just
- 56:20kidding. Well, you haven't heard mine yet, so...
- 56:21Yeah, hit me with it. Mary -Kate and Ashley Olsen's...
- 56:24No, so... They get brought up so often. They're
- 56:27going to... Look, when you're trying to look
- 56:29for movies that aren't Oscar -nominated, it's
- 56:31easy to kind of just go with, you know, switching
- 56:32goals. That is fair. However, I did go with a
- 56:34movie that was Oscar -nominated. So I looked
- 56:37at... Kind of the same thing you were saying.
- 56:39And that's why I was reacting a certain way where
- 56:41I was like, oh, no. Yeah. He picked what I picked.
- 56:43It is also the story of a man and his singular
- 56:46vision, a man who's plagued by being creative
- 56:50and doing everything he can to kind of move forward
- 56:54in life. He's plagued with a vision and he has
- 56:56to put it into paper, put it into reality. And
- 56:59he's willing to move his family to far distances.
- 57:02And I'm talking about The Brutalist. A lot of
- 57:05Cimarron feels very... Well, not inspired, obviously.
- 57:09But The Brutalist feels like it was inspired
- 57:11by that scope of something like Cimarron. And
- 57:14specifically not just the idea of moving to this
- 57:16location and trying to start anew, but the idea
- 57:18of how plagued Yancey was with feeling like,
- 57:22you know, I yearn for the mountains and I must
- 57:23go be among the mountains. That's a similar thing
- 57:26from Adrian Brody's character in The Brutalist,
- 57:29where he feels like... He has to do this. He
- 57:33has to be creative. He has to go and give himself
- 57:35a shot to a point where it destroys his life
- 57:38and his relationship with not just his wife,
- 57:41but with his niece. And it feels like he was
- 57:44destroyed by his own ambition. And that's something
- 57:47that I felt very similar to in Cimarron. Yeah,
- 57:49I like that. I yearn for the sad building. I
- 57:53must go. It's calling me. I yearn for the sad
- 57:56building is an amazing tagline for the Brutalist.
- 58:00It's pretty accurate. It's pretty accurate. He
- 58:02be yearning. He be yearning. And sad. No, I like
- 58:05that. That's good. That's solid. Once again,
- 58:07I feel like you're making the letterbox more
- 58:09difficult to make, so thank you for that. I intentionally
- 58:11did this. That'll be great. I just wait for the
- 58:14last conversation you and I have on a given day,
- 58:17and if you didn't laugh at a joke that I made,
- 58:19I'm like, there's another Oscar -nominated movie
- 58:21I'm double -featuring to make his life more difficult.
- 58:24Just hand a fist. Ooh, that Kyle. I'm going to
- 58:29get him. Yeah. So, hey, that's Cimarron. I want
- 58:32to know what people at home think. Not you, Bryce.
- 58:35We already know. Yeah. We got your Letterboxd
- 58:37rating. Nice tattoo, though. But you know what?
- 58:39Actually, do let us know, Bryce, because based
- 58:41on our new system of rating on Letterboxd, we
- 58:43need to know if your two stars is an uh or an
- 58:46uh. Yeah. Very important. Very important. Listen,
- 58:49if it's anything other than a hmm. Keep it to
- 58:52yourself. Yeah. Problematic. Just send us, quick,
- 58:56in the Discord, just send us, quick, like he's
- 58:58going to do in the next five minutes, but send
- 59:00us in the Discord just an audio clip of you high
- 59:03-pitched or low -pitched, and we'll know. Yeah,
- 59:05no context, though. No context. Oh, I love that,
- 59:07because this is recorded a month out, and I'm
- 59:10going to forget. So good. This is truly like
- 59:13Cimarron, where it's going to be like 40 years
- 59:15from now, and Bryce just leaves that, and we're
- 59:18like, okay. He saved all those people in that
- 59:20oil rig. But yeah, great tattoo. Yes, also great
- 59:25tattoo. People at home, though, I do want to
- 59:27know, because this is now going to be our lowest
- 59:30rated Best Picture winner. True. So far. Yeah,
- 59:34so far, for sure. I want to know if you did watch
- 59:37this one at home. Because a lot of the times,
- 59:40too, I think that... People that go through every
- 59:42year might just watch the winners. So if you
- 59:45did watch this, what did you think of this film
- 59:48in particular? If you do have thoughts on that,
- 59:50shoot us an email at outaopodcast at gmail .com.
- 59:54We will read those responses if you want during
- 59:57our ceremony episode at the end of this five
- 1:00:00movie run. I say if you want. Can you imagine
- 1:00:02someone who like sends a like glowing, I loved
- 1:00:05this movie. Don't include this. Yeah. And you
- 1:00:08know what? I wouldn't. Consent is important.
- 1:00:11But yeah, do that. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
- 1:00:14And we mentioned the Patreon at the top of the
- 1:00:16show, patreon .com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast.
- 1:00:20And what else do we have? Like. Rate, review
- 1:00:23the show. Yeah, and make sure that you join the
- 1:00:26Patreon to join the Discord, because just like
- 1:00:29we did with Sinners last month, we love doing
- 1:00:31watch parties, and we look forward to the next
- 1:00:33time that we do it, especially when we talk about
- 1:00:35these movies from the 1930s for this year. So
- 1:00:37very excited to do that in the future, so keep
- 1:00:39your eye out for that too. Yeah. We'll have to
- 1:00:42start planning watch parties like a month in
- 1:00:44advance, I think, so that we can promote them
- 1:00:46in the episodes. And also find out which ones
- 1:00:48are on YouTube that we can share. This one is
- 1:00:51because it's public domain. That's true, and
- 1:00:54that's how I watched it because my DVD didn't
- 1:00:56work. Yeah. This movie is on DVD, and you can
- 1:00:59actually find it, but good luck with your disc
- 1:01:02working. Yeah. Shout out to the Cult Classic
- 1:01:04Cinema Archive, though, for having this available
- 1:01:07on YouTube and so many other films. Her page
- 1:01:11is... Do you think every decade that we cover,
- 1:01:14we're going to find a new YouTube channel? Maybe.
- 1:01:16Like the 20s was Pizza Flicks. Pizza Flicks.
- 1:01:19And now we're at the Cinema Archive. Yeah. I
- 1:01:22don't know. Maybe. Maybe we can reach out to
- 1:01:24some of these people and get them on the show
- 1:01:25one day. That'd be great. Yeah. But, yeah, there's
- 1:01:29Cimarron. That's going to do it for this. That's
- 1:01:32going to do it for this episode of the podcast.
- 1:01:33Okay, I take it back. There's Cimarron in that
- 1:01:36tone is the tagline for the poster. There's Cimarron.
- 1:01:38There's Cimarron. But we'll be coming back to
- 1:01:41you next episode with East Lynn. Yeah, really
- 1:01:45interesting one. Yeah, looking forward to that
- 1:01:47for sure. But until then, I'm your host, Kyle.
- 1:01:49I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies.