Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / The Illegals
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Eye Spy, the intelligence history podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg. Every few
- 0:12weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians,
- 0:14practitioners, and scholars in the field of intelligence
- 0:17to explore some aspect of the past and what it
- 0:21can tell us about the present and future of intelligence
- 0:23studies. Shaun Walker is The Guardian's Central
- 0:27and Eastern Europe correspondent. He's the author
- 0:30of The Long Hangover, Putin's New Russia and
- 0:33the Ghosts of the Past, and Odessa Dreams, the
- 0:36Dark Heart of Ukraine's Online Marriage Industry.
- 0:39His latest book is The Illegals, Russia's Most
- 0:42Audacious Spies and Their Century -Long Mission
- 0:44to Infiltrate the West. Welcome to I Spy, the
- 0:49intelligence history podcast. Today, I'll be
- 0:52speaking with Sean Walker about his new book,
- 0:55The Illegals, Russia's Most Audacious Spies and
- 0:57Their Century -Long Mission to Infiltrate the
- 0:59West. Welcome. Hi, thanks very much for having
- 1:04me. So, to begin, many of us have a preconceived
- 1:09notion of what an illegal is like from TV shows
- 1:13such as The Americans. In your book, the illegals
- 1:17program seems to be the most effective weapon
- 1:19of the Kremlin and is also really remarkably
- 1:21resilient, having survived World War Two, having
- 1:25been revived after the collapse of the Soviet
- 1:27Union and so forth. So why and how have illegals
- 1:32endured and remained a constant tool for Moscow
- 1:35to use? And how does what you've researched and
- 1:39witnessed firsthand clash with the fictional
- 1:42portrayals we are used to consuming? Wow. Well,
- 1:48yeah, that's really interesting. I mean, I think
- 1:51if you take the Americans as the sort of the
- 1:55most recognisable fictional portrayal of illegals,
- 2:00I think parts of it ring very true from the people
- 2:08I've spoken to. I think, you know, the obvious.
- 2:11So the Americans being set. I guess early 80s
- 2:15what doesn't quite fit with illegals at that
- 2:21time is that of course in the Americans kind
- 2:23of they're out shooting people and doing really
- 2:27intense active missions and kind of on the brink
- 2:31of being caught all the time but just about evading
- 2:34it which of course makes for great tv but like
- 2:37by that stage in the illegals program most of
- 2:41the illegals actually were not doing very much
- 2:45active. These were long -term missions. Part
- 2:49of the idea was that they should kind of lie
- 2:51low and that they would be there in place if
- 2:55the US and the Soviet Union entered the so -called
- 3:00special period where the Cold War would turn
- 3:03hot. And then, you know, there may be no diplomats
- 3:06in the US. So you then turn to the illegals as
- 3:09your people behind enemy lines. So to do kind
- 3:13of really risky missions was actually not something
- 3:17they were doing at that time. But if you look
- 3:19back into the history of the illegals program
- 3:21in the 20s and 30s, when sort of the so -called
- 3:24great illegals were around, actually, they were
- 3:28doing much more of that kind of thing. They were,
- 3:31you know. being sent to assassinate people or
- 3:35infiltrate places or you know actively recruit
- 3:38and handle agents um uh steal the diplomatic
- 3:43cables of western countries all these kind of
- 3:47kind of exciting traditional things you think
- 3:49about as spies doing um and Yeah, so I think
- 3:56so. So it sort of takes that that kind of active
- 3:59component of it from earlier illegals. But I
- 4:01think what it did get right in the Americans
- 4:04from. I think a thread that like ran through
- 4:08the research of from all the periods is this
- 4:12kind of psychological aspect of it and how challenging
- 4:18and difficult it is to sort of live this double
- 4:22life for so many years. And obviously, all spying,
- 4:27all espionage work involves that. in some degree
- 4:32but like for illegals it's just this particularly
- 4:35intense visceral thing where in many cases uh
- 4:40you're lying to your own children who think they're
- 4:43kind of ordinary americans or germans and in
- 4:45fact their parents are russians and again you
- 4:48know that's something but that's probably the
- 4:50conceptually that's the thing that's most gripping
- 4:53in the americans say and that is indeed something
- 4:56that um you saw with a lot of i saw a lot of
- 4:59the characters that i was writing about so i
- 5:01would say yeah it's it's um at different times
- 5:07the program kind of morphs into different things
- 5:10but but that that that psychological tension
- 5:13is is perhaps the thing that's most present all
- 5:15the way through and how did you approach writing
- 5:21about this topic if you can share any methods
- 5:24you used um and Especially considering the current
- 5:28challenges of gathering material from Russia
- 5:31and what roadblocks you face in your research
- 5:35and how did you overcome them? Yeah, I mean,
- 5:39it's been a really long process. It started about
- 5:4310 years ago, I think, the first idea when I
- 5:46did an interview with the two sons. of an illegal
- 5:53couple that had been arrested in Boston in 2010.
- 5:58Actually, in many ways, I believe that this couple
- 6:01was the inspiration for the Americans. So they
- 6:04had two children who were 16 and 20 when the
- 6:07FBI kind of came knocking and basically discovered
- 6:11that their whole upbringing had been a lie. So
- 6:15I interviewed these two kids. I did a Guardian
- 6:17magazine story about it at the time. And I mean,
- 6:20I was really fascinated by it is, I think, probably
- 6:24still one of the most read stories I've ever
- 6:26written. So I could see that other people were
- 6:29also fascinated by it. And at the time, I sort
- 6:33of had this idea, well, maybe I should look into
- 6:35this and try and write a book on it. But it just,
- 6:37as you say, it seemed a bit challenging. I mean,
- 6:41the KGB archives are closed. You know, the parents
- 6:45of these two boys. um they weren't going to be
- 6:48giving kind of open reveal interviews about what
- 6:51they've been up to in in the us for all these
- 6:54years so i kind of discarded it a bit but i started
- 6:58reading about the history of the illegals program
- 7:01and trying to find as many different things as
- 7:05i could to to read about it and what i sort of
- 7:08started realizing was that there were these two
- 7:12elements to it where on the one hand There were
- 7:15these really interesting, fascinating characters
- 7:17getting up to all these crazy kind of spy capers
- 7:21that were just interesting stories. And on the
- 7:24other hand, it was like at every point of the
- 7:26way, it somehow told you something really interesting
- 7:30about Russia at that moment or the Soviet Union
- 7:33at that moment and was a real reflection of the
- 7:36way things were. I write back to the origins
- 7:39of the illegals program in the Bolshevik underground
- 7:41before the Russian Revolution. So I started that
- 7:46and I think, yeah, it was one of the helpful
- 7:50things of covering such a large period in the
- 7:53book was that it allowed me to dip in and out
- 7:56of stories and tell the parts of stories that
- 8:00I could tell more thoroughly. So, you know, if
- 8:05I was writing a biography, so there are some
- 8:07illegals, for example, the first one I write
- 8:09about in a lot of depth, Dmitry Bistrolyotov,
- 8:11who worked in the UK. in London in the early
- 8:151930s. And you have fantastic sources for like
- 8:21his mission in London. Then after that, all you
- 8:25have is his memoirs, which are amazingly written
- 8:28and hilarious and kind of exciting, but you feel
- 8:32like they're probably full of fabrications and
- 8:34you no longer have the corroborating sources.
- 8:36So if you're writing a biography of him, that's
- 8:39a problem. But for me, I could just tell his
- 8:42story with the part of it that I could tell.
- 8:45So I think it was, yeah, it was a mixture of
- 8:47the earlier stories, memoirs, Russian books,
- 8:53archives. Clearly, the archive that I would most
- 8:57love to read is the KGB archive, and that's fully
- 9:00closed. But what we do have is the Mitrokhin
- 9:03archive, which was, you know, this KGB archivist
- 9:08who for 10 years... secretly copied day by day
- 9:11documents in the archive and in the early 1990s
- 9:15defected to Britain and they MI6 dug up all his
- 9:19papers and took them to Britain and so obviously
- 9:22there were two books that were written by the
- 9:25historian Christopher Andrew together with Matrokin
- 9:28about his documents but there's also loads more
- 9:30in the actual documents including loads about
- 9:33illegals and those have been opened for researchers.
- 9:37since 2014. So I read, I spent a lot of time
- 9:40in Cambridge reading those. And then, I mean,
- 9:44I'm not a trained historian, I'm a journalist,
- 9:46so I did a lot of journalistic work, particularly
- 9:49with the more recent characters, tracking people
- 9:50down, doing interviews with them, meeting people
- 9:53who'd known illegals and, you know, both sides
- 9:56of their identities, and kind of through this
- 9:59patchwork of different sources and methods, kind
- 10:02of was able to put it together. yeah wonderful
- 10:06and um delving deeper into your interviews you
- 10:10mentioned that you spoke with former illegals
- 10:13as well as their descendants um and given that
- 10:16some of these individuals were trained in deception
- 10:18how did you determine when to trust their accounts
- 10:21what challenges did you face in navigating this
- 10:24balance between your individual narratives and
- 10:27the archive and can you give us some examples
- 10:32of what it was like to interview these individuals
- 10:34and if anything in particular stood out to you?
- 10:38Yeah, so I mean, they are, one thing that I think
- 10:42runs through the personality of different illegals
- 10:45I met is that they are all really charming people
- 10:49and engaging conversationalists. And that was
- 10:53obviously part of, I mean, they're trained to
- 10:56be like that and they're trained to be able to
- 10:58be really, really good social operators. And
- 11:03they're trained to lie and they're people who've
- 11:06spent years and years lying. So it does mean
- 11:09that you approach it, I guess, with a bit of
- 11:14caution. And I mean, I've been working as a journalist
- 11:18for years and I feel like I have a fairly good
- 11:20instinct for like when somebody is being more
- 11:25or less truthful or when they're being truthful,
- 11:27but hiding. some part of it or whether they're
- 11:31just full of shit um and but of course you have
- 11:36to you have you come out of meeting some of these
- 11:38people and you think well okay i mean i had the
- 11:41feeling that they were um being truthful but
- 11:44but but who knows i mean they're uh it's difficult
- 11:48so yeah of course you're then where you can you're
- 11:52trying to corroborate what they've told you with
- 11:55um secondary stuff now clearly that's not always
- 11:59possible if somebody's telling you about a mission
- 12:01they were on 50 years ago and they tell you you
- 12:03know i then i went to a bar and got drunk i mean
- 12:05i can't that i have no way of finding the bar
- 12:09and finding witnesses of that etc etc but i think
- 12:13what you what i could do was you know if you
- 12:18if you have a few test moments where you are
- 12:22able to check something and you see that this
- 12:26person has more or less reliably told you this
- 12:30and it does turn out to be true or conversely,
- 12:33it doesn't turn out to be true. I think that
- 12:35gives you a feeling for like how reliable the
- 12:38rest of the testimony may be. I think in the
- 12:40book, I've tried to, you know, there are places
- 12:43where, I mean, frankly, even if the archives
- 12:47do open, we may not know. real specifics of kind
- 12:50of narrative detail and i've tried to mark where
- 12:53things are based on just conjecture or one source
- 12:56or where it's not very clear um and i've also
- 13:00um yeah i've i i've also sort of allowed for
- 13:07the fact that i think in any book about particularly
- 13:11a book about intelligence um There's always going
- 13:15to be this sense that like maybe part of this
- 13:17is missing and maybe maybe I haven't quite got
- 13:21to the absolute bottom of this. But at some point
- 13:25I feel like, you know, I've done the best I can.
- 13:27And that's almost that's almost part of the charm
- 13:30of these stories that you've put together, these
- 13:33like fascinating stories. But like, I'm pretty
- 13:36sure that they are they are the real full stories.
- 13:39But, you know, maybe they're maybe they're not.
- 13:42In your book, you quote George Blake as saying
- 13:46that only an intelligence service which works
- 13:48for a great cause can ask for such a sacrifice
- 13:51from its officers. And so I'm wondering, do you
- 13:54think Soviet illegals were part of a larger ideological
- 13:57mission? Or is there something else at play?
- 14:01From your research? What goes into making or
- 14:05becoming an illegal? And is there something about
- 14:08personality, necessity, or is there something
- 14:11else? So I think in terms of the ideological
- 14:15part of the question, so I think it's clear that
- 14:19there was this, the illegals and the history
- 14:27of the illegals, there was this kind of strong
- 14:29element of KGB mythology. around this program
- 14:34because it did come out of the bolshevik history
- 14:37there were all these great illegals in the 20s
- 14:40and the 30s um and so you see that it it becomes
- 14:47something that um something that almost lives
- 14:52for its own sake that it's it's like a proud
- 14:54part of the soviet heritage um i also think there
- 14:58was there was a very strong particularly when
- 15:00you look at the cold war period there was a very
- 15:03strong ideological component so you were they
- 15:08were recruiting promising students straight out
- 15:11of university and one of the one of the key factors
- 15:16and the key criteria was that they should be
- 15:18from you know so -called politically reliable
- 15:21family and that they should be patriotic and
- 15:25then they were given As part of this long training
- 15:28program, a surprising amount of it was also based
- 15:32on kind of Marxist -Leninist ideology and on
- 15:36making sure that these people were going to be
- 15:40reliable Soviets. Because the Soviet Union is
- 15:47a really paranoid society and nobody in the Soviet
- 15:51Union is able to just travel the world freely
- 15:54without... Most people are not allowed to travel
- 15:58abroad. If you are allowed to travel abroad,
- 16:01you have KGB minders, or if you're in the embassy,
- 16:04you have the counterintelligence, KGB counterintelligence
- 16:07that's keeping an eye on you. And illegals are
- 16:09basically the only people who, by definition,
- 16:14they can't be watched over because they can't
- 16:16have any links or connections with Soviet Union
- 16:18when they're in position. So the Soviet state
- 16:21is sending these people abroad for years on end.
- 16:24and wants them to remain loyal and is very scared
- 16:28that they're not going to remain loyal so in
- 16:30order to create these loyal and this kind of
- 16:33quite paradoxical makeup of somebody who's going
- 16:36to be this sort of maverick who can lie to everyone
- 16:42around them, but is also going to remain totally
- 16:44loyal to Moscow and to the KGB. It takes them
- 16:48years of training that kind of sometimes veers
- 16:51into something that looks a bit more like a kind
- 16:53of cult induction where, you know, they're really
- 16:57kind of almost broken as people until they understand
- 17:02that, like, they can never lie to their handlers
- 17:05and that they always have to serve the Soviet
- 17:07cause. And when they go abroad, I mean, in some
- 17:11of the cases, this ideological conviction fades.
- 17:15But in many cases, it actually stays there. And
- 17:19I think that's perhaps because one of the reasons
- 17:23is that it's much easier to stay patriotic when
- 17:28you're abroad. So these people were not living
- 17:30in the Soviet Union. They weren't seeing, particularly
- 17:32in the 70s and 80s, the kind of harder, more...
- 17:36depressing sides of soviet life they were in
- 17:39the west and of course they were seeing problems
- 17:41in western societies because these places weren't
- 17:44perfect and so actually it was in a way many
- 17:47of them really kept this really strong soviet
- 17:50conviction and then the last thing i get i think
- 17:53is during the cold war i mean a large a large
- 17:56this is a generate these were generations that
- 17:58kind of grew up in the shadow of the second world
- 18:00war And they felt that a large part of their
- 18:03mission was dedicated to kind of avoiding a nuclear
- 18:09war, another global war. And so there was this
- 18:12kind of strong component of promoting peace that
- 18:16was kind of part of the ideological makeup as
- 18:20well. Absolutely. And something that's really
- 18:24great in your book, I think, is how you really
- 18:26focus on the origins at first of the illegals
- 18:29program stemming from the Bolshevik revolutionary
- 18:31underground, which kind of created this template
- 18:35for this deep cover espionage that Soviet intelligence
- 18:39institutionalized. So can you reflect a little
- 18:43bit of how the Bolshevik experience in foreign
- 18:47intelligence was shaped, for instance, through
- 18:50the colorful persona of Trlisar and his personal
- 18:53experience as a revolutionary and underground
- 18:55operative, and how this really shaped the intelligence
- 19:00culture of early Soviet foreign intelligence?
- 19:03The whole concept of illegals, of course, comes
- 19:07out of that revolutionary culture and it was
- 19:10initially the division was you know the the elements
- 19:16of political life in czarist russia were legal
- 19:21and elements were not and so lenin's idea was
- 19:25that the bolsheviks should use all of the opportunities
- 19:29they had legally so they should In the end, he
- 19:33decided to send people to the parliament when
- 19:35it was formed, and they should do trade union
- 19:38work where it's allowed. So you have these legal
- 19:41workers, but at the same time, they should have
- 19:43an illegal network. Better translation is a clandestine
- 19:47network that would be doing secret party work
- 19:51and secret organizing. And these people have
- 19:56fake documents. They communicate in invisible
- 19:58writing. They have code names. There's a lot
- 20:02of the kind of tradecraft and conceptual basis
- 20:05that actually carries on for decades afterwards.
- 20:11Yeah, and Trillis, the guy you mentioned, so
- 20:16he is an old Bolshevik revolutionary. He spends
- 20:21some years in prison. He is sent to Siberia in
- 20:27exile. And after the revolution, he kind of,
- 20:31he's really, after the February revolution, he's
- 20:33released from prison and he kind of becomes this.
- 20:37uh underground bolshevik revolutionary organizer
- 20:40in the far east um and he is undercover so he's
- 20:45he's not in this case in a foreign identity but
- 20:47he's uh disguised as a merchant um he is um yeah
- 20:55he's captured on a number of occasions um and
- 20:59and when the bolsheviks take over he is asked
- 21:02by uh felix Szerzhinsky, who is appointed by
- 21:07Lenin as the head of the Cheka, the new kind
- 21:11of security service, if you like. And there's
- 21:14a small foreign department they're just setting
- 21:16up. And Szerzhinsky asked Trilisa to lead it.
- 21:20And yeah, Trilisa basically takes, it's a small
- 21:23department. They're kind of making things up
- 21:26as they go along, working out what the rules
- 21:28are. But he takes this heritage of working in
- 21:30the underground against the Tsars. and kind of
- 21:34repurposes it to a foreign intelligence service.
- 21:39So they start to, as I mentioned a bit earlier,
- 21:44they have this roster of sort of these people
- 21:48who either in Russia or in other European countries
- 21:50have been used to living in the underground,
- 21:53have been used to taking on various personas
- 21:56and identities. And these people are then sent
- 22:01abroad on undercover missions, which could be
- 22:06both in those very early years, it could be both
- 22:10against the remnants, the whites, the kind of
- 22:14exiled pro -Tsarist Russians who were dreaming
- 22:18of kind of overthrowing the Bolsheviks and restoring
- 22:20their order. Or it could be against, it could
- 22:25be to try and find information from capitalist
- 22:29countries. And strikingly, I think you highlight
- 22:36how Stalin's own early career began in the shadows
- 22:40as well, and how he sort of mastered escape,
- 22:44disguise and deception. He even cross -dressed
- 22:48at one point to flee exile. How do you think
- 22:51that these stories contribute to the sort of
- 22:55mythic narrative of illegality within the revolutionary
- 22:59ethos? Yeah, I mean, it's kind of fascinating
- 23:07how much this sort of, this idea of, as the Russians
- 23:16call it, the kind of set of rules around living
- 23:22a clandestine life and how to live in the underground,
- 23:27how much this is a part of most of the leading
- 23:32Bolsheviks that come to power in 1917. I think
- 23:37that is part of the reason why this program takes
- 23:41on such a life of its own. throughout the hundred
- 23:47years of this book, I kind of felt that, you
- 23:54know, the idea of using, so the idea of Trilliser
- 23:56using illegals and when he takes over in 1922
- 23:59as the head of foreign intelligence is brilliant.
- 24:02It makes a lot of sense. And I mean, they don't
- 24:05have other options and it works really well for
- 24:07them. But there's a number of periods over the
- 24:10next hundred years, basically, where you think,
- 24:13okay, I mean, At this stage, this isn't an effective
- 24:18method of spying anymore. It takes so long to
- 24:23create these people. You don't have these cosmopolitan,
- 24:27well -travelled people who can do this very naturally
- 24:30anymore. It just doesn't quite make sense. But
- 24:33at every one of these junctures, the programme
- 24:37continues or is reborn and keeps going right
- 24:42up until today. So I think this sort of origin
- 24:46story in the Leninist underground is a big part
- 24:50of why it was something that, yeah, the intelligence
- 24:56bosses were so proud of. I think it's a combination
- 24:58of that. And then as it went on over the years,
- 25:02this feeling that this is something that's kind
- 25:05of unique to the Russian services and doesn't
- 25:09really exist anywhere else in intelligence. And
- 25:15how do you understand the purges and Stalin's
- 25:201936 to 38, the Great Purge? And how does this
- 25:26really fit into this idea of, you know, agents
- 25:30as loyal to the state, but then we have, you
- 25:32know, this really powerful authoritarian regime
- 25:35that can just eliminate all of these agents as
- 25:40well? Yeah, I mean, the purchase was one of was
- 25:44kind of a really interesting moment for me when
- 25:46I was researching this book. So one of the sort
- 25:49of first character that I follow in detail, Dimitri
- 25:51Pistriotov, who I mentioned, who is working in
- 25:54London. He he's a kind of brilliant kind of spy
- 25:59from the movie's figure that he's, you know,
- 26:01he's. uses seduction. He changes disguises kind
- 26:06of from morning till evening. Like he's kind
- 26:09of very colorful character. And he eventually
- 26:13is withdrawn to Moscow, violently interrogated
- 26:18and tortured during the purges and is eventually
- 26:21convicted of being a Czech spy. So basically
- 26:28an illegal for the west posing as an illegal
- 26:33for the soviet union um and is sent to the gulag
- 26:36for 20 years um and i mean the yeah the terror
- 26:42is obviously i mean there's been many many books
- 26:44about the terror and why it happened and there
- 26:47are all kinds of different institutional and
- 26:50personal and structural reasons why this might
- 26:54have happened but something that really sort
- 26:57of struck me while i was doing this research
- 26:59is that Again, you look at the whole history
- 27:02of the Bolshevik Party and you look at this idea
- 27:05of using illegals and that they're sending somebody
- 27:08like Dmitry Bistreljotov to London for years
- 27:11on end, where he is a devoted Soviet communist,
- 27:15but he's posing every day as a banker from Dresden,
- 27:18as a capitalist. And as we said, all these people,
- 27:25including Stalin himself, had their origins in
- 27:28these kind of underground movements. So that's
- 27:31your sort of conceptual basis. And you're working
- 27:36on the assumption that you're sending people
- 27:39out in this like very, very deep disguises to
- 27:43burrow into enemy societies. It suddenly becomes
- 27:46a bit more natural to assume that. others are
- 27:50also doing that to you and that you know among
- 27:53this mass of loyal soviet stalinist workers for
- 27:58sure there are some enemy spies who are you know
- 28:01deep under deep deep cover and i think it's you
- 28:04know you we it's pretty obvious from the way
- 28:07that stalin would go after people's families
- 28:09and things like that that You know, he was he
- 28:12was ruthless and he for sure knew that some of
- 28:15the people that were being shot were innocent.
- 28:18But I think there's a good chance that, you know,
- 28:22when the sort of conspiratorial thinking that
- 28:26many of them weren't innocent and that there
- 28:29was this huge conspiracy of different foreign
- 28:32intelligence services and. and people inside
- 28:35the Soviet Union, like it suddenly starts to
- 28:37make more sense, to me at least, when you look
- 28:40at it through this lens of the illegals program.
- 28:43How did this all evolve over time, especially
- 28:49considering the transition from wartime alliance
- 28:51to Cold War hostility, sort of reshaping Soviet
- 28:55influence operations in the US? And why did the
- 28:59KGB come to view illegals as essential in an
- 29:02environment of increased counterintelligence
- 29:04surveillance yeah so in the i mean when the cold
- 29:09war starts um i think two things happen um one
- 29:14is that the the sort of the impunity with which
- 29:20you could just have spies wandering in and out
- 29:23of western countries in the pre -war years gradually
- 29:27changes um this huge investment in the fbi uh
- 29:32suddenly you know whereas in the 30s and even
- 29:36in the during the war years like spies in the
- 29:42soviet embassy could happily meet with their
- 29:47us sources in a restaurant or in a cinema that's
- 29:52no longer really possible like the fbi is all
- 29:54over them if you or if you're a spy posted under
- 29:57diplomatic cover you're going to be followed
- 29:58everywhere you go um And so it becomes almost
- 30:03impossible to do like real espionage work out
- 30:08of the embassy for the Soviets. And so clearly
- 30:11the natural solution is illegal because you can
- 30:14have these people who have no obvious connection
- 30:17to the Soviet Union. And, you know, there is
- 30:22this long history of using them and it just makes
- 30:24a lot of sense. But the other thing that's happened,
- 30:27as we kind of already discussed, is that these
- 30:32Brilliant, natural operatives from the pre -war
- 30:36years don't really exist anymore. And I mean,
- 30:39in the early post -war years, there are a few,
- 30:42so most of the illegals that are sent abroad,
- 30:45people like Rudolf Aebel, people like Conan Malody,
- 30:48like Yevgeny Brick, these are still people who,
- 30:52for some reason or other, had had some kind of
- 30:55upbringing in the West. So Aebel was born in
- 30:57Britain. malodi was grew up in uh california
- 31:03with an aunt evgeny brick i think his father
- 31:06was posted to the soviet trade mission in new
- 31:12york so they'd grown up in america or in britain
- 31:15they spoke native english um and there was this
- 31:20kind of transition period where um you still
- 31:24had illegals who had these kind of talents. But
- 31:27then by the time you get to somewhere around
- 31:291960, they have this problem that the Soviet
- 31:36Union is becoming more and more of a closed and
- 31:39paranoid state. And that actually, even if you
- 31:44had... grown up in the US, that would exactly
- 31:47be a reason for suspicion and to keep you away
- 31:50from a sensitive job rather than a positive point.
- 31:53So you end up at the sort of peak of the illegals
- 31:57program, which is probably where most people
- 31:59are familiar with it from, you know, the Americans
- 32:01and elsewhere, where, you know, you literally
- 32:04are plucking an 18 -year -old or 20 -year -old
- 32:08Soviet student who's never left the Soviet Union.
- 32:12and spending years kind of moulding them into
- 32:16a foreigner. And that is clearly, I mean, it's
- 32:21more difficult, it's more time consuming, and
- 32:24probably ultimately less likely to be successful
- 32:27than if you're working with people who already
- 32:30had a lot of those skills and had grown up speaking
- 32:33five or six languages and were sort of used to
- 32:37making those transformations. did the psychological
- 32:40long -term strain of living under false identities
- 32:45shape the personal lives and relationships of
- 32:48these Soviet illegals? You mentioned this a lot
- 32:51at the beginning, but how did this affect perhaps
- 32:58men and women differently? Did you notice any
- 33:01differences or similarities between male and
- 33:05female operatives? Well, so with men and women,
- 33:10it's interesting. I mean, I think KGB and its
- 33:15predecessor organisations were all very, very
- 33:18heavily male -dominated organisations. And with
- 33:25a few exceptions, but not many, before around
- 33:31the mid -1950s, illegals were all men. and they
- 33:39were only recruiting men. And at some point,
- 33:44exactly because of these new conditions we were
- 33:49talking about where there are these longer -term
- 33:52Cold War missions, you have to go off for years,
- 33:56you're really, really out there alone. It takes
- 34:03a tremendous toll on people's psychological state.
- 34:09So Yevgeny Brick, who I mentioned briefly, he
- 34:12was sent to Canada in the 50s and he was meant
- 34:16to make his way to the US, but when he arrived
- 34:19in Canada not long afterwards, he had a wife
- 34:23in Moscow, but the idea was that the wife would
- 34:26stay in Moscow and he would go back every few
- 34:27years to visit. And at some point he's staying
- 34:31in a guest house in a... going around the towns
- 34:35where he's supposed to have grown up in so he
- 34:37can collect some stories that he could later
- 34:39tell to people about his supposed youth and in
- 34:43one of these towns he stays in a guest house
- 34:44and he falls in love with the daughter of the
- 34:49owner of the guest house and immediately tells
- 34:51her everything tells her he's a Soviet illegal
- 34:53and he's here undercover and this woman persuades
- 34:57him to go to the police and tell them everything
- 34:59and the police end up running him as a double
- 35:04agent. And to cut a long story short, he ends
- 35:08up going back to the Soviet Union and they realise
- 35:11he's been turned into a double agent and he goes
- 35:13to prison for years. So there's a number of cases
- 35:16like this of illegals defecting or going a bit
- 35:21mad under the pressure. So at this point, they
- 35:25come up with an idea to recruit... uh women uh
- 35:29as sort of partner illegals and they will send
- 35:33illegals abroad in pairs um and that will kind
- 35:37of yeah will alleviate the loneliness of these
- 35:40long solo missions but it will also mean that
- 35:43both halves can kind of keep an eye on the other
- 35:45one and if if someone's going a bit mad they
- 35:48can drag them back to the soviet union um and
- 35:53yeah i mean the kgb again being a sort of macho
- 35:57misogynist organization their assumption is is
- 36:00that the woman will always be the sort of supporting
- 36:02illegal they will do the radio decoding they
- 36:05will be the sort of you know rock of support
- 36:08at home but like the male will be the sort of
- 36:12main spy um which kind of continues right uh
- 36:17up until the post -soviet era and in many cases
- 36:21you can see that um The woman's clearly got more
- 36:26aptitude than the man in a couple. But still,
- 36:30the man is kind of seen as the guy who's supposed
- 36:32to be out doing the real espionage stuff. But
- 36:36yeah, I think for both sides, I mean, the whole
- 36:39the program is littered with stories of both
- 36:41male and female operatives kind of having really
- 36:47serious mental health crises, having crises of
- 36:50faith, having. There are cases where, you know,
- 36:54one case I write about where before they were
- 36:59deployed, the couple, the woman got pregnant.
- 37:02And, you know, if you have a child as an illegal
- 37:04couple when you're already abroad, then the child's
- 37:06a great part of your cover. But if you have a
- 37:08child before you depart, you can't take it because
- 37:13the child doesn't have a Western birth certificate.
- 37:15It doesn't have any records. So it just becomes
- 37:18a liability. So they had to just leave the kid
- 37:22behind with grandparents and go off on their
- 37:24mission. And that essentially, in this particular
- 37:27case, led to the woman having something akin
- 37:31to a nervous breakdown and being called back
- 37:35to the Soviet Union. So I think, yeah, these
- 37:37longer missions, they were really, really tough
- 37:41psychologically. Some people thrived with the
- 37:45sort of double life, but more often it was something
- 37:49that kind of caused a lot of problems. And so
- 37:52do today's new army of virtual illegals still
- 37:56carry the same legacy, whereas digital impersonalization
- 38:00made the concept of human intelligence almost
- 38:03obsolete? So I would say it's more that, yeah,
- 38:06I don't know if it's made human intelligence
- 38:09obsolete. I think it's definitely broadened the
- 38:11options for doing things and it's also lowered
- 38:14the risks of doing things. So, you know, if you
- 38:17look at, yeah, I mean, what I called the virtual
- 38:21illegals, I mean, this idea that... To take one
- 38:24example, the sort of 2016 US election influence
- 38:28campaign, where you had people sitting in Russia,
- 38:32setting up Facebook accounts, posing as Americans,
- 38:35and essentially paying and organizing other Americans
- 38:43with real political agendas to set up protests,
- 38:50to set up events. I mean, this is something that
- 38:54a real illegal who'd spent years training, you
- 38:59wouldn't get them to do that because it would
- 39:01just be, I mean, it's so risky if they get caught.
- 39:04Like, what a pathetically small thing to risk
- 39:08all of that training for. But in the case of
- 39:11someone on Facebook, you know, you make your,
- 39:13you add a couple of pictures, you have a few
- 39:15statuses, you message that I also love Trump
- 39:18and like, let's do an event here and here. And,
- 39:21you know, if at some point it goes wrong and
- 39:23they get suspicious, you can just delete the
- 39:25page and create a new one. So I think from that
- 39:31perspective, yes, I mean, it just gives you these,
- 39:36it creates these new opportunities for sort of
- 39:41low cost, low training, low risk and potentially
- 39:48big reward. But I think that's not going to be
- 39:54a substitute in the eyes of the SVR for somebody
- 40:00who is trained and on the ground and having real
- 40:03human interactions with people. I mean, there's
- 40:06a whole extra question of whether in today's
- 40:10day and age, illegals, these long term illegals
- 40:15are useful or not. useful enough to justify the
- 40:21kind of time and expense that is spent training
- 40:24them I think you know in a weird way my answer
- 40:29might have changed in the last few years because
- 40:31I mean it's pre -2022 I would say you know illegals
- 40:41were designed for a time when Russian or Soviet
- 40:44citizens couldn't travel in a non -suspicious
- 40:47way. So you couldn't do what the CIA, you couldn't
- 40:51do like a CIA style non -official cover where
- 40:53it's an American business person or an American
- 40:55consultant and nobody suspects the CIA because
- 40:58the minute you saw it, there was no such thing
- 41:00as a Soviet business person. And the minute you
- 41:03saw a Soviet consultant or a Soviet journalist
- 41:05or whatever, you would suspect they're probably
- 41:07a spy. so you had to have these foreign identities
- 41:10to to sort of avoid that suspicion but once you
- 41:14get to the 90s and you have you know hundreds
- 41:16of thousands of russians who are traveling russian
- 41:19scientists russian business people russian cultural
- 41:22people and you know in that huge volume of people
- 41:25who have no connection at all with the intelligence
- 41:28services it's quite easy to slip in a few that
- 41:30do and like isn't it easier to do that than to
- 41:35train someone for like five years to pretend
- 41:37to be an Argentinian. But I guess what we're
- 41:42seeing now is that actually Russia's become quite
- 41:48toxic again, that it's become more difficult
- 41:50because of what Russia's done in Ukraine and
- 41:53because of Russian intelligence operations like
- 41:55poisoning Sergei Skripal and this kind of thing.
- 41:59It's much harder for Russians to travel. and
- 42:03therefore much harder for Russian intelligence
- 42:04services to use Russians on Russian passports
- 42:08traveling for supposedly innocent purposes. So
- 42:12potentially, alongside all of the computer stuff
- 42:16and alongside all of the things that... new technology
- 42:20allows them to do, such as recruiting one -time
- 42:24actors on Telegram to do sabotage actions and
- 42:28this kind of thing, which is, again, just much
- 42:31easier than anything they could have done in
- 42:33the 70s or 80s. But maybe there is, and certainly
- 42:36I think they, in Moscow, they feel there is still
- 42:40a place for this kind of seemingly outdated,
- 42:44traditional, illegal, where you literally sit.
- 42:47down a Russian and like train them to be someone
- 42:50from a foreign nationality. Interesting. And
- 42:56what do you hope readers take away from your
- 43:00book? So I hope two things. I mean, I think there
- 43:05isn't, you know, I don't feel like I'm a one
- 43:08big idea person. I don't think that like, you
- 43:11know, if you understand this book, you will understand
- 43:14that like. X is the key to Russian history. But
- 43:19the two things that I would hope that readers
- 43:21forget from it is firstly just a bunch of like
- 43:26getting to know a bunch of like incredible characters,
- 43:31sometimes hilarious, sometimes brilliant, sometimes
- 43:36evil, but like always kind of fascinating. And
- 43:41the second thing I would hope is that As I say,
- 43:45I mean, for me, what was interesting about this
- 43:48is the way that this illegals program over 100
- 43:50years kind of operates as this shadow history
- 43:53of the KGB and of Russia itself. And I would
- 43:58hope you get this sort of sweep of 100 years
- 44:00of Russian history told through an interesting
- 44:04lens. Yeah, really interesting. Thank you so
- 44:09much for sharing all of your knowledge and insight.
- 44:15Thank you very much for your interest. I really
- 44:17appreciate it