Latest / Ego and Other Things / What is My Story? (Part 2) | Worldview Series
Transcript
- William: Alright, so picking up from last time, I was talking about how I left my father's house and I wasn't sort of dealing with a lot of the emotional fallout and trauma that came from being kicked out of my dad's house and confronting him about his abuse and how I didn't even really know that you kind of had to process all that kind of stuff or even how to go about it. Certainly there was nobody in my life at the time who was trying to help me to deal with it. I was really on my own. And what I would learn later on when I did therapy is at the time I really dove into politics as something where I could offload and express my anger and frustration and debate. I could sort of get angry at you know, the government and the way that things were being run, rather than having to deal with my own emotions and feelings that had come up with confronting my father about abuse and finally escaping his household and being free for the first time. And I would say that it was this passion around politics, or this this this getting in into politics and really starting to think about that and starting to debate with people about these different political ideas was really where my first, I want to say, intellectual interest really began to expand for the first time. And I talked about last time how I had grown up in a house where kind of one side of my family was very conservative and I got a lot of conversation with my dad, who was sort of run of run-of-the-mill, most libertarian-leaning conservative. And on the other side I got my my grandfather, who was a very strong liberal, like right out of the sixties and seventies, and how I would kind of go back and forth between them. And learned that you know different authorities in my life had completely different perspectives, and really began thinking about okay, what do I think about this? Rather than just kind of regurgitating exactly what my dad believed, I had the opportunity to have other perspectives. But I was as skeptical of my grandfather's liberalism as I was my father's conservatism. And So I I began on this path of political basically political interest and sometimes I would talk to my friends about it though they weren't all that interested sometimes I'd talk about talk with teachers about it but they weren't all that interested so a lot of times what I would do with this is I would not just I guess do my own my own research. I was becoming more and more familiar with the internet kind of iPhones and things were becoming a big thing so I had a lot more access to to online information which was both a good thing and a bad thing and YouTube was becoming more or at least YouTube was I was becoming more familiar with a place like YouTube. so I got a lot of my like political information from just things I read online. And there were kind of some books here and there that I read about it. and I was still kind of, I don't know, mixing all this political interest with the the metaphysical mysticism that I had been interested with, but I was sort of more leaving that behind as I had as I was becoming more independent from just my father and and because that's originally where it where it picked up a of this kind of mysticism, right? And you know, I again personally this time was a time where I I didn't really deal with my feelings, I really didn't think about it. This is almost to I would say to basically to my junior year, where I wasn't r super dealing with my emotions, but I also had a lot of freedom all of a sudden. So I would go out with my friends to like heavy metal shows and you know, just talk with them and and wander around town after school and I was kinda interested in school, especially interested in social sciences and I think at one point I got to take an economics class, which kind of aligned with my political interests. And my political beliefs kind of rapidly went through these periods of transformation. Because I think I started off from like a pretty almost rigidly conservative viewpoint. And then at other points I was more convinced by like liberal perspectives. I like I would talk to my teachers and And other kids. And I I grew up in Massachusetts, which which was a very liberal kind of place, a very blue state. So most people there are were liberal. And of course many of my teachers were liberal liberal. And many of the students that I was going to school with had parents who were Democrats and liberal and whatnot. So I got a lot of that perspective, but I kind of liked being this outsider, right? I kind of liked being the the black sheep, in one sense. I got a lot of pride out of, you know, holding to the opposite view, but at the the sort of conservative view. But at the same time, there were a lot of points that they were making, that really made sense to me. And so I sort of started to gravitate towards this position that I didn't really understand at the time, but basically I liked the idea of freedom and and l and liberty in all areas of life, right? So I was really attracted to kind to conservative economic arguments about, you know, freedom from taxation and regulation, the right to sort of spend and utilize money in the way that you wanted to, the right to to s to run your business in the way that you saw fit, the idea that, you know, consumers were responsible for, you know, figuring out, I guess, what was a good business and a bad business. But when it came to a lot of the social issues, I was really against that. I mean, at this point I considered myself an atheist. In fact, I went through I've talked about this in other other videos, but I I went through this kind of what I call metaphysical Satanism, where I pretty much you know, saw myself as an individual consciousness and rebellion to this larger consciousness and I saw that prefigured in characters like like Satan and Prometheus and I looked to those people as as kind of heroes, like people who stood up against authority and tyranny, for the sake of what they really value and and they sought freedom and liberty. And again, this was kind of a reaction of against the authoritarianism and the violent abuse of my own my own father. And so the idea of liberty in the political sphere against the government was very attractive for that reason. so oftentimes I associated social regulation not only with authoritarian control, but also with religion. The idea that religious people, Christians were kind of out to get people and to, you know, conform them to their their moral beliefs. They wouldn't just let people live the kinds of life that they wanted to live. so when it came to arguments for kind of civil civil freedom, civil, yeah, civil and political freedom, I felt very sympathetic with the liberals. And when it came to arguments for economic freedom, I very I felt very sympathetic for conservatives. And around that time, I mean both the Republican and Democratic parties, conservative and liberals have evolved. but at that time, this is what the way that those parties marketed themselves. Conservatives tended to market themselves as pro-economic freedom, but you might say morally concern, right? They wanted to legislate morality. And the liberals saw themselves sort of marketed themselves as you know, live and let live people when it came to social issues like gay rights and drug use and that kind of stuff. But Wanting to make the economic situation more egalitarian by using the force and the violence of the state to redistribute wealth from those who had a lot to those who had a little. And I was sympathetic to the economic arguments on the conservative side and sympathetic to the political and civic freedoms expressed on the democratic side. And I was pretty you might say politically ignorant. Like I was ignorant of the different kinds of parties. I was ignorant of political history. I mean, it was at this time that I actually got interested in it and began even learning about it. And I remember there was one part, I always laugh at myself for this because it's just to me it's it like it it shows my enthusiasm on the one hand, but my naivete on the other hand on the other hand. And it was this I I remember I came to this conclusion one day where I was like, wouldn't it be great if we had a party that emphasized both economic freedom and civil and political freedom together? Because both of those elements seem really great for me, and I can't really decide between this party or that party. I wish there was a party that combine these two together. And the kind of thought that I had at time was, well. I should make that party, right? I should try to make that party and grow that party and then try to become president. Maybe I could like, you know, help the world, like change America, right? And it was this very much common thing that happens in teenagerhood and this sort of messianic, wanting this messianic destiny, right? Wanting to be wanting to save the world. And trying to do that through what I understood at the time. And so I had this vision of like creating. This I think I was gonna call them the New Conservative Party or something like that, that focused very much on freedom and was against the kind of contradictions against that freedom that I saw in the Republican Party. Again, this was a very simplistic and naive view of a teenager, an early teenager for its two political parties and and two political ideologies. but that was a thought I had at the time, so I started looking up. You know, how do you go about creating your own party? And I learned all about the third parties, all the parties that you don't really get a chance to vote for because they're not really allowed to to run in they're really barred from wide political access for a number of bureaucratic reasons. But I learned about the third parties and the two party system. And you know, looking through the list, going through the list of the third parties, all these different kinds of parties that had been created, I of course came acros came across libertarianism as like the libertarian party in the United States, which quite literally I remember I I went to their their website and they had this graphic that was split in two. And on the the right on the on the right side of it, they had the conservative. economic freedom, like we're for economic freedoms, which the conservatives have. And on on the left, they had the the social freedoms of the Democratic Party. And they said, we're for the social freedoms, but we're not for for government interference on the other side, right? We're for freedom in all things, liberty in all things, right? Libertarian. And I was like, yes, that was the that's the that's the party I've been looking for. That's the ideology that I've been looking for, and so I stumbled upon libertarianism for the first time. And and I began to explore libertarianism. I remember I read I think I read read John Stuart Mills on Liberty at this time. I started to get into like the I wasn't reading books as much at that time, or at least not books about like political ideology or about f I I didn't know really what even philosophy was at this point. I wasn't reading books about political philosophy at this time, but I was doing a lot of like again internet research, right? looking into like libertarianism and the different kinds of fields. And I got really excited about libertarianism, the idea that there was a party out there that was interested in in freedom in all aspects of life. And that's kind of I wanted to, you know, become a part of that party and join it. And I just started digging into it. I started watching YouTube videos around it and just soaking in these ideas. And again, I was super I was hyper focused on this, like all the personal emotion stuff kind of just shoved shoved away, hyper focused on learning about libertarianism. And I would try to talk with people about it, and they weren't all very interested. teachers about it, they weren't all that interested. And I I again there's a sense of I remember a sense of it was like isolation. Like I was discovering all these really exciting things that I was becoming more and more interested, political ideas. that I was getting excited about, but really feeling like I hadn't do it on my own or by myself because my teachers didn't seem interested, my friends didn't seem interested, and my my my mother and my my stepdad in particular didn't seem all that interested. So you're trying to trying to I guess process and deal with all this stuff on your own. And I would get into more and more debates and more and more arguments, you know, again not hadn't really learned too much about tactfulness or or any of that, but we'll get into that a little bit later. And then I remember I was watching some videos on on YouTube and I came across this video that said ten reasons why libertarians are wrong. And it was made by a guy named Stefan Molyneux, who is a Canadian philosopher and podcaster. Those of you who know about him know his his record and kind of the things that he's gotten into lately, at least since since like 2014 or so. So I'll talk more about him later and I'll address some of the more controversial things later. But At this time, you know, this video was I really I thought it was maybe somebody, somebody who was critiquing libertarianism from like a liberal perspective or a conservative perspective. I thought was like mainstream criticism of the libertarian position. And I so I was, you know, I interested in watching it because I wanted to see like what it what I had heard other critiques, but I was looking for more criticisms of it. And I was interested in what this guy said. But it turned out that this guy, Stephon Molyneux, was not a liberal, not a conservative. He was an anarchist. Specifically, he was an anarcho-capitalist, which you know you can pretty much just go and look it look it up, but basically the idea of a society that is completely dominated by an actual free market. Anarcho-capitalism, but essentially he he he marketed himself as an anarchist. And the critique of the libertarianism that he gave in that video was quite compelling to me. Because in that video, he argued that the libertarian position actually contradicts itself. Because while it is for freedom in all things, it retains the violence of the state when it comes to the sort of the minarchist state, the The police, the firefighters, and judge. And the libertarian critique of conservatives and liberals is that they impose their moral views or what they think is necessary and good through violence on other people unilaterally without their consent. But the political libertarian position when it comes to the minarchist state is the same thing. They believe that the minimal state is both necessary and good. And they were willing to use force and violence to impose the minimal state as a sort of necessary evil. And Molyneux's argument was that this contradicts the the moral principle of non-contradiction, which is a a fundamental the non-aggression principle, which is a a fundamental principle of the sort of libertarian philosophy in general. And I found his arguments at the time to be really compelling. And it was shortly And because of that video, I started to get much more interested in anarchism and in libertarian anarchism, the the anarcho-capitalism that Molyneux was was talking about. And I began to get really interested in Molyneux in general. and this this I would I would I was a convinced Yeah, I was a convinced anarcho-capitalist by the time I was in my junior year. And I remember, and I know why, because I remember I took an economics or political, I think I was a no, I took a political politics class in high school. And one of the projects was that we were to come up with our own party and kind of run for this mock election with the teachers. And Me and my friends, mostly because I was I was excited about it and did most of the work, did this we did like the anarcho-capitalist party. And I even I remember I bought the flag for it and like I went all out because it was just really kind of exciting for me. but so I went from sort of like, you know, trying to parse conservative and liberal views to Edging towards libertarianism, learning about libertarianism, and then eventually becoming an anarcho-capitalist. And today I still consider myself to be an anarchist or a volunteerist. I wouldn't say I'm an anarcho-capitalist, and I don't ascribe to Molyneux's particular philosophy, but I mention him because he was actually my my introduction to philosophy as a whole. Molyneux, for better or for worse, because again, I I, you know, for those of you who know, he is a very controversial figure and has definitely stepped out on extreme limb when it comes to a number of issues. And he's not somebody I really follow anymore, and I've pretty much left behind philosophically for a number of reasons. There are many things that I disagree with him strongly about, but at that point, he was. my introduction to philosophy on the one hand, again for better or for worse. And it started off with this interest in anarchism and anarcho-capitalism. I pretty much, you know, rated his his podcast catalog for topics related to that. And eventually I also got interested in more direct atheism. But really I got I got interested in in Molny's kind of whole philosophy what he was talking about. I I started to listen I essentially started to listen to his his podcast and kind of absorb the things that he was talking about. And like I said before, he was my introduction to philosophy as a whole. I mean he would use terms like metaphysical, epistemological, ethics, political philosophy, epistemol you know, all these different kinds of he would Name drop different thinkers and philosophers. he had, I think he had a master's in the history of philosophy or something like that. And of course, he he l marketed himself as a philosopher and dealt with philosophical issues in a broad range of categories. And it was because of listening to his podcast that I kind of got introduced to even the concept of philosophy at all. And began to through my exposed to kind of the broad the broad field of philosophy itself. It was at that point where I started to read histories of philosophy and introductory books about philosophy. I started to learn about, you know, Plato and Socrates and Aristotle and kind of just the the philosophical tradition as a whole. Eventually I would get through him I will I would get introduced to Ayn Rand, who exposed me to a really kind of a systemic way of thinking about philosophy, because Molyneux wasn't really systemic. We'll get to Ayn Rand in the probably maybe the next episode, because we're starting to get to the end of the 30 minutes here, which is all I want to do today. But the thing I wanted to emphasize with Molyneux is that Again, for better or for worse, he was my introduction to philosophy and to philosophical thinking. The very idea that politics was not like this isolated intellectual branch, but actually the way that you decide political questions is by investigating ethical questions. And the ethical questions themselves depended on other questions dealing with how do we view reality and how do we view knowledge, how do we view human beings. So we started to to broaden my view of this interest. And I started to get really interested in philosophy in general, but also interested in what Molyneux was talking about in particular. And so one big thing he did for me at that early stage was again introduce me to philosophy and a variety of other thinkers, and introduced me to economic, like more technical economic thinking. Introduced me to sort of the Austrian school and the Keynesian school of economics and kind of how they conflicted, and later on I would go to, you know, read these authors myself. So it kind of opened me up to, you might say, the broader intellectual environment, but specifically the broader philosophical environment. But more importantly and more crucial, this point is because as I was talking about in the beginning, I'd kind of stuffed all of my emotions and trauma down, right? I I had almost tried to just move on from my childhood, from my past, to not think about it. And it was coming out in all of these kind of toxic ways. Like I was pretty angry. I funneled a lot of my anger into my politics and in arguments with people. I was at times feeling very depressed, very anxious, and very isolated. it was kind of just wreaking havoc on my life in a lot of ways, to the point where, you know, my political interest and my growing philosophical interest was like the only place where things I felt like I had any kind of control. It was very similar to when I was a child and my realm of thought was my only place where I had control. But what Molyneux did was kind of Mawuni would talk a lot about peaceful parenting. He would talk a lot about how your childhood influences your thoughts and your emotions. He would talk about how the past influences the present. And he would very much encourage you, can encourage you individually to confront. your childhood past and experiences to think through it, to feel through it, to be forthright about what happened to you, to sort of be your own moral advocate when it comes to when it comes to that, to trust in your mind and your memories, not sort of allowing other people's narratives to gaslight you into a false picture of what your childhood was like, but rather Take your own memories and your own feelings and your own thoughts seriously. So on the one hand, individually confront your past yourself, but also to confront the people around you, and particularly your parents, with the truth of that past, right? So not just kind of inauthentically holding all that in, but actively expressing that particularly to your parents. And that was another massive revelation, which again kind of increased my my trust in Molyneux at the time. you know, Molyneux in in a in in a way became this kind of masculine, I want to say this masculine guide to the intellectual and emotional realm, right? And I just didn't have the other people around me to, you know. throw up the I didn't have anybody around me I could trust to sort of throw up the red flags that Molyneux was showing, which I would learn about later. But again that's a that's a we'll get into that a little bit later as the story progresses. But for me what he did do positively at this time was basically I from what I listened to him, I felt encouraged to confront my past openly, to confront my emotions openly. And to confront my parents openly about what I felt and experienced. It was like this renewed impetus to be authentic with myself about the past, which at the time I wasn't doing, I was ignoring it. And basically because I didn't know how to deal with it. And Molinu gave these kinds of insights that helped me to understand what had happened in my childhood and gave me even a way to articulate what I felt about it, the things I couldn't articulate before, I was able to articulate it through the language that Molyneux gave me. And not only that, but he pointed me to the realm of psychology, particularly Alice Miller. And Alice Miller was huge in my emotional development and and and you know basically saying like you have a right to authentically experience like the anger and the outrage and the depression and the grief. You have the authentic right to experience and think these things, right? But don't direct them at the don't project them, right? Don't project them onto the the false the false sources, like political sources, right? But go to the real source, right? Tie these emotions and these thoughts to their real source, not to where you're projecting them to. It was through Molonu that I I even began to understand that my political all my political energy and interest really had much more to do with my childhood and my past and the unprocessed trauma than it had to do with than it had to do with anything related to, you know, politics, because I didn't really have any control. Over politics. And so again, Molly for better or for worse was my introduction to like the realm of psychology and my own inner experiences and the realm of philosophy and the realm of economics, all three of which would go on to All three of which which I would go on to explore in greater and greater depth, ultimately ultimately leaving Molyneux behind. and he also gave me my first impetus towards like a strong atheism. that because he was a very he was a very strong and convinced atheist. And again, I listened, I was just kind of going through his catalog and and listening to all these different ideas. So my thoughts for quite a while were very reflective of what. Molonu himself was talking about, particularly, I want to say in his earlier his earlier work. There was a turn he took around 2013, like in his current stuff, but I wasn't necessarily listening to his current stuff. I was listening to like I I kind of just went back to his first podcast, which did way back, I want to say in 2007 or something like that, and was just listening all the way through up. And I think. I only even got as far as like ep episode a thousand or something like that. But that's that was my exposure, kind of to Molyneux. And I read some of his books and things like that. I still have a lot of his books because it's at the very least of an interesting perspective. But but he was my introduction to a lot of these things. And my my thoughts at that time very much reflected what he talked about, because he was very persuasive. He was my my first, you know. almost say I want to say worldview perspective on the idea. And I had a lot of respect and trust in him because of the different kinds of revelations that I that I got from him. And again, this was the point, again, around the end of junior high, coming into senior year, and particularly over the s the the summer in between, where for the first time I became aware of the emotional connection to my childhood and the need to think about that and the need to process it and the right I had to authentically experience the things that have happened to me and to find the the real culprits in that not to project it onto these onto these things. And what's interesting about that time is that I mean on the one hand I I had to move again. So I went I I spent my so I spent my freshman year and one high school, my sophomore junior year at another high school and then my senior year at another high school. So that summer I moved and went to a new high school, a smaller high school, and over that summer, where I really first started to confront my childhood, I lost like all my way. I think I lost I went from 250 to 180 over the course of probably six months. And sorry, over the course, yeah, over the course of not six months, over the course of a year essentially. And part of that had to do with the fact that I wasn't I mean really I wasn't holding in all of this emotional weight and trauma. I was starting to at least examine it for the first time. That would take a long time before I was able to process it and really overcome it. And the thing about extreme trauma like that is that you never wholly over overcome it. You learn how to deal with and mitigate the effects of it that you carry through your life. But It would be a long time before I could say I reached equilibrium with with a lot of that. and ma and I have to credit Molyneux and the kinds of people that he pointed me to or especially Alice Mill Alice Miller for for helping me with that. so I'll leave it there. I'll leave it at the summer of of junior high where I started to confront that things and we will pick it up from there next time. But as always, thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.