Latest / Comeback Files: Survival, hope & second chances / When Words Cut Deep: How to Stop Believing Every Criticism | Comeback Files
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that follows someone saying something unkind to you, and it feels less like quiet and more like the ground has suddenly vanished beneath your feet. I want you to know right now that you are not broken because you felt that drop. Let’s start with the body. Because before your brain can even process what was said, your nervous system has already made a decision. Your heart hammers against your ribs. Your throat tightens. Maybe your face goes hot, or maybe you go completely cold, numb, like ice water in your veins. This is not a failure of character. This is biology. It is an ancient alarm bell ringing in the center of your chest, telling you that you are under attack. For thousands of years, being criticized by the tribe meant potential exile, which meant death. So when someone snaps at you, when they roll their eyes, when they offer a backhanded compliment disguised as advice, your body prepares for war or flight. But here we are, sitting on our couches or hiding in our cars after dropping kids off at school, and there is no tiger. There is just a comment from a boss, or a remark from a partner, or a judgmental glance from a stranger on the subway. The danger isn’t real, but the feeling is. And if you’ve spent any part of your life trying to be the good girl, the reliable employee, the perfect friend, that alarm bell rings louder than anyone else’s. You internalize it immediately. You swallow the words whole. You let them settle into your bones and become part of your skeleton. I see you doing that. I do it too. But we need to learn how to spit those words out before they digest. Here’s where the turning point lives. It starts with understanding the difference between a mirror and a window. When someone criticizes us, especially in the moment, we tend to look into the mirror. We assume that their words are reflecting our true selves. We think, 'If they see this flaw, it must be real. If they are angry, I must have done something wrong.' We accept their perspective as objective truth. But criticism is rarely a mirror. It is almost always a window. Through that window, we are seeing their stress, their insecurity, their bad day, their own unresolved pain, or simply their limited understanding of the situation. Think about the last time you were really tired. Irritable. Maybe you snapped at your partner over something small, like leaving a dish in the sink. Did you actually hate the way they loaded the dishwasher? No. You were exhausted. Your tolerance was thin. Their action was just the spark, not the fuel. Now flip it. Someone snaps at you. They aren’t judging your worth. They are struggling with their own capacity to handle frustration. When you can separate their delivery from your value, the hook loses its barb. You stop taking the bait. You realize that their opinion is data, but it is not destiny. It is one person’s reaction in one moment, filtered through their own messy humanity. It is not a verdict on your soul. So, how do we create space between the hit and the response? We practice the pause. Not the polite, nodding smile while your insides are screaming. I mean a genuine, internal pause. A breath that lasts longer than usual. A moment where you say to yourself, 'Wait. Let me see if this is true, or if this is just noise.' It sounds simple, doesn’t it? Like something you’d read on a yoga mat. But try it the next time someone cuts you down. When they say, 'You’re so disorganized,' instead of immediately defending yourself or crumbling inward, take a breath. Feel your feet on the floor. Remind yourself that you are safe. That you are whole. This pause is your sanctuary. In that second, you get to choose who you are. Are you the person who believes everything they hear? Or are you the woman who knows her own worth, who trusts her own integrity, who knows that one person’s opinion does not define her reality. It takes practice. You will forget. You will react. You will spiral. That’s okay. It’s not about fixing it overnight. It’s about noticing the spiral sooner next time. It’s about catching yourself mid-fall and remembering that you have hands strong enough to hold onto the edge. That pause is where your power lives. It is where you reclaim the narrative from them and bring it back to you. Once you’ve paused, once you’ve stepped back from the emotional tide, you can begin to sort. Not all criticism is equal. Some of it is valuable feedback, wrapped in poor packaging. Maybe your colleague pointed out that your presentation slides were cluttered. That might be useful. You can take that grain of truth, discard the harsh tone, and use it to improve your work. That is growth. That is learning. But other criticism is pure chaff. It is gossip. It is projection. It is someone trying to make themselves feel bigger by making you feel smaller. Ask yourself: Is this coming from someone who wants the best for me? Do they have my back? Do they understand my context? If the answer is no, then the criticism is irrelevant. It’s like asking a fish to judge a bird’s flying skills. It’s the wrong metric entirely. When you learn to filter, you stop carrying the weight of every opinion thrown your way. You become selective. You keep the useful stuff. You toss the rest. This doesn’t make you arrogant. It makes you discerning. It protects your energy. And let’s be honest, your energy is precious. You don’t have room in your head for everyone’s bad day, everyone’s bias, everyone’s misunderstanding. You only have room for what serves your peace. I want to talk about the story you tell yourself after the conversation ends. Because often, the most damaging criticism isn’t the one spoken aloud. It’s the echo. It’s the voice in your head at 2 AM replaying the interaction, adding insult to injury, magnifying your mistakes, minimizing your efforts. 'They’re right. You are clumsy. You are difficult. You never get it right.' This inner critic is loud. It is persistent. It wears the mask of self-improvement, but it is actually sabotage. We need to challenge that narrative. When you hear that voice, ask it: Who is this really? Is this your voice? Or is it your mother? Your old teacher? That ex-partner who tried to shrink you? Often, the inner critic is just an old recording, a habit formed in childhood or past trauma. Recognizing it as external helps you detach from it. You can say, 'Thank you for your concern, but I disagree.' You can gently correct the record. 'I made a mistake. That does not mean I am a mistake.' 'They were upset. That does not mean I am unworthy.' Rewriting the story is an act of rebellion. It is choosing love over fear. It is choosing truth over shame. And it takes time. Be patient with yourself as you rewrite these pages. Ultimately, resilience to criticism comes from a deep, unshakable knowledge of who you are. This is your internal anchor. When the winds of other people’s opinions blow hard, you need something solid to hold onto. This isn’t built in a day. It’s built in the small moments. It’s built when you honor your boundaries. When you say no without guilt. When you celebrate your small wins. When you treat yourself with the same kindness you’d offer a friend. Every time you validate yourself, you strengthen that anchor. You prove to your nervous system that you are safe, that you are enough, regardless of external validation. You stop looking for permission to exist. You stop waiting for applause to feel real. You become your own witness. And when you are fully witnessed by yourself, the judgments of others lose their sting. They bounce off. They become background noise. You can listen, you can learn, but you cannot be moved. This is the freedom we are working toward. It’s not about becoming immune to pain. It’s about becoming anchored in truth. It’s about knowing that you are complex, flawed, beautiful, and worthy, all at once. And no single comment can change that. Thank you for letting me into your day. Thank you for listening, for feeling, for showing up. I’ll be here tomorrow with another piece of the puzzle. Until then, breathe. You’re doing better than you think. I’m Sherri Ruane, and this has been Comeback Files. Take care of yourself, sweet friend.