Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / How Angel City FC Reimagined Their Identity in Mere Days
Transcript
- 0:0014 months ago, Angel City introduced Alexander
- 0:03Strauss as the coach that would lead one of the
- 0:06most ambitious projects in NWSL history. One
- 0:09year later, they fired him. On that very same
- 0:13day, the first rumors spread about the eventual
- 0:17signing of Ali Senor on a club record transfer
- 0:20fee of $850 ,000 for a player who, mind you,
- 0:23had six months left on her contract. I'm trading
- 0:27away one of the brightest teenage midfielders
- 0:29in American soccer, Kenny Fuller. Those aren't
- 0:32three completely unrelated headlines. They're
- 0:35one cohesive story that I want to answer. What
- 0:39does this past week tell us about where Angel
- 0:43City, from an administrative standpoint, believes
- 0:46the club is heading? And how, as a journalist,
- 0:50do I view these moves? And that's the biggest
- 0:53part to think about because... Over the past
- 0:56few weeks, Angel City's been in the narrative
- 1:00for on -the -pitch reasons, which is not necessarily
- 1:03the main way we're used to hearing about them.
- 1:06It's always because of something off the field
- 1:09or because of perhaps a winning streak. But this
- 1:15time it was because they made three organizational
- 1:17decisions that on the surface seem completely
- 1:20unrelated. They spent... approximately $850 ,000,
- 1:24as I mentioned, one of the largest guaranteed
- 1:27transfer fees in NWSL history for Ali Settnor.
- 1:29And I think you can argue that fee was justified
- 1:33because elite young American attackers are incredibly
- 1:37difficult to acquire. You can argue that trading
- 1:40Kennedy Fuller was necessary if it meant bringing
- 1:42a player. like Setnor, who Angel City clearly
- 1:45believes can impact gains immediately. And you
- 1:48could argue that Strauss simply wasn't getting
- 1:50enough out of this talented young luster, which
- 1:53was the notion that, albeit in very unconventional
- 1:56ways, is being conveyed by Parsons and co. throughout
- 2:00this entire week. And I think those are all reasonable
- 2:03conversations to have, but they're not the right
- 2:06ones for us to be having in this moment because
- 2:11If you only analyze these moves one by one, I
- 2:14think there's this much bigger overarching story
- 2:17to be told that reveals how Angel City sees itself
- 2:20and where it wants to be. It reveals something
- 2:23about how the club could use its competitive
- 2:25window, which we thought was going to be a long
- 2:28-term project. Yet this young group continuously
- 2:31is being broken up, whether it be Thompson to
- 2:35Chelsea to Kennedy Fuller. That's, I think, what
- 2:40I really want to get into today, not necessarily
- 2:41whether Angel City won these trades, not whether
- 2:45the coaching hand itself was right or wrong.
- 2:48We don't really know whether or not these firings
- 2:50are going to be right until a while, but we can
- 2:52decipher what these decisions are telling us
- 2:56about one of the league's biggest clubs and whether
- 2:58this marks a fundamental shift in the way that
- 3:00they're trying to build a championship winning
- 3:02team. Welcome back to Open Soccer Podcast. I'm
- 3:06Liam Greco. One of the things that I love covering
- 3:08most about this league is sometimes the biggest
- 3:10stories aren't actually the headline transfers
- 3:13themselves. We have so many of them. This is
- 3:16the League of Chaos NWSL After Dark for a reason,
- 3:18but I think it's oftentimes... the connections
- 3:21between them. If you've opened social media over
- 3:23the past few days, you've probably seen all of
- 3:26these stories in their own separate posts. The
- 3:28Angel City in turmoil headlines, whether Senators
- 3:31were worth the money, did BFC just steal one
- 3:34of the country's best young midfielders, and
- 3:36did Strauss deserve more time than the 14 months
- 3:38he was allotted since his hiring, which in a
- 3:41lot of ways wasn't even a full year due to his
- 3:43delayed arrival. What if this is all evidence
- 3:46that Angel City as a whole is kind of hitting
- 3:51the panic button on their prior identity and
- 3:55trying to completely revitalize the team and
- 3:57change what they're being built. Organizations
- 4:00don't make decisions like these in isolation,
- 4:02especially those that strive to operate at Angel
- 4:05City's level. They're not just going to accidentally
- 4:06spend nearly a million dollars on a player, despite
- 4:10the fact that her form recently hasn't merited
- 4:13it, nor did her contract length merit it. And
- 4:16you don't actually just trade away. whatever
- 4:19young midfielders in the country who'd benched
- 4:21for game weeks on end for no clear reason when
- 4:25your midfield was very much not creative or thriving.
- 4:28And you don't dismiss a coach who they hired
- 4:30specifically after this long -winded process
- 4:33that they lauded about so heavily in every single
- 4:36press conference. And they said he was the one
- 4:39who could build a long -term sustainable project
- 4:42based on his reputation with Bayern Munich. These
- 4:44are all strategic decisions that are... backpedaling
- 4:48on the identity that Angel City was finally starting
- 4:51to forge as a concrete one. And when multiple
- 4:54strategic decisions all happen within really
- 4:57a day, it's asking whether or not this team is
- 5:01ready to be the team that they act like they
- 5:04are off the field, on the field, and whether
- 5:07or not more particularly these decisions are
- 5:09connected by a larger philosophy. And throughout
- 5:12this episode, I hope to articulate a case that
- 5:15proves why they are. This isn't just any club
- 5:18though. I think before diving into like the specifics
- 5:21of the matter, it's important that we zoom out
- 5:23for people who might not understand how big of
- 5:26a deal this is because Angel City is one of the
- 5:28most fascinating organizations in league history
- 5:31and the fashion that they entered the league
- 5:33where we were used to seeing 3 ,000 people crowds
- 5:36playing in high school worthy facilities to Serena
- 5:40Williams, Jennifer Garner, and Natalie Portman
- 5:42co -founding a club. They've become one of the
- 5:45league's defining brands, consistently ranking
- 5:47among league leaders in attendance, despite some
- 5:49recent declines due to poor performance on the
- 5:52pitch that led to these moves being made. And
- 5:54they play in one of the largest sporting markets
- 5:56in the world. Their ownership group includes
- 5:59globally renowned figures from sports, entertainment,
- 6:02and business. And whether or not you support
- 6:04Angel City or not, I've been quite critical of
- 6:06them. From a footballing perspective on this
- 6:08show, it's undeniable that they've become one
- 6:11of the faces of this league. And that visibility
- 6:13comes with opportunity, but also pressure because
- 6:16the expectations that are being forced upon them
- 6:19are very different. No one expects a first year
- 6:22expansion club to immediately compete for championships.
- 6:25People understand that they need time, but they're
- 6:28entering their fifth season. They're in the midst
- 6:30of it right now. It honestly feels like the season
- 6:33is becoming a bit of a wash when you fire your
- 6:36head coach and trade away one of your best young
- 6:38midfielders. This two cycle of expansion teams
- 6:41come into the league and assuming that they take
- 6:43the next 18 months to forge this new identity
- 6:47again, it'll be another third cycle coming into
- 6:50the league. They've invested heavily in infrastructure.
- 6:52Their training facilities are better. They've
- 6:54spent a lot of money on their roster and coaching.
- 6:57I think it's clear to me that the expectation
- 6:59for this Angel City team isn't just to make playoffs.
- 7:02They want to be winning trophies. And that's
- 7:06why I think this firing really does mean a lot.
- 7:09Has one of the strongest coaching resumes in
- 7:12women's football for a reason. He's known for
- 7:15structured positional play that has a very disciplined
- 7:19tactical orientation while ultimately cultivating
- 7:22player development. And on paper, it looks like...
- 7:24This was the appointment that Angel City needed.
- 7:26This is the person that could change the trides
- 7:29of the team. They looked like they were turning.
- 7:31The roster looked stronger. There was more continuity.
- 7:33There was talent. And the season actually began
- 7:36as well as supporters could have hoped. They
- 7:38opened with three consecutive victories, top
- 7:41of the table of nine points. And at that point,
- 7:43it felt like the project was coming together.
- 7:46Over the next eight league matches, Angel City
- 7:48won just once. Instead of building momentum off
- 7:52of the back of their... Good start to the year,
- 7:54performances became inconsistent, and perhaps
- 7:56we saw the team slip back into habits that have
- 8:00left them falling much closer to the bottom and
- 8:03middle of the table rather than climbing back
- 8:06up to the top. For 11 matches right now at this
- 8:09mid -season break, Angel City sat at four wins,
- 8:12six losses, and a draw, scoring 16 goals while
- 8:15conceding 14. Totals that aren't disastrous,
- 8:18but they're also not really representative of...
- 8:22what the club wants to be if they're truly a
- 8:24team that wants to challenge for championships
- 8:25and has the ambition that Angel City has exemplified
- 8:29and talked about having. And so that's the context
- 8:32around these moves that gets lost when we discuss
- 8:35just the traits themselves. None of those decisions
- 8:38were happening in a vacuum, although I do think
- 8:41ownership definitely has economic incentives
- 8:45for this team to... continue succeeding on the
- 8:48pitch. It happened because Angel City clearly
- 8:51had reached a conclusion that this wasn't working.
- 8:55And I think it's valid to ask, did they just
- 8:59simply decide they needed another elite young
- 9:01attacking player who was more ready for the team
- 9:04now? That doesn't really make sense because Setnor
- 9:07had fewer goal contributions than Fuller and
- 9:09fewer minutes. Did they decide the coaching staff
- 9:12wasn't maximizing the talent available? Well,
- 9:15That doesn't really make sense either, because
- 9:17on paper, this roster that they laud to be playoff
- 9:20ready really doesn't have the depth to compete
- 9:22in this league. They decide that patience became
- 9:25a luxury they couldn't afford. Well, given the
- 9:27man six months since he actually had stepped
- 9:30foot in L .A. and the general manager had not
- 9:33had any splashy signings besides Emily Sams,
- 9:37who's a good defender, but doesn't assault the
- 9:40gaping attacking holes they speak about in these
- 9:43preseason. documentaries that they have the money
- 9:46to sign a superstar. The question for me is,
- 9:49why don't they do it? Because if they have all
- 9:51these resources, they keep on trying to build
- 9:53up anticipation and then just pull the rug out
- 9:55from under the excitement and remind fans why
- 10:00the team was where it was. It's not impossible
- 10:04in women's soccer in a global landscape to succeed
- 10:07from day one, but you have to have the right
- 10:10pieces in place. And the fact that their SoCal
- 10:11neighbors, San Diego, have been far more successful
- 10:15than them on the pitch through all of their turmoils
- 10:17legally and professionally off the field have
- 10:19somehow still maintained a track record that
- 10:23has attracted the top players in the world. That's
- 10:25a whole question for another episode. Well, Angel
- 10:27City can't even seem to bother acquiring any
- 10:30of those players if you're an Angel City fan.
- 10:32What is there to be excited about now? Granted,
- 10:35I think there is a lot to be excited about. Adding
- 10:37Set Norwich, a team that's already very talented
- 10:40with lots of young players. But the problem is
- 10:43that if this core five years down the line leave,
- 10:47I think Angel City's started to redefine their
- 10:50identity out of fear of that issue continuing
- 10:52to unfold, which is why the story serves a much
- 10:55closer look. Let's start with the headline that...
- 10:58really tells us how Angel City values the future
- 11:00the most. Ali sent or transfer. She's someone
- 11:03to me who I think very much could have moved
- 11:05to Europe, had options there. We know that. And
- 11:08she's chosen twice to stay at the end of his
- 11:11L. If this is also any other team in the league,
- 11:15I don't think we'd even be having this episode
- 11:17solely about one club. I just think it's a headline
- 11:21if a side that has... been the face of this league,
- 11:25arguably, been what this league has wanted to
- 11:29build around from a commercial standpoint. We
- 11:31keep hearing about all of these goals, all of
- 11:33these metrics off the pitch, but then we just
- 11:37don't see that same success coming to fruition
- 11:40on the field. And I think that's what's really
- 11:42frustrating for a lot of Angel City supporters.
- 11:44At the end of the day, most teams that are at
- 11:47the bottom of the table make coaching changes.
- 11:49That's a headline, yes, but it's one that we
- 11:52know to come to fruition. when a side doesn't
- 11:54get results. If an expansion team decides to
- 11:57cash in on a young player to strengthen in that
- 11:59position with more proven talent, it's another,
- 12:02you know, understandable decision. But Angel
- 12:05City isn't a team that we judge like most clubs,
- 12:08nor should they be. I think they've set themselves
- 12:10a bar that they want to strive for very publicly.
- 12:15And when you keep jumping and falling and failing
- 12:19to reach it, I just think it's hard as a journalist
- 12:22to ignore that. And also to the side of the matter
- 12:26that this is a team that has tried a lot of different
- 12:29superstars on the field as their face on the
- 12:33pitch and it just not working out. And so I think
- 12:37as a flagship organization, one of the highest
- 12:40attended clubs in women's soccer, a recognizable
- 12:42brand of the sport playing in LA, the largest
- 12:45sports and entertainment market, arguably in
- 12:48the world. This is not a team that doesn't have
- 12:50the pockets to invest. Their ownership has shown
- 12:52that willingness both on and off the field. And
- 12:54the future of the NBCL is always at the center
- 12:57of the Angel City conversation, which is a privilege.
- 13:00And as I mentioned earlier, it's also a burden
- 13:02that the teams have to deal with because I think
- 13:04at some point, the discussion has to not just
- 13:06be, when will this investment start? When will
- 13:09the expectations that are rising every day meet
- 13:12that quality and on the pitch and winning on
- 13:16the pitch and roster depth? And at some point,
- 13:19it just becomes a race where you can't win in
- 13:23any world. And the idea of a better club just
- 13:28starts to fade away when the patterns of not
- 13:33successful roster building continues to repeat
- 13:35itself. I mean, no one expects every club to
- 13:38compete for championships every single season.
- 13:41That's not realistic. But when you have the resources
- 13:44that Angel City has had and they only played
- 13:46the playoffs once in their history, You have
- 13:48to eventually stop asking why you're not improving
- 13:50and start asking why you're not winning and why
- 13:53the results are just really not guiding where
- 13:55they want to be. And that's, I think, the very
- 13:59much headline of the story and that the opt -ins
- 14:03around the team was very much surrounding the
- 14:06head coach who had been hired in the worldwide
- 14:08search. This was an extensive process and the
- 14:12roster had this established core that... At that
- 14:15time, centered around the Thompson sisters, Kendi
- 14:19Fuller was a part of that young core too. Evelyn
- 14:23Shores eventually came in later that summer to
- 14:25shore up the defense, no pun intended, and you
- 14:28added in Emily Sams later that offseason, despite
- 14:31Thompson having departed, and tried to fill the
- 14:34Thompson -sized hole with Standa Silensdottir,
- 14:36who, albeit having a slower start adjusting to
- 14:39the league, has had a breakout 2026 season when
- 14:42she's been on the pitch. I think... their team
- 14:45that should be in the playoff picture that was
- 14:47the expectation for the season yet so far it's
- 14:50been very much defined by their inconsistency
- 14:52and lack of meeting these bars they haven't failed
- 14:55entirely but I think it's also something that
- 14:59needs to be discussed because this isn't a team
- 15:04that is the worst in the league we they're not
- 15:06they're not a bottom of the barrel you know who
- 15:08organization that just is struggling on all fronts
- 15:12and has no optimism into their team. The defense
- 15:16was organized. The attack was creating chances.
- 15:18They scored lots of goals and finally appeared
- 15:21to have stability on the touchline when that
- 15:22face was constantly rotating. And then once that
- 15:27coach left, I think it really started to all
- 15:31unravel because on paper, the numbers themselves
- 15:35weren't the best. Like conceding just 14 goals
- 15:39does suggest there were stretches where the defensive
- 15:41structure was working. But I think there is something
- 15:44to be said that championships aren't won on potential.
- 15:48They're not won on a roster being built to succeed
- 15:52in three years. They're built on winning now.
- 15:54And consistency was exactly what Angel City just
- 15:57could not find. When a club underperforms, I
- 16:01think there's a lot of expectations around Angel
- 16:04City specifically. There's a lot of different
- 16:08explanations. I'd like to say this is us trying
- 16:10to diagnose the problem. Maybe the roster wasn't
- 16:13as strong as everyone believed. I think I'm very
- 16:14much in that camp. I think there's a lot of talent
- 16:17on the top end. But if you're kind of bragging
- 16:20in a lot of ways that, oh, we have all this money
- 16:22to find a star and don't do it yet. Granted,
- 16:25this comes out on Monday, June 22nd. I might
- 16:29be a fool by the time this is out, but also I
- 16:31probably won't be based on the track record we've
- 16:33seen, right? I just also struggle to believe
- 16:36that this team is being built on a roster that
- 16:39can win championships when we see what a Gotham
- 16:43looks like. These are teams that have won titles.
- 16:46When you're trying to compete for a title, you
- 16:48can't just imitate what they've done. You got
- 16:50to do it yourself. You know, you got to have
- 16:53the star power that a Gotham earns as Gotham's
- 16:54an all -star team and whatnot. But they're a
- 16:56team that is built under the same rules as everyone
- 16:59else in this league. And you can mope around
- 17:01about it all you want. But at the end of the
- 17:03day. they won like fights twice in the last two
- 17:07years, twice in the last three years, excuse
- 17:09me. So I think that's something that very much
- 17:13seems to be the problem. And it feels to me like
- 17:15it's a combination of that roster issue, hence
- 17:18bringing in Ali Setnar before the transfer window
- 17:20internationally even opened up. And also this
- 17:23idea of the tactical system, not maximizing the
- 17:26players available, hence the idea of switching
- 17:28the coach. But at some point, just switching
- 17:30coaches continuously. really fix the overall
- 17:33problem when maybe it might just be the fact
- 17:36that the team itself isn't set up to succeed.
- 17:39Injuries did disrupt the continuity of players,
- 17:41as I mentioned, like Svenderson and Svartir,
- 17:43missing vital matches. But I think it's just
- 17:46at the end of the day that these are ultimate
- 17:49expectations that, albeit perhaps unrealistic
- 17:52based on the roster this team has had, that has
- 17:54never been a championship level roster. I think
- 17:58it's interesting to me to see how they responded
- 18:00to that turmoil. They didn't just make one adjustment.
- 18:02They made several all at once that will have
- 18:05very long lasting impacts pointed in the same
- 18:08direction. Less patience and urgency and aggression
- 18:11to really get this team competing as quickly
- 18:16as possible. How much patience did the ownership
- 18:18really have after investing heavily in a roster?
- 18:21But I'd also like to question how heavily that
- 18:24process really was. They had signed Sarge Orson
- 18:26last summer, who was supposed to be a veteran
- 18:28anchor, in the back line. But instead of it turning
- 18:31out like an AKB kind of signing where the veteran
- 18:34presence helped, it didn't really materialize.
- 18:38And I'm not only blaming her specifically, but
- 18:40I just think there's countless examples of signings
- 18:42that Angel City have made that, of course, with
- 18:44the nature of this league, we don't know the
- 18:45financials, but they haven't played like big
- 18:48money signings. I think that Jaden Shaw going
- 18:51to Gotham for $1 .25 million very much reestablished
- 18:54what business looks like. And I have to wonder.
- 18:58where Angel City would be if they were in the
- 19:00race for a player like Jaden Shaw. But then again,
- 19:02now you start asking yourself without a coach,
- 19:05how are they going to attract top talent? How
- 19:08are they going to convince top talent in a year
- 19:11or one year out from a World Cup, right? This
- 19:14is not the time to mess around. And if you're
- 19:15going to move, you better get it right, especially
- 19:18if you're not someone who's solidified on your
- 19:20World Cup roster. One correct answer. Some of
- 19:24the greatest teams in football were built through
- 19:26years of gradual development. And maybe Angel
- 19:28City just has the answer none of us have, but
- 19:31so far just has not seemed like that. I feel
- 19:33like others became champions, and this is what
- 19:36happens in most cases, because the ownership
- 19:38recognized the moment and decided to be aggressive
- 19:40and act decisively. And I think Angel City believed
- 19:43that was the decision they were making. They
- 19:45looked at the first half of the year. They reached
- 19:47a conclusion. Not that. The lack of success was
- 19:51in spite of the talented roster they had, not
- 19:53because they lacked the talent on the team. And
- 19:56so they decided that waiting for things to naturally
- 19:59improve wasn't enough. Again, a lot of this comes
- 20:02with time, whether we'll know if it was the correct
- 20:05decision to make. But I think that by spending
- 20:09an exorbitant amount on Ali Setmore, I think
- 20:13it very much showed to everyone that this is
- 20:16the team. that they want to be in the headlines,
- 20:19not just for off -the -pitch reasons, but for
- 20:21on -the -field reasons, see the summer. I want
- 20:24to talk about not just the number, but how much
- 20:27that number means, because five years ago, paying
- 20:30anywhere close to that for an NBSL player would
- 20:33sound unimaginable. Transfer fees weren't even
- 20:36discussed in this way a few years ago. And spending
- 20:40and committing almost a million dollars, which
- 20:42was near the price that... this cost to even
- 20:45acquire this franchise in the first place to
- 20:47get a single player speaks to how dramatically
- 20:50the economics of the league has changed and how
- 20:53clubs are investing more aggressively to keep
- 20:55up. Ownership groups are harnessing that ambition
- 20:57or becoming more ambitious, understanding the
- 21:00lucrativeness of this women's soccer landscape
- 21:02right now and elite young American talent in
- 21:05league with capped international spots. And quite
- 21:08frankly, despite a very lucrative college system,
- 21:11there's not an infinite number of American young
- 21:13players. This is not like the WSL, where you
- 21:16can just sign any young talent from Europe. And
- 21:18it's a valuable commodity in the women's game
- 21:20that cannot be undenied. And so I think it's
- 21:23very much something that speaks to where this
- 21:26league is heading. But the strategic tool that
- 21:28a transfer fee is being used as by a club as
- 21:32Angel City to seem that they're willing to pay
- 21:35premium prices, if they think that one player
- 21:37can move them closer to that goal of winning
- 21:39a title, I think the club thinks they're much
- 21:42closer to winning. a championship than we do.
- 21:45They believe this player invested a lot into
- 21:49their group, hence justifying the level of investment
- 21:51from the top down. She's just 22 years old, set
- 21:54in her number one overall draft pick in this
- 21:57league, has been a top player since her college
- 21:59days at US Women's National Team International.
- 22:02She's someone who is comfortable playing across
- 22:05multiple attacking positions, can start wide,
- 22:07drift centrally underneath as a nine. Don't really
- 22:10know how she's going to be used yet. Maybe I'll
- 22:12show up right as a second forward when needed
- 22:14alongside a Tiernan or a Jansdottir. A case study
- 22:18to me that very much reminds me of Jaden Shaw
- 22:21making two moves in quick succession. One very
- 22:24much not working out and the second working out
- 22:26much better in Shaw's case for Centenor. We'll
- 22:29see. But at the end of the day, versatility nor
- 22:32potential don't command an $850 ,000 transfer
- 22:35fee. So what is Angel City really trying to buy?
- 22:38I think they're trying to buy a profile player
- 22:40who can not just produce goals and exists because
- 22:44it's easy to become obsessed with the sole production,
- 22:47the sole raw numbers when evaluating transfers.
- 22:50And though those matter, I think that front offices
- 22:53aren't evaluating players in that same light
- 22:56other people do. I think clubs are paying for
- 23:01the potential that they see in someone and what
- 23:03they believe they're going to see, not just out
- 23:06of a mere five, 10 years, but I think in Centra's
- 23:09case, they believe this can be. a revolutionary
- 23:11shift within mumps. And that's a very important
- 23:14distinction to make because she entered with,
- 23:17you know, respectable production, nothing insane
- 23:19that honestly didn't even beat Fuller's totals.
- 23:23She'd shown flashes, decided to move up and progress,
- 23:27but she hasn't even put together the type of
- 23:29dominant end of herself season where everyone
- 23:31unanimously agreed that she was one of the better
- 23:34attacking players in this league. She's honestly
- 23:36not had... production since year one, where it
- 23:40was pass the ball to Centenor and do whatever
- 23:43she wants in Utah. And so that's what makes this
- 23:47investment really fascinating. I don't think
- 23:48Angel City or any economist would say this was
- 23:51a good transact when you're paying for the current
- 23:53version of Centenor. They're very much trying
- 23:56to pull for the player they believe she'll become
- 23:58in the next two, three years under the pressure
- 24:00of making an Emma Hayes World Cup roster. If
- 24:03she develops into a consistent US Women's National
- 24:06Team starter, like her ceiling suggests, becoming
- 24:09one of the league's premier attackers and helping
- 24:11Angel City compete for championships, then great.
- 24:13Don't even remember the transfer fee. I don't
- 24:15think people really care about Gotham spending
- 24:17more than a million dollars to spend on Shaw
- 24:20because she won us a title and she's going to
- 24:23be the franchise face for Gotham. And Angel City
- 24:26fans should be hoping this is the exact same.
- 24:30situation because I think that it's the perfect
- 24:32comparison because a lot of people probably thought
- 24:35it was a very high price for Shaw. At the time,
- 24:38it very much didn't match where the market was
- 24:41at, but it redefined it. And Angel City re -ink,
- 24:45you know, redefining things. In hindsight, we
- 24:48view this transaction as the price of acquiring
- 24:51a franchise player. Money inevitably raises the
- 24:53expectations that Norah's not going to have the
- 24:55supporting house that she had at Kansas City.
- 24:59Fair or unfair, this is a move that will be watched
- 25:02and thrusted upon Centenor everywhere she goes.
- 25:05Every single performance, the goals, the missed
- 25:07opportunities, anything she does will be micromanaged
- 25:11and analyzed to a level that I don't think a
- 25:13player at her age has ever experienced before.
- 25:15It's a reality of modern football. The bigger
- 25:18the investment, the bigger the scrutiny. And
- 25:19for a team with the Igers, with Willow Bay, they
- 25:22don't want to wait to win. This is a team that
- 25:25spent hundreds of millions of dollars finding
- 25:27a player for less than a million dollars. for
- 25:29them is pennies, but this is also a level for
- 25:34people of that wealth of embarrassment to be
- 25:38so successful as an entrepreneur, to have the
- 25:41awards and accolades that they all possess, and
- 25:44to not be able to build a team that can compete
- 25:47in a league that has owners that don't spend
- 25:49pennies on transfer fees. That's, to me, I think
- 25:52what's more sad about Angel City right now. and
- 25:56where they're at. But I also think having worked
- 25:59with this club, this is, by the way, I want to
- 26:01add this in here, one of the most professional
- 26:03organizations this league has. I think it's one
- 26:05that's been one of the more interesting clubs
- 26:07to work with, given their very much big media
- 26:09profile and ability in a lot of ways to transcend
- 26:13what this league was looking for. But I think
- 26:16it's also worth looking at this move specifically
- 26:18before moving on to Kennedy from a different
- 26:21angle and what kind of player on a less granular
- 26:24level was Angel City searching for? Not depth,
- 26:27not experience, clearly not someone nearing the
- 26:30end of their prime. They wanted someone entering
- 26:31it young enough to build around, but also established
- 26:35enough to compete immediately. American talent
- 26:39that doesn't come off trees, right? You can't
- 26:43just pick one. as they've learned very quickly,
- 26:46to star immediately. But they want someone like
- 26:49Thompson who can become a recognizable face of
- 26:53the club and therefore also the national team,
- 26:56a combination that is very hard to find. It's
- 26:59not something that's available often for clubs.
- 27:01And I think the price very much was spurred on
- 27:05by the competition that has been reported to
- 27:08have been held for Set North Services. They weren't
- 27:11paying. for her ability in a way, I think they
- 27:13were also paying for the scarcity of the market.
- 27:15I mentioned that given the moves that are being
- 27:18made that we'll talk about a little bit more
- 27:20in depth later on, no coach trading away one
- 27:24of your most brightest young stars because you
- 27:27benched her and the team failed to win. I think
- 27:30these are discussions that are valuable and quite
- 27:33frankly, need to be had despite whatever repercussions
- 27:37all face for them. Because at the end of the
- 27:40day, I think It's about holding a team accountable
- 27:43that we know should be doing so much better on
- 27:45the field. And they've said so themselves. They've
- 27:47made this move. They've told us where they're
- 27:49at. And I think it's now the elephant in the
- 27:52room that we can verbalize out loud that makes
- 27:54the conversation not just more nuanced, but I
- 27:58think multi -worth it, making her one of the
- 28:00largest transfer fees in league history. I think
- 28:05where's the money coming from? In this move,
- 28:09it was a player because immediately after making
- 28:12one of the biggest investments in league history,
- 28:14presumably this, we don't know the order of it.
- 28:17My guess is it probably was that Fuller wanted
- 28:19to leave and they went for Centenor. But regardless
- 28:21of the details, Angel City made a different decision
- 28:24that also revealed just as much how much they
- 28:27view their future by trading away Kenny Fuller.
- 28:30And this very much reminds me of the same conversation
- 28:34we had about. Sam Kerr and Lily Rilla speaking
- 28:37that with a salary cap leak, every single transfer
- 28:40has a clear opportunity cost. And when announcing
- 28:44the Sentinel signing, a lot of the conversation
- 28:45was about who they were gaining and what they
- 28:47were getting from her. But a lot of these storylines
- 28:51and accolades are ones that I think Fuller very
- 28:54much fits too, because these players are both
- 28:58very much young stars in the making. Setnor one,
- 29:02it's a little bit more polished. And Fuller is
- 29:05a player who I think has been in her age group,
- 29:07but also in just the general young crop of talent
- 29:11coming into this league, foregoing even high
- 29:13school and college to be here before turning
- 29:17professional, having that experience at the youth
- 29:20international level, calm under pressure, plays
- 29:22of a maturity that is far beyond her years with
- 29:25creativity between the lines, vision to play
- 29:29passes that most players simply don't even...
- 29:31seen perhaps most importantly she processes the
- 29:34game and is very much articulate off the field
- 29:36as you heard our interview of her she's the sweetest
- 29:38person but also such someone who's wise bound
- 29:41for years and in every single asset plays with
- 29:44a level of grace that is far beyond her age which
- 29:47is one of the country's top young prospects granted
- 29:50as of all players there's this very much tendency
- 29:55to highlight some of the weaknesses that every
- 29:57young player has in their game. For Fuller, I
- 29:59think the physicality is definitely one of them.
- 30:01She's had perhaps less of a seamless transition
- 30:05to stardom in this league than other peers of
- 30:08hers that have gone the college and high school
- 30:11system. But regardless of some of her areas of
- 30:15growth that I think the AFC will very much tap
- 30:17into, it goes back to what I was saying about
- 30:19Sentinel and that players don't become available
- 30:22like a Fuller very often. The AFC is willing
- 30:26to get investments. made for a player at her
- 30:28very young age and experience level, not someone
- 30:30who's internationally, but like acclaimed player
- 30:33at the senior team. But this is very much to
- 30:35me signaling Bay is in it for the long haul.
- 30:38They're very much trying to build this young
- 30:41core that I think is a similar idea and project
- 30:44to what Angel City built, bringing in a foreign
- 30:45coach who had a known track record of cultivating
- 30:48young talent, buying a future in this talent
- 30:52of Fuller. And that's where the philosophical
- 30:54question begins because Angel City was doing
- 30:57the exact same thing a few years ago and arguably
- 31:00did something very similar by acquiring Centenor
- 31:02of just a very different timeline. An already
- 31:05established professional in Centenor is someone
- 31:08who's much more capable of immediately contributing
- 31:11on paper than Fuller, who's earlier in her development
- 31:14with the extraordinary ceiling. That's a big
- 31:17difference. But I think it's also important to
- 31:19raise the question of with slightly less prestige
- 31:22and significantly fewer minutes. solar's raw
- 31:25production was just as good as not better than
- 31:28sentinels and one player might help you in more
- 31:31games now but in theory the other one would be
- 31:34better at helping you win more games three or
- 31:35four years from now but i think there's a lot
- 31:37of arguments that both players would fit both
- 31:40of those roles better each front office and these
- 31:43times of ambiguity there's no one clear right
- 31:46answer how to decide what choice they wanted
- 31:48to make what timeline mattered more to them angel
- 31:51city and bay both made their choices and I think
- 31:55that's a good way to kind of round that part
- 31:58of it out. Well, I guess also I want to say,
- 32:01like, I want to be very careful here because
- 32:04I think this is a trade that has and will be
- 32:07framed in overly simplistic ways that water down
- 32:10the substance I've tried to dive into. I don't
- 32:13think that Angel City gave up on Kennedy Fuller.
- 32:15I think that trading a young player isn't necessarily
- 32:18an indictment on their ability. I think it was
- 32:22very much... clearly not the right fit for a
- 32:24player who has goals to continue progressing
- 32:26when you're making this big investment as a player
- 32:28to not go to college and i think in our conversation
- 32:32she dove into this much more eloquently than
- 32:34i could and that wasn't necessarily something
- 32:36on her radar even though she had already committed
- 32:39to a college she was fine sacrificing that but
- 32:43i think there's a lot of ulterior motives from
- 32:45all parties player club and even within club
- 32:49it goes down to coaching gm ownership what is
- 32:53their big hand of quite frankly money have to
- 32:56do with this i think it is a roster building
- 32:59process that requires difficult choices for angel
- 33:02city and they very much have started to evaluate
- 33:05how each of those roster spots are being used
- 33:07differently based on those results development
- 33:10is still important in their mind but the immediate
- 33:13impact becomes a lot more important as a trade
- 33:17-off. Championship college teams make the decisions
- 33:19all the time. We just saw Gotham make that same
- 33:21one last week. The challenge is making the right
- 33:23ones. And with Angel City, it just hasn't seemed
- 33:27to be something that they've done a lot so far.
- 33:30I think with this new era in women's soccer of
- 33:32players going pro so much earlier, it's really
- 33:35important to honor that development isn't linear
- 33:38because for every teenage prospect who becomes
- 33:41a superstar, there are many others whose progress
- 33:44stalls. Some just need consistent minutes, others
- 33:48need a different tactical environment, and some
- 33:51need patience. And as NWSL rapidly tries to keep
- 33:55up with the developing women's soccer world,
- 33:58a lot of these questions are not going to be
- 34:01answered today, like a lot of the things I'm
- 34:04saying in this episode. But I think now that
- 34:06we've had a few years of data of this experiment
- 34:10of the U18 entry mechanisms and ways for younger
- 34:14players to get into the professional game, not
- 34:17via college soccer. I think it's very interesting
- 34:21to see what teams are willing to provide that
- 34:23runway for young players. At this time, I think
- 34:26Angel City looks less willing to wait based on
- 34:30this decision, whereas the AFC is willing to
- 34:32provide that runway. The AFC already tried the
- 34:34superstar approach of Dana Castellanos, Asisat
- 34:38Oshuela. Both of those players, of course, have
- 34:40departed after year one or year two. And so there's
- 34:44definitely a difference with the cadence of each
- 34:47team. And I wouldn't say that neither approach
- 34:50is inherently wrong. There are different organizational
- 34:53philosophies with one club investing heavily
- 34:56in what a player in fuller might become, while
- 34:59the other is investing heavily in what the player
- 35:01they believe can already can be with a supposedly
- 35:05higher floor and ceiling. This is why I don't
- 35:08think this trade should be viewed as a big winner
- 35:10versus loser debate. While sports media loves
- 35:13framing this transaction this way, I think the
- 35:16reality is much more complicated. Imagine we're
- 35:19sitting here three years from now with Centenor
- 35:21as one of the best leagues attackers, Angel City
- 35:25having made multiple playoff runs, but at the
- 35:28same time, fully developed into one of the NWSL's
- 35:31premier creative midfielders with BFC and...
- 35:34There's a world where both clubs feel like they
- 35:36made the right decision. These connections, while
- 35:39all integral to the overarching story of Angel
- 35:42City, are also very separate. For Bay, this is
- 35:45them taking the opportunity to capitalize off
- 35:47of a top young player that they believe has a
- 35:50lot of talent now and also a very high ceiling
- 35:53going forward that wasn't getting the minutes
- 35:55of Angel City she needed to develop. And they
- 35:57capitalized off of that. Similarly to what happened
- 36:00with Lily Real, where she just wasn't getting
- 36:02those minutes with Gotham. I don't think these
- 36:05teams made similar moves, despite them going
- 36:08for attacking midfielders on the younger side
- 36:11of things, because if the way they were doing
- 36:14things wasn't trying to save the same principles
- 36:17or solve the same problem, Bay is more interested
- 36:20in long -term development, whereas Angel City
- 36:23is very much adamant on accelerating their competitive
- 36:26timeline, objectives that aren't mutually exclusive,
- 36:29but for both teams have failed when coexisting.
- 36:32I think the fact that they didn't happen in isolation
- 36:34just matters to you. And these moves happened
- 36:38around perhaps the most consequential decision
- 36:40of them all, dismissing head coach Alexander
- 36:42Strauss. Because once you change the coach, this
- 36:47whole story comes together. Investing in heavily
- 36:50proven talent and moving on from one of your
- 36:53long -term prospects. It becomes more complicated
- 36:57and a steeper task to argue that these are isolated
- 37:01events as they begin to look more like pieces
- 37:04of a much larger organizational switch. I think
- 37:08the big question of today's episode is not about
- 37:11who wins or who loses because both these teams
- 37:14are not going to win a lot of games tomorrow.
- 37:18Though Angel City is very much adamant on building
- 37:20towards playoffs, without a head coach, that's
- 37:23going to be hard. But this is a team that...
- 37:25has the cap capability, has the backing, has
- 37:28the identity to win. This is not a bad roster
- 37:32by any means, guys. This is a team that should
- 37:34be competing for games with the additions needed.
- 37:38There was a big injury to Hina Sugita. A lot
- 37:41of these things need to be acknowledged. And
- 37:43also, I think the big question of this episode
- 37:46is, has Angel City stopped building for tomorrow
- 37:48and started demanding results for today? And
- 37:51to answer that, we have to talk about Alex Strauss.
- 37:54If the Centenor transfer tells us anywhere Angel
- 37:56City wants to go and how the Kennedy Fuller trade
- 37:59tells us how quickly they want to get there,
- 38:02then I think the dismissal of Alex Strauss forces
- 38:05us to ask one final question. How much patience
- 38:08did this project ever really have? And was it
- 38:11set up to succeed in reaching the goals that
- 38:14the club had set for themselves from a higher
- 38:17up standpoint, being disconnected from the actual
- 38:20sporting staff? Because unlike a transfer, Changing
- 38:24managers is not replacing one person. It's an
- 38:27admission that something bigger has failed. Whether
- 38:30it's tactics, culture, player relationships,
- 38:32which all three of them might have come into
- 38:34play in this instance, results are simply timing,
- 38:37which feels unlikely, the latter given his mere
- 38:4012 bumps on the touchline. Coaching changes are
- 38:43organizational decisions that have large impacts
- 38:47over a team, especially one that I think was
- 38:50made initially, the hiring. to stop this instability.
- 38:54And I think that it's important to rewind to
- 38:56when he was hired initially because English City
- 38:58didn't appoint him out of just a mere panic hire.
- 39:04They conducted an extensive international search
- 39:06and landed one of the game's most respected women's
- 39:11coaches. He was known for structure, possessional
- 39:14discipline, controlling matches through possession,
- 39:16for developing players over time rather than
- 39:19solely relying on the individual brilliance that
- 39:22perhaps some top European clubs and leagues with
- 39:26less competition can get away with. I think that
- 39:31building an identity, creating a sustainable
- 39:33football philosophy that is long lasting for
- 39:36years to come beyond one coach, beyond one player,
- 39:38is messaging that matters. And I think that Angel
- 39:42City's promise of a long -term vision very much
- 39:45shows where the results have failed. It's easy
- 39:49to talk about. There was results from a wins,
- 39:51loss, and league position standing. But I think
- 39:53one thing I just kept asking myself while researching
- 39:56this episode was whether the underlying football
- 39:59actually justified the decisions that Angel City
- 40:02made. Because those aren't the only things and
- 40:04always coexisting. Angel City has played well
- 40:08and lost. They've played poorly and won. And
- 40:10so I think whether or not Strauss deserved to
- 40:13ask his job, I wonder what Angel City looks like
- 40:17on the field with him. in comparison to what
- 40:20they'll look like without him? That's the question
- 40:22I think we won't get to know. And I think that
- 40:26they were really trying to build something. They
- 40:28looked much more comfortable building out from
- 40:30the back. The spacing from between players was
- 40:32organized. The fullbacks were pushing up way
- 40:34higher to provide width. And the midfield was
- 40:36creating multiple numerical advantages during
- 40:39buildup. There was a tactical framework in place,
- 40:41not just 11 players improvising. But I think
- 40:44having a plan and consistently executing it are
- 40:47two very different things. failed. One issue
- 40:50that repeatedly appeared was turning possession
- 40:52to high quality chances. Angel City could often
- 40:55progress the ball into the final third. The problem
- 40:57mainly came once they arrived there. Too many
- 41:00attacks stalled around the edge of the penalty
- 41:02box and final passes didn't always arrive due
- 41:05to a lack of synchronization within the runs
- 41:08and crosses frequently lacking a target. Instead
- 41:11of creating clear -cut chances. Possessions often
- 41:14ended with speculative shots or hopeful deliveries
- 41:17into the box. And while those are okay sometimes,
- 41:19when that makes up the majority of your actual
- 41:22chances, it is concerning because possessions
- 41:25isn't always creating danger. At some times,
- 41:29Angel City really struggled to consistently turn
- 41:32territorial control and big spurts in possession
- 41:37into goals. The other side of the ball was also
- 41:41interesting too, because as I mentioned today,
- 41:43the numbers weren't catastrophic defensively.
- 41:47The team wasn't collapsing every weekend and
- 41:49the organization actually held up reasonably
- 41:51well. The problem was that when you're not creating
- 41:54enough on one side of the field, every defensive
- 41:57mistake, every goalkeeping mistake becomes magnified.
- 42:00One missed assignment, one transition or turnover,
- 42:02and suddenly you've dropped points. That's why
- 42:05I think simply looking at the goals they've conceded
- 42:07doesn't tell the whole story. It wasn't just
- 42:09the defending. It was the balance between the
- 42:11offense and the defense and an offense that simply
- 42:13couldn't produce, leaving the defense to fall
- 42:18victim to a single mistake ruining the match.
- 42:21And that's a question of personnel because every
- 42:24coach at the end of the day inherits strengths
- 42:26and weaknesses. No tactical system is really
- 42:28existing in a vacuum. It does beg the question,
- 42:31was this roster perfectly suited to the style
- 42:33that Strauss wanted to play? Because Parsons
- 42:35spoke a lot about at the Angel City fan event
- 42:38how it didn't fit what they wanted. But that
- 42:41confuses me because you know what Strauss wants.
- 42:43He's not a coach who's just going to lent into
- 42:46a club's identity because Angel City doesn't
- 42:48have a strong identity that you inherit. It's
- 42:51not like a Barcelona where you go in and you
- 42:52know you're going to play tiki -taka football.
- 42:54In a new system, the players have to learn spacing,
- 42:58timing. The pressing triggers, the rotations,
- 43:01the relationships, these concepts don't become
- 43:04automatic after a single preseason. And that's
- 43:06one reason why many coaches who emphasize positional
- 43:10football often ask for patience. Their systems
- 43:13typically approve over multiple seasons, not
- 43:17multiple weeks. Of course, none of that excuses
- 43:20poor results. Professional sport doesn't operate
- 43:23under. Theoretical progress and owners clearly
- 43:26are not awarding brownie points for tactical
- 43:28ideas. I think eventually performances do have
- 43:32to translate into wins and that's the developing
- 43:34dilemma that Angel City has faced. Was the football
- 43:38improving enough to justify staying the course
- 43:41or had ownership seen enough to conclude that
- 43:44a different voice, a different figure was needed
- 43:46in the locker room? I think that's what makes
- 43:48this discussion so fascinating. Because these
- 43:52questions are really complicated. Reasonable
- 43:54people who are all experts and confident enough
- 43:59to speak on the matter will have differing opinions.
- 44:00Because unlike some coaching changes, this wasn't
- 44:03objectively right or wrong. I think you could
- 44:09have built a logical argument either way. And
- 44:13I feel like I've said this so many times today,
- 44:15but it's ultimately when the dust settles where...
- 44:20The debate will ultimately fall over time. If
- 44:24Angel City rapidly approves under whatever new
- 44:27coach they hire, many people point to this decision
- 44:30as a necessary turning point in the club's history.
- 44:32But if the same issue continues, despite yet
- 44:36another managerial shift, the conversation shifts.
- 44:39And the question becomes whether the coach is
- 44:42even the biggest position in the first place.
- 44:44That's why I don't think his tenure should be...
- 44:46Strauss' tenure should be judged solely because
- 44:49of the record. I think it has to be judged by
- 44:52the gap between the football he wanted to play,
- 44:56the football Angel City wanted to play as a whole
- 44:58from a club perspective, and the football they
- 45:00produced. And those three things very much did
- 45:03not look in sync. And I think at some point you
- 45:05have to ask if the club keeps picking the wrong
- 45:10coaches. Is it really a problem of the coach
- 45:14themselves? We saw Becky Tweed get the nod only
- 45:17to get fired. We saw, obviously, Mark Parsons
- 45:20come in, do this worldwide search to get a coach
- 45:23that simply disappointed for a club with championship
- 45:27ambitions. And I think it's now time to make
- 45:31the case for why that change did make sense.
- 45:34Results matter. And no matter how impressive
- 45:37your resume is or how successful you were in
- 45:40another league, or even how attractive your tactical
- 45:43philosophy was to the club. And it had its moments
- 45:47of brilliance. Professional sports and your job
- 45:50in that team is ultimately judged by the very
- 45:52harsh line of performance. Everything needs to
- 45:54be perfect. And Angel City didn't have the internal
- 45:58expectation of fighting to stay in the playoffs.
- 46:01They wanted to be competing near the top of the
- 46:03table. This roster includes experienced internationals,
- 46:06emerging U .S. talent, and... players capable
- 46:09of completing up almost anyone in this league.
- 46:11Ownership and supporters invested heavily and
- 46:15financially. And if you're running the club,
- 46:17you could realistically conclude, at least for
- 46:19the affirmative side of choosing to fire him,
- 46:22that the performances simply weren't matching
- 46:24the quality available. And that's a completely
- 46:27fair argument to make because, you know, sometimes
- 46:29the coaching and employment just doesn't fit.
- 46:31Even great coaches can be the wrong coach for
- 46:34a particular club at this particular moment.
- 46:36We've seen it. happened across world football
- 46:39countless times, success elsewhere doesn't automatically
- 46:42translate everywhere, especially into a new league.
- 46:45But there's another side of the coin that deserves
- 46:47equal attention. If you hire someone specifically
- 46:50because they're known for building sustainable
- 46:52projects, how long should that project actually
- 46:55be allowed to develop under that coach? One season?
- 46:5918 months? That's a difficult question because
- 47:01there's not a universal answer, but it feels
- 47:04like the answer that Angel City got was the wrong
- 47:06one. projects genuinely need time because as
- 47:09i mentioned earlier there's so many intricacies
- 47:10to them that players need to learn the principles
- 47:13and recruitment have to align with the coaches
- 47:15ideas the culture has to develop the relationships
- 47:17have to form and this does not happen overnight
- 47:20and i think the timeline seemed to contradict
- 47:23the original message which is why i think so
- 47:27many people were surprised because the club said
- 47:29this is about building something lasting then
- 47:31before that vision even had time to fully mature
- 47:35the architect of it was gone. Again, that doesn't
- 47:38necessarily make the decision wrong, but I think
- 47:40it does make it worth examining whether or not
- 47:43other people in the organization, i .e. Mark
- 47:46Parsons, are the right people for the job. Because
- 47:48at the end of the day, if you think this roster
- 47:51is talented, but it's not producing, you're the
- 47:53one bringing these players in. You're the one
- 47:54who's entrusting these players within the system.
- 47:57And if multiple coaches, not under Mark Parsons
- 48:01per se, have failed, but... multiple coaches
- 48:03with this team has failed maybe the roster just
- 48:05isn't the right fit there's something underlying
- 48:08besides the coaches for me that's my diagnosis
- 48:11that needs to be addressed at the end of the
- 48:14day what if the club itself changed this is the
- 48:17third possibility that is the non -factor of
- 48:19the coach not the players of the coach but the
- 48:22organization think about everything that happened
- 48:25around the same time they were making this record
- 48:29investment from Allie Setnor making the difficult
- 48:31decision to part ways with Kennedy Fuller and
- 48:33I think this leads to growing expectations for
- 48:35ownership on the pitch maybe Angel City looked
- 48:39around and decided that its competitive window
- 48:41opened sooner than expected they saw that Setnor
- 48:44wasn't fitting of Angel City she was probably
- 48:46a target they've looked at in past years she
- 48:49was one they inquired about earlier this season
- 48:51and they decided to go in for her when they had
- 48:54the chance if that's true then Maybe Strauss
- 48:57wasn't dismissed because he was a bad coach.
- 49:00Maybe he was dismissed because the organization's
- 49:03priorities changed faster than his project could
- 49:06develop. I don't think it's necessarily a question
- 49:10of whether or not he's good enough because he's
- 49:12a proven coach. He is a good coach. The players
- 49:15loved him and respected him. I think the question
- 49:17really is whether or not Angel City decided they
- 49:21no longer had the time for the long -term bill
- 49:23that Strauss was requiring. And honestly, we
- 49:27might not ever know what explanation is perfectly
- 49:30correct. Maybe the internal standards weren't
- 49:32being met. There were factors that we never saw
- 49:34and ownership genuinely believed a different
- 49:36voice was needed. Professional clubs make decisions
- 49:39with information that ultimately rarely becomes
- 49:41public. What we can evaluate is the pattern that
- 49:44is becoming too difficult to ignore. Invest in
- 49:47a player who can help immediately, trade one
- 49:49of your biggest long -term prospects, and replace
- 49:52the coach hired to oversee a long -term rebuild.
- 49:56viewed individually each move has some semblance
- 49:59of a justification albeit not strong and when
- 50:03viewed together they begin to tell a different
- 50:05story about urgency rising expectations and a
- 50:08club deciding that progress was no longer enough
- 50:11results had become the priority and the team
- 50:14was willing to make big decisions to get what
- 50:16they needed when this becomes the right decision
- 50:18is something we'll definitely be discussing over
- 50:21the next few years and i think This team will
- 50:24have a legacy that is based on whether these
- 50:27moves move the team into championship contention.
- 50:29If they do, this leadership will be seen as bold
- 50:32and decisive. But if they don't, people will
- 50:35inevitably ask the right question of whether
- 50:37the club abandoned its vision before it even
- 50:40had the chance to prosper. And that's why I think
- 50:43the discussion expands far beyond one manager
- 50:46or player. It's really about the organization
- 50:48that Angel City wants to be. A club willing to
- 50:51wait for sustainable success or... a club determined
- 50:53to accelerate its timeline, even if it means
- 50:56making uncomfortable decisions along the way.
- 50:59That question doesn't just define Alex Strauss's
- 51:02tenure, it defines the future of Angel City.
- 51:04And I think there's a temptation whenever a club
- 51:07makes these decisions to just end the story with
- 51:12the headline, but I think that's a very narrow
- 51:13way of looking at it. If we zoom out for a minute,
- 51:16Angel City's summer starts to look less like
- 51:18an outlier and more of a reflection of where
- 51:20the NB cell is heading. This isn't the league
- 51:22it was five years ago, even two years ago with
- 51:25world competition, more desperate, I guess, policies
- 51:30being implemented to keep the best players in
- 51:31the league, the economics expectations and ambition
- 51:34has changed and clubs are starting to behave
- 51:37differently because of the environment they're
- 51:39operating under. For years, NB cell wasn't a
- 51:42league where transfer fees. dominated the conversation
- 51:44and now it's no longer the case and I think there's
- 51:48this belief that ownership has where they're
- 51:51not just investing simply to keep place they
- 51:54want the returns financially and competitively
- 51:57over time the playoff appearances the championships
- 52:00the commercial growth and national relevance
- 52:02matter when you're investing more and when winning
- 52:07matters more to these teams because they have
- 52:10direct financial incentives, the booming valuations
- 52:13of these clubs in their pockets. We're seeing
- 52:14so many sales for a reason. Patience becomes
- 52:17much harder to justify. I think with the broadcast
- 52:22deals growing, attendance records continuing
- 52:24to be challenged across the league with Denver
- 52:28and expansion clubs coming in and setting new
- 52:32precedents for current clubs to follow and European
- 52:35teams overseas remaining very active in the transfer
- 52:38market. NWSL teams aren't competing against each
- 52:41other anymore they're competing globally but
- 52:43they're also competing against the WNBA and men's
- 52:48sports because NWSL is taken more seriously now
- 52:50but with that prestige comes not prestige comes
- 52:55more pressure and if you're in Needle City you're
- 52:59not asking can we be better to the club next
- 53:01to us they're asking can we build a club that
- 53:04attracts and keeps the world -class talent that
- 53:06keeps fans in the seats, that keeps the club
- 53:09in the headlines. And that's why this eye center
- 53:11transfer matters beyond Angel City. It's about
- 53:14what clubs are willing to do now to spend for
- 53:17elite domestic talent. If you're one of the best
- 53:19young American players, despite what soccer Donna
- 53:22might tell you, your market value has fundamentally
- 53:25changed. That's good news for players and agents
- 53:28and for the league, but it creates pressure because
- 53:30when you're spending at that level, Supporters
- 53:33are going to expect results. Any $150 ,000 transfer
- 53:37is not the same as adapt signing. It's very much
- 53:43something that happens with investment and the
- 53:46headlines that come with the player are followed
- 53:49by expectations. I think this is ultimately something
- 53:53that will come with media scrutiny intensifying
- 53:57and the timeline of the club. compressing which
- 54:01granted not unique to angle city it's professional
- 54:03sports in a butt and nutshell and i think the
- 54:08question is whether women's soccer is entering
- 54:09that same era and whether or not it's a good
- 54:13thing because there's obvious positives better
- 54:15players higher facilities sorry higher salaries
- 54:18better facilities more opportunities throughout
- 54:20the sport but if organizations become increasingly
- 54:24impatient do coaches actually receive enough
- 54:27time to build something sustainable Young players
- 54:30receive the minutes they need to develop and
- 54:32to be self -pioneering in that department now,
- 54:34we must not lose that. Do clubs become too focused
- 54:38on solving today's problems at the expense of
- 54:40tomorrow's opportunities? And these are questions
- 54:42the league, but specifically clubs who are underperforming
- 54:45like Angel City will need to wrestle with. And
- 54:48Angel City might be the May 1st major example
- 54:51of chapter after chapter of that tension playing
- 54:54out in public, which brings me back to the original
- 54:57question that started off this episode. What
- 55:00do the Settner transfer, Fuller, trade, and dismissal
- 55:03of Alex Strauss's duties have in common? Very
- 55:06little on paper, but underneath the decisions
- 55:09is the common thread of urgency. Each move signaling
- 55:12a club that believes waiting carries its own
- 55:15risks. Waiting for prospects to develop, tactical
- 55:18ideas to click, or results to inevitably arrive?
- 55:21Ingle City appears to have decided that waiting
- 55:24was no longer the best strategy. With that said,
- 55:26we're both remembered as visionary and short
- 55:28-sighted. Only time will tell. Anyone who claims
- 55:32they know the answers to this equation that is
- 55:34unsolvable is overly confident. And I think a
- 55:38lot of these factors of who's winning in these
- 55:42moments comes down to how these players and clubs
- 55:45progress. Maybe we'll look back at a stretch
- 55:48and wonder whether the club abandoned a promising
- 55:51long -term project before it had the chance to
- 55:53fully mature or... How it allowed Angel City
- 55:56to win their first title. That uncertainty that
- 55:58makes sports compelling is what makes this episode
- 56:02compelling. But regardless of how these individual
- 56:04moves will be remembered, they stand as a marker
- 56:07of something bigger. A moment where one of the
- 56:09NFL's most ambitious clubs made it clear that
- 56:11competing wasn't enough. They want to content.
- 56:16When I started this episode together, I thought
- 56:18I was going to be talking about three completely
- 56:20different stories, and I never thought it would
- 56:21end up like this. Instead, after doing immense
- 56:25research and diving into every single article
- 56:28to get one -liners about how Angel City had been
- 56:32seeking Settnor's trade for months, or that they
- 56:37wanted this thing, and I was watching the video
- 56:39of Parsons at the press conference, or not even
- 56:42the press conference because he didn't even hold
- 56:43one at the end of it. It was just such a mess,
- 56:46but I think that's kind of the fun of this all.
- 56:49They all have different storylines. They're a
- 56:52statement about where the club believes they
- 56:54need to be today and where it should be tomorrow.
- 56:57For years, Angel City has been a defining brand
- 57:00of women's soccer, drawing incredible crowds.
- 57:02One of the league's strongest commercial identities,
- 57:04investing heavily in facilities, infrastructure,
- 57:07and player recruitment. But eventually these
- 57:09ambitious clubs off the field release that presence
- 57:13when they're not meeting it on the field. The
- 57:16crossroads they're reaching is that building
- 57:18isn't enough. I think supporters have eventually
- 57:21stopped celebrating progress off the field and
- 57:24start expecting trophies. The club appears to
- 57:27have looked at the first half of the year and
- 57:28reached a conclusion that the club didn't lack
- 57:31the talent or the future that wasn't despairing
- 57:36to win games, but that waiting for everything
- 57:40to naturally come wasn't an acceptable strategy
- 57:44for the team. So that's that for today. I think
- 57:48these outcomes aren't exclusive, but not every
- 57:52trade has to produce a winner or loser. And I
- 57:55think that what's going to happen from this episode
- 57:58will fascinate me most because these decisions
- 58:04will all reveal things about the league itself
- 58:06that I don't think anyone can really qualify
- 58:10now because Fuller is a player, Setnor is a player
- 58:14who have such promising futures and Anyway, these
- 58:17free moves are separately their own items, but
- 58:21Angel City as a whole, they're definitely looking
- 58:24at this in one cohesive measure. Thank you so
- 58:28much for listening. And that's all for me today.
- 58:30Peace out from your host, LDG. Bye. See you next
- 58:33time. Thank you for listening to the Women's
- 58:46Soccer Podcast. If you enjoyed this episode and
- 58:48would like to help support the show, please subscribe
- 58:50and leave a rating and review. To stay up to
- 58:52date with the Women's Soccer Podcast, you can
- 58:54follow our show on Instagram at the Women's Soccer
- 58:56Podcast with underscores in between each word
- 58:58and on Blue Sky at the Women's Soccer Pod. Make
- 59:01sure you hit the follow button wherever you get
- 59:03your podcasts so you can be the first person
- 59:06to hear our Thursday interviews with a special
- 59:08guest and our Monday deep dive solo episodes
- 59:10covering the newest headlines in the women's
- 59:12soccer world.