Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #69🎙️ |Public Inquiry Review of the week 26th May 2026 |
Transcript
- 0:05Unknown: Another week done at the public inquiry, sitting here
- 0:09on Saturday afternoon, trying to make sense of it all. I'm not
- 0:13entirely sure this week was really about the roads, which
- 0:18was what it was purported to be about. Now, don't get me wrong,
- 0:22we spend most of the week talking about roads, road
- 0:25abandonment, road safety, visibility displays, traffic
- 0:29movements, junction designs, heavy goods vehicles, road
- 0:33audits, road standards, and every conceivable variation of
- 0:37the word road you can imagine, but if you take a step back from
- 0:42the engineering drawings and the consultant reports and the
- 0:45endless technical language, I think something else is
- 0:48emerging, and indeed has been over the last number of weeks,
- 0:51coming rapidly now into much sharper focus, because what I
- 0:55think what we witnessed this week is much more a debate about
- 0:59trust, trust in institutions and in processes. Trust that public
- 1:06bodies are acting in the public interest, and trust that
- 1:10ordinary people still matter. One of the biggest issues this
- 1:14week continue to be the proposal to abandon part of an existing
- 1:18public road, and the question around this is, can a piece of
- 1:23public infrastructure, such as road, be altered, diminished, or
- 1:28removed primarily to facilitate a private commercial
- 1:31development? It begs the question, do roads not belong to
- 1:36us all, as they are public assets. Following this train of
- 1:42thought throughout the week, I couldn't help but notice that
- 1:46public interest and the commercial interests are being
- 1:49presented as if they were the same thing. One could be
- 1:54forgiven for thinking that these interests are being
- 1:57intentionally conflated, so lines become blurred as to where
- 2:02the DFI interest ends in the matter, and that of the company
- 2:05begins, creating ever more confusion, and of course they
- 2:11are patently not the same thing at all. To get to this position,
- 2:16both parties would have had to consciously adopt their
- 2:18language, and it is noticeable how language is used as the
- 2:23weeks unfold at the public inquiry, language tells us how
- 2:28people think, language reframes the message, language can
- 2:33intentionally create assumptions and ambiguity, we human beings
- 2:41were a bit like fish who swim in a sea of language, and when
- 2:44people stop being people and become receptors, something
- 2:47important gets lost. It is truly the language of corporate
- 2:53colonialism. When used in this way, our lived experience
- 2:58disappears, our community disappears, the reality of our
- 3:03daily lives disappear. We are no longer valued, we no longer
- 3:07count, and what remains is something that can be measured
- 3:10on a spreadsheet. The role of DFI Rhodes also continues to
- 3:15generate questions. People listening to these proceedings
- 3:19week after week are forming their own opinions. Many are
- 3:24increasingly asking whether DFI Rhodes is acting as defender of
- 3:28public infrastructure or whether its role has drifted into
- 3:31facilitating the ambitions of the applicant. I know that's an
- 3:36uncomfortable thought, but confidence in institutions
- 3:40depends on people believing that those institutions are
- 3:44independent. Once that confidence starts to erode,
- 3:48everything comes into question. Environmental issues continue to
- 3:53feature heavily through the week. Also, the gradual upland
- 3:57industrialization of us of what is currently a rural landscape,
- 4:02and again the discussion was wrapped up in technical
- 4:05evidence, but the underlying question remained
- 4:08straightforward. What sort of a place are we leaving behind, and
- 4:13who gets to make that decision? Because once this type of
- 4:17industrialization occurs, it is really difficult, if not
- 4:21impossible, to reverse. Future generations don't get a vote,
- 4:27they simply inherit whatever bad decisions we make. And if this
- 4:33week is anything to go by, the attitude of the departments en
- 4:37masse seems to be, let's go for growth now, and the future can
- 4:40go to hell, too bad for the human beings coming behind us.
- 4:46During the week, we also heard discussions around explosives,
- 4:50the kind of explosives, the delivery of explosives, and risk
- 4:53and safety, and you know experts can debate probabilities all day
- 4:58long, but local people. People tend to ask far simpler
- 5:01questions. Will this make my community safe or less safe?
- 5:07It's not an unreasonable question, and one that is
- 5:09entitled to be heard. But being allowed to come to the table and
- 5:13speak, though, is not quite the same thing as being heard. What
- 5:18I do know is that what we are watching during the course of
- 5:23this public inquiry is actually a test of democratic
- 5:26accountability and I don't say that lightly because when people
- 5:31begin to lose confidence that processes are fair, when
- 5:35communities feel excluded from decisions affecting their lives
- 5:39and when public bodies appear increasingly distant from the
- 5:43people they are supposed to serve, something important
- 5:46begins to break down. Democratic values don't disappear
- 5:52overnight, they erode gradually, one compromise at a time, one
- 5:57accommodation at a time, one procedural decision at a time
- 6:02until eventually people wake up and wonder where the hell all
- 6:05the safeguards went. For years, we've said that Save Our
- 6:10Sparrows is a stand for the air we breathe, the water we drink,
- 6:13the earth that supports us, and the health of communities now
- 6:16and into the future. But listening to proceedings this
- 6:20week, it increasingly feels like we are also becoming a stand for
- 6:25democracy itself. Looking across the Atlantic, at the moment,
- 6:29we're seeing what happens when institutions are weakened and
- 6:32democratic norms come under sustained pressure. So, as we
- 6:37head into another week of this inquiry, I think the biggest
- 6:40question is no longer whether a road should be abandoned. The
- 6:44bigger question is this: Who is this process serving? Because of
- 6:49public inquiries, public bodies and public infrastructure are no
- 6:53longer primarily serving the public. Then we have a much
- 6:57bigger conversation on our hands than simply where a road goes,
- 7:02as always. Thanks for listening, and I'll see you all next week.