Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / The Impact You'll Never See: Can One Teacher Still Change a Life?
Transcript
- Ilana: Have you ever driven home from school wondering, did I do anything today that actually mattered? If you've been asking yourself whether teachers can still change lives, then the answer is absolutely. And I'm gonna share why. Imagine as a teacher someone asking you to write down everything you did from 830 to 3. Not all of the prep that happened before 8 30, not any of the stuff that happened after the bell rang. Just 830 to 3. So what is that? That is all of the lessons that you taught. It is all of every redirection, every emotional check-in, every hallway conversation, which I absolutely despise, every adjustment that you made because a student needed something different, every pivot, every time you were flexible, every assessment decision, every time you tracked data, all of the conflicts that you helped to resolve. Every moment that you encouraged a student who was ready to give up or who was too afraid to initiate a task, every time you noticed something that wasn't said out loud, every small decision that you made that helped a student feel like part of the classroom community, that you helped the student feel like they belonged. By the time three o'clock hit, that list would be pages long. Okay, so what? Well, can you imagine trying to evaluate the impact that you had as a teacher by looking at only one of the lines on that list? One assignment, one assessment, one check-in, one test score, one observable outcome? Would that actually tell the whole story? Probably not. And yet, this is often the tension that teachers experience. You spend your days doing hundreds of things that matter, many of which are invisible. Then at the end of the day, you wonder did any of it make a difference? I have gotten a lot of emails recently from you asking if it was still possible to change a student's life. You've written to me that you had a favorite teacher. They inspired you. They helped you in a certain way. It changed the trajectory of your life. Or it changed how you saw yourself. And now you're left wondering can one teacher still change a life in the current world that we're living in and that we're teaching in, where classrooms are full of anxiety? Phones, smartphones, smartwatches, they're everywhere. And the research is showing that attention spans for students are at an all-time low. Hi, I'm Alana Heffer. Welcome to Pedagogically Speaking, the where we share our experiences, we learn from one another, and we ask some hard questions and hopefully get some good answers from them. Okay, let's be honest. Expectations on you as a teacher are staggeringly high, and they are continuing to rise. You are expected to be educators, counselors, technology experts, behavior specialists, relationship builders, data analysts, and somehow still create engaging individualized lessons every day. Many of you are wondering, does any of it actually matter? Let's get into it. I think it's really important to understand why this question has become so common around teachers right now. I know you teach and you wonder, am I getting through to them? Teaching has become so complex, and you're asked to deal with things you never thought you would have to. And yeah, the expectations are continuing to grow. I remember when I first started teaching, yes, I did have to differentiate for my students and ensure that they had meaningful learning experiences, of course. But back then I was also given time to collaborate with my colleagues, to learn from them, to try new ways to approach learning in my classroom. I was given something that we don't have anymore time and space. Most of the time that I had in my classroom as a teacher w was spent teaching. I was able to give extra time to the students who needed it Because I could have the rest of the classroom working on different tactile activities independently and in small groups. But it's not like that anymore. It is so different now. You plan lessons, assess learning, provide feedback, and create opportunities for students to develop knowledge and skills. But the role has completely expanded, and now you need to understand Universal Design for Learning or UDL. And create inclusive classrooms, you're expected to not only recognize but respond to a wide range of learning needs and make sure that every single student can succeed. Look, I'm an inclusive education teacher. Inclusion is one of the most important commitments we can make in education, while also being the most complex and underfunded. Inclusion requires Time. It requires supports from many different people, collaboration, resources, teaching materials, training, ongoing professional development, adequate funding, and a school community that truly understands and supports inclusion. And you're trying to do this important work while balancing increasingly diverse needs in the same classroom every day at the same time with no time to prepare. Inclusion isn't about lowering expectations, it's about removing the barriers so that students can genuinely have an opportunity to learn in meaningful ways. At the same time, you're also supporting students through growing mental health challenges, and you're expected to be the counselor in the classroom. Teachers who've been doing this for a while will tell you that this job has changed. It's not just noticing whether a student understands a math concept or can write a paragraph anymore. You also have to notice notice when students stop participating, when someone seems withdrawn. And then you're supposed to know what to do about it without any training and usually without any support. It is exhausting. And you start wondering if you can actually help. Any of your students. And then on top of all of this, which is already quite a lot, we're working in a time when public conversations around education can feel incredibly critical. You hear that schools need to do more. Schools then put that burden and that pressure onto you, and you wonder how you can possibly reach all of your students and inspire them as the load continues to intensify. That's when that teacher guilt. Really kicks in. When you give so much of yourself to this work, you want to know that it matters. You want to know that the long hours meant something, that the difficult conversations mattered, that the moments that you chose, patience instead of frustration, mattered. That the time that you spent believing in a student who wasn't sure they could believe in themselves mattered. And I think that's why you know this question's been popping up so much because you aren't doubting yourself as a teacher. You know, this is a question that is stemming from hope. The hope that what you do does actually matter and that it has a meaning. I hope that the moments that no one sees you do still count. A hope that all of the effort that you're putting in is remembered. But what do students actually remember? I'm not gonna lie, I'm not like many of you. I did not become a s a teacher because I loved my teachers and had good experiences in school. But even I still remember my favorite teacher. It was Mrs. Metter, my grade four teacher at Lord Lansdown, and I absolutely adored her. Everything she did was just amazing. Even just the way she walked in the in the room put made students just feel happy. She was wonderful. She made me feel seen and heard and safe, which were things I had never felt at school before. She expected excellence with kindness. Because of her quiet persistence, I actually did better at school because I wanted to. Unfortunately for me, she was there covering a maternity leave and so she left after the winter break. and then we got the regular teacher back for the classroom, which I don't remember her name. But I do still remember Mrs. Metter I still even remember what she looked like. And that was thirty three years ago. So I mean, can you think about your favorite teacher? You probably remember what they taught, but that's not gonna be the first thing you remember. You remembered how they made you feel. This kind of reminds me of an article I saw in Ed Utopia by Yuki Tirata, The Science of Student Motivation, where David Yeager talks about his experience as a teacher. And he says, I had come to the classroom mainly because I wanted to motivate, inspire, and engage teenagers. Ye Yeager then talks about how frustrating he found it to connect to his students. he wanted he thought that you know performance the was the way to create like relationships and so he was he talks about how he tried to be like Robin Williams and and that whole standing on the desk thing to motivate students. but when that didn't work, he he kept teaching and then he realized not only what motivated students, but what helped them connect to them. You know, he said, tedious tasks such as double checking data in a spreadsheet may feel like a burden to students, but if those calculations are connected to real life problems that kids care about, ensuring that local water contamination levels are low, for example, then students often rise to the occasion and demonstrate the discipline and hard work that's commonly lacking with traditional assignments. They were motivated because the work they were doing tapped into their sense of purpose. It mattered. Okay, so we know that we can motivate students and we know that they can they can do some really hard work if they feel connected to it, right? That that connection to self or to the world around them. But what happens if they just never tell you? the cruel part of teaching, right? Doctors, they often know if a patient recovered. Architects can stand in front of a building that they designed. Writers, you know, they finish a book and people buy it. Teachers, you rarely get to see the ending. You know, sometimes we do get lucky. A friend of mine who teaches in high school has a stu student that keeps coming to them for help, only now it's with their college work and a local high school they have this amazing tradition where students get dressed up in their gowns and they have flowers and they drive them on buses to the different schools where they w they can go and give a give a flower to their teachers and it's just a beautiful moment. I r I love it. but for every student who does does go back, there are hundreds who never do. And it's not because you didn't matter, it's because as we all know, life just Carry them forward. Students become nurses, doctors, Sparkies, parents, coaches, scientists. They remember how their t favorite teachers made them feel. They remember the kindness, the helping. And they bring all of that to who they become. Kindness spreads. Confidence spreads. Curiosity spreads. You just never witness most of it. Okay, so now the original question, quietly, ask yourself in your head, can one teacher still change a life? Yes, you may not change every life because that's impossible. That's an impossible burden for anyone. Every teacher does change lives. Rarely, I think, in ways that we can even imagine. If you're listening to this, you know, maybe you're driving, walking your dog, or enjoying a quiet summer morning. I want you to think about something. Somewhere you have a former student. Who still hears your voice when they doubt themselves? You probably don't know who they are and you may never know. They won't write you a letter. They won't call back to visit. They may not even realize that something you said or the way you greeted them every morning or the expectation you held for them, the patience you showed them on a difficult day became the part of the way they see themselves. And that is the strange thing about teachings. So much of its impact is invisible to the person who's doing it. We live in a profession that measures what can be counted. Assessment data, attendance, graduation rates, engagement surveys. Yeah, okay, those things matter, but some of the most important outcomes of teaching don't fit neatly in a spreadsheet. It's that student who starts believing that they're capable, who learns that mistakes are part of learning and not proof of failure. Those moments often reveal their significance years later. So can one teacher still change a life? I believe the answer is yes, because you show up day after day in the ordinary moments that shape who young people become. And while you'll never know every life that you have influenced somewhere years from now, someone will remember your classroom. As the place where they first believed they could succeed. That's why the work you do matters. Maybe the question isn't whether teachers are making a difference. Maybe the question is whether we are looking for evidence of that difference in the places where it actually exists. Thanks so much for listening. See you next time.