Latest / The World Unexplained / DR. LOEB DISCUSSES WHY HE BELIEVES THERE EXTRATERRESTIAL BEINGS
Transcript
- 0:02The World Unexplained, the a podcast that explores the unusual beliefs, conspiracies,
- 0:11customs, rituals, and traditions from around the world. This is your host,
- 0:17Doctor Carlos. Welcome back, everybody. I'm a great guest with me.
- 0:28He's the Frank B. Bear, Junior Professor of Science at Harvard University,
- 0:32the former chair of Harvard's Department of Astronomy, founding director of Harvard's Black
- 0:37Hole Initiative, and director of the Institute for Theory and Computation. You can't
- 0:42ask for a better guest. But he wrote a great book, and I'm
- 0:45telling you right now it's a really a fascinating read. It's called Extraterrestrial The
- 0:48First Sign of intelligent life beyond Earth. I know can't wait to hear it
- 0:54me and either. So let's welcome to the show. Doctor Avul, Welcome
- 0:57sir. Thank you for having me. Oh, thank you for being This
- 1:00is really a fascinating read. You got some great reviews Sean Carroll from the
- 1:06World to the Quantum World. He gives you great reviews on the book.
- 1:08So tell us a little bit about what got this whole book started. This
- 1:11is an interesting story, well, it was an object that was discovered in
- 1:15October twenty seventeen that happened to be the first object from outside the Solar System
- 1:23that was spotted near Earth from a telescope in Hawaii, And at first people
- 1:29thought, well, it's probably just like the objects we've seen before in the
- 1:33Solar System, a comet or an asteroid, basically a rock, and as
- 1:38time went on, it started to look very weird as we collected more evidence
- 1:44about it. It had an extreme geometry based on the amount of sunlight that
- 1:49reflected as it was tumbling, so it was at least ten times longer than
- 1:55it was wide when projected on the sky. And then it show any cometary
- 2:00tail. There was no gas evaporating from it, and so people said,
- 2:05well, maybe it's just a rock without any ice on the surface that would
- 2:09evaporate. But then it exhibited an extra push away from the sun, and
- 2:15the question was what gives it that push? And the best model for the
- 2:20way that it reflected sunlight was that of a disc shaped object, a flat
- 2:25object like a pancake, And it wasn't really clear what this object, what
- 2:31the nature of this object is the only way I could have thought of explaining
- 2:38the extra push that it exhibited is that if it comes from the reflection of
- 2:44sunlight, just like in the case of a sail of a boat that reflects
- 2:50the wind and pushes the boat forward. In the same way, you can
- 2:54have a light sail, where a sail is reflecting light and getting pushed.
- 3:00And this is the technology that we are currently developing for space exploration. The
- 3:05advantages the spacecraft doesn't need to carry the fuel with it. But what it
- 3:10does imply is that this object may be of artificial origin. It's not a
- 3:15rock, it's not a naturally produced object. And that's what opens up a
- 3:21new window into the possibility that we might not be alone, and that in
- 3:27fact, we might not even be the smartest kid on the block. Yeah,
- 3:31and that's interesting because you know, some of the comments you had made,
- 3:36you brought up the idea that we're not alone. You're kind of trying
- 3:39to get rid of the Fermi paradox, if I'm correct. Well, there
- 3:46is what we know that half of the sun like stars have a planet roughly
- 3:54the size of the Earth the same separation, and what that means is that
- 4:00there are billions of Earth Sun systems that have similar circumstances. To that that
- 4:05we find around us, and if you arrange for similar circumstances, you are
- 4:11likely to get similar outcomes, and so it's quite likely that they were and
- 4:17perhaps our civilizations out there. The question is why don't we see them around
- 4:24us or getting any signals from them? And that was Fermi's paradox. He
- 4:30was asking where is everybody? And there are several possible answers to that.
- 4:35It's possible that technological civilizations are short lived and so they only live for a
- 4:43short window of time during which you can receive radio signals from them. But
- 4:48on the other hand, if they send out spacecrafts or produce space junk,
- 4:56we could still see it after long after they are dead. Would be relics
- 5:00that are left behind, and I call that space archaeology. Just like we
- 5:05find evidence for cultures that existed on Earth and are not around anymore in the
- 5:11form of relics when we dig into the ground, we can do the same
- 5:15thing in space and finding messages in bottles, you know, like technological equipment
- 5:23that is not functional anymore or other space debris could indicate that there were other
- 5:30civilizations before us, even though they are not around anymore. Fascinating, fascinating,
- 5:38So I guess a lot of the findings make you feel good in the
- 5:42sense of like when they found water droplets in Mars, this could somewhat corroborate
- 5:46that theory as well. They're finding other things in the Moon that there might
- 5:49have been something living there. Now those things really adding to your theories.
- 5:54Now that there is extraterrestrial life, Well, the Persevere's mission will get to
- 6:00Mars in the middle of February and well look for evidence or traces of life
- 6:09that may have existed or may still be there. And of course, if
- 6:15we find evidence for life on Mars, that would open up a whole new
- 6:20range of possibilities on other planets as well. And so far we only know
- 6:28for sure that there is life on Earth. One reason that I search for
- 6:33intelligent life out there in the sky is because I have a hard time finding
- 6:40it here on Earth. Let me ask you this now, this is called
- 6:50which in the Hawaiian language means a scout or a messenger from far away.
- 6:58The telescope that discovered this object is situated on Mount Halakala in Maui. Oh
- 7:04wow, it's a pretty mountain too. Let me ask you this so when
- 7:10you were I know, in the book you talk about the political ramifications,
- 7:13the religious ramifications about this discovery. If we were actually to discover aliens out
- 7:18there, what are some of your takes on that. Well, finding evidence
- 7:24for another technological civilization would change our perspective about our place in the universe.
- 7:30That's why many people do not want to discuss it. When my daughters were
- 7:35infants, you know, they tended to think that they are at the center
- 7:40of the world and that they have qualities that are really special. But once
- 7:46they grew up and went to the kindergarten and met other kids, they got
- 7:49a better perspective. And of course, if they insisted on staying home,
- 7:55they could have maintained their view that they are really unique and special. And
- 7:59so that's what many people prefer not to not to explore, not to go
- 8:03to the cosmic street and find evidence for others, because then we can still
- 8:09believe that we are special and unique. But my point is that this will
- 8:16just maintain our ignorance that in fact, it's better to know what is out
- 8:22there, because reality doesn't go away if you ignore it, and then it
- 8:28will change the way we think about ourselves. If we find evidence for others
- 8:31that are perhaps even smarter than us, we can learn from them. If
- 8:37there are dead civilizations out there, then we can learn from their mistakes and
- 8:41not repeat those mistakes, have a better future for ourselves. We got like
- 8:50one hundred questions that have popped up on my head. But do any of
- 8:54the past cases, any of them stand out to you, even mysteries like
- 9:00Area fifty one and any other discoveries that we've heard about, Bob Lasar,
- 9:05anything at all that pops up and says that, really your new discovery of
- 9:09the really collaborates whatever else I saw out there, anything else that stands out
- 9:15for you with respect to unidentified flying objects or other reports here on Earth.
- 9:22I think, rather than focus on documents that are being declassified based on all
- 9:30instruments that were used decades ago, we should really embark on deploying the state
- 9:37of the art instruments in those same sites and checking if there is anything unusual
- 9:43happening there. And then nowadays we can do a much better job because we
- 9:48have better recording devices, both in terms of cameras the audio sensors, and
- 9:54let's just check rather than argue forever about the reality of those previous reports.
- 10:01That's a great point. What are some of the newer technologies that they're using
- 10:05right now, sorry, What are some of the newer technologies that they're using
- 10:09right now that you think are really really helpful in identifying intelligent life. The
- 10:15astronomy community has telescopes and instruments that could potentially search for technological signatures out there.
- 10:26For example, we could search for industrial pollution in the atmospheres of planets
- 10:33around other stars. We could search for swarms of satellites surrounding other planets,
- 10:41for photovoltaic cells covering the day side of planets around other stars, or for
- 10:48artificial lights on the night side. These are things that were not searched for
- 10:52in the past, and that we hope will be searched for in the future,
- 10:56if astronomers will only be open minded to discovering those things rather than placing
- 11:03a taboo on any discussion on the search for technological signatures. Got a couple
- 11:09more questions. Fascinating stuff. Fascinating stuff again, folks. The book has
- 11:13written by doctor Abby Lobe Loe b It's extraterrestrial, the first sign of intelligent
- 11:18life beyond Earth. Doctor Lobe, if you had your chance and they said,
- 11:22doctor Love, you have controlled NASA anything you want, that's all you.
- 11:28What would be some of the first steps you would take going down that
- 11:31cosmic street, as you called it. What would be some of the first
- 11:33things you would do right now? Well, first of all, I would
- 11:39study all the objects that we can identify that enter the Solar System from outside.
- 11:45The situation is similar to going on the beach, and most of the
- 11:48time you see rocks or seashells that were naturally produced, but every now and
- 11:54then you see a plastic bottle that indicates that the civilization is nearby. And
- 12:00so we should engage in a search for all the interstellar objects that enter the
- 12:05Solar System and study their nature. And by study I mean arrange for a
- 12:13spacecraft that can take photographs of these objects from a close by encounter, and
- 12:20that would be one of my first priorities. And then we could also search
- 12:26for technological signatures on planets around stars that are very far away by developing new
- 12:33telescopes, new observatories that can do that. And there is also, of
- 12:39course an interest in searching for primitive life, microbial life, and the one
- 12:46way to do that is by looking at a composition of atmospheres of other exoplanets,
- 12:52and that will be done anyway by the current plans of the astronomy community.
- 13:03But the search for intelligent life is not really at the moment part of
- 13:07the mainstream in astronomy. Good point. I guess my last two questions do
- 13:15you think we've ever been visited by alien that's an interesting question. We don't
- 13:20know if they ever visited. I think that we do not deserve to be
- 13:26visited. I don't think that we're special or unique. I don't think that
- 13:30we are particularly intelligent based on what you read in the news every day,
- 13:35and so I wouldn't be surprised if we are just like ants on a sidewalk
- 13:39that are many like us throughout the galaxy, and we don't deserve any special
- 13:45attention, And so, out of modesty, I would assume that we are
- 13:50not a destination for visits. Maybe they're trying to teach their other children this
- 13:56is what you don't want to be. Thank you here, what not to
- 14:00be like, doctor Lot. But I guess my other question is how did
- 14:03it change you? It's been three years since you saw it. Did it
- 14:07change you at all? And your how you view the world, how you
- 14:11viewed life. Well, this is discovery of course shaped my research, but
- 14:18also changed the way I define my goals in the future in terms of what
- 14:28do I look for and what do I write about? Uh. And then
- 14:33most importantly, it changed the way I perceive the scientific community because it's it's
- 14:41There was a lot of pushback to the suggestion that we may have witnessed a
- 14:46technological relic, and I think that pushback is inappropriate. We should be open
- 14:52minded to this possibility and not put blinders and not put restrictions on this taboo
- 15:01on discussing technological signatures. And I very much hope that by writing this book
- 15:07and by advocating for open mindedness, that my colleagues will in the future allow
- 15:13younger people to explore these possibilities. I agree. I mean, I think
- 15:18it's people should be open minded to certain things so they find out what's really
- 15:22happening right now. Check it out. Now. My last question, I
- 15:26guess would be, we've heard of a lot of different mythical creatures. Some
- 15:31would argue they're not mythical, the bigfoot, walkness monster, But then there's
- 15:35one like the reptilians, right, the reptoids do you think any of these
- 15:39I could think. I know your answer from the earlier comment, But do
- 15:41you think any of these could be alien life forms just trying to spy and
- 15:46see what's going on or anything of that nature. Probably not. And these
- 15:50are different types of animals that we can at least genetically relate to other animals,
- 15:56And it doesn't look like are in terms of their DNA are distinct,
- 16:04So I wouldn't think so. I mean, they just look strange. And
- 16:10of course the animals that we may find on planets around other stars would be
- 16:14even stranger because then most of the stars are actually dwarf stars, much smaller
- 16:18than the Sun, and they are cooler than the Sun is and as a
- 16:25result, you know, they e meet mostly infrared lights. So animals around
- 16:30most of the stars would probably have infrared eyes, very different from the eyes
- 16:34that we have, and they would look weird to us once we find them.
- 16:41But here on Earth, I think there is good evidence that all of
- 16:45the animals that we see are related to each other through the DNA, and
- 16:49nothing looks as if it was planted from another place. What would be your
- 16:55last message? You want everybody to know, you want people take on most
- 17:00importantly, I think science is maintaining your childhood curiosity and being open to the
- 17:07possibility that you will discover something unexpected. And so it's really fun to maintain
- 17:17open mind and open mind to finding new things. And I'm really fortunate to
- 17:23practice science, and I feel that it's a great privilege to perhaps discover that
- 17:30we are not alone and that there might be smarter kids on the block because
- 17:37we can learn from them. Absolutely completely agree. Thank you again, doctor
- 17:42Lote for being very truly appreciate it my pleasure. Thank you for having me
- 17:47folks again. The book fascinating read. I'm telling you right now, actually
- 17:51terrestri the first sign of intelligent life beyond Earth. Look, even if you
- 17:53don't believe it, I think it's got The book's got a great message.
- 17:56I highly recommend it to a great read. Thanks everyone for listening. If
- 18:00we want support our podcasts, make sure to share a subscribe