Latest / The Long for Truth Show / Beyond the Scriptures: Chasing After God's Voice (a Discussion with Chris Rosebrough)
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to the Long for Truth podcast. I'm Robin Long. Join my husband
- 0:06Dan and I as we explore the roots of the early Pentecostal and Charismatic movements,
- 0:11and we shine a light on false doctrines and false teachers in the modern
- 0:15church. Let's get started. The Bible does speak that God speaks through his
- 0:22word, but it never says that God only speaks through his word. Why
- 0:27would God create us with the ability to communicate and then not communicate with us?
- 0:36Okay, again, I don't I'm not trying to put someone down that
- 0:39has that belief, But that's Bologney John Chapter ten, Jesus said, my
- 0:47sheep, hear my voice. Listen to that again. He basically says the
- 0:51default position for anybody who's a part of the fold, the flock, the
- 0:56family of God, what my sheep do is here my voice. God's voice
- 1:00sounds like spontaneous thoughts that light upon your mind while your eyes are fixed in
- 1:06Jesus. But the works of God we want to do, and the works
- 1:10of God are doing what God has shown you to do, doing what God
- 1:15has directed you to do. Rather he's directed you from his word, or
- 1:19rather he's given you what we would term a ram a word which is not
- 1:23necessarily a written word, but it's a word God speaks to your heart that
- 1:27agrees with the spirit of the rest of the Bible. When I want to
- 1:34hear God's voice, when I want to listen for an impression, I want
- 1:38to hear God speak, I need to listen for me. Yes, God
- 1:42speaks through his word, and yes God speaks through his still small voice.
- 1:45But yes, God still speak speaking through burning bush encounters today. Come on.
- 1:49Learning to hear God's voice takes practice. So this is not like you
- 1:53know, you and I sitting on a couch at Starbucks and having conversation.
- 1:57This is a supernatural God, invisible speaking to my internal heart. That is
- 2:02that's going to take practice, but it is possible. And the more you
- 2:07hear his voice, the more you get clear on how God speaks, the
- 2:12more easy it becomes. I've never heard, I must say right up front,
- 2:15I've never heard the audible voice of God. But I get deep what
- 2:20I call deep impressions. The Bible says in John, then not everything is
- 2:23in the word of God, and God still speaks today. Well a person,
- 2:27have you ever been in a relationship with It doesn't speak. So,
- 2:30yes, God speaks through his word, and God speaks through people still today,
- 2:32regardless of what the man made false doctrine you've created that says God no
- 2:37longer speaks. That's bologney. Hello everyone, welcome along for truth. My
- 2:42name is Daniel Long. So when you open up the scriptures and you read
- 2:46them, you are reading the very words of God. You are actually hearing
- 2:53the very voice of God when you are reading the scriptures. But there are
- 2:59many people today, many Christians, who think that they need more. They
- 3:04think that they need some kind of direct revelation from God in order to really
- 3:12know that God is speaking to them. So today we're gonna be talking about
- 3:15that topic and joining me is Pastor Chris rose Barrow. Pastor Chris Roseborow is
- 3:22the pastor of Kong's Finger Lutheran Church in Oslo, Minnesolda. Did I say
- 3:27that right? Minnesota, Minnesolta. He's also the host of the Fighting for
- 3:32the Faith YouTube channel and podcast. Chris, thank you so much for joining
- 3:37me today. Thanks for having me on Dan. All right, So,
- 3:40this desire for direct revelation or hearing the voice of God from script and you
- 3:46know, instead of from hearing it from scripture has kind of permeated the church,
- 3:53and in my opinion, many Christians who say that they need more than
- 3:58the Bible or they need to hear God directly, are actually elevating experience over
- 4:05the Bible. Would you agree with that? I completely agree. In fact,
- 4:11it's that's exactly what is happening here. And in my experience as somebody
- 4:15who's been critiquing many charismatics now for going on, you know, a couple
- 4:21of decades now publicly, I would note that I've listened to many a sermon
- 4:27by people in the charismatic movement who legitimately talk down got word, uh,
- 4:31you know, talk about it in such terms it's it's like yesterday's revelation.
- 4:36It's it's it's a stale word from God and they need fresh revelation and think
- 4:43this. And I've even heard people say that if you're not hearing the voice
- 4:46of God, you should question whether or not you're even saved. If you
- 4:49don't know the vice of God, you're not saved. H you know that
- 4:54That's how I seen this go. Yeah, I've I've heard the same thing.
- 4:59So there's a guy by the name of Mark Verkler, have you ever
- 5:00heard of him? Oh yeah, yeah, all right. So Mark Verkler
- 5:08is the author of this book for Keys to Hearing God's Voice. He's also
- 5:13the what he calls the president and founder of Communion with God Ministries. I
- 5:18want to show you a clip by Mark Erkler, and I just want to
- 5:21get your input on it, okay, And if you need to stop,
- 5:27just say stop and we'll we'll stop and we can comment. Okay, all
- 5:32right, Here we go. Hunger to hear God's voice? And I didn't
- 5:38know how to hear his voice. I read the Bible through and didn't seem
- 5:42to teach me how to hear his voice. And it's because I was reading
- 5:45it improperly because I didn't really know how to read it. I was reading
- 5:47it as my culture taught me to read it. Here we go. So
- 5:53note if you said that ironically, right, Yeah, he read the Bible
- 5:57all the way through, yep, and and he still didn't hear God's voice.
- 6:01He was hearing God's voice all along the way. And the fact that
- 6:08he said what he said on ironically just is so ridiculous. But the second
- 6:12issue there is that what he said is actually quite critical. He said that
- 6:17nowhere in the Bible, did he read instructions on how to hear God's voice.
- 6:23That's an important thing because you can read the Bible from Genesis all the
- 6:27way to the Book of Maps, and you're not going to hear any instruction
- 6:30on how to hear God's voice. And in order for a doctrine to be
- 6:34a biblical doctrine, it has to be explicitly taught in the scriptures. So,
- 6:39for instance, we believe in the doctrine of the deity of Christ,
- 6:43and the reason why we do is because there are so many texts that clearly
- 6:46say that Jesus is God, and as a we have that established fact.
- 6:53But nowhere in the Bible are you going to hear Well, Erkler is the
- 6:57guy who's promoting these four steps to hearing God's voice. Nowhere in the scripture
- 7:01are you going to find those four steps laid out you. Step one,
- 7:04you know, get into the lotus position. Step two, you know your
- 7:08mind or weird things like this, right you, Nowhere in the Bible are
- 7:12you given those instructions. So, on the face of it, this isn't
- 7:16a biblical teaching that He's giving. And the irony here is thick. If
- 7:21you know your Bible. But if you don't know your Bible, this guy's
- 7:25going to sound like, you know, wow, this is making sense,
- 7:27but no, in fact, he's contradicting the scriptures left right in the center.
- 7:30Yeah wow, which was to take my mind and apply it to the
- 7:33word. But what the Bible really says is take your heart and apply it
- 7:38to the world word. Let your heart instruct your mind, and let your
- 7:42heart teach your mind, because out of the heart flows the issues of life.
- 7:45But I didn't know anything about my heart or how to define it,
- 7:47and so I didn't know how to let my heart teach my mind. So
- 7:49when I read the Bible, here's the issue of the heart. It's deceitful
- 7:54and desperately wicked above all things. So to let your heart dictate what the
- 7:59scriptures are supposed to be telling you rather than what the text itself says is
- 8:03a very dangerous thing. Yep. And this and this is all part of
- 8:07like the main culture of Pentecostalism in the Charismatic movement is the constant reinforcement that
- 8:13that there is a difference between head knowledge and heart knowledge, and head knowledge
- 8:18is looked at with suspicion and is considered to be dangerous. It leads to,
- 8:24you know, doctrines and doctrines divide, whereas you know, the heart
- 8:28is all about the feelings and the experience. But here's the issue, is
- 8:33that Scripture explicitly says that we are to worship the Lord, our God with
- 8:37all of our heart, soul, mind and strength. Christ says to the
- 8:41woman at the well in Samaria, those who worship the Father will worship him
- 8:46in spirit and in truth. And so you'll know that you don't get one
- 8:50without the other. And when you put your feelings in the lead, you've
- 8:54got a big problem. And that is and you're turning off your brain.
- 8:58And reality is is that there's always like a law of diminishing returns when it
- 9:03comes to like feelings and chasing after them, because always the question is how
- 9:07is this supposed to make me feel? But the reality is is that when
- 9:13you read the Bible correctly, and you read it through, you know,
- 9:16and actually let the narratives speak to you, you can't help but have an
- 9:20emotional reaction to many of the stories. I always like to say that the
- 9:24Book of Ruth is like the best chick flick in all of the scripture,
- 9:28and I can't read Ruth without a little bit of mist coming out of my
- 9:33eyes at the end. It's just so awesome. But I don't turn off
- 9:37my mind. Instead, my mind then stirs up the emotions of my heart.
- 9:43And so this, this, this psychotomy, the account of my heart
- 9:46has to instruct me. I would say he's probably twisting that text. And
- 9:50my question is which which church denomination just tells you just read it with cold
- 9:56intellect and with no emotion at all. I don't know that. I don't
- 10:00know that denomination at all. Yeah, it's just theology. There was no
- 10:05revelation knowledge. When the people disciples in the Amas road hurt Jesus unfold the
- 10:11scripture, they said, did not our hearts burn within us? But and
- 10:15the irony there is that Jesus was unfolding the scriptures to the opening up their
- 10:22minds so that they wouldn't understand the Bible right. And I would note that
- 10:26the Nord of Amais begins with these guys really being upset and sad and desponded,
- 10:31and Jesus holds their eyes. The Greek there it says he held their
- 10:35eyes that they wouldn't recognize him, and he says, one of these things
- 10:37that you're discussing, and they are you the only person from Jerusalem that doesn't
- 10:41know what's going on? He goes, well, what things they said?
- 10:45Well about Jesus of Nazareth, we had hoped that he was, had hoped
- 10:48that he was the messiah that one promised to come, but they crucified him,
- 10:52and now we got reports that they're saying that he rose from the dead.
- 10:56They don't know how to sort all this out. And just Jesus,
- 10:58how slow of heart to believe that all that is written in the scriptures,
- 11:03he says. And so he walks them through this beautiful Bible study, beginning
- 11:09with Moses and all the prophets, showing all the texts regarding himself. And
- 11:13so he gave them a great theology lesson, and that theology lesson led to
- 11:18emotion and emotional reaction, but also with the mind engaged again false dichotomy,
- 11:24split mind and heart. Yep, it was opening scripture to us. And
- 11:28I didn't have that burning sensation. I didn't have the Holy Spirit opening scripture
- 11:31because I didn't pray over it. I didn't know I was supposed to.
- 11:37I finally found defesions one seventeen and eighteen. I prayed that the eyes of
- 11:39your heart, say eyes of your heart, eyes of your heart would be
- 11:43enlightened. Say that would see you know, I missed that prayer, and
- 11:48I went through a Bible college without praying, and I prayed that the eyes
- 11:50of my heart would be enlightened, that I might know hunger to hear voice?
- 11:56What's that so long? And then you know verse Claire looks old like
- 12:01me? So I mean when we were younger, open the eyes of my
- 12:05heart little yeah, come off? Yeah, you never heard that, right,
- 12:09right? So that was Mark Verkler. And so as we move forward,
- 12:18Chris, I want to show a couple of more clips here. But
- 12:20there are some passages of scripture that a lot of Christians who desire for that
- 12:28extra biblical revelation like to use. One of those verses is John ten twenty
- 12:33seven. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them and they follow
- 12:37me. Do you want to take some time and just open up your Bible
- 12:41program and talk to us about that verse? So, first of all,
- 12:46where if we go to the text itself, so we're in Mark ten,
- 12:50sorry, John ten, John ten, I want to point something out to
- 12:52you. In John ten, Jesus says, and this is, you know,
- 12:58kind of a continuation what's going on. In Chapter nine, Jesus is
- 13:01going after the Pharisees. He says, truly, truly, I say to
- 13:03you, he who does not enter the sheep fold by the door, but
- 13:07climbs in by another way, that man is a thief and a robber.
- 13:11Okay, so no, we got a thief and a robber. He's talking
- 13:13about the Pharisees. But he who enters by the door is the shepherd of
- 13:18the sheep. To him, the gatekeeper opens. The sheep hear his voice,
- 13:22and he calls his own sheep by name and leads them out. When
- 13:26he has brought out all his own, he goes before them, and the
- 13:28sheep follow him, for they know his voice a stranger. They will not
- 13:33follow, but they will flee from him, for they do not know the
- 13:37voice of strangers. And then watch what they said this figure of speech Jesus
- 13:43used with them. So Jesus here is speaking in a figure of speech.
- 13:48And it's true his sheep hear his voice. But I would throw into the
- 13:52mix then, like something like Luke ten sixteen, Jesus talking about his disciples,
- 13:58he says, the one who hears you hears me. The one who
- 14:01rejects you rejects me. The one who rejects me rejects him who sent me.
- 14:07And so when the charismatic or Pentecostal reads to John Tennants as well,
- 14:11that means we need to hear hear the voice of Jesus. That number one,
- 14:15the text says it's a figure of speech, so it's not talking about
- 14:18hearing the literal voice of Christ. In Christ and other passages makes it clear
- 14:22that in order to hear his voice, one needs to hear his disciples.
- 14:28And so I would note that Jesus didn't write any books while he was here
- 14:31on planet Earth. And we have no recordings none whatsoever of Jesus that appeared
- 14:37on the ancient version of TikTok. As a result of it, we have
- 14:43we have no record of what his voice sounds like at all. And uh
- 14:48and and even what he looks like. You know, you have to die
- 14:50and you know to see that. But all that being said, I can
- 14:54say definitively I've heard the voice of Christ every day for decade because in the
- 15:01scriptures and I hear his voice specifically in the Gospel text, and then throughout
- 15:09all of scripture, because all scripture is God breath, they aneustas, and
- 15:11it's profitable for teaching. In fact, let me show you that tech real
- 15:15quick too, while we're at it. If we go to a second Timothy
- 15:18chapter three, you'll note here a little bit of of some context. Timothy.
- 15:26Second Timothy is the last of Paul's letters. He's about to die,
- 15:31and so he's writing this letter to a young pastor who pastors of congregation in
- 15:37the city of Ephesus. His name is Timothy, and he is reminding him
- 15:43that in the last days that there will that people will be lovers of self,
- 15:46lovers of money, proud, arrogant, abuse of disobedient to their parents,
- 15:50ungrateful, unholy, heartless, unappeasable, slanders without self control, brutal,
- 15:54not loving the good, treacherous, reckless, swollen with conceite, lovers
- 15:58of pleasure rather than verse of God. He's describing Trinity Broadcasting Network to that
- 16:03before it appeared, right, and so note then he says, this is
- 16:08kind of Paul's parting shot. You, however, you followed my teaching,
- 16:12my conduct, my aim in life, my faith, my patience, my
- 16:17love, my steadfastness, my persecutions and sufferings which that happened to me at
- 16:22antiochy Conium and Listra, with persecutions I endured. Yet from all of these
- 16:26the Lord rescue me. Indeed, all who desire a godly life in Christ
- 16:30Jesus will be persecuted. I've never heard Jelostin preach on that text. While
- 16:37evil people and impostors will go on from bad to worse, deceiving and being
- 16:41deceived. So we got all kinds of deception and nastiness going on. But
- 16:45watch this but day you as for you, you continue in what you have
- 16:51learned. And I firmly believe, knowing from whom you learned it, and
- 16:55how from childhood you've been acquainted with the sacred writings Gramata right, the scripture
- 17:03which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus.
- 17:07And then we get this text that we're all familiar with. All scripture graf
- 17:11is breathed out by God and is profitable for teaching, for reproof, for
- 17:18correction, and for training and righteousness. And watch this next part so that
- 17:22the man of God may be complete and equipped for every good work. You
- 17:29and I as Christians are absolutely incomplete without the scriptures. And what is it
- 17:33that completes us. It's the Bible. This is what jointing us to and
- 17:38we are equipped for how many of the works that God is going to have
- 17:41us do? Answer every single one of them. And so, Paul,
- 17:48it is as parting shot as like hit your nose in the book and keep
- 17:52it in the book, keep preaching the book. In fact, he goes
- 17:53on to say, so I charge you in the presence of God and of
- 17:56Christ Jesus, who's the judge living in the dead and is a hearing in
- 18:00his kingdom, preach what the word the right. I'm talking about direct revelations,
- 18:07you know when you know from kat Kerr after her you know, latest
- 18:10trip to Heaven. We're talking about sacred writings. That's what's in the context.
- 18:15Be ready in an out of season reprove, rebuke, can exhort with
- 18:18complete patients and at did okay, you can translate that as doctrine for the
- 18:23time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching or doctrine, but having
- 18:29itching ears, they look humulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions and
- 18:33they'll turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths. I
- 18:40think that that's pretty much the day we live in right now, don't you.
- 18:42Yes, I do, so do yeah, And so I would note
- 18:48that that you'll know that Paul's final shot is listen to the word. Peter
- 18:52does the same thing. Second Peter, you know, and points everybody to
- 18:56the Word. Notice what he didn't say, now here are the four steps
- 19:00to hearing the voice of God. So make sure that this is going to
- 19:03illuminate your path and so that you can hear God's voice moving forward. He
- 19:07makes it clear that all scriptures say a news to us that's God breathed.
- 19:11And so you'll note the Holy Spirit is intimately involved in not only the writing
- 19:15of the scripture, but the author of Hebrew says the Word is living and
- 19:19active, sharper than a double edged sword. Right, So all of that
- 19:23being the case, you'll know that God, the Holy Spirit is intimately linked
- 19:27with the scriptures and this other stuff. Yeah, not so much, not
- 19:34so much. Lets one final, one final text? Can we do that?
- 19:40I gave you a couple of them, but we're kind of running a
- 19:42little bit behind. So I'm gonna I hear first kings, wait a minute,
- 19:47what no, Second Chronicles, twenty twenty. And they rose early in
- 19:51the morning and went out into the wilderness of Takoa. And when they went
- 19:52out, Josephat stood and said, hear me, Judah an inhabitants of Jerusalem,
- 19:57believe in the Lord your God, in you will be to established.
- 20:00Believe his prophets, and you will succeed. And here I hear that all
- 20:07the time, you know, believe the prophets, and you'll even hear.
- 20:14And the clip that we look at with Tony Evans say something similar to that.
- 20:18Right, here's your problem. And the problem is is that that is
- 20:23still a historical narrative, and it happens to come in the context of a
- 20:30great trial to the people of Jerusalem, Jehosaphat being the king of of you
- 20:37of Jerusalem at the time. And and as a result of it, he's
- 20:41offered up a prayer in the early part of Second Chronicles chapter twenty, basically
- 20:47calling on God and saying, you know a great multitude is coming, is
- 20:52coming against you from Eden, from beyond the sea, and behold they are
- 20:55in Haza zonne Tamar. That is Angetti and then Jehosaphat was a fraid and
- 21:00said his face to seek Yahweh and proclaimed to fast about all of Judah,
- 21:03and Judah assembled to seek help from Yahweh. From all the cities of Judah,
- 21:07they came to seek Yahweh. So at this point Jehosah Phat he has
- 21:11everybody pray and uh, and he gets a word back uh, you know
- 21:17afterwards as to what was going to happen and uh. And he basically told
- 21:22the people, believe what the prophets said, and you will succeed in what
- 21:26in what is coming in in the resolve of the actual conflict, the resolve
- 21:33of the of the of the thing that Jehosah Phat needed to pray for.
- 21:38So this isn't some kind of an ongoing and every one of you, you
- 21:42need to believe the prophets, and then we need modern day prophets giving us
- 21:47fresh revelation. I would note that I actually do listen to the prophets,
- 21:52and I do believe them, h like Prophet Jeremiah or Isaiah or Amos or
- 21:57Zachariah know. So I do listen to the prophets. But this is not
- 22:02some kind of a command that's telling me that we need to have profits today.
- 22:06And I would note that I happen to have lived and was a charismatic
- 22:11at the time when God supposedly re established prophets back in the late nineteen eighties.
- 22:18And and you ask any any charismatic living in the eighties, you know,
- 22:22back then, were there any prophets on the earth? No? What
- 22:25happened, Well, they disappeared after the you know, somewhere in the around
- 22:29the second century, and then God reestablished them. That was, you know,
- 22:33that was all part of like the third wave of the charismatic movement,
- 22:36was the reestablishing of the of the prophets, and then you know, later
- 22:38the re establishing of the apostles. But in my day, nobody, you
- 22:44know, when you know, when I was younger, nobody was talking about
- 22:45the ongoing prophets of Christianity. In fact, if you want to write a
- 22:49really short book that you can you can title it the Great Profits of the
- 22:55tenth, eleventh, and twelfth century. Oh man, All right, So,
- 23:03Chris, this next clip that I'm going to show you is by a
- 23:07woman and I'm and I don't know if I'm pronouncing her name right, but
- 23:10own you own Michelle on Onara Onara. I think that's how you say it.
- 23:15It's really difficult, all right. So this is her website, Chris,
- 23:19and look at the little caption there right next to her picture. The
- 23:25prophetic listening method is an advanced is that modality of spiritual direction that focuses on
- 23:33discerning God's voice and God's will for very specific matters and a believer's life and
- 23:42then if you go through it. Yeah, yeah, she this is a
- 23:45whole kind of school thing for her. And of course, of course it
- 23:49costs, it's not free. But but but anyway, this is a video
- 23:55we were talking about profits. This is the cell phone profit Seants with Michelle
- 24:02here. So let's take a look at this and then I'll get your comments
- 24:06on this. With prophetic listening, we help our clients discover their listening styles.
- 24:11Some people hear him telepathically, other people here or we call it still
- 24:15small voice in the church as you know, Yeah, that was another verse
- 24:21I'm gonna take a look at. Was the still small Voice of God,
- 24:23but telepathically And she says that now we don't call it telepathically or telepathic.
- 24:30We call it the still small Voice of God. Oh, yeah grief.
- 24:34Okay, yeah, here we go. Other people hear him through music.
- 24:38I hear him through lyrics to songs. Sometimes other people get images. And
- 24:44so whatever their style is or multiple styles, we help them discover that and
- 24:48then we tackle the specific questions with them, and so they have a safe
- 24:53zone and space to hear the Lord speak. We get rid of any type
- 24:59of demonic or counterfeit spirits that would try to infiltrate that time, so that
- 25:04they know when they're listening, they can listen competently and just write down whatever
- 25:08they're receiving. And then we come together and we compare. Okay, so
- 25:14automatic not really automatic writing well kind of right, you know, you're listening
- 25:18and then you're writing down what you're receiving. Yeah. Wow, pretty creepy
- 25:25stuff. And and this guy, you know, Sean Bolls, he's pretty
- 25:29popular in the the New Apostolic Reformation and anyone, all right, okay,
- 25:36what did you hear? This is what I heard? All right? What
- 25:37does that look like for you? To be an obedience and see the fruit
- 25:42of what God is trying to trying to tell you and instruct you? So
- 25:47well, that's interesting because it really is like you're you're helping, do not
- 25:51necessarily the interpretive to bring steps to it so that there's no beings pross because
- 25:55I feel like every time God speaks, it's like Jesus is up and having
- 25:57going on. They're gonna listen, are they gonna you know? Like he
- 26:00so much and it's like that when you help. One of my favorite jobs
- 26:04is to do exactly what you're saying. I feel like you're doing it as
- 26:07a as a service to the body of Christ and beyond. And I what
- 26:11I find myself and I volunteer countless hours this where I sit down with friends
- 26:15who and they always have excuse like my wife's the prophetic one or my friend
- 26:18down those three they had a vision once and I'm like, no, no,
- 26:21no, it's just because you're not focused on how you hear God.
- 26:23So like, let's go into there's He'd wired you for this, He's created
- 26:26you for this, And it's so beautiful to watch people because once there's a
- 26:30few moments where they get their listening styles. You would say, and I
- 26:33like that you would use the word telepathic because that word was similar to what
- 26:37Paul said that he used the word that we now drive. Let me back
- 26:41that up just a little bit so you can hear that. Yeah, yeah,
- 26:45let me back it up just a little bit here, use the word
- 26:49telepathic because that word was similar to what Paul said. He used the word
- 26:55that we now drive psychics from, unfortunately, but basically was this place of
- 26:59it's another sense that's beyond, it's a spiritual sense. And unfortunately that new
- 27:03age and that, you know, the different movements of taking these words and
- 27:07branded them and like all of a sudden, we can't have them anymore because
- 27:10the church is afraid, you know, versus. Actually, the majority of
- 27:12the way God speaks it's through impressions within and through speaking to us through it
- 27:17could be a verbal image or or a picture image, or a sense or
- 27:19a feeling. And we need to learn all these because it's all biblical.
- 27:22It's all there, all right. So there's a lot to talk about there.
- 27:27Yeah. So the apostle go ahead, is how lame this God is?
- 27:33Yeah? Yea, because number one, this modality is nowhere taught in
- 27:38scripture. How come she's charging money to teach it? That mean my question?
- 27:42And then how that God is talking? And I can't figure out if
- 27:47that's the voice of God or a piece of undigested anchovies from the bad pizza
- 27:52I had last night. That's speaking to me, how you know, because
- 27:55you're going to note that the deity that they're that they are believing in the
- 28:00spirit that they are believing in, speaks, but we are not capable of
- 28:06knowing that he's speaking. This is Isn't that odd? You know? Go
- 28:11back into the archives of Fighting for the Faith recently did an interview with the
- 28:17Peaches on open theism. The God of the Naar is an open theist god.
- 28:22Uh, you know, he is completely powerless, doesn't know the future
- 28:27and all this kind of stuff. And so for years, I you know,
- 28:30I had a character on the Fighting for the Faith podcast. We called
- 28:33him Vincent. He was he was the Holy Spirit. He would say,
- 28:40Hi, this is the Holy Spirit, and I need some help because you
- 28:45know, you know the world is so complicated and stuff, and I'm talking
- 28:48and nobody's listening, and I'm trying to figure out how to get people to
- 28:52listen to me. And so if you could like to teach them some modality
- 28:56that would then make possible to determine you know, at the idea here,
- 29:00Okay, this is nonsense because in the beginning of the book. And in
- 29:07Genesis one one, God said, let there be light, and there was
- 29:10light. Right. The university said there going, Well, you know,
- 29:12that's not my listening style, so I'm not really sure, you know.
- 29:17Yeah, And and the thing is, Chris, if God is gonna speak,
- 29:21like if you look at the prophets in the Old Testament, you look
- 29:23at how God speaks our God, God spoke to his apostles in the New
- 29:27Testament. They didn't have to try to figure this stuff out. Here's four
- 29:33ways we can listen here, let's see what. Well, John, what's
- 29:37your listening style, because my listening style is you know what I'm saying,
- 29:41it's like, it's it's it's it's mind boggling. That. And so you
- 29:47notice again that she charges for these things, you know, and this is
- 29:52all it looks like to me, that it's all a money thing. Yeah,
- 29:56yeah, you're not wrong. These people exploit people in there greed.
- 29:59I would, I would, I would kind of point this out. There
- 30:02is an actual prophecy by a fellow by the name of Baalim. If you
- 30:04heard of bail him and his daughter. I have heard of bail him.
- 30:07You go into your old Testament, and you read the account of Balim Baalim
- 30:11was a wicked man. I mean, as he was paid money to curse
- 30:15Israel and and and so, you know, they had set up this ritual.
- 30:19He he was kind of a prophet for profit. He was a guy
- 30:23you need a blessing or a curse, I'm your guy, the money kind
- 30:26of stuff. And I killed you not you know, he went to go
- 30:30curse Israel. But then he invoked the God of Israel and Jesus showed up.
- 30:36I say Jesus because it's a it's a pre incarnate appearance of the Son
- 30:40of God. And and basically tells him you're a dead man if you'd say
- 30:45anything other than the actual words I give you. He had never been to
- 30:48you know, a single Jennifer Leclair profit school with the prophet. He was
- 30:53the guy charging people money for you for prophetic activations and stuff. And he
- 30:57legitimately heard voice of God. Wicked man, and he ended up giving some
- 31:03wonderful prophecies regarding Christ. And you know, one of the things that we
- 31:08know about God, God doesn't lie. That's part of because of a prophecy
- 31:12that he gave that's recorded in the Torah. And and yet you know,
- 31:17you'll know, this wicked evil fellow never really uh you know, understood.
- 31:22You know, he didn't learn his modality and different listening style. God showed
- 31:26up talking to him and made it clear, you're gonna say only the words
- 31:30I give you to give. If God is going to speak to you,
- 31:34he is just going to speak to you. You're gonna hear him. You're
- 31:37gonna you know, he's just gonna boom, right, You're gonna know.
- 31:41You're not gonna have to look see was that God? Or was that Let's
- 31:45see what you know? Let's see. I gotta open up the marks book
- 31:48here and see if I can see which key I've got to look at to
- 31:52see if this is God. God is gonna speak You're gonna know it,
- 31:56right. And I know there are great accounts like you of the guy who
- 32:00was sent to baptize the Saul of Tarsus. Okay, he's just been blinded
- 32:05by God. He's been you know, in Damascus for three days, completely
- 32:07blinded. And I kid you not the way the text reads. You know,
- 32:12Christ, you know, spoke to Ananias and immediately Antonius knew exactly who
- 32:17he was talking to. Now, what's funny we went The text that they're
- 32:22always going to go to is at the beginning of First Samuel, where Samuel
- 32:25as a young boy, he's sleeping in the Holy of Holies, which he's
- 32:30not supposed to do, and God, God shows up to talk to him
- 32:34could basically begin commissioning him as a prophet. And when God spoke to him,
- 32:39he didn't recognize that it was God talking. He thought it was Samuel.
- 32:44That's the only thing that made sense, and so he he went.
- 32:46He went several times to Samuel, said you know, what is it that
- 32:51you need? You know, you know, and Samuel, uh, you
- 32:54know. Basically the high priest basically told him, you know, listen.
- 32:59If he's to you again, say speak Lord, your servant, listens.
- 33:02But the reason why it was imperative that at that point that Samuel, this
- 33:07young boy, wasn't really aware that he was hearing the voice of God,
- 33:10is because God was about to speak a judgment prophecy against Eli and his sons
- 33:16because of their wickedness and the wickedness that He permitted to be taking place at
- 33:21the at the Tabernacle. And so you know, God made it, made
- 33:24it happen in such a way that the recipient of the of the words of
- 33:29Judgment knew that God was the one speaking it. And so you know that
- 33:32that's that's like the one rare exception. And uh, and it happens,
- 33:37happens to be in partly in the way in which God chose to reveal himself
- 33:43to Samuel and then begin to call him as a prophet. But that's your
- 33:45only case where you have somebody who was confused as to the identity of the
- 33:50person who was speaking when God spoke. Well, you're absolutely alright, Chris.
- 33:54And that that's that that is the thing that has always puzzled me.
- 34:00If you have to figure out how God is speaking, how do you even
- 34:07know it's God at all? You know, the only surefire way is to
- 34:12open up God's word and to read. That's how we know for sure that
- 34:15God is speaking to us. I've never opened a Biblical text and go,
- 34:19I wonder if this is God talking to right? Right, exactly every time
- 34:24I've I've read the Bible, I know that God is speaking to me.
- 34:29And and I even begin to tell you how many times while I've been reading
- 34:32a Biblical text like following just like a standard plan like I'm going to read,
- 34:37you know, the Old Testament, and I'm going to do this in
- 34:38a few months or whatever. The text that I'm reading that day, Holy
- 34:43smokes. It's like God was reading my emails and new exactly I needed to
- 34:47hear and it was a timely word and it's like, oh, thank you
- 34:52God. And other times when I've been wrestling and struggling with things, God
- 34:55has spoken his law to me from his word and just held me on the
- 35:00spot. I can't even as as a pastor. One of the things I
- 35:04experienced from time to time is after delivering a sermon, someone coming up to
- 35:08me and going, oh, man, it's like you've been living in my
- 35:10house with me and you have like a hidden camera on me, because that
- 35:15sermon just spoke directly to me. And I always when it happen, as
- 35:19I sit there and call all I did was preach to the text. You
- 35:22know. It's like, but that's the thing, you know, you know
- 35:27what God's word does stuff in, you know, and when it's litimately preached
- 35:31and rightly taught, it's going to convict people of their sin. It's going
- 35:35to comfort them of the assurance of the forgiveness that they have in Christ.
- 35:38And you'll note that the scriptures are full of wisdom. Then two that take
- 35:43us from foolishness in our sin to bearing the fruit of the spirit and living
- 35:47in true wisdom. And read the Book of Proverbs, and and you'll know
- 35:52that what Paul wrote under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, it's gonna make
- 35:55us complete. We are incomplete without it. We are completed with it.
- 36:00And buy it and it's going to prepare us for everything. And the person
- 36:05who poo, who's the word of God? That's a person who never is
- 36:08reading it anyway. Yeah, yeah, all right. Let me ask you
- 36:13this, Chris, are you ready to hear from Stephen Furdick? S?
- 36:20All right, let's let's watch this clip by Stephen Furdick. I didn't have
- 36:24time to put this word in the sermon. It starts with the letter C,
- 36:27so it could be a bonus point confirmation. God. God will speak
- 36:30something over here, over here, over here, and you'll start noticing it.
- 36:32You'll start noticing little things, and then it'll you hear it in the
- 36:36sermon, and then you hear it in a movie, and then you hear
- 36:38it in a song, and then you hear it you'll see it on somebody's
- 36:40the back of their window, and then you hear it through. He's describing
- 36:45omens. That's exactly what I was going to ask you. I was gonna
- 36:49stop it and ask you that that sounds like omens to me. That omens.
- 36:52That's legitimately forbidden by scripture. You are not to listen to omens.
- 36:58And so this, you know, so God has spoke to and you connected
- 37:00here and you're watching a movie and all of a sudden there's say, oh,
- 37:04that's that's that's the reading of omens, and we are forbidden by God's
- 37:07word to do that. Wow, your your husband, and then you hear
- 37:10it through and you just see it, just hear it, and you start
- 37:14seeing it and you start hearing, and then you have to discern, which
- 37:16is to separate. That's what Eli did. He discerned, hebreward his being.
- 37:21He discerned, he separated, He made a distinction. He had a
- 37:22discernment to know this is the Lord. So he's in the passage there,
- 37:30I believe what you were just talking about in where Samuel was in the temple
- 37:34and he's, uh, you know, and he hears the voice of God
- 37:37while he's sleeping as a child. Yeah, but focus wrong character, you
- 37:42know, Eli discerned, So what it's this? This is not some kind
- 37:47of of an omen going on here. It's the repeated pattern of Samuel's showing
- 37:52up saying you spoke to me, I'm here, what you know? What
- 37:55is it that you want? That he finally realized, Okay, something more
- 37:59is going on here. And it was imperative that Eli know what's going on
- 38:01because God spoke words of prophetic judgment against Eli and his son's a Hafni and
- 38:07Phineas, and so God wanted to make sure that Eli knew he was chatting.
- 38:15He was, he was gonna he was having a conversation with Samuel,
- 38:17because Samuel was going to be prophetically speaking God's judgment against him. M Pauline
- 38:23the boy. So he said, when when it happens again, and this
- 38:28is the word of the Lord for you, when it happens again. When
- 38:31it happens again, if it happens again, just say speak Lord. Your
- 38:36servant is listening. And I want to show you something that the Lord just
- 38:40showed me. His greatest revelation happened in rest. So I guess Samuel's greatest
- 38:49revelation happened or Eli, Yes, Samuel's when it happened while he was resting,
- 38:55and this the Lord just revealed that to Stephen Verdick. Wow, whoa
- 39:00yeah right there in the service that that's just nonsense, just complete goblety gook.
- 39:07And not only that, it's you know, always and again they're trying
- 39:09basically reading these biblical texts. You know that, so we got historical narratives
- 39:14and they're trying to find applications, so this them becomes a prescriptive text.
- 39:19God's going to talk to you the same way. You know, you're gonna
- 39:21piece it all together the way Eli did. No, that is not what's
- 39:27going on, and that's not how we hear God's voice. In fact,
- 39:30I would note that if you pay attention to scripture, uh, you know
- 39:36Daniel's seventy weeks read Daniel nine, the seventy weeks are fulfilled and and God
- 39:42makes it clear in the interpretation. He gave the angel Gabriel that it during
- 39:46the seventy weeks that God would seal up prophecy prophecies sealed. You know,
- 39:52there are no are no prophets today. Nobody who is legitimately a prophet that
- 40:00the prophecy itself has been sealed at the completion of the of the seventy weeks,
- 40:05which is why there were no profits from the from the time of the
- 40:07Apostolic era until today. Because today's prophets they are the ones prophesied by Christ
- 40:15as the false prophets that would be permeating the church immediately before his return.
- 40:20But there were you know, there were no prophets in the eighth century,
- 40:22the ninth century, the tenth, eleventh, twelfth, and thirteenth there were
- 40:27no prophets okay, and there in fact, when I was growing up,
- 40:30nobody talked about prophets today because everybody believed that the prophets had ceased. And
- 40:37so you know, people come along today claiming that, you know, they're
- 40:39getting these direct revelations and that they are continuationists. They are they have rewritten
- 40:45history and h And you know, the thing is is that guys like me
- 40:50who live that history, we know for a fact from our experience that nobody
- 40:53was talking this way back in the eighties. No one was eli didn't say,
- 41:01oh, that may be God, you better run out and catch him
- 41:06before he leaves. Well, if God spoke to you better chase him down.
- 41:09No, if it was God speaking, he'll come back. All you
- 41:14got to do is be in position for it. That's all you've got to
- 41:16do. You don't have to yep. And the position that you have to
- 41:22be in is any position. Really, as long as you are opening up
- 41:25the Bible and you were holding it, you can be sitting in your easy
- 41:28chair, you can be listening to it in your car, you can be
- 41:32you know, sitting at your desk. As long as you were reading the
- 41:36scripture. It doesn't matter what position you're in. You're hearing the voice of
- 41:38God. This is nonsense, I mean, and verdict is the king of
- 41:44the narcissistic Isogese. He's a narcoge and and he's he's he's literally reading stuff
- 41:50into this text that is not there at which go to a way of twisting
- 41:54scripture. And this is not a descript a prescript of text. It is
- 42:00not telling us that we need to get into some kind of position in order
- 42:04to hear the voice of God. This is not normative for us. In
- 42:07fact, if you read the Bible from cover to cover, you'll note that
- 42:12God's voice is not consistent throughout the history of Israel. And the history of
- 42:17the of the scriptures, you know, and in fact, prophets were pretty
- 42:22rare, uh and and you know, and you know, and and hearing
- 42:28the voice of God was also a rarity, which is part of the reason
- 42:30why these things got written down. And because when God spoke, you collect
- 42:36those words up. That's why, that's why we have the Bible. Yeah,
- 42:39it's just it seems like a whole lot of work to me. You
- 42:43know, I have to nowly see okay, I have to discern all right,
- 42:47was that me? Was that God? Okay, so let me go
- 42:51back. I can't remember what are the keys? You know what I mean.
- 42:53It just seems like all of this nonsensical work when you could just be
- 42:59opening up the Bible and saying, God just spoke to me because I just
- 43:04read from the scriptures his very words. But the other thing is the person
- 43:09who's in the scriptures, and they immediately know this stuff is counterfeit. They
- 43:14just know because you know, when when you are when you are exposed to
- 43:19the scriptures rightly taught in in large quantities. I mean this it literally,
- 43:24you know, like inoculates you against these types of diseases, you know,
- 43:29and you know, palls teachers. Yep, yep. All right, so
- 43:32let's switch gears real quick. Well we're not really switching gears, but let's
- 43:36talk about the ram A word versus the Lagoffs word. Okay, Robin and
- 43:42I this entire video on this, but I want to get your take on
- 43:45it. So I've got a very popular evangelical pastor by the name of Tony
- 43:50Evans. I'm sure you've heard of him, and he's going to talk about
- 43:55the difference between the ram A word and the Lagoffs So can I play the
- 44:00clip for you? Sure? All? Are you ready? Here we go?
- 44:02Oh yeah. There is the graffe. The graffe is the book.
- 44:07It is as it sits on your shelf, on your coffee table. It
- 44:12is the written, recorded word of God. That's the grafe. Then there
- 44:16is the logos. The logos is the content and meaning of the graffe.
- 44:23So you could never even open the Bible, but it would still be the
- 44:27Bible because it is the written word of God. But the logos is what
- 44:30it says and what it means by what it says. That's why Jesus Christ,
- 44:35by the way, is called the Logos of God and John one one
- 44:37because he came to explain the Father to us. So it is the content
- 44:44and its meaning. That's the logos. Okay, I gotta stop this just
- 44:47for a second because I'm irritated because when I was in Greek class with you,
- 44:52one of the things that you said was, it's not logos, it's
- 44:55lagos. And every time I say logos, insane. But anyway, they
- 45:01haven't studied Greek. It's lambda, amacron, gamma, omicron, sigma,
- 45:08okay, and acron is short. Oh, so it's lagas. And anyone
- 45:13who says it's logos or Jesus, no, it's las. Yeah. Anyway,
- 45:19that was just that was just a pet peeve of mine. But I'll
- 45:21continue. But then there is the ram a word. The rame a word
- 45:25is the specific utterance into your specific situation. You need a ram a word
- 45:32because you got a real dilemma, a real problem. A raym a word
- 45:37is not a general word. It's just it's not even a sermon, because
- 45:40a sermon can can be one word for everybody. A raym a word is
- 45:45God's word to you. They're in a dilemma and they need a rame of
- 45:47word, which is a prophetic word. He said, if you'll listen to
- 45:52the prophet. Now, now, just because somebody preaching you don't mean that
- 45:54the prophet. They've got to be consistent with the written word and with the
- 46:00word before it can even be considered to be a prophetic word. So if
- 46:05the Rayma word is not consistent with the living word and the written word,
- 46:08it in fact it's not a Rayma word, and that's a false prophet.
- 46:13But he does give his applicational words to specific scenarios, to the prophetic voice
- 46:20today. All right, so here's here's what I'm guessing he's saying. So
- 46:27you have the you have the written word, the lagos, not the logos,
- 46:30the lagos, the graphic, yes, yes, yes, forgive me
- 46:34the graphic, and the lagos is the content that the lagos words, the
- 46:38content in the Graphe is that that that's if that's what I'm hearing, If
- 46:44I'm hearing him right, And then the Rayma would be God's specific word to
- 46:50you. This this word that is and yet isn't Rama and lagos used interchangeably
- 46:57throughout h throughout the Bible. So yeah they are you know, so Rayma
- 47:02can also be part of the written word as well, Am I right?
- 47:07That's correct? I would note, if anyone is going to challenge you,
- 47:12this is where they're going to challenge you. I would point them to Michael
- 47:15Brown, doctor Michael Brown, and he and I don't get along very well.
- 47:20We don't see eye to eye on a lot of things. And just
- 47:22go through the archives on his YouTube channel and type in the word rama and
- 47:28he will he will school you on the fact that lagos and rama are used
- 47:32interchangeably in the Greek New Testament. And this claim of charismatics that the rama
- 47:37word is the specific prophetic word for you and your circumstances. That ain't a
- 47:42biblical thing. It's not a distinction in the scriptures at all. If you're
- 47:46to take the logos though, and contact it with rama, for example,
- 47:51and you have you know, faith comes by hearing and hearing by the rama
- 47:53of God. Is it correct to say that the rama is more when God
- 47:59illuminate or speaks the word to you essentially, as opposed to just no,
- 48:02that's that's a very famous misconception popularized by some of the best known Word of
- 48:08Faith teachers. There may be something to the concept thereafter, but no,
- 48:14Rama and logos are used quite interchangeably in the Bible. All right, Chris,
- 48:19So let's transition into the sufficiency of scripture. And so does the Bible
- 48:25say anything about itself being sufficient? And I know we looked at that.
- 48:30I think it was what Second Timothy three sixteen that we looked at. That's
- 48:35a really good one. But you've covered that one. Is there anything else
- 48:37in scripture? Then? So I made the claim that the apostle Peter,
- 48:42he his last epistle heat points to the scriptures as well. So note here
- 48:47in Second Peter, Chapter one a Peter, just before he's crucified upside down,
- 48:53he says, we did not follow cleverly devised myths when we made known
- 49:00to you the power and the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ. But we
- 49:02were eyewitnesses of his majesty, for when he received honor and glory from God
- 49:07the Father, and the voice was born to him by the majestic glory.
- 49:09This is my beloved son, with whom I am. Well. Please now
- 49:14a little bit of a note. He's referencing the transfiguration event, the amount
- 49:19of transfiguration. And note he's not saying you need to have that same kind
- 49:22of experience like we had on the top of the mountain. Watch what he
- 49:25says we ourselves we heard this very voice born from heaven, for we were
- 49:31with him on the Holy Mountain, and we have the prophetic word more fully
- 49:36confirmed, to which you will do well to pay attention to his a lamp
- 49:40shining in a dark place, until the day dawns in the morning star rises
- 49:45in your hearts. Knowing this, first of all, no prophecy of scripture
- 49:49comes from someone's own interpretation, for no prophecy was ever produced by the will
- 49:53of man. But men spoke from God as they were carried along by the
- 49:58Holy Spirit. And so you'll note that Peter's final shot is get into the
- 50:04word it is living in act, it's, it's, it's this is from
- 50:07the Holy Spirit, and pay attention to it as a lamp shining in a
- 50:10dark place. God's word is a lamp to our feet and a light to
- 50:14our path. If you want to talk about how the Bible talks about it's
- 50:17itself, some one hundred and nineteen is your is your text. It's a
- 50:22long one. No one likes to read it because how long it is.
- 50:25But I dare you to read it and think and to think that the Bible
- 50:30is a lesser revelation. In fact, the whole point of Psalm one hundred
- 50:34and nineteen is by is pointing us to the sufficiency and the excellency of scripture.
- 50:39How can a young man keep his way up here by guarding it according
- 50:43to your word? Da Var in Hebrew. With my whole heart, I
- 50:47seek you, Let me not wander from your commandments. I have stored up
- 50:52your word in my heart that I may not sin against you. Blessed are
- 50:55you, oh Yahweh. Teach me your statutes with my lips, I declare,
- 51:00are all the rules of your mouth in the way of your testimonies.
- 51:02I delight as much as in all riches. I will meditate upon your precepts
- 51:07and fix my eyes on your ways. I will delight in your statutes.
- 51:10I will not forget your word. And so you'll note that the Bible speaks
- 51:17very highly of itself and very poorly of people who want who cause people to
- 51:23believe in lies or wander from God's word. So my next question then,
- 51:29is, so this is just a question about these prophets like sewan bolts.
- 51:35Are they adding to scripture when they are claiming to speak for God? Are
- 51:43they what the Bible says not to do adding to his word. They are
- 51:49adding to his word. But I would note that they they specifically make it
- 51:52clear that they're not adding to the scriptures, okay, okay, And so
- 51:57what they're basically doing with this whole rama word thing, okay, is that
- 52:01they've created a junk drawer. These are junk drawer prophecies. And the thing
- 52:07is is that, uh, you know, so somebody comes up to at
- 52:09church and says, oh, you know, I have a Rayma word for
- 52:12you, and are you ready for this? Dan? The Lord has revealed
- 52:15to me that he's going to restore all your hair. Okay. Oh,
- 52:24man, I tell you what I I Oh, oh, you should see
- 52:29some pictures of me when I was first married, when Robin and I first
- 52:31got married, I got a whole way of hair. And it's yeah,
- 52:35getting old stinks. It's just it's terrible really. But so, but so,
- 52:42if I were to say that I'm not adding to the scripture, I'm
- 52:45just basically giving a prophetic word, and you know that's supposed to be interpreted
- 52:49in its particular season. And I would note if you want to see a
- 52:53similar time when we had problems with false prophets, you know, within the
- 52:58visible church. I'm using church in the widest sense. Here read the prophet
- 53:01Jeremiah and uh. And there there in one particular instance you had. You
- 53:07know, God was basically saying he had Jeremiah basically create a yoke, you
- 53:13know, you know, a wooden yoke, and he was prophesying with this
- 53:15prop telling people that they were going to have to submit to the yoke of
- 53:20Nebuchadnezzar and that they were going to be taken into exile for seventy years.
- 53:23And this prophet, I think his name is Mistaiah, he comes along and
- 53:28he breaks that yoke, and he he offers a different competing word of God.
- 53:31Now, of course it wasn't written in scripture and what that wasn't his
- 53:35intent, but his intent was basically to undermine and challenge the word that Jeremiah
- 53:40spoke and basically said that no, no, no, the exiles are coming
- 53:45back. They'll be back in just a couple of years. And afterwards,
- 53:49God basically chastised Machaiah and said, listen, you've caused people to trust in
- 53:54lies words that I have not spoken. I God didn't send you, He
- 53:59didn't say these things. And as a result of it, God killed him.
- 54:02He died that year, and Jeremiah's prophecy came true when you read the
- 54:07prophet Ezekiel. The problem of these falls was still pervasive among the exiles in
- 54:15Babylon at the time, and as a result of it, there were people
- 54:17who were basically saying, why should we even listen to any word of God
- 54:22because none of his words ever come true. And the reason why they were
- 54:24saying that is because all these false prophets were speaking these words that just were
- 54:28completely false. But that was part of the process to kind of wean them
- 54:30away from these yahoo's and the YouTube prophets of Ezekiel's day and get them back
- 54:37on the sound words of God. But I'll let you read Ezekiel there.
- 54:40But the idea then is is that they're not technically adding to scripture, but
- 54:45they are adding words to God that, you know, basically attributing words to
- 54:50God that God hasn't spoken. Yeah, so then if you what was the
- 54:55clip that, oh, it was the woman that was with shann Bolts Michelle
- 55:01on our own Yea. She mentioned writing down what you hear at least if
- 55:08so, so you have her saying that, and then you have books like
- 55:12Jesus Calling, where yeah, you're hearing Jesus and then you're writing down what
- 55:17he's saying. You may not be adding a scripture there. But those words,
- 55:22because they are supposed to be coming from God, are they not on
- 55:24par with scripture? Would you? You would almost have to say they are.
- 55:29So. So here's the thing is is that although the charismatics will say
- 55:31these words are not on par with scripture, these that we're not adding this
- 55:35to the Bible, still they believe those are words from God, and as
- 55:38a result of its impeating, it's a competing source of revelation. So when
- 55:44in theology, one of the things that we talk about when we're doing analysis
- 55:49of any particular religious group, we have to identify what is the material and
- 55:53their formal principle. And the material and formal principle for every theological system is
- 55:59going to be what is considered to be the authoritative voice of God. Okay,
- 56:05And so for Biblical Christians, the answer soul of scriptura. You know,
- 56:08that is that is our material and formal principle. Everything centers on scripture.
- 56:15If you were to look at Mormons, Mormons believe in the in the
- 56:17in the King James Bible, insofar as is correctly translated. They believe in
- 56:22the Book of Mormon, doctrine and covenants, the Pearl of Great Price,
- 56:25and as a result of it, they have all these other things as well
- 56:29as the living Voice of God through whoever the current prophet in Salt Lake City
- 56:34is. And so you have all of these different voices than that equal the
- 56:38voice of God, and that you know, and all you know, you'll
- 56:42know. In their particular case, they put everything on par with Scripture.
- 56:45Okay, and then you know, you take a look at like the Pharisees,
- 56:50they tried to play this game too. By the way, the Pharisees,
- 56:52they had this thing called the oral Torah and otherwise known as the tradition
- 56:58of the Elders, and it had all these extra commands that were not found
- 57:01in the written Word of God and Christ himself. In fact, let me
- 57:04show you this from Scripture and Mark seven. Christ really huge rebuke of them
- 57:13is centered on this whole tradition of the elders. And listen to what happens
- 57:16here. So when the Pharisees gathered to Jesus with some of the scribes who
- 57:21had come from Jerusalem. They saw that some of Jesus' disciples ate with hands
- 57:25that were defiled, that is, unwashed. And I would note that nowhere
- 57:30in the scripture in the toad do you see the command in general for people
- 57:35to wash their hands. If that were there, my mom would have been
- 57:37going to that text all the time I was being raised, because I had
- 57:42to. I had to wash my hands before every meal. But what this
- 57:45command was, it's only found in the oral tourrad It's not in the written
- 57:49Tora. And I'll explain. So the Pharisees and the Jews, they do
- 57:52not eat unless they wash their hands properly, holding to the tradition of the
- 57:58elders. This actually should be capitalized. Tradition of the elders is a body
- 58:01of work, and at the time of Christ it was the oral to rags.
- 58:07Gets written down later in the Talmuds, but it says, and when
- 58:10they come from the marketplace, they don't eat unless they wash. And actually
- 58:15that's the word baptidzo. And there are many other traditions that they observe,
- 58:19such as the washing of cups, pots, copper vessels, and dining couches,
- 58:23and so the way, the way, the ceremony worked. If you
- 58:27were out shopping in the agora, that's that's the marketplace where you buy your
- 58:30fruits and vegetables and all your goods and stuff like this. If you're out
- 58:35among the goyim, then when you come in to your house, there's a
- 58:39there's a little wash basin and a picture set up, and which you're supposed
- 58:44to do. The way the ritual works is you put your hand, left
- 58:46hand over the over the picture, over the basin, take the picture,
- 58:51poor little water on it. Switch hands, right hand, palm down,
- 58:55Pour some water on it. Switch again, left hand, palm up,
- 59:00water on it, right hand, palm up. And then you sprits your
- 59:02hand. You kind of shake off the water, and you say this little
- 59:06prayer, I thank you, Lord, God maker of heaven and earth,
- 59:09that you have given me the command to wash my hands. That's the ritual,
- 59:14okay, And you'll know that's nowhere. Yeah, that's the ritual itself,
- 59:17and that is nowhere found in scripture. And so in this particular occasion,
- 59:22the Pharisees are kind of checking Jesus out to see if if he's on
- 59:25the level, if he's kosher, and this is where they go to war
- 59:29with him because Jesus didn't allow his disciples to do that ritual. And so
- 59:35the Pharisees freak out, why do your disciples not walk according to watch this
- 59:38the tradition of the elders. This is a competing source of divine revelation,
- 59:45which Jesus by not allowing his disciples to follow those commands of saying that ain't
- 59:50a valid source. So but they eat with the filed hands. And so
- 59:52Jesus said to them, well, did Isaiah prophecy of you, you hypocrites?
- 59:57As it is written this, people honors me with their lips, but
- 1:00:00their heart is far from me in vain do they worship me? Teaching as
- 1:00:04doctrines the commandments of men, you leave the commandments of God, and you
- 1:00:07hold to the tradition of men. And then he said, you have a
- 1:00:12fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to establish your tradition.
- 1:00:15So note here Jesus is making it clear that true saving faith, it's almost
- 1:00:22like it only has one hand, like it can either hold on to the
- 1:00:24scriptures or it can hold on to these other competing sources. But it can't
- 1:00:29hold on to both because when you bring these other competing sources that claim to
- 1:00:34be from God, you end up losing the Bible altogether. You make it
- 1:00:37void. So you have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in
- 1:00:43order to establish your tradition. For Moses said, honor your father and mother,
- 1:00:46and whoever reviles father or mother must surely die. But you say,
- 1:00:52if a man tells his father or mother whatever you would have gained from me
- 1:00:54his corebon, that is a gift given to God, then you no longer
- 1:00:58permit him to do anything for his father and mother, thus making void the
- 1:01:01word of God by your tradition that you have handed down. And many such
- 1:01:06things you do. And I would note that when although these people would say
- 1:01:10they're not giving us, you know, biblical scripture level revelation, they still
- 1:01:15believe that's the voice of God speaking. And as a result of it,
- 1:01:20you'll note so many of their so called prophecies, aside from being completely nonsensical,
- 1:01:24they actually end up making void the word of God. And so many
- 1:01:29charismatics are completely clueless about what the Bible ligitimately says and teaches because they are
- 1:01:36constantly chasing after these experiences, this other voice and trying to discern if God's
- 1:01:42speaking to them by the cardinal that flew up and landed on their windows.
- 1:01:46Stuff like that. Yeah, yeah, all right, So Chris, let
- 1:01:52me ask you this. So we know that the Holy Spirit does guide his
- 1:01:55people, He guides them through the Word. What about things like promptings that
- 1:02:01people talk, you know, promptings of the Holy Spirit. You know,
- 1:02:06I had this desire to go to the grocery store, and I get there
- 1:02:12and I started walking around, and I ran into an old friend and was
- 1:02:16able to share the gospel of them. And that was the Holy Spirit giving
- 1:02:19me that desire to go to the grocery store. You know, that kind
- 1:02:21of thing. I've heard Charles Stanley say things like that, and just what
- 1:02:25are your what are your thoughts on stuff like that? I would say you
- 1:02:30need to be super careful with stuff like that, because on the one hand,
- 1:02:34you don't want to deny that the Holy Spirit does kind of give us
- 1:02:37a kick in the pants at times, and he does. I would note
- 1:02:40that if God has to do that, you're he's you're not paying attention to
- 1:02:44his word, because oftentimes people will say, you know, I don't know
- 1:02:46if I should help that person or not in the Holy spirits going. And
- 1:02:52so if he has to get out the spurs and kick you in order to
- 1:02:57get your mule butt moving, that's not a think that's a bad thing.
- 1:03:00But the other the other part of this is is that so many people they
- 1:03:05try to take these these kind of rare things and turn them into the norm.
- 1:03:08But as so I'm a confessional Lutheran, so are you. We believe
- 1:03:13that men are called to the pastoral office. And let me tell you there's
- 1:03:15promptings involved in that. So I remember when I first began to suspect that
- 1:03:22I was called to be a pastor, and I could not get I couldn't
- 1:03:27shake the feeling. I just it was the only thing that was making sense
- 1:03:31with what was going on. And so I actually went to my pastor and
- 1:03:35I said, Pastor Swirlat, you know, I'm thinking that I'm being called
- 1:03:37to the pastoral office. And the first thing he said to me said,
- 1:03:40you knock that off. He says, he says, just ignore it.
- 1:03:44That feeling will go away. I said, okay, all right. So
- 1:03:50I took his advice. I tried to forget it and ignore it, and
- 1:03:52I came back to him a couple of years later, I said, it
- 1:03:54ain't going away, it's gotten worse. And so you know, but that
- 1:04:00anybody who who thinks that they're being called in the pastoral office, that's this
- 1:04:02first thing in order to basically get the person to start to start to think
- 1:04:08critically, is this really God calling you into the pastoral ministry or not.
- 1:04:12And here's the thing, just because I felt called doesn't mean that I was.
- 1:04:15And so you that we actually believe in kind of like you have the
- 1:04:19immediate call, and then you have immediate call. And so although I believed
- 1:04:26I was called to the pastoral ministry, that began the process of me studying
- 1:04:30to show myself approved as one who can rightly handle the Word of truth and
- 1:04:34who could receive a call. And so then ultimately then it was confirmed that
- 1:04:41I was called to the pastoral office when I received an actual call to pastor
- 1:04:45a congregation I was except called from Kongsvinger Lutheran Church. That then became the
- 1:04:50proof that what I was feeling was in fact from God. And then though
- 1:04:57oh I'm sorry, go ahead, go ahead, no, no, go
- 1:04:59ahead, the desire should be there right because Paul says in in both Timothy
- 1:05:04and Titus that he who desires the office of overseer bishop desires a good thing
- 1:05:12which should be there in the first place. And if the desire is not
- 1:05:14there, you probably not called it anyway, I know, you know what
- 1:05:17I mean? Yeah, and there, and there were several times I tried
- 1:05:21running from it. That doesn't work, so, you know, so I
- 1:05:28would say. So. The idea then is is that we don't deny that
- 1:05:31the Holy Spirit prompts. But over and again, going a note you you
- 1:05:35run into a problem, and that is is that if you legitimately are being
- 1:05:41prompted, my question is what are you being prompted to do? And can
- 1:05:45it be validated from scripture? Okay? And oftentimes when when I talk to
- 1:05:49somebody who feels that they're prompted, h then you know, I sit there
- 1:05:54and go, boy, you know, it sounds to me like the Holy
- 1:05:56Spirit is screaming at you because you're you're ignoring what the Bible actually says.
- 1:06:00This should be a no brainer. You should be helping this person, and
- 1:06:03now you're feeling prompted to do so. It's like you wouldn't even need the
- 1:06:06prompt if you would have just obeyed the text and so that that's you know,
- 1:06:12these are one of these things. But over and again. What happens,
- 1:06:15though, is is that you're going to note the devil is a good
- 1:06:17fisherman. And here's where we have to we have to be very careful because
- 1:06:24you'll note that because of original sin, you and I have a problem,
- 1:06:27and that is is that we think way too highly of ourselves. We think
- 1:06:30that we're super important and that somehow, if God is prompting me or talking
- 1:06:34to me or doing or directly speaking to me or whatever, that that makes
- 1:06:38me super important. But in reality, all that is most of the time
- 1:06:42is bait on a hook, and it's the devil fishing for you and using
- 1:06:45your vanity against you, and then he'll hook you with worthless words and and
- 1:06:49then you know, after you buy into this whole thing, you believe that
- 1:06:54you're a prophet, you're a living apostle, and you're none of the none
- 1:06:58of the above. It's it's it's really awful, and so we've we've got
- 1:07:01to be careful. And you'll note that Scripture legitimately tells us to not believe
- 1:07:09every spirit, but to test the spirits to see whether they are from God.
- 1:07:14And so you know, it's not to say that God han't prompt he
- 1:07:19can, but you're going to note that there needs to be all kinds of
- 1:07:24safeguards in place that you don't end up down some weird ditch. And then
- 1:07:28you know, next thing, you know, you've got your business cards saying
- 1:07:30that you're apostle. You know you're not you and I, like you said,
- 1:07:34we're confessional Lutherans, so we have the sacraments. It seems to me
- 1:07:40that this idea of constantly needing to hear something from God, it's almost like
- 1:07:48sometimes it can be assurance of saying, you know, like is God really
- 1:07:53dealing with me? Is He really there for me? If I'm not hearing
- 1:07:57his voice, or if he's not prompting me, or or he's not speaking
- 1:08:00specifically to me, is he really there? So it almost can be like
- 1:08:06an assurance of either salvation or an assurance that God is with me. You
- 1:08:11know, we have the sacraments, we have the Lord's Supper, we have
- 1:08:14baptism, we look to we have all of these things, but we have
- 1:08:16the Word of God. But you know that's kind of do you do you
- 1:08:20get where I'm going with that? I know exactly I know exactly what you're
- 1:08:25talking about, because in a way, these experiences then they serve the function
- 1:08:30of the extranose word of God that comes to us from outside of us.
- 1:08:35So I know that I'm forgiven because God's word says so, and I can
- 1:08:40hear it the solution. And I know that I am that I am united
- 1:08:44with Christ because every time I have the Lord's Supper right, the body and
- 1:08:49blood of Christ given and shed for the forgiveness of my sins, I can
- 1:08:53point back to my baptism when I'm united with Christ and his death and his
- 1:08:56resurrection. These are all coming from outside of me to me, giving me
- 1:09:00assurance. But here's the thing. So let me give you the scenario.
- 1:09:03You're on your way to church and you're you still have young kids. So
- 1:09:06you have three young kids in your car, and you know how well they
- 1:09:11all get along, and so you've got the baby screaming, You've got the
- 1:09:14three year old throwing cheat cheerios all over the place and having a temper tantrum,
- 1:09:18and then the oldest kid is misbehaving and actually inciting all kinds of anxiety
- 1:09:23in this and your wife has lost your mind, and everybody's screaming in the
- 1:09:28car, and you're clenching your fists on you and you're on your minivan going
- 1:09:30to church, right, and I kid you not, Okay, you say
- 1:09:34something brilliant like, everybody stop yelling. Right as you yell this thing out,
- 1:09:41right, you're trying to get control of the situation. So what happens
- 1:09:43is is that as soon as you pull into the parking lot there you've got
- 1:09:46the parking lot volunteers with their little light things guiding you to where you're supposed
- 1:09:50to park. And as soon as you get to the parking lot, everybody
- 1:09:55puts on their Christian face like, hey, we're all along, we're all
- 1:09:58whatever. Of course, inside you're seething and raging. You get out of
- 1:10:01your car and somebody says to hey, brother, blessed to be here.
- 1:10:05Oh yes, I'm the head and not the tail. Oh I'm so blessed
- 1:10:08to be here. I can't wait to feel the anointing in worship. Right,
- 1:10:12So you put your kids in the in the in the childcare, you
- 1:10:14go up to the main sanctuary for the service, and then the lights turn
- 1:10:18off, and the smoke and the mirrors and the disco ball turn on and
- 1:10:21everybody swaying in the spirit, they got their hands up and stuff like this,
- 1:10:25and they're feeling stuff, but you're not feeling anything right, And the
- 1:10:30reason why you're not feeling anything is you haven't you haven't resolved the conflict that
- 1:10:33that just occurred in your minivan on the way to church. And as a
- 1:10:38result of it, now at the end of the service, you have a
- 1:10:41complete crisis, wondering if God the Holy Spirit has left you because everybody else
- 1:10:46felt the spirit, felt the anointing, got the ghost bumps and all this
- 1:10:49kind of stuff, but you didn't feel nothing because you're still angry about what
- 1:10:53happened in the car. And so as a result of it, you begin
- 1:10:57to have a crisis, thinking that somehow you and God are at odds with
- 1:11:00each other or God is now displeased with you because you didn't have a feeling.
- 1:11:05And so you'll note that these feelings oftentimes are these direct revelations. Also
- 1:11:11they play a role which then becomes the centerpiece. Well, everything has to
- 1:11:15be okay with me and God, because otherwise he wouldn't have let me feel
- 1:11:17the anointing during the worship the other day, and I wouldn't have gotten the
- 1:11:20ghost bumps. So we have to I have to be type with Jesus because
- 1:11:24I had that. But then when it doesn't show up, you know,
- 1:11:29now you have a real crisis of conscience going on here. And the problem
- 1:11:33is is that nowhere in scripture are we to look to these experience as we
- 1:11:36are to look to the external word of God to give us that assurance and
- 1:11:41faith hangs onto what God's word says, regardless of what we are feeling in
- 1:11:46the moment. Amen. Amen, Chris, this was a fantastic conversation.
- 1:11:53I really really appreciate you coming on here and talking with me about this because
- 1:11:58I think this is really important. You hear this everywhere you turn. You
- 1:12:01you know, you watch any sermon on YouTube just about and you're hearing the
- 1:12:06pastor say God spoke to me and told me this, or you know,
- 1:12:10told me that, and so this is a really important topic. I really
- 1:12:13do appreciate you taking out, you know, time out of your busy schedule.
- 1:12:16You pastor khans Finger, you also pastor a Lathy and Lutheran church.
- 1:12:20You teach Greek, you do Catechism classes. You're constantly on the run,
- 1:12:26and so you coming on here means a lot. Thank you very much.
- 1:12:30Thanks for having me Dan, it was a pleasure to be on your on
- 1:12:32your channel. I appreciate it. Folks, thank you so much for watching
- 1:12:35and I hope this has been helpful. If it has, please make sure
- 1:12:40you pass this video along. We'll see you next time.