Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / On This Day in History, Sh!t Went Down: with "Sweary Historian" James Fell
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. On his
- 0:57website, he calls himself a sweary historian. Oh that sounds like my kind
- 1:03of history teacher, if you will. He has written for a lot of
- 1:07publications over the years, even over the decades. But the reason we're talking
- 1:11today is because I was reading snippets from his latest book on this day in
- 1:17history shit went down with the title like that, we have to talk.
- 1:23Welcome author James Fell. Thanks so much for having me on the show.
- 1:27Seth. How do I introduce him? Do I say historian? I know
- 1:30it's a sweary historian, but introduce yourself to the audience. Well, I
- 1:34mean I don't have a PhD in history. I have a master's degree.
- 1:38I always felt a little bit like having a bit of imposter syndrome with calling
- 1:44myself an historian. Uh, well, you only have a master's in history.
- 1:48Yeah, I'm sorry. Well what are you doing here? Get this
- 1:51guy out of here. He's only got a seven year program behind him.
- 1:53Yeah. But you know, I've had other you know, academic professional,
- 1:59you know, tenured history professor saying, oh, you're absolutely an historian.
- 2:01So according to them, I am. I just happened to like to swear
- 2:05in my writing. But you know, I don't teach it at a university.
- 2:07I'm more of a I take history and make it accessible to people by
- 2:13making it, you know, fun and profanity filled. You know, it's
- 2:15funny because and I've told this story before. When I was in school,
- 2:21all of my history teachers were like football coaches, and they needed somebody to
- 2:27teach history. And they'd come in and it was data points, bullet points,
- 2:30you know, dash dash dask. But it was never like the story
- 2:34of history. In fact, it wasn't until I was a senior in high
- 2:37school. Missus Bridges comes in and starts to tell us the story of what
- 2:40happened and why it happened, and how it relates to today. In that
- 2:45line, you know, those who do not learn from history are destined to
- 2:49repeat it. But you're a storyteller. I mean, that's why I like
- 2:52about you. That's purposeful, right, Oh yeah, I mean I started
- 2:55this kind of on a lark because I'd been a fitness motivation type writer and
- 3:01my previous book that was published in twenty nineteen had kind of tanked, and
- 3:05in twenty twenty my writing career was on life support and the only thing I
- 3:08really had going for me was eighty thousand followers on Facebook, and with literally
- 3:15nothing else to do, I started this column, and much to my surprise,
- 3:20it immediately took off. And I think it was the fact that I
- 3:24was making it fun and interesting and telling, you know, some of the
- 3:28stories people had heard before, but they hadn't heard it the way I told
- 3:30it, and other ones were rather obscure, and they're like, oh wow,
- 3:35that's really cool. Like you know, today, October thirtieth, the
- 3:38day we're doing the recording, anyway, is the day of the War of
- 3:43the World's broadcast in nineteen thirty eight, which pretty much everybody knows that story,
- 3:47but I told it in an interesting way and exposed some realities about it
- 3:52that a lot of people didn't know, which is that the whole mass panic
- 3:55thing was really blown way out of proportion. It was done by the newspapers
- 4:00because there wasn't much of a panic at all. It was actually quite minimal,
- 4:04but newspapers saw radio as their primary competitor, and so you know,
- 4:10the next day, the newspapers are all going, oh, extra extra read
- 4:13all about it. Radio broadcast causes mass panic because they wanted radio to look
- 4:17bad. They wanted, you know, people to believe that newspapers were the
- 4:20only source of real truth, and you know, have people more likely to
- 4:26buy newspapers and advertise the newspapers then listen to the radio. Well, let
- 4:30me jump in real fast. For those under the age of forty, this
- 4:34was a classic orson wells Am radio broadcast where he acted like a newscaster acting
- 4:44out the war of the worlds, and he was saying, you know,
- 4:46they've landed, they're coming, they're among us. You know, people are
- 4:49disappearing. I think there may have been sound effects and all that. It
- 4:51was just quite a production and the story was that every day radio listeners thought
- 4:59that they had come, they had landed, that it was over, and
- 5:02that there were people jumping off of bridges and out of buildings and killing themselves
- 5:08and you know, running away and this sort of mass panic. But you're
- 5:11saying that was all manufactured. I mean, there was some panic, but
- 5:15they told people in advance that this was a story, you know, that
- 5:19this was pretend this was you know, radio story time. But people weren't
- 5:25really listening that closely, kind of like you know today when you're listening or
- 5:28watching TV and scrolling your phone at the same time. There were people that
- 5:31were only sort of half listening. But the thing was, it was nineteen
- 5:34thirty eight, and they heard the words invasion, and they heard the words
- 5:39gas attack because it was like Martian gases, and some people thought, oh,
- 5:43you know, everybody was kind of freaked out about that Hitler douche bag
- 5:46at the time, so they thought maybe Germans were invading. So some people
- 5:49called their local police station and said, what the fuck's going on, and
- 5:53the police said, you know, it's pretend there aren't Martian invading invading.
- 5:57Nobody's coming to anal prob You come the fuck down, and but it did
- 6:03get enough people calling in that the cops did show up at the radio station
- 6:08and try and shut it down, and there was a bit of a scuffle
- 6:11with the producers. But you know, they said that this is fake,
- 6:15but they made it the way the broadcast made it sound like during the broadcast
- 6:19that it sounded like it was serious. But you had to be pretty clued
- 6:24out to not really get that it was, you know, just a pretend
- 6:28story. And it wasn't even that popular, like not even it wasn't a
- 6:30popular broadcast, like not many people were listening to it. It wasn't like
- 6:34the whole nation was wrapped listening to this thing. See that's a surprise too,
- 6:39because the way the story was told to us is that, you know,
- 6:42there was there were so few choices when it came to media back then
- 6:46that everybody listened to exactly the same show, and the whole planet was sitting
- 6:49and rapped attention that kind of thing. I was listening to the story of
- 6:53the audience who who heard this bought it freaked out, and I thought,
- 6:57you know, things haven't changed all that much, have they. We must
- 7:00look around at media audiences now and they believe the first thing that's tweeted,
- 7:05and it's pandemonium and you never actually get the lie refuted. I mean when
- 7:11you look around at the world, you see not much has changed. Yeah,
- 7:15like what's I don't know the exact quote, but it's like a lie
- 7:18goes around the entire world before the truth has even finished getting its shoes on.
- 7:25Is sort of how it goes. And you know, you look at
- 7:28the QAnon stuff that people believe that it's it's not a big surprise that there
- 7:33were people that bought into this because they immediately immediately go into panic mode.
- 7:40But like I said, like, it wasn't that many people that were that
- 7:44freaked out about it. It's funny I'd mentioned my history classes. I went
- 7:47to a private Christian school, so history and science classes those are relative terms.
- 7:53But in our history class, we all learned that the American founding fathers
- 7:58were all like little Jesus, I mean, total saints. They did nothing
- 8:01wrong, they had little halos, they had auras about them. Christ had
- 8:05actually probably brought them down on the palm of his hand to found the country.
- 8:09And you're a historian, so tell me about the founders and the perception
- 8:16of the founders in this country in twenty twenty three, well, I think,
- 8:20you know, most of them were slave owners and the whole you know,
- 8:26Declaration of Independence. All Men are Created equal. It was, you
- 8:31know, just white males they were talking about, and so, yeah,
- 8:37it was we're talking about the eighteenth century here. They had some very warped
- 8:41ideas as far as modern people are concerned about gender and race and things like
- 8:48that. So yeah, no, they were not perfect by any stretch of
- 8:52the imagination. Washington and the Cherry Tree, right, we thought, oh
- 8:54wow, what a beautiful story. And it was only when I was in
- 8:58my thirties that I read that it's total shit. And actually, one of
- 9:01the things that a lot of people don't know was that, you know,
- 9:05the causes one of the main causes of the American Revolution was that, you
- 9:11know, when it was under the control of the British Empire, the British
- 9:15Empire had said, Okay, we don't want these colonial settlers pushing any more
- 9:20westward into Appalachia. We want to protect that area for the Native Americans that
- 9:26live there. And the colonists were like, fuck that, there's all sorts
- 9:31of land out there that we want to grab, you're not the boss of
- 9:33me. So there was a lot of motivation to become independent so that the
- 9:41colonists could start moving westward and commit genocide against the Native Americans and take their
- 9:46land. Well, how much of the exit, some would say exodus from
- 9:52Britain was about escaping theocracy, and we talk a little bit about escaping the
- 9:58dominion of the Church of England to be able to be free. Is that
- 10:01a myth as well? No, there, I mean it was you look
- 10:07at the Puritan invasion on the Mayflower. That Puritans weren't very well thought of
- 10:13in Britain. You know, there was the Church of England that was sort
- 10:18of the official church, and then you know, some of them went to
- 10:20Holland and then they said, okay, well they weren't very well appreciated and
- 10:24they're either. So eventually they realized that, oh, well, you know
- 10:28we can we can go to the United States and have religious freedom there,
- 10:33which for them was the freedom to totally fuck up American social moras for the
- 10:41next several centuries. You ask a lot of people ask a question like why
- 10:45are Americans so uptight about sex? And a lot of it had to do
- 10:48with the type of people that flocked to what became the United States, imposing
- 10:54their very uptight morality upon society. You know, you look at at Western
- 11:01Europe and it's comparatively speaking, very sexually liberal compared to a lot of the
- 11:05United States. It's interesting we talk about our historical figures deified Christopher Columbus.
- 11:13I'm embarrassed, James. I'm embarrassed because I used to think, you know,
- 11:16he discovered America and I for so long, and then I finally actually
- 11:22read the history on Columbus and said, oh my, holy what the I
- 11:26just could not believe what an absolute monster the guy was. Have you gotten
- 11:31into Columbus? Yeah, I wrote about him, and I quoted from a
- 11:37letter that he wrote on the return from his first voyage, where he was
- 11:45talking basically writing to Isabella and Ferdinand, saying, oh, yeah, this
- 11:50place is just ripe for conquering, Like these people are so meek that we
- 11:54could easily conquer them and enslave them and convert them to Christianity, and there's
- 11:58lots of gold for us to steal. Like basically, he was saying that
- 12:01this place is just ripe for exploitation. And he also, you know,
- 12:05brought slaves back with them, many of whom died on the return trip.
- 12:09So he was One thing people don't know is he never actually landed on the
- 12:16continent. He only landed, and I think he first landed in thea what
- 12:18became known as the Bahamas. But he never actually, out of his four
- 12:22voyages, ever landed on the mainland. And he was so horrific in his
- 12:28behavior, some of the nasty shit that he did that even the people of
- 12:31the time in the fifteenth century were like, this guy's pretty harsh, Like
- 12:37wasn't he called back to Spain, like to stand trial or give it count
- 12:41or some mean somebody got pissed, right, Yeah, I don't remember the
- 12:45exact details. That's the problem when you write so many short history pieces,
- 12:48people are like, that's okay, that's okay. You know, I know
- 12:54I've got quite a decent education through the writing of all these stories, but
- 12:58you know, having a one of the reasons why I write it down is
- 13:01so that I don't have to remember it. I've got a pretty good memory
- 13:03for a lot of this stuff. But other times it's like, oh,
- 13:07you know, if you give me a minute, I can look it up
- 13:09because it's in my book. I wrote it down, but I don't have
- 13:11a perfect memory. Like this is one of the reasons that when I engage
- 13:16in conversations about life, the universe and everything, I feel a little bit
- 13:20of panic always under the surface. And it's not because I don't feel like
- 13:24I can have the conversation, but because as I get older, my memory
- 13:26is terrifyingly bad. And if you pause and say, oh God, I
- 13:31can't remember what's that name? Who said that? Where's that quote? What
- 13:35chapter? What book? You look unprepared. You know. I just the
- 13:39style over substance thing I've told when I'm doing media interviews for this, saying,
- 13:45if there is a particular story date that you want to talk about,
- 13:48please let me know in advance and I'll read up on it right before it.
- 13:52Is it true that you do a date or like people contact you and
- 13:58throw out the date of their birth day and then yeah, what you give
- 14:01them a tidbit about this day in history for their birth date. Well,
- 14:05it became a very popular thing where, you know, people would tell me
- 14:11that they bought the book and they left it lying around and the first thing
- 14:13people would look at look up, they go, oh, hey, what's
- 14:16this and the first thing they would look, They want to know what I
- 14:18wrote about for their birthday? So what I actually did? I just launched
- 14:22this a couple of days ago. A friend came up with the idea of
- 14:26you've heard of a horoscope, which is, of course, you know,
- 14:28bullshit. I came up with a thing that I integrated into my website called
- 14:33the History Scope, which is, Okay, what cool or possibly really fucked
- 14:37up thing did I write about on your birthday? So if you go to
- 14:41my website, James Fell dot com, there'll be an immediate pop up window
- 14:46saying, you know, welcome to the motherfucking History Scope, and you put
- 14:48in the month and day of your birth and it'll give you a snippet of
- 14:54what it was that I wrote about for that day. So because people just
- 14:58they want to they want to know the story for their birthday. Like I
- 15:03know, the only thing I know. I think David Letterman has a birthday
- 15:07on April twelfth, which is my birth That's the only thing I know about
- 15:09my birth. Do you want Do you want me to tell you what I
- 15:13wrote about for that day? I hey, wait, you actually have it
- 15:15at your fingertips. I will flip to that page in my book April twelfth,
- 15:20that is the day that, in nineteen sixty one that Yuri Gagarin went
- 15:26into space, the first person to ever go into space. And what's interesting
- 15:31about Uri is that six years later he was on backup for the Soyu's one
- 15:37mission that ended up killing one of his fellow cosmonauts, and so the Soviets
- 15:41said, oh, well, we can't have the first cosmonaut die. So
- 15:46they said, you don't. You don't get to go into space anymore.
- 15:48So he went back to being a test pilot, and a year later,
- 15:52in nineteen sixty eight, he was flying a MiG fifteen and it crashed and
- 15:56he died. So, see, this is why James and I are talking
- 16:00like you just cracked open a truth egg on this show. There's a story
- 16:04in your book that really struck with me. You talked about the five missionaries
- 16:10in Ecuador. I want to say it was nineteen fifty, something like mid
- 16:14twentieth century. I want to say it was in the fifties. Five of
- 16:17these Christian missionaries go to some remote area in Ecuador. They're going to bring
- 16:22the gift of the Gospel to the local tribes. Yeah, it was nineteen
- 16:27fifty six and it will be the Haraani. I apologize if I pronounced that
- 16:33incorrectly. Were uncontacted, violently hostile tribes in the Amazon, and these five
- 16:42Christian missionaries decided that they were going to bring the word of Jesus to them.
- 16:48And so what they did was they flew a plane and they circled the
- 16:53plane around the tribe and then lowered gifts of like pod and machetes and stuff
- 17:00like that, and then the tribes people put some of their own gifts in
- 17:07the basket to return up to you know, Sky Santa, and they took
- 17:10that as, oh, well, they're ready to receive the Lord. And
- 17:12as it turned out, they weren't receiving shit because they landed their plane on
- 17:17a river bank and then went out and at first things were okay, but
- 17:21then you know, there was a little bit of a cultural clash misunderstanding,
- 17:26and so the Herni said nope, fuck these guys, and they went out
- 17:30and killed the shit out of all five of them, and you know,
- 17:33set their devil sky machine on fire. Too. And you would think you
- 17:38would think that in the aftermath of that, they would say, Okay,
- 17:42we need to leave these people. The fuck alone. But being fundamentalist Christian
- 17:47evangelical zeale at douchebags. No. What happened instead was that the story made
- 17:52international news, and tons and tons of money came in to finance further evangelizing
- 18:00efforts, and these Christians kept going back trying to contact this tribe, and
- 18:06eventually they were successful in converting some of them to Christianity, which makes me
- 18:11just go Jesus fucking Grid, like, oh God, look fine, fine,
- 18:15we'll say the prayer. Just stop showing up and bothering us. Well,
- 18:19the reason it came to my mind is that in my old Christian radio
- 18:23days, our AM station used to run the gospel program or an evangelical teaching
- 18:30program that was hosted by his widow, Elizabeth Elliott. Jim Elliott was one
- 18:34of the missionaries killed, and so his wife was a radio host. And
- 18:40I hate to say it this way, but she essentially built her ministry and
- 18:42reputation on the corpse of her husband, you know, oh yeah, totally.
- 18:47You know, he had gone, he'd given everything for the cause of
- 18:49Jesus, and what a great example. And here I am carrying the torch.
- 18:52I mean, I don't think that's just the cynic in me. I
- 18:55think she literally did use his casket as a soapbox. Yeah, and not
- 18:59only that, but a fundraising vehicle as well. Crazy. I want an
- 19:03autograph from you, James. I was going to bring this up earlier,
- 19:06but I want your autograph for one specific reason. This was a post that
- 19:11you put on Facebook on the sixth of October. It may have been shortly
- 19:15around this time that I reached out to you and said we have to talk.
- 19:18You use the following nicknames for Donald Trump in one piece one article.
- 19:26Scooby, coop Manchurian, cantalope, danger yam, copper tone, caligula,
- 19:34orangutan, oligarch, cadet, bone spurs, tangerine, palpatine, a golf
- 19:42hitler, jackass o, lantern, Donnie crapple, seed, dayglow, taint,
- 19:48stain, orange, shit, gibbon. I don't even think I got
- 19:52them all. I was laughing out loud. You must be smiling. Tell
- 19:59me you're not cracked yourself up when you're writing about the orange Avenger. There
- 20:03is a good chance that if you laughed while reading it, this is going
- 20:07to sound terrible, terribly lame. But if you laughed reading it, I
- 20:11was probably laughing while I was writing it. And I can't take credit for
- 20:15all of those names. Some of those were just ones you know, you
- 20:17hear and surfing the internet. Other ones I did make up. I think
- 20:21Johndice Jesus was one that I definitely made up. I have used danger Yam,
- 20:27I think five times in the last week. I just just made me
- 20:30laugh out loud. I am shocked. I here's the part of the where
- 20:36the audience is like a cramp. Here, he goes. I am reading
- 20:38that the vast majority the front runner in today's Republican Party for the twenty twenty
- 20:45four presidency remains Donald Trump. And I watch soundbites from his they're not news
- 20:52conferences, his rallies, and I just hear this word sound. I mean,
- 20:55it's more and more disjointed and bizarre and stupid and crazy and conspiratorial and
- 21:00pathetic. And I'm like, who looks at that and says more, Please
- 21:04write I want that, give me more of that. I just I've given
- 21:10up hope, James. I literally think bring on the asteroid, right,
- 21:15you know, I think that it's a combination of two things. It began
- 21:19with a lot of it really does have to do with white supremacy. He
- 21:25became very attractive to a lot of white people because he didn't have to do
- 21:30anything for them in terms of improving their station in life. He just had
- 21:36to make it okay to take pride in being white. It was LBJ who
- 21:41said that if you can make the lowest white man feel like he's better than
- 21:48the best black man, then he won't notice that you're picking his pocket.
- 21:52And there's still a lot of truth of that in the United States, where
- 21:56you know, Trump came along, or danger Yam came along, told people
- 22:00that you know, it was it was okay for them to feel pride in
- 22:04being white. That was all that they really needed in order to start worshiping
- 22:10the guy, because these a lot of them were, you know, feeling
- 22:12very destitute and believing conspiracies about you know, the great white replacement and stuff
- 22:18like that, and that was they He didn't need to, you know,
- 22:22give them healthcare or jobs or any of that kind of stuff. He just
- 22:26had to make them feel good about being white, and that was enough.
- 22:29And then after that you've got the whole concept of throwing good money after bad
- 22:33that once you are committed to basing, you know, your personality around trump
- 22:40worship. It's really hard to stop, and so a lot of them have.
- 22:47You know, once they get into this cult of trump Ism, they
- 22:48just they can't let go of it, and and no amount of rationality or
- 22:56evidence is going to make them stop, because has so much of their identity
- 23:00has become wrapped up in it. Next, we're going to talk weird history,
- 23:08some wellness, bullshits, and the myth that we skeptics are always skeptical.
- 23:15More with James Fell. Next, Your support on Patreon keeps me doing
- 23:27what I'm doing. I'm so thankful for the sponsors of the show, but
- 23:32it's the patrons who really do the heavy lifting. If you like what you
- 23:36hear and you want to support it, become a patron Patreon dot com slash
- 23:41Seth Andrews. Continuing my conversation with author and historian James Fell. His latest
- 23:49book is titled On This Day in History, Shit Went Down. It was
- 23:57early October you had written a piece that or late October. He was called
- 24:02Homo sapiens are primed for belief. We talk a lot about this. You
- 24:07know, how psychology can be weaponized to consolidate, to rally, to enrage,
- 24:14to terrify, to distract, and you got into sort of how the
- 24:18elites have long used moral panic for power. You want to get into that
- 24:23at all. There is a famous quote by the science fiction author Robert Hyland
- 24:29that goes, you can sway a thousand men by appealing to their prejudices faster
- 24:33than you can convince one man by logic. And that is one true fucking
- 24:37statement. It's been the whole us and them mentality of using an enemy to
- 24:45distract people from the horrors of their own government has been utilized a great deal.
- 24:52We see it in the Middle East right now, where there's a lot
- 24:56of theocratic Islamic nations that are oppressing the shit out of their own people,
- 25:03but they use Jews in Israel as a distraction from that. Is like,
- 25:08you know, don't worry about how much we're oppressing, you hate those Jews
- 25:11over there. And also Trump did it with the whole build the Wall type
- 25:15of stuff where he said terribly untrue things about people that were coming across the
- 25:22border in order to distract from the fact that you know, he was a
- 25:26terrible person, a terrible leader, and a terrible president. It was funny
- 25:32I saw something online that showed part of the wall that had been constructed,
- 25:37and it was like billions of dollars for the wall, and then it showed
- 25:41like some milk crates stacked on top of each other to get over the wall.
- 25:44And they're like milk crates twenty five bucks something along those lines. You
- 25:48know that I look all around it, like many people in my direct family
- 25:52are. I mean, it's not that they're not intelligent, but it's that
- 25:57there's I mean, I hate to say it this way, but I mean
- 26:00everybody's coming for them, right. The immigrants are coming, right, They're
- 26:06spilling over the border. It's a parade every single day of murderers and rapist
- 26:10and they want you and your kids and your job and your freedom and your
- 26:12church and your Bible. The Muslims are coming, the Socialists are coming,
- 26:17the Satanists are coming. They're all coming for I mean, these people are
- 26:19It's a terrified demographic. Have you talked about sort of this continuing, Like
- 26:26I come out of the Satanic panic, that's not over. I mean the
- 26:29Satanic panic continues, right. You know, being a skeptic is a tough
- 26:33road to hoe. You know, I'd like to think I'm a pretty smart
- 26:37guy. I've pretty well educated, got a couple of master's degrees and did
- 26:41pretty well. And I believed some really bullshit stuff when I was younger,
- 26:47and questioning what you hear, especially when it's told in a convincing manner,
- 26:53is tough. I still fall for stuff. I've had to train myself that
- 26:57as soon as I hear something that go out. Wait a second, let's
- 27:03google and find out. Let's find out before you go and post this immediately
- 27:08to your three hundred and twelve thousand followers on Facebook. Let's do some due
- 27:12diligence here. And you know, I've been doing this for years, exposing
- 27:17bullshit. You know, when I used to be a fitness writer, I
- 27:18got my column with the Los Angeles Times because I was exposing bullshit in the
- 27:23fitness, health and weight loss industry. So I've been paid as a sort
- 27:29of skeptic for a long time, and I still have that urge to immediately
- 27:34believe the first thing, that as soon as I hear something, because it
- 27:38provokes an emotional response which overrides, you know, the prefrontal cortex, and
- 27:45you're just not fuck that got a rage, right, And I think there's
- 27:51something naturally, Like you talked about people being afraid and fear of selling.
- 27:56Yeah, that's how we survived as a species because we have long had a
- 28:00very violent history of you know, if it wasn't you know, sabertooth murder
- 28:06beasts that we had to worry about, it was it was our fellow hominids
- 28:11that we had to worry about, and or you know, constantly being fearful
- 28:17of diseases and having enough food and all that kind of stuff. That we
- 28:22are innately fearful beings because it's something that's allowed us to survive. So when
- 28:30some polished media douche comes on and tells us to be afraid of this,
- 28:36our instinctive response is to believe them and to be afraid. You're not just
- 28:41a historian, but you're also like the Vitruvian man, Like you're a fitness
- 28:45guy. You're extremely healthy. You wrote the book about being extra healthy.
- 28:49Is that part of a journey of yours? I know, like pen Gillette
- 28:53just recently in the last few years, lost one hundred pounds and he wrote
- 28:57a book about how we did it. Was that what happened with you?
- 29:02No, I got into so I got the freshman fifteen times a few when
- 29:07I was in university, and after I finished my undergrad which was in a
- 29:11history of course, I realized, wow, I really gained a lot of
- 29:15weight. And just as I'd been living with my girlfriend and I wanted to
- 29:21propose to her, so just as sort of a lark, I thought,
- 29:23I know, before I propose, I'm going to get in shape. And
- 29:26my mother had struggled with her weight her entire life, and I'd seen her
- 29:32try every bullshit gimmick that there was and obviously none of it worked. And
- 29:37so just sort of deep down I knew, well, okay, I think
- 29:41to get in shape, I need to stop eating so much crap, stop
- 29:45drinking so much booze, and start exercising. So that's basically what I did,
- 29:48and I got in shape. And then it wasn't until fifteen years later,
- 29:53you know, I'd gotten an MBA and I was working in marketing,
- 29:56and then around the age of forty, I was just like, you know,
- 30:00I don't really like this marketing stuff. I really wanted to be a
- 30:03writer. That was my passion, and I thought, well, fitness is
- 30:07an area where I felt that I had learned quite a bit, and I'd
- 30:11become quite passionate about it, and so that was I started with a local
- 30:15magazine writing for them, and then a year later I was the call of
- 30:18the fitness column MYSS for the Los Angeles Times. Because I was skeptical and
- 30:23science based, but also I was funny, you know, I was entertaining,
- 30:26and there wasn't a lot of that going on at the time. There
- 30:30weren't a lot of other writers that had that skill, I guess, and
- 30:33that's how I landed that job. It's one of the cruelties of life.
- 30:37As I age. I love food more. It tastes better, but you
- 30:41know, my metabolism moves at the speed of litigation. That just you know.
- 30:48And I've got some young people on our tennis team and then they can
- 30:52eat pizza at every meal and it's you. They look amazing, and I'm
- 30:55like, you just enjoy that. You just enjoy that one Just to wait
- 31:00one day you will wake up. The wellness industry. I love this conveniently
- 31:04nebulous term. A one trillion dollar plus industry where people are hawking all kinds
- 31:11of stuff, most of it unregulated by the FDA, and yet most of
- 31:15them get away with it. Right The Gwyneth Paltrows of the world are selling
- 31:19their vagina eggs and filling their pockets. So, as a wellness guy,
- 31:26give me some of the stuff that drives you the most crazy at least these
- 31:29days. Well, I'm certainly I don't consider myself a wellness guy anymore.
- 31:33That's a previous space former for wellness guy. As an everyday dude who looks
- 31:40around as a skeptic. What do you think what makes you nuts? I
- 31:45think, you know, one of the things about I think keto is one
- 31:48of the things that bothers me a lot because it's it's really not a healthy
- 31:53type of diet, and yet it's sold as the greatest diet you can possibly
- 31:56be on. And the thing is that most of the people that say either
- 32:00doing the keto diet are not in ketosis, and they wouldn't want to be
- 32:05anyway. It's not a healthy state of being. And as well as saying
- 32:08that it violates the you know, the laws of thermodynamics by saying that if
- 32:14you are on a low carb diet or a ketogenic diet, that you don't
- 32:19have to worry about calories. You can consume as many calories as you want,
- 32:22and that is just blatantly, blatantly false, and it has been disproven
- 32:27through randomized controlled trials time and time again that when it comes to losing weight,
- 32:34it is about creating a sustained chloric deficit. And it doesn't matter what
- 32:38the composition of your diet is. You could be eating nothing but fruit loops
- 32:43and frosted flakes, and if you are in a chloric deficit, you will
- 32:45lose weight. You could be eating nothing but boiled chicken and broccoli, and
- 32:51if you're in a chloric surplus, you will gain weight. And that's a
- 32:53fact. So that's that's the one that bothers me. The monster are going
- 32:58to get hate mail, I wrote. I slagged on ketogenic diets and low
- 33:06carb diets and anti sugar fear mongering for years and I got a lot of
- 33:12I'm used to it. But the thing about it, you know, we
- 33:15were talking about fear mongering. There's a lot of fear mongering in diet.
- 33:19And the one thing about low carb that quote unquote works for people is rule
- 33:25simplicity that following a specific type of diet is mentally taxing. It's a very
- 33:31difficult thing to do. And when people say, oh, don't eat carbs.
- 33:37They have a tendency to end up cutting out all sorts of problematic foods
- 33:42like, oh, well, you know, McDonald's cheeseburgers comes with a high
- 33:45carbohydrate bun. Therefore, I need to stop eating McDonald's cheeseburgers or donuts and
- 33:51other sort of treats like that. And it creates a very simple rule for
- 33:57them to follow, which defact do results in fewer calories being consumed and therefore
- 34:04leads to weight loss. And therefore they think that low carb diets are a
- 34:08miracle. And you could just say, you know what, another rule would
- 34:13be, well, just don't eat out anymore, just prepare meals at home
- 34:16and don't worry about your macronutrients nearly so much, and it would probably end
- 34:21up with the same type of a result. This is just such a bunny
- 34:23trail. It's not even remotely in my prep you know, I just just
- 34:28because it's we can move on. It's okay, no, no, no,
- 34:30but I mean we're just talking over coffee. I have a presentation that
- 34:34talks about deep seated beliefs, the stuff that's been branded into our brain that
- 34:37feels intuitive and when you come forward and you're like, well, actually,
- 34:40there's no science to back that up. People don't say that's interesting. Let
- 34:45me go and do some further digging. Can you send me some sources.
- 34:49I want to have the best idea. Instead they say no, no,
- 34:52no, that makes no sense. One of them was MSG. Right,
- 34:55MSG is not the horror movie that people say that. It isn of the
- 35:00natural foods that we eat, and people consume it all the time without a
- 35:04problem. You would have to have a massive amount of it to have any
- 35:07kind of reaction unless you have a specific allergy. We talk a little bit
- 35:13about gluten in that way. Sugar does not make children hyperactive. I said
- 35:17that the other day, and I thought they were going to circle my house
- 35:20with torches. Yeah, we both have a mutual friend ive at dontreumon the
- 35:23Sybabe that a feature years ago on chiropractic. I'm surprised that there hasn't been
- 35:30a fatua. I mean, I guess the level of vitriol against her was
- 35:37insane. Oh yeah, I remember that. The fallout from that was just
- 35:43brutal. And you know, I've experienced some online viciousness from some of the
- 35:47things I've written, and I don't think I've ever experienced anything like that.
- 35:52She was very brave to take that one on. And I think that everyone,
- 35:57even the most hardened skeptics of their pet bullshit, they don't want to
- 36:02let go of that. You know, people can be skeptical about religion and
- 36:08you know, crop circles and alien anal probes and all that kind of stuff,
- 36:13But then there's this one thing that it's like, no, I don't
- 36:15believe that. One of the ones that I ended up sharing that the amount
- 36:21of backlash that I got was just ridiculous. Was there was research that showed
- 36:25it been done via an MRI that showed that female squirting as a sexual thing,
- 36:37that mostly what was coming out was urine, and there were people in
- 36:40the comments that just freaked out. There was like, no way, she's
- 36:45not peeing. I'm not peeing. It was I'm afraid to google this one,
- 36:51James. Yeah, it's getting a little bit in C seventeen there,
- 36:57but yeah, it's that was the one. It was. It started with.
- 37:02I think it was that that Facebook page I Fucking Love Science shared this
- 37:07new research about it, and the comments were just unreal that these were people
- 37:10were fans of science and it's like, here's the science we're showing that,
- 37:14you know, during and it's not necessarily the same thing as female ejaculation.
- 37:20It's a different thing. But it's like, yeah, this or the female
- 37:23orgasm that results in this massive amount of liquid being expelled is mostly urine.
- 37:30And people lost their minds. They were really upset about that. It's just
- 37:36just a direction. I did not expect our conversation to go Jacks. People
- 37:39wanted to believe that there was some like magical orgasm bladder that's never showed up
- 37:45on any you know, sort of autopsy or CT scanner. Guys believe that
- 37:50their penises were so magical that it like opened a doorway in the space vagina
- 37:54continuum to like magically transport this love nectar outer something. Wow. So many
- 38:00little, so many little mini phrases in that notation that need notation. Talking
- 38:06here with historian James Fell, given that you call yourself a sweary historian,
- 38:10and that you are very colorful and an extremely funny way, I think you
- 38:15ever have sort of the you know, people show up with your their shirts
- 38:19button to the top, chastising you for being so profane. You know,
- 38:22you'd be so much more effective if you would stop with all of that swearing.
- 38:27Oh yeah, and it's it usually doesn't go well for them in the
- 38:30comment section because it's happened so often. I do have some very wonderfully dedicated
- 38:37followers on my Facebook page that it happens frequently enough that people will say,
- 38:43oh, you know, you sound uneducated and this would be a lot better
- 38:46if you didn't swear, and they usually get pretty dogpiled, and I just
- 38:52I let the dogpile happen because they can delete their comment if they don't like
- 38:54it, and usually they end up doubling and tripling down. But you know,
- 39:00people share articles saying that, you know, people who swear are actually
- 39:04more intelligent. I don't know if that's actually true or not, whether they're
- 39:07happier, you know, I would say, so they walked into your living
- 39:10room, James, they walk into your house, whether it's online on your
- 39:15page, I have the same thing happened. They'll walk in and go,
- 39:16well, that's not why I'm here, and I'm like, well, there's
- 39:20the door, right, kock off. Yeah, have a nice day,
- 39:22thanks for stopping by. And I think a less vitriolic response to that is
- 39:29there is no end of written history that has no profanity in it. Go
- 39:36read that instead. One of the things that has helped me reach a certain
- 39:42audience is people who like the profanity. If you don't like it, fine,
- 39:45duly noted, fuck off, go read somebody else. Well, it's
- 39:49it's not just that. I mean, I've seen and I've seen people who
- 39:52use a lot of color in their language. But and I'm not blowing smoke
- 39:57at you, but it's I think language which is a tool, right.
- 40:00You are punctuating something, You're looking for a specific reaction, You're coloring it
- 40:06in a specific way, and there's an art to that. I've seen people
- 40:08in the sound like a boy's locker room, but it's they're not communicating anything.
- 40:13It's not clever, but yours is. In fact, That's why I'm
- 40:15reading, and I'm kind of cracking up, but I'm also learning something.
- 40:19At the same time. I want to do some more history, like some
- 40:24sweary history lessons drawn out of his book More with James Fell. Next today,
- 40:37I have the pleasure of talking with a sweary historian, James Fell,
- 40:42author of the new book On This Day in History, shit went down.
- 40:50As we get into the final part of our conversation. I really want to
- 40:52hyper focus on the book. You pinball around centuries. You're here, You're
- 40:57in the fifteen hundreds. Oh wow, it's like, you know, last
- 41:00year. I mean, I don't know when it was. When's the most
- 41:01recent? Can you, I don't know, give me the brochure on what
- 41:05this book covers. I mean, it does go back to before the Common
- 41:12Era, as far back as you know, thousands and thousands of years ago
- 41:15that they were able to even though they were using a different calendar, people
- 41:19that were chronological scientists were able to determine, Okay, this thing happened on
- 41:23this day. Yeah, there's ancient Roman Empire, ancient Greek Empire, and
- 41:30a lot of it is more the last couple of centuries. But there's also
- 41:35more recent stuff I wrote about, like getting very recent. I wrote about
- 41:39the ship that got stuck in the Suez in twenty twenty one, but then
- 41:45I also use that just as a jumping off point to talk about the Suez
- 41:49were in nineteen fifty six, where the Egyptian president decided to sink a whole
- 41:55bunch of ships in the Suez Canal as part of the war that it ended
- 42:00up shutting it down for something like five months. And I also did a
- 42:02story about when Rudy Giuliani did his infamous press conference at the Four Season Landscaping
- 42:13Company, and there was a joke in there that there was a crematorium on
- 42:17one side and a porn store on the other side, and that he was
- 42:22between a cock and a charred place. We talked about the Zuez Canal.
- 42:28Actually wrote about this when evangelist Franklin Graham came out whenever they finally dislodged the
- 42:34ship that was stuck, and he's like, the Lord, the Lord,
- 42:37we prayed, and it has been dislodged. It's been like a week and
- 42:39a half. And of course they were waiting for the tides because of you
- 42:45know, the cycle of the moon and gravity and all those things. So
- 42:47I'm like, well, wait, wait a minute, God needed a week
- 42:50and a half to wait for the moon to do to the tides. What
- 42:52would have happened anyway, And people were over there digging and it's just absolutely
- 42:57insane, right, yeah, it's I mean, it's like gun violence.
- 43:00Thoughts and prayers has not done anything to prevent that. So it's anything like
- 43:07give me, I'll put you on the spot real fast. But give me,
- 43:09you know, one or maybe two specific stories out of the book.
- 43:14Give me, give me a more sola. We'll send them out there for
- 43:16the entire buffet. So one of the ones that I wrote about was the
- 43:20defenestrations of Prague that you know, I remember learning the word defenestration as a
- 43:24kid and thinking, oh, that's that's funny. It means to throw someone
- 43:28out a window and thinking it was a funny word, and then you know,
- 43:31wondering, let's like, wait, was that a thing that people actually
- 43:35did? And as it turned out, there were three different ones I wrote
- 43:37about, mostly about the first one that happened in the early fifteenth century.
- 43:42These were people that were like proto reform us of the Catholic Church, is
- 43:46like almost a century before Martin Luther showed up and you know, came up
- 43:51with his ninety five reasons why the Catholic Church could fuck off. And there
- 43:55was this group in Prague that were called Hussas, and they were followers of
- 44:01a guy named Jan huss who was a church reformer and he'd been burned at
- 44:05the stake, you know, for praying wrong. And his followers were going
- 44:08to the town council to protest, and somebody threw a rock from the top
- 44:14of the town hall and hit one of the Hussites, and it gave everybody
- 44:19a grand fucking idea, and they went in and threw a bunch of members
- 44:22of the town council out of this high window and they died because those kind
- 44:27of checks don't bounce. But but yeah, then there was so that became
- 44:35a thing called the Defenestrations of Prague. That there was another one a century
- 44:39later, and then another one a century after that, and it was the
- 44:43one it was I think it was in about sixteen nineteen, I think.
- 44:47And the funny thing about that one was that there was another one of these,
- 44:51you know. It was this was after Protestantism had gotten legs, and
- 44:54again it was Protestants versus Catholics, and they threw a bunch of people out
- 44:59of I think it was the Prague Castle. And they didn't die, though,
- 45:02because they landed in a big manure pile, so they didn't die.
- 45:07And of course the Catholics had to say, oh, they were saved by
- 45:08angels, but no, it was actually a pile of shit that saved them.
- 45:12But the thing, the result of that was that it initiated the Thirty
- 45:15Years War that resulted in something like eight million deaths that were you know,
- 45:22it spread across Europe. That was largely battles between Catholics and Protestants because you
- 45:28know, the Catholic Church was losing power to the Protestant Reformation and they didn't
- 45:32like that one bit. You know, it's funny when I read your stuff,
- 45:37but I read any when I read Evet. You know, she likes
- 45:40to post this moment in science. I'm struck by just how awful we've been.
- 45:46I I really do try to see the good in people when I think
- 45:51there's a lot of good out there, But I also look around and I
- 45:54think, why, how well? Who was who thought that was moral?
- 45:58And who did? How could someone in that kind of cruelty? And you
- 46:01know, she wrote an article together. I couldn't even finish it about you
- 46:04know how they back in the space race days they put a dog in a
- 46:07rocket, and you know, I can't even think about it because it makes
- 46:12money. So as you look at the history, just we'll finish with a
- 46:15philosophical note. When you look at the history of history and the behavior of
- 46:20humankind, are we good what do you think. You know, it's funny,
- 46:29I think that the average person is and you know, we're very communal,
- 46:35and you look at modern society today, the vast majority of us are
- 46:39not murderers. The vast majority of us are not terrible people doing terrible things.
- 46:45The problem is is that the way that society has worked across the millennia
- 46:52is that it's usually the meanest motherfuckers that end up in charge. That someone
- 46:58who is willing to lie, cheat, the kill, use their power in
- 47:02order to gain more power end up achieving it, and then others, you
- 47:07know, the vast majority of society are bystanders looking for who is going to
- 47:15come out on top, and then we're going to end up following them because
- 47:17you know, they don't want to try and get into the fray. The
- 47:22famous quote that most of us know is that power corrupts, and absolute power
- 47:27corrupts absolutely. There's more to that quote that I can't remember it exactly,
- 47:31but it's something to the effect of powerful men are almost always bad men,
- 47:37and that's that ends up being true. So the typical human ends up just
- 47:44being a bystander to those who are willing to duke it out and usually it's
- 47:49the most vicious that ends up on top, and they end up controlling our
- 47:52lives. I have that conversation when I talk to people and they talk about
- 47:55karma, the sort of cosmic equilibrium. You know, they're going to get
- 48:00what's coming, what goes around comes around. I'm like, Karma's crap.
- 48:02Like we all know people, terrible people who got away with it, and
- 48:07we know lovely people who just got their asses kicked for their entire life.
- 48:12The whole idea and beyond that. When I read the headlines every single day,
- 48:15I think it was Carlin who said something along the lines of inside every
- 48:20cynic is a frustrated idealist, James, I'm a frustrated idealist man. Yeah,
- 48:27I'm meant wide eyed wonder about the world, about the future, and
- 48:30I'm struggling. Brother, you know, I am as well. There's a
- 48:35famous quota. It was not originally said by doctor Martin Luther King Junior,
- 48:38but it was popularized by him. It was actually a nineteenth century white dude
- 48:43pastor who came up. I can't remember his name, but it goes the
- 48:46arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice, and
- 48:51unfortunately that's not true. I mean, doctor King was a very religious man,
- 48:57and I'm not. I don't believe that there is any other worldly power
- 49:01that is guiding us. The only way that the moral arc of our species
- 49:07bends is if we humans band together, working toward bending it towards justice.
- 49:13And unfortunately, there's a lot of pushback from those who are of more conservative,
- 49:20fascist type mindsets that think that you know, I got mine, fuck
- 49:24you, And they're very insular and protectionists and do not believe that the rising
- 49:30tide is going to raise all boats. They see life as a zero sum
- 49:35game. And you look at the majority of people in the United States do
- 49:42have fairly progressive ideals, and yet a very loud, vicious minority, which
- 49:51is still quite sizable, is able to seize power because they're able to do
- 49:57unethical, immoral things in order to to gain that power. So it becomes
- 50:02disheartening to see that the majority wishes are being trampled upon by a vicious minority
- 50:10that's just willing to do anything to win. Because when you're willing to do
- 50:15anything to win, you often do. Those who do not learn from history
- 50:20are destined to repeat it. Sorry, I just brought that full circle.
- 50:22James, you see what I did? You see what I did? And
- 50:24actually the actual quote it was George Santiana. I believe it was around early
- 50:30twentieth century philosopher, historian. It's actually condemned to repeat it is the way
- 50:37it goes, which makes it a little more ominous. See, this is
- 50:39why I need to speak to someone who actually knows history before I do quotes
- 50:44from historical figures. James Fell. I'm going to include the link to the
- 50:47book because it's awesome. I learned a lot. I laughed out loud.
- 50:52It's digestible. The chapters, I mean you can sit back and you can
- 50:55actually they're they're concise enough you could read them aloud to a friend. And
- 51:00that's just that kind of stuff. So you know, I'm a fan.
- 51:04I think we learn best through stories, and you're a wonderful storyteller. And
- 51:08I appreciate you having a conversation with us today and good luck with the book.
- 51:12Well, thanks so much. If I can give like just a very
- 51:15brief plug for it, please do. It has been incredibly popular as a
- 51:21holiday gift, So if you're wondering what to buy for somebody that only costs
- 51:23you know, twenty two dollars. You can get that. And the other
- 51:28thing that was I was very surprised to learn that kids actually love it.
- 51:34That I did not write this book for kids, definitely not, and yet
- 51:37there are many children. I heard from a lot of parents and said,
- 51:39oh, yeah, I bought this book and my kids stole it and they
- 51:43won't give it back. And these are quite often kids that don't even like
- 51:45to read. I've learned that I've turned many kids into readers because the stories
- 51:51are short, they're four hundred to five hundred words, and they're unapologetic and
- 51:54you know, very liberal leaning and full of profanity. And kids seem to
- 52:00love it. So if you have a team that you think you're not sure
- 52:04what to get them as a gift, then I could teach them some new
- 52:07words. His website Jamesfell dot com. Thanks again for coming, man,
- 52:13Oh, thank you so much. I had a really good time today.
- 52:15I appreciate it. Set Follow the Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a
- 52:20complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the
- 52:24Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming
- 52:30free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com