Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Legal Ethics in the Age of Social-Media Discovery
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:06Legal Ethics in the Age of Social Media Discovery.
- 0:10I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:12Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:14Association. And now I am delighted to introduce
- 0:17our speaker for today's program, speakers, I
- 0:20should say, Serena Perali and Christopher Perali.
- 0:24Serena is a co -founder of Perali Law. She's
- 0:26a trial lawyer and specializes in representing
- 0:29clients who have suffered catastrophic injuries.
- 0:32During her career, she has secured millions of
- 0:34dollars in settlements for clients, even securing
- 0:37one of the top 100 personal injury settlements
- 0:39in the country in 2020 and a top 10 premise liability
- 0:43settlements in California in 2025. Christopher
- 0:47is also a co -founder of Perali Law, where he
- 0:49leads the firm's litigation practice and focuses
- 0:52on catastrophic injury cases on behalf of individuals.
- 0:55He began his career representing Fortune 500
- 0:58companies in complex litigation, including matters
- 1:01that reach the US Supreme Court. He was also
- 1:04selected to co -author a section on the California
- 1:07Consumer Privacy Act for the California Illegation
- 1:10Review published by the California Lawyers Association.
- 1:13Since co -founding Perali Law in 2021, the firm
- 1:16has recovered more than $100 million for injured
- 1:19clients. We're so excited to hear what they have
- 1:21to share with us today, so I'm now going to turn
- 1:22it over to them. Thank you so much, Alla. So
- 1:27pleasure to meet you all. Today's presentation
- 1:30has to do with the ethics in the age of social
- 1:34media discovery. It's something that in almost
- 1:37every single one of our cases, we have to deal
- 1:40with both good and bad. And sometimes the defense
- 1:44also has to deal with as well. So let me share
- 1:47the PowerPoint. Give me a second. Sure. Are we
- 2:06good? Yes. Okay. Awesome. And again, thank you
- 2:10all for showing up. I know this is one of the
- 2:12more interesting topics. There's going to be
- 2:16some case law discussion, but more importantly,
- 2:19I'm going to give some great examples of a case
- 2:21that we tried and how social media kind of bit
- 2:24us in the rear. And then two other cases where
- 2:27the defense thought they had us on some social
- 2:30media that with a little bit of context made
- 2:33them look horrible. That's the fun stuff. But
- 2:36let's get through the case law and some examples
- 2:38first and the framework. So our mantra when it
- 2:42comes to social media is to be proactive and
- 2:45not reactive. I'm probably going to say this
- 2:48a few times, but once you start making excuses,
- 2:55multiple excuses, or trying to put things into
- 2:57context multiple times, it starts to not look
- 3:02so great for the client. Even the most non -nefarious
- 3:07things, some very normal pictures, if you constantly
- 3:11have to explain yourself over and over and over
- 3:15again, it starts to affect credibility. So our
- 3:21mantra is be proactive. Don't let it get there.
- 3:25Give me one second. All right. So here's the
- 3:29presentations chopped up kind of into four tranches.
- 3:33The landscape of what social media is and how
- 3:37it affects our cases. Your duties. of how to
- 3:41counsel on these issues and how to preserve evidence
- 3:44and not run into any issues with the court, discovery,
- 3:47both from the defense and from you, and the ethics,
- 3:51the scope, and the SCA, which is the Communications
- 3:55Act that we'll get into, and then how this all
- 3:57plays out at trial. I know these slides can sometimes
- 4:04be cheesy, but when I look at these numbers,
- 4:07it's staggering. So 5 .3 billion global users
- 4:11as of April of 2025 are on social media. 65 %
- 4:16of the world's population happens to be on social
- 4:20media. Estimated of almost 5 .9 billion folks
- 4:24by 2027 will be on social media. And it's been
- 4:27an evolving medium for about 30 years. Social
- 4:31media has popped up about 30 years ago, and they're
- 4:35morphing and changing every single year. And
- 4:39we like to treat, at Perali Law, social media
- 4:41as, we like to treat social media as a potential
- 4:46exhibit. Anything on your client's social media
- 4:49feed, and this is really prevalent in our practice
- 4:52of personal injury, Can and will be used against
- 4:56you in depositions and a trial so it's very important
- 4:59for you to understand that a Social media is
- 5:03incredibly prevalent everyone almost everyone
- 5:06is on it and photos reels Stories can all be
- 5:13taken out of context and used against your clients
- 5:16So, you know, this is a great slide to give the
- 5:23social media post some context of how it becomes
- 5:28an exhibit and how it gets taken out of context.
- 5:32So one of your clients could go check in at the
- 5:35gym. They go to a beach party or a vacation.
- 5:38None of those photos in isolation disprove your
- 5:43client's injuries. But what they do is they start
- 5:46to Allow the defense to create this exaggeration
- 5:51inference, even though it 99 % of the time is
- 5:55not true at all. But when you have multiple of
- 5:57these photos back to back to back to back and
- 6:00you're sitting at trial, it starts to build this
- 6:03inference that maybe the plaintiff is actually
- 6:06all right. Maybe they're having a great time
- 6:09while they're at the beach. You know, doesn't
- 6:12live like their life is too bad compared to what
- 6:14they said at this on the stand. So another thing
- 6:17is you know, social media is not chronological.
- 6:21It doesn't order everything in your life in a
- 6:25chronological order. Sometimes you can post a
- 6:27picture from three years ago that has nothing
- 6:31to do with your current state. And unless you
- 6:35can explain yourself or authenticate and show
- 6:38that that picture was from a previous time before
- 6:41the incident, before the injury, it can really
- 6:43affect you. Another thing to keep in mind is
- 6:47Friends and families can tag your clients in
- 6:50photos or posts. It's not just sorry, stories,
- 6:56photos or posts that your client puts up. They
- 6:58can be tagged in a different medium. So it's
- 7:01very important to understand that, you know,
- 7:04you have a good understanding of your client's
- 7:06social media, but also Who they're close with,
- 7:10who their front families with check their social
- 7:13media to see if there's any tags that may pop
- 7:16up later. Um, this is a great, so this, this
- 7:21happened in one of my earlier cases. Uh, one
- 7:24of my clients right before trial on LinkedIn
- 7:28hit open to work, you know, on the LinkedIn banner,
- 7:31the purple ring around your profile. That was
- 7:34painful because this client. I don't think they
- 7:38knew that they clicked on that, or I think they're
- 7:40browsing through LinkedIn. And that bit us in
- 7:43the rear when the client was trying to explain
- 7:45that they can't work the way that they used to.
- 7:49They couldn't do the job that they were once
- 7:50doing before. And that one little innocent click
- 7:54on LinkedIn was a sore topic. So what we do at
- 8:00Prolly Law, is as soon as we take in a case,
- 8:03along with everything else that we do for the
- 8:07investigation into the case, into the client,
- 8:10into everything that we, you know, to make sure
- 8:12it's a case that we can take on, we also ask
- 8:15them for everything about their social media,
- 8:19every single account that they're on, right?
- 8:22Whether it's LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok. Facebook,
- 8:27whatever it may be, we ask them for every single
- 8:31account and even accounts that they don't currently
- 8:34have or that were deactivated. We also go through
- 8:37the content ourselves. This is incredibly important.
- 8:41This isn't something that you pawn off and you,
- 8:45you don't, you know, you don't think about for
- 8:47the next three years. It's very important, especially
- 8:49on catastrophic adjuring cases, especially on
- 8:52cases that there might be some type of credibility
- 8:54issue, maybe a disputed liability case, um, you
- 8:57know, cause credibility cuts a million different
- 9:00ways. Um, if the jury finds you not credible
- 9:03on one topic, it's going to leak over to a few
- 9:06different things. Um, so again, Search the accounts.
- 9:10Look at everything. Put the context of the case
- 9:14and the injuries and the incident through the
- 9:16lens of their social media to see if it matches
- 9:18up, to see if your flags go up. Also understand
- 9:22your clients' habits. I have clients that post
- 9:25one time a year, and I have clients that post
- 9:2710 times a day. It depends, right? And those
- 9:30can mean completely different things in the context
- 9:33of litigation. So again, clients that share every
- 9:38single thought they have on social media, those
- 9:41clients need to be handheld a little bit more.
- 9:46You need to explain to them how the social media
- 9:49posts may implicate their case, how it may affect
- 9:52their credibility. We'll go into what you can
- 9:55tell them legally and ethically and what you
- 9:59should do, but just kind of as a precursor. And
- 10:02again, the why you have to tell them, hey, everything
- 10:07you do can be used against you. I understand
- 10:10that you still want to live your life. I understand
- 10:12you're not, you know, you can still go to the
- 10:16beach, you could still celebrate a birthday,
- 10:18but be mindful of what those photos may look
- 10:21like and be mindful that it may be used against
- 10:24you at a later time. Chris, can I just raise
- 10:27a point? Absolutely. If you could go back for
- 10:29a second. Again, we're looking at everything
- 10:33through the lens of trial, even though most cases
- 10:36don't end up going to trial. So for intake, you
- 10:39know, through pre lit through litigation, I always
- 10:42have checkpoints that, you know, sometimes I'll
- 10:45have our paralegals or staff calendar on their
- 10:48own separate calendars to go back through the
- 10:50lifetime of the case and look up those handles
- 10:53if they're public, which we'll get to later,
- 10:56meaning that anyone can access them. and take
- 10:59a look and make sure that there isn't anything
- 11:02that's, you know, red flag. And the reason that
- 11:05you want to do that, and again, we'll get into
- 11:07this a little bit later, is not to tell them
- 11:09to delete it because that is completely unethical.
- 11:12You don't want them to do that, but to get behind
- 11:14the ball and not have surprises later, for example,
- 11:18in a deposition about something that you really
- 11:20didn't know about. You took your client's word
- 11:23on, you know, I haven't posted since we signed
- 11:25up the case. Well, in fact, if you actually looked,
- 11:28maybe a month after signing, they forgot that
- 11:29they posted something. So you really want to
- 11:33get behind the ball. So one of the things, again,
- 11:35I have my staff do, whoever it is, case manager
- 11:38or eventually paralegal who's helping me litigate
- 11:41the case, is just make a calendar entry, go through
- 11:44all the handles again, and make sure that there's
- 11:48nothing new that we didn't know about. I mean,
- 11:54that's a great point. And I'll say this, you
- 11:56know, depending on the type of case, we will
- 11:59also Sreena. uh, myself, Ali or whatever attorneys
- 12:04in our office that's handling the case, we will
- 12:07go through it ourselves as well. If it's a case
- 12:09where there's disputed liability, you know, there's
- 12:12going to be some type of credibility fight. Um,
- 12:15you know, the defense is talking about liens
- 12:17the whole time and attorney referral care and
- 12:20all that fun stuff. Um, you want to make sure
- 12:24that you don't have this leak in your ship where
- 12:28Again, that single leak can now cause some type
- 12:32of inferences to come into the jury's mind. And
- 12:36again, like Serena said, not every case goes
- 12:38to trial. We've tried a handful of cases out
- 12:40of the hundreds that we've settled over the past
- 12:42few years, but still. If everything's prepared
- 12:46as if it's going to trial, you're going to get
- 12:48much better settlements. So going back to our
- 12:51process, so there's the intake artifact. It's
- 12:56a social media form. Almost every firm I know
- 13:00does this. And if you guys don't, you absolutely
- 13:02should, is send some type of letter. to the client
- 13:06explaining everything, telling them that we need
- 13:09all of their handles, all of their usernames,
- 13:12active or dormant, to preserve everything and
- 13:15don't delete anything. We also advise them, hey,
- 13:21you may want to potentially pause posts or revise
- 13:26posts before posting them, or thinking about
- 13:28posting posts before posting them, because these
- 13:31may affect your case. Again, we never... ever
- 13:35tell them to delete anything. That's not ethical.
- 13:39We never do that, nor should you. We tell them
- 13:43in this letter that anything posted may be used
- 13:45in court and may be used against them in public.
- 13:48And why it matters? So not only do we send them
- 13:53this letter, we advise them to sign it, just
- 13:56so you have a document of a date and a time that
- 13:59you counseled your client and told them the pros
- 14:02and cons of social media and how it may affect
- 14:05their case. It matters. I've had a case where
- 14:08we told this to the client before we started
- 14:11making them sign these forms. We told them, hey,
- 14:14we sent them the standard social media letter
- 14:16that everyone does. Three years later, The social
- 14:20media came around, bit us in the rear, and the
- 14:22client was like, hey, you never told us this.
- 14:24And I had the email that we sent to them that
- 14:27showed them everything that we told them of.
- 14:29We obviously talked to them over the phone. We
- 14:31tell them about it. And it's much better to have
- 14:34it in writing. It's safer for everybody. One
- 14:37thing, sorry, Chris, I want to say just as an
- 14:39intro, if you could go back before we get into
- 14:41the rules, what it warns. So one thing that I,
- 14:47you know, many, many plaintiffs, right? I mean,
- 14:50we're catering this discussion to both plaintiffs,
- 14:53plaintiff and defense counsel, but on the plaintiffs
- 14:55end, right? A lot of plaintiffs, this is their
- 14:58first time, you know, filing a lawsuit. You know,
- 15:01getting into deep legation, having their depositions
- 15:03taken and maybe even going to trial, right? Very
- 15:07few and far between. They don't know what to
- 15:09expect litigation, let alone the process of having
- 15:13every part of their life picked apart. And one
- 15:16thing when they don't understand that process,
- 15:19the best. I could do is explain to them exactly
- 15:21what the next two, three years is going to look
- 15:23like if I could tell already that it's going
- 15:26to go through a heavy set of litigation and ultimately
- 15:29maybe trial if, for example, liability is very
- 15:31disputed or the damages are extremely disputed.
- 15:36But one thing I tell them is this idea that the
- 15:40defense does a really good job. in those heated
- 15:44cases to do sub rosa where you know they hire
- 15:47an independent company to follow the plaintiff
- 15:49to kind of figure out is this person being credible
- 15:52about their injuries or what do they do on the
- 15:54day to day and typically it's done before depositions
- 15:58for impeachment purposes at the time of deposition
- 16:01but anyway i explained to the client look uh
- 16:04this is something that's done so you know um
- 16:07just be mindful of it but Social media nowadays
- 16:10is free sabrosa for defense attorneys and when
- 16:14Chris will explain we've used this on the defense
- 16:17as well so it is a free platform and what better
- 16:20way to get sabrosa footage than from the plaintiff
- 16:23themselves right and it is I mean you could really
- 16:27get impeached as a plaintiff if you're posting
- 16:29something in the defense you know. And not only
- 16:33is it the photo kind of damning if it's really
- 16:35bad, but sometimes what's written underneath
- 16:38it can be just as equally damaging. Sorry, or
- 16:44the username of the client. They could have an
- 16:50interesting username on their social media and
- 16:53that's not the best when it's published as an
- 16:55exhibit. into trial and the jury's you know you
- 16:59have a 65 year old woman that's sitting there
- 17:02that's very conservative that looks up and sees
- 17:04a pretty wild name it's not fun it's not fun
- 17:08i found that obviously our older clients um you
- 17:12know they understand this concept of sabrosa
- 17:15and how this is a form of sabrosa but it's really
- 17:18The younger generation who's now grown up not
- 17:20knowing anything but social media and constantly
- 17:23posting and sharing their lives that find this
- 17:25an issue they just don't see how it could potentially
- 17:28affect them like years down the line like they
- 17:30don't care you know summer right now they're
- 17:32going to go out they want to do something it
- 17:34doesn't mean that they're not injured or they're
- 17:36you know just generally they're not suffering
- 17:38from their injuries or having a hard time but
- 17:41they like to share their lives because it's what
- 17:43they've known to do anyhow so point is. it's
- 17:48really it is a type of subversive. So that's
- 17:50something I also explain. Go ahead, Chris. Thank
- 17:54you. OK, so the rule, it's rules of professional
- 17:59conduct 3 .4a. So it prohibits unlawfully obstructing
- 18:05another party's access to evidence or unlawfully
- 18:09altering, destroying or concealing a document
- 18:11or other material having potential evidentiary
- 18:14value. So The purpose of this is so both sides
- 18:21have a free and fair opportunity to get all the
- 18:25facts in the case and get all the evidence to
- 18:27try their case or to litigate their case. You
- 18:30don't want one side to gatekeep access to information
- 18:34that the other side legally has a right to obtain.
- 18:37So essentially, we cannot scrub a client's digital
- 18:42history. We cannot advise the client to delete
- 18:46posts. We cannot interrupt that process at all.
- 18:50What we can do is tell the client, educate the
- 18:54client and anticipate what the defense might
- 18:56do or the other side might do with the photos
- 18:59that you do already have or stories or reels
- 19:02that you already do have. So what documents exist
- 19:05when this rule triggers and we'll get into how
- 19:08this rule is triggered need to be preserved.
- 19:11You can't delete them. It's simple as that. I've
- 19:13heard A lot of people do a lot of things that
- 19:16are not proper, but I just want to make sure
- 19:19that everyone here understands that you can't
- 19:22go in there and cherry pick and delete the stuff
- 19:24that you don't like. That's just not ethical.
- 19:28Not only is this a model rule. sorry, an ethical
- 19:33rule. There's also a business and professional
- 19:35code section that implicate both moral turpitude
- 19:40and deceit if you go in there and start deleting
- 19:42things for your client. Sorry. Sorry, go ahead.
- 19:48Or advising them to delete anything. Exactly.
- 19:51Or telling them, advising them that you have
- 19:54to delete so -and -so. Sorry, Chris. Sorry, just
- 19:58one point here. By the way, Even if the client
- 20:02says I've always been a private user, meaning
- 20:05for the I mean, I'm sure everyone knows what
- 20:07that means, but essentially a private use being
- 20:10on private on any social media platform means
- 20:13that. An invitation must be sent to your client
- 20:16in order for them to accept it for that other
- 20:19user to be able to access your client's profile
- 20:21on social media. So sometimes clients say, well,
- 20:24I'm on private. No one's going to be able to
- 20:26see, you know, I've been on private my entire
- 20:29lifetime on social media. No one's going to be
- 20:31able to see. anything that I've ever posted,
- 20:34but can I just delete some of the things that
- 20:36I've already posted? And the answer is no, you
- 20:38cannot, right? They need to preserve all of those
- 20:41photos, whether or not they're private. So I
- 20:43just wanted to put it out there. Go ahead, Chris.
- 20:47As the previous slide we went over, I don't want
- 20:49to waste your time. So, okay, when does the duty
- 20:53attach? So it's a objective test. It's not a
- 20:57subjective test. So the duty is triggered when
- 21:00a party is objectively on notice that litigation
- 21:03is reasonably foreseeable, meaning probable and
- 21:07likely to arise from the incident or dispute.
- 21:09It's not just a mere possibility. So this doesn't
- 21:12mean that the duty attaches when you're filing
- 21:15a lawsuit or you're on the verge of filing a
- 21:18lawsuit or if you already filed a lawsuit. It's
- 21:21an objective standard when it's reasonably foreseeable.
- 21:27That's a phrase that Is tough to grapple with
- 21:30because it doesn't give you a bright line rule
- 21:32per se, but. I would always err on the side of
- 21:36caution. Some would argue that it's reasonably
- 21:39foreseeable that after getting rear ended. um
- 21:42you know and the driver comes out of the car
- 21:44and says hey it wasn't my fault boom you know
- 21:47that hey you may have to file a lawsuit it's
- 21:50probably reasonably foreseeable that if this
- 21:52guy that rear -ended you is disputing liability
- 21:54that you're going to file so from that point
- 21:56forward that duty attaches um At the bottom,
- 22:00like I said, it's an objective test. It's not
- 22:03subjective. It's not the impression or what the
- 22:07client thinks may be coming. It's an objective
- 22:11standard. And it's not certainty and it's not
- 22:15imminence. The standard doesn't require litigation
- 22:18to be certain. So as long as it's reasonably
- 22:22foreseeable. So let's go to the next slide. So
- 22:30code of civil procedure, 2023 .030 F acts absent
- 22:36exceptional circumstances. The court shall not
- 22:40impose sanctions for failure to provide ESI,
- 22:44um, electronically stored information, uh, lost,
- 22:47damaged, altered, or overwritten as a result
- 22:50of routine good faith operation of, uh, in electronic
- 22:54information system. So essentially if there was
- 22:57some type of auto deletion, This is more for
- 23:00the defendants. I don't think I've ever had a
- 23:03plaintiff that does this. I could imagine a situation
- 23:07where there's a social media influencer that
- 23:09likes to curate their feed and delete stuff from
- 23:12the bottom, right, and to keep it fresh. There's
- 23:15that possibility. So as long as, you know, there's
- 23:19not going to be any sanctions imposed for someone
- 23:21that's doing it in routine and good faith. Once
- 23:25that duty attaches, right? Once that duty is
- 23:28there, you can't say, Hey, our system just deleted
- 23:31everything. Once that duty is there, you should
- 23:34know, Hey, We need to be scrupulous. We need
- 23:36to go through everything. We can't just delete
- 23:38these photos for no reason, as long as you think
- 23:41they may be implicated in the case. So if it's
- 23:44a photo of someone eating a piece of cake that
- 23:47they didn't want to post, that's probably not
- 23:49going to be an exhibit used in a personal injury
- 23:52case. But if it's a photo of someone doing a
- 23:54backflip on the beach, different story. All right.
- 24:02So. This may seem aggressive, but it is a best
- 24:07practice. You can't delete the photos once the
- 24:14duty attaches, so you should preserve it. This
- 24:18is a lot of information for the defense, I believe.
- 24:22It's better for the defense. I did work on the
- 24:25defense side for a little bit. in Big Law before
- 24:27I came to the plaintiff's side, so all of this
- 24:29was familiar with me. But in the PI practice,
- 24:32we don't necessarily go through these steps as
- 24:35aggressive, but it's very important that there's
- 24:38some type of internal litigation hold, that there's
- 24:42some type of export of the native information,
- 24:46the native data that you have, whether it's texts,
- 24:49photos, whatever it may be. It's held, secured,
- 24:52siloed. exported and all the metadata is captured
- 24:55with that information. Again, on the PI side,
- 24:59we don't really have to go, sorry, on the plaintiff
- 25:03side rather in PI cases, we don't have to go
- 25:05to these great lengths. If you want to be super
- 25:10secure, you could always go through the social
- 25:14media platform and screenshot photos that you
- 25:17may think are relevant, that the defense may
- 25:19already have, and might be waiting for you to
- 25:22mess up and delete or alter. So it's very important
- 25:28that you keep it because nothing is worse than
- 25:32the other side knowing that you have altered
- 25:36or deleted photos or information. That's the
- 25:40cardinal rule. You just can't do that. Not only
- 25:43is it unethical, not only is the judge going
- 25:45to come down on you, not only will there be sanctions,
- 25:48probably not terminating sanctions, but there
- 25:50will be sanctions. But if it goes in front of
- 25:52a jury, it's just the worst thing that could
- 25:54happen. The cover -up is worse than the actual
- 25:58crime or the actual photo per se. So that's very
- 26:02important. This is a Virginia case. Uh, it's
- 26:06not in California, but in my research, I found
- 26:09this and it shocked me. So, uh, an attorney advised
- 26:12their client to clean up their Facebook page.
- 26:16That lawyer was sanctioned $500 ,000 and their
- 26:21license was suspended. Um, again, that's Virginia.
- 26:25It's not California, but it goes to show you
- 26:28that judges don't like this. It's not something
- 26:32that any of us should be doing and we should
- 26:33be very, very, very careful about it. This is
- 26:39something we all know. Once it's public, it's
- 26:43public, right? There's no requirement for a subpoena,
- 26:47no discovery request. There's no notice that
- 26:49you have that the defense is on your client's
- 26:52Instagram page, Facebook page, whatever it may
- 26:54be. If it's public, Assume the other side already
- 26:58has it. And Serena said it so well, it's, it's
- 27:01free sub rosa. It's just a living sub rosa that
- 27:06the defense can just check in and say, Hey, how's,
- 27:09you know, Mr. Johnson doing today? Let's see
- 27:11what they posted. Um, just be super, super cautious.
- 27:18Um, I want to say, sorry. Yeah. So when we're
- 27:24talking about, uh, Well the inception of the
- 27:27case so You know our firm we don't typically
- 27:30get the case pre -lit or right as it happens
- 27:33and most cases that we get either there they've
- 27:36been in litigation and we got to work it up for
- 27:38trial or We get the case and we know we're gonna
- 27:41file right away. It's just one of those cases
- 27:43however as a plaintiff's attorney if you do have
- 27:47a ton of pre -lit cases it's important again
- 27:50the minute that you get it if the incident has
- 27:52just happened, especially to advise your client
- 27:56of these issues because now I've been seeing,
- 28:00more often than I used to, adjusters, you know,
- 28:04they get a hold of social media as well. And,
- 28:07you know, when they call to try to settle a case
- 28:10or negotiate a demand that's been sent out, they
- 28:13point out, you know, social media posts. So that
- 28:16to me was really, really surprising because I
- 28:18used to see it kind of only in litigation, right?
- 28:22But now, again, even in pre -lit cases, if they're
- 28:27kind of big injuries and you know you could settle
- 28:29at pre -lit, client needs to be careful with
- 28:32what they're posting because, again, adjusters
- 28:35are looking at everything or peppering the file
- 28:38with the photos if they know that it's going
- 28:40to go into litigation, even if they're not going
- 28:41to negotiate a settlement with you. They'll do
- 28:44their due diligence. They'll go through all of
- 28:47the claimant at that time their social media
- 28:50pages and get everything that they can and put
- 28:53it into the file, you know, before it's sent
- 28:56off to defense counsel. Anyway, go ahead, Chris.
- 29:01So, you know, that previous slide was about a
- 29:03public profile, but, you know, something that
- 29:05we haven't even discussed at all during this
- 29:08presentation that You know, um, you know, I have
- 29:11a private Instagram profile. Um, what does that
- 29:14mean? Can the defense still get in there? Can
- 29:17the defense, um, still try to pull the photos?
- 29:20So, uh, the simple answer to that is no. Um,
- 29:26the defense can't either themself or I could
- 29:29say defense, no side can create either an account.
- 29:34and try to make a fake friend request to gain
- 29:37access to that account, nor can they hire a private
- 29:40investigator or an agent or someone to go out
- 29:42on their behalf to befriend the other, you know,
- 29:47plaintiff or defendant to try to get access to
- 29:49that private account. So the rules that create
- 29:52this construct are, you know, rule 4 .2, that's
- 29:57something we... We're taught super, super early.
- 30:00There's no direct or indirect communication with
- 30:03the person known to be represented about the
- 30:06subject of the representation without consent.
- 30:09You have rule 4 .1, no false statements. You
- 30:12can't knowingly make false statements of material
- 30:14factor law to a third person. You can't send
- 30:16them a message saying, hey, it's John from third
- 30:18grade. You remember me? Let's reconnect. Again,
- 30:238 .4C. You can't be deceitful, uh, fabricated
- 30:28profile used to gain access to private content
- 30:31is deceit. That's literally what it is. Can't
- 30:33do that. Um, and again, 8 .4, a no outsourcing.
- 30:37You can't hire someone to be your agent, to do
- 30:40something that ethically you're not allowed to
- 30:43do yourself. Um, I've never run into this. Have
- 30:47you run into the street? I have you ever caught
- 30:49the other side trying to do this? No. No, I thankfully
- 30:53not usually. I've heard stories. I have stories.
- 31:01I've heard stories and I do have some slides
- 31:03to kind of go into that in a second, but I've
- 31:06heard stories, but I personally, thankfully have
- 31:09never experienced this. Just in line with speaking
- 31:16to folks, so. You can speak to unrepresented
- 31:24witnesses. You may contact them directly. You
- 31:27have to identify yourself, explain the request.
- 31:30And if they say no, you have to take the refusal
- 31:34and just move on. And we'll get into this later
- 31:37too, but for jurors, so when I was doing my research
- 31:41and looking into things, I found an ethical opinion
- 31:46that had to do with an attorney. looking at a
- 31:50juror's LinkedIn. And you know how sometimes
- 31:53on LinkedIn, when you look at the profile, it
- 31:55tells you on the back end on the user that you
- 31:58looked at, it says, hey, so and so is looking
- 32:00at your profile. And that triggered a communication.
- 32:05And it was a big mess, big deal. So just a heads
- 32:08up, if you're doing research into the jury during
- 32:12trial, Uh, make sure that you have the type of
- 32:15LinkedIn account that doesn't leave that cookie
- 32:18crumb. Um, that doesn't, you know, ping the other
- 32:23side to let them know that this attorney or this
- 32:25person is staring at you, looking into you. It
- 32:28just makes them feel uncomfortable and it's,
- 32:30it's unethical. Um, all right. So. This goes
- 32:35in line with what we just talked about previously,
- 32:39that there's this fake friend requests and you
- 32:42know, they Trojan horse their way into your client's
- 32:45profile and start pulling stuff, um, from there.
- 32:49So essentially if the client always had a private
- 32:52profile, okay. It's not like they came to you
- 32:55and you told them, Hey, block it off. We know
- 32:58we're filing this lawsuit, go private, but rather
- 33:01They've always had a private profile. That's
- 33:03how they live their life. They like social media,
- 33:05but it's contained. It's not out for the world
- 33:08to see. You've, you've went through their whole
- 33:11entire Instagram. You've seen the good, the bad,
- 33:13and the ugly. Um, and you understand what might
- 33:17hurt you if the defense or the other side sends
- 33:21a proper discovery request that's tailored for
- 33:24that specific thing. Um, but they didn't and
- 33:27you're at a deposition and all of a sudden the
- 33:30defense pulls out this picture that you know
- 33:32for a fact that they should not have right um
- 33:35this is a kind of a step -by -step thing that
- 33:38you should go through so you know you know they've
- 33:41been they've been um private since the beginning
- 33:44At deposition, defense shows a photo for impeachment
- 33:46that was never exchanged and that they should
- 33:48not have had access to. So the inference is that
- 33:51there may have been some unethical contact made
- 33:53to gain access to your client's account. So before
- 33:57you raise any issues with the court, you have
- 34:00to work yourself backwards. So go through the
- 34:02client's account, see what friend requests they've
- 34:05gotten, see what friend requests they've accepted,
- 34:07understand how they may have gotten this information.
- 34:11Don't accuse the other side of breaching the
- 34:14professional rules that we previously spoke about.
- 34:18reverse engineering to figure out how they may
- 34:20have gotten it. And if it comes out that there's
- 34:23no way that they would have gotten this information
- 34:26except for sending a fake friend request or gaining
- 34:28access that they should not have had access to,
- 34:32then it's a huge issue that you must bring up
- 34:34to the court. Okay, scope and privacy. So, discovery
- 34:42reaches, as most of us know, Discovery reaches
- 34:46any non -privileged matter relevant to the subject
- 34:49matter of the action. Privacy is a qualified
- 34:53right. It's just, it's not an absolute shield.
- 34:55It's a pretty darn good shield, but it's not
- 34:59absolute. So what's a plaintiff puts a physical
- 35:03or emotional condition at issue? directly relevant
- 35:07content must be produced. So if the other side
- 35:11is smart about how they craft their discovery
- 35:15requests, they're going to be able to force you
- 35:19to produce certain things that you otherwise
- 35:22don't want to produce. We'll move on. So this
- 35:32is more for the defense than it is for the plaintiffs,
- 35:34but I've used precise drafting of discovery requests
- 35:37to get things out of the defense's Instagram
- 35:40that I've used in my cases, but that's very rare
- 35:44compared to the other way around. So, you know,
- 35:49produce your entire Facebook history, right?
- 35:51That type of discovery request. It's so broad.
- 35:55It's not precise. You could just absolutely destroy
- 35:58that object to it. No one's going to get compelled
- 36:01with that, but all photographs, videos or social
- 36:04media posts depicting plaintiff engaging in physical
- 36:07activities from the date of the incident to the
- 36:10present. That's tough. That's a tough one to
- 36:15say, Hey, that's vague and ambiguous or, you
- 36:18know, um, I know it's not an objection, but you
- 36:21know, sometimes. plaintiff's attorneys and defense
- 36:24attorney say, Hey, it's not relevant. Um, what's
- 36:27even better is if you can identify the specific
- 36:30accounts you're looking for, right? So all photographs
- 36:33and videos, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera on,
- 36:36um, plaintiffs Instagram account with the handle
- 36:39of at so -and -so, and that makes it even more
- 36:43targeted, even more narrow. Um, what, what, what
- 36:47I've seen is there's interrogatories that are
- 36:49sent to us saying, Hey, give us all of the social
- 36:53media platforms the plaintiff is on, and then
- 36:56they'll subsequently come back with another more
- 36:58tailored specific request. Serena, we're dealing
- 37:02with that in a case right now, right? Yeah, actually
- 37:06the defense did, I was just looking it up right
- 37:08now really quickly, the defense did a really
- 37:10good job, so we have a pretty contentious case.
- 37:17The defense sent a depot notice of one of one
- 37:20of our three plaintiffs and did a Request for
- 37:24production of documents and there was many many
- 37:28questions again. The whole concept was Instagram,
- 37:32but they broke up Everything that they wanted
- 37:35into like 20 different questions and they did
- 37:36a really good job, right? Please give us all
- 37:40your photographs in the past 10 years that you've
- 37:42posted on on Instagram, for example that shows
- 37:47any of the three plaintiffs on vacation or something
- 37:49like that. And even that they broke down. So
- 37:53I thought that they did a really good job. Not
- 37:55much was objectionable and I had to produce what
- 37:57they wanted. So again, like Chris said, key is
- 38:01to be very specific. And if you're not sure as
- 38:03a defense attorney, just take the concept and
- 38:06break it down into like 15 or 16 different, excuse
- 38:09me, 15 to 20 different requests for production
- 38:12of document questions. Yeah, I mean I mean that's
- 38:16the key to everything I think in our in our profession
- 38:18is to be super Tailored and super narrow just
- 38:24to get to the point and also not allow the defense
- 38:27or the other side any wiggle room Right, but
- 38:30it works both ways when we get hit with those.
- 38:33It's hey we have to comply so one big topic that's
- 38:41evolving, because this case is in front of the
- 38:44California Supreme Court. It's been there since
- 38:472024. There's no hearing scheduled, but it should
- 38:50be coming up soon. And it's being briefed like
- 38:53crazy from both sides. But it's the Stored Communications
- 38:58Act. So essentially, Section 2707 gives an aggrieved
- 39:05subscriber a private right of action. Actual
- 39:09damages, the violators' profits, statutory damages
- 39:12of at least a thousand dollars, and punitive
- 39:14damages for willful violations and attorney's
- 39:17fees. What is the Sword Communications Act? So
- 39:19essentially what it does is it prevents social
- 39:24media companies from complying with subpoenas
- 39:28in certain instances. It allows them some type
- 39:31of shield to not disseminate all of the user's
- 39:35content out there. There are some... exceptions.
- 39:39And, you know, it was mainly it was created due
- 39:43to a criminal case. So Section 2702 bars providers
- 39:50from disclosing private user content in civil
- 39:53cases. California discovery law does not override
- 39:58the SCA. So you can see in the O 'Grady case,
- 40:03the Superior Court stated that the Act makes
- 40:05no exception for civil discovery. And in Crispin,
- 40:09which is a great case, it extends the bar to
- 40:12social network sites hosting private messages.
- 40:15So if you're seeking production, you, so. You
- 40:21have to, so if your client's social media gets
- 40:25subpoenaed, um, it's going to go to, you know,
- 40:28meta or whatever company it may be. You can also
- 40:31try to argue that to the defense and the mean
- 40:33confer letter that, Hey, the SCA forecloses the
- 40:37subpoena. It's a losing battle. You're wasting
- 40:39your time. Um, and that request has to run through
- 40:42your party has to run through your plaintiff.
- 40:44They should be asking your client for that information,
- 40:47not the social media platforms. So consent is
- 40:54the exception that matters for the SCA. So in
- 40:58this case, Negro versus Superior Court. Insofar
- 41:03as the Act permits a disclosure, a court may
- 41:05compel that disclosure under state law. So as
- 41:09long as there's an exception to the SCA, it can
- 41:12be compelled. But Negro also holds that the California
- 41:17discovery law cannot be enforced in any matter
- 41:20that compels a provider to make a disclosure
- 41:22violating the SEA, um, again, it's to beat a
- 41:27dead horse. California discovery law does not
- 41:29supersede and does not overrule the SEA. Um,
- 41:34so the implied, the limit on implied consent
- 41:37was in the Facebook for superior court case.
- 41:40Right now, the case that's before the California
- 41:43Supreme court is snap versus superior court.
- 41:46And we'll get into that in a second. So, again,
- 41:52even though the SCA bars attorneys from subpoenaing
- 41:57these social media companies to get information
- 42:00from them, the content itself is still... free
- 42:04game if you go through the actual user, right?
- 42:08Um, so the, you know, this doesn't happen in
- 42:11these personal injury types of cases, but more
- 42:13in commercial cases, you know, the party downloads
- 42:15and produces their own archive. Um, consent can
- 42:18be established by a sworn declaration, identifying
- 42:21the account and expressly authorizing disclosure.
- 42:24If one side agrees, like, here you go. I've downloaded
- 42:27my own data from the website. I've compiled it.
- 42:29I've archived it. Here you go. that obviously
- 42:32that's fair game and that's okay. Someone with
- 42:36lawful access, a witness who received a message
- 42:39may produce what they hold, absent coercion or
- 42:42in terms of service violation. So again, if your
- 42:45client messaged someone or sent something to
- 42:48someone on the platform or outside of the platform
- 42:51from information from the platform, that's free
- 42:54game. They consented it. They put it out to a
- 42:56different person. This came up in the SNAP case,
- 43:00the SNAP v. Superior Court case that's in front
- 43:03of the California Supreme Court, is an in -camera
- 43:06review sometimes solves a lot of these problems.
- 43:09So a judge or special master's review, sorry,
- 43:14special master reviews and releases the relevant
- 43:16information. So the SNAP Court of Appeal itself
- 43:19directed production for an in -camera review
- 43:21to determine relevance. That is a route. that
- 43:25allows both sides kind of the freedom of information
- 43:28to grab what they want from the other side without
- 43:31that party kind of throwing away their privacy
- 43:35per se. This was a great point, and I think we
- 43:41should all understand this. The act, the SCA
- 43:44bars content, not account deactivation dates
- 43:49or login history. And I'll get into that later
- 43:54and Serena remind me if I forget, but that's
- 43:57a super important point. Okay, we talked about
- 44:04this, but. it started with the Facebook case,
- 44:09now it's with the Snap case. It's under review
- 44:13with the California Supreme Court. I think it's
- 44:16super important for everyone to pay attention
- 44:18to it. At the bottom of the slide right here,
- 44:21here is the docket number, S286267. Again, there's
- 44:27no hearing date that's currently set, but it's
- 44:29gonna be set very, very soon. And this case can
- 44:34radically change how our clients' social media
- 44:38profiles are used in litigation. So we'll see.
- 44:43I will say though, reading some of the briefing,
- 44:48it seems like it's a 90 to 10 split that... all
- 44:53the briefing is in favor of the social media
- 44:54companies to be able to block these subpoenas
- 44:59per se and not allow the content to be easily
- 45:02disseminated. I think Chemerinsky and there was
- 45:06one other group that was fighting it, but it's
- 45:10like a nine to one battle. All right. So this
- 45:17is the fun stuff. Uh, this is, this is probably
- 45:20why some of you are here. Um, so how do you deal
- 45:25with it? Right? So you have a case, you have
- 45:28a client, let's say it's a personal, personal
- 45:30injury case. Um, you get it referred to you after
- 45:35some pre, uh, pre litigation, um, sometimes even
- 45:39after litigation and you're left with some posts
- 45:42that you have to deal with. They don't look good.
- 45:44Your client saying they have a low back injury
- 45:46and there's some social media posts of them at
- 45:5024 hour fitness, or there's a social media post
- 45:53of them smiling at a birthday. God forbid. Um,
- 45:58so what do you do? So the question is never whether
- 46:01the post disproves the injury. It's whether it
- 46:05damages credibility. So very rarely does a photo.
- 46:11absolutely disprove the injury. Um, it would
- 46:14be like a guy saying, Hey, I can't lift a five
- 46:16pound bucket. And then there's a social, there's
- 46:19a post of him deadlifting 400 pounds. You have
- 46:22that. I'm sorry. Uh, your client's not being
- 46:26truthful. Um, and that's going to be a tough
- 46:29hill to climb. It's the other, it's the gray,
- 46:32it's the area where there's a bunch of happy
- 46:35photos, some type of physical activity, nothing
- 46:38too crazy, but you know, it's a death by a thousand
- 46:41cuts. There's so many of these that you constantly
- 46:44have to explain yourself over and over again.
- 46:47It starts to get tiring and it starts to be tough.
- 46:50So you have to early on in the litigation. Understand
- 46:55what you maybe have, what you may have to explain
- 46:57later and start to contextualize everything from
- 47:00the very beginning and have a heart to heart
- 47:02with your client. Ask them, what is this? That
- 47:0599 % of the time I get the best answers from
- 47:08my own client. Cause I don't want to speculate.
- 47:10The defense is usually speculating. I asked them,
- 47:13Hey, what does this mean? And once they tell
- 47:16me what, what it really shows and what was really
- 47:19happening, it makes perfect sense. Um, so establish
- 47:23the context. Oh, wow. So this is a great point.
- 47:30Not too many war stories, but I got to share
- 47:32this. We had this case where our client was catastrophically
- 47:37injured. She had a total dislocation of her left
- 47:40knee, severing of the arteries, severing of the
- 47:44veins, had a complete... Hinged knee replacement,
- 47:49knee reconstruction, which is if Google it after
- 47:53this, what a hinge knee replacement looks like.
- 47:56I've never seen one before. It's it's heavy duty.
- 47:59The doctor basically saved her leg and she was
- 48:01able to start walking again with the walker.
- 48:04There was a video of her doing rehab in her own
- 48:07house, in her bathroom, going about. 10 feet,
- 48:11right? You don't see the nurse and you don't
- 48:15see her husband cheering her on, but you see
- 48:17her with a walker, just grimacing, going about
- 48:2010 feet. Prior to mediation, the defense says,
- 48:25Hey, your life care plan is baloney. Um, your
- 48:28client doesn't need assistance. There's a video
- 48:30of her walking for 10 seconds, right? And it
- 48:34kind of just, it blew both of our minds. It's
- 48:36like, Hey, Uh, did you look at the other video
- 48:39where you see the nurse holding her from the
- 48:41back and you see her husband four feet away from
- 48:43her, just in case she falls over. And do you
- 48:45realize that she's using a walker and she's basically
- 48:48crying the whole entire time trying to make this
- 48:50walk. So, you know, um, context context is so
- 48:55important. You got to explain the medium. Um,
- 48:59so I've done this before successfully, but I
- 49:04can, or I relate. a social media profile to like
- 49:09your grandma's dresser, right? Your grandma has
- 49:13the happiest photos of her life on her dresser.
- 49:17It's the happy times, it's the birthdays, it's
- 49:19the births, it's the anniversaries. She's not
- 49:23gonna put up the 42 PT sessions she went to on
- 49:27her dresser, right? That's just, social media
- 49:30is... That that's what it is. It's it's for most
- 49:33people. It's there. Hey, look at my baby or hey,
- 49:37look at this award or hey, we're having a good
- 49:39time at this nice dinner. It's not the bad stuff.
- 49:42It's not the pain. It's not the grueling this.
- 49:45It's not the everyday grinding to get back to
- 49:47baseline. So again, it has to be contextualized.
- 49:53Raise it first. This is our mantra for everything.
- 49:57We always own the bad. quote unquote, bad before
- 50:02anyone else can do it to us. Right. So if there's
- 50:05a post that we think is not good, we will address
- 50:09it first. If the client is being deposed and
- 50:12there's this feeling that the defense is going
- 50:15towards some type of impeachment angle, just
- 50:18In the client prep be like, Hey, they're probably
- 50:21going to ask you about these be ready to explain
- 50:23it. So once that flag goes up in deposition,
- 50:26the client can talk about it freely and explain
- 50:28what those posts are. And that really takes the
- 50:31winds out of their sales. Okay. All right. So
- 50:39I just want to be mindful of the time. It's 10
- 50:4251. Okay. I will speed up. Um, this is the good
- 50:45stuff, uh, or the interesting stuff rather. So
- 50:48I'm going to go through three cases, uh, one
- 50:50that we recently or not recently, but one that
- 50:52we took to trial. And then two other cases that
- 50:55were settled. So this case. This is what really
- 51:00opened my eyes. Um, I knew social media was a
- 51:02thing. I knew that it could be used against us,
- 51:05but this, this case. Was concrete. So we got
- 51:09a case two years after the incident occurred
- 51:12right before. um the statute was up so we got
- 51:16the case we filed uh you know we looked through
- 51:19the client's social media and there were some
- 51:21things that we said hey um maybe you want to
- 51:25slow down on the posting um they replied that
- 51:29hey we're you know i'm an influencer this is
- 51:32what i do for a living i have to post and i go
- 51:35through the the referral file that i got from
- 51:38the referring attorney the referring attorney
- 51:39sent them the social media letter They advise
- 51:42them. And then we also advise them like, Hey,
- 51:44please. This case is contentious. You want to
- 51:48be careful. So, um, it was a, it was a car crash
- 51:53case. Client was claiming of lower back injuries.
- 51:56Um, you know, after we filed, we told them everything
- 51:59about how this may affect them later. And you're
- 52:03asking like, what, what's so bad on the feed?
- 52:05Nothing was bad in a, like in isolation, there
- 52:08was nothing that killed the case. But it was
- 52:11vacations, private jets, dinners at these like
- 52:16nightclub restaurants, bars, yoga, which again,
- 52:21in isolation, just because you have a low back
- 52:23injury doesn't mean you can't take a vacation.
- 52:25Just because you have a low back injury doesn't
- 52:27mean you can't go to dinner. Just because you
- 52:29have a low back injury doesn't mean you can't
- 52:30do yoga. You know, obviously depends on the severity
- 52:34of the claimed pain. But in isolation, those
- 52:37are all just you know, benign things. It's not
- 52:41a big deal. So prior to trial, we motioned and
- 52:45limited every single post didn't work. We argued
- 52:48with the judge constantly, not argued with, but
- 52:51we asked her to keep some things out. Nothing
- 52:54was kept out. Every single post came in. You
- 52:59know, we went through every objection you can
- 53:01think of just didn't work. She's a judge thought
- 53:04everything was impeachment. So this trial became
- 53:10a trial of social media, right? So I had to constantly
- 53:15explain what this meant in context, what that
- 53:19meant in context, what a private jet, it was,
- 53:22you know, it wasn't what you think it was, you
- 53:24know, it was a job. And then the nightclubs,
- 53:26it's not a nightclub, it's a restaurant that
- 53:28turns into a nightclub. And then the yoga, you
- 53:31know, She wanted to move around and move her
- 53:35body. It just, it, when you start having to explain
- 53:39yourself constantly over and over and over again,
- 53:43it just hurts. It really, it really, really hurts.
- 53:48And, um, Sorry, after we got defense on the case,
- 53:53we got defense on the case. It was the first
- 53:55time I've ever been defense happens to all of
- 53:57us. Um, and, you know, we spoke to the jurors
- 54:01after, and it was a huge factor for them. They
- 54:03said that it's not that the photos proved anything.
- 54:07It's just the, the, the. The amount of photos
- 54:12and the amount of explaining we had to do affected
- 54:16credibility. And once you lose credibility. or
- 54:19start to lose credibility, it's over. Everything
- 54:22gets put under the microscope and it really,
- 54:24really, really hurts. So advice was given and
- 54:27it was not taken and it really affected this
- 54:30case. And again, it was the volume. It wasn't
- 54:32just one post. So here are the fun stories. We
- 54:37had this case and Serena you handle this one
- 54:39where a client tripped and fell on a dangerous
- 54:42condition In the city of LA broke her elbow.
- 54:45It was an obvious dangerous condition obviously
- 54:47broke her elbow right of two weeks later she
- 54:50was Photographed with a dog in the opposite arm
- 54:55of the broken elbow Smiling at a birthday and
- 54:58for two years the defense attorney Okay made
- 55:04the biggest deal about this photo. Her whole
- 55:07defense was, eh, two weeks later she was fine,
- 55:10right? So it blew our minds that like, hey, she
- 55:13had an objective break. She's holding a little
- 55:16dog in her left arm and she's smiling at a birthday
- 55:18party. We, over so many phone calls, we tried
- 55:21to explain, tried to explain. Finally, it got
- 55:23to the point where we wrote a letter in writing
- 55:27to the defense, right? And... explained everything
- 55:31in context. What happened after that is the senior
- 55:35attorney jumped in, looked at the case file.
- 55:37We settled it a few weeks later. So one attorney
- 55:41got one crazy idea in their head and just stymied
- 55:44the case for two years. And she probably got
- 55:48a talk after this case and explained to her that,
- 55:51Hey, you know, you can't just hang on like one
- 55:53photo of someone smiling with dog in their hand
- 55:55and think that's your defense. Um, but It shaped
- 56:00all of the valuation conversations against the
- 56:02city. And again, once a more senior attorney
- 56:04came in, the case settled. Here's another one.
- 56:07We had a case where our client was rear ended,
- 56:11bad, bad, bad rear end. Okay. And they had a
- 56:13really bad back injury. And he posted a video
- 56:17during litigation of him like hiking and climbing
- 56:20a mountain. Right. Um, and here's the, here's
- 56:25the. Here's the funny part. So the footage, the
- 56:29video was of him about three or four years before
- 56:33the incident. Okay. And you could tell that because
- 56:36in the video he had long hair, like down to his
- 56:38shoulders and all throughout litigation and in
- 56:41his deposition, the guy had incredibly short
- 56:43hair and this post came out. After the deposition,
- 56:47right? So the defense called me and said, Hey,
- 56:49we got some really nasty things on your client.
- 56:51You're going to have some trouble at trial, blah,
- 56:53blah, blah, blah. You should really settle this
- 56:55case. And then when I explained to them, like,
- 56:57Hey, look at his hair. Look at the date. He posted
- 57:01a photo of him having like a good memory of a
- 57:03good time before your client absolutely wrecked
- 57:06his back. And now he can't do the things he used
- 57:08to do. And the case settled shortly after they
- 57:11thought they had something. It was completely.
- 57:16missed. So another thing, be very careful with
- 57:20what you think you may have. You want to make
- 57:23for damn certain that if you think you have some
- 57:26type of nuke that you're going to drop on the
- 57:27other side, that it's authenticated, and we'll
- 57:29get into that in a quick second. We might run
- 57:32a few minutes over, but I'm going as fast as
- 57:34I can. That it's authenticated and that it's
- 57:37actually depicting what you think you're showing.
- 57:41This is super important. On some of our cases
- 57:46with some of our clients for many reasons, we
- 57:49set up Google alerts. Uh, I want to know if anything
- 57:53pops up for that client, good or bad. It's very
- 57:56important. Um, another thing, you know, one new
- 58:01post can absolutely change the case on its head
- 58:04for better or worse. So it's very important to
- 58:06constantly remind the client that, Hey, Be mindful.
- 58:10I know it's fourth of July. It's coming up. I
- 58:12know it's the holidays. Just, you know, be mindful
- 58:16that anything you post can be used against you.
- 58:19Another thing that we've been running into recently
- 58:21is the case that settles with the confidentiality
- 58:25clause, right? A very aggressive confidentiality
- 58:28clause and The client goes and posts on Instagram
- 58:33and says, screw that defense, uh, screw the defendant.
- 58:38You know, they'll put the name of the company
- 58:40or the mall or whatever it is. I, you know, thankfully
- 58:43I got paid X amount, but it's not enough, blah,
- 58:46blah, blah, blah, blah. That post kills them.
- 58:50Right. It's it completely breaches confidentiality.
- 58:52And if the defense really wants to rustle some
- 58:54feds, they can come after them. Right. So we
- 58:57always tell the client. Assume that the defense
- 59:00is reading every single thing that you put out
- 59:03there on the internet. Spoilation by your opponent.
- 59:09Um, not too interesting, but it's there on the
- 59:12slide. I believe the slides here to download.
- 59:17Okay. Authentication. So I'll end on this these
- 59:21days, especially with. the emergence of AI and
- 59:25how quickly AI is evolving. I feel like every
- 59:29month it's taking like a 50 % leap, which is
- 59:32just mind blowing. I've never seen anything like
- 59:34this in my life. Um, but you can create some
- 59:38pretty damn realistic photos using AI, or you
- 59:43can take photos and alter them in ways that just
- 59:47blow my mind. So What you have to always be careful
- 59:50of is you have to make sure that the other side
- 59:52is trying to shove something down your throat,
- 59:54that it's properly authenticated. And obviously
- 59:57if it goes to trial, this is incredibly important,
- 1:00:00but even before then you want to make sure what
- 1:00:02they're showing you is 100 % true. And you want
- 1:00:05to press them on it early and often about the
- 1:00:08authentication issue, because more and more these
- 1:00:11things are, you know, not fully authenticated
- 1:00:14or they're not truly what they seem to be. And
- 1:00:17just to end it off, here's the six rules for
- 1:00:21our social media age cases. You want to audit
- 1:00:24at intake every account active or not on a signed
- 1:00:28social media form to your firm. Educate, never
- 1:00:32scrub. The case risk is the client. The license
- 1:00:35risk is yours. Don't tell the client to do something
- 1:00:38that ethically you cannot advise them to do.
- 1:00:41Know when the duty attaches. We talked about
- 1:00:44this, the reasonably foreseeable litigation,
- 1:00:47not the filing of the complaint. That's the standard.
- 1:00:50You should all be educated on that. Preserve
- 1:00:53affirmatively. This is better for the defense
- 1:00:54than the plaintiff, but it works for plaintiffs
- 1:00:57as well. Tell your client to save everything
- 1:01:00or screenshot everything. They're making big
- 1:01:03changes to their profile or doing things that
- 1:01:06are going to... potentially implicate some type
- 1:01:09of deletion issue, save it first, screenshot
- 1:01:12it, document it. Then you can delete it. Right.
- 1:01:14And if you get a discovery response request on
- 1:01:18that, on its nose for that specific issue, you
- 1:01:21got to give it up. And that's why you saved it.
- 1:01:24Um, Litigate scope in both directions. Um, you
- 1:01:28know, tailored requests going out, just, it works
- 1:01:31both ways, but make sure that your requests are
- 1:01:34tight. They're going after exactly what you want
- 1:01:36and something that a judge will say, Hey, yeah,
- 1:01:38you got to give it up. Um, and then if it's coming
- 1:01:42in, you're going to trial, rebut it. Right. Try
- 1:01:47to exclude it and finally try to cut it off with
- 1:01:51authentic authentication. And if all three fail,
- 1:01:54uh, hopefully it's not 30 Instagram posts that
- 1:01:58come in and just one or two. And that's a lot
- 1:02:00easier to deal with than, you know, 30. Sreena,
- 1:02:04anything else? Well, a few people asked the same
- 1:02:08question about what CBROSA means. So CBROSA is
- 1:02:11basically when one party hires a private investigator
- 1:02:17or a third party to take discrete physical or
- 1:02:22digital surveillance of your client. So for example
- 1:02:26in the physical setting it would be your client
- 1:02:29going grocery shopping. So any public place they
- 1:02:31just follow it's Kind of like what you think
- 1:02:34about they spy on your client They do hours and
- 1:02:38hours and hours of recording your client doing
- 1:02:41things like going to the grocery store going
- 1:02:43to work leaving driving Do we ending over to
- 1:02:48pick up trash? Yeah doing you know? Gardening
- 1:02:52in front of their home anything that Relates
- 1:02:55to like a public area and now we include that
- 1:02:59in digital surveillance because of course if
- 1:03:01your social media is public that is a public
- 1:03:04platform and they could surveil there too and
- 1:03:08again super important. I unfortunately I had
- 1:03:11the bad luck of having a case on my desk a long
- 1:03:14time ago when I first started practicing plaintiffs
- 1:03:18work where during the deposition our client was
- 1:03:22asked if he's able to carry a ladder. into the
- 1:03:25back of his truck, because he was claiming very,
- 1:03:27very bad back injury. And he said, no, I can't
- 1:03:29carry anything. And then they showed him a video
- 1:03:32that they had their private investigator do,
- 1:03:35I don't know, a week prior to his deposition,
- 1:03:37where he was literally at work, you know, outside
- 1:03:42in a public area, picking up a massive ladder,
- 1:03:45putting in his truck and different boxes. So
- 1:03:49impeachment, like it was it was It was wonderfully
- 1:03:52done by the defense, but that's what subversive
- 1:03:54means. It's using just any kind of video evidence
- 1:03:57of the client. Uh, they get impeached. It just
- 1:04:03depends on what what's happening in the video.
- 1:04:06I will say this. If you're in a deposition and,
- 1:04:09and your client's being asked very specific questions
- 1:04:13like, Hey, can you lift a four court bucket over
- 1:04:17your head? Right. You're in trouble. You're in
- 1:04:20trouble. Like they obviously have a photo or
- 1:04:23a video of your client lifting a four court bucket
- 1:04:26over their head. So what, you know, if you hear
- 1:04:28those questions in depot and the defense doesn't
- 1:04:32produce anything immediately, that should be
- 1:04:35a huge flag for you to go back and look for photos
- 1:04:38of your client lifting a four court bucket over
- 1:04:40their head. Right. There's a million of those
- 1:04:43types of questions. One last thing I want to
- 1:04:45say, and sorry for keeping you guys longer. Um,
- 1:04:49I had a slide up there about, you know, the content
- 1:04:52that's covered by the SCA, but not, you know,
- 1:04:56a lot of the little details. So what people can
- 1:05:00do is if your account was not private, if your
- 1:05:04plaintiff's account was not private and the defense
- 1:05:06goes through it and, you know, Maybe document
- 1:05:10some information, but doesn't snapshot it. And
- 1:05:13then later your client makes it private, right?
- 1:05:15And they have a feeling that you, you may have
- 1:05:18deleted some things or altered with your Instagram
- 1:05:20account or Facebook account. They can go subpoena
- 1:05:24these companies and get the information of logins
- 1:05:28and information about deletions, right? Or, um,
- 1:05:32profile changes. So you won't get the content,
- 1:05:35but you'll get data that things were altered.
- 1:05:39horrible, horrible. Again, the cover up is like
- 1:05:42worse than the quote unquote crime in those types
- 1:05:45of instances. Nothing is worse. And I just want
- 1:05:47to emphasize this. Nothing is worse than having
- 1:05:51a flat out lie or some type of deceit be put
- 1:05:55in front of a jury. That's the death sentence.
- 1:05:58There's no picture in the world that's worse
- 1:06:01than that. Maybe there's one or two, but You
- 1:06:04know what I mean. So it's very, very important
- 1:06:07to be ethical, to be above water, and to educate
- 1:06:11your client just early and often. It's so important.
- 1:06:18That's a great ending point. All right. Well,
- 1:06:21thank you for joining us for this awesome discussion.
- 1:06:25I think it's important. It's so prevalent. It's
- 1:06:30so prevalent. But thank you all. This concludes
- 1:06:35today's presentation. Thank you so much Christopher
- 1:06:37and Serena for an excellent presentation and
- 1:06:39thank you so much to our audience for joining
- 1:06:41us today. Have a great day everybody. Thank you.