Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 147 - Jeff G: Privacy and the Architecture of Freedom
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 147 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:37Yes, hello, I'm back from Serbia.
- 0:40It was an incredibly interesting trip, actually, somewhat surreal at times as well.
- 0:47Have you ever spent three hours in a taxi with two flat earthers?
- 0:52Like you literally can't get away?
- 0:55Well, I have now.
- 0:56And to be honest, it was actually quite fascinating. You know me, I'm an armchair psychologist, so ideologies like that really interest me.
- 1:06And until that point, I had actually never come across someone who believed in that stuff in person.
- 1:13Anyway, I won't divulge here. Go and have a look online if you want to test your own theory on the shape of the earth.
- 1:21yes episode 147 we're at now great harsh ad number loved by british snooker fans as well
- 1:31if you don't know the connection there look it up welcome indeed to this episode which is
- 1:36as always greatly supported by our wonderful partner veritas villages veritas villages are
- 1:43off-grid energy self-sufficient luxury communities in latin america designed specifically for freedom
- 1:50lovers bitcoin is accepted at all villages including for the purchase of property you know
- 1:57where to go to find out more but i'll give it to you anyway www.ecovillages.life forward slash free
- 2:05cities everything's in the show notes as always and if you want to meet the guys from veritas
- 2:10villages in person patrick hibbert and others he's the creator of veritas villages will be speaking
- 2:16at this year's Free Cities Conference in Prague 31st of October to the 2nd of November 2025. It's
- 2:23coming up soon. The Free Cities Conference really is one of the highlights of my year.
- 2:30Prague's also a very beautiful place to spend a few days in early winter too, especially if you
- 2:35can take your loved one with you. It's very romantic. If you're in this space or indeed if
- 2:41you want to be in this space then this is the gathering for you just ask anyone who's ever
- 2:47attended before and i will see you there right today's guest he's a developer in the privacy
- 2:55space he's also a climber more of that in the podcast uh there's going to be some quite important
- 3:01alpha here for you if like me you're into privacy but you don't necessarily know what makes one
- 3:08protocol better than the other. Jeff G develops on Noster, which you should know about already.
- 3:16If you don't, check the show notes for some links. And he's currently responsible for creating
- 3:21what is its most secure messaging layer to date, something that will become incredibly important
- 3:28in the not too distant future if we continue along the same centralizing trajectory that we
- 3:35currently see in so many countries around the world. Here's an AI breakdown for the curious
- 3:42amongst you. The discussion ranges from AI tools and privacy concerns to the evolution of secure
- 3:49messaging where Jeff introduces his project White Noise and its use of message layer security,
- 3:57MLS. One to watch that is on Nostra. Along the way they explore the limits of existing platforms
- 4:04like WhatsApp and Signal, the challenges of metadata privacy and practical defences
- 4:10against sophisticated threats. The conversation broadens into Bitcoin, eCash and mesh networks
- 4:19and wraps with reflections on teaching digital responsibility, the trade-offs between privacy
- 4:25and convenience and the promise of open source decentralized technologies to shape a freer
- 4:31internet if this sounds too technical for you please don't stop here give it a go i ask all
- 4:37the normie questions this stuff is really important to wrap your head around it's easy to predict
- 4:44what's coming in the future and as a sovereign individual you must take responsibility for your
- 4:50and your family's privacy it's up to you to be the one who gets everyone on board with this stuff
- 4:57there's a lot of pressure around the world right now to give up privacy and as far as i'm concerned
- 5:04the people who advocate for that are not on the right side of history right some thank yous this
- 5:10week before we go to my new subscribers and you know what quite astonishingly the free cities
- 5:18podcast got to number three in the top 40 shows on fountain this week and our latest bonus episode
- 5:27with Gigi and episode 144 with Leon Wancombe, which has been doing very well, have both been
- 5:33hovering in the charts around seventh place on the top 40 of episodes two. So many thanks to you
- 5:42for choosing to listen. It's great. We're currently we've dropped down to ninth in the top 40 of shows,
- 5:49but really for a good week, we were hovering around the top. So many thanks to you in particular,
- 5:56shadrach silas thornbrook set in stone by the way you're this guy's a real baller he's he's streaming
- 6:04200 sats per minute when he's listening to your show so set the stone thank you very much indeed
- 6:11tim a n t chris albanese uh there's a private end pub there one k j q e bullish mike matthias
- 6:23cousin Vinny you know who you are many thanks I appreciate you I appreciate your continuing
- 6:30subscriptions they really do make a difference to me right let's get on with this time to learn
- 6:38how to become your very best private sovereign individual as you sit back relax and enjoy my
- 6:48conversation with Jeff G
- 6:53now um yeah i don't have a start and a finish so we're already rolling cool um i've got to
- 7:13recount a little story for you because you're you're a techie person this i had a catastrophic
- 7:18hard drive failure yesterday oh yeah oh doesn't happen very often these days and yeah it was a
- 7:25spinning disc one okay so probably it does let's turn that off sorry let's get rid of all my in it
- 7:32let's turn that off and um i've been i've been in the media years so i back everything up yeah
- 7:39and luckily i had backed this i backed this up because it was all the recordings i've done over
- 7:43the last seven days yeah but i wasn't as on it as normal so there was an absolute there was a gap
- 7:49there was yeah there was so i didn't lose any data but what i did discover is i've lost the complete
- 7:55back catalog of my whole podcast every single file including all the templates for the video
- 8:02files and all this stuff right and it's not bothering me yet too much but because i can
- 8:09recreate all those what i haven't lost is anything that's not recreatable which is good
- 8:13but what the reason i'm telling you is because this time i went to chat gpt and i've i feel like
- 8:20i've made a friend with chat gpt for the first time this guy or girl or whoever it is and i i
- 8:27started using venice i use venice.ai yeah yeah but it was it was and it wasn't getting what i
- 8:33wanted i went to chat gpt and all of a sudden almost the first thing it says was we're cool
- 8:38you're in my hands now it's really weird that is weird and and it's been it's guided me through
- 8:45this process so i i've got five terminals open i'm i'm putting all this code in and every time
- 8:50i put something in i'm telling jettgpt what comes out and it's saying great we're on it it's
- 8:55happening it's really you're going to get this stuff back don't worry and now i've got a probably
- 9:00a 15 to 16 hour process running so i ran disc disc util yeah yeah like a dis recovery thing yeah
- 9:06Yeah. Well, it's the one, it's a free open source one.
- 9:10Yeah.
- 9:11And it good And it even saying update me every hour and I tell you how long it going to be whether I think the drive good or not after one hour And it like wow you know that is really new and amazing and different but what crazy is like I said thank you a while ago I
- 9:30instantly I and I was like hold a minute dude you're falling down yes the wrong rabbit hole
- 9:36yeah you're not this is not a person this is not a thing but compared to Venice which was like
- 9:43a computer talking to me yes chat gbt was really starting to sort of talk at it with me and stuff
- 9:50yeah the crazy thing about the models is that especially the really frontier models you know
- 9:54the you know chat gbt 5 or claude 4 um i actually prefer claude over chat gbt i mean especially in
- 10:02the coding domain i think claude's way better how do i how do i access claude though if i wanted to
- 10:06you just go to i think it's called.com or anthropic or claude are there places like you
- 10:10know i use venice just because i'm i don't like putting all my if it's code i don't mind giving
- 10:14it to chat but if it's like talking about my family or something i don't want i mean all of
- 10:20those frontier models are running on you know giant data centers in the cloud and so anything
- 10:25you give the hosted providers they have and yeah they say like private mode like don't store my
- 10:31stuff but you know they can use venice says though that it's venice it's encrypting it from
- 10:35your so you're doing it all locally and then when it sends it is encrypting yes exactly so there's
- 10:40some providers like venice like maple ai which is the you know former mutiny guys um you know those
- 10:46do things a bit differently but the major providers which are the ones that have the best models
- 10:50are the ones that are a little bit less you know privacy oriented well i'm one i'm one of those
- 10:56people that thinks that the dystopian ai future is as likely as the utopian one so i don't want it
- 11:04And I don't want it to be involved deeply in my personal life because it will be able to annihilate me.
- 11:12And really, I mean, the local models are actually getting, you know, the open source models that you can install locally and run on a laptop and run on a laptop in a way that's not completely terrible.
- 11:23Like you're not going to have to wait 20 seconds for every response.
- 11:26They're actually getting pretty good.
- 11:27And I have a feeling that we're going to get to a point pretty soon where, you know, the amount that we can both spend and get out of, you know, each of the next generation frontier models, it's going to be like iPhones.
- 11:38They're just going to kind of be the same pretty much.
- 11:40And so at that point, I think a lot of the open source is going to catch up, you know, in short order.
- 11:45And we'll all be able to run, you know, very, very compelling, very powerful models locally on our computers and have perfect privacy.
- 11:53Perfect. Right. I'm glad to hear that.
- 11:54At least I hope. That's my hope.
- 11:55The funny thing is, though, because of my history of using AI, while I was doing all that stuff, I was very nervous because it's hallucinated many times with me.
- 12:05And it was saying, right, now we're going to wipe that drive because I went out yesterday and I bought a whole new five terapyte drive.
- 12:13So I'm copying what's there onto there before I do anything.
- 12:17It's going to take like 24 hours or something ridiculous.
- 12:19But it's saying now I'm doing this and this and this.
- 12:21And I'm thinking, dude, is it hallucinating?
- 12:24It might just be about to wipe my good drive.
- 12:27Yes.
- 12:27You know, like, so I'm still not there with them.
- 12:30The way I used to check AIs in the past was already ask them about myself.
- 12:35Because I've lived two very distinct lives.
- 12:39I had a media career.
- 12:40And then I have a kind of like Bitcoin and libertarian bit.
- 12:45And most places have never actually connected the two.
- 12:49JTBG now does.
- 12:51So it's worked out that that's the same me.
- 12:53because they're very different worlds but it still hallucinates like there's a couple of books that i
- 12:58haven't written they're just made up completely made up out of nothing they don't even exist as
- 13:03real books right this is what it says about you because you tell me whether it's hallucinating
- 13:08okay i asked it who's jeff g it's like uh full-time nostor developer supported by open sats
- 13:15focusing on building open decentralized tools for the nostor ecosystem that's all correct okay
- 13:20creator founder of white noise correct still correct i know that one a project aimed at
- 13:25bringing messaging layer security mls capabilities to nostra including support for end-to-end
- 13:31encryption encrypted direct messages and private groups okay your contributions white noise
- 13:38nostra.how you've done nostra talks podcasts featured in how to monetize your nostra apps
- 13:45hosts oh you host a pod as well thank god for nostor uh i don't host that that's actually a
- 13:51friend of mine's i've been on that podcast all right i've been oh it says okay it says hosts
- 13:55episodes there see it's hallucinating yeah okay summary jeff jeff g is a core figure in the nostor
- 14:02ecosystem leading privacy focused development improving the onboarding experience via nostor.how
- 14:09and actively educating and shaping the community through podcasts and talks it's fairly accurate i
- 14:14guess is that good yeah yeah fairly accurate i'm glad it didn't come out with like something in the
- 14:18deep past where you're like whoa how did it know that but well yeah have you got is have you got a
- 14:23different past like a lot of people who work in this kind of space i mean everybody comes from
- 14:27doing something before unless they're 20 years old at this point so i think uh yeah my past is all
- 14:32startups uh i've been working in tech startups since kind of 2011 12 something like that anything
- 14:37i might have heard of anything interesting or what kind of stuff um i worked at a company the first
- 14:41startup i ever joined actually is a company called intercom which is a fairly big one now uh they are
- 14:46um you know the little chat bubble thing that comes up you know pops up at the bottom of your
- 14:51screen little circle and you tap it and it opens up a window they actually invented that oh really
- 14:55and then everybody took it but they're still around and they're still doing you know great
- 14:59business ask me a question then because i've often wondered this when you're having a chat
- 15:03conversation with a company even if it's a real person is it you know when it waits and it shows
- 15:10you someone is typing yeah is it doing that to make you feel more relaxed it depends on the
- 15:15company uh i know with intercoms it's real uh it is a real typing indicator yeah yeah i mean i think
- 15:21that's the thing it's always with those things and intercom has been really at the forefront of this
- 15:25and they're probably the best customer support ai in the world at this point um because they just
- 15:31understand more about human behavior and what humans actually want to do on both sides of the
- 15:36table you know like it's not nice for a customer support person to sit there and just blindly
- 15:40answer the same stupid question all day every day um it's a horrible use of humanity so like
- 15:45perfect use of ai but there's every now and then you want a person to step in and be like okay i
- 15:50got you like this is going to be a really weird one but like we can navigate this together and
- 15:54we can sort it out so a lot of what they say to you is generated automatically like tons at this
- 16:00point like most companies if they are not solving 50 to 70 percent of customer requests using
- 16:05something automated their test even if you think you're talking to a real person i mean it doesn't
- 16:10matter i'm thinking of amazon there's the most common one i go on and it's always it's often
- 16:15someone in india i think because there's a lot of indian names but there's a there's a couple of
- 16:20answers you get a lot i'm sorry to hear that let me see if i can that's obviously uh someone sending
- 16:27a message to calm you down right because basically it's going to take longer and if they just stay
- 16:32completely silent you get annoyed yeah i mean but think about this uh they're programmed to say that
- 16:37whether they're a human or they're an or they're an ai right they went through a training that gave
- 16:42them a script that told them to do certain things in certain cases so either way they've been
- 16:46programmed to do the thing um would you rather have that response in a sub-second or have somebody
- 16:51be able to read all of the documentation instantaneously and give you the right answer
- 16:54without having to go look i would much rather that so like i'd rather have an ai for most stuff that
- 16:58I want to deal with with the company. It's probably a soundboard as well, isn't it? Sorry to hear you.
- 17:03Yeah, exactly. I don't know. Radio shows like bang, bang.
- 17:09Yeah, that's interesting. And what other things have you done then just so that I can get an idea?
- 17:14I mean, it's kind of been across the board. I went to school actually for finance in Spanish. I didn't
- 17:19do anything computer science related. To be honest, I kind of knew I wanted to do computer science,
- 17:24didn't get into the program originally, and then got distracted with climbing for a bunch of years.
- 17:28And then kind of came back around to it on my own later.
- 17:31Is that anything to do with, am I allowed to say where you live?
- 17:34Yeah.
- 17:35Well, is that anything to do with where you live in Italy?
- 17:37Because there's some good mountains there.
- 17:38Well, the climbing does, yeah.
- 17:39Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 17:40We live basically where we live in Italy for the mountains.
- 17:42Really?
- 17:43Yeah, yeah.
- 17:44And you say we, it sounds like you're, whoever else is there.
- 17:47Yeah, me and the family.
- 17:48You're all into climbing.
- 17:50Yes.
- 17:50My wife and I actually met climbing years ago.
- 17:52Have you done any pretty epic things?
- 17:55What's the most epic thing you've ever done?
- 17:57My wife and I met in Yosemite.
- 17:58And I've spent a couple of years living in Yosemite Valley climbing.
- 18:02So El Cap, half down.
- 18:03Have you done El Cap?
- 18:04Yeah, a bunch of times by a bunch of different routes.
- 18:06You're real.
- 18:06Yeah, it's really fun.
- 18:08It was like such a good time.
- 18:09Oh, tell me about that.
- 18:10I love, I'm fascinated by climbing.
- 18:14I've never climbed in the most extreme way.
- 18:18I've hiked a lot of mountains.
- 18:19I've been up to 6,500 meters and lived in the Himalayas for a long time.
- 18:24And I've climbed Mongolia's tallest mountain, which is one of the really remote places.
- 18:28with ice picks and stuff like that but i've never done oh shit yeah technical climbs sleeping on
- 18:35right you know what my favorite film of all time is meru have you seen it was so good yeah that actually i feel like jimmy chin like sort of solidified his you know career on that one because that film was so good But what amazing about that film is apart from the fact the story amazing the timeline amazing because it a long timeline as well
- 18:55And the whole, there are so many little quirky things to it.
- 18:56And the history of that mountain, like, the whole thing is really cool.
- 18:59But what's amazing is I think that film taps into the essence of how insane it is when you climb things like that.
- 19:11And living vertically is a thing.
- 19:13But no, not even that.
- 19:14It's like I think my theory, see, on climbers who go to that extreme is they are trying to access a certain feeling.
- 19:21Right.
- 19:21and the only way they can do it is literally live on the side of a mountain for two weeks
- 19:26freeze their feet and fingers off and when they get to that top and you see this in mirror there's
- 19:33just kind of like there's like no nice one dude you know and and that's it yep that's it there's
- 19:38nothing to it and that whole thing and and i get too fun is what i call it you know type two so
- 19:44there's type one fun where it's fun while you're doing it and fun when you think back on it later
- 19:48you're like that's just enjoyment right like normal things that people think of as fun
- 19:51type two fun is mostly suffering while you're doing it and when you look back on it somehow
- 19:56your memory has magically transformed it into something very lovely and amazing and something
- 20:00you really love do you get scared on like el cap for example oh yeah for every i mean if anyone
- 20:04doesn't know el cap is is it the the tallest flat face in the world it's not the tallest flat face
- 20:09in the world there's a few others that are bigger but i mean it's one of them and i think it's i
- 20:14mean it's a thousand meters um in its tallest section a kilometer it's a kilometer tall and
- 20:18And what is amazing about it is, you know, it's 10 minutes from the side of the road.
- 20:22Like you literally drive into the valley, you park your car in El Cap Meadow, you walk 10 minutes in flip flops and you put your hands on a kilometer tall wall.
- 20:30And the wall goes, it's like a wave.
- 20:32It's lower than vertical for the first half.
- 20:34And then it goes vertical and then it's over vertical.
- 20:37You know, it's overhanging for the top half.
- 20:39So when you look up, it's like literally standing under a kilometer tall wave of granite.
- 20:43And it is the most beautiful face in the world.
- 20:45god and it's two or three days normally to get up it it depends on the route um so if it's easier
- 20:51routes you can certainly do them faster than that you know lots of people have done you know the
- 20:55nose which is kind of the standard route right up the front of you know right in the middle of the
- 20:58wall um they've done it in a couple of hours uh you know super super strong folks like you know
- 21:02alex hondold and others um most normal humans would take you know two three days to do the nose
- 21:09but as soon as you start to go into harder territory where the climbing is you know more
- 21:15strung out much more difficult and again most people are actually doing lcap with artificial
- 21:20climbing aid climbing which is instead of using just your hands and feet you're putting gear into
- 21:25the wall and you're actually hanging on the gear and standing up in these little ladders to reach
- 21:28up and put some more gear in so it's that's a slow process you know it's vertical engineering
- 21:33you're carrying a ton of gear you have to carry all your water with you you know and it just takes
- 21:38time so how do you go to the loo just out of interest i've never well i mean do you literally
- 21:42just let it go into the wind but uh number two you've got to bring you you can't just oh you
- 21:47can't you know no it's totally illegal in lcap you'd kill someone right like imagine being killed
- 21:50by falling shit depends how much you ate i suppose right if you had a big meal yeah you bring a very
- 21:56specific piece of tech called a uh poop tube and it's a piece of pvc pipe with caps on both ends
- 22:01and a you know runner around the end of it and you've got to bag everything and put it in and
- 22:05take it with you yeah so if you can you probably try not to because that is a right i mean it's
- 22:11actually not a big deal like once you get used to all the systems it's it's surprisingly
- 22:15straightforward to do pretty much everything um and you'll never have a better night's sleep than
- 22:20you do in a portal edge and i mean mostly just because you're absolutely exhausted yeah you lie
- 22:25down and you're like oh god i'm done have you had any scares in your climbing career i mean nothing
- 22:30nothing that I would say like was really actually very very close to you know ending my life I've
- 22:39definitely had a lot of scares I've definitely a lot of falls that scared the crap out of me
- 22:42I've definitely been in situations where I was like two or three things go bad here and we're
- 22:46in a really bad situation but I think we're going to be okay but that was mostly around exposure to
- 22:52be honest and to be honest most of the people that die on El Cap die of exposure because they go up
- 22:56in a t-shirt, you know, there's a storm that comes in, it dumps a bunch of snow on them,
- 23:00and then they can't get out. So it's exposure that kills most people, not the actual fall,
- 23:05or, you know, not the actual climbing. I mean, rockfall is the other thing that I worry about.
- 23:09And I think that's the thing I worry about more now, also given where we live, just because we're
- 23:13in the Alps and, you know, big mountains fall down. In a place like Yosemite, you've got glacial
- 23:19granite that has been there, you know, forever. And yes, there's rockfall, but the routes are so
- 23:24well traveled that most of the loose stuff has been knocked off um and so it's a little bit safer
- 23:28in that have you been up the matterhorn i've not been up the matterhorn i've been i've climbed a
- 23:32bunch in chamonix um which is just around the corner from the matterhorn i've skied on one
- 23:36side of the matterhorn but i've never climbed it but that doesn't that's not a problem you look at
- 23:40the matterhorn you think good fun you don't think yeah yeah it would be a pretty straightforward i
- 23:43mean it's a really well trodden route it's kind of an alpine slog there's a little bit of kind of
- 23:47scrambly stuff with an ice axe but i don't think it would be anything i couldn't do it anymore i'll
- 23:52be honest as for some reason as i've grown older i've i've got vertigo and um even when i was
- 23:59climbing the one in mongolia that was what four or four odd years ago um it was ice axes and but
- 24:08it wasn't that it was probably that it wasn't that and i i didn't look down in fact we had a we had a
- 24:15lot of um weather come in so i couldn't look down there's nothing to see nothing to look at
- 24:18fortunately yeah but um but i know now i watch videos still all the time and i could not stand
- 24:27like for example on the side of el cap and look down my i get actually physical reaction in my
- 24:32knees and feet yeah they start you know yeah i i didn't and i don't want to do about it because
- 24:36it's in a one way it's annoying same with same with the alps there's a lot of really interesting
- 24:41treks in the alps that involve walking across like little bits of metal right yeah those things
- 24:47And that would also scare me too much. I think I might run the risk of actually my knees going, you know, and like feeling like they're going to fall away from you.
- 24:56It's one of those things you habituate to, though, like like everything you get used to it. And it's, you know, climbers talk about having a good head or not. And having a good head just basically means like, am I in the mind state that I can that I can take exposure, that I can concentrate on what's in front of me and like do the thing I need to do without thinking about too much the consequences like you can, you know, assess the consequences, know what you're getting into in a realistic way, but also just zero in and focus on stuff.
- 25:22And that takes time. Like it takes practice to develop that. And it comes and goes. Like it's not something like if I went out now and I haven't been climbing all that much recently. If I went out now and tried to climb something, it would probably scare me to death. Like I'd be up there being like, oh, my God, I can't take this. But if you do it on a really, really, really basis, you really kind of get into that groove and you you have a better ability to sort of focus, assess, you know, actual risk versus perceived risk.
- 25:44You know, your brain is going to tell you like, this is no place that you should be like, you need to get out of here immediately. And the trick is just going, actually, I am safe. I have done the right things. I do have my stuff set up. I am looking at, you know, something that I need to do here. And maybe there is a certain degree of risk. But I feel that that's in my range right now. I can do this.
- 26:04It's a great, actually, it's a great teacher for life in general. And especially, you know, what you do in the privacy world is super connected with things like that. I mean, because you know that if you, on the whole, in privacy-centric apps, if you mess up once, you've messed up the whole thing because you've revealed what you don't want to reveal.
- 26:29And then a bit of software can connect that to that, to that, to that, to that, to that, to that.
- 26:33So you really do have to risk analyze that thing.
- 26:37I mean, do you ever wonder when you write like white noise?
- 26:40I don't know.
- 26:42No, probably a lot of people don't know what white noise is, actually.
- 26:45Maybe you should say it yourself and then you can, and then I'll ask that question again.
- 26:49Yeah, perfect.
- 26:50Yeah, yeah.
- 26:50So White Noise is kind of the messenger app that we're building on top of the, it's a spec for Nostra.
- 26:58It doesn't actually write a new protocol, but it is a kind of specification for how to apply the MLS messaging protocol into Nostra's relay and identity system.
- 27:08Just before you go on, we do talk about Nostra on this show, but in case you didn't, I did a big two-hour chat with Ben Ark, and it's about episode 100-something.
- 27:17So I'll put it in the show notes just in case.
- 27:20But I always, Nostra and Bitcoin, two important things to get into.
- 27:23Very important.
- 27:23Yeah, yeah.
- 27:24And Ben does a great job of explaining exactly what Nostra is.
- 27:27He was there from the very beginning.
- 27:28So yeah, so effectively, you know, we've got, maybe I'll zoom out a little bit and talk about MLS for just a second so people understand what that is and why that's important to what we're trying to do.
- 27:39So, you know, if you think about secure messaging, you know, all the way at the beginning, we had, you know, telephones where the switchboard operator could literally listen into everything you were doing.
- 27:48You know, radio is the same.
- 27:49Telegraphs were the same.
- 27:50Like we had to relay messages through other people and they could read those.
- 27:53And so we back in those days, we came up with like, you know, weird, you know, human readable and understandable codes that we could use to sort of, you know, do cipher text and stuff like that.
- 28:02All of that stuff evolves over time We get to the Internet The Internet is fully unencrypted for a long time Finally Google kind of makes everybody do it just by virtue of the fact that they had a monopoly with Chrome
- 28:12And they went, nope, we're doing HTTPS everywhere all the time.
- 28:17Which is, I mean, it's encrypted, but...
- 28:19It's encrypted traffic.
- 28:20So the traffic is encrypted, not necessarily the data on either end.
- 28:23And why is that bad in messaging?
- 28:26Because someone can intercept it right now?
- 28:28Well, no.
- 28:29I mean, think about this in the earlier internet.
- 28:31Like all websites used to just be served plain text, right?
- 28:33And in a lot of cases, that doesn't matter.
- 28:35If you're just serving your, you know, plain public website in plain text over the line, like who cares?
- 28:40But you would never have gotten credit card payments on the internet if you hadn't had the ability to somehow take the message on one side in plain text, encrypt it, send it through all the servers in the middle, and then decrypt it on the other side.
- 28:52And so that's, you know, SSL and, you know, TLS and all that stuff is the kind of encrypted transport on the internet.
- 28:57And it just became standard.
- 28:59And what's your opinion on it?
- 29:00Is that a good standard?
- 29:01Oh, yeah. I mean, it's an absolutely necessary part of the Internet.
- 29:03But you wouldn't want to evolve it anymore, is it?
- 29:06No, I mean, it is an evolving standard.
- 29:07Like, TLS is continuing to sort of get better over time.
- 29:10And actually, MLS is based on the same sort of design principles as TLS was.
- 29:15You know, you should have a handshake.
- 29:16You should be able to agree with the person you're going to talk to that, like, we support the same features so we can do the thing well.
- 29:23And, you know, it's just it's an absolute foundational piece of the Internet that no one thinks about, which is a great thing, right?
- 29:30So in messaging specifically, yeah, we could always encrypt the stuff in the middle.
- 29:36But if you're going through someone else's servers, there's going to have to be some, you know, you're going to do something there, right?
- 29:41The server is going to have to know something about you in order to get the message to the other person.
- 29:47And so we had these protocols early on, like off the record was one of the really earliest ones that we're trying to figure out how do we do encryption for messaging where you can keep an ongoing conversation with someone.
- 29:57But if someone gets the key, they're not going to be able to decrypt all the messages in the past or all the messages going forward.
- 30:03You know, somebody gets your key and doesn't say anything and you keep talking.
- 30:06They just keep decrypting messages as you go.
- 30:08They can follow you along and see what's going on.
- 30:10Which is that that was the basis of kind of World War II cryptography, wasn't it?
- 30:15You only needed one sort of secret.
- 30:17Yes.
- 30:18If you figured out how they were creating the secrets, you could decrypt all the messages.
- 30:22Right.
- 30:22And this is why, like, the Enigma machine was so difficult for them because they would change the secret every day.
- 30:28So they had 24 hours to try to figure out how the thing worked, and then it would flip, and they'd start over from scratch.
- 30:34Right. So it was doing that. I thought the Enigma was just one encryption and then it ran down.
- 30:39The Enigma was a complicated encryption scheme that it took a long time to figure out what they were doing with it, but it also was a rotating key.
- 30:46And most encryption schemes were rotating keys. Like, you had some way of kind of formalizing.
- 30:50Like if you think about the old spy movies where they like have a newspaper and they leave it on the thing and somebody circled a word like that word is the changing key, you know, like.
- 30:57But would they have to send if it was if in the World War Two case, would they have to send over the rotating keys in one batch in one time so that they knew?
- 31:09Because that's also an attack.
- 31:11No. So this is kind of gets into deterministic key generation or the key derivation functions, which is everything that all of our secure messaging stuff online is built on now is you need some deterministic way to go from one key to the next key.
- 31:23And so either you have to deliver the key manually, you know, and that's non-deterministic.
- 31:27Like that's, you know, you circle a word in a newspaper or somebody sends you a message in another communication channel, you know, a messenger shows up on a boat and tells you what the next month's worth of keys are going to be.
- 31:38That's one thing.
- 31:38The other thing is start with a key and then start with some, you know, secret to you and your group, but known way of deriving out the next key.
- 31:47Some way of taking a word and, you know, it's like on the first letter, we're going to add 12 and then get to the next letter.
- 31:54On the next one, we're going to add 14.
- 31:56On the other one, we're going to subtract 7.
- 31:57Like you just kind of, you can manipulate a thing in a certain way to get a new key.
- 32:01Is that two things?
- 32:03So is that the word and the way we decrypt the word?
- 32:07And they can be sent separately.
- 32:10Because if someone finds those two things.
- 32:12They can do whatever they want.
- 32:13Yeah, exactly.
- 32:14They have the keys to the kingdom.
- 32:15So presumably you want to split that into as many things as you can.
- 32:18Exactly, exactly.
- 32:19So this is, I mean, cryptography in general is cat and mouse, right?
- 32:24It's always going to be cat and mouse.
- 32:25There's always going to have to be changing standards because people will figure out ways, you know, eventually to sort of get around some of these things.
- 32:32you know yes there is extremely strong cryptography but as computers get better like many of these
- 32:39you know cipher suites and things are just becoming obsolete right and with this idea of
- 32:45quantum computing it's going to make a whole bunch more stuff obsolete and so we have to come up with
- 32:48ways to kind of fight against that so um let's jump back to messaging so you've got like off the
- 32:54record was like one of the original protocols that specified how can we do you know forward
- 32:59secrecy and post-compromised security. So how do we keep keys rotating in a way that keeps the
- 33:03conversation secure so that even if an attacker got one of the keys, they are only going to get
- 33:07a tiny slice of our conversation. The signal protocol kind of grew out of the off-the-record
- 33:13protocol. Moxie Marlin's bike, and I can't remember the other guy's name, so sorry, but
- 33:18they came up with the signal protocol, which is the kind of classic double ratchet algorithm that
- 33:24you hear a lot of people say double ratchet encryption. And the idea there is that there's
- 33:28actually multiple key derivation functions. And you've got a way to agree on a key, a shared key
- 33:33between two people that you create one key derivation function. So that's like kind of a
- 33:37trunk of a tree and that's generating a certain key. And then using that key, people derive out
- 33:44other keys. And so you and I both have then two chains of messages. One side is a sender side,
- 33:50one side is a receiver side. So my sender is your receiver, your sender is my receiver.
- 33:53and that's how we actually send messages we generate keys on those small chains to encrypt
- 33:59the actual message and then every now and then we rotate the key in the middle and that basically
- 34:04changes what's called the epoch the whole thing moves forward and we start doing the thing again
- 34:07um just a question in that system in like in signal are you signal if you if you delete a
- 34:14message is it deleted is it so think about it this way in indian encrypted messaging
- 34:20the idea is you i have a message i encrypt it so imagine i just put it in a box and lock the box
- 34:26you have the key to the box right i can then send the box through the mail through whatever channel
- 34:31i want to and the person in the middle doesn't have the box so they can't see what's inside
- 34:34you get the box you open the box and you then have the thing you're the only person that has
- 34:40the thing now um and obviously if we're talking about messaging i've got a copy on my end and
- 34:44you have a copy on your end no one in the middle has any like they've got an encrypted copy but
- 34:49They can't do anything with it unless they get a key to unlock the box in the middle.
- 34:54Could they in the future, though?
- 34:55Absolutely.
- 34:56Yeah, absolutely.
- 34:56So all our messages that we're sending now are potentially revealable in 40 years.
- 35:02Yeah, 100%.
- 35:02And that's what they say, basically.
- 35:04When quantum arrives in a usable, actual functioning format, all of the messaging is going to be immediately decrypted.
- 35:14And I mean, that's on one side super scary for a lot of people that have lots of skeletons.
- 35:18that you know you know they're never going to get rid of those right like the internet's a giant
- 35:21copy machine yeah totally so i mean you're always going to fall foul of a law in the end because
- 35:25laws don't 100 and the question is more do is it going to be something people care enough about
- 35:32you know going back that far to look for like no government's going to go and be like oh you bought
- 35:35drugs in college on you know this platform they might say you didn't pay tax in 1980 whatever
- 35:42that's potentially true or more to the point they if you are a target if they target then they'll
- 35:48use yeah yeah all bets are off like they'll use all of that stuff against you so how would you
- 35:52we're still going back to what you were saying how would you mitigate against that in its current
- 35:57form then say you're a signal user and you you want to try and for you know so signals actually
- 36:04already helping protect you against this because they are already they've already moved to a
- 36:08quantum resistant cypher suite. So it's a collection of, you know, algorithms that you
- 36:13use to do this, which is, you know, generally assigning a scheme and a hashing scheme that fit
- 36:19together. And they have moved to algorithms that are quantum resistant. So they're much harder for
- 36:23quantum computers to solve. How do you know something's quantum resistant? A bunch of math,
- 36:28you have to have really giant gigabrain cryptographers do formal proofs in mathematics
- 36:33to show that this is not only, you know, very difficult for a classical, you know, digital
- 36:39computer to solve, but it's also incredibly difficult for, you know, the way we think
- 36:43about how qubits are going to solve things.
- 36:45So if we know what's quantum resistant, how come we don't do quantum then?
- 36:50How can we not already have quantum computers?
- 36:53Laws of physics.
- 36:53It's like really, really hard to get this stuff done properly.
- 36:56You know, you've got...
- 36:57So theoretically, we know what quantum is.
- 36:58Theoretically, we know exactly what it is.
- 37:00we're actually in the position of like how do we take that and make it physical reality break that
- 37:04down for me so i can understand it what is i don't know quantum as well but like my understanding at
- 37:08a very very high level is you are going from zeros and ones to something that can be you know quantum
- 37:15super superimposed and so you can have multiple states of things at the same time um and that
- 37:22gives you the ability to have way more states possible thus you can have you know a computer
- 37:27that can do way more calculations way, way, way, way faster.
- 37:30And is that something to do with having to use minus 280 degrees or something?
- 37:35That's exactly, yes, correct.
- 37:36And they can't keep the chip stable enough.
- 37:39You know, think about it as a circuit.
- 37:41You know, a circuit is either open or closed.
- 37:42And that's basically what a digital computer is.
- 37:44It's either open or closed.
- 37:45And we figured out how to do, you know, transistors that are either open or closed.
- 37:48And they're very stable.
- 37:50In quantum, it's incredibly unstable.
- 37:53And the thing has way more states.
- 37:55And so it's just like, and so they try to get it super, super cold to slow everything down.
- 38:00and they're still working on ways to like how do we error correct these things because if you think
- 38:05about it a transistor an electrical transistor if it gets hit by a photon in the wrong way it will
- 38:09bit flip and like that's a thing that certain parts of computing have you know have to worry
- 38:14about like very low probability but it does happen yeah yeah um and so that in quantum is still
- 38:20incredibly difficult and you know what bit flipping i've thought that that is the same
- 38:25same process as um dna evolution i think there's a four i this is purely my own idea right yeah i
- 38:32mean it would make sense that you can bit flip dna and that's what causes things to change i mean
- 38:37it's it's conceptually the exact same process you know mutation is basically a bit flip yeah but
- 38:42it's weird when you think about it in computer terms because you don't imagine that there might
- 38:46be a piece of well a photon that can actually kind of collide with your computer and do something to
- 38:53it yeah yeah yeah that's weird yeah that is weird but they are fundamentally it is still electrons
- 38:58right like you're still dealing with electrons in a digital computer or a quantum computer or
- 39:01whatever so it's um you know and it's interesting to know like our computing at the moment is is all
- 39:07incredibly deterministic right it's if if else loops it's you know loops of going through you
- 39:13know lists of things you know it's why computer programmers are quite you know rigid deterministic
- 39:18people they can read through this stuff in very logical patterns the interesting thing i think
- 39:22about quantum is that like, I think it does open up way more probabilistic computing. And, and the
- 39:27stuff that we're getting at with AI now is going in that direction in some ways, like, and, and some,
- 39:32in some degrees, like in a really weird, basic way, Nostra is kind of similar. Like there is no
- 39:37global feed of reality. Like there is no one single truth here. You've got all these relays
- 39:42and all this data. And what you see is you, you know, your constructed reality around you.
- 39:48and that's much more like the real world right like we don't know what real reality is because
- 39:52we just can't be everywhere all at once and take in all the information we're still going back to
- 39:56what you're saying but you're making me think of other things i was about to ask that exact question
- 40:00but i've got another one to do with ai and quantum based on what you've just said because when i look
- 40:06at ai now i think it's quite primitive because it's just it's basically looking at everything
- 40:12and then trying to make a prediction about what should be said based on that so there's no
- 40:17actual understanding there unless the basis of understanding is that it could be but that seems
- 40:23a bit brutal to me yeah yeah so how would that how would quantum affect that would that be
- 40:30because i when i look at ai now i think that doesn't seem like intelligence that just seems
- 40:36like a computer program running and guessing things until it gets it right based on information
- 40:41so will quantum make that a little bit more brain light do you think or am i wrong are our brains
- 40:47just stupid guessing machines no i mean i actually there's a really good framework that uh a guy
- 40:52i think it's john vervecki i get his his surname wrong yeah yeah yeah some max was talking about
- 40:59him yeah he's awesome and he has a really great way of thinking about uh cognition and intelligence
- 41:04and uh consciousness and i think it's a really really great way to kind of frame this question
- 41:10which is there are lots of different types of knowing, right? Like knowing that a cat is a
- 41:14mammal is a fact, right? Like you just, it's a thing that you can or can't, you know, know if
- 41:19you've never seen it before, you are ignorant of that fact, but it is no matter what, right?
- 41:23But there's other types of knowing. And AIs right now are incredibly good at that type of knowing.
- 41:27They've read every book. They've read everything on the internet. They have, you know, they know a
- 41:31lot of things about the world, but they've never, you know, walked through a field at sunset,
- 41:37and felt the breeze in their face.
- 41:39They don't know what that feels like.
- 41:41And they don't know procedural things like,
- 41:43what is it to swim?
- 41:46They can read all the books about swimming,
- 41:47but until you've been dumped in a pool,
- 41:49you don't know what swimming is.
- 41:51And so there's different types of knowing.
- 41:52And those are just a couple of examples.
- 41:54There's actually more that he goes into.
- 41:56But I think as AI gets progressively better,
- 42:01it's obviously going to get better
- 42:02at being able to crunch all that data, right?
- 42:05But I kind of feel like we're approaching
- 42:07the upper limit of like they've already crunched the entire internet right they're going to be able
- 42:10to form maybe better connections between things we might be able to give the ai an ability to sort
- 42:15of start to make um you know leaps between things try to be a bit more creative try to connect dots
- 42:21that don't seem connected which actually humans are really good at ai still aren't um but i don't
- 42:27know that we're ever going to get to a point where they've got that those other types of knowing that
- 42:31really only humans can have because we are going through the world and trying to i mean we have an
- 42:36incredible sensory organ, right? Like we have all these, we have ears, we have eyes, we have nose,
- 42:40we taste, our skin is, you know, feeling things constantly. We're actually not paying any attention
- 42:44to like 99.9% of that data. We just throw it all away instantaneously. And our brain is making
- 42:49these calculations of what matters to me right now. What can I, you know, safely throw away?
- 42:55I want to conserve as much energy as possible, but then how do I take all of what I am looking at,
- 43:00fit it into what my memory and my, you know, myself says is important. And then what am I
- 43:06going to do with that information um it's kind of incredible how much your brain is doing it could
- 43:10be though that what you've just described could still be that type one error error correction
- 43:17guessing you just add more senses i mean you described our senses there and it just occurred
- 43:21to me well yeah walking through and feeling the breeze is a function of feeling and smelling and
- 43:28sound so true maybe if you create a humanoid with receptors for those things maybe maybe we'll get
- 43:35to the bandwidth that bandwidth required but like i think the bandwidth required there is enormous
- 43:41it's kind of unbelievable right maybe it must be sure it's a question of time i suppose is the
- 43:45bigger thing is like how close are these things and i think i would posit that like agi is a long
- 43:50way out um i think we will get stuff that feels very very intelligent i mean we already have stuff
- 43:56that feels very intelligent like you can sit there and talk to claude or chachupiti and feel like
- 44:00you're talking to a human most of the time yeah um you know they do hallucinate still they do mess
- 44:04stuff up but you know they are very very intelligent at pretending to be human i i was thinking often
- 44:10the ai i see now is a bit like don't take this the wrong way because i do there's an autistic
- 44:16person in my life i'm not being rude to autistic people but autistic people look at what the world's
- 44:22happening and they try and mimic it and it's a bit like that with with some ais you realize
- 44:26the only difference is people um ai says things very authoritatively every single time yes it
- 44:34never has a conversation with you where it's like i'm not sure it could you know which is what humans
- 44:39do because we don't know everything but ai unfortunately thinks currently that it knows
- 44:44everything yeah well and when you correct a certain maturity actually so if you think about
- 44:47it like ai is sort of like an early teenager who's like no i know how everything works you know so i
- 44:52think as they mature they will get better at that but yeah you're right but when they when you correct
- 44:56them they it's bizarre because it's non it's very unhuman to go if you if i told if i said oh you
- 45:03know bitcoin's got 23 million you know there's 23 million bitcoins available and you're like
- 45:08it's actually 21 and i go oh yeah you're correct bitcoin's only got 20 you know like
- 45:14no human would do that right i would be like bitcoin's got a large supply of is it 21 million
- 45:21and you'd be like, yeah, it's 21 million.
- 45:23You know, it's like, but they do not do that.
- 45:26Right.
- 45:27Let's go back to where we were.
- 45:29Messaging, private messaging.
- 45:30Okay.
- 45:31So we got up to the Signal Protocol.
- 45:33Yes.
- 45:33Signal Protocol is, I mean, it was groundbreaking, right?
- 45:36Like it was a really big deal.
- 45:38And, you know, the guys were able to license that technology to Meta for,
- 45:43you know, they put it into WhatsApp.
- 45:45It was part of like Google Messenger.
- 45:47Like Signal Protocol is everywhere.
- 45:48It's not just in Signal.
- 45:49You know, the underlying protocol itself.
- 45:51the main difference between what signal does and what the other guys do is they might be using the
- 45:56same encryption scheme for the actual messages but the metadata around the messages is actually
- 46:02almost more important and more sensitive than the actual content of the message um so there's
- 46:07you know confidentiality and then there's privacy and confidentiality is like you know our messages
- 46:13are protected privacy is actually who's talking to who when like maybe why they're talking to each
- 46:18other. And so both of those things are really important if you actually want to talk about
- 46:24the privacy of a scheme. So WhatsApp perfectly fixes confidentiality. They're end-to-end
- 46:30encrypted. Their AI is in the chat with you, by the way. You can turn that off, but you're also
- 46:37going to turn off a bunch of other useful features because they're all grouped together in the same
- 46:40panel. I've never thought of WhatsApp as being a good place. I mean, they say they're end-to-end
- 46:45I don believe I mean it a very much trust me bro type of scenario Like they don tell you it closed source They do tell you that like yes under the hood you know we know we using signal protocol but like there a bunch of ways to break around that and say well we just put our own group member who invisible in the chat and then they
- 47:01also part of the conversation um that's my base case there is like there's just a bot in the chat
- 47:06i mean would that be called a backdoor is a backdoor something completely i mean a backdoor
- 47:10is something slightly different like because they're closed source because they own the whole
- 47:13scheme it's not even a backdoor it's just like this is part of the software like this is how
- 47:17it's literally built um you know a backdoor is more uh we have an encryption scheme but there's
- 47:23something that you know no one knows about that we can just turn it off or we can enter the chat
- 47:27whenever we want through this kind of super user access because i saw on online this week that
- 47:33um the eu are pushing to add backdoors to signal but yes chat control is back but funny enough i
- 47:41I use something called Molly, which is an open source version of Signal.
- 47:45Yes, I've heard of this.
- 47:46Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 47:46Right.
- 47:47Don't ask me whether it's better or worse.
- 47:49I just read the blurb and saw the groups and thought, okay, I'll do it.
- 47:53My daughter uses it.
- 47:55But what I find weird is if you – because obviously if Signal added a backdoor, Molly would not, right?
- 48:01Well, here's the thing.
- 48:04Well, Molly, if it wants to continue working with Signal, would almost certainly have to be very, very compatible.
- 48:09Like it would be very hard for Signal to add a backdoor in some way that, you know, Molly wouldn't sort of break on, right?
- 48:17Because when you're doing these encryption schemes, I mean, what I'm talking about now is like the actual encryption protocol.
- 48:22When you're doing them, if you get it wrong, it just doesn't work anymore.
- 48:25Like it completely stops working.
- 48:27And so, you know, if you've done the key derivation function slightly differently so that you can have an extra key somewhere, I mean, yes, there's potentially ways that are like, you know, undetectable or that don't have side effects.
- 48:39But a lot of these things are just math equations.
- 48:40And so if you change something, it changes something.
- 48:44Would that be a signal then that they have changed something?
- 48:46If a fork of signal couldn't interact with signal in a private way, would that be a signal that they've been…
- 48:54Potentially.
- 48:54Yeah, potentially.
- 48:56And again, I think signal is actually a great player.
- 48:59I think they're a good actor in the space.
- 49:00I think they do everything they possibly can to minimize the amount of metadata they have about their users.
- 49:05You've got to sign up with a phone number.
- 49:06They know they can connect you through that phone number to this user, but they actually minimize as much as possible in their servers what they have.
- 49:13And they try to delete it as fast as possible.
- 49:15And so I think, you know, they are they are good actors, but, you know, they're a centralized player.
- 49:21Right. They've got a 50 million dollar server budget.
- 49:24They've got a U.S. foundation.
- 49:25They have a CEO and all three of those things can fall apart in one way or another.
- 49:30And then Signal disappears for all of us.
- 49:32Why did they use phones just as a convenience?
- 49:34Yeah, absolutely.
- 49:35i mean so they could have done like nostr uses nothing you just you just create a thing there's
- 49:40a few things i use well nostr has to use phones too i mean it's it's whatever the computer is that
- 49:45you're actually no no i mean using your phone number as an identifier yeah they had to pick
- 49:50something and they um because it's a pretty full-on identifier isn't it yeah to them it's
- 49:56actually also just a spam protection measure because they have to run all these servers that
- 49:59do all this stuff um that don't do a lot of encryption and you know moving stuff around
- 50:03it's expensive and so they actually spend i think somebody told me recently that it's
- 50:07it's high it's like 20 or 25 percent of their whole budget every year is um sms you know just
- 50:14those verification sms's and that's just to stop spam basically you know because otherwise people
- 50:19would just create all these numbers that are fake use those create accounts you know and figure out
- 50:23ways to spam the network horrifically now signal has to worry about that because they have to pay
- 50:28all its servers right um nostr kind of gets around this by saying yeah there's spam and it's definitely
- 50:34going to affect everybody but it's so spread out that you know mostly it doesn't really have much
- 50:38of an effect now as we grow i bet that'll become a problem and we'll have to figure that out but
- 50:42like right now it's not really what do you mean spread out can you explain that yeah so imagine i
- 50:48mean signal has i mean it's a fleet of servers but it's all controlled by them they have to run the
- 50:53servers, they have to pay the server bills. Nostra relays are very dumb. They're not very,
- 50:58you know, resource intensive. It's effectively just a simple database. All we ask relays to do
- 51:03is accept events that are valid, you know, cryptographically signed validly. And when we
- 51:09ask you for something, if you have it, give it back. That's it. You don't have to do anything
- 51:12else. You don't have to compute stuff. You don't have to do any cryptography. Like all you're doing
- 51:16is taking something storing in a database and then returning a response if you, you know, have
- 51:20something. So that makes running a Nasta relay quite cheap up to, you know, fairly large sizes.
- 51:27And certainly, yes, once we get to, you know, a mass adoption point where we have millions and
- 51:32millions of users running a very large relay is going to be costly. But the people who are going
- 51:37to run very large relays are people who are running businesses where that very large relay
- 51:41that they're paying for directly improves the UX for their user base. And that's going to make
- 51:45total sense for them. But there's all sorts of ways you can run small relays. You can control
- 51:50the amount of data that comes into them. You can whitelist who's allowed to post and who's not.
- 51:55And so there are a myriad of ways where running relays is actually super cheap and you can
- 52:00actually run them on your phone. You can run them on a laptop, like no big deal.
- 52:04And I think the world we head towards is, yes, there's a number of very large relays,
- 52:10but in a power law dynamic, it falls off fairly fast. And there's a long tail of relays that will
- 52:15accept most messages and also are completely commodity and don't matter to the actual end
- 52:21user. You know, if you're connected to three or four of these things and one or two go down because
- 52:25of spam, who cares? You just switch. You just move around. And so especially for our use case,
- 52:30it's really important to us that we never run servers. You know, like it's we don't want to
- 52:34have any servers. We're like we're client side software. You know, when the government shows up
- 52:38and they're like, give us, you know, all the data on your users. We're like, we don't have any.
- 52:41all you can do is go to github and see our code base that's it we've got to talk about that later
- 52:45let me remind that yeah because you know i think we've just seen a ruling in the u.s which might
- 52:52be bad news for that in the future makes me very nervous right okay we're definitely definitely
- 52:57coming back to that let's finish the so the signal story currently still a good app to use i think
- 53:02it's great yeah i think it's great i think they do a good job um you know is it foolproof absolutely
- 53:08not like nothing is foolproof like if you want actual privacy you need to go way away from a lot
- 53:14of other humans and have a private conversation in the middle of nowhere and even then you know
- 53:19look up yeah exactly there could be a camera above you um so you know it's tough to get real real
- 53:27privacy these days um but i think you know signal does about as good as you could possibly hope um
- 53:33for most use cases. I'm glad about that. I've got white noise, but obviously most people I know
- 53:40aren't on white noise. So we'll get there. It's early. You know, one other thing that I'd love
- 53:45to mention here is that, you know, a lot of people focus in on the actual encryption scheme and use
- 53:50or, you know, things like that. Um, it's really important when you're thinking about privacy,
- 53:55you know, to think about like to do a proper threat assessment, right? Like who are you
- 53:58actually trying to maintain privacy from like are you just trying to not stick out in metas
- 54:04profiling things so you don't get you know garbage ads or so that they don't know more about you than
- 54:08you want them to know that's like one thing if you're against a state level actor you're kind
- 54:13of screwed like there's no way you're going to be able to get away from the nsa like if they really
- 54:17want to find you they will find you um and they will know everything about you really even even
- 54:22Even decrypting messages?
- 54:26It's less about decrypting the messages as it is about figuring out ways that they don't have to decrypt the messages, right?
- 54:32Like they will, you know, if you're important enough, they've got a portfolio of zero day exploits that they've never used before that they'll figure out how to get onto your phone one way or another.
- 54:41And then they'll just have full root access to everything on your phone.
- 54:44And then they've got everything on the phone.
- 54:47And so, you know, when we're talking about Signal, you have a decrypted message.
- 54:51You encrypt it.
- 54:52you send it, the other person decrypts it on their side, they've got a decrypted message.
- 54:56If the person that is attacking you is already in your phone at root level,
- 54:59they have your messages, like they have everything.
- 55:01And graphene and those kind of things?
- 55:04Graphene is a great project and they do, and this is the thing, like
- 55:08the better that a phone and the operating system protects you against zero days,
- 55:12the safer you are. And so things like lockdown mode on iOS are actually really, really important.
- 55:18Like I think everybody should have lockdown mode on. It makes a really big difference.
- 55:21You know, I've talked to security researchers, you know, good friends that find these things in the wild and that do a lot of the research on Pegasus and are the people that point out when they found people who have been affected by Pegasus.
- 55:33And universally, the first thing he says is always like, just turn on lockdown mode.
- 55:37It like makes almost no difference.
- 55:38And it makes a huge difference to like to your use case, but it makes a huge difference to your actual security.
- 55:43Hold a minute.
- 55:44Lockdown on mine.
- 55:45I've got graphene.
- 55:46Yeah.
- 55:47It's a button you actually have to press, I think.
- 55:48so i don't know exactly what the difference is and like you know i know graphing is very good i
- 55:53think it's actually more lockdown mode like by default i think there's also some extreme settings
- 55:58lockdown mode on ios is just this mode where it's a one switch and it turns on a bunch of features
- 56:04it won load images by default it won you know do a bunch of things that look when i go to turn nine off yeah is that lockdown is that different i thought that was i thought that means scramble the whole phone and so that yeah i don know exactly what that is but lockdown
- 56:21mode on ios is basically hey we're going to turn on a bunch of extra features that are going to
- 56:24reduce your user experience a little bit you know we're going to not load images by default we're
- 56:29going to make you opt in on certain things certain websites are not going to work because we're not
- 56:32going to load javascript you know random javascript from servers we don't know um but in return it's
- 56:39going to be much harder to hit you with a zero day because most zero days come in through things
- 56:42like sms messages with a link in them or an image that comes in through a chat that looks like an
- 56:47image but like buried in the image when your parser goes through it and tries to decrypt it or a pdf
- 56:52loads of zero days and pdfs actually just say what zero days it's basically it's because it's an
- 56:57exploit that's never been used in public never been seen so researchers will go through software
- 57:02they will find places where it's like hey if we are able to craft a pdf something that looks like
- 57:09a PDF, but buried in that PDF is a tiny bit of code that does one weird thing with the way that
- 57:14the parser, you know, the thing that looks at all the binary data of what your PDF is,
- 57:19if it makes that parser choke in a weird way, do something it's not supposed to do,
- 57:23and somehow upgrades our access into, we have total control of your phone,
- 57:28like that's the classic zero day that they're all looking for. And a lot of the recent ones,
- 57:33the things that Pegasus and its predecessors are...
- 57:36Pegasus is Israeli spy tech, basically.
- 57:39It's a program that loads of governments use.
- 57:42They've all been caught recently using a bunch of European governments that love to yell about how private and how much they care about privacy.
- 57:48The Italian government was just caught using this against journalists in the country who were reporting on the migration crisis from Africa.
- 57:56And this happens.
- 57:57And Italy's response to this was they got caught and they were like, yeah, but all these other European countries are doing it too.
- 58:02Do individuals use Pegasus?
- 58:05Good question.
- 58:06good question no there's no as far as i know there's no open source version of this this is
- 58:11like a but but you know hackers in general that's what they're doing that's what they're doing yeah
- 58:15and and basically pegasus is a you know a suite of semi-legitimate hacking company that just says
- 58:22we are a suite of tools for government and law enforcement and you're like no wow so i didn't
- 58:28know that i didn't know yeah it's new to me it's pretty scary stuff like it's it's scary and so
- 58:32you know you find these zero days and they're very hard to find and you know they're worth
- 58:35millions of dollars like the hackers out there in the dark you know markets that do this can make a
- 58:40lot of money doing this um but you know back to the earlier point like the nsa has many of these
- 58:45in their pocket and they're just waiting for if you're important enough they will pull one out and
- 58:49use it um and then they'll have access at the bottom level so like computers are not safe period
- 58:54like it's just it's a fact if the government wants to talk to you they will talk to you but
- 58:58What about Bitcoin wallets then?
- 59:01I mean, presumably the NSA could just take any of your Bitcoin.
- 59:04I mean, anything that's connected to a real computer, yeah.
- 59:07Now I know why people.
- 59:08This is why completely disconnected hardware wallets are pretty important, right?
- 59:12You want a signing device that has generated your private key never to touch the internet.
- 59:18Cold card is for those.
- 59:19Yeah, cold card is gold standard in my opinion.
- 59:22Those guys are so paranoid.
- 59:23And when you actually talk to them and you get into the weeds with them, you're like,
- 59:26oh my god you've thought of so many things here and you know i love some of the open source
- 59:31signing projects that are out there for the ethos behind them but i don't think that like their
- 59:37purpose fit for very large sums of money you know there's a scale here right like if you have a
- 59:42little bit of bitcoin it's totally fine to have it on a hot wallet on your phone like we should not
- 59:45be yelling at people that are getting into the space for having 50 bucks of bitcoin in a hot
- 59:50wallet like totally fine or a custodial service like just leave them alone for a bit it scales
- 59:55And the security needs to scale with that, you know, with how much you have to protect and how much you have to protect changes based on what your circumstances, right?
- 1:00:03Like 50 bucks of Bitcoin might be life changing to people in certain parts of the world.
- 1:00:07And, you know, they need to treat that accordingly.
- 1:00:09But I think if you want to think about like real security, you know, you need to have a kind of complicated setup that, you know, has a bunch of things that never touched the Internet and are very geographically dispersed.
- 1:00:22And even that is hard, right?
- 1:00:24Like, taking full-person responsibility is hard.
- 1:00:27That's just the fact.
- 1:00:28Those, the volume of people who should be in that situation is going up rapidly, I think.
- 1:00:36Because if you look back to the big pump of Bitcoin adoption, it was about 2017.
- 1:00:43That was a lot of individuals, wasn't it?
- 1:00:46Yeah.
- 1:00:47And if you track forward now.
- 1:00:49Yeah, we're 10, 12x from even the highs in there.
- 1:00:52It's easy to predict that there's a number of, quite a high percentage of those people should be pretty well off at the moment, if they just held.
- 1:01:01Yeah, and if they held.
- 1:01:03So I bet it's a smaller percentage than we think, but yeah.
- 1:01:05But still, I mean, the point is, in four years' time, there's going to be another big batch.
- 1:01:10And that batch from 2017, they're going to be like the 2013 lot who are basically boiling it on a yacht.
- 1:01:17Yeah, if they want to.
- 1:01:19Exactly, exactly.
- 1:01:20If they want to, they could, easily.
- 1:01:22But it's interesting. You're right. You're absolutely right. You know, if they can get on your phone, if they can get in your computer, then they would be able to have a screenshot of the time when they flashed up your private seed and you wrote it down or you were whispering it as you wrote it and the mic was picking it up or, you know.
- 1:01:40There's a million ways that this goes wrong. And again, it's like how much like you need to do the threat assessment, like how much of a target are you actually? How much, you know, what's more risky? Like somebody was saying the other day, like, I bet more Bitcoin has been lost from people trying to do the right thing by then people who just put their seed phrase into Google Doc and left it on a, you know, on Google servers for 10 years and then found it later. And they were like, oh, there's some Bitcoin here. Like, you know, people foot gun themselves pretty regularly.
- 1:02:06And so it's sort of, you know, do a threat assessment, really think through, like, am I going to be able to actually do the thing that I'm trying to set out to do?
- 1:02:13Am I technically capable and competent enough to deal with this and figure out what to do there?
- 1:02:18Like, if you're not technically capable and competent, maybe it does make more sense to go to someone like Anchor Watch and be like, hey, I'd like to, you know, do a collaborative custody thing with you guys and ensure this because, you know, it's meaningful to me.
- 1:02:30I'm happy to pay a little bit of money for it.
- 1:02:32You know, there's nothing wrong with custody.
- 1:02:33it's more a thing of if you're if you have custody forced upon you and you have no choice
- 1:02:38that's what where things go very bad um if you have the ability to move your things away from
- 1:02:44a custodian and you actually value their service and they provide a good service there's nothing
- 1:02:48wrong with that okay back to right we've just hit the end of signal by the sounds of it
- 1:02:54yes let's go back so evolution from signal yes so signal is great signal's major downfall is that
- 1:03:00it doesn't scale well. It is what's called a pairwise protocol, which means that if you are
- 1:03:05in a DM with somebody, me and you, it's great, works perfectly. If you start scaling up the group,
- 1:03:10we have to, each of us, for every message we send to the group, we have to individually encrypt it
- 1:03:14to every member of the group. And so that doesn't scale well. It scales linearly. You know, more
- 1:03:19group members means way more computation. And so when you get to very large groups,
- 1:03:24signal effectively just breaks. You know, it can't support groups of thousands or millions.
- 1:03:28and so that's always been something that this you know signal has done a lot of work and that's
- 1:03:34part of you know the stuff they do in their servers there's like all these bolt-on protocols
- 1:03:38that help make signal work better in groups but fundamentally everybody kind of knew that like we
- 1:03:43have to figure out something better for groups that scales better and so somewhere in 2017 2018
- 1:03:47a group of you know very very smart people who have been working in cryptography and and the
- 1:03:52signal protocol and stuff got together and went okay we're going to come up with a scheme that's
- 1:03:55going to do better for large groups. And what they came up with is what became MLS, message layer
- 1:04:01security. And it's, you know, kind of like TLS, you know, transport layer security. It takes a few
- 1:04:08of those ideas and applies a, you know, somewhat similar encryption scheme. So it's sort of a
- 1:04:14double ratchet-ish type scheme, but arranges a group in what's called a binary tree, which is a
- 1:04:19tree where, you know, it splits into two leaves from every node as it goes down. And so the group
- 1:04:25members in this ratchet tree across the bottom, you know, the very bottom layer. And then there's
- 1:04:30keys at all of the nodes above them. And the way it's set up means that when you change part of the
- 1:04:36group, you don't have to change the entire group structure. And when you have to encrypt things,
- 1:04:41you don't have to encrypt to everybody, you're encrypting to the keys along a path to the root,
- 1:04:47where everybody else can derive keys down from that root and get what they need. So we're back
- 1:04:52to these key derivation functions again.
- 1:04:53So it's a different way of applying key derivation functions
- 1:04:55and structuring a ROOP in a way that takes a problem.
- 1:04:59You know, in computer science talk,
- 1:05:00it takes it from a linear scaling problem
- 1:05:01to a log scaling problem, which makes a huge difference.
- 1:05:05And is this the pinnacle?
- 1:05:07Will it be the pinnacle?
- 1:05:08I think it's a incredibly good standard.
- 1:05:10I know it's being adopted by a lot of really big companies.
- 1:05:14And for good reason, it's going to help save them
- 1:05:17millions and millions of dollars in servers.
- 1:05:19It's also very well proved, you know,
- 1:05:21from an academic point of view, like the cryptography is very solid. It's also got this
- 1:05:25really cool property that you can upgrade groups and change groups over time in terms of like even
- 1:05:31stuff down to like what Cypher suite they using So you can completely change from a non resistant to a quantum resistant thing in a group in flight You don have to like disband the group and restart with the same people So it got a lot of cool properties that I think make
- 1:05:44it quite durable towards the future. It's also got an extension system that's sort of
- 1:05:49built into it that allows you to kind of sidecar data into the encryption scheme.
- 1:05:55And one other big thing that I think it gives you over Signal is it gives you sort of
- 1:05:59cryptographic, you know, a cryptographic guarantee of the entire group state.
- 1:06:04So, you know, cryptographically that like, these are the members of the group.
- 1:06:07These are the extensions that this group is using.
- 1:06:09This is the, you know, cipher suite we have to use.
- 1:06:12Like all of that is, you know, signed and hashed.
- 1:06:14And so, you know, okay, this is the state and we all, everybody in the group has agreed
- 1:06:18that this is the state.
- 1:06:20And so that gives you some interesting things that you can do with it.
- 1:06:22Why aren't Signal adopting that?
- 1:06:26It'll be interesting to see what they do.
- 1:06:27uh whether they decide to their problem right yeah it'll be interesting to see whether they
- 1:06:31uh stay with their own thing or if they start to move towards something like mls or buy a company
- 1:06:36or buy white noise i mean they don't even need to it's an open source thing like they've got
- 1:06:41plenty of smart people that could apply this and it's you know i think mls itself is very very
- 1:06:45complex um but once you have an implementation library that does the really base cryptographic
- 1:06:50math and like does have all the you know tests and things that cover off and you know does the
- 1:06:56test vectors that show that it's doing what it's supposed to be doing.
- 1:06:59You know, building an app on top of that becomes a lot more straightforward.
- 1:07:03I think the hard part for what we're doing is, you know, everybody up until now, you
- 1:07:07know, MLS has only been on internet standard.
- 1:07:09That's the other kind of cool thing about it.
- 1:07:11It was, you know, it's an IETF, so Internet Engineering Task Force, internet standard.
- 1:07:17You know, TLS is in that group.
- 1:07:18There's, you know, this is a worldwide group that comes together and is incredibly bureaucratic
- 1:07:23and slow.
- 1:07:23Oh, okay.
- 1:07:24But it's a bunch of engineers coming together and going, this is the thing, stamp.
- 1:07:28We've done lots and lots of work to prove that this is the thing, and we're all going to use it.
- 1:07:32Or if you want to use it, you know at least that the legwork has been done.
- 1:07:38Wow.
- 1:07:39And, you know, most of the things that are, you know, basic internet technologies are in this group.
- 1:07:42You know, TCPIP, TLS, like all that stuff is, you know, in IETF.
- 1:07:47And are there any apps that I would know, non-NOSTA apps, as in, that are using it already?
- 1:07:53Yeah, yeah. So there's Wire is a kind of well-known tool.
- 1:07:56We use that in our foundation.
- 1:07:59So the Wire guys are actually some of the original writers on the MLS protocol.
- 1:08:03I'd never heard of Wire until I joined the Free Cities Foundation, but our whole company runs on Wire.
- 1:08:07Yeah, yeah. There you go. So WebEx from Cisco uses it as the handshake for getting into webinars.
- 1:08:13So before you actually get the webinar stream, you have to do all this handshake stuff to actually enter the room to then get the stream.
- 1:08:20and that's all done with MLS.
- 1:08:22Now, everybody that's done this so far
- 1:08:24is a centralized service.
- 1:08:25They have a server in the middle
- 1:08:26that can guarantee identity
- 1:08:27and can guarantee transport, right?
- 1:08:29So MLS itself is transport and identity agnostic.
- 1:08:32It's like, that's for you to figure out.
- 1:08:34You know, we just talk about
- 1:08:34how you're going to structure the data
- 1:08:36and how you're going to do the encryption.
- 1:08:38And so that, when I started to talk to the guys
- 1:08:40that, you know, work on this stuff,
- 1:08:42they were like,
- 1:08:42we don't know of anybody
- 1:08:43that's done it decentralized yet.
- 1:08:45Like we've heard people talk about it,
- 1:08:46want to do it, but you know, good luck, have fun.
- 1:08:49They knew about NOSTA though.
- 1:08:50They roughly knew about Noster.
- 1:08:52You know, most people in that space are pretty skeptical of Bitcoin.
- 1:08:56Really?
- 1:08:57Yeah, it's weird.
- 1:08:58I've never understood how they can compartmentalize like that.
- 1:09:02But I think it's partially just because they didn't go down the legwork of understanding.
- 1:09:06Where are they skeptical?
- 1:09:08I mean, it's addressable probably.
- 1:09:10They just haven't done the work.
- 1:09:11Yeah.
- 1:09:12They haven't done the work and they don't care.
- 1:09:13And so it's one of these things where, you know, some of them get it.
- 1:09:16Some of them don't.
- 1:09:17I never push it because it's just like, I'm not going to spend my time doing that.
- 1:09:20But they were supportive in the sense of this would be cool to see, ask questions, help out.
- 1:09:27And so my job was basically how do I apply this into Noster and do it in a way that doesn't leak metadata?
- 1:09:36How do we put this encryption scheme in, use public relays, send everything across public-facing stuff in a way that if an observer is looking at all the traffic, they don't really know much?
- 1:09:48you know uh and that proved to be you know pretty tricky just before you go on i just had a thought
- 1:09:55this is a complete tangent but does this system have any benefit to privatizing bitcoin transactions
- 1:10:03and things like that yeah well privatizing bitcoin transactions maybe a little less the way you
- 1:10:08described it then was you're sending things over an open network and no one really can derive much
- 1:10:14information from it which is the essence of bitcoin privacy in a way yeah well the problem
- 1:10:18Bitcoin is that those transactions need to be public, right? Like it needs to be a public ledger
- 1:10:22so that everyone can verify. Um, what about a second layer then? Absolutely. Yeah. So this has
- 1:10:29all sorts of use cases in, you know, things like, uh, multi-sig coordination, great use case, you
- 1:10:34know, like you've got a wallet, you want to be able to coordinate with other people to do all
- 1:10:37the signing. Um, you need some way to, to do that in a way that is secure. Um, so that's a great
- 1:10:43use case for it. I'm sure there are, you know, second layer things that you could do, you know,
- 1:10:47But I think there's probably slightly better ways to do it in a lot of cases just because there's a lot of overhead with setting up a group, with keeping the group state up to date, making sure that all the devices are clients that need to be in that group.
- 1:11:02When you join an MLS group from your phone and your computer, and this is the same with Signal, by the way, you're actually two different members in that group.
- 1:11:10It's just that the UI sees that, hey, this is actually the same person and kind of collapses it to one person in the view.
- 1:11:15but you are cryptographically two different entities in that group um so i think you know
- 1:11:22for certain bitcoin applications especially closer to the humans it makes a tons of sense
- 1:11:27you know i think when you start to get down into the weeds of like how would you know lightning
- 1:11:31privacy work or there's other solutions that are going to make a little more sense fair enough okay
- 1:11:35so you so there are no decentralized versions or they weren't there weren't there's a bunch of
- 1:11:41people working on them you know i know that the mastodon folks are are dying to have this their
- 1:11:45proposal leaks metadata all over the place um the blue sky folks would love to have this too but
- 1:11:51their pds system doesn't really allow for it um because it's a quite a centralized identity server
- 1:11:56thing um so i think i think we're like the first properly decentralized version of this that does
- 1:12:03a really good job hiding privacy um i haven't heard of any others that you know have made me go
- 1:12:08oh we actually missed something there and in order to interact with it you just need a noster
- 1:12:12you just need a noster publicly that's it right um and what i what i noticed was i haven't actually
- 1:12:18i've got it but i haven't actually sent a dummy message yet that's okay but what i noticed was
- 1:12:23what it didn't do was pull in my my list of known people so from noster and obviously there's a
- 1:12:30privacy that there's a privacy feature or am i no no that's it's probably just an early version
- 1:12:35yeah yeah like we're trying to get this out as early as possible to get things and we've gotten
- 1:12:39so much great feedback and to be honest the app barely works for certain people and the longer
- 1:12:44you've been on nostr and you sign into white noise the more problems you're going to find
- 1:12:48because you've got all these it's actually down to relay and like how relays interact with things
- 1:12:52and when you're trying to be quite private with with certain parts of data it makes it harder for
- 1:12:56relays to understand what's going on and so it makes it harder for things to overlap if you've
- 1:13:01got the kind of outbox model set up where you've defined all these different relays that you want
- 1:13:05to use for different purposes so that's generally the thing that makes this really hard you know if
- 1:13:10you sign up with a brand new account on there like if you just create account it's almost universally
- 1:13:14going to work and you know once you get into the edge cases of which there are a lot in our early
- 1:13:19you know cohort of users which are all the you know people that have been on NOSTA a while
- 1:13:22that's what we're kind of working through now I think this is true right not a lot of people
- 1:13:26realize this but on nostr currently if you're using primal or amethyst or whatever when you
- 1:13:32send a direct a dm yeah it's public right pretty much i mean yeah the content of the message is
- 1:13:37encrypted with a very lightweight encryption scheme the all the metadata of who's talking
- 1:13:42to who and when that's all public um and there's actually bots that go around just reporting on
- 1:13:47this the dm reporter bot it's very funny well what i what on mine i use amethyst but when someone
- 1:13:52sends me a dm it becomes a notification yeah as in not a just there's a dm notification and
- 1:13:57that's the giveaway for me that's the giveaway right yep and and there is another scheme like
- 1:14:02you know i think it was like a year and a half ago or almost two years ago at this point um
- 1:14:05you know the earliest version of the you know dm scheme nipo4 which is what primal and damas still
- 1:14:12use um that's like always been known to be bad right like we've all known that from the beginning
- 1:14:16and ben arc was the one who wrote that originally and like he never meant that to be an actual
- 1:14:21encryption scheme. It was like, let's see if we can get semi-private messaging on Nostr.
- 1:14:25You know, hacked it up in a few hours and like, okay, this is good. And there's like 30 people
- 1:14:30using Nostr, right? Like there's no one on the network. And it just somehow hung around for a
- 1:14:35long time. And so there, you know, whatever, a year and a half ago, a bunch of devs got together
- 1:14:40and did some work to come up with something that was a little better, you know, in terms of it's a
- 1:14:45better encryption scheme for the actual content, but it also wraps the messages in another message
- 1:14:50so that it hides all the metadata.
- 1:14:52So what you see on the network is some random pub key
- 1:14:55that we've never seen before sent a message to
- 1:14:58that mentions someone,
- 1:15:00We don't know what that message is.
- 1:15:01It could be anything inside.
- 1:15:02And the person that, you know, receives the message knows how to unwrap that message and then get to the actual encrypted option.
- 1:15:08So the plan going forward would probably be that the YNOS protocol would just get incorporated in other things.
- 1:15:16Yes, exactly.
- 1:15:16And that's actually what's taken so long in the project.
- 1:15:19You know, like first I had to figure out how to even apply MLS into NOSTER.
- 1:15:22And like once I was fairly sure that was possible, then I actually started with instead of writing white noise,
- 1:15:28I was concurrently writing all the libraries that I would want other developers to use to do this.
- 1:15:33And so I wrote the spec of like, this is how you're supposed to do the thing.
- 1:15:36And then I wrote the libraries that implement that spec.
- 1:15:39And at the same time, I was sort of writing the proof of concept of what the white noise messenger was, sort of to test the libraries I was building.
- 1:15:47And as we've gone on a little bit, we've now got a pretty solid basic library that does the thing correctly.
- 1:15:54It's written in Rust, so we'll be able to bind out to other languages and give this to other developers.
- 1:15:59And white noise has come a long, long way in the process.
- 1:16:02So I want this to be fully interoperable.
- 1:16:05I know for a fact that, like, you know, Vitor with Amethyst, Will at Damas, Million with Primal,
- 1:16:10they're all just like, tell us when it's ready and we're going to implement it.
- 1:16:13And, like, we'll do this right across the board.
- 1:16:15And you're funded by OpenSats, is it?
- 1:16:18Or it can't be a business for you?
- 1:16:20You're just giving it away freely?
- 1:16:20No, this is definitely not a business for me.
- 1:16:22And it was actually funny, like when I started to think about the project, it was sort of, do I try to raise VC funds for this or do I stick to the open source grants model and, you know, try to do this as like a public benefit type thing?
- 1:16:35And, you know, I would say it was like a hard decision.
- 1:16:39It actually wasn't.
- 1:16:40You know, I'd been on an OpenSats grant for a little while at that point.
- 1:16:43And to me, this is a project that needs to be fully open, fully, you know, untethered to something where there's a financial outcome.
- 1:16:50Maybe described by OpenSats.
- 1:16:52I assume that they weren't large grants, though, not enough to live off and stuff.
- 1:16:56No, well, I think OpenSats has done a really good job.
- 1:16:59So let me quickly give the definition.
- 1:17:01Like OpenSats is just a 501c3 nonprofit that takes in grants and donations from, you know, big foundations, from donors.
- 1:17:08You know, they've gotten a lot of kind of their seed capital from Jack Dorsey.
- 1:17:12And they fund Bitcoin, Lightning and Nostra projects.
- 1:17:15and specifically they fund developers with grants that generally run for you know six months to a
- 1:17:23year they also have a long-term support program which does you know two-year grants um i was one
- 1:17:29of the very first grantees to get an open sats grant you know at the beginning of nostr um they'd
- 1:17:35been doing a little bit of bitcoin grants and they started doing nostr grants and you know i was
- 1:17:38funded for a year with that and then i got a renewal and got another year um that's actually
- 1:17:42just ended. So now I'm no longer funded by OpenSats. But, you know, there's been a bunch
- 1:17:47of other organizations in the middle as well, like HRF gives Bitcoin grants for developers.
- 1:17:52I'm very lucky to be working with them and gotten grants from them.
- 1:17:54It makes perfect sense though.
- 1:17:55Yeah. It makes total sense. And so there's an ecosystem of places that
- 1:17:58are granting money to developers and projects for things. And I think it's cool because,
- 1:18:03you know, OpenSats focuses more on sort of very wide, they're happy to give developers who might
- 1:18:09not even have necessarily a clear project in mind, but have shown proof of work and built
- 1:18:13interesting things that are just experimenting with a lot of stuff. And I think that's really
- 1:18:16important on one side. HRF tends to fund stuff that's like a bit more, this is a known project
- 1:18:22and it's a project that fits into our remit of, you know, trying to make more freedom in the world.
- 1:18:27And so HRF has been a really great partner to White Noise and me and everything. So they've
- 1:18:31been amazing. But yeah, like I think where this is headed is I'm probably going towards, you know,
- 1:18:38creating a 501c3 going you know part of my job will be making sure that we always have money to
- 1:18:43keep this project going um so you're going to do this full-time i mean i've been doing this full-time
- 1:18:48for over a year now and i intend to continue working on this for as long as humanly possible
- 1:18:53um you mentioned jack yeah tell me about bit chat which i haven't used yet
- 1:18:58it's so much fun really it's so much fun yeah i mean look i think you don't think it's a serious
- 1:19:05contender though well it's just a totally different thing right like it's um i think you know taking
- 1:19:11one step back i think jack is a such a unique human um like how many people can you pinpoint
- 1:19:16in the world that have made billions of dollars and are still hacking on stuff in their spare time
- 1:19:22and are still looking at how do we increase freedom and agency in the world like there's not many
- 1:19:28right you know billionaires usually get stuck into other things um so the fact that you know jack has
- 1:19:34a public company that has two incredibly you know profitable business lines that he has to deal with
- 1:19:40you know wall street on a regular basis but finds time to hack on stuff you know vibe code apps in
- 1:19:45his spare time is kind of nuts talking of before we go oops before we go out are you vibe code in
- 1:19:51this or are you no no the thing are you coding it a lot so there's parts of you know this where llms
- 1:19:57can be really helpful you know like writing documentation writing some tests like those
- 1:20:01are great anytime you get to code that is fundamentally novel that's new they where
- 1:20:06you're combining things that you know an llm has never seen the number of hallucinations goes through
- 1:20:10the roof and it's like totally useless you also just don't want to be vibe coding stuff that
- 1:20:14really matters you know like no one should ever be vibe coding on bitcoin core like that's just
- 1:20:18fundamental fact but what about you as a are you a coder yeah so you're sitting at the you're you've
- 1:20:24got your hoodie on i use lms constantly for all sorts of stuff from everything from just
- 1:20:29hey can you give me you know i can't remember what the api definition of this method is can you give
- 1:20:34me a quick like summary of it or tell me more about how this piece of the protocol works and
- 1:20:39we like talk back and forth about it it's a great pair programmer and as a you know experienced
- 1:20:45engineer you really benefit from having someone to bounce ideas off of and having someone who's
- 1:20:49literally read all the documentation for every software ever you know created in the world and
- 1:20:53can immediately give you a correct answer on basic information without without prying 2d i take it
- 1:20:59you could go and get a very well-paid job somewhere probably yeah just so i'm just formulating a
- 1:21:05picture we've only just met and i'm yeah please very pleased to meet you but i'm working this
- 1:21:09stuff out right bit chat okay bit chat is awesome bit chat is super super fun um i love the idea of
- 1:21:15kind of off-grid stuff like that you know using mesh networks using wi-fi using radio you know
- 1:21:20using satellite stuff i think um where we have gotten with the internet over the last 25 years
- 1:21:26is terrifying. It's become completely centralized and totally owned by five companies and governments.
- 1:21:33And that's not somewhere I would like to be. You know, like, to be honest, I would almost rather
- 1:21:38it be wholly owned by governments rather than, you know, five big companies. Governments are at
- 1:21:43least not as useful. They aren't as competent as these companies are. You know, like, Meta is full
- 1:21:50of incredibly intelligent people. And I worry about their motivations. And so I think, you know,
- 1:21:56Anything that helps us go in the direction away from this, you know, pure centralization,
- 1:22:02like the internet that most people know right now is actually just five companies and their
- 1:22:06platforms.
- 1:22:07Like it is a platformized internet rather than the open decentralized protocol based
- 1:22:13thing that we started with.
- 1:22:14And I want to do everything I can to make us go back in that direction.
- 1:22:17I think that's where we get freedom.
- 1:22:19That's where we get interesting ideas.
- 1:22:20That's where people actually benefit from these tech rather than, you know, being sucked
- 1:22:25off of by the parasites.
- 1:22:26And Jack's BitChat is essentially a mechanism for transmitting data directly between devices over Bluetooth, whatever it can get its hands on.
- 1:22:38Well, there's nothing super novel about this, right?
- 1:22:40Like we've known about mesh networks for a long time and Bluetooth is, I think, only recently becoming viable there with like Bluetooth low energy.
- 1:22:48You know, it's used as low energy.
- 1:22:49It can do a little bit, you know, decent range on it.
- 1:22:52um so for certain use cases like you're in a cities or you're in a panel like in a talk at
- 1:22:59bitcoin honey badger or you know or baltic honey badger we were in panels it'd be like okay open up
- 1:23:04bit chat and send us questions and like you're basically just getting the questions from the
- 1:23:07room right it's ephemeral it disappears immediately um you know there's no identity attached to it
- 1:23:13so i think there's some fun stuff there but it's worth mentioning that you could transmit a message
- 1:23:18from that room to australia providing you have enough it could make yeah and it has to be a it
- 1:23:24has to be within sort of striking distance i mean 100 feet 100 meters is that right yeah you're not
- 1:23:29going to get you're not going to get it across the channel or across the across the no you're
- 1:23:33going to have to hook into something that can do longer distance at some point um so it's it can be
- 1:23:38really good for very you know small geographic locations um i mean you could easily relay stuff
- 1:23:44across the city in a couple of minutes but like i was i was a journalist in london for
- 1:23:49almost eight years and often we used to cover demonstrations and during demonstrations the
- 1:23:56police used to shut off the mobile phone signal this was back in the 90s and 2000s like it was
- 1:24:02happening back then so that would really be a great exactly exactly and i think the cool thing
- 1:24:08about bitchat is that it fun um people love it it like spreading really quickly and it making us figure this whole like mesh thing out because you know talking to like Kale who the one that does the BitChat Android app You know he like it so interesting because we have no idea how these mesh things are you know prioritizing different you know mechanisms
- 1:24:31Like there's no optimization here at all.
- 1:24:34It's literally like try to connect to anybody you see and just send messages, you know, and it fails in all these weird ways.
- 1:24:38And so I think it's we need to get better at understanding, like, how do we do mesh well?
- 1:24:43We know how we do, you know, the internet well when you've got a wire.
- 1:24:46But how do you do mesh over Bluetooth or radio or Wi-Fi?
- 1:24:50It must be great at festivals as well.
- 1:24:52It could also be amazing at festivals.
- 1:24:54Half a million people all in one place.
- 1:24:56Yeah.
- 1:24:56And the mobile phone signal can't handle all that data that you can do.
- 1:25:00Exactly.
- 1:25:00So I hope that we are going towards a future where we have way less centralization on the internet.
- 1:25:06And we've got little pockets all over the place that do different stuff at different layers of the stack.
- 1:25:11And like, yeah, it's going to connect to the internet.
- 1:25:12some point beam you across the ocean but you know do you need your you know town chat or whatever to
- 1:25:20actually hit the internet no it doesn't it can literally stay locally and it could be on a server
- 1:25:23in someone's basement and it never touches the internet at all and obviously that would have a
- 1:25:28big impact on bitcoin payments as well bitcoin payments on just privacy in general the less you
- 1:25:35can feed data and traffic and information to facebook the better but i mean for example i
- 1:25:41i've been to um el salvador a few times and i've realized very succinctly that if you don't got a
- 1:25:49phone signal it's very difficult to make a bitcoin transaction and you get used to around here not
- 1:25:54having that problem but when you go something like that yeah the papusa lady wants some bitcoin
- 1:25:58off you and you can't send it presumably these mesh networks would you would be able to use the
- 1:26:03mesh networks and then would with the and then settle later or you maybe use lightning and settle
- 1:26:08later or something yeah well i think i don't even think it would be a settled later type of thing
- 1:26:12because um you know those technologies bitcoin specifically and lightning you know do require
- 1:26:17you know being connected so to give you any sort of feedback like it worked so it would really work
- 1:26:23wouldn't it i could send lightning to you and me over a mesh network we would never have to touch
- 1:26:28the internet but you wouldn't be able to validate anything about it that it worked or that it
- 1:26:33actually happened at all and so i think you know for your example there cash is a way better use
- 1:26:38case because cashew is a bearer instrument so like you can give a token to someone and yes they
- 1:26:43don't know there's there's a window there where you could double spend on it because if you ran
- 1:26:47back to the internet and spent that same token before the other person could you know get internet
- 1:26:52and exchange the token have we got time to go into cashew we've been going nearly an hour and a half
- 1:26:56i've got all the time you want right yeah effrat's coming in at half an hour for a friend nice yeah
- 1:27:01yeah right good friend yeah she's great um because i use cashew mini bits yeah i use mini bits once
- 1:27:06again because people that know a lot more than me said this is amazing use this right yeah um
- 1:27:12i didn't realize it was a bearer instrument how does that work so cashew is basically like a
- 1:27:18wildcat bank right like the idea behind the cashew mint is that they're taking in some asset in this
- 1:27:24case bitcoin they are holding that and they're giving you an iou in return effectively um and
- 1:27:31that iou through cryptography is blinded they don't know how much they don't know who they're
- 1:27:36giving it like the bank is totally blind, which is a really great thing, right? They can't do any,
- 1:27:42you know, anything funny with you specifically, because they don't know anything about who they're
- 1:27:46dealing with. They're just like, hey, this is Bitcoin. Yes, this is real. Okay, here's your
- 1:27:50thing. When I see this thing come back to me, I'm going to, I'm going to honor that, right? So that
- 1:27:56when this IOU comes back to me, I'm going to give the Bitcoin out to whoever has it. It doesn't
- 1:27:59matter who has it. And that's, that's kind of what eCash is, right? Like you, it's a blinded
- 1:28:05transaction where it doesn't matter how many times or how many different people that that e-cash token
- 1:28:10that iou moves around in the system once it comes back to be traded from the mint that created it
- 1:28:16um if it's a you know a mint that's acting in good faith they return the bitcoin and burn their iou
- 1:28:22so that's the point you need to be online at the when it comes in and out yes the trade point that
- 1:28:28that point at which you want to melt the e-cash or you know trade it in for you know the actual
- 1:28:33asset underlying it that's the point that you need to connect to so that means from mini bits i could
- 1:28:38spend bitcoin over a mesh network oh yeah and and they've got they've got all the stuff already i
- 1:28:44mean cali was playing with this and putting cashier tokens in uh in bitchat and it works fine you know
- 1:28:49like it pops up in your thing and like yes there's a you know there's a place in there where yeah it's
- 1:28:55custodial this is that that's absolutely incredibly amazing and solves one of the biggest problems i
- 1:29:02i think personally yeah is connection with the internet that's yep and again that's like there
- 1:29:07is a there is a there is a risk in the middle yeah i mean cash is a little bit better in this case
- 1:29:12right because i guess the mint that you're trusting is the actual government so like
- 1:29:16you are more comfortable trusting them than some person on the internet that just happened to set
- 1:29:21up a mint so trust in your mint or spreading your trust across many mints is really important in a
- 1:29:27system like cashew but it gives you other properties that are really really beneficial
- 1:29:31and so when people yell about like oh but it's custodial it's like yes fine but like everything
- 1:29:36is trade-offs right like you are always going to trade something for something else and so
- 1:29:40cashew makes the trade of yes this is custodial but like look at all this cool shit we get
- 1:29:44yeah is this an example of that the meme that we are really early is that going to become some kind
- 1:29:51of standard because i hope well why wouldn't it i mean like this is the dream is being able to
- 1:29:57You cash you on a card and you have NFC tap everywhere and you pay just like you pay with your MasterCard or Visa.
- 1:30:04Like the UX of Visa is incredible.
- 1:30:06You just show up and go ding and you walk away.
- 1:30:09That's it.
- 1:30:09And so if we can get, you know, experiences like that, you know, everybody loves to like go and spend lightning off their own node.
- 1:30:17But like how nice is it to sit there and wait for 12 seconds while Zeus spins and you're like, please work, please work.
- 1:30:23And, you know, like it sucks.
- 1:30:25It's terrible.
- 1:30:25So we need to get to a place where our UX is as good or better than Visa before people are actually going to think this tech is useful.
- 1:30:31But also with Cashew, there's a great privacy angle to that as well.
- 1:30:35I mean, incredible privacy, yeah.
- 1:30:36Because the Mint has no idea who you are.
- 1:30:38And the token that went out just moves around however long in the community before it gets exchanged.
- 1:30:44So, I mean, Cashew, I can see why they called it Cashew now.
- 1:30:47Because it really is very similar to cash.
- 1:30:49It's a bearer asset that you give to someone and you're private, providing Google's not looking at you through a telescope or whatever.
- 1:30:56No one knows.
- 1:30:56This is old tech too, right?
- 1:30:58Like David Chaum came up with this e-cash concept in 82.
- 1:31:01Yeah, Chaumian e-cash.
- 1:31:02And the thing that stopped him was he didn't have a way to do it without having to go through the centralized financial system.
- 1:31:08You know, he almost had it where he had deals with Visa and MasterCard and big banks to use this as kind of the cash that people would use in the digital world.
- 1:31:18and it just kind of fell apart at the last second because the centralized players didn't want it or
- 1:31:23didn't what year was that 2000 well 82 is the first paper 1982 and then you know in the 90s
- 1:31:30he had a company that was trying to do this and it you know just didn't work what was he doing in
- 1:31:342009 i mean david chom's an interesting guy uh uh yeah we can go on but go and look into it i mean
- 1:31:41it's just he's i think david chom was an incredibly intelligent person obviously he came up with
- 1:31:46cash like the whole idea of the scheme is is pretty amazing he came up with this kind of
- 1:31:50blinding scheme for you know and the math behind it i think on the business side i think he overplayed
- 1:31:56his hand in a few cases where you know he tried to get too much and deals fell apart because of that
- 1:32:01um and i think in bitcoin i don't know 100 like what his thoughts on but i think it was like it
- 1:32:08took him a little while to come around to it in the sense that like maybe a sort of not made here
- 1:32:13sort of stance or opinion.
- 1:32:14Derangement syndrome.
- 1:32:15Maybe, I don't know.
- 1:32:16Bitcoin derangement system.
- 1:32:16I think he's pretty into it now,
- 1:32:17but like, you know, I don't know.
- 1:32:19I think it's been used much better
- 1:32:20with the recent Cashew and Fetty
- 1:32:23and things like that
- 1:32:23that are coming back to eCash,
- 1:32:25but through a Bitcoin lens.
- 1:32:26I think we get a lot more.
- 1:32:28So just to get it straight for my listeners,
- 1:32:31going forward,
- 1:32:32if you were to sort of make some suggestions,
- 1:32:37it would be Nostra, obviously.
- 1:32:39It would be Bitcoin,
- 1:32:41but with using a cashier version of Bitcoin would be a good idea.
- 1:32:45Use layers of Bitcoin, right?
- 1:32:46Like I think all of these things, again, comes back to trade-offs.
- 1:32:49Like, you know, you hold your life savings somewhere super, super safe.
- 1:32:52You're not walking around with your life savings constantly.
- 1:32:54You know, you don't like you expect to have a little bit of cash in your wallet.
- 1:32:58And if you get mugged for that little bit of cash, okay, not the end of the world.
- 1:33:01Like, you know, if you get away with your safety, then you're fine.
- 1:33:05And I think that's the way to think about these things as well.
- 1:33:07Like your hardware wallet that's completely disconnected from the internet that holds your life savings doesn't go everywhere with you.
- 1:33:13Your cash wallet does.
- 1:33:14And, you know, maybe the mint rugs you at some point.
- 1:33:17But your money in your cash wallet was even spread across 10 or 20 mints.
- 1:33:20And so it's like nothing.
- 1:33:22It's no big deal.
- 1:33:23You know, it's not life-changing bad for you.
- 1:33:26And so I think, you know, and lightning sits in the middle.
- 1:33:28Lightning is sort of the lingua franca of you know high payments with Bitcoin You know it going to be used by you know the payment settlers all these you know different mints it going to be used by different you know layer two protocols So between Cashew and you know ARK or you know any of those things you going to
- 1:33:45end up with this sort of lightning payments in the middle. And so yeah, for people, I would say,
- 1:33:51you know, yeah, have a lightning wallet, have a Cashew wallet, play with these things,
- 1:33:54you know, do it with a very small amount of money. You know, all of these things are still new tech.
- 1:33:58I mean, I think Lightning is pretty solid at this point, but Cashew is definitely still new.
- 1:34:03But get familiar with them and know which trade-off you're taking and why.
- 1:34:08And also think about it for what application you're using it for.
- 1:34:11And from a privacy standpoint, how would you operate in the world?
- 1:34:14Social media, money, you know, those kind of aspects.
- 1:34:17Yeah.
- 1:34:17I mean, I think just more people need to think about it, right?
- 1:34:20Like I'm doxxed.
- 1:34:21Like I've been on the internet forever.
- 1:34:23I do try to go back regularly and sort of nuke as much as I can, you know, from the past.
- 1:34:27um but what kind of stuff like you mean just the internet's a copy machine though like yeah but
- 1:34:32yeah social media stuff kids right yeah 12 10 and 9 whatever mine are basically the same age and
- 1:34:37it's the same scenario of you know i've explained it's like privacy is a semi one-way door like once
- 1:34:43you go through the door you're not going back and getting it like so what are you telling your kids
- 1:34:47go on then what are you advising one is we i mean we're trying to keep them off of phones for as long
- 1:34:51as possible um how old is your oldest is 12 right mine's pale she has and he doesn't have a smart
- 1:34:57phone and he's killing us over it but like it's like hold the line you know i i was very
- 1:35:03the same for a long time and then i i did i don't know i don't think i'm coping i i because i gave
- 1:35:12her a graphene phone we we operate with signal she has a vpn on there she understands all this
- 1:35:18stuff i figured and i use this as an example you know my wife's email address is hotmail still i
- 1:35:24she's in her 40s and she right okay my bank account is still the hsbc from when i went to
- 1:35:31university at 18 right yes i use vodafone which is 20 i started in the late 90s you know yeah so
- 1:35:38if i start her on graphene proton mail is her email address you know probably it's gonna do well
- 1:35:45that's not the part that matters the part that matters is what what is she posting online and
- 1:35:49where you know what i mean like she's not on social media yeah well actually but there's a
- 1:35:54backdoor social media that's whatsapp yes she's on whatsapp correct in a group and i i she understands
- 1:36:01this now because i said alice that is a social network yeah don't think facebook instagram
- 1:36:06tiktok there's no you're in a group chat there's even you can post what you've been up to today
- 1:36:11it's the same thing but it's but i mean we shouldn't just demonize social media and you
- 1:36:15know blanketly like i think there's there are you know things that are there are redeeming qualities
- 1:36:21about certain social media platforms.
- 1:36:23I think the problem is that like the social media
- 1:36:25that most people look at and think at
- 1:36:26is entirely ad driven.
- 1:36:28And that means you are the product.
- 1:36:29And so that means they will extract
- 1:36:31as much as possible from you in pursuit of that.
- 1:36:34And so to me, it's more helping my kids
- 1:36:37use the right tools, like it sounds like you're doing.
- 1:36:39It's understanding the models
- 1:36:41and like why does a platform want you to be like this?
- 1:36:44And why does this platform have this algorithmic feed
- 1:36:48that its sole job is to keep you there?
- 1:36:51um and if you arm people with those tools and that understanding my hope is that like at least they
- 1:36:56are going in with eyes open and you know you can use these tools to your advantage but just know
- 1:37:01that like just like a knife it's dangerous you know if you use it wrong it's going to cut you
- 1:37:04how long do you think you'll keep your son off smartphone then i think he's probably gonna
- 1:37:0913 is probably where it's i don't think we're going to be able to mine is 13 but she got it at
- 1:37:1512 yeah and i i'd we had well i i had actually in our family liz doesn't care she's not that
- 1:37:21bothered about all this stuff but i had thought because i had i felt the most strongly about it
- 1:37:27it's like no no never and then and everyone said oh but reality is going to hit home and
- 1:37:33the friends are going to do this and blah blah blah and and the one that got me actually in the
- 1:37:36end was the inability to contact me when i was away like right now she's always sending me messages
- 1:37:44all on signal videos this kind of stuff coming through and then you do have to give yourself a
- 1:37:50reality check because it's not all bad and i think people like us we jump straight into the this is
- 1:37:56terrible yes and it is in many ways but it is also not and you can keep your kids away from viruses
- 1:38:03if you want and when they're an adult they'll be they'll get loads and loads of illnesses so
- 1:38:07i'm kind of bringing myself to the middle as fast as i can and i figured this is the best way and
- 1:38:12I agree. I mean, I wholeheartedly agree with that statement. I think, you know, the important thing is, to me at least, is, you know, that my kids are able to take personal responsibility and understand the tradeoffs that they make in certain things. And so like, you want to go on social media, fine. But like, know what you're doing, know what you're getting into, know why you want to do that. Don't just blindly do it because everybody else does it and not think about it. But yeah, there's plenty of amazing things about the internet.
- 1:38:39In my case, we have actually banned her from being on legitimate social media websites.
- 1:38:47But for me, and I've always framed it as when you're old enough, you'll understand why you don't necessarily want your image all over the Internet, basically.
- 1:38:55Sure, it's in WhatsApp chats.
- 1:38:58There's pictures of her in her group chats and stuff.
- 1:39:00But that's the long and short of it.
- 1:39:02And I don't know.
- 1:39:03I'm probably overdoing it because I just don't know because I didn't have that.
- 1:39:08I got on I got a mobile in the late 90s I was a journalist so we used them quite quickly I used
- 1:39:15digital photos early I didn't adopt social media very quickly I remember looking at it thinking
- 1:39:20it was weird and very intrusive yeah you know and and you know but obviously now I do but I use it
- 1:39:27for a business I hardly tweet I tweet business things about the podcast I I've stopped using
- 1:39:32on Facebook, obviously. But if I was going to, it's the most I would want to do is to show
- 1:39:38five people the family photos. We don't need to do that on Facebook. We can do that on a group chat.
- 1:39:43I actually have come full circle. I think I was just eternal tech optimist and loved technology.
- 1:39:48And I was on all the platforms super early. I was still in university when Facebook was launching.
- 1:39:53And so I was in there before most people. I was on Twitter very soon after it launched.
- 1:39:57and for a while it was just like, oh yeah, this is great.
- 1:40:02This is all good.
- 1:40:03Whatever, you can post whatever you want
- 1:40:04and it wasn't until much later that I was like,
- 1:40:07hang on a sec
- 1:40:07and as it started to go darker and darker,
- 1:40:10it was like, okay, what I understood this to be
- 1:40:13is not actually what this is
- 1:40:14and to that one-way door point,
- 1:40:18it's really hard to get rid of stuff on the internet.
- 1:40:20It's a copy machine
- 1:40:21and it's really good at copying things
- 1:40:23and so you can try to delete accounts
- 1:40:25But like, you know, 90% of SaaS startups, when you delete something, it's just a flag in a database that says delete it or not.
- 1:40:32It's still in the database.
- 1:40:33It's still there.
- 1:40:34They still have it.
- 1:40:35So, you know, to anybody in the younger generation, it's really just like, you know, guard it.
- 1:40:41Because once you give it away, it's gone.
- 1:40:43And, you know, be aware of what it actually is and why it is the way it is.
- 1:40:48But I think explaining it like that to kids really works.
- 1:40:51I think so too.
- 1:40:51Because if you say nothing ever gets deleted, it just gets signaled to be not looked at.
- 1:40:57Yeah.
- 1:40:58And then you say, right, you've got a camera in your room looking at you at all times.
- 1:41:02How do you feel about that?
- 1:41:03It's like, I don't want that camera.
- 1:41:05Exactly.
- 1:41:05Right.
- 1:41:05You don't want to do that stuff on the internet.
- 1:41:07Right.
- 1:41:07It's exactly the same thing.
- 1:41:08And they get that.
- 1:41:09Yeah.
- 1:41:10We're private by nature.
- 1:41:12And I really hate this kind of global push to normalize guilt around privacy and stuff.
- 1:41:19Yes, I hate it.
- 1:41:20But I think there's something deeply, deeply disturbing and driven in it. It's very much that we various, you know, interested entities around the world need you to not care about privacy in order to get their way. And you have to really assert it now. And the worst thing is, of course, that as less and less people assert it, you lose your, the people that are asserting it also lose their privacy.
- 1:41:46Exactly.
- 1:41:47Because now we've become targets.
- 1:41:48It's a reverse network effect. Yeah. Yep.
- 1:41:49So, I mean, just comment on that briefly before we go then.
- 1:41:52How do you mitigate that scenario?
- 1:41:56I mean, I think this is a two-pronged thing.
- 1:41:59And it's easy to get blackpilled on privacy because people just don't care.
- 1:42:03They will take convenience every day of the week over maintaining privacy.
- 1:42:08However, I mean, I think we're getting to a shelling point where, you know, the powers that be are pushing things too far, right?
- 1:42:16It will go too far at some point and more and more people will start to pay attention to this.
- 1:42:21I think the other piece is, you know, the younger generations do actually think about this stuff.
- 1:42:27And I think they get, you know, they get the dark half of their experience online pretty quickly.
- 1:42:33And I wonder if we're going to go back towards, you know, less online time.
- 1:42:38You know, people put in like I saw some random video that somebody had posted about, you know, 1985 and like what it was like to grow up in 1985 online.
- 1:42:45And like all these kids were like, is this real?
- 1:42:47Like could this could that actually have been the way things were You know you went over and like hung out with your friends at their house And like you know you had to call on pay phones like they were all in awe that like this could be and this looked so beautiful to them yeah yeah it was like we don go outside we don talk to people face to face
- 1:43:04we don't hang out we don't you know everything has to be pre-programmed and pre you know so i think
- 1:43:09younger the younger generation i think is going to turn faster on this stuff it my my kids are a good
- 1:43:16anecdotal example then because i and i obviously it's us but we have managed to convince them
- 1:43:23that it's uncool to be head in the phone all the time because that's kind of when whenever they hang
- 1:43:30out with someone or if you know my daughter goes on some trip and she's with people she doesn't know
- 1:43:36when we're discussing it afterwards it'll be oh yeah she was just all over you know and she doesn't
- 1:43:42want to associate with that person yes and i don't know whether that one day she might go oh my god
- 1:43:47my mom and dad hoodwinked me or whatever but also we just you know push like we we we push her in
- 1:43:53directions of working outside playing outside right she's a horse rider so we are a great expense
- 1:43:59yeah orchestrated a scenario in which she can ride a horse whenever she wants and all those things
- 1:44:06when you add up make the idea of sitting down and looking at a phone a bad idea yes basically yes
- 1:44:12but it's not a simple thing and i feel deeply for people who who work hey just living imagine
- 1:44:19living in a city in some and not going outside much and having a job that keeps you out of your
- 1:44:25kids lives and blah blah what else is going to happen right right it's it's it's miserable that
- 1:44:31way right and like humans were not made to live like that and um i think we've tried to do the
- 1:44:36exact same thing it's like no go and play like and well you're rock climbers as well so that must
- 1:44:40yeah and we live in a small town so it's super safe and like you know there's all sorts of things
- 1:44:44that you know add up to this and i think this is you know where hopefully you know my idea of the
- 1:44:50promise of the internet was always like you can go anywhere and do anything now like you are not
- 1:44:54constrained by geography anymore and you know i've been working remotely since like 2007 or so 2006
- 1:45:00maybe. And it was so weird for a bunch of years for most people. And now it's become completely
- 1:45:05normal. And, you know, but there's a dark side of that, which is you need to use that to your
- 1:45:10advantage rather than just be like, I can work anywhere. So I'm just going to stay inside and
- 1:45:13work and be on my computer all the time. It's like, no, go somewhere where you actually enjoy
- 1:45:17the place that you get, you know, fulfillment from the things that are around you, interact with the
- 1:45:22people that are around you, you know, and I think that's hard for a lot of people. But at the same
- 1:45:26time like that's where all the contentment and fulfillment happens you know it's in the real world
- 1:45:30and these things fundamentally are just tools like they are tools that are meant to serve us
- 1:45:35not to serve facebook and google and we need to just make that the case amen to that and actually
- 1:45:41we never got to talk about this but it doesn't matter that could happen another time but
- 1:45:44what you're describing is basically where our foundation what we do is all about i think you
- 1:45:51are in the business of dealing with digital freedom and i think we're in the business of
- 1:45:56trying to it's much harder it's much more messier way messier yeah dealing with physical freedom and
- 1:46:01yeah but they are very highly connected as we can see and we'll get more and more intricately
- 1:46:07connected as we go on so yeah absolutely um i was gonna say many thanks for um well number one doing
- 1:46:14what you're doing i think anyone who's doing open source tools for freedom lovers are on my christmas
- 1:46:20list every year they're great people um so thanks for that but also thanks for you know i've never
- 1:46:25met you before i just sent you a message on nostril and said will you come sit down with me and talk
- 1:46:30and you went sure yeah so i love talking about stuff like this talking shop is is great fun uh
- 1:46:34so it's uh i appreciate it right well great anyway and then yeah please please i'd love to reconnect
- 1:46:40in an amount of time in the future next time we run physically in just to see how it's going but
- 1:46:47yeah just for everyone it's it's white noise and it's a nostor thing so you've got to be
- 1:46:52you've got to kind of yeah you can check out the site is just white noise.chat is the website and
- 1:46:57we've got a little bit of information there and you can you know points you to download links and
- 1:47:00things like that um you know if you're not on nostor i would say just uh download primal as
- 1:47:05a starting point it's a great ux to get started you know you create a key pair the app does it for
- 1:47:10you you know if you want to it's got a built-in lightning wallet you can set up really quickly
- 1:47:14for zaps and you know that sort of thing um and just play around like i've heard so many people
- 1:47:19say this is the you know first experience with social media that actually felt like wholesome
- 1:47:24and positive rather than draining and soul destroying like a guy a guy on the panel we
- 1:47:29were doing at baltic honeybeger the other day had a question but he first started out by saying
- 1:47:34thank you all nostr is the only thing that supports my mental health rather than destroys it
- 1:47:38That's like amazing.
- 1:47:39It's the good mornings that I like, obviously.
- 1:47:42One of the redeeming factors.
- 1:47:44Everyone says good morning.
- 1:47:45Yeah, yeah.
- 1:47:45But it is.
- 1:47:46It's like 1950s digital realm, isn't it?
- 1:47:48It feels like that, yeah.
- 1:47:50So it feels great.
- 1:47:51I'm sure the spammers and the scammers and everybody else will show up eventually.
- 1:47:55But for now, it feels like you're somewhere.
- 1:47:57It feels like you're on the internet in 1994.
- 1:47:58But hopefully, you would posit that by the time the scammers turn up, because of your ability on NOS to really tailor make your experience,
- 1:48:08experience yes you should be good for that i mean obviously there's going to be you're going to come
- 1:48:12up against some things but you should be good because the algorithm is completely within your
- 1:48:17within your sphere of control absolutely 100 and like the web of trust aspect that you know we know
- 1:48:23you know from a research point of view webs of trust work really well and it's how our brains
- 1:48:27function when we operate in the real world like do i know this person through someone else how
- 1:48:31much can i trust them um we haven't built out the digital systems to make that work really well yet
- 1:48:37But I think that's part of what Nostra gives us is the ability to really kind of map that analog into the digital world.
- 1:48:45So that, yeah, go ahead, spammers, like have at it.
- 1:48:47Like we don't have to look at it.
- 1:48:48We'll never see it.
- 1:48:49We'll never know.
- 1:48:49It's so exciting.
- 1:48:50I'm so glad I spoke to you this morning because you're right.
- 1:48:54You can get a bit blackbilled about all this stuff.
- 1:48:55But actually, it's so exciting because a lot of things are arising right now, which are very much digital representations of really fundamental old school cultural things that we do.
- 1:49:10Like exactly what you've just described.
- 1:49:12I've never heard anyone describe Nostum like that.
- 1:49:14I know there's the identity part is really important, but you're absolutely right.
- 1:49:18Yeah.
- 1:49:18You know, I knew you because of Max and I trust Max implicitly and I know he wouldn't be mates with you if you were a douchebag, you know.
- 1:49:27Totally.
- 1:49:27There is no way of working that out.
- 1:49:29Right.
- 1:49:30You're absolutely right.
- 1:49:31Right, right.
- 1:49:32And it's kind of interesting that the only decentralized social network, you know, decentralized system that's actually not a social network, Nostra, it's a generic publishing thing.
- 1:49:40But we're sort of, you know, bootstrapping the network by shitposting, you know, like Matt O'Dell always says.
- 1:49:46We are getting to that network effect of knowing who's who by virtue of a bunch of people just posting GM and sending random stuff in a Twitter-like scenario.
- 1:49:57And a lot of other things, like PGP failed because they really couldn't build a network effect around it.
- 1:50:03So having multiple modes to do that means that the entire network is better.
- 1:50:09Any business that comes and builds on Nostra immediately has the entire user base at their disposal.
- 1:50:14and every new business or new user or everything supports everything.
- 1:50:18So it's like a network effect of network effects.
- 1:50:20So I think it's probably the only thing that's in it, you know,
- 1:50:24that has a real chance of functioning.
- 1:50:26And also it's very useful in the sense that if you, a lot of apps now,
- 1:50:32if you want to download a new app on Noster,
- 1:50:35it'll say who out of your friend group already has.
- 1:50:38That's brilliant.
- 1:50:39ZapStore is the quintessential example of how cool Noster can be.
- 1:50:43You can develop an app, you can sign it so that everybody knows that like, hey, me, the person that you're talking to over here is the developer and I've signed this app cryptographically.
- 1:50:53And it's the same thing on the same, you know, on the server.
- 1:50:56And you just freely download it without having to enter any KYC, anything.
- 1:50:59And it shows you that, oh, these mates of yours have already downloaded it.
- 1:51:03I've already downloaded it.
- 1:51:03Cool.
- 1:51:04So I know I'm on the right version and not some scam version.
- 1:51:06Exactly.
- 1:51:07Yeah, yeah. So there's like a million ways where this web of trust, this network, this kind of open publishing system means that we get the possibility of building a brand new internet that's like fully open. Yes. We hope, we hope. Long road though, it's a really long road.
- 1:51:22Yeah, but you say we hope. It's already here. Like we're using it.
- 1:51:26That's true.
- 1:51:26I'm using Nostra every day, much more than Twitter.
- 1:51:28Yeah.
- 1:51:29It's weird that like this morning when I went to message you on Nostra, none of our messages were there. And then like 20 minutes later, they popped up. Yeah, that's weird and annoying, but I'm still using it.
- 1:51:39It's early, but it does work. Yeah, most of the time.
- 1:51:42anyway Jeff
- 1:51:43many many many
- 1:51:44many thanks indeed
- 1:51:45for coming
- 1:51:45and this has been awesome
- 1:51:47I'm really happy
- 1:51:47I really have
- 1:51:48got wrapped my head
- 1:51:50around some important
- 1:51:51concepts here
- 1:51:52so many thanks for coming
- 1:51:53thank you for the invite
- 1:51:54it's been super enjoyable
- 1:51:55I'll see you next time
- 1:51:55yeah thanks
- 1:52:12Thank you.