Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Tuesday, August 15, 2023
Transcript
- 0:23Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. Decision
- 0:28You are surrounded. We list round Radio turned on from the studios of w
- 0:38VRC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes
- 0:43the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this he is Metro News
- 0:49Talk Live with a Hobby Kirchick activated switch networking chill from Arles Stand Bye you
- 0:57Happy You're on Metro News talk Line with Hobby kirch of Aliz brought to you
- 1:03buy in COVID Insurance and circling you with coverage to protect what you care about
- 1:07most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more. Good Morning. Ethan Coffins
- 1:11is our producer, Jack Carlson, with a video stream you can watch at
- 1:15wv metronews dot com. The phone numbers one eight hundred seven six five eight
- 1:19two five five, text me three or four, Talk three or four.
- 1:22Yes, we'll get to the fourth indictment of Donald Trump and more later on,
- 1:26but I want to start this morning with what's going on at w VU
- 1:30with the planned cutback of what will amount to one hundred sixty nine faculty members
- 1:41of eliminating what is it thirty two majors at the university, thirty two of
- 1:46three hundred and thirty eight majors, one hundred sixty nine faculty positions. I
- 1:49want to start there and we head on yesterday Lisa Professor Lisa de Bartlomeo from
- 1:55Foreign Languages, which is targeted for elimination, and also WWU President Gordon Gee,
- 1:59who was driving these changes at the university, and I want to make
- 2:02a couple of points about it and get your take at one hundred and seven
- 2:06six five eight two five five or text me three or four, talk three
- 2:08or four. First is a very personal one. That is I came to
- 2:15the university in nineteen seventy four, long time ago, and just as a
- 2:20country kid who hadn't betten very many places and didn't have many worldly experiences,
- 2:25came to w VU and it was it opened my eyes to the world.
- 2:30It was a great avenue for me and it was life changing and one of
- 2:37the great opportunity, one of the great advantages was there there were so many
- 2:42opportunities at w VU. If I wanted to, I could have studied foreign
- 2:46languages. I could have studied art and ceramics at the SAC. I could
- 2:52have done any number of things because of the hundreds of options available along with
- 2:58the different clubs and organization. As it turned out, I ended up going
- 3:01to the journalism school and studying journalism and working at the daily at the name,
- 3:05so so everything worked out. But but I appreciate, I always appreciated
- 3:10the broad mission of the flagship university of the state and the fact that as
- 3:15a state resident, it was pretty affordable for me, and that has always
- 3:20been very important to me. So that gives me pause then when I consider
- 3:28the proposals that are being made by WVU on these cuts. But I also
- 3:32have to find some reasonableness here and some balance. And let me start with
- 3:38a couple of points. One is the criticism that WVU should have done more
- 3:45sooner, and that's a fair criticism, because this is the university could have
- 3:53perhaps seen the demographic shift earlier. It was overly aspiration, perhaps by Gordon
- 4:00Gay to say in twenty fourteen that there will be forty thousand students over the
- 4:03next ten years. Those kinds of things were again not on target and perhaps
- 4:12too aspirational. You could not have you could not have foreseen though the pandemic
- 4:18and the result of the pandemic not only in students not going to college,
- 4:25but also the dropout rate. The dropout rate increased significantly. The retention rate
- 4:30was a problem at WVU, but also so so WVU. Could they have
- 4:38done more sooner? Yes, yes they could have. But also if they
- 4:42had done more sooner, what would that have looked like? If you're going,
- 4:46if you're anticipating budget deficits and you could do more sooner, that would
- 4:51still look like reductions and cutbacks and changes, that would still look like a
- 4:59reduced see spending in certain areas. Second point, are the cuts being evenly
- 5:05distributed? Again a fair question. I did some checking on this. Since
- 5:11twenty fifteen, the number of non faculty positions non faculty positions at WVU since
- 5:15twenty fifteen is down five hundred, five hundred So to my knowledge, these
- 5:23one hundred and sixty nine faculty cuts are the first time, and I'll staying
- 5:29corrected if I'm wrong, the first time there have been significant faculty reductions.
- 5:33But over the last seven years there have been five hundred, five hundred nine
- 5:38to be exact, reductions in non faculty positions, and there have been and
- 5:45I'm trying to gather data on this. There have been some eliminations and consolidations
- 5:49in administration, whether Stewart Hall or in Health Sciences. In some cases someone
- 5:56left and the responsibilities were put onto somebody else. I think there have been
- 6:00a couple of positions eliminated, and again in Health Sciences and in Stewart Hall.
- 6:03I don't know the numbers there, but it's not as though the bureaucracy
- 6:10of the highest positions has grown while this deficit was starting to appear. It's
- 6:16my understanding, and here's a legitimate question, why with this deficit is it
- 6:24just academics it's facing scrutiny. There is also an ongoing review of non faculty
- 6:31positions, and I think it's by the same consulting firm that has looked at
- 6:36the faculty positions and at the programs, and the goal there is to find
- 6:43out, given the size and mission of the university, is the university right
- 6:49sized when it comes to those non faculty positions, or do you have does
- 6:55the university have too many? So that area is also being scrutinized by and
- 7:01again I believe it's the same consulting firm that looked at the faculty and academic
- 7:08classes. And there will be a results and recommendations coming on that. So
- 7:14there's a right size that's coming there as well. Top administration salaries, and
- 7:20this is always an issue whenever their cutbacks. Why is he Gordon Gay making
- 7:25eight hundred thousand dollars? Why is Rob also making what he's making. I
- 7:29think it's four hundred thousand or three hundred thousand or something like that. Why
- 7:32is Mary and Reid making what she's making? And that is I mean,
- 7:36that's fair, that's fair, especially when Gee makes more than other college presidents
- 7:42in the Big twelve. One can argue that he has more experience than the
- 7:46other college presidents. But I get that, I get that. I do
- 7:50think that under closer scrutiny, and I don't know the details exactly here,
- 7:56but I think that Ge does return some money to the university. I think
- 8:00in the six figure category, I think all subset at the faculty meeting,
- 8:03he's doing some of that too. But look that that's a natural. If
- 8:07you are well paid, you have to expect. So if you're Ge or
- 8:11alsopper read, if you are well compensated, you have to expect that when
- 8:16there are cutbacks that you are going you and your salary are going to get
- 8:20cited by those who don't like the cutbacks that are being made, So that's
- 8:24that just goes with the turf. And if you're paid very well and you're
- 8:28in a position of making making critical decisions, you just got to expect that
- 8:33you're going to get that, So that goes with the turf. I also
- 8:37understand that that talk of reductions or cost savings in the academic areas is not
- 8:48new, that this these kinds of conversations have been going on for a while,
- 8:54and now it's now it's being taken very seriously. So there is a
- 9:01suggestion, at least on the part of the administration that, look, we've
- 9:05been talking about this for a while, and have deans and heads of schools
- 9:09taken this seriously? What about more money from the state. This comes up
- 9:15a lot too. Well. Marshall's getting forty five million dollars, Pure Pod
- 9:18Community Technicals getting twenty five million dollars. The cancer center at ww you got
- 9:22fifty million dollars. Here's here's something to think about there. This legislature is
- 9:31the votes are not there, the support is not there for allocating more money.
- 9:41A substantial amount of additional money to WVU or Marshall or any other school
- 9:48to meet structural deficits. That's just not that's just not going to happen now,
- 9:54because the legislature is they're trying. The legislatures just that's not what they're
- 10:01going to do. What they will do, and what they have done,
- 10:03is put money in what they consider to be investments. They're going to invest
- 10:07in the cancer Center, They're going to invest in Marshall cybersecurity System, They're
- 10:11gonna invest in Pierre Ponds Community Technical College because they think those are good investments
- 10:16where there's returns on investment. But they're not going to allocate money to schools,
- 10:22in this case WVU to meet their budget, to meet their payroll not
- 10:26gonna happen unless and until w V or any other school does more to get
- 10:31their own financial house in order. So that is a that's just a non
- 10:35starter. Also, the money from the surplus is one time money, and
- 10:41if you talk about sustaining salaries, that's an ongoing expense. The areas that
- 10:50are targeted our areas that according to the university, have seen a drop in
- 10:56enrollment and the university and I think this is a defensible position. The university
- 11:03is repositioning itself to put resources toward areas where there's more enrollment, to take
- 11:11resources away from areas that have declining enrollment. Maybe they don't have substantial research
- 11:18investments, and that's the direction layer headed. And I wonder this. I
- 11:24don't know this, but I wonder this. I wonder if there are because
- 11:28most of what's coming out now is criticism from members of the faculty who object
- 11:31to what's going on. And I get that. I wonder if there are
- 11:35not any deans or faculty members in certain areas of university who are actually in
- 11:43support of this because they believe that there should be more resources in their area
- 11:48and less in areas that have declining enrollment, but they don't want to say
- 11:52it because they don't want to be chastise or ghosted by their colleagues. So
- 12:03and finally, when you're when you're faced with a deficit, there are only
- 12:07a couple of options. I got a text yesterday somebody said, well,
- 12:09what about all the other options? What are the other options? And let's
- 12:13say it's a fair criticism that the university should have been on this early year.
- 12:18You could have done other things. It could have been a softer landing.
- 12:20Okay, let's say that that's fair, because it probably is fair.
- 12:24Probably is fair. But now here's where you are. So then what are
- 12:28your options when you have a deficit? What are they? And you're not
- 12:33going to get any additional money from the state, Well, you can try
- 12:35to get more money from students. Well, you're already pricing students out out
- 12:39of the market, so you can't. I know, there's a small increase
- 12:41in tuition. You can't go out and have a big increase in tuition.
- 12:46You have to cut expenses. You have to cut expenses. And that's that's
- 12:50what they're doing. And also, I gotta tell you coming and and I've
- 12:56been I'm influenced by in lifetime in the private sector because those of you in
- 13:01the private sector know this. This happens all the time. Now we look
- 13:05at universities and colleges differently. I get that. I get that, and
- 13:09it's not completely analogous higher education and the business sector. I get that.
- 13:13But also businesses have to do this. Our company has to do everybody has
- 13:18to do this. You have to adjust, you have to pivot, you
- 13:20have to reposition, and sometimes you have to make tough decisions that leads to
- 13:24people losing their jobs. That's harsh, that's painful, that's reality. Take
- 13:31a break. Talk line continues will return in just a moment. Are you
- 13:33tired of joint pain or muscle injuries holding you back? Trust the experts at
- 13:37CMC Orthopedics and CMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized treatment options tailored to your needs.
- 13:45CMC offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types of pain and injuries. Our specialists
- 13:50provide tailored options from diagnosis to rehab with state of the art facilities for top
- 13:56quality care. Visit CMC dot org slash Orthopedic to learn more. Metro News
- 14:13talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling
- 14:18you with coverage to protect what do you care about most? Visitingcovid dot com
- 14:22to learn more. Talk line from me and COVID Insurance Studios. Let's go
- 14:24to Ryan Schmells Fox News Radio, a fourth in ditment against Donald Trump and
- 14:28more. Ryan, Good morning. What do you have on this? Hey,
- 14:31good morning, hoppies. So we're looking at a ninety seven page indictment
- 14:35containing forty one felony counts against Trump and eighteen defendants, and that alleges that
- 14:39they unlawfully conspired and endeavored to conduct and participate in a criminal enterprise in Fulton
- 14:46County, Georgia and elsewhere. And keep mind that word criminal enterprise because that's
- 14:50kind of playing into one of the charges in here, which claims that many
- 14:56of these defendants violated what they call the Rico Act, which is, you
- 15:00usually something that's used on mobsters, but in this case, the DA in
- 15:05this case, which is Stanny Willis, believes that they participated in a criminal
- 15:09enterprise to try to overturn the twenty twenty election results. Yeah, the allegation
- 15:13is it was a conspiracy which violated the Rico which a state law, a
- 15:18state law in Georgia, not a federal law. Correct, that's correct.
- 15:20Yes, And a lot of different states do have some type of Rico law.
- 15:24Pretty much when the Supreme Court allowed it to take effect, a lot
- 15:26of states adopted their own version of it, and Georgia certainly has its own
- 15:31right now. And Ryan, some of the pushback on this, there's a
- 15:33couple. One is obviously from Trump supporters like okay, yet again, two
- 15:39tier justice system Trump will raise more money on this. Russia, Russia,
- 15:43Russia, I mean all these things, but also but also some suggestion that
- 15:46wait a minute, the federady looking into these things. Can you charge can
- 15:52you have state charges and federal charges for kind of the same thing. Well,
- 15:58I certainly believe that it's a possibility. It looks like it is there
- 16:00are able to do it, if in fact they are in different jurisdictions.
- 16:03Now, of course, I do think there will be likely some evidence that
- 16:07may overlap with the Jack Smith's indictment as well as this one involving da Willis,
- 16:14So I wouldn't rule that out, but I do think they are pretty
- 16:17separate, considering that this one's probably hyperlocal to Georgia. All Right, Ryan
- 16:19Schmillis Fox News Radio on the new indictment is Donald Trump. Thanks Ryan,
- 16:22good to talk to you and appreciate it. Text copy This is a text.
- 16:27In my view, the nature of high education is changing. I'm sad
- 16:30for WVU, but the market is moving toward educational partnerships. Business want young
- 16:34folks to start working after high school to develop the work ethic. Once proven,
- 16:40the company will offer higher education and promotion potential to keep those higher quality
- 16:44folks. More and more companies are partnering with colleges to offer targeted degree programs
- 16:48for the current job markets. The dream of college after high schools an old,
- 16:52antiquated idea reserve for the wealthy or those willing to put half their life
- 16:59in debt. That's a that's an interesting and I think valid point, and
- 17:03that's part of what has contributed to the decline enrollment, not at every school,
- 17:07but at many schools. And of course WVU Marshall facing the same thing.
- 17:11Their enrollment is down. And as I've said previously, I think that
- 17:15a higher ed got was guilty of hubris that it thought there would always be
- 17:22more students, They could always charge more money, they could always build more
- 17:26buildings, that students wanted this lifestyle, so there would be these rec centers
- 17:32and all these things, and and big sports programs. And by the way,
- 17:37the wv Athlay Department is self self sustaining, so it has a separate
- 17:42as a separate budget, is not supported directly by the university. So yeah,
- 17:48you know, I get that, and then us reality kicked in.
- 17:52Reality was, as you said, there were people coming out of high school.
- 17:55They could get pretty good jobs without going to college, and the student
- 17:59debt issue hit where a lot of young people just said, I'm not gonna
- 18:00do it. I'm not gonna I'm not gonna come out of school with one
- 18:03hundred thousand dollars in debt, and so that tempered going to college. COVID
- 18:11was a black Swan event that kept people home, that affected retention. So
- 18:18a combination of factors along with the demographics. Demographics, there's not as many,
- 18:23you know, the growth and population not what was expected. Hoppy,
- 18:33let's see, I'm wondering why there's not a place I was able to access
- 18:37and find out how many millions are used for d EI and similar programs,
- 18:41new programs available how to be in Anti racist sixteen nineteen project that look,
- 18:48WVU they have they deal with diversity. They have a diversity program at WVU,
- 18:55like every institution does. But to my knowledge, w VU is not
- 19:03doesn't have is not headed in a particular direction that some of you would considered
- 19:10woke that would discourage students from attending. I do not think any of that
- 19:15is a factor in the decline and enrollment. Tech spy, w you needs
- 19:19to take care of business. They're supposed to be the best in the state.
- 19:23They may have to reconsider their student growth plan less emphasis on programs and
- 19:27other colleges can provide because that hurts the smaller colleges WV. You should focus
- 19:32on what it does best. It may lead to a smaller college in my
- 19:37opinion, says the texture hobby. Can you list the majors being cut?
- 19:41Please? It's thirty two. I can't list them all there there. There
- 19:45might be a link in our story on our website w VU if you go
- 19:51to their website. I think there's a link to it. But they're they're
- 19:55out there. They're out there, hoppy. But those of us who've been
- 20:00in the private sector also no. You can cut an extreme. You can
- 20:04expense. Cut an expense only once. Then you have to focus on revenue.
- 20:10All right, we'll take a break of me back. This is talk
- 20:11Line on Revenue or talk Line on Metric. Is the voice of West Virginia.
- 20:33Talk line for me and COVID Insurance Studios. Jack Potson, the millions
- 20:36here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Get in
- 20:37the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega m Against drawings Tuesdays
- 20:42and Fridays. Will you be the next Big Winner? Play today? The
- 20:45bibeball Jack Pott is two hundred thirty six million dollars. The Mega megis Jack
- 20:48Pott is thirty six million dollars. Text three or four Talk three or four
- 20:52hoppy. I suppose if these cuts help resolve the issue, the ends justify
- 20:56the means. But I don't have to like it. That it's true.
- 21:00Of course, that's true. Nobody has to like it. Nobody should like
- 21:03it. It's painful. These are painful things. I don't think anybody takes
- 21:07any joy in this. I know nobody would take any joy in this.
- 21:12And those of you out there who are in the private sector, who are
- 21:21in business or bien in business, you know what it's like. You don't
- 21:23want you don't take any joy in laying people off or eliminating positions. How
- 21:27many times did you do that during the during the pandemic, And it's painful.
- 21:33You know these people, you know their families, and but sometimes you
- 21:38don't have many options. You don't have many options. And when you have
- 21:44a business or in institution where your biggest cost is people, that's where the
- 21:52money is. That's how you save the most amount of money is by eliminating
- 21:56salaries. And that's that's that's an annual savings because then you don't have that
- 22:03payroll every year. So yeah, who likes it? Nobody? Three or
- 22:12four talk three or four. Happy If mister mister Kirchivill, if Biden was
- 22:18a real leader and cared about the country, he'd pardon his son and Trump
- 22:22and announced he wasn't running in twenty twenty four. Ah happy, Please clarify,
- 22:33as Governor Justice signed the bill that allows the half refund on the personal
- 22:37property tax on vehicles for people who pay in full. I don't think he's
- 22:41signed that yet, but unless there's a technical issue, he will. And
- 22:48that will mean that when you get your tax, your personal property tax bill
- 22:52now for your vehicle, if you choose or you've already chosen to pay in
- 23:00full, to pay in full, you will be able to claim You'll be
- 23:04able to claim half of that the twenty twenty four half half of that on
- 23:11your twenty twenty four taxes. Don't think he's signed it yet, but he
- 23:15will unless there is a some sort of technical issue with it. I'll be
- 23:22the University of Southern New Hampshire as one hundred thousand students. Why does in
- 23:26WW go national advertising. I don't know that. I don't know anything about
- 23:33I see that advertised too. I'm not sure. Well, I could say
- 23:40a couple of things. I don't know much about that school. I'll be
- 23:45the federal government is the blame. Is to blame for the higher increase in
- 23:48prices for college education. Federal subsidized student loans enabled universities to increase their tuition
- 23:53prices. The more the institution raise their prices, the higher the amount of
- 23:57student loans increased. Once again, the federal screwing things up. Well that
- 24:00this student debt thing is awful. I don't think that it makes sense to
- 24:08just forgive the loans to students who've graduated. But yeah, this a lot
- 24:18of a lot of money available. Oh, you can get loans, don't
- 24:22worry about you can get loans, get these big loans, and then you
- 24:25come out of school with this massive debt. It's it's a it's a burden.
- 24:32I think that, And I'm pretty sure. I'm pretty sure that a
- 24:40student from West Virginia High school, student from West Virginia who wants to go
- 24:48to w VU or Marshall or Concord or Shepherd or wherever. I'm not gonna
- 24:56name them all. And you go to that school because these schools they need
- 25:02enrollment. And you say, look, I got pretty good grades, I
- 25:06got the promised scholarship. I need some additional help. What can you do
- 25:10for me? And put them on the line, Put them on the line
- 25:12and say and see what they do well and give you a big one.
- 25:15Well alone. What about scholarships? What about grants? What about work study?
- 25:21What about just a break? And put them put it on them to
- 25:25help you be able to afford to go to college. Hoppy, I'm sure
- 25:33you know this not just tuition. It significantly adds to the cost of colleges
- 25:37off in room and board and go do we double the cost If people can
- 25:40get a degree from home and remove the room and board, many of them
- 25:41will. That happened. That's happened too, and that was COVID too,
- 25:47where young people realize, you know, I can do this from home.
- 25:52I don't need to go and maybe they don't want to go to a brick
- 25:55and mortar. They can do this from home, they can do it on
- 25:59their computer. They can save money. Hype the whole Trump indictment is a
- 26:06continuation of Russia, Russia, Russia by the Democrats. The DOJ has been
- 26:10politicized, and they fought tooth and nail not to release information requested in the
- 26:14Hunter Biden investigation. The whole system is corrupt. There. The the indictment
- 26:21in Georgia has strong political overtones because she's a Democrat, and because of the
- 26:29way it was handed down, I mean came down last night. It's like
- 26:32there was a sense of urgency last night to get it out, and a
- 26:36lot of the allegations are similar to what the federal indictment is. So yeah,
- 26:42I mean, there's there's going to be some legitimate criticism about the political
- 26:45overtones. However, However, a lot of the indictment includes things we already
- 26:52knew about the attempts by Donald Trump and his entourage to overturn the results of
- 27:02the election in Georgia that's already in many cases has been documented. Find the
- 27:08eleven thousand, seven hundred votes, going to a county courthouse and seizing the
- 27:14voting machines, trying to intimidate vote counters, harassing somebody who want somebody who's
- 27:22a woman who's working the election, saying well she was passing what was it
- 27:27passing something to somebody else? It turned out to be a mint. I
- 27:30mean all these things. I think there was tremendous pressure, undo pressure on
- 27:36Georgia officials to change the outcome of the election. Happy. My daughter got
- 27:42caught up in the college illusion eight years ago, so she now has a
- 27:45degree in psychology and his twenty one thousand dollars in debt, working part time
- 27:48in retail. I'm hesitant to send my son to Fairmont next week, but
- 27:52he did receive some scholarships and is going into civil engineering. Hopefully that will
- 27:56provide him with a job when he graduates, but unfortunately in four years.
- 28:02I am a firm believer in young people being able to make decisions about what
- 28:10they want to do in life, what they want to study, what they
- 28:15want their careers to be. But those same students must go into that with
- 28:22a sober realization of what the jobs are, of what the jobs are.
- 28:30So the world the country needs psychologists, I'm certain of that, but what's
- 28:37the job market for psychologists? No offense to psychologists, but what's the job
- 28:41market for that? You know, the country needs people who are museum curators.
- 28:48I understand that, but what is the job market for that now?
- 28:51You may still want to pursue that, and that's fine, that's fine,
- 28:55that's up to you, but there is not all the job market is a
- 29:00great equal as they're not. All these jobs are created equal. And you
- 29:06may have your heart set on being a museum curator, more power to you.
- 29:11But if you have a degree in curating museums and you have a degree
- 29:18in cybersecurity, job market is going to be different. That's just the reality.
- 29:25It's just a reality. And perhaps I don't know because I haven't talked
- 29:30to a guidance counsel in years. Perhaps guidance counselors need to do a better
- 29:33job of telling young people, Hey, good for you, you can study
- 29:37that. But I want you to understand something. Here's some information on what
- 29:40the job market is right now. I'll be the budget issues at WB You've
- 29:45been around for some time now. I have a question, did any of
- 29:48the departments that are being impacted do any recruiting of students to fill the seats
- 29:52in their classrooms? I don't. I don't know. I don't know that
- 29:56it's a fair question. Don't know, I don't know. Hoppy' about the
- 30:07Chronicle of Higher Ugation article on wv's problems. A lot of food for thought.
- 30:10Yeah, that was a really comprehensive article. I read it twice yesterday.
- 30:14A very detailed piece in the Chronicle concerning wvu's situation, and a lot
- 30:19of good detail in there. In fact, I have tried to get the
- 30:25reporter who wrote that article on my show, emailed them a couple of times.
- 30:29Haven't heard back. All right, we'll take a break and be back.
- 30:30Are you ready to start your career? The path to employment can sometimes
- 30:34feel overwhelming. Workforce West Virginia is there to guide you every step of the
- 30:40way. We understand the challenges you face. Where to begin, how to
- 30:41stand out from the crowd, finding the right opportunity. With Workforce West Virginia,
- 30:47you can access resources, personalized guidance, find hidden opportunities, discover apprenticeship
- 30:52programs and virtual job fairs. Tayword to your interests. When you're ready to
- 30:56start your career, start with Workforce West Virginia. Visit Workforce wv dot org
- 31:02to learn more. This outreach campaign is financed by federal dollars. Metro News
- 31:19talk Line with Hobby kirchibilas brought to you by in Coca Insurance, encircling you
- 31:25with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visitingcovid dot com to learn
- 31:29talk on COVID sre studios, jackpotts in the millions here in West Virginia.
- 31:32Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Get in the powerball drawings Mondays,
- 31:34Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Megamens drawings Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the
- 31:38next big Winter Plate? Today? The powerball jackpot is two hundred and thirty
- 31:42six million dollars, the Megamens jackpot thirty six million dollars. So Martinsburg has
- 31:48an issue that a lot of communities struggle with, and that is you want
- 31:52to take care communities want to take care of the homeless. You want to
- 31:56feed people who are in dire stra But how much of these services do you
- 32:04want to provide and where do you want to provide? The Martinsberok City Council
- 32:07now has rejected the extension of a permit to continue a feeding program in downtown
- 32:15Martinsburg. Marsha Kavalik from the Panhandled News Network and WEP and Martinsburg joins a
- 32:20Marshall. Good morning, So what's this story all about? Good morning.
- 32:23As you mentioned, it is a common theme around cities, that balancing act
- 32:28between serving folks who habit to find themselves homeless and creating a quality of life
- 32:34for visitors and property owners. As you mentioned, on Thursday nights City council
- 32:37meeting agenda whether or not they could approve or deny a special event permit for
- 32:42Sanctified Street Ministries homeless feeding and church service, which would have happened every Thursday
- 32:47through December twenty eight. That was denied after a discussion among the council members,
- 32:54particularly Fourth Wards City Councilwoman Kimberly Nelson, who said the city wants to
- 33:00help the homeless, but they're considering the rights of property and business owners.
- 33:05Our Clint Gage was out at that meeting and said that there had been off
- 33:07the record business owners who had talked about some of the visitors to these feeding
- 33:14programs urinating around the public properties and otherwise just not respecting other people's property rights.
- 33:22So that's the conundrum, Marsha that many communities face, and that is
- 33:25okay, yes, help the homeless, but they were doing this in downtown
- 33:29Martinsburg and then the business owners and say, well, this is really this
- 33:32really affects affects business and affects the downtown, and I guess council just finally
- 33:40decided, you know, we can't can't do this anymore. Is that what
- 33:44they decided? So, uh, you know, obviously this was one group
- 33:49that wanted to provide there are other groups that do also provide meals to the
- 33:53homeless and services. One of the local feeding free organizations provides lockers for some
- 34:01of the homeless as well. I'm not sure if this is going to be
- 34:05something that will be reconsidered as each of these groups come up with you their
- 34:10applications to do service in the city. But one of the aspects that Councilwoman
- 34:16Nelson brought up was the fact that a few blocks away is the Martinsburg Union
- 34:21Rescue Mission, which is going to have hopes to open a family shelter,
- 34:25the six or four Project and a women's shelter in Morgan County by November.
- 34:31Already, the Martinsburg Union Rescue Mission in July housed folks for fifteen hundred and
- 34:38three folks lodging for their men's service, and they served more than eighty five
- 34:45hundred meals during last month alone. Marshall Cavali from the Panhandled News Network and
- 34:50w Epman Martinsburg. Thanks Marshall, good to talk to you. Appreciate it.
- 34:53This is not this is in the same genre, I mean the genre.
- 35:00This is in the same universe, but not exactly the same thing.
- 35:02And I know I've talked about this some and that is the substance abuse issue,
- 35:07and I don't know what to do. We are at a My location
- 35:15in Morgantown is right on Spruce Street downtown and there's a I've talked about this
- 35:21before. There's a walkway beside our building and it's kind of isolated, and
- 35:24it goes down to an area where a lot of people who have substance abuse
- 35:30issues, a lot of them traffic and every day and I'm not exaggerating now
- 35:35it used to be every couple of weeks. It used to be a couple
- 35:37of times a week, and ounce every day. There are people who gather
- 35:40there and they inject drugs, they smoke whatever it is, whether it's meth
- 35:45or or you know, heroin or crack or I don't know. I don't
- 35:51know what it is, but it's happening all the time, and this morning.
- 35:58So when I when I get here in the morning early, I usually
- 36:00go out and look because I can see, you know, what's going on
- 36:02out there. And there is a young woman and she's smoking something and you
- 36:08know, got the tinfoil out, got the lighter out, lighting it up,
- 36:12smoking it and okay, all right, And I mean, I don't
- 36:17consider that a threat to me. I mean, I'm safe inside the building.
- 36:21She doesn't seem like a threat except to herself. And then I come
- 36:23back later, you know, twenty minutes later, and I see and she's
- 36:27just nodding. She's just nodding off. She's sitting there and you've seen it,
- 36:30you've seen it in your town. People are extremely high. And she's
- 36:34just nodding off. She's leaning over and leaning over, leaning over, leaning
- 36:37over till she almost falls over. Then she kind of sits up a little
- 36:39bit and leaning over, leaning over and leaning over. And I'm thinking,
- 36:44and I'm not, I'm not. I'm not telling you this story like that
- 36:46this has anything to do with me, except that that many of you may
- 36:52be of a confronted with this, and you go, what do you do?
- 36:54What do you do? Because there's a range. First I thought,
- 37:00I'm gonna go out and take her a cup of coffee, you know,
- 37:02and ask and see if she's okay, and maybe that how are you feeling?
- 37:07Are you okay? You know? Can I help in some way?
- 37:12Then I thought, no, I'm not going to do that. She's extremely
- 37:14high, she's nodding off. That's not going to make any difference. And
- 37:19then a couple other people gather. Then I think, I'm talking to one
- 37:22of our assistants. I think maybe we should call the police, or maybe
- 37:25we should call somebody who wants to know in case she needs an art can
- 37:30I don't know, I don't know, and I don't I don't say that
- 37:36so you'll have any empathy for me. I'm just saying I think that is
- 37:39what everybody who is or many people who are in the same situation, are
- 37:45confronted with. And look, if it's a family member, which many of
- 37:50you have dealt with, you got to do the best you can, try
- 37:52to get help for him whatever. And it's it's a horrible, horrible situation,
- 37:58try to do your best. What if you're out of what if you're
- 38:00just sort of witnessing it. What if you're a witness to it. I
- 38:05don't know, do you. I don't know, tech STOPI agreed that many
- 38:14students have been going to college would have been better off taking a different route.
- 38:16Colleges are gonna have to adjust to smaller, more realistic student numbers unless
- 38:21they just want to do away with standards and hand out water down degrees.
- 38:23President geeseaid he wants to provide students with what they want. Maybe they just
- 38:28need to open a bordello and attach a brewery the And I know they're making
- 38:32a joke there. But I went to w VU and I got my party
- 38:37on hard. I also got a really good I think education. I think
- 38:42I was inspired by what I learned at w VU, and I was frequently
- 38:50inspired by really really smart professors and it was life changing for me. But
- 38:57also got my party on. I mean, I think you can do both.
- 39:00I mean, you just have to. You have to make you have
- 39:02to ration it, right, I mean. And one thing I did was
- 39:07I just always went to class. I figured if I'm there, I improved
- 39:14my chances significantly of doing Okay, I always went to class. All righty,
- 39:32we'll be back in six minutes. This is talk line on Metro News.
- 39:36Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. Welcome back, our number
- 40:27two talk line on the Metro News readio network from the Incovid Insurance Studios.
- 40:30Well, I was doing something. I was doing something, and that's why
- 40:35I was late coming back. I know you think I'm just like sitting here
- 40:43eating donuts. All right, we'll get back to the text in just a
- 40:49minute, but we keep an eye on No Labels. No Labels is a
- 40:52nonpartisan, bipartisan organization. That is, it is looking at the possibility of
- 40:58running a unity check. It's in twenty twenty four for president and vice president
- 41:02featuring a Democrat and Republican. We're paying attention to this for variety of reasons.
- 41:07One is that's on its own merits, and also that Joe Mansion is
- 41:12being seriously considered as one of the candidates as a presidential candidate under No Labels.
- 41:20Joe Cunningham joints us and his chair of No Labels that joins us on
- 41:23Metro and News Talking and Joe, good to talk to you again. How
- 41:25are you hey, Great to be here, Abby, Thanks for having me,
- 41:30Thanks for coming on. So you're adding states where you could be on
- 41:35the ballot where you have ballot access. What are you up to now,
- 41:38Yeah, so we just announced yesterday we're on ten states and we're in the
- 41:43works of many more. Hope to be on by twenty or so by the
- 41:45end of the year. It's a process, and you know, you have
- 41:50to go by the Obviously, the walls of each jurisdiction, each state are
- 41:53different. Some states doing allow you to get on til next year or until
- 41:58you actually nominate a candidate. So we're as far long as we can be
- 42:02right now, but we're still pressing ahead to get on, you know,
- 42:06on the balance. And look, Hobby, this is all about giving voters
- 42:08a choice because when you take a step back, the majority of Americans don't
- 42:14want to see this rematch between Trump and Biden in twenty twenty four. And
- 42:17we're just trying to be responsive to the common sense majority. You know,
- 42:22well, what critics say is, what are you doing. You're failing up
- 42:24the process. You're either going to ensure You're gonna help ensure that Joe Biden
- 42:30wins or Joe Biden loses, or Trump wins or Trump loses, whatever happens,
- 42:32You're gonna get blamed for it. So FYI you know that. Yeah,
- 42:37you know here that the truth is, this is the United States of
- 42:42America. We have freedoms, we have a constitution, and in the Constitution
- 42:45there's no mention of parties. We're just being responsive to the American people,
- 42:50the majority of Americans who want other options, and we're exercising this right and
- 42:55our constitutional freedoms. And there's nothing wrong with that. And so you know,
- 43:00look, I mean, we had this due awfully. It's it's obviously
- 43:06not serving this country very well. It's not functioning as it should, and
- 43:09so we're trying to provide another option, a buy parts and ticket Democrat Republican
- 43:15No Labels have been organization as a c fourth nonprofit's been working for over a
- 43:19dozen years to try to bridge that parts and divide. I served in Congress.
- 43:23I was a member of the Problem Solvers Caucus, which is a group
- 43:27of half Ms half Republicans that meet every week try to address the nation's issues.
- 43:32That was formed by No Labels and they also expanded that over into the
- 43:37Senate to make it buy CAMRA. But at the end of the day,
- 43:40this is about giving Americans another voice and another choice. In twenty twenty four,
- 43:45should the candidates from the major parties be so unfavorable to the majority of
- 43:51Americans. Joe Cunningham is with this director of No Labels, So I'm must
- 43:57hesitate to ask a question that I know you're going to artfully dodge, but
- 44:00I you know, and that is about Joe Manchon. And Joe Manchin was
- 44:05on this program earlier. When was it a couple of days ago, Monday,
- 44:09I think or Tuesday? And he said, look, he said he
- 44:15may become independent, he may switch to become an independent because he doesn't think
- 44:21the extremes of either party you are addressing the real needs in America, and
- 44:24therefore he might become an independent thinking seriously about it. So look, he
- 44:29was candid about thinking seriously about becoming an independent, so candidly, how seriously
- 44:34there's No Labels thinking about Joe Manchin as their candidate. And I'm not trying
- 44:40to be coy here, but I can tell you what you can't. You
- 44:45get set me up like that and say, rfully dodge, But I'm not
- 44:46being coy with him being straightforward and honest, and that we haven't begin to
- 44:52consider candidate yet because we don't know if we're going to do this. This
- 44:54is this is being set up at an insurance policy to be put in place
- 45:00if two conditions are met. Number one, if the major party nominees are
- 45:04viewed so unfavorably by the majority of Americans where they don't want to see them
- 45:07in a rematch i e. Trump and Biden. And number two, if
- 45:10our polling shows that we have a pathway to victory. Now we'll make that
- 45:16decision sometimes next spring, March and April. But but look, you know
- 45:21I worked with Center Mansion when I was in the House and he was in
- 45:23the Senate. We got the Great American Outdoors back Signing Law by Presidents Toronto
- 45:27is one of the bills, one of the many bills who worked on together.
- 45:30He's been very involved in the problem Solvers Caucus and to try to purge
- 45:35the partisanship, and we appreciate that. But you know, going back to
- 45:39how I started, we really haven't begun looking at candidates and considering them and
- 45:45probably won't until sometime early next year. Okay, but you would agree,
- 45:49you would agree, is that Joe Mansion, with the kinds of things he
- 45:52says, the kinds of position he takes, the kind of philosophy has that
- 45:58he fits. He fits with the kinds of things that No Labels you and
- 46:02No Labels talk about. You would agree with that, wouldn't you. Look?
- 46:06I have a gray amount of respect for Center to Mansion. I was
- 46:09the first Democrats to be elected in the first congressional district in South dahnt in
- 46:14forty years. And I had Republican mayors endorsing me because I was putting our
- 46:16country they had a party. Center Mansion has been one of those leaders.
- 46:21Say West Virginia's lucky to have them. And you know, the types of
- 46:24candidates I can tell you that we'd be looking at would be folks that are,
- 46:29you know, willing to put their country first, willing to work across
- 46:31the aisle, you know, willing to simply get things done. That's been
- 46:37the goal of No Labels, you know, no matter what party you're in.
- 46:40And I think it's you know, look, it's We've built a large
- 46:44home for a large number of people who feel disaffected through politics right now,
- 46:49who feel like, you know, that maybe the Republican Party or Democratic Party
- 46:52doesn't fully represent them and and they just want their government to function. We
- 46:57appreciate leaders who stand up on their own two feet and push back against their
- 47:00respective parties. Let means standing up for their country. Joe Cunningham is with
- 47:05the Seas with no Labels. Director no Labels are now up to ten states,
- 47:09Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Nevada, North Carolina,
- 47:14Oregon, South Dakota, Utah. What about West Virginia looking to West
- 47:16Virginia trying to get on the ballot here, Yeah, we're working, you
- 47:21know, in some phase and in about every state right now, and again
- 47:24it depends upon what each specific state laws are. As I mentioned earlier,
- 47:31some states don't allow you to get on the ballot until you have a name
- 47:34candidate, and we don't know. Yah. Step one, we don't not
- 47:37sure if we're gonna run and take it. This is an insurance policy.
- 47:39But number two, if we do nominate somebody, it's not gonna be told
- 47:44you know, next spring. Okay. Here's the thing, and that is
- 47:47if you take a poll and you well polls have been taken and ask people
- 47:52would you like another option than Trump or Biden, you got to get a
- 47:54big number. You get a pretty big number there of people are yeah,
- 47:58I like I don't like another option. And then but then a couple of
- 48:01things. One is I just want to see if you agree with this.
- 48:05One is that when then when you have the option and there's a real campaign,
- 48:08then people might not be as enthusiastic about that person as another option.
- 48:14And the other the other aspect of it is that even if they like the
- 48:16other person as an option, it is really really hard to get elect electoral
- 48:23votes because the you know, whoever gets the majority of votes gets all the
- 48:29gets all the electoral votes except in two states. So can you speak to
- 48:32that? Yeah, you know our polls and this poll was Slash on MSNBC
- 48:38this past weekend where it talks about polling, you know, with Biden and
- 48:44Trump and a third party ticket. Third party ticket was pulled at thirty with
- 48:47Biden at thirty seven and Trump down at twenty eight. Yeah, this corroborated
- 48:52across the spectrum that this is shown to have initial interests. And that's generally
- 48:57how polling starts. Right. You find out there's no is there is there
- 49:00is there a doorway when you name candidates, things change. I mean,
- 49:06I'll admit that, but something like this is viable, happy and I tell
- 49:10you it goes back to timing right. I mean, we're staring down the
- 49:14barrel of a very very unpopular rematch right now. And you know, Gallup
- 49:21had the highest number of independence in America identify themselves as such here recently,
- 49:28folks are folks are looking to get past this partisanship and turn the page.
- 49:31And no labels has you know, spent the last twelve years trying to you
- 49:37know, trying to purge that partisanship in Washington, DC. And what we're
- 49:42doing right now is just in response to folks. So will it change,
- 49:45Yeah, it'll change. But I feel like we have responsibility to the American
- 49:50people, the vast majority of Americans who are craving another option, to give
- 49:54that to them and and look and let them respond how they want. If
- 50:00you know, there are people who may go back to the cars and corners,
- 50:02but you know, we're hopeful that the numbers, the numbers stick,
- 50:07and if we do nominated ticket, it'll be a marquee level ticket with infrastructure
- 50:14behind it, with a movement behind it and people behind it. Is something
- 50:16that can hopefully take off and change the course of our country. Joe Cunningham
- 50:21with no labels, Joe, good to talk to you. Again, thanks
- 50:22for coming on and stay in touch. Stay in touch. Okay, thanks
- 50:27so much, all right, talks soon. Talk line continues. We'll return
- 50:30here in just a minute. Trusted experts at WWU Medicine Children who specialize in
- 50:37correcting scoiosis, a curvature of the spine. Their fellowship trained pediatic orthopedic surgeons
- 50:44use the most advanced technology and safest imaging to assess your child's condition. This
- 50:49includes three D CAT scanning, functional MRI and EOS imaging which uses a reduced
- 50:54amount of radiation that's faster and safer for your child. And learn more at
- 50:59wukids dot com, WWU kids dot com. Metro News talk Line with Hobby
- 51:15Kirchibill is brought to you by in Covid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to
- 51:21protect what do you care about most? Visiting coovid dot com to learn more
- 51:24talk line from me in COVI Insurance Studios. We got some developing stories here
- 51:28which we're gonna get to momentarily, and one is there's a development in the
- 51:31Bob Huggins DUI case and Jeff Jenkins will have a report on that in about
- 51:37ten minutes. He's finalizing that. And also there's been a settlement in a
- 51:43police brutality case in the death of Michael Scott Junior and an allegation of police
- 51:50brutality against a couple Dunbar police officers, a settlement in that case. And
- 51:53we'll have attorney Jesse Forbes representing the Scott family coming up at eleven forty fives.
- 52:00To stay with us for developments in those stories. But let me start
- 52:04this segment on Metroner's talking with John Decker's senior national editor of White House,
- 52:09correspondent for Great Television in West Virginias WSAZWTPWDTV and w VVA. He also is
- 52:15an attorney. John, Good morning, thanks for joining us. So break
- 52:19down this latest indictment against Donald Trump. What is your objective take on this?
- 52:24Well, my take is this is different than the case that has been
- 52:28brought in Washington, DC by Jack Smith, a special counsel. That's that
- 52:32federal criminal case that's only four counts against Donald Trump. This is broader.
- 52:37This involves a significant number of indicted co conspirators as opposed to unindicted co conspirators
- 52:45like the Jack Smith case. And it also includes the charge of racketeering which
- 52:49is a very serious charge in the state of Georgia. A conviction there means
- 52:54a mandatory minimum sentence of five years in prison. So with Donald Trump and
- 53:00those co conspirators are facing Fannie Willace, who is the district attorney in Fulton
- 53:06County, has indicated she would like her case to get started as far as
- 53:09a trial is concerned, in the next six months, which is going to
- 53:14be difficult, hoppy, given all of the other criminal matters that are now
- 53:17facing Donald Trump. John, how do you get to a racketeering charge in
- 53:22this instance? And again that's a state law, maybe you're not as familiar
- 53:24with that as federal law. But what conditions would warrant a racketeering charger charges?
- 53:31Well, there is a federal racketeering charge as well, that's on the
- 53:37books, but obviously that's not being applied here to state law. And this
- 53:40has to do with what Fannie Willas claims or alleges to be a criminal enterprise,
- 53:50a conspiracy involving efforts to overturn the twenty twenty presidential election. That's how
- 53:55you get to that particular charge, as you know, as it relates to
- 54:00the federal charges against Donald Trump. The special counsel Jack Smith decided not to
- 54:07go down that road. That was an option that was available to him.
- 54:09He streamlined his case. He streamlined his case for a number of reasons,
- 54:14including I think the fact that he would like to get his case get started
- 54:17relatively quickly. As you know, he's asked for a January second start date
- 54:22as it relates to that case here in Washington. John also is this involves
- 54:28a lot of people's not as Donald Trump. There are what eighteen defendants,
- 54:30is that right? And so that's with a lot of different allegations, and
- 54:37some of them that we know, even though there allegations in the indictment that
- 54:40we know from previous reporting are factually correct of individuals who were trying, in
- 54:45one form another to interfere with the election in Georgia or to change the outcome
- 54:50of the election in Georgia. Fair. That is fair. And some of
- 54:53those individuals are names that we know. Some are names that are unfamiliar to
- 54:58most Americans in terms of their names. Rudy Giuliani, who in the federal
- 55:02indictment is unindicted co conspirator number one. He has been indicted in the Georgia
- 55:09case. He of course served as the personal attorney to Donald Trump in the
- 55:13aftermath of the twenty twenty election. Mark Meadows is indicted in Georgia. He's
- 55:17not at all indicted in Washington, nor is he really mentioned in that forty
- 55:22five page federal indictment, but he plays a prominent role as it relates to
- 55:28what Fannie Willis alleges in her in her indictment. And in addition to that,
- 55:32some other lawyers that we came to know through their actions to reverse the
- 55:37results of the twenty twenty election, Sidney Powell certainly comes to mind. She's
- 55:42an unindicted co conspirator in the federal case. She is an indicted co conspirator
- 55:46in the Georgia case. John, I wonder, when you have this many
- 55:50people indicted, and when you have mandatory jail sentences on rico charges, if
- 55:54it's reasonable to think you would have some individuals who indicted or thinking I'm not
- 55:58going to jail, I'm going I'm gonna tell everybody what I know about everything
- 56:01that happened. Is that reasonable to think? It's reasonable to think absolutely,
- 56:07And as you know, Donald Trump has been paying the legal bills for a
- 56:09lot of individuals who have been called up in these criminal cases against him.
- 56:15I don't know how many of the individuals that have been indicted now in Georgia
- 56:21will fall under the umbrella of being so quote unquote protected by Donald Trump's large
- 56:27s as it relates to paying off legal bills. But they can get quite
- 56:30expensive, and that often is one of those factors that convinces individuals to cooperate
- 56:37or to plea to lesser charges. That may be the case in Georgia.
- 56:42And John Decker, Senior National editor of White House, correspondent for Great Television
- 56:45WSAZ, W, TAPWDTV and w VVA and West Virginia. John, thank
- 56:49you for your reporting in your insights. I appreciate it. Thank you,
- 56:52Happy, have a great day by bye. Do you realize your first line
- 56:58of network security starts with you employees? A link clicked on a bogus email
- 57:02or working remotely without a secure connection can wreak havoc on your business. Give
- 57:07your team the easy to use security tools they need. Learn more at citynet
- 57:12dot net, city net dot net techt topic. The problem with guidance counselors
- 57:16and colleges is they don't give kids the facts about the reality of the degree
- 57:21they are seeking. They just want the students. I don't I don't know.
- 57:25I don't know. I don't know that I understand the opinion. I
- 57:28just don't know that. I don't know how far a counselor would go in
- 57:37telling a student that the degree that hears you wants to pursue that there's not
- 57:44much of a market for that. I'm just not sure. But point being
- 57:49is that a student choosing a particular discipline OHSA to himself or herself to a
- 57:59primarily follow their dream. I get that I was able to do mine.
- 58:01You've probably been able to do yours, but also to understand or have a
- 58:07reasonable expectation of what the market would be once you finish your degree. Hoppy
- 58:15had a friend tell me this morning his daughter's a WWU student. She has
- 58:20some scholarships helping, and the tuition was just over two thousand dollars a semester.
- 58:22However, housing was over fourteen thousand dollars for the year, staying in
- 58:25a required campus dorm, no kitchen, etc. How can WV you justify
- 58:30that, Hoppy, I want to address the reduction in force. I worked
- 58:37at WV for thirty two years. My position was cut. This was done
- 58:40in such a poor way. I was sitting in my office and received a
- 58:45call that this was my last day. I could gather my things and leave.
- 58:50Shame on you, wvu how cowardly this was my livelihood. Following my
- 58:54cut, they announced raises in our department. I have lost all respect for
- 59:00you, says the texture Hoppy. Everyone doesn't have to go to college,
- 59:05graduate and be in debt right off the bat. No way to start a
- 59:07young person's life. There are I have no regrets about going to college.
- 59:14I've said before. I really benefited from going to college. It was a
- 59:16lot, a lot cheaper back then. But I also wondered. But frankly,
- 59:22that long ago, it was like everybody has to go to college.
- 59:24You gotta go to college or you're gonna go into coal mines. Not where
- 59:28I was. But and now, frankly, there are so many jobs available
- 59:31out there and the opportunities that come with a technical degree, you know,
- 59:37like a two year degree from community technical college. You can do quite well.
- 59:42All right, we'll take a break of me back. More to come,
- 59:44including an update on the hugging story. This is talk Line on Metro
- 59:46News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia talk line from me and
- 1:00:07Colvin Trance Studios. A settlement in the wrongful death lawsuit involving Dunbar police.
- 1:00:15We'll get to that in just a minute. But first, and also a
- 1:00:19new candidate in the race for State Center. But first, a development in
- 1:00:22the Bob Huggins dui case. Jeff Jenkins joins us from the Metro News News
- 1:00:24from Jeffrey, Good morning. What do you have, hey, hop?
- 1:00:27Yeah, you know, former coach Bob Huggins was supposed to be in court
- 1:00:30later this week for another appearance in Pittsburgh in the court in Pittsburgh Allegheny County
- 1:00:36Court. But we reported back on July twelfth that there had been an offer
- 1:00:43in the Huggins case on a basically a pre trial diversion program. It's called
- 1:00:46Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition for first time DUI offenders. We reported that on July twelfth,
- 1:00:53Well, on July fourteenth, he entered that so that was not listed
- 1:00:58though in any of the docket information. Quite honestly, that is listed from
- 1:01:01from the court system. So as I was checking with the court today about
- 1:01:07Friday's hearing, they alerted me that this had already been and they didn't know
- 1:01:12why it had not been posted quite honestly, but he had entered. He
- 1:01:15had entered this diversion agreement, and so we do have the story. What
- 1:01:21does that mean, Well, that means that he's on non reporting probation.
- 1:01:25All right, there's good. And if he does these things in a year,
- 1:01:30even less than a year, the record will be expunged. He's already
- 1:01:35paid three thousand, about twenty eight hundred dollars in fines, and that's everything
- 1:01:38is going to be connected with this, fines and court costs. So it
- 1:01:43is twelve months probation. Non reporting probation means, you know sometimes when a
- 1:01:46lot of times when you're on probation, you got to report every so often
- 1:01:49to a probation officer. But he's on non reporting probation. UH, driver's
- 1:01:53license suspended for sixty days, alcohol treatment program which really don't have any specifics
- 1:02:01on that, the payment of all court costs, and then the completion of
- 1:02:06an alcohol highway safety school twelve and a half hours of that. So this
- 1:02:10is a diversion program, which is not uncommon for DUI cases in Pennsylvania.
- 1:02:15Fair. That is fair, That is fair. That's what the Prosecutor's office
- 1:02:19there in Allegheny County tells me the District Attorney's office. This is offered commonly
- 1:02:23to first time non violent offender DUI offenders in Pittsburgh. Now his case,
- 1:02:30he's treated just a little differently because his blood alcohol content was higher. It's
- 1:02:35considered the highest level, which is point one zero is what he blew after
- 1:02:38that June sixteenth arrest. One zero. I thought it was point point two
- 1:02:43one two one. Yeah, two, I'm at point two one zero is
- 1:02:45what I meant. Yeah, yeah, Okay, So that is a it
- 1:02:50is a settled issue. He enters this diversion program, but there are certain
- 1:02:55certain benchmarks that he must meet and participating in this diversion. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:03:00And we've got the docket sheet now, we've got that from the from
- 1:03:04the Allegheny County District Attorney's office. That's included in the story. So if
- 1:03:07you want to read down how all the fees collected go up to three thousand
- 1:03:13dollars, you can. There's a little bit of a fee for everything,
- 1:03:15quite honestly, and in terms of the diversion that's there too. Yeah,
- 1:03:19it's all in there. Okay, all right, Joe, thank you much,
- 1:03:21alright, So coach Bob Huggins former coach Bob Huggins entering a DUI diversion
- 1:03:25program in Pittsburgh as a result of UI arrest a couple of months ago.
- 1:03:30Okay, So that's posted at wv metronews dot com. Joined by Delegate Joey
- 1:03:35Garcia, who is a Democratic delegate from Marion County. Joey, good morning,
- 1:03:38How are you hey? Happy? How are you'm well? Thank you
- 1:03:42have an announcement to make today, have already made, but you can make
- 1:03:45it statewide. What is it? I'm going to run for the thirteenth Senatorial
- 1:03:50District, which represents Montegea County and Marian County and most of that is within
- 1:03:55the areas of Morgantown and Okay, and this is a c the thirteenth now
- 1:04:00held by Democrat Mike Caputo, who has decided he is not running for re
- 1:04:04election in twenty twenty four. There's a Republican already in the race, Jonathan
- 1:04:10Board. I'll get to that in a minute. But Joey, you are
- 1:04:13again a delegate, a Democrat. Why have you decided to seek this Senate
- 1:04:16seat? I think we need somebody in this area that represents our values.
- 1:04:24And I think that really means there's one question that drives every decision, and
- 1:04:30that is how do we get people to stay, rebuild and succeed in West
- 1:04:34Virginia. And I've used that in other campaigns, but honestly, until we
- 1:04:38fix this problem with people leaving the state or people feeling that they have the
- 1:04:42opportunities to stay here or come back, that's the defining issue. And specifically
- 1:04:46in an area like Morgantown and Fairmont, where we are seeing growth, we
- 1:04:50are seeing industry, we're seeing new manufacturing up here. We have to provide
- 1:04:56all the incentives to make sure that people can come here and that we can
- 1:05:00lead really the state of West Virginia economically. Joey Garcia is with this season
- 1:05:06Democratic delegate from Marion County. He is announcing today he's running for the Democratic
- 1:05:11nomination in the thirteenth Central District Money Gill and Marion County's already a Republican in
- 1:05:16that race. Jonathan Board just do you know him? Do you know Jonathan
- 1:05:19Board? Jonathan's a nice guy. I mean I went to law school with
- 1:05:24Jonathan. We've worked. I mean he brought me into the Mary Kanny Chamber
- 1:05:26of Commerce a couple of years ago. Uh, he is. He's been
- 1:05:30a donor to me in the past. He's somebody who was at my ribbon
- 1:05:33cutting when I opened up a new law firm here last year. So he
- 1:05:38you know, he's always been somebody that that I've seen eye to eye with
- 1:05:43on really a lot of issues. And so that makes the question. I
- 1:05:47guess he feels that he wants to be a representative in this area, and
- 1:05:51that's that's fine, And I think that it's important that we have so many
- 1:05:58right now, so many Republicans, and there's a lot of people say,
- 1:06:00well, you know, the state's turning in a certain direction, and that's
- 1:06:03not healthy. That's not healthy to not have vigorous debate because most of these
- 1:06:10issues right now appear to be decided buying closed doors. And I think that
- 1:06:15Senate leadership will not recruited him, and that's great. But I'm here to
- 1:06:18represent the people of Marion County and make sure that and I'm not afraid to
- 1:06:23speak out about issues. I'm not afraid to vook my conscience, and I'm
- 1:06:27also not afraid to work across the ale and make sure that we make good
- 1:06:29things happening regardless of partisanship. All right, Joey Garcia today announcing he's running
- 1:06:34for the Democratic nomination for the state Senate in the thirteenth Senatorial district. That's
- 1:06:40a big chunk of marrying, big chunk of monte Galia seat is being vacated
- 1:06:43by Mike Caputo not running for reelection, and I guess maybe others are getting
- 1:06:47raised two but Garcia board, that's gonna be pretty good. That's gonna be
- 1:06:50one to watch, one to watch next year, and Joey will be talking
- 1:06:55to you and Jonathan are going forward. But I appreciate you coming on today.
- 1:06:58Good luck with your campaign. Great, thank you, thank you.
- 1:07:01Okay, So other news again to recap as Jeff Jenko's reporting a dead diversion
- 1:07:09program for Bob Huggins to deal with his DUI charge, certain certain requirements that
- 1:07:15he must meet that was actually agreed to a couple of weeks ago, but
- 1:07:18it's just now becoming public for whatever reason. And also coming up in just
- 1:07:25a couple of minutes, we're going to talk with an attorney for the family
- 1:07:28of an individual who was killed in custody with the Dunbar police. And there's
- 1:07:34been a settlement reached in that case. So that story when we return on
- 1:07:39Metro News talk Line. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to
- 1:07:56you by in Coca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 1:08:00about most. Visitingcovid dot com to learn more Talk line from me and cobD
- 1:08:04Schure in studios. It was a little over a year ago that Michael Scott
- 1:08:09Junior died in police custody, a custody of Dunbar police and lawsuit was filed
- 1:08:15on behalf of Michael Scott Junior against the City of Dunbar the Dunbar Police Department.
- 1:08:19Now there has been a settlement has been reached. Jesse Forbes is an
- 1:08:25attorney representing the Scott family. He joins us on Metro News talk Line.
- 1:08:29Jesse, good morning, what's the deal? Good morning, Hobby. It's
- 1:08:31Jesse Forbes here. Dante de Trappant of my co counsels with me as well.
- 1:08:36Appreciate being odd. Yeah, we had a hearing this morning and the
- 1:08:40court has approved the settlement. It's a two million dollars settlement with the City
- 1:08:44of Dunbar Officer Winter As an officer, Mason On behalf of the Scott family.
- 1:08:49The family's very pleased with the settlement, but obviously no amount of money
- 1:08:54is going to bring back their son and loved one here who should not have
- 1:08:58died in this tragic way. He was arrested on a misdemeanor trespassing warrant and
- 1:09:04immediately upon arrest was placed in handcuffs, and then the officer later described what
- 1:09:10he did to him as captured on bodycamp, as supplexing him, which is
- 1:09:14some kind of wrestling maneuver. It's not a police procedure. It caused the
- 1:09:18fractured skull bleeding on the brain. And then the real tragedy is they spent
- 1:09:23two hours after that deprising this young man of the medical care he needed,
- 1:09:27which would have saved his life according to the experts that we had in the
- 1:09:30case, and ultimately he died the following day at c anc as the result
- 1:09:36of the brain Jesse Forbes and Dante to traveling with his Dante, what was
- 1:09:41your impression of or your chake You've had a lot of cases your chake on
- 1:09:45what happened to this individual in police custody? Cool happy, thanks for having
- 1:09:50us on the you know, first of all, you know, I believe
- 1:09:54that it's the worst case of excessive force that I've ever seen, and fortunately
- 1:10:00was captured on body care and footage, and we were able to retrieve that
- 1:10:03footage and use it, you know, to support you know, what I
- 1:10:08believe is a huge settlement and an acknowledgement that somebody did something wrong and the
- 1:10:13real tragedy. And let me be clear that you know, we you know,
- 1:10:15we support police officers. We think there's great police officers all across our
- 1:10:19state are county and in the city of Charleston and surrounding city, but there
- 1:10:23are some really bad ones. And these Dunbar police officers not only fractured this
- 1:10:28kid's skull brain bleed, but then they carried him around for two hours and
- 1:10:32I didn't get him medical carrey even though he was killing them. You know,
- 1:10:36I have blood coming out of my ear canal, my head's killing me.
- 1:10:40I need to go to the hot sittle. And he was just getting
- 1:10:43bullied by a young police officer and Dunbar who has no business with a badge.
- 1:10:47Are those two officers still on the force? Hoppy that was asked by
- 1:10:53the judge to hear him this morning, and the attorneys for the insurance company
- 1:10:56for Dunbar indicated that both of them are still on the worse than Dunbar despite
- 1:11:00the investigations into this case. And you know, this case is really tragic
- 1:11:06when you think about how easily they could have saved his life. He's on
- 1:11:10the body cam footage, Michael Scott Junior begging one of these officers to take
- 1:11:15him to the hospital. He says, my head, my head, Please
- 1:11:17take me to the hospital. The pressure it hurts, and supposed to take
- 1:11:21him to a hospital, which they drove right by Thomas Hospital in South Charleston.
- 1:11:26They take him to the jail, yelled a bunch of explicits at him
- 1:11:29and told him they weren't going to take him to any hospital. It's really
- 1:11:32disturbing, and if you think about it, you know the George Floyd case,
- 1:11:35which we're all familiar with, which is one of the worst civil rights
- 1:11:39violations in the history of this country. That was nine minutes where the officer
- 1:11:43had his knee on Floyd's neck and it's terriffing. These officers used the weight
- 1:11:47of their badges on Michael Scott Jr. For two hours, and they could
- 1:11:51have saved his life and didn't. It's a real tragedy. Dante and I
- 1:11:56and Jesse mentioned this a little bit, but what is the reaction of the
- 1:11:59family. You know, the family views this as as closure, at least
- 1:12:05on the civil side. They still are hopeful that, you know, some
- 1:12:10prosecution will happen against these these two officers. They're you know, a very
- 1:12:15emotional day for Michael Scott Senior. He gave testimony about the settlement and talked
- 1:12:23about, you know, the relationship with his son and how he's going to
- 1:12:26be missed by him, his mom and his four sisters, and what a
- 1:12:30tragedy it is. But you know, at the end of the day,
- 1:12:32you know, they put into it. It's been a high profile case and
- 1:12:38they want to just kind of move on with their lives. But they're very
- 1:12:40hopeful that the US Attorney's Office or some organization maybe in DC will see fit
- 1:12:45to prosecute these police officers. Well, let me ask that question. Now,
- 1:12:48let me follow up there, and Jesse, I'll ask you, is
- 1:12:50that if this case is as egregious as you all say it is, and
- 1:12:54there's a lot of testimony to that effect, why isn't there a federal investigation
- 1:12:59of the civil rights violation here. Well, we believe there's been an investigation.
- 1:13:03It's unclear as to what the status is. That the civil case was
- 1:13:08actually stayed for a period of time because the US Attorney's Office has sent a
- 1:13:12grand jury subpoena to Dunbar for the bodycam footage of the other information Dunbar had.
- 1:13:17The civil case was allowed to go forward after that, and there's been
- 1:13:21no indication from the US Attorney's Office as to whether a charging decision has been
- 1:13:26reached. The family is obviously hopeful based on the allegations that we've mentioned here
- 1:13:31and the allegations that are in the complaint and that are supported by the bodycam
- 1:13:34and the other evidence in the case. The family is very hopeful that there
- 1:13:40will be a criminal prosecution in this matter. But that's really in the hands
- 1:13:44of the US Attorney's Office at this point. It is in their in their
- 1:13:46hands. But i'll finish up with you, Dante. Do you believe there's
- 1:13:48evidence here to warn a criminal indictment? Oh? Absolutely, There's no world
- 1:13:55hopy where a person can look at that body camera footage of a young man
- 1:13:59who's being compliant with police officers that gets picked up, handcuffed, slammed on
- 1:14:03his skull on the pavement, sustained skull fractures, and a brain bleed,
- 1:14:10all on body camp footage, and then they carry him around for two hours,
- 1:14:15which is also on the body camera footage of him pleading for help,
- 1:14:18you know, wanting to go to the hospital. And they take him out
- 1:14:21to the South Center Regional Jail and they continue to mislead the people out there
- 1:14:27as to what's going on with Michaels. They know they slammed him on his
- 1:14:29head, they know he's disoriented by that, and they allow them to knock
- 1:14:32hand Michael Scott Junior twice thinking that he might be on drugs when they know
- 1:14:36that they slammed his head into the concrete and cause a you know, a
- 1:14:41brain injury and he's disoriented from that. Later, when they finally get him
- 1:14:45to the seeing MC general, a nurse calls Officer Winters. This is on
- 1:14:51the body camera as well, and ask this guy shows up, he's you
- 1:14:56know, his head swollen, you know, he's got blood coming out of
- 1:14:59his years. What did the heck happened? And Winners continues to mislead and
- 1:15:02lives he says he tripped and ripped the earring out of his ear and just
- 1:15:06a bunch of nonsense. So yeah, we think that there's no world where
- 1:15:11this should not be prosecuted. Dante j Trapanneau Jesse Forbes with law firm representing
- 1:15:15the family of Michael Scott Junior, and a judge today. Judge Burger today
- 1:15:19approved the two million dollar payment to the family for the loss of life for
- 1:15:26this individual dot and police custody. All right, Jesse, Dante, thank
- 1:15:29you for coming on. I appreciate it. Thanks, Poppy, thank you,
- 1:15:31thank you. Talk on continues. We'll be right back. Talk one
- 1:15:55for me and COVI Insurance Studios. And Leslie Rubin wc HSTV reporting that former
- 1:16:01Chapmanville police officer Marcus Dudley now in custody and Dudley was recently indicted in Canall
- 1:16:11County in connection with the missing canine. Chase was the canine dog police officer
- 1:16:17that was assigned to Dudley and Chase disappeared. I think it was back in
- 1:16:24April or May the Chase disappeared and Dudley had some story about what happened to
- 1:16:28the dog. Nobody ever really bought that and then Chapman left the air.
- 1:16:33I mean Dudley left the area. A grand jury brought several charges against him
- 1:16:38in connection with the disappearance of the canine, which has never been found,
- 1:16:43by the way, and now Leslie Leslie Rubin reported that Dudley has been taken
- 1:16:47into custody in Henry County, Georgia. So he's in custody. There had
- 1:16:54been two scheduled court appearances for Dudley and he had not shown up at either
- 1:17:00one, but now he is in custody and pretty serious trouble. Also again
- 1:17:08to recap as Jeff Jenkins has reported that let me go back here a second,
- 1:17:15that Jeff Jenkins has reported that Bob Huggins has worked out an arrangement with
- 1:17:24the prosecutor's office in Pittsburgh on the DUI. Jeff reporting that Huggins is now
- 1:17:30on a non reporting twelve month probation period after entering a diversion program with prosecutors
- 1:17:40following his drunk driving arrest in Pittsburgh back in June. He was scheduled to
- 1:17:44appear for formal arraignment later this week, but that has been canceled because he
- 1:17:48has been accepted into the accelerated Rehabilitative disposition program for first time DUI offenders.
- 1:17:59Acording to the Allegheny County District Attorney's Office, the agreement includes probation or the
- 1:18:06option of termination after six months of all conditions are met, Suspension of the
- 1:18:12drivers driver's license for sixty days, alcohol treatment as recommended following the court reporting
- 1:18:18network assessments of the being an assessment and a alcohol treatment program. Payment of
- 1:18:24all court costs, and completion of an approved alcohol Highway Safety school classes approximately
- 1:18:30twelve and a half hours attendance required. Huggins must complete the terms of that
- 1:18:35agreement within one year. Also, he was fined about twenty eight hundred dollars.
- 1:18:41All right, see you tomorrow. This has been talk line on Metro
- 1:18:44News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia.