Latest / Surrounded / Is Wokeness Really The Issue?
Transcript
- 0:00Point,
- 0:00the point,
- 0:00the point of my why is that a problem?
- 0:02No,
- 0:03here's the problem.
- 0:03What matters for most people is whether they have a
- 0:06job that actually is able to pay the rent.
- 0:07I would so they can own,
- 0:08have a hope of owning a home,
- 0:10that they can marry who they like.
- 0:11Anyone who watches my show will know I call out everybody.
- 0:14No,
- 0:14you don't,
- 0:14you never call out Michael Knowles.
- 0:15He's done it multiple times.
- 0:16You've just pointed that out to me.
- 0:18I will call him out on it.
- 0:19It just sounds like you're not.
- 0:20Michael,
- 0:20if you're watching,
- 0:21I'm gonna ask you about that.
- 0:22You better,
- 0:23you better have your debate.
- 0:26I'm here with Tyler.
- 0:28Tyler,
- 0:28welcome,
- 0:29uh,
- 0:29to the Stranded follow-up.
- 0:31Well,
- 0:31thank you for having me.
- 0:33Of course,
- 0:33thank you for jumping into the arena and,
- 0:36um.
- 0:38Yeah,
- 0:38I,
- 0:39I would love,
- 0:39but I want to react to some clips,
- 0:42but before we kind of get into it,
- 0:44what,
- 0:44what are your feelings about
- 0:46the video now that it's,
- 0:47you've seen it in the wild?
- 0:49Oh,
- 0:50I like it.
- 0:50Like I,
- 0:51I like the video.
- 0:51I think,
- 0:52um,
- 0:52I,
- 0:53I love debate.
- 0:55I love arguing.
- 0:56I love contentious conversations.
- 0:59So you know this is my second time doing Surrounded,
- 1:02so I was very excited and I only have positive feelings,
- 1:05um,
- 1:06but you know,
- 1:06maybe that'll change after our conversation,
- 1:08John.
- 1:08Maybe you'll
- 1:09lock me down.
- 1:10I'll feel terrible about it,
- 1:11but so far I'm excited.
- 1:13Yeah,
- 1:13no,
- 1:14well,
- 1:14great.
- 1:15Positive feelings is what uh is always preferred.
- 1:18Um,
- 1:18I want to just kind of see your initial reaction with peers and
- 1:22then um I have kind of some questions for you because you,
- 1:25I think maybe of all the participants in this one,
- 1:28you maybe came in the hottest
- 1:30in kind of a unique way.
- 1:31You talk about how you're a liberal who respects free speech,
- 1:34and on that page
- 1:36you say the Republican Party,
- 1:37and I quote,
- 1:38is ferociously free speech.
- 1:40Yet Donald Trump two months ago signed an executive order
- 1:42banning the burning of the American flag.
- 1:44So how does that work?
- 1:45I don't agree with him.
- 1:46Yeah,
- 1:46but then how are they ferociously free?
- 1:48I don't agree with him.
- 1:48No,
- 1:48but no,
- 1:49on your book on page 81,
- 1:50you said they're ferocious.
- 1:51I would say in the last few years.
- 1:52The Republicans have been more pro-free speech than the woke left.
- 1:55That doesn't mean occasionally,
- 1:57as we saw with the Jimmy Kimmel thing,
- 1:58it doesn't mean that occasionally
- 2:00they don't do stuff,
- 2:01which I think is hypocritical because actually it's not supporting free speech.
- 2:05So I agree with you.
- 2:06So what um executive order did the Democrats pull?
- 2:10Were they banning anything to the regard of burning the American flag?
- 2:13Did,
- 2:13did,
- 2:14I don't think it happens.
- 2:14I'm talking about,
- 2:15well,
- 2:15I don't agree with it,
- 2:16so you want me to say,
- 2:17but your book it's a ferociously free speech.
- 2:19It's a contradiction.
- 2:20They are.
- 2:20Should we just turn,
- 2:21turn or tear page 81 out of your book then?
- 2:24No,
- 2:24no,
- 2:25no,
- 2:25you can be ferociously free speech and still occasionally do things.
- 2:28How did you memorize Pierce's
- 2:31book,
- 2:31uh,
- 2:32prior to debating him?
- 2:34As I told you,
- 2:34I'm just a really big Celebrity Apprentice fan,
- 2:36so it kind of comes naturally.
- 2:38But no,
- 2:38like I,
- 2:39so I read it.
- 2:39I read his book on the plane.
- 2:41Um,
- 2:42so like,
- 2:42you know,
- 2:43and when I read,
- 2:44I basically like,
- 2:45you know,
- 2:45on
- 2:46pages I find interesting
- 2:48whether it's like,
- 2:48you know,
- 2:49Piers Morgan or,
- 2:50you know,
- 2:50David Hume who I put on the same level,
- 2:52obviously
- 2:53I'll make like,
- 2:54uh,
- 2:54notes on the page.
- 2:56So
- 2:57I was going through his book and you
- 2:58know there's particular parts of him are interesting,
- 3:01especially when you talk about free speech.
- 3:02I'd make little notes of like what I would like bring up
- 3:05and then um
- 3:06I kept going back to them,
- 3:07the numbers just kind of stuck with me.
- 3:09I,
- 3:10I don't know.
- 3:11Yeah,
- 3:11it just happened.
- 3:12Pierce asked it in his own way.
- 3:14I think he,
- 3:14I can't remember how he said it.
- 3:15We'll see in a sec,
- 3:16but
- 3:17are you gifted with any sort of neuro,
- 3:19uh,
- 3:19divergence that allows you,
- 3:21um,
- 3:23better than average recall?
- 3:25Other,
- 3:25I call it neuro excellence,
- 3:27but you know,
- 3:29I don't know,
- 3:29like I think it's just like,
- 3:30um.
- 3:31It,
- 3:31you know,
- 3:32I'm,
- 3:32uh,
- 3:33it,
- 3:33it's just something that I've been good at
- 3:35when I,
- 3:35since I've been young.
- 3:36When I really enjoy something,
- 3:37I just have that natural like
- 3:40good recall ability,
- 3:41but that's all I think it is.
- 3:43I don't think it's anything too special.
- 3:44No,
- 3:45no official diagnosis yet.
- 3:47Maybe there'll be another surrounded for that
- 3:49that someone could diagnose me,
- 3:50but yeah,
- 3:51yeah,
- 3:51uh,
- 3:51Tyler versus,
- 3:52um.
- 3:54You know,
- 3:5420 medical,
- 3:55uh,
- 3:5720 medical professionals.
- 3:58Yeah,
- 3:58I might leave us sadder in that episode.
- 4:01No positive feelings there.
- 4:03OK,
- 4:03so
- 4:04let's watch the rest of,
- 4:05uh,
- 4:05the,
- 4:06the exchange because I do think,
- 4:07well,
- 4:07first of all,
- 4:08I just want to say I was a little jealous because like.
- 4:10If I ever was debating somebody who I did have,
- 4:13you know,
- 4:13like a,
- 4:14a really important point to bring up to,
- 4:16I would hope that I could come in as confidently
- 4:19and as prepared and equipped with
- 4:22real,
- 4:23you know,
- 4:23like material
- 4:25references like you did,
- 4:27um,
- 4:27with Piers,
- 4:28and it,
- 4:28it clearly kind of put him on his heels a little bit.
- 4:30I think it was
- 4:31maybe of the whole episode,
- 4:32it was where I,
- 4:34I saw him
- 4:35in a uniquely,
- 4:36um,
- 4:37vulnerable position.
- 4:39Uh,
- 4:39so let's,
- 4:39let's watch a little bit more of that.
- 4:41OK,
- 4:41awesome,
- 4:41yeah,
- 4:42I like the book.
- 4:42What can I say?
- 4:43Are you like one of those weird little mentalists
- 4:45who just remembers every single word of every page?
- 4:47I'm just a massive Celebrity Apprentice fan,
- 4:49so I need no idea.
- 4:50Oh,
- 4:50you killed Trace Adkins in the end.
- 4:52I really appreciate that.
- 4:52I actually bumped into him in Beverly Hills recently.
- 4:54But,
- 4:55so you're on page 245,
- 4:56you talk about how you are against,
- 4:58if you were king for a date,
- 4:59you would ban anybody
- 5:01who participates in cancel culture online.
- 5:03Yes,
- 5:03and you would call them out.
- 5:05However,
- 5:06Michael Knowles,
- 5:06a guest you have on all the time,
- 5:08has recently.
- 5:08Recently said that he wants to ostracize certain people from society,
- 5:12that when they,
- 5:13they say negative things,
- 5:14he was on this show and said if you wave the pride flag,
- 5:17you should be in jail for that.
- 5:19That is against the First Amendment and that it's absolutely cancel culture.
- 5:22I don't agree that you never call him out on that.
- 5:24You've never done it.
- 5:25You have him on the show all the time.
- 5:26I will,
- 5:26next time he's on,
- 5:27I will call him,
- 5:29you promise you have,
- 5:29you have a man.
- 5:30So like right now though,
- 5:31it just seems to me anyone who watches my show will know I call out everybody.
- 5:35No,
- 5:35you don't,
- 5:36you never call out Michael Knowles,
- 5:37he's done it multiple times.
- 5:38Pointed that out to me,
- 5:39so we'll call him out on it.
- 5:40It just sounds like you're not,
- 5:41Michael,
- 5:41if you're watching,
- 5:42I'm gonna ask you about that.
- 5:43You better,
- 5:44you better have your,
- 5:45OK,
- 5:45so then other than,
- 5:46so what has the left done?
- 5:47I'm not left or right.
- 5:50What has the left,
- 5:51what has the left done in the past 10 years that has
- 5:53been worse than trying to ban the burning of the American flag?
- 5:56Well,
- 5:56well,
- 5:56what's the woke left done?
- 5:57Pretty,
- 5:58they're trying to ban everybody and really they're trying to make it illegal.
- 6:01Name one example.
- 6:01That's just not flag.
- 6:03So yeah,
- 6:03but what legislation they put forward
- 6:06before we um.
- 6:08Well,
- 6:09yeah,
- 6:09I guess I'm just curious,
- 6:10where,
- 6:10where,
- 6:10where's your mind at reliving it,
- 6:12seeing it just there?
- 6:14I think that's like as good as it could have gone for me
- 6:17um in terms of that debate and in terms of Pierce because I,
- 6:20I like Piers Morgan.
- 6:21I like Pierce,
- 6:22right?
- 6:22I,
- 6:22I don't have anything um
- 6:24against him other than some of his positions
- 6:26and I do think he has a unique platform
- 6:28where he does seem to bring in guests from
- 6:30all over,
- 6:31um,
- 6:31the political aisle.
- 6:33And I think Michael Knowles is somebody
- 6:35who needs to be questioned on his values and free speech,
- 6:38right?
- 6:39So
- 6:40to get that concession out of him that at least he's going to ask about it
- 6:43and at least now there's like a video of him saying,
- 6:45hey,
- 6:45I will ask you about this,
- 6:47whether he does it or not,
- 6:48he hasn't done it yet,
- 6:49but if he does do it,
- 6:50I think that's really good.
- 6:51I think that's the most of a concession you can get out of someone
- 6:54in that kind of environment.
- 6:56Yeah,
- 6:57I really like when he addresses the camera.
- 6:59To your,
- 7:00uh,
- 7:01knowledge,
- 7:01has,
- 7:02has he gone any further to,
- 7:04uh,
- 7:04you know,
- 7:05to challenge Michael on,
- 7:06on his stance?
- 7:08No,
- 7:08he has not,
- 7:09and I,
- 7:09and truthfully,
- 7:10and like this is like no knock on Pierce,
- 7:12I just don't know if Pierce is equipped to like
- 7:14kind of be able to like,
- 7:15um,
- 7:16sift through the question
- 7:17because if you ask Michael Knowles this,
- 7:19this is what he's gonna say.
- 7:20So if he says this in the end,
- 7:21you can point back to this video.
- 7:23Michael Knowles will say something like,
- 7:24Well,
- 7:24I'm not a free speech to absolutist.
- 7:26I think there should absolutely be limits.
- 7:28Well,
- 7:29no one's a free speech absolutist.
- 7:30Most people have limits on it.
- 7:32What's the important distinction here is.
- 7:34Michael Knowles's idea of free speech
- 7:36is against the First Amendment.
- 7:38It's anti-constitutional and it's anti-American,
- 7:41and that's like the more force I'd want Pierce to bring to him
- 7:44that I am not holding my breath for.
- 7:46Mhm,
- 7:47mhm.
- 7:47And I hear what you're saying.
- 7:48You know,
- 7:49the
- 7:51probably the most notorious thing Michael Knowles has said
- 7:54is transgenderism should be eradicated from society or,
- 7:58you know,
- 7:58something very close to that,
- 8:00um,
- 8:01he said at,
- 8:02at,
- 8:02a very public event.
- 8:04Yeah I completely
- 8:05hear what you're saying.
- 8:07That seems like a very obvious overstep and over-policing
- 8:11of the idea of free expression that,
- 8:13you know,
- 8:14we would,
- 8:14we would see,
- 8:15uh,
- 8:15defended in the Constitution.
- 8:18In your conversations with Pierce,
- 8:19did you ever get to a point where,
- 8:22and I,
- 8:22you know,
- 8:22uh,
- 8:23remind me if I,
- 8:24if I missed it,
- 8:25where you kind of made some concessions on where there was over policing on the left,
- 8:29either on a legislative level or,
- 8:31or otherwise.
- 8:32So yeah,
- 8:32I,
- 8:33I'm not sure there's like much evidence for anything on a legislative from the left
- 8:37and like that's like kind of one of my bigger points is that,
- 8:40you know,
- 8:41the left is certainly pernicious in cancel culture.
- 8:44But it's not at the level of the right right now.
- 8:46It,
- 8:47yeah,
- 8:47if this video were done 10 years ago,
- 8:50like in 2015,
- 8:52I would agree with Pierce
- 8:53that the left was actually worse on free speech back then.
- 8:57Um,
- 8:57I'm a like I,
- 8:59I am a huge believer,
- 9:00and the left
- 9:01did take cancel culture too far.
- 9:03There were times where I thought,
- 9:05yeah,
- 9:05like this is.
- 9:06It's crazy
- 9:07and
- 9:08um
- 9:09something that people say on the left a lot and that you would kind of hear
- 9:12right you know when if you're in a political science
- 9:13classroom you'd hear the the smartest student in the class say
- 9:16well you know freedom of speech isn't freedom from consequences
- 9:20well yeah I know duh,
- 9:21no one believes this
- 9:22but the fact that these like social media companies
- 9:25and like um we're so connected now globally.
- 9:29Um,
- 9:29they do have power for people to lose their jobs over this stuff,
- 9:32right?
- 9:32There is this like power to actually,
- 9:34you say something people don't like and they can
- 9:36force you out of particular areas of life,
- 9:39and that's like that is dangerous,
- 9:41right?
- 9:41Like that's what like
- 9:42the First Amendment was to protect the government from doing that to you.
- 9:45And
- 9:46essentially
- 9:47corporations and public opinion
- 9:50can have very akin powers to the government as well,
- 9:53and I think it's important that we fight against that stuff.
- 9:55However,
- 9:56this conversation did not happen in 2015,
- 9:58it happened in 2025,
- 10:00so I was,
- 10:01I'm just more concerned.
- 10:01Turn to focus on,
- 10:02like,
- 10:02you know,
- 10:03the more immediate threat
- 10:04and you know if Pierce brings up examples to me
- 10:06of like cancel culture that's gone to the left,
- 10:08I,
- 10:08I think in most cases I'm just gonna concede that,
- 10:11yeah,
- 10:12like the left shouldn't be doing that too,
- 10:13and I will call them out on it,
- 10:14but like let's focus on what
- 10:16I believe is the dire problem.
- 10:18Yeah,
- 10:19well,
- 10:19let's talk about the dire problem in just a minute,
- 10:21but,
- 10:22um,
- 10:22you know,
- 10:23just to kind of
- 10:24pull up some examples I could think of,
- 10:26so.
- 10:27In the US,
- 10:28I think probably the finger of blame would go towards
- 10:31COVID and the suppression of speech on social platforms,
- 10:36you know,
- 10:36I think,
- 10:37I don't know if it was Zuckerberg,
- 10:38but there's a Twitter files,
- 10:39basically,
- 10:40you know,
- 10:41these,
- 10:41these anecdotes and,
- 10:43and corroborated stories that the government
- 10:45pressured social media platforms to suppress
- 10:49any information around,
- 10:51uh,
- 10:51or a lot of information around vaccines and vaccine hesitancy,
- 10:56um,
- 10:56and
- 10:58You know,
- 10:58I think the the the justification at the time was this is a
- 11:01dire public health concern,
- 11:03and
- 11:04You know,
- 11:05I think looking back,
- 11:06I would find it pretty
- 11:08clear that
- 11:09that overstep happened.
- 11:11Do you,
- 11:11do you agree or is there any,
- 11:13any light between us there?
- 11:14Yeah,
- 11:14so I,
- 11:15I would probably actually like
- 11:17mostly agree,
- 11:17but I think like the facts in the case are important,
- 11:20right?
- 11:20So specifically with Zuckerberg was the only one who's come in and said like look,
- 11:23we got
- 11:24pressure
- 11:25from the federal government to do this.
- 11:27However,
- 11:27um,
- 11:28this is actually struck down at the Supreme Court
- 11:31from 6 to 3
- 11:32because they did not have standing.
- 11:34We're not able to provide proof
- 11:36that the government,
- 11:37uh,
- 11:37applying pressure
- 11:39did change or did not change any policy,
- 11:42which is something that you would need
- 11:44now.
- 11:44I agree
- 11:45that too much pressure from the federal government
- 11:48can override the First Amendment
- 11:49and the courts recognize this.
- 11:52However,
- 11:52there just has been a lack of,
- 11:54um,
- 11:55evidence
- 11:56that this happened and it did affect,
- 11:58um,
- 11:58any sort of their policies as per,
- 12:02yeah,
- 12:02as per the Supreme Court
- 12:04now.
- 12:05Of course
- 12:05just the idea of doing that also makes me uncomfortable
- 12:09and I'd rather the government not be doing that,
- 12:11but
- 12:12if that's the most we have
- 12:14on what the left did,
- 12:15right,
- 12:15they put
- 12:16some pressure on Mark Zuckerberg and you know he had the
- 12:19final say if he wanted to do it or not
- 12:21versus,
- 12:22as I said,
- 12:23Donald Trump banning the um.
- 12:25Burning the American flag.
- 12:26JD Vent
- 12:27trying to get,
- 12:28uh,
- 12:28Florida,
- 12:29um,
- 12:30prosecutors to go after political streamers
- 12:32like the,
- 12:33the that or our political commentators like that to me
- 12:36is like the actual like really big issue here.
- 12:38Like
- 12:38these are two totally different things.
- 12:41Most recent examples which is coming from the Trump administration.
- 12:45Yeah,
- 12:46exactly,
- 12:46but I,
- 12:47I actually think somebody was arrested,
- 12:49uh,
- 12:49in the aftermath of Charlie Kirk's assassination,
- 12:53yeah,
- 12:53for like somebody arrested,
- 12:55yeah,
- 12:55yeah,
- 12:55so
- 12:56like
- 12:57again like.
- 12:58It,
- 12:58it,
- 12:59it's just,
- 12:59it's really hard for me to take like the comparison seriously
- 13:02if we're going to be like
- 13:04ignoring all these things.
- 13:05If we weren't ignoring all these things on the right,
- 13:07I would kind of be
- 13:08um with them like,
- 13:08yeah,
- 13:09you know what,
- 13:09the government shouldn't be applying pressure on people at all,
- 13:12um,
- 13:13but again like these are just two very different situations.
- 13:16Both are bad,
- 13:17just one's obviously much worse,
- 13:20and what,
- 13:21no,
- 13:21I,
- 13:21I,
- 13:21I totally see what you're saying and I love all the added context,
- 13:25um.
- 13:27Do you think,
- 13:28you know,
- 13:29obviously,
- 13:31you're saying that the right and the Trump administration is,
- 13:33is overplaying
- 13:35their hand on
- 13:38Enforcing their idea of appropriate speech or just,
- 13:40you know,
- 13:41infringing upon
- 13:43um free speech rights.
- 13:45Do you anticipate,
- 13:47um,
- 13:48you know,
- 13:48consequences for them politically and,
- 13:50you know,
- 13:51in,
- 13:51in upcoming elections?
- 13:52Do you think that that's really hurting them?
- 13:55Their political capital right now,
- 13:56you know,
- 13:57honestly,
- 13:58no,
- 13:58I don't think it is.
- 13:59I think most people don't like free speech.
- 14:01I've believed that for a long time.
- 14:03It seems like whenever the shoe's on the other foot,
- 14:06they're canceling or they're,
- 14:07they're,
- 14:07um,
- 14:08endorsing
- 14:08any form of cancellation from their side
- 14:10and even like the slight nudges from the government.
- 14:13So I,
- 14:13I,
- 14:13I truly think that like
- 14:15it,
- 14:15it doesn't bother people.
- 14:17Like I think that they,
- 14:18you know,
- 14:18they'll just justify it that it's OK,
- 14:20and this is kind of why it's entrenched in the Constitution.
- 14:24Because
- 14:25no matter how unpopular the speech is,
- 14:27you want that protection,
- 14:29so I do not
- 14:30anticipate um direct consequences
- 14:33for um that sort of behavior.
- 14:35I think you're probably gonna see like more consequences for like,
- 14:38you know,
- 14:39maybe how ICE conducts themselves
- 14:41or um how the economy is gonna turn out after,
- 14:44um,
- 14:44you know,
- 14:44this whole tariff war.
- 14:45I think that's gonna be more pressing unfortunately for me,
- 14:48but um yeah,
- 14:49I don't think free speech will have
- 14:50that big of an impact as people think,
- 14:53yeah.
- 14:54Since you're so,
- 14:55you know,
- 14:56well informed on this issue,
- 14:58I'm really curious what you think about
- 15:00in terms of like content moderation and maybe who has gotten it right,
- 15:04because,
- 15:04you know,
- 15:05something really interesting that's happened is like,
- 15:07you know,
- 15:07Elon bought
- 15:08Twitter,
- 15:09now it's X,
- 15:10um,
- 15:11and that has become
- 15:12a platform that's,
- 15:14you know,
- 15:15somewhat infamously known for
- 15:18very loose moderation.
- 15:19Um.
- 15:21And then you know there was an instance where Trump was removed from
- 15:24Twitter,
- 15:25um,
- 15:26you know,
- 15:27and now he,
- 15:28it's been reinstated,
- 15:29but he went on to make Truth Social and now,
- 15:31you know,
- 15:32he screenshots his post on Truth Social on X,
- 15:35you know,
- 15:35it's,
- 15:35it's had some.
- 15:37The way that,
- 15:38you know,
- 15:39previous administrations tried to enforce it and
- 15:41the way that billionaires like Elon Musk
- 15:44have reacted to
- 15:45that
- 15:46has had some real consequences in our information landscape,
- 15:49but I'm just curious,
- 15:50like,
- 15:50who do you think's got it right,
- 15:51uh,
- 15:52or the closest,
- 15:53um,
- 15:53to what,
- 15:54uh,
- 15:55is healthy free speech
- 15:57enforcement
- 15:58in a moderation standpoint.
- 16:00Oh,
- 16:01that's a really difficult question.
- 16:03Um,
- 16:03I like,
- 16:04you know,
- 16:04I actually think,
- 16:05um,
- 16:05YouTube gets it pretty well right now,
- 16:08like in terms of like a source I see,
- 16:10like,
- 16:10like YouTube will now like this video's going on YouTube.
- 16:13Yeah,
- 16:13this is YouTube.
- 16:14We're we all freedom.
- 16:15I know there's issues with monetization and stuff like that,
- 16:18but I'm not as concerned with monetization as I am just like.
- 16:21You allowed to say it
- 16:23like,
- 16:23um,
- 16:24Elon Musk to me
- 16:25like does seem like a true hypocrite when it comes to free speech.
- 16:29Like I,
- 16:30yeah,
- 16:30like he was like banning like,
- 16:32you know,
- 16:32like people who were kind of like Stephen King when he was
- 16:35kind of mean to him like like that that's not good.
- 16:37But um,
- 16:38yeah,
- 16:38I think YouTube has it pretty well,
- 16:40um,
- 16:43what's important to me with it is just that.
- 16:46We are,
- 16:47we should be allowed to make these arguments,
- 16:50um,
- 16:50but we should also be aware of where the arguments are coming from.
- 16:52So where I'll give Elon Musk some praise,
- 16:54I do love that factor where you could see from like where in the world is this person,
- 16:58um,
- 16:58tweeting from,
- 17:00and I think that kind of,
- 17:00uh,
- 17:01more has to do with an issue of like
- 17:02anonymity
- 17:03where
- 17:04when you're kind of like this.
- 17:05Blank face
- 17:06it,
- 17:07it can be a bit more pernicious but yeah in terms of like
- 17:10who I think is doing content the best it's probably YouTube,
- 17:14but I don't have like that strong of an opinion on it like um
- 17:17mostly but but what I do think
- 17:19with it though is that
- 17:20I would like to see in the future,
- 17:23um,
- 17:24there'd be some regulation from the government
- 17:27of.
- 17:28What sort of um
- 17:30allowances the social media companies have to give to the citizens
- 17:34in order to have their speech heard
- 17:36I do think that um.
- 17:38Our ways of communicating our ways of getting news is so reliant on social media now
- 17:43so when you are banning people and stuff like this,
- 17:45I do think that
- 17:46you're essentially banning like
- 17:48areas of the town square,
- 17:49and I do think that um the government needs to something to do,
- 17:52do about that,
- 17:53but
- 17:54I don't,
- 17:54I'm not gonna hold my breath for it.
- 17:56Mhm.
- 17:57Are there any limitations to who you would.
- 18:01You know,
- 18:01so you've been in surrounded more than once.
- 18:04Is there any,
- 18:05is there any limitation to who you would go toe to toe with in the center,
- 18:09you know,
- 18:09as far as like where they're coming from,
- 18:11any points of view where you just,
- 18:13you,
- 18:13you would refuse to entertain it.
- 18:16Yeah,
- 18:16I'm actually really glad you asked this question because I,
- 18:19I,
- 18:19I hate,
- 18:20I hate
- 18:21when people say
- 18:22you can't argue against fascism,
- 18:24you're not gonna argue someone out of fascism.
- 18:27I,
- 18:27I think that like this is actually just some laziness from a lot of people,
- 18:31um.
- 18:33When you get into topics of fascism or
- 18:36like you know extreme misinformation like conspiracy theories,
- 18:40what it just takes is it takes like a lot of research
- 18:42and it takes a lot of like sometimes like deep philosophical thinking.
- 18:46Fascism is ultimately like a philosophical.
- 18:48Idea
- 18:49and you need to be able to argue why
- 18:51a democratic system
- 18:53with like you know
- 18:55laws that are like uh not applied arbitrarily
- 18:58is superior
- 18:59to fascism on a moral level like that's
- 19:01sometimes the conversation that needs to be had.
- 19:03And I think people just don't like to think
- 19:06that um deeply about it or
- 19:08challenge their own beliefs on that
- 19:10so they don't know how to like dismantle it when you get someone to say like
- 19:14like I we saw with Mehdi Hassan,
- 19:16the guy said oh
- 19:17I'm a fascist,
- 19:18and he's like well I don't,
- 19:19I don't argue against fascism
- 19:21to me.
- 19:22It's like,
- 19:22well,
- 19:22what,
- 19:23what did you think you were doing,
- 19:24right?
- 19:24You're arguing against people who were on the far right.
- 19:27You need to be prepared
- 19:28to
- 19:29tackle those ideas
- 19:31and in terms of like conspiracy theories,
- 19:33well,
- 19:34it's true.
- 19:34If someone came on here right now
- 19:36and they were a flat earther,
- 19:38they would kick my ass in a debate.
- 19:40The,
- 19:40the reason is is because
- 19:42they know all the arguments and they know all the facts that help their idea
- 19:46where I really just know now I know like,
- 19:47well,
- 19:48you know,
- 19:48there are curves eventually and the scientists,
- 19:51um.
- 19:52Say this,
- 19:52but I would have to do serious research
- 19:55before I did that.
- 19:56But to me,
- 19:57that's my responsibility.
- 19:59If I signed it up for,
- 20:00if I signed up for Surrounded on a particular conspiracy theory,
- 20:03you better believe I would be
- 20:05researching the hell out of that topic.
- 20:07You would have all the pages earmarked.
- 20:09Yeah,
- 20:09I'd have the pages memorized if I,
- 20:11yeah,
- 20:12if I had to debate.
- 20:14Um,
- 20:14someone like Nick Fuentes
- 20:15or somebody more on the far right,
- 20:18I would really know,
- 20:19OK,
- 20:20where can I show logical flaws
- 20:22and moral flaws within fascism
- 20:25against a democratic system,
- 20:27so
- 20:28I,
- 20:29I do think that.
- 20:31People like to kind of um go into these conversations
- 20:34with like well these are like this is like
- 20:35the Overton window of what I'm willing to think about
- 20:38when it's too far outside of that I just kind of turn my brain off and say
- 20:42well you're obviously wrong.
- 20:43My background is in philosophy
- 20:45we were taught explicitly to.
- 20:47Do that.
- 20:48So I'm,
- 20:49I don't know if there's anyone that I would not
- 20:52talk to on surrounded
- 20:54now maybe out of just like pure interest like
- 20:55I'm not that interested in if the earth is
- 20:58flat or round like it's just not something that I'd be motivated to do,
- 21:01but definitely in terms of politically there's
- 21:03um
- 21:05no
- 21:06group or person that I would
- 21:07shy away from and there's some people I really want to debate too,
- 21:10so yeah,
- 21:10I don't think I would.
- 21:11No,
- 21:12yeah,
- 21:12I mean,
- 21:12I like that you bring up Nick Fuentes cause I,
- 21:15not,
- 21:16not suggesting at all that Jubilee is um planning on hosting him in the center,
- 21:20but,
- 21:21you know,
- 21:21there,
- 21:22there is this sort of um
- 21:25Moment right now where some people are bringing him on,
- 21:28you know,
- 21:28like Tucker Carlson,
- 21:29and they're having this kind of like
- 21:31pretty,
- 21:32I think Steven Crowder just interviewed him,
- 21:34maybe yes,
- 21:34yeah,
- 21:34I,
- 21:35I watched that actually,
- 21:35yeah,
- 21:36yeah,
- 21:36and obviously these,
- 21:38uh,
- 21:38these are much more softball like interviews,
- 21:42but now it's kind of raising this question of like,
- 21:44well,
- 21:45should we entertain
- 21:46the idea of having serious debate,
- 21:48and then,
- 21:49you know,
- 21:49now we're seeing the right
- 21:51go through this kind of
- 21:53You know,
- 21:53don't platform these people,
- 21:54you know,
- 21:55don't take them seriously,
- 21:57don't,
- 21:57uh,
- 21:58fuel their fires.
- 21:59But
- 22:00as we've kind of seen in recent history,
- 22:02that doesn't,
- 22:02that probably won't work and in a lot of ways just gives even more power to,
- 22:07to the person
- 22:08um who you're avoiding.
- 22:10But yeah,
- 22:11I,
- 22:11I,
- 22:11I completely agree and um
- 22:15I know this said a lot,
- 22:15like sometimes like when I go online on my YouTube.
- 22:18There will be a bunch of like,
- 22:19you know,
- 22:20video recommendations of like
- 22:22why surrounded is bad for democracy,
- 22:24right?
- 22:24like you know and some guy will give his video essay on why he doesn't like it
- 22:28and and to me the arguments always come down to
- 22:31we're just too lazy to look it up like we're too lazy to actually
- 22:35engage in the argument
- 22:37um
- 22:38that to me is like your own responsibility
- 22:41if you're listening to somebody
- 22:44and you can't um.
- 22:46Like refute what they said,
- 22:47that's always encouraged me
- 22:49to look it up
- 22:50and
- 22:50want to argue against them.
- 22:51So like that's just something that
- 22:53I believe in and I think it's um.
- 22:56Quite pernicious that
- 22:57people can't do that because,
- 22:58and I,
- 22:59I totally agree with you too,
- 23:00the interviews can't be softball,
- 23:02and I don't think that that's what surrounded is,
- 23:04right?
- 23:05I came in very hot with Piers Morgan,
- 23:06and Piers Morgan is somebody I like
- 23:08and I do believe
- 23:10it's fundamentally more of a classical liberal.
- 23:12I just think that he likes the Trump administration way too much,
- 23:15but I will come in super hot.
- 23:17I argued against Ben Shapiro the last time and I came in
- 23:20very hot
- 23:21on January 6th with him,
- 23:23um.
- 23:24And I think that as long as you take that attitude and that competitive attitude,
- 23:27it is OK to platform these people.
- 23:29There's nothing wrong with it refresh my memory on that's it.
- 23:32Where did you and Ben land with January 6th?
- 23:34If I can,
- 23:34I'll pull that clip in
- 23:36here as well.
- 23:37Yeah,
- 23:37um,
- 23:38so
- 23:39my,
- 23:39so
- 23:40before I do any,
- 23:41um,
- 23:42debate with these people,
- 23:43I always think,
- 23:43well,
- 23:43what's the million dollar question?
- 23:46Like what's the question
- 23:47that
- 23:48they will have to answer in a very narrow way.
- 23:51That's really hard to escape.
- 23:53Mine with Piers Morgan was
- 23:54name one piece of legislation that the Democrats have passed
- 23:56in the past 10 years that even amounts to that.
- 23:59There's,
- 23:59it's a really hard question to grapple with.
- 24:01Mine with Ben Shapiro was,
- 24:03why did Donald Trump wait 3 hours
- 24:05to tell the January 6th rioters to go home
- 24:08if he didn't want it to happen?
- 24:10And Ben's answer was,
- 24:12I don't know.
- 24:12I
- 24:13like,
- 24:13literally,
- 24:13that's what he says.
- 24:14I,
- 24:14I don't know.
- 24:15And to me
- 24:17that's almost like a concession of like
- 24:20he knows
- 24:21that he wasn't committing to the peaceful transfer of power.
- 24:23So I was really glad I was able to push Ben on that,
- 24:26and that's kind of where we came from,
- 24:28where Ben said,
- 24:29look,
- 24:29January 6th is bad,
- 24:30but
- 24:30I hope Trump doesn't do it again and I hope he doesn't,
- 24:33um.
- 24:34You know,
- 24:35hurt democracy more
- 24:36where my argument ultimately was like I think he will,
- 24:39and I said the Republican Party,
- 24:41um,
- 24:41is being ripped away from Ben,
- 24:43much to his chagrin,
- 24:44and I think with recent moments
- 24:46I think my,
- 24:46um,
- 24:47intuitions are coming to light if we were to just look past all.
- 24:50Criticisms of Donald Trump
- 24:52and just say,
- 24:52yeah,
- 24:52that's a difference of opinion.
- 24:54I do think January 6th probably stands out as the unique,
- 24:58you know,
- 24:58bridge too far moment where um
- 25:01his character was kind of on display and maybe sort of the fruits of
- 25:06His style of politics was on display in a way that
- 25:10is very hard to defend,
- 25:11and I think you're right,
- 25:12you know,
- 25:13the,
- 25:13the same way you say
- 25:15Pierce is kind of a classic liberal.
- 25:16I,
- 25:17I also think Ben Shapiro really
- 25:20in his heart of hearts is somebody who.
- 25:23Has very traditional American
- 25:25values
- 25:26and I,
- 25:26I sort of tried to thread the needle with the MAGA coalition as best as he can,
- 25:32um,
- 25:32so yeah,
- 25:33I like how you,
- 25:34how you look for that kind of million dollar question.
- 25:36I think it's a great skill
- 25:37and maybe my takeaway from you is like
- 25:39platforming is not the problem,
- 25:41it's just platforming responsibly or
- 25:44prepared platforming,
- 25:45um,
- 25:46is the way to do it.
- 25:48Yeah,
- 25:48I,
- 25:49I,
- 25:49I completely agree.
- 25:49Like we,
- 25:50I knew I was debating somebody like on that day.
- 25:53Like I knew
- 25:54for weeks
- 25:55that I was gonna be debating,
- 25:56um,
- 25:57a
- 25:58broadcaster
- 25:59and I was a woke liberal.
- 26:00So of course I'm going to
- 26:02read up on the issues,
- 26:03but I'm more so glad that.
- 26:05Like
- 26:05you touched on specifically that you believe Ben Shapiro
- 26:09believes in kind of like more conservative but
- 26:11nonetheless American values
- 26:13and I think it's um important for the left and the liberal side.
- 26:16I don't know where you stand politically
- 26:18but we have to be able to differentiate between the characters on the right.
- 26:22I think Ben Shapiro does care about America.
- 26:26I don't think Michael Knowles does and I don't think Matt Walsh does.
- 26:29I think those two are bad actors
- 26:32who do not
- 26:33respect the Constitution and do not respect
- 26:36democracy.
- 26:37Um,
- 26:37Piers Morgan,
- 26:38I think,
- 26:39does
- 26:39really want free speech.
- 26:41He's just confused.
- 26:43I get very sick and tired
- 26:45of people throwing around the term,
- 26:47oh,
- 26:47he's a grifter,
- 26:48he's grifting,
- 26:49he's just doing it for the money.
- 26:50I mean,
- 26:51a simple psychology will explain that.
- 26:54People like kind of tying to beliefs in like really like
- 26:58non-pernicious ways.
- 26:59If all your friends are on the right
- 27:01and giving you the thumbs up when you speak highly of Donald Trump,
- 27:05your brain will naturally just kind of like trick yourself to believe that stuff.
- 27:09Like you're not actually just trying to lie for
- 27:10money or for power and stuff like that.
- 27:12It's a very natural,
- 27:13it's group thing,
- 27:14like it's a very natural
- 27:15uh human idea like when we hang out with our friend groups,
- 27:18we are saying things that will give us like validation with them
- 27:21unconsciously,
- 27:22we're not doing it on purpose,
- 27:23so I think like.
- 27:24I would like to see the term grifter
- 27:27be kind of wiped away for 2026
- 27:29and let's just
- 27:30focus on what they're saying.
- 27:31We'll dismantle the arguments,
- 27:33and then I think that will be more,
- 27:34um,
- 27:35fruitful.
- 27:37Well,
- 27:37I love it,
- 27:38and I,
- 27:38I,
- 27:39I really agree with a lot of what you're saying.
- 27:41And Tyler,
- 27:41I,
- 27:42I will,
- 27:43you know,
- 27:43casting team,
- 27:44this is my endorsement,
- 27:45put Tyler in as many episodes
- 27:47as you can because,
- 27:49you know,
- 27:49that heat,
- 27:50that friction is,
- 27:51is so valuable.
- 27:53I really appreciate that and I think
- 27:56I,
- 27:56I,
- 27:56I was civil too though like I'm a,
- 27:57you know,
- 27:58I'm a nice guy,
- 27:59but
- 28:00yeah,
- 28:01exactly.
- 28:01I mean that's what I think surrounded should be.
- 28:04I mean,
- 28:04obviously I don't have any claim in it,
- 28:06but I,
- 28:07I appreciate that and um
- 28:09I appreciate free speech and I appreciate you,
- 28:11John.
- 28:11I appreciate you,
- 28:12Tyler.
- 28:13Yeah,
- 28:13thank you.
- 28:13Yeah,
- 28:14Jenny,
- 28:15welcome back to the Jubilee verse.
- 28:18Uh,
- 28:18welcome to the surrounded follow-up.
- 28:20Thank you for having me,
- 28:21John.
- 28:22Of course,
- 28:22um,
- 28:23and also thanks for,
- 28:24you know,
- 28:25being in surrounded,
- 28:26jumping into the arena with Piers.
- 28:28He,
- 28:28uh,
- 28:30obviously is a formidable debate
- 28:32opponent.
- 28:33What's it been like just sort of seeing,
- 28:35uh,
- 28:36the video and,
- 28:36and the interaction between the two of you,
- 28:39um,
- 28:39out,
- 28:39out in the wild.
- 28:41It's very interesting,
- 28:43a little surreal.
- 28:44It's always a little weird to see
- 28:46myself on camera.
- 28:48Yeah,
- 28:48and also,
- 28:49you know,
- 28:49it's one of those things where I never really thought I would meet someone like
- 28:53Piers in real life,
- 28:54so it's very interesting to be able to share a space with him and
- 28:57have some dialogue.
- 28:58It was very interesting in terms of debate.
- 29:01I think that
- 29:02he has some very interesting debate tactics that
- 29:06I hope that I came across well encountering,
- 29:10but it was definitely a challenge to navigate for sure.
- 29:14Yeah,
- 29:14well,
- 29:15you have,
- 29:16so you've been in surrounded before,
- 29:17you know,
- 29:17you've debated Candace.
- 29:19You do seem
- 29:21quite calm in those interactions.
- 29:23Is that something,
- 29:24uh,
- 29:24you take pride in,
- 29:25or are you known as like somebody who can handle high pressure situations?
- 29:29I definitely take pride in that.
- 29:31I try to consider myself,
- 29:32I,
- 29:33I see a lot of my opponents,
- 29:34or not opponents,
- 29:34my colleagues
- 29:36approach,
- 29:36um,
- 29:37debate
- 29:38in different ways.
- 29:39Um,
- 29:39some are very aggressive,
- 29:40some are very like.
- 29:42I'm
- 29:43out to
- 29:44own somebody.
- 29:45I think my approach is a little different.
- 29:47Um,
- 29:48some people maybe think I'm a little too mild mannered,
- 29:51but
- 29:52I try to think of myself as an empathizer.
- 29:56I want to come into the conversation with
- 29:58trying to understand where they're coming from.
- 30:01And then either trying to figure out how to break that down
- 30:04or um
- 30:06try and get them to understand my point of view.
- 30:08I try to think of it more beyond just the person in front of me
- 30:11because I believe that maybe they are really set in their
- 30:13ways and maybe I won't be able to change their mind.
- 30:16I try to think about other people who share this person's views
- 30:20and what I can say to maybe make it make sense to them
- 30:23and get them to maybe understand a little bit
- 30:25more of the other side or a different opinion.
- 30:27Mhm.
- 30:28And did you feel like you got anywhere with peers?
- 30:31I'm going to be honest,
- 30:32it was a little tough.
- 30:33Um,
- 30:34Piers has a very interesting debate tactic of when he
- 30:38senses that you're going to go into a certain point,
- 30:41um,
- 30:41he doesn't want you to reach that point,
- 30:43so he'll instead shoehorn his own
- 30:47opinion or a redirecting question.
- 30:50He was trying to steer you towards limitless self-identity.
- 30:54Let's refresh and then,
- 30:55and then we can react.
- 30:57I said,
- 30:57um.
- 30:58Do you believe in limitless self-identity,
- 31:00and the,
- 31:01the wokey
- 31:02of the two guests said,
- 31:03I do,
- 31:04and you have to respect what people
- 31:06want.
- 31:06And she said yes.
- 31:07I went,
- 31:07OK,
- 31:07in that case,
- 31:08I,
- 31:09on International Women's Day,
- 31:10Piers Morgan,
- 31:11am now identifying as a black lesbian.
- 31:13And the black panelist burst out laughing because she knew what I was doing,
- 31:16which is taking this argument
- 31:18to its logical conclusion,
- 31:20which is once you make it limitless,
- 31:23society just collapses because anyone
- 31:25can say that they're anything they want.
- 31:27And,
- 31:27and you would say to me,
- 31:28if I said to you I'm a black lesbian,
- 31:30what would you say?
- 31:30I would say that you're conflating this idea of limitless.
- 31:34Like whatever gender expression or self-identity.
- 31:37I already said I don't agree with that.
- 31:39But you didn't say where the limit is,
- 31:40right?
- 31:41So for me personally,
- 31:42and what I believe is that there are scientific
- 31:44things that we can agree to like biological sex,
- 31:46right?
- 31:46But gender expression is a cultural and societal,
- 31:49where is the limit right?
- 31:50So you can't identify as another race because that's just genetically not correct,
- 31:54right?
- 31:55So there are limits to this.
- 31:56Yeah,
- 31:56I do.
- 31:57So I'm really curious where the woke limit is on self-identity.
- 32:00Gender is a social construct.
- 32:02The social construct means we made it up,
- 32:04right?
- 32:04Yes,
- 32:05exactly.
- 32:05So it's completely so therefore you can have whatever identity that
- 32:10you want because you've decided to create that but my point,
- 32:13the point of my,
- 32:14but why is that a problem?
- 32:15No,
- 32:15here's the problem,
- 32:16it's got so out of control.
- 32:19What are you thinking,
- 32:20feeling,
- 32:21just,
- 32:21uh,
- 32:21reliving it?
- 32:24Yeah,
- 32:24I think it was very difficult to
- 32:26try and get around peers' constant interrupting questions
- 32:30because I think that
- 32:32I do want to address them,
- 32:33but
- 32:34at the beginning of that I said,
- 32:35there are two points that I wanted to make,
- 32:37and I don't even think I got through to the second one
- 32:39before that happened.
- 32:40Do you remember the two points?
- 32:42Yes,
- 32:42the first point was that um
- 32:46when somebody presents their,
- 32:47well,
- 32:48firstly,
- 32:49pronouns or gender expression.
- 32:51All of that is a social construct,
- 32:53right?
- 32:53This is something that we as a society,
- 32:55an English society
- 32:56has decided to create in ways to express ourselves.
- 33:01And so
- 33:03The things that what I was saying,
- 33:04um,
- 33:05and he was conflating this idea to,
- 33:07I know I said a race,
- 33:08but what I really meant was ethnicity.
- 33:10Um,
- 33:10because race to a degree is also another social construct.
- 33:13What I intended was that ethnicity is
- 33:16like something that is biologically determined,
- 33:19right?
- 33:19And nobody is denying biological sex.
- 33:22Nobody's saying that male and female
- 33:24determinations don't exist.
- 33:26Um,
- 33:27but how we decide to express ourselves in society,
- 33:29to feel true to ourselves,
- 33:31that is a construct,
- 33:33that is a creation,
- 33:34just like things that are deemed feminine
- 33:36are feminine because society deemed it feminine.
- 33:39Right?
- 33:39Dresses are feminine because
- 33:42women of this society or people of this society have decided that that's what
- 33:45is womanly.
- 33:46But if we look at Scottish culture,
- 33:48they wear kilts.
- 33:49That doesn't make them any
- 33:50more or less
- 33:51masculine,
- 33:52right?
- 33:52And in Asian culture,
- 33:53a lot of men have like
- 33:55flowing robes that are basically dresses or skirts.
- 33:58That's not any more feminine or masculine.
- 34:00It's a cultural context.
- 34:01The second point that I wanted to touch on
- 34:04was um
- 34:06The way that somebody presents themselves to you,
- 34:09it's,
- 34:10that's just basic respect,
- 34:12right?
- 34:13The way that I introduced myself to Jenny
- 34:14as Jenny and you introduced yourself as John,
- 34:17Piers likes to take it
- 34:18super far
- 34:19and
- 34:20pick a really extreme example,
- 34:21be like,
- 34:22well,
- 34:22what if I want to be called Pierce baby
- 34:23or something like that.
- 34:25And I'm like,
- 34:26Well,
- 34:26if that really is how you want to be presented and you give people your name like that,
- 34:30then yeah,
- 34:30people should respect it as silly as you're trying to make that sound,
- 34:34just like how I introduced
- 34:35myself as Jenny today,
- 34:36even though my full name is Jennifer,
- 34:38right?
- 34:38So
- 34:39it really is preference and pronouns at the
- 34:41end of the day when you're addressing somebody,
- 34:43it's kind of ridiculous because I wouldn't call you he,
- 34:45him.
- 34:46I'd call you John.
- 34:47I'd refer to you as you.
- 34:49Right.
- 34:50And so I think it's just a very
- 34:52silly discussion to be having,
- 34:54and it does no harm to people,
- 34:56really.
- 34:57Mhm.
- 34:58No,
- 34:58yeah,
- 34:59I mean,
- 34:59if I were to steel man,
- 35:00where I think Piers is coming from,
- 35:02I mean,
- 35:02first off,
- 35:03I,
- 35:04I,
- 35:05I mean,
- 35:05I,
- 35:05I think I mostly agree with you.
- 35:07And,
- 35:07and when
- 35:08the pronoun
- 35:10sort of
- 35:11topic entered sort of
- 35:13the,
- 35:13the public discussion years ago and became sort of a,
- 35:17a,
- 35:17a point of contention.
- 35:19I held a very similar position as you,
- 35:21which was just like,
- 35:22we're talking about just
- 35:23basic common decency and respect.
- 35:25Um,
- 35:26and I think
- 35:27what I'm hearing from you is kind of like,
- 35:30A good faith assumption that
- 35:32the request is coming from a sincere place.
- 35:35And so,
- 35:37you know,
- 35:37we're honoring people's requests for alternative pronouns when those requests
- 35:43are sincere.
- 35:45I think what
- 35:46Piers is sort of pointing out as a concern and
- 35:49sort of maybe people on that side of the camp
- 35:52is
- 35:53the fear of
- 35:54societal abuse,
- 35:55but also sort of,
- 35:56I think,
- 35:58disorder.
- 35:59I think we're making it out to be so much
- 36:01more than it really is.
- 36:03And at the end of the day,
- 36:03it's really just about respecting how someone feels and also using pronouns too,
- 36:07um.
- 36:08I actually picked this up at my current workplace,
- 36:10which is
- 36:10they had this really amazing discussion saying,
- 36:13sharing your pronouns,
- 36:14even though you're a cisgender,
- 36:15a cis normative person,
- 36:17it helps that other person whose pronouns may be a little different,
- 36:20feel a little
- 36:21less
- 36:22like in the spotlight.
- 36:24It's to help them blend in with society,
- 36:26because if I just put she,
- 36:27her in my title and everybody's got pronouns,
- 36:29and we don't pay attention to
- 36:31like somebody that has like zim
- 36:33or zer or whatever pronoun is out there,
- 36:36right?
- 36:37And it makes it a little
- 36:38less of like putting them on the spot
- 36:41and having to make them answer for it or having them stand out
- 36:44because really at the end of the day,
- 36:45I think everybody just seeks belonging.
- 36:47I think a lot of people do seek uniqueness,
- 36:49and that's a different conversation to be had,
- 36:51but
- 36:52I think if it makes one less person or one person feel a little less alone in the world
- 36:57and it does no harm to somebody else,
- 36:59like it really does no harm to
- 37:02anyone that I know.
- 37:03Um,
- 37:03to call someone else a different pronoun,
- 37:06then
- 37:07why is that a problem?
- 37:08New words get created every day.
- 37:11Slang,
- 37:12any kind of
- 37:13old words are discovered all the time.
- 37:15And again,
- 37:15back to the point that I made during
- 37:18the debate is that
- 37:19plenty and plenty of languages that exist today
- 37:23don't even use pronouns and you can still know who you're talking to.
- 37:26So I think that it's
- 37:27just not really that important to be
- 37:30Like
- 37:31policing people on whether you should or shouldn't say them.
- 37:34Anything you would want to say directly to Piers,
- 37:36just assuming he's watching this and and and would listen.
- 37:40Piers,
- 37:41it was a pleasure being able to have a discussion with you.
- 37:45Um,
- 37:46I wish that you would let more people
- 37:49have
- 37:49a chance to speak.
- 37:51Um,
- 37:51I know that's your,
- 37:52your MO,
- 37:53your tactic,
- 37:53that's great,
- 37:54works for you,
- 37:55but
- 37:56I'm a lot more interested in having a discussion rather than trying to
- 37:59own somebody in a debate,
- 38:01and I hope that the spirit of that discussion continues
- 38:04with any future discussions that you have with people.
- 38:07Any other debates that you may have in the future,
- 38:09because I think that it's so much more important that we
- 38:12are able to open our minds and learn from each other rather than
- 38:15try and prove each other wrong
- 38:17or pin each other in a corner.
- 38:18I think that discussion really unites us all,
- 38:20and I find these conversations to be really
- 38:22important to be having with everybody and for people listening
- 38:26at home as well
- 38:27to glean from what they will.
- 38:29I'm here with Nick.
- 38:30Welcome to the surrounded Follow up.
- 38:32How are you doing,
- 38:33Nick?
- 38:33I'm doing great.
- 38:34Thanks so much for having me,
- 38:35John.
- 38:35Really great to be here with you.
- 38:37Yeah,
- 38:38likewise,
- 38:39and
- 38:40you had some sparring with Pierce.
- 38:43You were a formidable foe for him.
- 38:45Uh,
- 38:46what does it feel like,
- 38:47you know,
- 38:47seeing you guys go head to head,
- 38:48and he,
- 38:49he called you back,
- 38:50you know,
- 38:50so he,
- 38:51he liked what you were giving him.
- 38:52Yeah,
- 38:52it's funny,
- 38:53I was,
- 38:53I was torn coming out of it.
- 38:54It's so hard to tell in the moment,
- 38:56you know,
- 38:56how you're doing.
- 38:57I thought so many people gave such good arguments.
- 39:00Uh,
- 39:01in the moment,
- 39:01it felt very validating to be chosen to come back by Pierce.
- 39:04He's somebody I'd grown up watching,
- 39:06you know,
- 39:07on all the various different channels and shows he's had over the years,
- 39:10so it was a
- 39:11surreal experience to go toe to toe with somebody who's
- 39:14had so many countless hours of debates over the years.
- 39:17But I thought that there were several people who did just as well,
- 39:20if not better than me,
- 39:21so
- 39:21coming out of it afterwards,
- 39:22I was like,
- 39:23oh,
- 39:23did he pick me because I,
- 39:24I didn't know what I was talking about or something,
- 39:26but um.
- 39:27I,
- 39:27I think I did OK,
- 39:28and uh I got my main point across,
- 39:30which was
- 39:31just the way that I think some of the issues that uh
- 39:34go into the,
- 39:35the woke agenda tend to crowd out
- 39:37what I consider to be some of the more important issues,
- 39:39and obviously me and Pierce had some disagreements about that.
- 39:42Yeah,
- 39:43no,
- 39:43and I thought your prompt was really interesting and I want to get to that,
- 39:47but before we do that,
- 39:48his initial prompt that you
- 39:51debated him on
- 39:52was,
- 39:53I think it was,
- 39:53it was something to,
- 39:55to the likes of,
- 39:56you know,
- 39:56wokeism is fascistic or,
- 39:59you know,
- 39:59woke politics are,
- 40:01are,
- 40:01are fascist,
- 40:03um,
- 40:04and you kind of came in hot with,
- 40:05with some disagreement,
- 40:06and it kind of steered towards COVID territory.
- 40:09What were your takeaways from that initial interaction?
- 40:12So I thought,
- 40:13you know,
- 40:13I think he,
- 40:14he was actually correct to bring in COVID because of the argument that I was making,
- 40:18which is essentially that
- 40:19wokeism is not fascistic because fascism uses state
- 40:23power to coerce the positions it has,
- 40:25um,
- 40:26and I was thinking mainly about like,
- 40:28Uh,
- 40:28you know,
- 40:28people using certain slurs and things like that and getting called out for it.
- 40:32It's,
- 40:33to me,
- 40:33it's not fascistic to say you shouldn't say words that demean other people,
- 40:37you should treat people the way you want to be treated.
- 40:39I don't think that that's,
- 40:40you know,
- 40:41I,
- 40:41I,
- 40:41I don't think that it's like a huge burden on me
- 40:43to just avoid hurting people if I can help it,
- 40:46or if I'm aware that it's gonna hurt people.
- 40:48Um,
- 40:49but then because I had.
- 40:51I had
- 40:52tied it directly to this idea that it's not fascistic if there's no state power,
- 40:56and he said,
- 40:56well,
- 40:56what about the fact that the state was imposing its view around COVID,
- 41:01um,
- 41:01and isn't that fascistic,
- 41:03and
- 41:04Again,
- 41:05I go back to what is kind of the relative burden that
- 41:07it placed on me when it comes to vaccines and masks.
- 41:10You know,
- 41:11he was taking the standard of,
- 41:13uh,
- 41:13if you ever get sick,
- 41:14if you ever transmit the disease,
- 41:16if it,
- 41:16if it is not 100% effective in all cases,
- 41:20then it's not worth doing at all.
- 41:22Whereas to me,
- 41:22it was like this is a low risk,
- 41:24low kind of demand on me way of being considerate of other people.
- 41:29Um,
- 41:29so I didn't consider that to be.
- 41:32Fascistic necessarily,
- 41:34um,
- 41:35a lot of it seems to be that people feel that.
- 41:38You know,
- 41:39there's a difference between being criticized of something and
- 41:42actually facing
- 41:43political persecution or repression,
- 41:46and a lot of people
- 41:47just got criticized,
- 41:48whether it's for saying that they were against vaccines or masks or
- 41:52for saying that they were against things like Black Lives Matter,
- 41:55or against trans rights,
- 41:56or whatever the issue might be,
- 41:59but criticism is not repression,
- 42:01and that was really my,
- 42:02my basic point that I was trying to make with Pierce.
- 42:05Mhm.
- 42:06Yeah,
- 42:07I mean,
- 42:07when we rewind to COVID and I,
- 42:09I actually kind of did a little bit of COVID
- 42:11history with someone earlier when I was talking to Tyler,
- 42:15I,
- 42:15I do think,
- 42:17I think I agree with you,
- 42:17that's probably the right place to look
- 42:19because that's probably the closest example in recent history where
- 42:24that argument could be made.
- 42:25I think actually
- 42:27probably the best place to point would be schools and
- 42:31local government's decisions to close schools,
- 42:34which in hindsight.
- 42:36You know,
- 42:36it seemed to be probably actually
- 42:38not the best decision for
- 42:41the students.
- 42:42I know teachers,
- 42:43um,
- 42:44health
- 42:44at the time,
- 42:45and I,
- 42:45I remember hearing this on the radio endlessly,
- 42:48you know,
- 42:48there was a lot of concern about educators' health,
- 42:51and
- 42:51that was,
- 42:52you know,
- 42:53a,
- 42:53a part of the resistance to reopening schools in person.
- 42:57Um.
- 42:58I look back on that now and
- 43:00I think you could probably make an argument that
- 43:03those governments were making a very consequential decision
- 43:07that had some negative outcomes for a lot of kids,
- 43:11you know,
- 43:11because they were
- 43:12missing school and sort of,
- 43:13you know,
- 43:14they're kind of like now the COVID generation.
- 43:16I guess I could see how that fascistic argument
- 43:19could be made there.
- 43:20But then I also hear what you're saying where it's like
- 43:23wokeness has been primarily enforced on more of a cultural
- 43:28peer to peer level cancel culture and and.
- 43:32I wouldn't say that there was kind of this,
- 43:35this era of the Biden administration,
- 43:37you know,
- 43:37busting down doors.
- 43:38Um,
- 43:40what do you think of the arguments made though for,
- 43:42you know,
- 43:42some of the
- 43:44people being arrested for their social media posts over,
- 43:47over in Europe and,
- 43:48and think places outside of the US?
- 43:50Yeah,
- 43:51I mean,
- 43:51that's crazy to me,
- 43:52um,
- 43:52and that's part of this discussion too,
- 43:54right,
- 43:54is
- 43:55we're really having that discussion about wokeness and fascism,
- 43:58or I was in the context of the United States.
- 44:00Um,
- 44:01we obviously have a very strong standard of free speech in this country that,
- 44:05um,
- 44:06frankly goes
- 44:07way further than a lot of other countries do,
- 44:09including the UK,
- 44:11you know,
- 44:11as we become aware that certain phrases or
- 44:14certain ways or certain stereotypes are harmful.
- 44:17If you're aware of that and you
- 44:20continue to do it.
- 44:22And you get called out on it,
- 44:23that is kind of what it is.
- 44:25Um,
- 44:25I would hope people choose to be kind.
- 44:26That's what being woke is to me.
- 44:28Yeah,
- 44:29no,
- 44:29I,
- 44:30I hear you,
- 44:30and I,
- 44:31I,
- 44:31I carried a very similar definition or interpretation of
- 44:35some of those kind of social
- 44:38trends and social movements that were happening,
- 44:41you know,
- 44:42that began maybe a decade ago.
- 44:44And
- 44:45I will say though to Steelman Pierce a little bit.
- 44:49In hindsight.
- 44:51There was a,
- 44:51a moral panic element to
- 44:55kind of what originated as woke politics
- 44:58or wokeness where it was like it was sort of a,
- 45:00you know,
- 45:01seen as like a,
- 45:02a serious term,
- 45:04not a slur,
- 45:05um,
- 45:06and
- 45:07how
- 45:08it kind of turned into cultural attitudes and cultural policing
- 45:13and
- 45:14While fascistic might not be the right word.
- 45:18I think
- 45:19the reason Pierce's arguments or,
- 45:21or,
- 45:21you know,
- 45:21someone like Piers maybe is resonating a lot is I do think
- 45:24that that pressure was felt,
- 45:27you know,
- 45:27by a lot of people.
- 45:28There's,
- 45:29and you,
- 45:29you kind of hear this argument
- 45:31being made now that the left became
- 45:33a little too um
- 45:37Policing
- 45:38in.
- 45:40All arenas,
- 45:41um,
- 45:42and we can point out like the distinction that,
- 45:44yeah,
- 45:44maybe that wasn't happening in a state
- 45:47top-down fashion that much,
- 45:50but
- 45:51in terms of
- 45:53sexual politics,
- 45:54in terms of self-identity,
- 45:57in terms of how to talk about race,
- 46:00um.
- 46:02It became the party
- 46:04or the left became kind of the part of
- 46:05the spectrum associated with like a lot of finger wagging
- 46:09and so yes,
- 46:11fascist is like.
- 46:13Maybe not the right term,
- 46:14but I do think there's a validity and
- 46:16the reason it resonates is because of that feeling
- 46:18that a lot of people had,
- 46:20and
- 46:21Do you think there's been enough acknowledgement of that on the left,
- 46:24or,
- 46:24or do you feel like
- 46:26that's been blown out of proportion?
- 46:28So
- 46:30I,
- 46:30I,
- 46:30I kind of,
- 46:31I can see both sides of this one.
- 46:34I tend to think,
- 46:35and this is,
- 46:36this is just me.
- 46:37Um,
- 46:38the internet
- 46:39has tended to give voice to people who did not traditionally have a voice in society,
- 46:45or who,
- 46:45whose voices were just generally not heard by mainstream
- 46:49people like Piers Morgan,
- 46:50you know,
- 46:51if,
- 46:51if somebody didn't write a letter to the station,
- 46:53you weren't necessarily gonna hear these conversations of
- 46:56what people might have been thinking at home.
- 46:58At the same time,
- 46:59the people that are the most,
- 47:02Inclined,
- 47:03in my view,
- 47:04to engage in
- 47:07internet kind of bird dogging campaigns or just
- 47:10people who are the most inclined to talk online in general,
- 47:13are the people who,
- 47:15Are the are are more,
- 47:17more likely
- 47:18to feel alienated in,
- 47:21in the real world,
- 47:21for lack of a better term.
- 47:23Um,
- 47:24and so you have all these marginalized communities
- 47:26who kind of find each other online,
- 47:28who boost each other's voices online,
- 47:30and who are
- 47:31saying things they probably would have been saying
- 47:33in person anyway,
- 47:34but nobody,
- 47:36they didn't have a way of organizing and
- 47:37of like amplifying their voices before the internet,
- 47:40and so we're just noticing.
- 47:42This stuff more.
- 47:43I,
- 47:43I think a lot of people would agree with you there.
- 47:45OK,
- 47:45so I want to pull in
- 47:47a clip from the second encounter you had with Piers when he called you back,
- 47:50and this is,
- 47:51uh,
- 47:52around,
- 47:53you know,
- 47:53the debate
- 47:54and your argument that
- 47:57politics is a distraction from
- 48:00the more material
- 48:02but less savvy,
- 48:03less exciting.
- 48:05Issues that make a big difference,
- 48:07so let's,
- 48:08let's watch it and then we can talk more.
- 48:10So you have your fixed set of things that you care about,
- 48:12I respect that,
- 48:13right?
- 48:13A lot of people will,
- 48:14but again,
- 48:15Piers,
- 48:15I think everybody cares about these things,
- 48:17but they don't work people up as much and so it doesn't get as much airplay.
- 48:21Of course they do.
- 48:22No,
- 48:22we,
- 48:23we all know that if this was a discussion about the minutia of healthcare policy,
- 48:26it would not get as many viewers as an hour-long conversation about trans athletes.
- 48:31You don't come on,
- 48:31we know this.
- 48:32You don't think that issues,
- 48:33for example.
- 48:34Like the wars in Ukraine and Gaza,
- 48:35get people angry and passionate.
- 48:37If it bleeds,
- 48:38it bleeds,
- 48:38of course that matters.
- 48:40Of course.
- 48:40You don't think war and peace is incredibly important.
- 48:42You don't think the issue of globalization and the
- 48:45impact on people's jobs and lives has not been
- 48:47the subject of a lot of passionate,
- 48:48angry,
- 48:49animated.
- 48:49I think it gets far less airtime than it deserves because what we see
- 48:52is that whether you're on the right populist side or the left populist side,
- 48:56they've all got their fingers squarely aimed at the
- 48:59puppet masters pulling the strings behind our whole system.
- 49:01But it's the people in.
- 49:02Middle,
- 49:03and this is what I wish people would really understand at home.
- 49:05It is not the left that pushed woke politics or identity politics.
- 49:10It was neoliberals who wanted to have
- 49:12the,
- 49:13the current system maintain the status quo,
- 49:15but give people who hadn't had a stake in that system
- 49:18more representation within it.
- 49:20What matters for most people is whether they have a
- 49:22job that actually is able to pay the rent,
- 49:23I would say that they can own,
- 49:24have a hope of owning a home,
- 49:26that they can marry who they like to.
- 49:27That stuff matters.
- 49:28It only matters if the black trans leader.
- 49:31Of a company has only got that job
- 49:34because they're black and trans and not on ability,
- 49:36because then you move into a country and society
- 49:39which prides itself on mediocrity over meritocracy.
- 49:42I believe in opportunity for all
- 49:44at the bottom rung,
- 49:45but once that ladder starts,
- 49:47I believe only the most capable people
- 49:50should get to the top.
- 49:51The people getting tens of millions of stock options are not my priority.
- 49:54It's the person making minimum wage that's my priority.
- 49:57What are your initial thoughts,
- 49:58just,
- 49:58you know,
- 49:58seeing you guys go head to head.
- 50:01Um,
- 50:02I think that he kind of proved my point,
- 50:04cause he kept trying to go back to talking about
- 50:07woke politics and and saying like why
- 50:10that is actually really important.
- 50:12Um,
- 50:13my,
- 50:14my thought is,
- 50:16and I've seen this for at least the last 20 years,
- 50:19um,
- 50:19you know,
- 50:19they used to be called wedge issues,
- 50:21um,
- 50:22I guess they're still called wedge issues,
- 50:23but they find these things
- 50:25that,
- 50:25uh,
- 50:27Can drive a
- 50:28a find a values gap
- 50:31between different groups in the population
- 50:32that might have
- 50:3390% of their interests overlap,
- 50:35but there's this one issue they disagree on and it clouds out everything else.
- 50:39Um,
- 50:40and I think it's interesting that
- 50:43He kind of proved my point in the claim,
- 50:46because he kept trying to pivot back to why
- 50:49actually this is really important and who am I to say that it's not.
- 50:52And I guess what I,
- 50:54what I was thinking then and I still think now is,
- 50:57I wasn't saying that these issues are
- 51:00not important,
- 51:01people shouldn't care about them at all,
- 51:04but they should not dominate our public discourse in the way that they do.
- 51:08Mhm.
- 51:08Yeah,
- 51:08and I,
- 51:09that is,
- 51:09I think,
- 51:10uh.
- 51:11An interesting paradox because,
- 51:13you know,
- 51:13you could say that we live in a a very attention driven
- 51:16world and you could say that you know Donald Trump is,
- 51:19is the most attention
- 51:23friendly
- 51:24political figure we've seen in a long time,
- 51:27um,
- 51:28and so.
- 51:32When attention
- 51:34is what drives.
- 51:36The machine
- 51:40How do you move forward,
- 51:43achieving kind of material change
- 51:46in a political way.
- 51:50When
- 51:52Just through the nature of kind of virality and and attention,
- 51:55a lot of the oxygen.
- 51:58A lot of the,
- 51:58the content
- 52:00will be exploring
- 52:02these wedge issues or these woke issues.
- 52:05You know,
- 52:05what,
- 52:05what is the path.
- 52:07What's a political path to success there?
- 52:10If you're saying,
- 52:11hey,
- 52:11you know.
- 52:13Yes,
- 52:13these things matter,
- 52:14but these things matter more.
- 52:16But also these things
- 52:18Just
- 52:19aren't exciting,
- 52:19they aren't sexy,
- 52:20they aren't
- 52:21divisive enough,
- 52:23you know,
- 52:23you know,
- 52:24what do you do?
- 52:25It's,
- 52:25it's a little bit of a boring answer,
- 52:27but,
- 52:28um,
- 52:28political leadership and,
- 52:30and message discipline,
- 52:31I think are really important.
- 52:32We saw this with Obama when he first came into the presidency,
- 52:35right?
- 52:35Economy's falling apart.
- 52:37We need a stimulus,
- 52:38we need
- 52:38a million different things,
- 52:40and he chose to focus on healthcare,
- 52:42for better or worse,
- 52:43um,
- 52:44and,
- 52:45That that was something that
- 52:47helped millions of people,
- 52:49myself included,
- 52:49because I was able to stay on my parents'
- 52:51health insurance and all that other good stuff,
- 52:53so.
- 52:54Um,
- 52:54I think it's about
- 52:56political leaders
- 52:58understanding that,
- 52:59uh,
- 53:00they,
- 53:01they
- 53:02can get pulled in all kinds of different directions,
- 53:04and they can choose
- 53:06to respond to whatever the issue of the day is,
- 53:08or
- 53:09kind of like what Bernie Sanders has done for years,
- 53:12kind of like what you've seen Mamdani do,
- 53:13what you see more and more Democrats do.
- 53:16Pick the issue we're focusing on now,
- 53:18and anything that gets thrown at you,
- 53:20find a way to pivot it back to the
- 53:22issue that we're actually trying to address right now.
- 53:25And I know that's frustrating cause the,
- 53:26the counterargument to that is,
- 53:28well,
- 53:28Democrats are constantly,
- 53:30and I'm,
- 53:30I'm guilty of doing this right now,
- 53:32saying,
- 53:32We have to
- 53:33sequence things,
- 53:34and we have to go one at a time,
- 53:36and why can't we do many things at once.
- 53:38Um,
- 53:39and I wish that we could,
- 53:40I think we should be able to,
- 53:42but
- 53:42practically speaking,
- 53:44um,
- 53:45I find that it's more effective if we focus our attention
- 53:49on
- 53:50what's the highest impact thing we can do,
- 53:53what's the next highest thing,
- 53:53move down the list and do it sequentially like that.
- 53:56I know,
- 53:57I know that that is not the most popular,
- 53:59uh,
- 54:00approach these days.
- 54:01Yeah,
- 54:02well,
- 54:02I hear what you're saying about like affordability and and we are seeing that.
- 54:08You know,
- 54:08that's a,
- 54:09that's a resonant issue and I'm sure it will continue to be as the next,
- 54:14you know,
- 54:15election
- 54:16approaches and,
- 54:17and we kind of ramp up to that,
- 54:18still a little early,
- 54:19but,
- 54:20you know,
- 54:20this is the US and
- 54:22it's always just around the corner.
- 54:25Something that I'm curious what you think about is,
- 54:26do you think Democrats were just too timid and cowardly when it came to some of
- 54:35These wedge issues and just sort of planning a flag in.
- 54:40It's sort of middle of the road
- 54:42stance on,
- 54:44on some of them,
- 54:44you know,
- 54:46we kind of see someone like Pete Buttigieg now pushing back on,
- 54:50you know,
- 54:50elements of
- 54:52transgender politics in sports or,
- 54:55you know,
- 54:55and,
- 54:55and
- 54:56saying,
- 54:56yes,
- 54:56there's more nuance there than
- 54:58I initially acknowledged.
- 55:00Bernie Sanders
- 55:02talks about the border,
- 55:03um,
- 55:04in a way that you,
- 55:05you wouldn't have heard a Democrat talk about.
- 55:084 years ago
- 55:09or a few years ago,
- 55:11it,
- 55:11it felt
- 55:12to me like
- 55:14there were kind of just these
- 55:16low hanging fruit opportunities to just take a pretty
- 55:20general stance
- 55:22in the middle,
- 55:23but there was a fear,
- 55:25I sense
- 55:26on the left that you were going to
- 55:28really piss some people off.
- 55:30Do you think I'm overreading into that?
- 55:33Um,
- 55:34I,
- 55:34I can see why you feel that way,
- 55:36but I think I,
- 55:37I read it a little bit differently,
- 55:39um,
- 55:39I think that.
- 55:42Democrats are falling into a trap right now,
- 55:45where
- 55:46they think.
- 55:47You know,
- 55:48folks like Pete Buttigieg,
- 55:49Gavin Newsom,
- 55:50you saw him moderating on the transports issue as well.
- 55:53They read our defeat last year as being rooted in,
- 55:57we became disconnected from the American people on these cultural issues.
- 56:01My diagnosis of the last election is that
- 56:042024 was all about inflation and cost of living,
- 56:08and Trump addressed that directly,
- 56:10and for the Democrats,
- 56:12particularly Kamala Harris.
- 56:14Inflation was this awkward
- 56:17inflation happened under a Democratic administration.
- 56:21And so to acknowledge the cost of living crisis would have been to acknowledge
- 56:25that this inflation was a feature of this Democratic administration
- 56:30that had just lasted for the last 4 years.
- 56:32And it would have required a more fundamental and
- 56:36harder analysis of what to do about restructuring the economy.
- 56:41And again,
- 56:42our relationship with,
- 56:43frankly,
- 56:44our donors and like,
- 56:46what,
- 56:46how much power do we want to give workers?
- 56:48How do we actually reorganize the economy in a way that benefits working people.
- 56:52It is easier.
- 56:54As weird as this sounds,
- 56:56it is easier to say
- 56:57to me,
- 56:58we lost because of the transports issue,
- 57:01and let's just go to where we think the center voter is on that,
- 57:05because if we start talking about like
- 57:07the decline in private unionization rates,
- 57:09and what can we do to boost union membership,
- 57:12that's gonna piss off our donors,
- 57:14it's gonna break our coalition,
- 57:16and it's just
- 57:17easier.
- 57:18To,
- 57:19to lean into the culture war stuff
- 57:21than it is to really do a hard reflection on
- 57:23what we can do about the economic issues that really dominated the last election.
- 57:28Mhm.
- 57:29I hear what you're saying.
- 57:30I can't help but wonder though if there's a contradiction there because
- 57:35attentionally,
- 57:36if the average American
- 57:38is,
- 57:39their attention is on the wedge issues because of the way our media ecosystem works.
- 57:44Should we not assume that they're voting based on those wedge issues
- 57:48as well,
- 57:49even though,
- 57:50yes,
- 57:51the issues that might make the most material difference to their lives
- 57:54are kind of being neglected or not
- 57:56getting as much
- 57:57time at the mic,
- 57:59but is the voter truly aware of that or
- 58:02are they truly voting more on these cultural issues?
- 58:05I think it depends how you measure how much do people care,
- 58:08right?
- 58:09Um,
- 58:10if you go by the volume of
- 58:13online engagement around these issues,
- 58:14obviously,
- 58:15you would see that culture war,
- 58:17you would,
- 58:17you'd be led to believe that culture war issues are the most important thing.
- 58:20But when,
- 58:22when exit pollsters
- 58:23ask people what actually brought you to the ballot today,
- 58:28why did you pull the lever you did?
- 58:30The issues that rise to the top
- 58:31are overwhelmingly the more boring pocketbook issues,
- 58:34um.
- 58:35You know,
- 58:35for lack of a better term,
- 58:37uh,
- 58:38somebody might sit at the kitchen table and talk about their concern
- 58:42with,
- 58:43with trans athletes,
- 58:44but what they actually care about is the price of eggs.
- 58:46Like it might make for good
- 58:48Thanksgiving fighting to talk about,
- 58:50like,
- 58:51uh,
- 58:51you know.
- 58:52Gun control or abortion rights,
- 58:54but
- 58:55ultimately what people care about is,
- 58:56am I better off now than I was 4 years ago?
- 58:59Well,
- 58:59Nick,
- 58:59thank you so much.
- 59:01Great talking to you.
- 59:01I hope to see you again.
- 59:02Thank you so much,
- 59:03John.
- 59:03Hope to see you soon.
- 59:04Hoping to see you in there again and,
- 59:06and thanks for,
- 59:07for your extra time today.
- 59:09Yeah,
- 59:09thank you so much for having me.
- 59:10I hope you have a great rest of your day.
- 59:11Looking forward to the next time.
- 59:13Take care,
- 59:13Tyler.
- 59:14OK,
- 59:14thank you so much.
- 59:15If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 59:17be sure to like,
- 59:18leave us a positive review,
- 59:20comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 59:22Uh,
- 59:23you can subscribe to Tubbili,
- 59:24Jubilee's second channel.
- 59:26You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full surrounded episodes,
- 59:29but however you want to support us,
- 59:31just thank you so much for listening.
- 59:33Remember,
- 59:33you could be wrong,
- 59:35so could I.
- 59:35Keep your mind open
- 59:37until next time.