Latest / Jew York Times / Did Bibi Netanyahu Win? Israel Election UPDATE and West Bank Discussion
Transcript
- =JYT 10:29: I actually think even the normal professors will talk about a settler colonial model to describe Israel, but they also recognize that like America is a settler colon colony, they'll recognize Australia. They will recognize that there are a lot of settler colonies, and it doesn't mean that like everyone who settles has to die or like has to leave, right? They don't actually believe that every non-native person needs to leave the United States. So I think that when you talk to people in the poli-si space, they have more of this global perspective of even if we think Israel falls somewhere in the settler colonial world. We don't doesn't mean we think that something like extreme has to be done about it. And that I think is a huge difference. But when you're talking to the protesters who bring up settler colonial, they bring it up in a way that's like we are telling you that the foundational structure of this thing is something that should be taken away. The only way that Israel that Israel should not exist because it does not it because it exists in something that is the settler colonial thing that we can undo. So once again it's like the protesters are having one conversation and everyone above that is having a completely separate conversation. That is so the crazy people, I I'll just shorthand, we'll hug them the crazy people. What they see when they see Israel-Palestine, what they see is the French in Algeria, which is by the way not a settler colonial model. That's a traditional colony with a metropole, which is very different from a settler colony on an academic level. There's a difference. And so what happened in the French in Algeria? There was Algerian, native Algerian resistance, and the resistance got strong. And ultimately, what happens? Half a million, I think it's half a million, French colonizers left and went back to France. And so there are people who really see Israel-Palestine as that. As like the Jews will will just have resistance and the Jews will leave. Anyone in political science is not gonna say that. Any any serious political scientist, even in Columbia, NY, wherever you go, you're not gonna hear that from serious political scientists. You will hear it from anthropologists, sociologists, these academics who are just living with their heads in the clouds and aren't so detached from the reality on the ground. So I do think like that's an important distinction. Living yeah. I was gonna their thing is just being their thing is that they're being crazy. They're they're going for clicks. these are the people that are writing books. These are the people that are they call they say comrade. they genuinely they call us hi comrades. These are my friends and comrades. That's like actual phrase that people use. This is why I could never be in DSA, by the way. It's because if you're in DSA, you have to go to their conventions and you have to pretend like it's serious and stuff. And then whenever they they if you ever watch the meetings of them stopping and starting and being like, I've got a problem and then everyone has to listen to the fucking problem and then you go three seconds later and it's like this person was misgendered and you're like, Okay, fine. And then someone's like, I want to talk about mask policy and this is fine, and then what's lunch? And then everyone, one by one is is is voting, I would not be able to take it seriously at all. You need to go undercover to a DSA convention. That'll be I would watch that. I really need to. It would make me a funny. mic'd up. I would I gotta go there. The issue is that I would be giggling the entire time. This is like there's a performative element to it. Calling people comrades would make me giggle. But they believe they believe that it's actually important. they they Which is crazy. this is by the way, my grand my great grandparents were like in Stalin's labor camps. don't call me comrades. Please. Wait, we gotta start this podcast. We were recording, we have not intro the thing. Welcome to the Jew York Times, 120 Angry Seats, The Road to the Israel Election. My name is A Ton Levi. And as always, I am joined on this limited series that is not so limited because we will be doing this series for the next five years as they go through elections. Shanie Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. On today's episode, we are gonna be talking about the fallout from the election that happened earlier this week. Arab voter sky voting skyrocketed. BB kinda stayed in the game, has more votes. I'd say overperformed polling, but still underperformed compared to where he was before the election. The opposition against him is seemed to be really underperformed. There's now questions about polling and how the polling was so far off. All those stories end more on today's Episode Shiny, you can sing it with me. You can sing it not with me. Whatever you want. Do you do that at every pod do you do that for every podcast or just the ones that we no, we do it forever. That's the theme song to the New York Times. we do it every s we do it every single time. I okay so I wanna I guess with the top line story we're we're gonna here's how we're gonna break this down for listening audience. Okay, we're gonna do top line story of just counting up the votes and stuff like that. Then I wanna Shanid talk to you just about existential feelings related to the election. And then I wanna go through a little bit just more on the specifics of some of the bigger stories that popped out from What happened? The big top line here is that the Lee Could Party, Netanyahu's Lee Kud Party, it currently sits in the lead at fifty-three seats out of 120. The current coalition is now. Yeah, the Lee Could Coalition, which is him and then the Smotrich and Ben Gavir and the ultra-orthodox parties that have shooped together into one human centipede. Of of a block. They sit at fifty-three seats. Remember, you need sixty-one seats in order to and to control the government. The opposition against him, the Isencott opposition currently sits forty-three ish. Forty-eight for opposition. Zionist opposition doesn't incl not including Arab parties. You have forty eight in the opposition. forty-eight on the Isencott opposition side. And then the big story here also is that there is nineteen seats in the Arab voting block. So to take the Which is more than we thought. Which is du double the last time. To give you just the the bigger takeaway from here is that neither side can form a government. Isencott the only clear path to him forming a government would be to working with all of the Arab parties, not just Rom. The did I get that you you Nah, just you you say what you need to say and I will correct you and do what we please correct me as a as we go along. It's looking like It's looking like he's gonna need to have all the Arab parties, the the the the joint list and Rom on board in order to cross the 61 seat threshold. And it seems to be that because both sides don't have a clear path towards hitting the 61, that is very prob is likely that we're gonna be going into another election. That being said, there are weird amalgamations of something called a minority government. There's a unity government concept that's being pushed right now. There's all these different wheeling and dealing amalgamations of government that could happen that would prevent another election from happening, but it's looking like we are maybe going to another election. Shenik, correct everything I said wrong. No, definitely it's a political deadlock. There is no natural winner, there's no natural coalition. So, we had the polls have projected that there was the polls honestly projected this, rejected that there would not be a natural coalition. But we thought it would be a little bit simpler for Gotti Eisencott. I thought it would be a little simpler for Eisencott to form a coalition because I believed that he the polls had shown that there was a chance he would get enough enough votes. That he could all he would have to do, all he would have to do, it's still pretty complicated, will be to include the ROM party, which we've discussed is much more moderate in some ways and much e amen, much more amenable to joining coalition. Now it that's just not going to be enough numbers for him, given the overperformance of of Netanyahu and the Likud. and so given that he would need to, well, there's a variety of things, but it is technically a deadlock. The two, there are two thought clouds, my colleague Gabe called them, which is ideas percolating in the discourse around what Could emerge in terms of possible governments. But again, like this is Israeli politics. Literally anything could happen. Again, most likely outcome remains another election, which I really hope doesn't happen because I will just say the stars aligned. Well, it didn't work out, but everything was working in Gaudi Isaac's favor. So if this is how he did when he had 70,000 Israelis come in to vote mostly for him, let's I if I'm being real. and he got a ton our ton of Arab turnout. A lot of people went to the polls. This is what he came away with. He's not going to get this again. Another govern another election, as far as I am concerned, is probably a slam dunk for Bibi Netanyahu. Yeah. Which helps him in this, which which helps Netanyahu in this process. He doesn't have to compromise because if there's another election, he's gonna be fine. It's only gonna benefit him. He stays in power, runs again. If he's lucky, there's an Iran war before he is to run again. and like he's good. Because I as far as I'm concerned, is the best the opposition's probably gonna do. In my head, tell me if I'm wrong here, is that as much as Starz Line for Gotti, and this was the amount of votes that and the amount of seats that he was able to get just with everything going well and the seventy thousand people flying back and then everyone being so motivated and everyone having a lot of optimism. You know, on the Arab side also, you know, they had so much turnout. They had turnout like they really are the story of this election. The fact that they were able to get nineteen seats is crazy. In my mind, are they also not thinking? I don't know if we can do that again. This was it took a a Herculean effort to get to a point where they had everyone come out. I saw that there were some Arab voting districts that had 90% a little bit over 90% voter turnout for, you know, for the election. Is that gonna make them potentially compromise on some stuff with Gaudi? Like when Gaudi and the Arab bloc are going into negotiations right now, are they both coming at it from a similar Place where they both have, they both know that they need each other, or is one side coming in from a little bit more of an alpha position than the other side? Gaudi Isencott has two options. What they all require him to go back on promises he made to the Israeli public. Okay. Option one is some version of a unity government with Bibi Netanyahu. Okay? That means and that's what Herzog calls on. You have lot of Israeli pundits, mostly on the right, well, because that's who's in Israel, generally speaking. talking about a unity government, which to be honest is like what Israelis wouldn't like Israelis actually want this, where you would have Gaudi Eisencott's Yeshar party, you would pro you would have an Aftali Bennett and the Ariel Apid's party, you would have a Viktor Lieberman, and you would have the Lee Kud with Bibi Netanyahu. And you would keep out the Arabs, you would keep out the ultra-Orthodox, and you would keep out Ben Grimm Smutrich. That is a a possibility. That is a possibility that requires going back on several people. Sitting with Bibi Netanyahu, which is something they said they would never do. Now you could have some kind of prime minister rotation where you're the prime minister first, he's second, blah, blah, blah. I don't think Bibi's gonna accept that because why would he? Again, if there's another election, he only stands to gain. So I don't see him agreeing to not being the prime minister because he has no incentive to do that. But if there's some kind of configuration like that, if you have Bougie Herzog, the president, offering a pardon to Netanyahu in exchange for stepping down, again, I don't know why Bibi would do that. Realistically, is he actually gonna end up in jail if he doesn't do that? Probably not. He'll probably just stay the prime minister forever. So I don't think there's a lot of incentive for BB to compromise in a way that allows the other parties to form a unity government. I also don't want to see a unity government, but that's another story. So I'm not Why not? Why why don't you wanna see a unity government? Aside from anger, because it's right wing, it keeps out Yet Yirgolan, which is the person that like I feel most aligned with is Yet Your Golan at the Democrat team. And it's a right-wing government. Yeah, your Lapide would be the only person who is any version of left wing in that government. And you'd have the Likud party, which, to be honest, everyone sensible from the Likud party left. The Likud party is more similar to Betsal El Smutrich's party and Itamar Benfir's party than it is to Menachem Begging's Likud that he started. Okay? It's a very different party. It's like the difference, but it's like the Tea Party versus like George Bush. Okay. Yeah. It is, it is not the like. mainstream center right hawkish leak that once was. So I'm super unaligned with them. But this is something that a lot of Israelis actually would want because you'd be able to pass legislation on Haredi draft, which is really important for a lot of people. And you could, you can make a lot of changes when it comes to that. And generally speaking, on national security issues, you wouldn't be pulled to do the really extreme stuff in the West Bank. And the decisions made on broader national security geopolitical issues would be largely the same. So From an is from the average Israeli perspective, it's actually probably what a lot of people would prefer. and it's what Herzog is advocating for. So that's one possibility. Again, the reason I don't think that's as likely is because there's not a because all of the people in the opposition specifically said we're not gonna sit with BB Netanyahu. Okay. They that is was like one of their primary campaign promises. This would mean they'd have to do that. it's saying that when things were going better. Is that this is we now live in the current reality here where they are looking at this as it's better to have as You gotta be in the game to to have a seat in the game. And if this is the way for them to be in it, and there is you know, I I hear what you're saying with like B B not having any incentive to really to step down. But there has to be something that is offered to him. There has to be something that is given to him at some point where he's able to backpedal out of it in some like he's not looking for a a soft landing out of here. He's only gonna push forward and keep on pushing forward and keep on pushing. Why does he want a soft landing out of here when you can be the prime minister? I'm saying is that there's no way that there's I'm saying what I'm saying is that there's no way that there is a Likud unity thing that doesn't involve Netanyahu there. He would have to agree to it. And the Likud is very loyal to him, so he'd have to be the one to agree, which would mean he'd have to think that there will be a government without him if he doesn't agree. And well now let me tell you the other option. He would have to think that this is realistic for him to agree. because if he doesn't agree, most likely they just go to there's a good chance they go to elections and then he probably will just outright win. By the way, they just reported this morning that he like or yesterday that he told Betzel Smokter Tim ET Mar Ben Gevir, don't worry, you're my people. We're in this together. Not that that matters, but my point being he has committed to his coalition partners, which are the messianic folks. Well, it does matter a little bit because the word is that Trump the reports are that Trump has been pushing B B to form a government without Ben Gavir. So I do think that there are people that are telling Trump not to Yeah, th Trump is getting the TikTok, Instagram, Facebook algorithm version of what is happening in Israel right now is my assumption here. There's no way that he knows what a minority government is. There's no way that he knows the the i infrastructure and the minutiae of how these voting systems happen. What I'm sure he's being told is that hey, even the pro Israel people don't like Ben Gavir. even all your allies, there's no way that people at Jared Kushner's universe, there's no way that people in Mar-Lago are pro-Bengir. Even the psychos. Mike Huckabee is anti-Bengavir. that is where we're at with this. So I'm sure that he's being told the sensible American right-wing version of Israel would be a BB-led government without the psychos on, you know, in the smother's Ben Gavir side of it. So it's interesting that he is telling Ben Gavir because. when w I'm also seeing that Smotric is isn't being brought up as someone that would not be part of the next government. Trump is not pushing for Smotrich to be out of just Ben Gavir here. Which I do think is also yeah. I don't see a difference between them. I really don't. I think Smoke is a little bit better at speaking like a normal person, but I'm But then why is Trump not but Trump's not talking about Ben Gav about Smotric being kicked out? but on an an ideological level, I just think it's Smutridge is like a slightly a slightly more sophisticated version. That's a really strong word to describe him, but he's just a little bit better at politicking. And so like Trump probably hasn't heard his name as much, if I had to guess. But let me tell you about the other option. Okay. The other option, which again requires Eisencott to go back on on other campaign promises, which so would a unity government, most likely. But you could have a either a minority backed government or a government that actually sits with these folks. but essentially the opposition plus the Rom party plus you'd need the joint list, or you'd need at least some of the joint list, actually quite a few of them, because actually let me pull up the numbers right now so that I tell you the accurate ones. You would need, let's see, we have 48 plus Rom puts them at. Actually, Rom gained a seat from the joint list, which is helpful. How many seats is Rom at? Rum is, I think they're up to eight now. Okay. So that's so they so that's fifty-six with Rum. but then you need like half the joint list to agree, which means they could back you from the outside. I think it's like not silly. Obviously, there's a difference. Minority backed government versus actually having them in the coalition. the main difference is like they're not gonna get ministerial portfolios, they're not gonna get like they're not gonna be in cabinets, right? They're not getting real seats, they're just like voting for you. I think it's a bit of a distinction without a difference because you could have them in the government and still not give them ministerial positions. that's a different that's a choice you can make. But regardless, that's the other alternative. There's two questions that I want to bring up with this. The first one is explain to me just broadly what are the reasons why a Gaudi Isengott government would not be working with the joint list? The joint list has some, as far as an Israeli is concerned, pretty extreme positions. first of all, they are very unabashed, anti-occupation, pro-two states, pro-Palestine. Some of them are more unsavory. I think an Israeli might at least perceive them to be pro-Hamas or pro-October seventh. I think that's a stretch. You have one or two, you might have one or two figures who have been maybe made excuses for October seventh, but I wouldn't say they are like act they're like pro Hamas would would be like a pr a misrepresentation in my view. But for the average Israeli. They're not sitting there saying, Israel needs to be a Jewish and democratic state, which and and they're not Zionists, they would not call themselves Zionists. and again, Isencott and his whole c his whole whole Zionist opposition said we only want to sell people who believe in Israel's a Jewish and democratic state, which Mansoor Abbas of Rom has said, but the other leaders across the other parties have largely not said that. Like they don't call themselves, they don't go around saying we're Zionists. So that's already controversial, let alone this perception that they are like very anti-Israel. And some of them might be in some version of that world world, right? if there's if there's a vote that you have to do a national security vote on attacking Iran or something to do with Lebanon and Syria, something to do with Gaza, they're not gonna be on the side of the mainstream what the mainstream Israeli public, Jewish public wants to happen in any of those security situations, they're not gonna support. Now that said, so the Likud Party will support it. They'll still have a majority in the Knesset, even if they're not in your government, to do that. And there's no chance of giving them Actual portfolios to manage that relate to it. Just think about the ultra-orthodox. They have nothing to do with that. You don't give them portf by the way, there's they're also anti-Zionist, a lot of them. They're also like truly anti-Zionist members and leaders of the Ultra Orthodox parties. And you give them the health ministry. Okay? That's nothing to do with national security. They don't weigh in, they're not in the war cabinet. They don't want to and they're not. The question is: will a joint list allow this? But this is their time to shine. This is this is in they're in good shape right now. So they have some leverage, but also. They just had massive ver voter turnout more than they've seen. their voter turnout matched the Israeli public, which it never really never ever does. they hit let's see, 76.8 percent. historically, they've always come out lower than the overall public. They were at fifty-three percent in the last election, and now they were at seventy-seven percent. See why why this isn't I I just want to point it, this is an important conversation to have with the Arab voting turnout because the fact that they went up from 10 seeds to 19 seats, the fact that they are averaging over 75% the voter turnout, i not to om talk about the American protest side of this, but this element is completely left out. And it's something that is a little bit annoying to me, where you have a lot of protesters who have stayed completely silent on how Politics in Israel can make material changes to the Arab and Palestinian populations. You don't see anyone in the protest sphere talking about or celebrating the fact that they had all of these Arabs go out and really push for material change that can happen. And I think one of the reasons why is because if you acknowledge that Israel does have some form of government, then it kind of goes against a lot of what the protest is saying. The protest movement here is saying that they don't want to work with Israel in any capacity, and that includes. The politicians, that includes the government, that includes Knesset. And that is really comes at ahead. Where if you're silent on this, like it hurts Arabs, it hurts Palestinians. If you are someone in that universe that is not speaking up about this and not at least highlighting the fact that there are ways to make changes for Arabs and Palestinians there, then you you're hurting more than anything. You're not helping out. I'm talking about the Hannah Einbinders, Mark Rufflows. Why is Zol Ron where is DSA? Where's Zol Ron Mamdani? Why is Zol Ron not putting out a thing? And I also I'm bringing this all up because Brad Lander today, he tweeted about it. Now I it's one thing that people So he goes, if Gaudi Eisencott and the opposition bloc are remotely serious about getting rid of Netanyahu and about Israel's dem democratic future, they'll do the obvious strategic, non racist thing of forming a government with the Arab parties. A Jewish Arab political partnership is necessary to meet the political moment and for any shared future. Now tweet and you want to see Zora Mamdani make a tweet like that. That's your example. I want to see him say this was an insane Arab turnout. We are pro voting. The reason I am in the mayor's office right now is because I took a Democratic primary and I surged right when I needed to and I was able to get in there. I it is very frustrating that he's if you're gonna spend all of that time and effort just talking about how you're gonna arrest BB Netanyahu and how your whole thing is delegitimizing Israel and how and and how they're not our friends or whatever, all that stuff that you've said, which you did make somewhat center, not the only thing, but definitely somewhat center to your campaign. You do have an obligation out there to go and educate and to educate. There needs to be more information out there in that universe that there are Arabs. And Arab political parties that do vote and do have a say in this stuff. And what I will say also is that I don't like the lander tweet at all. Because it says non-racist thing. And that removes any legitimate argument and legitimate criticism that it when it comes to talking about actual problems when you want to work with a joint list who maybe has said some stuff, or maybe there are legitimate concerns when it comes to working with them. And I think that. For him to only take this one stance, this stance where we talk about the adults in the room talking about Israel, he doesn't do that. He only leverages it when he can get arrested by the government for going and doing olive whatever, just so that he can h highlight his just so he can get more political traction here. I just think that if they're gonna talk about the election, then you if you're gonna talk about Israel politics in general, you have to talk about the Arab voting population. And if you're gonna talk about Gaudi working with the Arabs, then yes, I'm sure that there are racist, unsavory reasons. Why do these people do not want to work with the Arab side, but there's also valid reasons. There is a valid there are valid security concerns. There are there are valid questions. There are valid questions. And when it comes a lot of the talking points are, well, we won't sit with with people who aren't Zionist when the ultra-orthodox parties are not Zionist. And I also think there's a lot of mischaracterizing all of the first of all, painting all the Arab parties with a broad brush when the Rom party is very different. And I think it's unreasonable to like say that all the Arab parties are the same before this election. We saw a lot of fear mongering about Arabs going to the the polls and a lot of it is racist. There's a lot of delegitimization of Arab voters. It's not just their parties. There's this idea that Arab voters are not legitimate. They are not full citizens. Their votes shouldn't matter as much. And it's not just about who represents them. It's about them as human beings and as citizens. So I do think there's a lot of racism in how people are talking about this issue. And I do want to see like strong Jewish Arab partnership. So like I actually don't think it was such a bad tweet. I hear what you're saying, which is like we want but to me Like a Broadlander type, this is actually the right move for him to be like calling for Jewish Arab partnership, highlighting the realities of what's happening in Israel. The phrase non race is a little much, but even in Israel, you see people on the left saying that this is a lot of there's a lot of racism and how people are talking about it. And I've been seeing weirdos online with large platforms saying, like, should Arabs even be able to vote? Should there be allowed to be Arab members of Knesset? and again, a lot of like lies saying that all of the Arab members of Knesset are pro Hamas, which is not true. I do think there's a lot of racism in there too, especially when we're comparing them to Kahanists who like are also crazy and horrible. Yeah, but who's yeah, but who's the tweet for then? Is it Tagti or is it to his base? No, it's Tagati Isencott, obviously. So then who but if he's Brad first of he's Brad Lander. He's a he's about to be Congress. This is I'm sorry, but it is Tagotti. This is to this is there's a potential one. He has to but if it i is it to Gotti or is it to his base though? Because then if it's to his base, he's calling Israelis and he's calling anyone with like he's calling it racist. I I I'm I'm fine with the tweet if it doesn't include the word racist. I think that once you I think once you put that in there, there's already so much complicated hatred and toxic rhetoric around this conversation. The last thing that we need is this guy saying that it is racist to ask any questions or to have any potential holdups with this. With working with an Arab base. I just think you're asking for a lot more nuance than most people are able to hold. and I also think and I think there's a lot of reasons. But I hear what you're saying. Fine, fine, fine. but I but I do think to your point, like maybe it is good for progressives right now who are usually coming out as pretty anti Israel, to say we support the idea we will we will be much more supportive of an Israel that has a Gaudi Isenkop prime minister that is in partnership with Arab parties. That's actually like a really good, encouraging thing to hear. That we will perceive Israel differently if there are changes. Now, again, Brad Lander is not the average, not like an anti-Israel protester on the street. And I don't expect those people to care. But I do think hearing that kind of language, if we do see a government like that, to what extent will it change American perceptions of Israel once we have members of the coalition or minority backed, but still seismically different. Seismically different. Yeah, I think it really will change things. and I think that it's good to have progressive people who are usually just yelling about the occupation to actually Put out a real policy position and proposal and say we think this would actually make a huge difference and it would be great for for the US as a relationship and Israeli aspirations, which it would be. That tweet would have been better if it included a lot more. I there's not a way to complicate it. There's a way to say, Hey Gotti, totally get the wh whatever. I understand this is complicated. I also see that there's a path. We are hoping that a a Jewish Israeli-Palestinian unity government, we would love to see that day and we would love to work with you to there instead of the criticizing for for Twitter points. I don't know. I it's maybe this is my own annoyance with Brad Laner in general that we're seeing. I got one last question and then I want to go to into some specifics here. So the big takeaway that I got from here, and correct me if I'm wrong, is that Gaudi Eisencott versus the polling underperformed and BB Netanyahu overperformed in a lot of ways. So I'm curious now, if you had to answer the question, who Did Gaudi Eisencott and the Eisencott block in general underperform more or less than BB's side overperformed? It was more of an overperformance from Nesanyahu's side, from the Likud more than anything else. I also want to emphasize something, which is that throughout this process, there's a lot of propaganda. So now I'm like setting the record straight. You're not even hearing that, you don't even know what I'm talking about. But like there is propaganda in Israel, and now I need to call it out, even though no listener has ever heard of it. But throughout the poll, throughout the pre-elections, the campaign season, There was a huge discrepancy between what the right wing pro BB channels were saying in the polls, where they were giving Netanyahu a huge leg up. They were saying this is going to be a clean victory. He's going to have a majority all on his own. And then there was channels 11, 12, 13, the more mainstream channels saying, no, he's not. And most of the polling I have cited is from the mainstream channels. I never at any almost any point, actually at any point on this on this podcast, did I cite the right wing channels because they were largely perceived as illeg as illegitimate. Now. In the end, BB overperformed. And so a lot of people in Israel are saying, wow, those right wing channels that you all ignored and neglected were correct. They were not. Those ch those polls, while yes, BB did better than expected, were still much farther away from what happened compared to the polls that I have shared and the mainstream polls. And I want to say that because I now see people on the right saying, like, maybe we should have been you should have been following the channel 14 polling all that long. Incorrect. They literally were giving that to Niao like 70 seats. Yeah, I read The guy's got 53 sleeps, seats, 53, maybe 56 now. Let's relax. He's not killing it over here. So important to say that. But yes, there was a as as I said in the podcast, he always overperforms. He overperformed a little bit more. But honestly, if if we'd really been thinking about it, this is what an overperformance looks like. It's not by a landslide. He is still again, the optimistic thing to remember for people like us is that he went from 68 seats. Okay. So he lost a lot, a lot of seats. Okay. He had a really clear majority, a really clear majority back in 2022, and now he's down to 53. Okay. So that is like a huge difference in seats. So the optimistic thing is to remember that. And and that also means that if we're Counting the Arab parties, which we should, because Arab parties are part of the Knesset and Arab Israelis are citizens, you have basically 70 out of 120 rejecting Netanyahu and being anti Netanyahu. So that also matters. So yes, will it actually translate into an into an electoral victory, into a real victory with a different prime minister? Maybe not. But at the end of the day, you have a clear rejection across Israeli society of this current government, a very clear rejection. Okay. So important to say. With I I want to talk about a conversation I had with my sister that we were talking about yesterday. when it came to voting. I can't believe you're outing your sister on here. I'll out she proudly is is listening to the New York Times out there. And I know my nephews are out there doing it. yeah, she's tuned in. She's actually given me some harsh criticism on some episodes, to be completely honest. Shout out to Tamar. Hi Tamar. We love At some point I I keep on almost putting her on the podcast, and then something happens, and then I don't put her on the podcast. And then there have been times where I've like, I don't know if I want you saying that publicly. Anyways, here's the story of my sister, who I love, and I will say she is a normal I'm normal. She's a normal person. My sister lives in the West Bank. When people think about the West Bank, I think that there is a huge misunderstanding about what the West Bank actually is. Realistically, there's 650 something thousand Israelis that live in some Areas in the West Bank. Largely they live in areas that are not contentious. There are places that have been there for years and years and years and years. Obviously, there's new chaos not contentious is a stretch. Since the sixty listen, obviously there's a big asterisk to all of this. This was land that has this is a town. Per usual, say what you gotta say and I'll correct you after. In the six-day war, there was in the actually Yom Kippra War, there was towns and and and places that were not Israeli, that then became Israeli, and through that process there were cities that were built, but they've been there since the seventies. Like at some point you have to say, like, all right, this is there's full towns and full areas in here. What? You look like you're gonna puke. Yeah. I'm not gonna puke. I I agree that there is a distinction within Israeli society between major settlement blocks, which are perceived by Israelis as being consensus, quote unquote, which are at this point large cities and towns, and that In the context of a final status agreement between Israelis and Palestinians, any sort of two state arrangement, most people, including like in in the Arab world where you have the Arab peace initiative acknowledging, there will be land swaps. And so these places will presumably be annexed into Israel proper if there's ever a two state solution. And I do think that is distinct from outposts deep in the West Bank that really block the ability for a pa a future Palestine to be contiguous. and I think those are perceived differently by Israel. That said, this is all occupied territory under international law. Regardless, Israel has not annexed the places that you're talking about. East Jerusalem, perhaps, but has not annexed the rest of it, which means that you have moved an Israeli civilian population into what is a military occupied militarily occupied zone, which is like a problem. But even though as like Jews, of course, my family lives there too. Okay. I'm not saying like I'm not this isn't a like a policy prescription for what should be done about it. It's not a moral, But there is a legal definition here that's important. The distinction between major settlement blocks and outposts is relevant in some ways. Like it's relevant because it depend it does affect like to what extent these settlements are blocking future Palestine. And that's a real implication. But on a legal level, there's they're the same. So Yeah, but on a practical level, yeah, but on a practical level, if these towns are gonna be in Israel anyway, there's no way a fraud. Isn't moving. They're not gonna be the where my sister lives, I'm not gonna say the town she lives in, but like it's not they're not moving this place. So here's what you're missing is that is that yes, you're right, but there's also a massive land grab happening right now in which the these towns are basically commissioning all of these hilltop outposts. Like they are continuing to send teenagers out to sleep in tents and carriers. One thousand areas around. And so what we might consider the blocks. Is gonna double in the 10 years if you have Yeah, but that but the thing is we agree and we also agree that this is I'm saying we agree, but we also agree this is bad, and that the only way to to talk about the expansion in a way that is practical is to say, listen, these areas I'll just use the world normal needs to draw a board. Exactly. A thousand percent. A thousand percent. But I'm saying is that when we're talking about this stuff, there is a normal area and then there is a holy shit, you cannot go over there area. Biggest problem here is that Israel does not define these borders and they don't rein in the groups of teens that get to go out there and sit on top of a mountain. Not just teens, also adults. I shouldn't have prayed. Adults, it's and it's not tens, it's that it's potentially thousand plus. it's a it's a huge fucking problem. But also, this is an actual issue that I have when we talk about the West Bank, not with you or whatever, is that there's a group of normal people there that are not going to go anywhere. That when we talk about Israel, it has to be acknowledged that this is an area. Of normies that are not encroaching, and then there's a problematic area that is encroaching. And yes, it is on Israel to define the borders and to define the lines, obviously, but I I you know, like they're there. Like it ain't there ain't move, it's not they're not moving. And when I and when we talk yeah, I I don't like the normies versus non-normies. I agree with here's two things I will say. Yeah that 80% of settlers live in four percent of the West Bank, and that is important to note, and the four percent is the areas that you're talking about. And the reason it's important to say that is because people believe on both sides that the settlements are too vast and and that they will never allow for a Palestine, therefore, like we shouldn't work towards a two state solution, and I don't believe that. And the other piece is that there are a lot of quality of life settlers. It is frankly much cheaper to live there. I don't wanna I again, like I hate this I am justifying breaking international law. And there are a lot of people who move into the West Bank because it's much cheaper, and because there's actually incentives from the Israeli government to do so for a lot of reasons. So, like, this is a government issue. Like I don't want to denigrate the actual human beings who are living their lives and doing things either for religious or economic purposes. I I recognize that also in the Israeli society, how it's perceived is just like not that bad anymore. Israelis don't see it as breaking international law. So even if I know something to be true, that's not how they experience it. And and this is like a government top-down issue. Like the government can can control this, can decide what to do about it. And so ultimately they I hold them responsible, not these individuals who again are like also my family too. And I and again, a lot of people are not ide that ideological. Although ultimately there are actually more people moving out of the West Bank than moving into it right now in terms of Jews. Yeah. Any population growth that you see is just all of the children they're having, but you see more more people actually leaving than c moving in. percentage of Americans who move there though, which is a separate conversation about how extreme how diasporas are more extreme than their native populations. go to stay road. You want to see a bunch you want to see a bunch of Trump flags? Go to Stay Root. Sterote is not in the West Bank, but yeah, is not a I know it's not in the West Bank. I'm saying that there's this idea of the diaspora Jews moving to areas almost to just be like, Yeah, we're here. Sure. Like yeah. I think that's everything that I had to say about this. but I I'm I am jet I'm also aligned with like that this is a I think this is a policy state level problem. So go I think this is also a marketing problem. To be honest, there's also a marketing issue here. I don't know why they call what? What's a mar what do you mean by marketing problem? I don't know why they w there's no reason to call to use the term settlers over and over and over in some of those areas. There's no my sister's not a settler. When when when when the average person thinks of the word settler, they don't think of wow, an upstart Jewish family is going out to, plop down and to settle the land whatever. I know then why do we use the word settler? Why does the marketing community is too nice or too denigrating? you think settler like Genigrated. There's no I'm not not the ones that are moving out out sorry, the ones that are moving out, sure. So you think if they live in a mainstream block, they should not be called settlers. But if they live on like an outpost deep in the West Bank. Who made the decision to use the word settlers? The word settlers when people tell you. Well, in Hebrew, you don't people don't anymore. There's actually a difference in Hebrew now where people say people use a a different I'm trying to think of the English translation of the different word, but it's like mitnachlim is settlers versus mityashvin, which is like it the same thing. I'm trying to think of a difference. But anyway, they use a different word in Hebrew. People actually don't really say settlers anymore in mainstream Israeli society because they don't consider people who live their settlers. I don't know, but I don't know why I whenever you hear Americans talking about the word settlers also w it's we use it not we but it feels like when American Jews talk about they use the word settlers also. I don't know why the word settler is the thing that they've decided to hold on to when talking about this because it is not viewed positively on the other side at all. It's not accurate. I wouldn't call it accurate to why is it not accurate? Well, I don't I now need to Google the legal definition of what is a settler. Now let's let's see what the internet is. Would you call someone who has a would you call someone who has a six figure tech job moving to Ephrat a settler because they want a larger to do what their what does their job have to do with anything? I'm talking about because we're not when I think about the words, the original idea behind the word settlers was we're going out and we're settling in the West Bank. We are there's a a farm element to this. There's a we're building structures. I added in international law and now it is more clear where it says a civilian Transferred or implanted by an occupying or governing power into a territory that is either occupied or disputed. That's accurate. That is an accurate description, including in the blocks. that is still at the very least disputed territory, if not occupied or disputed territory, I'll allow that. And and this is a civilian who is now in that in that area. I think that's a clear definition. But when people are thinking about the word settler, they're not thinking about That what they are thinking about is some kid going and harassing an olive farmer. When you ask an American j an American what they think about when they think about settler, they think that that is it. They don't think about some family moving to a place that's not contentious and just going there because they don't have to pay certain taxes. Stop saying it's not contentious just because it's racist. I would argue listening doesn't make it not contentious. I think that's I think a lot of things are fine. That doesn't make it fine. Yeah, but if it's in an area there is a there's a huge are you saying that there's no difference between someone that moves to an area that is established, established versus going out to the middle of the fucking boonies. I told you there's a difference, but those people are called hilltop youth. Hilltoppers. Those are that's different. There is there are different there different. I'm not educating America about a different qualification, a different classification of this already beyond complex Imagine if I'm in an argument with someone. Hey, that's hilltop youth. That's not settler youth. I think that there is a I think that is a legally correct terminology. I think it's acceptable to use it. What I but I and I recognize that people find it denigrating. nobody is actually forcing people to move there. But just to s just to have to put that out. Totally. No one's actually forcing you to move there. And I agree, in a future where there's a two-state solution, these and and these areas might be annexed into Israel and every and right, and Palestinians who live there, if there are any. Get citizenship to Israel, then they will no longer be settlers. That scenario doesn't exist. We are still in the in-between, the 75 year in-between phase in which like this is still disputed or occupied territory. Regardless of like if a lot of Israelis live there, if one Israeli lives there, or if a hundred thousand or two hundred thousand live there, it doesn't make it not disputed or occupied territory. This does not change the legal calculation. But it might feel different, and maybe it feels bad, but Are we gonna change legal definitions because it hurts people's feelings? It's not a hurts people feeling though. It's a it's a reality on the ground though. It's like at some point, if this place is not moving, if there's huge towns that are not being pushed out, there's never gonna be a a reality where Palestinians are gonna be reclaiming, Adam or whatever, this isn't a a thing that's gonna happen. So at some point, the practical reality of the situation has to be acknowledged and addressed. And if saying, if using legalese To define how technically speaking, one of the larger places that no one's gonna move out of is technically in this definition. And therefore you're using language that outs alienates or others that group in a way that makes them double down and be defensive, even though we know that calling them this is not gonna bring it to any conclusion. You know, the only way that stuff works there is if the lines are clearly defined in a way that is practical on both sides. Where the Israeli government has to say, line drawn, you can't go over there, you can go over here. The unfortunate reality also is that because you call everything occupied, because it's all technical is under this, it's hard to distinguish between new settlements that have gone up over the past year, those forty-two settlements that have gone up over the past year, versus the the the lack of them that went up the years before. It this this idea of new settlement expansion is relatively new. Like yes, there were It was slow. It wasn't it was every once in a while another place would get a nicer sign or whatever. Forty two in two years is not the reality here. So there has to be some difference. I'm not gonna agree to stop calling them settlers. Here's what I will agree to. I agree with Just my sister. No judgment. Just your sister. We'll stop calling your settlers. I will continue to call my sister a settler, by the way. We'll stop calling my brother in law and sister in law that as well for the purpose of the argument. But this isn't about them, by the way. I want to put that out. Yeah. Okay. Israel Policy Forum like On a policy level, actually agrees with you. we to not with the settler thing, but we did put out a policy report recommending that the US government make a distinction between building in the settlement blocks and building in the outposts. Because we said you should treat these differently. You should actually be much harsher when it's not about how many units are built, it's about where. Because you have to think about the practical implication, which is is this impeding a future Palestinian state, or is it not really affecting it? You have to think about the actual outcomes on the ground and make this distinction. And we did argue for that. So I do agree with you there's a distinction. And the reason why it might benefit us to talk about it differently, even though I'm not saying I'm I'm I'm not sold yet. But the reason I benefit us is because I don't I don't like that when I talk about a two-state solution, people who live in the settlement blocks think that I'm saying they all need to move when I'm not necessarily saying that. And I do think it's important if you want to get people to agree that they realize that we know that there's a difference between the eighty percent and the four percent of the land, eighty percent of people in the f settlement settlers in the four percent of the land, and the twenty percent living all over the place. Who we might need to figure some something out for them. which is a couple of different things. but I I I want them to know that I know there's a difference. And I do spend a lot of time having to explain that. So if not using the word settlers can address that issue, which is an issue I come up with a lot because people th everybody lives in a fraud is like me, do I need to move? I do think that's an important distinction, but I don't but I'm still gonna call them settlers. But I I agree with you that there's some nuance here that is important to lay out and it's actually important for getting people to align with my vision. Yeah. I and the and I will say also, past us, it's a marketing and messaging problem. There's a reason why. What are you marketing to? What do you what are you marketing into whom? I'm talking about whoever is in charge of the the the the conversation that happens when some kid in Colombia or some kid and why you're whatever, whoever is like dictating how we talk about Israel and we how we talk about the West Bank, whoever is in charge of making that argument and getting that argument put out to to whoever is willing to listen, whoever is engaged on Israel, I don't think that they do a good job at creating this distinction. And it is weaponized on the hard left side because they know that even whether they know it or not, they know that if they call everybody in the West Bank a settler, then every then everyone is against all of the West Bank and everyone who lives out there, they know that they've deleted all nuance from the conversation. By doing this. And there should have been an effort on our side of it to course correct that and to make a very easy to digest answer back to them when they go, everyone in the West Bank, all of the Israelis in the West Bank are wrong. If you were to ask the average person how many Israelis they think of the West Bank, I think that you would get a surprising amount of pr people that would say, that's that couple thousand roving mob of kids, obviously not just kids, but like that roving mob of Jewish terrorists. Like I I'm sure a lot of people think that it's just like The Palestinians that are there. And then also these Israelis that are going to bug the Palestinians. I don't think people realize the size and how big and how established these towns are. And that is something that should have been projected and portrayed out way better than it was. And now we're at this place where everyone's confused and no one has any idea of what's happening. And maybe that was by design on both sides. Like the other thing is that maybe it is all by design, you know, on the Ben Gavir and Smoke trick side of it, where they're like, hey, they all hate us. Of course they all hate us, and that's why we do these things. And on the other side, the Palestinian side or whatever, the care backed side, the IRGC secret Qatar funded money back side. Of course they have to make everyone in that area look as bad as they do. Which actually I think is a pretty good segue into the original question here, which was my sister and talking to my sister, I was asking her about who she voted for. This is a normy Jew. We'll use the term, whatever. Stop saying normy to describe people who move to the West Bank. Like what do we want to call her? the demo. Settlement blocks. She lives in the settlement blocks is someone that I would not consider an extremist, but someone who also technical ideological spectrum, which you're about to name. Yeah, I was I was gonna say this someone's like if we built out an ideological political spectrum and you placed them placed her on it, she might technically be an extremist. No, I know, but this is but this is but this is the conversation I wanted to have about this because what had kind of She is a she identifies as some version of Haredi. Now, when she told me this, I was actually surprised because growing up, I was like, I don't know, that religious or whatever, but you she's like, my rabbis haredi. So that's why I identify as also the way there's socially orthodox, there's socially Haredi too. Yeah, you know what? Yeah, she's socially Karaidi, fiscally conservative. But she, I was talking about, I was like, Who did you vote for? And she actually gave me an answer that really surprised me. And this is so once again, she has a couple kids out. In the West Bank, th that's that's where where she is. So she told me that she was she voted for what's it called? Mitsapim or the the Haredi the new Haredi. The Haredi public party. The new Haredi party, the one that this was her definition is that she knows she did some research. I think she also I think she said she took a quiz online or something, and she came to that conclusion because she was like those quizzes go on. But I will say I think she did more than just the quizzes. I think that the quiz pushed her into figuring out like whatever. but she voted for that party, even though she knew that they weren't gonna get in and they didn't get in. But she voted for them because she ideologically agreed with them. She liked how they were creating space in the modern world for Haredi Jews. They she was like, it's the one where some of the kids have to do the army or national service. The rest of them, if they want to do yeshiva, can do yeshiva. And giving kids better education. She brought up education as a big problem. that she voted for them. So that was so she was like, I aligned with them and I voted for them. She was deciding though between Smotridge and this party. And that was interesting to me because I was like, that's like a when I think about him, I think about his extremist views on whatever. And the reason she listed was because she was like, Hey, fix the roads out here. And that was a fascinating answer to me. Was that she's voting for this guy, or she was like considering voting for this guy who the rest of the world, when they think about these two thinguses, They think about them in the same way that they think about Omar Gaddafi and Adolf Eichmann. But reality on the ground is sometimes there is a weird, hey, he not to say this, but he made the trains run on time. And that was a very interesting like moment of like, huh? And what did I say to you when you told me that? You said she's not a settler. No, I said that's that's why Hamas won in 2007. Because they picked up the garbage and they had good social welfare programs. I s not to compare, maybe. But but I think yes, yes, authoritarians are good at governance often. not anymore with the Hamas case. By the way, to your your whole conversation about is is she a settler, I hate that we're picking on your sister. Samaritan, we love you, or sorry, we love you that we're making an example of you. But but the reason why the roads are being fixed in her town. Is because Batsala Smutrich is prioritizing the settlements. And she lives in a settlement. So as far as Batsala Smutrich finance minister is concerned, he has been funneling money into Jews living in the West Bank. So he is not distinguishing between the outposts and the blocks. He is investing money in building out Jewish settlement in the West Bank. And as far as and from his perspective, she's one of those people. So I and I actually think this is more to your point, but people on the right want to blur the lines a lot because. They know that the average Israeli sees what you see, which is like these are normal people living in Ephrat and Marayadumim. And they want to blur the lines between those people and the people in the outpost and say, we're all the same because they want to be able to take over all of Area C. So fine. it's complicated. I'm I'm flip flopping, but I feel like I've have I consistent? What you think? No, I first of all, I think that you've been Overly accurate. the whole thing with these, with all these, we are talking about the margin. We're talking about fringes here. We're talking about really this is minutiae on definitional differences between the stuff. So it's like fascinating that there's such subtle differences in how you go one way or another. everyone has their own baggage that they're bringing into this election. And it's just it was it was a thing I had not considered before about the Haredi vote in the West Bank that is going, you know, for infrastructure in a way that I did I really did not anticipate it. And investment in their community is just the And it's it's an interesting like it's a B plot to this thing where like, of course the guy who wants to take over the West Bank is gonna actually, you know, make the water system better and probably So the Jews living there only. Yeah, there was another there was obviously listen, and I'm pro that this podcast is pro that. Israel policy forums wasn't your one your policy does not make jokes like that on On public record, thank you. Let me say Israel policy reform is pro-water for everyone. Sure. Is there anyone that you guys are not pro-water for? Don't say that. We could be pro-water, sure. We're pro-water. All right. here is another question that I wanted to bring up. Lieberman. Now, we have not talked about Victor Lieberman on this podcast at all. And he is recently becoming a little bit more. Of a topic of conversation that's been brought up in this. Victor Lieberman, he's in charge of the my god, what's the name of the party? The Russians. Israel Beitinu actually Israel is our home, and he's very secular Russian. I'm right wing hawkish. Formerly could, leftly could to make this party aside. He is part of the he's part of the Eisenblock of things. He's very anti he's very anti-Netanyao, even though he's right wing. He doesn't want to sit with them. He hates Netanyahu also because His main issue, he represents a very secular public that hates the ultra Orthodox. The ultra Orthodox hate them back because they delegitimize the Jewish identity of Russians, some of whom are patrilineal, yada yada. And so his he hates that that BB has allowed the ultra Orthodox like to evade the draft and not pay taxes, et cetera, et cetera. He's most recently, I like most recent reports are showing him like trying to peel off Netanyahu member, which we didn't speak about in one of the configurations because I don't think it's likely. Is that you could have the opposition block peel off, as they say, convince people from the Likud to defect and come over to their side. But they'd have to get a lot of people from Likud and Likuds are pretty pretty loyalist, but he has been urging them to come and join the opposition. Again, I saw there's some reports also that he had cut off conversations with the Isencott. Yeah, exactly. I hear him urging Netanyahu members of Knesset to to join the opposition. I think he's a he's a bit of a flip flopper. He's an opportunist, we should say. he's also very stubborn. He's like the reason we had three election cycles back in twenty nineteen. So he's not afraid of more rounds. He's not afraid of more rounds of elections. I'll say that about him. He's also very Russian. He's very Russian. He's also the person who is most the person in the in the coal in the opposition block, in the Aizen block, that's most likely to have a problem sitting sitting with coalescing with the Arab parties. And that's important to say. This is a bigger sticking point for him. But he also has very loyal members of Knesset and very loyal voters. So I've heard analysts say it doesn't really matter what he does. His voters are never gonna abandon him. And so he doesn't really care. he's buying to he makes a decision, essentially. Can I can I guess as to can I guess as to why? He's Russian. His voters are Russian. This is like a Russian voting block community that and if I am someone a little bit exposure to the Russian community in New York, I I can imagine them being very stubborn and very We're only we're not voting for I think one in the whole country is a little stubborn. So the Russian points him out. I will say that getting Russians I they the Russians are voting for the Russian guy is what I would say. Unless the Russian guy tells them to go somewhere else, the Russians are voting for the Russian guy. I got another question here. Broadly, what went wrong for the opposition side of this? There was polling that was out beforehand that had them up higher. Obviously if the even if the polling's off, what happened? I think a lot of us were like drinking our own Kool-Aid. I don't think anything specifically went wrong. I think a lot of Jewish Israelis still support Netanyahu. And that's and and support Itzamar Benvir and Matalas Muttrich. And certainly the ultra-Orthodox people support the ultra-orthodox parties. And don't forget that demographic is growing just in four years. You have a lot of growth of that demographic because they're having an average of six to seven children. So ultimately, like it it makes sense. Like It it's hard for yeah, it's really hard for me to understand how is the average Israeli can vote for Bibi Netanyahu after October seventh, after 20 years of horrible policies that led to October seventh, after a lot of disasters. But what they're seeing is something totally different. They're seeing someone they trust, they're seeing someone who they believe waged wonderful wars with the United States against Iran and Lebanon and Syria. It's not exactly my interpretation of events, but that's what they're seeing. And they're experiencing a lot of fear. And fear mongering that a Isencott-led government is going to advance a two-state solution, which is, pretty hard to imagine, frankly. But but with they're sitting with this fear as well. So I just think he still has a lot of support in the Israeli public. That's the in the Jewish Israeli public. Now, broadly, if you when you pull the country, again, most of them are saying no when you're including Arab Israeli citizens, but he still has substantial support. He does. votes from the smaller, right wing parties as well, should say that. was there any on the opposition like the Democrats, it seemed to be that they had underperformed a bit. What what are they thinking? And what's interesting about them is that they seem to be the ones that were most mobilized. Is that they were the ones that when I was there over the summer, they were the ones that were everywhere. They were the ones that were door knocking. It seemed to be that they were the ones that had bigger investment in the grassroots ground Operation. Is there anything that they're maybe is it too early for post mortem, but is there anything that they're Did they did they do much lower than the polling suggested? I saw that they were in the I I remember pre-polling had them in double digits, and I think that they fell out in nine. No, low, low, low, eleven, twelve. Yeah. We discussed eleven or twelve. That's true. And and I think they did like a fabulous grassroots campaign. I think they did a great grassroots campaign. There's a lot of people who like move within the block. throughout. There's a lot of there's 20% undecided voters in Israel. So I think we see shift. On that on that voting demographic side of thing that you mentioned before, I I think Dan Sinor talked about this today about how the average amount of the average size of families, the average size of the Arab families is over three, and the Arab size of the the average size of the Haredi families is over three. And the average non version of that is like in the twos, like the just as regular Zionist Israelis and the low twos. So it just seems like a math equation over time that is not gonna be solved. Unless the liberal Jews start crapping out kids. Huh? Yeah. Libs. get the schmus. Shmishbach each other's that's my were any of those words. This is how this is my impression of of of a rabbi talking about sex in Tech Plath. Listen, Friday night they gotta schmishbuch each other's shwefech. And that was pretty fun. I thought that was very funny. We should warn people we did a lot of West banking. A lot of West more West banking than we thought we would have here. I Well, I didn't think I'd have such hot takes from you. Let me just look and see if there's anything you want to say. no, I just want to tell people what's gonna happen next. What's gonna happen next is that Bougie Hert Isaac Herzog, sorry, it's his professional name, president of Israel, is going to meet with the heads of every party. He's gonna ask them, Who do you want to be the prime minister? And then he's gonna add up the pref the preferences, the the recommendations. And he's gonna hand the mandate probably to the person who has the highest number of them, which really could go either way, probably will be Gotti Isencott, but I don't know. And then that person has to go and convince a lot of people who hate each other to sit together. So TPD. I'm excited. This is real high this is bra. This is Andy Cone. This is Andy Cone producing a Real Housewives reunion special. my god, that's actually the best. This is the best explanation of what is happening right now in the Israeli government. If you're confused about what's happening right now, now the election over. This is the same thing that Andy Cone goes through every time he has to have a reunion special where he sits down with all of the leaders of the different families and goes, like, hey Teresa Judece, is there any way I can get you to sit with Jackie Goldschlager? And then she goes to go over to Jackie and goes, Jackie, can you sit with Teresa Judece for for a taping? And then they both get out their disagreements. And eventually the Real Housewives reunion special comes on, and that's a beautiful thing. Real Housewives I didn't understand one single reference you just made. my God. We gotta watch Real Houses of New Jersey. Okay? We gotta I gotta get Teresa Judice on this on this podcast and see. She's the one that famously flipped the table during season one and was like, you're a prostitution, whore, and then flipped the table. That's a a thing that happened. No, cannot do that. Sheny, last question that I have for you. Yes. The election. that we are currently having right now. Good for Israel, bad for Israel. Was the outcome good or bad for overall bad, I think. Most likely bad. I I hate to say that. But I I although go listen to Iran Nissan and Dispute of Territory. He actually when when I started, he didn't say this on the air, but I was like, How do you feel one to ten? And he said eight, which is pretty nuts. So, you know. I I think that first of all, I I just I think ultimately good. I agree with I won't not go eight, but I will go like six to seven on this one. Only because, B B not winning, and I know that there's a it's we're so far from over, and I'm sure I am positive that week to week as we continue to do this podcast, which is actually why they deadlocked. A lot of people said that they deadlocked because they couldn't reach like a voting. No, they deadlocked because they wanted more 120 angry seats to lead up to the Israel election. Okay. I I think B B didn't win, and I know that there's such a long road here, if the The I've lived through two Trump administrations. I've lived through so much. We had health abortion got undone in my lifetime here. You know, like gay marriage could potentially get undone. This, if there's anything I've learned is that this is slow, methodical, long pro politics is a slow, long, methodical thing. Israel I is not going away. And if anything, BB has been reined in in some level, it feels like. It feels like We're gonna we've the fact that the Arabs have now a a playing card that they didn't have a like a week before is huge. Like it is a sign that stuff is gonna fundamentally have to change in some capacity. Will it be a massive change? No, it won't be a massive change. Just like everything isn't a massive change. And we politically I we've had our hearts broken over and over and over. You know what the when the last time I felt politically happy was when Trump got COVID. Okay. No, I'm joking. The last time I felt politically happy was when Biden won. And that was a very long time ago. And then since then, things have obviously gone terrible, but there's been little wins. There's little wins that come out of this. I don't think that this is the undoing. I don't think that it to me, this was like a more of a BB is gonna be out of here at some point rather than this is a continuation of BB. The country voted Overwhelming not over the country voted, more of them don't want him in there than they don't want him in there. To say that more people wanted didn't want BB out of there that wanted him to stay would be to ignore our voting populations. And I think that that cannot be ignored here. That I do feel more optimistic in a long term tenure, two year, I don't know, ten year, optimistic. Okay. You know what? Sold. I'm overall good. But no, because you're right. The the support of Rhoda and what happened with Arab voter turnout was enormous and really important and could actually change things. And right now we don't know if it will, but we could actually see amazing Arab Jewish partnership, which would be incredible to see. And and beyond that, I agree with what you're saying, which is that like things do change. you mentioned Rove Wade, like I always think about growing up all of the homophobic things I said, I would hear not I would say, I would hear in in my own community and from me. Almost from you. Almost Everyone I knew opposed gay marriage. That was a very controversial thing growing up. I remember a lot of people talking about it and thinking about it. And then by the time I was in college, this entire country, including Republicans mostly, supported gay marriage. It was a given. nobody would oppose gay marriage publicly. That would be like an embarrassing thing to oppose. and so things changed really now again, that was like a marketing campaign, like an incredibly impressive one from the queer community. Like honestly, kudos. But it changed really quickly. the other piece of demography, people thinking that the demographics of Israel changing mean it will inevitably become more more right wing. First of all, that's not what we saw in this election. And second of all, when I was growing up, Republicans used to lament and say, soon this country is gonna be majority minority. Therefore, what's the implication? Republicans will never win again. Once this country has like too many quote unquote immigrants, too many Latin people, too many people who are non-white, non-American born, what's too many, whatever, but that's their perception. Republicans are done for that we're we're now in Trump's second. And and there's a there's a high likelihood a Republican wins again, a Republican president who's to the right of what the Republicans back then even were, and saying more radical and racist things than those Republicans ever did. And so just goes to show like it's very hard to anticipate even what demographics will look like, let alone how those people are actually gonna vote when the reality hits in twenty years. So so I I'm with you. I'm with you, and I'm very much in that anything can happen in both directions. state. The only thing we know for sure is that you can get all of your Israel election updates on 120 angry seats. The lead up. Well, now we're in the election. I don't know what to call this now. Is there a term for the time after an election until like the five elections end and there's a final like we're done? No. election cycle. That's what I call it. Okay. We'll call this election cycle. So we're in the election cycle. 126. Yeah. What percentage chance do you give that? The most likely outcome is still another election, unfortunately. What break it down percentage wise? What do you think? I hate when you make me do this. fifty five percent another election. wow. That's actually to be honest, lower than I thought. Lower than you thought. I thought it was gonna be like a seventy thirty split, to be honest. Maybe sixty percent, but no, I think seventy is high. Well Shaanie, thank you so much for coming on to another New York Times, 120 Angry Seats. first of all, as always, you can listen to Disputed Territories. Territory. my god, I get it wrong every single time. Disputed territory with Shainee. you can check that out whenever you get podcast. Also, Patreon, we got the Patreon going. make sure to donate. Give me all your all your shekels, okay? All your shekels. All that money that you spent betting on polymarket about this election, donate to me instead, okay? and with that, November 5th, I'm in Philly, December tenth, I'm in DC, December 23rd, I'm back in Philly, and I think I'm actually in Toronto next month, randomly, very last second, so look for dates on theirs. And with all of that, as we always say, at the end of this episode, Barstuhl!