Alex Murdaugh Conviction Reversed: Former Prosecutor on How Toal Got the Law Wrong

True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews · May 15, 2026 · 19m

A former Chief Justice of South Carolina evaluated Becky Hill’s jury conduct and concluded Alex Murdaugh wasn’t prejudiced. Five sitting Supreme Court justices looked at the same record and said she applied the wrong legal standard entirely. The conviction is gone.Eric Fadds brings his experience as both a former prosecutor and current defense attorney to the question of how that happened. The court found Toal committed multiple errors: she placed the burden of proof on Murdaugh instead of the State, she questioned jurors about whether Hill’s comments changed their votes in violation of Rule…