Latest / Newcomer Pod / Streaming in Crisis (w/Lucas Shaw)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome Sally, I woke up to a crimson Sky.
- 0:15Wednesday morning to see a flare off in the distance, and I
- 0:18grabbed my son and I said that's looks missed, and it's bad.
- 0:23And he's like, what, what happens?
- 0:24Now, dad and I said, I don't know, I don't know.
- 0:29We'll have to figure it out. That was my reading of the road
- 0:31as Netflix is a as Netflix is earnings report anywhere.
- 0:34Sorry, just start out the episode.
- 0:36Hi, we're here with dead cat. This is Eric.
- 0:39I'm the author of newcomer I'm in New Orleans for a wedding.
- 0:42We all have a sort of ad hoc audio gear here.
- 0:45Tom, what you said you were hiking so was camping for the
- 0:48last couple of days. I did I camps from SF down to
- 0:51Los Angeles over the last few days.
- 0:53I'm back now, I'm back at home. So I do really excuses, but I
- 0:56definitely miss the last week of news.
- 0:58Who's so? I'm excited to learn about it
- 1:00all from you guys know. Yeah, I'm dragging.
- 1:01You back to the podcast when you're supposed to be on
- 1:03vacation but this extracurricular anyway and then
- 1:07we have Lucas Shaw here. My old colleague at Bloomberg,
- 1:10who is assembled enormous fiefdom on his, on the
- 1:15entertainment team. I think he's like the Czar of
- 1:18all things Hollywood. For Bloomberg.
- 1:21World Is Ours inside. The Bloomberg Empire, there was
- 1:25a period. Where is ours were very popular?
- 1:28Yeah. Come up with is ours for a
- 1:29particular cut, exact area that way you could create a new
- 1:33hierarchy within the existing scheme of hierarchies.
- 1:36I'm not as in touch with the Bloomberg politics of the day
- 1:40but Lucas is the epitome of the player-coach right reporting
- 1:45him. And you have a newsletter screen
- 1:47time, right? Yeah.
- 1:48Every Sunday. Yeah, the original Hollywood
- 1:50Entertainment News letter, I feel like, right.
- 1:52I know there's like they're a dime, a dozen these days.
- 1:54But I feel like back when I was, you know, on in the racket It.
- 1:58I was I remember yours coming out, like it's been a couple
- 2:01years since you were doing it, right?
- 2:03It's actually been 8 years. Wow, but it didn't get really
- 2:08routinized until about two years ago.
- 2:10Yeah, well I'm super excited to have you on.
- 2:13I mean Netflix as Tom was hinting at things have been
- 2:17crazy at terrible quarter fun to dive into streaming world and
- 2:22then after we talked about sort of the bloodbath at Netflix, we
- 2:26can compare CN n plus to quit being a debate, what went on
- 2:32there. And if now you're talking my
- 2:33language, if that is the most embarrassing which is the more
- 2:37embarrassing failure. I love y'all.
- 2:39We are devoid of takes but actually
- 2:57they just And in the course of a way you haven't had an outlet.
- 3:01Yeah. Just my kid.
- 3:03Okay. Any.
- 3:03All right, look at what you we sort of, you know, this the best
- 3:07I was actually reading your, you did a great like, QA sort of
- 3:10piece on what happened with Netflix.
- 3:12Can you just sort of explain to people why this is such a
- 3:16seismic quarter for Netflix? Well, so Netflix in the first
- 3:21quarter of 2022. So, the first three months of
- 3:24the year reported that it lost 200,000 subscribers.
- 3:28Which was a little I mean I thought they could have done a
- 3:31slightly better job messaging this only because they lost
- 3:34700,000 from exiting Russia so they really gained 500,000 in
- 3:39the quarter excluding that but they lost 200,000 first time
- 3:43they'd lost subscribers in about a decade.
- 3:45They also projected that in the current quarter that they would
- 3:48lose another two million subscribers so they're going to
- 3:51be down if they you know if they deliver on their forecasts about
- 3:542.2 million subscribers in the first six months of the year,
- 3:57which is really unprecedented in the company.
- 4:00Since it went into streaming, the stock, which had already
- 4:02been tanking for several months because people were nervous and
- 4:06Netflix, it issued kind of a crappy forecast, the previous
- 4:09time then declined more than thirty percent in one day and a
- 4:12company that was worth more than 300 billion dollars in November,
- 4:16is now worth less than 100 billion dollars, which is just
- 4:20remarkable. And I think people had been
- 4:22waiting for Netflix, to stumble again because it had just been
- 4:25this Narrative of like, everything seemed to go.
- 4:27Netflix is way for the Longest time and they finally did and
- 4:30when they did everyone piled on Rise already presented my
- 4:33newsletter you know it's Tesla Netflix have been these two
- 4:37highly controversial, shorted stocks that people always said,
- 4:41you know, like the Netflix case was it's taken on so much debt.
- 4:44You know, it kept trying it invested to grow and then it
- 4:47kept succeeding and Tesla has been similar.
- 4:50And now a Tesla's, like, I mean, obviously there's such different
- 4:54businesses and totally, you know, I'm but in terms of stock
- 4:57market Obsession and And sort of risky growth strategies.
- 5:00I think they've been to stalks people love to talk about and
- 5:04now Tesla's worthless. It's like a trillion dollar
- 5:06company. And yeah, we see Netflix with
- 5:09less than 100 billion in market cap.
- 5:12It's it's been. Yeah, I mean they're all.
- 5:14So, it's an interesting parallel because they were companies that
- 5:18started in, you know, very well known public Industries,
- 5:22Automobiles and entertainment. A lot of the reasons that people
- 5:26were skeptical of the companies, I know A far less about Tesla
- 5:29than I do. About Netflix been a Netflix's
- 5:30case. A lot of the Skeptics were just
- 5:33wrong. It's like, odette's can be a
- 5:34problem that was really never a problem.
- 5:35Oh, they're not going to be able to make TV shows.
- 5:37They really had no problem making TV shows, but one of the
- 5:40reasons to be skeptical was that there was a lot of competition
- 5:44or a lot of companies that were capable of making good film and
- 5:48television and they just had to figure out how to put them on
- 5:50the Internet and in a way for people to watch them like
- 5:52Netflix is technological advantage.
- 5:55Has waned considerably over the last many years, Years.
- 5:58This is where I, you know, I defer to the car experts on
- 6:01this. I it seems like Tesla has more
- 6:03of a real technological advantage.
- 6:05But similarly, you just have to give sort of the mainstream.
- 6:08Automakers a chance to figure out how to make electric
- 6:11vehicles and all of a sudden it maybe makes less sense that
- 6:14Tesla is worth more than all of them put together, right and
- 6:17Michael burry the you know short seller known from the big short
- 6:22tweeted what had come for Netflix would come for Tesla you
- 6:25know competition. Yeah so but let's Talk about the
- 6:28specifics of Netflix. I mean, yeah, you made the
- 6:32point. Russia is some of the reason are
- 6:35a big reason that they're losing subscribers this quarter.
- 6:38But but North America and Europe are both down on their own,
- 6:43right? And that's being made up for by
- 6:45growth in Asia. So there is like a real issue
- 6:49here that they're losing subscribers.
- 6:52You think that's competition is you know Disney plus Etc is sort
- 6:57of the meat the main Explanation there in the u.s. probably a
- 7:01combination of just Market saturation.
- 7:04It already has, you know, they not they no longer break out the
- 7:08us because it's US and Canada together but they have in the
- 7:11ballpark of sine of 70. 75 million customers at its peak,
- 7:15there were more than 100 million u.s. pay TV households and so
- 7:18maybe they're there is more to grow.
- 7:20I think Netflix, the hoped that it would get to 90.
- 7:22But they always ballpark, they'd be in kind of the 60 to 90 range
- 7:25in the US and they're right in the middle of that.
- 7:28So that's a big part of it and then yeah.
- 7:29Competition, you know, Netflix was one of the only games in
- 7:33town for the longest time, it was Netflix, Amazon, and Hulu,
- 7:35and Amazon was and continues to be a less popular service.
- 7:40And Hulu is always held back by the dysfunction of having
- 7:44multiple corporate owners. And so, Netflix was Far and Away
- 7:47the leader in the Clear Choice and now people have a lot of
- 7:51choice. And it's not that hard to
- 7:53cancel. And Netflix also keeps raising
- 7:55prices, and I think there's sort of a limit you reach, you know,
- 7:57Netflix used To be one of its main selling points was that you
- 8:00could kind of get the TV experience, but it was more
- 8:03convenient to use and it was a lot cheaper.
- 8:06And all of a sudden it looks of the different streaming
- 8:08services. Like one of the more expensive
- 8:10ones especially if there aren't shows that you're interested in
- 8:12watching. I'm curious about the internal
- 8:14thinking in Netflix. Over the course of the last
- 8:17couple of years because, you know, you talked about signaling
- 8:21to the street that you were going to get to whatever 90
- 8:24million pay TV households. As a potential goal, it seemed
- 8:27clear to me a Of years ago that wasn't going to be the case,
- 8:30right? I mean they were leveling off
- 8:31pretty considerably in North America over the last few years.
- 8:35They got a bit of a jolt when they sign that deal with
- 8:37Comcast, which got the, you know, the bundled with Xfinity
- 8:39which was helpful for a bit but it was clear that like that 100
- 8:42million marker was just something they weren't going to
- 8:45be getting towards barring, some sort of, you know, secular
- 8:49change in the industry. I mean, how long do you think
- 8:53people within Netflix at whatever level?
- 8:55But certainly at the higher levels we're starting to realize
- 8:58As that at least within North America and Europe, can either
- 9:00more mature markets, that they were headed towards this wall,
- 9:03that they were careening towards it.
- 9:04And I know we can get maybe into the pandemic and what that did
- 9:07of their business in a second. But just within like their
- 9:10expectations of this, you know, eventual bloody day, what a-what
- 9:14was there. I mean, were they shocked with a
- 9:16surprise to the seemed inevitable?
- 9:17Like, where were they I'd say prior to this past week
- 9:21Executives have up and down Netflix, including at the
- 9:25highest reaches, or always very consistent.
- 9:28Believing that their wild growth was clearly slowing.
- 9:31That there was still growth. Anytime I would ask about growth
- 9:34moderating and US and Canada or to them hitting a point of
- 9:38saturation. They would say, well, I know
- 9:39that people love to talk about this but we're still growing
- 9:42kind of 325 million customers a year and as long as even if
- 9:44they're, you know, the pace of growth has slowed if we keep
- 9:48doing that, you know, we'll get to, you know, we'll get to the
- 9:51numbers that we need to. I obviously had a hard time with
- 9:54the folks who said that but it was very consistent messaging.
- 9:57I would say. With among everyone, you know,
- 10:00after this week, there's at least a something of a
- 10:03recognition that, that they need to do more.
- 10:06That's clearly why they're there.
- 10:07Now, talking about a cheaper ad-supported service, it's
- 10:10something that they always said that they didn't want to do and
- 10:13as, you know, and, and their main intention out for do
- 10:16advertising. Yeah.
- 10:17It's one of those things, it's not like, and then, if all, if
- 10:20all goes, well, we're gonna introduce the ad-supported tear,
- 10:22it's like no one know what to tell her family.
- 10:24They've done that at work at time.
- 10:26And I, your His crate. It is a big reversal for
- 10:30neckflix to all of a sudden started saying advertise, right?
- 10:34I mean that's part of the signal here that there's a five-alarm
- 10:37fire, they've been so resistant to anything related to
- 10:42advertising over the years, right?
- 10:43Or was there any hint that they were going to make this
- 10:46reversal? There were hints in the recent
- 10:49and I'd say in the last month or two.
- 10:50You know, I had a meeting with a with a pretty senior person.
- 10:53There about a month and a half ago who used some language that
- 10:57that led me to To believe that their position was changing
- 11:00which was then repeated by the the CFO at at a benefit public
- 11:06event, I was one of those investor conferences.
- 11:08There, the two phrases were were not religious about advertising
- 11:12and then I forget what the other one was but they were both.
- 11:15I think we've never say, never right?
- 11:17Yeah. And Never Say Never Never Say
- 11:18Never And so for this is we're spending way too much time
- 11:23thinking about one company or reporting on when company comes
- 11:25in handy because like you hear that and you're like that.
- 11:28Though it's a minor change is is actually like pretty much yeah.
- 11:33So it did feel like they were going in that direction the the
- 11:36fact them doing it so quickly and by doing it really just
- 11:39saying that they're going to do it.
- 11:40I think did catch a lot of people off guard, you know, I
- 11:42spoke with I don't know half a dozen employees this past week.
- 11:46Who had no idea that was coming. I read.
- 11:48I think it was actually in the information which historically
- 11:50unreliable media coverage that, put that to the side made.
- 11:54It sound like this might have been almost inaudible that Reed
- 11:57Hastings. Called in the middle of the
- 11:59earnings call. Like I didn't listen to it, of
- 12:01course, but it sounded like he interrupted someone in the midst
- 12:04of answering a question. He was like you know and also
- 12:06we're thinking about advertising the next two years.
- 12:08Which I don't know how you know if truly off-the-cuff.
- 12:12It was for him to you know, see the stock market you know, see
- 12:14the post market trading just going in that direction and like
- 12:17what we got to do something and then you know you break in case
- 12:20of emergency and throw out that you know, that line is that
- 12:23right? I mean it's good.
- 12:24It truly have been something that was like in the In the Heat
- 12:27of the pan. Of the moment.
- 12:29Reed was like fuck is ADS. I don't know the answer to that
- 12:33but I think your your former colleague Jessica and I got sort
- 12:38of had a similar feeling both watching it and talking to
- 12:41people that it felt like, you know, there was a there was,
- 12:45they did a press. Obviously talked about this
- 12:47question in a prep call. They knew it was going to come
- 12:49up, it comes up all the time. Their Executives had made some
- 12:52noise about it. It felt like Reed Hastings said
- 12:56a bit more than maybe they were. Planning to say which you get to
- 12:59do when you're the co-founder and co-ceo and executive
- 13:03chairman but I, you know, I haven't done enough reporting to
- 13:06really know what was happening there, right?
- 13:08And I look, you can also walk things back a little bit.
- 13:10I all of us are familiar with reporters of CEO saying things
- 13:14and US blowing it up into a big story and then like calms team's
- 13:17coming out the next day and say I'm like well you know the
- 13:20context of that back none understand we're doing it in a
- 13:23week or in a year or two like you're either doing it or you're
- 13:26not right? I said doing not considering It
- 13:28was that was the active verb there.
- 13:30I'd have to. I'd have to look at the exact
- 13:32language, but that was it didn't feel like something you're
- 13:35walking back. Let's put it like this, if it
- 13:37was considering that probably would have been the big
- 13:39messaging the day after the event, right?
- 13:41It would have been, like, listen In the Heat of the Moment, you
- 13:44know, someone walked into Reed's room and his guest room, where
- 13:46he does his calls. And you know, that's that's
- 13:49really what he meant. And and you know, let's let's
- 13:51not get ahead of ourselves here. I mean, clearly seems like
- 13:53they're doing. I don't think they're, it
- 13:55doesn't seem like they're trying to walk it back, right?
- 13:58It's a huge thing to even float. You don't put the genie back in
- 14:01the bottle or whatever weird stock market expression.
- 14:05They would be especially because people have been speculating
- 14:06about Netflix doing this for years.
- 14:08Yeah, and Disney's doing it too. Right.
- 14:10So we're basically reaching a point where all these streaming
- 14:12services have their expensive subscription tear and the
- 14:16cheaper ad-based here to like keep juicing the numbers right.
- 14:18Yeah it's pretty much just Apple that doesn't and Amazon doesn't
- 14:21in Prime but they do have the I am DPT IMDb TV now since
- 14:27rechristened free And who knows what the name will be in, in to
- 14:31you, by the way. I mean, all of these add
- 14:33products on these streaming services are horrendous.
- 14:36I don't know if you've ever watched any of these ad-based
- 14:38tears, I mean I've watched II knew on Hulu and you just it's
- 14:41so many ads and you get the same ad over and over again, the low
- 14:44quality ads to, I mean, like IMDb TV, right?
- 14:47Which is net, which is Amazon, which is one of the largest
- 14:50digital ad companies in the world.
- 14:51The number of like, you know, pay College ads or repeat it Ads
- 14:58or just it's just amazing that even though these are the
- 15:01biggest ad companies out there have not like developed a really
- 15:04shitty product, which I imagine must be for Netflix, which is
- 15:07coming into it from a standing start, right?
- 15:09They don't have an ads team, they don't have the
- 15:10relationships to build that kind of a product and not have it
- 15:13completely screw up. What they consider a premium
- 15:16product is going to be nightmarish for them.
- 15:18I imagine it was very interesting or telling to me
- 15:21that in that answer, that we referenced at Reed Hastings,
- 15:24gave he referred to the competition.
- 15:26It would it's working for them. So we might as well do.
- 15:28It which is just not historically the net right way
- 15:31of going about things. Like Netflix is always we're
- 15:34going to do it our own way and yeah everybody says this other
- 15:36thing is better but we know more and so it does speak to the head
- 15:40of this moment where the company is under.
- 15:42A lot of pressure, I want to ask a little bit about the
- 15:44competition. I saw that your buddy, Matt Bell
- 15:47any had a piece saying that there's this like orgy of
- 15:50schadenfreude coursing through the industry right now, which by
- 15:53the way, disgusting image. And once I get it right, I mean
- 15:57like this is a company that Comes in there that disrupts,
- 15:59you know, the very sacred and profitable models of the Cable
- 16:02Bundle. And it probably unduly
- 16:04accelerates the decline of the theatrical industry.
- 16:08And they're paying, you know, Nan Market rates for content and
- 16:11they're poaching. All of their talent and the
- 16:14company's fucking led by a guy with David Lynch hair who's a
- 16:16math genius and you know, Coke creatively led by a guy who
- 16:20looks like he's constantly chaperoning like the Sadie
- 16:22Hawkins dance. But at the same time, like these
- 16:26companies, like you can't Enjoy the, you know, if you're, if
- 16:30you're a competitor, if you're a Disney or Warner media, you
- 16:33can't enjoy the Netflix situation for all that much
- 16:36longer, because if they're capping out at what, is it, 220
- 16:40million or so if that ends up being the global Peak, that is
- 16:43bad. Fucking news for all of these
- 16:45companies, right? I mean, Disney's whole like, you
- 16:48know, Bob iger's, magical trick that he pulled off and getting
- 16:50Disney revalued. A couple years back was
- 16:53predicated on the belief that they're going to get to why, I
- 16:56guess now it's changed with JPEG but it's like more than that.
- 16:58Right. Like, they, their minimum
- 16:59Global. They forecasts like 240 or
- 17:02something and by, by by 2024. If yeah, that's not that long
- 17:07for now, and they're not that much more sophisticated
- 17:10streaming. Penetration is like, 30%, right?
- 17:13I was looking through the Netflix, my making that payment
- 17:16ball, dude. It depends on what you consider
- 17:18the market, right? So are you measuring against
- 17:21anybody with a mobile phone? Are you measuring against
- 17:24anybody with connection to fixed Broadband?
- 17:26Are you measuring against? TV households World.
- 17:29ATV, how like, pay TV households worldwide?
- 17:32I think is in the like around. I'm gonna be off but let's say
- 17:36it's around 700 million, right? Which means that, yes, Netflix
- 17:39is, is at about 30, 35? I mean, this shows how
- 17:42disconnected I am from America though.
- 17:45I don't think my father watches streaming TV, but it's hard for
- 17:47me to imagine like the households just watching like
- 17:51regular cable and not using streaming it.
- 17:55It feels like they're totally different get out there in
- 17:57America. I mean but don't I mean, doesn't
- 18:00everybody still thinks streaming is going to win out.
- 18:02I mean it's a superior product and that sort of long-term is
- 18:06not Zero Sum so I'll start with the competition and
- 18:11schadenfreude which is I think there's there's it depends on
- 18:14who you talk to. There is no question that
- 18:17there's a large reservoir of resentment specifically in
- 18:20Hollywood for Netflix because it's success prompted.
- 18:24All these companies to merge restructure.
- 18:27It led Tell, you know, thousands of people losing their jobs.
- 18:30It led to everybody, you know, having to change the way that
- 18:33they did business. You've got, especially on the
- 18:35movie side. You have all these people who
- 18:36are very upset concerned about the future of the movie
- 18:38business, to future of movie theaters future of going to see
- 18:41movies in theaters, and a lot of them blame Netflix for that and
- 18:44they had to pay creators more God forbid.
- 18:47Yeah. But I do think aspects at the,
- 18:49you know, the tops of a lot of these companies there to Tom's
- 18:53point, they're not really celebrating because this poses a
- 18:57great danger for them. You know, they have had a
- 18:59re-engineer their companies to copy Netflix or really kind of
- 19:04write off of its coattails. And if you're going to Peak out
- 19:06at 220 million, you're going to, you know, all these companies
- 19:09are eventually going to run into some of the same problems that
- 19:12Netflix has and that's pretty scary for them.
- 19:14So what we, so what I mean. So this is now whatever week
- 19:17later or will be by the time this episode comes out.
- 19:20I mean what what moves did they take, how do they signal to Wall
- 19:23Street to their employees? That like hey look whatever
- 19:25disease is afflicting Netflix. That's not us.
- 19:28We don't have that problem of peeking well for one because
- 19:31they're starting from a smaller base and they're still expanding
- 19:34worldwide. They're still growing so Atrium
- 19:36acts reported that it R 8T reported HP Max added 3 million
- 19:41subscribers I think in the most recent quarter I've heard some
- 19:43pretty good things about Disney in the most recent quarter.
- 19:46So if those companies continue to grow they're going to at
- 19:50least for now be able to sort of forced all the Doom.
- 19:53The other thing that they can say to kind of to the the other
- 19:56question that Eric asked is that.
- 19:57Yeah, the The, the streaming Market continues to grow the
- 20:00number of people paying for a streaming service, or the number
- 20:02of subscriptions is going up. The amount of time.
- 20:06People are spending watching streaming relative to cable is
- 20:08going up, but there hasn't been a complete cannibalization and
- 20:12there might not be because you still have so much programming,
- 20:15specifically, news and Sport sort of tied up in the
- 20:18traditional TV business, right? All right.
- 20:21And I want to talk about this idea that account sharing is all
- 20:26of a sudden issue. This is Total like we need, we
- 20:30need something, right? We've been saving this one.
- 20:32I mean, it's, it's amazing that they're blowing.
- 20:34Both like we might do advertising and account sharing
- 20:38in the same. Call to me that underlines how
- 20:41terrible this earnings was because those seem like two
- 20:45bullets. So you'd pull out when you're
- 20:47really in trouble. I mean it's not like they didn't
- 20:49know that account sharing was going on.
- 20:51I mean, do you think this is just like a sort of thing that
- 20:54they're waiting for on a rainy day to say?
- 20:57Okay, we can we can crack down on this to improve the business.
- 21:01Yeah, they've been. So they've said in the past four
- 21:05years that there was a lot of account sharing when they were
- 21:07growing really quickly, they said they didn't care so much
- 21:10because exposing more people to the service was head of a net
- 21:13positive. It was basically like marketing,
- 21:16I'd say about three years ago, they started to take take
- 21:19cracking down on password sharing more seriously.
- 21:22You know, I had meetings with people and ahead of senior
- 21:24people at the company where they walk me through some of the
- 21:26strategies they were, The challenge that they've had is
- 21:29it's just it's really hard to curb password sharing because
- 21:33you don't want to alienate your customers, right?
- 21:35So you don't want to actually cancel people's subscriptions or
- 21:38prevent them from using it because that's bad for you, you
- 21:41know, I mean you're going to have you're going to have a lot
- 21:43of people upset with you. And so what are the ways that
- 21:45you can sort of subtly nudge people to start paying and
- 21:49they've tried some stuff so far? I don't think it's worked that.
- 21:51Well, they're now doing this new test in Latin America, where the
- 21:55kind of new strategy is just to get someone who's clearly
- 21:58sharing to pay a little bit extra.
- 22:00They don't have to set up their own account, just maybe you pay,
- 22:02you know, if you're a if you're the your pet, you're using your
- 22:05parents but you don't live with them, maybe you pay three
- 22:08dollars extra a month. It remains to be seen if any of
- 22:10this will work, it doesn't seem very like, rational markets to
- 22:14me. Like to me, it would seem like
- 22:16customers know that part of buying Netflix is that you have
- 22:19this service that you can give to your friends.
- 22:22Like that's part of what you're subscribing for any idea that
- 22:25they can just take that away and I don't, Want some of them want
- 22:29to unsubscribe. Seems crazy me.
- 22:30It's, it's a perk. It's an Express.
- 22:32Understood perk of yes. Dreaming where, I mean, like
- 22:36Netflix definitely played into that for a long time, I think
- 22:38they're even tweets still up there showing them talking about
- 22:41how, you know, love is letting someone use your Netflix account
- 22:44and I, by the way, have been enjoying your Hulu account.
- 22:47It's certainly a core part of good relationship but like,
- 22:49right, it's a don't shave on the podcast, what's one thing?
- 22:53But I also think that like these things just evolved over time
- 22:57and like I remember with With, you know, Adobe and Photoshop.
- 22:59They were like use it. You know, used to be pretty
- 23:01relaxed about piracy and the fact that there were so many
- 23:04young people that were just fairly easily downloading these
- 23:06things, but it changes over time and you have all.
- 23:09But I don't think like the idea of making a, you know, I like, I
- 23:12buy more the issue that it's just technologically,
- 23:14complicated to force people to a rather than like it undercuts
- 23:17the core offering of the service by saying everyone.
- 23:20And anyone can use someone's past what's also confusing.
- 23:23I pay for the Ultra Premium, whatever Netflix is and you get
- 23:26as part of that. More devices.
- 23:29So isn't that I'm confused, isn't that partially connected
- 23:33into account share? And it's like, yeah, my sister
- 23:35or whoever uses my Netflix so I bought the more premium one.
- 23:39So I have more devices at the same time, like is that not
- 23:42already addressing the count sharing, why don't I mean you,
- 23:45you tell me Lucas but like I imagine like that's one portion
- 23:48of the user base that they maybe are less concerned about, I
- 23:50think it's more, the people that are paying at the lowest tier
- 23:53that they're getting, you know, the least value from that are
- 23:55sharing those accounts to, you know, Large numbers of people.
- 23:59Yeah, and I look, they're definitely making noise about it
- 24:02now because they're in a tricky spot and they want to signal
- 24:05that they could. There's plenty of growth that
- 24:07they can get their also making noise about it now, because
- 24:10they've gotten so big that, you know, what was once sort of a
- 24:14tear point of per core for them? Marketing is now a bit of a
- 24:17problem because, you know, if you believe their numbers, there
- 24:20are 100 million households that are, you know, using Netflix and
- 24:23not paying for it. And if they can even convert,
- 24:25you know, 20 or 30 million of those to pay a little bit of
- 24:27money. A lot for them.
- 24:29It's a really tricky balance that they have to strike.
- 24:31I think both technologically in terms of how they sort of nudge
- 24:34people to do it. And I think you're right, Eric
- 24:36about kind of the perception of the company.
- 24:39And this is the tricky thing when you get really big is, you
- 24:42know, Netflix was this company that everybody adored because it
- 24:46had no, it made it super easy to watch TV at home and they made
- 24:48all these fun provocative shows and it's definitely entering.
- 24:52And I think has been for a while this phase where it's a little
- 24:55bit more of just, it's a massive Corporation and People's kind of
- 24:59positive association with it is being challenged a bit and
- 25:03cracking down on 1password sharing.
- 25:05And the way that they've messaged around it, I think
- 25:07doesn't help either because you have a lot of people who think
- 25:09that they're suddenly going to get cut off tomorrow.
- 25:12And that's not what's going to happen.
- 25:14I did want to ask, I guess, sort of about the Netflix brand or
- 25:19you know, if we're in this world where Netflix can't really say,
- 25:22okay, we're just going to be the big one.
- 25:24And instead, it's competing more as a peer against Disney Hulu
- 25:29Apple, Amazon. Obviously, they're all different
- 25:32size HBO Max. I mean, is Netflix going to have
- 25:36more of like a brand? Like I don't know what I
- 25:39associate Netflix with. Like where is Disney is able to
- 25:43say somehow? I mean this is what's amazing
- 25:45about Disney but Disney's able to be enormous and still have
- 25:49these iconic Brands where you understand what Disney is about
- 25:52and why you might subscribe. Like, do you see Netflix moving
- 25:55in terms of the actual sort of Content to any sort of thematic
- 26:00bundling. So people understand, do you?
- 26:02Netflix is about this or, or do they just want to be the sort of
- 26:06vague brand? That's like, everything for
- 26:09everybody will teach you. Your first point, I do think
- 26:13it's important to put into context.
- 26:14That Netflix is still magnitudes bigger than everyone else.
- 26:18I mean, you know, just in terms of subscribers, Netflix is
- 26:20bigger than Disney plus an HBO Max put together.
- 26:23Yeah. And so, the amount of viewership
- 26:25that it generates the amount of time people spend, it still
- 26:27dwarfs the Competition, but it does have.
- 26:31It does come at come at this, from a disadvantage in that, it
- 26:35doesn't have a long Legacy of making shows and owning things
- 26:39that people love. You know, Bob Iger bought a lot
- 26:42of the great brands that now constitute that kind of that
- 26:45Disney offering with Marvel Stars Star Wars and Pixar before
- 26:48Netflix had a streaming service. And so Netflix would sure would
- 26:52love to be able to have its own Marvel.
- 26:54It's not easy. Every, every studio in Hollywood
- 26:57wants to have their own Marvel. They haven't been able to do it,
- 26:59but it doesn't have many Brands like that, right?
- 27:01I mean, it's name. Yeah, I mean, this has been a
- 27:03debate that I've heard a lot between kind of current and
- 27:07former Netflix. People is like, should they
- 27:10because I think early on, they kind of identified these these
- 27:13different niches and kind of soup served them.
- 27:18And there are some people who wish that Netflix just like took
- 27:21that and owned it. But I think as Netflix got
- 27:23bigger and bigger and bigger. Oh, just like, well, let's do
- 27:25this. And let's do this.
- 27:26And let's do this. And let's just replicate
- 27:27everything. You could find in TV and, and
- 27:30that has, I think deluded the brand a bit because you're not
- 27:34sure there's this constant dialogue right about like, is
- 27:38quality on Netflix there. A lot of people who think that
- 27:40Netflix doesn't make good shows anymore and I get why they say
- 27:42that I even as a consumer probably blind is the greatest
- 27:46show of all time. What do you do?
- 27:47Yeah. Well, but see that's that's sort
- 27:49of what you're getting at. Right, is all these, all these
- 27:51kind of dating shows. They were hugely popular are not
- 27:54anyone's definition of quality, but I was at a I was at a You
- 27:58know, a birthday party on Friday night.
- 28:00And someone was telling me all about how they think the quality
- 28:03of Netflix has gone way down. And then that proceed or that
- 28:06precipitated like a 10-minute conversation between people
- 28:10about how much they love the ultimatum.
- 28:11Right? And so you can't you can't have
- 28:13it both ways. And, and Netflix has to figure
- 28:15out sort of the right balance of programming where they're sort
- 28:18of satisfying that big audience while also and maintaining this
- 28:23perception, that you can find really good programming there
- 28:25because there is some of it, maybe not at the same.
- 28:28Same rate as HBO or maybe you don't feel it as much because
- 28:31they drop everything at once. But there's still a lot of stuff
- 28:33on Netflix to watch it sort of two parts to that to keep coming
- 28:37to mind. One is like, let's not pretend
- 28:39here that have Netflix had run Severance, or, I don't know, the
- 28:43undoing or some, you know, of the White Lotus or something
- 28:46that they suddenly would have had three million more subs
- 28:48gained during the quarter. You know, obviously it would be
- 28:51nice temperature for Netflix to have those kind of hit, water
- 28:54cooler, whatever you want to call them shows.
- 28:55But that we're talking about a secular problem here.
- 28:58Now, so much that, like, you know, they didn't have an
- 29:01out-of-the-box enormous hit. And the other thing on the IP
- 29:04side, it's very funny for me to hear and I know you're talking
- 29:08about just, you know, the general populace complaining
- 29:11about quality of shows. If this is coming from
- 29:13high-level Executives at rival movie studios, why don't you
- 29:16guys develop some new IP and not just keep spinning off?
- 29:19You know, content that was created in the 70s and and 60s,
- 29:24and comic books and and Star Wars and Pixar, you know, things
- 29:27that you acquired, It's been a long time that I can remember
- 29:31that. A completely unique,
- 29:32out-of-the-box, huge piece of IP came from anyone these days.
- 29:36Well, they have. And if it did it, it probably
- 29:39came from Netflix. I mean the biggest new projects
- 29:43that maybe not in the movie side, but, you know, the biggest
- 29:46show of last year with Squid game, that's a totally new idea.
- 29:49It's from South Korea, like unlike anything that Hollywood
- 29:51is churning out or a la casa. De papel money, Heist, huge show
- 29:56from Spain for Netflix, A original Ip.
- 29:59I think someone will probably tell me if that's not true,
- 30:01right? You know, and then more
- 30:03traditional stuff like the witcher's video game and Bridget
- 30:05in is based on some books. But at least those are our sort
- 30:09of relatively new. It's yeah.
- 30:10You know, movies that were made in the 70s that they're still
- 30:13claiming as I go through. This is original Ip that we have
- 30:15it's like no not really. You guys are just kind of like
- 30:17mining further and further something that was made decades
- 30:20ago. Yeah, to an audience that wants
- 30:21it but it wouldn't call it new well and that's especially true
- 30:24on the movie site and fairness on the TV side.
- 30:26You know, HBO produces a lot of Original ideas.
- 30:29I think there are, I mean it's Disney plus obviously is still
- 30:32sort of the Marvel and Star Wars Factory but that's working so
- 30:35well for them. You know why deviate who lubed
- 30:37also has a lot of new original ideas.
- 30:39It's on the movie side where you know, we've just settled into if
- 30:43it's not a pre branded franchise, we have a hard time
- 30:45but the movie stuff is also driving the TV stuff, right?
- 30:48I mean with Disney plus? It seems like the most attention
- 30:50they get her from serialized versions of their movie
- 30:53properties. So it's sort of like all kind of
- 30:56one in the same thing when it comes to, you know.
- 30:58What original Ip Drive Subs. As far as that goes.
- 31:00Yeah, we're about to talk about CNN plus and B, as we can always
- 31:04go back and forth and this is the topic.
- 31:05Everybody wants to hear about. But before that, I wanted to ask
- 31:08one question, sort of out of left field, but just because
- 31:12we're talking about Disney and Marvel, I'm curious like this
- 31:16sort of Marvel sort of cheaply, produced shows or content, you
- 31:22know just the lower budget Marvel at the moment.
- 31:24Like is that a realization that like the Marvel Brand?
- 31:28They need to like squeeze everything out of it while they
- 31:30can like it feels like I guess if I were Disney and trying to
- 31:34preserve Marvel, like one strategy would be like cool
- 31:38little little. Make sure it like has longevity
- 31:41and the other would be like actually.
- 31:42Let's get every dollar out of it.
- 31:44We can and just like do everything until people get sick
- 31:48of this or or I guess the third is just that I'm so disconnected
- 31:51from reality and everybody loves Marvel so much that this will
- 31:54never never end. I don't know if you were to
- 31:57what's your view Of sort of how, they're how they're treating
- 32:00sort of the Marvel. Marvel in terms of, it's sort of
- 32:03continued sustainability. It's the most popular vein of
- 32:08Storytelling in the world. And it seems that every time we
- 32:11talk about superhero fatigue, something else comes along to
- 32:14prove to us that we're all wrong, you know?
- 32:16The new Spider-Man movie, you'd think that we're all a little
- 32:19tired of Spider-Man and then it goes on to be one of the most
- 32:21successful movies of all time. Those the the different shows on
- 32:25Disney plus including kind of Vision Loki, they seem very,
- 32:30very popular. You know, they're not cheap by
- 32:32the way. Eric, those stars look like a
- 32:33turtle's was cheaper. Some of them are cheaper than
- 32:37the others right there on a relative rollout, baby.
- 32:39But I think they're all pretty expensive and Disney.
- 32:42Just feels like, you know, it's going to keep playing its cards
- 32:46and keep playing to its strength until someone tells them, they
- 32:48can't anymore. I'm because they right.
- 32:50Look, they re being the wars are extremely quarters.
- 32:52You gotta, you gotta use your entire Arsenal.
- 32:54They ran into this with, with Star Wars, right?
- 32:56It's like there were, there was a A sense that maybe on the
- 32:59movie side, there was a little bit of fatigue.
- 33:01And so they have held off on just churning out new Star Wars
- 33:04movies, but they had a lot of success with the Mandalorian and
- 33:08TV. And so now that's turned towards
- 33:10up, you'll just hate bad ones and like good ones.
- 33:12And as long as they're good, you can keep pumping.
- 33:15Maybe can I ask one one final question on this segment to sort
- 33:18of end it? Yeah, I mean, going forward
- 33:21cover in this company. Lucas, are you now think about
- 33:24things like Netflix? Yeah.
- 33:25Yeah. Are you thinking about things
- 33:27differently at all? I mean, It's obviously a new
- 33:29era. And, you know, I think one
- 33:32aspect of what exactly this company is.
- 33:34There's been a lot of stories I've written them.
- 33:36I'm sure you have a lot of people have of like, you know,
- 33:38is Netflix moving from a tech company to an entertainment
- 33:40company. And the center of gravity is
- 33:42moved from whatever, blows Gatos to Hollywood and all of that
- 33:46stuff and, you know, we're in a position now where people are
- 33:48saying that like, oh, Netflix missed its numbers because it
- 33:51didn't have any big hits. Like, oh, that's kind of
- 33:53familiar. I know what happens when
- 33:55entertainment companies don't have big hits, they about
- 33:56quarter that just sounds But you're kind of just an
- 33:58entertainment company. You're obviously, you get this
- 34:01company very well and the sophistication behind it.
- 34:04But, do you think about them differently at all?
- 34:06Now, is this a different way to? Or at least he'll reader is a
- 34:09different way to look at this company than the way they may
- 34:11have in the past. I mean, I felt for a while that
- 34:13it was, it was more of an entertainment company than a
- 34:16tech company. You know, as soon as, as soon as
- 34:19they started spending, you know, five six times more on
- 34:22programming than they did on than they do in engineering when
- 34:25the all the hiring they were doing was in l.a. all their
- 34:27senior leadership. Up either moved to LA or had to
- 34:30spend a lot of time there. I mean, their CFO left basically
- 34:32because their CFO didn't want to move or the previous one, didn't
- 34:35want to move to Los Angeles wasn't the only reason but it
- 34:37was a major factor and so that is not what changes.
- 34:41I do think though that we're entering a period of kind of a
- 34:46new period of perhaps skepticism about the company and where
- 34:51there's going to be a lot of you know, probably a lot of internal
- 34:56unrest and hand-wringing About where it's going.
- 34:59And I think it'll be a pretty fertile time actually for
- 35:01storytelling about and the culture, right?
- 35:03Letting can you keep running the company and that aggressive, you
- 35:07know, internal criticism, shut Sunshine, everything sort of way
- 35:10that you know if you're not exactly the Cock of the Walk,
- 35:13might not be that easy to do the company's gotten really big
- 35:16really quickly and it's hard to preserve that culture and so I
- 35:22think that's that was already a problem.
- 35:24It was a problem internationally, you know, they
- 35:25had a really hard time. Getting people say in Japan.
- 35:28And which is has a very different kind of corporate
- 35:30sensibility to live by this Netflix culture, where you you
- 35:34weren't going to have it was hard to get, say, someone who
- 35:37was at a lower position in Japan, to be honest and
- 35:41criticize, their Superior that just was, is kind of very
- 35:44foreign to that country and you had problems like that, play out
- 35:47all over the world and I also think that as there's been this
- 35:50very steady influx of Hollywood people into Netflix and rising
- 35:54up, you know, it's hard for it, not to just start operating.
- 35:58I'm feeling like another Hollywood company.
- 36:00You know, my sort of take away right now, is it?
- 36:02Just Netflix? Felt like a special place to a
- 36:04lot of people for a long time and there were good, there was
- 36:06good and bad to that. And I think now it just feels a
- 36:09little bit more normal. Like a big company, something
- 36:12said about that, we're all, we're all just the same in the
- 36:14end, it all just kind of like dilutes to the mean II know.
- 36:17On the it's like we have two more in this like brutal culture
- 36:20where people get fired and they're like, yeah, I deserved
- 36:23it. Like I wasn't my Prime, they got
- 36:25my prime years out of me, and then they treated me like trash
- 36:28Shouldn't the best company in the world.
- 36:30I mean, I I interesting admire it, I am laughing, but it's,
- 36:34it's definitely get those conversations with with former
- 36:37Netflix people that will talk about, you know, the trauma that
- 36:39they went through dealing with the direct criticism and how
- 36:42many hours, they worked and all of that.
- 36:43But they don't speak ill of the company.
- 36:45They don't necessarily need some do obviously and those stories
- 36:48get written in there. Really interesting.
- 36:50But a lot of people it's just like, yeah, fucking insane over
- 36:52there, but I don't know. It seems to work and I like the
- 36:54work I did over there. I mean, is it is amazing?
- 36:57I mean, there's still Will you know I saw in this quarterly
- 37:00earnings they were still talking about like the fight with
- 37:03Blockbuster and stuff. I mean just just everything.
- 37:05Netflix has been able to do. I mean they wear that history on
- 37:08its sleeve and that that's given them some protection.
- 37:13Certainly in this hard time for them.
- 37:16But yeah. We'll see if that that last.
- 37:19Well this is it. Yeah I think there's a degree to
- 37:21which you know, Reed Hastings is one of the hand of the great
- 37:25entrepreneurs of the last 25 years, shall we say, a few, To
- 37:28make a list of the 10 best you probably be on it somewhere, but
- 37:32this is now sort of his legacy, right?
- 37:34As I think he was maybe ready to, you know, he'd made tedster
- 37:38and us the co-ceo. There was some assumption that
- 37:41some point in the next few years, he might just move up to
- 37:43being chairman and not be in their day-to-day anymore, that
- 37:47it's kind of harder for him to step away.
- 37:48Now, listen, if there's anything, we've learned from
- 37:50Disney, Hollywood, people don't just like, give you the edge.
- 37:53I feel like every anyway. That's a well, the Disney thing
- 37:56is a good comparison to As I mean, Iger was in a somewhat
- 37:59similar situation, right? Like he was set to walk off into
- 38:02the sunset and then Disney plus becomes a priority and decides
- 38:05to extend for a couple more years one because he's clearly
- 38:09addicted to the job and is you know, Tom Brady like terrified
- 38:12of what he would do after it. But also because it's like, you
- 38:15know, my legacy of buying up all this great IP of building Disney
- 38:19into a behemoth at a time where everyone else was shrinking.
- 38:22I can't just leave at this moment that we have the most
- 38:25important initiative in the last couple decades to you.
- 38:28To be launched and then covid hits and they have that awful
- 38:30earnings call anyway. Yeah, it's interesting how much
- 38:33these things end up being similar to each other.
- 38:35All right. Lucas.
- 38:35You want CN n? Plus, I want to let you, you
- 38:38frame it up because, you know, better than I, I cannot unless I
- 38:42know you've been focused more on the Netflix story but are you
- 38:45willing to sort of set the stage, the old head of CNN, Jeff
- 38:48soccer since deposed decided that to kind of bring this Cable
- 38:53News Network into the future. They needed a paid streaming
- 38:55service. Of course, for the Plus at the
- 38:57end of the name, Cuz that's what every streaming service does.
- 39:00And even though he was sort of ousted, right before the service
- 39:03came out, his then boss also since the pose or since I was 2,
- 39:06Jason Clark, I'll are out of brings this thing out right
- 39:10before Warner media. And Carl are was a Believer, and
- 39:14CN n plus. That's the sentence, right?
- 39:16Yes. So, they Warner media and
- 39:19Discovery are set of set to merge, but they want to rush CN
- 39:22n plus out the door before that happens.
- 39:25Both because they, you know, believe, And because they want
- 39:29to try, they figure if they get it out that the discovery people
- 39:31can't kill it and yet it took just one month for the discovery
- 39:35people to kill it. Is basically what happened.
- 39:38I mean, it this does feel very much like Quimby and who thought
- 39:41this was going to work. I really don't get the query
- 39:44comparisons. Oh, really?
- 39:45Yeah, gonna get into that. I mean, what do I think?
- 39:49Will be comparisons are the sort of self-evident launching a
- 39:52service where who has the intuition that there's demand
- 39:56for this product obviously the Formats are so different.
- 39:59Tom, you're like, I don't really have a billion dollars on this.
- 40:02No, I finish your thought. I'm just making faces.
- 40:06Well, yeah, I mean they're very different Services obviously but
- 40:10it's spend a lot of money to hire talent for a type of
- 40:17content that people are skeptical about on quippy.
- 40:21It's like, okay, we're inventing a format on CN n.
- 40:24Plus it's the idea that people are going to just subscribe For
- 40:28I mean you mentioned earlier in this conversation that you know
- 40:31there isn't there hasn't been sort of evidence of sort of
- 40:34stand-alone news interest. You're somebody's going to say
- 40:38that fox has had some success there but no not really though.
- 40:41I don't think the fox dreaming. That whatever.
- 40:43What is it called? Fox show talking about Nation,
- 40:45Fox Nation. I don't cover this shit before
- 40:48so I'm not up to date on the numbers.
- 40:49I don't think it's killing it. It's like okay, right?
- 40:51They haven't disclosed. Yeah, I think the similarity is
- 40:54that they both spent a bunch of money to create a Aid Service,
- 40:58that offered something that people can get for free in a lot
- 41:01of other places. The Quimby idea, never made
- 41:04sense to me, because they were basically saying we're going to
- 41:07take, we're going to make, you know, TV quality shows but at,
- 41:12you know, YouTube length and it's like, okay, but people and
- 41:15there is this inference that YouTube was not quality but
- 41:18people really, really love you too bright.
- 41:21So you didn't need and paid version of that and also people
- 41:25really, really love Netflix and they didn't need Their Netflix
- 41:28shows chopped up into nine minute and there's no part of
- 41:31that. And I usually, YouTube creators
- 41:32are responsive to what their customers want.
- 41:37Where as quippy was just like a top-down product where it was
- 41:40like, Hollywood says, like we know right?
- 41:44What? Yeah, I guess, here's where I
- 41:46would say the similarities and Divergence has our quippy is a
- 41:50classic Hollywood approach to a digital product.
- 41:52It's Jeffrey katzenberg seeing you to being like, well, this
- 41:55stuff isn't very good. It has no stars in And the
- 41:58Prussian quality is really bad. But what if we put huge Stars,
- 42:01what do you put the rock or or Kevin Hart in these things?
- 42:04And we have the same, you know, content length which is clearly.
- 42:07What the only reason people watch it is because it's short
- 42:09which like know and and it was a very yeah, like you said
- 42:12top-down approach, a Hollywood focus on what they think.
- 42:15Historically is worked. I think CNN my guests here is
- 42:19that it was partly X naught existential for them but they
- 42:23needed a digital play. That was more than just having
- 42:26videos posted on the Website and a social media presence, right?
- 42:30Like they were like, well, we're, you know, we're going to
- 42:32keep losing Subs here and let's just find a way to tap into
- 42:36streaming. So maybe it's not existential as
- 42:38in CNN, would shut down if it didn't happen.
- 42:40But there's a little bit more strategic imperative behind it
- 42:43where, as quippy seemed more like, well, let's invent a new
- 42:45category because we think it doesn't exist yet.
- 42:48We're CNN's is more like, well, let's just kind of makes a
- 42:50streaming version of CNN. That has somewhat, you know,
- 42:53focused content in that way. Yeah, CNN had to do something
- 42:57you can argue That it should have been integrated into HBO
- 43:00Max, you know, that's up for debate.
- 43:03But if you see what's happening to the Cable Bundle and you're a
- 43:06channel that makes a lot of money from the Cable Bundle.
- 43:09You try to figure out some solution to it.
- 43:11It's the same reason that, that Fox News did did what it did
- 43:15with Fox Nation. I mean you could always put jet
- 43:17which is a totally different type of, you know, the
- 43:19e-commerce play, where they spent a bazillion dollars to try
- 43:21and compete with Amazon. And yeah, I guess I find these
- 43:24things all annoying because they skip over the sort of minimum
- 43:27Viable product idea. And they just say, wow, if we
- 43:30throw Talent money marketing, everything at it, we can
- 43:35overwhelm. And then it's often just
- 43:38inexplicable, why these people are given sort of such long
- 43:42leashes when there's really no reason they couldn't do it the
- 43:45slow way, except if you did it, this low way, people might start
- 43:48to get skeptical and then you wouldn't get the same amount of
- 43:51money. You would, if you poured all the
- 43:52money in in the beginning, right?
- 43:54With a it's funny that you use the term Long Leash to describe
- 43:57see Then plus because they didn't get much time.
- 43:59Me, I was about to say it's like a comedic Lee Short, right?
- 44:02I think. But a lot of money, right?
- 44:04I mean, it's 300 million. Plus what is the number?
- 44:06Am I making that up there? Have been a few different
- 44:08reports. Some there was a 300 million,
- 44:10there was a 500 million a lot. If it's the 500 that had to
- 44:13include sort of the full budget for the year, you can you can
- 44:16nitpick are you can sort of, you can question.
- 44:20The programming choices they made, they went with 10 of
- 44:22these. A lot of Lifestyle shows that
- 44:24didn't seem to make a lot of sense for CN n plus those
- 44:27certain, you know, that The Eva Longoria show felt like could
- 44:29have lived on on HBO Max, but there was also they hired some
- 44:33really big news Talent Audie Cornish from NPR and Chris
- 44:36Wallace from Fox News, but there's not Scott Galloway.
- 44:43But they were, you know, they were trying to compare loose or
- 44:45the New York Galloway. That's why we brought you on the
- 44:47podcast. I hold you guys.
- 44:49Accountable for whatever wind sorry.
- 44:52The curse of Scott Galloway continues.
- 44:55I gotta I gotta wash my own streaming service and promise
- 44:57scholarship. Show.
- 45:00They I mean do you think this is a sign of actual like executive
- 45:07decision making that maybe posts as love in a somewhat positive
- 45:11light that he's willing to pull the plug on something that he
- 45:13doesn't believe in early on rather than just do it to you
- 45:16know, Susie goes and and you know be a kind of accommodating
- 45:20to the new talent but actually say look I have a strategy here,
- 45:23this didn't fit into it, the numbers at least early on didn't
- 45:25back it up. Like let's fucking kill it
- 45:27rather than You know, the may be more judicious.
- 45:31We'll look he's he's certainly come out of this transition.
- 45:34Looking good. Right there was a lot of, you
- 45:38know, we talked about some of the the built-up animosity
- 45:40towards Netflix. There's a lot of frustration in
- 45:43the kind of entertainment Community with AT&T.
- 45:45There's a lot of frustration with the leadership of Werner
- 45:47media because of what they did and how they released the movies
- 45:51at home, which I still think was the right decision from a
- 45:53business perspective view. But but there were definitely
- 45:56some missteps and how they executed that And so he was, he
- 46:00was coming in with people giving him move.
- 46:02He's at home, you mean? Skipping theaters?
- 46:03Yeah. When they, when they decided to
- 46:05release their entire slate of 2021 movies on HBO, Max and in
- 46:09theaters, at the same time, it caused this kind of whole shit
- 46:12show in Hollywood have represented a thing that only
- 46:14matters in Hollywood and the rest of America is like the rest
- 46:18of America is like movies at home.
- 46:20Great. Like I don't want to go to the
- 46:21theater right now. What's like no I need to read a
- 46:243000 word. Open letter by Christopher Nolan
- 46:27to understand why you've been wrong.
- 46:28And that's, that's what we start.
- 46:30I derailed that. But yeah, fine, but I think
- 46:33there's, he, he comes in with people giving him the benefit of
- 46:35the doubt because they want to see the company go in the right
- 46:39direction. And I do think there's there is
- 46:41something to being decisive because it you sort of when you
- 46:44rip the Band-Aid off, it really sucks for a little bit, but then
- 46:47you get to where you want. The question all have is, you
- 46:48know, they're they're going to, you know, probably lose a bunch
- 46:51of or fire a bunch of people through that.
- 46:53They're about to have to fire a bunch of other people through
- 46:55kind of re organizations and consolidations and
- 46:57quote-unquote. He's and if he can get that if
- 47:00David says, I can get through that without in a seeming like
- 47:04the bad guy. That'll be quite the trick with
- 47:05sorry. For the non-hollywood Among Us,
- 47:08what is his fiefdom? Or what are they mean proper so
- 47:11David's as love was until recently the the CEO of
- 47:15Discovery Communications which just owns a bunch of cable
- 47:19networks, you know, including Discovery and PLC and they
- 47:23bought scripts, which has HGTV and Food Network, and they then
- 47:27merge with Warner media. To, which is HBO, the CNN Warner
- 47:33Brothers Studio, and also the Turner networks like TNT and TBS
- 47:37and adults when their plan is to make HBO Max even more maximum
- 47:41maximum. Yeah.
- 47:41They, they keep saying that they want to have just one service.
- 47:45And so Discovery has the service Discovery plus, which kind of
- 47:49went through a similar, they didn't shut it down but they had
- 47:52gone in spending a bunch of money on shows with celebrities.
- 47:55And, you know, discovered he's always been kind of a low-cost
- 47:57programming place and They were they tried to go premium with
- 48:00Discovery. Plus it didn't work, they can
- 48:03regroup, then they do this deal. There's an assumption that
- 48:05Discovery plus will either just be folded into HBO.
- 48:08Max or will be bundled in some way that is positive for the
- 48:12consumer and CN n plus just didn't fit into this into this
- 48:16plan. You think the HBO Max brand is
- 48:18like set. Like at this point it's still a
- 48:20little nonsensical, right? It's possible that they will
- 48:23change the name. They have not, they have not
- 48:25made any public comments on it, you have a gut Feeling on that,
- 48:30I really don't. Because I think these companies
- 48:32have all taken different approaches with naming HBO
- 48:35continues to be a really good brand and I don't know why you
- 48:38want to throw that out to try to create something new, but having
- 48:41a bunch of reality television HBO with a brand won't mean
- 48:44anything in five years. I mean something, totally
- 48:46different, right? Won't mean the wiring, well, one
- 48:50assumes that they will still have all of those shows.
- 48:53They'll just, it'll be like like Netflix where they make a lot of
- 48:57really good Prestige programming.
- 48:58Then they also have all this other stuff, they already have
- 49:01kind of lowered the quality of from the HBO brain on HBO Max
- 49:04already a island is on HBO Max. That's how about watch that one.
- 49:08But yeah I mean the HBO Max original versus an HBO show it's
- 49:12obviously to almost any normal person, all the same thing but I
- 49:16know within hvo. There was a lot of massaging of
- 49:18like what could technically defined as an HBO show versus a
- 49:22Mac show that. Yeah I mean I know, you know,
- 49:24back at the end, the tail end of my covering the bead and the D,
- 49:27the deal with start To be discussed.
- 49:29There was a lot of consternation that Discovery was sort of
- 49:31associated with some of the worst quality content on
- 49:34television, right? I mean, this was like, you say,
- 49:36low budget reality stuff that could really be considered
- 49:39garbage. That was then going to be
- 49:41married with, you know, the premium most high-quality
- 49:44intellectual, you know, content that I feel like that's going to
- 49:47be one of the biggest issues for them to reckon with over the
- 49:50next couple of months is like, what brand do we really stand
- 49:52for? How do we keep HBO safe from it
- 49:55and, and, and like, you're saying, what do we call this
- 49:57fucking thing? Yeah, I mean all but it's the
- 50:00truth is all these services are going through this, right?
- 50:02So we've all talked about Disney on.
- 50:05This Disney is in the midst, and I forget, I think you, you wrote
- 50:08about this, Tom when you're still at the information.
- 50:10Jessica at the information loves to write about this subject,
- 50:12which is like, how do they teach us?
- 50:14Good to incorporate. Yeah.
- 50:16Yeah. How does Disney plus become more
- 50:19than just Marvel and Star Wars, right.
- 50:20This is a, this is a service that caters to those super fans
- 50:24and also to, you know, people with young kids because they
- 50:27have the Disney In the Pixar movies and all that, but it's
- 50:30it. The the general customer does
- 50:34not view that as something that they're going to turn on every
- 50:36night to find something new to watch, right?
- 50:38Like they're going to go there for a very specific thing and
- 50:41they've realized that if they want to hit the targets that
- 50:43they've put out, they're going to have to broaden what they do
- 50:46and it's why you see them putting Dancing with the Stars
- 50:48on Disney plus and they're going to keep doing stupid things.
- 50:51All these services are still trying to figure out how to be
- 50:54like Netflix, which is why some of the problems that Netflix has
- 50:57had recently. So much concerning for them.
- 51:00I teed this up earlier but so I just want to make sure it sounds
- 51:04like everybody. Thinks quippy was far worse
- 51:05since you know plus or so. What were the definitive takes
- 51:09on? Some of you are rejecting this
- 51:11framework at all. I didn't invent this.
- 51:13I've seen people saying this, I look they're both comedic
- 51:16blowouts. And and before I answer that
- 51:19question, I just want to say one quick thing because I did check
- 51:20in, on Twitter, over the weekend.
- 51:22Luke is, you can't say this because you still cover the be
- 51:24but Eric and I can the implosion of CN n plus is funny.
- 51:28I'm sorry. It fundamentally is funny, I'm
- 51:30sorry, people lost their jobs, it happens.
- 51:33It'll happen. Even more as the discovery
- 51:35integration goes through but like you don't have to sit there
- 51:37and cry about the fact that there are people who lost their
- 51:40jobs the whole way through. Enjoy the things that I like
- 51:42that. You should know you're taking a
- 51:45risk, they do act like it's a fucking tragedy.
- 51:48Anybody who started it. He had to admit that like, we
- 51:52went in, knowing, it was like a big gamble and your amazing part
- 51:55of taking jobs, like, betting on, like, how good the company
- 51:58is going. Do whatever you like that.
- 51:59I think the funny part is the The Clash of or the kind of the
- 52:05really rich powerful people and of basically fighting over the
- 52:09future of this thing because there was a point a week or two
- 52:12ago where it just seemed very clear to me that someone within
- 52:15the discovery Universe was leaking bad news about.
- 52:18So it n plus because they wanted to kill this thing.
- 52:21And so then you had some people on the, the within the kind of
- 52:24broader CNN Warner media universe, who wanted to try to
- 52:27rescue it. And so that part of it, I was a
- 52:29little bit of humor, I think the sad part is all the people who
- 52:33will lose their jobs as a result, but that is kind of sort
- 52:35of undeniably sad. It's sad to me.
- 52:38I think the funny part is this CNN has this very like, were the
- 52:42authority brand like we're delivering you like the news
- 52:46like we understand the world and then for the product of such a
- 52:51type of person to fail reflects that they don't actually
- 52:55necessarily understand the world.
- 52:57Obviously, They're not business people and their different
- 53:00things. And as a journalist, I'm
- 53:01sympathetic but I to me the funny part is the conflict
- 53:04between this brand of authority and they're sort of inability to
- 53:08judge their own likelihood of success your scrunchie a nose at
- 53:12this. Oh no.
- 53:12I'm just saying that shit's hard.
- 53:14Like I definitely the fact that it's run by journalists
- 53:17certainly doesn't mean that it or not run by journalists but
- 53:20they would be good at it but which is why I'm like just
- 53:23generally Pro you know, slow slow and steady growth.
- 53:27I mean that's you know we both Both came from the information
- 53:29that suggests is done. Like I I believe that some
- 53:32things are key, I mean, Disney plus was a huge, you know, out
- 53:35of the box, hit, you know, they got like 10 million Subs day.
- 53:37One there, there are things that, dude, legitimately take
- 53:40off. Typically those things were good
- 53:41ideas, whereas when you have a bad idea it tends to not do very
- 53:45well or were you're not operating from a position of
- 53:47strength? I mean, Disney had the best
- 53:50known entertainment brand in the world and launched this sort of
- 53:54just remarkable marketing campaign.
- 53:57You know, most of these other services.
- 53:58As you know, took Netflix years to even get to a million
- 54:01subscribers. It different news organizations,
- 54:04which is sort of the world that CNN's playing in had to spend a
- 54:06while to you don't usually jump out of the gate like Disney did,
- 54:10right? Well, Disney had an insane value
- 54:12probably was super cheap. This is a company that's like,
- 54:15sort of divvied out. It's like old properties and
- 54:18sort of not, you know, they just were very restrictive about what
- 54:21they let people have. And all of a sudden, they're
- 54:22like, giving people like everything.
- 54:24I mean, it was. Yeah, I mean, it's just amazing.
- 54:26So it's having a product that people, I want you guys are
- 54:29refusing, even ate in terms of quippy.
- 54:31Just say, I'm they'll know, you won't even address it head-on.
- 54:34We kind of already did. I feel?
- 54:35I mean like, like Quimby, like Lucas.
- 54:38And I think we agree on. First of all, way more money,
- 54:40invested billions, we're invested into quippy.
- 54:44So if the 300 million figure is right for CNN, we're talking
- 54:47like less than three times, you know the Investments.
- 54:51Wait no more. You know what I mean?
- 54:52Whatever, far less investment. You're like nobody it CNN called
- 54:56journalist Peters or Probably have but it's Tom got.
- 55:03She said that that journalists groom sources the same way that
- 55:06child Predators groom and you were that I was this list.
- 55:10I still have to inform everybody when I move into a new
- 55:12neighborhood that I'm a journalist, so it's very, it's
- 55:15very concerning for my personal life, but no way more money was
- 55:18invested into Quimby. It was as Lucas made the point
- 55:21earlier, a much worse idea. There was no reason for it to
- 55:24exist CN. N plus wasn't the first attempt
- 55:27at this thing, you know, Fox, Nation is still around, they're
- 55:30probably going to see other companies try to do this sort of
- 55:32thing right. There needs to be some kind of
- 55:34streaming answer for, for cable news.
- 55:36So it's hard for me to eat. It's not even in the same
- 55:38universe. There's a bunch of other CNN,
- 55:41pluses out there, right? I mean, there's every company.
- 55:44There's so many different Niche, streaming services, CN n plus
- 55:47just got a ton of attention because journalists are
- 55:50narcissists. And we like the right, but other
- 55:51journalists exact, right? I agree with like media already
- 55:54gets overcome this is that you know, media that happens to be
- 55:57populated by journalists is Yeah.
- 55:59A different level of narcissism that will require people to
- 56:02think it was a much bigger implosion than it was.
- 56:05Anyway, so my CN n. Plus show is not going to make
- 56:07it, I'm sorry to say but I'm still I'm still open for anyone
- 56:10that wants to buy the IP. Maybe the I don't know the
- 56:13newcomer streaming service can pick it up.
- 56:15So last thing here maybe just with the discovery this as love
- 56:18era of media. What do you look at with CNN
- 56:21plus now in the rearview mirror? Like what's next as like the
- 56:25biggest hurdle that they're going to have to address and
- 56:27like will give a sense as to what You know the the outside of
- 56:30Disney, the largest Media company out there is going to be
- 56:33going after. Well they have to figure out
- 56:35what they want and what they're streaming strategy is they have
- 56:37two different Services right now, they have Discovery plus an
- 56:39HBO Max one assumes that they should just be squished together
- 56:43because Discovery plus an HBO, Max are both making unscripted
- 56:47programming and Discovery plus has a, you know, a much smaller
- 56:52user base. But there's some, you know,
- 56:55there's some brand confusion there that that Eric alluded to
- 56:58earlier. HBO ran into this.
- 57:00When they first started selling HP.
- 57:02Oh, Max. Because there were all these
- 57:04different names. There's HBO Go and HBO now.
- 57:06And and so, which one were you getting?
- 57:08I mean, thankfully, at least they didn't go with with another
- 57:10plus and what prevent chance. Now, they have that shit can
- 57:15relaunch with the plus. I love how that you're strong.
- 57:17That seems like your strongest ideologies require us.
- 57:19Like I'm anti plus like that I'm alive.
- 57:22Oh, I have opinions about a lot of things.
- 57:23I'm just trying not to get in too much trouble today.
- 57:25Are you allowed? Are you free?
- 57:26Are you what? Yeah, I mean it looks.
- 57:28My newsletter is basically a weekly column.
- 57:30You you're not going to find like right really strongly
- 57:34voiced opinions but it's I wouldn't describe it as holy
- 57:37neutral. That's a big evolution.
- 57:38When I was there, when I was writing fully charged, they
- 57:43would never. Let me say it was opinion.
- 57:45It was I don't, I don't view it. As I don't view it in their
- 57:47different. I viewed as a report, I view it
- 57:49as a recorded column, sure. Hey, yes!
- 57:53Want the pure undiluted, Lucas shopping.
- 57:54You gotta sign up for Lucas. Plus, you gotta, you gotta get
- 57:58the premium. The premium level subscription.
- 58:00Don't you go and Balinese my eyes can go on, I go on the
- 58:04town, every Monday and then I occasionally appear on the
- 58:08business, which is Kim master show at KCRW.
- 58:11And there may or may not be some other things coming at some
- 58:15point, he knows when that's good, we got it, we got it.
- 58:19I think the other big question is, you know, David sighs lab
- 58:22has no experience running or little it's been a long time,
- 58:25running a big entertainment company that likes to spend.
- 58:28And a lot of money and so is, how is he going to feel when
- 58:32he's got a clear, a 200 million dollar check for a Batman movie
- 58:35or when he's got to sign off on an HBO show that's going to cost
- 58:38twenty million dollars an episode if he's if he's cool
- 58:40with it, great, but that's something he hasn't had to do in
- 58:44a in a very long time. If ever, I love it.
- 58:46He's in the hot seat. All right, thanks.
- 58:48Thanks for doing this. Lucas and do it on a Sunday?
- 58:50I appreciate it. Oh yeah.
- 58:51Almost for that kind of coverage and whatever the next implosion,
- 58:54maybe I'm sure you'll have something good to say about it.
- 58:56Yeah, thanks, Bethany. Goodbye,
- 59:10goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 59:14Goodbye.