Latest / Consumerpedia / 46 - Health Apps & Websites Often Share Your Data
Transcript
- 0:01A lot of us rely on technology to stay fit and healthy.
- 0:05Wearable devices make it possible to track your heart
- 0:07rate, blood pressure, glucose levels, sleep patterns or
- 0:10mentrual cycles. You can go online to learn more
- 0:13about medical issues and your mental health.
- 0:16Price comparison websites can deliver significant savings on
- 0:19costly prescription drugs. These digital resources may seem
- 0:23to provide confidential help, but in most cases, their parent
- 0:26companies are allowed to save, share, and sell the highly
- 0:30personal information they collect about you.
- 0:32I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer man, a contributing editor at
- 0:36checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:38consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:42consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:46Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:48any business we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:52completely independent and objective.
- 0:55Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 0:59the consumer man Herb Weisbaum. You may have heard about the
- 1:03Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, often
- 1:06referred to as HIPAA. It prohibits medical providers
- 1:09such as doctors, dentists, medical health professionals,
- 1:12clinics, pharmacies or nursing homes, and health insurance
- 1:15plans, including government programs such as Medicare and
- 1:19Medicaid, from sharing health information without the
- 1:22patient's authorization. But unlike doctors or other
- 1:25medical professionals, most health apps, websites and device
- 1:29makers are not required to keep your health information
- 1:32confidential. In this episode, How to Protect
- 1:35Your Sensitive Medical Information, we have two privacy
- 1:38experts joining us. Pam Dixon, Executive director of
- 1:41the World Privacy Forum, based in Portland, OR.
- 1:44Hey, Herb and Jen Colt, writer, a privacy researcher at the
- 1:47Mozilla Foundation, the nonprofit behind the Firefox
- 1:50browser. Hey, Herb, so let's start with
- 1:52this. I think a lot of people assume
- 1:54that when it comes to medical information, anything you
- 1:56disclose is private. But that's far from the case.
- 1:59Pam, why don't you explain what protections we have under the
- 2:02federal privacy law called HIPAA?
- 2:05HIPAA is as you said it's a federal.
- 2:07Statute, it protects the information that's flowing in
- 2:10the healthcare ecosystem. This is a really important thing
- 2:14to consider because if information is in the official
- 2:19formally regulated ecosystem like a healthcare provider, you
- 2:23know, a physician, A pharmacist, etcetera, then that information
- 2:28is in fact covered under HIPAA. But the minute you have
- 2:31healthcare information that is outside of that system, for
- 2:35example, let's say you. Take a copy of your records and
- 2:39you e-mail them to someone that is not a doctor.
- 2:43Those records no longer have that same protection.
- 2:47If your records are with a health care provider, then
- 2:50there's coverage. So Pam, let's talk about things
- 3:12that many of us do, and you tell us if they're covered by HIPAA,
- 3:16data collected from, which is done on your phone or web
- 3:18browser. If your records are outside of
- 2:53that system, they no longer have the coverage.
- 2:56So the very same information that would be protected in the
- 2:59hands of a doctor is not protected in the hands, for
- 3:03example, of a commercial company.
- 3:05This is very broad brush treatment of that, but that's
- 3:08about the approximation of how it.
- 3:19No information you provide to a website or app not affiliated
- 3:23with your medical provider. If it's not affiliated with any
- 3:26medical provider, no health data generated by smartphones and
- 3:30smartwatches. The wearable tech We all have
- 3:33Internet connected medical devices unless that technology
- 3:35is provided by entity covered by HIPAA for treatment purposes.
- 3:39It's all out unless there's a very exceptional circumstance
- 3:42that it's completely covered under HIPAA.
- 3:44So a lot of the routine things that people do as far as
- 3:47collecting health data are not covered by the federal privacy
- 3:50protection, and I got a feeling they may not know that.
- 3:53I think that is the number one problem that we're having in
- 3:55health privacy today in the US So what's the harm in having so
- 3:59many companies collecting this data?
- 4:01After all, it's just a smart watch keeping track of my heart
- 4:03rate or a medical website that knows that I search for
- 4:06ovulation or erectile dysfunction.
- 4:08What's the What's the big deal? There are a lot of big deals
- 4:11currently in our current environment.
- 4:13So let's say that. And these are real cases, by the
- 4:15way, so let's say that you are. A young woman and you've been
- 4:18suffering from anorexia and you go online and discuss this with
- 4:22your friends on social media. You could be denied an insurance
- 4:26claim for healthcare treatment based on this, even though you
- 4:29didn't do it within a healthcare setting.
- 4:31But that information about you and about your condition is
- 4:35considered to be fair game because it's out in quote UN
- 4:38quote the wild. It's unregulated.
- 4:40So your healthcare information, when it's outside of the HIPA
- 4:44protections, does not have all of the.
- 4:47Legal and privacy protections that your ordinary healthcare
- 4:50information would, That's the big risk.
- 4:52So if you are discussing, for example, a genetically linked
- 4:57disease like Hodgkin's disease or just a variety of other, you
- 5:01know, diseases that are terrifying and and scary, this
- 5:05could have an impact on what insurance companies think about
- 5:08your progeny, about your children, your relatives.
- 5:11So we have to be really cautious about the information we post
- 5:14about ourselves to the wide world, but also we need to think
- 5:18about how that will affect the people who are related to us.
- 5:21Because once the information is out, it's out there.
- 5:24And I think we all know now that there's no getting it back, and
- 5:28it's even more true today than it was in the past.
- 5:31So just to be clear, if I see a doctor about depression, that
- 5:34visit is covered by HIPAA privacy rules.
- 5:36A physician. The staff you ensure they can't
- 5:39share the information about the condition or treatment with any
- 5:41anyone else outside the HIPAA system.
- 5:43But if I search online for information about depression or
- 5:46download a discount coupon from a drug website that gives me a
- 5:49discount for the meds the doctor may have prescribed to treat
- 5:52that condition, HIPAA does not apply.
- 5:53And that information can be sold or shared.
- 5:55Did I get that right? You've got that right.
- 5:57Now. There are.
- 5:58There are always little caveats and use cases that are
- 6:01different, but if you're online and you're downloading a coupon
- 6:05just from the web, and it's not from my healthcare providers
- 6:08specifically, it's really problematic.
- 6:11Because you're basically giving your health information to a
- 6:14third party that's not covered under HIPAA.
- 6:16And you know, it's really challenging to tell what entity
- 6:20is covered under HIPAA and what isn't, especially when those
- 6:23entities are running around saying things like.
- 6:26We're HIPAA compliant. We have this trust mark here
- 6:29that looks like a HIPAA seal. So you've got to really ask the
- 6:32company in writing, are you regulated under HIPAA?
- 6:36Not are you compliant with HIPAA, but are you a regulated
- 6:39entity under HIPAA? And that's a yes or no question.
- 6:42There's no in between there To find out what's being shared by
- 6:45non medical providers with access to your private
- 6:47information and how it might be used, you'll need to read each
- 6:50company's privacy policy. But even if you do, you may find
- 6:53it deliberately vague or difficult to under understand.
- 6:56Jen you read Privacy policies for a Living as part of your job
- 7:00at Mozilla. What do you find?
- 7:01Oh man, I find a headaches often.
- 7:04A lot of times I didn't set out to read privacy policies for a
- 7:07living. I don't think anybody does.
- 7:08If I fell into it. And it's actually quite
- 7:11interesting, believe it or not, because privacy policies aren't
- 7:13written for I'm not a lawyer, they aren't written for me.
- 7:16They're not written for consumers.
- 7:17They're written by lawyers, for lawyers to protect the company.
- 7:20So they are very hard to read, intentionally vague, long and
- 7:25confusing. And they do cause some headaches
- 7:27at times, and a lot of times they use weasel words like may
- 7:30or could, that kind of thing, right?
- 7:32Oh yeah, They love vague words that say we may do this, we may
- 7:37collect some biometric information on you.
- 7:39For example, you know, your voice commands and that sounds
- 7:42good. They may just collect my voice
- 7:44commands. That makes sense.
- 7:45But by saying May and for example, they could also collect
- 7:49a lot of other biometric information on you which you
- 7:52know when you have a lot of cameras and microphones and
- 7:55sensors and everything. These days gets a little scary
- 7:57when you're talking about, oh, they can sense my emotions or
- 8:00tell if I'm drunk. And so that that does raise some
- 8:02flags for us when we see that vague language in privacy
- 8:05policies. So the bottom line here is
- 8:07they're collecting this personal medical data so they can use it
- 8:11and monetize it. Can you give us an example of
- 8:13how they might do this? Yeah.
- 8:15So if you take, for example, one of the mental health apps that
- 8:19we reviewed, there's a number of them that we saw do this.
- 8:22You, you land on the page, You're like, oh, I want to talk
- 8:24to a therapist. There's nobody around.
- 8:26This sounds like a good option, and you click the Get Started
- 8:28button and immediately you're dumped into a questionnaire
- 8:31where they ask you some pretty sensitive questions like are you
- 8:34depressed? Are you suicidal?
- 8:36Are you gay? Things like that.
- 8:38And that's before you've ever seen a privacy policy or been
- 8:41told how this data might be used.
- 8:43You're thinking, oh, which they're just learning about me
- 8:45to assign me a therapist, but it's not clear.
- 8:48And so if the company knows that you're depressed and they know
- 8:52your age and your gender and your depression, they can build
- 8:54a profile on you. Other companies can pay a lot of
- 8:56money to target people that are depressed for products that
- 8:59might not be really good for them.
- 9:01And maybe you shouldn't be targeted if they're depressed
- 9:04for those advertisements. So that could make their mental
- 9:07health worse. So that's just.
- 9:08One example of things that could happen that that are happening,
- 9:11a scary example. Now some privacy policies say
- 9:14the data we share does not include customer names, we de
- 9:17identify the information. It's anonymous what they get.
- 9:20Should that make me feel any better?
- 9:22You know, it can make you feel a little bit better.
- 9:24DE identified or anonymized information is definitely better
- 9:27than personal information that is connected to your
- 9:30identifiers. But it's not bulletproof.
- 9:32It's not solid. A number of researchers have
- 9:34found that de identified information is actually fair.
- 9:38Fairly easily reidentified, especially if location data is
- 9:42included and location data is included in some way in just
- 9:45about everything these days, whether it's your IP address
- 9:48from your computer or your location from your phone or your
- 9:51car. And so it's not bulletproof
- 9:54having just a deidentified data about you out there.
- 9:57And in the privacy policies I read, it actually gets a little
- 10:00scarier because almost all the privacy policies I read have a
- 10:03line that says. In how they outline how they're
- 10:06going to use your data and they say, oh, we'll only use your
- 10:08data if you give us consent. But then at the bottom they have
- 10:11a line that says we will de identify your data and then we
- 10:14can pretty much use it however we want.
- 10:16And so that's that's a red flag for us.
- 10:18Yeah, it should be. As part of its Privacy Not
- 10:20Included initiative launched in 2017, researchers at Mozilla
- 10:24monitored the privacy and security features provided by
- 10:27more than 100 popular apps and found that most of them failed
- 10:31to protect the information they collect.
- 10:34We'll talk to Jen about that next.
- 10:36I'm Her Weisbaum, and this is Consumerpedia powered by
- 10:39checkbook.org. If you like what you hear, we
- 10:43hope you'll consider being a consumer PDF supporter by using
- 10:46the link at the bottom of the show notes to make a small
- 10:48contribution each month. This is Consumerpedia.
- 10:53Mozilla recently issued a report on mental health apps, a report
- 10:57that one of our guests, Jen Cult Rider, wrote.
- 10:59The Mozilla team tested 32 apps and 20 of them.
- 11:02That's more than 60% failed to meet the group's minimum
- 11:05standards. Even more troubling, 40% had
- 11:07privacy practices that were worse than last year.
- 11:10Jen, tell us about that. Yeah.
- 11:12So coming out of the pandemic in 2022, we actually reviewed
- 11:16mental health apps because we were seeing a huge rise in them,
- 11:19billions of dollars being poured into it.
- 11:21A lot of people needed them. Well, we were curious about the
- 11:24privacy of these apps, and so we looked into them.
- 11:26And what we found was horrible. Of the 32 apps that we reviewed
- 11:29in 2022, only three did not earn our Privacy Not included warning
- 11:33label, which was terrifying for apps that collect so much
- 11:36sensitive personal information about your mental health status,
- 11:40your gender, your gender identity.
- 11:42You know whether you're suicidal, what your OCD triggers
- 11:45are, what your eating disorders are, all this crazy stuff that's
- 11:48being collected, And then privacy policies that are like,
- 11:51yay, we're going to collect this data and use some.
- 11:53Of it to make money or just trust us to secure it.
- 11:56And so we we raised the alarm last year and it was nice to see
- 12:00that other people kind of followed on that and we saw some
- 12:03of the regulatory bodies start to pay more attention.
- 12:06And so this year we decided we'd follow up and re review the 27
- 12:09mental health apps from last year as well as five new ones
- 12:12that our readers had asked us to review.
- 12:15And so this year things looked a little bit better.
- 12:17We had fewer privacy not included warnings assigned and
- 12:21that was encouraging. Some of the changes were small.
- 12:24You know a number of products that we use reviewed last year
- 12:27had very weak password requirements.
- 12:30You know, you could log into your app that let you track your
- 12:32symptoms and it just required A11 as a password and that's not
- 12:36very secure. And because we worked with some
- 12:38of these companies, they improved their password
- 12:40requirements or they clarified that all users had the same
- 12:43right to delete data regardless of where they live, which is
- 12:46significant. And so that's good change to
- 12:48see, but we still saw pretty much across the board with very
- 12:52few. Exceptions.
- 12:53Companies collecting a large amount of personal data and then
- 12:56talking about how in their privacy policies, how they can
- 12:59use that data for targeted advertising and share that
- 13:02information with third parties that they could also use to
- 13:05target you with advertising. So bottom line, things are a
- 13:08little bit better, but we still have a long way to go.
- 13:10Yeah, I'd say the bottom line is things were horrible and then
- 13:13when somebody pays attention and kind of raises the concern,
- 13:17companies are somewhat willing to make some changes and adapt
- 13:21whether it's a small. Company that's like doesn't
- 13:24have, you know, a whole lot of resources that changes a
- 13:26password requirement or a bigger company that gets in trouble and
- 13:29find millions of dollars by the FTC.
- 13:32Both of those things push for change.
- 13:34And then when people pay attention and raise concerns and
- 13:37call the companies out, change does happen.
- 13:39And I think that was the bottom line that I saw.
- 13:41There's still a long way to go because we live in a data
- 13:43economy and this is just the way it is and our data is not
- 13:47getting any less valuable. But if we make a stink and hold
- 13:51companies accountable, they will work.
- 13:52To do somewhat better. And that's something that we
- 13:55should aim for. But what about the bottom line
- 13:57take away that 40% had privacy practices that were worse than
- 14:00last year? I mean, it sounds like we're
- 14:01going backwards. Yeah, yeah.
- 14:02Well, out here fighting the good fight, you know, the bottom line
- 14:06is it takes a lot more people to step up and really push for
- 14:09change. It's hard, you know, There's
- 14:11just so much money in this data. And the more detailed the data
- 14:16is, the more valuable it becomes.
- 14:17Knowing somebody's depressed or knowing somebody's sexual
- 14:20orientation or being able to have all that information, but
- 14:23also combine it with information about where they live and how
- 14:26often they shop. You know, these profiles that
- 14:29you can build on people and just really target them.
- 14:32There's just so much money in that.
- 14:33And so the bottom line is, yeah, things are things aren't getting
- 14:36better in the big picture. Our privacy is still very much
- 14:40in jeopardy and we all need to do more.
- 14:42I think is the bottom line, especially the policymakers and
- 14:45the regulators and the companies.
- 14:47Because consumers should not ever be expected to sit around
- 14:51and read privacy policies all day long and constantly re
- 14:54review and make sure they consented to the right things or
- 14:57opted out if they have to. That's just too much to ask of
- 14:59consumers. So how can our privacy policy
- 15:02that's horrible get worse? I mean, what's worse than
- 15:04horrible? Uh, well, we saw one company
- 15:08that wasn't awful last year actually removed the language
- 15:12that made it clear that all people, regardless of what
- 15:15privacy laws they live under, could delete their data.
- 15:18And so now it said, oh, depending on your jurisdiction,
- 15:21if you live under California's strong privacy law or you live
- 15:24under Europe strong privacy law, you can have your data deleted
- 15:28because those laws require. But if you don't.
- 15:30We don't guarantee that, right? And so that's something that we
- 15:33saw going backwards. We also saw, you know, language
- 15:37that just got more vague, less clarifying, you know, things
- 15:41like that. Companies update their privacy
- 15:43policies all the time. And it's really hard to keep up.
- 15:47So Mozilla found that several mental health apps talk Space,
- 15:50Happify, and better help push consumers into taking
- 15:53questionnaires upfront without asking for consent or showing
- 15:57their privacy policies first. That sounds kind of troubling,
- 16:00yeah. We found that very troubling
- 16:02because these questionnaires from these mental health apps,
- 16:05you're having mental health issues, so you're not in the
- 16:07best frame of mind to begin with.
- 16:09And you go to the website for some of these apps and you click
- 16:13get started because you're like, I need a therapist, I can't find
- 16:15anybody, My mental health is crap.
- 16:17Get started. And immediately you're launched
- 16:19into a survey where asked very sensitive questions, like are
- 16:22you depressed? Are you suicidal, Are you
- 16:24anxious, are you gay? Are you married?
- 16:26Things like that. And this is before you've ever
- 16:29been offered any sort of privacy policy, any form to consent to
- 16:33have this data collected. But they do collect that data on
- 16:36you, and that's data that they could share with advertising
- 16:40companies like Google or collect and use that to target you with
- 16:43ads. And so that's really scary and
- 16:45really, really, really bad privacy practice.
- 16:48That data should never be collected without anybody being
- 16:51told how it's going to be used and then being asked to give
- 16:54explicit consent for it to be used any other way than to
- 16:57provide the service, which in this case would be a therapist.
- 16:59And that's what they found the FTC is find better help, almost
- 17:048 million. Dollars this past year because
- 17:06they had lied about some of their privacy practices.
- 17:09According to the FTC, they lied. And so it's good to see the FTC
- 17:14holding companies accountable. It's really scary to see them
- 17:17holding them accountable because they basically misled people
- 17:20through their privacy policies and use very sensitive data in
- 17:23ways that they shouldn't have. Your report called Replica My AI
- 17:27Friend, one of the worst apps ever reviewed.
- 17:29What made Replica My AI Friend so bad?
- 17:32Yeah, Replica AI friend was a app.
- 17:34That was requested that we review from our users and when
- 17:37we looked at it, we were shocked because it's an AI chat bot.
- 17:41Those are becoming very popular. This was one that's been around
- 17:44for a little while. And it was one that was designed
- 17:47kind of almost as a, you know, a friend, a girlfriend.
- 17:52A lot of people were using it in kind of girlfriends and flirts
- 17:56and and sexual situations. And so they're it's collecting a
- 18:00lot of very sensitive information and it earned all of
- 18:03our privacy Dings that we assign.
- 18:05Because we had serious concerns about how the AI was used.
- 18:08People didn't have any control or transparency into how the AI
- 18:12was used and they were creating these kind of girlfriends and
- 18:15then replica AI change the AI and suddenly you know, they
- 18:19weren't their girlfriend anymore and people were freaking out.
- 18:21And so it is very kind of unique and interesting example of a
- 18:26company really bad at privacy. But it was also the way of the
- 18:29future, with these chat bots and people forming relationships
- 18:32with him but not having any control over the.
- 18:35Company changing the algorithm next day and your friend now is
- 18:38an enemy, and that's really hard on your mental health.
- 18:41So how do you protect yourself and your personal health
- 18:44information when you go online? Use medical apps or smart
- 18:47devices? It isn't easy.
- 18:50We'll talk to Pam and Jen about that next.
- 18:52I'm her Weisbaum, and this is Consumerpedia powered by
- 18:56checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast Facts The
- 19:01global market for big data continues to grow by 14% every
- 19:05year. In 2020, it was valued at $56
- 19:08billion. With nearly half of that coming
- 19:11from healthcare data. When asked, 97% of US corporate
- 19:15executives said their companies plan to invest in big data and
- 19:18artificial intelligence. It's estimated that every person
- 19:22on Earth generates 1.7 megabytes of data every second.
- 19:28So we know the problem. Too much health data is being
- 19:30collected and shared, whether users realize it or not.
- 19:34Jen How can we use the privacy policy when these things are
- 19:37designed by lawyers to protect the company and nearly
- 19:40impossible to understand? What can we do staring at this
- 19:43thing that goes on forever and ever and ever and ever?
- 19:45Yeah, well. Let me give you a couple of tips
- 19:47that somebody that reads privacy policies for a living does.
- 19:51The first thing I do when I start to review an app is I
- 19:54actually go to the Google Play store.
- 19:56I ignore the data safety information because I don't
- 19:58trust that it's self reported by the companies.
- 20:01Google doesn't do a great job policing it.
- 20:03So I don't trust that, but I do click on about the app and then
- 20:06I go down and in that section there's a thing that says
- 20:09permissions. And I click on that link and it
- 20:11tells me what permissions the app will request.
- 20:13So is it going to use my camera? Is it going to ask to use my
- 20:16microphone, my track, my location?
- 20:19And if I'm, you know, doing an app that's going to give me
- 20:22recipes and it doesn't need use to my camera but requests it,
- 20:25that's going to be a red flag. If I'm downloading an app to
- 20:29listen to songs and tell me what the name of the song is and it
- 20:31requests access to my microphone, I'm like, that's OK,
- 20:34that's one of the first things I do.
- 20:36The second thing I do, when I go to a privacy policies, I
- 20:38actually look for the California privacy section and it's down at
- 20:43the bottom. Not all privacy policies have
- 20:45them, but because California has a really strong privacy law,
- 20:49companies are required to give more information to people in
- 20:51California. And so I go look at that and
- 20:53read that first because it's usually easier to read.
- 20:56It lays things out more clearly, there's less vague language.
- 20:59It's usually more shocking and telling you this is the data we
- 21:02collect. This is how we use it.
- 21:04You'll see the word sell in there a lot.
- 21:07California has a definition of selling data that a lot of
- 21:10companies dispute, but they are still required to report it.
- 21:13So I start there. I also use my control function
- 21:16on my computer a lot and look for words like sell, combine,
- 21:20data, broker, you know, delete. I just kind of look for the
- 21:23things that are important to me. What information is it
- 21:25collecting on me? Do I have any control over it?
- 21:28There's sections for this and can I delete it?
- 21:30And you can kind of just glance through those, especially the
- 21:32California privacy section, and get a feeling of whether
- 21:36something feels OK or whether something raises a lot of red
- 21:39flags in a couple of minutes, Pam many.
- 21:42Patients ask their physicians to recommend apps or wearable
- 21:45devices, and that's good. Can you assume your medical
- 21:47provider knows the data collection policies of the
- 21:50technology they're suggesting to you?
- 21:52It depends. On the providers, some providers
- 21:54are very up on this, but some aren't.
- 21:56So it's really good to have that conversation right in the office
- 22:00when you're having that discussion, but don't.
- 22:02Assume just 'cause my doc suggested.
- 22:04This or provided this that it's HIPAA compliant.
- 22:07That's correct. This is a very complex area and
- 22:10it's it's really difficult. In order for us to determine if
- 22:14an entity is covered under HIPAA or not, the surest way that
- 22:17we've found to ensure we have the right answer is to simply
- 22:21ask them. And if you use the term are you
- 22:24regulated under HIPAA? That should elicit the proper
- 22:28answer. They should say yes or no to
- 22:31that. So sometimes companies will say
- 22:33we're HIPAA compliant and if you say HIPAA regulated, they will
- 22:37understand what you're asking. You are asking for are you
- 22:40regulated under this actual law or not.
- 22:43But other than that, it's a very confusing area and doctors can
- 22:47be confused too an important. Point and I don't want this to
- 22:49get missed. Just because I download the app
- 22:52from Google or the Apple App stores does not mean my privacy
- 22:55is protected, correct? Correct.
- 22:58Yes, they they have some protections in place to try and
- 23:01weed out apps that are malicious or privacy disrespecting, but
- 23:06they're not foolproof. There's a lot of concerns around
- 23:10the apps and you know, if you go in and download Tick Tock, Tick
- 23:14tocks been in the news a lot for privacy concerns.
- 23:17If you go into the Google Play store and look at TikTok, it
- 23:19claims in their data safety information that they don't
- 23:22share any data with third parties.
- 23:23And that's just false. But you also just never know
- 23:26when you're going to download an app that's malware or
- 23:29suspicious. And so do a little bit of
- 23:31research. You know, make sure you're
- 23:32downloading a credible app from a credible company.
- 23:35I mean, one thing I do is just look for a privacy policy.
- 23:37Privacy policy should be on every app page in the app
- 23:41stores. If you can't find a privacy
- 23:43policy, do not download the app. Jen Colt Rider.
- 23:45Runs the Privacy Not Included research project at the Mozilla
- 23:48Foundation. It works to improve privacy for
- 23:51everyone. Jen, thank you for sharing what
- 23:53you learned with us. Yeah.
- 23:54Thanks for having me, Pam. I guess the.
- 23:55Best advice is be skeptical and watch what you share.
- 23:58I think that's the. Very best general rule of thumb
- 24:01advice. The second piece of advice I
- 24:03would have is this. If you're considering, you know,
- 24:06sharing your health information, your detailed health record with
- 24:11a website or an app, you need to be really certain that that
- 24:16website or app is actually regulated under HIPAA.
- 24:19If it's not, you are giving your health information to an entity
- 24:23that does not have the legal requirements to protect your
- 24:26privacy in the same way that HIPAA does.
- 24:28There's a lot of protections for patients in HIPAA and it's worth
- 24:32getting them. So for example, if you have the
- 24:34option to get counseling and it's online, make sure that all
- 24:39of the information that you're putting online, from your name
- 24:42to your demographic information, like your phone number and your
- 24:44e-mail, all of it, Make sure that they're not selling it or
- 24:48monetizing it because it's connected with a counseling
- 24:51session. So you want everything from A-Z
- 24:54to be covered. And you know, the best way of
- 24:56doing this is to write to. Through the company, through
- 25:00their e-mail, through their privacy policy, whatever contact
- 25:03information they have there and ask for their policy in writing
- 25:07and whether or not they are a fully regulated entity under
- 25:10HIPAA. The answer to this is yes or no.
- 25:12If the answer is no, really seriously consider not going
- 25:16there or sharing your information because it really
- 25:19becomes a free for all. It's a difficult choice to make
- 25:22and I understand there's a convenience, but it's super
- 25:25important to find actual healthcare entities who are
- 25:28trying to help. Help you who are working online
- 25:31and they do exist. Final point.
- 25:33While the FTC is using lawsuits to let the industry know it
- 25:36won't stand for misleading people about sharing their
- 25:38medical information, that can only go so far.
- 25:41Pam, I know you would like to see some strict regulations to
- 25:44control the marketplace. I would.
- 25:46I do think that we need to have a lot of oversight over what I
- 25:50call HIPAA adjacent information. Really, we're in such a digital
- 25:54era now. The outside of HIPAA health data
- 25:58is overwhelming the inside of HIPAA health data.
- 26:02So I do think that we need to think about how we can be
- 26:05protecting this data. I do think that ensuring that
- 26:09people are being very clear about whether they're covered
- 26:12under HIPAA or not is a really good start.
- 26:15And then after that being very clear about whether or not, or
- 26:19if they will in the future share or sell your health data to
- 26:24other parties for any use whatsoever.
- 26:26Pam Dixon is. Executive Director of the World
- 26:28Privacy Forum. You can find her online at
- 26:31worldprivacyforum.org. Pam, thanks for sharing your
- 26:34expertise with us. Thank you.
- 26:36What a pleasure. You can read more.
- 26:38About Health data Privacy by clicking the link in the show
- 26:41Notes And with that we come to the end of another episode of
- 26:44Consumer Pedia. Remember, we post new episodes
- 26:47every other Thursday. You can help us by rating this
- 26:50episode, and if you haven't done so already, follow us on Apple
- 26:53Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 26:58Another way you can support this show is to follow U.S.
- 27:00Consumer Pedia on Facebook and Instagram and My Consumer Pedia
- 27:04on Twitter. I'm Herb Weisbaum.
- 27:07Thanks for listening. Consumer Pedia is a public
- 27:10service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 27:13helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 27:16You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 27:19and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 27:22unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 27:25seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 27:28Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle.
- 27:32San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC To
- 27:36get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 27:38checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 27:42we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 27:45the bottom of the show Notes to make a small contribution each
- 27:48month. Consumer Pedia Empowering
- 27:50Consumers to Save Money and Make smarter choices.