Latest / Ego and Other Things / The True Self and God
Transcript
- William: Why do human beings need to believe in something higher than themselves? As an atheist, I think I would have denied this question altogether. From that perspective, from the philosophical perspective, I would have thought that human beings really don't need something higher than themselves in terms of their own values. You you could have made some arguments about whether or not human beings needed to rely on their social group, on their family, on their society in some kind of capacity in order to Survive in order to achieve the values that they were seeking. But my argument would have been that while this is true, The values which one holds, the sort of telos that one was striving after in their day-to-day life, came from within. It didn't come from what others dictated them to do. It wasn't determined by a god, it wasn't determined by a tradition, it wasn't determined by the opinion of the masses or society in general, but it was determined irrevocably by the individual. Or another way of putting that is that the individual had the irrevocable right to determine what it is that they valued and what it is that they were going to act for the sake of. And in this sense, one's moral core, one's value core, did not depend on anything else. There was meaning and purpose in life that could be derived entirely from oneself. And this self could be understood through exploration, through investigation, through testing one's values in the real world. And so in that sense, human beings didn't need something greater than themselves to find purpose or to find meaning or to find value. But rather they found it in themselves. And in fact, the greatest atrocities, in my view at the time, came from the fact that people would try to derive their meaning. They would try to derive their purpose and their values not from themselves, not from their own rational investigative understanding of themselves. But rather taking them uncritically from the people around them, from the society around them. When you looked at something like Nazi Germany, when you looked at the religious wars, when you looked at all of the greatest atrocities that were committed in our history, values that were enforced through violence and bloodshed and hatred and anger, it was this uncritical acceptance of the values around. oneself and that need to maintain that value, that purpose, that meaning by uncritically defending not only the the group from which one derived it, but also destroying or trying to snuff out or trying to eradicate. any opposing group and their values. Because of course, in the scenario where one's values depend on one's family or one's society, one's culture, one's religion, one's God, then anything which threatens those sources of meaning, anything which threatens those sources of meaning must be defended against other people to the death. And this was my view. In fact Placing your meaning and your purpose in something supposedly greater would have these kinds of disastrous consequences. And even the notion of the greater good must be individually derived. I mean, where else would you get the standard for what is the greater good other than your own evaluation, other than yourself? So not only did people not need To rely on something greater than themselves in order to have purpose or meaning or happiness. But in fact, that kind of devotion to something greater than yourself, especially uncritically, would be disastrous, would be absolutely disastrous. My solution instead was, as I alluded to before before, the cultivation of the self, the cultivation of self understanding and self objectification, you might call it individuation, in which one comes to know who they are, what one truly values, and tries to act for it in the sake for tries to act for it in the world for its own sake. Not for the sake of something greater, but for its own sake. The things that a person depended on for that, such as family and society and culture, the material of one's self, you might say, or least the material that was at hand for the cultivation and understanding of the self, because even the concept of the self comes from sort of a Western philosophical tradition, and of course one needs the materials of Food, clothing, a home. One needs some kind of positive social relationship with the people around you. One needs a certain amount of education, one needs protection, one needs to be able to cooperate with the people around you or the society around you or the culture around you, not merely in order to survive and to get what you need to survive day to day, but also to get the the basic materials and knowledge to even come to the idea of the self, let alone experiment with it actively. I mean you look at the the shelf of books behind me and none of these things, none of these books here would were written by me, but they were written by other people. And in one sense, I depend on other people to give me the sort of a knowledge or the insight into myself and into the world around me so that I could actually act for the sake of what I value or even know it. And so society and culture and other people sit within this strange relationship to the self as both an obstacle and a path. An obstacle in the sense that one often finds that we have to conform ourselves to our society or to the rules of our family, to the law, to the opinions of other people, which are not necessarily rational or. Have anything to do with what we value, we depend, or we must contend with these kinds of obstacles to our own self-expression, or even sometimes our self-knowledge. If a parent punishes a child for some form of self-expression, you you they punish a a young boy for wanting to wear a dress, for example, that's just one example. Then you reap you produce a sort of instinctive repression. You produce a certain sense, according to what you're restricting, that the child now has to become not who the child is, not part of the exploration of who they really are, but they must now conform themselves to whoever they have to be in order to avoid punishment, avoid harm, avoid the threat of death and annihilation by their parents. And it's And at the same time, what they need to be in order to gain love and care and the basic resources that they need in order to live, or even just the basic information to get along in life. So the people around you become this kind of obstacle. And this doesn't just happen in childhood, but as you grow up and you enter into society, society has many kinds of rules, both explicit rules within the law and implicit rules within so-called etiquette. And It is not at all clear that these kinds of rules are are innately rational or innately valuable. In fact, the history of cultural advancement, or you might say advancement in the world in general, is nothing other than individuals who saw saw the status quo of irrational rules and laws, either culturally or legally, and defiantly stood against those irrational. expectations or rules to assert their own values or to assert what they saw as value. And then that sort of new those new values become crystallized in a new form of law and a new form of culture, which a new generation of people oftentimes come up to try to break free from. And in part this is due to the fact that both culture and law are imposed on we have this sort of the human race has a sort of fascination with uniformly imposing laws and rules on everybody, regardless of whether it's valuable, rather than allowing for for voluntary participation. And so on a number of levels within our lives, within our day-to-day experience, society, the other even God or religion, depending on what kind of environment that we've grown up in, represents on the one hand, this massive obstacle to self-expression, this massive obstacle to even knowing oneself because of the incentives that have been set up. Not only the incentives, the disincentives to not act on what you actually value in particular cases, But the incentive not even to think on or to reflect on who you are and what you truly value. Because there is the potential danger that if you expose who you really are, and if you expose what you really value, even before acting on it, that you will face consequences, social rejection, violence, hatred, ostracism, punishment by the law, if not punishment socially. So there is an an internalized mechanism of repression, there is an internalized mechanism of inauthenticity, and so there is an internalized mechanism of turning away from the actual source of meaning and purpose and happiness within the self that comes only from the self. At the same time, one's society is. Necessary when society and culture and family is necessary in order to survive and get along. If you were born in the middle of the woods, you might, even if you somehow survived as an infant, you would be thoroughly crippled in your ability to know, the in your ability to communicate, and your ability to act imaginatively on what you actually valued. You would be sort of forced to live a kind of subsistence, basic level of survival until you died. There would be little to no chance for you might say a higher expression or even a higher knowledge of who you are. The very presence of death, the very needs of survival themselves represent an obstacle to authenticity, an obstacle to self-knowledge, an obstacle to the objectification of what we truly value, because there are conditions, there are the survival conditions that we inevitably must meet before we can even take on the task of authenticity. And for human beings, society and our family represent the main modes by which we survive in the world. In order to overcome this obstacle, in order to make survival more efficient and less devastating, we rely on the people around us, we rely on cooperation, we rely on certain shared ends with other people in order to meet the basics of our survival. And increasingly throughout history, not only to meet the basics of our survival. But to actually enable each other to become more no knowledgeable. And even in some instances authentic. And so the individual who is trying to who is trying to become authentic and know themselves and determine their own values, or at least discover what it is that they truly value, must maintain this kind of aloof distance between themselves and the world around them, the society around them. They must They must on the one hand refuse to be fully consumed by the social dictates of the world insofar as they disagree with one's or they are out of conflict with one's own internal authentic values. And at the same time, they must participate in that same kind of culture at some level in order not to face a devastating kind of ostracism or death. Now, in the modern age, it is easier to do this because of things like the internet or just things like generalized media. different kinds of generalized media media forms, we now have access to differing kinds of community, so that if the community that I'm directly in does not reflect what I actually value, then I might actually be able to go and interact with a group who who is more in in line with what I value. But even so, there is a sense in which one has to participate in the values of the world even if they don't even if they don't value them or think they're good or moral. in order merely to survive. There are very few people in this world who have gone to the extent of risking their lives, let alone their even their bodily integrity, or their or their guarantee of survival, in order to be truly self-authentic. So the personal example that I have is that I think that the institution of the state and of government, force and force and violence-based institutions like that, are entirely evil. And in some ways I've been able to act authentically in the world by disengaging from certain certain parts of it. I I don't part I try not to participate in forms of government institution that I can avoid. Like I don't go to the libraries, I don't vote, I don't I haven't joined a military career, I haven't gone to to college on the basis of some sort of government grant. I don't I d don't take any sort of welfare help. I try to avoid public insurance. And even many of those things, for example, public insurance or welfare, if my thrv survival was was significantly threatened in in in any other circumstances, I could certainly see myself taking help. in part because the government has made itself indispensable to living. But for instance, I I have you know, I I go for a walk in the morning and the these the my walk necessarily in includes you know public areas and public roads that are sustained by taxes, which are sustained by force and violence. And I willingly go and and do that because to try to radically disconnect myself from the violence of the state would so impair my ability to live or to do anything because the government has made itself so indispensable by coercion, that at some point I have to compromise. I have to compromise with something that I see as innately evil. I have to compromise in some way with the evil of the world, even to just get along. But at the same time, I have that ambiguity, right? I have that ambiguity of knowing, well, it is in some way necessary for me to involve myself in something that I don't value, that in fact I think is evil and immoral and wrong. But despite my actions, I don't value that. You see that that disconnect or that ambiguity. And that's just one line. I mean there are there are many different kinds of examples I think that one could bring up to elucidate this. But every individual who is aware of this kind of need to figure out who they are and really value and act it out in the world, I think. knows this kind of aloofness or this kind of ambiguity that that you have to have, where you again are forced to participate in some ways in the values of your society in order to get along and survive, while at the same time recognizing that you don't value that and trying to act or create a world for yourself that is in line with what you really value and who you really are, not what you are forced to be because of your society. And that kind of self-conscious aloofness, that self-conscious ambiguity, is the result of a pretty advanced form of self-development, a pretty advanced form of self-consciousness in the world. It is a result of having thought about these kinds of things and reflected on that relationship for a very long time, even if it is merely a half-formed instinct. Because of course, the majority of people will in large parts identify with their society or their culture or whatever they're sort of meshed in in that moment. They will largely identify with it because that was the environment that they had to grow up in, and that is who they had to become. And so they never had to have that moment of conflict or of open resistance to the kind of culture around them. In fact, in fact, part of the reason why we see such conflict in the modern age is because we lack the kind of homogeneity that used to exist in the past. And this is no argument for homogene or bringing back homogeneity. It's sort of just to illustrate the point that today people are confronted with diff the differences of other peoples and other cultures, even with their in their own country, far more frequently than they used to be. But what a person identifies with is not the necessarily the broad the broad culture. An American does not necessarily identify with the the the culture of the USA, the more so they identify with the culture of the people around them, the people around them. And this is what they conform to. This is what they identify with because it's who they had to become in order to survive. And the one who holds that kind of aloof relationship between the culture they must survive in and who they really are, that is a a sort of rare kind of development. So the sense the sense philosophically and psychologically speaking that people have of I need I need to believe in something greater than myself in order to be happy or to have meaning or to have purpose or to feel content is psychologically speaking really just the fear of death. Really is just this, well, I need to identify with this culture. I need to identify with my family. I need to identify with my religion. I need to identify with these broader cultural values that are greater than what I value, greater than who I am, greater than my own capacities, because without them, without them I am insecure. Without them, I risk the threat of ostracism. I risk the threat of rejection. I am I and therefore I risk the threat of death, or at the very least of A far lower form of life. Or level of resources than perhaps I'm used to. The desire to be part of something greater than oneself is a desire to be secure, the desire to survive, the desire to get along without strife. It is not necessarily an authentic desire. It is not reaching out to something that you genuinely value that is of, you know, I don't know, greater value than yourself, because again, yourself is a source of the things that you value in the first place. It is psychologically the desire to survive. And even a person who is conscious of that instinct to be subsumed in something greater for personal security is one who has to hold an aloof or ambiguous relationship to that sort of greater thing. That is the recognition that one's society, the people around one are necessary, are necessary in many ways to survive, are necessary for Individual evaluation for the understanding of who you are and what you value and acting for the sake of it. Without the society, you're dead and powerless. But when you are merely subsumed, when you are unconsciously subsumed by your culture, when you are have merely become what you needed to be in order to survive, you really cut yourself off from the vitality of who you are. the vitality of what you truly value. Or something like you have to sneak your authenticity into the culture in some way. And this is why most people live lead a lives of feelings of with feelings of meaninglessness and purposelessness. And they busy themselves enough so that they don't have to stop and think about how empty how unrelated their lives are to themselves, how unrelated their lives are to what they really value. To even the to even the the conscious recognition that they have never with with effort come to understand who they are. In part because that kind of effort almost inevitably requires some kind of confrontation, either a confrontation with one's family or a confrontation with the world around you. Which is dangerous and scary and chaotic, especially when one doesn't have a solid identity from which to launch this kind of confrontation. Being a part of something that is greater oneself greater than oneself gives one an identity, a a a secure identity that one does not have to question, that one does that does not depend on yourself for its maintenance, and in particular doesn't come into the conflict with the people around you. Or at least allows you to become part of a group where there is not that kind of conflict, where there is that kind of agreement, right? So maybe you rebel against the ideas and the values of your family, but then you quickly attach to the values of your friends and your peers, right? So let's say, just as an example, you reject the politics of your parents, and now you embrace the politics of your generation and your peers, and you become subsumed in the pol in defending the sort of politics of your peer group. It's not this thing that comes about as a rational inquiry, I I suppose, over the politics that that you're that that are involved here. But rather a attempt to have a solid identity, a secure identity that can survive your own Lack of identity because you've had to become something other than you are for the sake of your own survival. Which is in part why people defend these kinds of movements with such emotional ver with such emotional veracity, because their very identities are threatened, and not their true identity, not who they really are, not what they truly value. But the thing that they've staked their survival and especially their social survival on. So when political debates come, it's threatening to that false self. It's threatening to that persona that they've built for themselves in order to get along with the people that they are around, in order to survive socially. And of course, not only is the threat of the identity, because the true self knows. That they could work towards the true self. So there is an instinct, there is a recognition that even if one's identity were chipped away or destroyed for whatever reason, then there is the option to build the true self. But again, building the true self is isolating and alienating and oftentimes confrontational because who you are does not necessarily bode well with the world around you. And authenticity almost inevitably threatens survival. This is why, again, the one who has come to the the self-recognition of authenticity as a goal still has the struggle of this aloof reconciliation, of this recognition that they will never be able to, on their own, become who they really are because of the needs of survival. Now where this view has really changed for me since becoming a Christian is I almost don't want I almost want to say not so much in in a desire for something greater than myself, but a sort of recognition. A sort of recognition that has grown into Not necessarily desire, that's not the right word. A recognition that it's grown into a joy. And what I mean by this is that there is the recognition that from the atheist perspective, who I am, my true self, is actually never achievable. The authentic self is actually never achievable. And why? Well, one, because in the past it's been destroyed. I From the moment I was born, there have been aspects of myself which have been forced to conform to the world around me for the sake of survival. So that has set me on a course in my life, that has set me down a path of actions and causality, which I can never return to. I can never start life over again without the pressures of survival and become. Who I really am. Rather, today all I can do is attempt to become as authentic as I can in the moment, so that my life going forward will be more authentic or more true to myself than otherwise would have been. So even now I am not my true self. Even now I am not authentic. Not only because I am where I am, because of the inauthenticity of the past, whether it was my choice or not, but because even now I struggle to overcome, if if not explicitly recognize that I must conform parts of myself to the world around me just in order to survive, just in order to have the chance for moments of authenticity in the future. And so often so even all of this knowledge and even all of this work that comes from philosophy, that comes from psychology, that comes from the intellect, to recognize the true self and to strive as far as one can without destroying oneself to become that true self and and and that life, that project ultimately fails. You never come to the you never become you never you never come to the true self. You never become authentic. You never reach that ultimate self, that center of true values. You fail. You fail again and again and again. And all you get is these small growths and these small moments of authenticity. And ultimately at the end of that, you die. And from the atheistic perspective, that's the it. That's the end. Black unconsciousness. Nothingness. That's where authenticity leads you. It's a strange sort of paradoxical and I would say depressing perspective because your whole life you compromise on who you are to avoid death. You compromise on goodness. You compromise on what you actually value in order to avoid death. You pay the grim reaper every moment of your life, some part of your soul, some part of who you are, in order to live. Just a day longer. And at the end of all of that, you die anyway. At the end of all that, you have a blank. Black, unconscious void of nothingness. You never see the consequences of your actions down the line. You never see what it really meant to be who you are in the world. You think back to your memory, you can barely piece together the life you've lived up to this point. The most concrete thing is this one moment that you have. And every moment is just this brutal battle, this torn life between who you are and what you need to become in order to or what you need to be in order to survive. For it all to end in death. A life of torn suffering with moments of happiness, with moments of joy, all for it to end in death. And so from a philosophical psychological point. What I just told you fails to overcome evil and death. It fails to overcome evil and death. It's chained to evil and death. It must become, the self must become evil and reject itself and reject what's necessary for it to live, and or for the body to live. The soul must atrophy in some way in order for the body to live. And then even so, both body and soul die. And so philosophy and psychology are are unable to overcome evil and death. In fact, there's nothing in this world that is able to overcome evil and death. But when I came to faith in God, he revealed himself to me in a way that I could not deny. One of the first things I recognized was this: that God is the creator, that God is all powerful, that God is actually the source of who I really am. That God is not intimidated by death or by time or by evil. That God and God alone can transform me, can transform the world. In a way that overcomes both evil and death. That God can wipe away every t tier. That God can. Make all evil and suffering untrue. That only through God and God alone can I become who I really am, even above and beyond my own understanding of that. Because of course, any individual's understanding of who they are is is limited. We never get to the total self. We never get to the really true self. We only get these bits. We only get these bits that we have to test again and again in life. And fail to recognize, right? We are unable to even know who we really are. We only get guesses, better or worse guesses. But God knows who you really are. God knows what you truly value. God knows what would bring you purpose and meaning and life and joy and all of the things that we as humans crave. And this is why we crave God. This is why I have joy at God's existence, at the recognition of who God is, our perfect, all-powerful, all-knowing Creator. Because He knows who I really am. And He alone can work in me to get there. Despite my own failings, despite the evil and the death of the world. He alone, he alone can do that. And he does it through his son Jesus Christ. He does it through what Jesus did on the cross, taking on the evil of the world on himself and for our own sakes. And suffering that, dying, raising, being raised from the dead on the third day. Jesus now represents the path to who I really am. to who I really am, to being transformed. And Jesus is that path and that path alone. And so it turns out that Jesus. Who is God is the one capable of overcoming evil and death, not just in me, but in the whole world, and of transforming the world forever. And so only in him is there hope. Only in him is there hope for me, for who I really am, for what I truly value, whom only my creator knows intimately. and fully and only from whom my creator knows how To get me to a place where I can be fully who I am without the threat of survival, without the threat of evil and death, which hangs over that entire project of authenticity. It's the interesting thing where the egoists, the egoist is closest to recognizing God's love. The one who recognizes that all of their values comes from who they really are, is the closest to recognizing that God, their creator, who instilled in them their own values, knows better than they do even. How to transform them into the person they were always meant to be. Because I'm not the person to right now in this moment that I was meant to be. And you're not the person at this moment who you were meant to be. This world is not the world That it was meant to be. It's broken. And it's been broken by us. But God is willing to restore it. God is willing to create to transform us into the creations that we were always meant to be. And He alone has the knowledge and the power to do so, which is why I turned to Him in faith. Because I know that The knowledge, the so-called knowledge and wisdom of this world cannot overcome, cannot overcome death, cannot overcome evil, cannot overcome inauthenticity, cannot overcome force and violence, cannot overcome hatred. Not by itself. And so I recognize that's that God is something greater than myself. In the sense that He alone is able to know and transformed me as my creator. But myself at the same time is not lost in God. It's not as though I become a droplet in the ocean, which is God. In God's presence I am both fully and truly and for the first time who I really am. The singular individual. I am both the singular individual who is entirely. in line objectively as well as subjectively with who I really am and what I really value and at the same time God's child, at the same time, part of God's story. What God is working out through the world and where He is leading it. And there is actually no separation between the two. God has created me and you and everybody else to be a part of this story of transformation of love, of a story that only just begins, truthfully speaking, When Jesus comes back to transform the world. And so it's not so much of a desire as though a need or desire, it's not so much a desire for something greater than myself. As much as it's a recognition that who I am is fulfilled in God. Who I am is fulfilled in Jesus. And a trust. That God Will get me to the place of who I really am. That my individual self and who I really am and Humanity as a whole within God have no conflicts. Have no conflicts, but are perfectly at peace. Something like that. That's the best explanation that that I have of it right now. I think the most important part of that is the recognition that the wisdom of this world can't overcome the problems that humanity has been trying to overcome for thousands of years. We have always been trying to overcome evil and death in this world because these are the enemy of man. But evil and death, they come from within us. They come about because of our choices and because Of our sins. Either the sins of the people that have inflicted against us, force and violence that people use against children or against each other in the world, which forces us to conform to what we need to become in order to survive and alienate us from who we really are and what is of true value to us, or else the sins that we commit against others. The fear that we submit to. The fear that we u that the fear that we submit to that corrupts who we really are in order to live. Because we prize our life so much that oftentimes we prize it above what we really value and who we really are. We prize fear above authenticity, above truth. And we can't overcome it. No amount no amount of psychology can overcome it. No amount of philosophy can overcome it. No amount of science can overcome it. No amount of No amount of solitary reflection can overcome it. No amount of writing or recording or studying can overcome evil and death. And if you doubt that, look at the past. Read the tombs of works like I have here in the libraries of mankind. You will find no answer. The only answer is one. The only answer is Jesus. The only answer is God alone, who is all perfect, all powerful, all-knowing, all-loving. Our Creator who has the power to transform. Our Creator who has the power to overcome death and evil. Not just in the world, but in us. And so transform and restore us and help us to become. Who we were always meant to be, our true selves. And so I recognize that fact, that something greater than me, in particular, and singularly God. Is whom I require, whom I really require for life, for happiness, for purpose, for meaning. Not because he is something other than me, but because he is the one who created me. Not because he is something other than my true self, but because he was the one who created my true self. And he mourns probably more than I do at How much of who I am has been lost in this life? Or how much I've compromised who I really am for the sake of my own survival. I almost have no doubt that in fact, I have no doubt that he mourns that even deeper than I, that he longs for my restoration more even than I do. But that recognition brings me joy. That recognition brings me hope. That recognition on God brings me hope and joy. Because now, through God, through Jesus, I too can overcome death and evil. Death is not the end for me. The inauthenticity of this life, the ambiguity and the struggle between survival. And who I really am, that's not the end of life. That's not the end of life. In fact, God is using that to teach me. So I think we're gonna end it there. if you guys have any thoughts about what I was talking about, whether from the philosophical perspective, the Christians perspective, anything at all that I talked about here, you have any thoughts about that, questions, then just put that put those put those down in the comments because I would just love to be able to talk with you more about these kinds of things and just get into these deeper discussions about these supremely important. topics. If you like this video, then please give it a like. If you think that somebody else would benefit from this video, then please share it with them. And if you want more videos like this, please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.