Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #59: How Far Does the Freedom of Speech Go?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics With Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan political analysis.
- 0:05I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:07Today, we're gonna talk about the freedom of speech and how far it should go.
- 0:13It's always a salient topic, but arguably even more salient these days.
- 0:19If any one aspect is emblematic of the American system of government, it is the freedom of
- 0:25speech.
- 0:26There are five freedoms in the First Amendment, religion, speech, press, assembly, and
- 0:31petition, but speech is arguably the foundation for the other four freedoms and many of our
- 0:37other freedoms that we have.
- 0:39Yet the reach and limits of the freedom of speech have been constantly tested and refined
- 0:47over American history.
- 0:49Our views on the freedom of speech can be influenced by many factors like whether we are
- 0:55at war or peace, the goal of the speech and rhetoric in question, our biases in support or
- 1:02opposition of the people who are speaking, and our level of effective polarization.
- 1:08While we should be consistent in our application of the freedom of speech, that
- 1:12isn't always the case, not just because of biases, but also because it is often difficult
- 1:17to figure out where exactly the line should be drawn.
- 1:22So today we're going to cover a bunch of aspects of the freedom of speech.
- 1:28How did it become such an important part of the fabric of America?
- 1:32What are some government laws that tested freedom of speech?
- 1:36How has the US Supreme Court ruled on free speech cases in the past?
- 1:41Why does freedom of speech protect awful things that are said?
- 1:45How have biases affected how we think of freedom of speech?
- 1:49And finally, how do we protect and preserve the freedom of speech, not just legally, but in our
- 1:55personal lives?
- 1:57These are always important questions, but perhaps even more so in the midst of current
- 2:01free speech debates.
- 2:03So let's talk about it.
- 2:05The beginnings of free speech in America.
- 2:09A freedom of speech is a concept that has roots all the way back to ancient Greece, and it was
- 2:14one of the guiding principles that the founding fathers looked to when forming a new government
- 2:19due to American dealings with the British crown.
- 2:23Freedom of speech, especially speech that's critical of government, became an important
- 2:28foundation of American life.
- 2:31However, that freedom of speech was not originally part of the US constitution,
- 2:36which came after the articles of confederation, and
- 2:41the whole bill of rights was not part of the US constitution.
- 2:45That's why it's amendments one through 10.
- 2:47It wasn't part of the original document.
- 2:50Many framers of the constitution thought it was unnecessary to add that it was basically a
- 2:55given in the constitution that it it was self explanatory in that regard.
- 3:01But opponents to the constitution didn't believe so, and that was one of their many
- 3:05gripes with the constitution and wanting to stay with the articles of confederation.
- 3:10But as somewhat of a concession, the bill of rights was added a couple of years after the
- 3:15ratification of the US Constitution, which was fully ratified in 1789, and 1791 was when the
- 3:21Bill of Rights was ratified.
- 3:24And that includes the First Amendment rights of religion, speech, press, assembly, and
- 3:30petition.
- 3:32But interestingly enough, and this might sound very strange coming from today, but the federal
- 3:38bill of rights initially was not considered to apply to the state governments, only the
- 3:43federal government and how people interacted with it.
- 3:47The US Senate actually rejected an amendment that would have applied the Bill of Rights to
- 3:52the states before the Bill of Rights was ratified.
- 3:54So even though that was a topic of discussion, that wasn't quite added there.
- 3:58Now some state constitutions do have their own bill of rights, and a few of them had it prior
- 4:05to The US constitution.
- 4:07And you still see them in a lot of state constitutions, if not all of them.
- 4:10And oftentimes, they're more concrete and specific than The US Bill of Rights.
- 4:15Like, state constitutions are in general.
- 4:16The US constitution is a lot more vague and broad, whereas state constitutions are always
- 4:22more specific.
- 4:23Some are more specific than others.
- 4:25But in any case, the bill of rights, there's usually a lot more to it when you look at the
- 4:31state constitutional versions of it.
- 4:33Following the fourteenth amendment's ratification, the supreme court started
- 4:38applying The US bill of rights to state governments and how we interact with them as
- 4:43well through the due process clause of the fourteenth amendment.
- 4:47That applying that due process clause to the bill of rights and having that bill of rights
- 4:54be applied to the state governments is called the excuse me, the incorporation doctrine.
- 5:01This was not immediate, however, even though it
- 5:03was intended to be during Reconstruction.
- 5:10Much of these changes were the indoctrine or excuse me, the incorporation doctrine was
- 5:15applied did not occur until the twentieth century, well after reconstruction.
- 5:21Reconstruction happening to about 1877 ish because of the compromise of 1877 where
- 5:29Rutherford B.
- 5:30Hayes was elected president as republican.
- 5:34In exchange, republicans added reconstruction in the South.
- 5:37So even though that incorporation doctrine was
- 5:42trying to be implemented for the bill
- 5:46of rights to be applied to the state governments then, it didn't exactly happen
- 5:50then.
- 5:50It took decades later for it to start being that way.
- 5:55And speaking of having that bill of rights be The US bill of rights be applied more to the
- 6:03state governments, there have been a lot of government laws that have tested the freedom of
- 6:08speech over time.
- 6:10Some, obviously, more controversial than others, some more directly dealing with freedom
- 6:15of speech than others.
- 6:17And so many of these laws and actions have been controversial as to whether or not they
- 6:24violated the First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and the related First Amendment
- 6:31rights of religion, press, assembly, and petition.
- 6:37And they did they didn't always these laws didn't always lead to supreme court cases.
- 6:44Sometimes they did, and sometimes they technically didn't suppress free speech if you
- 6:49look at the letter of the law, but they basically found ways to do so.
- 6:52They didn't necessarily at face value deal with freedom of speech, but ultimately, they did in
- 7:00some way like Jim Crow laws.
- 7:02Some of them were not necessarily directly about freedom of speech, but we'll get to those
- 7:08in a minute.
- 7:09And there's too many of these examples to cover, but here are some of the major ones to
- 7:13know about.
- 7:14Probably the the earliest one to really test the freedom of speech was the Alien Sedition
- 7:20Act in 1798.
- 7:22During John Adams administration, the second president of The United States, these laws were
- 7:27passed, and they authorized the president to deport noncitizens, permitted their arrest
- 7:32during wartime, limited speech critical about the government.
- 7:36The US was on the brink of war with France.
- 7:38Ultimately, didn't quite happen.
- 7:41There was a quasi war, quote, unquote, but they didn't actually go to full out war even though
- 7:49only a couple of decades before the French had helped us achieve our independence.
- 7:54But these laws were directed against the Democratic Republican Party.
- 7:58It wasn't really about unity during wartime.
- 8:02It was deliberately targeted towards one party because that the Democratic Republican Party
- 8:07who will eventually become the Democratic Party was typically favored by new citizens.
- 8:13So the ruling Federalists put these laws to basically stifle them.
- 8:19And so that was a major contributor to the Federalists' defeat in the eighteen hundred
- 8:24elections.
- 8:25And after that, the Federalist Party never came close to taking power again.
- 8:31That that effectively killed them.
- 8:33They still lasted for a couple of decades afterwards, but they were pretty much finished
- 8:38after that point.
- 8:40There was also Jim Crow laws, which I just mentioned, which were designed to reproduce the
- 8:45conditions of slavery for black people without technically being slavery.
- 8:50So, yeah, they weren't being put in chains and working eighteen hour, twenty hour days for no
- 8:58pay, and they couldn't do anything of their own accord, but heavily restricted their ways of
- 9:04life so that they might as well still be considered slaves, especially in the South with
- 9:09various racist laws designed to suppress black voices such as their ability to vote.
- 9:14You had poll taxes, for example, which a lot of black people at the time were too poor to pay,
- 9:21which you you had basically had to pay
- 9:23a fee to go and vote.
- 9:26And then just racial intimidation in general, trying
- 9:32to get them to not vote by any means necessary.
- 9:37Even though they had the right to vote, they ostensibly had their first amendment rights.
- 9:43Especially in the South, governments found ways to stifle their freedom of speech.
- 9:48You also had the Espionage Act of 1917 and the Sedition Act of 1918.
- 9:54The Espionage Act made it a crime to convey information intended to interfere with the
- 9:59World War one effort.
- 10:01And the Sedition Act imposed penalties for a wide range of speech, including speech abusing
- 10:09the US government, quote unquote, the flag, the constitution, the military, and it's also the
- 10:16time of the first Red Scare, which was fueled by the Russian Revolution of nineteen
- 10:20seventeen.
- 10:20So, like many times when people try to curtail freedom of speech, they use it as an excuse to
- 10:27say, well, this we need to do it to ensure safety and security, which sometimes might be
- 10:34the case, but then sometimes there's an ulterior motive.
- 10:37A lot of times, there's an ulterior motive.
- 10:39And then you had a second Red Scare during the nineteen forties and nineteen fifties.
- 10:44Primarily, Joseph McCarthy, a senator from Wisconsin, was on a rampage to root out
- 10:51communists and government, both real and perceived.
- 10:53And there were, I believe, a few that were communists, but a lot of times, they either
- 10:59were provably not communist or there was not enough evidence to say they were.
- 11:05But a lot of it, of course, was just Joseph McCarthy being on a power trip, and a lot of
- 11:10people had their lives ruined basically and couldn't really defend themselves.
- 11:17And anybody who wanted to speak up and say, the House Un American Activities Commission or
- 11:24committee, excuse me, the HUAC and all these other anti communist efforts were going too
- 11:29far.
- 11:29You basically were labeled a communist sympathizer.
- 11:32And eventually, these false accusations did catch up with Joseph McCarthy, particularly
- 11:38when he went after the army and accused them of being filled with communists.
- 11:42That's when public sentiments start to turn against him.
- 11:46But those are just a few of the cases of government laws testing freedom of speech, how
- 11:51exactly, how far they could go, what were the limits, a lot of
- 11:55times it overstepped its bounds.
- 11:58Now as for the judicial branch of government, not congress and president, when it comes to
- 12:07historical SCOTUS cases, over American history,
- 12:12there has been loads of cases dealing directly and indirectly with the freedom of speech,
- 12:17especially since World War one.
- 12:20So many of these cases there's just so many of these cases that deal with freedom of speech
- 12:26that you just can't cover them all in one episode of the podcast.
- 12:31And that's not even getting into cases that are indirectly dealing with freedom of speech.
- 12:37And then you have state rulings, state level rulings on free speech that SCOTUS did not take
- 12:44up appeals on because, obviously, you had state governments and their state bill of rights.
- 12:50And then later on when the incorporation doctrine was applying The US bill of rights to
- 12:54the state governments, it had
- 12:56a lot of other state court rulings about freedom of speech and word extended.
- 13:04So that's not even getting into that either.
- 13:06But in short,
- 13:09I'll I'll give some key rulings in a minute.
- 13:12But in short, speech that is protected and not protected includes protected speech.
- 13:19You cannot salute the American flag.
- 13:22You can't be compelled to do so.
- 13:24You can wear black armbands to protest a war.
- 13:28You can use certain offensive words and phrases to convey political messages, to contribute
- 13:35money to political campaigns with certain restrictions, to advertise commercial products
- 13:40and professional services.
- 13:42Again, with some restrictions, like for example, tobacco companies can no longer make
- 13:47ads for cigarettes to put on TV, and you can engage in symbolic speech like burning the
- 13:53American flag.
- 13:55Speech that is not protected includes what any that is meant to incite imminent lawless
- 14:01action.
- 14:02You can't make or distribute obscene materials or at least to just anybody.
- 14:09You can't you can't burn draft cards as an anti war protest.
- 14:14Students can't print articles in a school newspaper over objections of the school
- 14:19administration.
- 14:20Students can't make an obscene speech at a school sponsored event.
- 14:24Students can't advocate illegal drug use at a school sponsored event.
- 14:29You can't defame people, so whether it's libel or slander, you can't plagiarize, and you can't
- 14:36give out true threats to people's lives and health.
- 14:41But some of the more specific instances of free speech rulings and whether that free speech was
- 14:48protected or not or considered free speech that should be protected.
- 14:53One of the earliest ones was Schenck versus The United States in 1919, And that ruled that
- 15:00freedom of speech can be curtailed if there is a, quote, unquote, clear and present danger.
- 15:05And in this case, Charles Schenk and Elizabeth Baer, two socialist activists, they distributed
- 15:12leaflets urging people to disobey the draft in World War one.
- 15:16They consider the draft a violation of the thirteenth amendment, which outlawed slavery,
- 15:21prohibited involuntary servitude, and they were charged with violating the espionage act of
- 15:261917, which we mentioned a bit earlier, by attempting to cause insubordination in the
- 15:31military and obstruction of recruitment.
- 15:33That those were the charges levied against them.
- 15:37And justice Oliver Wendell Holmes basically well, the the supreme court basically said the
- 15:44espionage act was was fine.
- 15:46But justice Oliver Wendell Holmes concluded that courts owed greater defer difference to
- 15:51the government during wartime even if constitutional rights were at stake.
- 15:56And that's where you hear the phrase if you've ever heard the phrase falsely shouting fire in
- 16:01a crowded theater, some people leave out the falsely part, but that's a key part of the
- 16:06phrase, falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater.
- 16:09That comes from this case, which is how Holmes compared Schenck and Baer's activities of
- 16:15disobeying the draft in World War one.
- 16:20A couple decades later, you had West Virginia Board of Education versus Barnett in 1943, and
- 16:26that ruled that you cannot compel people to salute the American flag.
- 16:30Children in a family of Jehovah's Witnesses refused to perform the salute to the flag and
- 16:37were sent home from school for noncompliance.
- 16:40It was considered a violation of West Virginia law where the salute was considered part of
- 16:46school activities and you had to do it.
- 16:49But the court ruled that you cannot enforce a unanimity of opinion on any topic.
- 16:54So they said that compelling people to salute the American flag was unconstitutional.
- 17:00Then you had Brandenburg versus Ohio in 1969 where it was sort of an overturn of Schenck
- 17:09versus United States.
- 17:10It was a partial overturn.
- 17:12You sometimes see supreme court cases not fully overturn a previous ruling, but partially do
- 17:18so.
- 17:18So it ruled that in Brandenburg versus Ohio in 1969, it ruled that a state can only forbid
- 17:24speech if it is a directed at inciting or producing imminent lawless action and b likely
- 17:33to incite or produce such actions.
- 17:35So basically, you're trying to make a lawless action happen and your action in doing so is
- 17:45likely to make that action happen.
- 17:49A KKK leader, a higher up leader in Ohio, Clarence Brandenburg, he made a speech about
- 17:56taking, quote, unquote, revenge on African Americans and Jews, potentially even marching
- 18:03on DC on the July 4.
- 18:04And he had a reporter cover the KKK rally for their local news.
- 18:12And because of this, Brandenburg was convicted of advocating violence under Ohio's criminal
- 18:18syndicalism statute.
- 18:21But the US Supreme Court ruled that the state law was overly broad and in violation of the US
- 18:27constitution.
- 18:28So it built upon Schenck versus US by proposing that there had to
- 18:32be an imminent lawless action test that seems to advocate overthrowing the US government, and
- 18:38it there has to be reason to believe that that action that's being provoked would actually
- 18:46happen.
- 18:49Same year as that case was the Tinker versus Des Moines case in 1969.
- 18:56Students rights to free speech did not end when at school.
- 19:00They can wear armbands as they are separate from actions and conduct.
- 19:04As long as that conduct did not quote materially and substantially interfere end
- 19:09quote, with school operations.
- 19:12Several students, including a namesake, Mary Beth Tanker, wore black armbands at school as a
- 19:19means to protest the Vietnam War and the draft to Vietnam.
- 19:24And they were dismissed from classes from school for refusing to take the armbands off,
- 19:31but the court ruled that the school violated their constitutional rights by doing so.
- 19:40Couple years later, Cohen versus California in 1971 ruled that states cannot ban expletives
- 19:46being used to convey political messages simply out of a concern for disturbing peace.
- 19:51They need a bit better reason to do that.
- 19:54Paul Robert Cohen, the namesake for the case, he had worn a jacket.
- 19:59And, this is during the Vietnam War during when the Vietnam War had a draft.
- 20:05He wore a jacket saying, I'm not gonna say the word, f the draft, stop the war.
- 20:12Again, referring to Vietnam War, which and that's kind of speech was illegal under a
- 20:18California statute.
- 20:20But the court ruled in his favor and said that he can wear that jacket.
- 20:26And then Texas versus Johnson in 1989 where the burning of the American flag is considered
- 20:33protected expressive speech.
- 20:35Gregory Lee Johnson burned the flag in protest of Reagan administration policies.
- 20:39I believe
- 20:40it was during the nineteen eighty four Republican National Convention, and he was
- 20:43arrested for it under Texas law.
- 20:46So years later, five about five years later, his it was
- 20:52ruled that his rights were violated, that you can burn the flag in protest you want.
- 20:59That's freedom of speech.
- 21:04And that that's just a few of the major cases dealing with freedom of speech.
- 21:10There's just too many of those to actually cover.
- 21:12But that Texas versus Johnson case is a good segue into this next topic, which is why the
- 21:21freedom of speech protects a lot of controversial speech, even ones that we would
- 21:26consider awful that are objectively awful, like racism or sexism or homophobia.
- 21:32Despite the many conflicts over how far freedom of speech extends, it does generally protect
- 21:38controversial, even abhorrent speech as long as it isn't already prohibited by law in other
- 21:45ways, like if you're trying to incite imminent lawless action and that action is likely to
- 21:53happen because of you provoking it.
- 21:57Why should we protect the speech though?
- 22:00It may seem like at face value, why would we want these kinds of things to be said?
- 22:06It's not about whether we want it to be said.
- 22:10You can start a slippery slope when government deems things as too awful to be said or
- 22:16expressed.
- 22:18And a lot of times that's just used as an excuse to stifle differing opinions.
- 22:23And then that means the government can pick and choose who gets to say what, which means there
- 22:28is no real freedom of speech.
- 22:30If you're picking and choosing what people get to say, that's not real freedom.
- 22:36And also legally, it can be hard to come up with concrete definitions of things.
- 22:44When you're writing legislation, there are often debates as to how exactly to word laws
- 22:50for various reasons.
- 22:51Sometimes laws can be considered too vague.
- 22:54They might be considered too specific.
- 22:57What is considered hate speech, for example?
- 23:00There's all these little nooks and crannies, and then everybody's got their own interests as
- 23:04to what exactly kind of speech they may or may not want curtailed.
- 23:10So sometimes there's those kinds
- 23:14of things that you know it when you see it, but you can't actually legally
- 23:20define it.
- 23:21Or even if you could, it's still something that is considered freedom of speech.
- 23:27And some things that are controversial now become much more commonly accepted by later
- 23:33generations.
- 23:34If you
- 23:34look at gay marriage, for example, fifty, sixty, seventy years ago, that was
- 23:40completely unheard of if completely anathema.
- 23:44Now it's a much more commonplace thing.
- 23:47And sometimes what is commonly accepted now was once controversial.
- 23:53If we talk about dress code, for example, I'm
- 23:55not saying dress code is good or bad.
- 23:57I'm just saying how people dress today.
- 24:03You would not see it from sixty, seventy, eighty years ago in a lot of cases.
- 24:09So
- 24:12what is considered acceptable or not often changes over time.
- 24:16And a lot of times that's that's for the better.
- 24:18Sometimes it's not, but some changes aren't always good, changes aren't always bad.
- 24:25Ideally, yes, we shouldn't say things that are racist, sexist, homophobic, or any other
- 24:31bigoted things.
- 24:32Yes.
- 24:32It would be nice for people to not say that.
- 24:36But if you really wanna try to change the minds of actual bigots, which is difficult, but it is
- 24:41possible, silencing them is not going to do it anyway, and it's just going to make them worse.
- 24:48They're going to act out even more so if you try to stifle their opinion.
- 24:53But a lot
- 24:54of times, people also try to
- 24:56make an excuse and say, somebody does not agree with something, they'll say something is
- 25:01bigoted, and it's not necessarily the case.
- 25:06But it also brings up another good point.
- 25:10Whether you can say something versus whether you should say something.
- 25:15Freedom of speech protects a lot of things, but is it something you should say?
- 25:20Paraphrase Jeff Goldblum's character from Jurassic Park, Ian Malcolm.
- 25:25We're sometimes so preoccupied with whether we could say something that we don't think if we
- 25:29should say something.
- 25:32Just because the freedom of speech is important to protect,
- 25:37we're not always good about determining whether we should say it.
- 25:43And the freedom of speech, a lot
- 25:45of times people don't realize that that does not mean freedom from consequences.
- 25:51A lot of people don't wanna be accountable for what they say and do, but
- 25:57that's a lot
- 25:58of times, that's not how it works, or at least people should be held more accountable for
- 26:02things they say and by more people.
- 26:04But a lot of times, people just wanna only hold accountable to people that are not on their
- 26:08quote unquote side of the aisle.
- 26:11And also some jobs, for example, limit what you can say in the context of the work and when you
- 26:17represent that employer.
- 26:19A lot of
- 26:19times that is allowed by law, but that can get a
- 26:24little bit murky when you start to ask, are those employers doing it at the behest of
- 26:29government?
- 26:30Then that's where you start getting into a little bit of
- 26:35a gray area.
- 26:35Does that start to become suppression of free speech?
- 26:39But generally speaking, employers have a
- 26:44lot more leeway as to what kind of speech they can restrict compared to the government.
- 26:50There's also that difference between private and public settings.
- 26:53Private settings are generally more restrictive on what you can say or people who own that
- 27:00private property, what they allow to say.
- 27:02If you say something that somebody does not like when you're
- 27:05at their house, they can kick you out.
- 27:07Yeah.
- 27:07You you're you're free to say what you wanna say, but that doesn't mean you can't doesn't
- 27:13mean you can escape the consequence of being kicked out of that house.
- 27:17So another case of, well, should you say something?
- 27:22A lot of times not.
- 27:24But there are some questions that we should all ask ourselves when it comes to whether we can
- 27:29say something versus should say something.
- 27:32So if you can say this thing that you wanna say, should you say it?
- 27:40One question to ask is, is what you're about to say unnecessarily inflammatory?
- 27:46Now, people are going to
- 27:47get mad no matter what because they can't accept the fact that some people think
- 27:51differently than them, even if you say it in the most civil manner you possibly can.
- 27:58But if we're saying it in a very inciting manner, if we're purposely trying to rile
- 28:05people up, should you say it?
- 28:08Especially when you're trying to do it on purpose because you see rage baiters all the
- 28:13time on social media, which is very effective because people engage with that kind of
- 28:18content.
- 28:21But should you incite people?
- 28:23No.
- 28:24You really generally should not.
- 28:26Now sometimes you you might have to say something that grinds people's gears, but if
- 28:32you're just doing it just to get a rise out of people, it's probably not that helpful.
- 28:39And even if we think we should say something, how should we say it?
- 28:44Even if we if the thing that we were gonna say that's inflammatory, if we really feel it needs
- 28:49to be said, we could maybe say it in a more neutral tone, more civil tone.
- 28:56Not necessarily polite.
- 28:57Civil and polite are two different things.
- 29:01Politeness is sometimes not what's
- 29:05not what's necessary, but
- 29:06you should be civil about it.
- 29:08Another question to ask is, is it reasonable to argue that what you're going to say is bigoted?
- 29:16Now, yes, bigoted speech is, generally speaking, protected speech, but you really
- 29:24shouldn't be saying bigoted things.
- 29:25Now some people will say you're being bigoted with what you say, but
- 29:30that's just because they don't like what you said, and they're just gonna throw a hissy fit
- 29:35about it.
- 29:37But if what you're saying is reasonably assumed to be racist, sexist, homophobic, whatever kind
- 29:44of bigotry it is, you don't need
- 29:46to say it, quite frankly.
- 29:48We don't
- 29:48we don't we don't need to be jerks towards people purely because they are of a different
- 29:54demographic group.
- 29:57Another question to ask yourself.
- 29:59Are you actually trying to solve an issue or contribute to a solution with your speech, or
- 30:06are you just trying to grandstand attack insight?
- 30:11Because a lot of times people just put their opinion out there and are just doing it just
- 30:15because they just can't help themselves or they're just mad about something so they need
- 30:21to put it out there right away.
- 30:22I used to do that when I was in high school.
- 30:26It's very unhelpful, dumb.
- 30:31Just saying it just to say something is not actually solving anything.
- 30:35Now, if you really wanna actually contribute to a discussion, that's great.
- 30:39But if you're just trying to do it just to signal that you're holier than thou or that
- 30:45you're actually trying to get people riled up or you're just flat out bashing other people.
- 30:52No, you shouldn't be doing it.
- 30:54Now you a lot.
- 30:55In most cases,
- 30:56you can do that.
- 30:57But again, doesn't mean you should say that.
- 31:01And then one last question, not necessarily the only other question you can ask yourself, but
- 31:06another big one.
- 31:08Is your speech trying to silence other opinions or advocating for the suppression of those
- 31:14opinions purely because you don't like those opinions, which happens a lot of times from
- 31:22people across the political spectrum.
- 31:24They try to shut out other people's opinions, not necessarily through legal means, but
- 31:28sometimes in their personal lives.
- 31:31If you are doing that, you don't truly respect freedom of speech.
- 31:35If you only believe in the freedom of speech for your side of the aisle, then you don't
- 31:39actually believe in freedom of speech.
- 31:41You just want a whole bunch of yes men basically congratulating you, patting you on
- 31:48the back for having the same kind of politics.
- 31:51It means you want people to pander to you.
- 31:54That's not how things should be working.
- 31:57But that's a good segue into this last section of this episode, and that's how do we preserve
- 32:07and promote the freedom of speech?
- 32:11Promoting freedom of speech in government laws and conduct and how we interact with it, that's
- 32:16one thing, and obviously it's very important, and that's typically what we deal with when we
- 32:22talk about freedom of speech.
- 32:24But we should also be promoting freedom of speech in our daily lives and how we interact
- 32:29with people.
- 32:31So
- 32:33how we actually talk to people, where we decide to live, who we decide to become friends with.
- 32:40All these things are all too often influenced by whether our political views coincide with
- 32:46those people we're interacting with.
- 32:49There is evidence to to indicate that more and more people are choosing to live in similar
- 32:58minded neighborhoods with the same party.
- 33:00So Republicans are moving more and more to Republican neighborhoods.
- 33:03Democrats are moving more and more to Democratic neighborhoods.
- 33:08That's not how we should be handling this.
- 33:13When we don't personally live up to the ideal of supporting free speech like we say we
- 33:18believe, not just, hey, I think legally we should protect people's freedom of speech, but
- 33:24you don't demonstrate that in your personal life.
- 33:29I think the idea that you support freedom of speech kind of rings hollow.
- 33:34When we don't live up to that ideal of supporting free speech like we say we do, you
- 33:40become more likely to be okay with government suppression of free speech and disregard for
- 33:46differing opinions because all you're getting is people who think like you, telling you how
- 33:52smart you are because you think like them.
- 33:55And if you're not getting other opinions, lot a of times you're gonna think you've got
- 33:59everything figured out and that other opinions don't matter.
- 34:02That's not how we should be handling things.
- 34:05So how can we better preserve and promote the freedom of speech, not just when it comes to
- 34:11government, but in our own personal lives.
- 34:14Because I think fact that we're not protecting freedom of speech in our personal lives or
- 34:24respecting it in our personal lives, I think has been a major contributor to government
- 34:29attempts to try to stifle freedom of speech.
- 34:34Tips to think about when trying to promote freedom of speech in your daily lives, in your
- 34:41personal interactions.
- 34:43Number one, do not demonize and dehumanize people.
- 34:48When we treat people as subhuman because they think differently than us, we become more
- 34:54likely to support suppressing their opinions because well, they don't even need to be
- 35:00regarded.
- 35:00Why would I care about their opinions?
- 35:02Yeah, Go ahead and shut them out.
- 35:04They're being stupid.
- 35:05They're being evil.
- 35:06They're being whatever it is, whatever excuse it is we come up with to try to stop people
- 35:13from putting forth their opinion.
- 35:16Do you wanna be treated the same way?
- 35:20Probably not.
- 35:21Now,
- 35:22even when people think about that question and say, no, I don't wanna be treated that way.
- 35:27They still don't care because they're like, well, at least it's not me.
- 35:30I'm gonna go ahead and
- 35:31and try to stop these people from putting forth their opinion about things.
- 35:38So don't not not demonize and dehumanize people because you'll become a lot less approving of
- 35:49free speech because you'll be okay with other people losing their freedom of speech, which
- 35:54means you don't actually support freedom of speech.
- 35:59Another tip to preserve freedom of speech in our personal lives.
- 36:03Be adamant, especially in the right to speak for others that don't think like you.
- 36:07This is actually more important than believing in
- 36:11the freedom of speech for your side.
- 36:13It's even more important for you to stand for the rights of other people like you because
- 36:17they'll probably return the favor if you do that.
- 36:22It's like that Voltaire quote of, I don't agree no.
- 36:27I'm gonna paraphrase it, but I don't agree with your stance, but I'll defend your right to say
- 36:32it.
- 36:32Believe it was Voltaire.
- 36:35A lot of times we only care about freedom of speech when it's for people we support, which
- 36:40again, that is not actually freedom of speech.
- 36:43There's a lot of hypocrisy in arguments about why group a should be free to speak, but group
- 36:49B should not in the same exact situation or why group A is being suppressed in
- 36:56a certain situation, but group B in the same situation is not being suppressed.
- 37:02There's a lot
- 37:02of mental gymnastics that go on in that regard.
- 37:07Again, that's not how we should be treating this.
- 37:09Freedom of speech is for everybody or it's for no one.
- 37:14And I think all of us would rather have well, most of
- 37:19us would rather have it be for everybody.
- 37:23But we have to make sure that we are being cognizant of that in how we interact with
- 37:28people.
- 37:29Another tip for preserving the freedom of speech in our personal lives.
- 37:36Do not put ourselves in information silos.
- 37:40Be willing to surround ourselves with a variety of viewpoints.
- 37:43Don't have any yes men.
- 37:44Don't have any people congratulating you for being a conservative like them or liberal like
- 37:49them, an independent moderate like them, whatever the case is.
- 37:54We don't need people pandering to us.
- 37:56Nobody should be being pandered to and told how smart they are just because they share
- 38:01political opinions.
- 38:04Now this isn't entirely our fault.
- 38:07Social media algorithms, the fragmentation of media in general, have done a lot to wall us
- 38:14off from other opinions that are not ours.
- 38:17Or even sometimes opinions that are similar to us, but
- 38:20are not quite the same because some people get pissed off at their own side because they're
- 38:25not enough on their side.
- 38:28Like when you hear Republicans and Democrats complain about, quote, unquote, fake
- 38:35Republicans or fake Democrats call them rhinos and dinos, Republicans in name only, Democrats
- 38:41in name only for short.
- 38:44It's that
- 38:44no true Scotsman fallacy.
- 38:46So you some people will get mad even if they're not
- 38:49if they're, like, 80% on their side, but not a 100% on their side because people need
- 38:56uniformity for some reason.
- 38:59So it's partly the fault of media,
- 39:01but it's also partly our own fault.
- 39:03We need to be more proactive in trying to find other people's opinions.
- 39:11We also need
- 39:12to teach people how to do that better as well because we don't teach people to critically
- 39:17think as well as we should.
- 39:20The fourth tip I will leave for
- 39:24how to preserve freedom of speech in our personal lives.
- 39:28Take the time to truly understand why people think the
- 39:32way they do, what they're actually thinking, and why they think that.
- 39:36Sometimes the the reasons we think people are why they believe a certain way, it's not
- 39:44actually why they believe what they believe.
- 39:46A lot
- 39:47of times it's actually not.
- 39:49And I've encountered that too where I've seen I think somebody thinks a certain way and I think
- 39:55I know why they believe a certain way.
- 39:57I still do it.
- 39:58We all do it.
- 39:59But then later on, I hear from them and I'm like, oh, okay.
- 40:03I see your points.
- 40:04Or am I am I still not agree, but I'm like, okay.
- 40:07Well, that's not why I thought you were thinking that in the first place.
- 40:11Everybody has biases that influence how they think whether they realize it or not.
- 40:18Everybody's got them.
- 40:19We all think our biases are less so than other people or that we've we've broken free of our
- 40:26biases or that we're not just we're not being biased.
- 40:29It's we've just figured things out.
- 40:32No.
- 40:34Take the time to actually understand why other people believe what they believe.
- 40:37You don't
- 40:37have to agree.
- 40:39In fact, a lot of times you're not going to agree.
- 40:42You don't have to change your mind.
- 40:45Not necessarily, but you have to give people a chance to say why they believe what they
- 40:55believe and actually make a concerted effort to understand that.
- 41:01And then the last tip I'll leave about promoting freedom of speech in our personal
- 41:06lives is we need to understand that rhetoric is not inherently violent.
- 41:13There's a lot of cases on the left and the right where people treat differing opinions as
- 41:20inherently violent or that it's going
- 41:22to foment violence.
- 41:24Even if
- 41:24it's something that's really despicable that's said, you can't just assume that it's going to
- 41:28foment violence.
- 41:29Go back to that imminent lawless action test, for example.
- 41:35We can find things that other people say to be despicable, abhorrent, etcetera, but it doesn't
- 41:42mean we can suppress them.
- 41:43And suppressing rarely, if ever, changes those opinions anyways.
- 41:47If you're really actually trying to make people, for example, not bigoted, like I said
- 41:52earlier, silencing them is probably not going to do it.
- 41:57Now even if you don't silence them, a lot of them won't change their minds anyways.
- 42:02But the point is they still have a freedom of speech.
- 42:06We don't have to like it.
- 42:09Affirming other people's freedom of speech does not mean you have to like what they say.
- 42:14A lot of times you should not like what they have to say,
- 42:19but they have the right to say it as long as they don't violate any laws that have been
- 42:28already established to be constitutional when it comes to restricting freedom of speech.
- 42:35And last thought I'll leave here is we really need to remind ourselves that we are a
- 42:43pluralistic nation,
- 42:44or at least we're supposed to be.
- 42:46Now that's something I wanna do a podcast episode or maybe have a guest on is pluralism
- 42:52and how pluralistic are we because a lot of people think that we're not really all that
- 42:57pluralistic and that it's it's a small number of interests that have all the power.
- 43:05That's a whole other conversation.
- 43:07But at the very least, we're supposed to be a pluralistic nation.
- 43:10We're supposed to be a marketplace of ideas.
- 43:13The system was designed to have a bunch of interests competing for political influence.
- 43:19The Federalist Papers even say as such.
- 43:24Now this country has not always lived up to its pluralistic ideal.
- 43:29For example, how we've treated race over time or women.
- 43:37So like a lot of cases, the American ideal and reality have not always matched, but we have
- 43:47made incredible strides to achieving that pluralistic ideal, and we should strive to
- 43:56improve in this aspect every day.
- 43:59We're supposed to
- 44:00be a marketplace of ideas, and progress only happens with a free exchange of ideas because
- 44:05nobody has everything figured out.
- 44:07Nobody has all the answers.
- 44:09Nobody's worldview is a 100%
- 44:11accurate.
- 44:13So the only way we actually make things better for everybody is if we have a free exchange of
- 44:20ideas.
- 44:21And who knows?
- 44:22Maybe you'll hear an idea that even if you don't entirely agree with it, you think, Well,
- 44:27you know what?
- 44:27This one part of it, that actually makes sense.
- 44:30And you wouldn't have ever known you wouldn't have gotten any better because you were trying
- 44:35to suppress that speech, or not even necessarily suppress that speech, but you tried
- 44:39to wall yourself by making an information silo.
- 44:44So make sure that we realize that the freedom of speech is not just about how the government
- 44:52treats us.
- 44:53It's about how we treat each other, whether indirectly through who we put in office or
- 45:01directly in how we interact with people.
- 45:05Because might might sound surprising, but sometimes people who think differently than
- 45:12than you aren't actually bad people.
- 45:16Even if they are misguided, they're not always bad people.
- 45:20Now whether they're misguided, that's a lot of
- 45:23times that's our own biases talking anyways.
- 45:25But people who think differently than you are not inherently bad people.
- 45:31Maybe they just haven't heard your side of the argument, but
- 45:37we need to be a little bit more understanding of people.
- 45:40And even if we don't agree with what they say,
- 45:46we need to affirm their right to say it.
- 45:50So that's gonna
- 45:51do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 45:53As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 45:55Please like, comment, subscribe, share with everybody you know.
- 45:59My links to the show notes, my Facebook, my Paul Raider author and speaker, LinkedIn
- 46:05profile, mymedium.com writings, my five day educational email course about mistakes we make
- 46:13when trying to depolarize American politics, and why we make those mistakes and how we can
- 46:20fix those mistakes so that we actually depolarize politics.
- 46:26And my book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections and how they could become more
- 46:31competitive.
- 46:32Just not arguing that we should or shouldn't have more independence.
- 46:35Just talking about the challenges they face and actual ways they can improve their station.
- 46:41And my website, paulraider.org.
- 46:45That's gonna do it though for today's episode.
- 46:48So again, thank you so much, and until next
- 46:51time, take care.