Latest / Ego and Other Things / Are we actually free, or are our choices determined by forces outside of our control?
Transcript
- William: Are we free or are our choices determined by factors that we can barely understand? Now I'm going to assume that, starting off with this question, that when we're talking about whether or not we're free, we are talking about free will, whether we have the actual native ability to choose. And not are we free in the sort of general sense, in the political or personal sense. In the political and personal sense, I can say that we are pretty thoroughly unfree, that we are often conditioned by the violence and the force that's inherent in our society, and by the conditioning and violence and force that we experience in the parent-child relationship, but by Just the description of the latter half of this question where it's talking about are we determined by forces that we can't understand? I think this is leaning towards that question of free will or determinism. Are we just causally determined like everything else in the universe around us? Or is there something special about us where we get to choose our own destiny? Where we get to choose our own actions? Now, philosophically speaking, I've Generally found this question to be kind of useless, sort of like a red herring. I I think that sometimes this question of free will gets brought up in order to Either justify or ignore ethical questions. There it's something like, you know, if we can't, if we don't have free will, right? If we can't choose our path, if if we can't choose right and wrong, but we are rather destined by causal forces outside of our control to choose between the right path and the wrong path, then we can't be held morally responsible for our our so-called bad actions. And therefore the whole question of morality and ethics as a field goes out the window. and this is where a bit of that energy around determinism comes from, from the attempt to to sweep away ethics entirely and and give people an excuse or give that individual an excuse to do something that they know is wrong. Or on the other hand, you have the energy coming from the free will crowd that is interested in pro proving free will. In order to protect or solidify ethics and giving people moral responsibility. So it's one of those questions that has a lot of energy behind it. It's one of those questions that gets a lot of attention because people think that the stakes are high. Personally, I think this is just again a red herring. I think whether you answer the question of free will by saying we have choice or we don't have choice. The ethical outcome is functionally the same. Meaning that the way that we actually respond to to evil and badness in the world is the same. Evil is something that is metaphysical. It's not something that gets determined by whether we choose it or not. Evil is the outcome of of an action or force. So or badness is an outcome of an action or a force. So we think about you know, somebody living peacefully in their home, for instance, a tornado comes through and rips through their home, destroys it. And that is experienced by the person as tragic and bad and part of the evil nature of the world, or at least part of the the bad nature of the world, the potential for for destruction and pain and suffering that is inherent in the world. Now we wouldn't we wouldn't assign the tornado any any kind of moral responsibility because We think it doesn't have any choice, it's not a human being, it doesn't seem to have options by which it chooses from, which seems to be the case with human beings anyway. but nonetheless we experience that that situation as a tragedy. And insofar as we are capable of, we try to prevent and mitigate those tragic outcomes, that evil or bad outcome from the existential. So we have weather reports, we have bunkers, we have insurance, we have different ways of trying to mitigate or or even prevent tornadoes from happening. Or at least being affected by them in one way or another. And this is functionally the same way that we approach the evil behavior or the bad actions of people in general. The one caveat that that we include in that is sort of how likely is the person based on their history, based on their intent, based on their character, based on why we based on what we know about the action itself. And the context behind the action. Based on all that, how likely is this person to you know commit this this kind of this action again? so in the base case, when people do something wrong, what happens is they they and they get caught and they get brought to court. there is a judgment about whether they are guilty or not guilty of committing the crime, that is whether or not they have or haven't done it. And then there's typically when it comes to sentencing, There is a second kind of evaluation of intent, of purposefulness, of whether or not this this person was trying to commit this bad action, whether it's an accident, etc. So you have something like manslaughter, where a person ends up, you know, they they by some mistake in driving, they they hit and kill somebody. but it was a mistake, it wasn't intentional. The the The outcome was this tragic situation of somebody dying. And of course the judge and you could say the society at large is is Trying to impose a punishment that is going to make other people more careful when they're driving, more paying attention to the law or not drinking and driving, these kinds of things. And so you get a charge of manslaughter where there is some sort of punishment in response to it, even if the person was didn't intentionally try to do it, or maybe it just happened to be a sort of freak situation, they'll still get a a charge of manslaughter because. This helps to incentivize all the rest of the people who are who are driving to be sort of more careful when they're out there. And so there's this way in which the justice system is geared towards, or at least the way that we typically understand justice, is that it's geared towards preventing the evil or the bad outcome in the future. If you have somebody who pre-planned some kind of murder or attack. or robbery or something like that. If you can show that they're they have intent behind that, that their character has led them to to be the kind of person who kills and robs and and maims and whatnot, then it's much more likely that the the punishment is going to be much more severe, that the person is going to be locked away in a place where they can't do that again, where you've curtailed the the repetition of that same kind of behavior. And of course, in situations where the the bad outcome is tied to something which doesn't seem likely to repeat itself, then there's practically no punishment. There's no separation. If we have I don't know, I can think of a situation like a mother trips over her baby, falls down the stairs and breaks her leg, the baby's not getting brought up on charges and put in prison simply because the the likelihood that this baby did this intentionally and this wasn't a complete absolute accident means that the baby's not going to the likelihood of this being repeated is incredibly low. And punishing a baby for doing that isn't going to incentivize the rest of society to be sort of more care the rest of babies to be more careful around their mothers. So any any idea of of punishment or of separating in in a jailhouse Or of trying to mitigate it for this potential repetition of bad action is mitigated by the way that the justice system actually functionally operates. And then probably the third aspect of that would be restitution. So if somebody gets gets harmed by somebody else and there's a possibility for a or r restitution, then usually the justice system tries to tries to coerce that restitution from the offending from the offending person. And so justice justice itself or the way that we respond to bad actions has very little to do with whether or not the person was determined to make the outcome or whether they supposedly chose the outcome. The question comes down to not so much are they morally responsible, but how likely are they, based on what we know, to repeat this action again and how effective is punishment against this this individual here likely to incentivize other people to to not commit the same kind of actions or be more careful in some way help prevent again the repetition of bad actions in the futures. That is essentially what the justice system is reacting towards. That's essentially the way that we look at at punishment, not really based on responsibility, or at least the question of responsibility becomes one of causal responsibility. Was this person causally responsible and how was this person causally responsible? for you know said that action. And we do the same thing with animals and insofar as we can in mitigate sort of natural disasters, we we do the same thing when it comes to sort of natural events. We treat people functionally at the very least as though they are determined, as though the question is again, how likely is this person based on what we know to to recommit this this kind of of crime? And how effective is the punishment in preventing those kinds of crimes from happening in the future. And so I don't know how much of the free will determinism debate would actually sort of change that kind of question. Because if people had sort of total free will, then we would still be trying to prevent bad actors by by locking them away. we would still be trying to incentivize people away. from from bad actions by imposing costs and penalties and jail time and things like that. And on the other hand, if they were completely determined, then then we would still be doing the same things. We would be trying to we would we would be saying, all right, this person has committed this bad action, we won't we don't want that bad action to keep happening, so let's lock them away or let's punish them in order to incentivize them and other people not to do it again. Right. So no matter which side of this Question that you land on, the essence of ethics, the essence of good and bad, and how we actually respond to it isn't going to change all that much. And our not only that, but our individual experience of the world is not going to change based on whether we think we are determined or free. And so this is why I talk about this whole debate as something like a red herring, as something like a distraction, because I don't know if going on either side of that question produces reliable or produces really any change, any meaningful change in how we functionally go about understanding right and wrong and responding to right and wrong either internally or externally. And something doesn't become good just because it becomes determined, or because it has free choice behind it. Something doesn't become bad because it is determined or because it has good choice in it. The the goodness or the badness of any of any action is has to do with whether it fits the the ethical category, whether it fits the sort of definition, not whether it it conforms to a free choice or a determined choice. so I kind of view the whole debate as a bit of a distraction. that being said, what I would what I would say is that from the philosophical point of view, I sort of just assume that I have free will, or I operate as if I have free will. And that mostly from the psychological observances of how that idea actually impacts your day-to-day behavior. I don't think that we Are able to choose our values, right? We're I don't think we're able to choose you could say the full potential of who we are. There's a sort of you know limited outcome that is related to our innate potential. And there is a sort of set of hierarchies of values that sit within us, and perhaps they compete on a surface level. And they relate and arrange themselves according to the actual options that we. That we have, the actual environment that we're sitting within. But we have no real choice to choose the values themselves. Choosing the value itself constitutes a value, constitutes a deeper desire to sort of be free. And the desire to be free would itself not be would not be chosen. So when we talk about freedom or we talk about liberty in that kind of sense, what we really mean is not. The freedom to choose what we value, but the freedom to act for the sake of what we value. the freedom to objectify or or to seek what we value. I think this is something that that John Locke pointed out, is that it's a bit absurd to try to get to the point of choosing your own values. Because what value are you going to base the choice of your values on? And if you can get there's a sort of infinite regress of values. along that that line of thinking. And the reality is that you have a a base of values that you simply don't choose but you act for the sake of. And there are competing values, there are means, you might say more superficial means to those more fundamental values that your mind is trying to distinguish fur between and and choose in terms of how much more efficient those choices would be to objectifying the more fundamental values. And there's a constant experimentation and you might say updating of the framework based on h what you actually experience, like whether or not when a value is manifested it makes you happy and fulfilled and satisfied and like you wanna like you want to maintain that kind of value. So there's a whole complex structure that I think people experience phenomenally as choice. And mostly as choice comes, I think choice comes to the conscious mind when the conscious mind has multiple s somewhat similar options to make about fundamental values, or perhaps two potentially valuable choices, two or more potentially valuable choices to or paths or potentials to be made. In regards to a more fundamental value, and it is sort of bringing up to the conscious mind, because the conscious mind is better at making detailed, explicit choices compared to the instinctual, the yeah, sort of ex instinctual mind. It has more of an eye for detail, an ability to sift between the true value of different options. And so when those conflicts come up or when those multiple choices come up, which are They come up almost moment to moment, but when they come up, they are given to the conscious mind for more of a detailed evaluation. And that sifting through is this choice going to be better or worse, I think is that experience of what people call choice. But that but it it it it very well may be that that's simply the your mind being conscious of the sifting process rather than necessarily choice itself. On the other hand, the experience of choice, I think, or the pres presuppos presupposition of choice is psychologically valuable because Regardless of the true nuance of the determinist position, as including different potentialities, and the exp the phenomenal experience of choice, I think the psychological premise of choice ends up leading you to feeling like you have absolutely no control over your life. You have no control over whether your life is going to end up good or bad, or whether you can really act. in a way that matters in the end for your own happiness and for your own meaning. Now, strictly speaking, the determinist position doesn't actually doesn't actually get rid of that. It just brings it down to causal, causal factors, and you're still left with the same experience and you're you're still acting automatically on the values that you have, which get experienced as choice. But psychologically, it feels like you're constrained. Psychologically, it feels like you have no control. Psychologically, it feels like I will always be who I am right now, no matter what, into the future, and there's no possibility of of change. And whereas psychologically, the experien the premise of free choice allows you to feel as though you have a a modicum of control. It allows you to feel as though you have. A an ability to change your your future. But real like the the truth is that regardless of the determinist position or the free will position, you do have the capacity to to to change your future and to act for the sake of what you value and to act towards who it is that you really are and discover more about yourself. Your future is not going to be the same as your presence. And this is again where it's like. I think that In terms of the experience of the world, there's not much of a difference between free will and determinism, even in terms of pursuing what makes you happy, even in terms of concepts like autonomy and control in your life, because where those things matter are not in this absolute control, not in this absolute autonomy, but am I able to act for the sake of what I value truthfully and in both both scenarios the the answer is is yes. So there's another area where I think these things kind of conflate, though I I really I tend to run with the psychological premise of choice just for the sake of that that sense of well-being, that sense of autonomy and control, which is connotated with the idea of free choice, but isn't necessarily connotated with the conception of being determined. But that is not again related to the truth of either of these concepts. That's more like a cultural overlay of how we sort of experience one or the other. So I will I I talk in terms of choices. I talk in terms of free will, but I don't feel as I don't feel as though I need to have certainty about one or the other in the debate because functionally there is no real difference between the two. So I would say that's that's basically the the secular philosophical perspective that I take. Free will, the the debate between free will and determinism is something which Either outcome doesn't really matter in the end. And we can faithfully put that question aside and still pursue the questions of of ethics and of how we should live in the world and of who we are and whether or not we live in a free society and whether or not we are being conditioned by our our social forces or by our parent-child relationship. We can put the question of free will aside and pick up the same kinds of questions that we were interested in to begin with. pretty safely, I believe. And the more interesting questions of freedom have to do: am I free from my society? Right? Am I free from the the violence of the parent-child relationship? Am I free from the coercive violence of the state to act for the sake of who I really am? Am I free to know myself? and yeah. And then I would say a bit of a a side note to all of this is one of the things that compounds that I think the really the reality of Control or the reality of choice would be knowledge, in the sense that the more that you understand about yourself and the world, the more options you have, the more paths you have for the objectification of of who you really are, the objectification of your of your meaning and your purpose and your life. And again, the the phenomenal experience of that is a broader choice. perhaps the determinist reality. I mean, really, I don't know. truth between one or the other, but even from a determinist point or from a determinist's point of view, you would view the expansion of knowledge as just the the greater ability to to act based on that automatically acting v value of pursuing knowledge. So like a machine, you you feed it more information, sort of like AI, right? AI doesn't seem to have choice, but we feed it more information. And the more information that we feed it, the more capable it seems of know, spitting out answers when it comes to to different kinds of things. And in a similar way, it that might be us, except that we have an internal drive to sort of gather our own information. And I think if you have that the sort of spark of that in you, then your biggest lever for that feeling of choice, for that feeling of control, and really for for the more possibilities of action, possibilities of objecting your finding yourself, it comes through knowledge. and this is why we say knowledge is power. So that would be again, that would be the philosophical or secular point of view. the Christian perspective that I've I've taken to this is little bit different, because I Would say that I largely agree with with with Calvin on this, where I think that if you read I think that if you read the word, particularly the New Testament gospels, you will find within that well, the New Testament in general, you will find again and again and again these statements of of determinism, these statements of predestination. That is, that those who will come to Jesus, those who will put their faith in God, those who are children of God and will enter a heaven, these have been predetermined from The beginning from the beginning. I believe that there is the elect, that those who come to believe in God and Jesus are chosen by God, that they don't come to God by their own choice, they don't come to God by by any sort of work of their own, but entirely by his grace, entirely by the spirit which moves in them. That was my own experience in coming to God. I was God probably God's greatest opponent for most of my life. And when I came to faith, it was a a movement, it was in me. It was something that was switched, I almost think like switched on, rather than something which I I chose to do. I often have described it as though I was looking off a cliff and saying, if I jump, that's that's dumb to jump because you know I'll jump and I'll die, right? That was kind of the thought of my life is that every you know, you see these people jumping off this cliff and you're going, What a bunch of idiots, they're all gonna fall to their deaths. And I'm staring off this cliff like, well, that's stupid. And then one day I kind of just got kicked off. I got kicked off the cliff. And now I found out that actually what looked like death was eternal life, right? what looked like slavery was actually freedom. But I can only understand that now. That I'm on the other side of faith, because faith was given to me by the grace of God. I believe that the gospels reflect that. And people ask about, I think the the trickiest question there that comes up is, you know, is there any room for free will or choice in in the biblical outlook, right? So for example, or an objection that's come up I've heard before is that, well, if people are completely determined. And God is in control and has all the power, then what about sin? I mean, how can we be given moral responsibility for our sins if we haven't chosen them? If it's just sort of part of our character or our nature? And how can we be responsible for that? And there, and therefore, how can God condemn us to to hell or eternal death or eternal separation from him based on something that we had no? choice over to begin with. And the first thing I'll say is I'm I'm not an expert on the Bible. I know about enough to preach of the gospel and much of the rest comes comes about on faith. But I'll try to give you the the way that I've thought about it, which is that when it comes to sin, when it actually comes to okay, am I going to do the right thing or the wrong thing, I think we have I think we have choice. I think there is when it comes to when it comes to our behaviors from a Christian perspective, I believe that we are free. And I believe that we are even capable of of doing good, so to speak. that one I I don't know, I I'm sort of fuzzy on. There's a sense in there's this phrase in Calvinism called total depravity, which is the idea that everything good comes from God. And so I I I wonder, I wonder to the extent to which we have control over whether or not we choose the good or not. I think God has given us freedom. And insofar as we use we have used that freedom for good, that ultimately have has its source in God. And so even our own goodness we must be thankful for for God because he is the the He's the author of all of all goodness. but I think that we we choose sin and evil. And it's that choice of sin and evil that really condemns us, that creates that separation, that creates that cost of sin, that condemns condemns us to hell and and to death. I also believe that It's not an like an it's not an absolutely free choice. And what I mean by that is that each person is born into a fallen world. Each per I mean beyond Adam and Eve, each person is born into a fallen world, into a world where one's parents and one's society, they they teach sin. In fact, the the way that I think about the the inheritance of sin is not so much like something that gets passed down through the blood. Or passed down genetically or something like that, but sin gets taught to people through the sins of the world around them. And that's how you you understand the options of the option of sin to begin with, is the way that teet people teach you. but even that, even within that you have a choice. Even within that, you have the ability to choose between whether or not you're going to commit sin. Or not commit sin. And it is your choice to commit sin that ultimately condemns you. And not only that, but it's your continual, you continue to choose sin. It's not just one time, the one time is enough. You people continually commit sins. Every day people sin, even if they have the capacity to choose otherwise. Everybody sins. And we just know that from the word. Nobody is righteous, not even one. So everybody sins, everybody chooses evil at some point in their life. And that's what condemns them. And the the original choice that they had was to follow God's law and enter into heaven, or disobey God's law and be condemned to death. And that was the situation for that seemed to be the situation anyway, un until Jesus came. And Jesus became our our mediator. God loved us so much that he came down to earth. and and paid the costs for us through through his son jesus and now because of the grace of god we those who god has chosen to bring into his kingdom he has given them grace he has given them the he has given them the revelation that they need to put their faith in Christ he has he has changed their hearts turned away their hearts but that grace that salvation is not a choice that salvation is a gift from God. That salvation is something that God changes within you and gives you. by his own will and by his own wisdom. And Why God makes the selection he does is not known. Whether or not anybody is saved is not really known. a person can can be A person can act in all the ways that seem to be of a Christian and still not be saved. So we none of us have the right to judge a salvation of another person. In fact, none of us even have the right to judge the content of one's sins. We can say that everybody does sin, but we cannot necessarily judge that, you know, this person has actually sinned. there's a lot of not relativity, but there's a lot of human ignorance that's mixed up mixed up with it. In fact, the story of Job is is really a demonstration of this because Job is righteous, Job is good, but his friends assume because he is suffering that he must have sinned in some way. And but the story clearly tells you that Job was righteous. So there is this sense in which humans put themselves in the seat of judgment, they put themselves in the seat of knowing whether or not somebody is saved and knowing whether or not somebody is is has sinned or not and how they have sinned and how they haven't sinned. And I don't think the gospel says anything about that. Or it is not the human's place to make the judgment, it is it's God's place to make the judgment about us. But in terms of our grace and our salvation, we don't have the choice to do that. Now the caveat there is is if you're hearing this and you're wondering, am I one of the elect, right? Am I one of the ones that are going to be saved by Jesus? If I am I the one that will receive God's Spirit. What I can tell you, and you know what the sort of what the good news is, is that If you have those doubts, call out to God. If you have those those doubts, then call out to Jesus and ask him to reveal himself to you. Ask to have faith in him. And he will. He will reveal himself to you. He will give you faith if you ask. The very fact that you have doubts, the very fact that you are worried, the very fact that you are you know listening to this and not just turning away from it and saying, what nonsense, what garbage, you know, finding some sort of justification about it. The very fact that you are worried about your salvation is a signal that you should cry out to God. It's a signal that you should cry out to Jesus and put your faith in him. The gospel says that anybody who comes to him will receive him. Anybody who accepts his gift of faith and salvation will receive it. But he's moving you that way. He's responsible for that movement in you and pushing you towards grace and salvation. So don't ignore it. Accept it. Right. Clearly you're one of the elect if you go and put your faith in Jesus. so the experience is sometimes is one of calling, right? But God is generating the movement within you. So if you have doubts, call out to Jesus. Go put your faith in it. Repent of the life that you've lived and put your faith in Him. And God will receive you. That's the promise that we have from the gospel. So if you have doubts, Do exactly what the g what what God has has told you. Put your faith in Christ and you will be saved. it's as easy as that. But from this question of predestination, again the the the the total answer is that we've been predestined. And that if you are if you are being drawn towards Jesus even as we speak, that itself is the work of God. That itself is a work of his grace. And it's a grace that none of us deserve. Again, who knows why God chooses who he does? but we know that it has nothing to do with us. I mean my my salvation was not earned through me. There's nothing special or good about me that I should become saved. for whatever reason God and wisdom that I can't understand or comprehend, God has chosen to show me grace. And that's what makes me so thankful in terms of that. But everything is predestined by God in this in this view. or everything is our choices our choice our our choices to to To choose sin or not to choose sin, I think God gives us freedom there. He gives us the moments of choice. I myself have had experiences of knowing absolutely that what I was doing was wrong and doing it anyway. So he gives us these moments of choice and all of us choose evil, all of us choose to to turn away from him. And then he chooses some among sinners to be the elect. And this is something that you you see it time and time again in The Old Testament, even with the Jewish people, is the Jewish people would rebel. There would be a remnant that God would preserve with no obvious markings of their specialness or goodness. It's not like the Jewish people deserved to be the special people. God was just showing them grace. but this remnant that comes out, it gets preserved. There's nothing that they've done to earn it, but God has preserved this remnant. it it builds, then the Jewish people rebel and they turn away. Remnant, this again, this pattern happens again and again in the old testament, and you see it renewed again and again in the New Testament with Jesus. you might have questions about, you know, where does evangelism s sit in that place? Because I'm out there sharing sharing the gospel, knowing that only the elect are going to receive God's call. And the answer is that that you know God chooses to work through people, God chooses to work through. through love and relationships and communication, and insofar as God wants to use me as an instrument for salvation, then he has given me whatever drive or whatever you know small ability I have to go out and do that. And he's going to use that in in whatever way, even though I I can't sort of understand it. And not only that, but the lot the the the events of my life are orchestrated by God ultimately. for for my good. He says that specifically about believers, that that Yeah, he sa he says that specifically about believers, that the li that the events of their life are orchestrated for their good. So in that sense, salvation is predestined. In that sense, the container of my life, or really the whole of my life, is is is directed by God. God has given me, God has allowed me the freedom of choice which I and everybody else often use for sin, and that's why. even now, even as somebody who's who's saved, I sin. I sin daily. And that renews my sense of dependence on God for goodness and for grace. And which deepens sort of my faith and trust in Him. So from the Christian point of view, I I take that that Calvinistic perspective of predestination when it comes to grace in salvation in particular. But I combine that with a certain kind of freedom to to choose to sin or not. That and and I believe that we are responsible for our sins in that way. At least I don't understand how we could be responsible for our sins without kind of active choice. But maybe maybe you guys out there would know a little bit more about that. So I think I'm gonna end it here. I hope that this was Clear enough. hope this is this was interesting. I'd I'd love to hear your guys' thought on this, either from the the philosophical perspective or the religious perspective Christian perspective. I mean, do you think that you do you land on this sort of free will on one side or the other of the free will determinism debate? Do you think that question matters? when it comes to the Christian question, do you think that salvation is predestined or that we we choose through and through? How do you kind of reconcile the responsibility of sin with with with hell and and salvation and all these different kinds of things. I would love to just to talk with you guys more about that. and if you if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think somebody else would find any of this interesting or helpful, then please share it with them. And if you want to hear more If you want to see more videos like this, then please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.