Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #236 - Annie Ohana / Wade Grant
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Coller,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, let's look
- 0:25at inclusivity and equity through a BC lens and how divisive some of these issues
- 0:31have become wide grant of the Musciam First Nation, will be here to discuss
- 0:35the troubling trend of truth and reconciliation being used as a political tool to sew
- 0:41division in our province. But first, Sexual Orientation and gender identity SOG can
- 0:47be described as resources and codes of conduct for BC teachers and educators as a
- 0:52way to protect vulnerable students and while it was introduced in twenty sixteen, there
- 0:58seems to be a loud backlash against it now eight years later. But is
- 1:03SOGI misunderstood? Here to explain. Sogi is the Indigenous Department head at La
- 1:07Matheson's Secondary School in Surrey, BC. Last year, she was one of
- 1:11the ten finalists for the prestigious Global Teacher Prize, which is like the Nobel
- 1:18Prize for educators. She is Annie o'hanna. Annie, what a pleasure.
- 1:23Thank you so much for having me. Well, thanks for being here absolutely,
- 1:26So let's start with the basics. I've even made the mistake on the
- 1:29show of calling sogi a curriculum, which it is not. Absolutely for people
- 1:34who may not understand it or may have heard of sogi, can you explain
- 1:37exactly what sogi is? Absolutely an easy mistake to make, and that's not
- 1:40a problem, and I'm glad people are starting to catch themselves when they do
- 1:42that. So first of all, one thing, maybe it's loud, but
- 1:46it's not large the backlash. I want to make that really clear. That's
- 1:49why I didn't say arch. Yeah, there you go. I think across
- 1:51the board we see that for the most part, sogi is very much accepted.
- 1:55So what is soji exactly? So, as you said, it's not
- 1:57a curriculum, it's a resource. It's almost like a guide. Right.
- 2:00It follows our human rights codes, which are very clear in terms of all
- 2:04the different things and protected characteristics that we want to protect our students ourselves,
- 2:08Like all these rights matter. Secondly, I like to consider it like i'most
- 2:13like talking about religion, right, so as teachers, we want to be
- 2:15mindful to include diversity, whether a student is Muslim or Jewish or Christian or
- 2:20punjab it's sorry, sick or a Buddhist right or atheist. All these things
- 2:23are really important to protect. And so if I can have some information about
- 2:28that that allows me to understand the customs, the traditions and ways that I
- 2:32need to perhaps make sure is included in my curriculum, the actual curriculum,
- 2:37then wonderful. So that's all SOG is. SOGI is a way to protect
- 2:40all people across all spectrums under what our BC Human Rights Code says we need
- 2:46to protect. So give me an example of where SOGI is applied, perhaps
- 2:49one of the more common examples of where SOG is being put into practical use.
- 2:53Absolutely, so we can look at KA twelve, but let's look at
- 2:55the elementary school example, where it seems there's a lot of consternation over that.
- 3:00So it could be as simple as a book that's read in class,
- 3:04a book that has multiple types of parents in it, and it's something like
- 3:07Dad takes John to the park, right, they play with Spots their dog.
- 3:10It's as simple as that. But instead of like leaving out only sorry,
- 3:15including only one type of family, we're looking at all types of families,
- 3:19right, So it's not we're not teaching sex. We're not teaching about
- 3:23you know, often something like pornography. There's no such thing as that,
- 3:25right. We are looking at like the day to day how do we talk
- 3:30to each other in humane ways? How do we make sure we respect people
- 3:32and their identities? And again that can be from a small little picture book
- 3:37to in Social Justice twelve, which is of course I teach looking at the
- 3:39gay purge that the history of the criminalization of homophobia. Sorry have homosexuals in
- 3:45Canada, which was a systemic kind of purge and a rature of the two
- 3:50SLGBTQI plus community. I have to be honest, none of this seems particularly
- 3:53controversial because I remember growing up and we learned about civil rights movements at the
- 3:58time, and that was part of school, even in elementary school. So
- 4:00I know that you, unfortunately have had to be the subject of a lot
- 4:04of abuse and harassment, both online and offline. What are the misconceptions that
- 4:11angry parents or non parents are bringing to you or bringing to the SOGI conversation,
- 4:15I guess, and I want to make differentiation. I think parents have
- 4:18concerns, should always be concerned about their chown's education and should always be involved
- 4:24in their children's schooling, right, that's paramount, absolutely. But what we're
- 4:28seeing is vitriol from a very small group of people that have like a political
- 4:31agenda that want to see the criminalization of to SLGBQI plus people out front.
- 4:36So they are lying, they are misinforming, they are disinforming, and for
- 4:41teachers like me to be called pedophiles, to be called grumors, to get
- 4:45death threats, anti Semitic, Islamophobic, racist attacks, because it covers the
- 4:49whole plethora. You know, there's even the anti vax crowd, anti science
- 4:54crowd in there, so mix that all together, and that's what teachers are
- 4:57facing. So I'm only one, there are many, and you will see
- 5:00human rights claims coming forward against some of these individuals because they are openly lying,
- 5:04they're defaming, and they're they're actually committing slander and libel against their education
- 5:10system. And most importantly, in some of the protests, people are seeing
- 5:14the active bullying of staff of students right at our doorstep, and that is
- 5:17simply unexcpt. I mean that sounds like a safety concern to me. Certainly
- 5:20death death threats are involved when it comes to let's say, actual parents who
- 5:25may have concerns, maybe they hear things or they see things online that are
- 5:29being amplified. What are there more most common complaints that are misconceptions of so
- 5:32gun So Number one, that somehow kids are getting gender affirming care at a
- 5:39very young age, which is simply inappropriate. We have a very strong system
- 5:43in BC Transcare BC people can look it up. Or that the resources we're
- 5:46using are not age appropriate and again not happening because as teachers, we can
- 5:50lose our jobs, we can lose our license over that. So those are
- 5:54two of the biggest ones that we're and that we're indoctrinating, right, that
- 5:58somehow we're teaching that there's no such thing as gender or that there's you know,
- 6:01gender ideology, which again all simply untrue. So I really want parents
- 6:05to reach out to their teachers and give them the moment to explain look at
- 6:11the actual materials, not just the one or two or four that they keep
- 6:14talking about, but the legitimate curriculum that we're using in our classrooms. Right,
- 6:19I've heard that or I've seen that online. In terms of your indoctrinating
- 6:23as kids, what do you say to parents that say that that are very
- 6:28firm that you know, you're teaching our kids that this lifestyle, that they
- 6:31should adopt, this lifestyle that they have issues with. Yeah, well,
- 6:35number one, it's not a lifestyle, right, So that that's the first
- 6:39thing I'm using. Yeah, no, no, I know, no exactly.
- 6:41So back to them, it's you know you're talking about it's like the
- 6:45the sorry, the color of your hair. It's the color of your skin,
- 6:48right, it's your DNA, that's who you are. So I am
- 6:51not going to erase anybody. I'm not going to turn anybody into a thought
- 6:55experiment. But secondly, that really very much what we have to focus on
- 7:00is that we're here to protect human rights. We're not indoctrinating anybody. We
- 7:03are being supportive of Canada's stance on the freedom of rights of all of our
- 7:09people. And students are people too, so they deserve that protection as well.
- 7:13A lot of the parents say that are angry about this or have misconceptions
- 7:16with SOGI, say that you're alienating the kids from the parents or from their
- 7:20families. What do you say to that particular charge that you know, you're
- 7:25not even telling us what you're doing in schools and you're putting ideas into our
- 7:29kids' heads. That is so far from the truth because as they themselves know,
- 7:31they can look up what's in our libraries, right, they can look
- 7:34up the curriculum online. The BC government has all of our curriculum right online.
- 7:38And again there can be investigations as well when things go astray, right,
- 7:43you know, in the examples that there are, so I would say
- 7:45that no, in fact, we're not ostracizing parents from their own students.
- 7:48It's some children. We want them to be involved every single day, every
- 7:53single moment. Absolutely. However, we have to remain clear that we have
- 7:57students that don't go home to save families. Unfortunately that you know, we
- 8:01have still examples of conversion therapy. We still have examples of kids coming to
- 8:05school with bruising right or self harm where they don't feel they can talk to
- 8:09their parents. Our hope is to actually start that conversation which I've had many
- 8:13times with students, where I go, how can we bring this to your
- 8:16parents? Right? What's a way to bring this so that we can all
- 8:20be in this conversation. But just like if a student is abused at home,
- 8:24we have to report that. We have a duty to report legally speaking,
- 8:28So We're not trying to change kids. We're not trying to tell them
- 8:31what to be or what not to be. We are simply trying to engage
- 8:35them as the human beings they are and hopefully have that full family support.
- 8:39And so what I'm hearing is in the only circumstance where there would be a
- 8:43disconnect from the child and their parents would be when the household is somewhat unsafe,
- 8:48right when authorities have to get involved, or there's issues of abuse.
- 8:50Absolutely, and in a world where we see the abuse of children, the
- 8:54exploitation, the sex tortion of children. We've lost two young teens not too
- 8:58long ago past year in Surrey and Delta, that we have to believe our
- 9:03children. We have to believe them if if they don't feel comfortable, if
- 9:07there's an unsafe measure. So I think that only adds to the equation of
- 9:11looking at it like how do we make families stronger? You know, how
- 9:13can we give them resources? So G one two three is a resource for
- 9:16parents as much as it is for schools right to really educate themselves. And
- 9:20in the times or there's a misunderstanding where there's a conflict in terms of tradition,
- 9:26and faith, et cetera. That's okay. But our human rights,
- 9:30our Charter rights do stand above any and all of our own kind of freedom
- 9:35of expression, freedom of religion. Right, that's the reality. There are
- 9:37reasonable limits within the first section that say, you know, like, there's
- 9:41a limit to that. So that's all we're doing here, And never ever
- 9:45are we going to hurt children, Are we going to touch children? Are
- 9:48we going to give them materials that are inappropriate? Well? Annie, I
- 9:50think you put it very eloquently, and I hope that you know, if
- 9:54these issues do trigger parents or create concerns, that they do talk to their
- 9:58teachers. So I appreciate that, and I appreciate your time absolutely, and
- 10:01we always want our parents to be involved in the education system. Annie,
- 10:03Thank you so much. Thank you so much, folks. That was the
- 10:07globally celebrated educator from Surrey, BC, Annie Ohanna. Now, after some
- 10:11business issues related to truth and reconciliation seem to be driving further division within BC
- 10:18politics. What's happening, let's talk about it up next. Welcome back to
- 10:30this is Van Color. Our featured guest to night is the Intergovernmental Affairs Officer
- 10:33to the muskliam First Nation. He is also a board chair for the First
- 10:37Nation's Health Council and a board member of Covenant House Vancouver. Currently seeking the
- 10:43Liberal nomination in Vancouver Quadra. He is Wade Grant and this conversation is brought
- 10:48to you by Pacific Sands Beach resortant to Fino laid back luxury as beachfront as
- 10:54it gets So Wade week on the show BC premier Davity b basically alluded to
- 11:03this idea that there is a polarization when it comes to Indigenous issues and in
- 11:09fact a deliberate politicization when it comes to relations between Indigenous people and non Indigenous
- 11:15people. I got to ask you, what are you seeing in this current
- 11:18climate? Well, well and thanks for the question, thanks for having me.
- 11:20I think that we see that people are using Indigenous rights, indigenous proven
- 11:26Indigenous territory as a way to mobilize people because for far too long in our
- 11:31problence, the education and the understanding of Indigenous peoples and the rights and the
- 11:37title they actually have and have been proven in the Supreme Court of Canada is
- 11:41something that people haven't truly learned and so to be able to be able to
- 11:46use that as a way to create an opportunity to divide people or have a
- 11:50dog whistle is a real easy target for people, and I've been seeing that
- 11:54more and more in the last three four years. And so why is that
- 11:58happening in the last three years four years because it seemed like the province was
- 12:01maybe not as fast as some people would like, but it seems like the
- 12:05province was making progress right. Yeah, absolutely. But people don't realize is
- 12:09that this has been going on for almost sixty years now. The Supreme Court
- 12:13of Canada in the nineteen seventies, out of the Calder case, recognize that
- 12:16my aboriginal title did exist in this country. And then we went to look
- 12:18forward with the Sparrow case and the Muscream that proved that muscular had a right
- 12:22to fish. Then we went to Delvium. So we've been using the federal
- 12:26courts to prove our aboriginal title and rights and so we've come a long way.
- 12:31But then it's a little bit of the unknown of where this is going
- 12:33forward. And I think people need to understand that Indigenous people, First nations
- 12:37people aren't here to impose their laws, impose who they are. I think
- 12:41they want to bring it in in lockstep with Western laws so that we can
- 12:45work together to create it even better and more inclusive community. One thing I'm
- 12:50seeing that I think I find concerning, but obviously I want to hear what
- 12:52you think is maybe a rise of denihalism when it comes to residential schools.
- 12:58We know that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission basically categorize this as a genocide.
- 13:03We know that even Pope Francis recognize this as a genocide. But I'm starting
- 13:07to see political voices downplaying that word or that term. Are you seeing that
- 13:13as well? And I guess how do you feel about it? I've seen
- 13:16it in many different places. I think the people need to understand that genocide
- 13:20has many different definitions. I mean, we think of genocide and the atrocities
- 13:24of the Holocaust in the earlier century, but genocide is in anything that has
- 13:28to do with trying to eradicate to people, whether it be through putting them
- 13:33in places where their living conditions are no longer tenable, or taking their kids
- 13:37away and putting them in places where they're not allowed to speak their language,
- 13:41they're not allowed to practice their culture, they're not allowed to use their history,
- 13:45anymore. These are ways of eradicating a generation so that that next generation
- 13:50is gone, is gone, is not connected to who they are. The
- 13:52one thing that people don't realize is that the actual i would say tagline of
- 13:56the residential school was to kill the Indian in the to make them more Western,
- 14:01which sounds like genocidal intent absolutely to me. And I think that,
- 14:05you know, I understand that people are just starting to understand this because for
- 14:07far too long in this province and in this country, we didn't learn about
- 14:11these things. We didn't learn that this country treated their first peoples in such
- 14:16an atrocious way. We want to be the bastion of human rights in the
- 14:20world, and I think that we can be, but we also have to
- 14:22recognize that we do have a dark past. We don't have to you know,
- 14:26we don't have to be vengeful about what happened. We can be angry
- 14:28and we can make sure that it doesn't happen again. Now I don't think
- 14:33this, but I've seen voices that say, let's just move forward, Like
- 14:35why are we still focusing on the past. You know, there seems to
- 14:39be this over emphasis on the dark side of Canadian history. But we have
- 14:43a lot of issues right now, let's move forward. When you hear that,
- 14:46why is it important that people understand this history for what it is,
- 14:50because this history is still showing tremendous effects of intergenerational trauma that I see today,
- 14:58even in my own communities or my uncle. I'm lucky enough. My
- 15:01parents didn't go to residential school, but my uncle did. And then his
- 15:03nephew didn't have a father because his father didn't learn to be a father because
- 15:07he went to residential school, didn't have parents that he went home to,
- 15:11and so then he goes into the foster care system and then ages out and
- 15:16he does not know how to be a father, and then he becomes a
- 15:18kid a father as well, and it doesn't know how to be a parent.
- 15:20So we need to understand them. We need to have more empathy that
- 15:24there is still a lot of trauma that people are still facing today. Just
- 15:28because you didn't have a direct impact one hundred years ago, we're still seeing
- 15:33the effects of them, and we can all come together to work together to
- 15:35heal those people so that they can be a better contributors to this country.
- 15:41In the overall dialogue in BC political culture, do you think we're moving backwards
- 15:46when it comes to digitals issues or things around reconciliation. I worked in the
- 15:52previous government with Christy Clark as her Indigenous advisor, and I thought I went
- 15:56there because I thought we were on the right track. We had a tremendous
- 15:58amount of of momentum with the new relationship that the Gordon Campbell government put in
- 16:03place, creating the Indigenous Reconciliation Ministry. Those types of things hadn't happened before.
- 16:10But I'm hearing from unfortunately, from some leaders in this province about if
- 16:15they got in that they would repeal the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous
- 16:21People's Acre, yeah andrep and these are things that we've fought so hard to
- 16:25implement in here for almost a decade. We've been finding to have these things,
- 16:29and they were tremendous rallying cries for First Nations to come together with the
- 16:33rest of the province of British Columbia, to feel welcome, to feel part
- 16:36of the province. But to have that taken back, I think is a
- 16:38step in the wrong direction. Now. I know this next question is going
- 16:41to be a bit loaded, but hopefully you can give me some some direction
- 16:45here. When it comes to misconceptions that generally British Columbians may have when it
- 16:51comes to relationships with Indigenous people. What are kind of the key misconceptions that
- 16:55you really hope can be dispelled as soon as possible. Well, I think
- 17:00as the chair of the First Nation's Health Council, I represent the two earth
- 17:02three First Nations in the province of British Columbia, and the one thing I
- 17:04always say is that we are not one people. The diversity of First Nations
- 17:08in this province is there's two or three First Nations over fifty different language groups.
- 17:12We're not the same just because we're First Nations. I'm just as different
- 17:17from a masculine member as a person from the Denalca Nation and Cranbrook BC,
- 17:21as a person from England is to South Asia. That's how different our cultures,
- 17:25our languages, our histories are. So don't group us in those types
- 17:29of things, but also recognize that you know, we're not come. I
- 17:33remember a story my mother told when she was early in her career, is
- 17:37that she asked people what they thought about reconciliation. The one thing that they
- 17:40were afraid of is that First Nations are going to come take their land back.
- 17:42That's not what's going to happen. That fear should be shot down right
- 17:48away. We want to just be part of the community one to make sure
- 17:51that we're creating a better society for the province in Canada. Wade a pleasure
- 17:56to chat with you. Thanks so much for your time tonight. Absolutely thanks
- 17:59for having memo folks representing the Muscliam First nation. He is weighed grant.
- 18:03Now up next in an episode about equity and inclusion. We have to talk
- 18:07about the backlash and I'll do that up next. Welcome back to this is
- 18:19Van Color Now. I cannot stand when people use the word woke as some
- 18:25sort of nebulous pejorative that just means something I don't like, especially when a
- 18:30lot of these woke things are just trying to point out or address unfairness.
- 18:36Let me explain, and let's take a moment. I want you to think
- 18:47about emergency room triage. A patient walks in with a minor cut that requires
- 18:52stitches. Ten minutes later, another patient arrives needing resuscitation since their heart has
- 18:56stopped. If there's only enough er staff to address one of these patients,
- 19:00they will focus on the person whose heart has stopped first, since it's more
- 19:04urgent. Now that's not equality. The patient needing resuscitation is receiving preferential treatment.
- 19:11But we understand that it's fair given the context. That's equity. And
- 19:17yet some of the loudest, most obnoxious, reactionary voices will reject equity in
- 19:22favor of equality under the law. But we know that equality or even law
- 19:27isn't enough. We have law mandating accessible public spaces, and yet in the
- 19:33city of Vancouver, with public sidewalks that everyone can use equally, there are
- 19:37over three thousand sidewalks without the necessary curb cuts to make those sidewalks accessible for
- 19:42people with mobility issues. Pay discrimination is illegal in BC, yet BC women
- 19:48earn eighty three cents for every dollar a BC man earns fifty five cents.
- 19:52In agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting. In fact, in crop
- 19:56production, men's paychecks have grown since twenty twenty, but women's paychecks haven't.
- 20:03Numerous studies have shown that Canadian companies engage in hiring practices where job applicants with
- 20:07names that signaled a non white race are less likely to get a callback than
- 20:12applicants with names that signaled white ethnicity qualifications being equal. Healthcare is universal,
- 20:19but we know that our healthcare system treats both indigenous healthcare workers and Indigenous patients
- 20:26with discrimination. Police enforce the law, but the Supreme Court of Canada ruled
- 20:30based on overwhelming evidence that police in this country systemically treat white Canadians more favorably
- 20:37than non white Canadians, which the RCMP admitted is true. There's a growing
- 20:42movement that wants Canadians to ignore these realities under the misleading guise of common sense.
- 20:48They will blame the erosion of your standard of living on woke ideological identity
- 20:53politics, scapegoating those who dare to point out these unfair realities. Why do
- 20:59they do this because they have no real solutions to your problems, and more
- 21:02importantly, they don't care. Folks, that's our show. Thank you so
- 21:15much for tuning in, and thank you to Annie Ohanna and Wade Grant for
- 21:18their time tonight. If you have any thoughts about my commentary or anything that
- 21:22Annie or Wade discussed tonight, shoot me an email mo at This isvancolor dot
- 21:26com. Also, please give me a follow on x or TikTok at van
- 21:30Color I always love hearing from you. Next week is our season finale.
- 21:36We got a duo of powerful BC ladies to close us out, so please
- 21:41be sure to tune in. For now though, this is Van Color and
- 21:44I'm moamir telling you that in a province where you can be anything, be
- 21:48colorful. Peace O