Latest / Film And Whiskey / American Beauty (1999) / Crown Royal Blended Canadian Whisky
Transcript
- 0:00In 1999, director Sam Mendes and star Kevin Spacey gave the world
- 0:05a deeply satirical look at the corporatized shell of 90s
- 0:10suburbia. In 2025, we drink a whiskey that
- 0:14begs the question, do you like getting nailed by the king?
- 0:22The film is American Beauty. The whiskey is Crown Royal.
- 0:29Do you get it? Do you get it, Brad?
- 0:32You know, it took me a minute, Bob, I, I, I think I finally
- 0:35understood the reference. Guys, this is the Film and
- 0:41Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 1:02podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:05glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:08I'm Brad Gee. And before we go any further in
- 1:12talking about this 1999 Best Picture winner, we've got a big
- 1:17announcement film and Whiskey Nation.
- 1:19Brad, this is your news to share.
- 1:20I the floor is yours, Sir. You can say whatever you want,
- 1:23but ideally the big news. My wife and I have had our third
- 1:29child. Baby, let's.
- 1:32Congratulations Sir, Brad is a dad times 3 and you know I
- 1:38couldn't be happier for you man. This is literally the first time
- 1:40we've talked since you had a baby.
- 1:42I was like save it for the pod. I don't even want to hear how
- 1:45this baby is doing. I, I don't want to be like that
- 1:47guy, but like, since my wife had the baby Bob, I, I, in fact,
- 1:55this is getting into a realm that we don't need to get into,
- 1:58but my wife is filling out the, all the information of like
- 2:03Social Security card and mom and this and that.
- 2:06And it asked for the birthing person's gender and it gave her
- 2:13the male and female option. And she goes, she goes.
- 2:19Man, that head was way too big to fit out of a penis.
- 2:27And that'll do it for us this week, folks.
- 2:30Thank you for joining us on the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 2:33Now, Brad, it's good to have you back.
- 2:35I can already tell how sleep deprived you are because that
- 2:38story would not have made it out in any other episode.
- 2:41But welcome in to Film and Whiskey.
- 2:43In order to balance out Brad and his insane takes, today we have
- 2:48brought along a guest who is joining us for probably what the
- 2:51the 4th or 5th time now it's our friend Noah Getel.
- 2:54Noah, how are you, man? Guys, we've met before, but
- 2:59something tells me you're going to Remember Me this time.
- 3:04Let's go. Do you have any huge
- 3:06announcements that that could potentially get us cancelled or
- 3:09just the 1 today? I still do not have any
- 3:13children. OK, that's good to to your
- 3:16knowledge. Yeah, I get it, man.
- 3:19Noah, it's really good to have you back on the show, man.
- 3:22Since the last time we spoke, I have been plugging Baseball the
- 3:25movie everywhere I can possibly think to.
- 3:27I was actually a guest on another unrelated podcast for
- 3:31work and the guy was like, we always ask people for a book
- 3:34recommendation and I was like, Noah could tell baby pick up
- 3:37Baseball the movie. So free promo here for you, my
- 3:41friend. It's a good book and now that
- 3:43the Cleveland baseball season is over, it's the only baseball I'm
- 3:47going to get for like 9 months. Brett.
- 3:49Yeah. Well the if you read the chapter
- 3:53on Major League, it does end with that very sentiment that
- 3:57they will lose and you will go watch Major League to make
- 4:00yourself feel better. So, you know, tonight's the
- 4:03night. Guys, that's that's for sure,
- 4:06man. Honestly, what a great.
- 4:08Chaser Man, what a great double feature pairing with American
- 4:11Beauty. Nothing goes better.
- 4:14Than those two. Classics of American cinema.
- 4:17Guys, I want to jump right in today talking about American
- 4:19Beauty. Obviously, this is a movie that
- 4:21we watched way back in season 1. And folks, if you are new to the
- 4:25podcast, welcome into Film and Whiskey.
- 4:27Each week we review a classic movie and a new glass of
- 4:29whiskey. This season we are going back to
- 4:32all the films we reviewed in our very first season and asking
- 4:35ourselves if they held up. And we have finally arrived at
- 4:39one of the more controversial films in our Season 1 lineup.
- 4:43Controversial a little bit because of the subject matter.
- 4:46I think in the age of of cancel culture, this movie has it's not
- 4:50even really taken on its own terms so much anymore.
- 4:53It's more controversial because of who's in it now.
- 4:55And I think that we'll get, we're going to have to get into
- 4:57that, Brad. That Thora, that Thora Birch,
- 5:01all of her controversy. She's the worst, am I right?
- 5:05As we get into the movie, I have to ask you, Brad, had you
- 5:09watched this movie in the interim between Season 1 and
- 5:12Season 10? Bob, this is a very rare answer
- 5:16to that question. Yes, I have really.
- 5:20I made I made my 2 best friends sit down and watch it and they
- 5:24felt very uncomfortable and they liked it a lot.
- 5:29Like, hey, guys, I need you to like, flank me on both sides of
- 5:32this couch, like, like Allison Janney and Wes Bentley on either
- 5:36side of Chris Cooper. Can you just like as we watch
- 5:38this movie, as I watch this film?
- 5:42No, I'm gonna throw this over to you, man.
- 5:44We gave you a list of movies to choose from, and this was, I
- 5:47think it gave us a couple options.
- 5:49But you were like, I will for sure join you for American
- 5:51Beauty if no one has signed up for that.
- 5:54So my first question to you, what the hell man?
- 5:58It's my favorite movie of all time.
- 6:00No, no. It's not no, no, no, Come on.
- 6:04Why No, because I like digging into the thorny ones.
- 6:09You know, like this was a movie. Like a lot of people, I loved it
- 6:14when it first came out and then I saw the critical reappraisal
- 6:19of it where like it literally there are dozens of articles
- 6:23written by esteemed film critics like saying this is the movie I
- 6:27have turned the most on over the years from my original opinion.
- 6:32And that really interests me. You know, as somebody who likes
- 6:34to look at movies through the lens of like, we know what were
- 6:37the values of the of the, the country and Hollywood when it
- 6:40came out versus now. Like those are the discussions
- 6:43that interest me the most. So I thought it'd be a fun one
- 6:46to dig in to, a difficult one to dig into and and I'm not really
- 6:50doing film criticism anymore so I can't get cancelled.
- 6:53So I thought I was the perfect person to do this.
- 6:56Very. Beautiful.
- 6:57You, you just cancel others vicariously.
- 7:00You come on our show to get us cancelled now.
- 7:03Well, guys, Michael, if we're going down, we're going down
- 7:06together here. Brad.
- 7:08I think that it's a perfect time to segue into our first segment
- 7:11of the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 7:14Brad's going to give us the movie plot with only 60 seconds
- 7:18ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 7:21this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 7:24Brad explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 7:27plot of the film that he has just seen often for the first
- 7:30time. Obviously is Brad's at least
- 7:33third time seeing this movie now.
- 7:35Brad, I got to ask you man, anything different jump out to
- 7:39you this time through or is this movie been kind of consistent in
- 7:44in how you've viewed it and thought about it?
- 7:48I found myself this time through really intrigued by following
- 7:56kind of the thread of like Ricky being the most mature human
- 7:59being in the film, like that, like that.
- 8:02For whatever reason, that just like frustrated me and was
- 8:07fascinating to me all at the same time.
- 8:10And it it feels like this artistic sense of like it's the
- 8:15people who feel the world that understand the world that I'm
- 8:18like, I don't know if that like sticks through all of Sam
- 8:21Mendes's films or if that's an Alan Ball, you know, type of
- 8:25thing, but that that was what I found myself focused on most.
- 8:29I also was like, as I was preparing for this specific
- 8:33segment, I was like, there's a weirdly a like large amount of
- 8:38things that happened in this movie.
- 8:41I think that was my biggest take away this third time through
- 8:44watching American Beauty. I was like, I forgot how much
- 8:48happens and it's like it's like pretty clean 2 hour film.
- 8:52Like it's not like we're hitting 23240.
- 8:54Like you're in, you're out and yet thing after thing and like
- 8:59there's like 6 different the character arcs and storylines
- 9:04happening and they all operate with each other differently and
- 9:09they all draw different things out of each other.
- 9:12I I had forgotten how much of A web this movie really is.
- 9:19Yeah, it gets a little convoluted towards the end of
- 9:22the film and I think some would say contrived and and I'm sure
- 9:24we'll talk about the way that all of these storylines end up
- 9:27intersecting each other and overlapping each other.
- 9:30But in order to do that, Brad, you've got to spoil this movie.
- 9:33So folks, if you have not seen this 25 plus year old film now
- 9:38hit pause here. I would recommend go watch
- 9:40American Beauty. I think it's a worthwhile watch.
- 9:42Come back and join us for the rest of the episode.
- 9:44But Brad, you have one minute to break down the plot of this film
- 9:48and go. American Beauty is a film that
- 9:51follows Lester Burnham as the main character and his family as
- 9:57they try to figure out what it means to be authentic and real
- 10:03in a world that has convinced them that pursuing all of these
- 10:07exterior things are important. Lester finds himself enamoured
- 10:12with one of his daughter's high school friends and is regularly
- 10:16fantasizing about her. His wife is trying to make it as
- 10:20a real estate agent and keep perfection as like her goal in
- 10:25life and ends up having a affair with one of the other real
- 10:29estate people in town. His daughter ends up dating
- 10:32their new neighbor who is a pot selling in kind of introverted,
- 10:39artistically minded person. And her friend who her dad wants
- 10:43to sleep with is obsessed with being a model and being wanted
- 10:46and attractive and all these things.
- 10:49And Chris Cooper is a in the closet farther than any human
- 10:55being you could have ever imagined.
- 10:58And at the end of the day, he shoots Kevin Spacey because
- 11:03because he's gay. That's the, that's the reason
- 11:10very concisely. I like that.
- 11:12There was nothing concise about that, Brad explains.
- 11:14Until the reason for the murder. And then it was like, yeah,
- 11:17yeah. It's because he's gay.
- 11:18I felt, I felt the clock pushing up against me.
- 11:21I, I, I didn't have much time left, Bob.
- 11:24Oh, man. All right, guys, I think that,
- 11:27you know, there's some, to Noah's point, there's some
- 11:30thorny places we can go with this discussion.
- 11:33I think I want to zoom out a little bit and kind of
- 11:35contextualize the movie. And that's why I appreciate Noah
- 11:38being here, because there's a lot of context to add to the
- 11:40movie. I think the first place I'd like
- 11:43to start is kind of focusing in on where does this land on the
- 11:51spectrum of satire? And it's partially because I've
- 11:54had one battle after another on the brain for the last week or
- 11:58so. No, I I know you saw the movie
- 12:00and loved it. I saw the movie and I am one of
- 12:03the like 5 people that it did not fully work for.
- 12:06And I think it's because they didn't quite nail the tone that
- 12:09the movie needed. And I've been thinking about
- 12:12like the different types of satire that we've seen
- 12:15throughout the years. You know, you've got your
- 12:17complete farces like a Doctor Strangelove.
- 12:20You've got things where the world feels kind of Askew and
- 12:23absurdist like a la Coen Brothers.
- 12:26Movies I think are really good at that.
- 12:29And then I think 1 Battle After Another was kind of that like
- 12:32Catch 22 type elevated, winking, witty.
- 12:37There's just something a little bit off about the world, but
- 12:40it's not enough to really be like farcical.
- 12:43And then you've got a movie like American Beauty, which I feel
- 12:45like is even more conservative in the way that it shows the
- 12:51absurdities of the world. It's more just that like
- 12:55everyone's kind of snide and sarcastic and there's some good
- 12:59punch lines, but the world itself is very, very similar to
- 13:04what you see in reality. And I think a good maybe touch
- 13:07point is a movie like Office Space, which I think comes out
- 13:10the same year as this movie. And Office Space just goes maybe
- 13:13one step further into the comedy realm.
- 13:16But I'm wondering, you know, Brad, to your point and know it
- 13:19to you, you guys have both talked about this being a satire
- 13:23already. And so a, do you see it in that
- 13:26sort of legacy of satires and, and where would you kind of
- 13:29locate it on that spectrum? Well, I think it has satirical
- 13:36elements, but I think so a big, a big problem for me with
- 13:41satires is when they try to also be sentimental at the same time.
- 13:46Like those two things are oil and and water for me, because
- 13:50satire requires some emotional detachment.
- 13:53Like, that's the only way satire really works is if you are not
- 13:58fully engaged and sympathizing with these characters, if you're
- 14:02looking at them from Askew, if you're laughing at them.
- 14:06And to try to bringing this emotionality that that Sam
- 14:11Mendes and Alan Ball bring to American Beauty is really when
- 14:14it it loses me, I have to say. And I think, I think, you know,
- 14:19Brad talked about how much. I have a lot more to say about
- 14:21that. But for the purposes of this
- 14:23question, Brad talked about how much stuff there was in this
- 14:26movie. It's not just plot, it's tone.
- 14:29I mean, this is a satire. It is a domestic drama.
- 14:34It's sort of a mystery. They frame the whole thing as a
- 14:37who killed Lester Burnham kind of thing.
- 14:39I mean, from the very beginning, from the first scene of the
- 14:41movie. And if I, if I had a note for
- 14:44the script early on, it would be like, let's just be one thing.
- 14:48And maybe that would be your note for one battle after
- 14:50another as well. Because that that's a lot of a
- 14:52lot of movie at the same time. But I I think American Beauty
- 14:56works at its best when it is satire, when it is funny, and a
- 15:01lot less well when it takes itself seriously.
- 15:05It it works well in the moments where like Kevin Spacey, like
- 15:09just looks at the camera goes and just like the little head
- 15:13tilt before he before he throws the asparagus plate like, oh, it
- 15:19freaking works. Dude, Spacey does this thing at
- 15:22multiple points in the movie. I think it's the asparagus
- 15:26scene. And there's a couple others like
- 15:27when he hands the bag of fast food out the window where he
- 15:31does like a bobble head effect as he does it like like his like
- 15:34his head is attached to his arm doing it.
- 15:36And it's real slight and subtle and it's just so freaking good,
- 15:40man. It's a really, I don't mean to
- 15:42bleed into the performances here too much, but part of the reason
- 15:46that I think the movie ultimately succeeds is that the
- 15:49performances are so committed. And while they are like a touch
- 15:54heightened, they never seem like they're in a different movie
- 15:59from each other or like characters who exist in a world
- 16:02that's not being portrayed here like it.
- 16:05You know, I think my gripe about this, the first time we watched
- 16:08it, Brad was Annette Bening's character because she is so
- 16:11heightened throughout the movie. But then I watched it this time
- 16:14and I was like, Annette Bening freaking kills it.
- 16:17And she's so good at this movie. Because, you know, maybe it's
- 16:21just that I've gotten older when you see people who are fake to
- 16:26their core like she is, and so deeply driven by those
- 16:30insecurities, I wonder to myself sometimes, like, what are those
- 16:33people like behind closed doors? And it turns out they're exactly
- 16:37like that. That's just how they are, you
- 16:39know? And and I think that she does a
- 16:41great job of portraying that. I say all that to say, I think
- 16:44that the the tone the movie is going for, it really is a
- 16:47balancing act to Noah's point, and whether it succeeds or not,
- 16:52I think falls on the script a lot more than it falls on the
- 16:55actors because I really don't have a lot of notes on the
- 16:57performances here. Yeah, I, I mean to speak to
- 17:02Annette Bening a little bit. Like, dude, that moment where
- 17:05she pushes herself up against the the window with the shutters
- 17:09and she starts slapping herself because she didn't sell the
- 17:11house. And you're just like, but yeah,
- 17:14like, this is just her childhood playing over and over and over
- 17:18again. She freaking nails her part.
- 17:22And I, I would say across the board, I think even the younger
- 17:26actors in this film really, really do an incredible job of
- 17:31bringing to life this world that no, I would agree with you.
- 17:35It like it's just exaggerated enough that it feels like you
- 17:41don't quite know what Mendez is always going for.
- 17:44But man, that the performances across the board, it makes sense
- 17:49to me why it won a lot of Academy Awards.
- 17:53I you know whose performance really popped to me this time
- 17:55around was Mina Suvaris. Like I thought she would.
- 17:58She is like genuinely great in this movie.
- 18:01She brings so much depth to that character that like the first
- 18:05time you watch it, you just you, you don't really see and you see
- 18:08her breakdown at the end. But when you watch it knowing
- 18:12like what her kind of her secret is, I think, you know, that
- 18:16character could have been a stock character.
- 18:18It could have been a caricature in a lot of ways, but she she
- 18:22really brought a lot to it. I was very impressed with her.
- 18:26It sounds like we're moving into the performances here because
- 18:28we've talked about like 3 people already, but I think I'll start
- 18:32it off this way. I'll give my my mean guy take.
- 18:35The only bad performance in this movie or the only actor who I
- 18:39felt had incredibly limited range was Thora Birch as the
- 18:43daughter. I thought that every line
- 18:45reading, like every line reading was very, very bad.
- 18:50And the moments of hers that worked are when she doesn't have
- 18:52any lines and she gets to like show complex emotion on her
- 18:56face. But you know, Brad, I think when
- 18:59we talked about this the last time you had you had brought up
- 19:01Wes Bentley as a guy that you were like, man, that what a
- 19:03boring guy, what a boring character.
- 19:05And this time watching him, the entire movie hinges on that
- 19:10plastic bag scene, which has been parodied to death.
- 19:14And people who are not fans of this movie pillory that scene.
- 19:19Again, I think any fault people might have with the movie is on
- 19:23the writing, which is sometimes seen as overwrought.
- 19:27But to be able to put a camera on this guy's face and have him
- 19:31tell a story about a plastic bag dancing with him and revealing
- 19:35the face of God, and he's choking up crying about how much
- 19:40beauty there is in the world? It freaking worked for me, man.
- 19:43And it worked because the performance was so committed and
- 19:46the performance was so authentic.
- 19:48It felt like I was looking into that guy's real inner thoughts
- 19:53as he gave that speech. As silly as that speech might
- 19:55be, it works for me, Brad. Yeah, I I'm with you, dude.
- 20:00This time through, I found myself so drawn in by his
- 20:04character and his characterization of it, that his
- 20:09ability to think deeply about the world, his ability to use
- 20:15his attention well. And I think, I think that's
- 20:18like, you know, the key element of his character.
- 20:20He's always. Mendez is always drawing our
- 20:25attention to the way he pays attention to the world through
- 20:28his use of videotaping everything.
- 20:31And when you look at every single other character in the
- 20:35film, all of their attention is on the wrong thing constantly.
- 20:41And it seems like, you know, he is the hero of our Ricky is the
- 20:45hero of our story because he has the ability to pay attention to
- 20:49the things that matter. And Thora Birch is kind of
- 20:52slowly coming along that way with him.
- 20:55And everybody else is just spiraling out into their own
- 20:59bits of chaos because of their inability to pay attention to
- 21:03the things that matter. Yeah.
- 21:06I'm listening to guys talk about this and I'm a little distracted
- 21:10because I don't know when it's my when it's the right time for
- 21:13me to say. I think this movie is pretty
- 21:15bad. No, no, no.
- 21:20No. You're out of here.
- 21:22We're kicking you out, man. Well, I can't, I can't let this
- 21:26keep going without me saying that because I do think there
- 21:30are some, I do think there are some good performances, although
- 21:34I think even some of the good performances are in kind of in
- 21:37the wrong movie in some ways. And I, I, you know, when this
- 21:44movie came out, there were a lot of movies at this time about
- 21:48guys who work in offices. You mentioned one of them before
- 21:52who are so miserable that the only way they can survive is to
- 21:56sort of develop an alternative personality.
- 22:00And in Office Space, he gets hypnotized.
- 22:03And in the Matrix, you know, he goes into the Matrix and in
- 22:07Fight Club he becomes Tyler Durden.
- 22:10And in this movie, you know, Kevin Spacey transforms into
- 22:13this other guy. Basically.
- 22:14It is sort of like he becomes Tyler Durden in a way, right?
- 22:18But I, the difference between those movies in this movie is
- 22:22that this movie does not understand how like inherently
- 22:27juvenile and contemptible that character is like in those other
- 22:33movies. Like in those other movies,
- 22:35we're not supposed to think these are great guys, you know,
- 22:38like, and in this movie, I, I don't know exactly what it is
- 22:43because I don't think it's fair to say they that he's the hero
- 22:45of the movie, but I do think the movie is aligned with him too
- 22:50much. I think the movie sees these
- 22:53events through his eyes to a degree that sort of implicates
- 22:57him as our de facto hero. Even though I agree with what
- 23:00you're saying that the Ricky Fitz character is actually like
- 23:02the film's, you know, moral center in a way.
- 23:07But I don't know if it's Kevin Spacey's kind of sitcomy
- 23:11performance or if it's the script, which, you know, I, I
- 23:15found it problematic the way that it, it really blames
- 23:20Annette Benning's character Carolyn for their marital
- 23:23problems so much more than it does Lester.
- 23:27So many scenes where it's like, oh, if she could only loosen up,
- 23:31you know, everything would be OK.
- 23:33But but throughout the film, I felt like they misunderstand
- 23:37this character. They misunderstand how much
- 23:39we're going to dislike him for trying to fuck a 16 year old,
- 23:42pardon my language. And, and they and they
- 23:45misunderstand the fact that he's just a a little jerk, you know,
- 23:49and I know, I know there's more to it than that.
- 23:51And and straight white middle class men have problems too.
- 23:55But but I, I it really was a core fundamental problem for me
- 24:00in the movie. Yeah, I think that's that's
- 24:03totally fair. First of all, you should still
- 24:05be doing film criticism 'cause that I think, was perhaps the
- 24:08clearest delineation of why the movie doesn't work.
- 24:12One of my big complaints about the the backlash to this movie
- 24:16is that a lot of it just seems like film Twitter backlash.
- 24:20Like it, it doesn't have a lot of substance and it's just
- 24:23become like American Beauty sucks.
- 24:25So we don't like it. And it, it becomes an echo
- 24:28chamber where there's really no reckoning with the film itself.
- 24:31So, so thank you for that. I think that to your point, the
- 24:35thing that caught me this time around was I, I, I had to remove
- 24:39myself quite a few times from the movie and ask myself, like,
- 24:43am I imposing 2025 woke goggles on my reading of this movie too
- 24:49much? Because in 1999, a lot of the
- 24:52things that were happening are objectively not OK, but
- 24:55audiences were at least willing to see it through to the end.
- 24:59Whereas I think now in 2025, a lot of it's like he's a
- 25:02predator. Click movies off, you know?
- 25:04And Kevin Spacey's personal life certainly has not helped that
- 25:08argument at all. I do think that at the end of
- 25:12this movie when he's about to sleep with Mina Suvari's
- 25:15character and, you know, she says, this is my first time.
- 25:18And it, it snaps him back to reality in in a really dramatic
- 25:23and profound way. And he covers her in a blanket
- 25:26and she starts crying and says, I feel so stupid.
- 25:29And he gives her a hug and she says, I'm sorry.
- 25:32And then he says, you don't have anything to be sorry about.
- 25:36And then they cut to the next scene.
- 25:37And I was like, you should be sorry.
- 25:40You're a 42 year old man. What are you not?
- 25:43You're taking no blame for any of this situation that you have
- 25:47caused. What are you doing, man?
- 25:50So I, I do, I do find that there's definitely points where
- 25:55they let Lester off the hook in a way that the other characters
- 25:59don't get to get off the hook, but also the other characters
- 26:02don't get shot in the head. So I mean it kind of balances
- 26:05out. I was, I was about to say, not
- 26:08getting off the hook would also include not being dead at the
- 26:12end of the film. Like sure.
- 26:14I don't, I don't know about that.
- 26:15I mean, in, in a sense you're correct, but in another sense,
- 26:19the guy dies with a smile on his face and we're listening to him
- 26:22talk at the beginning of the end of the movie.
- 26:23He gets the voice over. He's fine.
- 26:26Wherever he is. He seems very, very happy and
- 26:30at. Peace So so no, what I hear you
- 26:32saying is as long as you get to do a voice over about your life
- 26:35from whatever your afterlife is you're you're.
- 26:38You're happy. How bad could it?
- 26:40Yeah. Right, I want to go back to
- 26:44something Noah was talking about before and it's it's the 1999 of
- 26:47it all. So 1999 obviously being regarded
- 26:49as one of the best years for movies ever.
- 26:52I think people like to look at the Oscars best picture lineup
- 26:56and and Pooh Pooh it because you've got movies like the Green
- 26:59Mile, which I love that movie. I know that it's not a film
- 27:01Twitter favorite. The Cider House Rules.
- 27:04Objectively, I hate that. That movie sucked, bro.
- 27:08But then, you know, you've got movies left out like a Fight
- 27:11Club, like The Matrix and on and on down the list.
- 27:14And so this movie kind of catches all of the heat because
- 27:18it won best picture. You know, it's like a Forrest
- 27:20Gump situation, like Forrest Gump beats Shawshank and Pulp
- 27:23Fiction and Quiz Show. And so it's like now we hate
- 27:26Forrest Gump. Sometimes the worst thing that
- 27:28can happen to a movie's reputation is winning Best
- 27:31Picture. You know this movie percent man.
- 27:33I don't know. That people would like it if it
- 27:35didn't win, but I do know it wouldn't have the target on its
- 27:38back that it it has had since then.
- 27:41Noah, you are only a a few years older than us, so I don't mean
- 27:44to make you like the resident old guy on the podcast here, but
- 27:48you were much more aware of what was going on in the world in
- 27:501999 than Brad and I were at age 9.
- 27:53So I, I want to ask a little bit about, you know, the cultural
- 27:58political climate as well, because there's a reason that
- 28:02all of these like angry white guy movies are getting made in
- 28:041999. And I also think that we have to
- 28:08situate this kind of satirical movie among the other satires
- 28:11that are coming out like a fight.
- 28:13Fight Club is a satire. Like it's not super funny, but
- 28:16it's a satire. And Office Space is obviously a
- 28:18satire. You look at a movie that comes
- 28:20out like a year before this, Primary Colors, which is just
- 28:23lampooning the the Clinton administration and all of his
- 28:26scandals. Like there's a lot of comedy
- 28:29happening that is really trying to skewer the American cultural
- 28:34moment. And I'm just kind of wondering,
- 28:37like, is that lost today when we look back on American Beauty?
- 28:44It's hard for me to answer as somebody.
- 28:47Well, so I was 19 when this movie came out.
- 28:49So I wasn't so clued into like what adults were really seeing
- 28:54in the world at the time. I was more into smoking pot
- 28:57everyday and playing NBA2K on my I think it was Sega Dreamcast
- 29:02maybe. But, you know, I mean, I think,
- 29:06look, this is these these were the first Gen.
- 29:09X movies really that were being made at this time.
- 29:12But Gen. X film makers were getting their
- 29:14shot to tell their story. And what they wanted to talk
- 29:18about was their, you know, they're ineffectual fathers on
- 29:22some level. Like, that's a big, big thread
- 29:25running through these movies. They definitely want to talk
- 29:27about the fact that they, they didn't want to work for the man.
- 29:30They didn't want to sell out. That's what these movies were
- 29:32about to, you know, you could throw Reality Bites in the mix,
- 29:35which is sort of like the ultimate Gen.
- 29:37X movie came out a few years earlier.
- 29:40But I think they really kind of tell us who they are.
- 29:45I don't know if they tell us, like, what was happening in the
- 29:47country, although there were sex scandals at this time for sure.
- 29:51And this movie, you know, Primary Colors is a weird one
- 29:54because I see that movie as not exactly a defense of what
- 29:59Clinton did. But there's this sense that
- 30:01like, hey, you know, it's politics.
- 30:03Stuff happens, man, and it's just a big circus and you got to
- 30:06roll with it. Which, you know, I think Mike
- 30:08Nichols is probably talking about his time in Hollywood more
- 30:10than than politics when he makes that movie.
- 30:13But that's the idea. So I don't think any of these
- 30:15movies were really willing to look at what was happening two
- 30:20young women at this time. And I don't think America was
- 30:23either. You know, when I look back in at
- 30:25the Lewinsky scandal, I was a kid that I didn't really know
- 30:28what was going on. But I think it's atrocious.
- 30:31Like, I don't want to get too political, but I think it's
- 30:33atrocious the way the Democratic Party, the party supposedly of
- 30:36women like covered for Bill Clinton and made excuses for him
- 30:40and everything. So I don't think we as a
- 30:43culture, we're really ready to look at that.
- 30:45And I think, you know, this generation, I mean, these guys,
- 30:49Sam Mendes was probably like, I don't know, 30 years old or
- 30:51something when he made this movie.
- 30:53But all these guys were young guys and they were, they were
- 30:56espousing and inherently kind of juvenile point of view.
- 30:59And I don't mean juvenile as an insult.
- 31:00I mean, they were young and they were saying, you know what?
- 31:03I, I, I want to, I don't want to work in an office.
- 31:06I want to rock'n'roll all night and, and, and party everyday.
- 31:10And that's really what this movie and, and these movies as a
- 31:14whole are about. Nothing more complicated than
- 31:16that. I I was going to say, it seems
- 31:19to me, you know, this being a third time through for American
- 31:22Beauty, there's not much judgement on anybody.
- 31:27Like I it doesn't seem to me like Mendez has a position of
- 31:30trying to make a deep statement about the world.
- 31:36It just seems like it's kind of like, yeah, there's just
- 31:39shitheads all around you in the world and we should expect them
- 31:45to be that way. And I think that the reason I
- 31:47say that is the way the film treats Lester's obsession with
- 31:52this 16 year old is like, yeah, that's just what a 42 year old
- 31:57emasculated guy would do. And that like, that's just
- 31:59normal. And you're like, I that is not
- 32:05normal. Like that is something that
- 32:08hopefully as a society we are moving beyond to think that it's
- 32:11just normal that a 42 year old, you know, it's one thing to be a
- 32:1442 year old dad and go wow, that high school girl that is friends
- 32:20with my daughter is pretty and then move on with his life and
- 32:23never think about it again. It's another thing to just act
- 32:27like it's normal for what Lester's doing throughout the
- 32:29film. And it seems like you see that
- 32:31for a lot of the characters. Like, even for her, it doesn't
- 32:34feel like there's a lot of judgement for Angela's character
- 32:39that she wants to sleep around to get to the top.
- 32:43See, when I, when I watch this movie, like it, it, it recalls,
- 32:47I'm sure intentionally Lolita in a lot of ways, right?
- 32:50But Lolita is a satire like that is a dark satire.
- 32:54You do not think any of these men, either of these men are
- 32:57good guys at all. But this movie, they try to kind
- 33:02of take that idea and cram it into something a little more
- 33:05sitcomy. And that's really what I think
- 33:07doesn't work about it for me. Like, that could be very
- 33:11provocative if you want to make something truly avant-garde and
- 33:15say, like, look at this sitcomy family man who's trying to sleep
- 33:18with his his daughter's best friend.
- 33:21But they're not making something avant-garde.
- 33:23They're making something crowd pleasing at the same time.
- 33:26And I don't think those ingredients work together.
- 33:29Well, and I want to I want to talk a little bit about the word
- 33:31normal because like when you think about like what was the
- 33:34norm back then? Obviously what I'm not saying
- 33:36like every 42 year old man was lusting after a 16 year old.
- 33:39But there are we, we have lost the sacred texts of the creepy
- 33:44late 90s in a lot of ways. Like I don't know if you guys
- 33:47remember this like they used to have, like I remember watching
- 33:51like MTV, VH1 and they would have like countdowns on of like
- 33:57underage celebrities until they like days till they turn 18 and
- 34:02it's OK for us to want to have sex with them now.
- 34:06Like which which is hilarious. Like just masking the fact that
- 34:09you clearly want to have sex with this girl right now at 16,
- 34:12but you can't say that in polite society until she's 18.
- 34:16So this was the kind of thing we were dealing with in 1999.
- 34:18And so it's it's objectively creepy.
- 34:22It was also something that I think a lot of people could
- 34:24recognize as something that was happening in society.
- 34:28And I do think Noah too. One of the other things that is
- 34:32it really stands out to me now is like being a millennial
- 34:37turning 18 in the 2008 recession and then like everything being
- 34:42everything after that, being like, you have student loans and
- 34:44you can't afford anything now. So like, start from that point
- 34:47looking at a movie where these young boomers are able to make
- 34:53these flippant decisions with their lives of like, I'm going
- 34:56to quit my job. And, and like, his wife
- 34:58obviously is like, OK, so I have to pay the mortgage now, right?
- 35:01Like, they talk about finances a little bit, but then at one
- 35:04point Lester says his salary is like $60,000.
- 35:08And you're like, oh, man. Like how how times have changed
- 35:11when the financial security of a family could just be up like
- 35:15thrown into upheaval in 1999. And it really didn't affect that
- 35:18much. You know, Like, it it, it just
- 35:20seems like there were very different times.
- 35:23And these people were much more privileged than I think they
- 35:25realized at the time. Well, the people in this movie
- 35:29at least. Like I don't know that.
- 35:31That's yeah, yeah, for sure. You know what it would actually
- 35:33be like in real life? My hunch is if you quit your job
- 35:37and and start working fast food and then buy really expensive
- 35:42classic sports car, you actually are going to have some severe
- 35:46financial problems. But the film, the film is not
- 35:48interested in the realness of this at all that, and I don't
- 35:52really mean that as a criticism. I have other criticisms of it,
- 35:55but I think not wanting to get into the economics of it is like
- 35:58that's a justifiable decision in a way.
- 36:02Yeah. And at the end of the day, like
- 36:04the movie is just focused on the transformation of Lester from a
- 36:10spineless coward to somebody who's I've manned up and I'm
- 36:15taking control of my life. And he clearly isn't.
- 36:19But also he you know, he got that 60 grand all paid out.
- 36:23He got his severance, he got health benefits.
- 36:26He can blow it all. And you know, we're, we're not
- 36:28looking at the next the the 10 year plan, Bob.
- 36:30Well it's a good thing he got shot because he would had some
- 36:34some serious bills to pay after that.
- 36:36He probably had a nice life insurance policy.
- 36:38Honestly, it worked out best for everybody.
- 36:40Yeah. Yeah, for everybody.
- 36:45Oh man, guys, before we go to break, I do, I do think it's
- 36:48time to talk about Kevin Spacey. Obviously, like, you know, let's
- 36:52put the disclaimer here. Like it.
- 36:53We all know what Kevin Spacey is accused of doing.
- 36:56He to this day vehemently denies it.
- 36:58I'm pretty sure he's been found liable in in court for doing it,
- 37:02but he's no longer criminally liable for it.
- 37:04So there's no consequences legally for him.
- 37:06He is persona non grata in Hollywood.
- 37:09We understand, right? And I'm sorry to be the like,
- 37:12let's separate art from the artist guy right now.
- 37:14But like, this is 1999, we were not aware of these allegations
- 37:18for another, you know, almost 20 years about the guy.
- 37:21We're going to talk about this performance, which gets him an
- 37:23Academy Award. And I say all that, Brad, to
- 37:26kind of cover my ass a little bit when I say this might be my
- 37:29favorite Kevin Spacey performance because I I just
- 37:33recently went to the theatre to see seven.
- 37:36I'd never seen it on the big screen.
- 37:38Holy shit, what a movie, what a picture.
- 37:41Still have not seen 7. It is, yeah.
- 37:46I mean, it's it's it's mind blowing.
- 37:47But seeing Kevin Spacey in this, it's it's one of those things
- 37:51where like sometimes you have to see an actor in very tonally
- 37:54different roles in in really close succession to be reminded
- 37:58of what their range actually was.
- 38:00Because towards the end there, I think Spacey was just becoming a
- 38:02caricature of himself when he was doing the House of Cards
- 38:05stuff. But I've never seen him this
- 38:07loose in a movie. I've never seen him like this.
- 38:11I know for a fact that like Jack Lemmon is a big inspiration on
- 38:15him. This performance has Jack Lemmon
- 38:18written all over it In the physicality, in the line
- 38:21deliveries. I could see Jack Lemmon, you
- 38:24know, apartment era Jack Lemmon being slotted into this movie
- 38:28and giving a very similar performance to what space he's
- 38:30trying to do here. I like that a lot.
- 38:34That's a that's a good take, Bob.
- 38:37Thank you very much. I like it a lot.
- 38:39I like it a lot too. I, but I, I don't totally agree
- 38:43with the performance working. I think, I think Kevin Spacey's
- 38:47working really hard and he's making a lot of choices and I
- 38:49respect that very much. But I, I, you know, I don't know
- 38:54if it's his fault or the director's fault, but the tone,
- 38:57the tone of his performance does not always work for me.
- 39:00There's too, there's too much winking at the camera.
- 39:04There's too much like leaning forward and saying something in
- 39:07a quiet voice, like, you know, like there's a, there's
- 39:10something contrived about his performance.
- 39:12There's something too mannered about it, too measured about it
- 39:16that I just don't like. And I, and I will acknowledge
- 39:19he's got a tough job because he has to hold all of these tones
- 39:22basically in his performance. And it's really hard and maybe
- 39:24no actor could do it, but I like him best when he is playing a
- 39:29bad guy. Like I think, I think if you
- 39:32look over his filmography, it's pretty clear that when he tries
- 39:35to to play. And to be clear, you don't think
- 39:37he's a bad guy in this movie, Then you think he's the good
- 39:40guy. Who you?
- 39:41Want the hero of the film? Yeah, if, if, if they pitched
- 39:45this character as just like a juvenile, sleazy, you know, a
- 39:50hole, I think he would be really good for it.
- 39:53But I think they like him too much.
- 39:55They like this character too much.
- 39:56And by they, I mean the film makers.
- 39:59But like, when I look over Kevin Spacey's filmography, like my
- 40:01favorite performances of his are, you know, Usual Suspects.
- 40:07Obviously, I love him in LA Confidential.
- 40:10Like I really love him in that movie.
- 40:11And it's kind of similar in that he's a sleazy guy who sort of
- 40:14becomes a goodish guy by the end of it, but he's not like.
- 40:18He's not the main character. He gets to have his little his
- 40:22little journey off to the side while there is somebody who's
- 40:24actually righteous, you know, that Exley character played by
- 40:27Guy Pierce, who kind of holds the movie down.
- 40:31And I just think as a as AI, don't I, I, I just don't, I just
- 40:38don't buy him in this role. When all is said and done, he's
- 40:42too. He's too sleazy for me to really
- 40:46like, buy him as a suburban dad and I.
- 40:49Think part of the issue and and for me, it worked because I I
- 40:54felt like something clicked for me in the scene where Annette
- 40:57Bening catches him masturbating in bed next to her.
- 41:00And then they have the big argument and he's talking about
- 41:02like, you know, chafing the carrot, choking the Bishop.
- 41:04Some really great metaphors there.
- 41:08That scene is played like both of their performances and the
- 41:13dialogue is played like an old Hollywood, not screwball comedy,
- 41:19but like that sort of like Rock Hudson, Doris Day era comedy
- 41:23where you have these like zingers, not quite one liners,
- 41:27but it's all about the timing. And it's about a, you know,
- 41:29being a little bit more clever than people actually are.
- 41:32And I realized at that moment that like the comedy in this
- 41:36movie is pitched to like old Hollywood.
- 41:39And I kind of wonder if that is a little bit intentional because
- 41:43this movie is so much about, like, the facade of suburbia,
- 41:47the facade of, like, this 1950s American idyllic dream.
- 41:52To the point where, like, by the end of the movie, when all the
- 41:54masks are off and Annette Bening is just like, weeping in the
- 41:58closet, grabbing his shirts and letting out this scream.
- 42:01And you finally get Spacey kind of letting down his guard and
- 42:06everything clicking for him and him realizing how juvenile he's
- 42:09been. I think that juxtaposition of
- 42:12tones is what makes the ending of the movie work 'cause it's
- 42:15like everybody realizes how full of shit they've been the whole
- 42:18movie. And now finally it's like, oh,
- 42:21we're all maybe capable of having a real moment.
- 42:24And the tragedy of the movie is that it's it's too late for
- 42:27Kevin Spacey at that point, but. That's interesting.
- 42:29So you're saying they're all playing parts throughout the
- 42:31movie, which I think is true, and you're saying that they they
- 42:34harness like kind of contrived a genre kind of energy to convey
- 42:41that to the audience. That's an interesting take.
- 42:44I haven't heard that before. Look.
- 42:47At you, Bob. This is why I bring you on.
- 42:50My guy knows how to stroke an ego.
- 42:52He's very good at this. No, honestly, Bob, I'm I'm kind
- 42:56of with you. I think Spacey is brilliant in
- 42:59the role and for me it comes down to the and I I know this
- 43:05isn't this is the exact opposite of what Noah was saying.
- 43:08His sincerity in the role shines through that he is 100% this
- 43:16completely burnt out, angry with his life, just like questioning
- 43:23what the F happened to my life. And you see it when he's trying
- 43:27to, like, seduce Annette Bening on the couch.
- 43:30And he's asking her, like, what happened to us?
- 43:32Like, where'd we go? And like, that's his question
- 43:34He's asking throughout the whole movie is like, when did I become
- 43:38who I am? When did you become who you are?
- 43:42And all of the things he does in response to that question feel
- 43:46authentic and real. And yes, like some of them are a
- 43:50little bit satirical in the way he gets his severance from from
- 43:56his boss by, you know, basically blackmailing them into giving
- 43:59him a good severance. Like there's elements of it that
- 44:02feel little bit overwrought. But in the midst of all that,
- 44:06there's not a single thing that feels like A and then he did
- 44:10this and then he did that. Like it all feels like the story
- 44:14leads him to a place that makes sense for his character to do
- 44:18those things, and with a story underlying that, I think
- 44:22Spacey's performance really takes that character to the next
- 44:25level. I've been thinking a lot about,
- 44:30I've been thinking about Hollywood lately.
- 44:33I can't remember what brought it up for me, but do you guys
- 44:36remember in like the early 2000s when a a large cabal of
- 44:42celebrities got really into Kabbalah for a while?
- 44:45Like, that was the religion of choice.
- 44:47Madonna was, I think, leading the charge on that.
- 44:50And it was kind of like the competing weird religion with
- 44:53Scientology for a while in Hollywood.
- 44:56And you, you kind of come to find out about like some of the
- 44:59tenets of the cults that celebrities are attached to in
- 45:04Hollywood. And you're just like, why?
- 45:06Why are people like this? And and then you kind of think
- 45:10about like, what is like Hollywood is just a giant sham
- 45:14where everybody's pretending to be somebody they aren't to get
- 45:17ahead. And I, I mean, I'm making
- 45:19generalizations at this point. But I thought about that
- 45:22watching this movie that like, when you live your life in a
- 45:28preposterous place, like your solutions to your problems are
- 45:32all going to be preposterous. And I think that this movie is
- 45:34just a collection of people who live in a preposterous place in
- 45:39the suburbia of the late 1990s and are trying really
- 45:43desperately hard to fix those problems by, like, doubling down
- 45:48and finding the most ludicrous ways to do so.
- 45:51Like Kevin Spacey's response is like, I'm going to quit my job.
- 45:54I'm going to pretend I don't care.
- 45:55I'm going to smoke a bunch of weed and basically become Randy
- 45:58Marsh from South Park for a while.
- 46:01And then, like, at the end of the movie, I'm going to realize
- 46:03this is no way to live. And Annette Bening does the same
- 46:06thing by, like, screwing this other guy, listening to these
- 46:09dumb self help tapes, repeating mantras, and then realizing at
- 46:13the end of the movie this is no way to live.
- 46:15And to your point, Brad, it's it's the kind of thing that is
- 46:19like the tried and true trope of the village idiot is the only
- 46:23sane one in the movie with Ricky.
- 46:26But I don't know, man. Like, I, I know that it is
- 46:30heightened and it's a little bit satirical.
- 46:32It doesn't feel that far off to me to how people live their
- 46:35lives in these kind of weird, cloistered, secluded communities
- 46:41across the country. Well, well.
- 46:44Well, what? What is so weird about this
- 46:47community? Like I, I feel like this is a
- 46:49pretty normal average community. I mean, it's a, they're a little
- 46:52more money than average, but they're not like rich rich
- 46:55either, as we know. What what is so unusual about it
- 46:59too? I mean the teenagers seem pretty
- 47:01normal and average to me except for Ricky who is like from
- 47:05another planet. Yeah, I mean, maybe maybe you're
- 47:09right. Maybe it's not the community
- 47:11itself, but it's the sort of rat race life that these people are
- 47:14being asked to live. I I'm not sure.
- 47:16Well, now, do you? Sound like a Gen.
- 47:18X or not a millennial I have to say.
- 47:23You know what, Noah, that reminds me too, 'cause you were
- 47:25talking about this being like a a Gen.
- 47:27X movie because Sam Mendes is so young when he directs this and
- 47:30he's very much a Gen. X filmmaker.
- 47:33But I wonder sometimes. Sometimes I'm wondering right
- 47:36now, 'cause it just dawned on me like, is this actually is, is
- 47:42part of the reason this movie doesn't seem to have a message
- 47:44to you, because it's a Gen. X filmmaker making a movie about
- 47:49boomers and millennials from a Gen.
- 47:52X standpoint and failing to locate like, the moral center of
- 47:58that generation. Brad, you said that this movie
- 48:00is like really permissive to everybody in the movie.
- 48:03Part of me wonders if it's because, like, that
- 48:06permissiveness or that sort of like, cynical shrug is very
- 48:11emblematic of Gen. X film makers.
- 48:14And he's trying really hard to, like, put that viewpoint onto
- 48:21Lester and onto the kids in the movie.
- 48:25But there's really no Gen. X characters in the movie to
- 48:27kind of take that mantle on. No, there really isn't, man.
- 48:33Maybe, but I I think Ricky Fitz sort of is the Gen.
- 48:35X avatar in the movie. I mean he's the film makers
- 48:39avatar for sure because he is a filmmaker in in the movie.
- 48:44No. But he's, you know, he's the one
- 48:47who's like, I don't, I don't have to live like, like either
- 48:51my father figure across the street or my actual father.
- 48:54I'm going to go live however the hell I want.
- 48:56I'm just going to sell weed and treat my jobs like they're
- 49:00meaningless and, you know, just go to New York just because I
- 49:03can. I don't even need an education.
- 49:05I think that's kind of the Gen. X attitude that's present in the
- 49:09film. I will.
- 49:11I will say you talked about contrived characters before.
- 49:15The only character for me that feels really contrived is
- 49:18Ricky's mom. What is the deal with her?
- 49:23Like like Ricky's dad is on the edge of being contrived, but I
- 49:29think Chris Cooper just Oh my God, dude, what a freaking
- 49:33performance. Chris Cooper is incredible.
- 49:37The mom. I'm sorry but like the idea that
- 49:42she's that far gone because of Chris Cooper's like militaristic
- 49:49household is ridiculous to me. That you know, Ricky walks in.
- 49:54Hey mom, this is my girlfriend and she just stares for like 5
- 50:00solid seconds of like radio silence.
- 50:03I'm like. OK, here's the thing.
- 50:08This is why I love the movies, though, because I agree with
- 50:12everything you say. Like I It's a bad character.
- 50:15It doesn't make sense. Allison Janney is trying her
- 50:18best. And the reason that I don't care
- 50:22is because of the very last thing she says to her son when
- 50:26he's like, I'm going to go. And she's just like, she can't
- 50:29muster up anything else except just, like, wear a raincoat.
- 50:33And she's like, kind of crying. And I'm like, oh, dude, yeah, A+
- 50:38performance. I don't care.
- 50:40Your character sucks, but you're doing your best.
- 50:42Allison Janney, This is why we nominate you for Oscars.
- 50:46It's a green. Line.
- 50:47It's the essence of parenting, right?
- 50:49Wear a raincoat. That's all you.
- 50:51That's all you. Yeah.
- 50:53Is that another? Is that another euphemism?
- 50:59Brad, I think it's time for us to hit pause here.
- 51:01We need to go drink some whiskey and we have got a doozy of a
- 51:04whiskey today in Crown Royal, a whiskey I have not tried since
- 51:09season 1. What do you say we jump into
- 51:10that? Let's get to it, man.
- 51:18All right, so today we are checking out Crown Royal Blended
- 51:22Canadian Whiskey. Brad, it's been a while since
- 51:26we've had a Canadian whiskey on the show.
- 51:28And that is because frankly, Canadian whiskey is not always
- 51:32that good. And I stand by it.
- 51:35I'm, I'm just going to say it. There are definitely good
- 51:37Canadian whiskeys out there. But part of what makes Canadian
- 51:41whiskey so inexpensive and not beloved by especially bourbon
- 51:45drinkers is that the Canadian whiskey process typically
- 51:49doesn't involve using new charred barrels the way that
- 51:52bourbon will. They typically age their whiskey
- 51:55in used barrels. So they're sourcing barrels from
- 51:58Ireland, from Scotland, from America, from bourbon and rye
- 52:01barrels, and they're aging their whiskey in that.
- 52:03And so it is it, it's much less potent because it's extracting
- 52:07less from the wood because these are second, third, fourth fill
- 52:11barrels. But you'll also see Canadian
- 52:13whiskey aged for a lot longer than you would see like a
- 52:16bourbon aged. I think at one point we we may
- 52:20have had a a 20 year Canadian whiskey on this podcast at one
- 52:23time. And it's still only cost like
- 52:25$40. Right.
- 52:29Listen, when it gets up to that age level, you're getting a lot
- 52:31out of the wood and it's not overwrote.
- 52:33And I actually find some really well aged Canadian whiskeys to
- 52:35be quite good that that says nothing about what we're
- 52:38drinking here today. But just ask a a brief little
- 52:41primer on Canadian whiskey. That's why we don't have it that
- 52:45much. I I think it's pronounced primer
- 52:47A. What's that all a boot?
- 52:53Am I right? Dude I I'm kind of on the
- 52:56opposite end. Like cheap Canadian whiskey.
- 52:59I'm with you. Not great.
- 53:01Anything from their mid range up.
- 53:03I have really enjoyed what comes out of OH.
- 53:06Absolutely. The the great white N kind of
- 53:09knows what it's doing when it comes to that longer age, stated
- 53:12Whiskeys. So the Crown Royal that we're
- 53:15drinking today, I believe is at least three years old.
- 53:19I think it has to be at least three years old to not carry an
- 53:21age statement. I'm not entirely sure how old it
- 53:24is because this is like the most blended of blended whiskeys.
- 53:27I'm seeing in various places online that Crown Royal is made
- 53:31from a blend of up to 50 different whiskeys.
- 53:34Even though that they they claim that roughly 80% of their grain
- 53:37is sourced from Manitoba and the surrounding provinces, it's
- 53:41still such a huge blend that it's not going to have like a
- 53:45super distinct character. It will be probably very
- 53:48consistent from batch to batch because they're just blending so
- 53:51much whiskey here. It is 80 proof, so it barely
- 53:55qualifies to be sold in your local liquor store.
- 53:59I don't want to like knock this though, man.
- 54:01I, we can have AI have a tiny little bottle of Crown Royal.
- 54:05This cost me $0.99. And if it tastes good, I'm going
- 54:08to say that it tastes good. Yeah, I really like, I don't
- 54:11want to be a snob about this. Like it's cheap whiskey.
- 54:13We know what it is. And I think we're going to go
- 54:15into this tasting with that understanding.
- 54:18Yeah, absolutely. Dude, when I got under the nose
- 54:21for this, there it is not a complex whiskey Bob, but the the
- 54:27notes that I got were vanilla cream soda, effervescent, just
- 54:32like a really pleasant like sweet experience.
- 54:38It's a 7 out of 10 on the nose. It it's fine.
- 54:42It was good, yeah. Yeah, I'm going to give it a 6
- 54:451/2 on the nose because it it smells like it's been watered
- 54:49down, almost like it doesn't have any sort of ethanol that
- 54:52you have to push through to get any notes.
- 54:54I will say that like the second I poured it into my glass, the
- 54:57overwhelming note I got was honeydew, which is like I don't
- 55:01typically get that on whiskey. Sometimes you'll get like
- 55:03pineapple or a little bit of some some sort of a melon.
- 55:06This was like just straight honeydew.
- 55:08I thought it was really, really great.
- 55:10And then it became, like you said, cream soda and vanilla
- 55:13really took over for me. It almost reminds me of like a
- 55:15diet cream soda. Like there's a little bit of
- 55:18like an artificial note going on here.
- 55:20But again, to have just those 3 notes on like a, you know, $20
- 55:24bottle of whiskey is not bad. So I'm going to give it a 6 1/2
- 55:27on the nose. Yeah, I think the palette, it
- 55:30sticks in that vanilla for me, it turned into like a vanilla
- 55:33bean kind of note. It is very much so like a yellow
- 55:37cake with white frosting. There was like a hint of a light
- 55:42brown sugary vibe going on that I think you're starting to get
- 55:46from the oak. It's a fine palette.
- 55:49I'll give it a 6 1/2 out of 10. Yeah, it's really thin.
- 55:54It's really sweet. And then as you kick it to the
- 55:57back of your palate, I think the barley notes really take over.
- 56:02So it reminds me of drinking like a watered down Scotch with
- 56:07like Splenda. Like it's there.
- 56:10There is like a really artificial sweet note to it.
- 56:13I don't know if you've ever made a Godfather cocktail, which is
- 56:18just at one point they were making it with equal parts
- 56:21Scotch and amaretto. That's it.
- 56:24Now people are like, listen, Amaretto's way too sweet.
- 56:26Don't use equal parts. But it reminds me of that.
- 56:29If you get down to like the very bottom of your glass because
- 56:31you're drinking it on the rocks, there's a, there's just an
- 56:33overwhelming sort of like sickly sweet note that's kind of
- 56:38covering up that like blended Scotch note for me.
- 56:41Not a huge fan of this one, Brad.
- 56:42I'm only going to give this a 5 out of 10 on the pallet.
- 56:45OK. I mean, so for me, I'm the
- 56:48finish, the sugariness turns into almost like a traditional
- 56:52cane sugar. The brown sugar kind of sticks
- 56:55around. And for me, the only bit of
- 57:00complexity that I had for this entire experience was on the
- 57:03finish. It almost had like a little bit
- 57:05of an ashy tobacco kind of finish that I actually kind of
- 57:10enjoyed because it gave it a little bit of something.
- 57:14It's still not great. I'll give it a 6 1/2 out of 10.
- 57:18Yeah, I mean it, it is what it is.
- 57:19Like, you know, if you're buying Crown Royal, you know what
- 57:22you're getting. However, this I don't think I've
- 57:25ever said this before. Crown Royals flavored whiskeys
- 57:31are among the best flavored like the Crown Royal Apple and the
- 57:35Crown Royal Peach are like S tier flavored whiskey.
- 57:38Dude, people love that stuff. Oh, it's and it's really good.
- 57:42And I feel like because this already has that sort of
- 57:45artificial Splenda note in it for me, I'm like, let's just
- 57:49drink the flavored stuff. I think I actually enjoy that
- 57:51better than this. There's a note on the back of
- 57:54the pallet into the finish that is that like ashy cigarette kind
- 57:58of note that is just kind of covered up in this, this like
- 58:02Splenda sweet and low, you know, stevia type note for me.
- 58:07And it it hangs on and it it makes it a little too sickly
- 58:11sweet for me. Once again, I'm going to give it
- 58:13a 5.5 on the finish here. And that takes my balance score,
- 58:19I guess to just a six. Like I'm dealing with a 6A5 and
- 58:22A5 and 1/2. So I think I got to come out to
- 58:24a six on the balance here, Brad. I'll come out to A7.
- 58:28I like, I think that they they hit everything they want.
- 58:31It falls off a little bit with the the ashiness at the end,
- 58:35even though I kind of like that it's a 7 out of 10 on balance
- 58:40value wise. This is going to set you back.
- 58:42Right now it's on sale for like 2499.
- 58:45It is a $28.00 bottle of whiskey in the state of Ohio.
- 58:50No, no, I mean I had to buy a bottle of Canadian Club 12 year
- 58:58for us to drink at some point this season.
- 59:00I can't remember what movie it's paired up with and just looking
- 59:03at that bottle and how much darker that whiskey is because
- 59:07it's 12 years old and I remember how good that was for about the
- 59:10same price as this, about $25.00, right?
- 59:13This is like $10 too expensive. This is a $15 bottle of whiskey
- 59:18if ever I've seen one. And at $25 I I'm shocked at how
- 59:23negative I am about this whiskey.
- 59:24But like this is a this is a 4.5 out of 10 on value.
- 59:30Yeah, I, I, I I'm with you, Bob. I don't think it's a great
- 59:33value. It's a 5 out of 10 on value for
- 59:36me. For $28.00 you should be getting
- 59:40a lot more than this. If this was like 18 to 21
- 59:44dollars, it's it's a 7-8 out of town value.
- 59:47Like it's a good cheap whiskey. At $28.00 I'm expecting a little
- 59:51bit more honestly. For $0.99 that's it.
- 59:55That's actually a decent price for a pour of this.
- 59:59So if you want a pour of Crown, don't go to the bar.
- 1:00:03Don't buy a whole bottle. Go buy yourself a $0.99 little
- 1:00:07plastic bottle of Crown Royal just to try it out, just to see
- 1:00:10what it's like neat. You're coming out to what on
- 1:00:15this, Brad? A 31.5.
- 1:00:19I'm at a 27.5. So we're coming out to an
- 1:00:22average of a 29 1/2 or a 59 out of 100 on this, falling well
- 1:00:28short of our 30 out of, I'm sorry, 35 out of 50 average
- 1:00:33that's needed to give this a, a recommendation.
- 1:00:35I'm not going to recommend. And I remember kind of liking
- 1:00:38this back in Season 1. We will call it signs of growth
- 1:00:43and not signs of snobbery, but not this one's not doing it for
- 1:00:46me, Brad. Yeah, I mean, honestly, like I
- 1:00:49walked away from this thinking like, oh, that was like kind of
- 1:00:51a pleasant experience. It's generically sweet and has a
- 1:00:55tiny bit of complexity. It's it's OK, but it's crown,
- 1:00:59man. I I'm kind of with you.
- 1:01:00If you want to get Crown, go buy some Peach or apple.
- 1:01:05All right, man, on that note, what do you say we get back into
- 1:01:07talking about American Beauty? Let's get to it.
- 1:01:15All right, that was Crown Royal, a Canadian whiskey to pair up
- 1:01:19with American beauty Brad. Not our finest pairing, but you
- 1:01:23know what? What do we know?
- 1:01:26For a movie called American Beauty, we probably should have
- 1:01:30had an American whiskey. But.
- 1:01:33I I think I was being a wise ass in season 1 and I did that on
- 1:01:36purpose. 100% also me. You know the no never, you know
- 1:01:41the old like that certainly was a movie and it had a score.
- 1:01:46Crown Royal. Certainly a whiskey that was
- 1:01:50made from grains. And it comes in a purple velvet
- 1:01:54bag, Brad. I'm I'm a big fan of the purple
- 1:01:57velvet bag Bob. Nothing says classy like purple
- 1:02:01velvet. All right guys.
- 1:02:03On that note Brad, it is time for us to get into our game for
- 1:02:07the week which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 1:02:10Brad is going to try to stump your ball.
- 1:02:14To. Our right and what is wrong?
- 1:02:182 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 1:02:22the show where Brad presents me with three items as facts about
- 1:02:25the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 1:02:28Brad, I have had a very up and down season with two facts and a
- 1:02:32falsehood, including being let down by some guests.
- 1:02:35So Noah, you're on the thinnest of ice, man.
- 1:02:40Just you, you, you better be helping me out here today.
- 1:02:42I am one and two. I've been keeping score for
- 1:02:45myself so this is big because I can get back to 500, but this
- 1:02:48one, this. Is this is your chance baby?
- 1:02:50Yeah, this is not the guy I want trying to help me get out of a
- 1:02:53hole here. Brad, hit me with your two facts
- 1:02:58and a falsehood. All right, guys, fact number one
- 1:03:00that the film's iconic red roses were actually silk props for
- 1:03:05most of the shoot because the fresh roses would often wilt too
- 1:03:09quickly under the lights and ruin continuity.
- 1:03:14Fact #2 Director Sam Mendez's designed there.
- 1:03:18Director Sam Mendez designed the 2 girls look to change over the
- 1:03:22course of the film, with Thora Birch gradually using less
- 1:03:26makeup and MENA Suvari gradually using more to emphasize the view
- 1:03:31of their shifting perceptions of themselves.
- 1:03:34Fact #3 When Lester throws the asparagus, he was supposed to
- 1:03:37throw it at the floor. The redactions of Annette Bening
- 1:03:40and Thora Birch are genuine. Mendez kept the take because the
- 1:03:44startled expressions perfectly captured the tension of the
- 1:03:47scene. The only thing that makes #3
- 1:03:54sound kind of fishy to me and I didn't notice it until this time
- 1:03:58around because I got a a pristine HD transfer on my
- 1:04:02Amazon prime rental, is that when he throws that asparagus at
- 1:04:06the wall the the lemon slice sticks to the wall.
- 1:04:11And I'm like that was on purpose.
- 1:04:13So they they paid some prop master to put a fake like gummy
- 1:04:16lemon on the wall. I hey, listen, if that was
- 1:04:21Providence sticking that lemon to the wall, then I'm wrong.
- 1:04:24But that just seems a little too pat and on the.
- 1:04:27Nose well, and and I I got to be honest, I've I've I've not
- 1:04:31listened to every episode but the the the Rose one.
- 1:04:34If Brad made that up, that is incredibly creative.
- 1:04:40Is he capable of coming up with something that creative?
- 1:04:44That is for you to. Determine I was just going to
- 1:04:47tell you not to stroke his ego as well.
- 1:04:48And then you give him the backhand of like, is he even
- 1:04:51capable of that? It's like, oh, you corrected
- 1:04:53yourself. I don't need to.
- 1:04:54We'll find out in a minute if that was a compliment or an
- 1:04:58insult. I'm not sure.
- 1:04:59But I that I mean the the Rose thing, it would make sense to me
- 1:05:05that they wouldn't use real roses.
- 1:05:08But I don't know about the lights that looks that was shot
- 1:05:11outdoors. Like I don't think the lights
- 1:05:12would be the problem, would they?
- 1:05:16I don't know. Yeah, there's definitely some
- 1:05:17roses in like indoor vases and stuff as well.
- 1:05:21And you know this, this scene where the roses are falling from
- 1:05:24the ceiling, those could definitely be props.
- 1:05:28At one point, I mean CGI roses too.
- 1:05:30That's what that's what I was going to say.
- 1:05:31They looked like CGIIII think I'm with you.
- 1:05:34I think I want to go with the the asparagus.
- 1:05:40Also, someone could have gotten hurt, like if that was really
- 1:05:42improvised. Like, you know, you don't know
- 1:05:44where those shards are going to go.
- 1:05:46That's pretty dangerous stuff. Although this is a movie in
- 1:05:48which she tries to have sex with a 16 year old, so sure.
- 1:05:53But that's in the movies. Living on the.
- 1:05:55Edge. That's not you know.
- 1:05:58So wait, you sound really skeptical about the roses, but
- 1:06:00you're not choosing that as a falsehood.
- 1:06:03No, I think it, I think it's real.
- 1:06:07I think that I think that is real one because I think that's
- 1:06:11I don't. And as you know, sincerely, no
- 1:06:14offense, Brad, but that's too that is too wacky.
- 1:06:18If there is ever ever a phrase to guarantee that the person is
- 1:06:24meaning offense. I mean, does Brad even know
- 1:06:27about? Does Brad know about Silk Bob
- 1:06:30Like I would who? I wouldn't even think of silk.
- 1:06:32Where would that come from? I, I'm gonna be honest with you,
- 1:06:35man, I've insulted Brad a lot over the course of this podcast
- 1:06:39and I, I'm offended on his behalf, right?
- 1:06:42That's how insulting you're being to my Co host right now.
- 1:06:45I here's what I'm going to do for you, Brad.
- 1:06:47I'm going to choose #3 as the falsehood with a slight hope
- 1:06:51that it is number 1, so that you can vindicate yourself against
- 1:06:55these attacks, Brad. Oh, Bob, I appreciate you doing
- 1:07:00that because Noah number #1 was the falsehood.
- 1:07:10Well, well done, Sir. I stand deeply and profoundly
- 1:07:14corrected. It is no problem man.
- 1:07:17I this has. Been How do you even know about
- 1:07:19silk? I mean, I know he knows about
- 1:07:21the. Existence of silk.
- 1:07:22It's a completely new textile to him.
- 1:07:26It's so soft guys. I have not had this much fun
- 1:07:33with a 2 Facts and a falsehood since Zach a few weeks ago told
- 1:07:37us that he was just casually reading Stephen Foster's
- 1:07:41songbook. All right, well, I think the key
- 1:07:45here to a fun 2 facts and a falsehood is to insult Brad.
- 1:07:49But the key to a loss for me is bringing guests on because I
- 1:07:52have been steered wildly wrong. OK, I am taking Els left and
- 1:07:57right on this movie. Guys.
- 1:07:59I do want to get back into talking about this movie a
- 1:08:02little bit because you know, Noah has already said not a huge
- 1:08:05fan. Brad and I I think both still
- 1:08:07like this movie and I want to talk a little bit about its
- 1:08:13place now. We touched on it a bit.
- 1:08:16It's the victim of a lot of Twitter poo pooping.
- 1:08:21Noah. I'm wondering, like, is it
- 1:08:26possible to watch this movie free from the baggage of all of
- 1:08:32it's bad? I mean, free from the baggage of
- 1:08:34Kevin Spacey, free from the baggage of knowing that people
- 1:08:37hate it now, and I think free from a lot of the things we
- 1:08:41impose on it as 2025 viewers. I think there's the answer to me
- 1:08:47is no. And there's two things that
- 1:08:50could have happened that would have allowed us to and neither
- 1:08:54one of them happened. 1 is that Kevin Spacey could have simply
- 1:08:57gone away. And I think if Kevin Spacey went
- 1:09:01away, like didn't make those weird ass videos every Christmas
- 1:09:04and didn't pop up every now and then talking about what an
- 1:09:07injustice is, is being, you know, thrown out of Hollywood is
- 1:09:12I'm not saying we would forgive him, but I think we would
- 1:09:15inherently soften on his performances a little bit.
- 1:09:18Just not having to think about and see him talking about this
- 1:09:21stuff all the time. That didn't happen.
- 1:09:24The other thing that didn't happen is Sam Mendes didn't only
- 1:09:28make good movies because he has made some bad movies.
- 1:09:32And I think if if he went on to just make like good to great
- 1:09:36movies, like if you had a better track record over the last 25
- 1:09:40years, I think we might be more inclined to look back at this
- 1:09:45and say, OK, you know what, I'm going to look on the bright
- 1:09:47side. There's more to like.
- 1:09:48And I don't mean you guys, I know you guys still like this
- 1:09:50movie, but just in general, the film Twitter, the film world I
- 1:09:54think would would be softer on this movie because I don't think
- 1:09:59people are really, they're not really into Sam Mendes.
- 1:10:02There's not a lot of Mendez heads out there.
- 1:10:04I mean, I think we all agree he's made some good movies.
- 1:10:07He's also made some pretty bad movies.
- 1:10:09And I think there'd be a bit of a critical reappraisal if he
- 1:10:13were more revered or respected as a film maker today.
- 1:10:17And he really just kind of isn't.
- 1:10:20And I we've already kind of talked about the third thing, if
- 1:10:23this doesn't win Academy Award for Best Picture, like you
- 1:10:26could, you could win some acting awards, cinematography, all
- 1:10:30that. But if it doesn't win Best
- 1:10:32picture, I think people come back to this and go like, Oh
- 1:10:35yeah, this is pretty solid in those niche areas.
- 1:10:38It it's a perfect storm to have its reputation overturned over
- 1:10:43these years because it won Best Picture and people don't like
- 1:10:46it. It beat out all these other
- 1:10:48incredible movies that we do love from that era, and the star
- 1:10:53of it is a known predator. In a movie, like in a character
- 1:10:57where he is a predator like that is really hard to let go of all
- 1:11:02that stuff. 100%. You don't.
- 1:11:04You don't want Stacey to put a time to type Noah.
- 1:11:08Right. I could not have asked you to to
- 1:11:11team me up better for a conversation on Sam Mendes.
- 1:11:14When Brad, we we kind of interrogated all this in our
- 1:11:16Skyfall episode. But people do not like Sam
- 1:11:19Mendes. And when I say people, I mean
- 1:11:21film Twitter because they have nothing better to do than
- 1:11:23complain. But it it always does.
- 1:11:27It makes me wonder sometimes about like, I don't think we've
- 1:11:31fully gotten over auteur theory because we see a film maker like
- 1:11:36Sam Mendes, who admittedly has made some bad movies that did
- 1:11:38not work. And because Sam Mendes doesn't
- 1:11:42seem to have like a singular theme or vision that he tries to
- 1:11:46tackle, he's just a guy who is technically proficient and makes
- 1:11:52beautiful looking movies that sometimes work and sometimes
- 1:11:56don't. I think he gets seen as a hack.
- 1:11:59And and I wouldn't be like very clear here.
- 1:12:02I don't think he's a hack. I think he makes good movies.
- 1:12:06But it it seems like everyone is held to the standard of like, if
- 1:12:10you're not Scorsese constantly making movies about religion and
- 1:12:14the rot at, you know, the corrupt heart of America and you
- 1:12:18can't be that clear in every movie that you make, then you're
- 1:12:21not seen as a real filmmaker. And I do think that that Mendez
- 1:12:26deserves a little bit more credit.
- 1:12:27This is his first movie. Like, this is his debut movie.
- 1:12:30He wins best director and best picture.
- 1:12:33And no matter what you think of whether those were deserved,
- 1:12:36like I, I do think he should be taken a little more seriously as
- 1:12:41a force in Hollywood, you know, even if he squandered that in in
- 1:12:46the years after it. I mean, the way you were talking
- 1:12:50about him reminds me of how we talk about Rob Reiner, that like
- 1:12:54he, he doesn't have this direct, this vision of, you know, who he
- 1:12:59wants to be as a director. He just takes on a lot of
- 1:13:01different genres and different films and is a really
- 1:13:05proficient, adept director. And he he works well with actors
- 1:13:10and he's good behind the camera. And like, that's all we expect
- 1:13:14from him. I think that the Academy Award
- 1:13:18and all this set us up to think of Sam as a possible next right?
- 1:13:24Like it's, it's the LeBron syndrome for the last 15 years
- 1:13:27of like, well, Zion Williamson is the next LeBron and Ben, Ben
- 1:13:33Simmons is the next LeBron. And I like I've heard of 5-6
- 1:13:38next Lebrons and none of them have become the next LeBron.
- 1:13:41I I feel like you kind of have a little bit of that here with Sam
- 1:13:44Mendes where it's like, yeah, is he Ben Simmons bad?
- 1:13:46No, but is he LeBron good? Like, no, he's not that good.
- 1:13:51Also no. Yeah, well, and it's like if one
- 1:13:54of those guys won an MVP and an NBA championship in their rookie
- 1:13:58year, you know, like, yeah, those expectations would just be
- 1:14:02totally unreasonable. And and that's, that's
- 1:14:04definitely what we have here. There was almost a sense of
- 1:14:08like, OK, you did this. Now you have to show that it was
- 1:14:12merited. Like, how can how does that
- 1:14:14work? You can't show that it was
- 1:14:16merited with other films, like you won for that film at that
- 1:14:20time. So I I think it's totally unfair
- 1:14:23and totally unreasonable. But we do have to.
- 1:14:25And you've mentioned it, but I feel like it bears repeating.
- 1:14:28He's made some bad movies like that is part of the reason he is
- 1:14:33disliked, because he has made some bad movies and he's
- 1:14:37squandered some opportunities. He made Skyfall, which was
- 1:14:39phenomenal, and then he made Spectre, which was not.
- 1:14:43And it's, and I think people, yeah, people don't like him.
- 1:14:45I think they're all so confused. I think people don't know where
- 1:14:48to put him. And when film Twitter gets
- 1:14:50confused about something, they normally get angry about it.
- 1:14:54They don't. They don't know how to deal with
- 1:14:56their confusion. This is true.
- 1:14:59I mean, if you take you take his top three movies, though, I
- 1:15:02think, yes, the batting average argument is not in his favor,
- 1:15:06right? But if you take his top three
- 1:15:09movies, whatever #3 might be to you like, you know, Skyfall 1917
- 1:15:13and American Beauty or Road to Perdition.
- 1:15:17And if I told you, like you could have a career directing
- 1:15:19movies where your three best movies are Skyfall 1917 and
- 1:15:24American Beauty, you'd be like, sign me up for that all day.
- 1:15:27Those are those are. We've done all three of those
- 1:15:29movies on the podcast. I mean, let's be real, if you
- 1:15:31have three like produced by a major production studio movies,
- 1:15:36you're set for life. So I'll I'll take any 3 movies
- 1:15:39like. Can you imagine?
- 1:15:41Do you? Do you remember that for 19/17
- 1:15:44that was the Parasite year? Like Can you imagine if somehow
- 1:15:48that he had beaten Parasite that year too?
- 1:15:50Like how much everybody would hate him even more than they do
- 1:15:54now? And it almost happened.
- 1:15:56Like he was favored to win Best director and 1917 was favored to
- 1:15:59win best picture, like pretty close to the end.
- 1:16:02So he should be very happy that he did not win those Oscars.
- 1:16:07Another banger year 2019 as well.
- 1:16:10Incredible marriage story. I mean, just a just a freaking
- 1:16:12great the. Correlation that I'm seeing is
- 1:16:15Sam Mendes. Clearly he.
- 1:16:18Is what makes those years. If he makes a movie, it's going
- 1:16:21to be a great year. Guys, I think this is a perfect
- 1:16:24time to get into our final segment of the day, which we
- 1:16:27call let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:16:30episodes of Things, listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 1:16:34Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's struggle.
- 1:16:36It's the final segment of the day.
- 1:16:38Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:16:40part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 1:16:44to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:16:45Guys, I'm going to go ahead and get mine out of the way first.
- 1:16:48We we talked about Sam Mendez a lot.
- 1:16:50And Brad, you made a comparison to Rob Reiner.
- 1:16:53I actually think I see a little bit more vitriol directed
- 1:16:58towards Sam Mendes. And I think Noah, you're right.
- 1:17:00It's it's part of the confusion. But the closest corollary to to
- 1:17:05him that I can think of is the filmmaker Jason Reitman, who is
- 1:17:11a Neppo baby, to say the least, and really announced himself on
- 1:17:15the scene in independent cinema with this movie.
- 1:17:17Thank You for Smoking. And then follows that up with
- 1:17:19Juno, gets nominated for best picture for Juno, maybe best
- 1:17:23director as well. Then he does up in the air
- 1:17:26another best picture nominee. He gets nominated for best
- 1:17:29director. He does a young adult, a movie
- 1:17:31that I really like, and then immediately is like, let's make
- 1:17:35bad Movies Now. And that's all he does forever.
- 1:17:38And now he's making Ghostbusters sequels.
- 1:17:40And so like, he made a movie in I think 2013 that is probably
- 1:17:46his most reviled movie and a movie that I liked significantly
- 1:17:50more than most people. And it was called Men, Women and
- 1:17:52Children. And that was a movie very much
- 1:17:55like American Beauty. It was a movie about these Criss
- 1:17:58crossing lives in American suburbia and kids who are
- 1:18:01addicted to pornography and, you know, grown-ups who are fighting
- 1:18:07and maybe divorcing each other. And it's all phrased with this
- 1:18:09omniscient narrator who I think is Emma Thompson is narrating
- 1:18:14that movie. And it's there.
- 1:18:15She's like quoting Carl Sagan talking about the the tiny blue
- 1:18:19dot and how we all inhabit this. Or it's it's very similar to
- 1:18:23American Beauty in it's kind of pomp and circumstance and what
- 1:18:27it's trying to do on a cosmic level and watch that movie,
- 1:18:31which I don't hate, and then tell me that American Beauty is
- 1:18:34bad. And I think that every argument
- 1:18:37you have against this movie and Sam Mendes, it's like, no, no,
- 1:18:41there's this movie that you can put all of that on to.
- 1:18:44So for my scapegoat slash double feature, I'm going with this.
- 1:18:49And men, women and children. Oh man, just to be clear, I
- 1:18:54don't despise this film. I.
- 1:18:56Didn't think it was that bad. What a glowing recommendation.
- 1:19:01I'm going to pair this with the movie I absolutely love, and
- 1:19:06it's a movie that I think has somewhat similar of a premise,
- 1:19:12but it just moves in so much more hopeful of the direction.
- 1:19:16And I'm a very hopeful person. I like when a person is faced
- 1:19:20with their own death, them choosing the greater good
- 1:19:24choosing. A beautiful life.
- 1:19:27You have picked this movie like 7 Times Now.
- 1:19:30Breath. Because more people need to see
- 1:19:31this freaking movie. Bob Akiru is one of the greatest
- 1:19:34films ever made and everybody needs to watch it.
- 1:19:38And I feel like it has such a more impactful look on how
- 1:19:46humans actually thrive, that American Beauty and I, I like
- 1:19:51American Beauty. I think, Bob, what you said
- 1:19:54about everybody playing a character until the masks are
- 1:19:58shattered at the end of the film and they're all like, well,
- 1:20:00crap, Like what are we going to do now?
- 1:20:02I, I think there's something very important in that
- 1:20:06messaging. I just like Akiru way more.
- 1:20:10And what it is trying to tell you about the human experience.
- 1:20:14There you go. I love Akiru a lot and I love
- 1:20:19the English language remake that came out a couple years ago.
- 1:20:22Live in like. I thought that was almost as
- 1:20:25good, which is an. Incredible.
- 1:20:27That's because Bill Nighy is a freaking treasure.
- 1:20:31I. Totally.
- 1:20:32So good. I love everything he does and
- 1:20:34that is his best performance to me.
- 1:20:35I, I think he's really amazing in that movie.
- 1:20:39I, I am go. I so I'm just thinking suburbs
- 1:20:43movies, you know, and there've been a lot.
- 1:20:46I, I, I love the idea that you had of pairing it with like a, a
- 1:20:50Rock Hudson movie. I think that would be really,
- 1:20:52really cool. But I am going to go with A
- 1:20:56Nightmare on Elm Street. I think this is another movie
- 1:21:00about teenagers in peril in the suburbs in a very different way.
- 1:21:06And I think that movie really kicked off like a whole modern
- 1:21:09era of suburbs movies like it was before the John Hughes
- 1:21:13movies started happening. And I think I honestly think
- 1:21:17like the themes of Nightmare on Elm Street are present in a lot
- 1:21:20of these movies. You know, a lot of the John
- 1:21:21Hughes movies, The Burbs is a movie that I love that I think
- 1:21:24goes a lot to Nightmare on Elm Street.
- 1:21:26I wouldn't make an interesting pairing with this.
- 1:21:27But just like you don't like what the hell is happening on
- 1:21:30this street, like that's a movie that I, I, that's a, that's a
- 1:21:34genre that I like. And I think This American Beauty
- 1:21:37falls into that genre too. And I actually think there are
- 1:21:40little hints of horror throughout the film.
- 1:21:43So I think I think those might be brought out a little more if
- 1:21:46you paired it with a true horror movie like Nightmare on Elm
- 1:21:49Street. It's a movie about a a teenage
- 1:21:53girl who gets caught in a creepy old man's dreams.
- 1:21:56Like it's the same movie, you know?
- 1:21:58Yeah, exactly. Exactly.
- 1:21:59I was about to say, are you calling Kevin Spacey Freddy
- 1:22:02Krueger? It's it's a they're neck and
- 1:22:05neck biggest villains. Oh, man.
- 1:22:11All right, so Brad, I guess I I didn't have a chance to pair
- 1:22:14this movie up with either ET or Elizabethtown today, so I had to
- 1:22:17go with men, women and children. I do think if you want to go the
- 1:22:20Sam Mendes route, he makes a movie in 2008 called
- 1:22:23Revolutionary Rd. which is based on, no exaggeration, my favorite
- 1:22:29book I've ever read. It is the pros in that book is
- 1:22:32just it is so biting and so cynical and Mendez does not
- 1:22:39catch lightning in a bottle a second time with that movie.
- 1:22:43And I think part of the reason why is it just doesn't have the
- 1:22:45edge of this movie. And and I'm I'm kind of tipping
- 1:22:50into final scores here, Brad. I've come down a bit on this
- 1:22:53movie. Like I don't think it's a
- 1:22:54perfect movie. I do think some things have
- 1:22:57gotten lost in the last 25 years.
- 1:22:59And, and part of that is like, I was wondering at some point how
- 1:23:04creepy is Ricky in 2025 versus 1999 when he was only medium
- 1:23:09creepy. And now he's like exponentially
- 1:23:11creepier. And part of the reason for that
- 1:23:14is like he's filming people. And it's a very obvious metaphor
- 1:23:18of like the camera being the only impartial, objective
- 1:23:23observer of what's going on in the world, where everybody else
- 1:23:26is biased and and viewing it through the lens of their own
- 1:23:28bullshit. But now if you show somebody
- 1:23:32filming somebody, when we take videos in 2025, we take videos
- 1:23:39with the intention of that becoming for public consumption.
- 1:23:46Whereas in this movie, like he's only documenting it for himself
- 1:23:49to show the beauty in the world to himself.
- 1:23:51And I, I think that like overcoming that thing in his
- 1:23:55character where like, people don't understand I filmed
- 1:23:59something for myself anymore. It's like I filmed this to put
- 1:24:02it on the Internet and he's filming girls getting naked and
- 1:24:06dads pumping iron naked and everything else.
- 1:24:08Like, so I think that there's just some things.
- 1:24:12And that led to the question I asked Noah before, like, can you
- 1:24:15even view this movie apart from all of its baggage today?
- 1:24:17I don't think you can. And I don't think the movie is
- 1:24:20bulletproof enough to overcome all those things.
- 1:24:23I still think it's a really good movie, but I'm going to come
- 1:24:26down to an 8 1/2 on this movie. Brad from where I was in Season
- 1:24:291. Yeah, I I did find myself
- 1:24:32throughout this viewing wondering like, what does a
- 1:24:36world where everybody can take videos all the time due to the
- 1:24:42character of Ricky, because he's not interested.
- 1:24:45I don't like, honestly, he's not weird anymore.
- 1:24:47Because if you make this movie set in 2025, he's just another
- 1:24:51human being, but there's nothing unique about him taking a camera
- 1:24:54to school. So I I think that alone makes
- 1:24:57his character very fascinating in 2025.
- 1:25:02I'm, I'm with you, Bob. I think this is a really
- 1:25:06beautiful movie. It has a lot of great
- 1:25:10cinematography that we didn't talk about, but the the camera
- 1:25:15work I think is really good. I like the acting.
- 1:25:18I like the ultimate message of the movie.
- 1:25:22I think it's really well done overall.
- 1:25:24I'm at an 8 1/2 as well. You know, I wonder if in 2025,
- 1:25:30Ricky's thing would be that he like doesn't have a camera.
- 1:25:33Like if he doesn't have a people would be like, Oh my God,
- 1:25:36believe that guy doesn't have a phone.
- 1:25:37He's. He just walks around with a
- 1:25:39journal of writing down what we say.
- 1:25:40What a weirdo. I just pictured him walking
- 1:25:43around with like an old like 1860s Civil War era camera where
- 1:25:48he has to like take the cap off. He's like, everybody holds
- 1:25:51still. I I need to?
- 1:25:52Capture hold still for 5 minutes.
- 1:25:55He gets under like a curtain to look through the viewfinder.
- 1:25:59It is interesting though, because I think you could make
- 1:26:02it wouldn't be as, as interesting visually, but like
- 1:26:05you could make that argument that he actually does see things
- 1:26:08more clearly because he's not using a phone because he's not
- 1:26:11posting stuff on Instagram. So that would be an interesting
- 1:26:14way to do it if they were doing it in 2020 for the inevitable
- 1:26:17American Beauty remake that we all know is coming because this
- 1:26:21movie is so beloved. I, I'm going to put this at a 5
- 1:26:25out of 10. I, I don't think it's terrible.
- 1:26:29You thought it would be higher? No, I thought, I thought I'd
- 1:26:32been underselling. I, I, I don't think it's
- 1:26:36terrible. I just don't think it's very
- 1:26:38good. I think it has a lot of
- 1:26:39problems. I I actually think, and I never
- 1:26:42say this about movies because I don't watch TV, but I think it
- 1:26:46would be better as ATV series like Alan Ball made Six Feet
- 1:26:51under right after this. This was his next project.
- 1:26:55And this a lot of the problems I have with this is, is that there
- 1:27:00is too much into it, too much in it.
- 1:27:02It's too condensed. It has to rely on some, you
- 1:27:06know, sitcomy conventions and some, you know, some moments
- 1:27:10from Kevin Spacey that are, are meant to sort of bring the
- 1:27:13audience along instead of delving deeper into his
- 1:27:15character. And I think if you had eight
- 1:27:18episodes to tell this story, I think it would be better.
- 1:27:22And I think I, we could understand these characters
- 1:27:24more. And it wouldn't feel to me like
- 1:27:26it's trying to juggle tones that it really can't quite, you know,
- 1:27:30keep all the balls in the air. I think they would be able to
- 1:27:34expand both the comedy and expand the drama.
- 1:27:37And I, I think I think it would work better.
- 1:27:39So that that would be my tip. If I could go back 25 years, I'd
- 1:27:43say, guys, we're right on the cusp of the golden age of
- 1:27:46prestige TV. So just wait a year and then and
- 1:27:51then give Alan Ball a big a big check, HBO.
- 1:27:55It's like, hey guys, here's my pitch.
- 1:27:56You could make this movie as is and win Best Picture and Best
- 1:28:00Director and Best Actor or. Or you.
- 1:28:03Could. Or you could wait five years.
- 1:28:05Make an HBO show and have nobody notice because they're all
- 1:28:07gushing about The Sopranos. Exactly.
- 1:28:12You drive a hard bargain, Sir. All right, so that does it for
- 1:28:15us today. We're coming out to an 8.5 on
- 1:28:18average for me and Brad. And Noah's score doesn't count
- 1:28:21because he's the guest. So thanks so much for joining us
- 1:28:24today, Noah. Now you did mention that you
- 1:28:27were no longer doing film criticism as of right now, so
- 1:28:30fill us in a little bit on what you are working on and where we
- 1:28:33can find you. Oh sure, So I have pivoted.
- 1:28:36I'm making music now. I, I, it's something I did in my
- 1:28:4020s. I put out an album in my 20s and
- 1:28:42then I kind of moved away from it and now I've moved back to
- 1:28:45it. So I've put out two albums this
- 1:28:47year and I have a third that'll be out maybe by the time this
- 1:28:51this comes up. It's singer-songwriter stuff.
- 1:28:54It's very pleasant. I think the songs are not bad
- 1:28:58and you can find me on Band Camp and Spotify and other places
- 1:29:02that I don't I don't frequent but I'm told the music is on
- 1:29:05there as well. Man, just a a real whore for
- 1:29:10self promotion aren't you? I think the songs are not bad
- 1:29:14quote UN quote. Noah can tell.
- 1:29:18I think that. That you know what I honestly,
- 1:29:20I, I will say this, we hung out like a year ago, you came to
- 1:29:23visit Cleveland for a while and we went and had a couple drinks
- 1:29:26and you were like, I'm going to go to an open mic.
- 1:29:28And I was like, you know what, bud?
- 1:29:30You do what you need to do, right?
- 1:29:32I was like, I, I don't know if I'm going to come listen to you
- 1:29:34at an open mic. And then you started posting
- 1:29:36clips of you and your songs that you've written.
- 1:29:39First of all, you have a beautiful voice.
- 1:29:41Like you, like, are a legitimately good singer and
- 1:29:44songwriter. And I find that your music is
- 1:29:47like unironically, unabashedly very, very good and worth
- 1:29:52checking out. So if he won't, if he'll be too
- 1:29:54humble to say it, I'll say it for him.
- 1:29:56Check out Noah's music guys. Well, I set you up perfectly.
- 1:30:00My plan came to fruition here. Thank you so very much.
- 1:30:03That really does mean a lot. And I know you mean it because
- 1:30:06we were talking off off air and you said you want to come to an
- 1:30:10open mic soon and hear me play. So we'll do that and maybe we'll
- 1:30:15live stream it for your audience.
- 1:30:17Based on how 2 Facts and a falsehood of blend.
- 1:30:19I have so many thoughts on your musical capabilities, but I'm
- 1:30:24just, you know, I'm going to keep them to myself here.
- 1:30:26Do you even know what a melody? Is just know that if he writes a
- 1:30:32song about Silk now, Brad, that it was inspired by you.
- 1:30:35That's that's all we know. All right, guys, that does it
- 1:30:39for us here on Film and Whiskey today.
- 1:30:41We'll be back next week talking about a movie that we probably
- 1:30:44should have a moderator for. It's 1977's Star Wars Episode 4,
- 1:30:50A New Hope. Brad's one of Brad's favorite
- 1:30:52movies of all time. So join us as we debate that one
- 1:30:55again next week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:30:58I'm Brad Gee. And we'll see you next time.