Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #222 - Karen Mirsky / Dustin Godfrey / Kyla Lee
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight we'll talk about
- 0:24what you can and can't do in public? Can you film people, including
- 0:29vulnerable people in public even if they've asked you not to do so? Plus,
- 0:34after a BC Supreme Court decision blocked a law banning drug use in most
- 0:39public spaces, does that mean that drugs like fentanyl can legally be consumed on
- 0:44playgrounds? But first, as a protected democratic right? Why do some protests
- 0:50lead to arrests? Here to explain the limits on our right to protest is
- 0:54the president of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, with nearly two decades of
- 0:59experience in criminal defense, civil disobedience and police conduct cases. She is Karen
- 1:04Mursky. Karen, Hello, Hi there, mol How are you? Oh
- 1:08great? Thank you? Thanks for being here tonight of quest So I have
- 1:11to ask you we in this country, we obviously have a right to protest,
- 1:15and yet I see protesters being arrested all the time. So when does
- 1:19the right to protest become unlawful? Well, you know, when we talk
- 1:23about protests, we have to talk about different types of lawfulness. For example,
- 1:30a mass protest somebody something that we might consider at the art gallery,
- 1:34for example, may spill over onto streets. It might block streets. There
- 1:38might be some municipal by law infractions if you think about occupy movement, for
- 1:42example, living or staying tenting in the art gallery spaces for some time.
- 1:49In any event, there are of course protests that involve planned illegality, which
- 1:55oftentimes that kind of civil disobedience is meant for arrests, and police events do
- 2:00arrest, but there is a lot of gray area in there because police and
- 2:05government essentially recognizes that this is a protected right. Okay, so it sounds
- 2:09like you can march down the street, but as long as you're not blocking
- 2:14the street itself or sitting in on private property or even public property. But
- 2:19after hours it's still lawful. Right, it's still lawful, and even when
- 2:23it isn't. For example, if you see people who might be going into
- 2:27private businesses a bank, for example, to have a protest or to sit
- 2:30in there, police might attend. They might speak to people, give them
- 2:34an opportunity to leave before they then affect an arrest. And how do we
- 2:38define civil disobedience? I know this is obviously popularized by Gandhi and Martin Luther
- 2:43King, But does this Does civil disobedience basically mean that you are knowingly breaking
- 2:47the law, but you're just not being violent? Indeed? Yeah, so,
- 2:51and that's exactly what Gandhi had considered conceived of when he thought about civil
- 2:55disobedience. Essentially, you're planning unlawful activity as a way of engaging government in
- 3:04a discussion, right, And so the thrust of civil disobedience is that people
- 3:07are intentionally breaking the law and then submitting themselves to the court system for punishment.
- 3:14They're effectively surrendering their good conduct, using their good character as a way
- 3:19of marking dissent over something that they feel they have a moral obligation. And
- 3:24this would include the folks that you know create blockades on bridges, right,
- 3:29Like, they know that they're breaking the law, but they're being nonviolent,
- 3:31am I right? Yes? One of the hallmarks of civil disobedience is nonviolent
- 3:36protest. Does that also include not destroying property? I mean, if you
- 3:39throw a soup on a painting in a public art gallery, is that considered
- 3:45civil disobedience or not because you're destroying public property. Well, you know property,
- 3:49I asked. It's a very good question. I will say that a
- 3:52lot of the individuals that we see kind of going and defacing paint work or
- 3:55defacing somebody's you know, business, putting paint a lot of times that's washable,
- 4:01and they're not actually destroying property. You'll see people still arrested for mischief
- 4:05in certain circumstances. People on bridges are a little bit different. The way
- 4:10the courts have interpreted this is you're actually creating enough of a risk of violence,
- 4:15largely because people will get pissed off with you that they feel the need
- 4:19to take some kind of let's call it corrective action. So it's almost like
- 4:24incitement. Then I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incitement, but
- 4:29you know you're the lawyer making sure. Yeah, I mean, it creates
- 4:32a set of circumstances that make it more likely that there will be violence or
- 4:38a risk of violence. But when we do talk about nonviolent protests, there's
- 4:42a lot of areas that we need to stop and consider how we define violent
- 4:46protests. The Charter, and particularly Section two of the Charter, which is
- 4:50our fundamental freedoms protects peaceful assembly, not lawful assembly, but peaceful assembly.
- 4:57Now, within that, of course, there are limits on free expression and
- 5:01free assembly that are for example, violence is not protected activity. However,
- 5:08how do we define that someone for example, who's on a hunger strike right
- 5:12self harming in some way. We don't actually have jurisprudence that gives us any
- 5:16real guidance around particularly freedom of assembly, but around protest activities that really push
- 5:23the boundaries of what may or may not be permissible. Let me get into
- 5:26one specific example. We've seen protests where hate speech is uttered or you have
- 5:30hateful symbols. Would that then make the protest unlawful or is it just a
- 5:36crime for that specific protester, Yeah, it would be for the person.
- 5:41So you know, if you're at our threats or display hateful imagery, yeah,
- 5:45I mean, the criminal law is geared toward you know, it would
- 5:47be a person charged. Yeah, And of course the crown would then need
- 5:50to prove the elements of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. And that's one
- 5:55of the reasons why we don't frequently see hate speech pursued under the Criminal Code
- 6:00because it's really difficult for the crown to establish what somebody's intending by their words,
- 6:04unless there's a really strong obvious meaning like a direct threat, a direct
- 6:10threat generally vilification of an individual or a group of individuals, detestation language that
- 6:15suggests that they're not there. But then less than hate speech. Of course,
- 6:20we have discriminatory speech right, which is something that would be covered under
- 6:25the BC Human Rights Code, And we also see hate speech coming in under
- 6:30the BC Human Rights Code, but again it's a relatively high bar, and
- 6:35generally speaking, we see discriminatory conduct discriminatory speech much more frequently under the Human
- 6:42Rights Code. Fascinating, Karen, I learned so much. Thank you so
- 6:44much for your time. Of course, absolutely take care folks. She's the
- 6:47president of the BC Civil Liberties Association, Karen Mursky. Check out their website
- 6:53online for more resources, including the updated Arrest Handbook with a new chapter on
- 6:58protest, civil disabl obedience, and Indigenous resistance. Now, after some business,
- 7:03does drug decriminalization in BC mean that drugs can be consumed anywhere in public
- 7:09including playgrounds? Will set the record straight up. Next, welcome back to
- 7:18this as Van color. On January twenty third, twenty twenty three, BC
- 7:23became the first province in Canada to receive a federal exemption to decriminalize some illicit
- 7:29drugs for personal use. Now, that doesn't mean that drugs are legal.
- 7:32It just means that drug users won't be arrested, charged, or have their
- 7:36drugs seized for personal possession of a small amount of cocaine, methantheenibine MDMA,
- 7:43and opioids including fentanyl. Last November, the BCNDP government passed Bill thirty four
- 7:49that banned all drug use in most public spaces, including playgrounds. But three
- 7:56days before the law was set to come into force, a BC superre Court
- 8:00justice granted an injunction against Bill thirty four, ruling that irreparable harm will be
- 8:07caused if the act comes into force, a ruling that the BCNDP government will
- 8:11now appeal. So does that mean that drug users can freely consume drugs in
- 8:16children's playgrounds? Here to explain is a freelance journalist based in the Vancouver area
- 8:22returning to the show they are dustin Godfree and this conversation is supported by shelter
- 8:26Point single malt whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island. Uniquely shelter Point So Dustin with
- 8:35this Supreme Court ruling, does that effectively mean that people in BC can freely
- 8:41use drugs in children's playgrounds? No? No, no, because that's what
- 8:48I've heard in the media. There's been a whole lot of misinformation and in
- 8:54a number of cases also like disinformation kind of floating around about this court decision,
- 9:00and like kind of one of the things that's like particularly frustrating about it
- 9:03in this case is that it's kind of coming from like all quarters. Right,
- 9:07It's not just coming from the National Post, It's also coming from the
- 9:09Toronto Star. It's not just coming from the BC United. It's also coming
- 9:13from the bc NDP, right, because they wanted to pass this legislation to
- 9:16effectively bar drug users from using in playgrounds. So that's why I'm also confused.
- 9:24Yeah, And so like shortly before Bill thirty four came in or was
- 9:28introduced by the BCNDP, they also asked Health Canada to amend the exemption from
- 9:33the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act to exclude playgrounds from like where people are allowed
- 9:39to possess drugs, and like that particular rule is still in place, Like
- 9:46there was a sort of like in Bill thirty four. It also had a
- 9:50provision that said that you're not allowed to consume drugs in playgrounds. Like the
- 9:52language between the two are pretty similar. Okay, So the Health Canada exemption,
- 9:58So what does that mean, Like you can't do drugs or hold drugs
- 10:01in playgrounds. So like the Health Canada exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances
- 10:05Act, that is like what governs the sort of the criminalization pilot projects,
- 10:11and like baked into it there are some sort of areas where you're still not
- 10:15allowed to possess drugs. So initially it included like daycares and schools, Costard
- 10:20Coast Guard vessels and helicopters, army bases, and then in September they amended
- 10:26it to include skate parks, playgrounds and splash pads. Okay, so Health
- 10:31Canada already said that you can't possess drugs consume drugs in these places. Yeah,
- 10:35exactly, And so like the court ruling doesn't really challenge that at all.
- 10:43When that change came into effect, nobody really bad at an I like
- 10:46nobody is challenging the playground band there. The issue with the sort of Bill
- 10:52thirty four is sort of the breadth of the law and sort of the breadth
- 10:56of the police powers that are afforded by it. Yeah, let's talk about
- 11:00Bill thirty four. Then if this law had become law and there was not
- 11:03a Supreme Court injunction, what would that have meant? Like where would drug
- 11:09users not be able to do drugs? When it comes to doing drugs in
- 11:11public, this is basically six meters from a doorway or bus stop in parks,
- 11:16beaches, things like that, and then you know all the other places
- 11:18that are already covered, okay, and so like when you kind of look
- 11:22at a map of the city, that's pretty much everywhere, like especially in
- 11:24the downtown east Side, where there is a lot of people who are forced
- 11:28to use drugs outside. You know, if you yeah, it strikes me
- 11:31that this would disproportionately affect one on house people, but then two people that
- 11:37may not have access to a safe consumption site. Yeah, exactly. And
- 11:41like that's kind of the thing about it is that it's not people who are
- 11:43like choosing to use outside. It's generally people who are kind of forced to
- 11:48use outside in part because you know, they don't have like their own housing,
- 11:52but also because they don't have a safe supply of drugs, and so
- 11:56you know, often they'll kind of want to use around other people so that
- 12:00they can be found in time for a you know, somebody to intervene in
- 12:05the event of an overdose. And so yeah, like I say, in
- 12:09the in the case of this, like the areas that are not covered by
- 12:13this, if you like look at like Google street View or whatever and like
- 12:16kind of map it out, there's like a few pockets of like sidewalk around
- 12:20the downtown east Side that wouldn't be covered, right, But then really it's
- 12:24kind of pushing people into the alleyways, and like the harm reduction movement has
- 12:28spent a lot of time, like pretty much the last couple of decades trying
- 12:31to pull people out of the alleyways because again, like that's where people kind
- 12:35of wind up dying because they're not found in time. Right. Wow,
- 12:39So I just want to be clear here. The Health Canada exemptions to decriminalization
- 12:45basically say that you can't use it as several places, but including schools,
- 12:50daycares, playgrounds, splash pads. That's already entrenched in the law. The
- 12:54BCNDP basically wanted to expand that to cover more public spaces, and that's where
- 12:58the Supreme Court stepped in and said, no, that's too wide of a
- 13:03breath. Basically, yeah, and like I want to say that like part
- 13:07of the issue with a lot that like a lot of people kind of ignore,
- 13:09Like a lot of people talk about it as a public substance use issue,
- 13:15and like, yes, that's the name of the bill, and that
- 13:16is like a section of the bill, but there's a whole lot also dedicated
- 13:22to world's like expanding police power to you know, basically continually displace on house
- 13:30people or on house drug users, I should say, And like all they
- 13:33really needs to tell somebody to move along is reasonable grounds to believe that a
- 13:39person has recently used drugs in this space. And like, I'm there's like
- 13:46a legal test for reasonable grounds to believe. I'm not a lawyer. I
- 13:50don't know what it is. I looked it up on Google. I found
- 13:52like a twenty four page report explaining it. Yeah, so I don't think
- 13:56that that's really being tested on the ground, but's probably going to be happening
- 14:00on the ground. Is basically just police discretion. And what happens when you
- 14:05have police discretion is usually it disproportionately impacts certain people, and you kind of
- 14:09talked about this recently on your show with Harrison Mooney. It disproportionally impacts black
- 14:15people, Indigenous people, and people of color. This whole thing sounds like
- 14:18Bill thirty four was effectively, you know, in practice killing decriminalization, like
- 14:24really taking a lot of the legs out of it in terms of what it
- 14:28was trying to accomplish. I guess one question I have is that there are
- 14:31going to be a lot of non drug users who say, you know what,
- 14:35I just want to walk down the sidewalk, or I want to go
- 14:37to a park. Sure it's on a playground, but I want to go
- 14:39to a park, and I don't want to see people smoking meth or doing
- 14:43a rail of coke. What do you say to those folks? Because I
- 14:48can understand their concerns as well, and there is an idea of you know,
- 14:52social order, right, So what was the what would the response be
- 14:56to them? You know, I do want to be like careful in sort
- 15:00of like there's sort of an ongoing campaign for like the last century basically of
- 15:05like demonizing unhoused people and drug users, right, And like, you know,
- 15:11you're far more likely to be assaulted by somebody that you know, then
- 15:16by like a stranger in general. Right, And so I do want to
- 15:18be careful to like not validate sort of like the fear of the other in
- 15:22this case. So what I think is kind of like a way to that
- 15:26I would sort of talk about it is why do people feel forced to use
- 15:31outside? And I think that's sort of like a myth that sort of gets
- 15:37like perpetuated about things like harm reduction. Is that like people who are in
- 15:39favor of harm reduction just want people to be able to use drugs wherever,
- 15:43whenever, however, and that's it, that's all. But like the point
- 15:46is keeping people alive and then also bringing in solutions like safe supply, giving
- 15:52them housing, having enough overdose prevention sites, things like that, right,
- 15:56like giving them ways that they can not use, so advocate for more services.
- 16:02You know, if the visuals or that disorder troubles you. I guess
- 16:07that makes sense. Yeah, we spend a whole lot of resources basically just
- 16:11kind of like like pushing people down when we could spend probably fewer resources just
- 16:19kind of like helping people up and like allowing them to sort of like live
- 16:23on their own sort of like with live with dignity and sort of be able
- 16:29to support themselves right with housing, with income, supports with a safe supply
- 16:33of drugs. And you know, it's like really frustrating to kind of see
- 16:40this, this demonization expanding not just like into sort of like all quarters of
- 16:45the sort of political spectrum, and it seems like there's like kind of fewer
- 16:49and fewer places where you're actually seeing people sort of actually like defend the need
- 16:56for giving people service absolutely, Dustin, I appreciate your time tonight. Thank
- 17:00you so much. Thank you folks. They are freelance journalists, Dustin Godfrey,
- 17:04always producing great work. Find them on X and substack. And thank
- 17:08you to Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations, especially the uncomfortable
- 17:14ones that need unpacking. Now after a little business, Are you allowed to
- 17:18record people in public? Seems creepy, right, but is there a law
- 17:22against it? Kyler Lee will let us know up next welcome back to this
- 17:33is Van color. Are you allowed to film people in public? What if
- 17:37they ask you to stop? Creepy? For sure? But is it illegal?
- 17:41Here to explain is my counterpart on the Soapbox Social Panel, which you
- 17:45can find on CBC Radios on the Coast with Gloria Macarenko every Thursday at four
- 17:49ten pm representing Acumen Laws. He is Kyla Lee and this is Kyla's Court,
- 18:00and so Kyla. Let's say I come across Rick Dollywall and Don Taylor
- 18:11in a public park and they're on a bench and they have a bowl of
- 18:15butter chicken and instead of eating it with non they're just eating it with a
- 18:18spoon, and I think it's funny. So I start recording them and they
- 18:22ask me to stop. Am I within my legal rights to record Rick Dollywall
- 18:26and Don Taylor in that scenario. That's an extremely specific example, but yes,
- 18:32if you're in a public place, you can record anybody that is also
- 18:36in a public place without their consent because in Canada, legally speaking, we
- 18:41have one party consent. Where the area gets a little bit gray is what
- 18:45you do with that recording afterwards? What if I post that clip online?
- 18:48Probably because these are sort of public profile people, you wouldn't run into at
- 18:53any concerns under the Privacy Act. But it is in British Columbia law a
- 18:57tort that doesn't require any damages to post any private information or to share any
- 19:03private information about another person without their consent. So if they said, hey,
- 19:07we don't want you to film us, that's essentially explicitly telling you that
- 19:11they're not consenting and you shouldn't post that information online. Oh interesting, So
- 19:15I can record it, but I can't post that because they told me not,
- 19:18because they told you not to, and they revoke their consent. Now,
- 19:22obviously it gets a little bit more complicated when you deal with people who
- 19:25are public figures, right, because there's this public interest component associated to it,
- 19:30and you have sort of a diminished expectation of privacy. Although I don't
- 19:33know that your buttered chicken eating habits fall within the scope of the alleged butter
- 19:38chicking butter chicken eating habits. So one question I have is, let's say
- 19:42you are in a public space, you're in a park or something, but
- 19:45you start recording someone's residence, whether it's a condo building or a house.
- 19:51I mean, that seems really creepy and probably illegal to me. Where does
- 19:53the law stand there where you're in public but you're recording someone's private residence.
- 19:57Again, criminally speaking, that's not a criminal offense because if it's visible from
- 20:03a public place, you don't have a reasonable expectation of privacy if you know
- 20:06the public can see you, right, And that's why we can criminalize people
- 20:08who stand naked overlooking a park in their windows because they're exposing themselves unlawfully to
- 20:15the public. But again, if you start to post that information online,
- 20:19you run into concerns under civil law that you're violating the Privacy Act, and
- 20:23you can be sued and you can be made to pay, even if it
- 20:26doesn't cost anybody anything. It sounds like that would be stalking though, if
- 20:29you're like really recording someone's home from a public place, though, well,
- 20:33it depends on why you're recording it. Maybe you're just walking by you see
- 20:37something interesting in the window that catches your attention, versus you're standing outside your
- 20:41ex's house to try and catch them doing something and recording them for that reason.
- 20:45Interesting. In Vancouver specifically, we've had these issues with YouTube documentarians going
- 20:52out and recording vulnerable people, sometimes in vulnerable circumstances. I think you and
- 20:56I can both agree that that's really gross. Is there anything to protect vulnerable
- 21:02people who are maybe experiencing some sort of mental health episode or even a physical
- 21:04health episode. Definitely, there are the provisions of the Privacy Act again that
- 21:08say that you can't do this, but especially if you're sort of profiteering off
- 21:11it, if you're an organization, So if it's a company that's recording this
- 21:15for footage for some sort of video or something like that, there are additional
- 21:19privacy obligations that you have when you collect personal information from people that you can't
- 21:25just disclose it. And if you're trying to make money off it, then
- 21:27that is prohibited under BC's Privacy Act to use somebody's likeness or use somebody's image
- 21:33for the purposes of your personal financial gain. What if you just blur out
- 21:37their face, then you get into again more of a gray area. But
- 21:40if the person is still identifiable, maybe they have really identifiable tattoos or scars,
- 21:45or something about them, a distinguishing pair of shoes that they always wear,
- 21:48then that could still violate their privacy because you can identify who that person
- 21:52is and learn information about them that they may not have wanted. Broadcasts of
- 21:55the entire world fascinating, Kyla, always interesting. Thank you so much for
- 21:59your time tonight. Thanks for having me. Absolutely, folks, that's our
- 22:02show. Thank you so much to Kyla Lee, Dustin Godfrey, and Karen
- 22:06Mursky for tonight's show. We will be back next week. In the meantime,
- 22:08find me on x or TikTok At Van Color. Of course, this
- 22:12is Van color, and I'm moamir telling you that in a province where you
- 22:15can be anything, be colorful. Peace,