Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Live with Global Automakers of Canada on Tariffs, SC Proposes DTC Bill
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning, everybody. Tuesday, February 3rd. We're so happy because Kyle's at Disney having a good time, and Michael and I get to hang out and try not to burn the company to the ground.
- 0:10Today [laughs] we're talking about tariffs, and we're also talking about legal [laughs] decisions being made. The third story is always a thing. We wanna talk about the third story before we talk about the third story.
- 0:24But South Carolina kind of proposed a bill to let some people build and sell cars in their state. We won't talk about who it is until later. But Michael, we have one of your countrymen on the show today.
- 0:36Is that how you say it? Is it, is it me? [laughs] Am I- [laughs] No, you- Am I one of my countrymen on the show? [laughs] No, no. Well, I guess. You're one of his countrymen.
- 0:44We have Global Automakers of Canada- Ah, yes... President and CEO David C. Adams on with us in just a moment. It's fun, you and I got to, to speak with him actually yesterday.
- 0:54Uh, in the midst of all the conversations hap- happening about tariffs, I felt like for a moment we were right in the center of the news.
- 1:01Yeah, and I mean, who, who better to talk to than someone who leads an organization, an association that works directly with, you know, four or five major automakers who are building vehicles right inside the country?
- 1:15So I, I'm pretty excited to hear what he has to say. Yeah. Before we get into the stories, just wanna remind you that asotcon.com is live. You can get your tickets to ASOTU CON.
- 1:26Um, I'm so excited that we already have a bunch of tickets sold for this event, and I've heard that we have some delegations from some other countries aside from Canada showing up- Wow...
- 1:36from across the pond as they say. So it's actually turning into a bit of an international event, which is not what we would- I do say... have expect- I do say. [laughs] That was really good. It was really good.
- 1:46So, uh, make sure you get your tickets as early as possible. One of the reasons is they are as cheap as they will ever be right now. So asotcon.com, head out there, grab your tickets now.
- 1:56We're gonna be introducing a ton of speakers, a ton of sessions. All the fun, all the fanfare, and obviously all the insights. Um, so you, you don't wanna miss it.
- 2:05How many products, we, Kyle and I were talking about how many products, like, that are now full-fledged tech products, the idea for the product started on a stage at ASOTU CON last year.
- 2:15When's the last time you could, anybody in our industry could say something like that? Like, that's a pretty bold statement. Yeah.
- 2:21Well, actually, we should make a list one time and just get the people to say, "Oh, so a dealer said this on a panel," and we got together afterwards, and here's the product. Just one time, though.
- 2:28I never wanna revisit that list ever again. [laughs] Yeah. [laughs] Absolutely. All right, let's get to some news.
- 2:35So, uh, President Donald Trump announced a temporary suspension of planned US tariffs on Mexico yesterday after reaching an agreement with Mexican President-elect Claudia Sheinbaum.
- 2:45The deal includes Mexico deploying 10,000 National Guard troops to the northern border, or its northern border, our southern border, uh, with a primary focus on stopping fentanyl trafficking and furthering negotiations, uh, on security and trade.
- 2:59So Trump was going to put this 25% tariff in place. It was supposed to go in, in, in effect midnight last, or starting February 4th, like midnight tonight, tomorrow, tonight? Midnight to- [laughs] Yeah, midnight.
- 3:11Like six hours ago. Eh. [laughs] But agreed to pause them in exchange for Mexico's commitment for increased border security.
- 3:18US officials from the State Treasury and Commerce Departments are gonna lead further discussions, with Trump saying he will participate- First, can I just say, tell me you're an entrepreneur without telling me you're an entrepreneur.
- 3:29You're like, "On the fourth, the third, the second, the what?" What day is it today? [laughs] And they go, "I've been married 20 years?" [laughs] "When did that happen?" [laughs] Who would've g- how'd I get here?
- 3:43Now- Who is this?... speaking of, speaking of f- picking fights with Canadians, like, you know we love hockey, right? Like, that, that's what keeps coming to my mind.
- 3:51It's the only sport- I'm like, we're not afraid of a body check... where fighting is actually part of your statistics. Yeah, it i- I mean, see? [laughs] And, and widely adopted by all organizations.
- 4:00We all want hockey stick growth. Yeah. [laughs] Can, can I, can I make a, can I just jump in and make a little, a minor observation that- Yeah, yes... uh, after- Yeah, please...
- 4:09after President Trump's second call with Trudeau yesterday that happened, uh, just around 4:00 PM, he, he left that call to go meet with the Florida Panthers, a hockey team- [laughs]... who won the Stanley Cup. No way.
- 4:23Yes. Yeah. No. Okay. Is this a conspiracy theory brewing- I, I don't-... on the morning show? I'm not sure. Guys, you know, all roads are leading to me being
- 4:33that dude in his 60s who wears oversized Wrangler khakis, a fleece shirt, and fleece vest, and who operates ham radios.
- 4:42Like, I'm just gonna go up- [laughs] He's already, he's already digging a hole so he can bury the school bus with an oxygen filtration system in it. Yeah. I'm- Like all his neighbors in Texas...
- 4:50the International Space Station on my ham radio- [laughs]... 'cause I, [laughs] just to get away from it all. Speaking of tariffs- Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Well, that didn't take long.
- 5:02Uh, on the northern border, US tariffs on Canada are going to be postponed by 30 days as the two countries are nego- have negotiated a border deal.
- 5:10Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of Canada said after finishing a second call with President Trump. So, um, yesterday we were definitely, uh, throughout the day saying, "Is it gonna happen with Canada?"
- 5:22They're getting on the phone, they're meeting. In the meantime, we were able to sit down and talk with the president and CEO of Global Automakers of Canada, David C.
- 5:31Adams, about, uh, the industry and what the northern perspective is on all of this, uh, this situation is to begin with. He had a great statement yesterday.
- 5:39He said, quote, "The United States and Canada aren't just each other's largest trading partners, but we actually build things together, not for each other."
- 5:48He said, "There's no other industry where this is the case more than the automotive industry, where we have had sectoral free trade between the two countries since 1965." Wow. I like the sound of this guy already. Yeah.
- 6:00We, we gotta dig into this conversation with him so you can hear what he has to sayAll right, we are here with President and CEO of the Global Automakers of Canada, David Adams. Thank you so much for joining us today.
- 6:13Thanks for having me, Paul and Michael. Appreciate it. Um, okay, so there's obviously a whole lot going on. As of time of recording this interview, it is, uh, in the afternoon on Monday.
- 6:25So we know right now there's a, a big high-stakes meeting going on between President Trump and Mr. Trudeau, and they are- they're figuring it out. They're talking about things.
- 6:33Maybe we'll have some news by, uh, the time this releases the next morning, but maybe not.
- 6:38Without a doubt, a lot of, um, a lot of talk, a lot of fear, um, a lot of resolve going, uh, both ways as these tariffs has been, have been, um, placed, threatened, placed. I don't even know where they are.
- 6:50They're just kind of going into, uh, effect potentially. We hear everything from the American side.
- 6:58Uh, obviously our partners on the Canadian side affect both parties, and we thought it'd be great to get some perspective from the Canadians, um, and from you and yourself. How are automakers looking at this?
- 7:09What is the, the feeling and the sentiment around dealers, and how are you preparing to potentially deal with tariffs so that we can keep serving customers?
- 7:19Well, there's a lot to unpack there, but let's start by saying- Sure is. [laughs] Look, [laughs]
- 7:24you know, where, where we are right now, as the President has indicated, um, you know, a- again, that, that could change as a result of the conversation that the Prime Minister and the President are having as we talk, basically.
- 7:34But, um, as it stands right now, the President, uh, plans on enforcing tariffs on essentially all products from Canada as of, uh, what, um, this evening, I guess, coming into effect at 12:01.
- 7:47Um, and, uh, Canada, uh, late Saturday evening, the Prime Minister announced, uh, a package of 155 billion, uh, in retaliatory tariffs, if you will, with, uh, first tranche potentially going into effect on February 4th as well.
- 8:04That would be, uh, $30 billion, and then, uh, the government will be undertaking a consultation on what other products that could potentially form the res- rest of that, uh, 130- 125 mil- billion that would be applied to, um, uh, US imports.
- 8:19So, um, rapidly heading into a tariff war, unless this can be averted and it's, uh...
- 8:26I mean, I, I, I know it was just perhaps one piece of news in the US, but, uh, if you were watching Canadian TV, um, you know, uh, CBC, CTV, uh, streaming, like, all day Saturday on what, what, what about the tariffs and what this means for Canadians.
- 8:41So it's, um, you know, it's a, a salient issue in the, um, in the hearts and minds of, I think, all Canadians at this point in time. Can you- Something... I, I, I was gonna say, something that I think is so unique about,
- 8:54uh, Canada-US relations in particular is that here you have two countries that could essentially, by all stretch of the imagination, self-suffice without any trade between the two, right?
- 9:06Canada makes its own automobiles. It has fresh water and minerals and lumber and oil and, and, and.
- 9:14And then you have America just south, uh, a- across the border, which has lumber and minerals and oil and could potentially make its own vehicles. So w- what do you think they're really trying to get at?
- 9:26It- what, what's your opinion on what they're really trying to figure out here? Is it the, quote-unquote, "unfairness," as they've said, or do you think there's an underlying issue that they're really trying to expose?
- 9:41Yeah, I, I guess what I would start with is your, um, your premise there, Michael, and, um, you know, I think the reality is, is that, um, we're inter- we're, we're interdependent. We need each other.
- 9:53And, uh, you know, perhaps maybe Canada [laughs] needs the US more than the US needs Canada.
- 9:58But the rea- reality is, is that for things such as, uh, electricity, oil, y- I think you guys get something like about 60% of your oil imports come from, from Canada.
- 10:08So, um, uh, critical minerals, and you can say, "Well, those are necessary for the EV industry."
- 10:15Well, okay, maybe, uh, the President doesn't care that much about EVs, but he does care about national security and being able to build, uh, uh, planes and, uh, defense equipment and, uh, steel and aluminum.
- 10:27Uh, you know, aluminum is a major export into the United States. But, you know, by the same token, um, we're... I think there's about 34 US states where Canada is the largest market for those states.
- 10:39Um, you know, if you look at Ontario alone, where I'm based, um, you know, we're...
- 10:44If we were our own economy, we would be about the, uh, I think it's about the third or fourth largest economy that trades with the United States.
- 10:54So, look, we've had a long history of, um, of having an integrated economy, uh, building things together, and no- and that's no more is that truer than in the automotive industry, as opposed to building things for each other.
- 11:10Um, so automotive industry, you wind the clock back to 1965 when the Auto Pact was first signed, which was the first stage towards, um, you know, free trade, uh, sectoral free trade in the automotive industry.
- 11:25So we've had, a- again, like we're talking 60 years of, uh, of experience of, of building that, that, those industries together, building vehicles together, having parts in, in Canada go into components in the United States, coming back to finished vehicles in Canada, and vice versa.
- 11:43So I guess my, my message there would be is that you're not hurting one side of the border without hurting the other side of the border with tariffs.
- 11:52And I think that that, that will come home to roost, and we've already seen some, uh, some statements coming out of some of the, um, auto trade associations in the US saying that these, uh, these tariffs are highly ill-advised.I think I, I like your sentiment there, and I do think that the people who are kind of caught in between all of this, right?
- 12:12If there are deeper issues that people are trying to, like, move across and, like, get, get the point across, the, the reality is the industries in both countries, respectively the auto industry, does genuinely believe we're better together.
- 12:27And so... And, and that's, I think, one of the most beautiful things about business in general.
- 12:32Um, business finds a way to cooperate, finds a way to make things work, finds middle ground, because that's kind of the premise of, of doing global business or doing international business. Um, can you- Sure...
- 12:43give us a, a slight o- a little overview of what your position actually entails? Because I'm sure our audience is not familiar.
- 12:49And if you could just give me, give us a, you know, a summary of what your purview is, um, as the president and CEO. Yeah.
- 12:56Well, I think just, um, to highlight for your, your viewers, listeners, um, our, uh, industry association, we have 15, well, 16 member companies.
- 13:06Two of those member companies produce vehicles in Canada, Honda and Toyota. There are five companies that actually produce vehicles in Canada: Honda, Toyota, uh, Ford, General Motors, and Stellantis.
- 13:17So we have some of the producers and, uh, there's another trade association that has the, uh, remainder of the producers.
- 13:24But I think from our perspective as an association, we've always taken the position that, um, you know, tariffs are anathema to growing, uh, an economy.
- 13:35Um, they, uh, they're essentially a tax on, on business that ends up getting passed on to consumers. Uh, they end up impeding economic growth, and I think these are all the things that we will,
- 13:47uh, start to see, um, you know, as these, uh, these tariffs play out, unless we can get, um, uh, some speedy resolution to this, which is what we're all hoping for.
- 13:58Uh, I think the president had a discussion with, um, the president of Mexico earlier today, and, uh, I understand from that discussion Mexico essentially got a, a stay of execution with respect to the tariffs for- One...
- 14:12another month because they agreed to, uh, um, you know, I think they've committed 10,000 troops to the- Yes... to the border, uh- Yep... have t- uh, made some commitments on fentanyl and, uh, who knows what else.
- 14:24And I think the problem for everybody is that it's very unclear to Canadians, to Mexicans, and to perhaps the Eu- European Union, who he's, uh, supposedly coming after next, uh, kind of what, what do you want?
- 14:37You know, what, what will satisfy you?
- 14:39And it's been, uh, uh, it's been fentanyl and, and the il- illegal migrants coming over the border for Canada and Mexico, but I would argue from a Canadian perspective, look, it's, uh, it's, um, uh, magnitudes of difference between Canada and Mexico.
- 14:56If you look at fentanyl, for instance, I think US stats show that it was about, you know, 38 pounds that came in from Canada and, uh, 11,000 pounds or more that came in from- Wow... from Mexico.
- 15:08So we're, we're.01%- That's a good point... of the, of the fentanyl problem. Does that mean that we, we shouldn't do anything? Well, no. Absolutely.
- 15:15I think we've, we've always, our governments have always worked collaboratively together to, uh- Mm-hmm...
- 15:20to safeguard the border and to also streamline the border because both of our economies, uh, depend on one another for, for the trade that we talked about earlier on. Mm-hmm. I've always been curious about this piece.
- 15:34So they, they announce a tariff. Is it as quick as, like, you see it on the next invoice? Great question. Like, how quick does it actually show up? How, how, how quickly
- 15:46do we assume that that price or that tax, as you've suggested, that gets passed on to consumer is recognized? Yeah, it's, it's a good question, and I'm not sure that I've got a complete answer for you.
- 15:59But, you know, what, what I do know is that, um, you know, look, um, some companies will, will say, "Well, I don't wanna be in a position where I'm passing all of that, uh, on to my consumer, so, you know, I'll eat a portion of it for a bit."
- 16:13They might not be able to do that forever. Um, but reality is it, it will at, at some point get passed along to the consumer.
- 16:20In terms of when it actually impacts, um, goods crossing the border, for instance, uh, my understanding of the situation is that, okay, the executive order has been given.
- 16:31There would have to be some, uh, I think, guidance documents, if nothing else, put together for border officials and that kind of thing.
- 16:39Um, so, uh, a- and can that all be done between, you know, uh, Saturday when the tariffs were announced [laughs] and, uh- I mean, we have- The port... ChatGPT now, so. [laughs] Right?
- 16:51David, David, uh, our time is just about up, but I have one probably the most- Yeah... important question. Um, do Canadians watch the Super Bowl, and if so, who are they rooting for this year?
- 17:01[laughs] Well, they, they do, they do watch the Super Bowl, but, uh, the, uh, uh, tied to our discussion is, uh, everybody's talking about how much more the avocados and the beer is gonna cost because of the, the tariffs.
- 17:14So- [laughs]...
- 17:17you know, I think it'll be a good game and, uh, you know, I, I, I think it would probably depend on the Canadian, uh, uh, you know, who, uh, who they think might, uh, might win the Super Bowl, but- Re- regardless of the familiar color with one of the teams, I would- [laughs]...
- 17:30I would argue that, uh, the best team is the one that is, you know, not red. [laughs] Well, I'm trying to think now. I'm trying to think now, Dave, who, who, who in our league has the reputation of the Cheatin' Chiefs?
- 17:46[laughs] Chiefs. Is it the BC Lions? Is it the Tiger-Cats? Like, who, who do we give that title to? You're asking the wrong guy. I don't follow football that much. I follow hockey, so we... Wanna talk hockey? Ah.
- 17:56Who do we give it to? Is it the Maple Leafs? [laughs] Or is it the Stampeder? Is it the, the, the Calgary Flames? Is it... [laughs] Maybe the Canadians.
- 18:04Look, I'm just surprised you got all those names for the different teams there. Yeah, listen to him go. He's flexing now. When he goes, "Yeah," he's just s- he's just braggingAll I know-...
- 18:14Iowa Senators As, as a son of South Philadelphia, I welcome all of Canada to be Eagles fans next Sunday. Eagles fans. There you go. [laughs] Oh, well, Dave, this has been such a joy.
- 18:23Thank you so much for joining us, certainly on late notice. Uh, Dave Adams, the s- president and CEO of Global Automakers of Canada, thanks so much for joining us today. Thanks, guys. Anytime. Appreciate it.
- 18:35[laughs] I don't know where you got a hat in between this interview or not. Is this, is, is this your Canadian hat or your Texas hat? It is my Calgary Stampede hat. Oh, my. Oh, and is that your Calgary accent as well?
- 18:48No. It's p- no. No, no, no, no, no, no. I can't do it anymore. I know. I was at N- we were at NADA and everyone said, "You sound like you, but Texan," and I was like, "Oh, [laughs] okay." You know, I wonder,
- 19:01now, now I'm wondering that if, if this is kicked down the road for, what was it, a month? 30 days on both sides? Yeah, 30 days.
- 19:11I, I really don't feel like it's going to happen, and I think we'll see what the markets do. You know, like, are the markets gonna respond? The announcement came after the markets were closed yesterday.
- 19:20This is before they're open. So, um, I kind of feel like this is, like, a pre, a pre-gone cor- a foregone conclusion. Is that what they say? Yeah. I, I think... Well, there's a couple of things here.
- 19:30I wanna go back to what you, the, what you quoted from, uh, Mr. Adams earlier about how we build things together.
- 19:38I'm like, here's an individual who before we met with him, he said, "Hey, give me a little bit of a rundown on a SoDo More Than Cars. Like, what do you mean? Where, where did this come from? What does it stand for?"
- 19:47And, and he had no context, yet deeply rooted in his being, in his mode of operation, he knows that the automotive industry of all industries is one that builds together- Right...
- 20:01works together, and I thought that was kind of an, an inspiring, kinda third-party validation- I like that... of what we all believe in our community in the auto industry. It is. The second thing that came to my mind is
- 20:12just look at what happens when you pick up the phone. Yeah. [laughs] You know? Just answer the phone.
- 20:19Look, we can avoid so many things if we don't just always do text and email follow-up, and seven-day follow-up this and that. Like, pick up the phone- Oh, I like that... and talk to the people.
- 20:30You can solve big problems. I like that. Speaking of trying to solve some big problems. Stop. Segway. It's time. [upbeat music] We'll see. We'll see. What, what is the big problem we're trying to solve?
- 20:41Well, South Carolina- Oh... it seems like, is solving big problems. Let's, let's... They like to solve big problems. Let's talk about this.
- 20:47So South Carolina's making waves as a new bipartisan bill aims to allow direct-to-consumer EV sales. Uh-oh. Ugh.
- 20:56If passed, this could be a game changer for Volkswagen-backed Scout Motors, which is set to build a massive [laughs] two b- b- b- billion dollar plant in the state. Couple of, couple of bucks. Couple of bucks.
- 21:08Current franchise laws ban direct-to-consumer vehicle sales. The new bill, the South Carolina Consumer Freedom Act, would- Yep...
- 21:16change that as the bill specifically applies to automakers that have never had a franchise dealership agreement. Uh, so what do we think is the, the thing here? Dealers aren't happy. No.
- 21:27The, the South Carolina Automobile Dealers Association strongly oppoji- opposes the legislation, claiming it unfairly benefits Scout Motors.
- 21:35And prefi- previous efforts to allow direct EV sales in South Carolina have failed, with a similar bill in 2019 not advancing past committee.
- 21:45If passed, the new bill could set a precedent for other states with similar restrictions.
- 21:50Uh, while Governor Henry McMaster has not taken a position, he told local media that he supports, quote, "Anything that is good for the consumer," close quote.
- 22:00And of course, a Scout spokesperson said in a statement to Automotive News, quote, "Right now, outdated blanket government restrictions render direct sale impossible.
- 22:11Ironically, and sadly, the people who build Scout vehicles won't be able to buy them under current regulations," close quote. Whoa. All right, so it's getting 40...
- 22:19Nathan, can you look up to see if Tesla's allowed to sell direct-to-consumer in South Carolina? He's gonna look that up. Sure. I can, I will get on that right now. I mean, what, what do you think?
- 22:30I mean, this is- Two b- $2 billion and, and it seems like another one of these things where the government's kinda skirting around, uh, dealerships, and of course, the dealers are not happy about this.
- 22:41You know, there, this is just adding fuel to the fire in the debate whether or not Scout is a, like, full derivative of Volkswagen, which it is. Right. Um, there is shared leadership.
- 22:54The funding for the new company came from VW. And so dealers, I think, have rightfully have a bone to pick, saying, like, "We would, been asking you for trucks for years.
- 23:03You went ahead and you took our good leadership and the dollars you made from our stores, you used it to fund this other company, and now you're going to sell these products that we've been telling you our consumers want- Yeah...
- 23:16outside of our ability to do so. Not only that, but it's gonna compete with us." South Carolina's in, in a tricky spot though, right? 'Cause you have a company that invests, uh, $2 billion in your state. Mm.
- 23:26And that's a viable reason for you to want that company to be able to sell their products in your state. So, you know, I think it, it's not an easily solvable problem.
- 23:37I mean, from a dealer standpoint, like, what we think is that Scout should be able to be sold through the franchise network and some select VW dealers should have the opportunity to run Scout, uh, sell Scout products.
- 23:50I still don't know how they're gonna service these products. Yeah. And, and so I, I... You know, it'll be, we'll have to see. I mean, the bill hasn't passed, but it has been presented.
- 23:59Nathan, did you find out whether or not- I did... you can sell Teslas? So, so you, there are several states still with bans on direct sales models, um, including South Carolina.
- 24:09The other ones are Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Iowa, Kansas, uh, Kentucky, Louisiana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, West Virginia, and Wisconsin.
- 24:18Wait, it's not banned in New York?Uh, it is, it is n- it is not- [laughs] Uh, with, it, it, New York has store limits.
- 24:28Oh, that's interesting, because in New York, what Tesla did in the central New York region near Syracuse, where, where Nathan and I live, is that they just did the same play that tobacco companies did.
- 24:38They just put, sold their products from, uh, Native American, like, reservations. So it's not US soil technically. Mm.
- 24:46It's Native American soil, so there's a big Tesla store and a big Tesla hub on a reservation here in upstate New York. You know, who doesn't love a good loophole? [laughs] Yeah.
- 25:00I mean, that, that is just the, the, the industry that we're in right now. But without a doubt, we'll, we'll see if this one passes, but dealers absolutely have a legitimate complaint. Oh, yeah. And, you know- Right...
- 25:11and I, I understand South Carolina, like, trying to not get in the middle. There's gonna be no way to really win this one.
- 25:17I think the only way to get a win-win is for Volkswagen to realize the value of the dealer franchise network and start to spread out distribution.
- 25:23They might be in for a little bit of a rude awakening, because it takes a lot of money and time to build gra- brand credibility from the ground up. And- Yeah... and they're just starting from scratch.
- 25:35Like, no one really remembers what a Scout is. [laughs] I didn't know until they released the EV version, and I'm 45.
- 25:42I mean, y- you know, at the end of the day, you say Scout to me and I'll, I just go, I, I think of wearing a beret and a waggle and saying, "We will dib, dib, dib and dab, dab, dab," and, uh, I got no interest in that anymore.
- 25:54That sounds like a Canadian thing I don't understand. [laughs] On that note, I think- Well, we're about to find out all the Canadians that watch the morning show, that's for sure. That's true.
- 26:02I think we've done enough damage for today. Look, whatever's happening out there, tariffs, laws, whatever, you can count on one thing, is when you serve the people, things tend to go a little better for you.
- 26:11We'll see you tomorrow. [upbeat music]