Latest / Braver New Worlds / Power, Trust, and Building a More Just Economy with Shantel Suárez Ávila
Transcript
- Nathan: Hello and welcome back to another episode of Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell the future we want to see. My is Nathan Young. I am your host. In today's is with Shantel Suárez Ávila She is fundraiser being able to do this podcast and have these conversations with my guests. But there's another part of all of this that I'm excited about too. And I wanna share that with you now. Alongside these podcast conversations, I'm also building out a set of live gatherings a way of bringing people together in person have conversations similar to the one that we're having with each other here. founder of the fundraising consultancy Mas Alla, is Spanish for Beyond or Further. The event series I'm putting together, it's called Big Idea Night. I'm bringing together smart and thoughtful people own community to share what they know and what they is at different venues all around my hometown of San Diego. at these events. They'll be giving a presentation and sharing stories about the big ideas that they have to share, She's also a leader in rethinking how communities fund and maintain the work that they care about. returning to the audience and inviting people in attendance to have a conversation amongst themselves about the big idea as it's being presented too. And so a lot of this conversation, we are talking about something that's just sitting underneath so much the change we want to see in our world. that is good old fashioned money. Talk how it moves, who controls it and what it actually take to shift it in a way That's rooted in trust and care and community. about creating opportunities for people to meet each other, engage with the ideas that we think are important, and think collectively about how we can live and lead into a changing world. Over time, I envision this growing into a community for thoughtful people to come together and share the stories and ideas that could potentially make our world a better place. so if you're in San Diego and this sounds interesting to you, check it out. It's called Big Idea Night. You can go to bigideanight.com or find us on social media. And I'll include a link in the show notes here too. And you're not in San Diego, but you're interested or interested in bringing this to your city, let's talk. Maybe there's a way that that could be done. We also talk about this relatively new concept in the nonprofit world called community-centric fundraising. it's essentially a framework for how nonprofits can approach fundraising differently ⁓ more of a focus on justice and equity at the center of it. if you're in the nonprofit world, there's a discussion, a of times nonprofits really came from like a charity background and it was all about charity and that discussion is changing a lot these days to be more about justice. so community-centric fundraising is this idea, this framework for fundraising that's sort of at the center of all that. If you want to know more, I'll put a link to more about it in the show notes. So we talk about that a little bit in the podcast as well. Right. Thanks for listening to my little spiel and now back to the show. But there's also something that's really interesting that's going on in this conversation that we have that like revealed something interesting about both of us. didn't notice it at the time, but I really noticed it when I went through and I edited this episode. We haven't known each other for that long of a time and sometimes when you're talking to somebody in a podcast you kind of miss and things you're talking about we have a lot of mutual respect for each other. but it's interesting that these spots where we were sort missing each other too. And it's very subtle. Like, I don't know that anybody really would notice it other than me as I'm editing it. And I'm thinking about like, okay, what was going on there? And I realized that like, we sort of come from fundamentally different frames in the way that we're approaching the work that we do and the way that we approach partnership and collaboration. And you see us sort of like discovering this about each other through the course of the conversation. very much a collaborator and a community builder and it sounds like she ⁓ really working collaboration with the people and organizations that she partners with. whereas my way of working is a little bit more of side by distinct partnership and with some willing to like exercise some persuasion as well. I think those are like sort of our two respective default And as we're having this conversation, we're sort of realizing how the person maybe approaches ⁓ thinking about partnership and collaboration differently. And you're kind of seeing that's coming in our conversation. think towards the we sort of get this point where like realizing that we both maybe have something to learn from each other, ⁓ but also like. the ways that our different mutual ways of operating have. have different benefits, like we need both. And so I thought that was really interesting as I going through the episode editing it yesterday to kind of see that come out. perhaps you'll it too. Let us know if you do. Maybe I'm just like, I just made this up myself, but I'd be if anybody else sees it. I think it's a really great conversation that Shantel and I had. And if you're interested more that community-centric fundraising concept, I'll have a link about that in the show notes. And so without further ado, here's episode. ⁓ Thank you so much for Shantel for being on here and enjoying this conversation. really appreciate that we've been able to have ⁓ frank and honest conversations about money fundraising here on this podcast. We had this episode, had Loretta Turner. couple episodes ago, not that long ago. So if curious, go look that up. And I think this is really important because money is like unavoidable. Everything that we want to do, everything that we want to create is going to come down to money at some point where the money goes and who has control of the money and ⁓ gets to say who says where the money goes is to be a part of the dynamic that we've got to deal with for a lot of what we want to create in this world. And so I know that so many of us that wanna do good can almost have this tension around money and the stories that we tell ourselves about money. But I think there's a lot of important conversations that really need to be had here. And so hopefully we can have more. I'm looking forward to it. curious to hear your thoughts too. What's your relationship with money like? How could you see money moving differently? I'm also curious if anybody noticed that thing that I mentioned at the beginning about Shantel and I sort of speaking different languages around collaboration and partnership and pitching and persuasion and the way that we talked about things and sort of to a ground on that through the course of the conversation. And what did you think of the place that we seemed to end up? also, the obligatory things you send, say at end of a podcast, if you haven't already, like ⁓ and so you can help the algorithm know who else to send this podcast to. If you're not watching it on YouTube, like that's actually like, a lot of people are watching it over on YouTube. hey, I'm all for it. I don't usually watch podcasts on YouTube. I listen, but if you wanna watch, you can, we're there. And I really appreciate the people that are on YouTube watching it, because it seems like a lot of new people too, so that's great. And if you got something out of this episode, Share it with someone who you think might benefit from it too. I also do lot of short clips of each episode. Those are on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn. So go find those and share those as well. And you can find information and ways to connect with Shantel in the show notes and check out her consultancy, Mas Alla. Shantel, welcome the podcast. Shantel: Hey Nathan, thanks so much. Nathan: I always like to just start off by having you introduce yourself real quick to the audience so they'll know a little bit about you from your own words. And if you're interested in the event series I mentioned in the commercial, you can find a link to that in the show notes too. that, thanks much for being here. Really appreciate all you that are listening. We're on episode number nine. ⁓ I'll make big deal about number 10 when that happens next week. ⁓ But number right for us, did it, nine. And yeah, ⁓ see in the one. ⁓ Shantel: Yeah, well thanks so much for having me again. Hi everyone, I'm Chantal Suarez Avila and I am... daughter of Mexican immigrants, originally grew up in the Chicagoland area, moved out to San Diego, California with my now husband and two dogs five years ago. beyond the personal, the founder and principal resource strategist at Mas Alla along with other groups that I organize with and have fun with out here in San Diego that I'm sure I'll tell you more about it this conversation. Nathan: Yeah, cool. And how we met was I heard you talk about community-centric fundraising. I was so fascinated by the concept that and a couple other people were talking about and I was so intrigued by the idea because it's definitely something that's aligned with things I've thought were important, but I had questions about it too, about like, okay, how does it actually work? there's cause there's definitely like an ⁓ idealistic of it, but then there's a sort of a brass tacks of like, how will it work? so it's been really interesting to just sort of follow your journey and get more involved to learn more about it too. And ⁓ I'm guessing that's of what we'll be talking about here today, right? ⁓ Shantel: Yes, community centric fundraising is a framework. created by fundraisers of color out Seattle. And I think it was back in 2017 or 2019, definitely before the pandemic. there's been grassroots movement prior to community-centric fundraising that have definitely influenced the framework and the principles, but I don't think we've had as a in the nonprofit fundraising sector 10 principles like we have through community-centric fundraising. The first one being our fundraising must be grounded in social racial and economic justice, that's principle number one. when I learned about community-centric fundraising, I just hadn't the groups say the things so clearly. I think we all have feelings of, yeah, how can we move more in justice? ⁓ how do we do that in the fundraising sector, in particular in the nonprofit sector, in relationship to both philanthropy and government? So, ⁓ that has become a global movement now because ⁓ you think about capitalism, how money is moving in the public sector for public good, that is something that the entire world grapples with. But in the United States, since the founding of community-centric fundraising, folks have subscribed and tried to sort of be in conversation about the principles, what they mean, and to your point, Nathan, is like, then how do we practice them? Right? How do you move from like concept to doing it in practice with just like within yourself, on your team, with others, with your stakeholders, right? And that's the journey, right? I think that's the journey we're all on when we think about our values and how we practice them. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. I know a lot of your work is around fundraising. I'm curious, how much is practice infused in your work? Basically, can you kind of tell us a little bit more about what you're doing with community-centric fundraising, both in your own organization, but also ⁓ as a community that you're building in San Diego too? Shantel: Yeah, as I answer that, I just want to lift up how I even got connected to community-centric fundraising. Because think that learning about community-centric and wanting to practice it has really been my journey in how I created my company, Mas Alla. Mas Alla stands for beyond in Spanish. And so this idea of like, yeah, how do we practice fundraising in a way that can led by our values? ⁓ And how we center community along the way? ⁓ And community fundraising was one of the earlier frameworks that I got exposed to when I was trying to figure out how to do that. One, so it gave a framework, it gave me vocabulary, ⁓ and it gave me community. So, when community -centric fundraising was forming, there was a Slack channel there was Slacks for people by interest, by geography. Following their website newsletter was a good way to of, for to learn and be in community and feel like I wasn't alone in ⁓ figuring out how to fundraise differently, right? And Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: ⁓ thing to underline you're trying to a braver new world, ⁓ a braver new space community. ⁓ The feeling of like, Am I alone in this journey? That can be really isolating and discouraging and ⁓ motivating, right, to then be able to do the courageous work. And so I just want to underline there's a lot of good community building opportunities that then help me feel like more confident in experimenting and practice community -centric fundraising than with my partners. And so Mas Alla works with social justice, Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: BIPOC leaders across the US who work at nonprofit organizations that not only working towards justice for their communities, but trying to practice their values in fundraising. ⁓ We that through the development of fundraising strategy ⁓ and execution of those fundraising strategies. Our relationships matter where we build community that you create trust. And I think with that right? An openness to try something new where then you can experiment and practice together. And so ⁓ been able to do that since 2019 when did Mas Alla when I was still living in Chicago is work with partners and I always tell folks I'm not an expert in this, but I'm here to figure it out with you. And yes, ⁓ I am more exposed how to do this work Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Shantel: by working with so many teams across the US. But the sentiment of let's figure it out and let's brave together is, again, common as to how this work happens. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. So with your work with Mas Alla and your clients the work you do is a lot is a more kind of a strategy and consulting around strategy or how much are you actually getting in there and doing fundraising with them or even getting your own hands dirty as far as how you're doing work. Shantel: for all the entrepreneurs founding organizations, it takes time to even figure out like, how do you talk about your work and like in a way that you know, a way that like can resonate and make sense to you and make sense to others. ⁓ Nathan: ⁓ Yeah, I know. Yeah. Shantel: So now, you know, I said I founded Mas Alla back in 2011. Nathan: specialize Shantel: 2011. Nathan: I specialize doing for other people, helping other people do it and I struggle with it for myself so I get it. ⁓ Shantel: Yes, hit up Nathan. But no, it takes time and I think it's just especially when you're experimenting, it does just take time to figure out like, what am I doing and how do I talk about it? I can now confidently say it's 2026 now and I want to give a shout out to my colleague, Dan Miller, Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: helped us put together our first five year strategic plan for Mas Alla because we were finally ready to get our heads together around like this is what we've done, this is what we want to do and this is how we want to do it, right? And so was able to help articulate a lot of these ideas for us. ⁓ to your question, so yes, I would say two buckets. One is getting your hands dirty, putting together fundraising helping groups implement with their... Nathan: you Shantel: like an individual giving campaign, a digital campaign. could be like, hey, Mas Alla, we're trying to raise a million dollars in new revenue. Can you help us figure that out? And that takes time. And so from strategy to execution, we figure out, OK, what revenue streams would make most sense for your team with the strengths that you have, with the capacity that you have, with the organizational sort of strategy Nathan: Mm-hmm. you Shantel: you have to then be able to do that work. So yes, our ⁓ we in there we see it, we want to feel like we are part of ⁓ a organization's team. And so that's part of partnership that we like to create. It takes a lot of trust and courage to be able to raise resources, especially these days with the amount of, Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: just ⁓ we're dealing with politically speaking. But second bucket I would say is... Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Shantel: In the nonprofit sector, there is there is this need to, of course, bring in resources community, there's a need advocate for resources into community, and how those resources are redistributed. But also, there's a need to work on our belief systems about money and how Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Shantel: we do it and how we need to be at. so those belief systems are also a part of our work. And we do that through trainings and workshops and speaking engagements where we introduce frameworks like community -centric fundraising or the water of systems change that is all about. How do we do systematic transformation at numerous levels, starting with your belief system. ⁓ And other that just, ⁓ and I up because it's a good starting place for people to ⁓ have shared language vocabulary as they're working on changing their, or just evolving ⁓ their mentality about things are and how things Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: could be and so that bucket for me is really fun. It takes more time, Mental that ⁓ into organizational systematic ⁓ takes more time but I think an absolute need for it, right? Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. so what I'm hearing from you, yeah, is like, you're kind of the full spectrum and maybe kind of at a point in your business, which I relate to, where you're kind of figuring out like, okay, which is the piece works out best for this actually like working as a business, even though ⁓ need everywhere, but also like finding a good set like steady clients to work around whatever need that you can provide there. But I love how you're talking about... You know, so many things there. You're talking about the mental mindsets that we all have. The mental mindsets that probably people on the fundraising side have, the mental mindsets that people on the donor side or like even the foundation side have, mental mindsets that like we have around, you even people that may or may not be involved in the nonprofit world or ⁓ justice world, but like the mindsets we have about like where we put money and, you know, what is worthy of money and all that. And then on top of that, like the systemic challenges into all of it. So, I love how your job has a sort of bigger perspective around it there too. Shantel: Yeah, today, I have to bring this up because one of the sort of fundraisers that I have followed for years, Kim Klein, ⁓ has grassroots fundraising, has a book on ⁓ grassroots ⁓ and her team just announced that their fundraising consulting firm, they're sort slowly closing down, they're closing up shop, ⁓ they're gonna Like how ⁓ Nathan: Hmm. Shantel: cool is that like you get to return and then transition your work. That's so cool. And you get to talk about it with your community. And brought up something in their today's newsletter where they shared like, hey, y'all, we're closing or retiring, but we want to leave you with some last ⁓ reflections. Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: Yeah, I mean, if we don't think about fundraising holistically, and if we're not critical about the systems that we're a part of, think that's the journey we have. We have to the work, the function matters, but also the systems are failing us, right? The systems are failing us, and we do have to have a more wholesome conversation. And so ⁓ today, she was Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Shantel: finally my ask of course I cannot end this without asking you for something as a fundraiser right that that's that's the stereotypes always making right please start as many conversations as can with this statement ⁓ every billionaire is a policy failure and for me like that that spoke to me because for so long it it ⁓ it speaks to like why I do this work right there's ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: inequality, there's power and resource hoarding and if we can't see those things, it's harder for us to really change the systems that are failing us, right? And I bring that up because the ⁓ that we have in our systems, These arguments or notions of like, isn't enough money. It's a myth. There's tons of money in the United States. We are a very wealthy, affluent country. It's always about what are our values, budget priorities, and redistributing our resources. And that's the big picture, systematic work that we even as fundraisers Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: have to be talking about. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, definitely. now with everything going on the news, we're seeing there wasn't enough money for any sort of goodwill or Medicare extensions, but we're spending that much money like in a week, just throwing bombs. So yeah, ⁓ So okay, here gets to like a fundamental tension I have about fundraising. And I'm to hear your perspective. And this is gonna be like, Shantel: That's right. That's right. Nathan: I want to share sort of my perspective on it. curious to hear your perspective and like as an entry way to just understanding more of your philosophy around fundraising because of what you're getting at is like, yeah, there is this tension where I love the idea of community-centric fundraising because it is very much about people ⁓ Shantel: Yes. Nathan: in their community, investing in their own community, and realize that there needs to be this sort of co-investment in what's going on in our own communities, in our own backyards, and how we're helping each other on whatever level that is, whether that's a neighborhood level or a city level or just your social network level. That's not even getting to like the whole like systemic thing of recognizing like there are these systemic differences that make resources available differently. And that was tension that I was dealing with was there's ideology of community-centric fundraising, but to put it into practice, you're still running up against this thing that like so much of the money the community needs is not in the community. It's somewhere else. ⁓ And that's gonna come to the community. And that person or whoever has that money or is in charge of that money, they're not necessarily incentivized to do that. Or, you know, so a lot of they're incentivized to hold onto the money or they've got just different incentives. And so I guess I'm curious, both like your own thoughts on that, but also like how much shift you are seeing too in some of the people that do hold the purse strings being more open these community-centric fundraising models. Shantel: So For me, When I hear your tension, another tension comes up for me. So one, I think oftentimes... because of the type of society and culture we have in the United States, which primarily has been a very individualistic society, culturally speaking, think we have a harder time even seeing ourselves as part of a collective society. And so I think that's also part of the learning and the tension that sometimes we experience, from like what maybe in this scenario is like, okay, community orgs, nonprofit orgs, communities that they're serving and people with resources and power. And there's already the siloing of power dynamics that is happening, but also because I think society, this society in the US is more ⁓ just the get-go ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: about how to protect our property, protect the land been stolen. We have that history and part of that is we're learning. And I think this is the power and beauty of diversity and immigration is that you have more ideas about how Nathan: you Shantel: to be in community when you have more types of cultures in one place, right? And so I think for me with community-centric fundraising, this is a framework that speaks to especially fundraisers. And I would say to add to that is like, this is a framework that is meant for everyone who cares about equity and justice and ensuring that communities are getting the resources that are rightfully theirs. me, It's like expanding this framework conversation that ⁓ feels they're a stakeholder in what community is. If don't feel they're a part of collective that's another tension that we're trying to go with and so we if you're an individual donor or Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: or just someone who isn't even involved and has a bunch of time. People themselves, I think have to feel like they're a part of the greater whole so that we can also work alongside each other like we are a collective. Does that make sense? And I want to name a group that I follow that I think is doing amazing work. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, of course. Shantel: Called resource generation. So these are younger folks or folks who have more progressive ideas and that their wealth probably was stolen. How their families accumulated wealth was because ⁓ had an unfair tax system. these folks that are already willing to be critical about like, wait, where did my family wealth come from? those are the conversations that we need to have in this country. We don't we don't talk about reparations. We're not even there yet. Right? It's like, we don't want to have the hard conversations, right? It's hard to have these hard conversations. But I really admire this group because it's folks who who have inherited who are trying to be more critical and not coming from a place of guilt or shame. But like yeah, we can be critical about what we have and how things can be and because I have, let's say I've inherited this wealth, can move money differently than maybe what my previous families have done and I can do it differently. And so for me, I think they're a wonderful group to follow I think they're paving the way for a lot of... individual donors who we can do it differently. way that our previous generations have been doing it, can do it better. They like to use frameworks like solidarity economy, essentially frameworks that are about if we don't see ourselves in a collective, if we can't do well for the collective, the collective isn't doing well. Nathan: Mm-hmm. ⁓ Shantel: Maybe just to bridge those two things, I do think it starts from people have to see themselves as a community member that is part of a collective versus on their own in their own place the world you know. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's so interesting. So yeah, if I understand that correctly, basically it is, yeah, people kind of born into wealth that are looking to redistribute it. Shantel: Yeah, redistributed with their values. also I think I would be like truth too, like, because that's not to say that, you know, people who inherited wealth in the past weren't practicing their values. They were. They were maybe practicing a different set of So in the nonprofit sector, we have this how do we move from charity to justice? Because the nonprofit sector philanthropy was created with charitable values, which was sympathy for the poor, right? But there's reasons why are poor people and if we're not having right. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-mm. Yeah. Shantel: We still trying to have those conversations. I think resource ⁓ is, I am trying to practice my values, but it involves like justice and it involves doing more sort of investigative work on how resources got here to begin with. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's so interesting. And so, like on one hand, I love it that it's happening, but on the other hand, it's like frustrating that it's so up to of, you know, still up to a set of individuals that are like willingly doing this on their own, right? ⁓ the other piece I want to investigate, because I'm always thinking about like, okay, what's the sales pitch? What's persuasive edge here? I'm just curious, like what is going on in their minds that makes them think this way as opposed to other way they're thinking where they could be going after more in doing things that inflate their ego or whatever somebody with a lot of wealth, generational wealth, might do with that money. Horde it, create their business, whatever they're gonna do. I'm so curious what's going on that makes them think this way as opposed to any other path they could go. Shantel: Man, I wish I was a wealthy individual redistributed to be able to like, I don't know, but I think that's like an invitation to like, I follow them. And I, I know I want to figure out how do I work with these people? Because for me, beyond like, so let me a step back. How we even define resource, going back to belief system matters. So resource the our way of working at Mas Alla are Nathan: hahahaha Yeah. Shantel: monetary and non-monetary resources. Right? So it could be cash money, it could be time, it could be a talent. All of these things are examples of resources. Well guess what? We all have different types of resources available to us because of XYZ reasons and for folks who have more money, cash money is a resource they have but I imagine for the folks at Resource Generation there's probably like other things that they're holding, Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: that from time to talent to figure out like, yeah, how how do I move this in a way that ⁓ is ⁓ harmful? I imagine, don't know, so invitation maybe to bring someone on from resource generation. ⁓ There's a chapter California ⁓ and I think have a new executive director. I love that they're moving resources ⁓ with a justice mindset and ethos, ⁓ but I see them Nathan: Yeah. Okay. Shantel: as a peer organizer trying to transform the systems that are failing us. From what I learned and what I've been monitoring of their work, they too are like, systems are failing us. So when I previously asked, every billionaire is a policy failure, I think there is already a recognition. I we see eye eye in that, right? Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: I think maybe I'm more of a, more on the advocacy side of things. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: We can call it whatever we want, but we still need to change the systems. And I leave it to very savvy communicators like Nathan, other folks, ⁓ to help At the end I'm just like, systems are broken. We to change the systems. And I'm happy to collaborate with people who have that communication strength to out, how do we talk about it? ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: Can join this conversation and hopefully then change our policies, right? So like, that's why I'm like, yeah, let's collaborate. Because I don't know if that's necessarily my strength, but always love to be able to collaborate with folks with different talents, you know? Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, just from, cause we haven't even known each other that long, but just from what I've seen, yeah, I definitely see your strength as like the collaborator and the community builder and the sort of system thinker. That's what I've seen so far. So ⁓ hear that. And ⁓ takes all types, right? We need all these different people acting in here in different ways. Shantel: I'll see. Nathan: I always send this pre-interview form and you filled out a lot of great ideas on there and you had big ideas, big visions and I love it. we've talked about a lot of these big visions here already in this conversation. And I guess I'd like to hear about kind like what are your ⁓ main theories of change? How do we move towards this new world that we're talking about here? And we've been talking about it in terms of fundraising, but. As we've talked about too, there's so many other things that come into that also. So I guess I'm just curious to hear more about what are some of your theories of change or things that need to shift to get us to a better place? And that's a big question, right? ⁓ Shantel: Yeah, it is a big question. Yeah, it's big question. I think for me, I'm going to tie it to ⁓ how did even get into this work? And then how do I do it now? Because the thing is to create a braver new world all folks, right, have access to housing, food, job security, clean air, healthier planet, ⁓ the ability enjoy leisure, feel joyful and then ensure that we still have a caring democracy that like is representative of the ⁓ people. Yeah, that's We've been, We've been doing it for so long. I'm just kind of like, gosh, Someone brought up in one of my conversations recently, a MLK's book. Where do we go from here? Nathan: Hmm? Mm-hmm. Shantel: Like Chaos or community and I'm like man we've been doing this for so long and and I it has lot to say about our human sort of history and characteristics. But I've been ⁓ ⁓ this, where do we go from here? Chaos or community? ⁓ And what you said, I'm like, dude, community every day, all day, building community is really hard, right? Because there's people are at different in their journey, people have different capacities, right? There's just so much goes into even in a way that feels inclusive like folks feel like they belong and they can contribute right that's a journey in itself ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: Chaos or community? Yeah, of course community. And I don't want to be paralyzed by the chaos that is happening even now or in the future. And so for me, yeah, the big change I want to see is probably the dreams of so many people that came before me ⁓ that will come after me is how do we do this? So that everyone can have equal access to resource equal access to decision over their ⁓ I go to truth like, ⁓ we haven't even ⁓ peeled back all layers of the history this country yet, right? And so sometimes it feels so hard to, to ⁓ want this braver new world because ⁓ so much of the not ⁓ looking into our past, haven't even done yet. I think both can happen simultaneously. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Shantel: I think there's going to be visionaries, there's going to be people who want to transform, and then there's people who want to tell the stories and everyone between. And I just think we're all needed, right? We all need to figure out what part of that spectrum and journey sort of we're contributing to. And I'm always just reminded like, at the end of the day ⁓ even if you have a win, whether it's a small win large win it's still about us as people and our relationships and bonds. So for me, I want to be super real about even if everyone has housing, food, security, but do we feel as humans Nathan: Mm. Shantel: and towards one another is really important, right? I think then there's that part of joy and happiness that I think humans deserve, right? Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. I love it. Shantel: think I knew that I wanted to be a part of the resource since young. I grew up in a pretty Mexican Mexican American neighborhood in the Chicago land area that was next to black neighborhood in Chicago and then next to a mostly ⁓ white community. And ⁓ me since young, I remember being like, dang, just five minutes away, I'm experiencing different worlds. And as being the curious child that I was, when you go to this community, like... Why does it look this way? And when you go to this community, why is it that there's more parks here? So this question of why, and already sensing, the access to certain resources and how resources are being made available? As a child, I didn't have that language, but I just remember being Why is you be out Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Shantel: side in this park with no real I guess for whether going to be I like, So I started kind of just paying attention to that early and just wait, there's white people here, there's black people here, there's like brown people over here. Why? And so this question of why I've always had since a child, I ended up studying public policy because like, I understand people have agency, but there's also reasons why these communities exist, right? And so there's this just constant wanting to understand why are certain realities the way that they are? And then ⁓ my, personality of like, but it can be different, right? Beyond taking it for what it is, but it can be different. And how do we and how can we do that? ⁓ And ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. ⁓ Yeah. Shantel: I, for me, I value policy, policy creation, improvement. And when I was in my public policy undergraduate degree, I love being on because I could always start sensing people's different screens. ⁓ I'm the I'm going to analyze this. Okay, I want to learn how to communicate this potential policy that we're creating. And then I'm like, well, this budget seems really interesting. ⁓ Try to take advantage of know, it's like, how much money do we think we need? You know, and that's already how the my own sort of interest towards budgets that are paired to ideas or solutions from like community members. I want to work with people who Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: have real experience on the solutions that they ⁓ think address the issues that they're facing. ⁓ And want to work with visionaries, dreamers, I work with people who are brave to a different way and of course there's failure, but that's type of risk that I want to practice in lifetime is I don't want to feel scared to pursue something because it's not mainstream. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Shantel: you know, And I feel more comfortable working on a budget and potentially pitching, fine, that's the lane that I'm gonna take, right? I like to think of as like, this just a solution that we either to implement ⁓ or... ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: can just experiment with, pitch ⁓ language important. And the end of the day, are things that we're trying to help make the world a better place and ⁓ have real impact on people. And so maybe you can tell me because you're more a word Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: communications sort of sprains back up but ⁓ sometimes when hear the word pitch it it doesn't feel serious enough for me ⁓ it's like ⁓ I'm picking you so bet ⁓ something about the word pitch does not feel serious Nathan: Okay, all right. share an answer, but I just want to call it, I just really appreciate that mix of like vision and practicality and like asking the questions that you shared there that sounds like that's just been a part of you from ⁓ get-go and from an early age and you you've brought that to where you're at right now. So I, that was really intrigued by everything you just shared there in that regard. So thank you. ⁓ Shantel: ⁓ Yeah, thanks for also giving me the opportunity to share about my childhood upbringing. Nathan: Yeah. So let's see, when I talk about pitch, when I think of it that way, I mean, basically like what I'm saying is... Shantel: Okay. Nathan: And this comes back to my work too. Almost every time I'm working with a client, the biggest thing I've got to do is try to get them out of their head and into the head of the person that they're trying to talk to or influence or persuade or whatever that is. And so the pitch is really kind of getting to the emotional needs of that person and like what they need and what they want. And so I think about this so much in nonprofit space where if we're doing fundraising, if we're trying to raise money and maybe I think there's a lot of times we go to this thing of like, we're doing really good work. This is really important work. You should fund us. You should give us money. But that might be true and that might be a completely valid reason, but that might not be the reason that creates an emotional interest in the audience that you're pitching to. ⁓ And when you think a foundation, like sometimes they might just be looking for the most risk averse Shantel: Yeah. Nathan: person, like the safest person to give money to. If you think of like, maybe it is ⁓ an they want to give money to whoever's going to make them look the best. There could all these different things going on for ⁓ why people are contributing money these causes. And it's not necessarily about just the quality of the work the organization is doing for better or for worse. It doesn't mean to negate that as far as like how any organization positions themselves, but just to step out and think of how do we augment the way you share what you do ⁓ the value of what you do in a way that's like gonna resonate with the actual audience that you're trying to ⁓ here. Shantel: Yeah, and that's making me think of a I was recently a part of. Sam Choi the Nonprofit invited a few of us to accompany him to this one session at USC ⁓ called Coalition for the Uncommon Good. I was like, that seems interesting. Rhetoric for ⁓ the Uncommon Those ⁓ are even that I'm not sure I've even seen together in one sentence. ⁓ Nathan, I think that's a big part of numerous I like, yeah, I think about communication. I can, I love collaborating with the communicators, but I still have ideas about it, ⁓ you know, like, wanting ⁓ more like curiosity, To your point to be a better relationship builder, to be a better community builder, because it takes communication, right? ⁓ And so ⁓ sat on Keeling's sort of Nathan: Get away. Yeah, totally. Shantel: research where she was sharing to this group of students, ⁓ colleagues, not even folks who don't even go to USD like me. Just little bit about her ⁓ work and you're ⁓ and you know, still even processing that is just sharing like rhetoric basics and I don't know, you probably have your own thoughts on this too, but I've learned a few things that is making me think of the point that you're making. So one, rhetoric is not or bad. So even right now I'm catching myself. ⁓ feels doesn't feel like that right I'm like wait hold up maybe I can like my feelings related to that ⁓ then she had mentioned persuasion is used in rhetoric ⁓ and the of persuasion from I guess ancient times I remember Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: bringing up Plato and such, philosophers of that time, like modes of persuasion include ethos, which ethics and values, pathos, which are feelings and attachments, ⁓ and that can reasons and words. ⁓ And I I'm bringing that up because I feel like I hear that a little bit in your response. ⁓ Nathan: ⁓ yeah, 100%, Shantel: And just appreciate maybe we're communicating in this way, but ⁓ just get more expansive about the work that do with the different type of audiences and potential supporters, partners of our work. And so I don't know, I'm just appreciating that you're thinking of it up here. Especially for someone who's like, I'm like, just the words, keep it simple, need to. especially for partnering with strong communicators as well. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Well, totally. This is why I'm appreciating your approach to like a collaborative thing because yeah, it takes these types because you're talking about a bunch of stuff I can't do. ⁓ Like I can't do budget. That doesn't like, I can't do that. That doesn't work for me, but I can help sort of figure out the pitch. And that idea that brought it, ethos pathos logos. I bring that up all the in my work, in my workshops when I work with people Shantel: Yeah. Nathan: because it is like the... I shifted a little bit though. One of the things I asked too is like, what is the most important of those? And how important are each of those pieces relative to each other? different research I've seen, there's no really definitive research on this that I've seen at all. So it's kind of just a little bit subjective, but the logo, so logical pitch is like 2 % of the pitch and the pathos, the sort of the emotional pitch that is like And the rest is the ethos and that's the values and beliefs, but also that's the trust and that's the relationships. And so a lot of times that does come down to like who is, cause how I understood it and how I've read it is that the ethos a lot of times the way Plato positioned it or Aristotle, I think it was Aristotle who positioned it was that the speaker, who the speaker is, is the most important thing. Our fundamental feelings about that speaker matter almost more than what they say. And so that gets back to like building relationships too, right? this is part of the work that has to happen in regards to fundraising. And so there is a piece where it is about like... Shantel: Well, then maybe that's where I am, Nathan. Thanks for sharing that. think sometimes I, Maybe I, without knowing that you're giving me more vocabulary, I think that's where my mind goes is however we want to say it, like I'm down, but of course, like still be smart. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Mm. Hmm? Hmm? Yeah, yeah, totally. Shantel: Okay, so you just said Aristotle has this positionality. But are there different positionalities about this? Or is it kind of like, whatever all the... Nathan: Yeah, I mean, it's kind all over the place because I don't know that there's any, Like, yeah, it's a little bit more in the realm of like, what's the word I'm looking for? I want to say a fancier way of saying old wives tales. More academic way of saying that to where I don't know that there's any like real, real research or data on it. But I mean, I think you can find data on it in other ways. And like, it also depends on how you position it. Shantel: Yeah Nathan: A lot of the big part of the ethos is just getting to that conversation to where the pathos even matters, where the emotional appeal even matters. Because think of it like this, this is an example I bring up my workshops all the time. ⁓ get an that says, hey, you just won a million dollars, all you gotta do is click this link and I'm gonna send you all this money, congratulations. You're like, I don't think so. Like, No, I don't. Shantel: Yeah. Nathan: I don't recognize this person, know who this is. And like, a million dollars would be amazing, but you don't trust the person saying you've won a million dollars. Meanwhile, your best friend shows up and they're like, I need help, I need $1,000. You're give them $1,000, right? Because it's like your best friend. And so just that sort of gulf between trust there ⁓ is, be huge. Shantel: Yep. That's right. Yeah. That's so, yeah, I'm like, don't know if I'm gonna be able to form all my thoughts right now. last year all the funding cuts at the federal level, right, so many for-profit, non-profit, right, everyone has impacted by sort of this rough economy now that ⁓ experiencing. Except very rich people. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Shantel: So, you know, People are like, how do I adapt? How do I adapt? There's right now there's hesitation to move money. There is no money coming from certain sources. How do I adapt? And then ⁓ people coming to a person like me that are like, you do this for a living. How do we do it? Right? And I'm just kind of well, I'm also adapting right along with you. Right? And so, that's obviously an answer that feels hard. But at the same time, ⁓ it did Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: challenge me quicker, right? Because there was this feeling of what have we learned from past these times of like chaos and ⁓ instability, right? ⁓ And. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Shantel: Of course, yes, we have to figure out financially, we have to figure out okay, how much money do we got? We can do scenario planning, do all of this. And just keep doing the work that you do the way that you do it, because your reputation matters even more, right? And The trust that people have in how your team is doing the work Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yes. Yep. Yep. Mm-hmm. Shantel: matters even more. So that I'm connecting it back to trust because at the end of the yeah, we respond in many situations, but especially when things feel more unstable, It's a big opportunity to practice our values and if we're always about trust building and relationship building and being collaborative those things are just going to get even ⁓ more heightened during this time. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, totally. That's so interesting too because it is in these moments too where so easy to feel a little bit more desperation and compromise on the values and the relationships from that place of desperation and that's like the exact opposite thing to do. Shantel: Completely, and we've named some tensions, right? That's a tension that I was holding, still hold, but especially last year is like, man, Mas Alla's values are abundance, care, reciprocity. And I was like, wow. It feels really hard to practice abundance when there is like, right, a waterfall of executive orders that will now responding to there is like less money from the federal government. I had partners or people organizations I knew like 50 % of their budget poof in one quarter. That meant 50 % of their workforce poof didn't do the job, right? Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yep. Yep. Shantel: So for me, that's a tension of when things feel more chaotic, when you're there's more scarcity and what's available when there's already this ⁓ feeling like, my God, I need to need to bring in resource because I need to make sure right my team is here and they're taking care of. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: For me, I'm just like, ⁓ my God, how do I practice abundance now when it feels extremely overwhelming? And those were conversations we were having throughout the year because when we were sitting in client meetings with some of our partners out of Chicago and all the ICE raids were happening and all the deportations we're having, they're coming to meetings about money and their community members are getting deported. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Shantel: And then also, how can we stay calm and abundant in the future when the present feels really harmful and and problematic? That, for me, was a huge tension from last year that I'm still learning how to do ⁓ as a human, as a colleague. ⁓ all I can say is Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: Just like how we all have different strains, just like, yeah, it's still needed though, right? We can't create a braver future without that hope, without that belief that things can change, things can be better, we can do better. And unfortunately, abundance in other ways, right? Abundance in other ways and... something that I wanted to share with you your community here was when I was trying to figure out like, okay, how do we adapt during these times when telling us that there's resource constraints and then like, there's money being held in endowment and in advice funds and our tax is so shitty. How do we do it? These are the conditions, these are the environment. And I was looking to my who've been around like 30 plus years ⁓ and... Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: I've always knew that collaboration is important, essential, but I think it's that much more important during times. And going back to this conversation we were having, if we don't see ourselves as part of the collective, Nathan: Mm. Yeah. Shantel: Yeah, this notion of like, need to see ourselves as part of the collective and that our maybe individual negative impact is on its own. It's like, ⁓ right? People are going through it. We need to be together. We need to figure this out together. ⁓ And then when comes to resources is like, how can we share our resources when the environment already feels challenging enough? That's another tension. It's like how can we share our resources? that has actually helped us through and through humans. Nathan: Yeah. Shantel: And it feels hard sometimes, right? And so recently my colleague, Ana Soto from Akizo was like, hey, the other day I remembered the quote that you shared at the nonprofit institute, actually, you were, Nathan. De uno come en cuatro, Spanish phrase for from one many can eat ⁓ and this idea of like, yeah, if we don't see our resources as things that we can share ⁓ especially ⁓ times of high need, that's something that I think we're all still grappling with. Right. and you know, these feelings of how can we share our resources? How can we feel more collective in the process? And then on top of that is like, need for resource for our community, for the long haul and as unrestricted as That is still something that like I do through Mas Alla and now. In the future through the collective resourcing cohort that we're trying to pilot here in San Diego because yeah, right now I would say collaboration doesn't necessarily feel like the most mainstream behavior and how for profit to nonprofit, right, to all the sectors. I we're still learning how to be more collaborative? you know? ⁓ And this would be a cohort experience to help leaders from all sectors in San Diego Nathan: Mm-hmm. Shantel: Like learn how to evolve their behaviors or mindsets around resources be more collaborative and advocate for more resource distribution and something I'm really excited to experiment with and Hopefully in future can talk to you a little bit more about that that has been something that as I've adapted with the times Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Shantel: it's going to take so many of us to be able to do this work together and people should not feel alone during these ⁓ unquote chaotic times. Like, yeah, I think like how do, yeah, how can we be in community ⁓ these times, right? Nathan: Yeah. I love so many things you said there and there's so many threads I want to pull out of there, but also I think that's probably a good spot for us to wrap it up today because we've already been talking for a while. But yeah, we'll just a pin in all those things, because I think there's a lot of really valuable things there. So Shantel, tell everybody how they can ⁓ get hold of you or find you if they're interested. Shantel: Yeah. Yes. Definitely. Yeah, you're interested in learning about centric fundraising, the water systems change, the that we do at Mas Aya from strategy to execution to any of the narrative change workshops and trainings that I mentioned to you, reach out to us. ⁓ We have website, masallaconsulting.com. I know, I'm sure Nathan will probably share a little bit more details. Nathan: from the stone oaks. Shantel: the notes, yeah. But our website is our best place to get connected with us. You can contact us there. ⁓ on LinkedIn. ⁓ personally on LinkedIn. If you're a friend of Nathan, you most likely will be a friend of mine. Yeah, excited to connect with folks in the future and figure out, so happy to join Nathan to be able to have these conversations like, break new worlds. ⁓ They're happening like, just need more people to get in there, you know? Nathan: know it. Yeah, totally. be in there doing it. Yeah, yeah, totally, Yeah. All right. Well, awesome, Shantel. Thanks so much for being out here and so much good stuff. This fundraising conversation is so rich for me because that really is going to be at the core of everything, right? Unfortunately, our world needs money. And so how we think about getting money to communities and thinking about it as a justice project is so valuable. So I really appreciate the insight there. Alright, well thanks so much Shantel, thanks for being on here. Shantel: Yeah, thanks Nathan. Thanks everyone.