Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Revenue Guidance to Set Expectations
Transcript
- Lucas: Roblox is up 18 percent in the past five trading days. Coinbase up nearly 12. That's not just market noise — a lot of it comes down to how those companies managed revenue guidance on their most recent earnings calls. Luna: So guidance is becoming a strategic lever, not just a number they throw out to satisfy analysts. Lucas: Exactly. For post ipo companies especially, guidance is one of the few tools they have to shape the narrative. Once you're public, every quarter you're expected to deliver a number — but that number is as much about psychology as it is about finance. Luna: Walk me through the mechanics. A company reports revenue of, say, $1.2 billion. But they gave guidance of $1.15 to $1.18 billion. So they 'beat' — and the stock pops. Lucas: Right. And that pop is often engineered. The classic playbook is to set guidance conservatively — what the Street calls 'sandbagging' — then beat it by a comfortable margin. Investors love a beat. But there's a risk: if you sandbag too much, analysts start discounting your guidance, and the whisper number becomes the real target. Luna: The whisper number — the unofficial expectation that traders and analysts talk about off the record. If you beat official guidance but miss the whisper, the stock can still sell off. Lucas: That happened to a few post ipo companies in early 2026. They reported numbers that looked fine on paper, but the Street had already priced in something higher. And the stock dropped 5, 6 percent in a day. So guidance is a double-edged sword. Luna: So how do companies decide where to set the bar? I imagine there's a lot of negotiation between the CFO and the IR team. Lucas: Absolutely. And the board is involved too. They look at internal forecasts, pipeline visibility, macro conditions. The goal is to set a range you're confident you'll hit, but leave enough room for a beat. Typically, the range is about 3 to 5 percent wide. So if you expect $1.2 billion, you guide $1.16 to $1.20. Luna: And the low end becomes the de facto floor. If you hit the low end, it's a pass. If you hit the midpoint, it's fine. The top end is the stretch goal. Lucas: Yes. And companies that consistently hit the top end or raise guidance during the quarter get a premium multiple. The market rewards predictability with a higher price to earnings ratio. But there's a trap: if you raise guidance too aggressively, you set yourself up for a miss next quarter. Luna: So it's a pacing game. You want to show growth, but not at the cost of future credibility. Lucas: Exactly. And for post ipo companies, credibility is everything. They don't have a long track record. One big miss and the stock gets cut in half, and it can take years to recover. Luna: Let's talk about a specific example. Rivian started delivering the R2 recently, but they just cut hundreds of workers. That suggests maybe their guidance wasn't as robust as they hoped. Lucas: Right. Rivian is in a tough spot. They guided for a certain production ramp, but the macro environment for EVs has softened. So they're cutting costs to protect margins. The market reaction was interesting — the stock is actually up 8 percent over five days. That might be because the cut signals discipline, not desperation. Luna: So the content of the guidance matters, but so does the story around it. If you frame a cut as 'efficiency,' investors may reward you. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the earnings call becomes a performance. The CEO and CFO spend weeks preparing scripted remarks, Q&A prep, and they rehearse answers to tough questions. The guidance number is just one data point in a broader narrative. Luna: What about companies that don't give guidance? Some high-profile tech companies have stopped doing quarterly guidance. Lucas: That's a luxury reserved for established giants like Apple. For a post ipo company, not giving guidance is usually a red flag. Investors interpret it as uncertainty. Unless you're a very special case, you need to provide at least a revenue range and maybe an earnings per share range. Luna: And the frequency matters too. Most companies guide quarterly, but some give annual guidance with quarterly updates. What's the trend? Lucas: The trend among post-IPOs in 2026 is toward quarterly guidance with a full-year framework. That gives investors a sense of the trajectory without locking you into a specific number too far out. And it allows you to raise or narrow the range as the year progresses. Luna: And there's the lockup expiration angle. Many post ipo companies have lockups expiring 6 to 12 months after the IPO. How does guidance play into that? Lucas: Great point. A lockup expiration can flood the market with shares. So companies often try to time their guidance communication to build confidence before the lockup ends. If the stock is strong and guidance is upbeat, insiders can sell into strength, and the stock absorbs the supply better. Luna: So they're essentially using guidance as a buffer against dilution. Lucas: Yes. And some companies even announce a buyback alongside the lockup expiration to signal that they believe the stock is undervalued. That's a powerful one-two punch. Luna: Speaking of buybacks, we've talked about those in past episodes. But guidance is really the first line of defense against volatility. Lucas: It is. And the best CFOs I've covered treat guidance like a promise. They don't want to break it. So they build in buffers, they stress-test assumptions, and they communicate clearly. The market hates surprises — even positive ones can cause whiplash if they're too big. Luna: Why would a positive surprise be bad? You'd think investors would love a huge beat. Lucas: If a company beats by 20 percent, investors wonder: did they intentionally lowball guidance? Can we trust their numbers going forward? It creates skepticism. The ideal beat is 2 to 5 percent — enough to show strength, but not so much that it raises questions. Luna: So there's an art to the number. It's not just about the math. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why many post ipo companies are hiring investor relations specialists from more seasoned public companies. They bring the playbook. I know one IR director who came from Procter & Gamble, and she transformed how her company communicated guidance. Luna: Before we wrap, I want to come back to the broader point. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, there's a simple way to support them. We deliberately don't run ads — no sponsors, no pre-rolls. If you value that independence, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep the focus on substance. Lucas: Absolutely. And it keeps us free to dig into topics like guidance mechanics without having to tailor the conversation to an advertiser. So, back to the original thread: I think the key takeaway for anyone listening is that when you see a post ipo stock move after earnings, look beyond the headline number. Look at the guidance range, the trend, and the narrative. That's where the real story is. Luna: And watch for raises. If a company raises guidance mid-quarter, that's often a stronger signal than the beat itself. Lucas: Right. And keep an eye on the whisper number. If you can get a sense of what the Street really expects, you'll understand why a stock acts the way it does on earnings day. Luna: Good stuff. Next episode we'll look at how secondary offerings interact with guidance — because that's another layer of complexity for post ipo companies. Lucas: Looking forward to it. For now, keep building, keep investing, and stay curious.