Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline For Wednesday, September 27, 2023
Transcript
- 0:27Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. Decision.
- 0:32You're surrounded on Liberals in Emergency book Gatio on Radio turned Off. From
- 0:41the studios of w VRC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice
- 0:46of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this
- 0:52here is Metro News Talk Live with a Hobby Kirch of blencol Activated Switch Lives
- 0:59where you kill from stand by You, Hoppy. You're on Metronews talk Line
- 1:04with Hoppy Kirchibliz brought to you buy in COVID Insurance and circling you with coverage
- 1:10to protect what you care about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more.
- 1:14Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on Metro News from the and COVID
- 1:18Insurance studios. Hoppy Kirchiville with you Ethan Coflins as eye producer, and Adriana
- 1:23Linhart is handling the video stream. You can watch at wv metronews dot com.
- 1:26The phone number is one eight hundred seven six five eight two five five,
- 1:30text me three or four Talk three oh four. That's three or four
- 1:36talk three or four coming up. We're gonna have a couple of angles on
- 1:38the very significant lawyer fees that are scheduled to be paid out in at opioid
- 1:44settlement, one hundred and forty one million dollars two lawyers and law firms.
- 1:48We'll get into that this morning with a further explanation on it, but let
- 1:52me start here. A lot of attention appropriately on wvu's right sizing, and
- 1:57that is going to involve layoffs of about one hundred and forty faculty and the
- 2:04elimination or adjustment or right sizing of several dozen programs at the university. It's
- 2:09been very controversial. WVU is not alone. This is happening in many colleges
- 2:14and universities across the country, and it's not alone in West Virginia. Shephard
- 2:19University in the Eastern Panhandle is also going through a right sizing because of a
- 2:24expected budget deficit. According to President Mary Hendricks, they've canceled or delayed forty
- 2:30four staff positions for administrative positions, sixteen faculty positions, also looking at programs
- 2:37and enrollment in those programs. Doctor Hendricks joins us on Metro News talk line.
- 2:40Doc Hendricks, good morning, thanks for joining us. How are you
- 2:43this morning. Oh, good morning, hockey. We're doing great here.
- 2:46It's a beautiful day in the Eastern Panhandle. And Shepherdstown is a beautiful town.
- 2:52So you've got a nice it is. It's a great place. It's
- 2:53a great place, and that is a wonderful university there. I went there
- 2:59for a year before I train for the WVU, so piece of my heart
- 3:01is there. But also your school, like other schools, are going through
- 3:07right sizing, variety of reasons. Why are you right sizing right now?
- 3:13Well, we appreciate this opportunity. Hoppy, I would say, like most
- 3:17schools in the United States, we're looking at our operations. We're looking at
- 3:23our enrollment. In this post COVID time, I think many of us had
- 3:31issues, had difficulties trying to understand how we were going to bounce back after
- 3:37the pandemics. So now we have this opportunity to look at our academic programs.
- 3:43Are they still all relevant for our students or our students looking for something
- 3:49different. We also look at our operations. Are we operating efficiently? Should
- 3:55we be looking at more energy efficient opportunities? And then of course we all
- 4:02in West Virginia have the benefit of the wisdom of our border governors. And
- 4:09I will tell you that our bord of governors, highly distinguished individuals led by
- 4:14Gad Caperdon, they are focusing on our financials and they have asked us to
- 4:20make cuts we're appropriate over the next two years to be able to address our
- 4:27six million dollars structural deficit, and we are making extraordinary progress toward that goal.
- 4:34Is that President Mary Hendricks is with a Shepherd University, so are using
- 4:40the process much like WV and other institutions have done that as you look at
- 4:43enrollment and find out what programs have declining or stagnant enrollment and what programs have
- 4:48increased enrollment. Yes, Hoppy, we do a very similar exercise. But
- 4:54let me tell you how we started here. When we discovered in May,
- 4:58just as past May, that we had the six million dollar structural deficit.
- 5:02The first thing we did is we send out a campus survey our entire campus,
- 5:08and we said, can you please give us suggestions for revenue generating and
- 5:13cost savings ideas? And we received about two hundred ideas. It's remarkable how
- 5:19this campus has pulled together toward this common goal of reducing our expenses. Then
- 5:28the next thing we did is we looked at our college structure. We reduced
- 5:30our structure from four colleges down to three. We were able to save money.
- 5:35We looked at our personnel positions open do we need them all? We
- 5:41focus on operations and now we are totally focused on assessing the academic programs and
- 5:48really academic prioritization. Well, you have to there will be some then,
- 5:54and I guess you haven't gotten here yet, but there will be some academic
- 5:57programs that will be eliminated. Well, we're not at that point yet,
- 6:02and so I don't want to speak too soon, but let me just tell
- 6:06you how Shepherd is dealing with issues such as if we have to reduce personnel
- 6:15costs, we bring everyone together and we ask do we have opportunities to bring
- 6:20in extramural support, that is Grant's contracts to be able to support some personnel.
- 6:27And we have found out the answer to that is yes. We go
- 6:30to our foundation and we ask them for their help in supporting some of our
- 6:34personnel and positions. It is truly a multi focused approach on trying to bring
- 6:44in revenue to replace operational expenses. And I have to say I have never
- 6:51seen a campus, come together and try to help each other like we are
- 6:58going through right now. Understand that you look for more revenue. I get
- 7:01that, but you've got to be careful on tuition obviously, because your price
- 7:05students out of the market number one at number two. That even if you
- 7:10can bring an additional revenue correctly, if I'm wrong, you're just not going
- 7:14to be able to get through this without some cuts and some eliminations. Fair
- 7:18well, that is a fair statement. Yes, we're quite practical when we
- 7:25look at how to bring in extra revenue quickly. We actually are assessing some
- 7:30of Shepherd's assets that we might be able to sell, and so right now
- 7:36we are getting ready to sell one of our buildings on campus. This is
- 7:43just a building a little bit off campus, I should say, our human
- 7:46resource building, and we're hoping to bring in some very positive revenue from that,
- 7:53which would be essential. But you're correct, we have to be very
- 7:58practical in our approach that we're going to have to make some reductions. President
- 8:03Mary Hendricks is with this from Shepherd University. They, like a lot of
- 8:05schools are going through right sizing, Shepherd has an ideal location. They're in
- 8:11the growing Eastern Panhandle. You're in Jefferson County. Of course those are growing
- 8:15counties. You're strategically situated for the Tri state area. Yet enrollment has been
- 8:20declining. I know you're up about one percent from the previous year, so
- 8:24that's a positive, but your overall it's been overall to kind of about a
- 8:28thousand students over the last ten years. Why has enrollment been declining? Do
- 8:31you think? Well, I think we look like many other institutions in the
- 8:37country that we just don't have either the same number of students graduating from high
- 8:43school or that those students wish to go to, say a community college or
- 8:50straight into work. But I have to tell you those students, we look
- 8:54at them, we look at our demographics, and we are developing program set
- 9:00would attract more adult learners that would attract more two plus two agreements with community
- 9:07colleges, and that's why we're starting to see our increases actually over the last
- 9:11two years. Last year we had a little over seven percent increase in enrollment
- 9:16because we're able to focus on students that we hadn't previously focused on, and
- 9:24so I see us being able to trend upward over the next few years.
- 9:30And we have quite a strategic plan for doing that. We were emailing back
- 9:35and forth yesterday and you emailed me some points that you had been talking about.
- 9:39You said, I going to make institutions across the country are undergoing similar
- 9:43assessments, which is absolutely true WWU a perfect example. You also said industry
- 9:46performs these types of strategic evaluations on a continual basis if their goal is to
- 9:52achieve success. I think sometimes Higher ED views itself as not business like,
- 9:58that it is separate from other institutions in the country. But you specifically cite
- 10:03the example of industry. Can you speak to that, Yes, and I
- 10:09appreciate that question. If we just look around us, look at the automobile
- 10:13industry, right, it has truly been transformational over the last many decades.
- 10:20If we look at the railroad industry. I mean, we have to think
- 10:24about ourselves as being relevant to today's student population. So why shouldn't we use
- 10:33the same basic principles that industry uses to constantly and continuously assess themselves. Look
- 10:41at Google, look at Apple. My goodness, we smile about this because
- 10:48our students are with us through this streamlining and right sizing exercise. They see
- 10:56what we're going through and this is teaching them. I mean, they're the
- 11:00next generation of leaders and model citizens. When they encounter these types of issues,
- 11:05they will know to constantly assess their progress and where their position is in
- 11:11the marketplace. So this is a learning experience for everyone. Hoppy, you
- 11:18probably have seen what has happened at WVU that they're going to right sizing too.
- 11:24It's a bigger institution, so it's a bigger right sizing. There has
- 11:26been a significant amount of pushback from faculty, from some staff, from students.
- 11:33There was a rather contentious Board of Governors meeting a week or so ago
- 11:37when they approved the right sizing it's going on. There was a vote of
- 11:41almost eight hundred faculty members, a vote of no confidence of President. Gee,
- 11:46what kind of pushback have you gotten from faculty, staff and students at
- 11:50Sheppard. Well, our approach, and I'll just have to share this with
- 11:54you has been so transparent that a couple of weeks after we discovered a structural
- 12:03deficit of six million dollars, we immediately started messaging. We appeared before our
- 12:11faculty Senate, before our classified staff members, and now before our Student Government
- 12:16Association Fall Assembly. We continuously talk about this and most importantly, our progress
- 12:22towards targeting that goal. That's essential. We have a great faculty Senate.
- 12:31I like to brag about our faculty hobby because we have so many finalists among
- 12:35our faculty and winners of the West Virginia Professor of the Year award. So
- 12:41this is such a class group. So what I'm saying is, right now,
- 12:48the most important thing we can do is just share all the information that
- 12:52we have when the time comes when decisions are made. I'm sure we're going
- 12:56to hear a lot of comments. We're ready for criticisms, but we also
- 13:03have to be ready to justify our decisions based on data. So all of
- 13:07our faculty, department heads and administrators are looking at the data right now for
- 13:13academic prioritization. Everyone is seeing this. President Mary Hendricks, President of Shepherd
- 13:20University, also going through a right sizing. Madam. President's good to speak
- 13:22with you. Good luck with your process. Thank you for coming on today.
- 13:26Thanks for having me happy. I really appreciate it. Take care you
- 13:30two talk line continues. We'll be right back you time joint pain or muscle
- 13:33injuries holding you back. Trust the experts at CMC Orthopedics and CMC Orthopedic Trauma
- 13:39for personalized treatment options tailored to your needs. CEMC offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for
- 13:46all types of pain and injuries. Our specialists provide tailored options from diagnosis to
- 13:50rehab with state of the art facilities for top quality care. Visit CMC dot
- 13:56org slash Orthopedics to learn more. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is
- 14:11brought to you by in Coca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what
- 14:15you care about most. Visit incovia dot com to learn more. Talk line
- 14:20from me in Cova Insurance Studios Text three or four Talk three or four,
- 14:26Yes, Hoppy. Most successful industries use right sizing, but before the crisis
- 14:31is too large to correct without major consequences that could be avoided by prudent and
- 14:37early actions. In Wu's case, that should have been happening ten years ago.
- 14:41Well, who really knows, I mean, in fairness, even in
- 14:46industry ten years, who knows what's going to be, what the state of
- 14:50things will be in ten years? Who could have foreseen COVID in higher ED,
- 14:56could a higher ED have seen some of this coming? Earlier. Yeah,
- 15:01yeah, I mean I think that is a fair criticism overall that Higher
- 15:05ED, which again I think got a little bit too insulated as to what
- 15:13the trends were in this country concerning enrollment and couldn't see COVID coming. I
- 15:16get that, but probably got too comfortable. As I've said many many times,
- 15:20enrollment will always go up. They can continue to raise tuition, they'll
- 15:24build nice buildings that students alike, and everything will be okay, except it's
- 15:30okay until it isn't okay. And that's what happened to Higher ED. So
- 15:33now you do see this be Could they have seen it sooner? Yes,
- 15:35that's fair. But now there is inevitable, right size thing that's going on,
- 15:39I think, Shepherd and the reason I was interested in this story is
- 15:41for three reasons. One is that it is an example that WVU is not
- 15:48the only institution that's going through this. Number two, it's happening across the
- 15:54country. Number two is that it's not the only institution in West Virginia that's
- 15:58going through this. I think Marshall's doing some of the same two and some
- 16:02other institutions. You just don't hear as much as much about it. Number
- 16:06three is Shepherd. Is This actually surprised me a little bit about Shepherd because
- 16:11Shepherd is there at this prime location in the eastern Panhandle, in a part
- 16:17of the state that is really growing Jefferson in Berkeley County, Berkeley County is
- 16:21the fastest growing county in the state. It's it's ten miles ten miles from
- 16:25Berkeley County to Shepherd, and there are a lot a lot of Martinsburg kids,
- 16:32a lot of Berkeley County kids that drive over and go to Shepherd and
- 16:34can meet to Shepherd. Jefferson County kids go there. And also you get
- 16:37a lot of out of state students in Shepherd because it's a good school and
- 16:42it's cheaper than alternatives. When I was there a long time ago, We've
- 16:45got a lot of students from New Jersey, from New Jersey because it's drivable
- 16:52and you can't afford or get into Rutgers. So it's very popular school.
- 16:56But even Shepherd has seen a decline in enrollment by about ten thousand students over
- 17:03the last ten years. Now their enrollment it may begin to turn around.
- 17:07They had a seven percent increase in fall twenty twenty two. I let's see
- 17:11it was in one percent in the fall of twenty twenty three, so maybe
- 17:15that's maybe that's reversing now, maybe they've bottomed out, But clearly they have
- 17:21had some of those same issues as other institutions have as well. And look,
- 17:26they had they had growth when they were really booming and enrollment was up
- 17:30and the money was they were in good shape on money. They were expanding,
- 17:33they were doing sort of satellite campuses and other activities, and now they
- 17:37just can't afford that. Was it a mistake. I don't know if it
- 17:40was a mistake at the time, but they're correcting it. So they're going
- 17:44through these recommendations. Now do they continue at the current level, do they
- 17:47continue but with a specific action plan to make some changes, or they do
- 17:51it at a reduced level or consolidate, or do they discontinue with the teach
- 17:56out plan, which is exactly what WVU has been doing. It's exactly what
- 18:00many other institutions are doing. So this is not just WVU, It is
- 18:06a lot of institutions across the country that are doing this. Taxit three or
- 18:12four Talk three or four. And I thought it was interesting too that President
- 18:18Hendricks sited business and cited industry in this saying, that's what businesses do.
- 18:27And I know it's not completely analogous hire it to business, but some of
- 18:30the same principles have to apply. Mike and Brickley County. Mike, what's
- 18:33your take on this, hey, Hobby. First of all, I'm not
- 18:37sure where you got your number about ten thousand lost ten You should just mention
- 18:41the thousand ten thousand students in the list they lost a thousand. If I
- 18:45said ten thousand, I apologize I made a mistake. They lost a thousand,
- 18:48said, oh, I know, they lost a thousand. My mistake.
- 18:52So one thing that has to be taken into considerations, specifically the Shepherd
- 18:56is the unique We have Blue Ridge and Community and Technical College over here right,
- 19:03very populous, is an offshoot which is an offshoot of the old of
- 19:08Shepherd. All of the two year programs that used to be under the Shepherd
- 19:12Community and Technical College, which was broken off and later was named Blue Ridge
- 19:18Community and Technical College, were former separate I mean what would be now?
- 19:22What would if it was still the old way of the Shepherd Community and Technical
- 19:26College, Those Blue Ridge students would be Shepherd students. Well, was the
- 19:30old way the better way. Oh, in my opinion, it was much
- 19:34better. And let me just give you one example, Poppy, and I
- 19:38give you a personal example of somebody in my family. And I'm a Shepherd
- 19:42graand and w Grant, so I know a little bit about both. Plus
- 19:45as you may or may not know, I'm kind a little experience in the
- 19:48legislature. My sister went to Shepherd in a two year program at the time
- 19:56in the early to mid eighties, and it was nursing. You go get
- 20:00a two year RN nursing degree. Now you have to do a four year
- 20:04degree if you want to get an r in degree at Shepherd. So people
- 20:11are opting, maybe in the case of nursing, to go somewhere else because
- 20:15they can go do an RN program in two years. Now. She later
- 20:18went back and got a four years Let me ask you this, okay,
- 20:19but would you agree? Would you agree? Would you agree? And look,
- 20:22you can have we can have a debate over whether they should have that
- 20:26Blue Ridge should still be a part of Shepherd. But since it's not given
- 20:29the current status, is that the right thing to do to right size?
- 20:33Well, I mean, first of all, what I'm saying is there hasn't
- 20:37because they spun off part of their universe, part of their old college.
- 20:41It's not compared. And like when you're trying to compare what happened, what's
- 20:45happening at WV and what happening in Shepherd, it's two different things. The
- 20:48reason for losing students, part of it is they spun off part of the
- 20:51universe versity into a whole different university which has grown by leaps and bounds.
- 20:56Blue Eide Community Technical Colleges got tons of students. Yeah, but you know,
- 21:00I gotta hit the break. I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing,
- 21:02because there's certainly a market for people to go to community college and get
- 21:06the kind of skills necessary for the workplace today. Mike, thanks for the
- 21:08call. I'm in a thousand, ten thousand. Obviously, this is talk
- 21:11line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's ten thirty.
- 21:15Let's get a news update. Checking with the Metro News radio network. Find
- 21:18out what's happening statewide this hour, all across the great state of West Virginia,
- 21:23West Virginia Metro News. I'm Kerry Hooda Sack. Danielle Walker has parted
- 21:27ways with the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia after serving less than six
- 21:32months as their executive director, the ACLU confirming Tuesday Dot Walker, a former
- 21:37member of the House of Delegates from Monteglia County, is no longer with the
- 21:41organization and that Eli Bombwell has been serving as the interim executive director since September
- 21:45fifteen. Parkersburg Mayor Tom Joyce says, even though the city doesn't currently have
- 21:49a lot of people sleeping on the streets, he's throwing his support behind a
- 21:52public camping band ordinance. It hasn't been a problem for a few years for
- 21:56us, but we certainly don't want it to become a problem. The ordinance
- 22:00was approved by city council Tuesday night. State Senate Finance Committee Chairman Eric tar
- 22:04is reacting to Governor Jim Justice's recent financial disclosure in which Justice received a loan
- 22:10from his former advisor, Brake Harry, somebody who loaned him personally at a
- 22:15ten percent interest rate money for whatever. We had no idea what those loans
- 22:18are for, and then it happened. Immediately after he left the Governor's office
- 22:22and went to be on the board of governors with the Western University The form
- 22:25included a long list of assets, but showed many made little to no income,
- 22:27as well as millions of dollars in debt. The annual Preston County Buckweet
- 22:32Festival opens today in downtown Kingwood. Festival General Chairman Harry Hayes says more than
- 22:37ten thousand buckwheat pancakes and sausage genners have been prepared. The buckwheat cakes and
- 22:41sausage are at our community building. Those are all you can eat buckwheat cakes.
- 22:47The event runs through Sunday. You're listening to Metro News, the voice
- 22:49of West Virginia, Nicktronian States, your source for high school sports coverage and
- 22:56the exclusive home of the high school sports Lawn. President by Palmer, Red
- 23:00Persinger, Dave Checklin and Joe Bracado bring you the latest scores and news,
- 23:03along with player and coach interviews and in depth stories. Catch your high school
- 23:07sportsfix every Wednesday night this fall and follow your favorite team all season long The
- 23:14High Schools Sports Line presented by Palmer here on the Metronews Radio network and online
- 23:19at wv metronews dot com. Hey, high school football fans, if you
- 23:23want to see where your team ranks every week. Check out the Thornhill Autogroup
- 23:27Power Rankings at wb metronews dot com. Every Sunday evening, we will update
- 23:33the football power ranking. To find out where your favorite team ranks. Go
- 23:36to wv metronews dot com, look on the high school sports tab and then
- 23:41high school football Power Rankings. Well twenty twenty three Metronews Power Rankings presented by
- 23:45Thornhill Auto Group or Road to Total Savings starts with Thornhill. Visit them on
- 23:51the Thornhill Motor Mile. The money Galia County Health Department's Quick Response Team is
- 23:55planning to use a one million dollar grant to help address opioid overdoses. RT
- 24:00coordinator Britney Irax says they've handed out free in the lock zone, but more
- 24:03needs to be done. There's always room for improvement, and that is really
- 24:07what we're doing with this grant, is we want to make sure that we're
- 24:11getting all the data. We want to make sure that we're doing all of
- 24:14the right things to help our community that we can US. Senator Shelley Moore,
- 24:18Capita, announced the funding Tuesday from the Metro News anchor desk, Gncarri
- 24:22Houda suck talk Lient on Metro News from the Kova Insurance Studio's got a text
- 24:42somebody saying that listeners says that enjoy making excuses for WVU and the w engaged
- 24:48in bad PR. Let me answer that. One is that when you're laying
- 24:51off of one hundred and forty faculty members and when you're eliminating programs and majors,
- 24:57there's no such thing as good PR. I mean what I mean,
- 25:03there's not good PR. I mean there's spin. You can try to spin
- 25:07it, but it's not like, oh, let's let's turn this into a
- 25:11positive. That's very, very hard to do. And also I don't really
- 25:14care about the PR. The second point is I think they're doing the right
- 25:17thing. I mean, yeah, as I've said, is it a legitimate
- 25:21criticisms that w could have been on this sooner? Yes? Is it legitimate
- 25:25criticism that they overspent? Likely? Is it a legitimate excuse? Is the
- 25:30legitimate point that Gordon gey over and it was out over skis on that forty
- 25:33thousand prediction? Yes? All fair, All fair? Now what are you
- 25:38gonna do about it? You're gonna hide, You're gonna hid your head in
- 25:41the sand. You're gonna do something about it. What they're doing is making
- 25:42difficult decisions that it will in fact, I believe right size the university for
- 25:48the future. So, as you know from following the news, in these
- 25:55opioid settlements, the lawsuits by the state and by cities and counties and communities
- 26:02against opioid manufacturers and distributors and pharmacies resulted in settlements totaling almost a billion dollars
- 26:10nine hundred and forty million dollars. The Attorney General's office hired outside the state,
- 26:15hired outside council, and communities hired outside council to handle these lawsuits,
- 26:22and the agreed upon payments to these law firms and lawyers total one hundred forty
- 26:30one million dollars. One hundred forty one million dollars. That is a lot
- 26:33of money. And there are complicated, complicated, complicated formula as to who
- 26:37got what and how much. But let's dig into this a little bit.
- 26:41Tony Majestros at Charleston Attorney and one of the attorneys whose law firm was paid
- 26:47handsomely for their work on this. In fact, of the amount in the
- 26:52settlement that the lawyers are getting twenty two and a half million went to Fitzsimmons
- 26:55Law Firm of Wheeling and twenty million to Feral Fuller of Huntington and Palm Gestro
- 27:00of Charleston. And Tony is a member of Obviously Pale and Majestro. He's
- 27:04also a representative of West Virginia Association for Justice. Tony, Good morning,
- 27:07How you doing great, Toppy? How are you to day? Well?
- 27:11Thank you for coming on. So look, we talk many times during this
- 27:14litigation, and I know that your all firm put in a ton of time
- 27:17and a ton of hours, ton of energy and effort which you don't get
- 27:21paid for unless there's a settlement and then you get a portion settlement. So
- 27:23I do get all that, and I know there's a formula which gets rather
- 27:26complicated, but is a hundred in total? Is one hundred and forty one
- 27:32million dollars two attorneys who held the action against the drug manufacturers and the pharmacies.
- 27:41Is that a justified amount? Yes? It is happy And I think
- 27:44I want to start with unless you know something I don't, we still haven't
- 27:48been paid a dime in this. I know, I know this is just
- 27:49a recommended amount, and that's good, but go hit Yeah, and that's
- 27:53this is litigation that has been going on for six years. This is litigation
- 27:59where the lawyer was the as Judge Wilkes recommendation notes that the lawyers advanced up
- 28:04to thirteen million dollars of their own money. We're not talking about value of
- 28:08time. These are checks the law firms wrote to finance this litigation. When
- 28:14when I look, I checked yesterday when you asked me to come on,
- 28:18and I found out one hundred and seventy seven thousand hours were expended by the
- 28:23professionals in this case, over three hundred legal professionals. So so in judging
- 28:27this amount, you have to look at the enormity of the case and the
- 28:32enormity of the problem that the state, the state faced. I mean,
- 28:34the judges in the in in this litigation, both in West Virginia and other
- 28:38places, have said that this was the most complex and sophisticated litigation in the
- 28:44history of the US civil justice system. We litigated in the state court,
- 28:48federal courts, federal bankruptcy court. This case was a big case, and
- 28:52it was a big case because of the big problem. I'm the defendants in
- 28:56this case who made billions of dollars or work used of helping to create the
- 29:00largest man made epidemic in the entire world. And West Virginia, of course,
- 29:04was at the epicenter of this crisis. So in judging what we may
- 29:08end up within the end and it hasn't been finally approved you, I think
- 29:14your listeners need to keep all of that into account. And finally, the
- 29:18risk. You know this, they call these contingent fees. The reason they're
- 29:21contingent fees is their contingent on success. Every It makes a big deal when
- 29:26we succeed in a case. Nobody ever calls me to come on to explain
- 29:30how how what happens when I when we lose cases and have to eat the
- 29:36time and the costs. So there's risks involved and this risk that the defendants
- 29:40lawyers don't have to face. But wait, are you saying that majestrial laws
- 29:44sometimes lose cases? Shocked? I'm shocked. I tell you every once in
- 29:48a while we try not to. But there's that risk, there is there
- 29:52is. Would you would you agree that while this was incredibly complicated, I
- 29:56do get that, and countless hours I do get that as well. Would
- 29:59you agree though, that the that the ultimate end that as you work,
- 30:03you and others worked on this case, that you envision that there would be
- 30:06an end where these drug companies, pharmaceutical companies, pharmacy companies would settle because
- 30:11that's what they were doing in other cases. Well, I mean when we
- 30:15started the case, they weren't doing that. This is litigation we essentially developed
- 30:19from the ground up. The theories were theories that the West Virginia lawyers developed.
- 30:25These theories. Paul Farrell and I were the first ones to file cases
- 30:27against the distributors in federal court. We developed the theories that led to the
- 30:32national national settlements in West Virginia. We didn't just have settlements. We had
- 30:36trials and one of which you you knows, as you may recall a hobby
- 30:41didn't go too well for us. And you know the in state court there
- 30:45was there was there was a trial against the manufacturers then went all the way
- 30:49to closing arguments before the defendants set up. So settlements in this in this
- 30:53case weren't guaranteed at any time in any time in this litigation, let me
- 31:00Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrissey, and again outside council was and I think you
- 31:03all represented communities, right, and not the states that created in West Virginia
- 31:07we represented. Well, let me get you to react to this, because
- 31:10the Attorney general did there were outside councils that represented the state. And again
- 31:14it's been complicated, but there were law firms representing the state, there were
- 31:17law firms representing the communities. But the attorney general did say, Patrick Morrissey,
- 31:22he's going to be on this program later this hour, said I'm troubled
- 31:25by the aggregate amount of attorney fees that will be paid from the settlements,
- 31:29which includes cities and counties. So this is the age saying he's bothered by
- 31:34the total amount. What's your response to that. Well, I think if
- 31:37you look at the total amount it at with the combined it ends up being
- 31:41a little bit shy of fourteen percent thirteen point six percent of the entire award.
- 31:48That is way lower than than what's commonly done in civilitigated, which is
- 31:52about thirty percent. I mean, and you know, and the mounts the
- 31:56percents go down when the mounts at state go up. That that's standard.
- 32:00But thirteen point six is not a bad number. And then this case,
- 32:04the cities and counties that hired us did so after competitive bidding, and they're
- 32:07not it's you know, not some poor person who's injured and having to figure
- 32:12out how to pay medical bills. These are sophisticated cities and counties are sophisticated
- 32:15entities with their own council that they bid this out. And the most of
- 32:20the bids in the case were twenty five to thirty percent that were accepted.
- 32:23So, you know, I think the cities and counties got a bar.
- 32:25Again, ultimately, the Attorney General's calculation, I haven't verified it is that
- 32:30his lawyers are going to get paid like seven seven point something percent, and
- 32:35and and the city and county lawyers who are going to get a similar percent,
- 32:38And you know that to me is says that that that those are reasonable
- 32:44given the risk and the incredible work that went on and what there's particularly with
- 32:47respect of the cities and counties. Don't forget the attorney generals settled the case
- 32:52with the distributors prior to us bringing bringing the city and county claims against them,
- 32:57or very early in that in that in that process, we didn't think
- 33:00there was enough money on the table for that, and that's what prompted my
- 33:04clients to hire us to bring those cases. Ultimately, that resulted in an
- 33:09additional four hundred million dollars compared to the seventy seven million the attorney general.
- 33:14God. So the net recovery just on that settlement, after paying the lawyers
- 33:19for the cities and counties is three hundred and twenty two million dollars. You
- 33:22know, I think we were worth what we got. That's four times the
- 33:28fees the fees that we'll get out of this. That's not a bad that's
- 33:30not a bad deal for the victims of the opioid epidemic in the state of
- 33:36West Virginia. So you get throughout a number earlier you talked about hours and
- 33:39fees and looked your private business. But so did you say your law firm
- 33:45put up like thirteen million over six years. What the order says is that
- 33:49all of the law firms evolved in the West Virginia litigation, including the state's
- 33:52lawyers, the court accounted for thirteen million to be paid back. Okay,
- 33:58that's all law firms. Yeah, which which comes out off the top off
- 34:01the fifteen percent that the court carved out for fees. And it's not in
- 34:07addition to the fifteen percent fee. Let me read you what Greg Thomas said,
- 34:12and he is a representati of the West Virginia Citizens against Lawsuit Abuse,
- 34:15and he said, we hope the legislature will do a thorough review of these
- 34:17contracts and fees being paid to avoid any such windfall for a handful of attorneys
- 34:22in the future. That's what he said. He said, well, that's
- 34:27what he said. Yeah, so we have twenty five firms, three hundred
- 34:30professionals. It's not a handful and it's not a windfall. I point out
- 34:35that the settlement itself and the structure of how the settlement would go with something
- 34:43that the Attorney General brought to the legislature and got passed and the Court of
- 34:49the both the court approved our division of fees and money to the clients,
- 34:53and the legislature approved it, so to approved the structure of how that would
- 34:58go, ultimately leaving it to the judges to decide. So this is not
- 35:00something that the legislature is unaware of. This is something that the legislature I
- 35:05think explicitly approved. And this may go down a rabbit hole, but I
- 35:08think what the legislature proved was a state law concerning law firms that work specifically
- 35:15for the Attorney General, and you all work for the cities and county.
- 35:16So I'm not sure the state law applied in the case. Now I'm talking
- 35:20about specifically with respect to the open Woid litigation. The member of mandum of
- 35:23understanding between the cities and counties and the Attorney General was approved by the court.
- 35:28The Attorney General then took it to the legislature and enacted it and had
- 35:32it enacted, and ultimately the West Virginia First Foundation then gets approved. So
- 35:38all of these documents is the idea that we were splitting money between the state
- 35:42and the cities and counties, and the idea that the warriors would be paid
- 35:45out of that fee subject to what the court recommended, was something the legislature
- 35:50had before in this specific case and approved it. I don't think. I
- 35:53think there might have been one or two votes against it, if any,
- 35:57and the entire legus would you if finally, and I do think there is
- 36:01that this story requires what you are providing, and that is an explanation of
- 36:06what was involved in six years of litigation. So I do get that.
- 36:10However, when people read the story and they see, okay, the total
- 36:15settlements came to nine hundred and forty million and the attorneys get one hundred and
- 36:17forty one million of that is there, in your opinion objectively it kind of
- 36:22a shock value there that people look and go, wow, the attorneys got
- 36:25rich on this. I think everything about the opioid epidemic in the litigation is
- 36:34shocking. The problem that resulted in cases. In the case that recovered,
- 36:39and after we get the bankruptcy claims, we'll be over a billion dollars.
- 36:43And I should point out this is twice what cities and counties and states who
- 36:49opted into the national settlements are getting. I mean, we did a really
- 36:51good job here, and so that's why I decided to come on and explain
- 36:55this, because it's easy for somebody to like Greg Thomas, to to talk
- 37:00about large numbers without giving us the context desires. We had a big our
- 37:05state faced a big, unprecedented problem. We were at the epicenter of the
- 37:08europioid crisis. A bunch of lawyers stepped up and devoted hours and thousands and
- 37:15hundreds of thousands of hours for a couple of years. My firm was doing
- 37:17nothing else but this. So you're saying the state you're saying the state did
- 37:21better. You're saying West Virginia, which is the epicenter of the UPRO crisis,
- 37:23did better in these settlements because of what you all did. Yes,
- 37:28I mean I think it's I think that is an established factor, and go
- 37:30look at the other settlements and roughly, I think we did about twice as
- 37:34good as everybody else. All right, Tony Majestro who's a West Virginia Association
- 37:37for Justice, also an attorney with Majestro Law, Majestro Powell and Charleston or
- 37:42Pale Majestro and Charleston. Tony, good to talk to you. Thanks for
- 37:45coming on, Thank you for let me explain things Abby. Sure, all
- 37:47right, talk line continues. We'll return just to all the state met coal
- 37:50make steel. Did you know that metallurgical coal impacts our daily lives in many
- 37:54ways. It's the coal used in the steel making process. Driving over a
- 37:58bridge or loading your family into an automobile, you experienced the value of metallurgical
- 38:01coal. The most met coal produced in the United States is found right here
- 38:06in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure, comfort and convenient all made possible by metallurgical
- 38:10coal. Learn more about met coal in the impact of the Metallurgical Coal Producers
- 38:15Association at Metcoal Producers dot Com and remember met coal Make steel. Okay,
- 38:21I have thirty minutes to get everything I need for my Halloween party. Gotta
- 38:23move it like Pacman to outrun the ghost this year. Oh no, I
- 38:30forgot to get gifts. I know I'll get the pac Man Halloween Scratchers.
- 38:35They'll love them. Over four point five million in total prizes up for grabs
- 38:38on West Virginia Lottery Halloween Scratchers. Get them before they go steal the many
- 38:45time only must be eighteen or older to play. Please play responsible. Pacman
- 38:47is registered and copyrighted by Bandai Namco Entertainment, Inc. You're listening to talk
- 38:51Line on Metro News The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the
- 38:58Mountain state's only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million
- 39:02hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking
- 39:07down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Hurdles and other
- 39:12reptiles and amphibians are kind of at the center of illegal collection, wildlife pouting
- 39:19issue and West Virginia is not exempt from that. Whether it's hunting and fishing
- 39:23news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. People will
- 39:28call when they're standing right next to a rattlesnake on a trail or in the
- 39:31middle of a road. I try to catch every one so that we could
- 39:36market or see if it's one of the snakes that we had previously marked.
- 39:39West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven h six am and for
- 39:45your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news
- 39:49and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News, the
- 39:52Voice of West Virginia. Everybody, It's Tony Kuritti and I'm Brad Howse,
- 39:58and that makes two of the three g guys that bring you the podcast entitled
- 40:00Creatively Enough Three Guys. Before the game, it's our opportunity to really drill
- 40:06down on WVU football and basketball. We break down the opponent and then review
- 40:10every single game. We'll give you some numbers, we'll bicker back and forth,
- 40:15we'll take your calls, your text your tweets, and get into some
- 40:17of your questions and we invite you to join us each and every episode at
- 40:21three Guys before the Game from Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens
- 40:25quick and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast.
- 40:31Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If
- 40:36you see news happening, become a Metro News Hawk by texting news to three
- 40:39five six five one. If you take a picture or video of what you
- 40:44see, submit that as well. Text the word news to three five six
- 40:47five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates applying. Please
- 40:52don't text and drive. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchibill is brought to
- 41:10you by in Covid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 41:15about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more talent from me and COVID
- 41:19Ensured studios in the Dale Miller Building, Jack Potts and the millions in West
- 41:22Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Getting the Powabaut drawings Mondays,
- 41:25Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Megamillions drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you
- 41:30be the next big winner. Play today the Powabaut jackpotters eight hundred and thirty
- 41:34five million dollars. The megaming is Jackpott two hundred and sixty seven million dollars.
- 41:37Please welcome Brad mcclinney via Skype. We wanted Brad, how are you
- 41:44good? Good? So, Governor Justice's financial report, as required by his
- 41:49Senate candidacy, has been posted. You have written about it in detail,
- 41:52and as we expected, there's some fallout from it or some comment and criticism.
- 41:57What have you heard? Yes, these mandatory financial reports are meant to
- 42:04be tools for the public to look at their senators or candidates for Senate and
- 42:10assess what is your income, where does your financial loyalty lie? Do you
- 42:15have any debts that could be concerning potential conflicts of interest? They can be
- 42:21used that way for anyone. And yes, they also, once they are
- 42:25filed, become the grist of politics. So, as we might have expected,
- 42:31the political campaigns in opposition to Jim Justices run for US Senate have weighed
- 42:38in. Democrats weighed in in advance at the national level, and they criticized
- 42:43Justice for taking a sweet time and even filing this and then the campaign of
- 42:47Alex Mooney, the congressman who also wants to win the Republican nomination for US
- 42:54Senate, weighed in as well, criticizing Justice for going one hundred some days
- 43:01beyond the original due date, but also alleging that the Justices finances don't quite
- 43:07add up. Justice, of course made his name as a businessman. These
- 43:13finances show a lot of assets, but not much income coming in, and
- 43:16also significant liabilities. Finally, Senate Finance Chairman Eric Tar a regular critic of
- 43:24Governor Justice, and I should say that that Tar is now officially an endorser
- 43:30of Alex Mooney's campaign. He raised some specific questions about what he saw in
- 43:35this Justice report. One of the questions is what is the deal with the
- 43:40multimillion dollar loans from former senior advisor Brake Carey to Jim Justice. The other
- 43:47question raised by Tar was there are there are lines of credit at zero percent
- 43:52interest from some of the Justice holdings, the Greenbrier itself, some of the
- 44:00coal companies, and so Tar's question generally was, well, how does that
- 44:05work a line of credit specifically from the businesses to the owner Jim Justice at
- 44:12zero percent interest? And is there any is there any conflict there that we
- 44:19the public should be asking more questions about? Rd Maclini Metro News dy correspondent
- 44:22Thank you, Brad, appreciate it. Read his report at wv Metronews dot
- 44:28com. It's flu season. Arm yourself against the flu by getting your flu
- 44:31shot at Fruit Pharmacy Today. Fruth also has other vaccines such as pneumonia,
- 44:36shingles, whooping coffin more. Please speak to your local Fruit pharmacist about your
- 44:40vaccine needs free with most insurance, no appointment needed. Be prepared for this
- 44:45flu season with over the counter medications, vitamin's, cough drops, tissues,
- 44:50and more. Order online at Fruit Pharmacy dot com for curbside pickup or local
- 44:53delivery. Fruit your hometown Family Pharmacy does your business. The mobile workforce employees
- 45:01love it, but you know it can be challenging to keep them connected,
- 45:05productive and secure. Sitting NEETs Mobile workforce solutions give businesses the tools to stay
- 45:09connected and productive even when employees are on the go. Mobile security and device
- 45:15management, secure remote access, cloud based collaboration tools, and more. We
- 45:20have solutions for your needs and budget. Call us today at eight four four
- 45:23sitting Net or visit us at sittynet dot net. This is talk line on
- 45:30Metro News The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain state's
- 45:37only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quartermillion hunters and anglers
- 45:42across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and
- 45:45fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Hurdles and other reptiles and amphibians
- 45:52are kind of at the center of illegal collection wildlife proaching issue, and West
- 45:58Virginia is not exempt from that. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just
- 46:02compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. People will call when they're
- 46:07standing right next door rattlesnake on a trail or in the middle of a road.
- 46:10I try to catch everyone so that we can market or see if it's
- 46:15one of the snakes that we had previously marked. West Virginia Outdoors covers it
- 46:20all Saturday mornings at seven o six am, and for your daily fix,
- 46:23Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the
- 46:28woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News. The Voice of West Virginia.
- 46:34Hey everybody, it's Tony Curiti and I'm Brad Howse. And that makes
- 46:37two of the three guys that bring you the podcast entitled creatively Enough, Three
- 46:40Guys Before the Game. It's our opportunity to really drill down on WVU football
- 46:45and basketball. We break down the opponent and then review every single game.
- 46:50We'll give you some numbers, we'll bicker back and forth, we'll take your
- 46:53calls, your text your tweets, and get into some of your questions,
- 46:57and we invite you to join us each and every episode. Three Guys Before
- 47:00the Game from Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick and for
- 47:05decades, you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now
- 47:10here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see
- 47:15news happening, become a Metro News Hawk by texting news to three five six
- 47:19five one. If you take a picture or video of what you see,
- 47:22submit that as well. Text the word news to three five six five one
- 47:27to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text
- 47:30and drive. Talk line from me and Cove Insurance Studios Network security is serious
- 47:54business, and sitting net is serious about protecting your business and your employees from
- 48:00day's constant barrage of cyber security threats. Let's city Net be your cybersecurity hero.
- 48:05When it comes to technology. Sitting Net connects, protects, and perfects.
- 48:09Let me do some texts at three or four talk three or four text
- 48:13Hoppy. I understand, Texter says, lawyers need to get paid. However,
- 48:16I lost a sibling to opioids. What are my parents get? My
- 48:21parents get to watch lawyers get miggans and miggans and more handed out to government
- 48:24while they have to eat the cost in time they put into attempting to save
- 48:30my sibling. Says the texture. I need to I'm pretty sure that how
- 48:37the money is distributed would be in the settlements, and I probably need to
- 48:44do a deeper dive on then. Text three or four talks for you,
- 48:50Hoppy. How much does each lawyer on average get from the settlement? I
- 48:52don't know. There's like three hundred lawyers involved. According to Tony. Somebody
- 48:57said three hundred. I don't know how they do that. I mean,
- 49:00there are the specific amounts for the law firm law firms, and I think
- 49:05there's a link to that in Brad Michaelhenny's story. I think Brad's initial story
- 49:10may have well had a link which said how much each law firm got as
- 49:17to each attorney. I couldn't tell you Text three or four, Talk three
- 49:24or four. Happy you think he's going to say it wasn't justified. It's
- 49:30outrageous. That is the amount. Oh please hoppy. The paint is drying
- 49:38too slowly, says the texture. I'll be what what was this lawsuit all
- 49:45about? Getting rich? Because we know no one went to jail and Big
- 49:50Pharma is still in business. No change on the drug problem, says the
- 49:54Texture. Uppies it corrected. Zero dollars from the OPI old lawsuits go directly
- 50:04to those affected by it. Again, I don't know. Usually in settlements
- 50:08it says how the money's going to go. I'm would imagine that the money
- 50:14or the bulk of the money goes toward either treatment or prevention. I don't
- 50:21know what form three three or four, Talk three or four. I'll be
- 50:29how much with the lawyers charging per hour, I don't think there was an
- 50:31hour. They're on contingency fees on this, so they keep track of their
- 50:37hours but it's but it's it's a percent. What works out is a percent
- 50:42of the settlement. So my understanding is it's not like, wow, this
- 50:45is how many It was three hundred dollars an hour, Therefore you oweys this
- 50:47much money. I don't think it was out. I think it was contingency
- 50:50fees that they were paid. They were paid based on a negotiated percentage or
- 50:55amount based on the size of the settlement. This is talk line on Metro
- 50:59News. At News is the voice of West Virginia. Alrighty, our number
- 51:31two talk line on the Metro News radio network all across the great state of
- 51:36West Virginia. Let me get back to the size of the fees paid to
- 51:40the lawyers and the opioid settlements. Again, state getting state communities getting nine
- 51:47hundred and forty million dollars out of various pharmaceutical and pharmaceutical A related companies in
- 51:53the opioid settlements in these cases, and of that roughly fifteen percent. And
- 52:01again it's kind of a complicated formula or formulas. It depends on whether the
- 52:06law firms we're working for the state or for cities and counties. And then
- 52:08where it just is it kind of gets a bit complicated, but it averages
- 52:14about fifteen percent of the nine hundred forty million totals, so that the attorney's
- 52:16fees add up to about one hundred and forty one million dollars. Two firms
- 52:22national firm of Motley Rice and the local firm of Web Law Center. They
- 52:25served as outside council to state Attorney General Patrick Marriscy. They're in line for
- 52:30about forty two million dollars representing the state as a whole. And beyond that
- 52:36there are lead firms representing cities and counties and they're payouts like twenty two and
- 52:40a half a million to fit Simmons Law Firm of Wheeling, twenty million to
- 52:45Ferrell and Fuller of Huntington, and Palmgustro of Charleston. Let me bring in
- 52:50West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrissey on this again appoint man on part of this
- 52:55litigation. Patrick, Good morning, how are you hey. I'm doing fine
- 52:59up. Thanks for having me on on this important topic. Yeah, thanks
- 53:02for coming on. Let's just start with the big picture, and that is
- 53:06people look at this number. I had Tony Madjestrible on earlier and he was
- 53:08explaining, look You're talking about thousands of hours, hundreds of attorneys, years
- 53:13and years of litigation to get to this. Therefore, there's a justification for
- 53:16the amount. And in your opinion in Toto, is there a justification for
- 53:21one hundred and forty one Megan, No, Well, Hoppy, I'm gonna
- 53:24I'm gonna walk you through a little bit of the background, and the first
- 53:28thing I do want to say is that there was a lot of very good
- 53:30work done by all the attorneys in these cases, the attorneys for the state,
- 53:36the attorneys for the cities and the counties, and the result was phenomenal.
- 53:40I think, based on our calculation, we probably have the largest per
- 53:45capita settlements against opioid supply defendants in the nation, So huge victories for West
- 53:51Virginia. Now, in terms of the fees, this gets a little bit
- 53:55complicated. This is kind of an unusual case because it involves both the state
- 54:01of West Virginia, which I get to direct the litigation over and negotiate fees
- 54:06over, and the counties and the cities, and so the attorneys fees were
- 54:12handled differently by each So for instance, hop you know, probably from going
- 54:15back to the beginning my tenure in office, I've made it a priority to
- 54:21lower outside council fees, and in fact, when I came in, the
- 54:24contingency fee contracts for outside council were routinely thirty three percent, sometimes up to
- 54:30forty percent. That's why I put in playee in outside council policy. We've
- 54:35dramatically reduced the fees. The legislature codified that, and then since then we've
- 54:40increased our focus on it to get lower and lower fees, and in fact,
- 54:45happy in this instance, our office negotiated one of, if not the
- 54:51lowest contingency fee percentage to be paid and opioid litigation in the country, and
- 54:57it looks to be under eight percent, and I'm not a aware of any
- 55:00other state in the nation that's done that. So that's the piece that we
- 55:05bring to bear. Now, I have argued that that was a good number.
- 55:08People still can make resources on it, but we actually believe that the
- 55:14more money that goes to help people in need is a better way to spend
- 55:19the money. So we've argued to have it lower than the fifteen percent.
- 55:22We've made submissions of that. We argued for the lower fees, that's better
- 55:25for the people. So do you think then that finn Simmons Law, that
- 55:30Feral Fuller, that pal Magestro and other law firms that represented cities and counties
- 55:36got too much. Well, I think that it's up to the court now.
- 55:40The panel's going to review it. I mentioned there was a lot of
- 55:44good work that was done, but quite frankly, when you have the benefit
- 55:47of under eight percent, and we did a lot of the work right,
- 55:52and other people did too, A lot of law firms did it. I
- 55:54don't have the breakdown of every hour for what people put in, but I
- 55:59will tell you I think that the aggregant amount is too high. I think
- 56:02what the state did is phenomenal because we ended up negotiating something that was under
- 56:09eight percent. I think that the problem is the law currently limits that to
- 56:15the state based contract, not to local and city. So I do think
- 56:19that the amount is too high. I'm not going to talk about specific firms
- 56:22other than say I think everyone did a lot of very good work to counties
- 56:25and cities, but I certainly would have more money going towards the target to
- 56:30help people most need. So if again, to continue on the subject for
- 56:37just a second before I move on, but if you believe that your office
- 56:43negotiated a very very reasonable and low to reasonable amount and fees at under eight
- 56:47percent. But you think that the total amount, the aggregate of one hundred
- 56:52forty one million, is too high, then that by definition suggests that you
- 56:55believe that the other law firms that represent community cities and counties got too much.
- 57:02Well, I certainly think that the aggregate amount was too high, and
- 57:07I would have it lower, And we've proposed to have a lower hoppy we
- 57:10could actually provide to you and make it public for everyone. The difference if
- 57:15he did the fees under our amount versus the fees under the proposed order,
- 57:21and I think it would be tens of millions of dollars. So yes,
- 57:24I would like to see lower aggregate fees. I would like to see it
- 57:29much more consistent with the way I handled outside council. I think that a
- 57:32lot of people did very good work, but at the same time, I
- 57:36think that the citizens should benefit from a better negotiated rate. West Virginia Attorney
- 57:42General Patrick Morrissey would when you were very critical of the mcgrawl Attorney general's tenure
- 57:49and hiring the outside council and how much they got paid and some of those
- 57:52and were contributors to mcgrawl, etcetera, etcetera. But why didn't Why couldn't
- 57:58your office, and I don't know the of your resources, Why couldn't your
- 58:00office handle the litigation itself rather than higher outside council. Yeah, it's a
- 58:07great question. So when we're talking about something that's as complex as the opioid
- 58:12litigation and you're going in we actually had a trial hoppy. We went to
- 58:16seven weeks. There are literally dozens of lawyers that are constantly working on it.
- 58:22We don't have those kind of resources to handle a trial of that size
- 58:25in house, so hoppy, we've actually brought a lot of the work inside
- 58:30the offense. I think you know that that's been widely reported. But there
- 58:34are going to be some cases that are so large that a state of the
- 58:37size of West Virginia, with the amount of lawyers that can handle a big
- 58:42case going to trial, we need the assistance of outside council. So what
- 58:45we've done is in select instances we've brought outside counsel in. And as I
- 58:51mentioned, I think that our fees that we negotiated, I believe of the
- 58:54best of the country, there at least one of the best in the country,
- 58:59and that's been the philosophy that I've driven. So everyone knows that the
- 59:02taxpayer's benefit and I think that the results were outstanding. You can't get better
- 59:07than number one in the country for per capita settlements, but that's a judgment
- 59:13call to be able to maximize the dollars you can bring in. And as
- 59:15I mentioned, a lot of attorneys did a lot of really good work,
- 59:19but we wouldn't have had the ability to do all of it just outside of
- 59:22our office with the limited resources we have. Patrick Marcy's with his West Virginia
- 59:27attorney Genermalan Patrick. What I'm going to bring up next is really the subject
- 59:30for a more thorough discussion at a later date night I want to do that,
- 59:36but just briefly, I would imagine that how the money is distributed this
- 59:39nine hundred and forty miging how that money is distributed is in the settlement documents,
- 59:45so I guess I need to go back and read those, But can
- 59:46you give me an overview of how this money will be used to deal with
- 59:52the opioid crisis in West Virginia? Absolutely, so hoppy of this was a
- 59:58handle based upon an agreement between the State of West Virginia through my office and
- 1:00:02the counties and cities and not be all fifty five of the counties and virtually
- 1:00:07all the cities signed on to that, and then literally every member of the
- 1:00:13legislature signed on to it. The governor signed it into law. We wanted
- 1:00:16to have that transparency so people know where the benefit of all these sentiment dollars
- 1:00:22go. And here's the quick breakdown of it's probably going to end up being
- 1:00:27close to a billion dollars gross by the time we get done with the Purdue
- 1:00:30Farm and the other cases of that. The first thing the court will do
- 1:00:35is deduct the attorney's fees and the cost, and then that net amount three
- 1:00:40percent is going to be held by the state more just held in trust and
- 1:00:45anticipation of potential future litigation, but then in fact that the state doesn't use
- 1:00:50it or go back to the counties, the cities, and the foundation.
- 1:00:53The counties and cities get twenty four and a half percent of the dollars,
- 1:00:58and then the foundation, the West Virginia First Foundation, will get seventy two
- 1:01:04and a half percent of the Money's Hoppy, the crown jewel of this effort
- 1:01:07is the West Virginia First Foundation that's being run by eleven board members, reflecting
- 1:01:15picks from all across West Virginia. There were regional elections that were made where
- 1:01:20each region of the state got to put someone forward. It was voted on
- 1:01:23in a public meeting. Then the governor named five picks, and I'm now
- 1:01:29in the process of interviewing for an executive director that I'll bring before that board
- 1:01:34so that the board can get constituted and it can begin. And then what
- 1:01:38I would anticipate they're going to go for the creation process the by laws,
- 1:01:44They'll do a needs assessment, will hire a CFO, It'll be run like
- 1:01:47a traditional foundation, and they will have the ability to dictate how a lot
- 1:01:52of those resources get provided subject to the conditions of the settlements. Hoppy and
- 1:01:59all that, quite frankly, is available on our website and it's all transparent.
- 1:02:04If folks have any questions about it, we're happy to provide that.
- 1:02:07But I would urge people to look through the West Virginia First Memorandum of Understanding,
- 1:02:13and that's the document between my office between the counties and cities and the
- 1:02:16state, and we use that. It's the framework for how all the settlement
- 1:02:21moneyes get handled. I'll tell you what. I will review that and we
- 1:02:23will watch that closely because I think that is going to be a huge story
- 1:02:25going forward of that board and foundation how that money's distributed. One quick question
- 1:02:31about it is that would there be any mechanism for any victims of opioids to
- 1:02:39receive any money? That is, I had an interesting textbody, somebody you
- 1:02:44know had a family member who died from an opioid overdose directly resulted from the
- 1:02:50dumping of pills in West Virginia, and maybe they spend who knows how much
- 1:02:52to get their son or daughter, brother and sister into treatment or whatever they
- 1:02:57did. Is there anything for victims or would there be or could there be?
- 1:03:01So there's certainly no exclusion for victims. So the foundation or the counties
- 1:03:07and cities could look at that question and analyze it. I think that the
- 1:03:10overall goal was to really have a comprehensive approach to attack the drug problem holistically
- 1:03:19from a supply, a demand, an educational perspective, especially with the volume
- 1:03:23of fatnel and the other deadly products coming in. But hoppy, I think
- 1:03:27that's certainly available that if there's a creative proposal that goes to the board that
- 1:03:31people will take a look at it. And I do think that there's so
- 1:03:37many people that were so badly treated and you can't bring back the terrible loss
- 1:03:42of life, but you need to respect it and try to make sure another
- 1:03:45generation doesn't fall prey to senseless deaths. West Virginia Attorney General and Republican gubernatial
- 1:03:52candidate Patrick Morrisey. Patrick, thank you. Good to talk to you today.
- 1:03:55Hey, thanks, and this is a big topic and I appreciate your
- 1:03:59raising it and I know we'll talk more as the Foundation comes into sharper focus.
- 1:04:04Absolutely look forward to it. Thank you, Patrick, Thank you.
- 1:04:08All right, talk client continues. Okay, I have thirty minutes to get
- 1:04:11everything I need for my Halloween party. Gotta move it like pac Man to
- 1:04:14outrun the ghost this year. Oh no, I forgot to get gifts.
- 1:04:19I know I'll get the pac Man Halloween scratchers. They love them. Over
- 1:04:25four point five million in total prizes up for grabs on West Virginia Lottery Halloween
- 1:04:29Scratchers. Get them before they go steal the many time. Only must be
- 1:04:33eighteen or older to play. Please play responsible pac Man is registered en copyrighted
- 1:04:36by Vandai Namco Entertainment, Inc. Met Coal Makes Steel. Did you know
- 1:04:41that metallurgical coal impacts our daily lives in many ways? It's the coal used
- 1:04:45in the steel making process. Driving over a bridge or loading your family into
- 1:04:48an automobile, you experienced the value of metallurgical coal. Most met coal produced
- 1:04:53in the United States is found right here in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure,
- 1:04:58comfort and convenient all may possible by metallurgical coal. Learn more about met coole
- 1:05:01in the Impact of the Metallurgical Coal Producers Association at Metcoal Producers dot com,
- 1:05:06and remember, met coole make Steel. You're listening to talk Line on Metro
- 1:05:11News, the voice of West Virginia. What you need to know today is
- 1:05:16just a click away. WV metronews dot com as the latest statewide news stories
- 1:05:23from the capitol city to your hometown. Follow your favorite sports teams from high
- 1:05:28school to the pros. Hunting and fishing information is always on the Outdoors page,
- 1:05:32and never miss your favorite Metro News program with live streams and archived episodes.
- 1:05:39Wherever you are in the Mountain State. The information you need is at
- 1:05:43WV metronews dot com. Hi, this is Travis Jones. Joined me and
- 1:05:47coach Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six z six until eight o'clock on the
- 1:05:51Metro News radio network for the City. At Sunday nights, Statewide sports Line
- 1:05:56four wrap up the weekend sports in the Mountain State. Talk about the Mountaineers
- 1:05:59High School and the Mountaineese Conference. Plus you can join the conversation on our
- 1:06:02toll free line or on our text line at three oh four Talk three oh
- 1:06:06four. Join us every Sunday night from six h six until eight pm on
- 1:06:11Metro News. It's the City at Sunday night, Statewide sports Line. News
- 1:06:15in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro News
- 1:06:19for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow
- 1:06:25West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News hawk
- 1:06:29by texting news to three five six five one. If you take a picture
- 1:06:32or video of what you see, submit that as well. Text the word
- 1:06:36news to three five six five one to submit your tip or story. Standard
- 1:06:41texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Hey there day Weekly Here
- 1:06:45are your host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready for an epic journey.
- 1:06:48Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got all the excitement you need
- 1:06:53from sports to tech, music, pop culture, and everything in between.
- 1:06:56Join Cooper and I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating interviews, fun
- 1:07:00games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep you a bok.
- 1:07:03Metro News Hotline is your go to source for sports, news, entertainment,
- 1:07:06and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three to six on Metro
- 1:07:11News and wv Metronews dot com. Metronews talk Line with Hobby Kirchiblas brought to
- 1:07:30you by in Covid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 1:07:34about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more. Talk line from me
- 1:07:40in COVID Insurance Studios in the Miller of Building Jared hawperin Fox News Radios in
- 1:07:43Semi Valley, California for tonight's Republican presidential candidate debate. Good morning, sir,
- 1:07:48early there, I am. I am already poolside. Good morning pool
- 1:07:51side. No, I don't think so. I think you're probably getting your
- 1:07:56press pass in order and getting ready for tonight is what I imagine will be.
- 1:08:00Yeah, so I think gonna be a fascinating night, smaller slight of
- 1:08:03candidates than last time by one at least, And I think what's interesting is
- 1:08:09do the candidates change strategies from what we saw a month ago because there has
- 1:08:14not been a huge shift in polling since then. You've seen a pretty good
- 1:08:19bump for Nicky Haley, so look for her to maybe continue in sort of
- 1:08:26the fashion that she hit has, maybe even against the Bake Ramaswamy, who
- 1:08:30has also seen some polling go up, and they certainly have very different shoes
- 1:08:34on a lot of different issues. You know, you're going to have Governor
- 1:08:40de Santas Phil in that center podium. He kind of held serve last time,
- 1:08:45but played I think more of a secondary roles. That's the kind of
- 1:08:49the big moments to see kind of do that again maybe it do no harm
- 1:08:55kind of debate or does he try and break out? And obviously you know
- 1:09:00candidates are going to have to handle the facts for a second time that the
- 1:09:01front runners not participating and how is that a factor? There's counter programming that
- 1:09:06the former president's doing, and so we'll see how all of that plays out.
- 1:09:11Yeah, that's a very interesting dynamic and concerning that, what candidates other
- 1:09:18than Chris Christie will make note of the fact that Trump isn't there, or
- 1:09:21will they just kind of try to avoid that because they don't want to offend
- 1:09:27any Trump folks who are watching, although the Trump folks are probably watching Trump,
- 1:09:30you know, to listen. I think I think you have seen an
- 1:09:34increase in that kind of why isn't he here from the fantists, right.
- 1:09:41I think the fantists really believes that he does best if it's maybe a two
- 1:09:47person race like him versus Trump, and so he is going to have to
- 1:09:50start finding ways to maybe separate himself a little bit, maybe be a little
- 1:09:55bit more aggressive. Maybe not in the same way that Chris Christie is,
- 1:09:58but certainly I could see somebody like the stantists maybe making mention of who's not
- 1:10:04here in a way that kind of cast out on, you know, the
- 1:10:09seriousness of Donald Trump or something like that. Right here we are at the
- 1:10:12Reagan Library. There's an event that is being co sponsored by you know,
- 1:10:18the Reagan Foundation is set up. By the way, it is amazing the
- 1:10:21podiums or underneath the Air Force one plane. So yeah, with the mountains
- 1:10:29in the background. And so I wonder kind of with that Reagan legacy kind
- 1:10:33of looming over this event. You know, I think a lot of people
- 1:10:40can look at the Republican Party today and say, maybe it's not the same
- 1:10:43Republican Party as it wasn't a Reagan Yeah, you know, what's that legacy?
- 1:10:47What is the Reagan kind of view on foreign policy or anything? Right?
- 1:10:54You know, how does that breakthrough tonight in a way that maybe it
- 1:10:56hasn't in previous debate? Well, and on that because as the Republican Party
- 1:11:00today, and certainly there's a division in the Republican Party and far and half
- 1:11:05of it or a part of it is not anything like Ronald Reagan, and
- 1:11:10another part still was sort of hanging on to the legacy of Ronald Reagan.
- 1:11:13Yeah, it's not one. I mean, that's the thing. I think
- 1:11:14the Republican Party right now is still a party that is kind of in a
- 1:11:17lot of self self debate. And listen, that's pretty normal for a party
- 1:11:23out of power. You know. The Democrats certainly went through that. Yeah,
- 1:11:27you know that the Democratic Party today is not the Democratic Party of sty
- 1:11:30years ago. Right, and so that's normal. But I do wonder,
- 1:11:34you know, just sort of with the legacy of Reagan looming over all of
- 1:11:38this, you could see Nicki Hagley maybe making a big issue of that,
- 1:11:41maybe a Chris Christie making an issue of that. You know, those are
- 1:11:45foreign policy views that I think shift pretty closely or aligned pretty closely with with
- 1:11:50Ronald Reagan. Yeah, well you'll be there covering it live coverage Fox tonight.
- 1:11:56Yeah, we get started seven o'clock Eastern. I'm trying to do the
- 1:12:00math in my head ten o'clock Eastern time. The debate starts at nine o'clock
- 1:12:03Eastern time, which is six o'clock specific And uh, well, I can't
- 1:12:11believe that, like restaurants will still be open when I get off the air.
- 1:12:13I've never experienced that for debate. Report. Well, you'll be you'll
- 1:12:15be busy following reports. I will all right, to think of it.
- 1:12:20The thing about the life, the road not travel. Jared Alfred, Fox
- 1:12:25News Radio, and he'll be part of the Fox Radio coverage of the debate
- 1:12:28tonight. All right, good luck tonight, Thanks here, thank you,
- 1:12:30bye bye. Text toppy. Why isn't the state paying attorney's fees in buildable
- 1:12:33hours rather than contingency fees. You know, I'm not I think that's the
- 1:12:39way you handle action like this is that you're working on a contingency fee.
- 1:12:45That is, if you're the pointiffs attorney that you're filing suit, that you're
- 1:12:49working on a contingency fee. That if you get a settlement. If you
- 1:12:53get a settlement and you get a percentage of the settlement, Hoppy, these
- 1:12:57people complaining about the amount these lawyers are going to get need to look in
- 1:13:00the mirror. How much are they donating to Trump's legal fees. I guess
- 1:13:03they don't see anything wrong with the amount Trump's lawyers are getting. If these
- 1:13:06lawyers work for the state to get settlements, then they deserve to get paid,
- 1:13:11says the texture. Hoppy asked Patrick how much each individual who was hooked
- 1:13:18on these pills is going to get and when is the check going out?
- 1:13:24Well, I, well, I'll be going to be a foundation to keep
- 1:13:31under the microscope. It will and I had a text on this earlier,
- 1:13:34and that'll be part of our job and other media in West Virginia to cover
- 1:13:40this foundation and not only the creation of the foundation, but also that it's
- 1:13:45meetings and how they decide how they're going to spend the money, because this
- 1:13:47is a lot of money, a lot of money. I'll be the reason
- 1:13:56AG's office could not handle the case internally does not so come down to resource.
- 1:14:00There's no offense to the AG's office, but their attorneys don't have the
- 1:14:03skill or experience to handle cases like this. Well, I do get.
- 1:14:09I do get the use of outside council on something like this, where you
- 1:14:13get a law firm or firms that are experienced of a body of experience in
- 1:14:17this kind of litigation, which is extremely complicated, very very complicated. So
- 1:14:24I do get that. And they did arrange a contingency fee for those law
- 1:14:29firms who handled the state portion of under eight percent. All right, we're
- 1:14:35gonna take a break and come back on Metro News talk Line. When we
- 1:14:39come back, Alex Mooney, West Virginia second District Congressman in US and a
- 1:14:43candidate, So we'll get the latest on what's going on now in the House
- 1:14:46of Representatives on this whole budget issue and is there going to be a government
- 1:14:50shutdown that's coming up next. This is talk Line on Metro News. Metro
- 1:14:54News is the voice of West Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get a
- 1:14:59news update with the Metro News Radio Network. Finalance happening statewide this hour,
- 1:15:02all across the Great State of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News. I'm
- 1:15:10Chris Lawrence. Say. Barbara County woman is pleading guilty to the shooting death
- 1:15:13of her husband after a successful appeal of her twenty twenty murder conviction. Twenty
- 1:15:16three year old Carle Reid was convicted of second agree murder and sentenced to forty
- 1:15:20years in prison for the killing of Marcus Fagans, but the state Supreme Court
- 1:15:24throughout the conviction after the judge failed to instruct the jury the shooting could have
- 1:15:27been accidental. Instead of a new trial, Reid has agreed to plead guilty
- 1:15:30voluntary manslaughter and faces a maximum of fifteen years in prison. The plea agreement
- 1:15:34requires her to serve at least a third of that sentence until sentencing. She's
- 1:15:38on home confinement. Atlanta based Arcelin has announced the acquisition of Bell Chemical in
- 1:15:43Kanawa County and oppress release. Announcing the sale, Arceland said the purchase enables
- 1:15:46them to expand their product presence into markets adjacent to their core chemistries and businesses.
- 1:15:51Bell Chemical, located at the former DuPont Plan in Bell As a leading
- 1:15:55manufacturer of methylamines and derivatives with a wide range of product applications. They boys
- 1:16:00sixty people. Parkersburg City Council approves an ordinance that outlast camping, cooking,
- 1:16:03for habitation or storage of personal items on an extended basis on public property.
- 1:16:09The measure, aimed at cracking down on potential problems at the homeless in the
- 1:16:12city, was approved on a vote of seven to one forbidding the activity on
- 1:16:15streets, sidewalks, parks, parking lots, public rights of way or under
- 1:16:18bridges. Mayor Time Joyce backs the measure and says it protects city investments in
- 1:16:21quality of life things like the new three mile trail being built is designed for
- 1:16:28bicycling, walking, jogging, etc. It's just, you know, it's
- 1:16:33not the place for homeless persons. You're listening to Metro and News, the
- 1:16:36Voice of West Virginia when the Mountaineers play. The best game date coverage is
- 1:16:43on Metro News. WVU travels to Fort Worth this Saturday to take on the
- 1:16:46TCU Horn Frogs, Joing Hoppy, Kirchibill, Kyle Wiggs, Brad Howe and
- 1:16:50the rest of the Metro News crew starting at four pm for the Kickoff special,
- 1:16:55followed by the Countdown and the Vandalia Health Sports broutch. During the game,
- 1:17:00it's Game Line, then after the game, it's the wrap Up Show.
- 1:17:02Get the most comprehensive and candid coverage of the Mountaineers on Metro News,
- 1:17:08the Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia, here are some numbers for you.
- 1:17:13Forty one the percent of West Virginians with high blood pressure. Seven.
- 1:17:17We rank seventh in the nation for prevalence of stroke one. We also lead
- 1:17:23the nation and prevalence of heart attack. High blood pressure is called the silent
- 1:17:27killer because many people don't know they have it. High blood pressure can lead
- 1:17:30to heart attack or stroke. So talk to your doctor and learn your blood
- 1:17:33pressure. Knowing those numbers could just save your life. Brought to you by
- 1:17:36the Benadom Foundation in the American Heart Association. Mercer County commissioners are getting heat
- 1:17:43from a proposed leash ordinance they're considering for dogs in the county. It's a
- 1:17:46measure that would require pads to be leashed or confined to the owner's property.
- 1:17:50Although not intended for hunting dogs, the Commission is getting a lot of pushback
- 1:17:55from hunters who typically don't hunt with dogs on their own property, but might
- 1:17:59be object to this ordinance if it is approved. It was passed through first
- 1:18:01rating earlier this week from the Metro News anchored Ask I'm Chris Lawrence talk line
- 1:18:20from me in COVID Sure and Studios, jackpots and the millions here in West
- 1:18:24Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Getting the pieball drawings Mondays,
- 1:18:28Wednesdays and Saturdays, and the Mega Meens drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays.
- 1:18:30Will you be the next big Winter Plate? Today? The powerball jack potter
- 1:18:33is eight hundred thirty five million dollars, the Mega Means jack pot two hundred
- 1:18:38sixty seven million dollars. Okay, follow me here. Speaker Kevin McCarthy is
- 1:18:44going to do an add on on border issues on a continuing resolution to try
- 1:18:48to break through this budget impass, which if you don't have something worked out
- 1:18:54by midnight on Saturday, you'll have a government government shutdown. So yesterday the
- 1:19:00House voted to advance four appropriations bills, a move that McCarthy allies hope would
- 1:19:06build some goodwill to the holdouts there. And as they do that, the
- 1:19:12McCarthy and his allies are putting together a continuing resolution, but as kind of
- 1:19:16a sweetener, he's expected to add on a border crackdown bill that would include
- 1:19:24numerous Trump area policies Trump Air policies, like requiring authorities to detain all migrants
- 1:19:29or return them to Mexico or their home country, and restart construction of the
- 1:19:33border wall. So that would be part of apparently that would be part of
- 1:19:35the stopgap measure to try to get everybody, all the Republicans on boarder.
- 1:19:40Let me bring an Alex Mooney, West Virginia, Republican Congressman of the second
- 1:19:43District, also us in a Canada congressman, good morning, good to have
- 1:19:45you back. So did I describe that accurately? Is that where things are?
- 1:19:49Yeah? You did? You did? That's pretty accurate. Okay,
- 1:19:53where are you? Where are you? Then? On all this? Well,
- 1:19:56I think we should do more. I mean, this is like Lucy
- 1:20:00Charlie Brown, the football man. This is my ninth year in congress.
- 1:20:01Hoppy, We've they've been doing this, but we should have waited until four
- 1:20:04days before. I mean, this whole thing was designed to put us up
- 1:20:09against the fence and having very bad options. But I mean I think,
- 1:20:13look, I'm not taking anything off the table as far as how I might
- 1:20:15vote on Saturday, which the last day of the month, when some agencies
- 1:20:18might might close down if we don't pass the regular spending bills. I'm just
- 1:20:23saying we need a plan that balances the budget. I know you talk about
- 1:20:25this on your show, and it's been nine years and it's going to keep
- 1:20:28happening. We have to control spending, control the debt and the deficit.
- 1:20:32And today with the wopeness going on in government, not just the border,
- 1:20:35the borders off and given more money to the border patrol agents to import eleegal
- 1:20:41immigrants because because Biden's flavoringly breaking the law, he's just bringing an end so
- 1:20:45it's not a matter of funding. We have to force them do their job.
- 1:20:47But they got wopeness going on in the energy sector, which affects West
- 1:20:50Virginia. I commended Ronymore. You know, he's running from my seat led
- 1:20:55a group of people. It wouldn't bank with companies at the criminate against Cole
- 1:20:59Well, we need to stop the world this in the financial sector, we
- 1:21:00need to stop transgender sex change surgeries in the military. There's a lot of
- 1:21:03things we need to do, but I think the voters gave us to mandate
- 1:21:06to do. In addition to the border wall and to other ideas that are
- 1:21:12out there. Okay, I do get where you're coming from on those things,
- 1:21:15but there is the reality of what can be done now prior to the
- 1:21:20government shutting down, and the options if you want to if you want to
- 1:21:25keep the government from shutting down, which I think you do, but we'll
- 1:21:28get to that. The options are the options are pretty limited right now,
- 1:21:31considering it would have to pass the Senate as well. So therefore, the
- 1:21:33specific question which I would like you to answer is that is that McCarthy's going
- 1:21:40to put forward a continuing resolution that would have some strict immigration legislation in there.
- 1:21:47Would you support or oppose that? Well, I said, I'm not
- 1:21:51teaming off table. I mean, I'm going to consider the options at that
- 1:21:54time, Hoppy, but we still, as you did say in your show,
- 1:21:58we did finally yesterday for the first time, but we did pass one
- 1:22:01bill funding bill for the Veterans Affairs. But yesterday we went ahead and pass
- 1:22:05the consideration of the Agricultural bill, and then we have the Foreign Operations Bill.
- 1:22:10We're working on all this week, so I want to see where we
- 1:22:13get to. We're not there yet. We still have today, Tomorrow,
- 1:22:15Friday. I'll stay over the weekend. I'll stay next week. We still
- 1:22:18have the chance to do this right and get progress on many of the spending
- 1:22:23bills as we can the proper way. But I would not. I would
- 1:22:27not be in favor of just kicking the can down the road another thirty days
- 1:22:30and giving Barack Obama unlimited spending authority. Joe Biden, sorry, Joe Biden.
- 1:22:35I keep seeking for Obama Biden administration from my first two years. But
- 1:22:40giving Joe Biden unlimited authority, I mean they act the same. They're both
- 1:22:43trying to radily transform America. Anyway, But yes, thank you for gret
- 1:22:46you. I would not be giving Joe Biden unlimited authorities do whatever he wants.
- 1:22:49The I R S Agents, you know, the two tier system with
- 1:22:53justice come out of Apartment Justice. There's a lot of issues. I think
- 1:22:57the voters expect us, expect us to push back on that, not just
- 1:23:00kick the can down the run another thirty days, because I'll be on your
- 1:23:02show a month from now having this exact same conversation. Happy, Well,
- 1:23:06we have the exact same conversation thirty days with another continuing resolution. So I'm
- 1:23:12gonna wait and see how things look on Friday or Saturday before I commit one
- 1:23:15way or another on that. Okay. So, but as you well know,
- 1:23:17you can only do and you can look. You can take a principal
- 1:23:20stand, which it sounds like you want to do, but you can only
- 1:23:23accomplish what you have the votes to accomplish. So it comes up on Saturday.
- 1:23:29If you don't have the votes to accomplish what you and some others in
- 1:23:31the House want to accomplish, then are you okay with taking what you would
- 1:23:36believe would be a principle stand and shutting down the government. No, I
- 1:23:41don't think we're gonna shut down the government. I would not be for shutting
- 1:23:45down the government. I still think we can at least pass the military funding
- 1:23:48bill so we keep the military paid. I would I would be for really
- 1:23:51sticking what we call around here, sticking with regular order and passing those spending
- 1:23:56bills. One at a time. Look, I'm gonna I'm not gonna lose
- 1:23:59a lot of sleep if the Environmental Protection Agency it does not pass and that
- 1:24:02gets shut down, I'm just not gonna go out. I'd be okay with
- 1:24:05that. There's other things I would not be okay with. So I just
- 1:24:09think we should pass a spending plan. We should but a spending plan that's
- 1:24:13conservative, and I'll have to look at the options. I think we can
- 1:24:15get several of them through. There's still time to get several of them through.
- 1:24:18And there might be a short term measure that gets passed. Whether or
- 1:24:23not I vote for it, I don't know. It depends what's in there.
- 1:24:24It's not going to be what we call a clean resolution, meaning no
- 1:24:28restrictions whatsoever. You just talked about the border security issues. Maybe there's some
- 1:24:31other things we could put in a spending plan, a short term spending plan,
- 1:24:35you know. So I'm not gonna take it off the table, but
- 1:24:38I you know, it's not going to solve the problem. The problem is
- 1:24:42it doesn't solve the problem down the road. Okay. So one of the
- 1:24:45things being talked about, and it gets talked about a lot, and Republicans
- 1:24:49and Conference Committee last week talked about this and that is creating a commission to
- 1:24:54examine the national debt. I know maybe people roll their eyes at a commission
- 1:24:58and a blue ribbon commission, oh my god, but there is some there
- 1:25:01are some smart people. There are some smart people saying, you know,
- 1:25:03if you had a commission like the Border, like the Base commission, that
- 1:25:08makes recommendations and then Congress votes it up or down, that it would be
- 1:25:13easier for Congress to do something about runaway spending. Would you support or oppose
- 1:25:18the creation of a debt commission or a National debt Commission? Well, I
- 1:25:26mean I would be okay with creating a commission. Hoppy, but both parties
- 1:25:30know what we need to do. And this isn't a Parson comment because both
- 1:25:31parties need to be better when it comes to spending. I think we know
- 1:25:35what we need to do. There's been plenty of studies out there. We
- 1:25:38need to cut spending, we need to say no to spending. We need
- 1:25:41reforms. We all knew that. I'm okay with a commission, but I
- 1:25:45don't know that that changes anything. We just need the appetite. We're seeing
- 1:25:48it right now. It's like, are we actually gonna cut spending and reigning
- 1:25:51in government or not, you know, and on that and I'm sorry interrupted,
- 1:25:55Go ahead, I interrupted you, And I have another question. All
- 1:25:57right, Well, okay, so you know, I get I mean,
- 1:26:00I do get Republicans and to some reget others who who want to reign in
- 1:26:04spending. The kinds of things that Republicans are talking about now and cutting and
- 1:26:10I'm talking about the House is strictly discretionary spending, which is only about one
- 1:26:15sixth of all federal spending. So why are Republicans willing to say we want
- 1:26:20to cut spending, we want to cut spending, but they're only willing to
- 1:26:24cut what is amounts to one sixth of the budget. You don't want to
- 1:26:27touch social security, don't want to touch medicare, you don't want to touch
- 1:26:30the military, you don't want to touch border security. So why is all
- 1:26:32that stuff off the table? How do you think both part you need to
- 1:26:36come together making sure those programs stay solvent and we when why I was on
- 1:26:42the Budget Committee my first two years, we did pass some reforms to make
- 1:26:45those solvent and make them, you know, pace themselves better. So I
- 1:26:48mean in the short term and long term. We do have to deal with
- 1:26:51those issues as well, but you know, right now we're just dealing with
- 1:26:56the spending bills and those are things we can look at as well. West
- 1:27:00Virginia Second District Congressman, US Center Accunta Republican Alex Mooney. We'll get you
- 1:27:05back maybe Monday, which I'd like to see what happens on Saturday. Okay,
- 1:27:09all right, sounds good. All right, thanks Alex. Good to
- 1:27:12talk to West Virginia congressman. Now and US Senate can Alex and money talklink
- 1:27:15continues. We'll go right back. As West Virginians, we are proud of
- 1:27:18the natural beauty of the Mountain State, and at ZMM Architects and Engineers,
- 1:27:23our goal is to provide design solutions that give people that same pride in our
- 1:27:28built environment. That commitment to quality can be seen in educational facilities throughout the
- 1:27:32state, from Edgewood Elementary School to Huntington East Middle School and at the expanded
- 1:27:38Wood County Technical Center. ZMM Architects and Engineers, you see us in your
- 1:27:42community every day. WVU Medicine Children's has been named the number one children's hospital
- 1:27:50in West Virginia by US News and World Report. For the third year in
- 1:27:55a row. We're the largest group of pediatric, primary specialty and high maternal
- 1:28:00care providers in the state, and we're home to the state's only pediatric cardiac
- 1:28:04surgery program and pediatric epilepsy monitoring unit. Trust the top children's hospital in the
- 1:28:11state, w VU Medicine Children's Visit WVU kids dot com. This is talk
- 1:28:16Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginian. What you need to
- 1:28:23know today is just a click away wv metronews dot com as the latest statewide
- 1:28:29news stories from the capital city to your hometown. Follow your favorite sports teams
- 1:28:33from high school to the pros. Hunting and fishing information is always on the
- 1:28:38Outdoors page, and never miss your favorite Metro News program with live streams and
- 1:28:44archived episodes wherever you are in the Mountain State. The information you need is
- 1:28:48at wv metronews dot com. Hi, this is Travis Jones. Joined me
- 1:28:54and coach Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six zero six until eight o'clock on
- 1:28:58the Metro News Radio network for the City. Next Sunday Nights, Statewide sports
- 1:29:01Line, we'll wrap up the week in sports in the Mountain State, talk
- 1:29:03about the Mountaineers High School and the Mountaineese Conference. Plus you can join the
- 1:29:09conversation on our toll free line or on our text line at three oh four
- 1:29:12Talk three oh four. Join us every Sunday night from six ozho six until
- 1:29:15eight pm on Metro News It's the City at Sunday nights statewide sports line.
- 1:29:20News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro
- 1:29:26News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your
- 1:29:30fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News
- 1:29:34hawk by texting News two three five six five one. If you take a
- 1:29:39picture or video of what you see, submit that as well. Text the
- 1:29:42word news to three five six five one to submit your tip or story.
- 1:29:46Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Hey there day weekly
- 1:29:51here your host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready for an epic journey.
- 1:29:55Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got all the excitement you need
- 1:29:59from sports to tech, music, pop culture, and everything in between.
- 1:30:01Join Cooper and I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating interviews, fun
- 1:30:06games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep you a book.
- 1:30:10Metronews Hotline is your go to source for sports, news, entertainment,
- 1:30:13and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three to six on Metro News
- 1:30:17and wb metronews dot com. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought
- 1:30:35to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do
- 1:30:40you care about most? Visitingcovid dot com to learn more Talk line from me
- 1:30:44in COVID Church Studios. Please welcome Miya McGinnis, who is president of the
- 1:30:47Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, who is watching, probably with great angst
- 1:30:51of what's happening under the Capitol. Done. Good morning, Mamya'm good to
- 1:30:54talk to you again. How are you good morning? I'm good. I'd
- 1:30:58say it's angst, fuck, frustration, and just kind of dismay the state
- 1:31:01of our politics. Well, okay, so let me a little background here
- 1:31:06is that there was a by Parson Agreement of the Fiscal Responsibility Act, which
- 1:31:11set the spending for the next fiscal year, and under that there was an
- 1:31:15agreement that would actually at least hold some of the spending levels at current levels.
- 1:31:20I didn't do a ton about the deficit, but it does help some.
- 1:31:25But with that, wouldn't you think there's an obligation by all members of
- 1:31:29Congress to then say, okay, that was what we agreed to, so
- 1:31:30now we have to pass the spending within that agreement. I would, and
- 1:31:35you summarized that perfectly, right. So we had the death ceiling showdown,
- 1:31:39and out of it came and actually a decent first step of a fiscal plan.
- 1:31:44It was going to save one to two trillion dollars. That's not nearly
- 1:31:46enough to get us where we need, but it's certainly an impressive start.
- 1:31:50And so within that plan, they set the spending caps for the next two
- 1:31:54years at certain levels, and then three years after that suggested levels the level
- 1:31:59that it's supposed to be at this year. This is for discretionary spending.
- 1:32:01The Senate has passed appropriation builds that are above the level. That hasn't been
- 1:32:05covered as much in the news I've noticed, because everybody's talking about how its
- 1:32:10great it is that it's bipartisan, and that is good, But they actually
- 1:32:13break the caps on the higher level, and then the House is refusing to
- 1:32:16come in anywhere close to the level agreed upon, going significantly lower, and
- 1:32:21so nobody thought the deal was perfect. It was a good first start,
- 1:32:26but a deal's a deal. And of course, if you have all sides
- 1:32:29saying, oh, we're going to change those numbers, we're going to have
- 1:32:31another showdown, which has become all too common in Washington and where there's so
- 1:32:38little trust already. I think, when there's a clear deal, we have
- 1:32:42to stick to it. Why aren't we Why aren't they not? You and
- 1:32:45I? But why aren't they? Yeah, yeah, you and I would
- 1:32:48probably no. And the Senate, the way they got to a bipartisan agreement
- 1:32:53was they gave a little bit more spending for all the things they wanted.
- 1:32:56Oftentimes I'm a big, big fan of bipartisanship, but too often the way
- 1:32:59we get there is one side trades one unfunded thing for the other side unfunded
- 1:33:04thing. And we've had that a little bit on this deal. And as
- 1:33:06a result, over ten years, it would probably lead to about one hundred
- 1:33:11and fifty five billion dollars in additional borrowing, not as part of the deal,
- 1:33:15but the House it's a very different dynamic. You have some extreme conservatives.
- 1:33:19It's a very small group, but they are holding out because they didn't
- 1:33:24like the deal at the time. And I think the point on all of
- 1:33:27this is what they're holding out for, which means discretionary caps are too low,
- 1:33:33aren't There's not enough savings for what they want. That is a reasonable
- 1:33:38thing to hold out for, But the problem is they need to focus to
- 1:33:43moving towards entitlements and the other areas that really are where the savings would be
- 1:33:48found. Well, that's a great point. I read your als website frequently
- 1:33:54and I wrote about that today because there is the part and I just ad
- 1:33:59out, like Maximoni, the part where they want to lower spending. Discretionary
- 1:34:02spending makes up only one sixth of all federal spending and the real money,
- 1:34:08I mean that's real money too, But the biggest chunk of money is in
- 1:34:11Social security, medicare, the military, those kinds of things. And how
- 1:34:15can you reasonably get a handle on federal spending if you're not looking at the
- 1:34:20entirety of spending by the government. Yeah, that's the only way that we're
- 1:34:28going to make progress on this issue is if we deal with the fact that
- 1:34:30social Security is headed towards insolvency, we deal with the fact that Medicare is
- 1:34:33headed towards insolvency. Instead, we have everybody promising not to do those things,
- 1:34:43and a situation where we are negotiating on this tiny sliver of the budget
- 1:34:46that will never generate enough savings. And so we've got to get to a
- 1:34:51situation where our politicians are out there talking about the actual situation that we are
- 1:34:57facing and leveling with the American tax pairs, and we are willing to reward
- 1:35:01them as the voter the vote boost to do the right thing. And so
- 1:35:04far we've got completely the wrong dynamic. Miam Beginnis is with his President Committee
- 1:35:09for Responsible Federal Budget. Let's go there, because I'm kind of obsessed with
- 1:35:13the Social Security thing and I write about it a lot. Yeah, the
- 1:35:16President said recently, and just a couple of days ago he said, look,
- 1:35:21don't worry, We're not going to touch Social Security and Medicare, and
- 1:35:26other politicians say that too, And that's very good on the stump. But
- 1:35:30as you all reported that that may sound reassuring, but you all reported the
- 1:35:34Socialty Retirement Fund is scheduled to become insolvent by twenty thirty three. In that
- 1:35:40year, annual benefits would be cut by seventeen thousand, four hundred dollars,
- 1:35:44or twenty three percent for a typically newly retired dual income couple. I mean,
- 1:35:47that's that's real. That's real, and that is just around the corner.
- 1:35:51But nobody, nobody wants to address that. I always like coming on
- 1:35:58your show because you make my points better for me than I know alike on
- 1:36:02these things. Well, it's absolutely right. So there is no question that
- 1:36:06legally Social Security is going to be insolvent in about a decade, and when
- 1:36:11that happened, the trust fund will not be able to pay full benefits.
- 1:36:15Those across the board. Cuts might be fine for somebody who's well off and
- 1:36:17doesn't need them, but somebody who depends on this program, that is not
- 1:36:21acceptable. That we are barreling towards this state. We have known about it,
- 1:36:26not for years, but for decades. Actually wrote my master's thesis about
- 1:36:30this quite some time ago. And those across the board benefits cuts are because
- 1:36:34our politicians are unwilling to tell the truth, make hard choices and make this
- 1:36:40program solvent again. And there's lots of ways to do it. We could
- 1:36:44raise the retirement age for younger people. We could slow the growth of benefits
- 1:36:47for richer people. We could raise the payroll tax cap or rate. There's
- 1:36:51tons of options. None of them are easy, but all of them are
- 1:36:56what we have to talk about. The right answer, by the way,
- 1:36:58is probably a combination of some of them. But there's different choices of how
- 1:37:01to fix it. The only choice that there shouldn't be no disagreement about is
- 1:37:06we cannot continue to delay because it just makes these things more difficult and it
- 1:37:11threatens the people who depend on Social Security. You know what I fear will
- 1:37:15happen is that Congress will do nothing, and then when it gets to the
- 1:37:18point where so Security is insolvent, then it'll just be more borrowing, and
- 1:37:25the debt will grow even more to pay all the benefits, and then we'll
- 1:37:30just have more borrowing. You think that's it, that's I do. I
- 1:37:32think there's a lot of people who think, don't worry, we're just going
- 1:37:34to borrow for all of this, and then they're not understanding that the excessive
- 1:37:39borrowing we already have means we're vulnerable on a national security level. We're vulnerable
- 1:37:44when the next emergency hits. We're vulnerable to creating hyper inflation from all the
- 1:37:48borrowing. We've already seen the effects of too high inflation because we borrowed too
- 1:37:53much. All of these things will be very harmful to us. And I'm
- 1:37:57not exaggerating when I say excessive in debt outness can undermine the standing of a
- 1:38:01country in the world. It's what ends great superpowers. So it is a
- 1:38:05really important issue not to borrow for the wrong things, but to borrow for
- 1:38:10the emergencies like COVID those make sense, but to actually deal with the policy
- 1:38:14choices to rebalance things like social security and our growing national debt. As interest
- 1:38:18rates are going up, our interest payments are starting to go up very quickly.
- 1:38:23We'll spend more on interest payments than we will on national defense in just
- 1:38:27a few years. Those are all very very bright warning signals. You know,
- 1:38:31I'd be more sympathetic to the far right Republicans in the House if they
- 1:38:36were talking about the entirety of the budget. I'm not sure it's still be
- 1:38:41all in on it, but I'd at least be more sympathetic to say,
- 1:38:43wow, you really are serious about federal spending, because you're willing to put
- 1:38:46everything out there absolutely so when you have you have both sides telling their crazy
- 1:38:51myths. You know, one side is, don't worry, we can just
- 1:38:55balance the budget on this tiny sliver of the budget. Couldn't be farther from
- 1:38:59the truth. Other side saying, all we have to do is tax millionaires
- 1:39:01and billionaires and then turn around and spend that money three times over. Neither
- 1:39:05of those will work. Everything has to be on the table. There are
- 1:39:10going to be hard choices. Perhaps the best way to go about this is
- 1:39:14some kind of a fiscal commission where we can insulate it from the rough and
- 1:39:17tumble politics that we are in the midst of, where nobody gives on anything
- 1:39:20and people would rather pander than tell the truth. But there is no question
- 1:39:26that people who are making promises that sound too good to be true are not
- 1:39:30leveling with voters. Mi McGinnis's President, Committee for Responsible Federal Budget. Always
- 1:39:33enjoy speaking with you. Thank you for coming on today. I always enjoy
- 1:39:38joining you. Thank you all right, bybye. Talk client continues right back.
- 1:39:41Let me ask you a question, are you a friend of coal?
- 1:39:44Throughout history, Cole has been a major driver behind West Virginia's economy. Billions
- 1:39:47of dollars of recent investment will ensure similar benefits continue for generations to come.
- 1:39:53Coal and coal fired power generator's account for over fourteen billion dollars and annual economic
- 1:39:59activity at least apply twenty four seven baseload electricity for our region. Coal continues
- 1:40:03to sustain fifty thousand plus West Virginia jobs, putting food on the table for
- 1:40:08Mountain State families. The industry stands united in support of good public policy to
- 1:40:13promote the growth of our extractive industries. We oppose the woke dimensions of state
- 1:40:16and federal governments working to abolish or diminish this amazing economic engine and time honored
- 1:40:23profession. And now we need your help. We invite you to join us
- 1:40:26as a friend of coal and let your voice be heard. Take an active
- 1:40:29role in standing up for miners, their families, and the benefits coal provides
- 1:40:32us. All to join and learn more visit Friends of Coal dot org.
- 1:40:36Than you like me can proudly say I'm a friend of coal. A message
- 1:40:41from the Friends of Coal. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News.
- 1:40:45The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain State's only hook
- 1:40:51and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quartermillion hunters and anglers across the
- 1:40:57state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories
- 1:41:00for more than twenty five years. Hurdles and other reptiles and amphibians are kind
- 1:41:06of at the center of illegal collection wildlife pouting issue, and West Virginia is
- 1:41:13not exempt from that. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories
- 1:41:17about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. People will call when they're standing right
- 1:41:21next to a rattlesnake on a trail or in the middle of a road.
- 1:41:25I try to catch every one so that we could market or see if it's
- 1:41:30one of the snakes that we had previously marked. West Virginia Outdoors covers it
- 1:41:33all Saturday mornings at seven o six am and for your daily fix Outdoors Today