Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️93 Dr Steven Emerman – When Engineering Meets Reality: The Curraghinalt Mine Waste Facility 03/09/26
Transcript
- 0:05Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign.
- 0:11And this podcast is following the Curranalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins.
- 0:19If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast number 43, the first in this public inquiry series. That will
- 0:29give you some of the background before joining us here.
- 0:33As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people,
- 0:42the water, and the landscape of The Sperrins.
- 0:47And if you've been following the podcast for a while, you may remember podcast number 23, Doctor Stephen Emerman, "The Science of Failure: Truth, Risk,
- 0:58and Responsibility.
- 1:01That was where we first met Stephen Emerman.
- 1:06Well, Stephen is back, and there's a very particular reason I've asked him to join me again.
- 1:11As recently as March 2o two six,
- 1:15he's completed a substantial new report examining filtered tailings facilities in Indonesia.
- 1:23I've put a copy of the full report in the show notes, so you can read it for yourself.
- 1:29Now you might reasonably be wondering what Indonesia has to do current out,
- 1:35and the connection is SRK Consulting.
- 1:39SRK's work features prominently in Stephen's report,
- 1:44and SRK also designed the proposed filtered tailings or dry stack mine waste facility at Kurinalt.
- 1:54Now, to be absolutely clear,
- 1:56Indonesia is not Kurinalt. Different project, different place, and different designs,
- 2:03but Stephen's report raises some important questions about filter tailings, about water and drainage, compaction, foundations, monitoring,
- 2:14and crucially, what happens when the reality on the ground doesn't match the assumptions made in the design
- 2:24also raises questions about SRK's reporting at the Obi Island facility, which I want Stephen himself to address.
- 2:32Our conversation today focuses on the mine waste facility proposed for The Sperrins,
- 2:39how it's supposed to work, what could go wrong?
- 2:42How would we know if something was going wrong?
- 2:46And what will be left there beneath the restored landscape long after the mining has stopped and the mining company has left the country?
- 2:56When the public inquiry resumes again in September, we're moving into this very subject area:
- 3:03the mine waste management plan, and drainage
- 3:07designation, methodology, and restoration.
- 3:13So, before we get there, I want to understand what Stephen's new work might have to tell us about the proposal here.
- 3:22But I think we need to start with something much more basic,
- 3:25because we've heard the words dry stack so many times throughout this inquiry that I think we've almost stopped thinking about what they
- 3:33actually mean.
- 3:35And rather than me trying to explain the engineering, let's ask Stephen.
- 3:40Stephen, welcome back.
- 3:43Let's just bring it back to basics before we get into the heavier part of this conversation.
- 3:50We've heard the word, or at least I've heard the dry stack words for so many years, all through this campaign,
- 3:59that I've almost stopped thinking about what it actually means.
- 4:04But these tailings aren't dry, at least the ones in Kurnal. So, what exactly are we talking about here when we speak about a dry stack facility?
- 4:14Okay. Well, the first thing is that the tailings are not literally Dry. The
- 4:23industry term is filter tailings.
- 4:26Okay, so the target water content for filter tailings is typically 15%
- 4:32Quite common that the tailings come out of the filter presses with water content 17% 18%
- 4:39If if things are off spec. They might be 2023, 25% water.
- 4:44So there's no universe in which this material would be called dry. Okay. Okay.
- 4:50It's really more like a moist soil.
- 4:54If you if you stand at a dry stock facility where I've done, okay, yeah, surf.
- 5:00Looks dry. You put your hand right below the surface, then it certainly feels moist, not soaking wet, but moist. It's almost like being on the beach.
- 5:08Okay, it's dry, dry on the surface, but but moist underneath.
- 5:13Whereas like dry, dry stack. Those are really marketing terms, and those are not really industry terms. So I only say dry stack facility when I'm
- 5:23quoting from somebody else. Otherwise, what I do, same as most industry people, we say filter tailings, filter tailing storage facility.
- 5:34Okay, in a filter tailings storage facility, there are
- 5:40many things that can go awry,
- 5:42as I'm sure
- 5:44I don't need to tell you. But what starts to happen when a few, one or two things
- 5:51don't go according to plan? Say the moisture is too high or too low, or there's something wrong with the drainage or the monitoring or something like
- 5:58that.
- 6:00You know what? What's likely to happen?
- 6:03Okay, I I think it helped if I back up a bit and explain what's the whole point of this technology. Okay, yeah. Otherwise, otherwise, it's quite
- 6:11mixed. Sure, it was like what could go wrong. Yeah. Okay. So what we're trying to do in the industry is avoid something called liquefaction. Okay. Let
- 6:21me explain what that is. Okay, and for her saw, if I want to back all the way back to the beginning, concept of tailings. Okay, so the vast majority of
- 6:30the ore body is not a commodity. Okay, it's mostly waste. Okay, something that you don't want. It's not the commodity.
- 6:38After you've extracted the commodity, you're left with this mass of wet crushed rock particles, plus chemical reagents, plus their reaction
- 6:48and degradation products. That's all called the tailings. Yeah. Okay. Now you have issues with storing this mass of wet fine grain material above ground and
- 6:59not having it collapse. Okay. So that's stored stored behind some kind of dam, okay. The dam might be built out of soil or rock fill or waste rock. Quite
- 7:12commonly, it's actually just built out of the coarser fraction of the tailings themselves. So the tailings dam is actually built out of the
- 7:19tailings, right? Okay. Now you have this slurry that comes from the ore processing plant. It's mostly water, 20 to 40% solids, and that's discharged behind the
- 7:31dam. Okay. Now you can't compact this material. It's it's too wet. You can compact it even if you want it. Okay. So it just the particles are just very
- 7:42loosely sitting on each other. They're touching each other, but but it's very loose. Okay, now what happens if we now have? Can I ask you a question there?
- 7:51Particle particle size. What what would particle size be in typical tailings
- 7:58situation? We're mostly talking about what's called silt-sized. Okay. Okay. Right.
- 8:08So that would be between 10625 millimetres up to two millimetres.
- 8:15Okay. So so finer than a sand, but coarser than a clay. In between the two, we call that silt. So so we have kind of a particles that are sitting on
- 8:24each other, and the pores are filled with water, but it has not been compacted.
- 8:30Okay, but now now what happens if we have a a shake like a very minor earthquake or nearby drilling or something? Okay, those particles will try to
- 8:40consolidate. They'll try to compact. Yeah. Okay. But if that process happens too fast, which it typically does, and the water can't escape from the pores fast
- 8:50enough, which it usually can't, then all that shaking does is pressurise the water.
- 8:56Okay. Okay. Yeah. So now what the water pressure is doing is pushing the particles apart.
- 9:01Okay. So now the particles aren't touching each other any longer, and the whole mass, that whole weight, is now just held up by the water.
- 9:09So now it behaves just like a liquid. Okay, that's liquefaction. Okay, that's what we try. That's the situation we try to avoid: is that mass of
- 9:19wet, fresh rock particles undergoing liquefaction.
- 9:23Brilliant. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. So, so how do we do that?
- 9:28What we try to do is pre-compact the massive tailings, so they won't try to compact during a a shake during a disturbance. Okay. To do that, you have to
- 9:41get to what we call the optimal water content for maximum compaction, and that is not dry. That's usually just a little bit under saturation. If you kind of
- 9:53imagine I have a soil and I want to squeeze it as much as possible, just get it just barely.
- 10:00Unsaturated, just under saturation. Now I can give the maximum squeeze.
- 10:05Okay, and that-that's what we call filter tailings technology. Okay, you filter the tailings to get the water content just below saturation. That's usually about
- 10:1615 to 20% and then
- 10:19behind the tailings dam. You compact those tailings, right? Okay. And now you you have not avoided entirely. You have reduced the the probability of
- 10:29liquefaction. Okay. Okay. Got it. Okay. Yeah.
- 10:34So,
- 10:36can I just hold that there for a moment? Sure. Sure. And I'm going to skip over now
- 10:43to your recent
- 10:46publication,
- 10:48the the filter tailings in Indonesia,
- 10:51and and its title is the catastrophic failure of a disruptive technology.
- 11:02One could you just explain what a disruptive technology is before we go any further? Oh, I see. Okay, well, it's something a lot of people say these days.
- 11:13Okay,
- 11:14so usually
- 11:17you have a new technology that appears. Okay, like we could say, oh, generative artificial intelligence. Okay, there's a new technology, ChatGPT, etc.
- 11:28Okay, most of us are familiar with that by now. Okay, so it produces a lower quality product.
- 11:37Okay, but it has other advantages like cost, convenience, accessibility,
- 11:45and so
- 11:46that's how it kind of
- 11:48starts to replace the existing technology through having some other advantage, and maybe at some point it achieves the quality of the previous
- 11:57technology, but but not necessarily. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Now it's often used in kind of a pejorative sense of
- 12:08acting without regard to consequences. Yeah. Okay.
- 12:12So there's kind of a mantra. It's attributed to many different people.
- 12:16Act fast and break things. Okay, which is generally acting without regard to consequences, okay, okay.
- 12:25So it's something we're confronted with a lot in the current stage of capitalism. Is disruptive technologies in which no one is stopping to think
- 12:33about. Wait a minute, is this a good idea? Do we want this? Okay.
- 12:38Okay. So hence the parallel then, and and and you when what your subject matter in relation to Indonesia,
- 12:46that's why you used it in your title,
- 12:51right? Yeah. Okay. Got it.
- 12:55So skipping forward a little bit, you speak about Obi Island. Am I am I
- 13:01pronouncing that correctly, obi.
- 13:05Yes, that's fine. Yeah. Okay.
- 13:08What did you find there that worried you sufficiently that you eventually use the words imminent catastrophic failure?
- 13:19Oh, okay. Well, well, let's take
- 13:22let's take those words apart a bit first. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So the phrase "catastrophic failure"
- 13:30is sometimes people will talk about a failure of a tailings dam and will say, "Ah, that wasn't a real failure. Okay, meaning something like it did
- 13:39not release all of the contents. Okay. Well, failure just means not meeting the performance objectives. So the performance objectives are: we don't want to
- 13:49see seepage on the face of that tailings dam. Well, if you haven't met that, the dam has failed. Okay. Yeah. Some people are actually fairly
- 13:59strict about this, they'll say public confidence is is a is a performance objective. So if the public has lost confidence in this dam, the dam has failed.
- 14:09Okay, if we actually have a loss of contents, that's a catastrophic failure.
- 14:15Okay. Okay. Yeah.
- 14:18So.
- 14:19Oh. Okay. So so catastrophic failure, and then the other word was was imminent. Okay,
- 14:28I I'm not sure now if I should have used that word that word imminent. That there's a term that's more often used in the industry,
- 14:36which is certain. Okay, what do we what what do we mean when we say failure is certain. Okay. Yeah. So we can find that used in um like Tavings Management
- 14:45Handbook to talk about certain failure. They took that language from Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which regulates hydro power dams in the U.S.
- 14:56Okay. What does it mean to say that failure is certain?
- 14:59Um. It means.
- 15:00That in any given year the the probability of failure is 10% or greater.
- 15:06Okay, and some people hear that and they say, "Well, wait a minute, that's not what I mean by certain. Okay, certain to me that means 90 to 100% Yeah.
- 15:14Okay, and I say, "No, no, it doesn't. No, it doesn't. Okay. Yeah, it depends upon what are the consequences of failure.
- 15:21Okay,
- 15:22if someone says I don't want to go to this restaurant without a reservation, we're certain to not get a table. Yeah, okay, 90 to 100% We won't get a table.
- 15:32That makes sense. Yeah. Okay, but well, let's talk about getting on an aeroplane. Okay, and let's say the probability of a crash is 1%
- 15:43Okay. Well, you know, in the U.S. there's 42,000 commercial flights a day. Yeah. So 1% failure would mean 420 crashes a day. Okay. And the next day, you
- 15:53would say, "I'm not getting on a plane. It's certain to crash. You say, "No, it's only 1% No, it's certain to crash. Yeah. Okay. So what you mean by
- 16:01certain depends upon what are the consequences of being wrong. Yeah. Okay, that's kind of one way to look at it. Okay, is a tan exam is not supposed to
- 16:12fail. So if probability is 10% or greater in a given year, we call that certain. Okay. Okay, and the other thing is that if the probability of failure is
- 16:23certain, we're supposed to take emergency action, like evacuate the downstream residents. Yeah, and no one quibbles about is it 10% is it 20% is it 30% It
- 16:33doesn't change the action you take. Yeah, so it doesn't matter. Okay. Okay. Yeah. So, so certain failure, I think, actually would have been a more
- 16:43a more technical expression, but I'm really I'm really meaning the same thing when I say imminent. Okay, it means just the probability is just
- 16:51unacceptably high, and right now we should take emergency action. We should evacuate downstream residents. We definitely certainly should not keep
- 17:01putting more tailings in this facility. Okay, and just just to come back to revisit the question, what what did you find there that suggested that there
- 17:11would be a certain catastrophic failure?
- 17:14Okay, okay. So so this was information in an assessment of the tailings facility that was done by SRK Consulting, and I understand we'll be talking
- 17:25about about them later, since they've been very involved in the Dalradian project. Okay, yeah. In their assessment, they reported that there had been
- 17:35essentially no quality control. Okay, that is the water content of the tailings was supposed to be 35% Okay, that's greater than for hard rock tavings because
- 17:47it's a different material, but actually it was anywhere from 8% to 36% Yeah. Wow, that's a huge range. Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
- 17:57And then the compacted density was supposed to be 2.20 metric tonnes per cubic metre, and sometimes it was, but sometimes it was as low as 0.93 metric
- 18:12tonnes per cubic metre. That is even fluffier than water.
- 18:17Okay, so so you had a very very loose material. Yeah. Okay, so which really has not been compacted at all, or not in any proper way, right? Okay, so the
- 18:29danger is, you know, why why did I say failure is imminent? Is that if you keep putting on more tailings on top of this material, I mean, suppose we
- 18:38even have perfect quality control from now on. You keep putting more tanks on top of this material. The danger is the whole mass will suddenly
- 18:47compact, beating it will undergo liquefaction. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah. That's why I said I said failure is imminent. Okay. And and that's why and um
- 19:00and they only referred to it as an uncontrolled risk
- 19:08in their report, as far as I know. They they did they did they said failure is an uncontrolled risk. Uh huh. Okay. I I think it's more and explain
- 19:18what did they mean by that. Okay. Yeah. And and how was what they were saying different from what I was saying? Yeah. What made you go further than what
- 19:28they said? Yeah. Well, well, it's it's a difference in perspective, but but let me explain. Okay. So that's very common in a in an assessment of
- 19:37a facility is is a risk analysis. Okay. So you go through all the different risks, and you say what's controlling those risks. Okay, so we might
- 19:47say
- 19:48you have a mine, and and a risk is a haul truck overturning, a haul truck going off the road. Well, that's risk a risk. Well, how do we control that risk? Oh,
- 19:58okay, we have a maintenance programme.
- 20:00We replace the trucks every three years. All our drivers must have clean driving records, very strict, no alcohol, no drug policy, etc.
- 20:10Okay, that's all the ways we control those risks. Okay, now SRK Consulting was saying the risk of failure was uncontrolled. Okay, that doesn't
- 20:20sound very promising, okay. Meaning there is nothing there is nothing that is controlling that risk. Okay. Okay.
- 20:31What was disturbing to
- 20:34me
- 20:37is they're then talking about how long it's going to take to fill up this tailings facility with tailings, and they're saying it's going to take longer
- 20:46than we had.
- 20:48It's going to it's going to fill up faster than we thought because the density is much less than had been predicted. Okay, so it was supposed to fill in
- 20:57six years. It's going to fill in four and a half years. Okay, and my reaction is, why? Why are we even talking about when the facility is going to
- 21:05fill? Okay, we should be immediately stopping deposition of any tailings.
- 21:11Okay, okay. I mean, I would say following steps:
- 21:16evacuate downstream residents, stop deposition of tailings,
- 21:21do whatever you can to stabilise the existing structure. That is like build some kind of containment structure downstream, and then evaluate
- 21:30the whole plan for what you're going to do with this very loosely packed mess. But we shouldn't even talking about when's this facility going to
- 21:38fill.
- 21:39Okay. Yeah. So I'd say that that was quite a a difference in in perspective. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Certainly was.
- 21:49And there's another part of your report that really stopped me in my tracks.
- 21:53You looked at different versions of SRK's report and found that some of the language had changed.
- 22:01Can you just tell us exactly what you found?
- 22:05I I can do that. This will take a bit to explain, but but first I I want to explain. This is that this is not a typical thing to have
- 22:13the whole sequence of revisions of someone's consulting report.
- 22:18Okay,
- 22:20this was provided to me through a data leak that was obtained by the Organised Crime and Corruption Reporting Project. Okay,
- 22:30they obtained this information. I don't know, but they obtained that and and they asked me to look at at all of this material. Okay, yeah. So I mean, I had the
- 22:39final report, which is the ninth version, ninth revision, but there were also multiple revisions: seven A, 7b, 7c, 7d, 7e, etc. Okay, so went through
- 22:49many, many revisions, and that's
- 22:53well. This is the first time I have ever had access to to that kind of information in terms of a consulting company working for a mining company that never seen
- 23:02the whole sequence of revisions before. Okay, okay, so just you know this this was an unusual thing. Okay, yeah,
- 23:11I I'm going to
- 23:13open my report so I can look through the sequence of figures and also make sure I'm giving you
- 23:21the exact correct information. Okay, yeah. So to start off, we had the first revision. Okay. Yeah. And that revision has a very large photo. It's it's a
- 23:33whole page photo. Okay. And it has a heading: View of DSTF Area. DSTF is Dry stack tainings facility view of DSTF area with significant water ponding. Okay,
- 23:47okay, and this is Figure 35 A in my report. So you can see the top of the filter tainting storage facility, and that is covered with water. Okay, now
- 23:58we're not supposed to have free water ponded water on top of a filtered tailing storage facility.
- 24:06That's defeating the whole purpose of of this facility.
- 24:10What would happen if there was ponded water on top of a tailing facility?
- 24:14Yes, that's what that's what I'm about to talk about. Okay, first of all, it greatly increases the risk of liquefaction because you have the pores saturated, and
- 24:24that's exactly what we are trying to avoid: is having pores filled with water. Okay, so so we have saturated pores.
- 24:32We can get water washing off the edges of that facility, resulting in gullies, washout, etc.
- 24:39If we do have a failure, it's going to be mixed with a lot of water, and that's going to increase the consequences of failure. If we have water
- 24:48sitting on the top, we certainly can't drive heavy equipment over the top to compact the tailings. Okay, even if you think you can move that that pond of water
- 24:59back and forth.
- 25:00The tailings are still too wet to be compacted. Okay,
- 25:05they're too wet, too wet to be driven on the tailings. Well, well, we say that we say we say they're not trafficable. Okay, the too wet to be the too wet to
- 25:13be driven on. But also, if you try to compact tailings that are too wet, we say on the wet side of optimum, yeah, you get a you get a very weak material.
- 25:23Okay, so the whole point of this technology was to obtain an optimum water content where you could get maximum compaction, which was on the dry side of
- 25:33saturation. Yeah. Okay,
- 25:36and now so anyway, we we got a serious problem here, and and and and part of the problem is that,
- 25:43as far as we know, that whole stack might be saturated, that whole filter tailing stack. It could be that it just won't drain, and it's completely
- 25:52saturated. Okay, so so we have potential. We have potential to have a very dangerous situation. Okay, okay, and in their report, they comment on this. This is in
- 26:03the first revision.
- 26:05During the site visit, some issues with water ponding and poor drainage appear to be present, and they refer to that photo I just showed. Yeah, yeah.
- 26:14The design considered that the compaction imposed on the tailings would be sufficient to prevent liquefaction. Okay. However, it is SRK's opinion
- 26:23that given the height of the facility (57 metres) the lack of quality control in the placement of tailings, and the observed surface water issues, further
- 26:34study is required to assess the risk for the tailings to exhibit contractive behaviour during undrained shearing, which means undergo liquefaction. Okay.
- 26:44Okay. So they're showing a photo of surface water ponding. They're explaining it's a problem. They're not explaining why it's a problem, but they're
- 26:51saying it's a problem, and they're saying further study is needed. Okay. I would not have said further study is needed. I would have said stop putting
- 26:59trainings on this facility. Yeah. Okay. Okay.
- 27:03I would also have asked some questions like, how persistent
- 27:09is this? When did it last rain? If it hasn't rained for weeks and there's still water sitting on top, I think, wow, this is really dangerous. This whole
- 27:17stack is saturated; it won't drain at
- 27:20all. Okay. Anyway, right. Yeah, those questions are not asked. Okay. Yeah. Okay. So, so what happens next? Okay.
- 27:28Now there's a follow up to the first revision. We still have that same photo. It's not a full page any longer. Now it's a quarter page. Okay. Okay. And
- 27:38now it says view of DSTF area with water ponding issues. Okay, so significant water ponding has now become water ponding issues, and it's a quarter size. Okay,
- 27:50okay,
- 27:51okay, that keeps going
- 27:54until we get all the way to revision eight A.
- 27:59Okay, yeah, and then we get a big change, and now it just says view of dry stack cavings facility area. That's
- 28:09it. No mention at all about water ponding. Okay. Okay. All right. And that same quote is there with important information removed. What's been removed
- 28:21during the site visit, some issues with water ponding and drainage appear to be present. That is gone. Okay, and the observed surface water issues
- 28:30that is gone. The rest of the sentence is there. It's actually left the whole sentence non-grammatical.
- 28:38Okay, because because it's it's removed those those key problems, okay. And then when we finally get to the final version, all they've done is
- 28:47they've corrected the grammar.
- 28:49Okay. So now, so now, so now it's a grammatical sentence. Okay. But we have a tiny photo. No mention of what the photo was showing. No mention anywhere
- 28:59whatsoever about surface water ponding that it exists, why it matters. Okay, all of that has been removed by time we get to the final final version. Okay,
- 29:10okay, yeah, and and in my report, you can follow this
- 29:14figure by figure, which are all screenshots from the screenshots from the revisions. And just to remind our listeners, the report will be in the show notes, so
- 29:24you can feel feel free to peruse it later at your own
- 29:29in your own time. So, Stephen, I'm not asking you to speculate why those changes were made,
- 29:36because neither you nor I can know that unless there's evidence for it. But as an engineer, when you see something like that happening between
- 29:43versions of a report, what do you make of it?
- 29:50Well,
- 29:55I guess I would have a lot of questions.
- 29:59Okay. Yeah.
- 30:00And
- 30:03I, I mean, first, I, I, I would want to know why. Okay, why is it something that was so important at the beginning now is completely gone?
- 30:16Yes, I, I would definitely have that, that question. Okay, yeah, I, I, I mean, I mean, my questions will kind of fall into two categories.
- 30:24The the first is something that
- 30:28I'm calling
- 30:31definitely when I was teaching I used to call it lack of curiosity. Okay, it's like when a student would just report a measurement that didn't make any
- 30:39sense with no commentary, I think. Didn't you wonder? Did you think about that? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And and I once said that to a journalist who said,
- 30:49"No, it's not called lack of curiosity. It's called lack of caring. Okay. So, for example, not asking questions like, "How long has this been water been
- 30:57sitting on the surface? and "When did it rain last?
- 31:01Okay. Not asking. those questions. That's what I call lack of curiosity.
- 31:06Okay.
- 31:10And and and and and again, I come back to you. Why why was this key information so important in the first version entirely missing by the end?
- 31:20Okay. Yeah. I wanted to keep in mind is the first thing I ever read was that final version,
- 31:26and I did see that figure, and I did not see there was surface bonding. Yeah. Okay. When later I went back to earlier versions, and that that was a full page
- 31:36photo. Oh yeah, now I see it. Yeah. Then I went back to later version, blew it way up, and yeah, then I could see it blew up. But even someone who's like
- 31:45expert at reading these kinds of reports totally missed that by the end. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, so yes, I do have, I do have concerns about this. Okay, and
- 31:56that kind of begs the question for us as a community
- 32:01trying to read consultants' reports. How do we know when we're seeing the whole picture?
- 32:07You know, it's almost an impossible thing for us.
- 32:12That's right. Okay. I. I mean, usually, when I mean, I look at a lot of consultants' reports. Okay. Yeah. I'm asking the question: Does this meet
- 32:22industry standards?
- 32:25Partly in terms of the report, but partly in terms of what's being proposed, like the design, the design for the dry stack facility at at the Corinn Yalt
- 32:34project. Does that meet industry standards? Okay. Okay.
- 32:38Or regulations. That that's often what I'm asking, okay, yeah. But in terms of
- 32:45have key inform has key information been left out?
- 32:50Did the consultants know something at the beginning that they did not report by the end? Yeah.
- 32:56Well, well, that's quite difficult to tell.
- 33:00Yeah.
- 33:01Okay. Yeah.
- 33:04I do get nervous when.
- 33:09I mean, in some cases, for example, for this Dalradian project, it's gone through so many versions. Okay, there's been so many consultant reports.
- 33:20There's information that was present in, for example, the 2019 environmental statement
- 33:27that's missing by time we get to the statement of case. Yeah, and and I wonder why, why, well, what what happened to that information? Yeah,
- 33:36okay, but what was in an early earlier versions of those reports? No, I I would have no way of knowing that.
- 33:43Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
- 33:48And then this brings me to a question:
- 33:52Does it matter that consultants are being paid by the company whose project they're assessing?
- 33:58I'm not suggesting that automatically makes their work wrong,
- 34:02but how should we take that relationship into account?
- 34:07Oh, oh, okay, yeah, that's a very good question. Okay, well,
- 34:12I, I, I mean, you can focus on the fact that the company is paying the consultants, but that that is certainly not an unusual thing.
- 34:23There's not many cases where that
- 34:27doesn't happen.
- 34:32I, I, I mean, typically a consultant is is paid by their client. Yeah. Okay.
- 34:39So,
- 34:41I mean, we have a concept we call independence. Okay, so so so so you want consultants to be independent. Okay, so so so what does it mean to be independent?
- 34:51It means you're not unduly influenced by your client.
- 34:55To say you're not influenced at all, I think, is not really realistic.
- 35:00But you're not unduly influenced. Okay,
- 35:04and then people ask questions like, "Well, what what makes that possible? What make it what makes it possible to be not unduly influenced? Okay, or
- 35:13they'll ask, "Well, well, what are the indicators?
- 35:16We call them verifiable indicators of independence. Yeah, yeah. Okay, I know a consulting company I admire a lot, and they have a very high
- 35:26standard for establishing their own independence. Okay, right. This is a
- 35:32common Brazil. Okay, yeah.
- 35:35So they have five verifiable indicators. I won't go the whole list. Okay, but but one of them is that what they give their client is final,
- 35:44no revisions, nothing. Okay, yeah, they gave it to them; it's done. Yeah, okay.
- 35:52What's the what's the trigger for them to be paid? They submit the final report. They're paid. Right. Okay. Okay. There's no response by the client, there is
- 36:01no. We'll look at her first, and then we'll pay you. Right.
- 36:05That's part of what they call being independent.
- 36:08Okay. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Now,
- 36:11so I have a consulting company.
- 36:15I don't follow that. Yeah. Okay. I don't think many clients would like that. Okay.
- 36:22But I say that
- 36:24there's only certain types of revisions I'll make. Okay, I'll correct a mistake, but usually something like you have the name of that town wrong, name that
- 36:33river's wrong. Okay, fine. Okay, okay, yeah.
- 36:37Quite often, people say we didn't quite understand that. Could you add some more explanation? So clarification, okay. So correction of of actual
- 36:46mistakes, clarification. Yes, that's fine, okay. But what I won't do is change a recommendation or a conclusion, right? Okay. Okay.
- 36:56That's only happened once.
- 36:59Okay.
- 37:02That was a case in which I said that
- 37:05the CEO and his consultants were incompetent,
- 37:09and they asked me to take that out. And I said no.
- 37:12That that's an that that's an essential part of how I reach my conclusions. Okay, is is the incompetence of the management? Right. So no, so no, I would not
- 37:21take that out. That's only time that's come up, right? Okay. Very
- 37:26good.
- 37:29Okay, let's. But anyway, but see, see, these would be reasonable questions to put to,
- 37:35I don't know, Galadian or the Planning Commission, RSRK Consulting, your your main consultants. That are they independent? Yeah. Well, how do
- 37:43you know? In in what sense are they independent? How do you know they're independent? What do you mean by independent? Okay, those those would all be
- 37:52reasonable questions. Okay, cool.
- 37:55Okay, let's put down Indonesia for a moment and move back to current out. Okay. So we know Dalradian is proposing a filtered tailings facility
- 38:05there, and and again, I'm not suggesting Obi and Corinalt are the same thing. Are the basic questions we should be asking whether one of these things is
- 38:16safe? Are they broadly the same? So in relation Indonesia versus Curranalt, are they broadly the same questions? Indonesia and Kurinyalt are not maybe as
- 38:26different as you might be thinking.
- 38:28Okay.
- 38:32I mean, it does rain more on Obi Island,
- 38:37but actually not that much more. I'm kind of a nerd about rainfall. Okay, I imagine you might be. Well, the the average precipitation at that mine site
- 38:46on Obi Island is 1754 millimetres. Right, and at the Kernel site, according to what I've looked up, 1527 millimetres. It's not a whole
- 38:57lot different. No, I I mean it's wetter, but it's not. Yeah, it's not. It's not a completely different climate. Yeah. Okay.
- 39:07The basic questions were asking about Kurnault, and the basic questions were asking that you asked about Obi Island.
- 39:15Okay.
- 39:17Are they the same? Are they similar? You know, can you compare one with the other? I that's what I'm trying to say.
- 39:24I mean, a question I could ask about both is: Are our industry standards being met? Okay, let's start there. Okay, yeah.
- 39:32I I mean, that's my typical approach to any
- 39:36you know proposal for a taintings dam consulting assessment of a taintings dam is: is this Tavings Dam following industry standards?
- 39:44Okay. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
- 39:47I don't have to have access to the underlying data or or to the earlier versions to to answer that question. Okay. Okay. So if you're asking me, does the
- 39:56Currynelt proposed Drystock facility.
- 40:00Industry standards. The answer is no. It does not.
- 40:03Okay, right. And there's another question you asked: is safe, which is a different,
- 40:09a different question. Okay, so I'll let you decide which which way you want to go right now. Okay, let's put. Imagine you're coming fresh to Coronel, right?
- 40:18Okay,
- 40:20and you're putting aside everything anybody else has said about it. Okay, what would you want to know before you could say, "Yes, I'm comfortable
- 40:30putting millions of cubic metres of mine waste here. Okay, okay.
- 40:36Comfort is kind of similar to safe,
- 40:39which is a different thing from meeting industry standards. So I want to come back and look this whole question about being comfortable and being safe.
- 40:48Right. Okay.
- 40:50So
- 40:53mining is a very
- 40:58risky business.
- 41:00Okay. There's always risks from mining. Yeah, the main risk is from collapse of the tailing storage facility. That's the number one risk anyone should be
- 41:10worried about is that catastrophic failure. Yeah, that risk is always present.
- 41:16Okay, we just ask. Well, okay, but do the benefits outweigh the risks?
- 41:23Okay, but then you come to another question. Well, wait a minute. Who is benefiting from this, and who is bearing the risks?
- 41:31Okay, if we're talking about a completely different group of people,
- 41:36like one party gets the benefits, another party bears the risks. Well, that's wrong right from the start. Yeah, and that should be end of the
- 41:43discussion.
- 41:45Okay,
- 41:46that's simple. Okay, no, it should be okay. I mean, I mean, any, I mean, I mean, people talk about you know, does does society need mining? Okay, do
- 41:57the benefits outweigh the risks? Okay, okay, and and my response is usually there's no such thing as society,
- 42:06okay? There's parties who want the mind who are going to benefit from it. There's parties who will bear the risks, and they don't want the mind. And
- 42:14usually, the reason you have a mind is the party that will benefit has more power than the party that's going to bear the risks, okay. The whole question
- 42:22about does it benefit society? It kind of imagines that society is some kind of giant town hall where we're all in this together.
- 42:34We're all going to benefit. We're all going to bear the risks. Okay, is this good for all of us? Okay. Now, I listen to your podcast on a very
- 42:43regular basis,
- 42:45and the public inquiry thus far seems to have not been run in that kind of manner.
- 42:52With the whole idea, we're all in this together. We're all going to benefit. We're all going to take the risks. Well, do the benefits outweigh the
- 42:58risks? Yeah. Okay. Those benefits and risks seem to belong to different parties,
- 43:04and we get and we got a problem right there. Okay, that that should end. That should end the discussion right there. Okay. Yeah. So if we ask, is it safe?
- 43:14Well,
- 43:16depends which side of that Tailings Dam you're on. Okay. If if you're not benefiting at all, but you're bearing the risks, you might think, why should I
- 43:25bear any risk at all?
- 43:28Okay, is it 100% permanently safe? Well,
- 43:33no,
- 43:34nobody would ever say that. Nobody could ever guarantee that. Yeah. Okay. So someone who lives down slope? Who doesn't plan to get a job without mine?
- 43:43They'll say, "What? What? What? What's in this for me? Well, why why should I bear the risk? Then nothing's ever going to make me comfortable. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
- 43:53That's a different matter than saying, "Well, what are the industry best practices? Industry best standards? Okay. It doesn't mean it makes it
- 44:00safe. I get you. Okay, it means well. This is the current best practice. Okay. Okay. Now, now, now, no, no, no. This is not the best practices. Okay. So you
- 44:11might say I've given you another problem on top of the problems you've already heard. Okay. Yeah. So, so, so, so, someone living down slope from this
- 44:20tailings dam, they're thinking there's nothing in this for me. I don't want to bear this risk. I don't care what. But wait a minute. Now you're telling me it
- 44:28doesn't even meet industry standards.
- 44:30Yeah. So
- 44:32you've you've obviously studied the plans in great detail. How does it not meet in your in your opinion? How does it not meet industry standards.
- 44:43Oh, okay. So let me
- 44:49let me give you three things.
- 44:54I'll give you three things. I'll save the most important for last.
- 45:01So,
- 45:05this would be hard to explain without looking at a diagram, a cross section of the dry stack facility. Okay,
- 45:13so I'll explain it in words, but your listeners will have to look at that diagram for themselves to kind of see exactly what I'm talking about. Okay,
- 45:23we have a type of okay, okay. So first of all, to explain one thing,
- 45:29the drive stack facility, filter tailing store facility, will be built in stages. Okay, you start off with what's called a starter dam. You put tailings behind
- 45:41it. As you have more tailings, you keep making that dam taller and taller. Yeah. Okay. Now they'll talk about adding perimeter berms with a height of
- 45:51five metres. Yeah. In stages. Okay.
- 45:55They say the function of that berm is to contain the tailings. Well, then we should call it a dam or a dike, okay. Yeah. A berm, okay. Fine, but it should
- 46:04be called a dike or a dam, okay. Contains the tailings, okay. Yeah. So, so each successive layer of tailings will have a berm or dike that's built out of
- 46:15a combination of two things: what's called waste rock and what's called ore rejects, okay. Ore rejects are the parts of the ore body they decided not to
- 46:23process because it did not have enough gold content. Yeah. Okay.
- 46:29So that that makes the dam. Okay. Now
- 46:34there's a type of construction that's called the upstream method. Okay. Now in the upstream method, when you build the success successive dikes,
- 46:44when you make the dam tall one taller, you put the dikes on top of the the tailings that are being confined.
- 46:54Okay, you really have to look at a diagram to see that. Okay, but there's uncompat there's unconfined tailings. Excuse me, the impact. tailings; those are
- 47:04underneath the dikes. Okay, that's the upstream method. Okay. Okay. The advantage of this method is that it it reduces the amount of
- 47:13construction material you need.
- 47:15Okay. Yeah. The disadvantage is that if the underlying tailings liquefy, the dams aren't doing anything. They'll just slide over the tailings or fall into
- 47:25the tailings. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. In quite a number of countries, this is illegal. This construction method, just to name a few, Chile. It's been
- 47:35illegal in Chile since 1970. Peru, Ecuador, Brazil.
- 47:40It's illegal. Okay,
- 47:44two big handbooks came out in 2023 by Society for Mining Exploration and and Mining Metallurgy and Exploration: Surface Mining Handbook and
- 47:52Underground Mining Handbook. Okay, both of those in the first chapter they unequivocally condemn that upstream construction method,
- 48:02right? Okay. Yeah.
- 48:05That's being used at this Grinnial mine.
- 48:09Okay.
- 48:11If you look, if you look at the cross section, you will see underneath each dike are tailings. Yeah. Okay. And you ask, well, what happens if those
- 48:20tailings liquefied. What's what's the berm doing? Well, nothing that's falling into or sliding over the tailings. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So,
- 48:31I I mean, there's no reason to do this unless well, you just don't have enough ore rejects and waste rock, which is probably the case.
- 48:39Okay, but that has been condemned by the industry. Yeah. Okay. That should not even be on the table for discussion. Yeah. Okay. Now,
- 48:50a second issue
- 48:53is a lack of knowledge of the foundation.
- 48:57Okay. So, what do we know about the foundation? We know there's peat. Okay. Under the peat, there's a gravelly sand. Yeah. Under that, there's a weathered
- 49:05schist. Under that, there's a rock called schist. Okay. They say they'll remove the peat. Fine.
- 49:15Um, I'm I'm not promising they'll remove all the peat. I'm saying yes, yes, that's the plan to remove the peat. Okay.
- 49:23I'll just tell a bit,
- 49:25just so your listeners understand what what what this rock type schist is and why it matters. Yeah. Okay. So if you start with a shale, okay, and
- 49:32now we do
- 49:35we cook it temperature and pressure on them. We do the earth does. Okay. The clays turn into micas, which are flat minerals,
- 49:43and that's called a slate. Okay. If you keep applying temperature and pressure, it cooks in a rock called schist, in which you now have bigger micas that are all
- 49:54aligned and lying on top of each other. Okay. Okay. It means it's a rock type with a great deal of.
- 50:00Foliation, great deal of layering. Yeah, so you could easily have slippage over the layers. Ah, yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Um, I would want to know
- 50:09the geotechnical parameters of that schist.
- 50:12Right. I would want boring samples, measurements. I'd want that to go into the stability analysis. And how many borings are there at the moment?
- 50:24I I I I couldn't tell you how many borings, but there's no measurements of the geotechnical parameters of the schist. Okay.
- 50:31Okay. So you can't go down from that. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
- 50:35I I've seen two measurements for the gravelly sand and zero for the schist. Right. Okay. So, so, so we're dealing with a foundation that's known
- 50:45worldwide to be problematic, and now we have no measurements of that foundation. Okay, and that would be called poor
- 50:54by by any standard.
- 50:56Okay, I I mean they're just assuming values for the schist. Okay, well, by any standard, no. Now you should have measurements. Yeah. Okay. How
- 51:05can you just make assumptions about that? Okay. You have this dry stacked facility on slope and ground with houses below it. Okay. And you don't think you
- 51:14should make measurements on the geotechnical properties of that schist? Okay. Well, no, we got a problem there. Okay. Yeah.
- 51:24Um.
- 51:29I I I'm going to throw in
- 51:31two more problems, and then I'll get to the most supported one of
- 51:36all. Uh. Okay. Yeah. Um. The earthquake design is really inadequate. Okay,
- 51:45that is the stability analysis only assumes an earthquake with a term period of 2500 years,
- 51:52and that does not meet the standard in the UK.
- 51:56The standard in the UK should be is what's called the maximum credible earthquake. That's the largest earthquake that's theoretically possible at that
- 52:04location, and that's based by the houses that are downslope from the dam. Okay. Okay. Also, by UK standard,
- 52:14this
- 52:16dam,
- 52:18the standings facility, should be able to withstand what's called the probable maximum flood. Okay, okay, that's the largest precipitation event
- 52:27that's even theoretically possible at that location.
- 52:31Okay, yeah. There's no discussion as to what precipitation event this facility can withstand.
- 52:40Okay, which
- 52:42I I I would definitely be asking this question: 100 year storm, 1000 year storm. Yeah. Okay. Um. This see, there is some information in the earlier
- 52:53consulting reports that's not in the later reports. Early reports 2019 says
- 53:00this facility will be unstable if the water table rises to with a height of 11 metres. Okay, and the time ask the question, but but when's that going to happen?
- 53:10Under what circumstances will you get that rise in the water table? Okay,
- 53:15and that that has not been answered. But the latest versions, what we see in the statement of case, does not address that question. Is what
- 53:24height of water table would you need to destabilise this facility?
- 53:28So that discussion is gone. Okay. Okay.
- 53:32I'm sorry. I'm adding additional things, but still holding off on the most important thing of all. Right. Right. Okay. Okay. So, so what would be
- 53:40a kind of a most important industry standard, something you always do, okay, is you always carry out what's called a dam breach analysis, a dam break
- 53:51analysis, a failure consequence analysis. You ask what happens when this tailings facility fails, okay, because what will be the extent of the tailings
- 54:02flood? The velocity of tailings,
- 54:05plus the consequences, impact loss of life, impact on farms, impact on highways, impact on hospitals, et cetera, et cetera. You do that
- 54:16failure consequence analysis. That is standard. Okay,
- 54:22that is totally missing
- 54:25in anything provided by the mining company.
- 54:29Okay,
- 54:31they even say outright. I, I,
- 54:34excuse me. I, I, I, I want to make sure I'm saying this exactly right.
- 54:42I'm seeing this exactly right.
- 54:46Okay,
- 54:49this is by SRK Consulting. Dry stack mine waste storage facilities are inherently stable.
- 54:58Well, no, they're not.
- 55:00Okay,
- 55:02I I mean no, they're not because I I mean first of all I can name start if we go back to 2022 I could name seven filtered tailing storage facilities that
- 55:12have failed. Okay, that's out of a few 100 worldwide. Okay, okay, I I would not call that inherently stable.
- 55:20Right. Okay. So no, that's not true. Yeah. Okay.
- 55:24Yeah. And then they say.
- 55:28So I want to make sure I'm saying this exactly right.
- 55:32This is in their statement of case.
- 55:37They say
- 55:39we don't even have to consider
- 55:42the possibility of failure. Okay. Oh, here's what they say. Okay. I'm reading from the Dowerian statement of case.
- 55:50Assessments have been carried out to determine whether the mine waste facility or the water storage ponds are Category A facilities. Okay. Now, if you're
- 56:00a Category A facility, you have to meet certain requirements. Okay, we won't get bogged down in that. Okay, then they say there's reading from the law: a
- 56:08waste facility shall be classified as Category A if one, a failure or incorrect operation, for example, the collapse of a heap or the
- 56:17bursting of a dam, could give rise to a major accident on the basis of a risk assessment. Assessment take into account factors such as the present or
- 56:26future size, the location, and the environmental impact of the waste facility. Okay, so it says if
- 56:34you could have collapse, then you're class A, and now those two other things that could make you class A. But we won't worry about that, okay? Right. But
- 56:43now, now, now Radian says none of that applies to us. It says based on consultation with various teams responsible for design of the mine waste
- 56:52facility and water storage ponds, none of the criteria above applies to either facility. Hence, they have not been assigned the Category A
- 57:00classification. This was confirmed by by completing the NIDOE questionnaires,
- 57:08which are included in Appendix D.
- 57:11The DSF Dry Stack facility will not contain materials which could be susceptible to runout type failure involving rapid release of chainings and/or
- 57:21process affected fluids, even event of poor operation or failure of critical controls. Okay, so they're saying we have not in any way considered the
- 57:31consequences of failure. We have decided failure is impossible. We are not even a Class A facility, so we are not. We are even outside of those
- 57:40regulations for the most hazardous waste facilities in Northern Ireland.
- 57:45Okay,
- 57:46now
- 57:50if I was the one evaluating this application, I would have a lot of questions.
- 57:56Okay, the first question I I would have is I first start off by saying, "Do you want to walk that back?
- 58:04Because if you don't want to walk that back, then we're done. Then there's nothing left to talk about.
- 58:09Okay. Because you you say you can't fail.
- 58:13Well, failures have happened. Brazil, January 2022. Mexico, September 2024, Brazil, December
- 58:242024, Indonesia, March 2025, Indonesia again, March 2025, Indonesia March 2026. Talking about failures with fatalities. Yeah. Okay, and telling me
- 58:36failure is impossible.
- 58:39Okay, you know what this is. You know what this is like. This is like someone applying for I don't know a permit to build a transatlantic ship the year
- 58:47after the Titanic sank and saying failure is impossible.
- 58:51Okay,
- 58:53and the permit board would say, "Do you want to tell me something about what happened last year at the Titanic? Like what what what did you learn
- 59:02from that? Why does that not apply to you?
- 59:05Yeah, those are the questions I would be asking.
- 59:08Yeah. Okay. I mean, really, that that is what people call due diligence. Okay. Let's say let's go back through each one of those recent failures. What went
- 59:18wrong? What did we learn from that? Why are you different from that?
- 59:22Okay, if someone comes off, comes right off, started off, failure is impossible. We don't even have to talk about failure. We're not even a Class A
- 59:30facility. I would say then go home, go go back to America.
- 59:34Okay, there's nothing further to discuss here. Yeah. Okay,
- 59:38and I'm sorry, I've been putting you off, but I've left off the very last thing we're saying does not meet industry standard. Okay, okay. So they say they
- 59:46have a plan after after the end of the lifetime of this mine. Sometimes they say 20 years. Sometimes they say 25 years. They say we we will monitor this
- 59:55facility.
- 59:58At first they said five years.
- 1:00:01Then they increased that to 15 years, but that 15 years was just looking at water quality. It wasn't talking about the integrity of integrity of the
- 1:00:11mine waves facility. Okay, yeah. Well, there's an industry standard on how long you're supposed to maintain
- 1:00:20a tailing storage facility,
- 1:00:23okay. And this is not me talking, okay. This is Tailings Management Handbook, Chapter One, First Chapter. What are tailings? It says tailing
- 1:00:31storage facilities require permanent maintenance.
- 1:00:34Okay, that's the industry standard, and permanent-that's a long time longer than five years. Yeah. Okay.
- 1:00:41This this was the cover story in December 2025. Mining engineering,
- 1:00:48it's the flagship journal of Society for Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration by the U.S. Forest Service. So it was now their position that tailing
- 1:00:56storage facilities require permanent maintenance. Yeah, and then they talk about how you're going to pay for that. Is that a trust fund? What needs to be the
- 1:01:04size of the trust fund? But that's their working assumption from now on: is permanent maintenance, right? Okay. Yeah,
- 1:01:13that would be my question. Where's your plan for permanent maintenance, and who's paying for that? Yeah. Okay. Okay.
- 1:01:23Yeah.
- 1:01:27Sorry, I'm giving you kind of long answers. Yeah. No, that's all right.
- 1:01:33Some of these I've asked you, but I want to just go back over a couple of points so
- 1:01:37people get it really.
- 1:01:46How when you're building a tailings waste facility,
- 1:01:52they speak about it being compacted to standard, right? And
- 1:01:58you're building a the waste facility all over the life of the mine. It isn't you just build it one day and then leave it.
- 1:02:05So and then given
- 1:02:09our our
- 1:02:11climate here, where the rain is often coming sideways at you on the hill,
- 1:02:17how did they achieve that day after day and layer after layer, and also given that it's
- 1:02:26well, they say they'll remove all the peat, but that's a hell of a lot peat to remove, you know. Taking that into consideration as well, and peat
- 1:02:33being a spongy type of material, you know. So, have you any comments about about? And and I know you've kind of answered it generally, but just so that the
- 1:02:43layperson on the street, you know.
- 1:02:46Well,
- 1:02:49okay. So, so, so the typical practice is you just accept the fact that
- 1:02:55you can't produce all the tailings with optimum water content. Okay, some will just come out of the filter presses too wet,
- 1:03:04okay? Yeah,
- 1:03:06or or sometimes it's just raining too hard and you just can't keep them dry enough, okay? So usually what you do is you have like a centre part of
- 1:03:15the facility. It's called the non-structural zone, where the tailings are just lightly compacted, okay. And then when you have tailings that have the
- 1:03:25right water content, you put that on the perimeter, and that's called the structural zone, and that acts as like a dam for the tailings that were
- 1:03:34not properly compacted.
- 1:03:37That's the industry standard. Okay,
- 1:03:41nothing I've seen from Dow Radian or SRK Consulting says that's what they're going to do. Okay. Nothing actually says what they're going to do with the
- 1:03:52tailings that are too wet.
- 1:03:54Okay. So
- 1:03:58we have a lot of issues. I mean,
- 1:04:01I I mean, are you going to stockpile them somewhere?
- 1:04:06I I don't know. You say you have issues in areas of high high rainfall, is you can't just spread the tailings out and let them dry in the sun. They can
- 1:04:14just keep getting wetter and wetter. Yeah. Okay. So I didn't see any discussion about what they plan to do with the tailings that are too wet, or
- 1:04:24what they plan to do in during periods of of high rainfall,
- 1:04:29I haven't seen that discussed.
- 1:04:32Okay,
- 1:04:34yeah, and and could it be the case that
- 1:04:37that you discover after
- 1:04:40there's a layer underneath that hasn't been compacted, probably probably because it's too wet or whatever, and and it's been discovered after 1000s of tonnes
- 1:04:50have been put on top of it. Like, is is could that happen?
- 1:04:55Wait, it can't happen, and it does happen. Okay, so I.
- 1:05:00I mean, yes, you have a standard for compaction, but you don't always meet that standard. Okay, so so you you could have insufficient compaction. Okay,
- 1:05:09now as you put more tailings on top, it means those tailings underneath will start to compact under the weight of the overlying tailings, meaning
- 1:05:18they'll start squeezing out the available water, and you'll start having a water table developing
- 1:05:25within that tailings facility. So that's the liquefaction thing begin to happen, is it? No, no, it could be a stage on the way to liquefaction, but it's not
- 1:05:34the same thing as liquefaction. Okay. Okay. So when I say water table, I mean that the pores Are saturated, yeah. Okay, so so even though the pores were
- 1:05:45unsaturated when you first in place the tailings,
- 1:05:49as you compact them more from more weighted tailings on top, you make those pores smaller. Yeah, and and what was not filled with water is now filled
- 1:05:59with water.
- 1:06:01Okay, so we say we say you start to build up a water table. Yeah. Okay. Now we don't want to see that because that could is not the same thing as liquefaction,
- 1:06:09but it could start to set the stage for liquefaction. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I mean, usually when people say filter tailings are not liquefiable,
- 1:06:21they're really meaning if you do everything perfect, if you don't make any mistakes, right? Okay, they come off the filter presses, filter presses with the
- 1:06:30right water content. They're properly compacted. They're compacted under dry weather. You have proper drainage within the facility. The drains don't get
- 1:06:40clogged.
- 1:06:41Yes, if nothing goes wrong, they won't liquefy. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And that reminds me. I forgot an industry standard. Can I? Can I add one more to my? Yes. Yes,
- 1:06:51please. Too. Okay. Okay.
- 1:06:54The industry standard is that you should assume that anything that can liquefy will liquefy. Oh. Okay. Okay, and it means that you should consider what is
- 1:07:04the liquefied strength of this material. When it liquefies, how strong will it be? Okay, and first of all, you got to measure that, and that hasn't been
- 1:07:12measured. Okay, and then you would want to assure yourselves that even if this whole stack is at its liquefied strength,
- 1:07:20it still won't collapse.
- 1:07:22Okay. Okay. Yeah. All of those things are are standards. Not just me talking. Okay. Those are all standards. Right. Okay.
- 1:07:31So I surprised when I started going the list. I started thinking of more.
- 1:07:38I might. I might have come up with eight eight areas of substandard practice, and so there's another one I want to ask you about. I was reading
- 1:07:46that there's a liner underneath it,
- 1:07:50and I hadn't noticed that within the modelling there's always an allowance for some seepage,
- 1:07:58and then I I didn't know if that was normal or not, you know.
- 1:08:02What I want to know is when does seepage become become a problem?
- 1:08:07Oh, I see. Okay. Well, I it's usually assumed that liners will
- 1:08:14will leak.
- 1:08:15Okay. Yeah. Okay. Liners will leak, and liners all also have a limited lifetime. Yeah. What is the what is the the lifetime on liners for
- 1:08:26mine waste tailings facilities?
- 1:08:2950 years is fairly typical. 50
- 1:08:32plastic liner. Okay. High density polyethylene. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. It have a lifetime of about 50 years. Right. I I think some people
- 1:08:41might say 100. That's kind of pushing. I think 50 years is like a standard. Okay. Okay. So especially when you think about this facility, will sit at its
- 1:08:50spot forever.
- 1:08:52Okay. 50 years is not really all that long. No. No. Okay. A liner that had been in place in 1976 would be fully leaking by this point. Okay, so so those are
- 1:09:05kinds of assumptions that are are made. Okay, so liners are nice, but nothing should depend entirely on the existence of a liner. Yeah, and then the
- 1:09:15material inside is still as toxic 50 years from now as it is as when it's freshly put in.
- 1:09:25Yes, correct. Yeah, yeah. Well, okay. Yeah, more or less. So, 50 years time, the place will be even more polluted than original than than it starts out
- 1:09:36originally. You know.
- 1:09:38Well, well, there's kind of because more leakage happening and and so on, you know. Well, that's the trouble. Is everyone's planning for a 20
- 1:09:45year mine? They're not planning for the 20,000 years
- 1:09:50after the mine closes. Yeah.
- 1:09:53Okay, which is what you know our descendants are going to be worried about. Okay.
- 1:10:00Yeah,
- 1:10:03and that really brings us to restoration about what we're actually leaving behind us, you know.
- 1:10:10And then they sure it's going to be restored and revegetated and become part of the landscape. Dot dot dot,
- 1:10:20But
- 1:10:23it never stops really being an engineered mine facility, even though there is vegetation and stuff on top. There's still this,
- 1:10:31you know, toxic problem underneath that never ever goes away.
- 1:10:35Is that correct?
- 1:10:36I mean, really, any engineered structure requires permanent maintenance.
- 1:10:43Okay, engineered structures are either maintained or they're demolished. They they can't be abandoned, or if they're abandoned, they just would
- 1:10:49eventually collapse. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Now, often people will point to a tailings facility. They'll say, "We've made it into a landform.
- 1:11:00Okay. Well, all that means is that it resembles a landform.
- 1:11:05Okay, and
- 1:11:07you keep in mind you have landsliding. Natural landforms undergo landsliding all the time. Yeah. So this is not an unusual. It's not an unusual
- 1:11:15thing. No. I'm sure. I'm sure you have landslides in The Sperrins. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Natural. Okay. Okay. Okay. But but the landslide doesn't
- 1:11:23release,
- 1:11:25you know, billions of metric tonnes of toxic material.
- 1:11:29No, does not. Okay, well, that's an essential difference. Yeah.
- 1:11:35Um, I think maybe I'm coming near my last question, but it's it's not quite monastic. If you're sitting across the table from people who ultimately have
- 1:11:44to decide whether this mine particular mine waste facility should be allowed to go ahead,
- 1:11:52what would you tell them they need to be absolutely certain about before they say yes?
- 1:12:05Okay. Well,
- 1:12:07first of all,
- 1:12:10I I I'll tell you the questions, but we already know the answers. Okay,
- 1:12:16and that sorry, that brings me up another industry standard. Sorry, sorry, they can't do so so slowly. Okay. A
- 1:12:29question I would ask is:
- 1:12:32Are there people living
- 1:12:34down slope from this dating facility? Okay.
- 1:12:38I already know the answer to that. Yeah. Okay. There are. Okay. Yeah.
- 1:12:43Now,
- 1:12:46that's an industry standard. That's also also very common regulatory standard. Is you don't set up a disaster waiting to happen.
- 1:12:55Okay. You don't store the propane tanks in the children's bedroom. Okay. You you know you don't you don't just set up these kinds of catastrophes.
- 1:13:04Okay, that's a very common regulation is a fixed buffer between tailing storage facility and and downstream homes. Okay, for example, People's Republic
- 1:13:15of China they have a minimum distance 1000 metres. Yeah. Okay, that's in in this case for this Cerrinnial project. There's I there's numerous homes
- 1:13:26and a highway. Okay, within 1000 metres downslope of that Tams facility. Okay. Now, for example, in in Brazil, the minimum distance is 10
- 1:13:36kilometres,
- 1:13:38and they can increase that to 25 kilometres depending upon the population density. Ecuador minimum distance is 10
- 1:13:45kilometres. Okay. Yeah.
- 1:13:48I mean, ask the question: Are there people living down slope? Well, I know the answer. The answer is yes. And I say, well, don't do it. Okay. Yeah. That's
- 1:13:56not an that's not an appropriate site for a tailing storage facility is up slope from people's homes. That's not appropriate. Okay. End of
- 1:14:06discussion.
- 1:14:08Indeed, that as as far as we need to go. Okay. But but I'd ask a question even before I'd ask that question. I'd say, do you have the consent of the
- 1:14:17people living down slope? Have they all signed off on this? Are they happy with this?
- 1:14:23Oh, I know the answer to that. That's why we're. That's why. That's why this whole hearing is going on. Yeah, because people. Some people are not happy about
- 1:14:30this. Yeah. Okay. Well, that's the most important thing of all. Yeah. Is is do you do you have their consent? Okay. And I and then I say even you have their
- 1:14:38consent. Do you have a far enough Distance,
- 1:14:41okay.
- 1:14:44So I, I, I would ask those questions. I'd encourage them to ask those questions, but we already know the answers. Yeah.
- 1:14:50Okay.
- 1:14:55I, I, I, I guess.
- 1:15:00It's hard to know how to rank all all the things we've been talking about. Okay, I I guess if I were in a position of a regulator, I'd be coming back to
- 1:15:11the things we talked about earlier. Okay, I'd be asking the mining company. You know, you you said you don't even have to do a failure consequence
- 1:15:18analysis. It's inherently stable. You want to take that back? Yeah. Okay.
- 1:15:25And if they're prepared to take that back, well, okay. Now let's let let's do a failure consequence analysis.
- 1:15:31Okay.
- 1:15:33Because if you don't do a failure consequence analysis,
- 1:15:37how are you going to do an emergency preparedness and response plan? Yeah. What would be the basis for that? Yeah. Okay. Or how do you know how to
- 1:15:45design the facility? I mean, you can have stricter design criteria as you have more serious consequences. Okay. And and anyway, and how do you
- 1:15:55expect the people down slope to make an informed decision if you haven't even told them what the consequences of failure are going to be
- 1:16:03okay. Yeah,
- 1:16:05and and I and I'd say, well, what about all those failures that have occurred
- 1:16:11in 2022, 2024, 2025, 2026? How were you outside of all of that? Yeah, yeah, okay, yeah. I mean, I mean, it's not like a new transatlantic ship, a Titanic,
- 1:16:25sank last year. It'd be like over the last four years, seven of these ships have sunk, and someone's coming up saying it's unsinkable. Well, yeah, I know.
- 1:16:34You want to have a serious discussion or not? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:39I think
- 1:16:40we might leave it on that
- 1:16:43note, Stephen. Okay, thanks very much for chatting to us once again, and
- 1:16:50we're looking forward to seeing you here at the public inquiry in September.
- 1:16:54I'm I'm looking forward to it. Stephen has raised some serious questions about the proposed Kernelt Mine Waste Facility. One of them being, if a serious
- 1:17:05failure has been ruled out by the independent consultant,
- 1:17:10do we, the risk takers, have a clear understanding what the consequences of failure will be and have a plan for it? And then there is the long term question:
- 1:17:22the proposed mine has a finite life; the mine waste does not.
- 1:17:27So, when we hear the word restoration, we need to remember that beneath that restored landscape remains a large engineered mine waste facility
- 1:17:36that must continue to be safe long after mining has stopped. You might say ad infinitum.
- 1:17:44When the inquiry resumes in September, these issues will come into much sharper focus.
- 1:17:50How certain should we be before we agree to leave something like this in The Sperrins permanently? That is the question.
- 1:17:59You have been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline.
- 1:18:05Thank you for joining us today.
- 1:18:07All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the
- 1:18:16conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about
- 1:18:24protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these
- 1:18:34voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 1:18:44who protect them.