Latest / Lantern Voices / Exploring Topics in Non/Human Coexistence, Part 2
Transcript
- 0:14Welcome to Lantern Voices, a podcast by Lantern Publishing
- 0:18and Media. The opinions and information expressed in this podcast
- 0:22do not necessarily reflect the views of Lantern Publishing and Media
- 0:26Incorporated. Welcome back everybody. This is Lantern Voices,
- 0:30a podcast by Lantern Publishing and Media. Hello, I'm your host, Luisa and
- 0:34today we have part two of our interview with the authors and editors of the
- 0:37book Exploring Topics in Non Human Coexistence.
- 0:40Two weeks ago we spoke to Nathan Poirier, Emily Trinetti
- 0:44and Lucrezia Barucca. Today we will talk to Marc Succita, another one of
- 0:48the editors, and with authors Amanda Williams and Varun Joshi.
- 0:52If you're just tuning in to Lantern Voices for the first time, first of
- 0:56all, welcome and thank you for being here. Second, here's a brief
- 0:59introduction to our podcast. We are part of Lantern Publishing and Media, an independent
- 1:04book publisher based in Woodstock, New York. We publish titles related to
- 1:08animal rights, veganism, social justice and more. In this podcast we
- 1:12interview authors, editors and contributors from the books we have published at Lantern.
- 1:16Exploring Topics in Non Human Coexistence is. One of those books.
- 1:19Actually, it was our first release of 2025. It was published on March
- 1:236th and it is a book that gathers a collection of essays about living
- 1:27and coexisting in a larger than human world. The authors come
- 1:31from many backgrounds and the essays talk about black trans feminism,
- 1:35brahminical vegetarianism, spirituality, humane education,
- 1:39and actions that go beyond education when it comes to animal rights
- 1:43activism. This is the first time that we have so many guests in a single
- 1:46episode and it is the first time that we have a two part episode.
- 1:50So if you've been with us for both part one and part two, let us
- 1:54know what you think about this format and if you haven't, but just want to
- 1:57share your thoughts about our discussion or books or podcasts, please do so.
- 2:01You can leave a comment down below if you're listening to this episode on Spotify,
- 2:04Apple Podcasts or YouTube if you're in a different platform.
- 2:08That's all right. Just let us know how we're doing on our social media.
- 2:11We are LanternPM on Instagram and Bluesky, Lantern Publishing and
- 2:16Media on Facebook and LanternPMOfficial on TikTok.
- 2:19And stay tuned to the very end of the interview to get a special discount
- 2:23coupon on our ebook store. So now let's welcome Amanda, Mark and Varun
- 2:27to lend your voices.
- 2:39I'm Amanda Williams. So, I'm Mark Suhida.
- 2:43My name is Varun Joshi. Welcome everybody.
- 2:47Thank you very much for being here today. How are we all feeling about the
- 2:51podcast? Good. Excited to do it and excited that the book has
- 2:55come out and, you know, is getting around.
- 2:59I'm trying to circulate this to my union department so people
- 3:03start talking about the issues in the collection more. And this is such a blessing
- 3:07to be able to do this. Well, thank you for having us. Yeah, I feel
- 3:11the same. I'm super excited. This is dope. I love podcasts.
- 3:14I'm a podcast nerd, so this is great. Thank you. Me too. Me too.
- 3:17I usually listen to podcasts when I'm doing reports and spreadsheets
- 3:21and stuff. So. Yes. Yeah, when we should be working, we are listening to podcasts.
- 3:26Well, I would like to start off by asking, how did you all end
- 3:30up as contributors to this book? What was your journey to get there?
- 3:33Did you knew each other beforehand? Like, how did you end up as contributors
- 3:37to Exploring Topics in Non Human Coexistence? Amanda, you said alphabetical
- 3:42With. With the first name you want to start us off in? Okay. Yeah.
- 3:46I probably have the worst answer to this. I actually don't remember how I got
- 3:50here. Maybe Nathan brought me in. Maybe I'm just coming
- 3:54into existence now. Who knows? But I do know that this chapter, the chapter
- 3:58I wrote in particular on Total Liberty, it was modeled
- 4:02after a chapter in another book that I wrote called the Overprivileged Human.
- 4:06And that book kind of looks at different dimensions of species
- 4:10privilege, one of which is liberty. So for me, it was just like
- 4:14continuing on this particular line of curiosity I had as
- 4:19a scholar activist. I. For me, and I think the answer for a lot of
- 4:22the contributors in this book is that they were brought in this through Nathan Poirier,
- 4:26one of the co editors. I know for a fact that some of the contributors
- 4:30he had connected with through a group called Students for Critical Animal
- 4:34Studies. And they've done online conferences. I think I've
- 4:38seen some of the other contributors work there. I participated in one
- 4:42myself. I know Nate pretty well because we were both graduate students at
- 4:46Michigan State and Sociology at the same time. And we were
- 4:50also both part of a kind of like a specialization,
- 4:53that's what the school called it, on animal studies. So it was like a lot
- 4:57of students in the humanities and social sciences that were
- 5:01interested in animals and culture and just our
- 5:06relationships with different animals and how we could improve upon those.
- 5:09That was a really cool group that was founded by someone named Linda Kalof and
- 5:14her. Her partner, Tom Dietz, who were now like retired
- 5:18professors, but they were kind of some of the earliest People doing a lot of
- 5:21work in this human animal studies area. So I actually met
- 5:25several of the contributors through that program. 7 Mattis writes
- 5:29the last chapter. She graduated from that program. And I also
- 5:33know Jihan Muhammad wrote a chapter on like
- 5:37the Kurdish diet and her experience of being like a Kurdish
- 5:41Muslim vegetarian. She also went through
- 5:45Michigan State. So I think a lot of the connections are made through Nate.
- 5:49Either kind of through Michigan State, through Institute for Critical Animal Studies.
- 5:53And then Nate also was a student at Kinesis University for
- 5:57a master's degree in Buffalo and that's where he met the other co editors.
- 6:01So just a little background about this book. I originally was going
- 6:06to be working with Nate on a different book project. I was a contributor for
- 6:09that and it kind of fell through. I had things come up and I couldn't
- 6:12end up giving him the chapter. So later on he came to me and said,
- 6:16hey, I'm thinking about doing another book and we're gonna have a call for submissions.
- 6:20You know, do you wanna be a co editor and submit something? And I thought,
- 6:24you know, we've been wanting to work together, let's give this a shot.
- 6:28That book got so many submissions that he was a bit overwhelmed by
- 6:32it. And ultimately what we decided to do is put out two books. So they
- 6:36put out another book which I think was called like Expanding the Critical Animal Studies
- 6:41Imagination. And about half of the submissions went in
- 6:45there and then the other half became the framework for
- 6:48this book. So I guess it just goes to show there's so many people interested
- 6:53in these topics after all, considering that,
- 6:57you know, he was able to put out a couple different volumes on it.
- 7:00And I will also add that I haven't met a lot of the contributors yet.
- 7:03So I'm actually just for the first time seeing Amanda and Varun. I've talked to
- 7:07Varun by email and so one of the things that's really cool about this book
- 7:11is that like people are from all over the place. We have an offer in
- 7:14Italy, contributors in the uk, someone from Australia,
- 7:17a co editor that's in New Zealand, and to make
- 7:21appointments to talk about and to make meetings to talk about the book.
- 7:25We had to, you know, work along, whatever, like a 12, 13 hour
- 7:29time difference to make those scheduled info. This is
- 7:33really, it's been like a networking experience putting the book together. It's almost like
- 7:37the network wasn't quite formed before the book came together, came together as
- 7:41we put it all together. So it's a really unique book in that regard
- 7:45that we kind of met each other as we read each other's work. I guess
- 7:49you could say no. That was it was music to my ears. Like it's just
- 7:52so grateful that I get to meet everyone here like this.
- 7:55The biggest benefit of this collection to me is meeting more
- 7:59like minded people that were in that same space. And like I can't. My face
- 8:03is hurting from smiling. I just wanted to shout out Nathan Poirier
- 8:07for I found out about this through him too. Student for Critical Animal Studies
- 8:11Institute for Critical Animal Studies I I followed it in grad school when
- 8:16I found out about it in 2018 and it gave me hope to
- 8:19pursue Green criminology in Canada to build upon it and
- 8:23anything Nathan posts I'm on that trying to
- 8:27be like okay, can I fit this into my schedule? Man, I can't. Oh I
- 8:31can. Like it just it's. And he's been so supportive taking time out of his
- 8:34next level busy schedule to help me
- 8:38and to respond to anything I say. I don't know how he does it,
- 8:41but God bless and so just shout out to him for that's the primary contact
- 8:45to how I found out about this. And I also found
- 8:49that a couple of scholars I try to creep on social media follow they shared
- 8:53it and in my university, I don't know how University of Guelph,
- 8:57they circulated a call for this as well. And so Dr. Sarah May Lindsay,
- 9:01I believe they're at McMaster University right now in
- 9:05Ontario, they circulated this. That got me hyped.
- 9:09And when I saw Aaron Jones and Sarah Tomasello as editors,
- 9:13I recognized their names too from stuff I read on the Student for Critical Animal
- 9:16Studies notifications and the the newsletter stuff I get.
- 9:20So that's how I found out about that and just super,
- 9:25super, super hyped. It's very interesting how we
- 9:29can collaborate with people everywhere and how better our
- 9:33work comes out when we have multiple points of view. My opinion at least is
- 9:37one of the advantages we have in this hyper connected world. Absolutely. Yeah. My next
- 9:41question is for Mark, but everyone can jump in and answer because it's about the
- 9:45book's introduction. So it kind of goes through everybody's work.
- 9:48In the introduction you and the other editors talk about how this book tries to
- 9:52go beyond vegan studies. And in part one, when we were talking
- 9:56with Nathan, Emily and Lucrezia about the word vegan and how
- 10:00when you talk about it it seems like you're branding some sort of content book,
- 10:04restaurant, meal, specific group to a specific group of people. Yet exploring
- 10:08topics show how veganism is actually intertwined with many other social justice and anti oppression
- 10:13fights. Can you talk a little bit more about this in the context of this
- 10:17book? And I think there's one, I don't remember the exact
- 10:20quote, but there's this one moment that you talk about different
- 10:24kinds of oppression, not necessarily putting them like categorizing them
- 10:29into things that they're more pressing or less pressing, that they are all needed
- 10:32to attention and they need to be solved at this moment. Yeah,
- 10:36no, I mean that is what I think too. What pops out is like the
- 10:39best thing about this book is I think it demonstrates how concern
- 10:43for the well being of other animals, animals and their rights is
- 10:47linked with concerns right for humans and the environment in
- 10:51general. And I thought it was interesting how they talked about how like vegan is
- 10:54branding because I kind of get it. It's like you almost make your audience really
- 10:58small when you make something a vegan book because there's a lot of assumptions about
- 11:01what veganism is. And typically that is that one,
- 11:06it's seen as radical, but here we try to demonstrate it's not that radical
- 11:09that intersects and connects with a lot of other causes.
- 11:13And in that regard it's really similar to those. But two, it's also kind
- 11:17of seen as very like white and middle class to
- 11:21upper middle class. And when you just look at, I think the diversity of like
- 11:25authors and perspectives in this book, we shatter that a bit.
- 11:28But most fundamentally, this book really describes like veganism
- 11:32as like a peace movement, a justice movement,
- 11:36and it shares the concerns with other movements. Right,
- 11:40such as like anti racism, gender equity,
- 11:43civil rights causes, combating state oppression,
- 11:47environmental justice. I mean, the first chapter of the
- 11:51book is black trans feminism. Talking about the challenges of putting people
- 11:55in different beings into categories and having to push away from
- 11:58that. So you start to see a lot of the parallels that these
- 12:03different forms of oppressions have as well as the social movements that are trying to
- 12:06combat them. Sometimes I hear the phrase total liberation. I've seen this
- 12:10use in a lot of other books, the idea that none of us are free
- 12:14until all of us are free. And if we can expand our sphere of
- 12:18justice and community more widely, this means having more respect
- 12:21for the earth, having more respect for non
- 12:25human animals and peoples of all backgrounds.
- 12:28And I think this book really demonstrates that because a lot of the chapters
- 12:33touch on sort of parallels between oppression as well
- 12:37as justice for non humans as well as for humans.
- 12:40I mean, for example, Varun has a really interesting chapter and he'll talk a little
- 12:43bit more about it. But, right, but sort of connecting issues that have to do
- 12:47with like the caste system, state oppression, animal welfare,
- 12:51and bringing these causes all together that are usually not presented together.
- 12:55So many chapters do this. And so we try to make the case that
- 12:59really, if you're fighting for justice and for liberty and for freedom
- 13:03for non humans, you're also doing it for humans and vice versa.
- 13:07And this is really important because a lot of times one of the criticisms I
- 13:11get when I tell people that I'm interested in, you know, how we can live
- 13:14more peacefully with other animals and the rest of Earth is that,
- 13:18well, there's so many problems with humans and human rights.
- 13:21And I try to demonstrate, and this book tries to demonstrate
- 13:25that concern for humans and concern for animals can come
- 13:29from the same place. And it's important that we push for both
- 13:33of them. And so there's just so many countless examples in this book across the
- 13:38different chapters of how were so actually intertwined with other animals
- 13:42and the rest of the environment. And I think a lot of the mindset that
- 13:47those things aren't together is just because in Western kind
- 13:51of culture, there's so much emphasis on this, like, humanity and
- 13:55animal or nature duality. And we just struggle to see our
- 13:59human affairs with affairs, you know, affect others
- 14:03that are not human in sort of the same light. So we really try to
- 14:07push that here and just show that oppressions are entangled,
- 14:10all our livelihoods of all living beings are entangled, and therefore
- 14:14justice involves taking a stand for all those
- 14:19different categories, if you will. Yeah, I agree with everything Mark
- 14:22said. And I always look at it as, you know,
- 14:27humans are animals too. The difference is only a political one.
- 14:31It's not one that exists in nature. Right.
- 14:35So, yeah, absolutely. There's this tension around the word vegan.
- 14:39And that's real. It's. It's a term that's become, like, so commercialized,
- 14:44so, like, narrowly associated with lifestyle choices or
- 14:48consumer habits. Like, is this dish vegan? Is this product cruelty
- 14:53free? And like, those choices, don't get me wrong, they can be meaningful for
- 14:57sure, but they also kind of obscure the deeper political roots
- 15:02or like, the radical potential of veganism. And I think really in this
- 15:06book, all of the chapters kind of speak to, like, this pushing back
- 15:10or pushing back of this narrow branding of veganism and bringing
- 15:15it really back into conversation with broader movements for justice.
- 15:19And so we're seeing it not as a siloed issue,
- 15:22but it's part of this interconnected web of struggles,
- 15:26like Mark mentioned, against white supremacy, patriarchy,
- 15:29capitalism, Ableism, settler colonialism, boar, all of it.
- 15:33The way animals are treated, it's not separate from how
- 15:37humans are treated. The systems of domination that
- 15:41are linked, so their liberation has to be linked too.
- 15:44My chapter, for example, it looks at species privilege through
- 15:49the lens of liberty. It shows how more than human beings
- 15:53are denied autonomy in the same systems that also restrict
- 15:57the liberty of marginalized humans. And we explore
- 16:02how the logic that underpins things like animal agriculture,
- 16:05ownership control, reproductive coercion,
- 16:09forced confinement is all mirrored in the oppression of
- 16:13women, immigrants, disabled humans and others.
- 16:16So when we say we're going like beyond vegan,
- 16:20vegan studies, whatever that means, we're not like leaving
- 16:23it behind, but we're rooting it more deeply in this like radical potential.
- 16:28It's not really branding veganism for mass appeal, it's unbranding
- 16:33it kind of from purity politics. And we're wanting
- 16:38to align it with resistance, with care, with solidarity and
- 16:42total liberation. Like Mark said on what Amanda and Mark were saying, I agree with
- 16:46everything that they said and they articulated it so beautifully. And I felt as though
- 16:50when it comes to discussing how veganism intertwined with other social justice issues
- 16:54and anti oppression fights, I almost felt as though there's a explicit
- 16:58but also implicit protest against commodification.
- 17:02We can call it tied to capitalism and the ways in which the
- 17:06term vegan is tied to consumerism, things like
- 17:10diet, where other aspects of the consumerism aren't even considered, like the use
- 17:13of leather or animal testing and like cosmetic products.
- 17:17And by just kind of conflicting against that,
- 17:22like struggling against it. I felt as though there was a return to
- 17:26bring the term justice and harm back to veganism, to remind,
- 17:31I guess the audience, maybe not the intended audience, but just to bring
- 17:35back those notions of justice and harm and hell, that's what it's always been about.
- 17:38That's what the notion of the ideology behind it, prior to even
- 17:42being a term in whatever years it was coined, now it was ultimately about reducing
- 17:46harm, about achieving some semblance of justice and how
- 17:50it's, it's not this independent random
- 17:54thing that is for a select group of, insert whatever negative stereotypes people
- 17:58come up with these days, white hippies that just do drugs and only eat tempeh,
- 18:02like whatever that is, it's fighting against that and saying no, it's a return
- 18:06to something that's more authentic, that's already been here
- 18:09for a long time. And let's, let's return to that. Let's, let's take a step
- 18:14back and stop looking at it. As whatever it's been associated with through
- 18:17this next level of commodification and association with capitalism and consumerism.
- 18:25We know the vegan activist community is out there and we want to
- 18:29connect with each and every one of you. We are proud supporters of
- 18:33initiatives that fight for a more compassionate world for all animals,
- 18:37humans and non humans alike. For more content
- 18:41on vegan activism, follow Lantern OS social media. We are Lantern
- 18:45publishing and media on Facebook, @LAWPM on Instagram
- 18:49and @LAWPM official on TikTok.
- 18:55That's very interesting that you bring up, going back to what it used to be
- 18:59and all that. I feel like most of my friends, acquaintances,
- 19:03family, they're not vegans or vegetarians. They usually use the
- 19:07argument as, oh, that's what cave people used to do. That's what my
- 19:11ancestors used to do. And when you look into it, especially, like,
- 19:14I come from South America, I'm Brazilian, and definitely we come from like many,
- 19:18many places, just like the rest of the people in the Americas. But if you
- 19:22look for the native Brazilians and how they were living, we're far
- 19:26away from what we have as a society model right now and far away
- 19:30from the farming and exploitation of animals that we have in society right
- 19:34now. So it's not, it's not exactly what people say.
- 19:38Varun, that one is for you. Before I go to the question itself itself,
- 19:41I would like to just comment something that it was very
- 19:45interesting for me reading your essay in particular. I have a very close
- 19:49friend here who promised to hear this episode. Let's see if she will. But she
- 19:54is from India and she is Punjabi and she was telling me,
- 19:58she keeps telling me about how vegetarianism works for Punjabi folks.
- 20:02And I learned a lot about it with her, but definitely,
- 20:06like, not everything there is to learn about it. And when I was reading your
- 20:10essay, a lot of her words came to mind to me because in
- 20:14Brazil we have this very specific idea
- 20:18of India as being this paradise for cows and, like,
- 20:22where they are completely safe from harm and everybody is vegetarian at
- 20:26least, and everybody is, like, centered and in peace
- 20:30with themselves. And this idea that's far away from
- 20:34what you showed in your essay and far away from what my friend tells me.
- 20:36So I think that that was initially very interesting to
- 20:40see how even in a culture that has some sort of cow
- 20:45protection that you described in the, in the essay,
- 20:49it's still very much rooted in the idea of dominance.
- 20:52So initially that was already a very interesting thing
- 20:56that I learned about India in your essay. But for this question, I would like
- 21:00to focus a little bit on what you talk about, the idea of ecocentrism as
- 21:03a possible pillar in which to base protection to the animals.
- 21:07I assume that we can talk about India, but also the rest of the
- 21:11world could benefit from this. And if you could briefly describe the
- 21:15idea of ecocentrism that you described in your chapter for our listeners who
- 21:19have not yet read the book and then give us some examples of how it
- 21:22could be a good starting point for a society that is more just toward more
- 21:27than human world. Absolutely. And thank you for sharing that. I, I,
- 21:31I hope your friend that listens to it like Namaste and Satsukal and
- 21:35I hope you enjoy the absolute heck out of, out of the whole collection.
- 21:37So just to start off with like the theoretical jargon,
- 21:41which I'll be honest, one thing that I love about animal studies, green crim,
- 21:44environmental sociology, is the theoretical stuff is just so much more easy to
- 21:48relate to and to think about in a more practical, applicable sense. So eocentrism,
- 21:53ecentrism, it's, I believe it was coined at first,
- 21:56I'm gonna apologies in advance, I'm probably gonna mispronounce a lot of names. I believe
- 22:00the individual's name was Aldo Leopold. And to
- 22:03define ecocentrism we kind of have to talk about a couple of two other isms
- 22:08that it's responding to. One being anthropocentrism,
- 22:11which is essentially the belief that humans are more special
- 22:15than the natural world and the non human. It prioritized the well
- 22:19being, the needs and the integrity of humans and human constructs
- 22:23over animals and the environment. It's a justification for almost every law we
- 22:27see in the world when it comes to governing animals or land.
- 22:31There's also biocentrism, which it recognizes that all
- 22:34living beings, animals, plants, they have intrinsic value and that it
- 22:39needs to be respected. And there's moral value attributed towards every single
- 22:43life, which at first glance seems really, really nice,
- 22:46but just we also have to fundamentally recognize that both anthropocentrism
- 22:50and biocentrism, the way it's been embodied in the actions of humans throughout
- 22:54history, has been pretty messed up for anthropocentrism, that's easy. A lot of messed
- 22:58up things are justified, like the mass killing of animals, abhorrent treatment of other beings,
- 23:03including humans. In biocentrism first class. It seems nice that
- 23:07we're going to recognize the intrinsic value of all animals. The problem is based
- 23:11off the actions of animal rights activists and a lot of social movements.
- 23:15Throughout history, they end up prioritizing animal rights and
- 23:20undermining human rights. In the process of doing that, in trying
- 23:24to recognize and achieve justice and achieve some kind of compensation
- 23:28for the harm they experience and just the awareness efforts, some of the actions can
- 23:32end up almost making fun of the different struggles that humans experience of.
- 23:36For biocentrists, like a classic example can be something like
- 23:40you have vegan activists or animal rights activists, I don't want to say vegans.
- 23:43Sometimes animal rights activists in general can try to accomplish this. A very easy example
- 23:47is the way seal hunts in Canada are
- 23:51treated where I'm against the hunting of seals. But I also recognize that
- 23:55there's. It's a lot more complex issue than saying something like, just don't kill seals
- 23:59at all. The communities that are engaged in the seal hunt often live in extreme
- 24:03poverty, food scarcity, food deserts that are intentionally designed that
- 24:07way. And when you just target seal hunting that they use for
- 24:11sustenance and for clothing and literal living, without acknowledging
- 24:15the other issues that come in behind that, a little bit of racism is coming
- 24:19out play, a little bit of settler colonialism is being reinforced. And sometimes it's
- 24:22not the intention of the activists that are pursuing those type of behaviors, but they
- 24:26end up manifesting the results of their actions and the lack of consideration
- 24:30and planning they're doing prior to engaging in their activities. So, so ecocentrism
- 24:34started off as more like an environmental, sociological. Just let's just look at the ecosystem
- 24:38as something holistic. Let's look out for ecosystems that will in healthy
- 24:43way, that promotes the natural land, but also the beings on that land, both humans
- 24:47and animals. But then in green criminology, which is kind of the way I interpreted
- 24:50ecocentrism from the work of Halsey and White, is it recognizes that it
- 24:55does one thing a little bit more radical than the initial conception of ecocentrism.
- 24:58It says, yes, we're going to prioritize the ecosystem, but not at
- 25:02the cost of maintaining arbitrary notions of what that looks like.
- 25:06Ecocentrism was first mentioned. I mean, it justified
- 25:09animal cullings, which on its own, I mean, yes, whole ecosystem can
- 25:13be justified. But even in the context of animal cullings, those are happening
- 25:17to preserve artificial boundaries of keeping animals separate from humans and not questioning
- 25:22and interrogating what, why those boundaries exist, who they benefit. So ecocentrism
- 25:26within a green criminology context are saying that, nope, animals and the
- 25:30non humans matters, but humans also matter. Can we walk this fine
- 25:34line, this very, very, almost impossible tightrope of making sure the
- 25:38rights are respected for every being involved. Can we
- 25:41try to look at each situation as unique and recognize that
- 25:45there needs to be the maximum amount of harm reduction in almost every
- 25:49social actor involved, whether it's the humans, the animals, the rivers,
- 25:53the land, the trees. So to apply that to what I wrote about. Sorry for
- 25:57this ramble, but like, I just need to do a bit of situating for what
- 25:59I talked about because, yes, I gotta reckon we have to recognize I'm.
- 26:04I'm a pretty privileged Indo Canadian Punjabi man who was
- 26:07born in Canada, that I don't have firsthand experience of what this looks like.
- 26:11I was inspired by Yamini Narayan's work, God bless her, and I was
- 26:15so inspirational to read her work. But as a Punjabi man who is
- 26:19a son of dairy farmers in India, I have a very limited understanding of what
- 26:23these issues actually look like. And I'm an outsider speaking about this, even if Punjabi
- 26:27is my first language and I think in it. So just. And what I'm going
- 26:30to talk about in regards to India, I'm talking about it as someone who's.
- 26:33I'm not Indian, I'm Canadian. I, I am culturally Canadian. I am.
- 26:38Take everything I say with a grain of salt and look at the references
- 26:41I wrote and then verify everything I've written for yourselves, anyone who's listening to this
- 26:45and read this chapter to what's happening in India with cows and just animals
- 26:49in general. First, we gotta recognize India is, is not a
- 26:52country. It's. It's a social construct that was created by the British and
- 26:56the elites in India at the time that benefited from a
- 27:00very arbitrary notion of let's just create a country. India has
- 27:0420 plus languages. It's composed of states that have very different
- 27:08cultures, a lot of commonalities, but there's a lot of different cultures. And it's been
- 27:11forced to exist as one country called India. Like, it doesn't
- 27:15make any sense. It's the equivalent of asking all of Europe to be one country
- 27:19and then arbitrarily selecting one language, saying, this is the language everyone's going
- 27:23to communicate in and be taught in. And even the term Hindu, like I'm a
- 27:27practicing Hindu, but that term doesn't exist in our faith. The original term is Sanatam
- 27:30Garam. Hindu just refers to people of the,
- 27:34the Sindhi Valley, Sindhi river, the Indus
- 27:38region. This was a term created by Mughals. Like, this is.
- 27:41We're already talking about how animals and people are treated in
- 27:45a political and geographical space that already
- 27:49has. So Much dispute and complexity in the ways in which they relate to one
- 27:53another. So ecocentrism, from my lens and from my
- 27:57perspective, just gives us a tool that we can just recognize this whole topic.
- 28:01Talking about anything in India, something as controversial as animal rights,
- 28:05something as complex as animal rights, and in human rights is a cluster fudge.
- 28:09It is not going to be easy. And there's multiple social actors involved
- 28:13that we have to account for. So how can we account for all social actors
- 28:16in a way that lets us at least attempt to respect their integrity,
- 28:20their. Their bodily autonomy and make sure that while we make any claims,
- 28:24any discussions, the least amount of harm is achieved. And you know, a lot of
- 28:27existing tools, they have a lot of value in other contexts. Matrices of oppression,
- 28:31intersectionality, unweld. I love all these terms, but I just. For myself,
- 28:35it was harder to apply them to India because of the different human dimensions
- 28:40that come up, like language, religion, caste,
- 28:43regionality. I figured ecocentrism would be a fun way to kind
- 28:47of interact with this. And it allowed me to kind of look at
- 28:51the ways in which cows are treated, but also the ways in which people of
- 28:55different castes are literally yanked from one social structure to
- 28:59another by a more dominant power to do with,
- 29:02with them whatever they kind of wanted. And I think going forward, I. I would
- 29:06like to believe that ecocentrism, it can be a good starting point to interrogate
- 29:10and just understand what a situation is when you're looking
- 29:14at it. If you think there's any types of harms being produced against humans,
- 29:17against animals, against the environment. Start with the fundamental questions that ecocentrism
- 29:21asks of how's the land being affected? How are humans being affected?
- 29:25How is the non human being affected? I think that very much to demonstrates
- 29:29kind of what you brought up at the beginning about like how this is more
- 29:31than just like a vegan book, because Verman really unpacks the complexity
- 29:35of even just that situation. Looking at using that ecocentric lens,
- 29:39which isn't, you know, is in many ways distinct and much wider than what we
- 29:43may think of like a stereotypical vegan lens. And there's
- 29:47just so many chapters that do that. I see a lot of similarities between Varun's
- 29:51chapter and the one by Jihan Muhammad too, about her experience of sort of reconnecting
- 29:55with native plants from Iraqi Kurdistan and sort of
- 29:59how the. Because of colonial forces being forced
- 30:03into cities by like the Saddam Hussein regime and those sorts of things.
- 30:07And so there's so many just overlap between human rights, but also
- 30:11the environment and Animals, and you just can't disentangle them. And that's what
- 30:15Varun's chapter and many of the other chapters show. And I think something that
- 30:19was interesting about your chapter, Varun, is it seemed that the cow was such an
- 30:22absent actor, despite the fact that all the discourses
- 30:26around the cow, most of this discourse around the cow actually had to do with
- 30:29human groups and human activities. Would you say
- 30:33that's. That's correct. Absolutely. Cows in this conversation are.
- 30:37They're the absent reference. They're not actually talked about and considered.
- 30:42On one hand, you have, let's call them what they are. You have Hindu nationalists
- 30:45that think they need to be protected under any, under any circumstance,
- 30:50but they use identifications, then flick violence on whomever they perceive as messing
- 30:54with cows, but the actual safety and security of cows isn't being guaranteed.
- 30:58Then you have people that say, you can't tell us what not to do with
- 31:02our diets, our cultural heritage. And in protesting that,
- 31:05once again, the cows are probably getting the worst end of the whole situation,
- 31:10where I think one of the examples I used was protesting cow
- 31:14protector violence by consuming beef at a beef festival. It's like,
- 31:18yes, you're protesting and you're right to your culture and your heritage,
- 31:22but that's same violence that cow protectors, I hate using
- 31:26that term, cow protectors or gold rush tricks are using to try to achieve security
- 31:30for cows by targeting people that allegedly harm them. Like, you're reproducing that
- 31:34same violence. And it's just, I found it ironic to talk about and read when
- 31:38I. Was reading your chapter and you mentioned something about these folks, they're the
- 31:42cow protectors that you mentioned, that they're like, we are not going to do any
- 31:46harm, but we are providing laws and establishment for people who don't
- 31:50have an issue with that so they can exploit it and generate money. And I'm
- 31:53like, well, that's doing harm by proxy, in my opinion. And it's just like the
- 31:58only way I can cope with it is laugh at how absurd this is.
- 32:00Like, and like, I don't want to make light of the situation, but it's like
- 32:03when you see someone, when you see groups like this in a country where your
- 32:07family is from behave like this. It's, it's. Yeah,
- 32:10it's depressing and, but at the same time, I feel like it does provide that
- 32:14opportunity to start challenging what these sources of arms are, is like, where do
- 32:18go ruckshucks? Where does that entitle? Where's that entitlement come from.
- 32:22Where does that perspective of we can weaponize something
- 32:27like a term like cow protector to enforce our own political will.
- 32:30And that gives us an opportunity to examine a lot of other sources of just
- 32:35not okay things. And let's just start identifying these different structures that
- 32:39we can hopefully start identifying as the maybe the core things
- 32:42everyone that's against these types of violences should be targeting. And in this case
- 32:46in India, rabbinical vegetarianism, which I just wanted to find that as well in India
- 32:51right now, it's a very, very Hindu nationalist state that is
- 32:55reinforcing a type of Hinduism that benefits and prioritizes people
- 32:59of the Brahmin caste. I am of this caste myself. These are individuals that are
- 33:02predominantly been in education and religion,
- 33:05occupation throughout history. And contrary to how the caste system is perceived, it's not this
- 33:09static. Once you're born into it, you're born into it dynamic. The caste system is
- 33:13just a way to describe whatever profession you really did. And medieval
- 33:17and feudal India. And Brahminical vegetarianism reinforces
- 33:21Brahman notions of animal welfare, that cows are specifically bovine
- 33:26cows, not buffaloes or bulls. Cows are at the top of
- 33:29this animal hierarchy because of their use, value, produce, milk, can be
- 33:34used in labor, companionship. They provide as just social beings.
- 33:38They're given more privileges than other animals.
- 33:42But ultimately they're also just used in a. They're a tool.
- 33:45They're used at the expenses of everyone in India. And Brahmins,
- 33:50despite taking care of them for most of their life, will still be complicit in
- 33:53allowing them to be killed off. Can't physically take care of every cow that you
- 33:56use for milk. And so Brahminico vegetarianism prioritizes cows, but that's
- 33:59pretty much the only animal that's being prioritized. Anyone who is doing anything to cows
- 34:04that they deem as inappropriate can be subject to extreme
- 34:08violence. They become. I want to make sure I pronounce the name right. Homo saucer.
- 34:13I'm sure I'm mispronouncing that, but this, this is a term called bare light.
- 34:16It means that being can be subject to whatever the more dominant powers
- 34:20want. They can treat the being with respect if they want. They can treat the
- 34:24being and dress it up in ceremonies and make it appear as though being is
- 34:28being respected. Or with the flick of a wrist, they can authorize the being's death
- 34:32and commodification. It's what Mark was mentioning. Like it's the cows
- 34:36in reference to the humans. Like what they can provide to the humans and not
- 34:39to their own benefit, which touches a little bit on what we
- 34:43were discussing in part one. That was the principle of non interference.
- 34:47We talked a lot about that in part one, so I'm gonna just pass it
- 34:51real quick here. But it is something that Nathan was mentioning about
- 34:55thinking about what the animals want for themselves instead of
- 34:59thinking what we can do for them. Trying to just make the connections between
- 35:03all these various human affairs. And of course you
- 35:08know, to us in this, in this group, it's very obvious. But sometimes to,
- 35:12you know, many others, it's not as obvious the way that what the
- 35:16humans are doing is obviously heavily intertwined with what the other animals are doing.
- 35:19Right. We don't live exists in a vacuum.
- 35:27Do you love new books? Do you need more titles about veganism,
- 35:32animal rights and climate activism on your bookshelf? Then go
- 35:35to lanternpm.org and check out all our books and ebooks available
- 35:39for purchase. You can find anything from beautiful illustrated picture books
- 35:44that introduce children to the values of compassion for our fellow animals to
- 35:48thoroughly researched non fiction books that give you
- 35:51all the facts to help you live a healthy vegan Life.
- 35:55Go to lanternpm.org and explore all of her books today.
- 36:02So Amanda, my next question is for you. You co wrote this
- 36:06chapter with Paisley, right? You two make an
- 36:10interesting parallel between the concepts of freedom and liberty. That hadn't
- 36:15occurred to me. Maybe because English is not my first language. I thought those were
- 36:18synonyms. And then when I was reading I was like, oh wait, there's a difference.
- 36:21And we have been seeing this year in the United States multiple situations
- 36:25in which freedom is being used as an argument to restrict liberties.
- 36:28I feel particularly especially after reading some examples that you say
- 36:32in your chapter. So since writing this chapter, do you believe activists
- 36:37should change or perhaps adapt their approaches to activism given the current situation?
- 36:41I know it's a very hard question, especially because at this moment
- 36:45we kind of don't know what we're dealing with very much. But do you believe
- 36:49there's anything that we could do, adapt or change given the current
- 36:53state of situation? I'm definitely not an authority on
- 36:56what activists should be doing right now. Obviously it's multifaceted
- 37:01and all of the issues are complex.
- 37:04Even singular issue is complex. But yeah, I do
- 37:08think activists could be more attentive to how language
- 37:12is used for sure, and how it's misused,
- 37:15especially in like political and organizing spaces. In the
- 37:19chapter we draw this distinction, as you mentioned,
- 37:23where freedom kind of represents this total absence of
- 37:27restraint, which means it can easily be used to justify
- 37:31harm, like claiming the freedom to deny someone healthcare,
- 37:35for example, or the freedom to exploit other beings.
- 37:38Liberty, kind of in contrast, is about balance
- 37:42and it's about responsibility. It's like this ethical exercise
- 37:46of freedom, but without infringing on others autonomy.
- 37:50So that distinction has become more urgent,
- 37:54like you said. I mean, here in the US we're seeing freedom invoked
- 37:58as a kind of rhetorical weapon to justify policies that actually restrict
- 38:03liberties. So whether that's targeting, you know, trans people, or it's criminalizing
- 38:08abortion, or it's eroding protections on the environment. So as activists,
- 38:13we have to be kind of sharp about how we talk about liberation.
- 38:16It's not just about individual freedoms. It's about building
- 38:20a world where everyone's liberty is respected and
- 38:25protected, including those outside the human species. And in
- 38:29the chapter, you know, we advocate for total liberation, which means confronting
- 38:34all the systems of domination. That's speciesism,
- 38:37racism, patriarchy, ableism, all of it.
- 38:40Adapting our activism. It doesn't mean diluting
- 38:45it. It means making it more precise, but also more expansive
- 38:49and deeply, deeply rooted in solidarity. Not like
- 38:53my freedom at your expense, but a shared kind of collective
- 38:58liberty that holds space for all beings to live and,
- 39:02and to move around and to flourish. One of the things I like the most
- 39:05about this podcast is that I have possibility of adding a little bit of personal
- 39:09notes to every question that I bring. And in your chapter, I think one
- 39:13of the things that touched me the most is living in the United States as
- 39:16a non citizen, but also from Latin America.
- 39:20So when I was reading all about, like, the.
- 39:24The border in Mexico and how it's restricting not only humans,
- 39:28but also the animals and the native species that always been there
- 39:32to just carry on with their lives, that was something that touched
- 39:36me very deeply. And I was thinking about how
- 39:40for seemingly arbitrary reasons. Right.
- 39:44That we all, all of the species should have to move and to go
- 39:47wherever they want to go. It's. It's just getting harder. Yeah.
- 39:51Liberty is so many things, but I think like you said, the first thing we
- 39:55kind of think of is movement. Movement. So, you know, it's so important, it's so
- 39:59intrinsic to what it means to be an animal. Right. That's like definitionally,
- 40:02I mean, there are some animals that don't move like sea sponges,
- 40:07but for the most part, animals move. And having autonomy, having liberty
- 40:11means that freedom of movement. So, yeah,
- 40:15I'm happy you picked up on that. And that resonated with you. Yeah,
- 40:18very much. Very much. Yeah. So that's that's why my.
- 40:21That's where my question came from, actually. And also, if I can add a follow
- 40:26up in your activism and in your life so far,
- 40:29have you found either moments of,
- 40:33I would say, joy for coping or found
- 40:36actions that you took that you're like, no, I think I should follow this
- 40:40line of activism right now, or I should follow. Even if it's like, I need
- 40:44five moments to drink tea with my friends because that brings my
- 40:48brain to the right spot. Like, have you found any of those actions that
- 40:52have been helping you through this moment? Man, being an activist is
- 40:56really hard. And. But yeah, no, to answer your question about joy,
- 41:00yeah, but it's not always in the way I expected.
- 41:04Since finishing this chapter, my life has changed in
- 41:07really profound ways. I went through a divorce,
- 41:11I lost my job, I moved to a new city. I got
- 41:15a whole new family, which includes human children. That's new.
- 41:18So it's been this time of like, really deep transformation for me. And honestly,
- 41:23I don't. I definitely wouldn't have made it through without, like, this intentional
- 41:27practice of joy. That's very important to me to have a gratitude
- 41:33practice because the wider, the wider world is so terrifying.
- 41:37The political climate, you know, the violence, the rising authoritarianism,
- 41:42you know, I'm speaking from a US perspective, but, you know, it's global
- 41:46issues. It's just a lie. And if, if I don't ground myself in these
- 41:50kind of like small everyday moments of joy,
- 41:53I can't keep going. And for, to me, to me, this might, you know,
- 41:57this might be like watching birds out my window with one of my kids or
- 42:01sharing a joint with a friend and like, giggling about something stupid
- 42:05or like taking my dog to the park and watching him pee on every
- 42:09single tree and leaf and rock and twig
- 42:13and then going back to do it all over again. And these,
- 42:18these moments, they don't fix the world, but they do kind of root
- 42:21me in it, if that makes sense. And it reminds me what, you know,
- 42:25what I'm here for, what I'm fighting for. And then kind of like on
- 42:29a more collective level, for the last year and a half, I've been
- 42:33working on a pressure campaign here in Kansas City to free this
- 42:37capuchin monkey. He's been imprisoned in this pet
- 42:41store in Kansas. And that's been really heavy. But it's also,
- 42:46it's given me something really meaningful as well. And it's like hope
- 42:50through community. And it's like working alongside local activists,
- 42:54meeting people in the community and realizing that really
- 42:59in a real way that we don't have to be the same to
- 43:02be together. And that's like deeply, that's deeply inspiring. And that
- 43:06gives me hope and it gives me joy. It reminds me that like coalition
- 43:11building, it's still possible even, you know, even in a world that's
- 43:15so fragmented and polarized. You know, if we can come together for one
- 43:19monkey, his name is Frankie in one city, you know,
- 43:22maybe we can do that for other injustices too. So, yeah, to your question,
- 43:26yes, both joy and hope show up for me.
- 43:30But it's not always big or flashy.
- 43:32It's quiet. It's in the midst of struggle.
- 43:36That's enough to keep going, I think. And I will get back to that question
- 43:40for everybody. In the end.
- 43:43If you're a human being living in the 21st century, chances are that
- 43:47you check your email every day. Also, chances are that your
- 43:51inbox is constantly pretty full. We know how important it is
- 43:55to keep up to date with things that matter. This is why our newsletter
- 43:59is so amazing. We only send one newsletter a month and within
- 44:03it you'll find all our latest news and sometimes access
- 44:07to exclusive content. Recently we went through all our contacts
- 44:11and did a huge cleanup, trying our best to make sure that no one is
- 44:15in the list multiple times. And no one's gonna keep getting tons of emails.
- 44:19We want to keep you informed without overwhelming you with
- 44:23a thousand messages. We know you don't have time to waste with 100
- 44:27new emails. Give your time to what really matters. Go to lanternpm.org
- 44:32and sign up for our newsletter today.
- 44:38Mark. Your essay debunks three myths about animal
- 44:42liberation and activism and I would like to focus for this question on number three.
- 44:47You mentioned that activists should go beyond providing information about
- 44:51suffering of non human animals, but actively try to engage with humans
- 44:56and show how suffering is often not aligned with their own personal values.
- 44:59What do you believe makes it so hard for humans to understand that non human
- 45:04suffering deserves to be stopped as much as human suffering? Thinking about this question,
- 45:08I could hit at it from a couple angles, I guess. First, just to kind
- 45:11of provide some context. Right. The chapter is looking at what are some
- 45:15common beliefs about, you could say animal liberation activism and
- 45:20veganism that not only necessarily that activists have, but the general
- 45:24public has about it. And I tried to dispel some of those. So some of
- 45:27the ones were ones things we kind of already hit on that there's this idea
- 45:30that, you know, people that advocate for these causes
- 45:34only care about animals. They don't care about humans. And the whole purpose of this
- 45:37book is this total liberation framework, that humans don't exist in
- 45:40a vacuum, that suffering can be shared through these entanglements. And we're
- 45:44just asking people to simply expand their lens and their view of community
- 45:48to include everyone. But that third part
- 45:51is really specifically at third miss really targeted to
- 45:55people that are trying to do this animal liberation work. Because I see a lot
- 45:59of people, they're good people, they're putting in a ton of like blood,
- 46:03sweat and tears, doing things like, you know, pamphletting, traveling around the country,
- 46:07showing films. And those things are valuable. But one of
- 46:11the questions I've asked, and I try to draw on some of those social science
- 46:15research I'm familiar with, which is sort of how values as guiding principles in
- 46:19our lives or these things that are kind of deeply socialized within us that we
- 46:23develop when we're young, and they are kind of the lens through which we see
- 46:27different social issues and how we relate to them. And the myth,
- 46:31I wrote it down. So just to say exactly the one we're talking about is
- 46:34providing people with information is sufficient to change their beliefs and attitudes.
- 46:38What I try to argue is that there's some content you'll show people that certain
- 46:42people just won't be that receptive to. You make it like an emotional response from
- 46:47them witnessing suffering, but they're not necessarily gonna just start acting and
- 46:52behaving differently. And so the idea then is that what
- 46:57are the different ways you can like package your message to still promote
- 47:01ways to reduce animal suffering for someone who's maybe not necessarily going to see
- 47:05some graphic film and suddenly become vegan? Right. So I'm skeptical
- 47:09of how effective those techniques are because I think they only tend to
- 47:12work on people who are already, because of their values, receptive to that
- 47:16message. And so one of the things I talk about is like,
- 47:20there's a lot of other approaches. For example, many people I know
- 47:24who like have a plant based diet, their concerns really aren't so much like ethics
- 47:29of treatment of animals, but it's like reducing carbon footprint or personal health.
- 47:33And while that's a different frame than I see it in, it could still
- 47:37benefit, you know, animals in the environment nonetheless.
- 47:40So what are the different ways we can package these things?
- 47:44And for many of those people, the way we have to package these
- 47:48things differently is because they do see non human
- 47:51suffering as distinctly different from human suffering. They don't see it as
- 47:56problematic. Right. They may have adopted the view that animals
- 47:59are kind of not very sophisticated and don't experience These
- 48:03things in the ways that we do. And I think it really all hearkens
- 48:08back to what I mentioned earlier, that I just think there's such a deeply
- 48:11established, like, worldview in a lot of,
- 48:15like, Western cultures that, that humanity and the
- 48:19rest of existence sort of exist in totally different circles.
- 48:23You know, one example that you see of this a lot is sort of the
- 48:26discussion in the Bible. And at least one common interpretation of it, right, Is that
- 48:30God had given humans dominion over the planet. And one way to interpret
- 48:35that is really the planet is a series of natural resources that we can use
- 48:39and animals are included in there. And we're created
- 48:43in the direct image of God. And the other beings aren't maybe necessarily they're just
- 48:47other creations for us. And I really think it's those,
- 48:51like, fundamental, the stories, the myths
- 48:55in our culture that really precede all the actual
- 48:59practices we have that are exploitative to animals and, and many others in
- 49:02the first place. Right. And so I teach a lot of classes at a university
- 49:06on like, environmental studies and sociology. And this is like a
- 49:10big thing. I try to push that. I think the basis of
- 49:14our really violent relationships with the rest of our planet in other
- 49:18animals is a byproduct of that worldview. And I think we have
- 49:22such a hard time kind of crossing this, this gap we've
- 49:27created between human and animal. So much so that that's why you probably
- 49:31see in mainstream society, veganism, something that's almost kind of laughed
- 49:34at or seen as sort of out there because people just can't imagine, like,
- 49:38closing that gap. And I think that's why it's hard. So in the chapter,
- 49:42I kind of say one, some people are not going to come around to this
- 49:44and seeing animal suffering as like equal or interconnected with human suffering.
- 49:48And you could still maybe reach them in some positive ways, but it's
- 49:52going to be a different frame. It might be more of like, how does this
- 49:54benefit you? There's such a hierarchy. Just like we see, you know, hierarchies in,
- 49:58in race and gender that are harmful. We see this in a very extreme form
- 50:02in the non human and human way. And it
- 50:06just comes to that, the socialization of those beliefs and values
- 50:10and kind of the culture myths, they're so deep that you can
- 50:14try and spend a lifetime changing them in people. And it's not a change that
- 50:18comes easy. And I really think it kind of just comes down to that.
- 50:21I've been asking a lot about what activists could do, what you think activists could
- 50:25do, but I think it's important to notice that our audience
- 50:28at LANTERN is mostly activists and mostly people who are eager
- 50:33to know more and see what other people are doing
- 50:37so they can collaborate. That's why we talk a lot about activists here. But if
- 50:41you think about activists, non activists, vegan and even vegan allies,
- 50:45which is a concept that have been recently presented that I thought it was very
- 50:48interesting, how do you think, all of you, that we can
- 50:53all, myself included, all of us, can help people
- 50:56who still don't understand the idea of species, the idea that
- 51:01there's a hierarchy among species, as another issue
- 51:05of our time, of the Anthropocene? Do you think that there
- 51:08is a way or maybe from your personal experience or studies that you found that
- 51:13people got convinced and understood this concept?
- 51:16Yeah, I can go first. Yeah, I really appreciate this question. Yeah.
- 51:20And I think we're all touching on this common misconception
- 51:24that exists, that as activists, we kind of have to, like, wait our
- 51:28turn to address more than human oppression.
- 51:32You know, that's assuming liberation is this line instead
- 51:36of what it actually is, which is a network. One practical step, we suggest
- 51:40in the chapter, is just to start from where you already
- 51:45are. And, you know, if you. And this is for
- 51:49activists or non activists, but if you are
- 51:53beginning this journey of opening up to the
- 51:57idea, like to the. To speciesism as
- 52:00a concept in your life, you know, if you live with other animals, many of
- 52:04us do, like companion animals, start practicing solidarity
- 52:07at home. You know, ask yourself, how much choice do
- 52:11my companion animals have in their daily lives? Do they get to decide
- 52:15who they interact with? Do they get to decide where they go, what they
- 52:19eat? Recognizing and challenging the, like,
- 52:22normalized control we have over other animals
- 52:26just in our daily lives, in our closest relationships, can be
- 52:30a gateway into understanding how deeply speciesism is woven
- 52:35into everyday life. And I would also encourage people to
- 52:39talk about speciesism not as this, like, standalone issue.
- 52:43I think it's important to talk about it as entangled
- 52:47with other oppressions. Always kind of situate it that way. So, for example,
- 52:52when we talk about borders, like you mentioned, you know, we can at the
- 52:55same time talk about the Sonoran pronghorn, Right.
- 52:59And the more than human lives impacted by the border militarization
- 53:03or just having a border in general. When we talk about reproductive justice,
- 53:07we can name explicitly the forced insemination
- 53:12of dairy cows as just another expression of patriarchal control.
- 53:16These are the kinds of connections that can help people see
- 53:20speciesism as part of that same oppressive logic that
- 53:24we're fighting in Other arenas. And I'd say,
- 53:28like, especially for vegans, be cautious about centering
- 53:32that conversation just solely on consumer choice. And like,
- 53:36yeah, food is powerful, but if you want to shift hearts and systems,
- 53:41like, in my view, we need to tell a bigger story. Like,
- 53:44speciesism is a form of domination and it's rooted in the same hierarchies that
- 53:48harm humans. Framing veganism as part of a broader liberatory ethic,
- 53:53one that values autonomy, consent, cohabitation.
- 53:56It can open up the space for, like, deeper, more transformative conversations.
- 54:01And so really, I think it's about widening that lens. That's kind of
- 54:05something that this book does generally, but it's also practical guidance.
- 54:09Speak up, connect the dot, practice solidarity across species line in your
- 54:13everyday life. People will see that and you could talk to people about it too.
- 54:17That's how, like, in my view, we move from this, like, personal practice to
- 54:21this collective change. First thing that kind of came to mind for me,
- 54:25and I think Amanda has already touched on this a bit, but I just wrote
- 54:27to, like, spend time with animals. It sounds weird.
- 54:31We don't do that a lot, right? Like, we're inside, like, at least us urban
- 54:35dwellers. And so, for example,
- 54:38I teach classes occasionally on these topics. And for one class,
- 54:42we go to, like, a farm sanctuary where it is, there's cows,
- 54:46chickens, pigs. And for a lot of the students,
- 54:50it's surprising because they haven't interacted with these animals in any really
- 54:54substantive way. They may have only indirectly interacted through their,
- 54:58frankly, their bodies at places like the grocery store. That's where
- 55:02they exist to them. They haven't seen them as like, out enjoying the sun,
- 55:06having fun together. Right. Looking out the back window of
- 55:10my apartment here, you know, I watched the squirrels play. Amanda mentioned, think about how
- 55:14you could have better relationship with your companion animals to understand
- 55:18that other animals are free, thinking beings,
- 55:22have their own life experiences. I think being able to spend time with
- 55:26them is important. And I have seen people that have really shifted their attitudes through
- 55:29that experience, right? That, oh, wait,
- 55:32the animals that are in these crowded industrial settings, these are the
- 55:36ones we're spending time with outside right here. That's a powerful, like,
- 55:39realization to come to because I think so much of what we
- 55:44know about the experience of other animals is what we're told by other humans
- 55:48and through these rather oppressive, very biased species
- 55:53lenses. So I think that's really powerful. And I wrote
- 55:57Build coalitions, cast your net wide. There's a lot
- 56:01of unlikely partners sometimes in these sorts of things. And some
- 56:05people may Cringe. I mentioned this in my chapter, but I've seen like
- 56:08in my own communities, a lot of progress between like animal rights activists
- 56:13teaming up with like conservation hunting groups to
- 56:17preserve large swaths of land. And one side is like anti hunting and
- 56:21the other side hunts. But it's like finding out that we can preserve a lot
- 56:24of habitats for the well being of a lot of animals. If you're
- 56:28willing to now and then find these unlikely coalitions, you can actually like, be really
- 56:32powerful and find some common organizing principles to roll around, even if it
- 56:36doesn't seem like ideologically pure. And of course, we have to choose how much we're
- 56:41willing to compromise. So that's just one example. But you
- 56:45can cast your net wide and find out that maybe your views aren't as alien
- 56:50as you think, that you can find common ground with people with really different
- 56:54worldviews from you and maybe do some really good things. I just want to take
- 56:57a second to appreciate Amanda and Mark, like what both of you just said.
- 57:00It's just, it's. I love the way you articulate it and just wanted to slightly
- 57:02build on each of it, starting with what you both said about basic interactions
- 57:07with your companion animals. It's. It's something that is so neglected, it's gets
- 57:12overlooked. And I just kind of wanted to take just a second to,
- 57:16to do that. Right here in, in the back. Right here. Hey, Timba.
- 57:20What's up, buddy? That's my golden doodle. He's 11 years old.
- 57:24I got him before I went vegan, before I knew of the arms
- 57:28of purchasing an animal from a, from a breed. Just purchasing an animal per se.
- 57:32And I think about from my own social position
- 57:36as, as someone from my religious perspective as a Hindu, I want to make
- 57:40sure my dog can experience as much experiences in the. Probably answer
- 57:45for more sizing a little bit here. I would like to believe he. Not that
- 57:48he recognizes each and every one of you, but sees something that I'm doing and
- 57:51that I'm acknowledging his presence there. Something like that. I know everyone in
- 57:54this room right now, virtual setting, they. They can understand what that means.
- 57:58Some other people might be like, yo, it's just a dog. Like, does it matter?
- 58:02And it's like first off, not an it. Do not refer to my dog as
- 58:05an it. My dog has sentience. My dog has consciousness and being and deserves to
- 58:09experience the way sentient beings deserve to experience. And something like
- 58:14that. You know, if you have been more. Maybe if I say it in a
- 58:16way that sounds a little bit Less harsh. I'm walking my dog when I'm out
- 58:20and about, when I talk to people about their animals, when you ask them something
- 58:24like, hey, so how does your dog act in this situation? Or in this situation?
- 58:28So often we might be internalizing. Our animals are just
- 58:32like robots that have automatic response to something. And if we can get
- 58:36people to just start thinking about their animals that are enclosed, proximity to them and
- 58:39how they can perceive and engage in the world, I feel like that's planting a
- 58:43small seed of recognizing that they're. They're more than just whatever they
- 58:47might perceive them to be in the first place. And I just acknowledge that right
- 58:51now. You know, I feel like unintentionally, just based off how we can speak about
- 58:54our animals and companion animals might even be contributing towards animal
- 58:59hierarchies. You know, in the west, dogs are going to have most places in the
- 59:03world. They're always going to be prioritized and. But if we can start talking about
- 59:07the animals that are at that higher level in our animal hierarchy that way,
- 59:11I think it can cause a little bit of cracks in that hierarchy.
- 59:14So that when we talk about other animals, animals that are used in agriculture
- 59:18or animals that are hunted or whatnot, I think it
- 59:23gives us a space that we can start to start chipping away at that hierarchy.
- 59:27And I also think that gives us space to maybe even think about other humans
- 59:31that a lot of people don't perceive as human for whatever reason
- 59:36because of their race, their gender, the socioeconomic class, their caste, whatever it might be
- 59:39to talk to the people about it. What do you think about these people's experiences,
- 59:43this being's experience just on. On to add to building coalitions.
- 59:47This is going to be very difficult, and I think one of the best ways
- 59:50we can do that is what Amanda was saying. Where, Start. Start with where you're
- 59:53at. Each of us in this virtual setting are at a different social position.
- 59:56I know myself, I go to religious spaces quite often,
- 1:00:00Hindu and Sikh spaces. There's a type of animal welfare ethic
- 1:00:04available there. And I know just myself as a, as a straight brown man
- 1:00:08who attends these places, because I'm welcome based off my faith, my knowledge there,
- 1:00:12I'm probably positioned to have conversations with them about animal
- 1:00:16welfare and animal rights, as opposed to if I were to try leafletting or
- 1:00:20if I were to try engaging in an open rescue, there's nothing wrong with doing
- 1:00:23that. But at the same time, the special access I might have based off
- 1:00:27my unique but also random social position that has some Fundamental
- 1:00:32value that needs to be capitalized on. My parents consume.
- 1:00:35They're vegetarian, but they still consume less than they have
- 1:00:39throughout. Throughout the years, ever since I've been vegan. And although I would love for
- 1:00:43them to be vegan, I've noticed the decline in the consumption of dairy because I'm
- 1:00:46able to ask them questions like, wait, we're supposed to love cows, supposed to respect
- 1:00:50cows? You know, what happens to cows in Canada? That's not respecting cows.
- 1:00:54And I'll build it out of fan and pairing it. That's a conversation that
- 1:00:58can have more value with them, as opposed to me trying to have that conversation
- 1:01:02with the average Canadian. That Ali doesn't really care about
- 1:01:06the relationship between cows and religion. So I definitely think there's so
- 1:01:10much value recognizing your social position to see where you can
- 1:01:14start with, because I think people would be impressed. They'll be shocked and maybe
- 1:01:18overwhelmed, but then excited about the different avenues, the different spaces
- 1:01:22they can access that maybe people around them aren't able to access. This is
- 1:01:26all great, too. I think that's great advice. And it just. It kind of occurs
- 1:01:29to me that maybe what we're getting at is a lot of the things that
- 1:01:32have to be done is just like, experiential and setting good examples and those
- 1:01:37sorts of things. Because if you're trying to talk about the term speciesism,
- 1:01:41that already is perceived as sort of a, you know, a philosophical
- 1:01:45eccentric term, you could lose people pretty quick.
- 1:01:48All of us have done some writing and scholarship, so that term is widely
- 1:01:52used. We know exactly what it means. But, you know, in terms of trying to
- 1:01:55be an activist, it's. It's not always so easy to approach things and talk
- 1:01:59about speciesism, maybe easier to show them ways to not be species,
- 1:02:04such as many that we've had mentioned here. One of the most
- 1:02:08interesting things that I've been learning talking to authors in this podcast is how to
- 1:02:12be more patient and calmer in
- 1:02:16my beliefs and what I do. Sometimes I
- 1:02:20feel like when I'm talking to folks, that not only in matters of veganism
- 1:02:25and vegetarianism, but in matters there are more political people who have
- 1:02:29political views are different than mine. Sometimes I just want to get on the soapbox
- 1:02:33and I just want to talk, and that's not effective most of the times.
- 1:02:37So it's very interesting for me with hearing and learning with
- 1:02:41you all, because I'm like, yeah, no, sure, if I. If I put
- 1:02:46into actions the beliefs that I already have of compassion, empathy,
- 1:02:50even with people that are not on the same Page yet that
- 1:02:53it's logical that they're going to be more receptive and more open to hearing
- 1:02:57me talking about it. Can I add to that, too? Now that
- 1:03:01you say that, I think that was a big learning journey for me as
- 1:03:05well. Through a decade's worth of activism is just like.
- 1:03:09And something I can encourage
- 1:03:13in other activists is just like a gentle reminder to, like, stay humble
- 1:03:17and build relationships. Because oftentimes
- 1:03:22when we're vegan, when we're involved in animal activism,
- 1:03:25it can sometimes make us feel like we've always got this, like,
- 1:03:29moral high ground or like we're operating from this place
- 1:03:33of ultimate logic and reason. But the truth is,
- 1:03:36like, we all have contradictions. We all cause harm in
- 1:03:40some way and all have this room to grow.
- 1:03:43So my encouragement is like, call people in, don't call them
- 1:03:48out. You know, build real relationships. Because according to all psychological
- 1:03:52research, the number one way people shift their views on anything is
- 1:03:57through connection. It's through trust. So through knowing
- 1:04:02someone and who see you, you want to be
- 1:04:06seen as more than just a project to be fixed. Right. Nobody wants to feel
- 1:04:09that way. And if we can lead from that place instead of from,
- 1:04:13like, judgment or superiority, I think we stand a much better
- 1:04:17chance of creating meaningful change. It's so beautiful that you said that. Like, I love
- 1:04:21that term, calling people in as opposed to calling them out. The type of language
- 1:04:24is used in so many different spaces to get effective
- 1:04:28communication to happen at a grassroots level. I've worked in harm reduction in the past,
- 1:04:32and when you're dealing with individuals that are struggling and on a
- 1:04:36journey with substance use, calling in is the only thing that's going to work as
- 1:04:40opposed to calling out, where you're approaching that conversation with compassion and more openness,
- 1:04:44even though it can chip away at you. And I think we can all be
- 1:04:47cognizant of, hey, this is going to chip away at us. Not every opportunity to
- 1:04:51talk about animals or humans is going to be right for us
- 1:04:55just because we're so burnt out or just we might not have capacity for it
- 1:04:58there. But that calling in, there's so much value in that. And from the
- 1:05:03social, the science of social change, like connection,
- 1:05:07sometimes it takes connection with literal people that you're related
- 1:05:10to. My family only experienced a reduction in Islamophobia
- 1:05:15and homophobia after I brought home a friend, best friend, who happened
- 1:05:19to come from a Muslim family until one of my nieces came out as gay.
- 1:05:23And it's like it sometimes it. And it's frustrating
- 1:05:27because you're essentially waiting for people to recognize humanity compassion.
- 1:05:31But it once you're at that stage where it is an opportunity to
- 1:05:35recognize that approaching it with that calling them in to recognize that connection and
- 1:05:40that love and that that ultimately healing I I think will hold a
- 1:05:43lot more value for activists going forward than opposite which not to
- 1:05:47say that you know strong emotions like anger, are they wrong? I don't,
- 1:05:51I don't think there's value in labeling those emotions like that. But in
- 1:05:55terms of the results we want, is it really going to work? Because I think
- 1:05:57there's more effective things an activist can do once they experience those intense emotions
- 1:06:01then to maybe act out on them in some of the actions
- 1:06:06that might be perceived or connotated with calling out that might
- 1:06:10lead to arguments might lead to the more friction as opposed to kind of that
- 1:06:13connection. Lantern Publishing and media
- 1:06:17is devoted to sharing messages of compassion. Our books inspire a
- 1:06:21better world by telling the stories of animal rights activists,
- 1:06:24climate activists and their fights for a world where
- 1:06:28everyone can live in harmony, no matter their species. Lantern is
- 1:06:32a 501c non for profit organization. Your donation helps us keep our
- 1:06:37work going. If you can go to lanternpm.org donate
- 1:06:42to help us with any amount. Once again, the website
- 1:06:46is lanternpm.org donate. Your generous
- 1:06:50gift enables you to support our collective mission to inform,
- 1:06:54inspire and educate. Thank you very much.
- 1:06:58Going back to that question about joy, mock and groom,
- 1:07:02if you can, can answer that one too. Amanda, if you want to add anything
- 1:07:06to it. Is there any moments of hope and joy that you have experienced
- 1:07:10recently that you would like to share to keep our hopes up? I think my
- 1:07:14answer is really unusual here because what I'm going to say is by no
- 1:07:19means going to probably be described by a lot of people as joy necessarily,
- 1:07:23but maybe more so hope. But it's already been alluded to.
- 1:07:27Right. You know, I'm in the US as well and I would
- 1:07:31say the prospects for total liberation with the current kind of political
- 1:07:35situation isn't great. Right. We see
- 1:07:38a lot of othering and a lot of anger
- 1:07:43and a lot of mistreatments.
- 1:07:46And based on the framework, you know, that we use in this book,
- 1:07:50I think it's going to affect, you know, not only many human groups
- 1:07:54poorly, most human groups frankly poorly, but it'll affect the environment,
- 1:07:58maybe non human animals poorly as well.
- 1:08:02And I think for a while it took me
- 1:08:05a while to get off the mat and kind of accept how
- 1:08:10things are going. That was challenging and paralyzing.
- 1:08:14But recently, and I'm not Really sure what it is. I think it may be
- 1:08:18partially that this book's coming out, but I feel sort
- 1:08:23of empowered. Like, I. I'm anxious to do things, you know,
- 1:08:27anxious to try to. To speak up for more peaceful coexistence.
- 1:08:31When we first put this book together, I was like, this is fun.
- 1:08:34There's some interesting information and perspectives in here. People will
- 1:08:38like to read it. And that was, frankly, kind of how I saw it.
- 1:08:41Now I felt like, wow. I didn't necessarily anticipate,
- 1:08:46when we first started putting this together, the time it would come out. And then.
- 1:08:50Then when it was coming out, I was like, this book needs to come out
- 1:08:53now. This message is more relevant and stronger than ever.
- 1:08:56And now I feel, like, proud and really excited about it, maybe in a
- 1:08:59way I didn't anticipate. And so that's motivated me to, like, get active and
- 1:09:03take on other projects. And even if that means sticking my
- 1:09:07neck out, because it's kind of a scary time to be outspoken as
- 1:09:11well, because there's so much. There's so much pressure to kind of clamp down
- 1:09:15on what dissidents or whatever you want to call it, right? You're seeing people who
- 1:09:18aren't US Citizens basically being deported because of
- 1:09:22political views. Right. And so while that's
- 1:09:26a scary environment, I feel like it gives my work and
- 1:09:30work of other activists and scholars meaning and feel
- 1:09:35like we're more needed than ever. So it feels very reaffirming.
- 1:09:38And so I'm just kind of trying to ride that wave,
- 1:09:42even if it's a little scary because, you know, you're afraid of, like, the blowback
- 1:09:46that could come with that. Who knows? Maybe it's dangerous for me to even say
- 1:09:49that here, but I really been feeling that way lately that it's, like, not a
- 1:09:53time to be quiet. It is a time to really do good work because it's
- 1:09:57really needed, and just the voices in this book are
- 1:10:01really needed. It's not just an interesting read anymore. Like, this is an act
- 1:10:05of resistance, and it's just act of peace.
- 1:10:10I'm sorry, I can't stop smiling because, like, just what you
- 1:10:13said right there, mark it like, it. It kind of embodies how,
- 1:10:17like, the. Riding that wave, like, it's needed right now. Like,
- 1:10:21being a part of this introduced me to over 15amazing
- 1:10:26people whose views I got to read, whose intellect I got
- 1:10:29to see on paper, on screen. And at a time like this, where it doesn't
- 1:10:33need to be said, the world is just so messed up in so many different
- 1:10:35Ways now is what it's needed the most and it's understandable if someone needs to
- 1:10:39take a step back because it can get a lot but it doesn't change that
- 1:10:43maybe annoying and cruel fact that it still needs to be done the most.
- 1:10:46I didn't want to bring this up but like it might be TMI but like
- 1:10:49I really just want to. This, this book, this chapter put me in a really
- 1:10:52messed up place. After I wrote it. I had submitted my
- 1:10:56proposal for my dissertation and I had a week off and I'm like
- 1:10:59yo, I'm writing a nice, I gotta do something. And when I,
- 1:11:03when I had the time dedicated towards the writing, I wrote this and,
- 1:11:07and Nathan gave me such amazing encouragement and I'm like okay, life's going
- 1:11:11to be good. A week after that and my apologies for anyone listening
- 1:11:15if this could be like trigger warning for self harm. I ended up in the
- 1:11:18hospital. I tried to kind of kill myself after I got out. I reached out
- 1:11:22to Nate being like Doug, I'm sorry but like I just, I don't know if
- 1:11:24this is the right thing for me to do. Like I went from like this
- 1:11:26unbelievable high to pressure of other work that taught to me because
- 1:11:30of the burnout I experienced reading into this because I'm reading stuff about so many
- 1:11:34messed up things happening to animals and people in a country that is.
- 1:11:37My parents are found that it makes a huge part of me and the support
- 1:11:41he gave me and the reassurance that you know, like we got, you got
- 1:11:46me to stick with it and to still edit it and to. And to want
- 1:11:48to be involved in it. And then the podcast opportunities, the constant emails
- 1:11:52from everyone about the progress with it has helped me stick with my dissertation.
- 1:11:56I was going to drop out, but I stuck with it. Submitted a proposal a
- 1:11:59few weeks ago and the only reason that happened was community was seeing
- 1:12:04the words of these amazing people here involved in this that just
- 1:12:07the small amounts of compassion that I just. They could
- 1:12:11just be words on an email, on a message. They allowed me, they put me
- 1:12:15in a position where I could go forward with this. And I
- 1:12:20think that's just people that are experiencing that spare because of how messed up
- 1:12:24the world is. I hope they can, can look, I think they can. They can
- 1:12:28see some of those small moments of, of support and community because
- 1:12:32it's there. It's smaller than maybe other spaces but I promise you it is definitely
- 1:12:36there and going forward. Like I'm hyped about not riding this
- 1:12:40wave too high because all things have come back down enough. But like, I'm looking
- 1:12:43forward to being able to, to see what these amazing individuals,
- 1:12:47including Amanda, Mark, yourself, Lisa, Like, I just, I. It,
- 1:12:50it's, it's inspiration, but at the same time it's just, it's this steady sustainable
- 1:12:54fuel. I feel if we just remember, you know, you are not alone in this
- 1:12:58and there's people that are experiencing exactly what you're, what you fell. And then
- 1:13:02we're not trying to have some kind of toxic positivity. Just say, just smile and
- 1:13:06you got this. When the world is so messed up as it is, especially when
- 1:13:09people's livelihoods are being compromised, their safety, the security, like, it's.
- 1:13:14There's still opportunity here to flourish every day and, and to, to do
- 1:13:18the work that is so, just so needed. I appreciate
- 1:13:22you saying that too, because I think, I'm sure a lot of the listeners can
- 1:13:25agree that trying to be an advocates for,
- 1:13:28for, well, not only just animals, but just any.
- 1:13:32All communities, the planet, it can feel very lonely
- 1:13:36and helpless sometimes. Right.
- 1:13:39And you need to be reminded that other people care.
- 1:13:44And being a co editor on this book, I got to read through a lot
- 1:13:47of chapters and give feedback on them. And reading through this and feeling like there's
- 1:13:52something that I could relate to in every single chapter, being inspired or impressed
- 1:13:56in every single chapter was a great feeling. And maybe that's what's so
- 1:14:00good about like kind of a collaborative book like this is that
- 1:14:04at least for the people involved in the project, but also, hopefully readers, you don't
- 1:14:08feel so lonely. You feel like you can keep going and,
- 1:14:12and, and do something positive. Thank you. Thank you all for your words. That,
- 1:14:16that was very, I'm very grateful that you felt
- 1:14:19this safe space to open up and to talk about this, because it's. When we're
- 1:14:24honest in street four, but we're going through, we don't sugarcoat things.
- 1:14:27And I think that helps us to create the sense of connection,
- 1:14:31even being far away from each other, geographically speaking. Before I let you all
- 1:14:36go, first of all, thank you for being here at Lantern Voices, being your guests.
- 1:14:39Thank you for this amazing book. Do you have any final words for our listeners?
- 1:14:43And that could be like any projects you're working on, anything you would like your
- 1:14:47listeners to know. If you have any links that I should add to the episode
- 1:14:50description and tell them, but also drop in the chat here in the conversation that
- 1:14:54we have in the studio, because then I'll upload it when I post
- 1:14:58the podcast. So the floor is all yours. Yeah, I'll go first
- 1:15:02again. Couple of book projects I'll
- 1:15:06mention. I mentioned earlier my book called the Overprivileged
- 1:15:10Human. That one is really about human species privilege and kind of looks.
- 1:15:13Looks at it from several different dimensions. You can get that through Active
- 1:15:18Distribution or PM Press. I wrote a kind of a companion book
- 1:15:22after it came out because it was a little more theoretical
- 1:15:25and I wanted a really practical companion to it.
- 1:15:28So I wrote a book called what Can I Do? You can get that one
- 1:15:32through Amazon, but that one is really like bulleted lists
- 1:15:36of what you can do if you have specific social privileges. Like it
- 1:15:40doesn't. It's short. You just look in the index and you're like,
- 1:15:44oh, I'm a white person. Okay, turn to page 80. Here's a little bulleted list
- 1:15:47of the things you can do. Like it's literally like that.
- 1:15:51So I have that one too. You can, you can pick up if you're interested
- 1:15:55or you want to give it to your family for Christmas as a
- 1:15:59passive aggressive way to say do better.
- 1:16:02I'm working right now on a book project about eco
- 1:16:07ability. So that one will probably come out maybe later this year, early next
- 1:16:11year, but I'm really, really interested in that.
- 1:16:15And I'm going to talk a little bit about speciesism, ableism and adult supremacy.
- 1:16:19You know, now that I got kids, I really think a lot about power
- 1:16:23dynamics and man. We treat children horrible in our society
- 1:16:27and I think that has a really strong connection with the way we treat other
- 1:16:30animals. So I'm working on a project on that too. So keep an
- 1:16:34eye out. I had a couple of links I wanted to
- 1:16:38share. That one is two most influential individuals that
- 1:16:42contribute towards my chapter. The first one is Dr. Yamini Narayanan. If you could
- 1:16:46please include this link. I want to reiterate anything I said about my chapter.
- 1:16:50Do not take my word for it. Right? It could all just be flawed.
- 1:16:53Read the work of Dr. Narayanan. Because the work that they're doing in India is
- 1:16:57so important. It's dangerous because they're challenging a lot of dominant
- 1:17:01systems from a centralized group. That is fine to do
- 1:17:05a lot of messed up things to people that have used likers. But they're just
- 1:17:08asking you to just look at animals as, as beings. Please read their work.
- 1:17:12It's. It's amazing. And when you're engaging with animal rights or
- 1:17:16anything animal related in India, just read, ask questions, have the
- 1:17:20judgments, let them sit with you, but just read more. There's so many scholars doing
- 1:17:23such important work that can just help with that maybe 101 education, but then
- 1:17:27more in depth stuff. And it is a, it's interesting
- 1:17:32and I promise they'll get more out of it. And then the second link was
- 1:17:35this is probably the most influential paper in my life by, it's called
- 1:17:38Crime Ecophilosophy, Environmental Harm by Mark Halsey and Rob White. It's just,
- 1:17:42it breaks down ecocentrism, biocentrism and anthropocentrism in a way that's looked
- 1:17:47at through green criminology, through the study of harms against the environment and
- 1:17:51animals. And it, it's not as jargony as
- 1:17:55a lot of academia. It's a little bit, I don't want to say, dated 1998.
- 1:17:58It's not that old because when I say that's old, I feel old. But it's,
- 1:18:01it's a very easy and a fun read and I hope everyone gets a
- 1:18:04chance to read those. And regards to There was one thing I wanted to share
- 1:18:08just because I forgot to share the joy, one thing of joy that just inspired
- 1:18:11me to like keep my hopes up prior to certain political election results.
- 1:18:15Coming out in the usa, I was gifted tickets to a hockey game in Buffalo,
- 1:18:19New York. Unfortunately, I'm an Ottawa Senators fan, cause of a lot of my sadness.
- 1:18:23But a friend and I decided to go and we were concerned with two brown
- 1:18:26men with large beards trying to cross the border. And we were
- 1:18:30thinking, should we go? Like, what if something happens? And just both of
- 1:18:35us had accomplished a lot at work and wanted to try to celebrate
- 1:18:39and we said, let's just, let's, let's try, let's give it our best shot.
- 1:18:41And we did. And God bless. Nothing happened at the barrier, but we visited
- 1:18:45an amazing vegan restaurant, a black owned vegan restaurant. And we
- 1:18:49had so much fun talking with the locals there that talked to us and reminded
- 1:18:52us that these, these labels of American, Canadian,
- 1:18:55they're labels for people. We love each other, we bond over
- 1:18:59the simplest things, like just very good food. And it was,
- 1:19:03it was inspiring. Not that I tried to go to the USA again anytime
- 1:19:08soon. Just, it was a reminder. These are people. These despite all the
- 1:19:12things happening in the political realm, I can't be hating on them.
- 1:19:16These are people. And if I can, if I forget to recognize that,
- 1:19:20how am I going to, am I going to do anything for animals or the
- 1:19:22environment? And so I just wanted to share that moment of joy. It was beautiful
- 1:19:25and just something I'm working on right now. I'm Gonna quit my PhD a few
- 1:19:28months ago, but I just submitted my proposal on Monday and ethics,
- 1:19:33hopefully they'll get back to me this century and when they do, the Anyone who
- 1:19:37qualifies to participate. This is, this is very easy. And I'm hoping to circulate
- 1:19:41this with everyone involved here, anyone who's done animal rights activism in Canada,
- 1:19:45just so I can discover the state of animal rights activism and hopefully examine
- 1:19:49the way law enforcement are in interacting with animal rights activism.
- 1:19:53Literature says that they're probably being politically suppressed. Lawful dissent
- 1:19:57is probably being suppressed, but it hasn't been proven in Canada. So I figured let's
- 1:20:01do that. It's a fun way to find people to talk to. And hopefully after
- 1:20:06the summer, after ethics clears, I can start looking for people to talk
- 1:20:09to and share their wonderful experiences with me. Please, please do share.
- 1:20:13Once you have the research and everything going on,
- 1:20:16ask. After the recording, I'll ask for emails and exchange contacts
- 1:20:21because we have a nice database at LANTERN of other activists and people we work
- 1:20:24with that we love to put into collaboration. So yeah, please do so.
- 1:20:28Varun, I appreciate your comment about going to Buffalo too. I'm from Detroit area
- 1:20:32originally, so we very close connection to Windsor, Ontario, which is across the river
- 1:20:36from us. And the wedge that's been put between kind of US and Canada is
- 1:20:40very disruptive and awkward just because there's
- 1:20:44such a history of travel between those two places. So one project I
- 1:20:48will mention is that I do a. If you guys hear the term a
- 1:20:52zine, it's like a small magazine. I do a semiannual zine with actually my
- 1:20:57spouse who is a artist who does a lot of work around
- 1:21:01trying to emphasize the. The individuality of different
- 1:21:06animals and trying to bring us closer to them. So we put our skills together
- 1:21:09to put together this series that features short
- 1:21:12articles, different images, poems,
- 1:21:16and in our latest edition that's coming out now, a interview
- 1:21:20with an urban farm here in Indianapolis, where I live now,
- 1:21:24where we talk about, you know, what we call food apartheid.
- 1:21:27Like the kind of, you know, disconnect of people from food through capitalism and food
- 1:21:31sovereignty and how to kind of bring people close to the earth and their own
- 1:21:35food again. So the series is called More than Human Society. It comes out twice
- 1:21:40a year. You can find more information on it at R E
- 1:21:44N S K Studio. That's Rensk Studio.
- 1:21:47Or there also is a Patreon site that I'll put in links
- 1:21:51as well, which is a place you can actually subscribe and you'll get it mailed
- 1:21:55to you. My spouse Also does another zine series called Non Human Neighbors,
- 1:21:59which is briefer and it's just kind of about honoring beings that she's been
- 1:22:03spending time with or seeing outside. So that's a project that
- 1:22:06is ongoing. That's pretty exciting. But I think the main thing I want to promote
- 1:22:10is exploring topics in non human coexistence, Passion,
- 1:22:14practice and presence. And Available Where Books Are Sold is out now.
- 1:22:18The wait is over. So let's not of course, forget to mention
- 1:22:22that Where Books Are Sold and at the Lantern website as well.
- 1:22:26You can check it out there. Louisa, you probably say that, but I.
- 1:22:30Have it right here. That actually gives me the perfect excuse to let the listeners
- 1:22:34know that if they buy the ebook on our website and use the
- 1:22:38Coupon lantern voices to 25, they actually get 25% off on
- 1:22:42the book. So this especially for podcast listeners and
- 1:22:46we usually just give this information at the end of the podcast to make sure
- 1:22:50that the ones getting the discount are the ones who listen all the way to
- 1:22:53the end. Sorry, could you just repeat that code again? I'm trying to get a
- 1:22:56couple copies to send to my family. It's lantern voices
- 1:23:0025 all together, no spaces and the numbers
- 1:23:042 and 5, our digits not written down. And that
- 1:23:08would be through the Lantern Books website. Yeah, on our ebook
- 1:23:12store on the website. It is also our 25th anniversary this year, so hence 25.
- 1:23:16All right, mark Varun, Amanda, thank you very much for
- 1:23:20being here today. I really appreciate the conversation and
- 1:23:24it was a pleasure getting to know you all. Thank you for having us.
- 1:23:27Yeah, thanks. It was great. This was awesome. Thank you so much. All right,
- 1:23:31I'll see you soon.
- 1:23:40Thank you for joining us for this two part episode on the book Exploring.
- 1:23:43Topics in Non Human Coexistence. Like we said now at the end of our conversation,
- 1:23:48you can use a special discount coupon on our ebook store to get
- 1:23:5225% off when buying your own digital copy of Exploring Topics in
- 1:23:56Non Human Coexistence or any other book ever featured in a podcast
- 1:24:01now or in the future. That means you can get 25% off on Jimmy
- 1:24:05Vidali's the Veganix Grower Handbook, Hobo Hannig's the Humane Hoax.
- 1:24:09Just bugs. You had to be there. Isabella LaRocco Gonzalez Sensoric
- 1:24:13landscapes, Angela Crawford's the Vegan Transformation and any
- 1:24:17other book featured in the podcast. Don't Forget, go to lanternpm.org,
- 1:24:21click on eBooks, select one of the books featured in the podcast
- 1:24:24and use the coupon lanternvoices25 on checkout
- 1:24:28thank you so much for joining us here today. Please leave a
- 1:24:32five star review if you like the podcast that really helps us reach more people.
- 1:24:35And we hope to see you again in two weeks for another episode of Lantern
- 1:24:39Voices.