Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / How Companies Fake Profits with Accounting
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever, like, wonder how a company can report glowing
- 0:04profits year after year and then suddenly they just announced
- 0:09they're completely out of money and going bankrupt?
- 0:12Yeah, I mean, it feels like a magic trick when you see it
- 0:14happen in real. Time it really does and
- 0:17unfortunately it's usually your wallet, like the everyday
- 0:19investors wallet ends up doing the disappearing act.
- 0:22Right. Exactly.
- 0:23And it happens so much more often than people realize.
- 0:26You know, you see these massive headlines about a huge retail
- 0:30chain or a major manufacturer just collapsing out of nowhere
- 0:33and the public is left totally baffled.
- 0:35Because the official reports looked incredibly healthy, just
- 0:38like weeks prior to the crash. Yeah, the illusion is incredibly
- 0:42convincing. I mean, it traps retail
- 0:44investors, it traps suppliers, and honestly, sometimes even the
- 0:47company's own employees are totally blindsided by it.
- 0:49Well, that illusion is our exact target.
- 0:51Today we're doing a deep dive into a really fascinating
- 0:55financial breakdown from a creator named Amu.
- 0:57Right. And he specifically dissects the
- 1:00accounting sleight of hand that these companies use to fake
- 1:03their profits. Exactly.
- 1:05But before we get into the weeds, I do need to share a
- 1:07quick mandatory message and disclaimer for our listeners to
- 1:12access more advanced researchers applications and our latest
- 1:15published personal intelligent multi agent deep value
- 1:18intelligence. Welcome to subscribe on deep
- 1:20values dot AI track total market temperature.
- 1:23Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 1:27Apple App Store. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:31on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 1:34or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:37is for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 1:40constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 1:44before making investment decisions.
- 1:45If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 1:48investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel
- 1:51at Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 1:53Much appreciate it. Awesome.
- 1:55Got all that out of the way. So diving in, the foundational
- 1:58concept you really have to grasp before looking at any financial
- 2:01statement is that net profit. That big bold headline number
- 2:05everyone obsesses over? Exactly.
- 2:07That number is literally just a calculation.
- 2:10I mean it is a story told through a series of well, human
- 2:13made accounting rules, right? Cash flow on the other hand is
- 2:17the only real measure of survival.
- 2:19Cash is objective reality. It's the gold and silver.
- 2:22Profit is just a story. I actually really love that
- 2:25framing. And according to Amuse's
- 2:27breakdown, you don't need like, a PhD in forensic accounting to
- 2:33see through the story. No, not at.
- 2:35All, you just need to understand the mechanics of two very
- 2:37specific areas on a company's balance sheet, right?
- 2:40Accounts Receivable and inventory.
- 2:42Yeah, if you grasp those two, you gain a massive advantage.
- 2:45You can basically sidestep I'd say 90% of the financial fraud
- 2:49traps out there. Because the vulnerability is
- 2:51almost always hide in those two categories.
- 2:53Always. I mean, to understand how a
- 2:55company fakes a profit, we first have to look at the very first
- 2:57step of the whole process, how they actually record a sale.
- 3:00Right, which brings us to the concept of accrual accounting.
- 3:03Yes, and accrual accounting is the standard system used
- 3:05globally. Omo uses this brilliant kind of
- 3:09script down example to illustrate this that I want to
- 3:11walk through. So imagine you run a small local
- 3:14bakery and let's call it a MOO convenience store, OK?
- 3:17I like it. So today you have a pretty solid
- 3:20day. You sell 200 bucks worth of
- 3:22bread. The 1st 100 bucks comes from a
- 3:25customer who walks in, buys the bread and hands you a crisp $100
- 3:30bill. Nice and easy cash is in the
- 3:32register. Exactly, but the second 100
- 3:35bucks comes from a regular customer.
- 3:37Let's just call him Lao Wang. OK, Lao Wang.
- 3:39He takes the bread but says, ah, you know, I'm tied on cash this
- 3:42week, put it on my tab, I'll pay you next year.
- 3:45Right. And under accrual accounting,
- 3:47transactions are recorded when the economic event occurs,
- 3:50regardless of when the actual cash changes hands.
- 3:53Wait, so just to be clear, it doesn't matter that Lao Wang
- 3:56didn't give you any money today? It doesn't matter at all for
- 3:58your revenue line. The system is designed to match
- 4:01revenues with the expenses incurred to generate them.
- 4:03So the moment Lao Wang walks out the door with that bread, your
- 4:06store's official revenue for the day is 200 bucks.
- 4:10But if you open the actual physical register, you only have
- 4:13100 bucks to pay your own suppliers.
- 4:15Exactly. And that gap, that space between
- 4:18the cash register and the record book, is where all the
- 4:21manipulation begins. Because you have 100 bucks but
- 4:24you're pretending you have 200. Well, you're recording that $100
- 4:28IOU from Lao Wang on your balance sheet as accounts
- 4:31receivable. The accounting rules say it is
- 4:34an asset because you expect to receive it.
- 4:36So on the income statement, my profit calculation includes Lao
- 4:41Wang's promise. Yes, your margins look great on
- 4:43paper, but if Lao Wang loses his job or moves away, or just, you
- 4:47know, decides to never pay you? Then that portion of my profit
- 4:51just vanishes into thin air. Exactly.
- 4:53OK, let's unpack this, because it's basically like bragging
- 4:57that you won the lottery just because your friend promised to
- 5:00buy you a winning ticket tomorrow.
- 5:01That's a pretty good analogy actually, but.
- 5:03Here's my question. Lao Wang is just one guy at a
- 5:06tiny convenience store. How do massive publicly traded
- 5:10companies pull this off on a scale that actually fools the
- 5:14entire market? Because Wall Street analysts
- 5:16aren't exactly looking at local bakery tabs, right?
- 5:19Well, the underlying mechanism is totally identical.
- 5:22It's just scaled up into a massive corporate strategy.
- 5:26Let's look at the manufacturing sector, OK?
- 5:28Amumi brings up the scenario of a really large air conditioning
- 5:31manufacturer, right. They're approaching the end of
- 5:34the fourth quarter. Right.
- 5:35Crutch time. The executive team is staring at
- 5:37their internal dashboards and they realize, uh oh, we are
- 5:41going to miss our annual revenue and profit targets.
- 5:44And missing targets is a disaster.
- 5:46The stock price tanks, the board gets angry, and let's be real,
- 5:51those executives probably lose out on millions in performance
- 5:55bonuses. Exactly.
- 5:56The pressure to find revenue immediately is immense.
- 5:59So under that pressure, they resort to a tactic known as
- 6:02channel stuff to the animal stuff.
- 6:03Yeah, the manufacturer will frantically call up their
- 6:06downstream distributors and essentially try to shove massive
- 6:09amounts of air conditioning units into their warehouses.
- 6:11Even if it's like the dead of winter.
- 6:14Even if it's the dead of winter and end consumer demand is
- 6:17completely non existent. OK, wait.
- 6:19Let me stop you there, because why on earth would a distributor
- 6:22agree to that? If I run a distribution center,
- 6:25I am absolutely not taking on millions of dollars of winter
- 6:29air conditioners just to do the manufacturer a solid.
- 6:33I have limited warehouse space. That's the catch.
- 6:37The manufacturer sweetens the deal to the point where the
- 6:39distributor basically can't refuse.
- 6:41Like what kind of deal? They might offer crazy extended
- 6:44payment terms. They'll say, look, take the
- 6:46inventory right now, but you don't have to pay us for 180
- 6:49days or even a full year. Oh wow.
- 6:51They might throw in massive volume rebates or even formally
- 6:54guarantee they will buy back any unsold stock.
- 6:57Later I see. So the distributor takes on zero
- 7:00risk. Exactly.
- 7:01And because of the accrual accounting rule we just
- 7:03discussed with Lao Wang, the absolute second those air
- 7:06conditioners leave the manufacturers loading dock.
- 7:09The revenue is legally recognized.
- 7:12The income statement instantly lights up revenue spikes, net
- 7:15profit targets are miraculously hit, and the executives secure
- 7:18their bonuses. That is insane.
- 7:20Meanwhile, the balance sheet tells the real terrifying story.
- 7:23Yeah. Yes, their accounts receivable
- 7:27inflates massively because remember, they haven't actually
- 7:30collected cash for those air conditioners.
- 7:32They've just collected a giant pile of corporate IO U's from
- 7:35their distributors. Right.
- 7:36They are literally pulling future uncollected money into
- 7:40the present quarter just to manufacture the illusion of
- 7:42growth. This gives us our first really
- 7:45major red flag, a tangible metric that you as an investor
- 7:49can actually. Check definitely you have to
- 7:51compare the growth rates. So if you pull up a financial
- 7:54report and see that revenue is growing at say 5%, but accounts
- 7:59receivable is growing at 30%. Then something is fundamentally
- 8:03broken in their sales process. A glaring disparity like that
- 8:06indicates the company is desperately handing out insanely
- 8:10favorable credit terms just to keep products moving out the
- 8:13door. So it's basically false
- 8:15prosperity. Exactly.
- 8:16They are lowering their standards for who they do
- 8:18business with. They're taking on riskier
- 8:20clients who might eventually default, all just to maintain
- 8:23the appearance of a growing top line.
- 8:25OK. So we have fake sales going out
- 8:28the front door, relying on distributors to act as a
- 8:31basically a parking lot for inventory.
- 8:34But eventually those distributors are going to push
- 8:36back. Yeah, they will run out of
- 8:37physical space or their own credit lines will completely Max
- 8:40out. Right, So when a company can no
- 8:42longer stuff the channel, where do they turn to hide their
- 8:45financial rot? Well, they turn inward.
- 8:48If they can't push the problem on to external partners anymore,
- 8:50they bury it right in their own warehouse.
- 8:53And this brings us to the second major accounting trick, which
- 8:56relies on a deeply, honestly counterintuitive rule regarding
- 9:00how the cost of manufacturing is handled.
- 9:03The accounting rule for the warehouse is where this gets
- 9:06completely wild. It's totally counterintuitive.
- 9:08Yeah, when I read a moves explanation it completely
- 9:11flipped my understanding of what an asset actually is.
- 9:13The core rule is basically this, the cost of producing an item.
- 9:18So we're talking the raw materials, the direct labor, the
- 9:21factory overhead, none of that is recorded as an expense on the
- 9:25income statement until that specific item is actually sold.
- 9:28Wait, really? Really.
- 9:31That expense is called cost of goods sold, and it's what
- 9:34directly reduces your gross profit.
- 9:37But until the sale happens, all the money spent manufacturing
- 9:40that item just sits on the balance sheet classified as
- 9:42inventory. And inventory is counted as an
- 9:45asset, yes. Inventory is an asset.
- 9:47OK. So if I run a factory and I
- 9:49spend a massive sortion manufacturing products that
- 9:52absolutely nobody in the market wants to buy, my company doesn't
- 9:57register a loss? Yep.
- 9:58I just get to claim I have a massive stockpile of valuable
- 10:01assets. Under the strict mechanics of
- 10:03the initial accounting entry, yes you do.
- 10:06That is wild. Ammu uses a clothing factory to
- 10:09illustrate just the pure absurdity of this rule.
- 10:12Let's say this factory produces 1,000,000 shirts of a specific
- 10:16design. OK, a million shirts.
- 10:18But the design turns out to be terrible.
- 10:19Consumer tastes shift, it's an ugly color, Whatever.
- 10:22They only managed to actually sell 100,000 of them.
- 10:25Leaving 900 4000 completely unwanted shirts sitting on
- 10:29pallets just collecting dust in the warehouse.
- 10:31I mean, basic common sense dictates the company just
- 10:35suffered A catastrophic financial loss.
- 10:38They wasted all that money making junk.
- 10:39Basic common sense, yes, but the accounting rules dictate that
- 10:43because those 900,000 shirts haven't been sold yet, the cost
- 10:46to manufacture them doesn't hit the income statement.
- 10:49So they don't drag down the profit.
- 10:51Right. The profit on the 100,000 shirts
- 10:53they did sell is calculated normally and the remaining
- 10:56mountain of useless inventory is treated as a huge pile of
- 11:00retained value on the balance sheet.
- 11:01That is incredibly deceptive just on its own, just hiding the
- 11:04loss like that. Yeah.
- 11:05But on this breakdown reveals it goes was much deeper than that.
- 11:09Oh yeah, it gets worse. Companies will actively exploit
- 11:13this rule by intentionally overproducing.
- 11:15Wait. Making more stuff they know they
- 11:17can't sell. Yes, specifically to manipulate
- 11:19the profit margin on the few items they do manage to sell.
- 11:22OK, break that down for me. How does making more garbage
- 11:26increase their profit? This involves the mechanics of
- 11:29fixed cost allocation. A factory has variable costs,
- 11:34like you know, the fabric and buttons for each individual
- 11:36shirt, right? But it also carries massive
- 11:39fixed costs. The lease on the factory
- 11:41building, the depreciation of $1,000,000 sewing machines, the
- 11:45salaries of the floor managers. Those fixed costs remain largely
- 11:50the exact same whether you produce 1 shirt or 1,000,000
- 11:53shirts. Right, OK, let's run the math on
- 11:55that because this is where the trick really takes shape.
- 11:57Let's say my factory have $1,000,000 in fixed costs for
- 12:01the year, right? And I only produce 100,000
- 12:04shirts. OK, each of those shirts has to
- 12:06absorb $10.00 of that fixed overhead.
- 12:08Correct, but if you run the machines 24 hours a day and
- 12:12crank out 1,000,000 shirts, that same $1,000,000 in fixed costs
- 12:16is now spread across a much larger pool of product.
- 12:19Oh I see suddenly E shirt is only absorbing $1.00 fixed
- 12:23overhead instead of 10. Exactly.
- 12:25By intentionally overproducing, the company artificially crushes
- 12:29the per unit cost of every single item.
- 12:32So when they sell that small batch of 100,000 shirts, the
- 12:35official accounting cost attached to those specific
- 12:38shirts looks incredibly low. Yes.
- 12:40And because the recorded cost is so low, the gross profit margin
- 12:45on those sales looks phenomenally high.
- 12:47They've essentially laundered their massive factory expenses
- 12:50by burying them in the mountain of unsold shirts in the
- 12:53backroom. That's a great way to put it.
- 12:55They turn their warehouse into a literal black hole for expenses.
- 12:59They get to report these surging gross margins to Wall Street
- 13:03looking like they run an incredibly the assistant
- 13:06operation. Wait, let me push back here for
- 13:07a second. Doesn't Wall Street have like
- 13:10armies of auditors? Every public company gets
- 13:13audited by major accounting firms.
- 13:15They do. How does a company claim a
- 13:17million out of style shirts are a massive asset without an
- 13:20auditor walking into the warehouse and just calling their
- 13:23bluff? Because valuation is inherently
- 13:24subjective and management always has a really good narrative
- 13:27prepared. So they just lie to the
- 13:29auditors. Well, they spin it when the
- 13:31auditors question the value of those 900,000 shirts.
- 13:35Management argues, oh, these aren't out of style, they are
- 13:38classic fits. The domestic market is just a
- 13:40little soft right now, but we have a highly strategic plan to
- 13:44sell them in overseas markets next quarter.
- 13:46Or they'll say we are going to repurpose the fabric into
- 13:49something else. Exactly.
- 13:50They sell the auditors a story about future marketability.
- 13:54And the auditors just buy it. To force the company to
- 13:57recognize the loss, the auditor has to demand what is called an
- 14:01inventory impairment provision. An inventory impairment
- 14:04provision, OK. Yeah, it's an official write
- 14:06down of the inventory's value and it hits the income statement
- 14:10immediately as a massive expense, which totally destroys
- 14:13the company's profit for the year.
- 14:15So management will obviously fight tooth and nail to delay
- 14:18taking that impairment provision for as long as legally possible.
- 14:22Absolutely. As long as they can plausibly
- 14:24defend the feature value of the shirts, the obsolete junk stays
- 14:28on the books at full production value.
- 14:30OK, So we've got fake sales out the front door through channel
- 14:34stuffing and hidden cost in the back warehouse through
- 14:37overproduction. If I'm just an everyday investor
- 14:40looking at the headline numbers on Yahoo Finance or whatever,
- 14:43I'm completely blind to both of these maneuvers.
- 14:45Totally blind. So how do these two tricks
- 14:48combine to create like the ultimate illusion on an earnings
- 14:52report? Well, when you look at the
- 14:54surface level metrics, the combined effect is basically
- 14:57mesmerizing. A MU sets up a hypothetical
- 15:00scenario that captures this perfectly.
- 15:02Imagine you are reviewing a company's annual report.
- 15:06You see their top line revenue grew by 10% this year.
- 15:10That is solid, steady growth. I like that.
- 15:13Then you look at the bottom line and their net profit jumped by
- 15:1620%. Honestly, if I see that without
- 15:18knowing any better, I'm thinking this is a fundamentally sound
- 15:20business. They're growing sales and they
- 15:23are scaling efficiently because profit is growing faster than
- 15:26revenue. It looks like a screaming buy
- 15:28signal. And if you stop your analysis
- 15:29there, you are consuming the exact narrative the executives
- 15:33engineered for you. The truth requires looking under
- 15:35the hood at the balance sheet. In the same hypothetical, you
- 15:39check the assets and discover that while revenue only grew
- 15:4210%, their accounts receivable shot up by 100%.
- 15:46Oh wow. Furthermore, their inventory
- 15:48spiked by 80%. The entire narrative just
- 15:51collapses. It reverses completely that
- 15:54glowing 20% profit growth doesn't actually exist as
- 15:57tangible wealth. It is a phantom.
- 15:59Because the profit has entirely morphed into those two highly
- 16:03toxic assets we've been talking about.
- 16:05Exactly. Warehouse junk represents by the
- 16:0880% spike in inventory and uncollectible IO US represented
- 16:12by the 100% spike in accounts receivable.
- 16:15The wealth is just sitting there in the form of Lao Wang's empty
- 16:18promises and a million shirts nobody wants to wear.
- 16:22It is brilliant in its mechanics, but it's genuinely
- 16:25terrifying because it operates completely within the boundaries
- 16:28of standard accounting frameworks until the sheer
- 16:31weight of the lie causes the whole structure to implode.
- 16:34Which it always does eventually. So how do we actively protect
- 16:37ourselves? Because AMU provides some really
- 16:41actionable metrics to cut through the noise, right?
- 16:43He does. You need tools that act as lie
- 16:45detectors for financial statements.
- 16:48The first critical tool is analyzing the trend of accounts
- 16:51receivable days. OK, let's define that clearly.
- 16:55That metric basically calculates how many days on average, it
- 16:59takes a company to actually collect the cash from its
- 17:02customers after a sales officially recorded.
- 17:04Right. And you can find this ratio
- 17:06calculated for you on almost any major financial data platform.
- 17:10The absolute number matters less than the multiyear trend.
- 17:13OK. So the trend is what's
- 17:15important, yeah. If a company typically takes 30
- 17:18days to collect its cash, and over the next three years that
- 17:21number creeps up to 45 days, then 60 days, then 85 days, the
- 17:25alarm bells should be absolutely deafening.
- 17:27Because it proves they are finding it increasingly
- 17:30difficult to extract actual cash from the market.
- 17:33They aren't just selling to Lao Wang anymore, they're selling to
- 17:35Lao Wang's unreliable cousin who has literally no intention of
- 17:39ever paying them back. Exactly, they are degrading the
- 17:42quality of their customer base just to keep the revenue graph
- 17:45pointing up into the right. It is a flashing indicator of
- 17:48underlying weakness, right? And the second tool is arguably
- 17:52the most important principle in financial analysis.
- 17:54We actually mentioned it at the very beginning.
- 17:56Cash is king. You have to compare the fairy
- 17:59tale against the ground truth. The fairy tale being the net
- 18:02profit printed on the income statement.
- 18:03Exactly. And the ground truth is found on
- 18:06the cash flow statement, specifically a line item called
- 18:09net cash flow from operating activities.
- 18:11Right. No accounting adjustments, no
- 18:13delayed expenses, no IO US, just the actual cold hard cash
- 18:18generated by the core day-to-day business, yes.
- 18:23The relationship between those two numbers reveals the true
- 18:26health of the enterprise. If a company reports 100 million
- 18:29in net profit, but their operating cash flow is only 10
- 18:33million, and this discrepancy persists for several consecutive
- 18:37years. There is a massive probability
- 18:39that the company is sustaining itself on accounting magic
- 18:42rather than a viable business model.
- 18:44Because eventually true profitability has to manifest as
- 18:47cash in the bank. You cannot pay your warehouse
- 18:50workers with accounts receivable.
- 18:52And you definitely definitely can I pay your corporate taxes
- 18:54without of style shirts. The bills require actual
- 18:58liquidity. Exactly.
- 18:59A structurally sound company will produce cash flow that
- 19:03closely tracks its net profit over time.
- 19:05When you see a persistent divergent, meaning profit climbs
- 19:09higher and higher while operating cash flow stays flat
- 19:12or trends downward, you are witnessing a company basically
- 19:16hollowing itself out from the inside.
- 19:18The. Facade looks totally pristine,
- 19:19but the foundation is crumbling away, right?
- 19:22Well, we've covered a tremendous amount of ground today.
- 19:24And the core take away for you listening is really a shift in
- 19:27mindset. You no longer have to be just a
- 19:29passive consumer of financial headlines.
- 19:31No, not all. Net profit is a story told by
- 19:33management, shaped by accruals and cost allocations, accounts
- 19:37receivable and inventory. Those are the dark corners where
- 19:41the plot holes are hidden and operating cash flow is the
- 19:44ultimate, undeniable truth. It demands an active, highly
- 19:48investigative approach to investing or even just
- 19:51understanding the corporate landscape.
- 19:53You have to look at the relationship between the
- 19:55statements rather than isolating single metrics.
- 19:58Which leaves us with a genuinely chilling thought to consider as
- 20:01we close out this deep dive. It does when you realize that
- 20:06these perfectly legal accounting frameworks provide executives
- 20:09with the tools to mask severe operational failures behind a
- 20:13wall of corporate IOU's and warehouses stuffed with obsolete
- 20:17products. It really forces you to look at
- 20:19the market differently. Exactly how many of the
- 20:21seemingly thriving, headline grabbing businesses dominating
- 20:25the news cycle today are actually just paper tigers?
- 20:28Just completely hollow on the inside, artificially propped up
- 20:31by channel stuffing and delayed impairment provisions.
- 20:33Just waiting for the inevitable day when the music stops and the
- 20:36cash finally runs out.