Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Electric Duel: Combustion Versus Current in Modern Racing
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to the deep dive. If you're if you're tuning in
- 0:13today, you're the kind of person who really craves A thorough
- 0:16understanding of the world. You want the insights, the the
- 0:20aha moments, but without drowning in overwhelming
- 0:23information. Exactly.
- 0:24You want the deep knowledge, but delivered in a way that respects
- 0:27your time. Right.
- 0:29And today we are throwing out the rule book.
- 0:31We're looking at the Ultimate automotive showdown, internal
- 0:35combustion engines, you know, ICE versus electric vehicles.
- 0:40But we aren't testing them in stop and go traffic.
- 0:42No, definitely not at a suburban grocery store charting station.
- 0:45We are throwing these technologies into the most
- 0:48extreme punishing laboratories on earth, which is professional
- 0:51motorsport. And we have an incredibly
- 0:53diverse stack of sources to guide us.
- 0:54Today we pulled a really fascinating YouTube documentary
- 0:59transcript by New Scientist that covers the absolute mayhem of
- 1:03Rallycross. Love Rallycross?
- 1:05It's chaos. We also have a detailed
- 1:07technical breakdown from blackcircles.com.
- 1:10That one compares the pinnacles of circuit racing, So Formula
- 1:12One and Formula E Yeah, the. Circuit stuff.
- 1:14And finally, we're utilizing a translated Italian technical
- 1:18analysis that literally takes us up the sides of mountains, in
- 1:21hill climbs and then deep into the brutal desert of the Dakar
- 1:25Rally. It's a massive stack of data,
- 1:28and we've sifted through all of it so you don't have to.
- 1:30The goal here isn't to declare a single absolute winner between
- 1:34gas and electric. The physics and the track
- 1:37conditions are just. They're far too complex for a
- 1:40simple binary choice. Yeah, it's not a 0 sum game.
- 1:43Our mission is to understand exactly where and why each
- 1:47technology excels based on the laws of physics and engineering.
- 1:51And what that ultimately means for the you might be driving 10
- 1:54years from now. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:56I want to start with the most famous glamorous streets in
- 1:58motorsport Monaco. Oh yeah, the ultimate test of
- 2:02precision. Right, and the black circles
- 2:04article gives us a staggering statistic that just.
- 2:07I mean, it stopped me in my tracks.
- 2:08When Formula One races on the Monaco St. circuit, a car
- 2:11completes a lap in roughly one minute and 10 seconds.
- 2:14Which is blisteringly fast. Insanely fast.
- 2:17But when a Gen. 3 Formula E car races on that exact same layout,
- 2:21it takes about one minute and 32 seconds.
- 2:23Yeah, that is a massive 22 second gap per lap.
- 2:28In the racing world, 22 seconds isn't just a gap, it's an
- 2:31entirely different time zone. It really is, and to understand
- 2:34why that massive gulf in time exists, we have to look under
- 2:38the hood, both literally and philosophically.
- 2:41What's fascinating here is this sheer difference in power and
- 2:44design freedom. Right, because they are playing
- 2:46by completely different roles. Exactly.
- 2:49Formula One is the undisputed benchmark for raw, terrifying
- 2:52speed. Those cars rely on a highly
- 2:55complex hybrid turbo V6 engine pushing at around 1000
- 2:59horsepower. 1000, yeah. And they hit top speeds of 360
- 3:03kilometers per hour, which is about 223 mph.
- 3:06And they do it with immense aerodynamic downforce.
- 3:09For anyone not spending their weekends reading aerodynamics
- 3:11textbooks, Downforce is essentially using the air
- 3:14flowing over the car to create this this invisible hand that
- 3:18just crushes the vehicle into the track.
- 3:20It's what lets them take corners at completely unnatural speeds.
- 3:24Speeds that would send a normal car flying right into the
- 3:27barriers. And crucially, F1 teams build
- 3:29their own bespoke they literally have hundreds of engineers
- 3:34constantly tweaking tiny carbon fiber winglets just to shave off
- 3:37fractions of a second. But Formula E takes a completely
- 3:40different approach. The Gen. 3 cars are pushing a
- 3:43maximum of about 470 horsepower, or roughly 350 kilowatts.
- 3:48So less than half the power of F1.
- 3:50Right. And their top speed tops at
- 3:52around 280 kilometers per hour, so 174 mph.
- 3:55But the big difference? Unlike the limitless aerodynamic
- 3:58warfare of S1, Formula E uses a spec chassis.
- 4:02Meaning every single team uses the exact same physical car
- 4:05body. Exactly.
- 4:07The teams are only allowed to develop the internal powertrain
- 4:09and the software that manages the energy.
- 4:11And that spec chassis completely changed the engineering game.
- 4:15Formula E isn't actually trying to beat Formula One at a speed
- 4:17contest. They have a completely different
- 4:19mission. F1 is about raw performance
- 4:22pedigree, ultimate engineering freedom.
- 4:24Right, the pinnacle of speed. But Formula E was built from the
- 4:27ground up to promote electric mobility.
- 4:30They specifically race on temporary tight St. circuits in
- 4:34city centers to bring the message of sustainability
- 4:37directly to urban audiences. Their focus isn't aerodynamic
- 4:41perfection at all. No, it's energy management.
- 4:43The drivers have to constantly manage their battery usage and
- 4:46master regenerative braking just to ensure they don't run out of
- 4:50use before the checkered flag. And if we connect this to the
- 4:53bigger picture, the feasible connection to the track reflects
- 4:56those divergent missions perfectly.
- 4:58I mean, the tires tell the whole story.
- 5:00They really do. The tire breakdown in the black
- 5:03circle source highlights the divide beautifully.
- 5:06Formula One uses Pirelli tires and they bring 5 different dry
- 5:09compounds to a race weekend. Ranging from very soft and fast
- 5:13to hard and durable. Plus the specific wet weather
- 5:15tires. But the fascinating part is that
- 5:17these tires are designed with high degradation in mind.
- 5:20They are engineered to wear out quickly.
- 5:22Which forces the teams to make mandatory pit stops.
- 5:25Exactly. It turns tire strategy into a
- 5:28dramatic, high stakes race deciding chess match.
- 5:32It's a system designed entirely around creating strategic
- 5:35entertainment and maximizing grip for just a few fleeting
- 5:37laps. But Formula E operates on the
- 5:40exact opposite philosophy. They use hand cooked tires and
- 5:44they only get one single highly durable all weather compound for
- 5:48the entire race. Just one tire for everything.
- 5:51Rain or shine, right? Wet track or dry asphalt?
- 5:54They use the same tire. Plus the tires are made with bio
- 5:57source materials and there are absolutely zero pit stops for
- 6:00tire changes during a race. Formula E sacrifices all that
- 6:03strategic drama of pit stops to align with an eco friendly
- 6:06mission. They want to prove that a
- 6:08sustainable tire can handle the brutal instant torque of an
- 6:11electric motor in very weather conditions.
- 6:13Without needing to be thrown into a scrap heap after 20
- 6:15minutes, it's a test of life cycle sustainability versus a
- 6:19test of fleeting absolute grip. Which raises a really important
- 6:23question. What happens when you take these
- 6:25two radically different philosophies, internal
- 6:28combustion and fully electric, and you force them to race
- 6:30against each other at the exact same time on the exact same
- 6:33track? Oh.
- 6:34Man, that brings us to our second source, the New Scientist
- 6:37breakdown of Rallycross. For those who aren't familiar,
- 6:41Rallycross is absolute mayhem in the best possible way.
- 6:45Pure chaos. We're talking 4 minute high
- 6:47adrenaline, short sharp Sprint races.
- 6:51The tracks are this chaotic mix of asphalt and loose dirt and
- 6:55there is a lot of physical contact.
- 6:57Cars bumping doors, dirt flying everywhere.
- 6:59It's incredibly visceral and for the 2024-2025 season, the FIA
- 7:04World Rallycross Championship launched what they called the
- 7:07Battle of Technologies. They allowed fully electric cars
- 7:10to race head to It's the. Perfect laboratory for direct
- 7:15confrontation and the tail of the tape here is wild.
- 7:18The EVs are producing a massive 680 horse power but they weigh
- 7:22440 kilos, while the gas cars produce slightly less power at
- 7:26600 horsepower but they are significantly lighter, weighing
- 7:30in at 12,080 kilos. We really need to define the
- 7:33difference between power and torque here, because that's the
- 7:35Crucible of this entire experiment.
- 7:38Power or horsepower generally dictates your top speed.
- 7:42Torque is the actual twisting force that gets you off the
- 7:44starting line and. That's where the technologies
- 7:46diverge, right? An internal combustion engine
- 7:49has to build up its revolutions, its RPMS, to find its maximal
- 7:52torque. It takes time, but an electric
- 7:56motor delivers its maximum torque the literal millisecond
- 7:59the driver touches the pedal. In a rallycross, that instant
- 8:02torque is everything. Getting to the first corner
- 8:05first in these short Sprint races gives a driver a 70%
- 8:09chance of winning the entire heat. 70%.
- 8:11At the starting light, the EV launches like a rocket.
- 8:14The gas cars simply cannot match that initial explosive burst of
- 8:18acceleration. They.
- 8:19Just get left behind off the line.
- 8:21Exactly, and the EVs also dominate on the long straights
- 8:25and in higher altitude tracks like the one in Montenegro at
- 8:281000 meters, where the electric motors don't suffer from thinner
- 8:31air. Here's where it gets really
- 8:33interesting, though. You might think that EVs just
- 8:35run away with it and dominate the whole season, but remember
- 8:38that weight difference you mentioned?
- 8:40The 160 kilos. The gas cars are 160 kilos
- 8:44lighter. That is roughly 350 lbs.
- 8:47I found the map on that staggering. 160 kilos isn't just
- 8:51a heavy suitcase in the trunk. That's like carrying two full
- 8:55grown adult passengers in a race where fractions of a second
- 8:58matter. You cannot cheat physics.
- 9:00That extra 160 kilos in the electric car is largely due to
- 9:03the heavy battery packs, and that weight creates massive
- 9:06inertia. So they struggle to stop.
- 9:08Right when an EV driver approaches a sharp dirt corner
- 9:11at 100 miles an hour, they have to start braking noticeably
- 9:14earlier because that heavy battery fundamentally wants to
- 9:16keep moving in a straight line. Meanwhile, the lighter internal
- 9:20combustion cars are incredibly nimble.
- 9:22The source details how the gas cars can brake much later and
- 9:25dive much deeper into the twisty sections of the circuit.
- 9:28They dance right around them. Exactly.
- 9:31They might lose the Drag race off the starting line, but they
- 9:34claw that time come back by dancing through the tight
- 9:37corners where the EV struggle to manage their own mass.
- 9:40And the outcome of this clash is quite telling.
- 9:43The sources reveal that Johann Kristofferson won the 2024 title
- 9:47driving an interning combustion car A.
- 9:49Gas car one, Yeah. Ultimately, on these tortuous
- 9:53mixed surface tracks, extreme lightness and agility were able
- 9:57to overcome brute electric power and instant torque.
- 10:00And it wasn't just a battle of physics on the track, either.
- 10:03The New Scientist source highlighted a real cultural
- 10:06divide among the fans in the grandstands.
- 10:08Which is fascinating to see play out.
- 10:09It really is. The younger generations are
- 10:11drawn to the cutting edge EV technology.
- 10:14They see it as the necessary future.
- 10:16It aligns with the sustainability goals mentioned
- 10:18by team owners who want to look their kids in the eye regarding
- 10:20climate change. But on the flip side, you have
- 10:23the traditionalists. They miss the sensory
- 10:25experience, the smell of the unburned racing fuel, the
- 10:29deafening chest rattling roar of the combustion engine.
- 10:33Yeah, the EVs are fast, but they emit this high pitched whine.
- 10:36For some fans, the lack of noise drains the adrenaline right out
- 10:40of the sport. Motorsport is having to balance
- 10:42its loud, visceral heritage with the undeniable reality of a
- 10:47changing climate and evolving Rd. car technology.
- 10:50And the organizers are doing their best to be impartial,
- 10:52offering a grid where both technologies can coexist and
- 10:55fans can just root for whichever philosophy they prefer.
- 10:58Which is a great segue to taking this battle of physics even
- 11:01further. We've talked about horizontal
- 11:03inertia on St. circuits and dirt tracks, but what happens when
- 11:06you take these same heavy batteries and ask them to fight
- 11:09something even bigger? Gravity.
- 11:11Yes, the translated Italian technical analysis dives into
- 11:15extreme environments, starting with hill climbs like the
- 11:18legendary Pikes Peak and drag racing.
- 11:21This is where we enter the domain of pure torque, and it's
- 11:25where the electric vehicle becomes an absolute monster.
- 11:28If we look at the physics of a hill climb or a drag race,
- 11:31you're fighting two things, gravity and inertia.
- 11:35And as we mentioned with rallycross, an internal
- 11:38combustion engine has to build up RPMS and if it's
- 11:41turbocharged, the driver has to wait for the exhaust gases to
- 11:44spool up the turbo. Turbo lag.
- 11:46Exactly. Turbo lag.
- 11:47There's a delay between pressing the pedal and actually getting
- 11:50the power. But the EV just goes 100% of the
- 11:53torque is available at 0 RPM. But the altitude factor is what
- 11:57truly separates them in a hill climb.
- 12:00As you drive up a mountain the air gets thinner and internal
- 12:02combustion engine literally breathes air to mix with fuel
- 12:06and create small explosion. Sorry, it needs oxygen.
- 12:09The Italian source notes that a gas car loses about 10% of its
- 12:12power for every 1000 meters of elevation it climbs.
- 12:15It is quite literally suffocating as it goes up.
- 12:19By the time an ICE car reaches the summit of a mountain like
- 12:21Pikes Peak, which sits at over 4300 meters, it's gasping for
- 12:26air. It's just a shadow of the
- 12:27powerful machine that started at the bottom of the mountain.
- 12:30But an electric vehicle does not need oxygen to generate power.
- 12:34It operates in a completely closed loop.
- 12:37It delivers the exact same mic, dropping brutal power at the
- 12:41starting line as it does in the freezing thin air at the 4300m
- 12:45summit. That's incredible.
- 12:46This independent relationship with the atmosphere is why EVs
- 12:49currently hold the absolute records for zero to 100
- 12:52kilometer per hour acceleration, doing it in under one second.
- 12:55Under one second, yeah. And it's why they hold the
- 12:57outright all time record at Pikes Peak.
- 13:01In a fight purely against gravity and thin air,
- 13:03electricity is currently unmatched.
- 13:05OK, so EVs conquered the mountains because they don't
- 13:07need to breathe, but then the Italian source pivots to the
- 13:09Dakar Rally. This is the grueling, punishing,
- 13:13trackless desert. And honestly, when I think of
- 13:15EVs, I think of range anxiety. Oh absolutely.
- 13:18The idea of taking a battery powered car into the middle of
- 13:21the desert, hundreds of miles from a charging plug, racing for
- 13:25weeks on end, It just seems like an absolute deal breaker.
- 13:28And it would be for a standard EV, but Audi came up with an
- 13:31engineering solution for their RSQE Tron that is nothing short
- 13:35of a paradigm shift. What did they do?
- 13:37They realized the best way to beat the desert wasn't to build
- 13:40a better gas engine or bigger battery, but to completely
- 13:44rethink the entire drivetrain. The vehicle is driven entirely
- 13:48by electric motors on the axles. However, it carries an internal
- 13:52combustion engine on board. Wait, so it has a gas engine
- 13:55too? Yes, but the key insight here is
- 13:57that the gas engine is not connected to the wheels at all.
- 14:00It acts strictly as an onboard generator, running at its most
- 14:03efficient steady RPM to constantly charge the batteries
- 14:07while the car is racing through the desert.
- 14:09To a layperson, this sounds crazy.
- 14:11It's a paradox of weight. You are carrying the weight of a
- 14:14heavy battery pack, plus the weight of gallons of liquid
- 14:17fuel, plus the weight of a combustion engine.
- 14:20It sounds incredibly heavy. Why go through all that
- 14:22incredibly complex engineering? Why not just use a traditional
- 14:26gas engine connected to a gearbox like everyone else?
- 14:29The source points to the sand dunes as the ultimate answer,
- 14:33right? Yes, the dunes are drivers worst
- 14:36nightmare. Driving a two ton vehicle in
- 14:39deep soft sand requires constant unbroken momentum.
- 14:44You can't. Stop.
- 14:45You can't even hesitate if a driver in a traditional gas
- 14:48powered car shifts gears. There is a fraction of a second
- 14:51where power stops going to the wheels, or if their RPM is
- 14:55dropped too low, the torque vanishes.
- 14:57And the heavy tires just dig in. Exactly.
- 15:00The car gets bogged down once you sink to your axles in the
- 15:02deck car. You are waiting hours for a tow
- 15:04truck and your race is effectively over.
- 15:07So Audi realized that the efficiency gained by letting the
- 15:09electric motors perfectly manage the sand outweighs all that
- 15:13physical mass of carrying three power systems.
- 15:15Exactly because the Audi does not have a gearbox or mechanical
- 15:18drive shaft connecting the front and rear wheels, it bypasses the
- 15:21limitations of traditional cars. So it's not physically linking
- 15:25the wheels together, right? It relies entirely on an
- 15:28electronic all-wheel drive system.
- 15:30The onboard computers can synchronize the electric motors
- 15:33on the front and rear axles in mere milliseconds.
- 15:36Milliseconds. They can detect a loss of
- 15:37traction on a single wheel and adjust the power outs and almost
- 15:41instantly, which prevents the wheel spin that digs a car into
- 15:44a sandy grave. The source describes it as
- 15:47allowing this massive, heavy vehicle to magically float over
- 15:51the soft dunes. The electronics manage the
- 15:53traction so perfectly that the mechanical limitations of a
- 15:57traditional gas car are completely bypassed.
- 15:59It's changing the game for off roading.
- 16:01Think about what this means for consumer vehicles in the future.
- 16:04Just imagine off road trucks with no differentials to snap,
- 16:08no mechanical Dr. shafts breaking on rocks, just
- 16:11intelligent motors at each axle doing of the thinking for you.
- 16:15And the proof is in the results. This isn't just a whiteboard
- 16:19theory. This specific technological
- 16:21advantage LED legendary driver Carlos Sainz to win the Dakar
- 16:25Rally in 2024. Wow.
- 16:27It marked the first ever victory for an electrified vehicle in
- 16:30the absolute harshest, longest desert endurance race on the
- 16:34planet. So what does this all mean for
- 16:36you? We've covered a massive amount
- 16:38of ground today, from the pristine strategic streets of
- 16:41Monaco to the chaotic dirt of Rallycross, up the suffocating
- 16:45heights of Pikes Peak and across the endless dunes of the Duck
- 16:49Hard Desert. Yeah, and if we synthesize
- 16:51everything these sources are telling us, it becomes clear
- 16:54that this isn't just sports trivia.
- 16:56Motorsport has always been the ultimate research and
- 16:58development laboratory for the cars we eventually drive to work
- 17:01or the grocery store. Right?
- 17:03The sources show a very clear split in where we are
- 17:06technologically today. If you're looking for raw top
- 17:09speed, lightweight agility and tight corners, and the complex
- 17:12strategy of fuel and tire management, the internal
- 17:15combustion engine, especially as it transitions towards
- 17:18sustainable fuels, still holds the crown.
- 17:20Like we saw with Formula One's sheer speed and the lighter gas
- 17:23cars dancing through the twisty sections of rallycross.
- 17:26But if your environment demands instant explosive acceleration
- 17:30off the line, total immunity to high altitudes, or the kind of
- 17:33millisecond perfect traction management required to float
- 17:35over desert sand, electric propulsion is absolutely
- 17:38undeniable. We saw that with the Sub One
- 17:40Second drag times, the Hill Climb records and Audi's
- 17:43historic to Car win. They are two different tools
- 17:46excelling at entirely different jobs.
- 17:48It really reframes a whole gas versus electric debate.
- 17:52It's not about which is universally better, it's about
- 17:55what you are asking the machine to do.
- 17:57Recognizing those specific strengths is crucial as we look
- 18:00at how infrastructure, tire manufacturing and vehicle design
- 18:04will evolve over the next decade.
- 18:05I want to thank you for joining us on this deep dive.
- 18:08It's a lot of complex physics, white dynamics, and engineering
- 18:11to wrap your head around, but hopefully it gives you a much
- 18:14clearer picture of what's actually happening beneath the
- 18:17hood of the future. I want to leave you with a final
- 18:20provocative thought to Mull over, something to explore on
- 18:23your own. Right now, as we've seen in our
- 18:25sources, we're mostly watching electric motors being forced
- 18:28into traditional racing formats, racing on tracks that were
- 18:31originally designed for gas cars a century ago.
- 18:34But if Formula E software keeps evolving and Audi's traction
- 18:38management proves that heavy mechanical Dr. shafts are
- 18:41completely obsolete, what happens to motorsport when
- 18:44engineers completely stop trying to make an EV act like a
- 18:47traditional car and instead design an entirely new type of
- 18:50racing circuit? Imagine a track built vertically
- 18:53or with impossible angles that exploits maneuvers a gas car
- 18:56couldn't even physically attempt without stalling or starving for
- 18:59fuel. Keep that in mind next time you
- 19:01see a race. We'll catch you on the next deep
- 19:03dive.