Latest / Crafted Clarity: Distilling the Tension Between Success and Significance / The Vanity Tax: Trading Cosmetic Clarity for Rooted Substance | Crafted Clarity Podcast

Transcript

The Vanity Tax: Trading Cosmetic Clarity for Rooted Substance | Crafted Clarity Podcast · Crafted Clarity: Distilling the Tension Between Success and Significance

• 0:02
  I was sitting across from a leader recently over a glass of
• 0:06
  whiskey. Of course when he says something
• 0:08
  I don't hear said out loud very often, I think I'm becoming
• 0:13
  irrelevant. He then paused, took a sip and
• 0:17
  added. I'm just not sure if that's a
• 0:20
  bad thing or not. He just said it.
• 0:24
  No set up, no explanation, just an honest thought spoken out
• 0:29
  loud, hanging in the air between 2 glasses.
• 0:34
  I've sat at this table with a lot of leaders lately, and over
• 0:38
  the past few years I've heard versions of that same statement
• 0:42
  over and over and they don't always use the word irrelevant.
• 0:47
  Sometimes it sounds like I think my time as CEO might be done, or
• 0:54
  I'm not sure this role makes sense for me anymore.
• 0:57
  No matter how they say it, the tension is always the same.
• 1:02
  Things are shifting, and they're aware of it, but the problem is
• 1:08
  they don't know what to do with that awareness.
• 1:12
  For most of us, when we feel a shift like that, when we sense
• 1:16
  the ground moving beneath the success that we've spent decades
• 1:20
  building, our first instinct isn't to lean into the change.
• 1:25
  Our instinct is to hide it. We feel this massive, unspoken
• 1:30
  pressure to be the one person in the room who has it all figured
• 1:34
  out all the time. We're terrified that if we show
• 1:39
  what we're actually sensing, the hesitation, the questions, the
• 1:44
  cloudiness of our own transition, our teams, our
• 1:49
  boards, or even those close to us might sense a lack of
• 1:54
  confidence. So we start to create a gap.
• 1:59
  A gap between the role we perform and the self we actually
• 2:04
  are. We convince ourselves that the
• 2:06
  only way to protect what we've built is to keep the self out of
• 2:12
  sight. We tell ourselves that
• 2:14
  significance is something that we'll get to later.
• 2:18
  But for right now, the success requires us to stay polished.
• 2:24
  It requires us to look and act the part.
• 2:29
  We start to believe that our value is tied to our clarity, to
• 2:34
  our ability to be consistent, predictable, and shelf stable.
• 2:40
  And when we can't find that clarity internally, we
• 2:43
  manufacture it externally. We turn to more performance.
• 2:49
  We start doing the work of stripping away anything that
• 2:52
  looks like struggle or uncertainty.
• 2:55
  We try to present a version of ourselves that's perfectly
• 2:59
  clear, even if what's inside is starting to feel cloudy.
• 3:05
  And that is where the performance begins.
• 3:14
  I recognize the look in his eyes immediately.
• 3:17
  And because I've lived that performance too, there have been
• 3:21
  seasons where I spend more energy on the presentation of my
• 3:25
  leadership and the actual practice of it.
• 3:29
  Seasons where the gap between what I was feeling and what I
• 3:32
  was showing was costing me everything.
• 3:37
  I've had those mornings, and maybe you've had them too, where
• 3:41
  I've sat in my car before a meeting and literally rehearsed
• 3:45
  my answers. Not because I didn't know the
• 3:48
  business, and not because I didn't know what I believed.
• 3:53
  I rehearsed because I wanted to make sure I sounded certain.
• 3:57
  I wanted to sound impressive. I would memorize A polished
• 4:02
  elevator pitch. I would intentionally smooth out
• 4:05
  the pauses in my speech because I was terrified that a moment of
• 4:09
  silence would be interpreted as a moment of hesitation.
• 4:15
  I even found myself overdressing for casual meetings, just to
• 4:18
  make sure the outward appearance matched the role I thought I was
• 4:22
  supposed to play. I wasn't trying to be dishonest.
• 4:27
  I was trying to overcome the internal haze of my own
• 4:31
  transitions. I was trying to manage the
• 4:34
  imposter syndrome that whispers you're not actually what people
• 4:38
  see. I thought that if I could keep
• 4:42
  what others see perfectly clear, then I could keep the fear of
• 4:47
  irrelevance at Bay. We tend to do this because we
• 4:53
  believe our value is tied to clarity.
• 4:56
  We think that the clearer we are, the more trustworthy we
• 4:59
  are. So we work overtime to strip
• 5:03
  away the cloudy bits of our humanity.
• 5:06
  We hide the fatigue, we mask the questions, and we edit out the
• 5:11
  very things that actually make us uniquely us.
• 5:16
  We're so busy trying to be impressive that we've forgotten
• 5:20
  how to be present. And yet, looking back on my own
• 5:24
  journey, the best conversations, the ones that actually built
• 5:29
  trust, the ones that led to real significance, like the ones with
• 5:33
  leaders, happened when I finally stopped trying to look the part
• 5:39
  and simply showed up as myself. But Polish feels safer,
• 5:45
  especially when you're standing at the crossroads between what
• 5:48
  you built and what you're built for.
• 5:53
  As whiskey ages, it doesn't just sit idle in a barrel.
• 5:58
  The whiskey is actually breathing, interacting with the
• 6:01
  wood of the barrel. As it does, it absorbs tiny,
• 6:05
  complex compounds like fatty acids, proteins, and esters.
• 6:12
  These are literal bits of the barrel.
• 6:15
  They're the chemical evidence of time, heat, and pressure.
• 6:20
  They are what makes the whiskey what it is.
• 6:24
  If you were to put that whiskey into a glass straight from the
• 6:27
  barrel, the whiskey might look a bit hazy, especially if you
• 6:31
  served it over an ice cube. To a distiller, however, this is
• 6:37
  perfection. They know that those cloudy bits
• 6:41
  are where the unique flavor lives.
• 6:43
  It's where the character is. To the Maker, that haze is the
• 6:48
  soul of the spirit, the proof that this whiskey has actually
• 6:52
  spent years being formed by the barrel.
• 6:57
  But here's where the tension begins.
• 7:00
  Consumers of whiskey, generally speaking, don't want a cloudy
• 7:05
  spirit when they pour a glass, they want to see clear, amber
• 7:10
  whiskey. In other words, they want
• 7:14
  cosmetic clarity. To the average consumer, clear
• 7:19
  equals quality. They've been told that if a
• 7:22
  spirit isn't transparent, it's somehow contaminated or off.
• 7:28
  They want a product that is predictable, shelf stable and
• 7:32
  visually perfect. So to meet that expectation,
• 7:38
  distillers have to perform a massive, expensive intervention
• 7:42
  known as chill filtering. They drop the temperature of the
• 7:46
  spirit to just about freezing. This forces the flavorful
• 7:50
  compounds to clump together so they can be physically stripped
• 7:54
  away. It's a costly and unnecessary
• 7:58
  step. It takes time, money, and
• 8:02
  resources that could be spent on the spirit itself.
• 8:06
  But the distiller pays that vanity tax because they're
• 8:11
  afraid that if the consumer sees the real, unfiltered haze of the
• 8:15
  wood, they won't buy it. Or worse, they'll think the
• 8:20
  whiskey is inferior. And this is the exact tension we
• 8:26
  feel when we are seeking more significance in our lives and in
• 8:30
  our leadership. Our default state, the one that
• 8:34
  we've acquired through the years of leading, failing and growing,
• 8:39
  is textured. Like the raw whiskey, it's
• 8:42
  complex. It's seasoned, but as we move
• 8:47
  from success towards significance, that season's date
• 8:52
  is often at odds with what's expected of a great leader.
• 8:57
  The consumer in our lives, the board, the marketplace,
• 9:02
  sometimes even our our own circles and families expects us
• 9:06
  to be crystal clear. They expected the polished
• 9:09
  elevator pitch. They expect the certain answer.
• 9:15
  They expect us to look shelf stable and consistent no matter
• 9:19
  how much the world is changing around us or what's changing
• 9:22
  inside of us. So we start paying our own
• 9:27
  vanity tax. We spend our best emotional
• 9:31
  energy filtering our souls. We strip away the fatty acids of
• 9:35
  our true convictions. We edit out the esters of our
• 9:39
  hard earned intuition because we're afraid that if people see
• 9:44
  our haze, our questions, our slower pace, our deeper
• 9:49
  formation, they'll think we've lost our value.
• 9:54
  In other words, we work hard to remove the very things that give
• 9:59
  our leadership its character. We're making ourselves clear for
• 10:04
  people who don't even know what they're missing.
• 10:07
  And in the process, we're filtering what we were meant to
• 10:11
  offer. But there is another way.
• 10:17
  One of my favorite whiskeys is oak and Eden.
• 10:20
  One of the things that make them unique is that they include a
• 10:24
  Spire of wood, a small spiral of American oak sitting right
• 10:29
  inside the bottle. They call this in bottle
• 10:33
  finishing. Unlike other spirits that are
• 10:36
  finished aging in the barrel, filtered and then bottled, the
• 10:41
  wood Spire inside the Oak and Eden bottle allows the whiskey
• 10:45
  to keep interacting with the wood, still changing and still
• 10:49
  steeping. This is because it is a non
• 10:54
  filtered spirit. Because it's a non chilled
• 10:57
  filtered spirit, it might be a little hazy in your glass, but
• 11:02
  Oak and Eden isn't trying to win a beauty contest for cosmetic
• 11:06
  clarity. They've made a different choice.
• 11:10
  They've chosen rooted clarity. They understand that the haze
• 11:15
  isn't a defect. It's the evidence of depth.
• 11:20
  It's proof that the spirit is still being formed by the Spire.
• 11:25
  For those of us seeking significance, this is the yes
• 11:28
  and moment. We don't have to choose between
• 11:33
  being messy and being valuable. We just have to realize that our
• 11:37
  value now comes from a different source.
• 11:41
  Rooted clarity isn't always visually clear to those standing
• 11:45
  on the outside. It's internally aligned.
• 11:50
  It's a clarity that comes from knowing who you are and what
• 11:54
  you're built for. When we're steeping like that
• 11:58
  whiskey with a Spire in it, we're allowing our life to be
• 12:02
  formed by calling. And when this happens, others
• 12:06
  notice the difference. They can feel the presence of
• 12:10
  someone who's stopped rehearsing and started being.
• 12:15
  And in our leadership, that presence actually lingers.
• 12:22
  But let's be honest about the tension here.
• 12:25
  Most of us want both. We want the rooted clarity.
• 12:29
  We want to feel that internal alignment and that sense of
• 12:33
  being built for something deeper.
• 12:36
  But we're also terrified to let go of the cosmetic clarity.
• 12:39
  We still want to look strong. We want we still want the
• 12:43
  polished answer. We still want the approval of
• 12:47
  the people who have only ever known the filtered version of
• 12:50
  us. The real tension is that the
• 12:54
  path to significance requires us to tolerate a little visible
• 13:00
  evolution. It requires us to let the haze
• 13:03
  show while we're still in the process of becoming.
• 13:08
  And that feels like a risk. It feels like that we're
• 13:12
  inviting people to judge the work before it's finished.
• 13:17
  But here's what I've learned sitting with leaders inside
• 13:20
  these discussions. The vanity tax is what keeps you
• 13:25
  stuck in success. It's the price you pay to stay
• 13:29
  exactly where you are. It's the energy you spend
• 13:34
  maintaining a version of yourself that you've already
• 13:37
  outgrown. If you want to move towards
• 13:41
  significance, you have to be willing to be non chill filter.
• 13:47
  You have to have the courage to stop filtering out your humanity
• 13:50
  just to survive someone else's perception.
• 13:55
  Because when you finally stop trying to be clear, you start
• 13:59
  becoming substantial rooted. Clarity doesn't come from
• 14:03
  removing the mess. It comes from staying in the
• 14:07
  wood. It comes from trusting that the
• 14:09
  very things you're trying to hide, your questions, your
• 14:13
  fatigue, your need for different pace, are the oils and esters
• 14:18
  that your organization needs right now.
• 14:23
  They don't need another rehearsed answer, they need a
• 14:27
  present leader. We've talked about the tension
• 14:34
  of becoming irrelevant and the high cost of the vanity tax, but
• 14:38
  now comes the discernment part. These are the questions I've
• 14:42
  shared with leaders, the ones that I've sat with who are
• 14:46
  feeling this tension first. Where are you paying the vanity
• 14:51
  tax right now? Where are you spending time and
• 14:55
  resources working to remove the cloudiness, smoothing out the
• 14:59
  pauses, rehearsing the certainty, and filtering your
• 15:03
  character just to align with someone else's perception?
• 15:09
  What is this filtration costing you?
• 15:13
  And second, do you have the courage to let the haze show
• 15:18
  while you steep? Significance requires substance
• 15:22
  and it requires the weight of your real, unfiltered life.
• 15:27
  Are you ready to stop managing the clarity of your bottle and
• 15:31
  start honoring the depth of your spirit?
• 15:36
  The world is filled with chill, filtered leaders.
• 15:40
  It needs someone who has stayed in the wood long enough to have
• 15:43
  something authentic, significant and that lingers.
• 15:51
  If you've gone to a tasty a whiskey tasting, then you know
• 15:55
  you write down what you want to remember.
• 15:58
  Here are my tasting notes from today.
• 16:00
  Yours might be different. We often misdiagnose the
• 16:05
  internal shift from success towards significance as a loss
• 16:09
  of edge or relevance. This fear drives us to pay the
• 16:14
  vanity tax, the massive emotional cost of chill,
• 16:18
  filtering our leadership to ensure that we look clear,
• 16:22
  certain, and shelf stable for those watching us.
• 16:28
  Haze is not a flaw, it's the evidence that time spent in the
• 16:33
  barrel, the cloudy bits of your questions, your fatigue, and
• 16:38
  your evolving pace are where the flavor and soul of your
• 16:42
  leadership live. Cosmetic clarity.
• 16:49
  It's a result of filtering. It looks impressive and
• 16:52
  consistent, but it can leave the spirit thin.
• 16:57
  It lacks A richness and the lingering character that only
• 17:00
  comes from being unfiltered and rooted.
• 17:05
  Clarity. That's the in bottle Spire
• 17:09
  approach. It's the clarity of a leader who
• 17:12
  is still steeping, still interacting with the wood of
• 17:15
  their calling. It may look cloudy to someone
• 17:19
  looking for a quick answer or shallow leadership, but it has
• 17:24
  the weight required to linger. If this resonated with you, I
• 17:32
  encourage you to download the tasting notes from today's
• 17:36
  conversation at craftedclarity.net/tasting
• 17:40
  Notes. You'll find these questions and
• 17:42
  others as you distill today's conversation.
• 17:47
  Thanks for joining me in the tasting room.
• 17:50
  And remember, clarity isn't found, it's crafted.
• 17:59
  Thanks for listening to Crafted Clarity.
• 18:02
  If you're a leader wrestling with the tension between success
• 18:05
  and significance, or if you're trying to align your work with a
• 18:08
  deeper calling, I'd love to connect with you.
• 18:10
  If your organization is facing questions about strategy,
• 18:14
  whether it's alignment, ROI, or building confidence in your
• 18:17
  team. This is the work we do every day
• 18:19
  at ibrand. And if you walk this journey
• 18:22
  yourself, or maybe you're right in the middle of it, I'd love to
• 18:25
  hear your story and maybe even shared here on the podcast.
• 18:29
  You can find me at craftclarity.net.