Latest / Big Dog Dynasty Fantasy Football / EP. 21 - Would You Rather Week 9
Transcript
- Eric Hofstee: Welcome back, big dogs. This is the Big Dog Dynasty Fantasy Football Podcast. I'm your host, Eric Hofstead, and alongside with me as always is Kyle Butts. Kyle: boo. Eric Hofstee: I really like the Richard Sherman jersey, man. That thing's tight. Kyle: Hell yeah, dude. Twelfth man. Eric Hofstee: Y twelfth man, that's right, for all you Seahawks fans out there. Kyle: The legion of boom, dude. Eric Hofstee: What a great secondary man and what a great name too. Cam Chancellor Kyle: Sex. Eric Hofstee: was probably my favorite player in that secondary, dude. He just laid a boom, you know. Kyle: Hell yeah, dude. Chancellor, freaking Sherman, Eric Hofstee: Thomas. Kyle: yeah, Earl Thomas. Eric Hofstee: Talk about a rocket coming right at you, dude. Kyle: That's a bad mother. Eric Hofstee: so for those of you that are listening for the first time or maybe you've listened to all of our episodes, we're gonna do something new today. We're gonna do a would you rather edition. So we're gonna go through each position and say, Would you rather have this guy or this guy? And this is for like anybody that has trades out there and they're thinking about tearing down at one position to maybe add another player at another position. So like for example Yeah, me and Kyle did a trade recently in one of our leagues where I traded him Drake May and I teared down slightly at quarterback the Trevor Lawrence and I also got Christian Watson in the deal because I wanted a higher upside wide receiver that I could plug into my lineup. And so that's what gave me the spark this idea for this episode. So hopefully you guys enjoy it. And we're gonna get right into it. So Kyle, this one's pretty close. this is arguably top three, but would you rather have Drake May or Caleb Williams in Dynasty? These are gonna be tough. They're all gonna be tough, man. They're all gonna be super close. Kyle: as far as let's see, let's look and see where they're at right now. But I mean Drake Drake May is what? QB three and what Eric Hofstee: Crazy after his slow start too that he's already rocking it up to Q B three. But Trevor Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: Lawrence was QB three before his bye week, so I'm a cr I'm giving it that little you know. Kyle: I'm gonna go average though right now. So Drake May's at twenty two point one points per game and Caleb's at ninety both of these guys I love. The the reason why I I kinda offered you that trade for Lawrence and Watson is 'cause we're our teams are kinda on the opp opposite end of the spectrum. I I was planning on a two year rebuild. I got a ton of wide receivers, young guys, and so I was I was hoping to you know, I knew Drake May would Would be all right, but I'm also the guy that any chance I got in rookie drafts, I took Caleb Williams. So I think I'm probably attached to both of those guys. But I I'm in my mind, I'm gonna take Drake May just slightly above Caleb Williams. just 'cause I think like Drake May has shown that he has well he's outproduced Caleb Williams with less less weapons. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Done more with less. Kyle: Yeah, Caleb is good and he's like that s that scramble, kinda on the run, make things happen. Whereas Drake May is gonna is that I got a cannon and I'm gonna use it, and I don't know, that's always Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: been my s my s favorite style of quarterback and and Brett Favre. Shout out Brett Favre. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: but I just just slightly, I'm I'm gonna take Drake May. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, the this one's tough, right? So Caleb Williams obviously has the better offensive coach, better offensive weapons. And I do think over the course of their careers, Caleb probably I mean, see them like as far as who finishes higher than the other. I honestly see it being split by the time their career's done. Like Caleb's gonna have some years Kyle: For sure. Eric Hofstee: where he's higher. Drake's gonna have some years where he's higher. Drake may just give you much more of a rushing floor than Caleb does. Like Caleb will get you like ten anywhere from ten to twenty yards a game, you know, and like thirty on the high end, whereas Drake May thirties is low end on the rushing. And so just to play devil's advocate, I'm gonna go Caleb here. I mean, they're only ten months apart in age, so you can't really say anything about age difference, but as far as the weapons and the offensive coach, you know, Ben Johnson isn't afraid to go put up fifty or sixty points on somebody. And I feel like if the Patriots ever get a solid running back, like they might start leaning on the running game more there in New England just 'cause of how Vrabel likes to do things. I mean, I watched him for a long time when he was in Tennessee, right, and Derrick Henry and if he's got a great running back, he's not afraid to ride him. And I mean we'll see if they obviously if they get like some real weapons around Drake May, then maybe I'll change my mind and you know, and it's Drake May hands down. But at this point, I gotta go with weapons. I know Drake May's done more with less, but like I said, over the course of their careers, I think as far as who finishes higher than the other, they're gonna flip flop a lot of years. So just to play devil's advocate, I'm gonna go Caleb there. So next, Brock Purdy or Trevor Lawrence? Kyle: I I think I'm gonna give the slight edge to Purdy just because he is Mr. Consistent. Trevor Lawrence has definitely been better the last two years. The offense has been humming. Liam Cohen's done a lot for that team, done a lot for Trevor Lawrence, I think. But Purdy is just Man, he just he gets it done. you don't get any dud games from Brock Purdy. I know he's like kinda struggled with with injuries, but I think like mentally as far as just a player, I think he has just that little extra that Trevor Lawrence doesn't have. You know, Trevor Lawrence was supposed to be like this generational quarterback and like he's been great, you know. I got him on a lot of teams. He's been good. But Purdy just like is a set and forget it, I know the last time they played he had zero wide receivers, but I mean he didn't kill you. He's never gonna kill you. and right now the only knock on Trevor Lawrence is like that that dude gets pulled every fourth quarter. He doesn't even play a full game, you know, so Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: just because the defense is good, Tootin's good, so I don't know. I'ma I'm gonna take Brock Purdy slightly. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, so on the last one I was playing Devil's Advocate just to do it, but this time I have conviction in it. I'm gonna go Trevor Lawrence, hands down. because you look at the situation around Purdy, right? Kittle's aging, he's not getting any younger, Mike Evans is gonna be who knows how many more years he's got, Christian McCaffrey's gonna be out of there soon. And then then what kind of Brock Purdy do we get when it's just stribling and whoever else they put around him, right? And so Trevor Lawrence, you got Travis Hunter, Parker Washington, Brenton Strange, Tootin, they're all young and they're growing with Lawrence. And I've watched a lot of Jacksonville's games this year and some of the throws this guy is making, he's one of Kyle: For sure. Eric Hofstee: one out there. Like I he's he's got parrot cojones on him, let me tell you. Kyle: That frickin' missile to Brian Thomas Jr. who's about to get traded so that Brock Purdy can use him. But man, that was a yeah, be beautiful, Eric Hofstee: Fingers crossed, fingers crossed. I would love to see that. Kyle: beautiful throw. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, and so I mean, I just it it took him longer than people like you said, he was projected to be like the next Andrew Luck type player coming out of college and whether it be 'cause he had Urban Meyer his rookie year, I mean the guy didn't have a fair shake his first couple of years. Yeah. Kyle: System. I I I yeah, I think it's a system for sure. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, and Brian or what Liam Cohen has definitely rided the ship there and has it pointing in the right direction. And just the cast around Lawrence is young and they're all growing together in that system. And I think you just you know, Purdy may give you a more consistent, like higher floor, but Lawrence, man, he's got a ceiling that only a few can reach in the league. And so give me Trevor Lawrence there. Kyle: What's good too is Purdy was more of the rusher. and Lawrence is over the last two years he's he's done more r more running, you know. He's probably not gonna get the rushing touchdowns like he did last year. I mean th this year he hasn't really got the rushing touchdowns, but he can run. He's got wheels. Eric Hofstee: For sure. And he's not afraid to lower his shoulder too. And so yeah, honestly coming on like to last year I started to see a little bit of Drake May, Josh Allen in him where he can he can move, man. He's got some wheels, like you said. Kyle: Yeah, it's gonna come down to haircut for me though, dude. I can't Eric Hofstee: Dude, if he ever cuts his hair, like watch that the all the strengths in his hair, all the talents in his hair, like watch him just be a terrible quarterback when he cuts his hair. But this one's this Kyle: Yeah, I don't know. That's a goofy, goofy ass style. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, man. it it it it's not very common that you see that kind of those kind of locks on a quarterback, you know? All Kyle: For sure, for sure. Eric Hofstee: right, this next one they're gonna these ones are s gonna start getting tougher. Jaden Daniels or Joe Burrow? In a in a six point passing touchdown league. Obviously four point I think you lean towards Daniels, so that's why I'm gonna give you the six point passing touchdown. Kyle: man, Eric Hofstee: Burrow's almost thirty Kyle: I don't know. This this w Eric Hofstee: and Daniels is almost twenty six, if that sways you. Kyle: I don't I don't I don't know. I don't think it I don't think it does. I I don't know. I think it's gonna come down to me like Chase and Higgins, you know? Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: the commanders for whatever reason can't seem to s stay healthy around the board. I know like T. Higgins hasn't been like the model picture of perfect health, but and Joe Joe Burrow's been playing weird. he's not good the first half or first quarter or so of the game, but then last week too they throw six touchdowns. it's like Eric Hofstee: Ridiculous. Not many quarterbacks have that kind of upside. Kyle: I like that and that's what I think it comes down to. Joe Burrow is like the upside is unrivaled. Like nobody else I have n since the la since Joe Burrow came out, nobody's matches that dude's upside. You know, I've had him on some dynasty rosters where like I thought I was out of it. And here comes Joe Burrow, four hundred yards, six touchdowns, fifty burger, and I got Chase Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: or Higgins or Gasicki or somebody else, and all of a sudden it's like I'm down eighty points and I just won, you know? So Eric Hofstee: Sure. Kyle: I think it's gonna go to the upside, but that's like not Jaden Daniels. We I still don't think we've seen his upside. I think if they can get him some weapons and he can stay healthy, I mean Joe Burrow's been hurt too. But I mean Jaden Daniels has look this year has looked pretty good with the weapons that he has as well. So But I'm gonna take Joe Burrow, yeah. Eric Hofstee: This time I'm gonna agree with you, I'm gonna go with Joe Burrow as well. ar he's arguably the best thrower of the football in the NFL. I mean, the guy's just a natural quarterback, you know, and some people like to dis discount him for that, like, he's just a pocket quarterback. But how many quarterbacks can go out there and get you four hundred yards and five tutties? You know like Kyle: Well yeah, and the the defense is better but it's still not good. So the we l we love it. Yeah. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, he's still gonna be in a lot of shootouts. Yeah, for sure. It's very fantasy friendly there in Cincinnati, and that's that's what it's all about. Jaden Daniels, he kinda has to do it all himself. Whereas Burrow can throw a slant to Chase and it's gone ninety yards to the house. And so Kyle: God, some of those Higgins catches this we last week God damn. Eric Hofstee: Dude, that guy is a monster, bro. he'd be a wide receiver one on just about every other team in the league except JSN and Chase, Kyle: Well Yeah, just just don't Eric Hofstee: dude. Kyle: d don't talk too loud about you know. You you gotta keep healthy, you know. Just keep on the field. There's like a whisper. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, for sure. Yeah. As long as he's healthy, man, that guy's a stud, for sure. All right, so next, the last of the quarterbacks we're gonna talk about, would you rather have Shuck or Bryce Young? Kyle: this is a easy one for me. I'm gonna take Shuck. I think that offense is kind of like ascending. The Panthers are kind of falling back into what they were. which I know you hate to hear. Eric Hofstee: Every team goes through a rough patch during the season, dude. Kyle: Yeah, I just I I don't know, I like what they're doing like in New Orleans. they're the best worst team like in the NFL, I think. the offensive line's like kinda not healthy right now, so he they're kinda pressuring Shuck, but Shuck has shown that he's he can he can make it happen and I like I'm a big Jordan Tyson guy. I hope it I hope it works. I like Olave. Juwan's there right now. If they can get a run game, I think that would really help Shuck. Bryce Young is just I I just I can't I can't tr I can't trust him. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, this is gonna be a homer pick for me, obviously, but I'm gonna have to say Bryce Young. he's got the longer leash, number one overall pick, whereas Shuck was a second rounder, so if he does start going in the opposite direction trend wise, I could easily see them cutting bait with him, say, we don't have that much invested in him, let's just go get a different quarterback and you can't really say anything about the coaches in the scheme. The Saints have Kellen Moore as the head coach. Panthers have Dave Canales and they're both great offensive minds. So there's I don't really lean one way or the other there as far as coach, but and then you look at the talent as well, Bryce Young has Jalen Coker, Ted Aurora McMillan, the Saints have Chris Olave, Jordan Tyson. So I mean there's a lot of similarities between the two, right? And I just think Yeah I'm kinda I'm kinda Kyle: This is probably more of like for me the I think th what would seal the deal one way or the other is whether you play in a four point or a six point passing touchdown league because just 'cause Shuck runs he's got like a higher rushing floor than Bryce Young, whereas I do think that the offense is when it's when it's on, they the Panthers have a running game and he can throw the ball to Chuba and Tet and Coker Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: and whoever they wanna mix in at at tight end. So I think Bryce Young has the higher touchdown passing upside. Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Sure, that's fair. six point Euline Young, four point Euline Chuck. Alright, so that it is close, yeah, I'll I I'm not gonna lie, it's it's just a homer pick. Give me Bryce Young. But it's not because of lack of faith. Like I do believe in Bryce Young where you know, I went to like his second season, I think it's the year he got benched and I went to Carolina to watch a game and they were playing the Chargers. He looked so terrible that game. I was ready to just write this guy off, like get rid of him, get him out of there and He's proved me wrong ever since he came back from being benched and so I'll never go against Bryce Young again. But all right, so now that was it for the quarterback debate. So if any of you guys are out there and you got some trade offers sitting out there and you wanna like tear down from one guy to the other and maybe add a piece, like j we're just giving you our thoughts on like, you know, who we like better. And so, tier lists don't always mean everything. Like you gotta have conviction in your own guys and what you believe. And so if you like one player better than the other, don't be afraid to make that move, like regardless of what dynasty values say. So running backs. Jeremiah Love or Devon Achen? Kyle: man. Eric Hofstee: I had to lead that one off for you specifically. Kyle: Can I flip a coin? Eric Hofstee: I wanna I wanna hear some conviction in your argument. Kyle: I don't know. I think I'm still gonna take I think I'm still gonna take a ch A Chan. Eric Hofstee: There's four year difference in age if that sways you one way or the other. Kyle: I don't know, after to be honest with you, a couple of weeks ago I made this trade and I traded A Chan for Jeremiah Love. I needed a running back this season. Even though me personally, I think A Chan I don't know. I think I would take A Chan six out of ten times over Jeremiah Love. just 'cause I've seen what he's done and now that I've and I've kinda seen what the Cardinals do to their players, Man. I don't know. I'd I'd have to probably take love though for the for the age. The the Cardinals can't be this bad for this many more years, can they? I d I don't know, man. That's the tough that's Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. It's tough. Kyle: a tough that's the tough part. I mean, I know love's like dealing with the ankle injury and stuff right now and like y you hate to see it 'cause this is exactly what like Hampton went through last year and Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: Genty's going through this year and HN's s ACL, right? A C L Eric Hofstee: Yeah. And then you saw how they were using him this year. He wasn't giving you those high upside games like he was with Tua, when when Malik's at quarterback. he was mid, to be honest, even before he got hurt. Kyle: do do the Dolphins get a quarterback next year or do they run Malik Willis? that's yeah. Eric Hofstee: That that's gonna be a big question in draft time for sure. Kyle: I'm gonna take love and just hope that he can figure it out. 'Cause like when they used him this year and he was the guy, he looked great and he was healthy and Eric Hofstee: They used them too much in the preseason, I'll tell you that much. this is when all this injury stuff started was by giving them fifteen, twenty touches in a preseason game. what are we doing? Kyle: Yeah, the fourth overall pick or whatever it was. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: Com come on. yeah, I'm I'm gonna take love for the age and just cause the I don't know, the uncertainty around the Dolphins is yeah, that's yeah, Eric Hofstee: It's worrisome, for sure. Kyle: worry worrisome. Both both teams suck. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, agreed. Both teams do suck. I'm gonna have to agree with you on this one. I'd rather have Jeremiah Love. the age obviously has something to do with it, but then like I said, you know, we've seen how Miami wants to use Devon Achan this before he got hurt, and it was kind of mid and with the emergence of Ollie Gordon. Like what what does that backfield look like when A-chan comes back? You know, is he more of a Kyle: I don't know if I'm worried about that, but yeah. Eric Hofstee: I I think you should be a little bit. just like we were talking about on the last episode with Braylon Allen and Brees Hall, right? Like if you can sell A Chan for a hall, you know. But then if A Chan gets traded, then I might be even higher on him just depending on where he goes. So but if he doesn't get traded, I think you're gonna see a lot more of a split backfield between Ollie and A Chan. Or maybe maybe they get get both on the s field at the same time, you know, have A Chan working out of the slot more, maybe go double running back with Malik Willis. I don't know. this is really dependent on what the o what the Dolphins do this off season as far as like do they get a quarterback, do they stick with Malik? Do they trade HN, etcetera? There's a lot of questions up in the air. Whereas with Jeremiah Love, I know what's going on there and I mean if look at what Tyler Algier did last week. You're telling me Jeremiah Love can't go out there and do the same thing? Kyle: block on Caleb Downs that that offer good God. Eric Hofstee: Dude, they were dogging Caleb Downs. Did you Trey McBride saying like Yeah Kyle: First pick for what? First I like to see that. you know, and like now that we're talking about that, but like the veteran presence I think is the biggest thing for me. Like the Dolphins have all those young receivers. Malik Willis is not a seasoned quarterback. By any means. Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: the the Cardinals don't have anybody. So you would hope that they would take a quarterback this next year or figure figure out the quarterback situation. But to have McBride and Michael Wilson and Algier, and they I know their first round, I think he was a tackle this year. He was he was injured, he's out for the season, but they should get him back. Like I feel like the core for the Cardinals I can trust at least, you know what I mean? to have those guys on the team. And Jeremiah Love already looked looked good. He's he's supposed to be good and he's I mean, I know he's dealing with the with the ankle injury, but like he's the prototypical size that you look for at a running back, whereas H and's undersized, which I think Hann'll be fine. You know what I mean? I I know we both love Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Yeah, this is not saying he's all of a sudden gonna go down the tank, but Kyle: Right. Eric Hofstee: I would rather have Jeremiah Love and you know, speaking of the Cardinals and like their quarterback situation, what I would really love to see is Gardenu Minshew just play out of his mind and then they say we're rolling with Minshew, that's our guy. 'Cause I've always loved watching Garden Minshew play football, man. So Kyle: You love Jordan's in the headband? Eric Hofstee: Yeah, bro. Kyle: you that's one of those guys, he's kinda like Baker, but you Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: you can't hate the guy, you know what I mean? He's just like he's he's having fun, You can't can't hate on him. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, he's fun to root for, absolutely. All right, so next, Jonathan Taylor or James Cook? Who would you rather have? Kyle: Who I think this is more just a strictly age thing, but I I think I'd take James Cook. ch Really? Are they? Eric Hofstee: They're only seven months apart, if that sway you. Yeah, they're both twenty seven. Yeah. Kyle: Man, really? I was I Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: was expecting I don't know. I I'm I'm still gonna take Cook. He's on the better team, he's on the better Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: offense, he's tied to Josh Allen, he's everybody said can't score touchdowns, then he went out and scored touchdowns and then said, he can't keep scoring touchdowns. Well, he's been scoring touchdowns again, so I'm gonna I'm gonna take I'm gonna take that. Jonathan Taylor's probably the better running back, but right now, I mean unless he gets traded, but like where does he go? If he goes to Denver, I don't know if I love it. If he goes Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: to Cincinnati, maybe, you Eric Hofstee: Seattle. Kyle: know, Se Seattle, Seattle or the Vikings. I mean, he's got he's got Eric Hofstee: Are you really excited about any of those places? I don't know. Kyle: Yeah, I don't know. I'd be more excited with the Colts with the t but they already kinda are are tearing it down, 'cause you already kinda know what they're what they're willing to give so I'm gonna yeah, I'm gonna go James Cook. Eric Hofstee: think out of out of all those teams, I would rather him go to Seattle 'cause at least you got a winning organization there. You kinda know what kind of system they run. Kyle: Yeah, they'd split carries with Charbonnet and price and like they would. Eric Hofstee: my god. N well you you would expect one of those to at least be going back to Indy in the trade, you know. So Kyle: Yeah, I don't know. I think the only team that realistically you would get the same would be the Vikings. Was the Vikings want to run the ball. They want Kyler Murray to throw it ten times. And Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: they would they would literally give Taylor thirty carries and let the defense win the game. You know what I mean? So like in that aspect I think it'd be it'd be all right, but Eric Hofstee: All right. Yeah, I'd have to agree with you and go James Cook. you know, everybody when he came in, he can't play like his brother Dalvin, he c he can. he can't handle a three down workload, he can. he's just a pass catcher, no, he can run between the tackles too. No, he can't score touchdowns, yes he can. the guy's just proven everybody wrong every step of the way and he's become the d you know, a big dog there in Buffalo. And over the course of these guys' career, obviously you'd probably rather have Jonathan Taylor for the most majority of their careers, but I think Cook's gonna age better, if that makes sense. being more like he is more of a pass catcher and that ages nicely in the NFL. And so yeah, I mean without really having to age to make any difference here, I'd have to go with Cook based on the upside of the offense that he's in. And he's not splitting touches with anybody there. Whereas we'll see what happens with Jonathan Taylor. But if he I doubt he stays in Indy, but if he does, you can't be excited about the prospects there. And if he goes to Seattle, like you said, he'll probably end up splitting touches with somebody. They're not afraid to do that, no matter who you are. Yeah, I mean I yeah, I'd have to go with Cook 'cause of opportunity, team upside. Yeah. And fact that he's a better pass catcher than JT, so I think he'll age more gracefully. Okay. Kyle: Yeah, J James Cook has I I think he has just a l a little bit more tread on the tires to I mean yeah, I guess I didn't realize that, but James Cook kinda came in a little older. Whereas Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: he's only in his what fourth season and Taylor's in his sixth, so Eric Hofstee: Yeah, so maybe that's why you thought there was a age difference 'cause Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: Cook hasn't been in the league as long but he came in older. Yeah. Kyle: Yeah. I remember that now. Eric Hofstee: All right. Next Bascial Tootin or Kyron Williams? Kyle: Hmm. Eric Hofstee: So Kyron's twenty six years and two months and Tutin is twenty three years and seven months. Kyle: Those are my guys, dude. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. 'Cause ideally, you know Kyle: I'm taking Tutin. Eric Hofstee: yeah, I'd think so too. But ideally, you know, in most people's eyes, Chiron would probably be worth more than Tutin. So like Kyle: Karen is worth more than Tutin, I I th I I believe. Eric Hofstee: So if you could trade Kyron for Tutin Plus all day. That's what I'm doing. Yeah. So Kyle: Yes. All day. All day. I think you could get I think you could get it done too. I think at the end of the season, let's see. Average points pretty one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten. Kyron's like running back ten points per game, sixteen point nine. Tutan's at fifteen point eight, he's fourteen running back fourteen. I think that Tutin can stay stay that way. he might be able to climb up a couple spots. He'll probably overtake Henry, probably Jalen Warren. but I mean he's gonna finish right there with with Kyron. So I think if if yeah, like you said, if I can go plus and I mean I'd still give a first round pick right now for Kyron. Like I I don't think he's going away. He's gonna keep Corum off the field in in my mind, like for He's gonna be the guy. He's Kyron Williams is a touchdown machine. And as long as Eric Hofstee: For sure. Kyle: yeah, as long as McVay and that offense is good, I I don't think they're gonna just like cut bait with them. but would you say Tutin's twenty three and Kyron's twenty six? I mean, if if I can get younger and tear down a little bit, whether it's a player or a pick or whatever, I would I would go that route. So man. Th the only difference in my mind right now is the Rams are not gonna get better offensively, I don't think. Whereas like the Jaguars are an ascending offense Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: and just like you talked about Trevor Lawrence earlier, Parker Washington, that defense. Yeah, the Brenton Strange Eric Hofstee: Brin Strange. th they got a lot of pieces. Kyle: th Hunter on defense and offense, that's an ascending team, whereas the Rams I feel like are just trying to hold on. Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: And with Quorum working in, I mean Tootin's not I mean, Rodriguez is getting in there. He's got some touches and some touchdowns or whatever. But like Tutin's the guy, you know. Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: They're both they're they're they're not highly invested draft capital guys, but they did pay Kyron. So like if you wanted to take Kyron over Tutin, I mean they did pay the man, so That's a tough one. I'll Tootin' Tootin' time. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, I I'ma lean with you there and go facial tutin as well. for all the reasons that you said, there's nothing really I can add to it. So next DeAndre Swift or Jalen Warren? They're around the same age too. There's only four months difference. Kyle: Yeah. I don't know tr my my trust and I don't know where it comes from. I have these guys b both of these guys on a lot of lot of different teams. One one of them. I'm I'm gonna take I'm gonna take Swift. they got the quarterback, they got the wide receivers, they got the tight end, they got the coach, they they they got it figured out and Swift, I mean, he just showed you this week. I mean, he had what, like thirty nine rushing yards and he had three touchdowns. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: he he is a perfect fit for this offense. They're not they're willing to feed him the ball and ja is as good as Jalen Warren's been, Jalen Warren's been around for a while too on Pittsburgh. But like for whatever reason, even like I mean Dowdles looked looked good too, but I mean Warren's kinda kinda ceiling w I don't know. They're both in the same kind of similar similar backfield situation because once Menungai comes back, I do think Monungai will Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: take some carries. But the Bears offense right now is just tiers higher than Pittsburgh. So I think I think I'd Eric Hofstee: Yeah, Kyle: take take the shot on Swift. Eric Hofstee: This is arguably one of the toughest discussions we've had yet because based on the eye test, Shaylin Warren looks better than DeAndre Swift, if you ask me. The guy is just electric. He's got juice. Every time he touches the ball, it feels like he's gone for five, ten yards a carry. And don't even get me started with him coming out of the backfield p catching passes. The dude's just a stud. Kyle: But last week w what what are you doing? You don't throw the ball? Come on, dude. Eric Hofstee: Zero receiving yards, a one one target? Dude. Nah. I don't I don't I don't I don't even want to talk about that. I had a parlay on that that did not hit just because of Warren. And he's hit Kyle: Okay. Eric Hofstee: twenty four and a half every game. And then the week I go to make a parlay on it. Zero yards? What are we doing? Kyle: Weird. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. But anyways, I digress. Yeah, this one It's tough because the situation you would lean towards Swift, right? And then Aaron Rodgers is going to be gone this year. So but I have a feeling Pittsburgh will figure out how to get a quarterback some other way, whether it's through trade or drafting a quarterback. Sh you know, it's supposedly going to be a pretty decent quarterback class this year coming out in twenty seven. So I'm gonna lean with my heart and I'm gonna go Warren here. Kyle: Is Swift twenty eight too? Well. Eric Hofstee: Twenty seven point eight. Yeah. I'm gonna lean with my heart and I'm gonna go with Warren here. Cause you would think in theory, if they do go get a rookie quarterback next year, they're gonna lean on Warren even more so. I don't you know, we'll see what happens with Dowdle if he stays in Pittsburgh or what, but yeah, I just I gotta go with the eye test and lean with my heart and go Warren. Like he looks like the better player. between him and Swift, even though Swift has the better situation and probably higher touchdown upside. But I think, you know, Monungai's gonna make a big difference when he comes back. Like me and you both love Kyle Monungai. And Dowdle's okay, but he's not Monung if you ask me. Yeah, and then also I'm gonna go Warren here because I'm looking at Dynasty Nerds right now, shout out to them. But Warren is one, two, three, four, five, six, six seven spots below DeAndre Swift. So if everybody else views that teardrop the same and I can get Warren plus for DeAndre Swift, I would do that in a heartbeat. Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. So that's what also listen Like I said before, this is why we're talking about this. if you can find those tier differences where you're okay tearing down and getting plus on top of it, then do it. And I think this is a perfect example of that. if there are other people out there that view Swift that much higher than Warren and I can capitalize on that and get pretty much the same production from Warren minus maybe the touchdown upside. But and get plus on top of that, I'm gonna do that all day. I'm gonna lean with Warren and try to get plus. All right, so that's it for the running backs. Let's go ahead and move to wide receiver. it's gonna be a little bit tougher because there's good wide receivers, man. Malik neighbors or C D Lamb? Lamb's twenty seven, Malik's twenty three. Kyle: that's a easy for me. I'm taking Malik neighbors. I don't care who the quarterback is. Dart, JJ McCarthy, I mean even Winston when he was in there, but Malik is ascending. He's the younger guy. You're gonna get that offense looks o okay, you know. and part of the re part of the part of this too, I mean C D Lamb is he's in his prime right now, but I don't know if they can maintain a quarterback or whatever and just keep some consistency around neighbors, I I don't see those guys as much much different, to be honest with you. Neighbors is coming off the injury this year, kinda slow to start the season, but he's looked like Malik Neighbors. You know what I mean? Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Everything you drafted them to be. Kyle: Yeah, and to be honest with you, right now it's like Dak doesn't look good. The Cowboys don't look good and that's obviously some recency bias or whatever. You have at least you have a strong, solid foundation for that offense. So, they could pick it up on any time in any time and CeeDee Lamb is obviously what, wide receiver two right now. But if I can just we were talking about tier down, if if I can get Malik Neighbors plus, it doesn't even have to be I don't know, not may I dunno. It's ph I don't know, man. That's a that's a tough one. But I I I'd take I take neighbors. I take neighbors for the youth. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, I'd have to agree. there's not much separating these guys production Kyle: Hmm. Eric Hofstee: wise. obviously C D already has his quarterback situation figured out with Dak. They got a great connection. But Malik's proven he can produce with anybody at quarterback. Quarterback proof. And that's what you love to see out of wide receivers. Somebody that always puts up numbers and, you know, makes the quarterback trust them no matter who the quarterback is. And the youth sways me here as well. I mean, if I can get four years younger and it's not like you're tearing down that much in production, and Kyle: so C D Lamb's at seventeen point four points per game and Malik Neighbors is at fourteen. And like I said, the first two weeks, Neighbors was kinda yeah, kinda working himself back in. But Eric Hofstee: Throw that out the window. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Kyle: the the last couple of the last month that dude has been dominating. Nine targets, fifteen targets, twenty targets. get get out of here, dude. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. y you definitely love to see that. That's always you know, that's always been my thing. I want the guys with all the targets. Like Kyle: Annie's the only show in town. Eric Hofstee: mm-hmm. Yeah. Alright, so this one next one should be a little tougher. I'm gonna try to stomp you on some of these. Drake London or Tedaroa McMillan. Kyle: I have no Drake London on any dynasty team and it makes me sad, It makes me sad Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: because I have none. But my my brain says that I should want London more, but like my heart says tet, you know? Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: And I know I'm not like the biggest Bryce Young guy, but I'm also not a strong believer in Michael Panics. Eric Hofstee: Panics, yeah. Ted O's two years younger if that makes any difference. Kyle: that does. That that helps that helps me for sure. I just I feel like For some reason I just trust the Panthers more than the Falcons. I d like can Canales is like like I said, for all the struggles that Bryce Young has, like he's slowly been progressing to be better. Coker's looked good, which helps open up the field for Tet. Chuba's the running game's there, so they can't just like focus on one or the other. London is the only wide receiver. So Eric Hofstee: Yeah, that's what I was gonna point out. Yeah. Kyle: that's like that's the tough thing for me. I think both of these guys, to be honest with you, are gonna be fairly close. but London has the higher upside. So that's that's the only thing I lean I think into a little bit man, that's a tough one. Eric Hofstee: to counter your higher upside point, Tedaroa did have a a hundred almost a two hundred yard game with three touchdowns. Kyle: For sure. Eric Hofstee: so I like to think he can match London for upside. Kyle: I just think that London can do more like he has a higher weekly upside, I think, consistently. Eric Hofstee: Sure. Sure. Kyle: I don't know. that's that's kinda how I feel, like I said. I I I feel like every single time my team plays against Drake London, he goes off. I'm gonna throw that rain game out. Ooh, I don't know. I'm gonna go Tet, final answer. Eric Hofstee: Yes. Yeah, I'm gonna make the same homer pick and you know, I'm gonna go Tet as well. I mean they're both kind of built very similar, right? They're both like six four, six five. Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: the kinda well I'd like to say Tetaroa is definitely faster than Drake. Yeah, and then I do like Bryce Young more than Michael Penix. At least he can stay healthy. Whereas Penix is just, you know, I mean he's broke just about every bone in his body up to this point in his career. So yeah, give me the guy whose quarterback can stay on the field consistently. All right, so next these both of these guys are twenty six, so age isn't gonna make a difference. Chris Olave or Zay Flowers? Kyle: Zay Flowers. Eric Hofstee: Zay Flowers or Garrett Wilson? Kyle: Zayflowers. Eric Hofstee: Hm, interesting. I think Kyle: If the Ravens get rid of Lamar, they're stupid. Eric Hofstee: I don't think that'll ever happen, but you never know. Kyle: I I I I I would I wouldn't like I'll take the hit this year with with Zay. but I mean in in my mind the he has the better quarterback and to me he is more explosive and more reliable than either one of those guys. Like Olave is a is a great wide receiver and so is Jarrett Wilson, but in my mind they're more of a possession possession receiver guys that are gonna like try to win on can some contested catches here and there and kinda just they're kind of just like those route tact tacticians whereas like Zay Flowers can be so wide open and bust the craziest spin move and Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: dance side to side. I I don't know. I I would just take the upside of Zay Flowers. Eric Hofstee: Alright, I was gonna say Olave, but you've swayed me and I'm gonna agree with you and go say. let's see. Kyle: Hell yeah. Flower power, dude. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. All right. Carnell Tate or Luther Burton? Kyle: Who do hold on, with with the situation that we got going on right now with Wilson, Olave, Zay Flowers, who finishes higher this year? Eric Hofstee: I'll go allow it. Kyle: Yeah, you're probably right. Eric Hofstee: just 'cause I I we don't know what's gonna happen with Brissett and Geno Smith seems to not like Garrett Wilson the past couple of weeks for some reason. So Olave just provides the most consistency between those three. Kyle: know the Jets would never do it, but can can we just get we have so many receivers over the years, can we just get these guys like some wins and a quarterback? Eric Hofstee: Yeah. I'm telling you, Drew Meskmaker income and that's my dream for next year's draft. Kyle: It's like they they they finally get a decent quarterback in Geno that can get the ball and then it's like they draft all these w first round pass catchers to muddy the water, Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Yeah. like remember when Joe Flacco came in and he was giving Wilson like seventeen, twenty targets a game? Something like that. That's what we Kyle: Yes. Please. Yeah. Eric Hofstee: want to see. Yeah. All right, next, Carnell Tate or Luther Burton? Kyle: Man. I got both of these guys on a ton of teams. we haven't seen the best of Carnell Tate. And I don't think we've seen the best of Burden either. Man, I do not trust the Titans. That's that's like my one issue is like they have just squandered quarterback after quarterback after quarterback. But like Eric Hofstee: remind me. Kyle: but in my mind, like I don't know, like you've seen I guess more games of Burden, but it like for whatever reason they just will not h like it's like he gets targeted in the first half and Rome in the second half and Rome in the first half and Burden in the second half and they just don't they have too many too many guys, I think. Tate I think Tate, I think, has already kind of showed us that he can be that like hyper targeted guy and he can dominate doing that. So I'd like to think that Carnell Tate has the higher ceiling, just n not with Cam Ward, so Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: I don't know. That's that is a tough one for me. Eric Hofstee: Well, okay, let me see if I can sway you. Kyle: 'Cause I I I would probably trade Luther Burden for Carnel Tate. Eric Hofstee: Mm. Straight up interesting. Yeah. Kyle: Straight straight up. Eric Hofstee: obviously Burden's in the better offense, but I think, you know, any given week it could be Burden, it could be Levelin, it could be Rome. And I think once I mean, Cam Ward is improving, so I'm not gonna say he's not the long term answer, but Carnell Tate eventually will be the featured piece in that offense, week in, week out, wide receiver one, upside, I mean just this may not mean anything, but look at all the Ohio State products that come out. Jackson Smith and Jigba, Chris Olave, Garrett Wilson, we won't we won't say Marvin Harrison, but Amika Gbuka. I mean I Kyle: I dude, I regret trading DJ Moore for Marvin Harrison. I shouldn't have done that. Eric Hofstee: Nah, y you may regret it now, but in a few years you won't. that's a long term trade. Yeah, dude. Kyle: Come on, Marv, what the pff Pick it up, dude. Eric Hofstee: so that that would be my only thing is if he follows in these other Ohio State wide receivers' footsteps, then we should see at least wide receiver twelve or higher upside from Carnell Tate over the long term. Whereas Burden, like I said, I mean he will give you High upside weeks. he will give you a hundred yards and a touchdown on any given week. But consistently, I don't think so. You know, you're gonna see a lot more high upside consistency from Carnell Tate. Like he's he's gonna have a higher floor than Burden and I think he'll be able to match his ceiling over the course of the career, if not even a higher ceiling. Kyle: I like I don't think I don't I don't know because we haven't seen it obviously. JSN is like peak. That guy is the best wide receiver in the league. You know what I mean? But Carnell Tate has the path to be some sort of version of that, right? and like I have him on a lot of teams and I drafted him in redraft this year to on hopes of the upside just Cam Ward could get him the ball and like the schedule down the road down the Down the line for the rest of the season is pretty kit cupcake for the Titans as far as wide Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: receiver matchup. So hopefully Tate can just build on that and start dominating. But I want that guy that's gonna get the JSN target share thirty five percent, Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: And I I've I've watched a lot of those Titans games 'cause like I got Tony Pollard and I got like I said, Carnell Tate and I I know you and I both have a lot of Tajay Spears and like Tennessee, I I I have like a soft spot for that team. I like to watch them. Plus I'd love to see Cam Ward work out. But Carnell Tate is wide open. Like wide open. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: So it'll happen, you know. Eric Hofstee: Mm. So you Alina with me and going Tate? Yeah. Kyle: I'm ta I'm taking Tate. I'm taking Tate. Eric Hofstee: Alright. Alright, this next one's gonna I'm I'm gonna try to stump you on this next one. Christian Watson or T. Higgins? Kyle: Yes. Eric Hofstee: Ha ha ha. Kyle: Man I'm gonna t I'm gonna take Christian Watson, I think. I I have Eric Hofstee: Ooh. Ooh. Kyle: him I have him on some teams where I drafted him as a rookie and I've rode that wave. Whereas Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: I have zero T. Higgins. Like I I I think I had him on one team. I I I think I'm having him on one team still. but I've had him on a lot of redrafts. He's burned me a lot, like but Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Let the bad taste in your mouth. I gotcha. Kyle: Yeah. And obviously T's doing what he's doing, but if the what Christian Watson is doing this season, he's like proved that he's that alpha in that offense. And I trust Jordan Love as well. And I think Golden has really helped that whole offense work better as well. So I I just I I like I'm gonna get it a little nasty and just I'm gonna hope for the just the hey dude. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. the dude's got monster upside. I I'd be interested to see how that offense would be looking right now. If Jaden Reed was able to stay healthy and not get hurt, week one of the season. Would it change how things worked out, you know? Watson would obviously still be wide receiver one, but would he be having the same upside, you know, with a another receiver, you know, k soaking up some targets? Kyle: Yeah, I don't know. I I think I think it'd still be a lot of the same, but to be honest with you, I feel like that offense would be better with Jaden Reed just because they've they've been so bad running and Jaden Reed's like that short area yak guy. I think that it it would open up the offense even a little Eric Hofstee: Even more. Kyle: bit yeah, le even more for those guys. Man, I I know you're kinda in the same boat as me, but like Jaden Reed is like such a good player and he's had such such bad luck. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. I I took him in the second round of a lot of fantasy drafts when, he was a rookie and after that first year I was stoked, man. I was like, Great, another second round pick that I hit. And I like in one draft I took him and Josh Downs in the second round and I was absolutely stoked, And yeah, like you said, he's just so unlucky. Like he's a great player, super talented, in the right system, and just health isn't on his side. Same as Christian Watson early on in his career, so I don't know, we'll see, man. It sucks. Especially 'cause this Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: is his neck. So we'll see how if he's even ever able to come back from that, you know? Kyle: For sure. But I think Christian Watson, he just as a somebody that's been a football fan my whole life and played fantasy for a long time, but like Christian Watson reminds me of like OG Deshaun Jackson. And I don't know, I just yeah, I I liked Eric Hofstee: Just taking the tops off defenses, yeah. Kyle: it. It's like cool to have a player like that that I don't know, you know, it like shouldn't work, but it does and it's like sick, you know? Eric Hofstee: Yeah, he's the rare combination of size, speed and great hands. Like Kyle: Was it his rookie year that he scored all those touchdowns with Rogers, or was that year two? It was year one, I think, right? Eric Hofstee: Doesn't really sound like Rogers to get a rookie that involved, so I would say you're two, probably. Kyle: Maybe year two. But man, when he was just dude, he was playing nine snaps and he'd be fifty and a touchdown like every game, And it was Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: like, Man, this guy is dominating. Maybe Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: they should get him some more but he would you know, Mr. Ohstring. But he it seems like he's worked it out, so it's fun to see. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Yeah. For sure. this one's tough for me 'cause unlike you, I'm the opposite. I have one share of Watson and I have a bunch of T. Higgins. So I've always loved Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: T. Higgins. I mean he can give you what Kyle: They're back to back right now as far as points per game, so Eric Hofstee: Yeah, Higgins has the better quarterback than Joe Burrow. any given week he could outproduce Jamar Chase and give you, you know, wide receiver one upside. And when I say wide receiver one, not wide receiver one overall, but like, you know, top twelve, top ten. And Kyle: For sure, yeah. he was wide receiver one this week. He had to have been, right? Eric Hofstee: I don't know. I gotta check that. It was pretty close though for sure. The dude went off. Kyle: Yeah, he was. Wide receiver one this week and wide receiver two the week before. So the dude has been Jamar Chase Who? Eric Hofstee: Tearing it up for sure. Yeah. T. Higgins has always been the guy that, you know, if he could ever put together a full healthy season, you know that he would be a wide receiver one or a high end wide receiver two. And he's doing that this year. I mean, is he? Kyle: Wide receiver four on the season. Why Christian Watson's wide receiver three. Yeah. Eric Hofstee: Wow. Literally back to back. So in on the nerds rankings they're like four spots apart. So I think I'm gonna go with T 'cause if people are valuing Watson higher than T and I can get T plus, then I'll do that all day. So I think I'm gonna lean towards T Higgins here with confidence and yeah, give me T Higgins plus for Watson and I'll do that all day. Kyle: Yeah, I think the only thing that is interesting to think about is like Green Bay doesn't have a run game. So they've had to throw and then yeah, since Cincinnati yeah, Cincinnati, Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Well neither does Cincy. Chase Brown ain't doing shit. Kyle: like the run game's been kinda off too. So I think both of these guys have really like skyrocketed with the extra chances. So I mean that could go that could go either way and like Eric Hofstee: Yeah, we'll see how the offense starts to shape up. The healthier Josh Jacobs gets, you know, the more he gets involved. in theory, the running game should pick up during Green Bay. but we'll see. All right, so that was it for the wide receivers. Next we'll go tight ends and that'll wrap us up. So gonna try to stump you. Harold Fannon or Tucker Kraft? Fannin's twenty two, craft just turned twenty six. Kyle: I think I would lean towards Tucker Kraft, just based around the offense and the quarterback situation. Fannon obviously like I mean, he got fed the last week or two and he he's g he's good, you know. They should utilize him more, but I mean they they have two young wide receivers they're trying to get involved. they're trying to get Judkins involved and Watson I I don't believe is the long term answer. So Whereas Jordan Love is gonna be around for a while, that offense is working working well, and I think even though you still have like two wide receivers that he has to compete with, Tucker Kraft has like shown you that on multiple occasions that like they're willing he's willing to they're willing to have him be the first read target and Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: he's the guy that like dominates over the middle and the shorter area as well as deep. So if one of those r receivers goes down, Tucker Kraft's gonna like vault up even more, which would probably be the same for Fannon too, but I just don't see the Browns offense being as top tier as the Packers. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. I'd have to agree with you here, even though I like Carol Fannon as the as, just a player more so. I believe he is more talented. But you gotta go with production and the system and Tucker Kraft is a dog, you know. Kyle: Dog. Eric Hofstee: And so Kyle: D A W G Eric Hofstee: Yeah. And so yeah, I gotta lean Kraft here as well. they it is close, but Give me the quarterback in the system. We we Cleveland hasn't gotten the quarterback position right in s what seems like thirty something years. So yeah, I'm I'm going with craft in Green Bay. All right. So Isaiah Likely or Sam Laporta? Kyle: man. Eric Hofstee: You you should already know which way I'm gonna lean, but Kyle: Yeah, I know I know you're gonna go you're gonna go Laparta. I think based off of man I That's a tough one. consistency wise, you it's probably Laporta just 'cause he's kind of done it. But I'm gonna take the upside of likely, I think, just the same way with like neighbors is it's like it's a one two punch, you know? Like Malachi Fields is a rookie, but I mean likely has been dominating with all all of the quarterbacks that they had. Dart was man, lighting him up, And Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: it only took a game or two for Winston to realize, wow, this guy's this guy's good, he's open. And man. Yeah, I think just just 'cause a consolidation of targets, to be honest with you. Laporta's good. Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: I don't blame ya. likely does probably give you the higher upside 'cause Laporta any given week could be the first option, the second option, the third option, the fourth option in the offense. Whereas Isaiah likely, he's always gonna be option number two. He's gonna soak up eight to twelve targets a game. And you know He's always had his fans out there when even in the years that he was behind Mark Andrews. I just think in the perceived value, a lot of people aren't as high on Laporta and are getting really high on likely. So if I can get Laporta plus for likely, I'll take Laporta plus. So I think and you I'm a big Laporta stand, I think the guy's super underrated. nerds have him as tight end eight, I think that's too low. I think he's a top five tight end. But like I'd I'd like I'd rather have Laporta than Fannon, you know. Kyle: Yeah. Eric Hofstee: so I think proceed value, like if like I said, if I can get Laporta plus for likely and build out my roster a little bit better, I'd have no problem doing that. I mean Laporta I think he can match likely's upside on some weeks. and he might He maybe doesn't have as high as the floor, but I don't know, man. I just I love Sam Laporta. I love the talent, I love the offense, the situation. So and like I said, this is more of perceived value if people are way higher on likely than Laporta and I can strike on that and get plus like something on top of Laporta, I'm taking that. So Kyle: Yeah, I don't I think just to add to your point is Laporta's probably like the safer bet, but I mean that that Lions offense has been doing it for a while. Whereas like I mean you can see this year, like the Giants like another new head coach, another offensive coordinator. They've gone through now their third quarterback, you know, it's there's really no safety, you know, whereas if Amon Ra doesn't play or Jameson Williams doesn't play or whatever, they they'll feed Laporta, so Eric Hofstee: Mm. Yeah. it's close, but you know, it's good that we don't agree on everything and we have some different perspectives. And so I like I said, I don't blame you for taking likely on the upside for sure. Kyle: if you if if it's if what you said's true and you could really make a trade and I could get, Laporta plus something, even if it's just a th a a older vet wide receiver or a depth piece running back, I'll I'll make that trade for sure. 'cause Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: in my mind I I don't see them that far apart. I I Eric Hofstee: I don't either, but this is the great thing about every league's different. Everybody values players differently. So I definitely think you could get that done in some leagues where you get something on top of Laporta 'cause somebody's just so high on likely, you know. Kyle: For sure. Eric Hofstee: Next, we're only gonna do two more comparisons or would you rather's and but this next one, Dalton Kincaid or Kyle Pitts? Yeah. Kyle: dude. Man, I I don't know. That's like Eric Hofstee: Anybody that's listened to our podcast before, you should already know which way I'm gonna go. Kyle: You're going Dalton Kincaid. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, I can't stand cow pits, dude. Kyle: I don't know, dude. I I think I'd still go Kyle Pitts, to be honest with you. It's probably nasty, but Kyle Pitts has the highest high higher upside in my mind if they can keep him like it like it is with the target share that he's been getting. He's been scoring touchdowns. He's been looking good. And Kincaid just disappears, but so can Pitts. These guys are the same Eric Hofstee: Ha ha ha. Kyle: Same to me, I don't know. Eric Hofstee: Does the quarterback sway you? obviously Kincaid has Josh Allen, Pitts has Penix. Kyle: Josh Allen's the by far the better quarterback, but It should be Kincaid. He's just like, Yeah, both of these Eric Hofstee: Ha ha. Kyle: guys have hurt me so bad. But Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: also I've I've rode I've ridden the high too, so Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: I want Kyle Pitts to be good, to be Eric Hofstee: Ha ha. Kyle: be what he should have been, Eric Hofstee: Yeah, a lot of people want Kyle Pitts to be good, but I don't know if he ever will be. You know, like he's he th he'll have good games, like great games, but over the course of the season he's not a guy that you're like confident starting week in and week out. Kyle: the the only the only I think the only the differentiator in my mind is just like last year, right? Like Drake London was hurt and Kyle Pitts was the whole offense Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: and DJ Moore was out and Kincaid didn't do anything. Eric Hofstee: He looks so awkward lining up as a wide receiver, dude. I'm like, what are we doing? Like, he doesn't need to be out there against the team's number one cornerback. You know? I don't know Kincaid. Like, Kyle: Who, Pitts? Kincaid? Eric Hofstee: dude, when Moore was out and I was watching some of their games, they had him lined up wide so much. And he just looks so awkward out there. Like he'd he's never played wide receiver before in his life. Which I don't know why. Like he's played Kyle: Mm-hmm. Eric Hofstee: the slot. Plenty. why does he look so awkward being out wide? I don't get it. Kyle: Yeah, I don't know, but that that's the Eric Hofstee: But Kyle: thing, I I know I don't know, anywhere that I've had Kyle Pitts, it's like you I you have to hold. there's no way you're trading because the when it's low, you ain't getting anything. And when it's high, Eric Hofstee: Mm. Kyle: you're still not getting anything. So Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: but like I think this year it's kinda like worked its way slowly, but I think Stefansky kinda like he has a plan on how to use him like correctly. Whereas before they were just r just like you were saying with Kincaid though, those fur the first the second year before Kyle Pitts got hurt that second season, it's like he's the wide receiver one on the team. He's like out there wide and it's like they never put him in the slot and they never use him as a tight end and it's like but this year they they kinda are, you know? They're they're moving London around, they're moving Pitts around, but Pitts is playing like a more traditional like bump and release and and he's getting some of the easy targets and I don't know, he's been more of a red zone thre th that's it's close for me. These guys Kyle all day, dude. Kyle on Kyle, dude. Eric Hofstee: Yeah, flip a coin. Yeah, stick with your Kyles, man. So you're gonna go pits, I'm gonna go Kink. All right, so this next one's gonna be a little bit harder than you think. it should be easy, but I think it's gonna be harder than you think. Kenyon Sadiq or Eli Raridan? Kyle: Hmm. Yeah, I probably still gonna have to take Sadiq just 'cause of the draft capital. That that'd be that'd be it, I think. Yeah. I think so, yeah. Eric Hofstee: That's the only separator, draft capital. But at at a certain point, three years down the line, we're not gonna be looking at this guy was drafted in the first round, this guy was drafted in the third, and it's gonna be who's producing the most and Kyle: Yeah. I yeah, I don't know, Eric Hofstee: It's tougher than you think. Like I said, I'll at first glance you should like, yeah, give me the first rounder. Kyle: Mm-hmm. Eric Hofstee: But me and you both have seen Rarodon and we know what he can do and when hun when Henry's out w we're about to find out this week, hopefully, if Henry sits, like what what is the ubicide? Kyle: For sure. you wanna know what's funny about this one though is like last week when we were talking about risers and you talked about Borkeshire on the d on the Jaguars, dude he had that Eric Hofstee: Ha ha ha. Kyle: like forty yard bomb touchdown. And I was like, Wow, dude, you know. That's funny. Eric Hofstee: Bro. I t i i I told you, man, he looks good. Like obviously Brenton Strange is there. But Kyle: For sure. Eric Hofstee: for a second tight end, that Berkshire guy, he's pretty freaking good. Kyle: Ye for sure. I I like I like Raredon. I think I think he could be good and you never really know what the Patriots are gonna do 'cause it seems like I don't know, they I d I feel like they don't ha they've never really known what to do with wide receiver. even Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: back Bill Belichick. They were like the worst team to draft wide receivers, Nikhil Harry and you know, they always got lucky on the West Welker and the Edelman, just like guys that were could play football that kinda worked themselves in, but as far as drafting wide receivers or trading for wide receivers, they suck at it. and Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Yeah, they're they're terrible at talent evaluation. Kyle: And so like Rarden, if he can get in there and like Hunter Henry's not young, you know, like he he could be the guy. Eric Hofstee: Think he's thirty two, Henry. He he's getting up there. Let me see. I'm looking at him. Kyle: So if they used him and it was just like Eric Hofstee: Yeah, he's almost he's about to turn thirty two, Hunter Henry, so Kyle: Yeah. Yeah. Charter should've kept him. Eric Hofstee: Mm-hmm. Kyle: Yeah, I I don't know. The unknown of Sadiq, I guess. There's just so many guys in that squad. Eric Hofstee: So you're going Sadiq. I thought the more you think about it, it gets tougher, Kyle: I think I I think Yeah, I think I think I have to just take the draft capital for now and just what I've seen on the field when he's Eric Hofstee: Sure. And I don't blame you. I think I will have to agree there as well. they're both athletic freaks, you know. Raritan's just a lot taller. Okay, but since you went Sadiq with that one, I'm gonna stick with Raridon here. Raridan or Terrence Ferguson? Kyle: I'm the Terrence Ferguson guy, dude. I'll Eric Hofstee: Yeah. Kyle: Just like the the Rams are gonna draft three more tight ends this year. Yeah. Yeah. Eric Hofstee: I y I know they are. Seems like every year they're like, We just need more tight ends. That's what we need. Kyle: And it's like as soon as Ferguson gets on the field, then he gets hurt, and then Devontae Adams is gone, but he's been hurt. It's man. I think I'd I think I'd still slightly take Ferguson just because he's like that he's that downfield weapon, red zone target, and we've seen we've seen him used as that, whereas like Raredon's still knew. I think that that would be my tiebreaker. Eric Hofstee: I'm have to disagree and go Raridon there. just 'cause sure the Rams use the tight end more than any other team in the league, but that's split between three different tight ends at all times. You know? Whereas Raridon has a chance to be like the one and only tight end in New England and tied to Drake May. Stafford isn't gonna be there much longer. He's maybe got a few two, three more years in him, maybe only one more year. But I'm gonna get you to say Raridon on one of these. I'm gonna go one more. Raridon or Eli Stars? Kyle: I rarited. I regret taking stawers anywhere, any pick. Eric Hofstee: Okay. All right, cool. All right, we can end on that one. Yeah. Just thinking that you could have got Raredon instead of Stours for sure. I don't blame you. Yeah. Kyle: Yeah, in the third or fourth round. Eric Hofstee: But all right guys, that was our first episode of Would You Rather. I think I had a lot of fun doing that. I don't know about you, Kyle, but yeah, I think maybe Kyle: That was pretty fun, yeah. Those are Eric Hofstee: maybe we'll do some more of those as the season progresses. And we could always do one two weeks from now and just talk about different names altogether. So yeah, thank you guys for listening. I hope you all enjoyed that as well. And next episode we're gonna do start sit plus player props as usual. And good luck in your fantasy matchups this week. And don't forget follow us on Instagram at Big Dog Dynasty F F. And We're gonna upload this to Spotify and Apple Podcasts or in YouTube. So listen to us or watch us wherever you get your podcast. And we love you guys. We thank you all for listening and we'll see you on the next one. We're out. Kyle: Ho ho ho.